| Parliament No: | 0 |
| Session No: | 2 |
| Volume No: | 14 |
| Sitting No: | 11 |
| Sitting Date: | 29-12-1960 |
|
Column: 885
LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY DEBATES
STATE OF SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
SECOND SESSION OF THE FIRST LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY
PART II OF SECOND SESSION |
VOLUME 14 |
Thursday, 29th December, 1960
The Assembly met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Sir George Oehlers, O.B.E.).
Dato Abdul Hamid Bin Haji Jumat, P.M.N. (Geylang Serai).
Inche Ahmad Jabri Bin Mohammad Akib (Southern Islands).
Inche Baharuddin Bin Mohamed Ariff (Anson).
Mr S. T. Bani (Thomson).
Inche Buang Bin Omar Junid (Kallang).
Mr K. M. Byrne (Crawford), Minister for Labour and Law.
Miss Chan Choy Siong (Delta).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Jurong).
Miss Fung Yin Ching (Stamford).
Mr Goh Chew Chua (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Deputy Prime Minister.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister for Finance.
Madam Hoe Puay Choo (Bras Basah).
Mr G. Kandasamy (Kampong Kapor), Deputy Speaker.
Mr C. H. Koh (Joo Chiat).
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Bukit Panjang), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture and Government Whip.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Dr Lee Siew Choh (Queenstown), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Leong Keng Seng (Serangoon Gardens), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (River Valley).
Tun Lim Yew Hock, S.M.N. (Cairnhill).
Mr Lin You Eng (Moulmein).
Mr S. V. Lingam (Aljunied).
Column: 886
Mr Low Por Tuck (Havelock), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance.
Mr John Mammen (Telok Blangah).
Inche Mohd. Ali Bin Alwi (Kampong Kembangan).
Inche Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Ulu Pandan).
Inche M. Ismail Rahim (Geylang East).
Mr Ng Teng Kian (Punggol).
Mr Ong Chang Sam (Choa Chu Kang), Acting Parliamentary Secretary to the Prime Minister.
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Home Affairs.
Mr A. P. Rajah (Farrer Park).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Culture.
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Bukit Merah).
Madam Sahorah Binte Ahmat (Siglap).
Mrs Seow Peck Leng (Mountbatten).
Dr Sheng Nam Chin (Nee Soon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Tan Cheng Tong (Jalan Kayu).
Mr Tan Kia Gan (Paya Lebar), Minister for National Development.
Mr Tee Kim Leng (Pasir Panjang).
Mr Teo Hock Guan (Changi).
Mr Thio Chan Bee, J.P. (Tanglin).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Deputy Prime Minister and Leader of the House.
Mr Wong Soon Fong (Toa Payoh).
Inche Yaacob Bin Mohamed (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Education.
Column: 887
ABSENT:
Inche Ahmad Bin Ibrahim (Sembawang), Minister for Health.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar).
Mr Chan Sun Wing (Upper Serangoon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Prime Minister.
Column: 887
[Mr SPEAKER in the Chair]
RESIGNATION OF MEMBER
(Announcement by Mr Speaker)
Mr Speaker: I have to inform honourable Members
that at 13 minutes past 2 o'clock today, I received
a letter from the Member for Hong Lim, Mr Ong Eng
Guan, which reads as follows:
`Mr Speaker,
Legislative Assembly of Singapore.
Sir,
I herewith tender my resignation under section 42
(2) (f) of the Singapore (Constitution) Order in
Council, 1958, from the Legislative Assembly of
Singapore with immediate effect.
Yours faithfully,
Ong Eng Guan
(Assemblyman for Hong Lim).'
In accordance with the relevant section, the seat
of the Member has become vacant, and under section
44, I shall duly report the vacancy to the Yang
di-Pertuan Negara, and the vacancy shall be filled by
election in the manner provided by or under any law
for the time being in force in Singapore.
Column: 887
PRESS PUBLICATION COMPLAINT BY MEMBER FOR HONG LIM
(Announcement by Mr Speaker)
Mr Speaker: On the 23rd day of December, 1960,
the then hon. Member for Hong Lim drew my attention
to that day's Straits Times containing what he
described as an account of that day's proceedings,
that is to say, the proceedings in the matter of the
motion moved by the Deputy Prime Minister in
relation to that Member.
Column: 888
The article in question was captioned. "Ong must
cite law to back his motion". The Member referred to
two paragraphs therein and invited my opinion as to
whether - to quote his words - "any of the passages
referred to is a matter which is sub judice".
I then expressed the opinion that there was no
matter which could be considered sub judice at that
moment, the expression "sub judice" being used with
reference to a court of law. Hon. Members will of
course know, for example, that under Standing Order
No. 19 relating to the contents of questions, no
question may be asked which reflects on the decision
of a court of law and no question shall be asked on
any matter which is sub judice; and again under
Standing Order No. 46 relating to the contents of
speeches, reference cannot be made to any matter
which is sub judice except by means of or in the
course of consideration of a Bill when reference may
be made, but only in such a way as will not, in the
opinion of the Speaker or Chairman, prejudice the
interests of parties thereto. I might add that in
the application of those Standing Orders the term
"sub judice" has been construed to have reference to
matters pending in a court of law and in a
Commission of Inquiry.
The then Member for Hong Lim, however, in response
to my enquiry, stated that he wished to raise his
point as a matter of privilege, drawing my attention
to the fact that the report was contained not only
in the Straits Times but also in other newspapers. I
do not think that the fact that the same report or
article is contained in more than one newspaper
could make any difference to a ruling as to whether
there has been any breach of privilege.
The passages quoted by the then Member for Hong
Lim as being in breach of privilege of this Assembly
are-
Firstly:
"This right has been admitted in the case of the
House of Commons and in all Legislatures patterned
after it."
The right referred to has reference to the right
mentioned in the article in the two
Column: 889
passages immediately preceding the passage quoted.
These two passages read as follows:-
"Mr Ong's motion not only asks the House to
rescind the Speaker's ruling but also claims that
the Assembly has no powers either to condemn him or
seek his suspension if he does not apologise or
repeat outside the Assembly the "malicious
falsehoods" he is accused of having made in the
Assembly.
It, in effect, challenges the constitutional
principle that the Legislature has the inherent
right, as stated in Standing Order 56, of
"proceeding against any member according to any
resolution of the Assembly."
Secondly, that is to say, the second passage
quoted by the then Member for Hong Lim is as
follows:-
"Last Monday, the Speaker ruled that under Standing
Orders the Assembly had powers to discuss the motion
and, if the evidence warranted it, to find the
member guilty of `dishonourable conduct'.
He also said that the Assembly had inherent powers,
should a member be found guilty, to suspend or even
expel him."
In regard to the first passage, it is apparent that
it merely purported to be an analysis of the legal
position which in fact had been urged by the Deputy
Prime Minister in his speech delivered when he moved
the motion, as is apparent in the next passage in
the article in question which reads as follows:-
"Dr Toh, in his speech on Monday, had cited cases
to show that the Singapore Assembly had these rights
too."
In regard to the second passage, it appears to be
a paraphrase of what I myself said, albeit not
exactly a complete or accurate paraphrase. The
passage has been taken out of context and must be
considered in the light of the following paragraph
which reads:-
"However, he expressed doubts as to what extent the
extreme powers of expulsion and suspension could be
exercised by the Assembly."
If the then Member for Hong Lim in drawing my
attention to the passages quoted by him and by using
the term "sub judice" sought to infer that the
passages are in the nature of comment calculated to
prejudice the proceedings pending on the motion of
the Deputy Prime Minister, then I am bound to say
that I disagree; I take the view that there is
nothing in those passages, more especially when not
read out of context, which can be said to have that
effect.
Column: 890
This must not be taken to mean that I am ruling
that any person who publishes any matter which is
prejudicial to proceedings pending in the Assembly
must necessarily be in breach of the privileges of
the Assembly. Such a publication must, to my mind,
first fall within the mischief of the Legislative
Assembly (Powers and Privileges) Ordinance, 1955,
which in section 24 specifically makes the
publication of certain statements and writings an
offence.
In the event, therefore, I cannot say that there
has been prima facie any breach of privilege in
relation to the matters raised by the then Member
for Hong Lim and do not therefore propose to take
any further action in the matter.
Column: 890
PRESS PUBLICATION STATEMENT BY WORKERS PARTY
(Announcement by Mr Speaker)
Mr Speaker: My attention has been drawn to a
statement purported to be issued by the chairman of
the Workers Party and published in the Straits Times
of Saturday, December 24th, 1960. The publication
reads as follows:
STATEMENT BY WORKERS PARTY
SINGAPORE. Fri.- The Chairman of the Workers Party, Mr David Marshall, today issued this statement:
"The first meeting of the new executive committee
of the Workers Party repeats that the Workers Party
is not associated with Mr Ong Eng Guan and had
never been associated with Mr Ong, but expresses
its sympathy and respect for the heroic effort of
Mr Ong in struggling against the attempt of the P.A.P. Government to silence him and nullify the
choice of the people of Hong Lim."'
Hon. Members will recollect that on the 19th day
of December, 1960, before the Deputy Prime Minister
moved his motion in relation to the then Member for
Hong Lim (Mr Ong Eng Guan), I went to some length
to indicate that in my view, the motion should on no
account be considered as a motion of censure and
punishment moved in the interests of Government or
of individuals in the Government, but should be
treated
Column: 891
as a motion which related to the dignity and
prestige of this Assembly and therefore was a motion
in the interests of the Assembly as a whole. I went
on to say that if the House was satisfied that the
conduct of the hon. Member for Hong Lim was such as
to be an affront to its own dignity and prestige in
the sense inter alia that that conduct had brought
discredit to the House as a whole - not merely to
individual Members of the Government Parliamentary
Party or indeed to any other Member of the House or
to persons outside the House - then the House might
feel itself justified in condemning or censuring the
hon. Member for Hong Lim and thereafter in
proceeding to consider what punishment, consonant
with its powers, it should mete out to him. I
finally stressed that the motion would and had to
proceed as a motion which affected the House as a
whole and which invited the House in the first
instance to say whether its dignity and prestige had
not been affronted by the conduct of the hon. Member
for Hong Lim.
In my view, therefore, the statement by the
Chairman of the Workers Party is prima facie a
gross, wilful and scandalous misrepresentation of
the proceedings of this Assembly within the meaning
of subsection (1) (c) of section 24 of the
Legislative Assembly (Powers and Privileges)
Ordinance, 1955, and I have accordingly referred the
matter to the State Advocate-General for such action
as he may think fit to take under that Ordinance.
Column: 891
BILL INTRODUCED
CONTROL OF RENT (AMENDMENT NO. 4) BILL
"to make temporary amendments to the Control of
Rent Ordinance (Chapter 242 of the Revised Edition)
and to restrict proceedings thereunder",
presented by the Acting Parliamentary Secretary to the Prime Minister (Mr Ong Chang Sam); read the
First time, to be read a Second time on Wednesday,
11th January, 1961, and to be printed.
Column: 892
APPROPRIATION BILL
Order for Second and Third Readings read.
2.45 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Mr
Speaker, I have the Yang di-Pertuan Negara's
recommendation that this Bill be proceeded with. I
beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second
time."
Mr Speaker, Sir, the Main Estimates of Revenue
and Expenditure for the public service during the
year 1961 have been considered and approved by the
Assembly at its last sitting as Sessional Paper Cmd.
No. 26 of 1960.
It is now necessary to give legislative approval
to the expenditure of the sums shown in these
Estimates and the annual Appropriation Bill now
before Members is intended so to provide.
Under section 97 (1) of the Singapore
(Constitution) Order in Council, 1958, an
Appropriation Bill containing under appropriate
heads of expenditure, the sums of money which are
required for the several services of Government
shall be introduced into the Assembly. The
Appropriation Bill lays out all the amounts approved
by the Assembly in the Estimates of Expenditure and
arranged under the Heads of Expenditure shown on
page 31 of Cmd. No. 26 of 1960. These sums shall be
paid out of the Consolidated Fund and once the
Appropriation Bill has been approved, the Minister
for Finance will be empowered to issue warrants
authorising expenditure up to the amount under each
Head in the Appropriation Bill to be paid out of the
Consolidated Fund.
Sir, I beg to move.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Third Reading
Mr Speaker: Will the Minister proceed with the
Third Reading?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Mr Speaker, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Third time."
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 893
PROPERTY TAX BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.48 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Mr
Speaker, I have the Yang di-Pertuan Negara's
recommendation that this Bill be proceeded with.
Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be read a Second
time."
Sir, the object of this Bill is to provide for the
levy of a tax on immovable properties in lieu of
rates leviable under the Municipal Ordinance and the
Local Government Ordinance, 1957, as on integration
of the City Council into the Central Government, it
will be no longer proper to levy Local Government
rates on lands and buildings, since these are made
on the basis of services and utilities of equivalent
value being provided from the revenue so obtained.
It will be necessary, therefore, to introduce a new
system of taxation to replace these rates.
The present Bill follows closely the procedure
laid down in the Local Government Ordinance for the
assessment of annual value of property and
collection of rates.
At present, rates are collected for the City area
under powers contained in the Local Government
Ordinance and for the rural areas under the
Municipal Ordinance. The consolidated rate payable
in respect of properties in the City area is now 36
per cent and section 7 of the Property Tax Ordinance
lays down that the property tax payable each year
shall be at this same rate of 36 per cent.
Some areas outside the City limits are, however,
paying rates at less than 36 per cent applicable to
the City area. It is intended to continue this
practice of charging lower rates for rural areas and
the first proviso to section 7 enables the Minister
to direct that the rate or tax in such areas shall
be such rate or rate less than 36 per cent.
The property tax proposals for 1961 are briefly as
follows.
At present, properties within City limits are
assessed at 36 per cent and properties in the rural
areas are assessed at 14 per cent, 18 per cent, 20
per cent, 23 per cent, or 36 per cent consolidated
Column: 894
rates. Instead of this multiplicity of rates, there
will be only three rates of Property Tax for
occupied lands, which will be 36 per cent, 27 per
cent and 18 per cent.
Properties at present paying 36 per cent rates
will continue to pay 36 per cent Property Tax on the
annual value ascribed to the property. There are
certain areas which previously were outside the City
limits but which have been brought into the City
area by the Local Government Ordinance, 1957, as
defined in the First Schedule to the Ordinance. They
comprise largely the areas at Pasir Panjang, Buona
Vista, Ulu Pandan, Holland Road and Ulu Kallang.
These areas were assessed at 23 per cent when they
were in the rural areas and the assessment of 23 per
cent was continued, although they were brought into
the City limits with the coming into force of the
Local Government Ordinance. These areas will now pay
the rate of 36 per cent instead of 23 per cent.
There are also a number of housing estates in the
rural areas which pay 23 per cent assessment. They
are Adelphi Park, Sembawang Hill, Thomson Rise,
Windsor Park, Serangoon Garden, Seletar Hill, Opera
Estate, Spring and Bedok Estates, Hongkong Park,
Bukit Timah Park and King Albert Park. These housing
estates have enjoyed urban facilities as lighting,
water, roads and so forth, and will therefore pay 36
per cent rate.
The 27 per cent rate areas will include areas at
present paying 19 per cent, 20 per cent and 23 per
cent. These areas will include properties lying
within-
(i) ½ mile on either side of Bukit Timah Road
from approximately 8 ½ m.s. and along
Woodlands Road up to the Causeway;
(ii) ½ mile radius of Nee Soon and Chong Pang
Villages and ¼ mile on either side of Jalan
Kayu;
(iii) areas at Serangoon, Paya Lebar, Bedok,
Changi and Loyang.
The remaining parts of the Island were previously
paying 14 per cent or 18 per cent. They will now be
assessed at 18 per cent. These areas comprise-
Column: 895
(i) the present undeveloped western portions of
the Island, i.e., Jurong;
(ii) the undeveloped northern and north-eastern
parts comprising Bukit Panjang, Sembawang, Serangoon and Katong;
(iii) some of the surrounding islands, i.e.,
Pulau Ubin, Pulau Tekong Kechil, Pulau Tekong
Besar, Pulau Blakang Mati, Pulau Bukom, Pulau
Bukom Kechil and a few other islands.
The above rates will be payable on houses or
occupied lands. The rate for vacant lands is at
present 36 per cent for properties in the City area
and this 36 per cent for vacant lands will apply to
the 36 per cent areas for 1961.
The rate for vacant lands in the 27 per cent and
18 per cent areas will be at 18 per cent and 12 per
cent respectively.
Details of the proposals will be gazetted shortly
and a plan will be made available for inspection
showing the rates applicable to the whole Island.
These proposals are not final and the public will
be given an opportunity up to 31st March, 1961, to
make representations regarding the inclusion of any
particular area or locality in one of the three
rates of tax proposed.
I have stated in my Budget Statement that the
present practice of assessing owner-occupied
properties on favourable terms is irregular and that
it is intended to stop this practice. However, in
order not to penalise owner-occupiers of small
properties, the rates of taxation will be fixed at
less than the general rate. It will obviously take
some time for the owner-occupied houses to be
re-valued at the proper values. Until the re-valuation
of these properties has been completed,
owner-occupiers will continue to pay property rates at the
proposed rates on present values. Similarly,
provision is also made in respect of industrial
premises in order to ensure that industrial
undertakings are not hampered through the operation
of the Bill.
Column: 896
It is proposed to withdraw the exemption of land
and buildings used as public burial and burning
grounds and certain institutions fostering the arts
and sciences which are at present exempted from
payment of rates under the Local Government
Ordinance or the Municipal Ordinance on the grounds
that these organisations are run on commercial lines
and they charge fees or levies for their services.
However, provision is made for exemption of
deserving cases of this nature and of buildings used
exclusively for purposes conducive to social
development. Provision is also made to allow
statutory bodies to pay half-yearly to the
Government an equitable sum in lieu of property tax.
It is proposed to make it mandatory for any
person who owns property which has not been assessed
to give notice thereof to the Chief Assessor. It
will also be mandatory for him to notify the Chief
Assessor when a building ceases to be occupied by
the owner thereof and is let. Because the tax is a
tax on the ownership of property irrespective of
whether it is occupied or not, refunds of tax for
"letted" buildings which have become unoccupied
during the tax year will cease.
Special provisions have been made for assessment
of taxes on new buildings, buildings which have been
rebuilt or enlarged, properties assessed for the
first time, and properties which should have been
assessed for rates under the Municipal Ordinance or
the Local Government Ordinance prior to the coming
into operation of this Ordinance but have not been
so assessed. It is provided that in all these cases
the tax shall be payable from the date of completion
of the building or in the case of land from such
date, not being more than six years prior to the
date on which the property is first assessed, as may
be determined by the Comptroller. In cases where a
building ceases to be occupied by the owner and is
let or where the rent thereof is increased, the tax
payable from the date of such letting or increase of
rent is to be calculated on the basis of a revised
value which may subsequently be ascribed to such
building. Provision has
Column: 897
also been made for any annual value or revised
annual value ascribed to a property during the
second half of any year to remain the same for the
ensuing year.
The procedure for hearing of objections on
assessments has been completely revised by the
establishment of an impartial Valuation Review Board
and for appeals to the High Court. The Bill provides
for temporary deletion from the Valuation List of
properties in respect of which notice of objection
to revision of annual value has been received and
for interim payment on due date of taxes on such
properties based on current valuation pending
adjudication of the objection to the proposed
revision.
In conclusion, I wish to say that it is not
intended to levy Education and Improvement rates of
4 per cent each, and that these two sections in the
Education and Planning Ordinance will be repealed.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
3.03 p.m.
Mr A. P. Rajah (Farrer Park): Mr Speaker, Sir,
there are one or two aspects of the Bill upon which
I wish to touch. The first, Mr Speaker, Sir, which
I think is a very serious one, is the Minister's
statement that in future it is not proposed to give
refunds in respect of unoccupied property. And the
basis for the change in law, it would appear,
according to the Minister, is that as this is
considered to be a property tax, therefore the mere
owning of the property should attract the tax,
whether or not the property, in fact, produces any
income. That, Mr Speaker, Sir, is a very serious
statement for the Minister for Finance to make. I
personally cannot see any difference, from the
taxing point of view, whether property is immovable
or movable. The Minister for Finance says that if
anybody in Singapore should be so foolish as to put
his surplus money which is lying in the bank without
earning any income, on a piece of land which,
through circumstances beyond
Column: 898
his control, ceases to produce any income, then that
property is still liable to tax. Contra - if he keeps
his money lying idle in the bank not earning any
income, as the Minister has not yet decided to
introduce a capital tax, he would be exempt from
taxation in so far as his idle money is concerned.
What then is the difference between tile two! If a
man shakes a leg a bit and wants to help me State
and himself, anti invests his money anti puts it to
some profitable use, then me Minister says, "Because
it is a property tax, I must tax you on the property
even though it does not earn any income." Supposing
a person owns 10 houses in, say, North Bridge Road,
and if a slump were to come - it might yet come within
the time of the present Government, some say it is
already here - then that person who has 10 houses
unlet would have to pay tax at 36 per cent. Where
does he get his money from to pay this 36 per cent?
He will end up in ruination, and so will the
property market. And it the property market is
brought to ruination, Mr Speaker, Sir, me economy
of Singapore also would to a large extent be ruined.
Now, I would ask the Government to reconsider this
proposition very seriously; even the principle is
unacceptable. I can see no justification for saying
that merely because you own property, you should pay
tax on it. I think the property should be put to
some use in respect of which the State is providing
services. That is the basic proposition on which
municipal assessments are levied, Mr Speaker, Sir,
and not because you own property. The mere owning of
property, from a municipal point of view, does not
attract rates. But if the property is of such a
nature that it attracts municipal services to
itself, or the preservation of which depends on the
provision of adequate municipal services, then in
return for those services a rate is levied. That is
the basis on which municipal rates are levied. The
Property Tax says:
`An Ordinance to provide for the levy of a tax on
immovable properties in lieu of the rates previously
leviable ...'.
Column: 899
Apparently the Government has forgotten the basis on
which this rate was levied by the City Council and
rural authorities. All they are interested in is the
monies which they can collect, not the purpose for
which the monies are collected.
If a house falls vacant, Mr Speaker, Sir, then it
is not using municipal services -it is not using
water; it is not using light; it is not using
sewerage facilities. What are the facilities which
the Government is providing in respect of that house
on which they claim a 36 per cent tax? It is
inequitable; it is scandalous. If that sort of thing
is allowed to come about, Mr Speaker, Sir, there
will be no building estates built in Singapore. The
Government has already stated, in the building
sector anyway, that it is both an enterprise between
the Government and the private sector in order that
adequate housing might be provided for Singapore in
future years. Government hopes to build 9,000 houses
next year. I do not think they will, but if they do
build, it will be a very good effort. But according
to plans, we need at least 15,000 to 20,000 houses
per year if we want to provide for the increasing
population, not to catch up, but merely to provide
for the increasing population. If Government
introduces legislation which is going to not only
discourage but also stop private development then I
cannot see how it is going to bring adequate housing
accommodation to Singapore. My experience of
Government is that they say one thing and they do
another. They say they want to encourage housing.
They say, "We want to encourage people to build
houses." I ask the Minister for Finance: does he, in
all seriousness, think that this omission of the
refund of tax now possible under the Local
Government Ordinance, whereby a person whose house
is unoccupied can go to him and claim a refund, is
going to help housing projects in Singapore?
Let us take a person, or a company, who has 20
acres of land and who wants to develop it. Under
present conditions it is very difficult to envisage
or to forecast
Column: 900
whether all those houses built on the land
would be bought or taken up by persons who want to
buy houses. Let us assume that that person is a
venturesome sort of developer, and he develops. If
he sells as much as 50 per cent of the houses to
begin with he is lucky, Mr Speaker; the rest of the
50 per cent lie vacant and idle. As soon as he
receives a certificate of occupation from the
relevant authority, the vacant houses will attract
property tax. What happens to the developer? He
faces ruination. He is paying a tax of 36 per cent
on the balance of the developed property. And what
is the annual value under the Property Tax? The
annual value, Mr Speaker, Sir, is the rent at which
it may reasonably be expected to let from year to
year. So it attracts tax at once and the position is
that he will have to contribute 36 per cent to the
Government by way of tax until such time as he has
disposed of his property. This is not the Ordinance,
Mr Speaker, Sir, that is going to help bring a
building boom to Singapore. If anything it is going
to help kill it. The P.A.P. Government has nearly
killed the building industry, and this Bill will
surely help to put the industry into a coffin and
place it well and truly seven feet under the ground.
Mr Byrne: Six or seven?
Mr Rajah: An extra one foot for the P.A.P.
Government! So that is the position which will ensue
if this Bill is passed without the provision which
is now already contained in the Local Government
Ordinance. Other than that, Mr Speaker, it is
merely a duplication of the existing provisions in
the Local Government Ordinance and the Municipal
Ordinance, except that it gives the Minister a lot
of powers personally, which the Local Government
Ordinance did not give to the City Council as such.
If the powers are used wisely by the Minister, well
and good. But if the Minister does not use those
powers wisely, but uses them in an oppressive sort
of way, then there again it is going to be a bad
thing. Mr Speaker, I am against the policy - that
Ministers should be allowed wide powers in respect
of which the public at
Column: 901
large do not know what line each Minister would
adopt. The provisions should be embodied in the
Ordinance itself.
Now, immovable property and investments, Mr
Speaker, are matters in respect of which the
investing public must be satisfied that the position
will be stable for a number of years. If exemptions
of this nature are to be left to the individual
discretion of the Minister, I am suggesting to the
Minister for Finance that that is not the best way
to inspire confidence in the investing public. Under
the Municipal Ordinance, Mr Speaker, Sir, there
were circumstances where areas which were not given
all the municipal services were not liable to the
complete 36 per cent rates. I hope the Minister will
keep that in mind when he considers these various
areas from the point of view of the varying rates
which he intends to tax.
There are certain areas in Singapore, Mr Speaker,
Sir, which do not have a supply of electricity.
There are other areas which do not have a supply of
water. There are yet other areas which do not have
the sewerage system installed. These are all
municipal facilities in respect of which this 36 per
cent is being levied by the Government. How the
Minister is going to sort out these things area by
area, I do not know. But I do hope that when the
Minister does make these levies, he will see that he
holds a balance between all the areas, and that in
respect of each of those areas which does not have
all the municipal facilities, an adequately reduced
tax is imposed.
The only other innovation to the Property Tax Bill
which was not in the Local Government Ordinance is
the provision whereby industrial premises could also
be exempt from the 36 per cent taxation as envisaged
for the rest of the properties. I do not propose to
touch upon this matter, because my colleague, the
Member for Cairnhill, will deal with it. But I do
wish to press upon the Minister for Finance this
position: that I think this Bill, which proposes to
levy a tax on unoccupied property which had
previously been rented, Mr
Column: 902
Speaker, Sir, is going to have the certain effect of
not encouraging builders to build in Singapore.
3.15 p.m.
Tun Lim Yew Hock (Cairnhill): Mr Speaker, Sir, in
the Budget speech, the Minister for Finance stated
that in regard to rural areas, it was not proposed
to increase the rates other than where there had
been improvements, such as roads, lighting, water
and electricity. But in his speech this afternoon,
he has told us that at the present time there are
five types of rates - 14 per cent, 18 per cent, 20 per
cent, 23 per cent and 36 per cent, and it is
proposed to reduce this number to three - 36 per cent,
27 per cent and 18 per cent. Therefore, by a mere
manipulation of reducing five types of rates to
three, those that are in the lower rates become
affected. In the case of 14 per cent rate,
therefore, there is already a proposed increase of 4
per cent. In the case of the 20 per cent and 23 per
cent rates, there is therefore a proposed increased
of 7 per cent and 4 per cent respectively. Over and
above that, the Minister is proposing that where
there are housing estates developed in the rural
areas, these will be rated at 36 per cent. There is,
therefore, an overall increase throughout all rural
areas in Singapore. He has said, Sir, that in the
case of vacant land in the city area, it is not
proposed to reduce the present rate of 36 per cent.
The 36 per cent will remain. But in the case of the
other areas, although the present rates are 27 per
cent and 18 per cent, it is proposed, if I heard him
rightly, to reduce it to 18 per cent and 12 per
cent.
In regard to industrial premises, the Minister
proposes that they should be given this special
inducement in order that there can be a greater
inducement for the industrialisation of Singapore.
Sir, new industries can come in under pioneer
status, and as a result of that, there is a sort of
monopoly. New industries can also claim a five-year
tax holiday. These are, in a way, very material
inducements to capital to come and open up factories
in Singapore. But to suggest that by giving special
rates in regard to
Column: 903
property tax, there is going to be a further
inducement is, I think, not quite right. What
capital is more interested in is not the few extra
dollars that can be saved by a reduction in the
rates of the property tax, but rather in a stable
political climate and industrial peace in Singapore.
The Ministry of Labour and Law is doing its best to
secure industrial peace, with the co-operation of
the T.U.C., although reports would appear that the
T.U.C. and the Minister do not see eye to eye on
this matter.
Mrs Seow Peck Leng (Mountbatten): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I merely wish to add to what the Member for
Farrer Park has said about paying assessment on
vacant houses. Even at present, when the rule is
that you can claim a refund of tax on houses that
are vacant, the refund is not given blindly and
haphazardly. The assessor will have to satisfy
himself that those houses that are vacant are not
kept vacant purposely for the benefit of the owner.
For instance, some owners keep their houses vacant.
They purposely put up very high and impossible rents
to keep them vacant in order to sell them with
vacant possession so that they would get a higher
price. Cases like that do not get a refund. I know
that. I have seen some people who have claimed a
refund, and I have seen them having to produce
evidence of their attempt to get their house rented,
and at a reasonable rate. So there is a precaution
already existing. If it is in the Minister's mind
that owners of houses could be working against the
interest of the State for their own benefit, that
is, by keeping houses vacant, then I would like to
point out that that is not so. Precautionary steps
are being taken by the assessors.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Mr Speaker, Sir, there is a
saying that when you scratch a Tartar you will still
find a Tartar. Here on the question of taxes on
property, we find the S.P.A. displaying the true
nature of their political sympathies.
Sir, to meet the point raised by the Member for
Farrer Park and the Member for Mountbatten that it
is iniquitous
Column: 904
to tax on unoccupied houses. The Member for Farrer
Park says that, in the past, services were provided
when houses were occupied, and when they were not
occupied, municipal services were not
enjoyed - services like water, light, gas and so on.
Therefore, in such instances, when the house was
vacant, there was no case for levying a rate. There
may be a point to that if it is a matter purely of
the Minister for Finance. But I would dispute his
contention that the State does not provide any
service whatsoever to the owners of vacant houses.
For one thing, the police maintain law and order.
Therefore, they safeguard the owners of such
property from being plundered. But this is the
point. Today we know that there is a shortage of
housing. It is very difficult to get accommodation
at reasonable rents. There is no excuse whatsoever
for any large number of houses to go vacant for any
long period of time. If that happens, it merely
means that the land-owners are charging too high a
rent. This being the case, it is only fair, taking
the long-term view of their net income, that they
should pay tax during the periods when their
property is vacant.
In the event that there is a slump - one does not
know, of course, what the future governments would
be then, of course, the situation may arise where
there is a surplus of housing and many houses are
vacant, although the rents charged are quite
reasonable. In that event of course, there would be
a case for reconsidering the position. But in the
present circumstances, where there is a shortage of
housing, it is absolutely scandalous that any large
numbers of houses should be vacant. If the tax on
vacant houses will have the effect of inducing
landlords to lower their rent, then I think we will
have achieved a very desirable social objective.
As regards stopping private development, I think
the Member for Farrer Park is fully aware that the
large housing estates which have been built in the
last few years have not been built to be let out;
they have been built to be sold to individuals, very
often on some instalment basis. So this question of
the building estates being hard hit by this tax does
not arise.
Column: 905
The Member for Cairnhill says that I promised
during my Budget statement that there would be no
increase in the rates of tax in the rural areas. I
said nothing of that sort. In fact, I went to some
lengths to explain that the rates in the rural areas
were low in the past for historical reasons, as
Singapore was then developing and there was plenty
of land then. But that is not the situation today. I
clearly hinted that there would be slight increases
in the rates of tax in the rural areas.
As regards special treatment for industries, I
think the Member for Cairnhill missed the point. It
is not merely that prospective investors will get
the benefit. The principal beneficiaries will be
those who are already running factories in the
rural areas today. They should be cushioned off from
any increase in costs. Perhaps I should explain that
in the rural areas, rates may have been increased
anywhere between 5 possibly to 10 or 12 per cent on
general properties, and we intend to exempt owners
and operators of industrial establishments from
these increases, so as not to increase their costs
of production.
The Member for Cairnhill also misunderstood the
point about tax on vacant land. In the city area the
tax is 36 per cent. The tax on vacant land at 36 per
cent remains there. In the rural areas the tax was
formerly 9 per cent, consisting of 5 per cent
improvement rate and 4 per cent education rate.
Therefore, what we are doing is not to reduce the
tax on vacant land in the rural areas but to
increase it. I hope I have resolved satisfactorily
the various misunderstandings which have arisen over
this Bill.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole Assembly.
Assembly immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Dr Goh Keng Swee].
Bill considered in Committee.
Column: 906
[Mr SPEAKER in the Chair]
3.29 p.m.
Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
The Chairman: Unless any Member wishes to speak on
a particular clause, I propose to take the Bill Part
by Part. Part II is clauses 3 to 5.
Clauses 3 to 5 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
The Chairman: Part III -
Tun Lim Yew Hock: Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like
to come back to clause 7 again.
The Chairman: I will make a note of that.
Clause 6 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 7-
Question proposed, "That clause 7 stand
part of the Bill."
3.30 p.m.
Tun Lim Yew Hock: Mr Speaker, Sir, in reply to my
question on the Second reading just now, the
Minister said that the exemption to be granted on
industrial premises does not mean only new
industrial premises, but it is also meant to cover
industrial premises already in existence.
Sir, in the Budget speech, the Minister said that
1960 has been a very good year and everyone has been
making money. Yet we now hear from him that capital
has to get an extra inducement after making so much
money, that they should not be asked to pay the same
amount of Property Tax, but that in order for them
to enjoy a very good year a little bit better, the
Property Tax, as far as they are concerned, if they
have industrial premises, will be reduced. Whereas
against that, it is suggested that on dwelling
houses in the rural areas the rates should be jacked
up somewhat in order that, according to what the
Minister has said, there can be a fairer rate of
property taxation.
Column: 907
Dr Goh Keng Swee: That does not call for any
reply, Mr Speaker, Sir.
Question put, and agreed to.
Clause 7 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clauses 8 to 64 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Bill reported without amendment.
Third Reading
Mr Speaker: Third Reading, what day?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Now, Sir. Mr Speaker, Sir, I
beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Third
time."
Question proposed.
Mr Rajah: Mr Speaker, Sir, in reply to my speech
on the Second Reading of the Bill, the Minister for
Finance said that as there is no visible sign (i.e.,
visible to him) of a slump at the moment in
Singapore, he feels that it is only right that even
those isolated properties-I think he would like to
emphasize the words "isolated properties" - which
cannot be let, should attract the property tax.
Mr Speaker: Order. I might remind the hon. Member
that we are on the Third Reading under Standing
Order 78 (1). Standing Order 78 (1) reads:
`On the third reading of a Bill amendments may be
proposed to the question "That the Bill be now read
a third time" similar to those which may be proposed
on second reading; but the debate shall be confined
to the contents of the Bill and any reasoned
amendment which raises matters not included in the
Bill shall be out of order.'
Mr Rajah: Mr Speaker, Sir, I was merely trying
to reply to something which the Minister for Finance
had said. He made the promise that if a slump were
to arise, he would think of introducing a new
provision to the Bill.
Mr Speaker: Order. I can only allow the Member
for Farrer Park to speak if he will specify under
which clause he hopes to bring that subject in. If
there is no clause, then, of course, he cannot
speak.
Column: 908
Mr Rajah: Sir, under the Property Tax Bill, the
Minister has wide powers to exempt properties from
taxation. He may exempt or reduce. Sir, could I
speak on that aspect of the matter? I think it is
clause 7, Sir.
Mr Speaker: Can the Member for Farrer Park
satisfy me that what he wishes to say is governed by
clause 7?
Mr Rajah: The proviso to clause 7, Mr Speaker,
Sir, which reads:
`Provided that the Minister may by order published
in the Gazette direct that the tax payable in
respect of properties within any area or areas shall
be at such a rate or rates being less than the rate
prescribed by this section for such period or
periods as may seem equitable to the Minister:'.
"as may seem equitable to the Minister" - Mr
Speaker, Sir, I am suggesting to you, Sir, that
where properties cannot be let and the owner has
honestly tried to let them, then equities do arise,
and probably the Minister may then be able to
proceed under that proviso.
Mr Speaker: Quite a very skilful manoeuvre! But I
suppose the Member for Farrer Park can suggest that
the rate should be .01 per cent or so?
Mr Rajah: Yes, Sir. Might I draw the attention of
the Minister for Finance to section 110 of the Local
Government Ordinance? Sir, the question of a refund
even now is not a matter of right. It is a matter
which the ratepayer has to satisfy the Chief
Assessor in fact. The mere fact that the property is
vacant does not of itself exempt it from rating. He
has to satisfy the Assessor under section 110 (4).
Sir, what I am suggesting to the Minister is this:
that where an owner under the Local Government
Ordinance could have satisfied the Assessor and
thereby obtained an exemption from payment of
assessment, in those circumstances, could I suggest
to the Minister that equities would arise and he
could then exercise his discretion?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Mr Speaker, Sir, I doubt very
much whether clause 7 of this Bill empowers me to
act in that way.
Mr Rajah: Yes, it does.
Column: 909
Dr Goh Keng Swee: It does not. In any case, it is
not intended to cover such cases. So I think the
Member for Farrer Park was just taking this point to
ventilate his grievances about the tax on vacant
houses.
Mr Rajah: Have you a vacant house?
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 909
IMMIGRATION (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.40 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs (Dr Lee Siew Choh): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I beg to move. "That the Bill be now read a Second
time."
Sir, the purpose of this Bill is to strengthen the
hands of the Government in its determined efforts to
combat illegal immigration into the State. Because
of the open nature of its coast line, its
comparative prosperity based on an entrepot economy
and stable conditions and the proximity of numerous
islands in its neighbourhood, the problem of
preventing illegal immigration into Singapore is not
an easy one. The problem has been accentuated by
recent amendments to immigration laws, which have
drastically reduced the number of immigrants into
the country. Active measures have been taken to
prevent such illegal immigration by the combined
efforts of the Customs, Immigration, Marine Police
and the M.R.N.V.R. These measures have produced
results, but it is felt that the Government should
be given more legal powers to have a better control
of the situation and to deal more effectively not
only with illegal immigrants who have entered the
State, but also persons who assist in bringing them
into Singapore. It is with these objects in mind
that the Immigration (Amendment) Bill, 1960, is
introduced.
Clause 3 of the Bill now gives power to the
Controller of Immigration to declare the presence of
a person unlawful at any time if he is satisfied
that the person is a prohibited immigrant or that
any material statement in the application
Column: 910
for his permit or certificate was false or
misleading. Under the existing law, the Controller
can only declare the presence of such a person
unlawful within two years after his arrival. The
effect of such a declaration is that the person will
be liable for removal from the State by order of the
Controller subject to appeal to the Minister. It is
considered an unsatisfactory position whereby the
Controller is only allowed to declare the presence
of such a person unlawful within two years after
arrival. The Controller should have discretionary
power to remove him from the State at any time after
his entry.
Clause 4 of the Bill amends the Immigration
Ordinance to authorise the seizure, detention and
forfeiture of any vessel below 75 tons which has
been used or is about to be used for the commission
of an offence against the Immigration Ordinance or
any regulations made thereunder. This amendment
therefore covers the seizure and forfeiture of
vessels used for the purpose of bringing in illegal
immigrants. An order of forfeiture of vessels is
only made by the court and shall be made if it is
proved to its satisfaction that an offence against
the Ordinance or any regulations made thereunder has
been committed and that the vessel was used in the
commission of such offence, notwithstanding that no
person may have been convicted of such offence. It
will be seen that forfeiture of a vessel now by
virtue of the new definition "vessel" in clause 2 of
the Bill includes everything found in it, and this
amendment is made with a view to deterring the
owners of small craft from engaging in the
profitable business of smuggling in illegal
immigrants into Singapore. The majority of these
illegal immigrants enter Singapore by means of small
craft from the adjacent islands. Under the existing
law, a taikong of a small craft bringing in illegal
immigrants can only be charged with the abetment of
the commission of an offence and experience has
shown that the punishment meted out to them is no
deterrent to prevent them using the same boats again
and again to bring in illegal immigrants. It is
hoped that this amendment will be an effective
deterrent.
Column: 911
Clause 5 of the Bill amends the immigration
Ordinance by putting the onus of proof on a person
who is charged and who has no valid permit,
certificate, pass or any other document or other
evidence accepted by the Controller as evidence that
he is a lawful resident, that he has entered or
re-entered or remained in Singapore lawfully. Under the
existing law, the Immigration Department has been
handicapped in its work of prosecuting in court
those illegal immigrants, who have already entered
the State, because it has to prove that they have
actually entered Singapore unlawfully and often
unless these persons admit that they had entered
illegally, it is not possible for the Immigration
Department to prove that they had done so.
Sir, the Government has given sufficient
indication that it is doing and will do all it can
legally, administratively and industrially and
through its encouragement of trade expansion to
secure the social and economic well-being of its
citizens. This Bill, which is aimed at illegal
immigration, is another additional means of
protecting the economic interests of its citizens
and safeguarding their employment opportunities.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole Assembly.
Assembly immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Dr Lee Siew Choh].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 911
ADMINISTRATION OF MUSLIM LAW BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.50 p.m.
The Minister for Labour and Law (Mr K. M. Byrne):
Mr Speaker, Sir, I have His Excellency the Yang di-Pertuan
Column: 912
Negara's recommendation for this Bill and I
beg to move, "That the Bill be now iead a Second
time.'
The Bill, as can be seen from the Comparative
Table attached to the Bill, follows the pattern of
the consolidation of the legislation relating to the
administration of Muslim law in the States of the
Federation of Malaya.
The Bill provides for the establishment of a
Majlis Ugama Islam to advise the Yang di-Pertuan
Negara on matters relating to the Muslim religion in
Singapore. It establishes a general endowment fund
to be kept by the Majlis Ugama Islam and this will
enable the Majlis to deal with wakaf, nazr and other
trusts which are intended for Muslim religious and
charitable purposes. The endowments at present
administered by the Muslim and Hindu Endowments
Board will be transferred to this Majlis. The Majlis
Ugama Islam is made the trustee of all Muslim
religious trusts, including mosques and burial
grounds, and it is also given the power, with the
approval of the Yang di-Pertuan Negara, to collect
zakat and fitrah to be used for Muslim charitable
purposes.
3.52 p.m.
[Mr DEPUTY SPEAKER(Mr G. KANDASAMY) in the Chair]
The distinctive features of the Muslims Ordinance
in Singapore and in particular the powers of the
Shariah Court are retained in the Bill. The Shariah
Court has been, I am glad to say, a successful
experiment in Singapore and the Bill seeks to retain
and in certain aspects to extend the powers of the
Shariah Court.
The Bill also does not follow the legislation in
the Malay states of the Federation in the punishment
of Muslim offences. Provision has been made for the
punishment of cohabitation outside marriage and
enticing an unmarried woman from her wali as it is
considered that these provisions are necessary to
secure compliance with the provisions of the Bill
relating to the solemnization and registration of
Muslim marriages.
In its broader aspects, Sir, the Bill
Column: 913
aims at re-organising the administration of the
Muslim law and Muslim religion in Singapore. The
mosque will be the centre of Muslim activity in the
various parts of Singapore. There will be
constituted a mosque area, daerah masjid, around the
mosque and the Muslims living in the area will be
given an opportunity to take part in the
administration of the mosque and its activities. The
Imam of the mosque will be paid by the Majlis Ugama
Islam, and if he is suitably qualified, he will be
appointed the Naib Kathi to solemnize and register
Muslim marriages in the mosque area, to register
consent divorces, and he will also be appointed the
Collector for the purpose of collecting zakat and
fitrah.
The Majlis itself, although it will be the nominal
trustee and will supervise all Muslim religious
trusts, will appoint local trustees for such
religious trusts. Although the Bill provides that
notwithstanding any provision in any written law,
instrument or declaration, the Majlis shall be the
sole trustee of all religious trusts, in practice,
the day-to-day administration of such trusts will be
left to the trustees, whether appointed by the
instrument or declaration or by the Majlis.
The central organisation for the solemnization and
registration of Muslim marriages and divorces will
remain with the Shariah Court and the Kathis. It is
proposed that the post of Chief Kathi be abolished
and that there should be, in the first instance, two
Kathis to deal with marriages where the woman to be
wedded has no wali and where the wali refuses to
give his consent to the marriage, and with marriages
where the man to be married already has a wife or
wives living. Other marriages may be solemnized and
registered in the mosque area where the bride
resides by the Naib Kathi of the mosque area. The
Naib Kathis will not be paid by the Government but
will be entitled to retain the prescribed fees for
the solemnization and registration of the marriage.
The Shariah Court will continue to deal with all
cases of disputed applications for divorce. Divorces
by consent will be registered by a Kathi or a Naib
Kathi.
Column: 914
As it is intended that the Bill be referred to a
Select Committee, I do not propose to deal with the
other detailed provisions of the Bill at this stage.
I would add, Sir, that the Bill has been considered
in detail by the Muslim Advisory Board and that it
has been approved by this Board.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
3.55 p.m.
Dato Abdul Hamid Bin Haji Jumat (Geylang Serai):
Mr Speaker, Sir, the Bill before us, "The
Administration of Muslim Law Ordinance" is a hybrid
one and the clauses have, in some instances, been
taken out in toto from the Muslim Law Enactments of
Selangor, Pahang and Penang. For this reason, Sir,
if not for any other, I welcome the Minister's
proposal to commit the Bill to a Select Committee.
Sir, when the first Muslims Ordinance, 1880, was
introduced in Singapore, the lawmakers then had in
mind not so much the desire to control the way of
life as a whole of the Muslims of Singapore, hut
rather the object was to lay down certain principles
of Islamic law which had been abused by some
sections of the Muslim population and which
conflicted with the non-theocratic laws of the
State. In fact, the provisions of the first Muslims
Ordinance never went beyond that. The intention was
specific and to the point where, in effect, it
became merely an accessory to the existing laws of
the country, although it was part and parcel of the
Statute Book.
Amendments were made to the Ordinance from time to
time, but even so the guiding principle was never
forgotten.
The present Bill, Mr Deputy Speaker, goes beyond
the original Muslims Ordinance, 1880, and the
Muslims Ordinance, 1957, both of which, if I may say
again, tended to accord certain principles of the
Muslim law with the existing civil laws of the
State.
For my part, I welcome these new additions for the
effect it would have in regularising the code of
conduct of
Column: 915
certain aspects of Muslim law. But, Sir, what we
agree to do or not to do in this Assembly is not
enough if we do not carry the support of the people
Outside. Doubts have been raised by Muslim scholars
as to whether this Assembly can introduce such a
Bill. And here, Sir, the question is not the
academic question, similar to the one we debated not
so long ago, of whether this Assembly is competent
to debate the issue under our Standing Orders, but
rather whether in a non-secular State like
Singapore, Islamic laws can be enacted to govern
Muslims in their way of life. Some Muslim
theologians hold the view that under Islamic law
only a Muslim Government can enforce the laws of the
Koran, like the Government of the Federation of
Malaya whose State religion is Islam.
Now, Sir, before I go any further, I would like to
stress for the purpose of clarification to this
Assembly and also to the Press - The Malay Press in
particular - that I am not here giving my views on
the Islamic law but rather expressing the views of
Muslim religious leaders outside this Assembly.
4.00 p.m.
Mr Deputy Speaker, there is then again another group of Muslims who contend that the provisions
contained in this Bill are not enough to cover all
aspects of Islamic law, even to the extent of
gaoling a Muslim for non-observance of his daily
prayers and fast, both of which to a Muslim and
under Islamic laws are the pillars and two of the
five fundamentals upon which Islamic religion
stands. Sir, these are some of the thoughts now
occupying the minds of some, if not all, religious
leaders since this Bill was published.
I would like now, Sir, to touch on some aspects of
the Bill which I feel require re-thinking. The most
important parts of the Bill, as I see it, are Parts
IV (dealing with financial problems), V (Mosques and
Religious Schools), and IX (Offences). Under clause
59, a General Endowment Fund will be established
into which all zakat and fitrah collected by the
collectors will
Column: 916
be paid. Clause 73 enables the Majlis, with the
approval of the Yang di-Pertuan Negara, to make
rules "to prescribe from time to time the amount of
zakat and fitrah to be paid by all Muslims in
Singapore", and also the distribution of the zakat
and fitrah to those eligible.
Here, Mr Deputy Speaker, arise two points. The
first is the determination by the Majlis of the
amount of zakat and fitrah. Now, how and in what
manner, and by what means, and by what yardstick is
the Majlis to determine the amount? Is this going to
be another Assessment Department of the Income Tax
Office? For all I know, it could be an arbitrary
decision depending upon the whim and fancy of the
members of the Majlis. Fitrah, of course, is not so
difficult since the calculation is based upon a flat
amount, whatever the means of the person concerned,
that is to say, those who are not exempted. But when
it comes to zakat, the question of determining a
person's property upon which a tithe of 2½ per cent
will be imposed is a highly complex operation.
The second point is the method of distribution and
entitlement thereof. In Singapore today, Sir, we
have public assistance by the Social Welfare
Department, which pays a mere subsistence allowance
to those unemployed. Under Muslim law, the poor and
the needy will be amongst those first eligible for
the distribution of zakat and fitrah, and these
people will probably be the same people who are also
eligible for public assistance. Now, Sir, is it the
Government's intention, once the Bill becomes law,
to withdraw public assistance from those who are
eligible for zakat and fitrah? It may well be that
the individual shares of zakat and fitrah could
amount to more than the pittance they get from
public assistance. I hope it is not going to be so.
Actually, Sir, we Muslims in Singapore (at least
the good Muslims) pay two types of what we may call
taxes - one to the Government in all forms, and the
other in the form of zakat and fitrah.
I now come to clause 77 which prohibits a person
from erecting a mosque,
Column: 917
without the approval of the Majlis. Sir, this raises
a very serious question. Since the time of the
Prophet, there has been, to my knowledge, no
religious restriction on the building of a mosque. I
know this provision is taken from the Selangor and
Penang Muslim enactments. But I would like to ask
the Minister: why introduce it here?
Then we come to the Offences section which is in
Part IX. Part IX begins with clause 126 which reads:
`Save as is otherwise in this Ordinance expressly
provided this Part of this Ordinance shall only
apply to Muslims.'
I repeat, Sir, "shall only apply to Muslims."
Further on, under the same Part, clause 131 is on
cohabitation Outside marriage. This clause states
that any man or woman who cohabits outside marriage
shall be guilty of an offence and shall be
punishable to a fine not exceeding $500 or for a
term of imprisonment not exceeding six months or to
both. Now, Mr Deputy Speaker, this means that if
you (anonymously) were to cohabit with a Muslim
woman outside marriage, the Muslim woman can be
sentenced to six months' imprisonment and to a fine
of $500, but you will go scot-free. That is what
this clause means. Where is the equality and
justice, Sir? My information is that under Muslim
law both should be punished. I would seriously
suggest, Sir, to the Government that this clause
should be totally deleted. In fact, Sir, even in the
Malay States, i.e. in the Federation of Malaya,
where the State religion is Islam, there is no
provision of this nature in the Muslim enactments.
Finally, Sir, I know that both the Minister and
the State Advocate-General have put in hours of work
in compiling the Bill. I hope their efforts have not
been wasted, but I would appeal to the Government,
on such a highly controversial subject, that it
would be better to go slow on the Bill and not to
rush it even in Select Committee. No one. Sir, least
of all myself, can speak with any authority on the
Muslim religion. We have to seek outside advice, and
the Select Committee is the best place for it.
I would also appeal to all concerned that in
moulding this Bill into its final
Column: 918
form, both sides of this House should work as a team
and party politics should not be brought in, either
into this Assembly or into the Select Committee. In
this connection, Sir, on a parting word of advice to
the Minister, I would advise him to print as many
copies as possible of the Malay version of this Bill
for distribution to Muslim leaders and organisations
throughout Singapore long before the Select
Committee begins its deliberations.
4.08 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development (Inche Yaacob bin Mohamed)(In Malay): Mr Deputy Speaker, the Administration of
Muslim Law Bill, which has been tabled by the
Minister for Labour and Law today, is a Bill which
could, be described as creating a new chapter in the
history of Singapore consonant with the Constitution
of Singapore, which enunciates the protection and
safeguard of the islamic religion of the Malays and
Islamic people of Singapore. I do not wish to dwell
at length on this point because this Bill was
actually promulgated on the advice of many religious
experts, and it has received the blessing of the
Muslim Advisory Board, and their views and findings
have been accepted.
On the subject of zakat, we are adhering to the
school of thought called Shafei. On the distribution
of the zakat, it will be distributed according to
the provisos contained in the Muslims Ordinance. For
instance, in the Muslims Ordinance the tithe is
divided into eight persons because two of these
conditions are absent in this law, and another one,
the ibni sabil which is non-existant in this
country. There are only six left. So only those
people who qualify under those six conditions are
eligible. There should be no controversy arising
because there is provision for the mufti to give it
his ruling.
The second point is the question of building
mosques. This has never happened, but according to
the Shafei school of thought, if there are two
mosques in the same area, then they should set
different times of prayer. This is merely
Column: 919
to prevent two mosques in the same kampong from
being erected which will eventually result in
misunderstanding among the people, but if it
happens, as it does happen because of certain
misunderstandings, a group decides to erect a mosque
and then not far away, say, 10 feet, there is
another surau built, then it is with this in view
that we have made provisions to restrict the
building of mosques.
Similarly, on the offences, we merely punish
people of Islamic faith who commit the offences.
There are other religions where, when you are in
love with each other, no problem arises; it is not
an offence. But in Islamic law, the marriage should
be solemnized before a priest or imam and witnessed
by witnesses. So it is necessary that the Muslim who
commits the offence should be punished. However if
a free thinker cohabits with a woman, that is
another matter. On this aspect of the Bill, too,
this has been discussed at great length by the
religious leaders. However, as a result of the wise
decision of the Minister for Law to commit the Bill
to a Select Committee, it is hoped that many more
religious leaders who are experts on Muslim law will
come forward to give their views and opinions so
that the incidents that took place with regard to
the Muslims Ordinance will not happen again.
4.15 p.m.
Inche Ahmad Jabri Bin Mohammad Akib (Southern Islands)(In Malay): Mr Speaker, as a Muslim, I
support this Bill in principle. Mr Deputy Speaker,
this is an important Bill as it affects the Muslim
community in Singapore and because the powers
therein are wide, and are more closely related to
the Muslim people in Singapore. I am of the opinion
that it is not for me to discuss this Bill. I am not
competent to do so. It requires religious experts to
be able to discuss this Bill. However, as my
responsibility in this Assembly is to draft an
Ordinance in the interest of the State of Singapore,
I will give this Bill my
Column: 920
consideration and careful study. However, as stated
by the Member for Geylang Serai just now, as this
Bill should be given thorough consideration by the
whole Muslim community, it is proper, therefore,
that it should be translated into Malay and copies
of it distributed to all Muslim organisations.
Just now the Parliamentary Secretary to the
Minister for National Development said that the
Administration of Muslim Law Bill did not receive
the response as should be expected from the
religious experts. The reason why no response was
forthcoming was that they were not able to
understand the provisions of the Bill. Moreover,
even those who have a knowledge of the Muslim
religion do not have a proper knowledge of the
English language. So I support the suggestion by the
Member for Geylang Serai that the Bill be translated
into Malay and copies of it distributed to the
various Muslim organisations. Let us not accept this
Bill just because it has been approved by the Muslim
Advisory Board. It is not enough, because I know
that although the Muslim Advisory Board is the body
to advise the Government on religious matters, it
does not reflect public opinion. So at the
suggestion of the Minister for Labour and Law
himself to commit the Bill to a Select Committee,
which is a commendable step, I welcome this Bill in
the hope that it will be enforced in the interest of
the Muslim people in Singapore.
Another point which I would like to remind the
Government about is that the Bill can be modified to
fit in with our wishes but the question of
enforcement is a matter which must be given careful
thought. From the provisions of this Bill, I think
powers have been vested in the Majlis Ugama Islam
which will issue rulings, administer finances and
decide on administrative matters concerning the
erection of religious schools and so on. Members of
the Majlis Ugama Islam will be nominated by the Yang
di-Pertuan Negara. I only wish to remind that this
Board should not be a place where people merely wish
to be nominated for the sake of being nominated. It
may well be that although they are of
Column: 921
the opinion that a certain matter is contradictory
to the Muslim law, they, as nominated members, may
not dare to voice their opinion openly. Because they
are nominated members, therefore, their interest is
in being members of the Board and nothing else. What
we hope is that the members of this Board will serve
on the Board to discharge truly their responsibility
towards the religion of Islam.
One point which impresses me, Mr Deputy Speaker,
is when the Parliamentary Secretary stated that when
people cohabit, the punishment is imposed only on
the Islamic people. According to the Parliamentary
Secretary, this is because the Islamic man has
committed the offence. If considered carefully, he
said originally that the aim of the Bill was to
abide by the provisions of the Constitution. It is
expected that the Constitution will safeguard the
provisions of the Islamic law. We should be able to
guide the people of Islam along the right Islamic
path for the reason that the Islamic law cannot be
applied to non-Muslims. So I strongly urge this
matter to be carefully considered in the Select
Committee.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Committed to
a Select Committee consisting of Mr Speaker as
Chairman and seven other Members to be nominated by
the Committee of Selection. -[Mr Byrne].
Column: 921
PINEAPPLE INDUSTRY (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
4.26 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Low Por Tuck): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg
to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
This Bill seeks to amend the provisions of the
Pineapple Industry Ordinance so as to give legal
effect to Government's policy for the Malayan
Pineapple industry contained in Command Paper No. 24
of 1960 which was
Column: 922
tabled in the Legislative Assembly on the 25th
October, 1960. Corresponding legislation has been
passed by the Federation House of Representatives on
the 30th November, 1960.
The present Malayan Pineapple Industry Board,
which consists of seventeen members, has been found
to be too unwieldy, and clause 2 reconstitutes the
Board.
The present functions of the Board are not
precisely set out and have been re-drafted in clause
4.
It is considered that there is no room in the
Board for two full-time senior Administrative
Officers, and clause 5 abolishes the statutory post
of Chief Executive Officer and transfer to the Board
the power to appoint such staff as it considers
necessary.
For flexibility and efficiency, the statutory
Executive Committee is also abolished and its powers
transferred to the Board under clause 6.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole Assembly.
Assembly immediately resolved itself into a
committee on the Bill. -[Mr Low Por Tuck].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 922
PRIVATE LOTTERIES (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
4.30 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Mr
Deputy Speaker, Sir, I have His Excellency the Yang
di-Pertuan Negara's recommendation to proceed with
this Bill.
Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a
Second time."
The object of this Bill is to give effect to the
proposal to raise the rate
Column: 923
of tax on private lotteries which I mentioned in my
Budget speech.
At present, promoters of private lotteries pay a
tax of 20 per cent on their gross receipts and
operators of fruit machines pay 20 per cent on 137½
per cent of their net takings. For reasons which I
have fully explained in my Budget statement,
Government considers it just and proper that the
rates of tax be increased in respect of these from
20 per cent to 30 per cent.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole Assembly.
Assembly immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Dr Goh Keng Swee].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 923
RUBBER ESTATES ASSESSMENT (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second read.
4.35 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Mr
Deputy, Speaker, I have the Yang di-Pertuan Negara's
recommendation to proceed with this Bill.
Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a
Second time."
Sir, the object of this Bill is to give effect to
the changes in the rate of assessment on large
rubber holdings which I announced in my Budget
Speech on the 29th of November.
At present, when the price of rubber is under 20
cents per pound, the estate owner pays 1 per cent of
the price as assessment. The maximum rate payable at
present is 3¼ per cent and this applies only when
the price exceeds 35 cents. Mr Deputy Speaker, Sir,
you will see that at the present price of about 85
cents per pound, an estate owner pays only 2½ cents
per pound. This is considerably
Column: 924
lower than the export duty on rubber in
the Federation. When the price of rubber moves
upwards, this disparity becomes even greater. There
is no valid justification for this anomaly and the
scale which is set out in clause 3 of the Bill goes
some way to reducing this disparity.
There is another matter which I wish to draw
attention to. This is that land in Singapore could
be put to better use than for rubber plantations,
and so I propose, as a measure to discourage the
alienation of land for rubber, to impose a quarterly
rate of $8.75 per acre on land under immature rubber
or where the trees have been abandoned. The
necessary provisions are contained in clause 3,
paragraph (a) and clause 4 of the Bill, while clause
6 provides for the necessary returns to be made by
estate owners to the tax department.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole Assembly.
Assembly immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Dr Goh Keng Swee].
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr DEPUTY SPEAKER (Mr Kandasamy) in the Chair]
4.41 p.m.
Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 3 -
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Mr Kandasamy,. I beg to move,
In page 2, to leave out lines 11 to 17 inclusive
and insert-
`"Provided that in respect of any such rubber
estate or part thereof in which no rubber trees are
tapped or in which the rubber trees are not tapped
to the satisfaction of the Comptroller the owner
thereof shall pay to the Comptroller a rate of eight
dollars and seventy-five cents per acre or part of
an acre in respect of such quarter in addition to
the rate ascertained in the manner hereafter
provided."; and'.
The reason for amending the proviso in clause 3 is
to close up the loopholes
Column: 925
which the original proviso has. Under the original
proviso, the owner of a rubber estate could evade
tax by tapping trees once or twice a quarter. They
would then have to pay the rate for the rubber
produced, and as this would be very little, the
assessment would be small. The new proviso therefore
allows the Comptroller to require payment of the
rate for untapped trees if he is not satisfied that
the yield is economic.
Amendment agreed to.
Clause 3, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clause 4 -
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Mr Kandasamy, Sir, I beg to
move,
In page 3, to leave out lines 29 to 34 inclusive
and insert-
`"Provided that in respect of any such rubber
estate or part thereof in which no rubber trees are
tapped or in which the rubber trees are not tapped
to the satisfaction of the Comptroller the owner
thereof shall pay to the Comptroller a rate of
eight dollars and seventy-five cents per acre or
part of an acre in respect of such quarter in
addition to the rate ascertained in the manner
hereafter provided.".'.
Sir, this is an identical amendment with the
previous one, and the reasons are the same.
Amendment agreed to.
Clause 4, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clauses 5 to 14 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Bill reported, with amendments; read a Third time
and passed.
Column: 925
INCOME TAX (AMENDMENT NO. 2) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
4.45 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Mr
Deputy Speaker, Sir, I have the Yang di-Pertuan
Negara's recommendation that this Bill be proceeded
with. I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a
Second time."
Sir, the object of this Bill is to give effect to
the proposals to reduce the rate of personal
allowances on income tax
Column: 926
and to provide for an "earned income relief" which I
outlined in the Budget Statement.
[Mr SPEAKER in the Chair]
The definition of "earned income" for the purposes
of the new tax relief is provided in clause 2 of the
Bill.
The proposed reductions in the rates of relief are
contained in clause 3. The allowances will be
reduced to $2,000 for an individual and $1,000 for
his wife. These deductions will bring our income tax
rates closer to those of the Federation. The impact
of these reductions is diminished by the new "earned
income relief" which is provided under the same
clause of the Bill, and is set at 20 per cent of
earned income subject to a limit of $1,000. The
average worker will hardly be affected by these
changes in the tax structure, because the 20,000 or
so new tax payers will only have to pay a total of
$750,000 per annum or an average of $37 each per
year. The maximum amount any new taxpayer will have
to pay is $20 a year if he is a bachelor and $50 a
year if he is married without children. The maximum
payable by any new taxpayer with three children will
be $12.50 a year. I am sure, Sir, that Members will
agree that this is neither iniquitous nor a hardship
on the lower income groups. As I have said
previously, the average family in Singapore does not
pay income tax until their earnings from work
reaches the region of $500 per month, even with the
proposed reductions of personal allowances. It is
relevant also to note that for a family of five with
an income of less than $10,000, or for a married
couple without children, with an income of less than
$9,000 or for a bachelor with an income of less than
$8,000, the tax in Singapore is lower than the tax
in the Federation. Therefore, Mr Speaker, Sir, it
cannot be said that our tax rates are onerous.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole Assembly.
Column: 927
Assembly immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Dr Goh Keng Swee].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 927
INCOME TAX ORDINANCE
(SECOND SCHEDULE)
4.50 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I have His Excellency the Yang di-Pertuan Negara's recommendation and move,
That this Assembly, pursuant to subsection (1) of
section 106 of the Income Tax Ordinance (Chapter
166), resolves that the Second Schedule to the said
Ordinance be varied by substituting therefor the
following Schedule with effect from the 1st day of
January, 1961:-
SECOND SCHEDULE
(Section 42)
Chargeable Income $ Rate
of
Tax
per cent
For every dollar of the first 1,500 5
" " " " " next 500 6
" " " " " " 1,000 7
" " " " " " 1,000 8
" " " " " " 1,000 10
" " " " " " 2,000 12
" " " " " " 3,000 15
" " " " " " 5,000 18
" " " " " " 10,000 25
" " " " " " 10,000 30
" " " " " " 15,000 40
" " " " " " 50,000 50
" " " exceeding 100,000 55
Sir, the object of this motion is to give effect
to the proposal to raise the maximum rate of income
tax from 50 to 55 per cent on income above $100,000
a year, as announced earlier in my Budget Statement
on 29th November, 1960.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Assembly, pursuant to subsection (1) of
section 106 of the Income Tax Ordinance (Chapter
166), resolves that the Second Schedule to the said
Ordinance be varied by substituting therefor the
following Schedule
Column: 928
with effect from the 1st day of January, 1961: -
SECOND SCHEDULE
(Section 42)
Chargeable Income $ Rate
of
Tax
per cent
For every dollar of the first 1,500 5
" " " " " next 500 6
" " " " " " 1,000 7
" " " " " " 1,000 8
" " " " " " 1,000 10
" " " " " " 2,000 12
" " " " " " 3,000 15
" " " " " " 5,000 18
" " " " " " 10,000 25
" " " " " " 15,000 40
" " " " " " 50,000 50
" " " exceeding 100,000 55
Column: 928
STATE MARINE ENSIGN
4.52 p.m.
The Deputy Prime Minister (Dr Toh Chin Chye): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That this Assembly adopts the State Marine Ensign
as described and shown in Paper Misc. 6 of 1960.
Sir, the House is aware that Singapore is the fifth
largest port in the world. Every day, a large number
of vessels enter port and leave the harbour. It is
an international custom for all vessels to fly a
flag of that State which it is visiting. It is
desirable, therefore, that in Singapore we should
have the possibility of distinguishing vessels which
are owned by the Singapore Government from visiting
vessels and other trading vessels which may be
registered in Singapore.
The Singapore Marine Ensign will be flown by all
marine craft in the service of the Government or a
statutory board, say, for example, when the Port
Authority is formed, light-houses, signal stations,
piers and wharves owned or operated by the
Government or statutory boards.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Assembly adopts the State Marine Ensign
as described and shown in Paper Misc. 6 of 1960.
Column: 929
SUSPENSION OF MEMBER
Order read for resumption of debate on Question
-[19th December, 1960]:
"That this House condemns the Member for Hong Lim
for his dishonourable conduct unbecoming of an
elected representative of the people in that he
repeatedly used his privilege in this Assembly as a
cloak for spreading malicious falsehoods to unjustly
injure innocent persons both inside and outside this
Assembly; that he be suspended from the service of
this Assembly until such time as (i) he apologises
to this Assembly for his dishonourable conduct; (ii)
he unreservedly withdraws his unfounded allegations
against the Prime Minister and the Minister for
Labour and Law; and (iii) he assures the Assembly
that he will not persist in abusing his privilege in
this Assembly by uttering malicious falsehoods,
unless he be prepared when challenged to repeat
outside the Assembly the charges he makes in the
Assembly."-(The Deputy Prime Minister).
4.55 p.m.
The Deputy Prime Minister (Dr Toh Chin Chye): Mr
Speaker, I beg to move,
That the debate on the motion standing in my name
be adjourned sine die.
Sir, six days ago, the former Member for Hong Lim
stated that he would substantiate all the things he
had said. This was reported in page 44 of your
unrevised transcript of proceedings on that day. At
that time, he begged for time to collect more facts
so that he could prepare his case. This is quoted on
page 45 of the unrevised transcript. He wanted an
adjournment to give him a chance to delve further
into the matter.
I was not in the Chamber, Mr Speaker, this
afternoon when you made your announcement that the
former Member for Hong Lim, Mr Ong Eng Guan,
tendered his resignation to you at 2.13 p.m. today.
This last-minute reversal of stand, after stating
explicitly that he intended to substantiate charges
which we believe to be false, speaks for itself. I
had expected him, honour bound, to pursue the
allegations he had made in this House. However, in
view of the fact that
Column: 930
he has changed his mind 17 minutes before the
sitting of this Assembly, I have to move that the
motion that is before the House should be adjourned
sine die.
The purpose of this adjournment sine die is that
since Mr Ong Eng Guan, the man who has made the
allegations, is no longer a Member of this House, it
will be better to have the allegations investigated
and conducted outside this Chamber. It is intended,
therefore, to set up a Commission of Inquiry with a
High Court Judge as Commissioner to investigate the
truth of the allegations that have been made against
two Ministers. It is our hope that the Commission
will commence its hearing and complete its findings
as soon as possible so that they could be tabled in
this House. Thereupon, I shall ask for this motion
to be put back on the Order Paper for debate.
After the Inquiry Report has been tabled in this
House, steps will be taken to hold a by-election in
the constituency of Hong Lim.
Sir, I beg to move.
Mr Speaker: The Question is really in two parts.
The Question is, "That the debate be now adjourned."
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That the debate be now adjourned.
Mr Speaker: Resumption of debate, what day?
Dr Toh Chin Chye: Sine die.
ADJOURNMENT TO A LATER DAY MOTION
Resolved, "That this Assembly do now adjourn to
11th January, 1961."-[Dr Toh Chin Chye].
Adjourned accordingly at
One Minute to Five o'clock p.m. to Wednesday, 11th January, 1961.