| Parliament No: | 0 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 23 |
| Sitting No: | 10 |
| Sitting Date: | 19-11-1964 |
|
Column: 771
LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY DEBATES
STATE OF SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
FIRST SESSION OF THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY
PART II OF FIRST SESSION |
VOLUME 23 |
Thursday, 19th November, 1964
The Assembly met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Mr A. P. Rajah).
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law.
Inche Buang Bin Omar Junid (Kallang), Parliamentary Secretary to the Deputy Prime Minister.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs and Government Whip.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta).
Mr Chia Thye Poh (Jurong).
Mr Chow Chiok Hock (Ulu Pandan).
Dr Fong Kim Heng (Joo Chiat), Deputy Speaker.
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister for Finance.
Mr R. A. Gonzales (Serangoon Gardens).
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development.
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Labour.
Mr Koo Young (Thomson).
Mr Kow Kee Seng (Paya Lebar).
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Tiong Bahru).
Column: 772
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (River Valley).
Mr Lim Huan Boon (Bukit Merah).
Mr Lim Kim San (Cairnhill), Minister for National Development.
Inche Mahmud Awang (Kampong Kapor).
Inche Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Mrs Devan Nair (Moulmein).
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ong Lian Teng (Bukit Panjang).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Education.
Mr Poh Ber Liak (Tampines).
Inche Rahamat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Culture.
Mr S. Rajoo (Farrer Park).
Mr Bernard Rodrigues (Telok Blangah).
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Tan Cheng Tong (Jalan Kayu).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Deputy Prime Minister and Leader of the House.
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour.
Inche Yaacob Bin Mohamed Al-Haj (Southern Islands), Parliamentary Secretary to the Prime Minister.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Health.
ABSENT:
Mr S. T. Bani (Crawford).
Mr Chan Sun Wing (Nee Soon).
Column: 773
Mr Chio Cheng Thun (Choa Chu Kang).
Mr Lee Tee Tong (Bukit Timah).
Mr S. V. Lingam (Aljunied).
Miss Loh Miaw Gong (Havelock).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Eng Guan (Hong Lim).
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Mr Wong Soon Fong (Toa Payoh).
Column: 773
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
ELECTION OF ONE MEMBER TO
FEDERAL HOUSE OF
REPRESENTATIVES
2.31 p.m.
Mr Speaker: Yesterday, I received a letter dated 16th
November, 1964, from His Excellency the Yang di-Pertuan Negara
to the effect that by virtue of the provisions of the Singapore
(Election to the House of Representatives) Ordinance, he had
been informed that a vacancy exists in the House of
Representatives following the resignation of Mr Ho See Beng,
and requesting me to arrange for the election of a Member in
accordance with the provisions of the said Ordinance.
Members of this House are aware that Mr Ho See Beng, who is
the sitting Member for Bras Basah and a member of the People's
Action Party, must be replaced by another member of the People's
Action Party on this election, and that is by virtue of the
provisions of the said Ordinance which I have just quoted. So
when Members elect another Member in replacement of the said Ho
See Beng, the Member should be nominated from amongst the
sitting Members in this House from the People's Action Party.
Now, by virtue of the powers vested in the Assembly under the
provisions of the Singapore (Election to the House of
Representatives) Ordinance, this Assembly will now proceed to
the election of the Member. Any proposal?
Column: 774
The Deputy Prime Minister (Dr Toh Chin Chye): Mr Speaker, I
propose Mr E.W. Barker to fill the vacancy.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health (Mr Sia Kah Hui): Mr Speaker, I second the proposal.
Mr Speaker: There being no other proposal, I declare Mr E. W.
Barker to have been elected to fill the vacancy.
In accordance with section 7 of the Singapore (Election to the
House of Representatives) Ordinance, 1963, I will certify to the
Speaker of the House of Representatives the name of the person
elected, that is to say, Mr E.W. Barker, as a Member of the
House of Representatives from Singapore to fill the vacancy.
There is now a certificate in my Chamber awaiting my signature
which will be signed during the tea break.
2.35 p.m.
Column: 774
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
CONTRACT LABOUR
Mr Bernard Rodrigues asked the Minister for National
Development (a) to list the areas in which contract labour
has been introduced in his Ministry to perform jobs previously
carried out by regular labour; and (b) to state the reason or
reasons why contract labour has been engaged to perform jobs previously carried out by regular labour.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, contract labour has not been
introduced by my Ministry to displace the regular labour force.
It has always been the practice, when there are temporary peaks
in the volume of regular work with which the regular labour
force cannot cope, to let the work out on contract. Otherwise an
increase in the regular labour force for an occasional overflow
of work would mean a redundancy problem when the volume of work
returns to normal.
In one particular case, the regular labour force expressed
aversion to the work of removal of sludge in the Ulu Pandan
Sewerage Disposal Works because of the unpleasant smell, and
asked to be taken off these duties. This work
Column: 775
has therefore been given out to contract since the end of 1963.
However, in certain fields of unskilled labour such as grass
cutting, planting of grass along road sides and side tables of
roads, the efficiency of the regular labour force is being
checked against work allocated on contracts in order to see
whether departmental labour is keeping up its rate of
productivity. There has been a tendency in the regular labour
force to slow down the pace of work in order to create overtime
on public holidays and Sundays. If this trend persists, the
productivity of the regular labour force will become lower and
lower and finally ludicrously uneconomic.
This problem is now widespread in all Government Departments
where overtime can be created by slowing down the pace of work.
The Government is having a committee to look into this matter
with a view to removing the temptation to slow down productivity
in order to create overtime. Unless this problem is solved, the
disparity between departmental labour and work let out on
contract will make it absurd for the Government to continue its
present policy of high daily wages at the minimum of $4.55 per
day for unskilled labour, with double and treble overtime for
Sundays and public holidays. The Government is sure that most of
its union leaders are keen to protect their honest and
hard-working members and will want to eradicate malpractices
leading to deliberate malingering and absenteeism.Absenteeism is
sometimes as high as 25 per cent on a week day and as low as 3
per cent on a public holiday when treble pay obtains. In some
cases, drivers of lorries have earned as much as $380 per month
and workers have earned more than $200 per month through
artificially created overtime giving them incomes more than
their supervisors. This problem has become more and more vicious
over the last six to seven years. A possible solution would seem
to lie, as in the case of the Singapore Port Authority, in the
abolition of overtime through the introduction of shift duties
at rates of pay which guarantee that the total
Column: 776
take-home pay will be at least 26 days full wages per month for
each worker.
The Government will be discussing this matter with the unions
to work out a solution which will do justice not only to the
honest and industrious workers but also to the tax-payers.
Mr Rodrigues (Telok Blangah) rose ---
Mr Speaker: A supplementary question?
Mr Bernard Rodrigues: Mr Speaker, Sir, a supplementary question.
Will the Minister state why he has not consulted the union concerned
before accepting and making use of contract labour? Will he also
undertake to consult the union concerned in future?
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, in my reply just now, I said
we do make use of contract labour during peak hours. That means
there is some work which has got to be done quickly. On the one
hand, we are trying to do our very best to expedite the work of
the Government; and on the other hand, there is a request here
which says, why did I not consult the trade union? It would have
taken me at least six months to get an answer from them if I
were to consult them whether contract labour could be used or
not. I think it is well within the authority of the Government
to employ contract labour if and when we think it necessary to
expedite work.
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah): A supplementary question. Will
the Minister tell this House how exactly the Government intends
to implement the P.A.P. policy on socialism ---
Mr Speaker: That is not a supplementary question.
Mr Ho See Beng: Sir, I would like to put it in another way.
Mr Speaker: The Member will have to rephrase it.
Mr Ho See Beng: If contract labour succeeds in increasing
efficiency, will the Government permit it to create more inroads
into the public sectors?
Mr Speaker: That is better.
Column: 777
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, we are aware of the abuse
which can take place in contract labour. But, at the same time,
Mr Speaker, Sir, we are elected by the people to administer the
government. We are trustees of the public funds. We are not
going to spend money to enlarge a force where malpractices such
as I have stated exist. It is our duty, Sir, to see that the
labourer is worth his pay. We do not want to have malingering.
We do not want to have artificially created overtime. In this
respect, I say that the trade union leaders and the members of
the trade union themselves have a responsibility. We are here to
foster a more enlightened labour policy. But, in doing so, Mr
Speaker, Sir, it takes not only the Government, but the labour
leaders and the members of the union to see that both play their
part. It is only when there is a certain minimum standard of
efficiency that we can undertake to see that more and more
daily-rated labourers are being used to carry out our work.
Column: 777
BILLS INTRODUCED
FEEDSTUFFS BILL
First Reading
The Minister for National Development (Mr Lim Kim San): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I have His Excellency the Yang di-Pertuan Negara's recommendation to introduce a Bill intituled "An Ordinance
to provide for the control of feeding stuffs for animals or birds."
I beg to introduce accordingly.
Bill read the First time.
Second Reading
Mr Speaker: Second Reading, what day, Mr Minister?
Mr Lim Kim San: The next available sitting, Sir.
Mr Speaker: So be it.
Column: 778
2.45 p.m.
ANIMALS BILL
First Reading
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I have His Excellency the
Yang di-Pertuan's recommendation to introduce a Bill intituled
"An Ordinance to amend and consolidate the laws for preventing
the introduction into, and the spreading within, Singapore of
diseases of animals; for the control of the movement of animals
into, within and from Singapore; for the prevention of cruelty
to animals; for measures pertaining to the general welfare, and
improvement of animals in Singapore and for purposes incidental
thereto." I beg to introduce accordingly.
Bill read the First time.
Second Reading
Mr Speaker: Second Reading, what day?
Mr Lim Kim San: At the next available sitting day.
Mr Speaker: So be it.
Column: 778
SLAUGHTER-HOUSES AND
MEAT PROCESSING FACTORIES
BILL
First Reading
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I have His Excellency the
Yang di-Pertuan Negara's recommendation to introduce a Bill
intituled "An Ordinance to provide for the control and licensing
of slaughter-houses and meat processing factories and matters
incidental thereto, and to repeal Part V of the Local Government
Integration Ordinance, 1963 (No. 18 of 1963)." I beg to
introduce accordingly.
Bill read the First time.
Second Reading
Mr Speaker: Second Reading, what day?
Mr Lim Kim San: At the next available sitting day.
Column: 779
CATTLE BILL
First Reading
The Minister for Health (Mr Yong Nyuk Lin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
lay upon the Table a Certificate of Urgency signed by His
Excellency the Yang di-Pertuan Negara in respect of the Cattle
Bill.
Certificate of Urgency handed in.
Mr Speaker: The Certificate is in order. Please proceed.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to introduce a Bill
intituled "An Ordinance to provide for the licensing of places
used for the keeping of cattle, the control of the transport and
movement of cattle and matters incidental thereto for the
purpose of the preservation of public health."
Bill read the First time.
Second Reading
Mr Speaker: Second Reading, what day?
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Immediately after the conclusion of the
proceedings on the Housing Developers (Control and Licensing)
Bill.
Mr Speaker: So be it. Are typed copies of the Bill available
for the use of Members?
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Typed copies of the Bill are with the Clerk,
Mr Speaker, Sir.
Typed copies of the Bill circulated to
hon. Members.
Column: 779
CONSIDERATION OF MORE THAN
ONE ITEM OF BUSINESS OF
SUPPLY
(Business Motion)
2.50 p.m.
Resolved, "That, notwithstanding the Standing Orders, the
Second Supplementary Estimates of Expenditure for 1964 and the
Second Supplementary Development Estimates for 1964 (contained
in Papers Cmd. 27 of 1964 and Cmd. 26 of 1964 respectively) and
the second and third readings of the Supply Bill and the
Supplementary Supply (No. 2) Bill, 1964, be taken today."-[Dr
Goh Keng Swee].
Column: 780
SECOND SUPPLEMENTARY
ESTIMATES OF EXPENDITURE
FOR 1964 OF THE STATE OF
SINGAPORE (PAPER CMD. 27
OF 1964) AND SECOND
SUPPLEMENTARY
DEVELOPMENT ESTIMATES OF
EXPENDITURE FOR 1964 OF THE
STATE OF SINGAPORE (PAPER CMD. 26 OF 1964)
2.52 p.m.
Order read for consideration in Committee of Supply [Allotted Day].
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
The Chairman: Second Supplementary Estimates of Expenditure for
1964 as contained in Paper Cmd. 27 of 1964. The summary is at
page 5 of the Paper.
No notice of amendment has been received. There are seven Heads
of Expenditure: Head 8 Planning, Head 12 Marine Surveys, Head 26
Customs and Excise, Head 34 Ministry of Culture, Head 39 Social
Welfare, Head 40 Ministry of Education, and Head 41 Ministry of
Law. I propose to take those Heads of Expenditure* en bloc.
*Following are the heads of expenditure:-
Head Title Total
$
8 Planning 47,790
12 Marine Surveys 5,330
26 Customs and Excise 173,250
34 Ministry of Culture 514,650
39 Social Welfare 1,129,578
40 Ministry of Education 10,824,000
41 Ministry of Law 5,100
___________
12,699,698
Total to be voted ___________
Column: 781
Question, "That the sums stated for the heads stated in the
summary of totals contained in Paper Cmd. 27 of 1964 stand part
of the Second Supplementary Estimates of Expenditure for 1964",
put, and agreed to.
Question, "That the sum of $12,699,698 shall be supplied to the
Government under the heads of expenditure for the public
services shown in the Second Supplementary Estimates of
Expenditure for 1964 contained in Paper Cmd. 27 of 1964", put,
and agreed to.
Resolution to be reported.
The Chairman: Second Supplementary Development Estimates of
Expenditure for 1964 as contained in Paper Cmd. 26 of 1964. The
summary is at page 4 of the Paper.
No notice of amendment has been received. There are five Heads
of Expenditure: Head D21 Ministry of Finance, Head D26 Customs
and Excise, Head D40 Ministry of Education, Head D41 Public
Works, Non-Recurrent (General), Head D43 U.K. Financial
Assistance Schemes. I propose to take those Heads of
Expenditure* en bloc.
*Following are the heads of expenditure:-
Head Title Total
$
D21 Ministry of Finance 5,900,000
D26 Customs and Excise 10,000
D40 Ministry of Education 1,000,000
D41 Public Works, Non-Recurrent(General) 150,000
D43 U.K Financial Assistance Schemes 831,385
___________
7,891,385
Total to be voted ___________
Question, "That the sums stated for the heads stated in the
summary of totals contained in Paper Cmd. 26 of 1964 stand part
of the Second Supplementary Development Estimates of Expenditure
for 1964", put, and agreed to.
Question, "That the sum of $7,891,385 shall he supplied to the
Government under the heads of expenditure for the public
services shown in the Second Supplementary Development
Column: 782
Estimates of Expenditure for 1964 contained in Paper Cmd. 26 of
1964", put, and agreed to.
Resolution to be reported.
Thereupon Mr Speaker left the Chair of the Committee and took
the Chair of the Assembly.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, I beg to report that the Committee of
Supply have come to certain resolutions.
Resolutions reported ---
"That the sum of $12,699,698 shall be supplied to the
Government under the heads of expenditure for the public
services shown in the Second Supplementary Estimates of
Expenditure for 1964 contained in Paper Cmd. 27 of
1964."
"That the sum of $7,891,385 shall he supplied to the Government
under the heads of expenditure for the public services shown in
the Second Supplementary Development Estimates of Expenditure
for 1964 contained in Paper Cmd. 26 of 1964."
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, I beg to move, "That the Assembly doth
agree with the Committee of Supply on the said resolutions."
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolutions accordingly agreed to.
Column: 782
SUPPLY BILL
2.58 p.m.
Order for Second and Third Readings read.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
The Main Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure for the year 1965
have
Column: 783
been considered and approved by the Assembly as Cmd. Paper 24 of
1964. Under section 85 of the Constitution of the State of
Singapore, Heads of Expenditure other than statutory expenditure
to be met from the Consolidated Fund have to be included in a
Bill to be known as a Supply Bill. The purpose of such a Bill is
to provide for the issue from the Consolidated Fund of the sums
necessary to meet that expenditure and the appropriation of
those sums for the purposes specified therein.
The Supply Bill before Members is to give legislative approval
for the issue of funds from the Consolidated Fund to meet the
sums of expenditure shown in the Estimates of Expenditure for
1965. In the Schedule to the Bill are shown the various Heads of
Expenditure and the sums that may be incurred in respect of each
Head, These have been approved by the Assembly in the Estimates
of Expenditure for 1965 and appear in page 39 of Paper Cmd. 24
of 1964. Once the Supply Bill is approved, I will be empowered
to issue warrants authorising expenditure up to the amount under
each Head as shown in the Bill to be paid out from the
Consolidated Fund.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Third Reading
Mr Speaker: Will the Minister please proceed now with the
Third Reading?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Third time."
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 783
SUPPLEMENTARY SUPPLY
(NO. 2) BILL
3.02 p.m.
Order for Second and Third Readings read.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I beg to
Column: 784
move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
The purpose of this Bill is to provide statutory authority in
accordance with clause 2 of Article 85 and clause 2 of Article
87 of the Constitution of the State of Singapore for certain
additional provisions for expenditure in excess of the
provisions for expenditure authorised by the Supply Ordinance,
1963. These additional sums which were scheduled as
Supplementary Estimates have received the approval of the Legislative
Assembly.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Third Reading
Mr Speaker: Will the Minister please proceed with the Third
Reading?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Third time."
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 784
LEMBAGA GERAKAN
PELAJARAN DEWASA
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.05 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education (Inche A. Rahim Ishak) (for the Minister for Education)(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second
time."
The Lembaga Gerakan Pelajaran Dewasa, constituted under section
5 of the principal Ordinance, consists of eleven members
appointed by the Minister for Education. Under paragraph (c) of
section 5, one member is to be appointed on the nomination of
the Minister for Labour and Law; under paragraph (f) of the same
section, one member is to be appointed from among the tutorial
staff of the University of
Column: 785
Malaya in Singapore and under paragraph (h) of the same
section, two members are to be appointed on the nomination of
the Trades Union Congress in Singapore.
Due to the change in ministerial responsibility in the
portfolio of Labour and Law and of nomenclature in respect of
the University of Malaya in Singapore and to the fact that the
Trades Union Congress is no longer in existence, no appointment
of members to the Board can be made under paragraphs (c), (f)
and (h) of section 5 of the principal Ordinance. Therefore, it
is necessary to amend these paragraphs to enable the Minister
for Education to make such appointments.
To avoid going to the Legislative Assembly in future for
amendments such as those I have just mentioned, it is considered
that the Minister for Education should be empowered to vary the
composition of the Board, by notification in the Gazette. It is
also considered that the Minister should be similarly empowered
to vary the number of the members of the Board and provide for
the manner in which additional members, if any, shall be appointed. The additional subsection (10) to section 5 proposed in the
Bill serves such purposes. In fact, identical provisions have
been made under subsection (4) of section 3 of the Architects
Ordinance (Cap. 189).
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to a
Committee of the whole Assembly.
Assembly immediately resolved itself into a Committee on the
Bill. [Inche A. Rahim. Ishak].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without amendment; read
a Third time and passed.
Column: 786
REGISTRATION OF DENTISTS
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.08 p.m.
The Minister for Health (Mr Yong Nyuk Lin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
This Bill seeks to amend the Registration of Dentists Ordinance
(Chapter 197 of the Revised Edition) to enable a dentist
registered in the Second Division of the Register of Dentists
and practising in Singapore to be appointed to the Dental Board
by the Minister.
The Dental Board formed under this Ordinance has as its main
function the control of the registration of dentists and the
regulation of the practice of dentistry in the State.
There are two classes of dentists who are registered under the
Ordinance:
Dental surgeons trained in recognised Dental Schools and have
Dental Degrees. These are registered under the First Division of
the Register.
Unqualified dentists who are non-graduate dentists but
registered under the Second Division of the Register.
Before the register for unqualified dentists was closed in
1950, opportunity was given to all unregistered dentists then
practising in Singapore to be registered under the Second
Division, if they should pass a registration examination. Out of
197 candidates who presented themselves for the said
examination, 173 were successful and were accordingly registered
under the Second Division of the Register. The Dental Register
as at 30th June, 1964, stood as follows:- 117 Division I
dentists and 223 Division II dentists.
The Division II dentists formed themselves into an organisation
known as the Singapore Chinese Dentists' Association. In April
this year the Association petitioned this Ministry for a
representative of the Association to serve on the Dental Board.
This proposition was acceptable to the Ministry because even
Column: 787
in Malaya, a representative from Division II Dentists had been
serving on the Malayan Dental Board for some time. Clause 2 (a)
(k) of the Bill now seeks to provide for such representation of
Division II dentists on the Singapore Dental Board.
The opportunity is taken in clauses 2 and 3 of the Bill to make
certain minor amendments in the Ordinance, mostly in
nomenclature. The words "Federation of Malaya" are to be
substituted by the word "Federation", except in section 5 (1)
(f) of the Ordinance where the words are to be substituted by
the "States of Malaya". The Head of the Department of Dentistry,
Faculty of Medicine, University of Singapore, is to supersede
the seat previously held by the Professor of Dental Surgery, and
the words "Malayan Dental Association" are to be substituted by
the words "Malaysian Dental Association" in accordance with the
new registered name of the Association.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to a
Committee of the whole Assembly.
Assembly immediately resolved itself into a Committee on the
Bill.-[Mr Yong Nyuk Lin].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without amendment; read
a Third time and passed.
Column: 787
HOUSING DEVELOPERS
(CONTROL AND LICENSING)
BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.16 p.m.
The Minister for National Development (Mr Lim Kim San): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second
time."
This Bill is the direct outcome of complaints from many sources
about the sharp practices of certain unscrupulous housing
developers in their dealings with house purchasers. Such
complaints have been ventilated in the Press from time
Column: 788
to time, the architects' profession have openly clamoured for
some form of regulation of building construction so that the
relationship between the developer and house purchaser is
properly set out, and even certain members of the legal
profession have been alarmed at the very one-sided contracts
which house purchasers have to enter into with the developer.
One may well ask why, in a system such as we have in Singapore,
any government interference with the laws of demand and supply
is necessary. The answer is simple. While the Government tries
to satisfy the housing necessity of the lower and lower-middle
income groups by providing public housing for sale or for rent,
it has always been assumed that the private sector will provide
for those who would wish to live in better types of
accommodation than those provided at public expense. Hence,
while we are aware that 14,000 to 16,000 units of housing may be
required each year, our efforts have been directed to supplying
only 10,000 to 12,000 units annually, leaving the remaining
one-third or so to be supplied by private enterprise. This is
healthy in so far as the State should not have the monopoly of
providing housing, private enterprise should participate in the
development of our city areas, and better type of housing should
be built at the same time as low cost housing.
Unfortunately, because of shortage of land, varying building
conditions and the upward trend of prices of building materials,
there are many uncertainties in the housing development
business. While certain well established development
organisations with proper financial backing and managerial
experience are able to cope with the changing situation and to
deliver the goods in accordance with the terms of agreement
entered into with the purchaser, the existence of such
uncertainties has given birth to a spate of mushroom housing
developers who use every opportunity to make quick profits at
the expense of the house purchaser.
In a situation where the purchaser is acutely aware that the
limited amount of money he has to purchase a house
Column: 789
might soon be insufficient due to rising land prices and
building costs, it is not surprising that he will be prepared to
enter into agreements which are so patently one-sided and most
disadvantageous to him. Many of these agreements provide for
refunds of deposit to the purchaser without any special reason;
increase in the price of the property to be purchased; no time
limit for the completion of the house; a free hand in varying
the materials to be used and in the alterations to the detailed
plans; and various additional items of expenditure.
As a result of such unscrupulous practices by certain
developers, many house purchasers have been properly swindled.
In the eyes of the law, there is little they can do about it
because the agreement they have entered into is perfectly legal.
Such purchasers have, therefore, little redress; they can, of
course, withdraw and have their money back, often many years
after paying the initial deposit, but by that time land prices
and prices of properties would have gone up to such an extent
that he would feel properly cheated.
On the part of the speculative developer, it is clear that he
has no intention of delivering the goods early; what he wants is
to make use of the purchaser's money for as long as possible. He
enters into a series of land speculations, promising flats or
homes for one set of purchasers after another, while in the
meantime either acquiring, mortgaging and re-mortgaging whatever
land he has got in the hope of cashing in on rising land values,
or if land values do not rise fast enough, using the money
collected as deposits for other types of business. All this is
most unhealthy for the economy of the State.
The main purpose of this legislation now before the House is to
give a certain amount of protection to the innocent house
purchaser by preventing the excesses of the building developers
and by bringing all housing developers under the proper control
of Government.
Column: 790
In the long term, the other more important purpose of this Bill
is to ensure that we encourage the establishment of proper
housing developers who will contribute their share to the re-development of the City of Singapore. As you know, Mr Speaker,
Sir, we are now going in a big way into the problems of the
large scale re-development of our City. The Government does not
intend to do, and cannot do, all the re-development but will
welcome private participation. In fact, it is the considered
view of the Government that every effort should be made to
ensure that the greater part, if not all of the re-development
of our City, should be done by private enterprise. The State
will only ensure that the conditions of urban renewal are
congenial for private participation. It will acquire the land,
do away with fragmented ownership, provide for the resettlement
of existing tenants, rehousing them in new housing estates,
replan the area on a comprehensive basis and make available
sizeable plots to private enterprises to develop in accordance with
a pre-planned pattern.
In order that this can come about, there must exist in the
State sufficient development organisation and institutions with
the proper financial backing and managerial experience to make
serious large-scale capital investments. There will not be any
place for unscrupulous speculators and opportunists. Hence the
need now to weed out such opportunists in order to foster the
healthy growth of sound development organisations. The
experience gained in developing houses for sale will go a long
way towards training these developers in the techniques of
development for long term investment.
The Bill now before the House will seek to enforce control over
the operations of building developers. It lays down that
developers, whether a company or individual or partnership, can
only operate with sufficient capital under a licence. In the
case of a company, it must have a paid up capital of not less
than $500,000, and in the case of a partnership or individual, a
deposit of $100,000 will have to be made with the Controller.
Column: 791
The Controller to be appointed under the Bill will be vested
with wide powers. He may, at any time after the grant of a
licence, vary or revoke any conditions of the licence or impose
conditions or additional conditions on the licence. There is,
however, a provision for appeal to the Minister in any case
where the developer is dissatisfied by the action of the
Controller. The use of the words "Housing Developers" will now
be regulated, and no one can now carry on the business of
housing development without a licence. Stringent control will be
applied on housing developers and every licensee will be
required to exhibit in his office a copy of his last audited
balance sheet and the full names and particulars of all persons
who are in control and management' of the business.
The housing developer will be required to appoint an auditor to
make a report upon his annual balance sheet and accounts, and
the Controller is furthermore empowered to investigate the
books, accounts and transactions of the developer, or the
Minister may order the Controller or an Inspector to investigate
into the affairs of a licensed housing developer. Where
purchasers are dissatisfied, the Minister can order an
investigation into the affairs of a licensed housing developer
if an application is made by not less than five purchasers.
In certain circumstances, such as a housing developer being
unable to meet his obligations, or if he conducts his business
in a manner detrimental to the purchasers or the public, or if
he informs the Controller that he is unable to meet his
obligations, the Minister may direct a company or board to
assume control.
The Bill will empower the Minister to make rules for the
purposes of the Ordinance in such matters as regulating the
advertisements of the housing developer, the use of names of
housing estates, the payments and deposits to be made by
purchasers at various stages of construction of the house, the
forms of contracts to be used by the housing developer, and the
conditions in the contract which, if used, will be void.
Column: 792
There is a prohibition in the Bill to prevent a person, who
becomes bankrupt, or suspends his payments or compounds with his
creditors, or if he is convicted of an offence involving dishonesty or fraud, from being a director, manager or secretary of
a licensed housing developer company.
The Minister will be empowered to exempt any person, group of
persons, society, company or statutory board from the provisions
of the Ordinance. There are also transitional provisions for the
licensing of housing developers who were in business before 1st
November, 1964, and who may not be in a position to comply fully
with the requirements of the Bill. In such circumstances, when
the Bill becomes law, they may be granted provisional licence
with or without conditions, for a period which may extend up to
five years, and which may be revoked at any time.
In drafting this legislation, careful consideration has been
given to all the complaints that have been received in the
Ministry as well as those made in the Press. I would also wish
to thank the Bar Committee for making suggestions for the
formulation of the principles of this Bill. They submitted
written views and suggestions to the State Advocate-General and
to my Ministry, and the State Advocate-General's Office in pre
paring this Bill have given careful consideration to their views
and suggestions.
Sir, I beg to move.
3.30 p.m.
Question proposed.
The Minister for Labour (Mr Jek Yeun Thong): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I rise to speak in support of the Bill.
Purchasers of houses have for a long time been at the mercy of
unscrupulous men whose sole aim has been to make quick money at
the expense of would-be purchasers. There are, of course, many
decent business men who develop housing estates, and their
service to society is acknowledged as an effective corollary to
the Government's policy of providing decent living standards for
the people. Over the past few years,
Column: 793
the Government has concentrated on building flats for the people
in the lower income group because this is the group that really
needs Government assistance. This has left people in the middle
and upper income groups to look to private housing developers
for houses. Once a man's combined family income is up to a
maximum of $800 per month, it is left to himself to find a
house. But this does not mean that he must be left to the
wolves. Many of these people, especially in the middle income
group, are ordinary working people who dream of purchasing a
house. They sweat and toil to save enough money at least for the
initial deposit for a house, foregoing many of the ordinary
pleasures of life. When they are exploited by unscrupulous
developers, their dream of a house of their own is shattered and
the attendant hardships are of some magnitude.
We must not allow racketeers disguised in the name of housing
developers to rob the fruits of prosperity of our society.
Prosperity must be shared. So is the wealth of our country. The
common man has every right to expect a decent house of his own
and to lead a decent life. We must not allow racketeers to
frustrate his hopes. And if racketeers make false plans and
promises to rob them of their hard-earned savings, it is the
duty of the Government to suppress these racketeers.
The few racketeers in the housing business are nothing more
than harmful parasites who live on the sufferings of innocent
people. They have probably no land, no concrete plans, and even
no business capital. Newspaper advertisements and flamboyant
brochures and pamphlets are published to lure deposits from
innocent buyers. The deposits so made constitute their working
capital with which they purchase land, not with the intention of
building houses thereon immediately, but with an eye to
speculative profit. They wait for some time until the price of
land increases and then notify the people who have booked houses
that in the light of the increased price of land,
Column: 794
an increased price over that originally agreed must be paid for
the house, and in some cases they even return the deposit, after
having made money out of the accumulated deposits, with the
trite excuse that the booking has been cancelled. In some cases,
a transfer fee in addition to the deposit is demanded and when
the frustrated buyer finally demands back the deposit, he gets
it, but not the transfer fee. If the buyer, on the other hand,
had deposited the money in a bank he would have earned interest,
but when caught in the web of these racketeers he not only loses
his transfer fee but the interest that he would have earned. The
racketeer has always the upper hand - he tosses the coin and
confidently expects to call always "Heads, I win, tails you
lose."
Some of the shrewder ones, however, give an appearance of
legitimacy. They make the price attractively low to lure buyers,
but what the unsuspecting buyer does not know is that the
developer has deliberately excluded from the price he quotes
very important items such as septic tank, electrical cables,
etc. When the house nears completion, and the buyer is already
firmly committed, the developer confronts the buyer for a few
thousand dollars more for the laying of cables or installation
of a septic tank, and so on. What can the buyer do but pay the
additional amount demanded, for he cannot live in a house
without basic necessities like lighting and modern sanitation?
It is sad to say that today there are already some house buyers
who are in a very ridiculous and pitiful position; living in a
modern house without modern sanitation.
We also know of developers who, in the final stages of
building, suddenly tell the buyers that they have to pay more
than the agreed price on the pretext that prices have generally
increased. In a few instances, resolute buyers have joined to
resist such developers with some measure of success.
I will now cite cases of housing companies which have caused
hardship to house-buyers.
Column: 795
The first case I would like to cite is that involving the
Jurong Park Limited at No. 38 Jurong Road, 8¼ milestone. In
1962, this company published advertisements in the newspapers
announcing its proposed housing estate. These advertisements
attracted many school headmasters and teachers in Chinese
schools in the Jurong area because it presented them with an
excellent opportunity to obtain adequate housing accommodation
close to their place of work. Many of them booked houses, but
more than 2½ years have elapsed since then, and the estate is
not even in its first phase of building programme. I also know
of one particular person, a friend of mine, who had dealings
with this same company. He was so eager to get a house in this
estate that he paid $2,500 to the company as a transfer fee to
book one and, in addition, he paid $1,000 as initial deposit.
His hopes, however, were doomed to despair for, when 6 months
later he visited the site, he found to his consternation that
the site remained nothing more than the original wasteland that
it was. There was no sign of building, not even a bulldozer or a
building contractor's temporary office. He, therefore, wrote to
the company asking when the house would be complete. The company
returned him the deposit of $1,000 he had paid, informing him
that his booking had been cancelled and that he would have to
look for a house elsewhere. The same letter also threatened to
take legal action against him for sending copies of his letter
to the Government. There was no mention of the $2,500 he had
paid as a transfer fee to book the house; it would appear that
this amount had vanished, not into thin air as would commonly be
said, but, I am sure, into the pockets of someone in the company
and permanently lost to the person who paid
it.
The second case involves the Singapore Trading Company,
Limited, of Nos. 4 and 4-1 Collyer Quay, which has several
building projects in Singapore. I am mentioning only one housing
estate in particular, namely the Hillview Estate which is also
in the Jurong area. About the middle of 1961, the
Column: 796
Singapore Trading Company, Limited, advertised in the Press
about this estate. They also printed a pamphlet giving details
of their scheme and inviting applications. They called it a
"Save $5 to own a house" scheme. In my view, this is highly
suspect. However, this is a small point and I do not propose to
go further into it. The pamphlet asked people who were
interested in the scheme to apply to the Singapore Trading
Company, Limited. But when they did apply and, after several discussions, decided to buy such a house, surprisingly enough they
were asked to sign the usual agreement not with the Singapore
Trading Company, Limited, but with an entirely different company
called the Popular Estates Limited. Though I am not familiar
with this sort of thing, it appears odd to me that one firm
should offer houses for sale and another firm should be a party
to the agreement. It would seem to me that this is a ruse to
outwit the purchasers because the company that offered the
houses for sale cannot be held responsible if the houses were
not built according to the original specifications printed in
the pamphlet. This would give the second company, the actual
party to the transaction, an opening to sell houses very
different from the original specifications, and the buyer would
have no legal right of remedy against either company. The
Singapore Trading Company, Limited, and the Popular Estates
Limited are, however, in the same premises and the Managing
Director of both these firms is one called Seah Boon Heng. Mr
Seah very recently made a generous donation to the building fund
of the St. John's Ambulance Brigade and thereby obtained some
publicity in the Press as a philanthropist. If the harvest
reaped by racketeering is transformed into a donation and makes
the donor a philanthropist, may we be spared in future from such
a travesty!
Let us come back to the Hillview Estate in Jurong. Three years
have passed but the Hillview Estate is hardly in the first phase
of building activity. The worried and indignant purchasers have
joined forces and formed an
Column: 797
association to protect themselves against the unscrupulous
developers. I commend them for the action that they have taken.
Accordingly, the Hillview Estate House Owners and Residents
Association was registered on 15th July, 1964, as a society. On
1st of June, 1964, three years after the purchase agreement was
signed and when the Association was still in its pro-tem stage,
the pro-tem Secretary issued a circular to its members, the
contents of which will clearly signify their plight. I quote
below a few significant paragraphs. It says:
'The Vendor [that means the Company] in his last letter dated
26th February, 1964, assured us that the whole project was expected to the completed within the next five months.
Since then three good months have passed and there seems to be
no sign of completion even after the lapse of five months. Work
seems to be in progress, but only at a very slow unsteady pace,
which could mean that the target date could be dragged on for
another year or so.'
This was three years after the purchase agreement was signed.
It went on to say:
'We also note from our inspection of the site that the Car
Porch is not in accordance with the requirements. The drive way
to the Porch is at a very bad angle in practically all the
houses. We have, therefore, insisted to the vendor that at all
costs the drive way must be flat or parallel to the ground. You
could undoubtedly expect a further delay over this
representation. Nevertheless, we expect to attain our aim
patiently.
A letter dated 28th May, 1964, has been received by all
house-owners from the vendor recommending that house-owners consider
to build on their own retaining walls in front, back and side of
our land, which we are aware will cost well over a thousand
dollars. This extra unnecessary expenditure could have been
avoided had the developer taken greater care while planning the
site. We have no intention of suffering over-errors committed by
the developer. Moreover, there is nothing specific in our
agreement to the effect that such expenditure must be borne by
house-owners. Therefore, the Committee has decided to seek
further legal advice to put such shortcomings right.'
This is the common plight faced by the house purchasers who fell
into the merciless grip of these sharks in the building trade.
Strange to say, however, the law is used to tie up the
Column: 798
purchasers in what is almost always a one-side agreement in
which, unfortunately enough, lawyers play the vital role, and
the purchasers are at the receiving end. The law, of course, is
an honourable profession and it is most unfortunate that in the
name of the law dishonourable documents are drawn up to fix the
innocent buyers. Because the legal requirements are met in these
documents, it is almost impossible to bring unscrupulous
developers to court if they failed to fulfil their obligations.
The documents are framed in such a way that the developer is
completely free to change specifications, raise the price and
use any material he likes, and it is more than likely that these
would be inferior ones. There are possibly other ramifications
in this type of racketeering but, because I have not got
sufficient information on them, I do not propose to go into them
now.
In the absence of legislation to curb and control housing
developers and to protect home buyers, a fertile field will
exist for avaricious developers. Like vicious man-eating sharks,
they always hunt for their prey. The Government has, therefore,
a duty to protect society from them. A firm line has to be drawn
between legitimate business and bubble. The bubble must not be
allowed to form and if already formed we must take steps to
ensure that the public is protected before the bubble bursts.
Legitimate business serves a useful purpose in that it
contributes to economic and social development but the bubble,
on the other hand, lives on the sufferings of the people and is
therefore absolutely anti-social.
There are many other instances and I hope members of the
public, especially the purchasers, who are victims of these
building sharks, will come forward to give information to the
Government and the Controller to be appointed under this
Ordinance, so that remedial action can be taken against these
sharks in the building trade.
Sir, it is these sharks that have spoilt the good name of the
building trade, and it is these sharks that the Government seeks
to control and suppress.
Column: 799
Sir, I personally have no special love or hatred for these
housing developers. I never had any occasion to buy a house
myself. However, as a representative of the common people, it is
my duty to voice their protest and indignation against such an
evil force in our society and if I cannot do this safely ---
Mr Speaker: Order. I hear disturbances in the House which must
distract the attention of Members. Will Members, when they leave
their seats, please see that their earphones are turned off? Mr
Minister.
Mr Jek Yeun Thong: As a representative of the common people,
it is my duty to voice their protest and indignation against
such an evil force in our society, and if I cannot do this
safely outside the House without being involved in expensive law
suits, then I must do it in this House under its privilege which
is meant for such purpose.
The Government is also interested in seeing that genuine
developers will not be seriously affected by this law. We have,
therefore, decided to commit this Bill to a Select Committee
after its Second Reading in order to hear views from various
quarters. We hope that this Bill, after introduction, will help
to regularise and strengthen the building trade in Singapore.
Mr Speaker indicated Mr Lim Kim San.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be committed to a Select Committee consisting of Mr
Speaker as Chairman and seven other Members to be nominated by
the Committee of Selection."
Mr Speaker: No, I have not put the Question yet. I was
wondering whether the Minister wanted to reply. If the Minister
does not want to reply, I shall now put the Question.
Mr Lim Kim San: No, I do not wish to reply.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Column: 800
Committed to a Select Committee consisting of Mr Speaker as
Chairman and seven other Members to be nominated by the
Committee of Selection. -[Mr Lim Kim San].
Column: 800
CATTLE BILL
3.53 p.m.
Order for Second Reading read.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
This Bill seeks to provide for the licensing of places used for
the keeping of cattle, and control of transport and the movement
of cattle and for matters incidental thereto for the purpose of
the preservation of public health. In recent months there has
been a serious deterioration of the cattle problem and large
herds of cattle have been found roaming about built-up areas,
even in the City centre, causing a health nuisance and causing
damage to property, plants (and even of life!). Urgent action is
now required to control this problem as these wandering herds
seem to have increased in numbers. As the development of the
City proceeds with increasing tempo, it is necessary to bring
this problem under firm and effective control if our health
standards are not to deteriorate. The fact that there is less
and less land for cattle grazing in the State must be
recognised, and where cattle grazing could once take place
without serious consequences, this is no longer possible in
Singapore today.
The cattle also present a problem in that they damage private
and public property and tend to pollute water courses, drop dung
on public streets and other public places; and, in short, con
stitute a serious health menace. Cowdung constitutes an
excellent source of breeding for flies.
In the past, the control of different aspects of cattle was
covered by three different authorities. Firstly, the Health
Department was concerned only with the control of cattle insofar
as the licensing of cattle sheds and the sale of milk and milk
products was concerned. Secondly, the Police were concerned with
Column: 801
stray cattle under the Minor Offences Ordinance. Thirdly, the
Primary Production Department have been concerned with the
animal husbandry aspects of cattle.
The purpose of this Bill is principally to control cattle
within the State, including stray cattle, for the preservation
of public health. The Police are too preoccupied and have not
been able to deal with stray cattle which anyhow present a
health problem also. This will be done by total prohibition of
cattle in certain areas which may be declared by the Minister as
restricted areas. In such restricted areas, no cattle of the
category described in the Minister's order may be kept at all;
if found, such cattle will be liable to seizure and disposal by
the Health Authorities without compensation. In other areas
which are not declared as restricted areas for cattle within the
State, the keeping of cattle will be permitted under licence
issued by the Director of Medical Services. Here too, this is
subject to the proviso that such cattle shall be confined to the
licensed place specified in the licence and shall not be
permitted outside such licensed place except upon penalty of
seizure and disposal without compensation. The Bill also
provides for the necessary powers to control the movement and
transport of cattle.
The Bill provides for penalties for owners of cattle or those
in charge of
Column: 802
the cattle for non-compliance of the provisions of this Bill or
Regulations thereunder.
Singapore is in the phase of rapid development and is becoming
a complex urban development. In this situation, it is not
possible to allow cattle within its developed and built-up area.
They present a serious health problem (besides other problems)
and the measures sought in the Bill are for an effective means
of controlling the cattle for the preservation of public health.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to a
Committee of the whole Assembly.
Assembly immediately resolved itself into a Committee on the
Bill. - [MrYong Nyuk Lin].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without amendment; read
a Third time and passed.
Resolved, "That this Assembly do now adjourn to a date to be
determined by the Leader of the House." - [Mr S. Rajaratnam].
Adjourned accordingly at
five minutes past Four o'clock p.m.