| Parliament No: | 1 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 25 |
| Sitting No: | 7 |
| Sitting Date: | 05-12-1966 |
|
Column: 417
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
FIRST SESSION OF THE FIRST PARLIAMENT
PART II OF FIRST SESSION |
VOLUME 25 |
Monday, 5th December, 1966
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Mr P. Coomaraswamy).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development.
Inche Buang Bin Omar Junid (Kallang), Parliamentary Secretary to the Deputy Prime Minister.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Chow Chiok Hock (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister of Defence.
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development.
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Labour.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State for Culture.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (River Valley).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah).
Column: 418
Mr Lim Kim San, D.U.T. (Cairnhill), Minister for Finance.
Mr S. V. Lingam (Aljunied).
Inche Mahmud Awang (Kampong Kapor).
Inche Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Mrs Devan Nair (Moulmein).
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Education.
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Culture and Social Affairs.
Inche Rahamat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr S. Rajoo (Farrer Park), Mr S. Ramaswamy (Crawford). Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance.
Mr Bernard Rodrigues (Telok Blangah).
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang).
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Deputy Prime Minister and Leader of the House.
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Minister of State of Defence.
Tuan Haji Yaacob Bin Mohamed (Southern Islands), Minister of State for the Prime Minister's Department.
Column: 419
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng (Joo Chiat).
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Health.
ABSENT:
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Education.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs and Government Whip.
Mr Chan Sun Wing (Nee Soon).
Mr Wong Soon Fong (Toa Payoh).
Column: 419
PERMISSION TO MEMBERS TO BE ABSENT
Under the provisions of clause 2 (d) of Article 30 of
the Constitution of Singapore, I have granted
permission to the following Members to be or to remain
absent from sittings of Parliament (or any committee of
Parliament to which they have been appointed) for the
period stated:-
Tuan Haji Yaacob Bin Mohamed (Southern Islands), Minister of State for the Prime Minister's Department - from 21st November to 3rd December, 1966.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs and Government Whip - from 21st November to 24th December, 1966.
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Education - from 5th to 14th December, 1966.
Column: 419
ASSENTS TO BILLS PASSED
I have been informed by the President that, on the
days stated, he assented to the following Bills:-
1st November, 1966
(i) Betting and Sweepstake Duties (Amendment) Bill; and
(ii) Currency (Amendment) Bill.
3rd November, 1966
Land Acquisition Bill
Column: 420
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
NEW MEMBERS SWORN
2.31p.m.
Mr Speaker: Order. The hon. Members desirous of
taking their seats will please come forward when their
names are called.
The following Members made an Affirmation of
Allegiance in the order below:
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng (Joo Chiat).
Column: 420
RESIGNATION OF MEMBERS
(Announcement by Mr Speaker)
2.36 p.m.
Mr Speaker: I have to inform hon. Members that at
10.15 a.m. on the 28th October, 1966, I received to
hand four letters each dated 27th October, 1966, under
the respective hands of -
(1) Mr Koo Young, who was elected to this House as Member for Thomson;
(2) Mr Ong Lian Teng, who was elected to this House as Member for Bukit Panjang;
(3) Mr Poh Ber Liak, who was elected to this House as Member for Tampines; and
(4) Mr Tan Cheng Tong, who was elected to this House as Member for Jalan Kayu,
resigning their seats in Parliament. Each of these
letters was received in my office on the 28th October,
1966.
I further have to inform hon. Members that at 9.55 a.m. on 1st November, 1966, I received to hand a letter
dated 27th October, 1966, under the hand of Miss Loh
Miaw Gong, who was elected to this House as Member for
Havelock, resigning her seat in Parliament. Miss Loh's
letter was received in my office on 1st November, 1966.
Column: 421
Under the provisions of Article 91(4) , the
resignations of Mr Koo Young, Mr Ong Lian Teng, Mr
Poh Ber Liak and Mr Tan Cheng Tong have effect from 10.15 a.m.
on the 28th October, 1966, and the
resignation of Miss Loh Miaw Gong has effect from 9.55 a.m.
on 1st November, 1966.
Accordingly, I report to the House that the seats of
the Members for Thomson, Bukit Panjang, Tampines, Jalan
Kayu and Havelock are vacant.
Column: 421
GIFT FROM HOUSE OF COMMONS
(Announcement by Mr Speaker)
Mr Speaker: I wish to inform hon. Members that on
the 16th November, 1966, on behalf of the House I
received from a delegation of the Commons House of
Parliament of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and
Northern Ireland a gift of a bookcase and books. I have
directed that the bookcase and books be placed in the
Library.
In connection with this gift a motion stands on
today's Order Paper in the name of the Leader of the
House.
Column: 421
ALLOCATION OF SEATS
(Announcement by Mr Speaker)
Mr Speaker: The recent bye-elections have caused the
capacity of seats on my right to be exceeded. Acting
under Standing Orders and in consultation with the
Leader of the House, I have in the course of allocating
seats to the three hon. Members who took their oaths
today taken the opportunity to reallocate seats to
certain other Members. By reason of the capacity of the
benches, it has become necessary to seat on my left
some hon. Members whose customary place would be on my
right.
Column: 421
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
2.39 p.m.
ADVERTISEMENT ON FOUNTAIN AT AIRPORT
1. Mr Teong Eng Siong asked the Deputy Prime
Minister why a firm has been allowed to incorporate an
advertisement in the fountain at the approach to
Column: 422
the Paya Lebar International Airport; whether the firm
pays a concession fee for the advertisement, and what
is the fee for a year.
Dr Toh Chin Chye: Mr Speaker, the decision to allow
the firm concerned to incorporate an advertisement in
the fountain built and paid for by the company at a
cost of $69,000 at the approach road to the Paya Lebar
International Airport was approved by the Malaysian
Ministry of Transport on the 5th July, 1965, when the
Department of Civil Aviation was under its control.
The company does not pay concession fees for the
advertisement, but it is responsible for the proper
operation and maintenance of the fountain, estimated to
cost $5,000 a year, in addition to the cost of
electricity and water consumed. At the end of five
years, from 1st January, 1966, the fountain and all its
fittings will become the property of the Government. As
advertising on the fountain has drawn unfavourable
comments from visitors to the Airport, negotiations
will be taken up to transfer the fountain to the
Government within the contract period.
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, can I raise a supplementary question?
Mr Speaker: Yes, certainly.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): I would like to
ask the Minister concerned, since this is a place which
many tourists will be visiting, whether we can take
immediate steps to remove this advertisement and,
instead, other advertisements, posters, or slogans of a
national nature be posted there. For instance, we can
publicise that we want to build a multi-racial society,
or that we welcome all international tourists to come
to Singapore.
Dr Toh Chin Chye: Mr Speaker, as I have pointed out
just now, there is a contract by which the Singapore
Government has to abide. And as I have indicated to the
House, we are now negotiating with the company
concerned to transfer the fountain to the Government
within five years as soon as
Column: 423
possible, and until we do so we are not in a position
to control any advertising slogans which are now
located on the fountain itself. However, I am quite
certain that the company, being a longstanding company
in Singapore, will co-operate with the Government, and
I am certain that there will be no difficulties when we
come to negotiate with them by which such a transfer
can be made to the Government.
Column: 423
ILLEGAL ENTRY OF PERSONS
INTO SINGAPORE
2. Mr Sim Boon Woo asked the Deputy Prime Minister
whether he is aware that there are people entering
Singapore illegally along the coast of Mata Ikan and
Padang Terbakar, and what action he has taken, or
proposes to take, in the matter.
Dr Toh Chin Chye: Mr Speaker, as long as there was
a curfew imposed in Singapore port waters, it was easy
to detect any craft making its way to Singapore. With
the ending of Indonesian confrontation, the curfew has
now been lifted and, as is to be expected, numerous
small craft make their way to Singapore from the
neighbouring Rhio Islands. Some of these are barter
traders who conduct their business at Telok Ayer Basin,
while others conceivably bring in illegal immigrants
who land at odd spots along the Singa-port coast line.
The Immigration Department itself does not have a
preventive branch to check these illegal entries, but
relies on the Ministry of the Interior and Defence for
surveillance of our coastal waters. The Immigration
Department is liaising with the Ministry of the
Interior and Defence on how to improve marine and beach
patrols. Immigration and security responsibilities will
be integrated when the Immigration Department is
transferred to the Ministry of the Interior and Defence
from the 1st of January next year. More effective
measures to control illegal entries can then be worked
out.
Column: 424
I suggest that the Vigilante Corps in those areas
close to the sea can perform a public duty by
patrolling the beaches as they did previously, and help
to detain illegal entries. From time to time, the
presence of illegal immigrants has been reported by
public-spirited citizens to the Immigration Department.
Raids are conducted and illegal immigrants are deported
after serving a term of imprisonment according to the
law.
Column: 424
STUDENT DEMONSTRATION OUTSIDE CITY HALL
3. Mr P. Govindaswamy asked the Minister of Defence,
in the demonstration by Ngee Ann College students in
front of the City Hall on 4th November, 1966, how many
Police officers and how many students were injured, and
how many students were treated for their injuries at
the General Hospital.
The Minister of State of Defence (Mr Wee Toon Boon) (for the Minister of Defence): Mr Speaker, in all, 13
Police officers were injured. One of these, a police
constable, was warded at the General Hospital for four
days with a 2-inch laceration on his right forehead.
Subsequently, 12 days' medical leave were prescribed
for him.
Six students were injured and were treated as
outpatients at the General Hospital. The most serious
injury among them appeared to be a fractured heel bone
and this, on the admission of the student himself, was
caused when he jumped from the City Hall steps to the
ground in order to avoid the Police.
Column: 424
NUMBER OF REPORTED GANGFIGHTS
FROM 1ST JANUARY, 1966
4. Mr Ho See Beng asked the Minister of Defence how
many cases of gang-fights have been reported to the
Police since the beginning of 1966, and how many of
them took place in bars.
Mr Wee Toon Boon (for the Minister of Defence): Mr
Speaker, Sir, since the beginning of 1966, three gang-fights have been reported to the Police, of which none
took place in bars.
Column: 425
COMMUNITY CENTRE AT 7 M.S. HOLLAND ROAD
5. Mr Chow Chiok Hock asked the Minister of Defence
whether he is aware that the Prime Minister promised to
build a community centre at the 7 m.s. Holland Road
when he toured the Ulu Pandan Constituency on 13th
February, 1966, and when the centre will be built.
Mr Wee Toon Boon (for the Minister of Defence): Mr
Speaker, Sir, the Prime Minister is not in the habit of
making promises during his tours of constituencies.
What was discussed in Ulu Pandan on the 13th February,
1966, was a proposal to establish a rural type
community centre near Yoon Kin Road, off 7½ m.s.
Holland Road. This was found to be unsuitable because
of the scarcity of population. The Prime Minister
advised the Ulu Pandan Citizens Consultative Committee
to look for an alternative site. He said that if this
site is found suitable, the People's Association would
give consideration to the proposal to establish a
community centre there. The suitability of this site is
being investigated by the People's Association. My
preliminary impression is that this locality is also
too sparsely populated, there being only 200 families
within a radius of two miles of the site. The Citizens
Consultative Committee has claimed that there are 500
families. If this site is not suitable, the People's
Association will assist in finding another site in the
Constituency.
Column: 425
SECOND LANGUAGE IN SECONDARY SCHOOLS
6. Mr S. Rajoo asked the Minister for Education, in
the implementation of the policy of compulsory study of
a second language in all secondary schools as from the
beginning of 1966, whether (a) teaching facilities for
second languages are provided in all Government and
Government-aided secondary schools (including Mission
schools), and language teachers are available for all
the four languages in all the schools, irrespective of
the number of students wishing to take a particular
language; and (b) all Government-aided secondary
Column: 426
schools (including Mission schools) have been made
to implement the policy and commence Tamil language
classes, where formerly there were none.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, facilities for
teaching any of the four official languages as a second
language are provided in all Government and Government-aided schools, including Mission schools. Where second
language teachers cannot be fully deployed in one
school, they teach in a group of schools. Where the
number of pupils choosing a second language is very
small, classes are conducted centrally both in the
afternoon for morning school pupils and in the morning
for afternoon school pupils. It is stressed that,
irrespective of the number of students wishing to take
a particular second language, adequate provision has
been made. All schools have been instructed to
implement the policy of a compulsory second language in
Secondary I from 1966 and provision has been made for
Tamil. This year there are 9 morning and 8 afternoon
secondary Tamil class centres, with 17 full-time
teachers to teach about 2,500 Tamil pupils. There is
also one English secondary school with two part-time
Tamil language teachers, one for the morning and one
for the afternoon, and two other schools have Tamil
language teachers teaching the language during school
hours.
Mr Rajoo (Farrer Park): A supplementary question,
Sir. I understand that Tamil classes are centrally run
at various places, due to the small number of children
taking Tamil as a second language. But my point in
bringing up this question here is that each and every
school, whether it is a Government or a Government-aided school or a mission school, should be self-
sufficient with language teachers in all streams of
language, and not depend on any special centres to be
provided by Government. I feel that the special centres -
Mr Speaker: Could the Member frame the supplementary
question rather than make a criticism of what the
Minister has said?
Column: 427
Mr Rajoo: My supplementary question is this. In
spite of the centres run by the Government for various
languages, will the Minister give an assurance that all
schools - whether they are Government or Government-aided or Mission schools - will be made self-sufficient
with language teachers to teach the respective language
in the school itself, irrespective of the number of
children taking a second language?
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, wherever there
is a sufficient number of pupils taking a second
language, a full-time second language teacher will be
provided. But if the number of students taking a second
language in a particular school is small, for instance,
two pupils, surely the Member for Farrer Park does not
expect the Government to provide a full-time second
language teacher for just two pupils?
Mr Rajoo: Mr Speaker, Sir, for in, stance, in an
English school where there are Chinese, Malay and Tamil
children -
Mr Speaker: Mr Rajoo, I am afraid I must pull you
up again. Could you frame the supplementary question?
Mr Rajoo: Yes. The supplementary question is this.
In schools where second language classes are run,
during the language period certain children will attend
either the Chinese or Malay language classes, whereas
the Tamil children in these schools will be left
without any teacher, because although classrooms are
available, there is no teacher to teach Tamil. That is
what I understand. Will the Minister look into the
matter and investigate where such a state of affairs
exists, so that Tamil-language teachers will be
provided and the Tamil children do not waste their time
idling during this language period?
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Yes, Mr Speaker, I will certainly
investigate if specific instances can be pointed out to
me.
Mr Speaker: In view of the number of questions we
have today - it is already five to 3 p.m. - I hope Members
Column: 428
will restrict their supplementary questions so
that those who have questions low down in the list will
have their questions answered orally. Mr Rodrigues.
Column: 428
SUPERVISION OF KINDERGARTENS
7. Mr Bernard Rodrigues asked the Minister for
Education, in view of the opportunity that can be
afforded to anti-national elements to poison the minds
of young children, if he will tighten up the
supervision of kindergartens or consider bringing them
within the state educational system.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, most
kindergartens in Singapore are supervised in one way or
another by the Government or a quasi-Government
organisation. These are private kindergartens
registered with the Ministry of Education, those
organised and supervised by the People's Association,
and creches and play centres organised and supervised
by the Department of Social Welfare. Owing to
Government supervision of one kind or another, it would
be extremely difficult for anti-national elements to
poison the minds of young children unnoticed. To date
there has been no report of such incidents in these
kindergartens.
However, for quite some time now, the demand for
places in kindergartens for pre-school age children has
been very great. This results in the establishment of a
large number of unregistered kindergartens which fall
into three categories: (1) those run by private
individuals catering for the upper and middle classes,
mainly in the private residential estates; (2) those
run by religious organisations in Housing Board Estates
or near squatter areas in the City area; (3) those run
by political parties, particularly by the anti-national
Barisan Sosialis. These kindergartens do not come under
the supervision of the Government and are, therefore,
open to exploitation by the anti-national elements,
particularly so in the case of those run by the Barisan
Sosialis in the rural areas. Besides the opportunity
afforded them to poison the minds of
Column: 429
the young children in their kindergarten classes, the
teachers of these classes and their helpers, who are
mostly members of the Barisan Sosialis, very often
exploit the opportunity of meeting the parents of these
children and putting across their insidious anti-national propaganda. Furthermore, these kindergarten
classes also provide a source of income to sustain the
livelihood of the Barisan Sosialis members. However,
the Government does not favour the negative approach in
dealing with this problem by closing down all the
kindergartens run by the anti-national elements. To do
so would fall into the trap of the Barisan Sosialis who
are bound to exploit the issue by accusing the
Government of being unsympathetic towards the welfare
of the children of the poor living particularly in the
rural areas.
There is a real demand for pre-school education by
Singapore parents in recent years as a result of
improvement in the standard of living and the awareness
of the value of an early education for children. This
is, therefore, a social problem which should be better
dealt with in a more positive manner. Since 1964, the
Government has, through the People's Association,
established kindergarten classes in the community
centres to meet the needs of the rural parents and to
counter the influence of kindergarten classes run by
the anti-national elements. By May this year, the
People's Association have established 159 kindergarten
classes with a total enrolment of 5,900 pupils. The
number of classes has since increased to 349 and the
total enrolment to 12,500, whereas both the number of
classes run by the anti-national elements and the total
enrolment have drastically dwindled. Furthermore, a
great majority of the kindergarten age children for
classes next year have been registered by the People's
Association.
While it is desirable that all kindergartens should
be supervised by the Government and be brought under
the Republic educational system, the cost of
implementing this by way of capital and recurrent
expenditure is, however, prohibitive. The
Column: 430
Government, therefore, does not envisage bringing the
kindergartens within the State educational system in
the foreseeable future.
Column: 430
INTEGRATED PRIMARY SCHOOL IN PUNGGOL
8. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for Education
whether and when an Integrated Primary School will be
built in the Punggol Constituency in the vicinity of
the 9th or 10th milestone Punggol Road.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, as the existing
schools can adequately cope with the present demand for
places in primary schools, the Government does not
propose to build any new primary school in Punggol Road
in the near future. A survey of the demand for primary
places in this area shows that the construction of a
new primary school is not required.
Column: 430
SECONDARY SCHOOL IN LIM CHU KANG
9. Mr Tang See Chim asked the Minister for Education
whether he is considering building a secondary school
in the Lim Chu Kang area to cater for the school
children living in that area.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, investigation is
being carried out by the Ministry of Education and the
Planning Department for the provision of a secondary
school building near the junction of Lim Chu Kang and
Choa Chu Kang Roads.
Column: 430
PURCHASE OF LOCALLY-PRODUCED MEDICINES AND DRUGS
(Government policy)
10. Mr Bernard Rodrigues asked the Minister for
Health what is the policy in regard to the purchase by
his Ministry of locally-produced medicines and drugs,
which are comparable in quality to the corresponding
imported articles, when the price of the locally-produced article is higher than that of the imported
article.
Column: 431
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health (Mr Sia Kah Hui) (for the Minister for Health):
Mr Speaker, Sir, I am pleased to inform the Member for
Telok Blangah that it is Government's policy to give
positive encouragement regarding the use of local
products, and in line with the policy a directive was
given on the 14th of December, 1965, to all Government
departments and statutory bodies by the Economic
Development Division of the Ministry of Finance on the
subject of preferential purchase of locally
manufactured products. To implement such a policy of
giving preference to locally-manufactured goods, a
preferential price margin of up to 5 per cent of the
tendered price of an equivalent imported product is
generally allowed. In certain instances, such as the
bulk purchase of medicines and drugs, the preference
price margin might even be higher.
Mr Bernard Rodrigues: A supplementary question, Mr Speaker,
Sir, if I may have your permission to break it into
three parts?
Mr Speaker: Is it one question or three questions?
Mr Bernard Rodrigues: A supplementary in three parts.
Mr Speaker: Can we have the first part first?
Mr Bernard Rodrigues: All right. First, Mr Speaker, is the
Minister aware that his Ministry is purchasing P.A.S.
tablets from a local factory at $4.38 cents per
thousand tablets, whereas the cost of such tablets,
after deducting the sales cost, is $4.45 cents per
thousand tablets?
Mr Speaker: What tablets are you referring to, Mr
Rodrigues?
Mr Bernard Rodrigues: P.A.S. tablets, Sir.
Mr Sia Kah Hui: As far as I can remember, the
contract was given to a local firm to supply this
particular drug at a cost that is much higher than the
imported product of the same kind. If the company is
going to have very heavy manufacturing costs, I do not
think Government is expected to bear the burden. As I
have said earlier,
Column: 432
there is already a margin of up to 5 per cent, and, in
fact, in medicines and drugs, the preference price
margin is even higher, especially in this particular
case.
Mr Bernard Rodrigues: Mr Speaker, second part - is the
Minister aware that S.A.T.A. is purchasing the same
tablets at $5.50 per thousand tablets from the same
factory compared to the Government's $4.38 cents per
thousand tablets?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: I am afraid I have no answer to
that, because S.A.T.A. is not a Government institution.
Mr Bernard Rodrigues: Mr Speaker, Sir, is the Minister
aware that his Ministry is even trying to reduce the
price of $4.38 at the moment?
The Minister for Finance (Mr Lim Kim San): Good for
him!
Mr Speaker: I think the Minister for Finance has
answered that question.
Mr Bernard Rodrigues: I did not get that one, Mr Speaker,
Sir.
Mr Speaker: He said, "Good for him!"
Mr Bernard Rodrigues: Then may I ask the third part of the
question, Mr Speaker? What is the Government's policy
in patronising local industry?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: As I have said earlier, there is
already this price margin of 5 per cent, and in
medicines and drugs the margin is even higher. I do not
think there should be no limit to the price that the
local company can ask. There must be a limit.
Column: 432
MOSQUITO CONTROL AND ERADICATION IN ANSON
11. Mr P. Govindaswamy asked the Minister for Health
what progress has been made in the control and
eradication of mosquitoes in the Anson Constituency.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health (Mr Chor Yeok Eng) (for the Minister for Health)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I regret to
inform the Member for Anson that so far no steps have
been taken to
Column: 433
eradicate mosquitoes in Anson Constituency. This is
because it is not possible to deal with the mosquito
problem of Singapore on a piecemeal basis, as are shown
in the results of a field survey without house-to-house
checks done on the 24th of November, 1966, in Anson
Constituency itself. The results are no less than 107
breeding places, mainly due to mosquitoes breeding in
water-bearing receptacles found in scrap dumps of
second-hand dealers, water storage tanks in
unauthorised dwellings, stagnant water in drains caused
by refuse thrown into them by hawkers and residents
over a very long time.
A lot of second-hand goods dealers in this area are
responsible for the dumping of discarded receptacles
which in turn become breeding places for mosquitoes.
This is a long-time process and it is difficult to
eradicate the mosquito menace within a short time. The
view of my Ministry is that the mosquito eradication
scheme can only be effective when it goes hand in hand
with the proper reorganisation of the Public Cleansing
Service which, I believe Members will agree with me, is
to be launched shortly, as well as the licensing and
control of hawkers, which campaign has already begun.
As we all know, Mr Speaker, the control and the
registration of such hawkers constitute a very major
part of the Ministry of Health and this work is
progressing satisfactorily.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, a supplementary question on the answer given.
I would like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary whether
he can implement the scheme as early as possible,
because this is the time when the rainy season is
around the corner and flooding is coming very soon. I
myself have been subjected to the mosquito menace. The
breeding of mosquitoes is increasing, and I would like
the Minister to implement the scheme as early as
possible so that the people of Singapore will be free
from the mosquito menace.
Mr Chor Yeok Eng(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, the
supplementary question raised requires me to implement
Column: 434
the scheme as early as possible. That, of course, will
depend on our resources. We certainly wish to implement
our scheme as early as possible. As I have already
indicated earlier, for certain reasons and because of
restrictions, we must do some preparatory work in
advance before we can do anything else. The mosquito
menace is a big problem arising out of various causes
and we must have an overall scheme before we can start.
A lot of preparation has to be made, and the moment
this is done, we shall launch a campaign to implement
the scheme. Whether this can be implemented as early as
possible will, of course, depend on the question of
staff and other resources.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol): Mr Speaker, Sir, a
supplementary question. I remember at the last Budget
session the Minister concerned replied to my question
on this mosquito menace. He did mention that his
Ministry was going to set up an Anti-Mosquito Unit.
Sir, after a lapse of almost 12 months, I am wondering
whether this Unit has, in fact, been set up and whether
work has been carried out to eradicate the mosquito
menace.
Mr Chor Yeok Eng(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
the question of an Anti-Mosquito Unit was first raised
by the Ministry of Health and this Unit has been
established. But because of the shortage of staff, the
work of this Unit cannot be launched on a large scale.
As I have already said, the Public Health Division of
the Ministry of Health is now preparing various schemes
and is in liaison with the various sections. So when
all this preparatory work is done, a proper scheme will
be launched.
Another question about the Anti-Mosquito Unit is
that, at the present moment, this Unit has already
carried out work in various areas in Singapore on a
regional basis. It is not possible to do the work on an
extensive basis because of the reasons I have given. So
I would like to appeal to Members in this House, as
they are very concerned with the mosquito menace, that
the
Column: 435
best thing for them to do at the present moment is to
start a cleansing campaign in their own constituencies,
or an anti-mosquito campaign in their own
constituencies. That is more effective at the present
moment.
Madam Chan Choy Siong(In Mandarin): Another
supplementary question, Mr Speaker. From the answer
given by the Parliamentary Secretary, I would like to
ask him a further question on this point. If his scheme
cannot be implemented within a year, then do not tell
me that the people of Singapore have to be tolerant
about mosquito bites for some more time. I appeal to
him, as he has already indicated that this problem is
actually dependent on the question of staff. Because of
the shortage of staff, he says he cannot carry out his
work as scheduled. I would like to ask the Minister
whether he is prepared to consider employing temporary
staff to eradicate the mosquito menace, because if it
gets out of hand, then there will be epidemics all over
Singapore.
Mr Chor Yeok Eng(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, this
question of the mosquito menace is getting more and
more interesting. But it is a question which requires a
long time to solve. I can assure Members that at the
present moment it is not just the question of staff
that is bothering us. As one can read from the local
newspapers, the labour problem is coming to the
forefront because of the Federation of Unions having a
desire to negotiate with the Ministry of Health. The
question is not just one of staff but is also one of
industrial relations. Furthermore, there is the
technical aspect of the problem. Some people simply do
not care much about the situation. They just dump their
empty tins around. So the first step now is for the
Members concerned to start their own campaigns within
their own constituencies - the campaigns to clean up
their own constituencies and to get rid of the
mosquitoes. In serious cases, I think, if notice is
given, I believe the Ministry of Health will take steps
to have some kind of regional control of the problem.
Column: 436
Mr Govindaswamy (Anson)(In Tamil): Mr Speaker,
what we want to know is whether the Parliamentary
Secretary is going to take steps to destroy the
mosquitoes. But what kind of answers is he giving? We
want to know what steps he is taking, but he is talking
about labour problems and other things. All that we
want to know is whether he is taking steps, and how
long it will take him to control this problem.
Mr Chor Yeok Eng(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
before we can do anything, we must have the necessary
staff. Without the workers, how can we do our work?
This is fundamental. That is why my answer involves the
question of industrial relations and some labour
unions. Some unions within the Ministry of Health may
want to take strike action. To put everything in a
nutshell, in answer to the question of the Member for
Anson as to whether we want to eradicate the mosquito
menace, of course, the answer is, "Yes, we want to get
rid of mosquitoes."
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
stand to be corrected if I am wrong. I heard the
Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health say
that he has difficulty in recruiting labour force to
eradicate the mosquito menace. I think he should refer
this matter to the Ministry of Labour. I am sure he can
get thousands of workers to eradicate the mosquito
menace. Why does he not take this step?
Mr Chor Yeok Eng(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, if
it is a question of recruitment, then I believe that
every Member here is quite clear about it. Each
Ministry has to work within its vote for the purpose of
recruiting staff. If we have no such vote, then we
cannot do anything even if we can get help from the
Ministry of Labour.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng (Joo Chiat): Mr Speaker, Sir, in
view of the tremendous mosquito menace, may I know how
many cases of malaria have been reported last year?
Mr Chor Yeok Eng(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, on
this question, I have no statistics at the moment. If
the
Column: 437
Member for Joo Chiat is interested, he can give written
notice and I shall endeavour to give him a reply.
Mr Ho See Beng: Just now the Parliamentary Secretary
has said that there is a shortage of funds in his
Ministry. But I have been informed that there is an
excess of funds of over a million dollars. I do not
know whether that is true.
Mr Chor Yeok Eng(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
am not familiar with the figures and I will have to
investigate before I can answer the question. If the
Member concerned is still interested, he can give me a
written question and I shall try to answer it at the
next sitting.
Mr Speaker: If there are any Members who want to
follow their questions with supplementaries, they had
better signify to the Clerk that they desire to
postpone their questions to a later sitting, otherwise
they will receive written answers and no more.
Column: 437
HOSPITAL INSTITUTIONAL QUARTERS
12. Mr S. V. Lingam asked the Minister for Health
(a) to give the names of hospitals where there are
institutional quarters provided for qualified
specialists; and (b) whether he will consider providing
such facilities to similar staff of other hospitals
where there are no institutional quarters as they may
be urgently required in emergencies when on call.
Mr Sia Kah Hui (for the Minister for Health): Mr
Speaker, Sir, the hospitals where institutional
quarters are available are as follows:
Outram Road General Hospital 18
Tan Tock Seng Hospital 5
Thomson Road General Hospital 1
Kandang Kerbau Hospital 1
Woodbridge Hospital 6
Trafalgar Home 2
Middleton Hospital 1
It should be noted that institutional quarters are
for medical officers and not necessarily for qualified
specialists
Column: 438
as mentioned by the Member for Aljunied. There is, I
understand, no policy at the present regarding the
provision of institutional quarters in hospitals, but
it is understood that the Economic Planning Unit is
studying this question. However, in the allocation of
the present available institutional quarters, a points
system is in use and some weight is given to those
medical officers who are particularly required to stay
inside the hospital compound.
Column: 438
RESUSCITATION SERVICE
MOBILE UNIT AT KANDANG KERBAU HOSPITAL
13. Mr S. V. Lingam asked the Minister for Health
whether he will consider the addition of a "Mobile
Unit", for providing Resuscitation Service, to the
present ambulance fleet of the Kandang Kerbau Hospital
to give a good and safe Maternity Service and when.
Mr Sia Kah Hui (for the Minister for Health): Mr
Speaker, Sir, a Mobile Unit to provide a resuscitation
service for the Kandang Kerbau Maternity Hospital was
seriously considered towards the end of 1959 but was
found not necessary for the following reasons:
One, Singapore being a small island and Kandang
Kerbau Hospital not more than 15 miles away from any
given point, and what with the excellent road
facilities throughout the island, access to the
hospital is rapid and easy.
Two, the proportion of women delivering in the
hospital is almost 75 per cent of the total deliveries
in Singapore. This being the case, it is estimated that
at the most about four cases per year of those who
deliver outside the Kandang Kerbau Hospital may need
the type of service envisaged for the Mobile Unit if
set up.
Three, the resources of Kandang Kerbau Hospital
itself are limited. It will be preferable to entrain
staff for normal hospital work which itself is already
severely strained rather than set aside valuable staff
just to stand by for occasional calls. To man a 24-hour
service, the Mobile Unit will require three
Column: 439
teams working in shifts - not to mention those who will
have to cover for leave when the staff take their
annual leave or emergency leave. The minimum staff
required to establish one Mobile Unit would be two
medical officers, five nurses, four ambulance drivers
and four attendants.
Column: 439
LICENSING OF HAWKERS IN
KAMPONG ARANG ROAD
14. Mr Ng Yeow Chong asked the Minister for Health
if he will take steps to license the hawkers
concentrated at the Housing and Development Board
Housing Estate car park near Kampong Arang Road, the
majority of whom are residents of the area, and to
arrange for them to be re-sited elsewhere in the
Housing Estate.
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (for the Minister for Health)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I am very happy indeed to
inform the Member for Mountbatten that the problem of
resiting the unlicensed hawkers now operating in the
car park near Kampong Arang Road has been fully
considered by the Housing and Development Board and
that a two-storey hawker centre will be built as soon
as possible to accommodate them at Lots 202-4, Mukim
25, off Mountbatten Road, as the operating site for the
hawkers. By then, all the hawkers will be sited in this
area.
Column: 439
FIRST AND SECOND CLASS BAR LICENCES
(Figures)
15. Mr Ho See Beng asked the Minister for Finance
how many first-class and second-class bar licences were
issued during the period 1st January to 20th November,
1966, and how many first-class and second-class bars
were there in Singapore on 20th November, 1966.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr S. Ramaswamy) (for the Minister for Finance): From the 1st of January to 20th of
Column: 440
November, 1966, 30 first-class public house licences
and two second-class public house licences were issued.
There are 294 first-class public house and 59 second-class public house licences now.
Mr Ho See Beng: A supplementary question, Sir. In
view of the high figure of first-class bar licences
issued by the Government, will the Minister consider
imposing a moratorium on the issue of bar licences, as
I have been informed that young bar waitresses, who are
engaged to sit with the customers, also take on other
assignments? In view of my information, this practice
will bring about a very adverse moral effect on our
young population. So I would like to ask the Minister
to consider my request to impose a moratorium on the
issue of bar licences.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I have not had the
pleasure of pub-crawling. So I am not able to confirm
whether what the hon. Member says is true. But our
policy here is to allow freedom to people to trade. If
there is any danger of moral turpitude, I think we will
tackle it in some other way, rather than by restriction
of bar licences.
Column: 440
INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS
(Safeguards)
16. Mr Teong Eng Siong asked the Minister for Labour
whether he is aware that in the past 9 months there
were about 6,000 accidents in industries of which 10
cases were fatal, 63 cases resulted in workers being
maimed for life and 627 cases resulted in workers being
temporarily incapacitated; and if he will say what
steps have been, or are being, taken to minimise
industrial accidents in order to safeguard the lives of
workers and the livelihood of their families.
Mr Jek Yeun Thong: Mr Speaker, Sir, in the first
nine months of this year the Labour Ministry received a
total of 6,383 reports of accidents. Of these, 83 were
fatal, 435 resulted in permanent disablement, and 5,865
resulted in temporary disablement. Fifty-seven of the
fatal accidents were accounted for by heart failure (9
cases), drowning (9 cases), explosions (13 cases),
falls of
Column: 441
persons (14 cases), and collisions (12 cases). Of the
435 permanent disablement cases, the degree of
disablement in more than half of them - 297 cases - was
from 1¼ per cent to 5 per cent. In another 107 cases,
it was from 6 per cent to 20 per cent. In the remaining
31 cases, disablement was about 21 per cent.
Investigations into the causes of accidents in
factories have revealed that most of them were due to
faulty operation of machinery, ignorance or lack of
training of the workmen, lack of coordination between
workers, carelessness or negligence of the workers
concerned, absence of safety devices or safety
appliances, and poor maintenance of industrial
equipment. Minimum standards of safety and health in
factories are laid down in the Factories Ordinance
which is enforced by my Ministry. During the last ten
months, factory inspectors made 6,246 inspections of
factories. It has been found that enforcement of the
law alone is not sufficient for the prevention of
accidents. It is necessary to educate the workers, to
arouse their safety consciousness, and also to improve
supervision of work by management. In order to do this,
a number of measures have been taken. Safety posters
have been printed and distributed to factories for
prominent display, and safety pamphlets are in the
course of preparation. The managements of bigger
factories have been persuaded to set up safety
committees in their factories to promote the safety
consciousness of their workers.
An industrial Safety Branch has been established
under the National Safety First Council with the aim of
preventing accidents in industrial establishments. More
regular visits to factories by inspectors of factories
are being planned so that advice can be given to
factory occupiers and a higher standard of safety can
be achieved. Arrangements have been made with the
Electricity Department of the Public Utilities Board
since September this year for the electrical
installations in factories to be inspected by
electrical inspectors.
Column: 442
In order to take preventive measures in respect of
occupational health in industry, it is intended to set
up an Industrial Health Unit. For this purpose,
assistance has been sought under the U.N. Expanded
Programme of Technical Assistance for an industrial
health expert. An expert is due to arrive here early
next year. The Industrial Health Unit, when set up,
will contribute greatly to the prevention of industrial
hazards to which workmen are exposed.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
a supplementary question. The Minister has mentioned
just now that a unit will be formed to look into and to
prevent accidents in industries. I would like to ask
whether his Ministry has regularly sent out officers to
inspect the various factories and installations in the
factories. He has also said just now that some of the
accidents were due to faulty machinery. I would
therefore like to ask whether there will be adequate
compensation to those workers who met with such
accidents. These accidents are disastrous because they
bring about more widows and orphans. So I would ask the
Minister to take appropriate steps to prevent them.
Mr Jek Yeun Thong: The Member for Sembawang did not
hear me just now. He has asked whether we have sent out
any inspectors to inspect these factories regularly. I
have said that during the last 10 months we have sent
inspectors to these factories for inspection and 6,246
inspections have been made during this period.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
the Minister has said that he has sent out inspectors
to inspect the various factories.
Mr Jek Yeun Thong: May I speak in Mandarin, Sir?
Mr Speaker: Certainly.
Mr Jek Yeun Thong(In Mandarin): These inspections
were made not after the accidents but before the
accidents. We sent them out before the accidents
happened. They were routine inspections.
Column: 443
3.30 p.m.
Mr Speaker: Under the Standing Orders, that
concludes Questions for the day. Questions not
withdrawn will be dealt with by way of written
answers*.
(*See Mr Barker's motion on col. 509.)
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I understand that under Standing Order 20, paragraph
(2) , Members are entitled to request that questions
that are not answered be postponed for oral answer at a
later sitting. May I request that my two questions set
down on the Order Paper be so postponed?
Mr Speaker: Mr Tang, I am afraid you are too late.
Fifteen minutes ago I said that anyone who wanted his
questions put forward to another day should signify to
the Clerk before 3.30 p.m. As that was not done, I will
now proceed to the introduction of Government Bills.
Column: 443
BILLS INTRODUCED
SUPPLY BILL
"to provide for the issue from the Consolidated Fund
of the sums necessary to meet the estimated expenditure
for the public services of Singapore for the year
1967",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by the Minister for Finance (Mr Lim Kim San); read the First
time, to be read a Second time on Wednesday, 21st
December, 1966, and to be printed.
Column: 443
SUPPLEMENTARY SUPPLY (NO. 3) BILL
"for making Supplementary Provision for the Public
Service for the year 1966",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by Mr Lim Kim San; read the First time, to be read a Second
time on Wednesday, 21st December, 1966, and to be
printed.
Column: 443
FINAL SUPPLY (1963) BILL
"for making Final Provision for the Public Service for
the year 1963",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by Mr Lim Kim San; read the First time, to be read a Second
time on Wednesday, 21st December, 1966, and to be
printed.
Column: 444
FEES (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Fees Ordinance (Chapter 165 of the Revised Edition)",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by Mr Lim Kim San; read the First time, to be read a
Second time on the next available sitting, and to be
printed.
Column: 444
HOLIDAYS BILL
"to provide for public holidays and for matters
incidental thereto",
presented by the Minister for Culture and Social Affairs (Inche Othman Bin Wok); read the First time, to
be read a Second time on Wednesday, 21st December,
1966, and to be printed.
Column: 444
SOCIETIES BILL
"to amend and consolidate the law relating to
societies",
presented by Inche Othman Bin Wok; read the First time, to
be read a Second time on Wednesday, 21st December,
1966, and to be printed.
Column: 444
TOURIST PROMOTION BOARD (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Tourist Promotion Board Ordinance, 1963
(No. 35 of 1963)",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by the Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker); read the First time, to be read a Second time
on Wednesday, 21st December, 1966, and to be printed.
Column: 444
LEGAL PROFESSION BILL
"to establish the Board of Legal Education, to
constitute the Singapore Advocates and Solicitors
Society and to amend and consolidate the law relating
to the legal profession',
presented by Mr Barker; read the First time, to be
read a Second time on Wednesday, 21st December, 1966,
and to be printed.
Column: 444
COMPANIES BILL
"to consolidate and amend the law relating to
Companies",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by Mr Barker; read the First
Column: 445
time, to be read a Second time on Wednesday, 21st
December, 1966, and to be printed.
Column: 445
GIFT FROM HOUSE OF COMMONS
3.41 p.m.
The Deputy Prime Minister (Dr Toh Chin Chye): Mr
Speaker, I beg to move,
That this House expresses its warm appreciation of the
generous gift of a bookcase and books which it received
on the 16th of November, 1966, from a delegation of the
Commons House of Parliament of the United Kingdom of
Great Britain and Northern Ireland as a token of
friendship and goodwill on the part of the House of
Commons and people of the United Kingdom towards the
Parliament and people of Singapore to commemorate the
attainment by Singapore of independence within the
Commonwealth.
Mr Speaker, Members of the House will recollect that
last month a delegation representing both sides of the
House of Commons paid us a visit and at the same time
presented us with a bookcase with some books on
Parliament and Constitutional Law to the C.P.A. in
commemoration of Singapore's attaining independence. We
had the opportunity to discuss many matters with them
on that occasion, and I have no doubt that as a result
of our discussions, they left Singapore with the
conviction that this Government is determined to carry
on the practice of parliamentary democracy,
notwithstanding the fact that today we see Members of
the People's Action Party alone occupying seats on both
sides of this Chamber. This is not our fault; neither
is it our intention to destroy the Opposition, but I
must certainly say that the Opposition in its madness
has destroyed itself. There is no clause in the
Constitution of Singapore which forbids or prohibits
the formation of other political Parties. Neither is
there any law which prevents representatives of
political Parties, or Independents for that matter,
from contesting the General Elections or, as the case
may be in the recent bye-elections.
If today the House sees only a one-Party
representation, it has been at the behest of the
people. It is ultimately the electorate, the people of
Singapore, who
Column: 446
decide whether they wish to maintain political
stability, whether they wish that there should be an
efficient, honest and stable government, to run the
affairs of State and, therefore, determine the future
of our two million population.
With these words, Mr Speaker, I will only reiterate
that the hopes and wishes of all those who wish
parliamentary democracy to be upheld will not be in
vain, and it is our intention to continue a custom
which we have had for the last decade. You yourself,
Mr Speaker, have expressed on behalf of the House your
appreciation of the gift and the goodwill visit which
was paid by Members of the House of Commons, and I do
not wish to add further to what you already have said.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this House expresses its warm appreciation of the
generous gift of a bookcase and books which it received
on the 16th of November, 1966, from a delegation of the
Commons House of Parliament of the United Kingdom of
Great Britain and Northern Ireland as a token of
friendship and goodwill on the part of the House of
Commons and people of the United Kingdom towards the
Parliament and people of Singapore to commemorate the
attainment by Singapore of independence within the
Commonwealth.
Column: 446
3.45 p.m.
REGISTRATION OF IMPORTS AND EXPORTS
(AMENDMENT) RULES, 1966
The Minister for Finance (Mr Lim Kim San): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I rise to move,
That this House, pursuant to subsection (3) of section
5 of the Registration of Imports and Exports Ordinance
(Cap. 261), resolves that the Registration of Imports
and Exports (Amendment) Rules, 1966, published as
Notification No. S 233 in the Gazette Supplement No. 85
of 28th October, 1966, as contained in Paper S.L. 61 of
1966, be approved.
Under the existing Registration of Imports and
Exports Rules, 1935, the Singapore Armed Forces,
including the Police Force, are requested to declare
their imports and exports. It is imperative that
information concerning weapons and ammunition imported
by
Column: 447
the Singapore Armed Forces should be kept secret. The
amendment to Rule 14 will exempt the Singapore Armed
Forces, including the Police Force, from declaring
their imports and exports.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this House, pursuant to subsection (3) of section
5 of the Registration of Imports and Exports Ordinance
(Cap. 261), resolves that the Registration of Imports
and Exports (Amendment) Rules, 1966, published as
Notification No. S 233 in the Gazette Supplement No. 85
of 28th October, 1966, as contained in Paper S.L. 61 of
1966, be approved.
Column: 447
ANNUAL BUDGET STATEMENT
3.48 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Lim Kim San): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the House approves the financial policy of the
Government for the year 1967.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I am privileged to present the
Second Budget of the Independent Republic of Singapore
today.
The first full year of our independence, 1966, has
been a period of intense effort and activity.
Separation of Singapore from Malaysia did not mean the
loss of the common market but the loss of expectation
of a common market. Our manufacturers have now overcome
this psychological barrier. Industrial output and
employment increased substantially. We have
consolidated and strengthened our financial position.
The uncertainty following separation has been
dispelled. Our official external reserves are up.
ECONOMIC REVIEW AND TRENDS
Growth of Gross Domestic Product
The economy continues to move forward. Gross domestic
product in 1965 increased by $206 million to $3,017
million, representing a rate of growth of 7.3 per cent
over 1964. This compares very favourably with 1964 when
the rate of growth was only 2 per cent. Even more
gratifying is the fact that in spite of sudden
political developments
Column: 448
in the last six years, Singapore has been able to
achieve a consistently high rate of growth. The average
annual rate of increase in gross domestic product
during the period 1960 to 1965 is 8.5 per cent.
Of great importance to the economy is the rate of
gross capital formation. In 1965 gross capital
formation increased by $49.1 million to $463.8 million,
reflecting an increase of 11.8 per cent over 1964. It,
therefore, accounts for about 15 per cent of the gross
domestic product. Though creditable, this performance
falls short of the 17.5 per cent to 20 per cent rate of
capital accumulation, which is considered necessary for
self-sustaining growth in developing countries.
External Reserves
Official external reserves of the Government and
statutory authorities have increased by $123.3
million this year, compared with the position in 1965.
Official reserves now total $1,038 million,
compared with $914.7 million in September last year.
It is made up as follows:-
1966 1965
Government reserves 554.31 484.7
Statutory authorities 183.69 153.6
783.00 638.3
Add estimate of 300.00 276.4
currency reserves
-------- -----
Total 1,038.00 914.7
======== =====
Our official reserves would probably be more, depending
on the amount of currency redeemed in Singapore next
year. External debts stand at only $61.75 million,
which is a slight increase of $2.75 million over last
year.
Rising External Trade
The buoyancy of the economy is reflected by the
rising volume of external trade. In the first nine
months of this year, imports were valued at $3,017.9
million, which is an increase of 6.3 per cent over the
same period in 1965. Similarly, exports expanded to
$2,494.6 million, an increase of 13.3 per cent over
last year. Total external trade by
Column: 449
the third quarter of this year has therefore shown an
increase of 9.36 per cent. Projected over the full
year, total trade may well exceed $7,200 million.
Though this would be still below the peak years of 1962
and 1963, prospects for improvement are good, bearing
in mind the resumption of trade with Indonesia and
establishment of direct trading relations with the
Soviet Union and East European countries.
An examination of the composition of Singapore's
growing external trade shows even more significant and
encouraging trends. Domestic exports, excluding
petroleum products in 1965, increased by $48.9 million
to $345.8 million. This represents an increase of 16.4
per cent over 1964. It forms 11.5 per cent of total
exports compared to 10.7 per cent in 1964. A large
proportion of the increase in domestic exports comes
from local industries. For instance, exports of wheat
flour in 1965 showed an increase of 125 per cent over
1964. Similarly, exports of steel bars and plywood
recorded increases of 140 per cent and 197 per cent
respectively over the previous year.
Imports of goods purely for re-export is declining in
importance. In 1964 re-exports of goods imported formed
37.9 per cent of total exports. In 1965 it fell to 36.2
per cent.
It is natural that with industrialisation, Singapore
will either process goods it imports before re-exporting them, or use them as raw materials for the
manufacture of new products, which are then exported.
Retained imports will therefore increase with the
years. In 1965 retained imports increased by $190.5
million to $1,809 million. But what is significant is
the fact that an increasing amount of imports retained
is in the form of either raw materials or capital
equipment required by new industries.
The growing volume of external trade has resulted in
higher earnings for Singapore also. In 1965 earnings
from trade was estimated at $396.2 million, or $44.5
million over earnings in 1964, which stood at $351.7
million.
Column: 450
Building and Construction
The value of buildings commenced in the first six
months of this year stood at $56.5 million as against
$80.7 million for the same period last year. Private
development fell from $42 million in 1965 to $28
million in 1966 for the same period - a fall of $14
million.
Investment in property is less attractive than
investment in other fields. I will outline later on the
steps we are taking to make investments in properties
in urban and designated areas a more attractive
proposition.
Transportation
Industrial growth and expanding trade is shown by the
increasing volume of shipping and cargo handled through
our port. The number and tonnage of ships entering and
leaving the port of Singapore in 1965 surpassed all
previous records with an impressive figure of 21,862
vessels of 90 million net registered tons. Performance
this year is likely to be even higher as there has been
a rapid increase in shipping movements during the first
nine months of the year. Cargo passing through the port
last year totalled 21.3 million tons, or an increase of
18.2 per cent over 1964. Performance this year shows
that cargo handled will reach 24 million tons in 1966.
Increase in cargo handled is due to Singapore's growing
importance as a centre for petroleum refining.
Discharge of industrial raw materials such as bulk
wheat and cement clinker is also rising rapidly,
testimony to Singapore's changing industrial structure.
Finance
The well being of an economy can also be tested by an
examination of its financial bedrock, namely, deposits
in the banks and advances made by them during the year.
As at the end of September this year, deposits of
customers other than banks totalled $1,337.2 million.
This is $115.2 million more than the amount of deposits
at the end of December 1965 and $172.9 million more
than deposits held at the end of September last year.
Increases in bank deposits this year are therefore
better than increases in previous years, which
Column: 451
averaged $82.3 million annually between 1961 and 1965.
Loans and advances of banks show the level of economic
activity generated. At the end of September this year,
loans and advances to customers other than banks total
$995 million, or an increase of $81 million over the
amount lent at the end of December 1965.
Control of Finance Companies
Of late, the activities of certain finance companies
have given rise to some concern, and I feel that a
public warning would be timely. Very simply, finance
companies receive deposits from the public on payment
of interest and re-lend this money to finance, usually
on hire-purchase, the sale of goods like motor-cars,
motor-scooters, radios, refrigerators and so on. In a
sense they operate like a bank, but unlike banks the
activities of finance companies are not governed by
law. Recently, there has been a spate of finance
companies advertising for deposits from the public
offering to pay rather high rates of interest. It
follows that in turn these finance companies must re-lend at even higher rates of interest in order to make
a profit. To do so, some of them may be tempted to take
undue risks in their lending and thereby endanger the
security of the deposits made by the public. There is
nothing wrong if a reputable finance company accepts
deposits from the public and in turn re-lends if care
is taken to ensure that the purpose for which the money
is re-lent is sound and there is reasonable credit-worthiness to warrant such lending. It is only when the
finance companies become reckless and accept
unjustifiable risks without regard to proper and
adequate securities, that the monies deposited by the
public are exposed to danger.
The Government will shortly introduce legislation to
regulate and control the operations of finance
companies in order to safeguard the interests of the
public who deposit funds with them.
Industrial Expansion
The industrial census of 1965 shows that output by
manufacturing industries
Column: 452
increased by 16.6 per cent from $927.9 million to
$1,082.1 million. Employment in these industries rose
by 13.8 per cent from 41,488 to 47,217. Value added in
1965 was $319.6 million compared with $282.5 million,
or a rise of 13.1 per cent. Wages also rose accordingly
from $111 million in 1964 to $132 million in 1965. This
is an increase of 18.9 per cent. The increase in
output, value added, employment and wages is due both
to establishment of new industries, as well as rising
production of firms already established. Output of an
established group of 882 manufacturing firms increased
from $918.9 million to $1,034.6 million, or 12.6 per
cent in 1965 over 1964.
Industrialisation remains the backbone of our
economic development. During the two years in Malaysia
no Pioneer Certificates were issued in Singapore, but
since August last year we have issued 58 new
certificates; in addition, some 25 more projects were
approved in principle. Today, there are 165 pioneer
industrial firms compared with 113 in 1964. 107 of
these are already in production while 33 projects are
in various stages of implementation.
By September 1966, the total investment of these
pioneer firms in fixed assets had grown to more than
$300 million from $255 million at the end of 1965. The
total value of output of these firms is expected to
reach $450 million this year, as against $318 million
in 1965. In terms of employment, the total number of
workers in pioneer firms has grown from 5,000 at the
end of 1964 to 12,000 today. For the industrial sector
as a whole, the production of all industrial firms -
pioneer and non-pioneer - in the Republic has risen by
nearly 20 per cent during the past 12 months.
Perhaps the most encouraging aspect of the industrial
development programme is that our exports of domestic
products have been increasing steadily. As noted
earlier, in 1965, $345.8 million worth of domestic
products were exported. This is expected to reach some
$450 million this year. Another significant aspect of
our programme is that we
Column: 453
have succeeded in broadening our industrial base. There
is today a wide range of industrial enterprises
scattered all over the Republic which are capable of
expansion. This includes the expansion of oil
refineries into a petro-chemical complex, the expansion
of general ship-repairing and building facilities for
construction of specialised vessels, construction of a
fisheries harbour as part of an integrated plan for
developing a deep-sea fishing and canning industry, the
production of parts and components for motor vehicles,
electronics and other engineering assembly industries,
the development of an integrated feedmill and vegetable
oil complex around the grain silo enterprise, the
expansion of caustic soda and chlorine production to
p.v.c. and other chemicals, the establishment of a
modern paper mill for supporting various paper products
industries, the expansion of garments manufacturing to
integrated textile mills, and the development of
integrated timber projects to make use of waste from
saw-milling and plywood factories.
To provide the infrastructure for expansion,
continuing efforts are being directed to developing new
industrial land and factory buildings. Prepared new
land for industry at the Jurong Industrial Estate has
gone up to 2,843 acres in September this year, as
compared with some 2,443 acres at the end of 1965. The
country's first flatted factory at Tanglin Halt
Industrial Estate was fully occupied immediately upon
completion. More will be built. Prepared sites in the
Kallang Park Marine Industry Zone and the Kranji Timber
Industry Estate are also in great demand.
NEW FISCAL INCENTIVES
The performance of the economy in 1965 and the current
year shows that it is moving forward. By all criteria -
external trade, domestic exports, industrial production
and savings - Singapore has an expanding economy. The
challenge really is whether the Singapore economy can
grow fast enough to solve its fundamental problem,
namely, generation of employment opportunities.
Column: 454
During the period 1961-1965, employment opportunities
increased by 57,600 jobs, or an average of 11,520 jobs
a year. This fell short of the 70,000 additional jobs
needed. This shortfall of 12,400 jobs, added to the
number of people already unemployed at the beginning of
1961, raised the number of unemployed to 56,300 at the
end of 1965. This level of unemployment constitutes 10
per cent of the total economically active population.
The incidence of unemployment is therefore high. Unless
we can during the coming five years reduce this
spectre, then all the economic gains will be lost in
the turmoil of social and political unrest. Over the
next five years from 1966 to 1970, Singapore would need
not only to wipe off the backlog of the existing
unemployed, but also provide another 95,000 jobs for
our youths, who would be leaving schools and seeking
entry into the labour market.
[Mr Tang See Chim in the Chair]
4.10 p.m.
The solution to this employment problem lies in a
crash programme for the development of export-orientated industries. As in the case of all countries
which strive for industrial development, we have
initially only a limited number of industries directed
entirely towards exports. The majority of our existing
industries still depend to a great extent on the
domestic market. This is inevitable in the early stages
of our industrial development. We must now move to a
new phase of the industrial programme, namely, the
development of export-orientated industries. In order
to achieve early full employment and to ensure long-term economic stability and growth, we need specially
to encourage manufacturers with established overseas
markets and which can draw their raw material supply on
a world-wide basis.
After independence, we began to work in this
direction. I am glad to report that we have now
completed the necessary administrative arrangements for
such a crash programme. This programme calls for three
major areas of action.
Column: 455
Development Training
Firstly, the development of human resources remains
our most valuable asset. It is only in recent years
that we began to gear our educational system towards
providing skills needed for an industrial society. In
order to achieve rapid technological advancement and to
develop to the full the potential quality of our
workers, it will be necessary to organise a mass
programme of training within industries for specialised
skills.
The Economic Development Board has already started,
on a limited scale, the training of technicians and
skilled workers in tool and die-making, electro-plating
and heat treatment. The specialised training programmes
help to upgrade the skill of our workers in the
existing industries and, what is more important, to
impart new specialised skills and knowledge to school
leavers to prepare them for new and more sophisticated
industries. A Metal Industry Development Centre and
Prototype Production and Training Centre for machinery
building, electronics, precision instruments, printing
and plastic will be set up. These centres will be
operated in close co-operation with industry. In
addition, specialised production teams, including
workers, will be sent overseas for on-the-job training.
Each of such schemes will be directed towards the
creation of specific factories. By building up a large
reservoir of technicians and skilled workers, and by
gearing training to the industrial promotion programme,
we can quickly enter into a more sophisticated stage of
industrial development.
National Productivity Drive
The second area of action lies in re-doubling our
efforts towards high quality and lower production
costs. This is because the international market is
becoming increasingly competitive. Young industries
take time to mature and yet meet fierce competition
from the start.
With the co-operation of the National Trades Union
Congress, the Singapore Manufacturers' Association and
the Singapore Employers' Federation, we jointly drew up
in 1965 a Charter for
Column: 456
Industrial Progress. It is recognised by all parties
that high productivity brings better wages and working
conditions, lower prices for consumers at home, and a
wider market abroad and, finally, adequate investment
returns, continuing expansion of production capacities,
and full employment. To translate this basic policy
into concrete action, practical steps have been
initiated. The Singapore Productivity Centre, under a
Governing Council with representation of all parties
concerned, will come into operation in January 1967.
The Centre will be entrusted with the responsibility of
launching a national movement directed to further
labour-management co-operation, and to improve the
operational efficiency of every enterprise in the
Republic.
Export and Investment Incentives
I come now to the third area of action. Clearly, the
success of our development training programme and the
national productivity drive depends ultimately on the
continuing expansion of our exports and the rapid
growth of our industrial sector. To achieve both
objectives in the shortest possible time, we need many
more entrepreneurs, much more managerial capabilities
and technical knowledge, and especially much more
international marketing "know-how". We have therefore
to attract the types of export industries which buy raw
materials and sell their products on a world-wide basis
and which can make full use of the high quality of our
labour force, our geographic advantages, and efficient
infrastructures. International manufacturers of this
type have more or less free choice in selecting their
plant location. Singapore, therefore, has to compete
with other countries in all parts of the world for such
enterprises.
This means that our fiscal incentives must be as
attractive as, if not more than, those offered by other
countries. To all industries, pioneer or non-pioneer,
which are prepared to play an active role in our export-orientated programme and to make a positive
contribution to this new phase of our industrial
development, the Government will grant, with effect
from 1st January, 1967, the necessary incentives for
export and
Column: 457
investment, for expansion as well as for encouraging
rapid technological advancement. This means the
incentives will apply to export profits earned in 1967,
and will generally be taken into account for the year
of assessment 1968.
Specifically, for export and investment, the
Government will grant approved enterprises the
following incentives:
First: Tax on interest earned by non-residents from
deposits held in an external account in a bank in
Singapore will be reduced from 40 per cent to 10
per cent.
Second: Interest paid from Singapore sources and
received by persons or enterprises overseas is
generally liable to tax in Singapore. Such
payments made on approved loans advanced to
approved enterprises in Singapore for the purchase
of capital equipment from abroad will be exempted
from tax.
Third: Profit on export of manufactured goods for
both existing and new manufacturing industries and
deep-sea fisheries, but excluding processing, will
be taxed at the equivalent of one-tenth of the
normal company tax rates.
This concessionary rate (4 per cent) applies to all
limited liability companies where the profits
derived from export are at least 20 per cent of
their total profits, and export sales (f.o.b.)
amount to not less than $100,000 per year.
Qualifying firms with pioneer status will be granted
this concessionary rate for a period of not less
than 10 years from the date of expiry of their
pioneer status. The concessionary period for
qualifying non-pioneer firms will be not less than 15 years.
Modern industries cannot afford to stand still. They
must be encouraged to expand their productive capacity
in order to achieve high volume and low cost of
production, thus enabling them to compete successfully
in the international market. For existing industries
Column: 458
which expand, the Government will offer the following
incentives:
In the case of plant expansion through the increase
of funds by an approved enterprise, it will be
granted tax exemption, from the date on which the
newly added equipment thereof starts to operate or
to render services, in respect of the income
increased as a result of such expansion, on a basis
similar to that applicable to pioneer industries,
provided that at the time of closing of accounts for
the year the expansion has resulted in a 30 per cent
or more increase in its productive capacity over the
appropriate existing capacity applicable prior to
such plant expansion.
It is appreciated by the Government that the
development of many modern sophisticated industries
such as petro-chemicals, pharmaceuticals, electronics
and specialised branches of engineering industries
incur high initial investments in research and pilot
plants or in specially designed tools and equipment,
which become obsolete in a comparatively short period.
In order to seek continuing advancement of the
technological level of our industries and to speed up
the process of development, the Government will give
the following encouragement:
Tax on royalties, licences and technical assistance
fees, and approved contributions to develop and
research costs payable overseas by approved
enterprises may be reduced from 40 per cent to 20
per cent, provided that such concession would not
result in transfer of any tax liability to the
resident countries of the recipients. Further, the
Government may exempt such payments in special cases
if the national interest would be thereby served.
Foreign recipients who derive royalties, licences
and technical assistance fees from Singapore and
convert such payments into equity of the
manufacturing firms operating in Singapore may be
exempted from tax liability.
Column: 459
Existing Incentives
In addition to these new incentives, we have already
provided for powers whereby the Government may approve
on application special accelerated initial depreciation
up to 100 per cent in one year and a three-year write-off for plant, equipment or machinery utilised in the
manufacture or processing of goods and materials.
Besides, approved manufacturers are now also entitled
to double deduction on expenditure spent on advertising
or market development. Investors will, of course, also
continue to enjoy the benefits of pioneer tax
exemption.
Urban Redevelopment Incentives
Members of the House are no doubt aware of our
programme to renew and redevelop our city and urban
areas. Clearance and demolition of the 135-acre Outram
and 90-acre Crawford precincts are progressing
satisfactorily. Part of these areas will be marked out
for development by the private sector and private
investors may also redevelop other city areas on their
own. Such development must, however, be sufficiently
comprehensive to make full use of the land and to
provide for better traffic circulation, pedestrian
bays, parking and other facilities. In order to
stimulate private participation in redevelopment of the
city, the Government has decided that with effect from
next year, the rate of property tax for properties
erected in areas designated for urban redevelopment
will be 12 per cent as against the present rate of 36
per cent. In addition, during the period of
construction, there will be a waiver of property tax on
the land for an initial period of six months, plus an
additional month for every storey of the building to be
erected on the property. For example, a 10-storey
building will receive a waiver of 16 months of property
tax on the vacant property while construction is going
on. Singapore has over the last six years achieved a
unique position in the provision of low-cost housing
and it is hoped that the Government's plans for urban
renewal with private participation will achieve equal
success.
Column: 460
Development Outlook
For private industry to respond fully to the new
fiscal incentives, it will be necessary for the entire
Government machinery to have a forward and enlightened
outlook. The administration must be infused with
enthusiasm for development and be intelligently
flexible to facilitate it. Experience in many countries
shows that unnecessary rigidity, officiousness and
delays will nullify the effects of incentives and
frustrate promotional efforts. What we want are results
- not red tape. We are giving high priority to a review
and examination of existing Ordinances and
administrative rules for their relevance to the
development effort. We must ensure that those who
respond receive full co-operation and support at all
levels and sectors of the Government complex.
General Review of Revenue and Expenditure in 1966
I now come to a review of revenue and expenditure in
1966. It was estimated that the budget for 1966 will
yield a small balance of approximately half a million
dollars. The objective was a balanced budget without
having to run down reserves. I am pleased to report
that from performance up to now, the position is
expected to be slightly better than originally
estimated and it is likely that we shall close the year
with a balance of about $5.7 million.
Revenue receipts for the year are likely to come out
at $537.3 million. A sum of $401.3 million has been
collected by the end of September. The balance of $136
million is expected to be collected in the last quarter
of the year.
Expenditure up to the end of September came to $354.5
million, including a sum of $23.3 million paid to the
International Monetary Fund and a sum of $1 million to
the World Bank, being Singapore's membership
subscription to these two world bodies. Expenditure for
the last three months of the year is estimated at about
$177.1 million inclusive of a transfer to the
Development Fund of $30 million. Total expenditure for
the year should then come out at $531.6 million.
Column: 461
With a total revenue of $537.3 million and a total
expenditure of $531.6 million, the surplus will amount
to $5.7 million; in other words, about $5 million
better than anticipated.
Revenue 1966
Total revenue for 1966 is as estimated, with short-falls from some heads compensated by increases in
others. Revenue from customs duties on liquor will
probably be $0.8 million less than anticipated, due to
a fall in consumption of imported malt liquors. Revenue
from imported petroleum products will be $25.5 million
less than estimated, but this will be more than offset
by an increase in revenue from petroleum products,
locally refined, amounting to $33.2 million. Revenue
from sugar is expected to be $3.1 million less, because
of duty exemptions to manufacturers.
Income tax collections will probably exceed the
estimate by $12 million, due in part to natural growth
and in part to more efficient administration.
Television does not seem to have adversely affected
other forms of entertainment, as entertainment duty is
likely to bring in $2.1 million more than estimated.
Excise duty on liquors is expected to exceed the
estimate by $3.8 million, due to increased consumption
of locally brewed liquor. Receipts from tobacco duty
are likely to yield $2.7 million more, due to greater
use of dutiable raw tobacco in local cigarette
manufacture.
Motor Vehicle Ad Valorem Registration Fees and Road
Tax are expected to exceed the estimate by $1.6 million
and $0.6 million respectively. Receipts from property
tax in the city area are expected to come up to the
estimate, but receipts from the rural area are expected
to be $2.5 million more, reflecting the trend of
greater development there.
Other important increases are sales of Goods and
Services from current operations, which is likely to be
$0.9 million more, and an increase of $1.9 million from
interest on the Republic's investments.
Column: 462
A number of lesser import duties were re-appraised
during the course of the year. They were found to be of
no value or unnecessary in protecting local
manufacturers and have been abolished. These duties
related to certain categories of spa and aerated
waters, non-aerated beverages, non-alcoholic beverages,
and compounds of alcoholic preparations. Import and
excise duties on certain types of lubricating grease
have also been removed. This is in keeping with our
policy not to hinder trade, where possible.
Expenditure 1966
In the course of the year, supplementary estimates
totalling $7.8 million were approved as follows:
(1) $6.3 million for the Telecoms Department;
(2) $1.45 million for the Ministry of Labour; and
(3) $43,000 for the Trade Division.
Supplementary estimates of $610,000 are being sought
for the Head of Expenditure "Public Works Recurrent",
making total supplementary estimates of $8.4 million
for the year. Provision for this Head was found to be
inadequate, i.e. "Public Works Recurrent". This was on
account of the large number of Government buildings
which had to be renovated during the year. During the
period under Malaysia, practically no maintenance was
carried out on the buildings which were Federal
responsibilities. This resulted in a larger than normal
number of buildings requiring urgent maintenance and
repairs. The other Heads of Expenditure are expected to
keep within the provisions voted.
With the addition of supplementary estimates of $8.4
million, total estimated expenditure for the year would
now be $545 million. However, in view of savings in
certain departments, actual expenditure for the year is
expected to be in the region of $531.6 million, which
is $5 million less than the sum of $536.6 million
provided in the Estimates.
Review of Development Expenditure in 1966
As for development expenditure for 1966, the public
sector development
Column: 463
comprises projects undertaken directly by Government
ministries and departments as well as schemes which are
implemented by the various statutory authorities. The
tentative public sector allocation for 1966 was $430.5
million, made up of $149.6 million proposed expenditure
by Government ministries and departments, and $280.9
million to be spent by the statutory authorities.
Allocation for Government ministries was subsequently
increased by a supplementary estimate of $27.2 million,
to make a total of $176.8 million. Based on actual
performance up to date this year, it is likely that
public sector expenditure for the full year will reach
$284 million. Compared with actual expenditure of
$250.6 million in 1965, this represents an increase of
13.3 per cent.
Expenditure by Government ministries will amount to
$113 million as compared with $67.2 million spent in
1965, reflecting an increase of 68.2 per cent. However,
nearly $20 million of 1966 expenditure arose from
payments for the SEACOM project as well as purchase of
the assets of Cable & Wireless Ltd. Land reclamation
and urban re-development have also shown rapid
progress.
Expenditure by the statutory authorities is estimated
to amount to $171 million, which is about 6.6 per cent
less than the $183.1 million spent in 1965. The fall in
expenditure here is due mainly to a reduction in the
expenditure of the Economic Development Board, largely
because the major portion of the costly infrastructure
development has been completed. Expenditure by the
other authorities was about 10 per cent higher in 1966
compared to 1965.
Sectoral development is likely to be: economic
development $191 million; social development $79
million; public administration and defence $14 million.
Ordinary Estimates 1967
The financial outlook for 1967 continues to be fair.
Total revenue is estimated at $590.5 million and total
expenditure at $590.2 million, including a transfer of
$30 million to the Development Fund. This gives a small
surplus
Column: 464
of $0.3 million. The estimated expenditure of $590.2
million for 1967 is higher than the sum of $531.6
million expected to be spent this year by $58.6
million. Fortunately, this increase is matched by a
corresponding rise in estimated revenue.
The estimated revenue of $590.5 million is $53.2
million higher than the revenue of $537.3 million
expected to be collected for 1966. Thus, in spite of
the rather steep rise in expenditure, it is possible to
have a balanced budget for next year.
The highest increase in estimated expenditure is, as
always, in respect of the Ministry of Education. For
1967, expenditure for Education is estimated at $143.7
million, which is $14.5 million more than the sum of
$129.2 million provided for this year. The main reason
for the increase is because of the expenditure on
secondary schools. This is required to accommodate the
large number of students taken into the primary schools
during the past few years and who would now move into
secondary level.
The next highest rise is in respect of servicing the
Public Debt. This is a statutory expenditure and shows
an increase of $11.2 million. With more loans being
floated with the years to finance development, the rise
in this expenditure is expected to continue.
The normal expansion of our Police and Defence Forces
results in a rise of estimated expenditure of the
Ministry of the Interior and Defence by $4.9 million.
The establishment of missions abroad in keeping with
our new independent status is expected to result in a
rise of $1.4 million in the expenditure of the Ministry
of Foreign Affairs. In addition, a provision of $5
million has been included under the Ministry of Finance
head of expenditure for the purpose of acquiring
property abroad for our foreign missions, and $1.0
million under the Contributions and Charitable
Allowances head of expenditure for contributions to
international organisations. For reasons which I have
mentioned, the estimates for the Telecoms Department
Column: 465
for 1967 show an increase of $6 million, This increase
was covered by supplementary estimates in 1966.
The estimates for the Postal Department show a rise
of $2.2 million. Of this, $1.5 million is on account of
a change in book-keeping procedure to conform to
Financial Regulations in respect of the mail conveyance
vote. Hitherto, receipts were credited to revenue only
after deduction of expenditure. This has been changed
to paying in gross receipts and meeting the expenditure
involved from an expenditure vote. The net result is
the same as both revenue and expenditure will be
increased by the same amount. The balance of $0.7
million of estimated increase in the expenditure of
this Department is due mainly to the separation of the
Postal Department from the Malaysian Postal Department.
As a result of the separation, the Postal Department
will have to set up new sections to deal with certain
functions previously discharged by the headquarters at
Kuala Lumpur.
The head of expenditure "Public Works Recurrent"
shows an increase of $1.4 million. This is mainly due
to the increase in the number of roads which leads to
an increase in expenditure on their maintenance and on
public street lighting.
The increases I have mentioned make up a total of
$47.6 million. The balance of $6 million is made up of
small increases of the other heads of expenditure on
account of normal expansion, such as about half a
million dollar increase for the Hospital Division and
$400,000 for Parks and Recreation.
Revenue 1967
Revenue from most of the major taxes are expected to
increase next year in the normal manner, resulting in a
total collection of $590.5 million.
Income Tax is expected to yield $114.0 million.
Excise and Entertainment Duties are expected to yield
$73.6 million. The major increases under this group are
from Entertainment Duty, liquors and petroleum. Excise
duties from petroleum
Column: 466
products, locally refined, will yield aim additional
$34.0 million but, as against this, it is estimated
that there will be a fall from revenue on duties of
imported petroleum products of about $24.8 million.
This reflects the effect of our industrial policy and
shows that with three refineries operating in Singapore
we are now depending less and less on imported
petroleum products.
Normal increases are expected in tobacco duties,
property tax and other revenue items.
Driving licence fees are being increased from $5 to $10 per annum, and this item is expected to bring in an additional $1.8 million. During the course of the year a review has been made of miscellaneous licence fees and fees for services
which have remained unchanged for periods varying from
10 to 30 years, and this is expected to yield an
additional $2 million.
Cable & Wireless Ltd, was acquired by Government in
1966 and the revenue from the telecommunications
(External) Service, and this new item of revenue is
expected to yield $8.9 million.
Singapore's share of Currency Profits will amount to
$12 million.
New Basis for Road Tax
Licence fees on motor vehicles have hitherto been
collected on the horsepower rating of the vehicles.
This is an obsolete method of taxing motor vehicles for
use on roads. It is now proposed to change this to
follow international practice by prescribing fees
according to the cubic centimeter cylinder capacity of
the vehicle. The new Road Tax will be 10 cents per
cubic centimeter. The revised fee is expected to yield
an increase of $5.5 million. Care, however, has been
taken to minimise the incidence of the tax on the
public transport sector. This is done by reducing the
seating fee of $5 per passenger per month to $3.50 for
licensed taxis and $4.20 for buses. Therefore, there
should be no increase in bus or taxi fares.
Column: 467
Taking these and the normal increases in other
revenue items, it is anticipated that the 1967 revenue
figure will amount to $590.5 million.
1967 Public Sector Development Programme
The public sector development programme for 1967 will
amount to $411 million. The distribution between the
Government sector and the statutory authorities will be
$151.3 million and $259.7 million respectively. The
allocation by the various ministries and statutory
authorities is as follows:
1967
Provision
Government Sector $ million
(1) Deputy Prime Minister's 12.7
Office
(2) Ministry of Interior and 12.3
Defence
(3) Ministry of Education 26.5
(4) Ministry of Health 4.1
(5) Ministry of Finance 2.3
(6) Ministry of Culture and 4.4
Social Affairs
(7) Ministry of Law and 88.7
National Development
-----
Total 151.3
=====
Statutory Authorities
(1) Economic Development Board 45.0
(2) Housing and Development 75.0
Board
(3) Port of Singapore Authority 43.8
(4) Public Utilities Board 83.0
(5) Singapore Telephone Board 12.9
-----
Total 259.7
=====
Total Public Sector: $411.0 million
Deputy Prime Minister's Office
The allocation for the D.P.M's Ministry will be $12.7
million. A large claim on the provision will be for
Column: 468
telecommunications development. It accounts for $5.7
million of the total. The major project here is the
installation of the Automatic Telephone Switching
Exchange which will be in operation before the end of
1967. This will not only bring in more revenue for
Singapore, but will also maintain our position as the
premier international telephone switching centre in
this part of the world. The Telex services for both
domestic and international communications continue to
grow. With the completion of the SEACOM cable next year
and the growth of commercial and industrial activities
in Singapore, the volume of traffic on the telex
services is expected to rise substantially in 1967. For
this reason $600,000 has been provided in the Estimates
for the purchase of more subscribers' teleprinter 12.7
machines.
The other projects of the Telecommunications
Department are designed to expand radio services and to
develop trunks and junctions to keep pace with the ever-increasing demand for telecommunications services.
The Civil Aviation Department is expected to carry
out a number of projects to improve airport facilities.
$6 million has been provided for 1967. For the safety
of aircraft operation the runway will be re-surfaced
next year. The Instrument Landing System and Visual
Approach Slope Indicators will be installed to assist
pilots bringing aircraft in to land especially at night
and during bad weather. The parking aprons and hangar
facilities will be expanded to cope with the
growth of international airline traffic to Singapore. A
start will also be made to extend the runway by
1,000 feet to 10,000 feet.
Ministry of the Interior and Defence
When the Government's policy of requiring newly
recruited civil servants to undergo military training
is implemented as from next year, it will be necessary
to increase the number of training depots and training
camps. Some of the battalion camps of our regular units
are in bad shape and will need to be rebuilt. Vehicles
available to
Column: 469
the regular battalions as well as to the People's
Defence Force are at present grossly inadequate. It is
necessary to acquire more vehicles as well as to
provide for a centre for maintenance and repair of
vehicles. A capital expenditure of $12 million for 1967
has therefore been provided for the expansion of the
People's Defence Force and the Police.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
4.50p.m.
Ministry of Education
The Ministry of Education will have a budget of $26.5
million next year. This is 68 per cent higher than the
1966 expenditure of $15.8 million. Of the total
provision, $22.5 million will be for the School
Building Programme. 1967 will see the completion of
Government's programme of expansion of primary school
building and emphasis will shift to secondary schools.
Thereafter, primary schools will be built only in newly
developed housing estates such as Toa Payoh.
To meet the need for skilled workers and technicians
for industry, Government will build two new vocational
institutes - one in Jurong for the teaching of
engineering trades and the other at Queenstown for
manual and applied arts. The Singapore Vocational
Institute at Balestier Road will also be extended to
increase its intake of students. A sum of $580,000 has
been provided for the expansion of vocational education
in 1967.
Ministry of Health
The Ministry of Health will spend $4.1 million on its
development projects in 1967; this is a threefold
increase over the expenditure of $1.5 million in 1966.
The main project is the establishment of the institute
of Medical Specialities and the Radio Therapy Isotope
Centre - a joint project between the University of
Singapore and the Ministry of Health. Structural works
on the proposed 9-storey building will begin next year.
Column: 470
The disposal of city refuse is becoming an acute
problem. The Kolam Ayer dumping ground is no longer
available for refuse disposal as it is now part of the
Kallang Basin Reclamation Scheme. Of the 600 tons of
refuse collected in Singapore every day, over 500 tons
are from the City alone. There is an urgent need to
divert city refuse to the rural dumping ground at
Tampines. To do this, more garbage and ancillary
vehicles will be required. A provision of $800,000 is
being made for the purchase of these vehicles. In the
meanwhile, detailed planning is under way to construct
an incinerator at Redhill for the disposal of part of
the city refuse.
Ministry of Finance
The total allocation to the Ministry of Finance is
$100.6 million. Of this sum, $85 million represents
loans to the Public Utilities Board, the Economic
Development Board and the Housing and Development
Board. Of the balance, $10 million is to set up a
Contingency Fund for development purposes and $3
million will be a loan to the Government Officers' Co-operative Housing Society. The remaining $2.6 million
will be spent on the expansion of the Customs Service.
The projects envisaged in 1967 will contribute to the
improvement of facilities for the control and
prevention of smuggling.
Ministry of Culture and Social Affairs
The allocation to the Ministry of Culture and Social
Affairs for 1967 is $4.3 million, which is less than
its expenditure of $7.6 million in 1966. This is mainly
because the major portion of television and radio
facilities has been provided in 1966 or earlier. Only
minor expenditure will be incurred in the Broadcasting
Division in 1967 for the completion of projects.
For parks and recreation facilities, 10 children's
playgrounds and 2 public parks will be built in 1967,
while the Changi beach resort will continue to be
developed at a cost of $100,000.
A new branch library will be constructed at Queenstown
next year to meet the demand for more library
Column: 471
facilities. The National Library now has a total
readership of 106,300, which is more than it can cope
with. The Library in Queenstown will be the first of a
series of branch libraries to cater for our people.
A Junior Approved School will be built in 1967 to
house and rehabilitate delinquent boys under the age of
16. To cope with the rapid growth of Jurong New Town, a
fire station will be constructed there.
Ministry of Law and National Development
The total provision for the Ministry of Law and
National Development will be $88.8 million next year as
compared to the expenditure of $55.3 million in 1966 -
a 61 per cent increase. This Ministry has the highest
share of the 1967 Development Estimates and accounts
for more than 50 per cent of the total Government
development expenditure for 1967.
The special projects undertaken by the Housing and
Development Board acting as agents of the Government,
namely, the East Coast and Kallang Reclamation Schemes,
Urban Redevelopment and Resettlement will cost $38
million in 1967. These are continuing schemes initiated
even before 1966. They have a long gestation period.
The benefits and services which the schemes will bring
will only be fully realised in 5 to 10 years, or even
15 years, particularly in the case of urban
redevelopment. However, they are bold and imaginative
schemes worth pursuing.
On completion, the East Coast and Kallang Basin
Reclamation schemes will make available 2,000 acres of
valuable land, most of it in the city area. The land
will be available for the development of industrial and
housing estates, schools, highways, commercial
buildings, and holiday resorts with hotels and
recreational facilities for tourists. The economic
benefits in terms of income and employment generated
consequent on the completion of these schemes will be
substantial.
Column: 472
Visible progress of urban redevelopment is evident
when travelling along Chin Swee Road and Sumbawa Road.
Vast areas in Precincts S.1 and N.l, which together
comprise 225 acres, have been cleared. Earth works and
the construction of flats, shops and schools have
already begun. While the acquisition of land and
properties and the clearance and resettlement of people
are a slow process, once completed, construction work
can proceed rapidly. For this reason, expenditure on
urban re-development in 1967 will be $15 million, which
is more than twice the amount spent this year.
The Ministry of National Development has two other
large projects in hand for 1967. They are the National
Sports Stadium and the Erskine Hill office building.
These schemes were initiated this year and work on them
will continue up to 1968 or 1969 for their completion.
The National Sports Stadium will cost $18.5 million and
it is proposed to reimburse the cost from the proceeds
of the Singapore Sweep. As the Sweep was only launched
in October this year, it may not be possible to derive
sufficient funds from the Sweep to meet necessary
payments in 1967. For this reason, it is proposed to
vote $3 million in the Estimates for the project next
year and to recover it from the Sweep in subsequent
years.
The Public Works Department will have a development
budget of $34.8 million in 1967, which is about a third
higher than the department's actual expenditure of $26
million in 1966. For roads and bridges a sum of $9.0
million will be spent, for drainage and flood
alleviation $3.1 million, and for sewerage works $9.3
million.
Although substantial investments have gone into the
opening up of new roads, the widening and improvement
of existing roads into dual carriageways, and the
introduction of one-way traffic systems, the problem of
traffic congestion, especially in the city, still
remains. This is evident from the frequent traffic jams
along main roads leading into the city. The P.W.D. has
recently set up a Special Traffic Unit to study this
Column: 473
problem, and 1967 will see the beginning of changes in
road development. As part of the new scheme of things,
the construction of some flyovers will begin in certain
main junctions, notably the one at Woodsville Circus
where Serangoon, Upper Serangoon, MacPherson and the
New Toa Payoh Roads meet. Another flyover will be
constructed at the junction of Whitley, Thomson and the
New Toa Payoh Roads.
The major project under drainage and flood
alleviation is the Bukit Timah Alleviation Scheme. This
scheme, when completed in 1969, will remove the present
serious flooding in the Bukit Timah area after heavy
rain storms. In 1967, $1 million will be spent on the
Bukit Timah project, which is expected to cost in all
$6.8 million.
Sewerage is an essential social overhead in any
modern city. The expansion of sewerage facilities in
Singapore needs to keep pace not only with population
growth but also with urban redevelopment and the
development of new housing and industrial estates. In
1967, the major schemes to be launched or continued
will enable an extension to be made of sewerage
facilities to Kallang Basin, Jurong and the urban
redevelopment precincts. Expenditure on treatment works
will also be substantial in 1967 because of the need to
increase their capacity in step with the expansion of
sewerage facilities.
Economic Development Board
The Economic Development Board proposes to spend $45
million in 1967, which is nearly 20 per cent higher
than the estimated expenditure of $38.0 million this
year. Industrial financing will claim $25 million of
the total, while infrastructure investment for the
expansion of Jurong and other industrial estates will
account for the balance of $20 million.
Housing and Development Board
In 1967, the Housing and Development Board is
expected to complete 12,000 housing units and shops.
The major development will be at Toa Payoh and Kampong
Tiong Bahru where it is proposed to build 10,000 units.
Column: 474
In urban redevelopment areas, about 2,000 units of
flats and shops will be completed before the end of
next year.
Port of Singapore Authority
The Port of Singapore Authority plans to step up its
expenditure programme for 1967. It proposes to spend
$43.8 million next year, as compared to the estimated
expenditure of only $5.0 million this year, an
eightfold increase. The main scheme under port
development will be the construction of four deep-water
berths at the East Lagoon which began this year. On com
pletion of this scheme in 1968-69 the turn-round of
ships at the Authority's wharves will be speeded up.
The construction of godowns and ancillary works will
also be undertaken to cope with the growth in the
number of vessels and the volume of goods handled at
the Authority's wharves.
Public Utilities Board
The Public Utilities Board proposes to spend $83
million in 1967.
Under Electricity, the main project is the Jurong
Power Station Phase I, the first two units of which
will be commissioned during the Plan period.
Preliminary work on the project has already begun.
Construction work will be pursued expeditiously next
year.
The expansion in generating capacity is justified on
two grounds: firstly, the expectation of increase in
power consumption by industries, and, secondly, to meet
the growth in domestic consumption due to population
growth and the extension of supplies to rural areas.
With the expansion of generating capacity,
substantial investments are necessary to extend the
network of electrical transmission and distribution
lines. In fact, capital investment in the distribution
network will be $31.0 million next year, which
constitutes two-thirds of the total budget of the
Electricity Department.
Phase I of the Johore River Scheme will be completed
next year and this will increase the reliable yield of
water supply by another 30 million gallons a day,
bringing the total reliable yield
Column: 475
from the various sources to 87 million gallons a day
for Singapore. The average yield will go up to over 130
million gallons per day.
The Gas Department will have a budget of $3.5 million
which will be spent mainly on the extension of the
distribution network to bring gas to Toa Payoh, Bartley
and Upper Serangoon areas as well as to Telok Kurau and
Bedok areas.
Singapore Telephone Board
The Singapore Telephone Board will spend $12.9
million next year. Its major expenditure will be for
the purchase of exchange equipment to extend the
capacity of existing telephone exchanges, especially
those serving the Katong and Bukit Panjang areas where
population has increased. To complement these schemes,
the underground cables and plant will be installed to
link the exchanges with subscribers. It is expected
that 6,000 new lines will be in service next year,
while the total at the end of this year will be 70,000.
Sectoral Allocation of Public Sector Development Programme
The proposals of ministries and statutory authorities
for 1967 in economic classification are as follows:
million
$
Economic Development 234.2 57.0%
Social Development 148.1 36.1%
Public Administration 28.7 6.9%
and Defence
----- ------
Total 411.0 100.0%
===== ======
The lion's share of the allocation goes to economic
development which is consistent with the objective of
promoting rapid economic growth. The provision for
social development ranks second in the Budget and will
be sufficient to maintain and improve the already high
standard of social services in Singapore.
1967 Development Estimates
I will now turn to the financing of the Development
Expenditure for 1967. Out of the estimated expenditure
of $259.7 million by the statutory authorities, it is
expected that $174.7 million will be
Column: 476
from their own resources or external loans, the balance
of $85 million will come as a loan from the Government.
Development expenditure by the Government is
anticipated to be $151.3 million. This, together with
the loan of $85 million to the statutory authorities, a
loan of $3 million to the Government Co-operative
Housing Society, and a transfer of $10 million to
create a Contingency Fund, give a total of $249.3
million to be provided for on Government account.
Financial Resources for the Estimates
Although the 1967 Estimates total $249.3 million, the
anticipated expenditure is estimated at $211.4 million,
or about 85 per cent of the total provision. We will
now examine the position of the Development Fund, which
is the source of finance for the Estimates, to
determine how it will meet this anticipated
expenditure.
The balance of the Development Fund at 31st December,
1965, was $179.7 million, while the inflow to the Fund
this year (1966) is expected to be $171.3 million,
giving a total of $351 million.
The total expenditure from the Fund this year is now
estimated at $212.9 million, which means that the
balance in the Development Fund at 31st December, 1966,
will be $138.1 million.
The inflow into the Fund in 1967 is 57.0% expected to
be $180.0 million. As the anticipated expenditure from
the Fund for 1967 is $211.4 million, the balance in the
Fund at the end of 1967 will be around $106.7 million.
The Government proposes to obtain loans from the World
Bank and other financial institutions, as well as from
friendly countries, to finance its development
programmes. Hitherto, World Bank loans have gone to
traditional projects such as power generation, water
supplies and port development. The Government will
continue to encourage the statutory authorities to seek
loans for such "bankable" projects, as well as for new
schemes such as electricity and water transmission and
internal telephones. Such loans will enable the
statutory authorities to reduce their dependence on the
Government for financing.
Column: 477
In the Government sector loan applications will
shortly be submitted to the World Bank for education,
roads and sewerage development. As Singapore has an
excellent record of well-planned and executed
development programmes, there will be a strong case for
additional loan financing from the World Bank. The
World Bank has financed similar schemes in other
countries. On the whole, the balance in the Development
Fund will be quite satisfactory.
Mr Speaker, Sir, though we are making progress, it
is not fast enough to be self-sustaining nor is it of
the magnitude required to solve our unemployment
problem. We must never forget that Singapore has no
agricultural base. We do not have what the economists
call primary income. Our earnings are from services
rendered, processing and refining of raw materials and
manufacturing -the last growing in importance.
Therefore, if we want to live well and improve our
standard of living, it is imperative that we should be
more efficient than others. This calls for the closest
co-operation between Government, the entrepreneurs and
labour and each must give of its best to bring about
ever-increasing efficiency.
The Government has given all the incentives necessary
to attract investment and to provide both the necessary
infrastructure as well as a stable political climate to
make investment possible. It is now left to our
entrepreneurs to show that they have inherited the
verve, resilience, drive and skill of our forefathers
and take advantage of the facilities and incentives
available. The Productivity Centre will help labour
achieve greater productivity and thereby contribute to
our efforts to industrialise and compete successfully.
Responsible trade union leaders know that it is through
greater productivity that wages can rise, for any
increase in wages without corresponding increase in
output will very quickly blunt our industrial drive and
add to our army of unemployed.
As I have stated before, the Government, apart from
providing the basic facilities already enumerated, will
hold
Column: 478
a fair balance between management and labour. While
seeing to it that there must not be any exploitation of
labour, we must also ensure that entrepreneurs get a
fair return for their investment. Without profits there
will be no investment and therefore no employment. At
the same time our society rightly expects work for
wages paid.
The fact of the matter, Mr Speaker, Sir, is that
without primary income we have no buffer to fall back
on. If there is a deterioration in the services we are
rendering or, worse still, a breakdown in the provision
of such services, inevitably this would lead to a
collapse of our economy. It is the duty of the
Government to see that no section of the population
endangers the standard of efficiency, either through
misunderstanding of the situation or through
irresponsible behaviour, such as malingering and
restrictive practices, which we see creeping into the
system. Prompt and effective action will be taken to
stop the rot wherever it is found.
It is ironic that the first full year after a
separation we did not seek was better than the first
full year of a merger and Malaysia we sought and worked
for so long and arduously. For the first full year of
Malaysia was the first full year of confrontation and
saw our annual growth rate of 8.5 per cent go down to 2
per cent.
This has not been so with the first full year of
Independence after we were suddenly separated from
Malaysia. Although the percentage increase of our Gross
National Product is not as yet available, the figures
show an increase of between 9 per cent and 12 per cent
in trade and revenue - cause for quiet confidence. But
this confidence must not lead us to smugness and
complacency. It must not lead our people, whether
entrepreneurs, or trade unionists, into believing that
the world owes us a living and that things will always
be all right. They will be all right only if we are
constantly alert, efficient and striving. For ours is
not any ordinary economy like that of many other
countries in this region. Our future is at once fraught
with peril and yet bright with promise, depending upon
how things
Column: 479
work out in Asia as a whole. If big power conflicts are
contained and the smaller countries turn to
constructive pursuits, then we shall thrive and prosper
in peace. If not, we must inevitably be embroiled in
grievous strife, with big powers exploiting the petty
feuds, jealousies and rivalries. But these are matters
beyond our dispensation. What we can see clearly is
into the 70's for, barring the unexpected, we can
assume a relatively quiet and secure situation in this
corner of South-East Asia. But we have lived long
enough to learn that the unexpected does often happen
and we are learning to make contingency provisions for
such accidents.
It has been my good fortune as Finance Minister for
two successive years not to have had to raise revenue
by increases in the rates of taxation. This year, the
only change is in the method of computing the motor-vehicle tax, which will bring in a small increase of
$5½ million in revenue, a step we are taking more to
establish sound principles of taxation than the need
for the $5½ million. But Singapore cannot assume that
the expanding cost of education, health and social
services, plus added burdens of our separate defence
expenditure, can always look after themselves. On the
one hand, my officials have had to do their unpopular
duty of using the pruning knife whenever they feel that
an item of expenditure was extravagant in relation to
our own economic capacity. On the other hand, our
entrepreneurs and workers must give of their best to
keep this economy humming and thriving, so that the
increased economic activity will always give an
increasing revenue.
Provided there is a clear appreciation of the
elementary facts of life in our lean society, and
provided that each and every sector plays its part,
there is no reason at all why we should not be able to
achieve our goal of a better life for all. Our people
have got what it takes to make Singapore prosper. What
is required now is an awareness of the problems before
us and a concerted response made to meet the challenge
of our separate destiny. Together
Column: 480
we should be able to surge forward to a better and
brighter future.
Sir, I beg to move.
Mr Speaker: The Question is, "That Parliament
approves the financial policy of the Government for the
year 1967." In accordance with paragraph (1) of
Standing Order 82, the debate now stands adjourned.
Debate to be resumed, what day, Mr Minister?
Mr Lim Kim San: On the 14th of December.
Mr Speaker: I think it is now a convenient time to
suspend the sitting. I suspend the sitting now and will
take the Chair again at 6 p.m.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
5.20 p.m. until 6 p.m.
Column: 480
Sitting resumed at 6.00 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
WOMEN'S CHARTER (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
The Minister for Culture and Social Affairs (Inche Othman Bin Wok): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
This Bill makes a number of significant amendments to
the Women's Charter, 1961. The Explanatory Statement to
the Bill sets out in detail the reasons for the
amendments, and for this reason and also because it is
proposed to refer this Bill to a Select Committee if
its Second Reading is approved, I do not propose to
deal in detail with the amendments proposed. I shall
only confine myself to a few of the amendments which
affect the principle of the legislation.
The purpose of the Women's Charter, 1961, was to
bring all marriages (other than Muslim marriages)
solemnised in Singapore within the ambit of the
Charter, so that all such marriages in Singapore will
be solemnised and registered under the Charter. This
clearly has
Column: 481
not been achieved, for there are still a large number
of Chinese customary marriages which appear to be
solemnised outside the Ordinance. It is, therefore,
proposed to amend the Ordinance to make it clear that
Chinese customary marriages will come within the
provisions of the Ordinance and that they must be
solemnised and registered under the provisions of the
Ordinance. Let me at once say that it is not the
intention of the Government to prevent such customary
marriages from taking place, as it is not the intention
of the Government to prevent Christian or Hindu
marriages from being solemnised in Singapore. All that
will be required will be that a person, before going
through a Chinese customary marriage, should comply
with the provisions of the Ordinance relating to
freedom to marry, age and consent. All persons will be
required to obtain a certificate for marriage under the
provisions of the Ordinance, but once he has obtained
this, he is free to have his marriage solemnised or
performed or carried out in any way he likes.
The second major amendment in the Bill relates to the
rights of married women as regards their property. The
Bill seeks to make it clear that married women may deal
with their property in the same way as men.
The Bill next seeks to bring the law relating to
divorce in line with recent legislation in other
Commonwealth countries. When the Women's Charter was
enacted, the provisions of the Divorce Ordinance were
incorporated in it without any substantial amendment.
The law relating to divorce has, however, moved forward
and the tendency in many countries is to recognise what
is known as the "breakdown" principle - that is, that
if a marriage is broken down and the Court is satisfied
that the parties can no longer live with each other,
then it is right that the marriage should be put an end
to. This principle, Mr Speaker, Sir, which has been
accepted in Australia and New Zealand and in many
European countries, is adopted in the amending Bill.
The Bill also seeks to provide more opportunities for
reconciliation before a divorce is decreed.
Column: 482
The Bill also provides that the children of void or
voidable marriages should be regarded as legitimate, as
it is not their fault that their parents have
contracted the void marriage.
It is hoped that the Bill will be welcomed as a
further step in the improvement of the position of
women and children in our family law. The rationale of
the Bill is that the happiness of the family should be
fostered by the law, but when all efforts fail, it is
better for the parties to part rather than to be forced
to live together in unhappiness and strife.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Madam Chan Choy Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, the Women's Charter was formulated in 1961 and
passed in that year. By its enactment, we can
understand that the purpose is to enhance the position
of women in Singapore, to enable them to secure their
rightful place in society - equal to men - and to enjoy
the same rights and privileges as men. Since its
introduction and during the period of its enforcement,
we have found that certain provisions in the Ordinance
cannot give effect to the purpose that we intend. As
these provisions do not achieve the purpose, it is,
therefore, proper and correct that the Minister should
introduce amending legislation.
But there is something in this amending Bill which I
regret very much. The Minister has omitted a point
which is more important than what he has said. This is
in relation to the representation which the previous
Minister received from the Women's Section in the
P.A.P. The representation stated that the Women's
Charter, in addition to enabling women to secure their
equal and rightful place in Singapore, should also
eradicate the practice of polygamy - the practice of
having three wives and four concubines - which has
caused disharmony in the family and disturbance and
disquiet in our society. According to the law then
prevailing, certainly if any one wanted to marry he had
to register under the Women's Charter to get his
marriage legalised before it was
Column: 483
recognised by the law. Then would the practice of
monogamy be effected. But we have found that there is a
big loophole. This is in regard to the definition of
the word "mistress". A man can have many mistresses
outside his family. If he does not register, then in
the eyes of the law he cannot be punished, and this
invariably constitutes a system of polygamy. From the
time when the Women's Charter was enforced up to now,
we have found that the number of divorces has been
quite high. This has been due mainly to such a practice
as I have said, that is to say, though women have
nominal protection under the law, the law has, in
effect, not provided actual protection for them,
because their husbands could cohabit with many
mistresses outside their homes. As a result, it leads
to disharmony in the family which in turn leads to
divorces. All this is because of the definition of the
word "mistress" which is not clear.
I would like to point out something about clause 28
in the amending Bill before us today. This appears on
page 8, line 35, in which connection the Minister has
mentioned divorce just now. When a couple have been
married for some time and find that they cannot live
together, they separate. During their period of
separation, they may hope to resume their harmonious
relationship and live together again. But this amending
Bill provides that if after seven years of separation
they cannot hope to be united again, then their
separation can be confirmed. Arising from this
provision, the pretext, "I am not satisfied and cannot
live happily with my wife," can be used as an excuse
for divorce to marry someone else. During this period
of separation the law does not provide the couple with
any means to reconciliate or to be reunited. So I feel
that this provision in the Bill is not quite
satisfactory, that if a husband, whose marriage was
registered under the law, finds that he cannot live
together with his wife again after a period of 7 years,
he could ask for a divorce. Why should a period of
seven years be provided? That is not quite correct. We
should have a proper and more effective
Column: 484
provision in the law to prohibit or restrict the man
from getting more mistresses outside the home. As it
is, the Women's Charter will be ineffective. In other
words, we want to implement the law to protect women
and enhance their position in society, and generally to
improve society as a whole. This amending law is
providing men with more opportunities to evade their
rightful duties to their wives, which will worsen the
women's position. Is this in keeping with the P.A.P.
policy as promised to the electorate in 1959? I do not
agree with this provision in clause 28, and I hope the
Minister will reconsider it when the Bill is in Select
Committee, in the hope that women can enjoy their
rightful place in the new society now that Singapore
has advanced from self-government to independence. In
this new era women should be enabled under the aegis of
the Government to develop their strength and ability to
serve the country and contribute to the betterment of
society.
6.18 p.m.
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, although I am
physically occupying a seat customarily reserved for
the Opposition, let me assure you that my heart is with
the Government. In this respect, I am sure I speak for
all my colleagues on this side of the House. It is
fitting that I should now rise to support the
Government on this Bill.
The Women's Charter is one of the noted pieces of
social legislation introduced by the Government. It
seeks to protect the rights and interests of women and
children in the Republic and to abolish polygamy. When
it was introduced in 1961, it demolished, as it were,
by a stroke of the pen, the polygamous haven that was
Singapore, no doubt to the regret of many a polygamist!
The Charter has been in existence for the last five
years, and during this time certain loopholes were
discovered. It is appropriate that the Government
should now take stock of this piece of legislation and
try to bring it up to date.
Column: 485
I was rather surprised just now when I heard the hon.
Member for Delta criticising one of the clauses in the
Bill. This clause seeks to permit the dissolution of a
marriage after separation for seven years, during which
time all attempts at reconciliation have been
unsuccessful. It would appear, from what she has said,
that once a marriage is contracted, it should never be
dissolved. That, Mr Speaker, I cannot agree to and I
do not think it is in line with present day
sociological trends.
Mr Speaker, the basic unit of a country is the
family. Whether a country is happy or progressive
depends upon whether this basic -
Madam Chan Choy Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
can I clarify in a few sentences? Just now I have
clearly pointed out that the Minister in this amending
Bill has provided one redundant clause, namely, clause
28. I do not mean that once a person is married he or
she should not be allowed to divorce for proper
reasons, because the law clearly and specifically
provides that when a couple have registered under the
Ordinance for two years, any one party who has been
cruelly treated, or has any dissatisfaction or has
sufficient reasons, could petition for a divorce. Then
why have this redundant clause saying that after seven
years they can petition for a divorce? Since they are
already allowed, after two years, to petition for a
divorce, why should you now add seven years? This would
encourage a husband to leave his wife to get a new
wife.
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I have no
experience in matters matrimonial, but I can assure the
hon. Member for Delta that seven years is a long time
to wait, and if I were -
Mr Speaker: Mr Tang, are you speaking with the
experience of a bachelor of seven years' standing?
Mr Tang See Chim: I am speaking, Mr Speaker, Sir,
as a bachelor of 34 years' standing! Mr Speaker, Sir,
as I was saying before the interruption, whether a
country is happy or progressive depends upon its basic
unit, that is, the family. As I see it, Mr Speaker,
Column: 486
Sir, there is no point in keeping two persons together
who cannot agree with each other and who hate the sight
of each other and are at loggerheads all the time. It
would not then be a holy wedlock but it would be a
wholly deadlock if the hon. Member for Delta had her
way! I am glad that the Government is committing this
amendment Bill to a Select Committee and no doubt
representations from the public, especially from
organisations connected with children and women, will
be made to this Committee. I wish the Select Committee
well in its deliberations. Mr Speaker, Sir, I support
this amendment Bill in principle.
Mr P. Govindaswamy(In Tamil): Mr Speaker, Sir, in
connection with clause 28 of this amendment Bill, if a
man has been separated for seven years, what will
happen to his life? The period of separation is not
proper, because if a man and a girl want to live
properly, then the number of years of separation should
be reduced. Only then will their future be happy. My
request is that the period of separation should be
reduced or deleted.
Inche Othman Bin Wok: Mr Speaker, Sir, I do not propose
to say more at this stage as the Bill will be committed
to a Select Committee. However, I would like to assure
this House, particularly the Members for Delta and
Anson, that the Select Committee will be happy to
receive and consider constructive suggestions.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Inche Othman Bin Wok: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the Bill be committed to a Select Committee
consisting of Mr Speaker as Chairman and seven Members
to be nominated by the Committee of Selection.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That the Bill be committed to a Select Committee
consisting of Mr Speaker as Chairman and seven Members
to be nominated by the Committee of Selection.
Column: 487
INSURANCE BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.27 p.m.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Mr Speaker, Sir, this Bill re-enacts the provisions
of the Insurance Act, 1963, of Malaysia which was
extended to Singapore in January 1965 and which after
separation is still operative in Singapore until
repealed. Hon. Members of the House may ask why it has
been found necessary to re-enact the provisions of this
Act. This is due to the following main reasons:
(a) Statutory deposits in respect of insurance
companies operating in Singapore are kept by the
Malaysian Accountant General and can no longer be
called upon to cover liabilities of Singapore
insurers.
(b) By virtue of the fact that Singapore is no longer
a part of the Federation of Malaysia, Singapore
securities are now automatically excluded from the
schedule of approved assets.
(c) It is desirable that some amendments which have
been made to the Malaysian Act since separation
should also be incorporated in the Singapore
legislation.
Briefly the Bill is a comprehensive piece of
legislation designed to control and supervise the
conduct of all types of insurance business. The basic
objective of the Bill is to prevent the repetition of
unscrupulous practices like those of mushroom insurance
companies and to encourage the growth of healthy
insurance business.
Turning now to the contents of the Bill, I would like
to elaborate on the more salient clauses.
Clause 2 of the Bill classifies insurance business
into two main categories, namely, life insurance and
general insurance.
Clauses 3 and 4 lay down the minimum conditions of
operations of
Column: 488
insurance companies in Singapore. These are
registration with the Insurance Commissioner and
lodging a statutory deposit of $300,000 for each type
of insurance business conducted. In addition, the
Commissioner must be satisfied that an insurer applying
for registration must have a surplus of assets over
liabilities of not less than $1 million if he proposes
to carry on one type of insurance business, or a
surplus of assets over liabilities of at least $l½
million if he proposes to carry on both types of
insurance business.
Clauses 7 and 8 of the Bill specify the type of
assets that may be accepted as statutory deposits.
These are cash, approved securities listed in the
Second Schedule to this Bill, bank covenants, or a
combination of any of these items. As the statutory
deposit can be regarded as a final safeguard of the
interests of policy holders, it logically follows that
the securities deposited have to be of the soundest
type, and it is for this reason that the Minister has
been given discretionary powers to refuse acceptance of
securities which are considered not satisfactory for
the purposes of a statutory deposit. With this
objective in mind, I shall be introducing an amendment
to clause 8 during the Committee Stage of the House
which will enable the Minister to limit the amount of
statutory deposit lodged in the form of bank covenants.
Clause 10 of the Bill requires insurers to establish
and maintain an insurance fund for each type of
insurance business conducted for the purposes of
meeting liabilities of Singapore policies.
Mr Speaker: Mr Lim, could I just interrupt you to
ask for the co-operation of Members on this side to
turn off the speakers that are close to them? There are
some speakers that are on and they are rather
distracting. As Mr Lim continues to speak, perhaps
Members may be able to detect them. Yes, Mr Lim.
Mr Lim Kim San: Clause 11 stipulates that a minimum
of 55 per cent of the assets of the fund must consist
of approved securities which are listed in the Second
Schedule to this Bill. As
Column: 489
assets in the Second Schedule are local in character,
this provision makes it necessary for insurers to keep
in Singapore, local assets to match at least 55 per
cent of the liabilities they have contracted. It has
been found that, with regard to some general insurance
companies, outstanding premiums and agents' balances
comprise a disproportionately large percentage of the
total assets of their insurance funds. This is clearly
undesirable as the solvency of the fund is dependent on
the extent to which such premiums and balances can be
collected. Clause 11 (2) of the Bill therefore limits
such balances and premiums to l2½ per cent of written
premiums. To allow insurers to achieve this percentage
smoothly and with minimum difficulty, a 2-year
transitional period is allowed during which insurers
are required gradually to reduce the amount of
outstanding premiums and agents' balances held as part
of their insurance funds until the target of 12½ per
cent is achieved. Again I wish to state here, Sir, that
during the Committee Stage of the House, I will be
proposing an amendment to this clause which will allow
the Minister to increase the minimum percentage of 55
per cent and to specify the minimum or maximum amount
of this 55 per cent that may be invested in any one or
more of the items listed in the Second Schedule.
Clauses 15 and 23 relate specifically to life
insurance companies. Clause 15 provides that premium
rates charged by life insurance companies must be
approved by qualified actuaries, whilst clause 23 makes
it necessary for regular actuarial investigations to be
made into the financial condition of the life insurance
companies.
Under the provisions of clause 22, all insurance
companies are required to lodge annual returns with the
Commissioner. The Commissioner can request insurers to
furnish him with information related to their business
if the information is required for the proper discharge
of his functions under the Bill.
Clause 27 lays down the conditions under which the
Commissioner may institute an investigation into the
whole
Column: 490
or part of the business of an insurer. Among these
conditions are failure on the part of the insurer to
comply with any provisions of this Bill relating to
insurance funds, and if it appears to the Commissioner
that the insurer is likely to become unable to meet his
obligations.
Clause 29 relates to winding up of insurance
companies.
Clause 32 provides for transfers of business.
Clause 35 provides for the appointment of an
Insurance Commissioner by the Minister. The
Commissioner would be responsible for administering the
Bill and would exercise the functions conferred upon
him by this Bill. The Commissioner is required to
submit an annual report to the Minister, a copy of
which is to be presented to Parliament.
Under the provisions of clause 45, the Minister may
make regulations for carrying into effect the objects
of this Bill.
The First Schedule to the Bill lists the definitions
of insurance terms; the Second Schedule lists
authorised Singapore assets for the purposes of
statutory deposits and insurance funds; the Third
Schedule relates to deposits required to be lodged by
associations of underwriters; and the Fourth Schedule
specifies documents to be lodged annually by insurers.
Mr Speaker, Sir, apart from the amendments to
clauses 8 and 11 which I have mentioned earlier, I
propose to suggest a few other minor amendments to the
Bill during the Committee Stage.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
6.37 p.m.
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I think this
Bill is a good one. It is designed to control and
regulate the insurance industry in Singapore. My only
criticism of this Bill is that it is not comprehensive
enough, especially in regard to motor insurance. The
law with regard to motor insurance at present requires
compulsory third-party
Column: 491
insurance. But third-party insurance, unfortunately,
does not include passenger liability. I would request
the Government to consider including passenger
liability possibly in an amendment to the Third Party
Risks and Compensation Ordinance as third-party
liability. Under the existing law, Mr Speaker, Sir, an
insurance company can still avoid liability with regard
to third-party risks in certain circumstances. This may
be just in respect of the insured, but it definitely
works an injustice towards the injured third party. To
overcome this, possibly Government can consider setting
up an insurance compensation fund. This could be
contributed to by the insurance companies undertaking
motor insurance business. The alternative is to require
insurance companies to insure drivers with regard to
third-party risks rather than insuring cars.
Let me give the House an example. Many of our
Government Front-benchers are accomplished golfers. I
understand the Minister concerned with this Bill is one
of them. A golfer should insure himself against third-party liability, in case he hits the ball into somebody
instead of into the hole. The present position of
insuring cars instead of insuring drivers is as absurd
as insuring the golfers' clubs rather than the golfers
themselves against third-party liability. Yet we think
nothing of that. May I recommend the Minister in charge
of this Bill to spend a few thoughts on this point,
possibly between golf shots?
Also clause 8 of the Bill enables an insurer to get
out of the deposit by getting a bank covenant. No doubt
the primary object of requiring the $300,000 deposit is
that there should be enough money to pay any
compensation when compensation is payable. But surely
there should be a secondary object, that this amount of
money should be invested in securities, especially
securities of local industries. So this requirement of
a $300,000 deposit would kill two birds with one stone.
It would also oblige insurance companies to invest
their money locally.
Column: 492
As I have said just now, Mr Speaker, Sir, this is a
good Bill on the whole, and with the exception of these
minor criticisms, I support it.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am most grateful
to the hon. Member for giving me food for thought in
between my golf shots! This is the initial step that we
are taking to control insurance. I am sure, as we go
on, we will do everything that is desirable to make
this Bill as fitting as is possible for Singapore. The
points that he has put up are of a technical nature,
and I am sure much thought has been given to them by
other countries. It would be the duty of the
Commissioner so appointed to bring all the salient
features of insurance business all over the world to
our notice, and it would be our duty to keep on
improving the Ordinance as time goes on. But for our
purpose now, since we are repealing the Malaysia
Insurance Act, as an initial step I would request that
we allow this Bill to go through.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Lim Kim San]
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
6.46 p.m.
Clause 1 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 2 -
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
In page 2, line 39, after "Ordinance", to insert "or
organisation registered under the Mutual Benefit
Organisations Ordinance, 1960,".
The reason for this amendment is to exclude the
application of this Bill to mutual benefit
organisations.
Amendment agreed to.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
Column: 493
In page 2, line 40, after "society", to insert "or
organisation".
This amendment is necessary as a result of the first
amendment.
Amendment agreed to.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
In page 2, line 44, after "society", to insert "or
organisation".
As in the case of the previous amendment, this is
also a consequential amendment.
Amendment agreed to.
The Chairman: There is a note,
In page 2, to insert marginal note "Ord. 42 of 1960."
against "Mutual Benefit Organisations Ordinance, 1960.".
This will be done.
Clause 2, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clauses 3 to 7 inclusive ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clause 8 -
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
In page 8, after line 34, to add -
"Provided that the Minister may, in his discretion
but subject to the provisions of subsection (1) of
section 7 of this Act, specify in writing the sum to be
covenanted for under the provisions of this
subsection.".
As mentioned earlier, Mr Speaker, Sir, statutory
deposits must be of the soundest and best securities,
and with this objective in mind, this amendment is
being introduced to clause 8 in order to enable the
Minister, if necessary, to specify the amount of the
statutory deposit that may be covenanted for.
Amendment agreed to.
The Chairman: A consequential amendment is necessary,
In page 8, line 34, to leave out the full-stop and
insert a colon.
Clause 8, as amended, ordered to stand stand part of
the Bill.
Clauses 9 and 10 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Column: 494
Clause 11 -
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
In page 12, after line 37, to add -
"Provided that the Minister may, in his discretion by
order published in the Gazette -
(a) increase the percentage referred to in this
subsection;
(b) specify the minimum or maximum percentage or
both minimum and maximum percentages of the
total value of the assets of the fund that
insurers may hold of any one or more of the
items set out in the Second Schedule to this Act.".
As has been explained, the provisions of clause 11
require insurance companies operating in Singapore to
establish and maintain an insurance fund of which at
least 55 per cent of the assets must be local assets
listed in the Second Schedule. Paragraph (a) of this
amendment enables the Minister to increase this 55 per
cent if necessary. Whilst the provisions of clause 11
stipulate a minimum investment of 55 per cent in local
assets, there is no provision to require insurers to
hold a well-distributed portfolio of investments in
their insurance fund. The amendment at paragraph (b) is
therefore being introduced to take care of the
situation when insurers invest a large proportion of
their funds in one type of asset. This is clearly
undesirable as the solvency and liquidity of the fund
is dependent on only one type of asset.
Amendment agreed to.
The Chairman: There is a consequential amendment,
In page 12, line 37, to leave out the full-stop and
insert a colon.
This will be done.
Clause 11, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clauses 12 to 15 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clause 16 -
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
Column: 495
In page 16, lines 14 and 15, to leave out "After the
end of six months from the date of the coming into
operation of this Act,".
This amendment is being made as it is not necessary
to provide for a period of grace for putting into
operation sub-section (4) of section 16.
Amendment agreed to.
The Chairman: There is a consequential amendment,
In page 16, line 15, to spell "no" with a capital N.
This will be done.
Clause 16, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clauses 17 to 42 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clause 43 -
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
In page 39, lines 34 and 35, to leave out "shall be
deemed to have come into operation on the 1st day of
July, 1966, and".
Mr Speaker, Sir, I wish to move the next amendment
to this clause before giving the explanation as these
two amendments are related.
The Chairman: Will the Minister make his speech on
the first amendment before moving the second one, and
then just move the second amendment without making a
speech on it?
Mr Lim Kim San: This amendment is made as it is not
necessary to back-date the coming into effect of Clause
43.
Amendment agreed to.
Amendment made: In page 39, line 36, to leave out
"then in force.".-[Mr Lim Kim San].
Clause 43, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clauses 44 to 47 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
7.00 p.m.
Clause 48 -
Column: 496
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
In page 42, after line 35, to add -"(2) The provisions
of subsection (1) of this section shall not affect the
obligation under the Insurance Act, 1963, of Malaysia,
with regard to the lodgement of returns for the
accounting period immediately prior to the initial
accounting period under this Act.
(3) The provisions of the Insurance Act, 1963, of
Malaysia, shall continue to apply to any insurer
carrying on business in Singapore until such insurer is
registered under this Act."
These two sub-clauses are saving provisions which
will cover the transitional period when the present Act
is repealed and a period of grace is given to insurers
to register under the new Act.
Amendment agreed to.
The Chairman: There is a consequential amendment,
In page 42, line 33, after "48.", to insert "-(1) ".
This will be done.
Clause 48, as amended, ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
First, Second, Third and Fourth Schedules ordered to
stand part of the Bill.
Bill reported with amendments; read a Third time and
passed.
Column: 496
ENTERTAINMENTS DUTY (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
7.05 p.m.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Sir, the Entertainments Duty Ordinance provides that
the rates of duty to be levied on different types of
entertainment have to be approved by a resolution of
Parliament from time to time. This is administratively
inconvenient in that if it is desired to vary the rate
of duty for any particular entertainment, it cannot be
done without reference to Parliament.
Column: 497
Clause 2 of the Bill seeks to repeal section 4 of the
Ordinance and provides the Minister with the power to
levy different rates by order published in the Gazette.
This allows for greater flexibility and is in keeping
with the powers of the Minister in other fiscal
legislation, for example, in the Customs laws. As the
law now stands, there is no provision for the Minister
to exempt any class of entertainment from the payment
of entertainments duty.
Clause 3 seeks to grant the Minister powers to exempt
any particular case from the payment of entertainments
duty subject to such conditions as may be imposed.
Permissive powers for the Minister to prescribe
different rates of duty and to exempt any particular
case will allow for administrative simplicity,
especially in cases where it is desired to stimulate
particular types of sport which may need assistance.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Lim Kim San]
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 497
GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
7.11 p.m.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Currently the Government Contracts Ordinance, 1949,
of Malaysia applies to Singapore. The purpose of the
Bill is to repeal the Malaysian Ordinance and
substitute it with the Government Contracts Act, 1966.
The Bill seeks to enact with suitable amendments the
provisions of the Government Contracts Ordinance, 1949,
of Malaysia. Under this Ordinance, any Minister may
authorise a public officer
Column: 498
to sign a contract. The new Bill before the House
provides that authorisation of officers will be only by
the Minister for Finance. As contracts invariably
involve financial matters, it is desirable that the
authority be from the Minister for Finance. In respect
of contracts signed outside Singapore, this authority
is also to be vested in the Minister for Finance.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Lim Kim San]
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 498
INCOME TAX (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
7.15 p.m.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Sir, at present there is provision under section 37
(2) of the Income Tax Ordinance for the approval of an
institution as "an institution of a public character"
whereby an amount equal to the sum contributed to the
said institution is an allowable deduction from
assessable income for income tax purposes.
Under paragraph (c) of the above sub-section "an
institution of a public character" is defined as an
institution or fund in Singapore under one of seven
categories, including "a public or other benevolent
institution not operated or conducted for profit". The
phrase is ambiguous because of the word "other", so
that this category is restricted to either public
benevolent or other benevolent institutions not
conducted for profit.
Column: 499
As the provision now stands, its benefits cannot be
extended to deserving public institutions which do not
strictly fall within the legal definition of
"benevolent". To give greater flexibility to approve a
public institution not strictly benevolent, it is
proposed that section 37 (2) (c) (ii) should be amended
by deleting the word "other" in the phrase "a public or
other benevolent institution".
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Lim Kim San]
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 499
RAILWAYS (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
7.19 p.m.
The Minister of State for the Prime Minister's Department (Tuan Haji Yaacob Bin Mohamed)(In Malay):
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
This Bill seeks to amend the Singapore Railways
Ordinance to enable automatic half-barriers to be
installed at five railway level crossings in Jurong.
Under section 17 of the Ordinance, the Malayan
Railway, which has extended its services to the Jurong
Industrial Estate, is required to provide manned gates
at level crossings. Owing to the prohibitive costs of
operating manned gates, the Railway Administration has
suggested the installation of automatic half -barriers,
and at some of the crossings where traffic is not
heavy, for such crossings to be declared open level
crossings without any gates.
The Economic Development Board supports the
installation of automatic half-barriers as they are
expected to provide more efficient services - costs
Column: 500
of employing gate-keepers and provision of houses for
gate-keepers would be eliminated and delay to road
traffic curtailed.
In order to allow the installation of automatic half-barriers, it is necessary to amend section 17 of the
Singapore Railways Ordinance. The amendment will
empower the Minister to exempt certain level crossings
from the requirement to have manually operated gates.
However, the Railway Administration will be required to
erect warning boards alongside the public road as well
as whistle signs upon the railway at suitable distances
from the level crossings.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Tuan Haji Yaacob Bin Mohamed]
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 500
NANYANG UNIVERSITY (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
7.24 p.m.
The Minister for Education (Mr Ong Pang Boon): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read
a Second time."
The amendments to the Nanyang University Ordinance,
1959, which this Bill seeks to introduce, were
initiated by the Nanyang University Council. These
amendments have been the subject of deliberations and
consultation among Council members, officials of my
Ministry, and the law officers of the Republic since
June 1964, when the Special Liaison Committee of the
Singapore Government and representatives of Nanyang
University reached agreement on the reorganisation of
Nanyang University.
Column: 501
The House will recall that the Special Liaison
Committee's agreement contained, among others, the
following clauses. I quote:
"(1) Nanyang University should be reorganised at an
early date. The details of reorganisation to be left to
the future Nanyang University Council using the Nanyang
University Review Committee Report and the Nanyang
University Ordinance as the basis for formulating
measures for reorganisation.
(2) After reorganisation, the Singapore Government
will treat Nanyang University on the same basis as the
University of Singapore so as to effect a reduction in
student fees and increase in staff emoluments and
further improvements in equipment and facilities.
(3) After reorganisation Nanyang University must
become a purely academic institution and should not be
manipulated or influenced by any political or
subversive activities."
The agreement also provided for a new Nanyang
University Council of 28 members, comprising 12
representatives, one each from the then 12 Malaysian
States, six Government representatives, three of whom
would be reserved for other State Governments of
Malaysia, three representatives of the Senate,
including the Vice-Chancellor, two representatives of
the Guild of Graduates and five community leaders.
However, before this part of the agreement could be
implemented, Singapore was evicted from Malaysia.
Consequent upon separation and the emergence of
Singapore as an independent and sovereign Republic, it
is only logical that Nanyang University, which has been
financed largely by grants from the Singapore
Government since 1964, should be controlled by
Singapore members in respect of its policy and
management.
[Mr Tang See Chim in the Chair]
7.28 p.m.
During the past 2½ years, the Singapore Government
has contributed $6,701,000 to Nanyang University,
consisting of -
Column: 502
Recurrent Expenditure $2,081,000
Upward revision of Staff 1,000,000
salaries
Bursaries 1,250,000
Tution Fee Subsidy 370,000
New Library Building 1,000,000
Scientific equipment and 1,000,000
library books
---------
Total 6,701,000
=========
This is only the beginning. As reorganisation gathers
momentum, the Singapore Government's financial
commitment towards the University will increase. Even
now the cost of maintaining a Nanyang student is about
$2,000 a year. Malaysian students who pay $720 a year
in fee without any assistance from the Malaysian
Government are being subsidised by the Government and
people of Singapore at the rate of about $1,300 per
student per year. At the same time, contributions from
the private sector in support of Nanyang University
have dwindled to negligible sums. In point of fact, the
total amount of private donations collected since the
establishment of Nanyang University is considerably
less than what the public has been led to believe.
According to figures published in the Nanyang
University Tenth Anniversary Souvenir, the amount
collected from 1963 to 1965 was only $12,070,000. This
was the sum collected in dribs and drabs over a period
of 13 years as compared with the $6.7 million which the
Singapore Government has spent on the University during
the last two and a half years. It is also significant
that of the $12 million raised from the private sector,
Singapore, exclusive of Government grants, accounted
for 80 per cent of this $12 million, while others,
including all the constituent States of Malaysia,
accounted for only 20 per cent. In the circumstances,
it is only right and proper that Singapore citizens
should have the final say on how Nanyang University
should be run. However, if, as reported in today's
Eastern Sun, certain Malaysian parents of the expelled
students believe that Singapore citizens who are paying
for practically the whole cost of running Nanyang
University
Column: 503
should not have a dominant say in its affairs, then
they can always set up their own university or persuade
their own Government to set up a Chinese University in
Malaysia, and the Singapore Government will undertake
to refund every cent that the Malaysians have donated
towards the establishment of Nanyang University.
An hon. Member: Hear, hear!
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, clause 7 of the
Bill before the House provides for a 21-member Council
consisting of the Vice-Chancellor, 2 members elected
from the Senate, 2 members from the Guild of Graduates,
3 members elected by members of the University from
amongst themselves, 7 members appointed by the Council
from persons prominent in the field of education,
culture, industry or commerce, and 6 members appointed
by the Government of whom 3 may be persons resident
outside Singapore. In making possible participation of
persons resident outside Singapore in the governing
body of Nanyang, the present University Council and the
Government are mindful of the support Malaysians have
given to the University in the past and the sincere
desire to preserve the sentimental link between Nanyang
University and the Malaysian people who, we hope, will
continue to support the University financially or
otherwise.
In order to provide for continuity in policy making,
this Bill also seeks to extend the term of office of
Council members from two to four years.
The other amendments proposed in this Bill are of a
minor character. Provision is made for the appointment
of a Deputy Vice-Chancellor to assist the Vice-Chancellor in carrying out his onerous duties. Such an
appointment has been found to be essential in most
universities in the world. At the same time, the
designations of some existing posts in the University
as laid down in the Ordinance are to be changed to
conform to designations currently used in the
University.
Column: 504
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
7.36 p.m.
As such, the office of the President as provided for in
the Ordinance is to be changed to that of Vice-Chancellor, which has been the designation used since
1960. Similarly, the designations of Secretary and
Treasurer are to be changed to Registrar and Bursar
respectively.
Finally, the existing Ordinance has two separate
sections to provide similar powers to the University
Council. Section 29 provides for rules to be made by
the Council and section 32 provides for statutes to be
made. In order to avoid duplication without curtailing
the powers of the Council, this Bill seeks to enlarge
the powers of the Council to make rules and remove its
power to make statutes. This is accomplished by
conferring on the Council the power to make additional
rules governing the powers and duties of the officers
of the University; the composition, powers, duties and
procedure of the Senate and the Guild of Graduates, and
the discipline and welfare of students. With this new
provision all the matters at present dealt with by
statutes will be adequately covered by rules, and
section 32 providing for the Council to make statutes
may therefore be repealed.
With these improvements in the Nanyang University
Ordinance, there is reason to believe that continued
support for the University will be forthcoming not only
from Singapore but also from Malaysia. Of the 1,678
students at present in Nanyang University, 840 or 50
per cent are from Malaysia. As I have said earlier, the
Singapore Government has been subsidising each and
every one of these students at the rate of $1,300 a
year, and the cost will increase as reorganisation
proceeds apace. Clearly the Government and the people
of Singapore should not be expected to bear this burden
indefinitely without assistance. On our part, Singapore
will continue to welcome students from Malaysia
provided they are here to seek knowledge, to acquire an
education and to make use of our facilities;
Column: 505
which are lacking in their own country. If, instead of
doing this, as so many have done in the past, they
become stooges of Communist front organisations and
engage in subversive activities, then Singapore will
have no alternative but to send them home. However, we
are hopeful that the unhappy events of the past will
not recur and that a new breed of students from
Malaysia will join their brethren in Singapore at
Nanyang solely for the pursuit of knowledge so that
under the guidance of the new policy makers, the
administrators and the teachers, the University will
develop into a true centre of learning not only in
Singapore but in the whole of South-East Asia.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, on the question of amending the Nanyang
University Ordinance, I, as a graduate of Nanyang
University, am particularly concerned with this Bill
and I feel that it is necessary to speak my mind on it.
In the first place, I wish to say in all earnestness
that I support the amendments to the existing Nanyang
University Ordinance, which is an Ordinance drafted and
passed into law by the Lim Yew Hock regime before the
P.A.P. came to power. This Ordinance came into
operation on 27th May, 1959. Several years have elapsed
and Nanyang University has developed. During this time
we have discovered that the Ordinance has not been able
to withstand the test of time. There are certain
unsatisfactory features in it. For example, section 9
provides for a Register of members being kept by the
Secretary. But in the subsection there is a provision
regarding the withdrawal of membership and the letter
of withdrawal is to be addressed to the Registrar
instead of the Secretary of the University Council. All
this is very confusing, and in implementing the
Ordinance, we find many defects in it. So this is not
ideal legislation. The existing Ordinance is unable to
keep pace with the progress of Nanyang University and,
even from the legislative point of view, it is far from
closely knit. This was drafted
Column: 506
some ten years ago, and even at that time it was found
to be defective. And at the present moment, it is even
more defective. I shall, therefore, support the
amendments to the existing Ordinance. They must be made
to meet the progressive requirements of Nanyang
University. Otherwise, the Ordinance will be
inadequate.
For example, talking about the Constitution of the
University, this is a statutory corporation. So its
membership has statutory force, and this is the basis
on which we must work. At the time when Nanyang
University was first established, the sponsors, perhaps
because of their desire to have more donations from
people in all walks of life, welcomed all persons to be
members of the University. But after several years of
development, in so far as the members of the University
are concerned, they must have a new attitude and a new
outlook. It is not just a matter of accepting donations
from the people. It is also a matter of administrative
control and certain adjustments should be made to meet
Nanyang University's developing requirements.
From the existing Ordinance of Nanyang University,
we can see that there are several grades of membership
of Nanyang University. If a person donates $1,000, he
can become a patron for life. If he pays up to $10,000,
he can become a life member. All these provisions are
very defective, because there are no detailed
provisions of a comprehensive nature to keep pace with
the development of the University.
The grant given by the Government of Singapore to
Nanyang University amounts to millions of dollars. As
the Minister has already indicated, the question
definitely arises as to whether the Government has
become a permanent patron of Nanyang University. So
even in law itself, there is a problem. According to, I
think, Rule 13 of the Second Schedule to the Ordinance,
when a patron is required to vote, he can have one
vote. In the general meeting, the Government is also
entitled to one vote in its capacity as a member.
Perhaps we can try to solve this problem through
Column: 507
legislative procedure or by adding certain provisions
to the existing Ordinance. But this is not mentioned in
the present amendment Bill.
Another point is that under the existing Ordinance of
Nanyang University, so long as a person donates $1,000,
he can become a member, but there is no restriction on
the membership, be he a resident, a criminal or a
winner of a four-digit lottery! This is a situation
which demands our attention, because if some people who
are believers in Communism are rich enough to become
members of Nanyang University, then they can organise
themselves. They can have 2,000 persons paying $1,000
each, and they can then control the University under
the existing Ordinance. This is a big loophole which
can be exploited. We must therefore take steps to
attend to this matter.
Furthermore, members of the Nanyang University are
not confined to Singapore alone. Some are in Hongkong,
Indonesia, Thailand and Malaysia. According to the
Singapore Republic Independence Constitution, there is
a provision concerning membership in statutory
corporations. Any person or group of persons who want
to become members of any statutory body, or any
corporation of a statutory nature, must have their
names approved by the President and gazetted. So I do
not know whether some Malaysians, who are members of
Nanyang University under the existing Ordinance, are
still considered members. I would like clarification on
this point.
There is one question regarding the election of three
members to the University Council at the general
meeting. We all know that the members of Nanyang
University are many in number. So any general meeting
will be something like a mass rally. Some of the
members are spread out over various places and it is
difficult to hold a general meeting. Experience in the
past few years has shown that a general meeting of Nanyang University is convened on the basis of a State
representatives' general meeting. So if you consider
this in the light of the provisions of the Singapore
Column: 508
Independence Ordinance, you will realise that some of
the members who are representatives will lose their
membership, unless the President of Singapore has
gazetted their names as members of a statutory body.
Under these circumstances, how can we convene a general
meeting? Does it mean that members in different places
can elect representatives from among themselves and
then attend the general meeting of representatives? Or
shall we do something else? So this is a legislative
detail which must be attended to, otherwise there will
be a lot of trouble and difficulties. I wish that the
Minister for Education can clarify the true position.
On another point, Nanyang University, ever since its
inception, has had a lot of problems over the
appointment of -
7.52 p.m.
Mr Speaker: In view of the time and as there are
many Members who would like to speak, it is obvious
that it will not be possible to have a full debate
today. The Minister for Law and National Development
may wish to move adjournment of the debate in order to
be able to move certain motions before the Moment of
Interruption.
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, I move,
That the debate be now adjourned.
Mr Speaker: The Minister has moved that the debate
be now adjourned under Standing Order 24 (1) . This is
not any curtailment of discussion but is, as I have
said earlier, merely to enable the Minister to move two
motions before the Moment of Interruption.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That the debate be now adjourned.
Mr Speaker: Mr Ong, resumption of debate, on what
date?
Mr Ong Pang Boon: 12th December.
Mr Speaker: The debate on the Second Reading of this
Bill will resume on 12th December.
Column: 509
ADJOURNMENT TO A LATER
DAY MOTION
Resolved, "That at its rising this day Parliament do
stand adjourned to 12th December, 1966." - [Mr Barker]
Column: 509
QUESTIONS FOR ORAL ANSWER
(Motion)
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, subject to the general
assent of the House, I wish to move,
That notwithstanding Standing Orders 18 and 20, the
Questions for Oral Answer today which were not reached
be set down for oral answer on 12th December, 1966, if
Members who asked them give notice to Mr Speaker by
the 8th December, 1966, that they so desire.
Mr Speaker, Sir, you will remember that earlier
today the Member for Choa Chu Kang was anxious to have
oral answers to his questions which were mainly
directed at my Ministry, and several of the questions
directed at my Ministry were not answered today. I
somehow feel that Members of the House, judging from
today's happenings, are rather anxious to have many a
supplementary question. So with that in mind, I am
moving the motion.
Hon. Members: Hear, hear!
Mr Speaker: Firstly, do I have the general assent of
Members to the Minister's motion?
Hon. Members indicated assent.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That notwithstanding Standing Orders 18 and 20, the
Questions for Oral Answer today which were not reached
be set down for oral answer on 12th December, 1966, if
Members who asked them give notice to Mr Speaker by
the 8th December, 1966, that they so desire.
Mr Speaker: The result, therefore, is that all
Members who had Questions for Oral Answer today, which
were not reached because of their anxiety over
mosquitoes in the Anson Constituency, will please
notify me before 8th December, 1966, that they want an
oral answer when the House next sits on 12th December,
1966.
Column: 510
So if no notice is received by me, the questions will
be answered by written answer in the usual way.
Column: 510
ADJOURNMENT MOTION
Mr Speaker: There is one further formality. Mr Ong,
can I ask you to move that Parliament do now adjourn to
enable the Member for Sembawang to speak?
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That Parliament do now adjourn.
Question proposed.
7.58 p.m.
CULTURE IN SINGAPORE'S NATION-BUILDING
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
after attainment of independence, Singapore has made
impressive and smooth progress in various fields, such
as internal administration, foreign affairs, defence,
economy, labour, education, culture, health, social
affairs, industrial construction and trade expansion.
To the two million people of Singapore, this is
undoubtedly a great achievement to be proud of.
Recently, however, in the field of cultural activities
which are so very essential to the spiritual life of
our people, some symptoms of decadence seem to have
appeared. By cultural activities, I refer to the
cinemas, the night-clubs, the dance troupes, books,
newspapers and magazines, chain-picture story books,
and the programmes broadcast over the radio and T.V.
The problems I want to deliberate on today concern some
unhealthy tendencies in the above-mentioned cultural
activities.
As we all know, culture and art constitute an
integral part of the spiritual life of the human being,
whose four necessities of material life are food,
clothing, shelter and travel. Cultural life exerts a
great influence on mankind as a whole. A good culture
will not only substantiate their spiritual life but
will also help foster a good and wholesome character.
It will also spark off their
Column: 511
wisdom and thinking, quite apart from stimulating their
will and spirit to move upwards and towards goodness
and nobility. This is the kind of good culture needed
by our newly emergent independent Republic.
8.00 p.m.
It being 8.00 p.m., the Motion for the Adjournment of
Parliament lapsed without Question put.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, I move,
That the House do now adjourn.
Question proposed.
CULTURE IN SINGAPORE'S NATION-BUILDING
Debate resumed.
Mr Speaker: Mr Teong, please continue.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Thank you very
much, Mr Speaker, I shall continue.
On the other hand, bad culture will paralyse the
human mind, make a person pessimistic, despondent,
torpid, and lead him to decadence and even ultimate
destruction. This is the kind of bad culture which we
must discard by all means.
The bad culture I have mentioned refers to films,
books, newspapers and magazines which contain
licentious, indecent, corrupting, fantastic and immoral
material. In the national language this kind of culture
is described as Kebudayaan Chabul. This expression has
a profound significance which connotes incest,
promiscuity, immorality, the infringement of the proper
code of conduct, sensual, adulterous and criminal
behaviour. In Singapore at the present moment, what
aspects of this bad culture have we? Let me give you a
few examples. Our cinemas are still flooded with
pictures depicting fantasy, monstrosity, shameless sex,
murders, brigandism, hooliganism, and James Bond-ism.
Rare indeed are there occasions when one is
Column: 512
treated to film shows with good themes of an educative
and meaningful nature. What educative effect will films
of this undesirable nature have on our people? What bad
influence will they exert on our youthful generation?
In the world of night clubs, Rock-n-Roll and A-Go-Go is
the rule, and in the dance troupes, excessive exposure
of a sexy nature is the centre of interest used to
attract an audience. What undesirable influence will
this kind of culture have on our younger generation?
Apart from this, they learn nothing but the art of
jumping-jack and flirting and petting in their crudest
forms. The streets of Singapore are flooded with chain-picture story books (Chinese comics) about monsters,
goblins, and fantasies, in spite of the action
Government took last month to ban the sale and
circulation of such publications by 44 publishing
houses in Hongkong. Extensive damage is being done to
our school children, causing them to procrastinate in
their studies and to dream of becoming flying heroes
like Batman.
In the fields of radio and T.V. broadcasting, apart
from programmes on political talks, forums, and
traditional dramas which are commendable, our radio and
T.V, stations have hardly been able to offer anything
new and meaningful. The films shown on T.V., except for
a small number of good educational ones which are very
few and far between, are mostly of a farcical nature.
If we allow this kind of situation to develop in its
own course, it will inevitably lead to the emergence of
some serious social problem. It is, therefore,
necessary to review the position with the utmost care
and attention.
The good and healthy culture which I have been
talking about refers to those movies, radio and T.V.
programmes, books and publications, etc., whose
contents are such as to extol virtues and condemn
vices, to cultivate an excellent character, to
enlighten and educate people to be noble in their
thought, to nurture and to bring about a keen sense of
morality among the people, and to encourage them to
strive for goodness and progress. At the present
Column: 513
juncture, culture should serve the purpose of fostering
the growth of national consciousness, the idea of
loving one's country and a spirit of patriotism.
I have said earlier on that all unhealthy culture, be
it in the form of film shows, books, newspapers,
magazines or chain-picture books, will definitely exert
an undesirable effect on our people, especially our
younger generation who will suffer even more harm, for,
being young people, they are not quite mature in their
thinking, are easily subjected to the influence of
yellow culture which will corrupt their thought -
Mr Speaker: Mr Teong, could you please speak a
little slower? The interpreters are having difficulty.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): If I were to speak
slowly, would I be restricted with regard to time?
Mr Speaker: You are obviously speaking too fast.
Could you speak a little slowly and more distinctly,
please?
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Yes, Sir.
And make them despondent, daydream and go astray;
worse, make them commit criminal acts. Many criminal
acts that are taking place in society, such as
fighting, robbery, theft, raping, etc., are mostly done
by young people.
To get down to the cause of all this, yellow films
and publications are mostly to blame. Last month, a
robbery took place in the Department of Social Welfare.
The robbers first handed a letter to the victim. On
opening the letter, it was found to contain these
words, "This is a hold-up." Is not such a dramatic
robbery learnt from and modelled on the style of
Western films depicting robbery? The harm caused by
these unhealthy films is, therefore, not a small
problem.
Mr Speaker, Sir, of course, it has been the
consistent policy of our Government in the field of
culture to uphold and promote the excellent cultural
traditions of the various races and to curb all yellow
culture. Hence, after our Party was voted into power to
form the Government of self-governing Singapore,
Column: 514
we immediately launched an anti-yellow culture
campaign. Measures were taken to ban pornographic
publications, close down massage parlours, and impose a
more stringent film censorship. On the other hand, we
have actively promoted a campaign for healthy culture,
such as the holding of Aneka Ragam Rakyat in various
constituencies which will help promote the interchange
and flow of the cultures and arts of the various races,
playwriting contests, the building of the National
Theatre, the holding of the South-East Asian Cultural
Festival and other activities. As a result, there is
manifest in our country a lively, flourishing, healthy
culture. Meanwhile, with the active encouragement of
the Ministry of Culture, various artist bodies of our
community have also been very active in recent years
and our painters have also held many exhibitions of
works with realistic themes. Therefore, except for
those obnoxious phenomena I have mentioned, the
cultural activities in our Republic are, by and large,
developing towards the better side.
But no matter how strict and stringent the Government
may have been in its measures, the sex-mongers are
still able to have their way in carrying on their
nefarious activities. This is particularly so when the
authorities concerned become lax, thus facilitating
such yellow culture to invade our country, spreading
its evil effects, and continuing to poison the minds of
our younger generation. For instance, only last month
44 chain-picture story book publishers in Hong-Kong
were banned from selling their publications in
Singapore, but such publications had already been in
circulation here for more than one year before they
were found out and banned. I think it is necessary to
find out why such phantom comics had been allowed in
Singapore for one year before they were banned.
Obviously this is ascribable to the laxity and
negligence on the part of the censoring authorities.
Apart from this, I would like to point out another
aspect of the matter which is rather serious. There are
huge cinema posters displayed at prominent places on
the roadside and advertisements put up by dancing
troupes in the newspapers.
Column: 515
They all depict sex and love-making and excessive
exposure. Similarly, advertisements by the cinemas and
dance troupes appearing in the newspapers also contain
pictures of excessive sensual exposure. It is obvious
that posters and advertisements of such obscenity
should not be allowed to be publicly displayed, for
they will give rise to a chain of dangerous reactions,
daydreaming, culminating in fatal traffic accidents and
other mishaps. But what puzzles me is that, in spite of
the fact that my colleague, comrade Chan Choy Siong,
the Member for Delta, raised this question in this
House last year and made criticisms of these obscene
advertisements, so far no measures have been taken by
the department concerned to curb such advertisements.
Of course, Mr Speaker, by enumerating those
phenomena of unhealthy culture, I do not mean to say
that yellow and unhealthy culture is out of all control
in our country. No. In fact, it is still under
effective control. But while we are in the course of
nation-building and bringing up a fine generation after
us, while the country is engaged in the setting up of a
disciplined society, and while our Prime Minister has
again and again stressed the need actively to bring up
a new generation with learning, scientific knowledge,
strength and courage, we should prevent such poisonous
culture from continuing its inroads into our country,
bringing in its train harmful effects on our younger
generation. Therefore, we should take early steps to
prevent and wipe out the spread of such yellow culture,
because it is against our aim and endeavour to nurture
and bring up a fine new generation. If we tolerate its
existence, it may even wipe out all our efforts.
Mr Speaker, Sir, undoubtedly a fine and healthy
culture will bring up and imbue a people with fine
thinking and character. On the contrary, a bad culture
will make a people decadent in thought and lethargic.
Therefore, cultural construction is very important to
the cultivation of character in the people and to the
great task of nation-building.
Column: 516
The renaissance of Europe in about the 14th
century is a good example. In a multi-racial society
such as ours, we must, first and foremost, develop and
give expression to the inherent fine traditional
cultures of the various races. Of course, I do not mean
to do away with all Western culture or to impose the
culture of one race upon the other races, as this is
absolutely impracticable. In fact, being situated at
the hub of South-East Asia and the cross-roads of Asia
and Europe, Singapore cannot entirely escape from the
influence of foreign culture. Even so, in order to look
after the interest of our people, we still have to curb
any foreign culture which has excessive poisons.
Secondly, as an emergent independent Republic, we
should create and enrich our own fine culture. Of
course, our cultural mission should aim at the dual
objectives of enriching the healthy and recreational
life of our people and helping in the promotion of the
task of nation-building. How to achieve these ideal
aims? I feel it lies in the joint effort of our
Government and the art circles. If pioneers and workers
in our art circles will exert themselves, they will
definitely be able to promote and enrich the cultural
life of Singapore.
Mr Speaker, Sir, finally, on the question of
cultural construction, I would like to offer my ten-point suggestions for the Minister's reference:
(1) A complete set of cultural policy be formulated
to serve as guidance to all future cultural activities
of the country.
(2) A Cultural Consultative Committee be formed,
comprising representatives from the Ministry of
Culture, educational, arts, cultural, religious and
journalistic circles and the N.T.U.C. to put forward to
the Minister now and then views on cultural
construction.
Mr Speaker: I want to assist the Member to make the
best use of his time. At 8.20 p.m., if any other Member
wants to speak, the Member for Sembawang will have to
stop and the Minister may want an opportunity to reply.
So the Member has got about two and a half minutes
left,
Column: 517
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): (3) A National
Film Studio be set up to take movie films of all
national construction, and, where possible, to take one
or two movies on a larger scale with contents rich in
national consciousness and educational value.
(4) A National Academy of Arts, to study the way to
develop our culture and arts and further to study the
arts and cultures of South-East Asian countries in
order to enrich our cultural heritage.
(5) A large-scale cultural festival be held annually,
to afford an opportunity for comparison and mutual
emulation between the fine cultures of the various
races, so as to enrich the cultural life of the
people and further promote progress in arts and
culture.
(6) A large-scale anti-yellow campaign be held
annually, to be promoted jointly and in mutual co-operation with the People's Association and civic
organisations.
(7) Stricter measures be taken in the censorship of
photographs, books, newspapers and magazines and all
corrupting, unethical and immoral films and
publications to be banned.
(8) Stricter restrictions be taken in regard to
cinema posters on hoardings on the roadsides and film
and dance-troupe advertisements appearing in the
newspapers, publicity of excessively sexy and indecent
exposure to be banned.
(9) Radio and television stations be stopped from
broadcasting any sexual, monstrous, immoral and
farcical programmes.
(10) More programmes of healthy and educational
content and significance be broadcast by radio and
television stations.
Mr Speaker, Sir, with this, I conclude my speech.
Mr Speaker: Mr Lee Khoon Choy.
Inche Rahamat Bin Kenap rose and then resumed his seat.
Mr Speaker: Perhaps the Minister can make a short
reply, and if he will restrict it to about five
minutes, there will be five minutes left,
Column: 518
The Minister of State for Culture (Mr Lee Khoon Choy): Mr Speaker, my reply will be more than ten
minutes.
Mr Speaker: Under Standing Orders, I am afraid the
House must rise at half-past eight, unless the Minister
wants to make use of some other occasion to give a full
reply. As we will be having many sittings in the course
of the later part of the month, perhaps Inche Rahamat
can address the House and the Minister can find some
other opportunity to reply to both Members.
Inche Rahamat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai)(In Malay):
Mr Speaker, I wish to speak on how our national
culture has deteriorated with the mixture of Western
culture and dances, for instance, the Shindig, the
Shake and the A-Go-Go. But I can conveniently describe
them as mad dances. Such dances have affected our
younger generation. They have become daydreamers. They
have completely neglected their obligations towards
society. They have become immoral as a result of these
mad dances. They keep their hair long and wear tight
trousers - this also applies to the girls - with the
result that we cannot make out who are the girls and
who are the boys! Some of them are still at school.
With the spread of such dances we fear that the
behaviour and conduct of our youths will damage our
local customs which are respected by other nations.
These youths will neglect their responsibilities
towards the nation and society. Is the Minister for
Culture prepared to condone such a state of affairs, or
is it the intention to make such mad dances our
national item? I cannot forget that in 1959, the
Government banned the Rock-n-Roll and the juke boxes,
which at that time were the craze of both boys and
girls, to such an extent that they neglected their
education and damage was done to their character. But
these mad dances are worse than Rock-n-Roll. Is the
Minister for Culture aware that Television Singapura is
encouraging such dances through the Istana Pesta
programme? The indications of this programme are that
our children are under the influence of such yellow
culture. I
Column: 519
hope the Minister for Culture of Singapore will take
steps to ban such dances so that our local traditions
will be respected.
Mr Speaker: Mr Lee, you have to compress what you
have to say.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, it is
difficult to reply in 5 minutes to the matters raised
by the Members, who took 25 minutes. But I shall
endeavour to do my best. If I have longer time I shall
give a more detailed reply.
To sum up, Mr Speaker, the two Members have spoken
generally on the so-called yellow culture prevalent in
Singapore. The Member for Sembawang spent some 20
minutes on this matter. But to sum up his speech he
appeals to the Government to take action to prevent the
flood of yellow culture in Singapore, to take more
restrictive measures against pornographic publications
and films, and to take positive steps to promote a
healthy cultural growth. In principle, Mr Speaker, the
Government has since 1959 been implementing this
policy. As a matter of fact, the Member for Sembawang
himself has admitted, by the examples given by him,
that the situation is not so bad. He says that yellow
culture is not so rampant as to be beyond redemption.
So, strictly speaking, the so-called unhealthy culture
is still under effective control. That is what he says
on his own admission. This is a fact, of course.
Mr Speaker, before giving a point-by-point reply to
the two Members, I shall let the House know briefly our
national policy on culture. It is dependent upon the
political system and the economic environment of the
nation. It is determined by the economy and the
politics of the country. In Communist countries where
the national power is unlimited, even, as the Member
for Geylang Serai has said, if your hair is too long or
your shoes are not where they should be, or the hairdo
of the women is considered improper, the nation has the
power to interfere with your personal life and describe
you as elements of yellow
Column: 520
culture and even brand you as anti-nationals. In short,
in a Communist dictatorship, the State has the power to
interfere with the way of life of each and every
individual in the country. But in the environment in
which we live, which is a democratic country practising
parliamentary democracy, we do not advocate the
unlimited power of the State. We have certain
limitations to the power of the State. Apart from
looking after the necessities of the people, such as
education, health, food and shelter, and security, we
allow and respect certain individual freedom of a
personal nature. Also, to judge others' standard of
culture by your own standard, and to impose your own
standard upon others, is against the spirit and
principle of democracy.
To illustrate this point. An African ballet troupe
came to Singapore some time ago. Some members of the
troupe were half-naked. If the Member for Sembawang
were to see the show, he would not be able to sleep the
whole night! But, generally speaking, from the artistic
and aesthetic point of view, such half-nakedness was
not provocative. It had an artistic effect. Even the
folk dance of Egypt, the belly dance, which is a
traditional dance, may be considered by some foreigners
to be yellow culture. But in a democracy we must not
adopt the views of a few Members and impose them on the
people of Singapore in general and restrict them in
their cultural activities. We will not force people to
cut their hair short, because, by so doing we will be
acting against democratic principles.
Talking about the promotion of a healthy culture, I
shall take this opportunity to say that ever since
1959, when we initiated the Aneka Ragam Rakyat, we have
also taken steps to establish a council which plans to
launch a purely local-orientated cultural festival to
display the work of our artists in Singapore. We want
our artists and other experts to study and to create
new art forms in Singapore and we shall launch a new
art festival next year. In the field of drama we shall
encourage our playwrights to write works reflecting
local life for our radio and television. Perhaps
Column: 521
this is what the Member for Sembawang would like to
have, but some matters would not be to his taste.
Because of the limitation of time, I shall under more
favourable conditions give a more detailed answer to
his speech.
Column: 522
The Question having been proposed at 8.00 p.m. and
the Debate having continued for half an hour, Mr
Speaker adjourned the House without Question put,
pursuant to the Standing Order.
Adjourned accordingly at
Thirty minutes past Eight o'clock p.m.
Column: 522
WRITTEN ANSWER TO QUESTION
Monday, 5th December, 1966
Column: 523
The following Question for Oral Answer stood on the
Order Paper of 5th December, 1966:
Land allocation for Malay Settlement at Ayer Gemuroh
22. "Mr Sim Boon Woo: To ask the Minister for Law
and National Development what progress has been made in
regard to the allocation of land for a Malay settlement
at Ayer Gemuroh and when allocation will be made to the
290 applicants."
Pursuant to Standing Order No. 20 (2) , the Minister
for Law and National Development supplied the following
answer:-
22. "No allocation of land in the Malay settlement at
Ayer Gemuroh has been made since 1959. The Government,
taking cognizance of the acute shortage of land, has
decided that the policy regarding such settlement
should be reviewed in the light of our rapidly
increasing population.
In Ayer Gemuroh for instance, some 82 acres of land
were set aside for a Malay settlement. This land,
however, was not completely vacant as at the
Column: 524
time of gazetting in March 1959 there were already 190
Malay, 16 Chinese and 5 Indian families living on it.
In the same year, 8 new families moved into the area
and were allocated one lot each. Hence, though in
theory it would appear that there were many lots which
still remain to be allocated, in actual fact not much
land is available for allocation at the site. Further,
some parts of this land are low lying and subject to
floods, and to make these parts suitable for habitation
will require considerable expenditure of public funds
towards earthworks and the construction of a sea-wall
as well as the provision of roads, drainage, water,
electricity and other facilities. The cost of
earthworks alone has been estimated at $40,000.
In view of the heavy expenditure required to settle a
few more families in this area, the Government
considers that alternative means may have to be found
to solve the housing problem of the applicants, as it
is evident that the advantages to be gained from the
expenditure of funds at Ayer Gemuroh will be very much
less than if the same sum of money is spent on a
planned housing estate."