| Parliament No: | 1 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 25 |
| Sitting No: | 6 |
| Sitting Date: | 26-10-1966 |
|
Column: 339
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
FIRST SESSION OF THE FIRST PARLIAMENT
PART II OF FIRST SESSION |
VOLUME 25 |
Wednesday, 26th October, 1966
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Mr P. Coomaraswamy).
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Education.
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development.
Inche Buang Bin Omar Junid (Kallang), Parliamentary Secretary to the Deputy Prime Minister.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs and Government Whip.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta).
Mr Chow Chiok Hock (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister of Defence.
Mr R. A. Gonzales (Serangoon Gardens).
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development.
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Labour.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State for Culture.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (River Valley).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah).
Column: 340
Mr Lim Kim San, D.U.T. (Cairnhill), Minister for Finance.
Mr S. V. Lingam (Aljunied).
Inche Mahmud Awang (Kampong Kapor).
Inche Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Mrs Devan Nair (Moulmein).
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Education.
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Culture and Social Affairs.
Inche Rahamat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr S. Rajoo (Farrer Park), Mr S. Ramaswamy (Crawford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance.
Mr Bernard Rodrigues (Telok Blangah).
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang).
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebah).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Deputy Prime Minister and Leader of the House.
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Minister of State of Defence.
Tuan Haji Yaacob Bin Mohamed (Southern Islands), Minister of State for the Prime Minister's Department.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Health.
Column: 341
ABSENT:
Mr Chan Sun Wing (Nee Soon).
Mr Koo Young (Thomson).
Miss Loh Miaw Gong (Havelock).
Mr Ong Lian Teng (Bukit Panjang).
Mr Poh Ber Liak (Tampines).
Mr Tan Cheng Tong (Jalan Kayu).
Mr Wong Soon Fong (Toa Payoh).
Column: 341
PERMISSION TO MEMBERS TO BE ABSENT
Under the provisions of clause 2 (d) of Article 30 of
the Constitution of Singapore, I have granted
permission to the following Members to be or to remain
absent from sittings of Parliament (or any committee
of Parliament to which they have been appointed) for
the period stated:-
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang) - from 2nd to 10th September, 1966.
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Education - from 1st to 29th September, 1966.
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs - from 1st to 12th September, 1966.
Mr Lim Kim San (Cairnhill), Minister for Finance - from 12th September to 10th October, 1966.
Dr Fong Kim Heng (Joo Chiat) - from 17th September to 17th October, 1966.
Column: 341
ASSENTS TO BILLS PASSED
I have been informed by the President that, on the days
stated, he assented to the following Bills:-
30th August, 1966
(i) Supplementary Supply (No. 2) Bill;
(ii) Free Trade Zones Bill;
(iii) Customs (Amendment No. 2) Bill;
(iv) Asian Development Bank Bill;
(v) Minor Offences (Amendment) Bill;
Column: 342
(vi) Limitation (Extension) Bill;
(vii) Constitution (Amendment) Bill; and
(viii) Road Traffic (Amendment No. 2) Bill.
31st August, 1966
(i) Punishment for Vandalism Bill; and
(ii) Judicial Committee Bill.
Column: 342
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
RESIGNATION OF MEMBERS
(Announcement by Mr Speaker)
Mr Speaker: Order. I have to inform hon. Members that
at 10.30 a.m. on the 18th of October, 1966, I received
to hand a letter dated the 4th October, 1966, under the
hand of Dr Fong Kim Heng, who was elected to this
House as Member for Joo Chiat, resigning his seat in
Parliament. Members will recall that Dr Fong has been
ill and has had to apply for periods of leave. In view
of his continued ill-health Dr Fong states that he
feels it his duty to resign his seat. Dr Fong's letter
was received in my office on the 4th of October, 1966.
I further have to inform hon. Members that at 10.30
a.m. on the 18th of October, 1966, I received to hand a
letter dated the 8th of October, 1966, signed by Mr
Chia Thye Poh who was elected to this House as Member
for Jurong. This letter was delivered to my office on
the 8th of October, 1966. The material part of this
letter reads as follows:-
"...the Party" (i.e, the Barisan Sosialis) "has decided
that all Barisan 'MPs' will resign their
'Parliamentary' seats as from today.
The 9 Barisan MPs are:-
1. Chia Thye Poh (Jurong)
2. Koo Young (Thomson)
3. Ong Lian Teng (Bukit Panjang)
4. Poh Ber Liak (Tampines)
5. Tan Cheng Tong (Jalan Kayu)
6. Miss Loh Miaw Gong (Havelock)
7. Chan Sun Wing (Nee Soon)
8. Lee Tee Tong (Bukit Timah)
9. Wong Soon Fong (Toa Payoh)".
Column: 343
I had to consider the effect of this letter in the
light of the Constitution, in particular, of Article 30
(2) (c) which provides that -
'The seat of a Member of Parliament shall become vacant, if,
by writing under his hand addressed to the
Speaker, he resigns his seat in Parliament;'.
In view of another letter I have received from Mr Lee
Tee Tong, who was elected to this House as Member for
Bukit Timah, what I say hereafter on Mr Chia's letter
has no reference to Mr Lee Tee Tong.
I have given Mr Chia Thye Poh's letter considerable
thought in view of the particular circumstances
affecting certain of the Members named in the letter.
To my mind, the provisions of Article 30 (2) (c) are
clear and preclude resignation by an agent. Any
resignation to be effective must, amongst other
requirements, be by writing under the hand of the
Member concerned and of no one else. I have, therefore,
come to the conclusion that the letter signed by Mr
Chia Thye Poh is ineffective for its expressed purpose
in so far as the following 7 persons are concerned:-
(1) Mr Koo Young - Member for Thomson
(2) Mr Ong Lian Teng - Member for Bukit Panjang
(3) Mr Poh Ber Liak - Member for Tampines
(4) Mr Tan Cheng Tong - Member for Jalan Kayu
(5) Miss Loh Miaw Gong - Member for Havelock
(6) Mr Chan Sun Wing - Member for Nee Soon
(7) Mr Wong Soon Fong - Member for Toa Payoh.
Mr Chia Thye Poh's own position caused me further difficulty in that, although the letter was under his hand and was addressed to me, he did not, in so many words, "resign his seat". However, after studying the matter and giving it considerable thought, I have come to the clear conclusion that Mr Chia Thye Poh's
personal intention was to resign his seat and that he
has adequately given effect to that intention by
Column: 344
signing that letter addressed to me in the terms in
which it was written and by causing that letter to be
delivered to me.
I also have to inform hon. Members that at 10.30 a.m.
on the 18th of October, 1966, I received to hand a
letter dated the 4th of October, 1966, under the hand
of Mr Lee Tee Tong, who was elected to this House as
Member for Bukit Timah, resigning his seat in
Parliament. This letter was received in my office on
the 14th of October, 1966.
Under the provisions of Article 91(4) , the
resignations of Dr Fong Kim Heng, Mr Chia Thye Poh
and Mr Lee Tee Tong have effect from 10.30 a.m, on the
18th of October, 1966.
Accordingly, I report to the House that the seats of
the Members for Joo Chiat, Jurong and Bukit Timah are
vacant.
Column: 344
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
NON-SINGAPORE CITIZENS
(Entry into Singapore)
1. Mr Ho See Beng asked the Deputy Prime Minister if
he will consider permitting the entry into Singapore of
non-Singapore citizens over the age of, say, 60 years
whose sponsors can adequately provide for them.
Dr Toh Chin Chye: Mr Speaker, Sir, the existing rule
is that widows of 65 years and above and widowers of 70
years and above will be considered for admission into
Singapore. I am prepared to revise this rule by
including widowers who are 65 years and above. However,
the Government has examined the question of whether the
age limit should be lowered to 60 years and has come to
the conclusion that, for the moment, it would be
inadvisable indeed to permit immigration of aged people
below 65 years.
Mr Speaker, the House is aware that as a little
island State, it is very necessary indeed that we
should exercise a firm immigration policy. Otherwise,
faced with our own population expansion together with
an influx from other territories, we might in the near
future
Column: 345
be encumbered with considerable social problems.
I would like, for the information of the Member, to
tell him that last year a total of 26 applications were
approved and this year, from January to September, a
total of 39 applications have been approved. The
majority of applications which were rejected were
mainly because the applications referred to those who
were below 65 years old. Another major reason was that
the applicant was living with other children either in
China or in India, and therefore could not be
considered.
I may also further emphasise that this regulation
concerning admission of aged parents into Singapore
refers expressly to widows or widowers and that these
persons should provide full evidence that they have no
other means of support if they are not permitted to
enter Singapore. I can assure the Member, as I have
done at the last sitting, that all applications are
considered on compassionate grounds but, at the same
time, we have also got to be fair not only to ourselves
but to the State so that we do not see that Singapore
is encumbered with unnecessary social problems.
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): A
supplementary question, Sir.
I would like to ask the Minister concerned this
question. In my constituency there is a resident who is
a citizen of Singapore and who has a mother of over 60
years of age in China. Several years ago he made a
request for her to come to Singapore but it was not
approved. The reason was that he had a relative in
China to support her. The complaint of this resident is
that this relative of his mother in China has already
been transferred to another place in China. So I would
like to ask whether the Minister will reconsider this
application.
Mr Speaker: I do not know whether the Minister can
answer that without notice.
Dr Toh Chin Chye: Yes, Mr Speaker. If the Member
will give me the name of
Column: 346
the applicant, the reference number of the letter which
he received or which his constituent received from the
Controller of Immigration, I will look into the matter.
But I must emphasise to him that there must be absolute
proof that there is nobody in China who could look
after the applicant. The Member has forgotten that the
ruling applies only to widows who are 65 years old and
above, and if she happens to be 62 years old, then I am
afraid she is not covered by this regulation and
therefore cannot be granted admission.
Column: 346
KEBUN UBI COMMUNITY CENTRE AT JALAN PENGGAGA
2. Inche Rahamat Bin Kenap asked the Minister of
Defence, with the resumption of normal relations with
Indonesia, whether steps will be taken to contact the
owners of the premises of the Kebun Ubi Community
Centre at Jalan Penggaga with a view to regularising
the tenancy of the Centre and if improvements will be
made to the premises, particularly to avoid flooding
during heavy rains.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Mr Speaker, Sir, the answer to
both parts of the question is "No".
No improvement to the building will avoid flooding
during heavy rains. The People's Association is
considering building a community centre elsewhere in
the constituency.
Column: 346
WOMEN IN SINGAPORE POLICE FORCE
3. Madam Chan Choy Siong asked the Minister of Defence
whether it is Government policy that women could and
should also share in the task of safeguarding the
security of our young Republic and whether he will take
immediate steps to create more opportunities for them
to serve in the Police Force.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Mr Speaker, Sir, it is the
Government's policy that women should share in the task
of safeguarding the security of our young Republic.
They take a rightful place in the ranks of both the
Police and the Army. The number of policewomen required
is, however,
Column: 347
limited by the fact that in the field of criminal
activity, particularly where violence is used, women
have not yet achieved equality with men. Therefore, it
is necessary to employ more policemen than policewomen.
Similarly, in the Army, women cannot be used as combat
troops, but they are usefully engaged in clerical,
nursing and communications work.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta)(In Mandarin): Sir, can
I supplement my question? If there are posts at present
which need women to come forward to serve the country,
especially posts in the Police Force, will the Minister
consider providing women with these facilities?
According to him, certain posts are not quite suitable
for women, but I understand that in the Police Force,
certain posts are quite suitable for women. Will he
consider providing better facilities for women to join
the Police Force?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Mr Speaker, Sir, at present the
number of posts in the establishment of policewomen is
something like 245 - in that order of magnitude - I
have not got the actual figure. Most of these posts are
filled. There are only a few vacancies, possibly about
half a dozen. These will be filled in the normal course
of work.
Column: 347
EAST EUROPEAN COMMUNIST COUNTRIES
(Setting up of Embassies or Trade Representations)
4. Mr Chow Chiok Hock asked the Minister for Foreign
Affairs whether the Government intends to set up
embassies or trade representations in East European
Communist Countries.
Mr S. Rajaratnam: The Member for Ulu Pandan will
recall my statement to this House on the 16th and 17th
of December last year in which I said that it was our
intention first to establish Missions in some ten
countries. At that time, I also mentioned that it was
our intention to set up other Missions when we can find
the personnel and the money or when political and trade
considerations justify their being set up earlier.
Column: 348
It is in such context that the establishment of
Embassies or trade representations in East European
countries will have to be viewed.
However, I would like to assure the Member for Ulu
Pandan that promotion of trade with as many countries
as possible regardless of ideological differences,
whether they are in the East or in the West, still
remains a major objective of our foreign policy. These
intentions have been embodied in the trade agreements
recently concluded with the U.S.S.R., Bulgaria and
Poland, which provide for the establishment of
Singapore trade representations in those countries in
the future.
Column: 348
HIGH COMMISSIONS AND EMBASSIES
(Personnel and expenditure)
5. Mr Chow Chiok Hock asked the Minister for Foreign
Affairs (a) to date, how many High Commissions and
Embassies have been set up and in which countries; (b)
how many personnel for diplomatic service have been
recruited; and (c) what is the annual expenditure for
High Commissions and Embassies.
Mr Rajaratnam: Mr Speaker, Sir, I informed this
House in December last year that it was the intention
of the Government to establish diplomatic missions
before the end of the year in ten countries.
As of now, diplomatic missions have been established
in the following countries: Australia, Cambodia,
Malaysia, New Zealand, Thailand and the United Kingdom.
In addition, a permanent mission to the United Nations
has been established in New York. It is hoped that
before the end of the year, diplomatic missions will
also be established in India, the United Arab Republic
and possibly Japan.
As regards the second part of the question, the Public
Service Commission has so far recruited four new
entrants, and in addition approved the secondment of
eight senior officers from different branches of the
home civil service for service in overseas missions.
These
Column: 349
figures do not, of course, include the heads of
missions nor do they include Division II officers
serving in overseas missions.
As regards the third part of the question on annual
expenditure, last year this House voted a sum of $� million for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. This sum
was spent on setting up the Ministry itself and two
overseas missions - one in Kuala Lumpur and the other
in New York. This year, a sum of $4 million has been
voted. However, since most of the overseas missions
were not fully established until the middle of this
year, the expenditure for the first half of the year
was below the expected average. Members will appreciate
that until the missions have been fully in existence
for at least a year, it will not be possible to give
reliable estimates of the annual expenditure.
Column: 349
PAYA LEBAR
(Integrated Secondary and Secondary Technical Schools)
6. Mr Tay Boon Too asked the Minister for Education
whether an integrated Secondary School and a Secondary
Technical School will be built in the Paya Lebar
Constituency.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, there are no
plans for the building of secondary schools in the Paya
Lebar Constituency under the Second Plan.
The International Airport takes up a quarter of the
area covered by this constituency. Whilst the remaining
areas are densely settled, it has not been possible to
acquire a suitable site within this constituency for
development into a secondary school, and the residents
living in this constituency are being served by
secondary schools in the neighbouring areas. One
secondary school is being built at Lowland Road, whilst
construction work on another secondary school in Mount
Vernon Road will begin shortly. These two secondary
schools are just outside the boundary of the Paya Lebar
Constituency and within
Column: 350
walking distance for students living in that
constituency.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I would like to ask a supplementary
question.
The point I would like to raise is that I regret that
the Minister for Education does not see fit to set up
the secondary schools as requested by me. There are
quite a number of residents in this constituency. If
there are not enough secondary schools, then -
Mr Speaker: I must draw the hon. Member's attention
to the rules which require his supplementary question
to be a genuine supplementary question and not a speech
of complaint about the inadequacy of the Minister's
answer. Could the hon. Member frame a question, please?
Mr Tay Boon Too(In Mandarin): Thank you for your
direction, Sir. It is very clear that if there is no
integrated secondary school in the Paya Lebar
Constituency, then it will be a great inconvenience to
the residents.
The point is that in the Paya Lebar Constituency,
there are no means of communication, no crossroads, not
even pirate taxis. Under such conditions, it is very
difficult for the residents to send their children to
schools outside the constituency. So I feel that it is
rather inconvenient in respect of time and other -
Mr Speaker: Mr Tay, I regret I have to rule you out
of order again. You may well have a genuine complaint,
and should you require it, I am sure the Clerk will
give you every guidance on how you can raise it on a
motion for adjournment or by some other device. But at
the moment, I can only permit you to ask a
supplementary question and no further. Do you have a
supplementary question, Mr Tay?
Mr Tay Boon Too(In Mandarin): That is what I wanted
to say - nothing more.
Column: 351
UNIVERSITY OF SINGAPORE
(Government's financial contribution for 1966)
7. Mr P. Govindaswamy asked the Minister for
Education what is the Government's financial
contribution to the University of Singapore for 1966;
and whether he will obtain and give a breakdown of
how the contribution is expended.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Government's
financial contribution to the University of Singapore
for 1966 is $10 million. Of this amount, about $9
million is for Personal Emoluments, the balance for
honoraria, departmental grants, new equipment and other
items of recurrent expenditure.
In addition, the Government has also made a provision
of $450,000 for the capital development of the
University of Singapore during 1966.
Mr Govindaswamy (Anson)(In Tamil): Is the
administration of the University going on properly, and
will the Government appoint a Commission of Inquiry to
look into it?
Mr Speaker: That question does go beyond the bounds
of a supplementary question, but if the Minister for
Education wants to answer it, he may.
The question was whether the Government is satisfied
with the administration of the University and also
whether it will consider appointing a Commission of
Inquiry.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, I have not
received any complaint about maladministration of the
University, I do not think the question of a Commission
of Inquiry arises at this stage.
Column: 351
MIDDLETON HOSPITAL
(Shelter for public)
8. Mr S. Rajoo asked the Minister for Health whether
he will consider the erection of a shed near the
entrance of the Middleton Hospital to accommodate and
give shelter to members of the public who visit
patients in the Hospital.
Column: 352
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am pleased to
inform the Member for Farrer Park that my Ministry has
plans to build a shed with seating accommodation next
year, costing approximately $2,000, for members of the
public who intend to visit patients at the Middleton
Hospital.
Column: 352
PAYA LEBAR
(Outpatient Dispensary)
9. Mr Tay Boon Too asked the Minister for Health
whether the Government is planning to establish an
Outpatient Dispensary in the Paya Lebar Constituency.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I regret to
inform the Member for Paya Lebar that there are no
immediate plans to establish an Outpatient Dispensary
inside Paya Lebar Constituency. The reasons are the
same as those given to similar questions raised by
other Members in the recent past. It is not possible to
have Government Outpatient Dispensaries in every
constituency, and in my opinion the present 26
Government Outpatient Dispensaries situated all over
the island are adequate to serve the needs of Singapore
for the foreseeable future.
Furthermore, residents of Paya Lebar Constituency can
go to any one of three nearby Government Outpatient
Dispensaries:
(a) Paya Lebar Outpatient Dispensary (with three
doctors) which is situated at the junction of
Upper Serangoon Road with Yio Chu Kang Road and
just outside the boundaries of Paya Lebar
Constituency itself;
(b) Lim Ah Pin Outpatient Dispensary (with one doctor)
which is just off 6th milestone, Upper Serangoon
Road; and
(c) MacPherson Road Outpatient Dispensary (with three
doctors) at Pesiaran Keliling, off Lower Paya
Lebar Road.
Column: 353
THOMSON ROAD MARKET
10. Mr P. Govindaswamy asked the Minister for Health
whether the Government will build a market between the
4 m.s. and 7� m.s. Thomson. Road, and when.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I regret again to
inform the Member for Anson that Government has no
intention of building a Government market between 4
m.s. and 7� m.s. Thomson Road for the foreseeable
future.
It has been the policy of Government to build markets
in areas where large-scale public housing is being
undertaken. In accordance with this policy, 10
Government markets with 2,171 stalls have been built
since 1961 in Housing and Development Board estates at
a cost of $2.3 million.
Column: 353
INSTITUTE OF RESEARCH ON PROBLEMS OF WOMEN
11. Madam Chan Choy Siong asked the Minister for
Culture and Social Affairs whether he intends setting
up an institute of research on problems of women, as
outlined in "The Tasks Ahead, 1959", with a view to
improving their social, economic and political status
in society.
Inche Othman Bin Wok: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Government has
since 1959 introduced various measures which have
considerably improved the status of women in Singapore,
including the enactment of the Women's Charter, 1960,
which, among other things, enforces monogamy in
Singapore except for Muslims, and the institution of
equal pay for women in the civil service. The problems
of women therefore no longer constitute an urgent issue
as it used to be in the old days. There is no reference
to the setting up of an Institute of Research on the
Problems of Women in The Tasks Ahead, 1959-1964 - at
least in the English copies. However, the desirability
of setting up a research institute to study these
problems will be looked into by my Ministry.
Column: 354
Madam Chan Choy Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, I have some
supplementary questions. I would like to ask the
Minister whether or not he knows that the setting up of
an Institute of Research on Problems of Women is stated
in Book III of the P.A.P.'s Policy?
The second supplementary question is: if he thinks
that this was the policy in 1959, whether he can tell
me when this institution will be set up, because last
year when discussing the Budget I asked this question
and he replied that it was under consideration. But one
year has already passed and the question has not been
dealt with.
Inche Othman Bin Wok: Mr Speaker, Sir, as I have said
just now, my Ministry will look into this question
first. So before I can give the hon. Member the date
when we will set up this institute, let us begin an
investigation first.
Column: 354
KAMPONG POTONG PASIR
(Assistance to farmers to combat pests)
12. Mr S. V. Lingam asked the Minister for Law and
National Development whether he has received any
requests from farmers of Kampong Potong Pasir and the
surrounding areas for assistance to combat pests
damaging their vegetables and what action has been
taken in the matter.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development (Mr Ho Cheng Choon) (for the Minister for Law and National Development): Mr
Speaker, Sir, there was a serious outbreak of pest
infestation in vegetable farms in Kampong Potong Pasir
recently, The pest was identified as Diamond-Back moth.
In early 1965 this species attacked vegetable farms in
Changi and Punggol, but with the assistance rendered by
the officers of the Primary Production Department,
these farms soon became free from infestation. In March
1966 the Diamond-Back moth appeared in large numbers in
and around Kampong Potong Pasir. Teams of Primary
Production officers were immediately despatched to the
scene to help combat the pest. They discovered that the
farmers there had been indiscriminately
Column: 355
spraying their vegetable crops with all types of
insecticides which proved to be ineffective, because
the pests had developed a resistance to such
insecticides. The problem was further aggravated
because the Potong Pasir farmers, owing to economic
considerations, were unwilling to adopt crop rotation
which is one reliable method of pest control and, in
fact, has proved effective in combatting the same pests
in Changi and Punggol.
On the advice of the Primary Production Department,
many farmers in Potong Pasir have now agreed to adopt
rotation of the crops. As a result, the extent of the
damage caused by the insect has been considerably
reduced. The Department has also recommended to farmers
the use of the moth alluring lights trap at night to
kill as many moths as possible. In addition, by
carrying out extensive experiments and field trials,
the Department has found an organo phosphorus
insecticide sold under the trade name "Phospherin"
which is effective against the Diamond-Back moth.
Orders for this effective insecticide have been placed
with overseas companies, and sufficient quantities are
expected to arrive very shortly.
Column: 356
The Primary Production Department has also carried out
film shows, lectures and discussions with farmers to
acquaint them with the latest information and
techniques in agricultural pest controls and
eradication. The Department has also helped the
affected farmers to obtain social welfare aid to
overcome their temporary hardship.
The pest infestation at Kampong Potong Pasir, though
not completely removed, has been minimised to a great
extent. It is expected that with the massive use of the
organo phosphorus insecticide after its arrival, the
pests will be wiped out.
Column: 355
MAKING UP OF BACKLANE AT RACE COURSE ROAD
13. Mr S. Rajoo asked the Minister for Law and
National Development whether the backlane behind houses
Nos. 50 to 78 at Race Course Road will be made up, and
when.
Column: 356
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (for the Minister for Law and National Development): Mr Speaker, Sir, the Public
Works Department has prepared a list of backlanes,
which include the one behind Race Course Road, for
vesting under section 44 of the Local Government
Integration Ordinance. It is expected that this
backlane, together with others, will be made up
sometime next year.
Column: 356
ABATTOIRS IN SERANGOON, KATONG AND BUKIT PANJANG
14. Mr S. Rajoo asked the Minister for Law and
National Development if he will consider setting up
Government abattoirs in the Serangoon, Katong and Bukit
Panjang Districts to facilitate the slaughter of pigs
and other live-stock for the people of those areas for
sale at rural markets.
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (for the Minister for Law and National Development): Mr Speaker, Sir, there are in
existence three abattoirs in Singapore - a pig abattoir
in French Road, a cattle abattoir in Jalan Besar, and a
sheep and goat abattoir also in Jalan Besar, opposite
the cattle abattoir. The numbers of animals slaughtered
in these abattoirs at present are about 1,200 pigs, 200
goats or sheep, and 30 heads of cattle each day.
A new modern abattoir is being built in Jurong. This
new abattoir will be highly mechanised and operated on
a mechanised system, so that about 200 pigs, 100 goats
or sheep and 15 heads of cattle can be slaughtered per
hour. The slaughtering and meat inspection in the new
abattoir will be of internationally accepted standards
so that we can issue veterinary certificates acceptable
to most countries to enable Singapore meat products to
be marketed in foreign countries.
The abattoir is being constructed at the cost of about
$5 million and is expected to be completed in July
1967. On completion, the new abattoir, together with
the existing ones, should be sufficient or adequate to
meet the needs of the whole island. However, if
Column: 357
they prove to be insufficient or inadequate, every
consideration will be given to build more abattoirs and
to site them in the rural areas.
Column: 357
CONSTITUTIONAL COMMISSION
ON MINORITY RIGHTS
(Publication of Report)
15. Mr Ho See Beng asked the Minister for Law and
National Development when the Government will make
public the Report of the Constitutional Commission on
minority rights which was presented to the President of
the Republic on 27th August, 1966.
Mr E. W. Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Report of the
Constitutional Commission, which was presented to the
President on the 27th of August this year, is under
careful study by the Government. It is intended to
table the Report, together with the Government's views
thereon, at the next sitting of Parliament, probably in
December.
Column: 357
PARKING LOTS IN FRONT OF SHOPHOUSES
(Reservation by shopkeepers)
16. Mr Ho See Beng asked the Minister for Law and
National Development if he will consider converting the
existing parking lots in front of shop-houses into
reserved lots for shopkeepers who may be willing to pay
the fee for such parking lots as is charged for season
parking.
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (for the Minister for Law and National Development): Mr Speaker, Sir, the Car Parks
Division has a total of 7,076 parking lots, of which
3,493 or approximately 50 per cent are delineated in
the central business districts where the demand for
parking facilities is ever-increasing.
The shortage of such facilities in certain areas has
added to traffic congestion; hence specifically to
allocate any portion of a road frontage for the
exclusive use of shopkeepers will further
Column: 358
aggravate the situation. Requests and petitions
received by the Car Parks Division for implementation
of parking schemes in areas where such facilities have
not been provided are indications of a general
awareness of the advantages of having as many car
parking lots as possible to enable shoppers to have a
readily available place to park their vehicles. Only
recently shopkeepers in Beach Road have petitioned to
the Member of Parliament for Kampong Glam for
restoration of parking lots which were deleted by the
Car Parks Division. Similarly, shopkeepers in Arab
Street have also requested the Division to implement
the pay parking scheme in this area for the convenience
of their customers.
The view of my Ministry is that it will be wrong to
convert the existing parking lots in front of
shophouses for the exclusive use of the shopkeepers, as
this will only affect business transactions and drive
away customers to localities where parking facilities
are more readily available.
I wish to point out that with the constant phenomena
built up in motor traffic at the rate of 700 new cars
per month, there may come a time when parking on the
roads will be totally amended to prevent the city from
being strangled. In anticipation of this, my Ministry
is already preparing plans for more multi-storey, off-the-street and underground car parks to be constructed
at which vehicles will be allowed to park without
detriment to the traffic flow which is the life-blood
of the city.
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah): A supplementary
question. Mr Speaker, Sir, from the answer given to me
just now by the Parliamentary Secretary, the Government
is only catering for the needs of the motorist. Will
the Government also consider catering for the needs of
the shopkeeper who is doing business connected with
loading and unloading if, in front of his shop, there
is a parking bay which is occupied by a motorist who
parks his car there, and this brings about difficulties
in loading and unloading?
Column: 359
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: Mr Speaker, Sir, the question
raised by the hon. Member for Bras Basah is whether we
can provide parking lots for loading and unloading in
front of shophouses. In fact, in every busy business
centre when a parking scheme is introduced, there are
one or two parking lots reserved for loading and
unloading. As I have just mentioned, we cannot reserve
a parking lot for every shopkeeper for loading and
unloading. In drawing up the lines in one street, we
can only provide one or two parking lots for loading
and unloading where there is a need for them.
Mr Ho See Beng: If the Department concerned does
provide a parking bay for loading and unloading, say,
about 50 feet away from a shop which requires this
facility, then it does not serve the purpose of the
shopkeeper. What I am asking is this: if a shopkeeper
has made an application to convert the parking bay in
front of his shop for his real need of loading and
unloading, will the Government consider his
application?
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: Mr Speaker, Sir, the answer is
very simple. If the shopkeeper wants to make use of the
existing parking lot for loading and unloading, he can
occupy the vacant parking lot for that purpose provided
he pays the charge.
Mr Ho See Beng: But when the parking bay in front of
the shop is being occupied by a motorist who parks his
car there, how can the shopkeeper make use of it to
load and unload the goods from the lorry?
An hon. Member: Hear, hear!
Mr Speaker: It is not a supplementary, but the
earlier question is. Do you wish to answer it, Mr Ho?
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: Mr Speaker, I consider this a
very simple question. He can find his own answer!
Column: 359
POST OFFICE IN DELTA CONSTITUENCY
17. Madam Chan Choy Siong asked the Minister of State
(Prime Minister's Department) whether consideration
will be given to establish a post office in the Delta
Constituency.
Column: 360
The Minister of State for the Prime Minister's Department (Tuan Haji Yaacob Bin Mohamed)(In Malay):
There are already two post offices in the immediate
neighbourhood, viz., Alexandra Road and Tiong Bahru
Post Offices, to meet the needs of the Delta
Constituency and, therefore, it is not considered
necessary to establish a post office in the
constituency itself.
Madam Chan Choy Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, I
would like to put a supplementary question to be
answered by the Minister of State, and that is, whether
he is aware that the development of Singapore is
proceeding ahead in order to meet the changes, and
these changes are such that they are beyond
description. For example, in the past, there were only
about 14,000 voters in this constituency. But at the
present moment the number of voters is more than four
times that in the past. This means there are about
70,000 voters in this constituency.
Another question I would like to ask the Minister is
whether he is aware that the changes in the Tiong Bahru
area have been very considerable. In the past, there
were only about 12,000 voters. But now because of the
housing development in this area this figure has
increased to about 60,000. In view of these changes,
can the Minister say that the needs in the past have
been satisfied and whether such needs have not
increased in view of the changes?
Tuan Haji Yaacob(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, we
realise that the rate of advance is rapid and that the
number of voters has increased. We also realise our
responsibility that there are two post offices in the
immediate neighbourhood of Delta Constituency. The
increase of the voters can be met by increasing the
staff.
Madam Chan Choy Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, I
still have a supplementary question to ask. The
Minister has mentioned just now the present services of
the two post offices, but in fact there is only one.
That one is in Tiong Bahru. I would like to ask him
whether he knows that, of the two post offices, one
belongs to Queenstown and the other to Tiong Bahru, and
whether
Column: 361
he knows that the Tiong Bahru post office, which is
very small, is situated in a shophouse of the Housing
Board? If there are ten persons in the post office, it
will be jammed up. In view of this, can he honestly say
that this post office itself is enough to satisfy the
local needs, and whether he is prepared to go there for
an investigation?
Tuan Haji Yaacob(In Malay): At this stage, I am
satisfied with the service provided by the post offices
there, as I have received no complaints of inadequate
service from members of the public. However, if the
hon. Member is really having difficulty, I will look
further into the matter.
Madam Chan Choy Siong(In Mandarin): Can I ask another
supplementary question, Sir? The Minister of State has
said that he has not received any complaints of the
inadequacy of the postal services. But as a Member of
the constituency, I have personally received complaints
on this matter. If I receive many complaints, will he
be prepared to consider increasing the postal services?
Perhaps the Member for Tiong Bahru himself may ask a
similar question?
Mr Speaker: I think the Minister of State did, in
fact, say that he would make an investigation if he
received complaints. So perhaps Madam Chan could
forward all complaints received by her to the Minister?
Column: 361
DRIVING TESTERS
18. Mr Sim Boon Woo asked the Minister of State
(Prime Minister's Department) if applicants for driving
licences have a choice in the identity of their
testers; if he is aware that certain applicants for
driving licences are refusing to be examined or are
otherwise avoiding being tested by particular testers;
whether he will inquire into the causes for such
refusals; and what steps he proposes to take to remove
those causes.
Tuan Haji Yaacob(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir,
applicants for driving licences cannot choose their
driving tester. There are 20 driving testers and
Column: 362
the applicant for a driving licence has to take
whichever driving tester is assigned to him by the
Licensing Officer.
It is obviously very undesirable to allow the
applicant for a driving licence to choose the driving
tester who is to test him. A person who has refused a
driving test by one tester cannot be assigned another
driving tester. If the department is to allow this, an
applicant, by refusing several driving testers, may
finally get a tester of his choice.
I am aware that certain applicants for driving
licences have withdrawn from taking their driving test
when they have been assigned a particular driving
tester.
I have enquired into the cause of their withdrawals.
It is not the applicants who have refused to be tested
by a particular tester but it is their driving
instructors who have refused to allow them the use of
the instructors' vehicles when applicants are assigned
to a particular tester. I have also enquired into the
reasons for this action by certain driving instructors.
These instructors had made certain general complaints
against a particular tester. In view of the generality
of the complaints, the instructors concerned were
requested to submit specific complaints for
investigation by the Registrar of Vehicles. A few
specific complaints were subsequently made and, on
investigation, it was found that they had either been
settled previously or were unjustified.
I would like to add that the method chosen by certain
driving instructors to redress their grievances is most
improper. My Ministry is prepared to, and will,
investigate specific complaints of misbehaviour or
misconduct against any tester, but we will not allow
ourselves to be intimidated or pressurised by
individuals or groups of individuals who have seen fit
to choose strong-arm methods for the redress of alleged
grievances.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi): Can the Minister tell this
House why is it that this is a complaint of the Driving
Testers' Association and not an individual complaint? I
would ask the Minister to inform this House whether he
will take into consideration the complaints of this
Association?
Column: 363
Tuan Haji Yaacob(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, my
Ministry has received the complaints referred to by the
hon. Member just now, but we must judge the complaints
on their merits. It is because the nature of the
complaints is general that my Ministry has no
alternative but to turn down the allegation made by the
Association.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Just now the Minister of State has
stated that there are 20 driving testers. Why is it
that only one particular tester is being boycotted by
the driving instructors and why are the other 19 not
boycotted? What is the reason for it?
Tuan Haji Yaacob(In Malay): Mr Speaker, the answer
is simple. If a person is firm, then he becomes
unpopular; but if he is flexible, then he will be liked
by all.
Column: 363
TRAFFIC LIGHTS AND ZEBRA CROSSINGS
19. Inche Rahamat Bin Kenap asked the Minister of
State (Prime Minister's Department) if he will consider
(a) the installation of traffic lights at the junction
of Geylang Road, Changi Road and Joo Chiat Road, in
view of the traffic jams at that junction at peak
hours; and (b) the establishment of a zebra crossing at
Changi Road in front of the Geylang Serai Vocational
School.
Tuan Haji Yaacob(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, it is
intended to re-install traffic lights at the junction
of Geylang Road/Changi Road/Joo Chiat Road. It is hoped
the traffic lights will be installed before the end of
the year.
It is not proposed to place a zebra crossing at Changi
Road in front of the Geylang Serai Vocational School as
the continual crossing of pedestrians will affect the
flow of traffic considerably, in view of the wide
stretch of the road. However, the construction of a
pedestrian overhead bridge across Changi Road, opposite
Changi market, is under consideration.
Column: 364
3.29 p.m.
Mr Speaker: In view of the fact that we are just one
minute short of 3.30 p.m., Members may consider
deferring Government Bills and taking Supply business
first, rather than interrupt Government Bills to go to
Supply and then come back to Government Bills. If that
course is acceptable, would the Minister for Finance
like to move the Business Motion?
Column: 364
CONSIDERATION OF MORE THAN
ONE ITEM OF SUPPLY BUSINESS
3.30 p.m.
Resolved, "That, notwithstanding the Standing Orders,
the Second Report of the Public Accounts Committee
(Paper Parl. 8 of 1966) and the Statement of Excess of
Expenditure for 1963 (Paper Cmd. 23 of 1964), as
amended by Paper Cmd. 13 of 1966 and the First
Supplementary Development Estimates of Expenditure for
1966 of Singapore, be taken today." ----[Mr Lim Kim San].
Column: 364
STATEMENT OF EXCESS FOR 1963
AND
FIRST SUPPLEMENTARY DEVELOPMENT ESTIMATES
OF EXPENDITURE FOR 1966
Order read for consideration in Committee of Supply
[Allotted Day].
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
3.31 p.m.
The Chairman: The Statement of Excess for 1963 is
contained in Paper Cmd. 23 of 1964, as amended by the
Corrigenda contained in Paper Cmd. 13 of 1966. The
Report of the Public Accounts Committee on the
Statement of Excess is contained in Paper Parl. 8 of
1966.
Column: 365
The summary of totals is on page 3 of Paper Cmd. 23 of
1964, subject to the following alterations in
accordance with Paper Cmd. 13 of 1966: the provision to
be voted for Head 37 - Accountant General - should read
"$34,773.74" instead of "$34,958.19", and the total sum
to be voted for all the heads of expenditure in the
Statement of Excess should read "$36,707.05" instead of
"$36,891.50".
No notice of amendment has been received.
Head 30 -
The sum of $17.13 for Head 30 ordered to stand part of
the Statement of Excess for 1963.
Head 31 -
The sum of $1,916.18 for Head 31 ordered to stand part
of the Statement of Excess for 1963.
Head 37 -
The sum of $34,773.74 for Head 37 ordered to stand
part of the Statement of Excess for 1963.
Question, "That the sum of $36,707.05 shall be
supplied to the Government under the heads of
expenditure for the public services shown in the
Statement of Excess for 1963 contained in Paper Cmd. 23
of 1964, as amended by Paper Cmd. 13 of 1966", put, and
agreed to.
Resolution to be reported.
3.34 p.m.
The Chairman: The First Supplementary Development
Estimates of Expenditure for 1966 contained in Paper
Cmd. 24 of 1966. The summary of totals is on page 6 of
the Paper.
I shall deal first with the heads of expenditure in
respect of which amendments stand on the Order Paper
Supplement. Head D 01 - Deputy Prime Minister. Mr Tang
See Chim, amendment No. (1) .
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head D 01 be reduced
by $10 in respect of subhead 028.
Column: 366
Mr Speaker, Sir, Singapore is an international
trading centre. It is, therefore, logical that we
should join in international communication projects,
and SEACOM is such a project. We should, however, be
able to know the extent of our commitments.
Unfortunately, our resources are limited and we must
make the best use of them. From the estimates, I see
that our original commitment was some $10 million. We
are now, however, asked to increase our commitment by
some $2 million. The reason given is that the increase
is necessary because of the re-routing and increase in
the capacity of the cable. It is, therefore, relevant
to ask whether Singapore was consulted on the re-routing and also on the increase in the capacity of the
cable to be laid. Can the Minister assure us that this
will not be an open-handed commitment in which we will
be asked to increase our contribution from time to
time?
The Deputy Prime Minister (Dr Toh Chin Chye): Mr
Speaker, to clarify the doubts of the Member for Choa
Chu Kang, I would like to inform the House that the re-routing of the SEACOM cable was contingent on account
of Indonesian confrontation. The original plan called
for a cable which would run from Australia to New
Guinea, New Guinea to Jesselton, and Jesselton to
Singapore. However, when confrontation broke out in
1963, the plan had to be revised, and consequently the
cable went up to Hong Kong, Hong Kong to Guam, Guam to
New Guinea and New Guinea to Australia. Singapore, as a
partner of SEACOM, has always been consulted on any
changes in plans in cable routing, and the increase in
capacity is to the advantage of all SEACOM partners. In
fact, from what I gathered just now, the forecast is
that even the capacity of 160 two-way channels will be
very much limited in the near future, when the project
itself opens. That is one of the reasons why ways and
means are now being studied as to how to improve
telecommunications between SEACOM neighbours - between
Singapore and Australia on the one hand, and Singapore
and Tokyo, and Singapore and Europe, on the other hand.
I can assure the Member for
Column: 367
Choa Chu Kang that all plans have been considered very
carefully. It is not the intention of the SEACOM
partnership to waste money unnecessarily. In any case,
this is an investment because telecommunications brings
in revenue and the expectations are that we will be
able to recover our capital expenditure within the next
6 to 7 years.
The Chairman: Mr Tang, do you wish to withdraw the
amendment or have it put to a vote?
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am satisfied
with the assurance given by the Deputy Prime Minister
and I wish to withdraw the amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head D 01 be reduced
by $10 in respect of new subhead 037.
Mr Speaker, Sir, telecommunication is vital to an
international trading centre like Singapore. I think
the Government deserves to be congratulated on its
decision to acquire the assets of Cable and Wireless
Limited and on its firm stand in its negotiations with
the Malaysian Government in regard to the acquisition
of Cable and Wireless Limited.
The point I want to raise is one of detail only. I
just want to know whether we are paying the right price
for the Company's assets. I have been trying to do some
research on my own, but, unfortunately, without much
success. Through the kind help of the House Librarian,
I managed to get a copy of the Company's Report and
Accounts for the Year ending 31st March, 1964 -that was
just before the Company was acquired by the Malaysian
Government then. Unfortunately, the Report contained
only consolidated accounts of the Cable and Wireless
Group as a whole, with no breakdown for the Singapore
operations, and without any indication of the value of
the assets in Singapore. I should be pleased if the
Minister would enlighten us on this point.
Column: 368
Dr Toh Chin Chye: Mr Speaker, if the Member for Choa
Chu Kang had earlier indicated to me what information
he required, I myself could have done a little
investigation into this enormous volume of files which
began since 1962. In that year the lease of Cable and
Wireless Limited was expiring and we had proposed the
formation of an Overseas Telecommunications Board which
would have, as partners, the Singapore Government
holding 51 per cent of the shares and the Company 49
per cent. In fact, at that period we had conducted
investigations into the capital assets of the Company.
I can assure the Member for Choa Chu Kang that an
enormous amount of detailed work has gone into the
valuation of the plant and removable and immovable
property of Cable and Wireless. He need not fear that
we have been cheated or over-paid on account of the
take-over. I will only add that there has been justice
done to both sides, to the Company and also to us.
The Chairman: Mr Tang, in view of that, do you wish
to withdraw your amendment?
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg leave to
withdraw the amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $19,618,358 for Head D 01 ordered to stand
part of the First Supplementary Development Estimates
of Expenditure for 1966.
Head D 04 -
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head D 04 be reduced
by $10 in respect of subhead 013.
In this subhead, Mr Speaker, Sir, we are asked to
vote some quarter of a million dollars without any
details being given to this House. Outpatient service
in the General Hospital is notoriously bad, and
unfortunately, I myself have had a very unpleasant
experience of such bad treatment. The usual excuse is
that the doctors in charge are over-worked. If that is
the reason, the remedy
Column: 369
is surely to engage more doctors and improve the
service, and not to inflict the result of this shortage
of doctors on patients.
3.45 p.m.
Inche Mahmud Awang (Kampong Kapor)(In Malay): Mr
Speaker, Sir, under subhead 013 of Head D 04, it is
recorded that outpatient attendances have increased
five times in the last decade while operations have
increased about four times.
In the improvement to existing wards and the increase
in the number of wards, I regret the conversions of
Wards Nos. 61 and 62 into paying-class wards. The
increase in the number of outpatient attendances and
operations shows that the people involved are not well-to-do people and if we increase the number of wards to
paying-class wards, this will not overcome the
situation.
The Minister for Health (Mr Yong Nyuk Lin): Mr
Speaker. Sir, may I answer the criticism of the Member
for Choa Chu Kang in the first place? I believe he
indicated that there was not enough information in
Paper Cmd. 24 of 1966 on the request for additional
funds to provide improvements to the Orthopaedic Unit.
I would like to give a little background history of
this particular item - Improvements for the Orthopaedic
Unit in Outram Road Hospital. The original plan was as
late as 1958 - eight years ago - and it was then
something like a $ 1� million proposal which in 1959 I
felt was excessive, and I had it brought down to a sum
of $300,000. There were therefore considerable savings
for the State of more than $1 million. Of this reduced
sum of $300,000, unfortunately, the Ministry of Finance
provided only $50,000 for 1966. Later on, an approved
transfer of $75,000 was granted, and the request in the
Command Paper is for a sum of $224,400 which is really
in keeping with a contract which has been let for a sum
of $339,967.80. This does not
Column: 370
include, however, a vote for "Furniture and Equipment"
which is estimated at nearly $110,000, but this sum
will be entered in next year's Development Estimates.
I hope that will meet the Member's request for more
information on the expenditure of this sum of money.
To answer his second question that the outpatient
service in the hospital is bad, I am sorry to hear that
he has had an unhappy experience in the hospital and I
would appreciate it if he would put this matter in
writing, indicating the day when he was at the hospital
and where he felt he had not been fairly treated, so
that I can investigate further into the matter. Because
I think it is pretty dangerous sometimes just to listen
to one complaint and "tar" the whole service. In my
opinion - as the Member himself has admitted - the
doctors might have been grossly over-worked and were
therefore perhaps a little short of temper during the
wee hours of the morning. However, if I can get more
information, I will be in a position to investigate
into the matter fully and give a firm decision on it.
But I do not think that it is as simple as suggested by
the Member, that to meet the situation, all we need do
is to employ more doctors. It is not that we do not
wish to employ more doctors. There are on the
establishment 450 doctors, and at the moment we have
close to 400 doctors. The vacancies are there. It is
available for any doctor who wishes to apply to be
considered for appointment, and it is very rarely that
we turn down any application from a doctor who wishes
to join Government service.
As regards improvements to the conditions of service,
etc., this is something which I, as a Minister, would
very much like to encourage and support. But here
again, there is my colleague, the Minister for Finance.
In addition, there is already a Salaries Commission in
existence and I do not think that we should anticipate
events or to say things which would embarrass the
working of this Commission.
Column: 371
I hope I have answered the comments of the Member for
Choa Chu Kang and I will now answer the Member for
Kampong Kapor.
He does not appear to be happy over the fact that the
funds asked for are for the renovation of Wards 61 and
62 into paying-class wards, because he feels that this
would not meet the situation of those less able to pay
after being admitted into the hospital. It is important
to remind him that the majority of cases admitted into
the Orthopaedic Unit are in respect of accidents
arising out of employment or motor traffic. In almost
every instance, it is the employer who will be bearing
the expenses for such treatment. Therefore, it will not
in any way increase the burden for the less fortunate
members of our public if they are admitted into paying
wards, because it is the employer who will have to meet
such liability under the workmen's compensation
insurance which every good employer takes up to protect
his liability.
As for the numerous accidents which we have -
something like 100 motor accidents a day - every car on
the road is covered compulsorily with third-party
insurance, and therefore personal injuries as a result
of motor accidents are rightful claims against
insurance companies. I have already indicated sometime
ago that it is our intention to make it so, so that
insurance companies will meet these dues. In the past,
for some queer reasons, the Government hospitals have
not taken the trouble to send bills to insurance
companies and I think it is time that this serious
loophole in the revenue of the State should be plugged.
I can therefore assure the Member for Kampong Kapor
that by having more paying-class wards in our
Orthopaedic Units we shall not be penalising the poorer
sections of the public, because we shall be able to
recover most of the dues from employers or insurance
companies. It is anticipated that we will be able to
get at least $� million each year by this process and
therefore we shall be able to recover all capital
expenditure probably in a matter of years.
Column: 372
The Chairman: Will the Member for Choa Chu Kang please
let me know if he wishes to withdraw the amendment or
have it put to a vote?
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg leave to
withdraw the amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $224,400 for Head D 04 ordered to stand
part of the First Supplementary Development Estimates
of Expenditure for 1966.
Head D 06 -
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head D 06 be reduced
by $10 in respect of new subhead 028.
In this new subhead, Mr Speaker, Sir, this House is
asked to approve a sum of some $6� million for the
improvement of Television and Broadcasting Services,
again without this House being supplied with any
information or a detailed breakdown of the amount
required.
It is appreciated that there is urgent need for the
improvement of television and radio services,
especially the radio services, since our independence.
We are a multi-racial, multi-religious and multi-lingual society professing and practising democratic
socialist principles. We should therefore make our
policy known to all our people at home and to project
our image abroad, and the best means of doing so is
through the television and radio services. But it does
not mean that this House will approve some $6� million
without knowing how the money is going to be spent. I
understand that the sum is in addition to the sum of
more than $3 million that has already been spent on the
new Television House.
There is one thing I would like to say about
television, and that is commercial advertising. Whilst
we appreciate that it may be necessary to allow
commercial advertising in television to help it pay its
way, commercial advertising seems to be now getting out
of hand, especially during what are called the "peak
hours"
Column: 373
when the amount of advertising time is fast approaching
that of the ordinary programme time. If this tendency
is not checked, we may soon get into the ridiculous
situation of having the "Radio Weekly" detailing only
the commercial programmes and leaving us to have
glimpses of cowboys shooting Indians in between the
commercials.
4.00 p.m.
Inche Othman Bin Wok: On the first query by the hon.
Member, I wish to inform the House that the need for
improving and expanding our television and radio
services has become extremely urgent. Included in this
expansion scheme are additional and more powerful
transmitters for both radio and television and
additional studio facilities for television. The sum of
about $6� million is therefore required. Actually the
total sum involved is $6.5 million and the breakdown is
as follows -
Radio Service - radio transmitters are about $2.5
million, the frequency modulated transmitter is over
$300,000, and there is also some payment of customs
duties which amount to $160,000. T.V. Service to
increase T.V. cover amounts to about $870,000; T.V.
equipment (non-engineering) is about $570,000. And the
Studios - four T.V. studios - works and buildings cost
about $400,000, and equipment about $1.4 million.
On the second query in which the hon. Member expresses
his fear of commercial advertising, I wish to state
that it is necessary to get income from advertising to
buy more expensive and better quality films as well as
to cover part of the cost of running the T.V. station,
which is, as we all know, an expensive affair. Compared
with other countries, Mr Speaker, Sir, the frequency
of advertisements appearing on T.V. here can be
considered low.
For the information of the House, Sir, the cost of
running T.V. Singapura is approximately $6 million per
year, and the revenue from commercial advertising is
about $3� million per year. Anyway, Sir, I can assure
the hon.
Column: 374
Member that my Ministry is keeping constant watch on
commercial advertising so that it will not get out of
hand.
The Chairman: Mr Tang, do you wish to withdraw the
amendment or proceed with a vote?
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, in view of the
assurance given by the Minister, I beg leave to
withdraw the amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $6,591,677 for Head D 06 ordered to stand
part of the First Supplementary Development Estimates
of Expenditure for 1966.
Head D 07 -
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head D 07 be reduced
by $10 in respect of new subhead 024.
Mr Speaker, Sir, there are two points to be
considered here. The first point is whether it is
necessary to disturb the present natural environment of
MacRitchie Reservoir. The second point is whether, even
if it is decided that we should do so, it is not a
question of wrong priorities.
On the first question, Mr Speaker, Sir, I think
MacRitchie Reservoir is a natural beautiful park as it
is. I have visited it, and it has all the aesthetic
features of a natural environment - tall shady trees,
soft green grass, birds singing overhead, insects
humming around. Mr Speaker, Sir, attap shelters cannot
take the place of shady trees, and paved footpaths
cannot take the place of soft green grass, and a
floating fountain and a tea kiosk will not, I submit,
Mr Speaker, Sir, improve the aesthetic features of the
park. When concrete and mortar and a motorway are
brought in, the natural environment of MacRitchie
Reservoir will be no more.
I take it that the P.W.D. will be in charge of the
project. The P.W.D. is a solid, hardworking department.
Unfortunately, it has so far not proved itself capable
of being the author of any
Column: 375
aesthetically beautiful project. Take the Raffles
Underground Car Park and Garden, Sir. It is functional
but it is ugly. It has a fountain and a flower bed, but
fountains and flower beds alone do not make beautiful
gardens. It is the arrangement - the overall
arrangement - of these things that makes beautiful
gardens. Mr Speaker, Sir, if Mount Faber is another
place to judge by, I feel very apprehensive about the
natural beauty of our park at MacRitchie Reservoir. I
do not think we have improved Mount Faber, scenically
speaking. On the other hand, I have heard a lot of
complaints that the cosiness of the place, the romance
of it, is being spoilt. The harsh public lighting is no
substitute for the soft moonlight.
But even granted that we are so insensitive as to
prefer a man-made fountain to a natural running stream
and decide that this project should be proceeded with,
regardless, there is still the question of priority to
be considered. We are a small country. Our resources,
as I have said just now, are limited. We must,
therefore, make the best use of them. We are here
proposing to spend a quarter of a million dollars on
something that needs no improvement, whilst, at the
same time, in the rural areas basic amenities like
electricity and piped water have not been provided for.
In my constituency in Choa Chu Kang, for example, Sir,
there are areas - and indeed large areas - where there
is not even piped water, not to say the luxury of
public lighting. And the money to be spent on these
projects could be better spent, I submit, on the rural
areas.
If a quarter of a million dollars could be channelled
into the rural areas, it would do a tremendous lot to
improve the basic standard of living of the rural
people. It would be little comfort to the rural folks
to be told by the Minister for National Development
that they could watch coloured water playing in the
floating fountain in MacRitchie Reservoir, when they
have not even piped water at home to drink or to use.
That is the irony of this project, Sir, and I beg to
move.
Column: 376
Inche Mahmud Awang(In Malay): Mr Speaker, on this
new subhead 024, I would like to know from the Minister
for Law and National Development whether the purpose of
this vote is to make a park for the people of Singapore
with the idea of reducing the dust and filth.
As I have said earlier about my suspicions regarding
payments made to the Ministry of Health, I am rather
worried if the use of the car park, as mentioned in
this scheme, is to be paid for, as is done at the
Airport at present, because it will be a burden to the
people who want to make use of the car park. Normally,
people who visit parks like MacRitchie Reservoir are
usually poor. Although we see them going there in cars,
these cars are sometimes borrowed from their friends or
hired. For example, on a Saturday if someone wants to
go for a ride or stroll in MacRitchie Reservoir during
the day, he has to pay car park charges at High Street
and then in the evening he will have to pay again. This
will be a burden, Mr Speaker. There are also occasions
when rich people go to the parks, but they will not
make visits to MacRitchie Reservoir as they have better
places to go to which are in line with their status.
But there are also rich people who go to MacRitchie
Reservoir. I would like to know once again from the
Minister concerned whether the use of the car park
proposed in this scheme will be paid for.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, I
would like to speak on this item to express some of my
personal views. On the question of establishing a
paying car park, some Members have expressed their
objection to paying car parks in certain areas. I feel
that in some places it is necessary to have paying car
parks. For example, on a public holiday many people go
to the MacRitchie Reservoir grounds. So if there is a
car park, it will be a great convenience to the holiday
makers and visitors. And if the authority should impose
a fee of, say, 40 cents per hour it is quite
reasonable. Otherwise, without this imposition of a
fee, there will be some jaga kereta boys operating in
Column: 377
this area. They will demand payment from motorists, an
act which is illegal. So the payment of 40 cents per
hour or 20 cents per half hour is quite a reasonable
measure. Government will in turn provide the necessary
facilities and make use of the money in some other
fields and the public will benefit.
4.15 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, whilst it is desirable
that development should, as far as possible, be spread
throughout the island so that our population living in
the various constituencies are all catered for, the
hard economic facts are that it is necessary to ensure
that the total quantum of funds available for
development projects are utilised in the best possible
manner. Although it is the aim to provide as large a
number of the population as possible with basic
amenities, like light and water, the deterrent factor
is often the heavy capital expenditure involved in
bringing electricity and water supplies to remote
kampongs off the beaten track. Choa Chu Kang
Constituency is one such area. The authorities
concerned in deciding whether to extend supplies to
specific areas have to have regard for the economics
involved. A sufficient rate of return on the capital
invested is necessary so that the scheme is economical
and the Public Utilities Board is able to meet the
requirements of the World Bank in respect of the
prescribed rate of returns for loans. Nevertheless, as
the Member for Choa Chu Kang will be aware, during the
last six years a sum of $700,160 has been expended to
provide water and electric services for Choa Chu Kang
alone. This figure of over $700,000 is only for water
and lights, and has nothing to do with roads or other
amenities. On water supplies alone a sum of $65,230 was
spent. On electric supplies a sum of $595,930. Street
lighting in the Member's constituency cost $39,000. So
as far as Choa Chu Kang Road is concerned - this is a
road - water and electrical mains have been laid right
up
Column: 378
to the end of the road, and I can assure you, Mr
Speaker, that Choa Chu Kang is a long road.
The other long road in that district is Lim Chu Kang
Road. On that road electrical mains have been laid up
to the 19th milestone, two miles from the end. No
doubt, in due course, supplies will be extended upon
request and, on the basis of determined priorities, to
extend these to the end. Despite all endeavours, there
will be villages in outlying areas far from the
electricity and water mains where it will be
exorbitantly expensive to provide the necessary
amenities. In many of these areas, for example, the
Southern Islands, Changi, Tampines and Sembawang, the
number of consumers is relatively so small as to make
the project completely uneconomical.
An example of the high cost involved can be seen from
the fact that to provide one mile of water mains in
Lorong Buang Kok, the cost was nearly $100,000. To
provide electric supplies to 290 houses at Choa Chu
Kang Road from the 13� milestone to the 14� milestone,
just one mile, the cost was $163,740; while to provide
one mile of street lighting from Bukit Panjang Village
to Yew Tee Village, the cost was $23,000. That I hope,
Mr Speaker, should dispose of the Member's arguments
as to priorities.
The Member for Choa Chu Kang also made the suggestion
that things at MacRitchie Reservoir should be left in
their natural beauty. He does not want me to disturb
the birds. I can assure him that the development
envisaged at MacRitchie does not involve the cutting
down of trees or turning the reservoir into an
artificial garden. The development envisages the
minimum clearance of shrubs and undergrowth only and
the provision of certain facilities, leaving the trees
and the landscape and the birds as far as possible in
their natural state.
Mr Speaker, this town is expanding fast. There is an
acute shortage of lungs and open spaces as a result of
our tremendous housing programmes and the idea behind
the MacRitchie scheme is to enable full utilisation of
one existing
Column: 379
open space by the population. The Member for Choa Chu
Kang will agree that a healthy community is a vital
necessity. The provision of facilities like a tea
kiosk, a bandstand and a fountain at minimal cost will
attract even more people to this already popular spot.
Not only will the people in the neighbouring Thomson
and Sembawang areas but also those from outlying
districts, including Choa Chu Kang and Kampong Kapor,
will be attracted to spend a pleasant evening in the
environs of this reservoir by the provision of these
minimal facilities. A tea kiosk is necessary in order
to keep out hawkers from the reservoir parks so as to
reduce the chances of water pollution. A floating
fountain in the reservoir itself should enhance the
beauty of the area at little expense. In short, Mr
Speaker, the project envisages the enhancement of the
natural beauty of the place by the provision of
additional features and not the creation of an
artificial garden. I am sure that when the development
is completed the Member for Choa Chu Kang will be
pleased with the results.
The Member for Kampong Kapor has been harping on the
charges which, he says, we might introduce at the car
park. He says, "Do not charge." The Member for
Sembawang says, "Charge."
I can assure both Members that before any fees are
imposed careful consideration will have to be given.
There must be a period of trial and experiment. At the
moment, there are no car parking fees at MacRitchie
Reservoir, though, I believe, the place is packed in
the evening and at night. We will only introduce fees
for parking at MacRitchie should the demand for car
parking spaces exceed the amount of space available,
and that, in fact, is the whole basis of car parking in
Singapore. Unless we charge fees for parking, the day
will come in Singapore, and it will come soon, when
there is complete traffic chaos in the town. But no one
has moved an amendment to the other subhead which deals
with the underground car park, so I will not make any
comments except to say to the Member for Choa Chu Kang
that though he does not like the
Column: 380
underground car park at Raffles Place, it serves a
useful purpose and in fact a hundred per cent of the
car parking places at the Raffles Car Park are now
fully used.
As for Mount Faber, he is entitled to his own views.
But you get a lovely view from Mount Faber, and if he
does not like it, I suggest he go elsewhere.
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am not quite
satisfied with the explanation given by the Minister.
While it may be quite true that a tremendous amount of
money is being spent in the rural areas - and he has
given me figures for the amounts spent in Choa Chu Kang
in respect of water and lighting - the fact remains
that in these rural areas the basic amenities of life
are not satisfied. My thesis is that unless and until
such amenities are satisfied, it is against socialist
principles that the urban areas should be given
amenities that are not the basic requirements of life.
The Minister has also said that it is a matter of opinion whether Mount Faber is a better area after a tremendous amount of money has been spent on it. I do not think it improves it scenically and I am sure a lot of people do not think so. If that is the case, why should we spend money on something that is not
necessary while, at the same time, leaving the basic
requirements of life not satisfied? Take public
lighting in Mount Faber, for example. I am sure it is
not appreciated there. In fact, I think it does cause
considerable annoyance to a lot of people, especially
loving young couples who visit Mount Faber. Funds for
such public lighting could very well be spent and would
very much be appreciated in, for example, my
constituency. That, Mr Speaker, Sir, is my thesis:
that the Minister has got his priorities wrong.
Mr Barker: The Member for Choa Chu Kang argues that
until every house in his district is supplied with
light and water, my Ministry should not do anything
about building parks or fountains.
Column: 381
4.30 p.m.
This is an argument which I cannot accept. It will
probably be 10 to 15 years before every householder in
his district is supplied with light and water. I have
given the reasons why up to date water and electricity
supplies have not reached every remote farm in his
district. Does it mean that I can do nothing to improve
the urban areas until I have satisfied every basic
requirement of his constituency? I can assure him that
we are spending more money every year on the rural
districts. And this goes for every rural district in
Singapore. Urban areas receive much less; then come the
semi-urban or semi-rural districts; then come the rural
districts. If we were spending more money on the urban
districts than on the rural districts, then I would say
we are wrong. But we are not doing .that. We are
spending more money in his district, which is rural,
than, say, my district in Tanglin which is semi-urban.
But if not every householder in his district of Choa
Chu Kang has light and water, I can assure him that
there are people in my constituency in Tanglin who do
not have light and water too. There are many other
constituencies which do not have these basic amenities.
But does it mean that we cannot build a fountain? We
have built so many flats in Singapore and we are
building more. We have spent hundreds of millions of
dollars providing housing. If I were to accept his
argument, it means that until we house everyone in
Singapore, no fountain should be erected. But a
fountain is a thing of beauty, and all he has to do is
to visit the three fountains, the giant fountains which
have been recently erected. I have not heard one word
of criticism. The only words I have heard are words of
praise.
As for Mount Faber, he grumbles about providing
lights. When we do not provide the lights, he grumbles.
When we provide the lights, he grumbles too. I believe
he is the only bachelor in the House. But before you
pull me up for
Column: 382
being personal, Mr Speaker, Sir, I think I should not
say anything further on that.
Mr Ho See Beng: Mr Speaker, can I contribute
something towards -
The Chairman: Most certainly.
Mr Ho See Beng: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am inclined to
agree with the Member for Choa Chu Kang that the
provision of basic amenities for the rural areas is
more urgent than that for the urban areas. I think the
Minister is a little unfair when he says that even when
we provide lights, the Member for Choa Chu Kang does
not like it, and when we do not provide lights, he also
does not like it. I think that is not the point of
complaint of the Member. He simply said that the
$30,000 which the Government wants to make use of to
develop MacRitchie Reservoir, could be better utilised
to develop the rural areas or places mostly populated
by poor people who are in need of amenities. I remember
at our last sitting the Member for Delta also shared
the same feeling that whenever a fountain is built, it
is built in the bourgeois area, say, in a place like
Tanglin which is well provided. There is no necessity
at all to build another fountain. That is all, Sir.
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, various speakers have spoken on the
question before the House. I would also like to express
my views and my feelings. I feel that this amount to be
voted for actually exceeds what the Government have
allocated for the Urban and Rural Services Committee,
and exceeds the Committee's approval to be spent on
Redhill, because the total expenditure on Redhill does
not exceed $30,000. Since the expenditure on building a
car park, attap shelters, garden seats and other things
at MacRitchie Reservoir exceeds the sum spent on
Redhill to provide basic facilities for the residents
there, most of the poor people there may have adverse
reactions to this sort of measure. As to the car park
to be provided in MacRitchie Reservoir. I myself do not
have a car, so I will not be making full use of the car
park. But
Column: 383
in Redhill there are many people who are still having
difficulties in their livelihood and they have not
reached a decent standard in their livelihood. I think
it is better to promote and raise the living standard
of the people in my constituency and other
constituencies than spend more money on the areas
already developed. What we want is something to meet
the urgent needs and not to add more to what is already
there. In other words, what we want is to have coal in
winter rather than add more flowers to a bloom. In
Redhill and other places we need further development.
If sums are allocated for such development and when the
living standard of the residents in the various
constituencies can be raised by the vote, then I will
be glad to see the Minister allocate more sums to
beautify parks and the scenery at certain places, or to
place certain singing birds in certain areas, including
the rural areas. I have no objection then. But, first
of all, we must try to raise the living standard and
provide basic living amenities to these people before
we vote for something to be spent on areas already
developed. I can say that this kind of action is not
100 per cent socialist. The building of a car park and
the planting of flowers in a public park - I do not
understand whether all this has anything to do with our
socialist principles. What we should be concerned with
is how to raise the living standard of the poor to
match that of the rich. We should not allow the poor
people to be poorer and the rich to become richer.
There is a strong contrast between the poor and the
rich. If we enhance this difference, then I will not be
happy to see it. There are millions of birds perched on
trees singing all day long, but they would not please
me. I think this sort of ideology should be
reconsidered.
I support the amendment of the Member for Choa Chu
Kang to reduce the vote by $10 and I agree with his
sentiments.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Lim Kim San): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I quite understand the anxiety of certain
Members of this House. Being members of a socialist
party, they are a bit
Column: 384
worried that there has been money spent on what they
consider to be the richer sector of the community. But
I would like to ask them to consider whether it is in
the interest of the country as a whole if we are to
stop developing the other sectors and keep on
concentrating on bringing the poorer sectors up and
letting the other sectors just -
Mr Ho See Beng: The need is greater.
Mr Lim Kim San: Quite agreed. The need is greater.
But do we ignore entirely the other sectors and let
them run derelict? Is that our idea of development? If
these Members look at the Budget, they will notice that
quite a large proportion of our expenditure is spent on
social services and on the infrastructure of economic
development - all with the purpose of uplifting the
standard of living of our people. It is also our duty
to see that the other sectors are not left derelict,
that their standard of living, their standard of
cleanliness and their standard of aesthetic beauty are
not brought down to those of the poorer sectors. I
think that must be kept in mind before they make up
their minds about voting on this supplementary
estimate.
The Chairman: Mr Barker, before you address and in
order to avoid the necessity of your speaking again,
may I inquire if there is any other Member who wishes
to make a contribution to this debate?
Hon. Members indicated dissent.
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, I just want to make
clear one matter which seems to be disturbing several
Members of this House, and this is the question of
fountains and I will come to the point. There are two
fountains in my district of Tanglin. One is at Farrer
Road -half that fountain is in my constituency and the
other half is in Ulu Pandan. There is another fountain
at Tanglin Circus, half of which is in my constituency
and the other half in River Valley. Putting two halves
together, I have got one fountain. Now, I would like to
assure all Members of this House that when the sites
for those fountains were
Column: 385
chosen, I was not the Minister for National
Development. I propose to give you the history of these
fountains. The question of fountains at traffic
circuses was first raised by the Prime Minister in a
memorandum dated the 7th of November, 1963, to the
Minister for National Development. At that moment, Mr
Speaker, I was happily seated in your Chair. The Public
Works Department was then requested to draw up a list
of likely sites where fountains could be put up. The
following sites were submitted: Orchard Road Circus,
Raffles Place, King George V Park, Guillemard Circus,
the roundabout at Farrer and Holland Roads, Tanglin
Circus, Empress Place and Finlayson Green.
4.45 p.m.
That was all in 1963. Sketch plans and estimates of
costs of these fountains were approved by my
predecessor, the then Minister for National
Development, and submitted to the Development Planning
Committee for approval on the 2nd of June, 1964. The
plans were to build small fountains costing about
$35,000 each at these eight sites. The Minister for
Finance - and I do not mean Mr Lim Kim San; that was
Dr Goh Keng Swee - in his capacity as Chairman of the
Development Planning Committee, disapproved of the list
submitted and commented - "Better to have two or three
lavish fountains than a large number of scraggy ones."
As a result, the Scientific Adviser was requested to
have a discussion with the Deputy Director of Public
Works, the Chief Planner and the Chief Architect on the
final plans regarding sites and sizes for some prestige
fountains.
At a meeting held on 16th October, 1964, at the Prime
Minister's Office, fresh plans for bigger fountains
were considered and it was decided to proceed with the
three fountains at the three sites just mentioned. That
was the 16th of October, 1964. I was appointed the
Minister for Law on the 1st of November, 1964. I was
still then Speaker of this House. I was only appointed
the
Column: 386
Minister for National Development on the 9th of August
last year. So in case Members of this House think that
I only build fountains in my own district, I hope that
the facts I have just presented will satisfy them that
I had nothing to do with the planning of the fountains
and, in particular, I had nothing to do with the
choosing of these sites for the fountains.
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, let me hasten to
assure the Minister for National Development that I,
for one, was not thinking that he was building
fountains for himself. But there is still the general
principle of priorities, and on this point I am not
quite satisfied with the explanation given and I wish
that this amendment be put to a vote.
Question on the amendment put, and negatived.
The sum of $97,997 for Head D 07 ordered to stand part
of the First Supplementary Development Estimates of
Expenditure for 1966.
The Chairman: The remaining heads of expenditure
undisposed of are Head D 03, Ministry of Education,
$479,000, and Head D 08, Public Works, Non. Recurrent
(General), $200,030.
Question, "That the sums stated for the heads stated,
as they appear in the summary of totals contained in
Paper Cmd. 24 of 1966, stand part of the First
Supplementary Development Estimates of Expenditure for
1966," put, and agreed to.
Question, "That the sum of $27,211,462 shall be
supplied to the Government under the heads of expenditure for the public services shown in the First
Supplementary Development Estimates of Expenditure for
1966 contained in Paper Cmd. 24 of 1966," put, and
agreed to.
Resolution to be reported.
Thereupon Mr Speaker left the Chair of the Committee
and took the Chair of the House.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to report
that the Committee of Supply have come to certain
resolutions.
Column: 387
Resolutions reported -
"That the sum of $36,707.05
shall be supplied to the Government under the heads of
expenditure for the public services shown in the
Statement of Excess for 1963 contained in Paper Cmd.
23 of 1964, as amended by Paper Cmd. 13 of 1966."
"That the sum of $27,211,462 shall be supplied to the
Government under the heads of expenditure for the
public services shown in the First Supplementary
Development Estimates of Expenditure for 1966 contained
in Paper Cmd. 24 of 1966."
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move that
Parliament doth agree with the Committee on the said
resolutions.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolutions accordingly agreed to.
Mr Speaker: We now revert to the introduction of
Government Bills, but in view of the time and the fact
that one Bill will be proceeded through all stages, I
would suggest that I suspend the sitting now and resume
at 5.30 p.m.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
4.54 p.m. until 5.30 p.m.
Column: 387
Sitting resumed at 5.30 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
BILLS INTRODUCED
FINAL SUPPLY (1964) BILL
"to make Final Provision for the Public Service for
the year 1964",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by the Minister for Finance (Mr Lim Kim San); read the First
time, to be read a Second time on the next available
sitting, and to be printed.
Column: 387
BETTING AND SWEEPSTAKE
DUTIES (AMENDMENT) BILL
First Reading
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I have the
President's recommendation
Column: 388
to introduce the Betting and Sweepstake Duties
(Amendment) Bill. I beg to introduce a Bill intituled
"An Act to amend the Betting and Sweepstake Duties
Ordinance (Chapter 158 of the Revised Edition)."
Bill read the First time.
Second Reading
Mr Speaker: Second Reading, what day?
Mr Lim Kim San: Now, Sir. I lay upon the Table a
Certificate of Urgency signed by the President in
respect of this Bill.
Certificate of Urgency handed in.
Mr Speaker: The Certificate is in order. Are typed or
printed copies of the Bill available for the use of
Members?
Mr Lim Kim San: Yes, Sir. Copies are with the Clerk.
Printed copies of the Bill distributed to hon.
Members.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Sir, the Betting and Sweepstake Duties Ordinance, as
it stands now, does not provide discretionary powers to
exempt any sweepstake from duty. This was appropriate
when all sweepstakes were organised for the direct
benefit of racing clubs or associations. But where a
sweepstake is organised for the purpose of raising much
needed money for approved public welfare projects of
one kind or another, the old provisions are obsolete
and it becomes necessary to provide discretionary
powers to enable sweepstakes to be exempted from duty
so that the proceeds may be applied directly to the
approved objects of the Sweep.
In this regard, Mr Speaker, Sir, I may say that owing
to the increasing demand for funds to finance welfare
and other charitable organisations in the State, the
possibilities of a Public Welfare Lottery were explored
as long ago as November 1965. The growing needs of
voluntary welfare bodies in Singapore
Column: 389
were stressed by the Singapore Council of Social
Service in a letter to the Minister for Social Affairs
dated April 6, 1966, which expressed support for any
move to set up a Public Welfare Lottery. Subsequently,
it was agreed that the Singapore Turf Club may run a
Singapore Sweep in place of one of the Club's usual
unlimited sweeps.
Arrangements are under consideration to ensure that
all funds will be utilised for public projects, such as
a national stadium or for welfare purposes, and the
exemption now provided by way of clause 2 of this Bill
will enable this to be done. But powers are provided
for the Minister not only to exercise discretion but
also to impose such conditions as may be deemed fit to
ensure that exemptions are applied in respect of the
proper purposes only.
In view of constitutional changes, the opportunity is
also taken in clause 3 (a) to delete the reference to
"the Colony" in section 3 of the Ordinance and
substitute it by the word "Singapore", whilst clause 3
(b) provides for the transfer of the power to grant
extensions of time for the payment of duty - an act of
an administrative nature - to the Commissioner of
Stamps.
Finally, clause 4 of the Bill makes unpaid duty a debt
due to the Government of the Republic of Singapore in
conformity with the other duties collected under the
provisions of other revenue laws in the Republic.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
5.36 p.m.
Mr Ho See Beng: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am very
astonished to know that the Minister for Finance
intends to introduce this Bill on a Certificate of
Urgency. It is as if Singapore is facing an immediate
invasion that such a Bill must be passed in this
Parliament with such an urgency. Mr Speaker, Sir, I do
not believe that any government in the world which
professes and believes in socialism will promote
gambling.
Column: 390
Mr Lim Kim San: On a point of order, Mr Speaker,
Sir. This is not a Bill to promote gambling. It is a
Bill to give me power to exempt duty on sweepstakes run
by the Club with a certain objective.
Mr Ho See Beng: Mr Speaker, Sir, I agree it is not a
Bill
Mr Speaker: Mr Ho, the Minister's point was that you
should confine yourself to the narrow ambit of the
Bill.
Mr Ho See Beng: Even if it is not a Bill but an
amendment to the Betting and Sweepstake Duties
Ordinance, I think it still runs counter to the belief
that the P.A.P. professes and believes in socialism.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I fail to see the need for the
Government to introduce this Bill on a Certificate of
Urgency. This method of a Government-sponsored lottery,
even though it is for a praiseworthy cause, is a rather
controversial topic. I am not speaking here only as the
Secretary-General of the N.T.U.C., but also as the
Member for Bras Basah Constituency. You may be aware of
the view of the N.T.U.C. in relation to any form of
gambling, that it does not, in principle, support the
idea of the Government of Singapore sponsoring a
lottery. As you may also be aware, I have recently
conducted a series of house-to-house visits in my
constituency. In the course of such visits, I have been
given to understand by a substantial number of my
constituents that they are not very happy over the
question of Government sponsoring a lottery. What will
happen is this. On the day of the drawing of this so-called welfare lottery, you will -
Mr Lim Kim San: On a point of order, Sir. This is not
a welfare lottery. This is a Singapore Sweep.
Mr Ho See Beng: Never mind. It is the raising of
funds by means of a lottery. We are all aware that only
the poor people will contribute towards buying these
lottery tickets, and you will find that 20,000 to
30,000 housewives will buy lottery tickets and they
will curtail their expenditure on marketing and food.
What happens is this, Mr
Column: 391
Speaker, Sir. When the husband comes home, he will find
that variety in the food on the table is missing, and
the so-called Sweep ticket, instead of assisting the
poor, I am afraid is going to bring about unhappiness
in all the families.
Mr Speaker, Sir, you will agree that if you take
money from the rich and give it to the poor, that is a
credit. But here, we are taking money from the poor and
giving it to the poor. I do not see any credit. But
some of you may take the cynical view that I am
criticising for the sake of opposing. This is not so.
Because it is the man who has interests in the Party
will only criticise. A number of my constituents who
are unhappy and who object to the Government sponsoring
a lottery may be misunderstood that they are only
voicing their apprehension in order to defend their own
illegal livelihood. But before any of you come to the
wrong conclusion that such persons are objecting to the
idea of the Government sponsoring a lottery with an
ulterior motive, I wish to impress upon you that these
persons are responsible and respectable citizens who
are engaged in making an honest living and are also
members of civic organisations.
It is for these reasons that I am of the firm opinion
that this Bill relating to the proposed Social Welfare
Lottery, or whatever name it may be called, should be
exposed to a thorough public debate, but not on a
Certificate of Urgency as if we are facing an immediate
invasion from our neighbours. And one way to gauge
public feeling on this matter of the Government sponsor
ing a lottery is to let the Bill be dealt with by this
House in the normal manner. By introducing such a Bill
on a Certificate of Urgency, the Government is, in
effect, preventing Members in this House from
discharging their obligations to their respective
constituencies. It is impossible for them to ascertain
the feelings of their constituents towards the Social
Welfare Lottery Bill. Mr Speaker, Sir ----
Mr Lim Kim San: Point of order, Mr Speaker, Sir.
This is not a Social Welfare Lottery Bill.
Column: 392
Mr Speaker: I think it is purely a question of force
of habit on the part of Mr Ho.
Mr Ho See Beng: That is why I say it does not matter
under what name it is called! It is raising money. A
rose by any name smells just as sweet. I am sure it is
not the intention of the Government of Singapore to
rush the proposed Bill through this House in order to
forestall the marshalling of public opinion against its
passage. I say this with confidence because the
Government subscribes to the practice and doctrine of
socialism.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the essence of democratic socialism
is that there should be, as far as possible, an equal
distribution of wealth, and one way of achieving such
an equal distribution is by minimising the possible
range of income. In this society where a person is
allowed to enjoy an unearned income, that is, income
from a lottery which is not given to him because of his
work or occupation but because of the windfall from the
lottery there is a basic contradiction between the
concept of sponsoring a lottery to raise funds for
social objectives and the concept of promoting any
measure that would enable a person to enjoy an unearned
income. In Singapore as it is, we have quite a number
of lotteries and games of chance where a person is
given the means to obtain such an unearned income. We
have, for example, horse racing, the illegal four
digits, the Chap Ji Kee. And I know that the only
argument that the Minister for Finance can put is, "Oh,
because we cannot stamp this out, we cannot control
this illegal gambling, so we must make it legal." That
would be the answer.
Mr Lim Kim San: He is putting words in my mouth!
Mr Ho See Beng: He will say it is because
Singaporeans go to Johore to buy lottery tickets. Is
that a valid argument? Are you going to tell me that
because we cannot eradicate gangsters so we must
legislate and give them a licence so that they can go
openly to
Column: 393
members of the public and extort money from them? Is
this going to be the reply to my criticism?
The Minister for Foreign Affairs (Mr S. Rajaratnam):
Are you going to buy tickets yourself?
Mr Ho See Beng: Oh no, no. Mr Speaker, Sir, if the
Government wishes to legislate on the proposed Social
Welfare Lottery, it would appear that its objection to
the running of an illegal lottery by private
individuals or syndicates is based not so much on
principle as on the fact that it is deprived of certain
revenues, in which case it is inconsistent for it to
treat those persons who are convicted of running
illegal lotteries and games of chance as criminals,
because their offence is not the crime of running a
lottery or games of chance but the withholding from
Government of certain revenues which they have
collected as profit. If the Government deems it
necessary to issue a Certificate of Urgency in respect
of the Bill on the proposed Social Welfare Lottery,
then it should make it a matter of urgency to remove
the offence of running illegal lotteries or games of
chance from the Criminal Ordinance or the Revenue
Ordinance.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the more I think of this, the more I
come to the conclusion that the Government has issued
this Certificate of Urgency because it realises that
the proposed Social Welfare Lottery will be a financial
success. But I will say this - and I will prove it to
the Minister for Finance - that there will be 20,000 to
30,000 unhappy families on the day of the drawing. I
have been given to understand that the million-dollar
sweepstake lottery organised by the Singapore Turf Club
has met with a response exceeding the expectations of
the organisers. I am quite sure that the Government has
issued this Certificate of Urgency in order to cash in
on the bonanza. While it is praiseworthy for it to find
all means of obtaining more revenue, I think there is a
limit to which a responsible government, especially one
which subscribes
Column: 394
to the principle of socialism, can afford to promote
gambling in order to bring in more revenue. I am not
objecting to this proposed Bill for the sake of
objecting, but a lottery, while giving rise to
expectations of a sudden windfall, may in the end leave
the poor poorer and the rich richer, because a lottery
is a game of chance, and the more tickets you buy the
greater are the chances of winning the jackpot. The
poor may strain their meagre resources, like the public
daily-rated employees to whom the Minister for Finance
has refused to give even one cent. They may be tempted
to buy and you make them poorer. So the poor may strain
their meagre resources to buy for themselves such
chances as are possible of winning the jackpot, but
they will not be able to compete with the rich who are
in a position to buy many more chances of winning the
jackpot and who, furthermore, are in a position to
afford it. Because of all the considerations which I
have mentioned, I strongly oppose the discussion of
this Bill by this House on a Certificate of Urgency.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
would like to express my views on this Bill. Just now I
have listened to the Member for Bras Basah's views on
it. He says that a lottery is contrary to the principle
of democratic socialism, and that the introduction of
this Bill will cause a lot of unhappiness to many
families. But I am of the view that it will not
necessarily bring about this unhappiness. If the
Member's reasoning could hold water, then I will
enumerate two facts to counter his arguments. Do you
remember that nine years ago when Singapore was in
Malaya there was the Social Welfare Lottery? Even now
there is the running of a Social Welfare Lottery. Many
people even go to Johore Bahru to buy lottery tickets.
These people go over there to buy tickets because of
economic reasons. Some buy only two or three tickets.
This will not be seriously detrimental to their
economic situation. If they are lucky enough, they may
get some prizes which may help increase their income.
It may help them economically.
Column: 395
The other point is that we know that for several years
Singapore has horse-racing. If the Member for Bras
Basah argues that horse-racing causes many families to
be unhappy, then, according to his calculations, there
will be many hundreds and thousands of families who are
very unhappy. But, on the other hand, we see Singapore
developing all the time. According to a World Bank
Report, the standard of living of Singapore is the
third highest in the whole of Asia. Whether or not the
issue of lottery tickets is contrary to the tenets of
democratic socialism, I will say this that in many
socialist countries there is also the practice of
running lotteries.
We have also heard the Minister say just now that the
proceeds from this lottery will be devoted to social
welfare and charitable organisations. It is meant to
benefit the public as a whole. A dollar from each
person will accumulate into a large sum, which will
help our development and assist in the work of social
welfare. It is because of this that I am not of the
view that running a lottery will be detrimental to the
nation, or to the economy or livelihood of the people.
On the contrary, it will contribute to the social
welfare work of our country.
Mr Tay Boon Too(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
would like to express my views on this Bill. I agree
very much with the sentiments expressed by the Member
for Bras Basah. At the same time, I beg to differ from
what the Member for Sembawang has said, and make some
criticisms of his speech. Our Government is a socialist
government. We understand what is the final aim of a
socialist government; that is, to give to each his due
and to extract from each his ability. If you get one
dollar from each man so that in the end the money comes
to fifty or five million dollars, then it will be
contrary to the policy of our socialist Government. It
will be to misunderstand our principles. So I agree
with the Member for Bras Basah that this Bill should be
debated by the public before it can he introduced into
this House,
Column: 396
Mr Lim Guan Hoo(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, on
the question of lotteries and sweepstakes, I have some
views of my own. I would also like to express my
disagreement with certain statements of a certain
Member here. The Minister has given reasons and
explanations which are not entirely satisfactory or
sufficient. Recently we have heard some Ministers
saying that wages should be in accordance with the
productivity of the person concerned. In other words,
it should be measured according to a person's effort
and performance, and this seems to be contrary to the
principle of this Bill. If the Government does not
clarify the situation further, then the public will be
led to think that the Ministers are inconsistent, and I
feel this is regrettable. So I hope some Ministers can
give explanations to enlighten us all. In view of the
Finance Minister's inadequate explanation, and also in
view of Members' arguments just now, there has been a
certain psychological reaction to this Bill. I feel
that the idea of getting some benefit out of a lottery
is the normal thinking of any ordinary person. If we
can be more practical in the analysis of human
psychology, then we can understand that the urge and
desire to get a windfall through buying lottery tickets
is a kind of economic as well as a psychological
manifestation. A windfall can be got through various
illegal or criminal methods, such as robbery or
stealing or smuggling. Through such methods, one can
overnight get some unjust windfall. That is practical.
It is more easily put into practice than running a
lottery. But if you say that it is fair and just on
socialist grounds that a person can get a windfall by
striking a lottery, then I do not quite understand the
meaning of "windfall" because from the standpoint of
socialism, we feel that there are certain
contradictions and discrepancies there. We see that
nowadays it is difficult to voice our thoughts on
socialism, namely, from each according to his ability,
and to each according to his need. In the situation
here in Singapore, most of our people have regular
employment. The Member for Bras Basah has said that the
housewives have to
Column: 397
look after their households, and the breadwinners are
the husbands or some other members of the family. If
these breadwinners have no means of sustenance, or if
they do not depend on their employment but on some
windfall to look after their families, then it is
unwise to spend too much money on lotteries and we
should adopt measures appropriate to deal with these
cases. But if people who are regularly employed look
for an opportunity to get a windfall through some
unjust or shameful or illegal or criminal methods, then
I say this is contrary to the normal means of earning a
living. Also it cannot be 100 per cent sound or
reasonable to support the running of sweepstakes. We
must urge that our socialist policies should be
implemented. Singapore cannot be isolated from other
countries. We cannot build a wall around it so that
other countries cannot get our people's money to spend
on their lotteries. But, on the other hand, if we can
run our own lottery, of course, it will prevent our
people's money from being drained into other
territories. The Member for Bras Basah has said that
the rich get the money from the poor by striking a
lottery, and then they spend it on the poor again.
That, I think, is difficult to understand. Is it really
justifiable to get money from the poor and spend it
back on the poor? I do not quite see his argument. We
are used to hearing very often the name of the N.T.U.C.
in his talks. I do not understand what is his purpose
in saying this. Is he trying to enhance his prestige by
calling on the name of the N.T.U.C.? Whether it is of
any use in doing this in this House I do not quite
know. It will have to depend on the Speaker to decide.
If it is intended that some poor people in Singapore
can overnight become millionaires -- but the chances of
this happening are very remote, only one out of one
million, and this is perhaps also not in keeping with
socialist principles - we can perhaps increase the
number of prizes by reducing the amount of the first
prize to, say, $100,000. Perhaps this will provide more
opportunities
Column: 398
for more people to get rich, and therefore it may be a
bit fairer. But in the past, from the point of law, if
people ran illegal lotteries and they were caught, they
would have to suffer the consequences. From the point
of law, in the past, there was no practice to regard
the winning of a lottery as a criminal act if the
practice was allowable under the law. So we cannot
credit or discredit the issue of lottery tickets. In
principle, we may support this Bill, hut what we hope
is that in practice there should be necessary
arrangements to ensure that the lottery system in
Singapore will not have any undesirable evil
consequences or any disadvantages which will make many
people change their correct concept of life or lead
them to believe that we are indulging in gambling. So
this is what the Government should pay attention to.
This is what I hope the Government can do. Finally I
would like the Minister concerned to clarify what I
have asked him to clarify.
Mr S. Rajoo (Farrer Park): Mr Speaker, Sir, I stand
not to support this Bill because we know that betting
and sweepstakes is a social evil, no matter whether
such betting is done by an organised club or
association or an individual, or whether it has the
blessing of Government. For a democratic government
dedicated to socialist principles to have the idea of
running a sweepstake or lottery for the purposes of
raising funds is very much deplorable. We have a stable
government and an able Minister for Finance who knows
ways and means of how to squeeze money in the way of
taxes from the general public. Yet the idea to have
some extra measures of free betting and sweepstake to
find more money will mean that he is trying to sneak
through the backdoor and induce poor housewives to
spend more money, and lately day-dreamers to find extra
money from their already over-burdened budget and
eventually making them poor. We believe in the
socialist principle of making men equal to one another
economically, but not in making the poor poorer and the
rich richer. When our neighbouring country was running
the Social Welfare Lottery, the buying and selling of
these lottery
Column: 399
tickets was banned in Singapore on the grounds that
this breeds evil. I wonder how, all of a sudden, the so
dedicated socialist government of Singapore found fit
to introduce this free betting and sweepstake to find
money for social welfare purposes. I hope we in
Singapore are trying to make hard-working, law-abiding
and good citizens of our people and not more gamblers
and bookmakers, as I feel this amendment will
eventually bring about.
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Member for Bras
Basah has two basic objections to this Bill: (1) that
it is being introduced on a Certificate of Urgency; and
(2) because he says it is a betting Bill. I can assure
the House that the Government is well aware that
because there is no Opposition in the House - the
Barisan Sosialis having resigned or attempted to resign
from their seats and having been derelict in their
duties - we must be very careful not to introduce Bills
if we can on Certificates of Urgency. For instance, if
we were to introduce the Land Acquisition Bill or any
Bill on the Constitution on a Certificate of Urgency,
that would be most reprehensible. But we have not done
that. When important Bills come up, because there is no
Opposition, we send them to Select Committee, so that
members of the public will have an opportunity to
present their views and the Committee an opportunity to
consider them. This is what has happened to the Land
Acquisition Bill which will be read a Third time today.
But this Betting and Sweepstake Duties (Amendment)
Bill is not a Bill to introduce betting in Singapore.
If we have no horse-racing and no sweepstakes, and this
is a Bill to introduce gambling for the first time in
Singapore, then we will never do it this way. But if
the Members who object to this Bill read it carefully,
they will note that it is a Bill to give the Minister
powers to exempt any sweepstake promoted, organised,
administered or operated by any racing club or
association from all or any of the provisions of this
Ordinance. It does not give him power to start a
sweepstake. We have those powers and we have had them
for many
Column: 400
a year. All this Bill does is to give him power to
exempt "The Singapore Sweepstake" - if you like to call
it that - from paying 30 per cent tax that should go to
the Singapore Government. And I cannot see why we
cannot bring it in on a Certificate of Urgency. The
tickets are, at the moment, being sold in Singapore and
the first draw will be held in early December. Hence
the urgency for this Bill.
When the People's Action Party came to power in 1959,
it was a puritanical Party. It appears to me, after
hearing some of our Members today, that we are still
semi-puritanical. There was a day when rock-n-roll was
banned in Singapore. I myself like rock-n-roll and I
saw no objections to rock-n-roll. Today, our youngsters
like to do the Twist. I do it once in a while, but
perhaps I am getting too old for it. But I think there
is a new thinking now. We have to cater for our youths
and every year there are 90,000 to 100,000 more voters,
and we have to cater for their taste. And if our youths
like to do the Twist, I say good luck to them. The days
of the pigtailed school-girls are over, and if the
Barisan Sosialis depend on them, I think they have not
got a hope. I only hope that members of our Party will
also move with the times.
6.19 p.m.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I feel very
uplifted listening to the Back-benchers and realise
that they still have a lot of idealism left in them.
But I would like to congratulate the Member for Bukit
Merah who has idealism tinged with realism. And I would
like to inform my friend, the Member for Bras Basah,
who happens to be missing here, that in my trip through
Bulgaria recently -it is a very socialist country - I
found that they run sweepstakes every week. That is a
very strong socialist country, but they have learnt
that idealism must he tinged with realism. And I hear
from my colleague, the Minister for Foreign Affairs,
that in his trip to Russia and several other Central
European socialist countries, they too run their own
lotteries. I agree that we should not
Column: 401
encourage betting or gambling if Members who object to
it can assure me that even without allowing betting or
gambling under control in Singapore, our people would
not gamble at all and that the 20,000 or 30,000
housewives would not feel sorry or would not buy
tickets from across the Causeway.
To reply to the Member's criticism that we are afraid
to have a public debate on the pros and cons of
allowing lotteries to be run in Singapore, I think my
colleague has answered in some measure the reasons why
the amendment Bill to the Betting and Sweepstake Duties
Ordinance is introduced on a Certificate of Urgency.
I resent very much the accusation of the Member for
Farrer Park who feels that we are introducing gambling
through the backdoor by bringing about an amendment
Bill to the Betting and Sweepstake Duties Ordinance. If
it was my intention to introduce, allow or encourage
gambling through the back-door, I would not have made
any amendment to the Ordinance at all, because I would
be able to get money simply by telling the Turf Club,
"All right, you run it, pay the tax and give us the
profits." That would be an easier way of doing it than
by coming here and seeking approval for this amendment
Bill.
As I said, if I can be assured that if we do not allow
the Turf Club to run this sweep and the population at
large would not spend their money on gambling, then I
would agree that we stop gambling here entirely. But
human nature is such that even if we do not allow
gambling, a large amount of money will be spent on
gambling - and illegal gambling at that - which will
encourage gangsterism, protection rackets and all sorts
of crimes.
Mr Ho See Beng: What are the police doing?
Mr Lim Kim San: I see that our friend is back here!
The police have not only to look out for gambling but
they have also other jobs to do. But can the Member for
Bras Basah tell
Column: 402
me that it is possible to eradicate gambling? If he can
say that, then we will give it a try. I think it has
been found that it is not possible at all to eradicate
gambling. So if we allow it to go underground, more
evil consequences will follow than if we allow it in
the open.
I cannot understand the argument of the Member for
Bras Basah and also the argument of the Member for
Farrer Park that the poor will get poorer and the rich
will get richer because of the sale of lottery tickets.
Do they mean to say that in every instance where
lottery tickets are sold, it is only the rich who
strike a prize? I think the Member for Bras Basah
contradicts himself when he says that the chances for
the poor are less for the simple reason that they
cannot afford to buy more lottery tickets than the
rich. If that is so, then more of the money will come
from the rich than from the poor!
Mr Rajoo: On a point of explanation, Sir.
Mr Lim Kim San resumed his seat.
Mr Rajoo: On what I said that the rich will become
richer and the poor will become poorer - it is a
possibility. A rich man buys about 1,000 tickets in a
sweepstake, whereas a poor man buys ten tickets. So the
chances of a rich man winning a lottery are a hundred
times more than those of a poor man. Therefore, it is a
possibility that a rich man will become richer and a
poor man will become poorer.
An hon. Member: Then good luck to him!
Mr Lim Kim San: That is exactly what I said. The
Member for Bras Basah contradicts himself. He said that
all the money will come from the poor. If that argument
is right, then most of the money will come from the
rich! [Interruption] And he says, "Well, look, it is so
successful, from what we hear, the sale of tickets is
more than what was expected by the Turf Club," it means
that there is a need for this here, that the majority
of the public are not of the same opinion as he. I
think it is important for me to say that no one is
Column: 403
under compulsion to buy these tickets. Therefore, if we
want to eradicate gambling, it is not by shutting our
eyes to it or wearing blinkers in order not to see that
the evil exists, but through education. That is my
reply to the Member for Bukit Merah. It is through
education in the long run that we will be able to
change the nature of our population. But until then,
let us tinge our idealism with a little bit of realism
and see that whatever money is spent by the people in
gambling does not leave this country.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to a
Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a Committee
on the Bill. -[Mr Lim Kim San].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 403
INSURANCE BILL
6.30 p.m.
"to provide for the regulation of insurance business
in Singapore, and for other purposes relating to or
connected therewith",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by Mr Lim Kim San;
read the First time, to be read a Second
time on the next available sitting, and to be printed.
Column: 403
ENTERTAINMENTS DUTY
(AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Entertainments Duty Ordinance (Chapter
161 of the Revised Edition)",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by Mr Lim Kim San;
read the First time, to be read a Second
time on the next available sitting, and to be printed.
Column: 403
GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS BILL
"to provide for the making of contracts on behalf of
the Government and for matters connected therewith",
Column: 404
recommendation of President signified;
presented by Mr Lim Kim San;
read the First time, to be read a Second
time on the next available sitting, and to be printed.
Column: 404
INCOME TAX (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Income Tax Ordinance (Chapter 166 of the
Revised Edition)",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by Mr Lim Kim San;
read the First time, to be read a Second
time on the next available sitting, and to be printed.
Column: 404
RAILWAYS (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Railways Ordinance (Chapter 110 of the
Revised Edition)",
presented by the Minister of State for the Prime Minister's Department (Tuan Haji Yaacob Bin Mohamed) (for the Deputy Prime Minister); read the First time,
to be read a Second time on the next available sitting,
and to be printed.
Column: 404
NANYANG UNIVERSITY (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Nanyang University Ordinance, 1959 (No.
27 of 1959)",
presented by the Minister for Education (Mr Ong Pang Boon); read the First time, to be read a Second time on
the next available sitting, and to be printed.
Column: 404
WOMEN'S CHARTER (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Women's Charter, 1961 (No. 18 of 1961)",
presented by the Minister for Culture and Social Affairs (Inche Othman Bin Wok);
read the First time, to be read a Second time on the next
available sitting, and to be printed.
Column: 404
INTESTATE SUCCESSION BILL
"to make provision for the distribution of intestate
estates",
presented by the Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker);
Column: 405
read the First time, to be read a Second time
on the next available sitting, and to be printed.
Column: 405
TRUSTEES BILL
"to consolidate and amend the law relating to
trustees",
presented by Mr Barker; read the First time, to be
read a Second time on the next available sitting, and
to be printed.
Column: 405
PUBLIC TRUSTEE
(AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Public Trustee Ordinance (Chapter 32 of
the Revised Edition)",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by Mr Barker; read the First time, to be read a Second time
on the next available sitting, and to be printed.
Column: 405
CURRENCY (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read. 6.37 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr S. Ramaswamy): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like to explain briefly the
necessity of this Bill. The Malaya British Borneo
Currency Agreement, 1960, signed by the Governments of
Singapore, Malaya and Brunei, established the Board of
Commissioners of Currency, Malaya and British Borneo,
as the sole currency issuing authority in their
respective countries. Under the terms of this Currency
Agreement, any of the Participating Governments can
replace the Board as the sole currency issuing
authority by lodging a notice of its intention to do
so, 18 months prior to the date it wishes to commence
its currency issue. Such a notice of replacement was
lodged by the Government of Malaysia on 12th December,
1964. This notice, therefore, became effective on
Column: 406
12th June, 1966, that is, 18 months after it was
lodged, and the Currency Board is then obliged to
relinquish its right to issue currency in Singapore,
Malaysia and Brunei. There is, however, provision in
the Agreement for the Board to continue to issue
currency for a further period of six months after the
notice becomes effective, if it is requested to do so
by the Participating Governments. Such a request was
accordingly made and the Board was therefore empowered
to issue currency in the territories of the three
Governments concerned up to 12th December, 1966.
The Participating Governments had also agreed that the
life span of the Board should be extended by a further
six months, that is, up to 12th June, 1967. As the
Currency Agreement does not provide for such further
extension, it is necessary to amend this Agreement. The
purpose of the Bill is, therefore, to give legal effect
to this amendment so that the Board can continue to
issue currency up to 12th June, 1967.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to a
Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a Committee
on the Bill .-[Mr Ramaswamy}.
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 406
LAND ACQUISITION BILL
(As reported from Select Committee)
Order for Third Reading read.
6.40 p.m.
Mr Speaker: Notice has been given by the Minister for
Law and National Development of amendments in respect
of clauses 22, 23, 31, 33 and 48 of the Bill as set out
in the Order Paper Supplement. The Bill accordingly
stands recommitted to a Committee of the whole House in
respect of those clauses.
Column: 407
Any other Member who wishes to propose other
amendments or new clauses is required to give notice of
his desire before the House resolves itself into a
Committee on the recommitted matter.
No other Member giving notice ---
Mr Speaker: Committee stage, what day, Mr Barker?
Mr Barker: Now, Sir.
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
6.44 p.m.
Clause 22 -
Amendment made: In page A10, line 28, at end, to
insert "and".-[Mr Barker].
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
In page A10, to leave out lines 29 and 30.
Mr Speaker, Sir, in Select Committee, clause 32 (1)
was amended to provide that the costs of an appeal
shall be in the discretion of the Board and shall
either be fixed by the Board or, on the order of the
Board, taxed by the Registrar or the Deputy Registrar
of the High Court in accordance with the scale
prescribed under the rules of the Supreme Court.
Accordingly it becomes necessary to delete clause 22
(1) (e) of the Bill.
Sir, I beg to move.
Amendment agreed to.
6.45 p.m.
The Chairman: There is a consequential amendment to be
made, in page A10, line 31, to leave out "(f) " and
insert "(e) " because of the deletion of paragraph (e) .
This will be done.
Clause 22, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clause 23 -
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, I beg to move
Column: 408
In page A11, line 17, after "appellant", to insert "by
delivering or tendering such copy to him or sending it
to him by registered letter".
Mr Speaker, Sir, this amendment has been moved as it
is considered advisable here to specify the methods
whereby a copy of the grounds of an award is to be
served by the Registrar upon the appellant.
Sir, I beg to move.
Amendment agreed to.
Clause 23, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clause 31 -
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
In page A15, line 37, to leave out "act", and insert
"Act".
This amendment corrects a slight printing error in the
Bill now before the House.
Sir, I beg to move.
Amendment agreed to.
Clause 31, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clause 33 -
Amendment made: In page A17, line 21, after "not", to
insert ", in the case of any such acquisition within a
period of six months of such land being devastated or
affected as aforesaid,"- [Mr Barker].
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
In page A17, line 24, to leave out "such devastation"
and insert "the time when such land was devastated or
affected as aforesaid".
Sir, it was suggested to the Select Committee that
there must be a definite period of time during which
Government may acquire land under the provisions of the
law. It is in the spirit of this suggestion that I have
now moved the two aforesaid amendments so as to
restrict the application of this provision to only six
months from the date of the occurrence of a fire or any
other act of God.
Column: 409
Sir, I beg to move.
Amendment agreed to.
Clause 33, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clause 48 -
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
In page A24, lines 5 and 6, to leave out "whether
before or after the enactment of this subsection,".
This phrase seems redundant and it is accordingly
being deleted.
Sir, I beg to move.
Amendment agreed to.
Clause 48, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Bill reported with amendments.
Third Reading
Mr Speaker: Third Reading, what day?
Mr Barker: Now, Sir.
Mr Speaker: Please move.
Mr Barker: I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read
a Third time."
Members of the House will recall that this Bill was
referred to the Select Committee on 22nd June this
year. Members will also recall that during the Second
Reading, I expressed the hope that when the Select
Committee calls for representations, persons with
positive contributions will come forward with
suggestions. I am, indeed, happy to report that the
response to invitations for representation was good.
Eleven written representations were received and the
Select Committee heard oral evidence from six of them.
Some of these contributions were valuable and many sug
gestions have been accepted. The Committee's Report was
published on 10th September, 1966, as Paper Parl. 9 of
1966.
Column: 410
Mr Speaker, Sir, the Bill as now tabled before the
House incorporates the recommendations of the Select
Committee. I do not propose to burden the Members of
this House with unnecessary explanations, but there are
two fundamental provisions on which there have been
representations which were unacceptable and which I
wish to take this opportunity to reiterate.
The first of these is the compensation provision in
the Bill. As has already been explained in this House
previously, the principle underlining this provision is
that no landowner should benefit at the public's
expense, from any windfall gains resulting from
enhancement of land values either through Acts of God
or because of public expenditure in the neighbourhood.
Members are aware of the phenomenal increases in land
values which result when heavily encumbered lands are
devastated by fire. This fortuitous increase in value
will not now go to the landowner. Again, development by
Government and public authorities in areas like Jurong,
Kallang Basin and Kranji has resulted in phenomenal
increases in land values in these neighbourhoods. It
was ironical that under the existing legislation, when
additional lands in these areas had to be acquired for
public purposes, Government had to pay compensation at
values which Government itself had helped to enhance.
The element of enhancement attributable in these cases
to public participation (as opposed to participation by
the private sector), is the element which under the new
Bill will be creamed off when land is acquired for
public purposes.
The second point I wish to make today involves the
concept of the Appeals Board. Mr Speaker, Sir, a
number of representations were received by the Select
Committee in which the same point was made. And the
point was this: all appeals should be heard by a Court
of Law presided by a Judge of the High Court instead of
the Appeals Board, as proposed. Mr Speaker, Sir, the
move to take appeals away from the Courts and place
them in the hands of an Appeals Board or tribunal is in
conformity with prevailing trends else.
Column: 411
where in the world of entrusting matters of specialist
evaluation to Administrative Tribunals where persons
with the requisite expertise can deal with issues
involving subjects with which they are themselves
familiar. Furthermore, procedures before such tribunals
are less formal, less expensive, more expeditious and,
perhaps, more satisfactory.
The provision of the Appeals Board envisaged in the
Bill is similar to the set-up in the United Kingdom,
but we have not laid down statutory limitations
prescribing minimum legal or professional
qualifications in order not to restrict the field of
selection. It is envisaged, however, that the
Commissioner and the Deputy Commissioner, both of whom
will have the status of High Court Judges, will be
persons who are either legally qualified or have
considerable experience in land administration and
other matters. The panel of assessors will be persons
with objective minds who will be able to assist the
Commissioner in assessing fair compensation after
listening to expert evidence on values.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
7.00 p.m.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol): Mr Speaker, Sir, firstly,
I would like to associate myself with the views
expressed by the Minister. Sir, as I see it, this is a
piece of legislation which definitely favours the poor
man. This is what we the P.A.P. Government stands for
- for the poor man. Let me take an example to
substantiate my argument. A few years ago when hell
broke loose in the Bukit Ho Swee area where thousands
of people were rendered homeless by fire, what did the
P.A.P. Government do then? Did the Government just
merely say, "Well, we will try to rehouse them." No,
far from it, not just trying in that direction. But the
Government took immediate steps to provide immediate
relief to the homeless. Then the Bukit Ho Swee fire
site was acquired and plans to put up decent flats with
the necessary social amenities
Column: 412
were drawn up and at once implemented.
Now, if there had not been any fire and had not the
Government acquired this site, today we will not see
the beautiful symmetry of a clean and healthy location
where numerous blocks of flats for the poor exist. I am
sure this House will agree whole-heartedly with me on
this matter. The Government, on the one hand, acquires
land for community use and those who think they would
suffer as a result should retune their minds and look
at acquisition as a means of allowing Government to
continue to provide the poor with decent homes and
better social amenities. On the other hand, the
Government, with the people's needs uppermost in its
mind, would continue to fulfil its obligations, come
whatever the obstacles.
I am surprised that those affected are asking for more
compensation than what is arrived at by our valuers.
They should have been happy with what they are to get.
In fact, I would say that the land value should be
reduced to as low a rate as possible in order to allow
the Government to continue to provide such amenities.
May I, Sir, stress that we do not wish to favour the
land speculators who jump at opportunities when
Government projects or public projects are carried out
in adjacent lands, thereby helping to boost up the land
value! We come from the masses and our obligation is to
them and them alone. If we allow these speculators free
rein, then chaos and financial difficulties would over-run us all and the Government would then have to dish
out enormous sums of money to pay for fantastic sums of
compensation to those involved. I think those
landowners who are rich must be practical. They should
be the first to come forward and assist in nation-building and make some sacrifices, for, as the saying
goes, Sir, "It is in the giving that we receive." Let
me ask them a question. What would happen to them if
the country goes down? Where would their landed
properties be then? If they would care to look at
certain countries not far from us, they would see my
point.
Column: 413
Sir, as our main objective is to help establish a more
equal and just society, therefore, our declared aim is
to acquire lands from time to time which will be
developed or utilised for public purposes, say, for
example, to build more schools, clinics, more blocks of
housing flats, more community centres, veterinary
extension centres and many others.
Lastly, Sir, I would urge those likely to be affected
to think well of others so that the declared aims of
the Government can be achieved with as little
inconvenience as possible.
Inche Mahmud Awang(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
support this Bill. It is, on the whole, good for the
lower strata of society. It is appropriate and in line
with our new status and new name, the Republic of
Singapore, and consonant with the concept of democratic
socialism which is strongly opposed by the Alliance,
the Barisan Sosialis and other Parties whose aim is to
perpetuate bourgeois rule. Why I say so, Mr Speaker,
is that lands which are acquired by Government will be
fully developed for the purpose of public projects;
clinics, dispensaries, hospitals, schools, cheap - I
emphasise cheap - flats, not high rental flats,
community centres and other projects which would be
enjoyed by the lower class society, not parks like the
MacRitchie Reservoir Park on which we have debated
today.
Our Government is not confiscating properties owned by
landowners, Mr Speaker, Sir. Before such lands are
acquired by Government, they will be assessed and
adequate compensation will be paid, which is not the
case in Communist countries. In other words, Mr
Speaker, Sir, both parties benefit. As has happened,
when a fire breaks out, it is the responsibility of the
government of the day to rehouse the fire victims in
flats and offer relief. The landowner shakes his legs
and when the land is free of squatters, he is in a
position to develop it for his own selfish interest.
Mr Speaker, Sir, it is
Column: 414
appropriate that this Bill, which will be approved by
Parliament, will satisfy all parties concerned.
7.10 p.m.
Mr Lim Guan Hoo(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
about this Land Acquisition Bill, we all may have the
impression that this is one of the important Bills to
be passed by this Parliament. I would like to deal with
this Bill in a wider perspective. Inevitably, a country
will have certain laws and rights to the land. This is
a necessary and an essential feature of the rights of a
country. And in the development of a country, it is
inevitable that there are certain changes. When certain
countries change from an agricultural economy to an
industrialised economy, it is necessary to acquire
land. This is called land reform. And at times it
happens that this leads to a struggle for power between
the landowners and the State. In countries which are
friendly with us, the Eastern European countries and
Egypt - I will just enumerate one example - in Egypt
there is also the problem of landownership and there
has been certain harm done by the system there. So
there is a policy on acquisition of land to meet the
requirement of the country in its development. To our
minds, the land is part and parcel of a country and it
is the right of the State to acquire and manage its
development.
Our island is a very tiny one and with our limited
land area, we have to build an ideal country.
Therefore, we must put our land to the best possible
use in order to meet our largest and highest demands.
We should have proper arrangements and measures in our
island State in order to ensure that every inch of land
can be put to the best possible use in order to
maintain national development and to promote the
prosperity of our country, so that we can extract every
benefit out of every inch of land and so that every man
can be used to the limit of his ability and everything
can be put to the best possible use. We should not have
the practice such as is obtaining in feudalistic
countries, to divide or
Column: 415
allot lands to certain landlords. But here in
Singapore, we should try to realise our own paradise.
We should not allow anybody to waste too large an area
of land. We do not have too many Christmas Islands to
be sold. Therefore, we must make the best possible use
of our land.
The Members of Parliament and the general public
regard the passage of this Bill as one of the important
steps taken in the process of development of our
country. We should concentrate all our energy and
attention on the development of our country, and in
this respect, the acquisition of land is very
important. It is a very essential feature in the
process of nation-building. We are short of land, and
there is a saying that God created the world and the
Dutch created land. We should also follow suit to show
that we can also reclaim land from the sea in order to
extend our land area, which is part of our nation-
building process. This is a step forward towards a
better future and the prosperity and development of our
country. This is an inevitable part of our endeavours.
I do not view this Bill as a piece of legislation but
as a dynamic step forward in the right direction of
nation-building. I believe that after the law is
amended, it will already have its own proper form to
meet the requirements of the time. Therefore, it is now
tabled in this House for discussion and passage. It has
already been considered in Select Committee and the
Report has been published. Advertisements appeared in
the Press on the 25th and 27th of June this year
inviting representations on the Bill. This is a show of
democracy, and I am very satisfied with the process of
the Bill. It is also comprehensive in its structure and
takes into consideration every aspect of the problem
arising out of land acquisition. The acquisition of
land is not always for perpetual possession by the
State. In some cases, land is to be put to use and is
required for a period of 3 years. Stress is put on the
use of land for public requirements and needs. Because
of this feature, the Bill has brought about a
socialistic change in land acquisition. In a socialist
Column: 416
country, it is fit and proper that every inch of land
should be put to the best possible use to yield the
best advantage for the benefit of the people and make a
very effective contribution to the development of the
country. This is a very essential feature of a
socialistic system.
Another characteristic of this Bill is that landowners
will not be able to benefit from an increase in land
value by receiving a windfall, so that nobody can
speculate in land value. This is also a good feature.
I would like this House to refer to page 18 of the
Bill. There is a provision that compensation should not
always be paid according to market value before
acquisition, because there are so many factors which
contribute to an increase of land value - some of which
are illegal. So after careful consideration and
deliberate study, the Bill is now in its best possible
form and it will not be detrimental to the people. I
have full confidence in it and I believe that when it
is put into effect and practice, it will be beneficial
to the people and the country.
I express my support for the Bill.
Mr Barker: There has not been a word of criticism. I
have nothing much to add except to say that I am glad
that our Back-benchers have realised the importance and
the necessity for this piece of socialist legislation.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
ADJOURNMENT
Resolved, "That this Parliament do now adjourn to a
date to be fixed."- [Mr Barker].
Adjourned accordingly at
Twenty-two minutes past Seven o'clock p.m.