| Parliament No: | 1 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 26 |
| Sitting No: | 15 |
| Sitting Date: | 21-12-1967 |
|
Column: 1011
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
FIRST SESSION OF THE FIRST PARLIAMENT
PART III OF FIRST SESSION |
VOLUME 26 |
Thursday, 21st December, 1967
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Mr P. Coomaraswamy).
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Education.
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development.
Inche Buang Bin Omar Junid (Kallang), Parliamentary Secretary to the Deputy Prime Minister.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs and Government Whip.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta).
Dr Chew Chin Han (Tampines).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Chow Chiok Hock (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister for Finance.
Mr R. A. Gonzales (Serangoon Gardens).
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development.
Column: 1012
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Labour.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State for Culture.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (River Valley).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah).
Mr Lim Kim San (Cairnhill), Minister of Defence.
Mr Lim Soo Peng (Havelock).
Mr S. V. Lingam (Aijunied).
Inche Mahmud Awang (Kampong Kapor).
Inche Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Education.
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Culture and Social Affairs.
Inche Rahamat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajoo (Farrer Park).
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Crawford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance.
Mr Bernard Rodrigues (Telok Blangah).
Column: 1013
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang).
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang).
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teo Hup Teck (Jalan Kayu).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Minister of State of Defence.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng (Joo Chiat).
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Health.
ABSENT:
Mr Chan Sun Wing (Nee Soon).
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Mrs Devan Nair (Moulmein).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Deputy Prime Minister and Leader of the House.
Mr Wong Soon Fong (Toa Payoh).
Tuan Haji Yaacob Bin Mohamed (Southern Islands), Minister of State for the Prime Minister's Department.
Column: 1013
PERMISSION TO MEMBER TO BE ABSENT
Under the provisions of clause 2 (d) of Article
30 of the Constitution of Singapore. I have
granted permission to Mrs Devan Nair (Moulmein) to be absent
from the sitting of Parliament today, the 21St December, 1967.
| | (P.COOMARASWAMY) |
| | Speaker, |
| | Parliament of Singapore. |
Column: 1014
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
ORAL ANSWER TO QUESTION
RETIRED CIVIL SERVANTS
(Re-employment in Government service)
1. Mr Ang Nam Piau asked the Minister for
Finance (a) how many civil servants have retired
on reaching the age-limit since 9th August, 1965;
(b) how many of them have been re-employed in
Government service and which department employs
the most; (c) how many retired officers have been
re-employed for more than one year, the reasons
for their continued employment and the basic
salaries they are being paid; and (d) if
Government will consider avOiding the re-employment of retired officers for more than one
year so as to make more jobs available for
Singapore's growing population.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Sir,
a total of 1,075 civil servants retired on
reaching the age limit since 9th August, 1965.
Of these, 73 persons or 6.8 per cent have been
re-employed. The hospitals and primary schools
employed ihe largest numbers. The hospitals le
employed a total ef 16 pensioners, 14 of whom are
medical ancillary staff and 2 are medical
officers. The primary schools re-employed 12
retired teachers.
Twenty-nine retired officers have been re-employed for more than one year. A re-employed
pensioner is normally paid four-fifths of basic
salary and variable allowance or the difference
between his last drawn salary and his pension,
whichever is the lesser.
The Government does not re-employ retired
officers without good reason. The number of
retired officers re-employed for more than one
year, namely, 29, will not make any difference to
the level of unemployment.
Inche Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan)(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, if I am not wrong, the Minister
for Education has stated that there are enough
teachers. Why are retired teachers now being re-employed?
Column: 1015
Dr Goh Keng Swee: There are only 12 retired
primary school teachers. I do not think that is a
very large number.
Column: 1015
BILLS INTRODUCED
CORPORATION DUTY (REPEAL) BILL
"to repeal the Corporation Duty Ordinance
(Chapter 159 of the Revised Edition)",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by the Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee);
read the First time, to be read a Second time on
the next available sitting of Parliament, and to
be printed.
Column: 1015
REDUNDANCY PAYMENTS
FUND BILL
"to establish a Redundancy Payments Fund and for
matters connected therewith",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by the Minister for Labour (Mr Jek Yeun Thong);
read the First time, to be read a Second time on
the next available sitting of Parliament, and to
be printed.
Column: 1015
CONSIDERATION OF MORE THAN
ONE ITEM OF SUPPLY BUSINESS
Resolved, "That, notwithstanding the Standing
Orders, the second and third readings of the
Supply Bill for 1968 and the Supplementary Supply
Bill, 1967, be taken today." - [Dr Goh Keng Swee].
Column: 1015
SUPPLY BILL
Order for Second and Third Readings read.
2.36 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
The Main Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure
for the year 1968 have been considered and
approved by the House as Cmd. Paper 26 of 1967.
Under section 85 of the Constitution of Singapore,
Column: 1016
Heads of Expenditure other than statutory
expenditure to be met from the Consolidated Fund
have to be included in a Bill to be known as the
Supply Bill. The purpose of such a Bill is to
provide for the issue from the Consolidated Fund
of the sums necessary to meet the expenditure and
the appropriation of these sums for the purposes
specified therein.
The Supply Bill before Members is to give
legislative approval for the issue of funds from
the Consolidated Fund to meet the sums of
expenditure for 1968. In the Schedule to the Bill
are shown the various Heads of Expenditure and the
sums that may be incurred in respect of each Head.
These have been approved by the House in the
Estimates of Expenditure for 1968 and appear in
pages 53 and 54 of Paper Cmd. 26 of 1967.
Once the Supply Bill is approved, I will be
empowered to issue warrants authorising
expenditure up to the amount under each Head as
shown in the Bill to be paid out of the Consolidated Fund.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Third Reading
Mr Speaker: Dr Goh, will you please move the
Third Reading?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Third time."
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1016
SUPPLEMENTARY SUPPLY BILL
Order for Second and Third Readings read.
2.38 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
Column: 1017
The purpose of this Bill is to provide statutory
authority in accordance with clause 2 of Article
85 of the Constitution of Singapore for additional
provisions for expenditure in excess of the pro
visions for expenditure authorised in the Supply
Act, 1966. These additional sums have been
scheduled as Supplementary Estimates and laid
before Parliament.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Third Reading
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Third time."
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1017
LABOUR (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.40 p.m.
The Minister for Labour (Mr Jek Yeun Thong): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
This is a short Bill. Its purpose is to seek
discretionary powers for the Minister to grant
exemptions from the prohibition of female workmen
working at night. "night" in the context of the
present provisions of the law means a period of
not less than 11 consecutive hours including the
interval between ten o'clock in the evening and
five o'clock in the morning or such other interval
of seven hours as the Minister may by notification
in the Gazette prescribe for any particular
industrial undertaking or branch thereof or kind
of labour. The restriction on the employment at
night of female workmen is in accordance with the
requirements of the International Labour
Convention and was introduced into the Labour
Ordinance in 1955. The situation then existing did
Column: 1018
not warrant the employment in Singapore of female
labour at night. However, with the increasing
impetus of industrialisation in Singapore, certain
export-orientated industries find it increasingly
difficult to meet production targets without
introducing a night shift in which female
employees may have to be employed in certain kinds
of labour. The law as it stands, however, will not
permit the employment of female workers beyond
twelve midnight in view of the very restrictive
interval period of seven hours contained in the
law. Apart from allowing for the variation of this
prohibited interval, there is no provision for the
lifting of the restriction entirely in certain
cases. The structure of our economy has changed
and will continue to change more speedily with the
progress of industrialisation, and it will be
necessary, in the interest of the economy, for
some factories, especially those which are export-orientated, to work on a 24-hour shift system
which will involve the employment of female
workmen at night in certain kinds of labour. It
is, therefore, necessary to take account of the
situation to ensure that existing legislation does
not stifle industrial progress and expansion and
deprive the creation of employment opportunities
to our people. The logic of the situation demands
that the present legal restriction on the
employment of female workers during a night shift
should be relaxed so that certain industries or
undertakings can introduce a night shift and
increase their productive capacity to meet the
demands of our export market. What is even more
important to us is that by allowing female workers
to work in the third shift, we are able not only
to utilise the expensive equipment and factory
space more profitably, but also to create more
employment opportunities for our workers. A number
of countries have provided for the relaxation of
night work in respect of female employees. These
countries include the United Kingdom and Japan. It
is pertinent to point out that highly
industrialised countries have thought it necessary
to relax the restriction in the interest of
Column: 1019
their economy and, therefore, a relaxation of this
nature would be of even greater benefit to a
developing economy such as ours.
Mr Speaker, Sir, there are certain categories
of female employees who even now work in shifts
round the clock, tor example, nurses and airline
workers in consonance with the social and economic
demands of these vocations. It must also be
mentioned that our female population today is more
progressive and sophisticated than they were
before, and that the well-developed social
services in the country serve their needs most
satisfactorily, both from the health and security
points of view.
The present amendment does not do away with the
existing restrictions, but only gives powers to
the Minister to grant exemptions where it is
desirable in the public interest to do so for the
purpose of maintaining or increasing the
efficiency of industry. It will not in any way
affect the protection that female employees now
enjoy, because before an exemption is granted
their interest will be very carefully considered
and in most cases we will consult the union before
we agree to exempt. But this is only applicable to
those unions which are willing to work with the
law. To the Communist-controlled unions which have
every intention to break the law, I say it is a
waste of time to consult them.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng (Joo Chiat):
Mr Speaker, Sir, I know it is rather difficult to
use certain terms and words. But these two words
"female workmen" really offend me. I cannot, for
the life of me, understand why our workmen should
become females. Why cannot we use better terms
like "female labourers", "female employees" or
"female workers", rather than "female workmen"?
Mr Speaker: I seem to remember that these are
words used in the Ordinance which this Bill seeks
to amend.
Column: 1020
Mr Bernard Rodrigues (Telok Blangah): Mr Speaker, Sir, I rise in support of
the proposed Labour (Amendment) Bill, 1967. My
reason in supporting the proposed amendment Bill
is that, from my experience as one of the
secretaries of the Pioneer Industries Employees'
Union, I have found that the absolute prohibition
against the employment of female workers in night
shifts is not conducive to [he industrial
development of Singapore.
There are certain industries, such as the
textile industry, where the jobs to be performed
by workers are of a very delicate nature requiring
infinite patience and a light touch. For such kind
of work, women workers are riiore suitable than
male workers. But because of the present absolute
prohibition against employing women workers on
night shifts, employers in such industries have no
other choice but to employ male workers during the
night shifts. As to why night shifts are
necessary, the explanation is that because it is
economical to utilise a set of equipment
continuously rather than to utilise double the
equipment half the time only. Also, the exigency
of business may require factories to operate
continuously for 24 hours a day in order to enable
deadlines for deliveries to be met.
During the present session in this House,
Members have heard the Minister for Finance
analyse the economic situation in Singapore and
emphasise the need for Singapore to develop more
industries and to cultivate a bigger export
market. One factor which may attract foreign
investors to Singapore and determine the
competitiveness of Singapore goods in foreign
markets is productivity of labour. The use of male
workers on night shifts in industries where women
workers are more suitable is not a circumstance
which is conducive to the promotion of higher
productivity of labour. Members of this House may
then ask why it is not satisfactory to employ male
workers in such industries. One explanation may be
that male workers who are employed on
Column: 1021
such night shifts find the work uninteresting and
uninspiring. Another explanation may be that male
workers do not have the necessary patience of the
female workers to do such work. Then again, the
wage level in such industries may be lower than
the wage level in other industries in the Jurong
Industrial Complex. I shall be talking more about
this wage level later on. But for the present I
shall confine myself to the explanation why
employment of male workers instead of female
workers on night shifts in certain industries is
not satisfactory. Because of the many reasons
which I have just enumerated, there is a high
turnover among the male workers who are at present
employed in night shifts as a result of the
absolute prohibition against female workers.
I am sure that Members of the House will agree
with me that any high turnover of labour force,
whether involving male workers or female workers
in any industries, is not a satisfactory
situation. In such industries where women workers
are more suitable, it must also be appreciated
that workers employed in such industries must
undergo long intensive periods of training. The
wastage of labour, therefore, can be imagined when
workers leave their employment immediately after
the end of the period of training or even before
the end of the period of training. Because of such
workers leaving their employment, new workers have
to be employed to take their place and this means
that new employees must undergo similar long
intensive periods of training. In such a situation
it is not difficult to understand that the workers
cannot attain a higher level of efficiency during
their period of training. And this is the
situation in those industries where female workers
are more suitable but are prohibited from work on
night shifts, because of the high turnover of male
workers employed on such night shifts. The
production of the factories involved suffers as a
result.
Column: 1022
It was in these circumstances that some of the
employers who are most affected by the absolute
prohibition against the employment of women work
ers on night shifts approached me to make
representations to the Minister for Labour in
respect of section 50 of the Labour Ordinance, so
that the absolute prohibition against the use of
women workers on night shifts should be removed.
I, accordingly, conveyed their views to the
Minister who, I am happy to say, is also of the
view that the absolute prohibition is impractical
and not conducive to the industrial development of
Singapore. It must be pointed out that the Labour
Ordinance was enacted at a time when Singapore's
economy was essentially orientated to the export-import trade. There were then not many
manufacturing industries, and those that existed
do not justify the use of women workers on night
shifts. The present situation is different. At the
risk of repeating myself, I must point out that
there are now in Singapore many industries where
women workers are more suitable than male workers.
This situation will continue in future when more
industries are attracted to Singapore, but such
industries which require women workers may be
discouraged from coming to Singapore if they find
that they cannot employ women workers on night
shifts.
The present amendment will remove the absolute
prohibition against the employment of female
workers on night shifts and substitute in its
place a qualified prohibition with an enabling
provision for the Minister to exempt any industry
or branch thereof from such prohibition. I think
the statutory safeguard against the exploitation
of women workers by unscrupulous employers is
adequate. And I am sure the Minister will make an
exhaustive investigation before granting exemption
from such prohibition to any employer making an
application to him in that behalf. I, as an
official of the Pioneer Industries Employees'
Union, can assure Members of the House that the
union will also see to it that, where women
workers are employed on night shifts, all of them
will receive the special allowance
Column: 1023
or night-shift premiums in line with those
prevailing among the other industries in the
Jurong Industrial Complex.
In this context, I wish to make some reference to
the surprising remarks of the Member for Delta,
who has said that the whole of the Jurong
Industrial Complex is one big chaos, presumably including the Pioneer Industries Employees' Union.
As to the specific allegation that workers,
particularly women workers, are earning a wage of
$2.50 per day, I wish to point out that these are
allowances paid during th.e period when the
workers are receiving training. Such periods of
training are seldom more than six months, and once
they have completed their training, workers receive an immediate increase in wages. I can assure
the House that the use of women workers on night
shifts does not necessarily mean exploitation of
women workers. My union, the Pioneer Industries
Employees' Union, in spite of the derogatory
remarks made about it, has always protected and
promoted the interests of the workers and will
continue to do so in the Jurong Industrial Complex.
Finally, if there is any significant number of
workers who are not members of the union, it is
because they are still under training or on
probation. Such workers may not be able to become
members of the union. This is an accepted
principle in industrial relations in Singapore.
But if the Member for Delta knows of any specific
instance of exploitation in Jurong, I should think
it is her duty to furnish such particulars to the
Ministry of Labour, if not to the union.
2.55 p.m.
Inche Mohd. Ariff(In Malay): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I cannot understand the intention of
the Minister for Labour in bringing forward this
amendment Bill which precludes women from working
at night. It is correct that female workers should
not be asked to work at night. If there are female
workers working in industries, they should work
during the day. The place for female workers,
especially married female
Column: 1024
workers, to work at night is the house, in the
house they can look after their husbands and
children whom they leave during the day. To the
best of my knowledge, the wife of the Minister for
Labour is working. I am quite sure he does not
wish his wife to work at night, leaving him alone
to tend to the children.
Mr Speaker, whilst not allowing female workers
to work at night, according to section 50
subsection (1), the Minister may exempt any
employer from asking his female workers to work at
night, if he is satisfied with his application
that it is in the public interest or to increase
efficiency of the industry.
Mr Speaker, the Minister for Labour is of the
opinion that female workers when working at night
are more efficient than male workers, but I cannot
see how female workers can show extra skill or
increased efficiency in this respect. I have also
heard from the Member for Telok Blangah just now
that female workers are more patient than their
male counterparts. I would like to cite an example
in the Singapore Telephone Board. Previously the
telephone operators who worked from 7 a.m. to 5
p.m. were female operators, and from 7 p.m. to 7 a.m. the switchboards were attended to
by male operators. But now for 24 hours of the day
the trunk call and inquiry services are looked
after by female operators. According to the
employers, this is to increase the efficiency of
the S.T.B. But both the female and male operators
have the same kind of work at the switchboard -
connect the plug, enquire and pull it out. If this
is a means to attract callers, then this may be
the reason. I cannot, however, see the extra
efficiency of female operators. I hope this
amendment will increase the efficiency of the
industries and I also hope it will not be a source
of inconvenience to the household. Mr Speaker, I
trust the Minister, when exercising his
discretionary powers to exempt applications from
employers, will consider whether they are for a
good purpose or not.
Column: 1025
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I fully
understand the intention of the Labour Minister in
introducing this amendment Bill, which is to gear
our legislation to the industrialisation of
Singapore. We know that this is a very competitive
age. In order to progress in our indus
trialisation, it is necessary to increase the
efficiency and productivity of our labour. This is
a good intention from the outset. But it may give
rise to two problems. Firstly, as the Member for
Telok Blangah has said, the wages of female
workers are lower than those paid to male workers.
I do not know whether there is really some form of
exploitation, because if low wages are paid to
female workers, then employers will tend to employ
more female workers. As a result, there will be
more unemployment among the male workers. This is
one point which I wish to bring to the attention
of the Minister. Mr Speaker, in order to give
facilities to and make it convenient for the em
ployers, we must advise them not to exploit the
situation.
The second problem arises in cases where
employers may have female workers. If night shift
is compulsory for female workers, then some
inconvenience will be caused to the household of
the female workers concerned. Before any
compulsion is exercised on working night shifts,
the employers should ask the female workers
whether they agree to working night shifts or not.
If some female workers are not prepared to work
night shifts, I think they should not be asked to
do so.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, I only wish to touch
on one aspect of this Labour (Amendment) Bill. It
is the labour policy of the Government to help the
workers. This is a progressive policy which is
difficult to find in South-east Asian countries.
We have every reason to be very proud of it.
Comparatively speaking, our labour policy is
better and more enlightened than that of other
neighbouring countries in this region. However, in
my humble view, if we have a new labour policy,
then there
Column: 1026
should be no distinction between female workers
and male workers in respect of labour. They are
workers all the same. We should not distinguish
between the sexes as far as labour is concerned.
It is the policy of the P.A.P. Government not to
make a distinction between the sexes. Of course,
in anatomy there must be some differences. A male
is a male. But in so far as the working class is
concerned, there should be no distinction between
female and male workers. In my view, there should
be equality between workers of the two sexes,
equal pay for equal work. This is in the manifesto
of the P.A.P. According to this progressive labour
policy, if we should come across any female
workers receiving lower wages than men, then, as a
progressive labour Government, we should not allow
this to happen.
Mr Speaker, I spoke earlier in this House about
the poor treatment given to workers in the Jurong
Industrial Complex. I was not talking about female
workers particularly. I was just passing a general
remark that the wages paid in the Jurong
Industrial Estate are generally poor. We should
not sacrifice the interest of labour in order to
cut down the cost of production. It is on this
point that I spoke earlier. We must give some
thought to the question of whether labour will
benefit by this kind of productivity increase. We
should not gauge the cost of production in terms
of labour only. We must not forget that if we cut
down the cost of production in terms of labour
only, that will give more benefit to the employers
and the capitalists. It is the business of employ
ers and employees together to shoulder a lowering
of the cost of production. I think the wages of
female workers are not so attractive as those paid
to the male workers. I do not know whether the
Labour Minister is aware of this. In my
constituency there are many female workers working
in the Jurong Industrial Estate. When I saw them,
they expressed the same sentiments. Mr Speaker, I
do not want to bring this matter up myself because
Singapore has many unions in existence and because
I do not want to show off. The unions have enough
strength to speak
Column: 1027
for the workers, it is my hope that the labour
leaders will make clear their attitude on this
point. But as a representative of the people and
since such views have been expressed by the voters
in my constituency, I have to bring them up in
this House. A progressive labour policy should
make no distinction between the sexes. All workers
must be given equal treatment and eoual wages.
Only then will there be no chance for the
employers to exploit the situation by way of a
disparity in the wages of female and male workers.
In this way the female workers will not be
exploited. Mr Speaker, if we allow this situation
to go on, then the tendency among employers will
be to employ more female workers and that will be
against our progressive labour policy. I do not
think the labour leaders will allow this to
happen, although most of them are of the male sex.
I do not believe the males will allow the females
to be exploited in this way.
In regard to night shifts for female workers in
this amendment Bill, several Members have spoken
on it. So far as I am personally concerned, the
main point will depend on whether there is any
necessity or justification for female workers to
work at night. There are many countries in Europe
where female workers work at night without causing
any inconvenience. In so far as security is
concerned, if female workers are safeguarded at
night, there will not be much trouble. That is my
view. Therefore, Mr Speaker, I hope the Minister
for Labour will take heed of the problems I have
outlined earlier and make some clarification.
3.10 p.m.
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Singapore has already
got the Women's Charter, and there have been some
amendments introduced in this House to improve it.
Now we are giving some thought to the labour laws
in regard to female workers working at night. We
are opening the door to female workers working
night shifts. Although it is your ruling, Mr
Speaker, Sir, that Members should not
Column: 1028
praise the Government too much, I feel I owe the
Government a duty to praise it in this respect. At
the same time ---
Mr Speaker: Mr Lim, I did not rule that Backbenchers should not praise the Government. Having
heard of complaints that they did not have enough
time on the Estimates, I said that if they did not
spend time praising the Government, they could
have that time to make their proper criticism of
the Estimates.
Mr Lim Guan Hoo(In Mandarin):
I thank the Speaker for his clarification. This
gives me encouragement to praise the Government
all the more. In short, the Labour (Amendment)
Bill and the Women's Charter are measures aimed at
the emancipation of the female sex. The idea
behind the amendment Bill is to give facilities to
female workers in cases where the work is more
suitable to them. The question that arises is
whether this amendment Bill will have any
repercussions. In some cases where the work is not
so suitable for female workers, will it be the
tendency for employers to employ more female
workers, instead of male workers? Will there be
any discrimination on their part between the
sexes? Is it possible to engage either a male
worker or a female worker? Will there be a
stronger bias against the males? Supposing you
want to engage a secretary, a male or a female can
do the job all the same. If you pay equal wages
for equal work, then, according to the Member for
Sembawang, this will give rise to exploitation.
There is bound to be a disparity in wages between
the two sexes.
Mr Speaker, I will now go to the second point.
Following the passage of the Labour (Amendment)
Bill, we can expect more female workers to appear
in our labour market, particularly in night
shifts. So the question of security measures
arises. I have some experience with regard to the
Redhill Industrial Estate. Previously some
factories in Redhill refused to engage female work
ers because at that time street lights were not
installed, so that some parts
Column: 1029
of Redhill Estate were rather dark. It was,
therefore, not convenient for female workers to
work at night. In spite of my repeated requests to
install lamp posts, we have not seen any in the
Redhill Industrial Estate. Because of the darkness
there was a sense of insecurity then among the
female workers who were called to do night shifts.
I hope that following the passage of this Bill,
appropriate steps will be taken to make working
conditions more conducive to the security of the
workers of both sexes.
3.15 p.m.
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah)(In Mandarin): Sir, what has been said by the Minister
for Labour to amend the Ordinance is to meet the
seriousness of the unemployment situation in
Singapore in the light of the economic situation.
In this context, this Labour (Amendment) Bill is
suitable, and I fully agree with it. But after
hearing the different speeches by the Members for
Delta and Telok Blangah about workers employed in
the pioneer industries in Jurong and other
industrial areas, it is not convenient for me here
to express any more points of view. If our
Government is a pro-labour government which adopts
a very enlightened policy on labour, I think it is
advisable to form an investigation committee and
go to the Jurong industrial area to investigate
whether it is true that the labourers there are
exploited by the employers, or whether they get
equal treatment for both sexes. This is my view.
3.17 p.m.
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson)(In Tamil): Sir, I wish to say a few words on this
amendment Bill. It looks as though the employers
will benefit by it, because the wages of female
workers are less. They will be of the opinion that
they may profit more if they employ female
workers. The men may take advantage of the
situation and send their wives to work at night
while they go off to sleep. If this is the
attitude of
Column: 1030
the men, then women will be working at night in
all the establishments. Why should we allow them
to work at night? We should provide security for
them and if they go to work after 7 p.m., their
parents or their husbands should escort them. So
it is not proper to send women to work at night.
Even if we have to do so, the employers should pay
them the same wages as the men. If we insist on
that, we have to see that the employers comply
with this request. I do not think this is proper
for the country or for the people.
The Labour Ministry says productivity will be
increased by the passing of this Bill. But this
aim may result in a decrease in production because
the employers may be employing female workers at
night and I do not think this will give any
benefit.
3.20 p.m.
Mr S. V. Lingam (Aijunied): Sir,
originally I did not intend to speak, but after
hearing some of the Members who spoke, I just wish
to say a few words. When the P.A.P. came to power
in 1959, it introduced the Women's Charter Bill.
Now we have the Labour (Amendment) Bill in front
of us, enabling women workers to work round the
clock. May I know when Government will introduce
an Act for men to safeguard themselves?
3.21 p.m.
Inche Rahamat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai)(In Malay): Sir, I support the amendment Bill because
we will stand to benefit both from the security
point of view and from the point of view of the
family relationship as mentioned by the Member for
Kampong Kembangan. But. I would like to ask the
Minister for Labour whether this amendment Bill
will be imposed on waitresses in bars and night
clubs who work beyond 10 p.m. If this is imposed
on them, it is good because it will be for the
benefit of our society at large.
Mr Speaker: I take it there are no other
Members who want to speak. Mr Jek.
Column: 1031
3.22 p.m.
Mr Jek Yeun Thong: Sir, the Member for Joo Chiat
is wondering why we call a woman a workman. I
really cannot satisfy his curiosity why we should
call a female labourer a workman instead of a
workwoman. I think this is the word in the
original Labour Ordinance where it is stated that
a workman means a worker whether it is of the
female or male sex. I think this is only for the
sake of convenience. Maybe the Member for Delta
has already answered the question when she said
that we must never emphasise the sex when we speak
of a workman. A worker is a worker whether it is a
male worker or a male worker.
I think it is rather old-fashioned of the Member
for Kampong Kembangan to insist that the female
worker should be allowed to work only in the day-time and not at night. He is also worried that,
with the passage of this Bill, telephone operators
and workers in other establishments will be
subject to this 24-hour work shift. I have said
just now that this law does not necessarily apply
to all the establishments. Once this law is
passed, it will still be necessary for a factory
or an establishment to apply for the right to work
female workers on a 24-hour shift. It is not
automatically the case that they will come in.
Initially we will only allow factories which are
export-orientated to put their female workers on a
24-hour shift. So the Member need not have any
worry that operators in the Telephone Board will
be put immediately on this 24-hour shift.
The Member for Telok Blangah and the Member for
Delta touched upon the low pay of female workers
especially in the factories at Jurong.
Mr Bernard Rodrigues: Point of clarification, Sir.
Mr Jek Yeun Thong resumed his seat.
Mr Bernard Rodrigues: Sir, I never said that the workers
are very lowly paid. I made a general remark, that
workers are paid according to the industry in
which they work.
Column: 1032
Mr Jek Yeun Thong: I beg his pardon. But last
Tuesday and also today the Member for Delta says
that female workers especially in Jurong are very
lowly paid. The Member for Bras Basah has
suggested that we should set up a commission of
inquiry to look into this matter. I do not think
this is really necessary. It may be a one-sided
affair because, according to a sample survey
conducted in July 1966, the monthly average
earnings of female workers of 18 years and above
in all factories was
$100.80, and the highest average monthly earnings
of $120.90 was recorded in the tobacco, cigarette,
cigar and other tobacco product industry, whilst
the lowest average monthly earnings of $70.50 was
recorded in the paper product, including
stationery and hard boxes, industry. The main
factor affecting the differences in the rates of
pay of female workers in various occupations and
industries is the skill required in the
performance of the job. In other words, the
greater the skill, the higher the rate of pay.
This is clearly manifested by the figures already
given for the paper product industry in which
unskilled labour is involved, as against the
relatively higher monthly earnings in the tobacco,
cigarette and cigar industry. In the textile and
garment industry, the predominant rates of pay for
female workers, other than those who are under
training or who are partially trained, vary from a
minimum of $2.70 to $2.90 per day of eight hours
in such occupations as weavers, spinners, knitters
and twisters. Whilst in the shirt and garment
manufacturing industry, the average wages per day
range from $2.58 to $3.24, in occupations such as
cutters, sewing-machine operators, iron workers,
packing workers and seamstresses, the average
wages are up to $5.49 per day. However, during the
period of training which ranges from one month to
six months, female workers are paid from $1.50 to
$2.25 per day according to the trade in which they
are being trained. After training,
Column: 1033
they are generally put on piece rates subject to a
minimum earning of $2.50 per day, which is the
amount an inefficient worker earns. A worker with
greater productivity earns from $4 to $5 per day
and even up to $8 in the case of some workers in
one particular factory. In other words, the
earnings are dependent on the skill of the worker,
and the greater the skill and productivity of the
worker, the higher the earnings. It is quite
evident that no factory will pay a worker much
more than he or she is worth in terms of
production. If labour costs are artificially
inflated merely to increase the earnings of the
workers even though their productivity is low, no
one is going to open a factory in Singapore. The
intelligent way to deal with this problem is to
help the workers to improve their skills so that
they may earn more.
The National Productivity Centre at J urong is
now considering the introduction of three
industrial training classes for new workers before
they get into the factories. The objective of
these classes is to acclimatise the workers to a
working environment with some rudimentary
knowledge of the trade into which he or she will
enter. This will enable them to imbibe more
quickly the skills required for the jobs they will
have to perform. These courses, in the initial
stages, will be mainly directed at producing
female workers for the textile industry so that,
with the skills that they will acquire in a
shorter period, they will start earning better
wages earlier. Indeed, trained textile and garment
factory workers can easily earn from $4 to $5 per
day with improved skills and better productivity.
Members of the House will agree that these rates
compare favourably with the rates given even to
male unskilled workers in many cases.
The Member for Sembawang is also afraid that by
putting female workers to work at night, it may
affect their family life. I do not think he need
worry about this because most of the workers in
these factories are between
Column: 1034
18 years and 22 years of age, and I do not think
that women in this age group have a lot of babies
to look after at home.
The Member for Bukit Merah is concerned about the
security of women who have to go home very late
at night. I think the answer, as he has said, will
be to ask for more street lights and to seek
better and more efficient police protection in the
area. But even at the present moment, without this
law being enforced, female workers still have to
go home very late, because they are allowed to
work up to 11 or 12 o'clock at night. But, on the
other hand, if this, law is passed whereby a woman
is allowed to work the third shift, then, instead
of going home at 11 or 12 o'clock midnight, she
may have to go home very early in the morning, at
6 o'clock, in which case I do not think we have to
worry much about the darkness.
Madam Chan Choy Siong rose -
Mr Speaker: Madam Chan, Standing Orders do not
allow a Member to speak more than once except in
Committee.
Madam Chan Choy Siong resumed her seat.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Jek Yeun Thong.]
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1034
COMPANIES BILL
(As reported from Select Committee)
Order for Third Reading read.
3.35 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Third
time."
Column: 1035
Hon. Members will recall that this Bill, which
is comprehensive and far-reaching in its effects,
was referred to a Select Committee on the 21st of
December last year. Since it has taken one year
for it to come back to this House and the memories
of some Members may be short, I think it would be
of advantage for me to read part of the
Explanatory Statement to the Bill:
`The need for an up-to-date Company law has long
been felt, as the existing law, which is based
upon the English Companies Act of 1929, is now
completely obsolete.
Whilst Singapore was a component of Malaysia, it
was associated with the drafting of a new
Companies Act for Malaysia which took over
eighteen months to prepare. The Malaysian
Companies Act, 1965, was enacted soon after
Singapore was separated from Malaysia and came
into operation in April, 1966.
This Bill follows closely the provisions
contained in the Malaysian Companies Act, 1965, as
it is considered that Singapore's new law relating
to companies should not be different from the
legislation in force in Malaysia in order to
facilitate trade and commercial intercourse with
and within this region.'
Sir, the response to invitations for
representations was good. Fourteen written
representations were received and the Select
Committee heard oral evidence from eleven of them.
Some of these contributions were valuable and a
number of suggestions have been accepted. I will
not burden Members of the House with details of
the amendments which have been made during the
Select Committee stage. These are listed out at
pages C8 to C37 of the Select Committee's Report
which was tabled in this House on the 7th of
December, 1967, as Paper Parl. 11 of 1967. Most of
the amendments are drafting amendments, while a
number of them have been incorporated as a result
of representations made by the Singapore Society
of Accountants, the Singapore Association of the
Chartered Institute of Secretaries, the Singapore
Advocates and Solicitors Society, the Association
of Certified Public Accountants, the Singapore
International Chamber of Commerce and the
Association of Banks in Malaysia. To these bodies
and to others who made representations to the
Column: 1036
Committee, I wish to extend our thanks for their
valuable suggestions and assistance.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the amendments as have been
made by the Select Committee, while they have gone
a long way to refine the Bill, do not substan
tially alter the character of the Bill. One Part
of the Bill, Part XIII, relating to reciprocal
provisions with Malaysia, which authorises the
Minister to make arrangements with Malaysia for
their extension to Singapore of winding-up orders
made in Malaysia and for the extension to Malaysia
of winding-up orders made in Singapore, has been
deleted. Deletion of this Part is considered
necessary as clause 340 of the Bill, which is
similar to section 340 of the Malaysian Companies
Act, with necessary modifications agreed to be
tween Singapore and Malaysia, should meet the
reciprocal requirements.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the Bill, as now tabled before
this House, incorporates the recommendations of
the Select Committee.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1036
FINANCE COMPANIES BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.42 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee):
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
This Bill seeks to license, and impose minimum
standards on, finance companies which accept
deposits from members of the public. Heretofore,
such companies did not have to comply with any
requirements, save those under the Companies
Ordinance. Inasmuch as these companies are
custodians of the savings of individuals, it is
imperative that their operations should be subject
to Government supervision in much the same way as
banks and insurance companies are. As a rule, the
role of finance
Column: 1037
companies as financial intermediaries is limited
to the mobilisation of domestic savings to finance
the purchase of consumer durables. In the absence
of proper supervision, however, these companies
could turn into vehicles for risking household
savings on speculative ventures of the directors.
There are two limbs to the definition of
"financing business" given in clause 2 of the Bill
- (i) borrowing money from the public by
acceptance of deposits and issuing documents
acknowledging indebtedness and undertaking to
repay the money on call or after an agreed
maturity period; and (ii) lending money to the
public or to a related company.
With the coming into force of this Bill, no
financing business shall be transacted by a
company unless it is a public company and is in
possession of a licence granted by the
Commissioner for Finance Companies who shall be
appointed by the Minister. One of the conditions
for the issue of a licence is that the paid-up
capital of a company shall not be less than
$500,000. The Bill contains transitional
provisions enabling exemption of existing finance
companies from this requirement. It also allows
the licensing of unincorporated firms, such as
pawnbrokers who are now engaged in financing
business, on condition that they incorporate
themselves into public companies within three
months.
A finance company is prohibited from engaging in
trade or investing more than 25 per cent of its
capital and reserves in other undertakings. Nor
can it acquire immovable property otherwise than
for the purpose of conducting its business.
Unsecured advances are subject to a maximum of
$1,000. There is also a prohibition on a finance
company dealing in its own shares. Existing
finance companies who have so entered into any of
these prohibited transactions are allowed six
months, subject to extension by the Commissioner,
in which to liquidate such transactions.
Column: 1038
Every finance company is required to maintain a
reserve fund. This Bill imposes restrictions on
the declaration of dividends to shareholders until
a company builds up its reserve fund equal to its
paid-up capital. A prescribed percentage of a
finance company's deposit liability shall be held
in liquid assets comprising legal tender, bank
balances, money at call, and Treasury bills. Here
again, existing finance companies are allowed a
six months' period of grace to meet this
requirement.
The Minister is empowered to prescribe maximum rates of interest payable on deposits and chargeable on advances, the maximum amount of advances which may be made to any person or class of persons, the maximum percentage of total assets that a company may hold in particular types of
advances, minimum down payments and maximum
maturity periods for loans or advances. The
Minister may also prescribe reserves to be
maintained with the Accountant-General.
The Bill provides for periodic inspection by the
Commissioner of the books and accounts of a
finance company. The Commissioner is also
empowered to obtain such information and data as
he may require for the proper discharge of his
functions. If a finance company contravenes any
provisions of the Bill or carries on its business
in a manner detrimental to the interests of its
depositors or becomes insolvent, the Commissioner
may revoke its licence. There is also provision
for appeal to the Minister on the Commissioner's
decision to revoke a licence.
In the event of a winding-up of a company, the
depositors shall be deemed to be holders of
debentures secured by a floating charge over all
the property and undertaking of the company. The
liquidator of the company is enjoined to inform
every debtor of the company and to require him in
writing to redeem within three months any property
he had deposited with the company as security.
Column: 1039
Co-operative societies, banks, and the Post
Office Savings Bank are exempted from the
provisions of this Bill.
This Bill has been drafted with the assistance
of an expert sent by the International Monetary
Fund. It was the intention of the Government to
send this Bill to Select Committee so that the
views of the public and those whose interests are
directly affected by the Bill may have opportunity
of expression. Unfortunately, in the last few
months there has been a very rapid increase in the
number of finance companies. This proliferation of
finance companies can hardly be looked upon with
equanimity. Members will recollect that in 1962 it
was necessary to legislate for the control of
mushroom insurance companies. Many of these were
of dubious character and in the process of
liquidation, large numbers of innocent persons who
had placed their money with these insurance
companies suffered losses. I am not suggesting
that all or any of the finance companies now in
operation are of the same class as the insurance
companies. I know for a fact that a number of
finance companies have impeccable backgrounds.
Unfortunately, I cannot say this for all of them.
In view of the very rapid growth in the number
of new companies, it is necessary to pass this
Bill without reference to Select Committee so that
proper control may be established and that future
proliferation can be checked.
Since the introduction of this Bill, I have
received a number of representations from finance
companies and these are being studied. Every
consideration will be given to the representations
and, if necessary, this legislation can be amended
in an amending Bill. I must say, however, that I
am not in sympathy with all the representations
that I have received. We cannot have finance com
panies encroaching into territory which properly
belongs to banks. It is not an accident that the
growth of finance companies took place at a time
when control and supervision of banks were
tightened.
Having said this, I acknowledge that different
kinds of finance institutions are
Column: 1040
needed to mobilise our capital resources and that
a proper role must be defined for finance
companies. This Bill is the first attempt at the
definition of such a role. Some companies have
expressed alarm that `they would have to liquidate
some of their liabilities within six months. I
give them an assurance that an extension of this
period will be granted to' finance companies which
have genuinely been attempting to liquidate these
liabilities within the six-month period of grace.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
3.54 p.m.
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson): Mr
Speaker, Sir, the establishment of finance
companies in Singapore has recently been
increasing at a very speedy pace. They might not
be as prolific as the mushroom, but they certainly
have become, in total, a very significant and
influential financial institution in our economy.
Their influence and dynamism in our economy have
caused us no comfort. As representatives of the
electorate, we cannot sit back with little care or
total indifference. As influential financial
institutions, the finance companies operating i11
Singapore may be able to contribute significantly
to the economic well-being of our society if they
are brought under proper control. On the other
hand, they may render inflation-investment,
disequilibrium and even economic chaos should we
indifferently allow them to run wild. I positively
support and congratulate our Minister for Finance
on tabling this timely Finance Companies Bill to
regulate the operation of finance companies in
Singapore.
Taking a sweeping survey of the island, we
discover the following types of business
organisations operating as finance companies.
First of all, there are the so-called hire
purchase companies which deal with sales of motor
vehicles, sewing machines, television and radio
sets and other durable goods in instalments. They
call themselves hire purchase companies when, in
fact, they
Column: 1041
are conducting sales of goods in instalments. The
distinction between hire purchase and sales in
instalments is this. On hire purchase terms, the
goods are delivered to the buyer after he has made
a down payment, but the ownership of the goods
remains with the seller, while the buyer enjoys
the use of the goods as well as the option to buy
while making the monthly instalments. On sales in
instalments, the goods are delivered to the buyer
who is supposed to buy the goods without an
option; thus the ownership of the goods goes to
the buyer immediately. Against this legal
conception of hire purchase and sales in
instalments, we understand that hire purchase
companies finance the sales in instalments on hire-purchase agreement, giving the buyer no option to
buy, but the ownership of the goods remains with
the finance companies unless and until the final
payment is made. In other words, the buyer has to
forego the option to buy and yet he holds no title
to the goods.
Many hire-purchase companies of this kind are
being set up with very little paid-up capital.
They normally act as agents for big finance houses
to conduct hire-purchase transactions. Though they
deal in the borrowing and lending of money, they
operate under the Hire Purchase Ordinance and are
not in any way regulated or restricted by the
Moneylenders Ordinance.
Secondly, we have pawnshops all over the island
borrowing and lending money. The bulk of their
business is to lend money on acceptance of durable
articles, though title deeds are also acceptable.
The sources of funds for their operations are
their own paid-up capital, operating profits,
deposits from the public, and money received for
custody. Many cases of deposits of money received
for custody are accepted on a gentlemen's
agreement and business trust, with or without
documentary evidence acknowledging their receipt;
and there are not a few cases where the so-called
gentlemen's agreement and business trust are
rendered valueless as they are not enforceable
Column: 1042
in a court of law or even in equity. As
we have as yet no legislation or a statutory
prescribed rate of interest payable by pawnshops
to the depositors of money, the consideration
allowed for the deposit of monies with the pawn
shops remains a subject for bargaining. Mr
Speaker, Sir, we require very little imagination
to visualise a simpleminded member of the public,
with a sum of money and without any investment
opportunities, going to a pawnshop and bargaining
with a highly business-minded pawnshop proprietor.
Then we have the business-front organisation of
the banks, i.e., the finance companies wholly
owned by the banks. Openly these finance houses
are set up to conduct business transactions which
the banks are prohibited from doing. For instance,
the Banking Ordinance controls the payment of
rates of interest by banks to depositors for fixed-term savings, but the finance houses are at
liberty in this respect.
Of course, we cannot afford to deny the
importance of moneylenders licensed or unlicensed,
in the money market. Licensed moneylenders, on
obtaining a licence, automatically come under the
restrictions and regulations laid down in the
Moneylenders Ordinance. Unlicensed moneylenders,
though not legally recognised, or to be more
correct, they are operating illegally, certainly
have some business influence in business circles.
Last but not the least are the finance companies
incorporated under the Companies Ordinance. They
form the major arm in financing business. They
deal in heavy borrowing and lending, yet they may
or may not come under the restrictions laid down
in the Moneylenders Ordinance, depending on
exemption provided in the Ordinance being granted.
On exemption being granted, these finance
companies have a free hand in financing
activities. They are apt to charge the borrowers
exorbitant interest rates.
Mr Speaker, Sir, having described the aforesaid
categories of financial institutions, my
uncertainty, which I hope can
Column: 1043
be clarified, is this. Is the Finance Companies
Act, 1967, as introduced by the Hon, the Minister
for Finance, to be adopted for regulating and
controlling all categories of finance
organisations, firms, houses and companies? Sub-clause (1) of clause 3 provides that no financing
business shall be transacted in Singapore except
by a company that is in possession of a valid
licence granted by the Commissioner for Finance
Companies, and "financing business" as interpreted
in clause 2 means the business of borrowing money
and lending money. Am I to understand that a
licence is essential for all types of financing
business organisations irrespective of whether
they are under the regulations and restrictions of
other Ordinances?
Mr Speaker, in our society where public
economic planning and private enterprises are
operating hand in hand, certain projects are
operating under statutory bodies as monopoly under
takings and as an encouragement to commercial and
industrial activities. In the absence of national
finance organisations, financial institutions
operated by private entrepreneurs become the baby
to be taken care of by legislation. From the
economic point of view, the financial institutions
in Singapore are playing a supplementary as well
as a complementary role to the banks as evidenced
by the fact that most banks establish finance
houses of their own. A banking corporation in any
country, even in totalitarian States, is a vital
financial institution. The banking corporations in
Singapore, as elsewhere, owing to certain
limitations, statutory, economic or otherwise,
have not been able to serve the economy to the
best of their ability and because of this, finance
companies have come into the picture. One of the
financial activities which the finance companies
undertake to supplement those of the banks is the
tapping of the financial resources at large and
collectively channel them into fruitful investment
and development projects. Another financial
activity undertaken by finance companies to
supplement those of the banks is to providc loan
facilities, it is very well
Column: 1044
known that practically all banks in Singapore are
reluctant to provide long-term loans and even
their short-term credit facilities are available
only to selected clients and with the provision of
security. In the light of these wants and demands,
finance companies come in to make available hire-purchase financing, house and property mortgage
loans to individuals, machinery and equipment
loans to industries, and general unsecured loan
facilities. In summary, finance companies provide
services and conduct financing activities which
are not available from banks and these
supplementary activities help in accelerating the
economic growth of the State.
Mr Speaker, Sir, knowing the significant role
the finance companies are playing in the economy,
we recognise without any reservation the urgency
of a Bill to regulate and control the operations
of finance companies as financial institutions,
lest they run wild and give rise to inflation,
business disorder and economic destruction. In
addition to recognising the need of a Finance Com
panies Bill, I wish to reiterate my appreciation
of our Minister for Finance in introducing the
Finance Companies Bill. But while we recognise the
need for such a Bill to be introduced to protect
the interests of depositors and the general public
against unscrupulous finance institutions, there
is also the need to review some of the clauses and
certain provisions included in the Bill for the
implementation and administration of the Bill. I
know that the object of the Finance Companies Bill
is to safeguard the depositors and the general
public against any malpractices by some of the
unscrupulous finance houses. I also know that
impractical restrictive control will curtail
business activities or even make the finance
institutions extinct. The possible adverse effects
will no doubt bring home serious negative
consequences to the State. While supporting the
Finance Companies Bill in imposing control on the
operations of finance companies and welcoming the
introduction of the Bill, I wish, Mr Speaker,
Sir, at this juncture to make
Column: 1045
some constructive criticisms of some of the
provisions of the Bill. Firstly, clause 20 limits
the investment of finance companies to the extent
of 25 per cent of the paid-up capital. The purpose
of including this restrictive clause in the Bill
is presumably to prevent finance companies from
engaging in risky investment and investing in
unsound propositions. It may be necessary to
ensure the sound investment policy of each finance
company, but a flat percentage may not be a good
yardstick in ensuring a sound investment
programme.
Secondly, there is the provision prohibiting
finance companies from granting loan facilities of
an unsecured nature of more than $1,000. Without
the support of any statistical information, I can
safely maintain that $1,000 is too insignificant,
and to take that amount as the ceiling is very
inadequate. Bearing in mind the business volume
and the turnover of the unsecured loan facilities
granted and executed by finance companies, I have
no doubt that the ceiling of $1,000 warrants
reconsideration. As far as I know, Sir, there are
finance companies who grant unsecured loan
facilities to borrowers to as much as $10,000 to
$20,000. The turnover of unsecured loan facilities
to within $1,000 does not constitute much of a
total. I will pause just a while to ascertain the
implications of unsecured loans. Do we, Mr
Speaker, Sir, consider a loan granted to a
borrower who has a guarantor willing to undertake
to indemnify the repayment as an unsecured loan?
If the Bill considers loan facilities granted with
some personal guarantee are unsecured loans, then
I maintain that the $1,000 ceiling warrants recon
sideration. If the Bill considers that as a
secured loan, I shall withdraw my observation in
respect of this restrictive
clause.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I should be very grateful if
the Hon, the Minister for Finance would kindly
assist in clearing up my uncertainties.
In conclusion, Sir, I wish to give my full
support to the Finance Companies
Column: 1046
Bill as introduced by the Hon. Minister for
Finance.
4.11 p.m.
Mr Chow Chiok Hock (Ulu Pandan)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I have something
to say on this amendment Bill. Certain points
therein should be brought up for discussion. This
Bill will not actually promote economic activity
and increase the liquidity of finances in the
country to the fullest extent. We know that the
capital of these finance companies is obtained by
way of deposits from the general public. These
finance companies are quite different from
ordinary banks. Since our own people invest in
finance companies, the Government should look
after them. The depositors are mainly middlemen
and other small traders. Finance companies are not
like banks which are controlled by big
capitalists. Finance companies carry on operations
which banks do not like to undertake. For
instance, they provide loans to the ordinary
people to buy cars or houses, or to set up small
family or cottage industries. The ordinary people
can get such loans from these finance companies
which they cannot get from the banks. I feel that
finance companies have a great role to play in the
accumulation of capital and a very important place
in our economy. This Bill touches upon something
that is of great importance to the general public
as well as to the finance companies. I do not
oppose its introduction. This Bill regulates
financing in our economy and protects the
depositors. The Government will have to exercise
some measure of control over these finance
companies. But because of their close relationship
with the population, especially our small
merchants, I feel that if we control these finance
companies too much or too strictly, then it may
cause some undesirable consequences. These finance
companies have a very close relationship with our
small merchants, industrialists and ordinary
people. The Government should not discriminate
against them or single them out for special
treatment because they have some contribution
Column: 1047
to make to our economy. Yet there is a
provision in the Bill that a finance company
should have $500,000 paid-up capital and also a
certain percentage of liquid assets. In fact, the
capital invested in some of these finance
companies exceeds the minimum amount imposed on
the banks.
Recently there was a regulation that if a
foreigner invests $350,000 in local industries,
then he can bring his family to Singapore and they
can even become citizens of Singapore.
[Mr Lim Cheng Lock in the Chair]
4.16 p.m.
This may appear to some people as some sort of
favouritism and therefore we have to look into
this.
There is provision for the post of Commissioner
for Finance Companies to look after the operations
and accounts of finance companies. Will this
enhance the confidence of our people in finance
companies? This legislation is aimed at
safeguarding the interest of the depositors. We
should look after the interest of all the people.
We should base our viewpoint on the benefit which
these finance companies can bring to our economy.
We should bear this in mind.
The Minister has said that the Bill is for the protection or the security of depositors, but he has not looked into the consequences. I am worried about the consequences that may befall finance companies as a result of the passage of this Bill. I am also rather worried about the consequences it
will have on our economy, a great part of which is
motivated and stimulated by finance companies
through deposits by the public.
The Bill also provides that finance companies
should not undertake certain transactions, and
unsecured loans should not be more than $1,000.
Certain transactions which are not allowed under
clauses 19, 20 and 21 and so on, will have to be
liquidated within six months. If finance companies
had entered into such transactions and if they
have to
Column: 1048
liquidate them within six months, then they will
have to auction their assets and business. They
have to close shop as a result of this. And what
benefit will it give to the depositors if such
consequences take place? Also the staff of these
finance companies will be joining the camp of the
unemployed. In fact, people find it more
profitable to have immovable property in their pos
session. For instance, a finance company can buy
over a whole building for its operations and for
letting Out to other businesses. Money accruing
from rents would be sufficient to meet expenditure
on running costs, etc., besides leaving a profit.
The finance companies can pay the 36 per cent
property tax and 40 per cent income tax. In
addition to paying these taxes, they can also make
a profit. So there will be no loss to anybody.
Without the profit finance companies can secure
from this sort of operation, how can they pay
interest to the depositors? If they are required
to auction all their immovable property, then this
may shake our economy. As a result, some family
and cottage industries may suffer, because they
cannot get loans easily from big banks. So they
have to look to finance companies for unsecured
loans. The finance companies are the only
providers of loans to them. According to the
provisions of the Bill, finance companies are
prohibited from providing unsecured loans of more
than $1,000. This being the case, the small
industries will suffer. And if finance companies
comply with these provisions, there will be
liquidation within a certain period and the small
industries will again suffer.
I will now touch on the provision of unsecured
loans which should not exceed $1,000. If this
provision is to be complied with and other than
the liquid
assets the finance companies have, I feel there is
no security for the depositors because the finance
companies can also give large amounts of loans on
other things. There is also a provision stipul
ating that the loans given out should not be more
than a certahi percentage of its paid-up capital.
I should say some finance companies may find it
difficult
Column: 1049
to carry on with their business because of this
restriction. Small industries will also suffer. If
the Government's intention is to look after the
interest of the depositors, then I would suggest
amending clause 16 of the Bill which provides
that:
`Where a finance company has accepted
money from any person as a deposit the company
shall within two months after the acceptance of
the money issue to that person a document which
acknowledges or evidences or constitutes an
acknowledgment of the indebtedness of the company
in respect of that deposit.'
Now if the finance company does not issue a
receipt on the spot on receipt of the sum of
money, it can put the money away without issuing a
receipt or any document to show that it has
already received that sum of money deposited. Then
where is the security that is talked of which the
depositor can have? If the finance company has a
latitude of two months, then it may, perhaps on
the last day of the second month, issue a receipt
of acknowledgment and the depositor will lose two
months' interest on the amount of money deposited.
If such a thing happens, it will be a loss to the
depositor because he has lost two months' interest
on that amount of money.
I think there are other Members who want to
speak on this Bill. So I would not like to say too
much. I feel generally that the Minister should
not be too insistent. He should be more flexible.
He should send the Bill to a Select Committee and
hear representations from the people concerned and
amend the Bill if necessary so as to make it
perfect.
4.28 p.m.
Dr Chew Chin Han (Tampines): Sir,
the expressed purpose of this Bill is to safeguard
the interest of members of the public who deposit
funds with finance companies. In moving the Second
Reading of the Bill, the Minister for Finance
tried to make out a case for his new law. As in
any trade or business, there are good companies
and bad ones, good traders and bad ones, There may
Column: 1050
be a finance company formed by persons who require
money for their own business. They are unable to
obtain finance from banks or other sources of
loans and so they form a finance company to raise
capi.tal for their own business. There may be
others where the intention of the directors is to
collect as much money as possible from the public
on the promise of very high interest, and then do
a bunk. Finance companies which are formed on this
basis or which are run on these lines are a menace
and the public must be protected from them. But
the question I ask is, are these .the only types
of finance companies? The answer must be "No". We
have not heard of any finance company in Singapore
failing. There are many finance companies
operating in Singapore. Most are honest and
provide a very useful service to the investing
public who do not have enough money to buy
property. Also to those who do not understand
shares, they give a slightly higher rate of
interest than the bank gives. There are many
borrowers who cannot obtain loans from banks. They
say that banks only lend money to people who have
a lot of money and want to double what they have.
It is impossible for the small trader or the young
professional man who is just starting out in his
career to obtain any starting capital from banks.
In other countries, banks are not so old-fashioned
as Singapore banks. The small trader and the young
professional man in Singapore must turn to finance
companies. The explanatory statemen.t of the Bill
says that it is proper that finance companies
should wherever possible be assimilated with
banks.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
4.30 p.m.
Why must this be done? Finance companies are
very different from banks. If we pass this new
law, we may have no finance companies but numerous
banks in a few years' time. Where then is the
small trader or young professional man to go if he
cannot give security to obtain a loan of more than
$1,000? If the main reason for introducing this
Column: 1051
law is to control the bad finance company, is
there no risk that we will kill the good finance
company as well? There is a serious danger that
this will be the result because there is little
that is certain in a section of this Bill. A lot
of discretion is given. I am not a lawyer. From my
little understanding of this Bill, the
Commissioner for Ftnance Companies is going to be
made a very powerful man. He may even have more
powers than other civil servants except the
Banking Commissioner. Everything is left to his
discretion. Under clause 5, he can grant a licence
with or without conditions. He may refuse a
licence. No rules are laid down, though he must
act with the approval of the Minister. He need not
give reasons. There is no appeal from him. Having
given the licence, he may at any time vary or
revoke the conditions or impose additional
conditions. This is in clause 5 (4). Sub-clause (4) says nothing about the Minister's approval.
Again, no rules are laid down to say when the Com
missioner can vary or revoke conditions. All that
the sub-clause says is that he can do so at any
time. Furthermore, there is no appeal; no notice
is required. A provision like this makes the Com
missioner a very powerful man indeed! Clause 7
also gives him such powers. So does clause 8, but
here in sub-clause (4) there is a right of appeal
to the Minister. But under clause 28 (3) , the Com
missioner must act in accordance with the
Minister's directions. I am not worried about the
present Minister, but who knows what kind of a man
our future Minister may be? There is no appeal
under clause 9. Clause 10 gives a finance company
a chance to present a case to the Commissioner
before its licence is revoked. Why cannot this
also be done in clauses 7, 8 and 9? So far I have
referred to the Commissioner's wide powers over
the issue and cancellation of licences and
conditions. He has similar wide powers over the
regulation of business. By clause 15, he can ask
for all information and data as he reasonably
requires. There is no limit - only the
Commissioner's ideas of what is reasonable! He is
given power to determine the minimum
Column: 1052
amount of liquid assets. This is in clause 24. By
clause 26, he can order corrective action. What
does "corrective action" mean? He can tell the
finance companies to stop business. He can also
tell them how to run their business, and if they
suffer a loss, clause 30 frees him and the
Government from responsibility unless he is guilty
of fraud. He is given wide powers but no financial
responsibility. This is very dangerous. Is there a
financial wizard in the civil service who can tell
competing finance companies how to run their
business properly? If a company fails, the
directors will naturally tell the public, "The
company has failed because the Commissioner gave
wrong directions." They may be wrong, but the
public may blame the Government. Does the
Government want the blame? My fear is about the
Commissioner's powers. If such powers are given to
one civil servant, other civil servants may want
similar powers, because their work will be made
easier. The Director of Public Works will be
`tempted to ask for such powers over the
contractors and engineers; the Chief Architect
will want powers over the architects; the Attorney-General will want powers over the lawyers; and the
Director of Medical Services will want powers over
the doctors. If all these civil servants can work
well without similar powers, why should we give
them to the Commissioner? I hope the Minister will
explain the necessity for this unrestricted wide
power. I also hope he will tell us whether any
other country has a law like this and whether
officers in charge of finance companies in other
countries have similar power.
I support the general intention behind the Bill.
I would like the Minister to give clarification on
the matters I have raised and to inform the House
why the intention cannot be carried out without
giving such wide powers to the Commissioner for
Finance Companies. Furthermore, would it not be
better if the Bill were sent to Select Committee
because it is quite complicated? I do not believe
there is an urgency to push it through for Third
Reading today. I am sure that if it is referred to
Select
Column: 1053
Committee, we can have not only the views of
finance companies but also the views of banks,
depositors and borrowers. There might be a
proliferation in the establishment of new finance
companies, but if we pass the Bill quickly
without careful examination, it will carry a lot
of dangerous provisions.
Mr Speaker: I propose to take the suspension
now and will take the Chair again at 5.10 pm.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
4.39 p.m. until 5.10 p.m.
Sitting resumed at 5.10 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
Debate resumed.
Mr S. Rajoo (Farrer Park): Mr
Speaker, Sir, it is satisfying to note that the
Government has realised the need to control
finance companies in the interest of members of
the public. We have seen many finance companies
and institutions advertise attractive terms and
conditions which they claim to be in the best
interest of the general public, but can they deny
the fact that ultimately it is they themselves
which stand to gain more than the general public?
Nevertheless, taking into consideration the fact
that the finance companies do have a genuine
interest in enhancing the financial and economic
interest of the public in particular and the
State in general, it is the duty of the
Government to protect the public from any swindl
ing by some finance companies. For instance,
before getting a loan on the pledge of a motor-car or an article, some companies do charge
"football money" which i's illegal and which will
never come out in the accounts. I am not saying
that all finance companies charge "football
money", but some companies do charge it. By not
showing this income in their accounts, they do
not pay income tax. The borrowers, in addition to
paying the illegal interest, have also to pay
more than what the
Column: 1054
law allows. Will the Government do something to
stop this illegal practice?
The next point I want to bring up is that
finance companies charge 10 or 12 per cent
interest on secured loans on hire purchase. This
interest is calculated on the original sum lent
and is not calculated on the amounts due after
payment of instalments. So this so-called ten per
cent interest actually works out to more than 18
or 19 per cent. We have laws to see that
mortgagors do not charge more than 12 per cent on
secured loans, but in the case of finance
companies, the interest charged is actually more
than the interest legally allowed. I hope the
Ministry of Finance will look into this problem
and standardise the interest charged.
The last point I want to raise is with regard to
"chit fund" which is publicly known as "tontine".
There are a dozen chit fund companies in
Singapore which run chit funds and they deal in
hundreds of thousands of dollars. They are not
doing business on the accumulated capital hoarded
by them but on funds collected from the public. 1
do not know whether, under the present Bill
before this House, these chit funds can be
controlled by the Government. Recently, I heard
that some of these companies are unable to repay
to the depositors the amounts deposited by them
after an agreed maturity period. People who have
been convicted of criminal breach of trust and
people of not a reputable character are known to
be managing such business. I appeal to the
Government to bring these chit fund operators
under some form of Government control by way of
legislation so that the public can be protected.
5.15 p.m.
Mr Teo Hup Teck (Jalan Kayu)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, the introduction
of this Bill aims at strict control of finance
companies and the operation thereof. It also aims
at the protection of depositors who invest money
in them. Therefore, the intention is good in
principle, and I believe it is the aim of the
Bill to get rid of those finance companies which
are
Column: 1055
not properly run or not bona fide. But the
operation of this Bill may also affect those
companies which are bona fide. So, Mr Speaker, we
must accept the fact that a well-organised and
properly operated finance company is of benefit
to small traders and wage earners in Singapore. In
short, to the small man, finance companies which
are bona fide are good because they provide easy
and convenient financial aid. But we agree that
those which are not so good, of course, should be
dealt with. So before this Bill is passed in this
House or implemented in future, we should go a
step further and study this Bill more carefully to
see whether certain clauses in it are over-restrictive, thereby stifling the proper operation
of bona fide finance companies. We must see that
such bona fide companies are not adversely
affected by the operation of the law. On the
contrary, if operation of finance companies in
Singapore contributes to the prosperity of our
country, then they should be encouraged and not
restricted adversely.
Mr Speaker, if this Bill is passed hurriedly
without any overall careful consideration of the
various repercussions and consequences, then it
will cause some confusion in our society, parti
cularly to those who are now depositors. Ef such
depositors lose their confidence in the finance
companies, then some sensitivity will be caused
and a lot of depositors will queue up outside the
finance companies to withdraw the `money they have
deposited. This will give rise to very serious
repercussions and dangerous consequences.
Mr Speaker, I fully endorse the views expressed
by the Member for Ulu Pandan when he suggested
that this Bill should be referred to a Select
Committee for further careful consideration. In
this way, representatives of finance companies and
members of the Singapore Chinese Chamber of
Commerce and other interested parties, including
members of the public, will be given a chance to
express their views on this Bill. At the same
time, we can avoid the misunderstanding on the
part of finance companies in Singapore who may
allege
Column: 1056
that this Bill is introduced in order to assist
foreign capital at the expense of local capital.
Mr Speaker, generally speaking, we all know
that the role played by finance companies is
similar to that played by banks in Singapore.
Mainly their business is to collect deposits from
the people and give out loans at some interest. So
in this way they are the same as banks. And their
existence need not necessarily pose a threat to or
compete with the banks in Singapore.
Mr Speaker, I wish to quote the editorial of
the Sin Chew Jit Poh of the 19th of December. This
editorial made certain suggestions in regard to
the present Bill. It says that banks play a very
important role in the accumulation of capital, but
the role that they play has not reached the ideal
stage. The standard of living in Hong Kong may not
be as high as Singapore, but, on the average, the
population in Hong Kong have about $2,100
deposited per capita in the banks. This is higher
than the average deposit in Singapore per capita,
which is only $650. So the average deposit per
capita in Hong Kong is about three times that of
Singapore.
In this respect, if finance companies can assist
in looking for liquid assets or idle capital, then
the accumulation of capital brought about by the
finance companies will be of great benefit to the
industrial development of Singapore, particularly
in the field of investment. So it is clear that
there is scope for expansion of the business of
finance companies.
The editorial also dealt with three points. The
first point is that this Bill is actually a
duplication of the Banking
Ordinance, but it is more restrictive
than the Banking Ordinance. So because of this
Bill, the position of finance companies in future
will not be as good as that of the banks, and
difficulties will arise which may stifle the
flourishing business of finance companies in
Singapore. This may give rise to very serious
consequences.
Column: 1057
The second point brought up in this editorial is
that the future activities and businesses of
finance companies under strict control will not
function so well, and this is the negative aspect
of this Bill. As a matter of fact, it may be good
to protect the interests of the whole of society,
but in protecting the interests of the society,
particularly the depositors, we should also see
that the restrictive law does not interfere with
the role played by the finance companies in
national development. And so they should be given
the same protection as insurance companies are
given in Singapore.
The third point brought up in the editorial is
that the regulation of the operations of finance
companies in loans and mortgages and other aspects
is too restrictive. It suggests that if banks are
allowed to give loans on hire purchases and
mortgages, why cannot finance companies be given
the same facilities? If insurance companies are
treated as banks, why cannot finance companies be
similarly treated?
Mr Speaker, the existence of finance companies
is more or less complementary to the operation of
banks in Singapore. I would like to show in what
way this is true. Many small traders,
industrialists, or small manufacturers are unable
to get financial assistance from banks, but they
can get it from finance companies. This is one
instance of industrial or commercial activities by
finance companies, and in this way they make a
great contribution to our economy.
Clause 6 of the Bill provides that the paid-up
capital of a finance company shall not be less
than $500,000. But clause 17 (1) (c) provides that
any unsecured loans should not exceed $1,000. So
if a company has a capital of $500,000, its
unsecured loan is to be limited by this clause to
$1,000 or less. This is inconvenient to the
operations of the finance company, and I feel that
this clause should be reconsidered. We must see
whether the financial position of the individual
finance company
Column: 1058
warrants such a blanket restriction. In other
words, we must have some discretion in respect of
restriction of loans according to the paid-up
capital and the position of the individual finance
company.
Mr Speaker, if a finance company is big, bigger
than the others, then I think it can increase the
loan granted. In order to meet the very high
overhead expenses, some finance companies may
raise "football money" or the rate of interest in
respect of loans given out, and because their
scope of activities is narrowed down, their
turnover becomes smaller. So their profits may not
be able to meet the overhead expenses. Because of
this, some of the finance companies may have to
retrench their' staff and some may have to close
down, thereby giving rise to more unemployment and
aggravating our present unemployment situation.
Mr Speaker, clause 21 of the Bill' says that no
finance companies shall purchase or acquire any
immovable property. We must understand that when
finance companies receive deposits, from the
public, they pay interest. Therefore they must do
some business by way of loans given out at higher
interest rates. If there is a provision that no
finance company shall purchase or acquire
immovable property, then how do we expect them to
continue with their operations? Generally speak
ing, banks can make use of money in current
accounts without interest. This position which is
enjoyed by the banks is not enjoyed by the finance
companies. In fact, banks also levy service
charges to meet their overheads, even in respect
of current accounts. On the other hand, finance
companies do not enjoy such facilities. So if they
are to be more restrictively controlled than
banks, then in order to meet their overhead
expenses and to maintain their level of profit,
they will meet with great difficulties. In fact,
they may not even make a profit at all under these
stringent restrictions. The idea of this Bill, of
course, is to protect the interest of the public,
and the strict control of finance companies is
good only to this extent. Mr Speaker,
Column: 1059
before this Bill is read a Third time, it is my
humble view, a view shared by the Member for
Tampines and the Member for Ulu Pandan, that it
should be referred to a Select Committee for
reconsideration.
5.32 p.m.
Mr Ho See Beng: Mr Speaker, Sir, I rise in
support of the Finance Companies Bill whose object
is to license and control finance companies and to
govern matters connected therewith. Since the
purpose of this Bill has been made very clear and
specific, therefore, bona fide finance company
houses should have no cause for any undue apprehension.
Although clause 22 of the Bill provides that
within six months of the date of its coming into
operation finance companies are required to
liquidate all transactions prohibited by the
provisions of the Bill, nevertheless, Mr Speaker,
Sir, earlier on the Finance Minister has already
stated that consequent on the passage of this
Bill, if and when genuine grievances arise, he is
prepared to consider sympathetically their
respective difficulties.
An important feature of the Bill is the
restriction placed on the powers of the directors
and other officers of a finance company to deal
with the money deposited with the finance company.
This is very important, Mr Speaker, Sir, because
many members of the public are induced to place
their savings in a finance company by the
attractive interest rates offered by the company
on such deposits. Up to now, there is no specific
Ordinance to ensure that a finance company takes
as good care of such deposits as any honest
businessman will take care of his property. In
that sense, the Government should be congratulated
on initiating such a Bill. Mr Speaker, Sir, my
concern is this. As a socialist by conviction, I
feel that the the larger interests of the
community in stead of a microscopic few should be
given first regard. Sir, another concern is this.
As a trade unionist, I feel that if the Minister
for Finance can give
Column: 1060
his sympathetic consideration to genuine
grievances, there is no fear at all for bona fide
finance company houses having to resort to
retrench employees as a result of the passage of
this Bill. And if this end can be achieved, I will
propose to the Minister for Finance that the
day of the coming into operation of this proposed
Act is not made retrospective but is to take
effect in the near future. Hence there is no need
to refer this Bill to a Select Committee.
5.37 p.m.
Mr Lim Soo Peng (Havelock): Mr Speaker, Sir, the touchstone test of this Bill is
not so much whether it can control finance
companies, but whether it can control them without
killing them. With the present-day economic
arrangements of our society and of any advanced
society, there is no dispute that finance
companies do play an important part in our
economic life. Gone are the days when a person
wants something, he saves for it. Today he pays a
small down-payment. Sometimes he does not even
have to do that, and he enjoys the use of the
article he wants and pays for it in instalments.
Consumer credit is now the rule rather than the
exception. Under such circumstances, finance
companies are something we cannot do without. And
yet for a long time many people have felt that
they should be abolished. Sir, this is because
finance companies readily lend themselves to abuse
by unscrupulous people. One of the causes of
apprehension over the profusion of finance
companies over the past few years is that by their
very profusion they are forced by competition to
pay such high interest rates that they can only
hope to pay them by resorting to speculative
ventures. A large number of finance companies are
known to be speculating, and at times even wildly,
in properties and in the stock market. If a person
speculates with his own money, that is his own
funeral if he fails. But when a finance company
plays around with depositors' money, then clearly
it is the duty of the State to ensure that such
things cease. The present Bill before the House
does provide
Column: 1061
the means to restrict the number of finance
companies.
Clauses 5 and 6 provide the Commissioner not
only with the powers to shape the structure of
finance companies, but also to limit them. I
personally would have preferred to see the figure
of $500,000 in clause 6 doubled. But I do not wish
to press this point as I am confident that the
Government will not hesitate to raise it should it
become necessary to do so.
Another cause of apprehension over finance
companies is that few of them provide adequately
for bad and doubtful debts. This is so because
operators of finance companies prefer to lose
other people's money rather than their own. And so
they distribute as much of their profits as
possible and allow their depositors to carry the
risk of bad and doubtful debts. Clause 12 will, I
feel, go a long way to safeguarding the depositors
and, in addition, to providing a built-in growth
factor for the finance companies to grow to a
reasonable size. Of course, this clause will have
the disadvantage of inducing minimum initial
capitalisation even when funds are available. It
is conceivable that funds which otherwise would be
capitalised would be rearranged as loans. However,
as such an arrangement will be countered by the
liquidity ratio required by the Commissioner, I
feel that a correct balance has been struck.
Clause 14 requires that every finance company
shall exhibit its balance-sheet and the list of
its directors at its principal and branch offices,
if any. The company is also required to publish
its balance-sheet in at least each of the four
local daily newspapers in the four official
languages. There is no requirement to publish the
list of directors. A better requirement, I feel,
is to have the publication in the leading instead
of any daily newspaper in the four language
streams. I further suggest that the list o
directors should also be published. My suggestion
to have publication in leading newspapers is to
ensure that some finance companies do not select
Column: 1062
little-read newspapers for publication of their
balance-sheet and widely-read newspapers for
advertisements calling for deposits.
Clause 20, as it stands, can, I feel, be by-passed quite easily. The clause only requires that
a finance company shall not hold share capital or
have a direct interest in any financial, com
mercial, agricultural, industrial or other
undertaking, exceeding a quarter of its paid-up
capital and published reserves. This clause does
not, in my view, prevent a finance company
indirectly committing funds exceeding a quarter of
its capital and reserves. I should like to see the
clause rewritten to include a restriction on
direct and indirect participation exceeding a
quarter of the capital and reserves. The proviso
that excess share holdings acquired in the course
of debt-realising should not be allowed, appears
not to be necessary. Indeed, the very existence of
this proviso indicates the weakness of the clause
itself.
Clauses 25 and 26 put teeth into the provision
for supervision. As such, the penalty provided
under sub-clause (4) of clause 25 of $250 is
rather low. Normally one would expect that no
finance company would refuse to show its books and
data to an officer appointed by the Commissioner.
The occasion when it will do so will be rare but
very important from the point of security of the
depositors. I would suggest a heavier penalty be
provided. Mr Speaker, Sir, with these comments, I
support the Bill.
5.45 p.m.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Tiong Bahru)(In Mandarin): Sir, I support the Finance
Companies Bill. Why I support it is that in the
past the law has loopholes. For example, not long
ago there was an assurance company owned by a
foreign investor. He earned a lot of money.
Perhaps the people thought that he was from a
financially strong country. Therefore, many people
bought policies from him and he earned a lot of
money. He requested the Government to allow him to
remit his money back to his country. After
investigations, the
Column: 1063
Government found that he had no capital invested.
Why is it easy to do business without capital? It
is because we have loopholes in our law.
Therefore, we must revise and amend our law in
order to deal with speculators.
We know there are many finance companies in
Singapore. There are as many finance companies as
there are coffee-shops. Therefore, we should con
trol them. We must take care and look into the
matter. We know that the capital of finance
companies varies. Some have large capital and
others have less. But the business done exceeds
the capital. Where is the security granted to the
depositors? One day if the money is swallowed up
by the company, who is to repay the depositors? Is
it the Government? Therefore, I fully support the
Bill introduced by the Finance Minister. However,
we should refer it to a Select Committee in order
to study it in greater detail.
5.49 p.m.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten):
Sir, I do not in any way oppose the introduction
of the Finance Companies Bill which is now tabled
in this House for Second Reading. However, I wish
to offer my brief observations. First, I do agree
that there is a need for the passing of laws to
control finance companies in the best interest of
the public at large. The main purpose of this Bill
is to safeguard the interest of would-be
depositors who are mostly the working-class in our
Republic. This is a correct move and in line with
the policy of our Government.
Secondly, the provisions in this Bill are far
too rigid. They are designed not only to control
and restrict the establishment of finance
companies, but also to regulate the scope of their
business.
Thirdly, I would like to offer some suggestions.
The control must be gradual and not too rigid.
Sir, the provisions contained in clauses 17 to 22
are far too stiff and restrictive. The result will
be that the small trading houses will have to
close down and the interest of the
Column: 1064
public may be jeopardised and unemployment will
also result. The control and licensing of finance
companies would create an impression that finance
companies in general have been fiddling with
public money. I agree that there may be a few
dishonest and unscrupulous ones, and so there goes
the saying - a rotten egg in a basket of good eggs
has made the entire basketful rotten.
According to this Bill, the Commissioner seems
to have wide powers. The prescribing of the
maximum rates of interest - and they are going to
be ceiling rates - should be treated as a guide
rather than an order, as some companies may not be
able to pay such rates. As a matter of fact, it is
purely in the public interest to have an equitable
distribution of profits. Unlike service, the
payment of interest varies according to the sums
deposited. For example, if $10 million has been
utilised and if it has resulted in profits of,
say, $1 million, then the management of the
finance company will be able to pass on part of
the profits to the depositors according to the
amounts they have deposited. Surely any finance
company which can afford to pay such bonuses
should deserve the support of the public.
Fourthly, the finance companies in our Republic
do play an important role in our economy. This
being the case, the Government should encourage
the existence of such companies rather than push
them over the cliff, so to say, because of the
extremely restrictive measures in this Bill. To
me, some of the measures are even stricter than
those in the Banking Ordinance.
My fifth point is that at the present moment the
finance companies are carrying on a very wide
range of business ii our trading society. If too
many restrictions are to be imposed, the end
result will be that a few finance companies will
exist and this will, in turn, contradict the
policy of our Government to encourage industrial
growth, as a lot of small traders and small
factories are depending on loans from finance
companies to carry out their expansion programmes.
Column: 1065
Sir, I now come to my sixth point. As the
present position stands, finance companies have
actually participated in the development carried
out by the private sector, i.e., housing
development for the higher income group, for which
there is at the moment no government
participation. In this particular field, a lot of
private funds are involved and the depositors will
then in turn enjoy the benefit.
Lastly, I wish to urge the Minister for Finance
to refer this Bill to a Select Committee for views
from all sections of the public. I see no urgent
need to rush through this Bill today.
5.55 p.m.
Mr Govindaswamy(In Tamil): Sir, this Finance
Companies Bill has my full support. It is to
control the activities of finance companies and to
safeguard the interest of the public. The proposal
that this Bill should be sent to a Select
Committee is a means of delaying its passage. My
view is that it should be taken through all stages
and passed into law.
5.56 p.m.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi): Mr
Speaker, Sir, the advent of finance companies
seems to be quite a recent one. They have sprung
up like mushrooms. At a glance, they may be
classified into three categories :-
1. Finance companies which are subsidiaries of
banks;
2. Small-time finance companies which lend
money in respect of sales or hire purchase
of cars, taxis and even to kelong owners,
fishermen and farmers;
3. Large finance companies which operate
independently in the field of investment.
Sir, the fact that banks operate their Own
finance companies appears to stress the need for
such institutions. It also to a certain extent
reflects the inadequacy
Column: 1066
of the services provided by the banks themselves.
On the whole, finance companies do serve the needs
of certain sections of our population. One may
place them somewhere between banks and the
chettiars or moneylenders. For those who have
access to banking facilities and who are reluctant
to use the facilities provided by the chettiars or
moneylenders, finance companies will be in a
position to offer the necessary assistance in
their financial problems. The increasing number of
finance companies operating in the Republic does
point to the necessity of legislating certain controls over them.
About the Bill itself, my colleagues and I are
concerned about the ceiling of $1,000 for loans of
an unsecured nature. This will definitely affect
the small traders, farmers and kelong owners I
hope the Minister will reconsider relaxing a
little on these $1,000 unsecured loans.
Sir, if finance companies are to be allowed to
continue their operations in the Republic, they
should be placed under some control in order to
safeguard the interest of small depositors, but
they should be allowed reasonable scope for
conducting their business to ensure that there is
enough profit for discharging their obligations. I
am sure that the Bill, in spite of its
restrictions, gives genuine finance companies, not
the mushroom type, enough scope to do business and
make some profit.
Sir, originally I thought that after the Second
Reading of this Bill, it would be referred to a
Select Committee to enable the affected parties to
have an opportunity to voice their opinion.; or
make their recommendations. Sir, I would further
add that it would appear, at first sight, unfair
on the part of the Government to pass a Bill of
such a nature without listening to the views of
the public. I could not understand the urgency for
this Bill going through its Third Reading today,
but having heard the explanation of the Minister
for Finance, I am satisfied and convinced that the
earlier the Bill becomes law, the better it will
be for the have-nots.
Column: 1067
Sir, I doubt whether other countries have similar
legislation, but unique circumstances must be met with legislation. After all,
the P.A.P, is the People's Action Party, not just
in name only. If we are to protect the small
traders, fishermen and farmers from being swindled
by unscrupulous operators of finance companies, the
protection given by this Bill is very necessary.
Sir, I support this Bill without reservation.
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang): Mr Speaker, Sir, the Government's intention
of bringing in legislation to regulate finance
companies was first announced in last year's Budget
debate. It has taken a full year for the Bill to
come before Parliament. It is, of course, better
late than never. It is very necessary that
legislation be introduced to control what my
colleague calls the mushrooming of finance
companies.
The object of this Bill is to protect small
investors. That is what a socialist government like
the P.A.P, should and must do. It is ironical,
therefore, that some of my colleagues in this House
who are good socialists should have forgotten the
small man and have taken up the cudgels on behalf
of finance companies. I think the reason for this
is that my colleagues are labouring under the
misunderstanding of what a finance company is. In
this connection, Mr Speaker, Sir, may I be allowed
to read the definition of "finance company" in
clause 2 of the Bill:
`"finance company" means any company licensed
under this Act, to carry on financing business,
and all branches and offices in Singapore of
such a company shall be deemed to be one finance
company for the purposes of this Act;'.
We must now go further down and read what the
definition of "financing business" is:
`"financing business" means the business of -
(a) borrowing money from the public, by acceptance
of deposits and issuing certificates or other documents acknowledging or evidencing indebtedness to
the public and undertaking to repay the money on
call or after an agreed maturity
Column: 1068
period, which period shall be not
less than one month of the original
acceptance of any deposit; and
(b) lending money to the public or to a company
deemed to be related to the finance company
by virtue of section 6 of the Companies Act,
1967 (hereinafter in this Act referred to as
the "related company") on the basis that the
public or the related company undertakes to
repay the money, whether
within an agreed period of time or
not, or by instalments;'.
Therefore, Mr Speaker, Sir, it is very clear from
this that a finance company is a company that
borrows money from the public and lends money to
the public: that is, a company that makes use of
the public's money by borrowing and lending and in
the process makes a profit. If it does not borrow
money from the public, it is not a finance company.
So in order to fit in with the definition, it must
borrow money from the public and lend money to the
public. When a company borrows money from the
public and makes use of that borrowed money to make
a profit, it must accept a certain degree of
control. If, however, it makes use of its own money
and does not borrow money from the public, it does
not come within the definition and it can do what
it likes. It can establish a limited company and
throw away its money by taking unnecessary risks
and nobody will complain, much less the Government.
But finance companies are not making use of their
own money; they are making use of the public's
money. The Government has a responsibility to the
public and must see that the small investors are
not - to use a common phrase done in. Therefore, if
finance companies want to make use of the public's
money, they must accept certain responsibilities
and must equally accept a certain degree of
control.
Without exception, all finance companies are, as
far as I understand, limited companies. In law, if
a limited company fails, who is responsible?
Nobody. The shareholders or contributors of the
company are only responsible to the extent of the
unpaid portion of the shares which they hold and
generally these shareholdings are very small and
Column: 1069
normally they are fully paid up. So when a finance
company, which is normally a limited company,
fails, who is responsible? Nobody. The
shareholders have fully paid up their shares. They
will say, "It is just too bad. The company has run
unnecessary risks and it has failed." You can only
get hold of their common seal. The directors are
not responsible, unless, of course, they can be
prosecuted under the Companies Ordinance for
fraud, and it is always very difficult to prove
fraud. Even if you succeed in the prosecution and
send them to gaol, what does it benefit the poor
investor? It is small consolation and cold comfort
to a small investor who has lost his life savings
to see the director of a finance company sent to
gaol. In this connection, I must point out that
even finance companies which are subsidiaries of
reputed banks stand in the same legal position.
They may be subsidiary companies but they are
separate legal entities. If a subsidiary company
fails, the parent company, which is a bank, is
under no legal obligation to come to its aid. In
this connection, Mr Speaker, Sir, perhaps I may
be allowed to quote a passage from the Minutes of
Evidence taken before the Select Committee on the
Companies Bill. I refer to the Report of the
Select Committee on the Companies Bill [Parl. 11
of 1967]. I quote from column 37 at page B 19 of
the Minutes of Evidence. As you know, Mr Speaker,
Sir, I was on this Committee and this is what I
said:
`...Surely a wholly-owned subsidiary - a finance
company - would also be a limited company. The
bank is legally in the clear. Although, according
to what you say [meaning what the witness says],
there is moral responsibility, surely moral
responsibility is just not good enough. We want
legal responsibility for the protection of the
depositors.'
And in the Select Committee you, Sir, as Chairman,
said:
`I think Mr Tang's point is simply this.
You make use of a bank's good name in your
advertisements to get deposits for that bank's
wholly-owned subsidiary finance company. You
utilise the bank's good name without any legal
liability on the part of the
Column: 1070
bank. Let us say today you have the Pasir Panjang
Bank Ltd. It owns a subsidiary finance company
called the Pasir Panjang Finance Ltd. You see irs
the papers advertisements by the Pasir Panjang Finance Ltd.
stating that it is a wholly-owned subsidiary of
the Pasir Panjang Bank Ltd. So there full
advantage is taken of the bank's, good name and
that may well be the only reason why the public
deposits with that finance company, rather than
with an index pendent finance company. But, at the
same time, the bank is not in any way legally liable
should its finance company fail. A bank may have
the advantage of that finance company without any
of the attendant disadvantages. That is the point,
is it not, Mr Tang?'
And I replied, "That is right." The witness then
said:
`Mr Speaker, although there is no legal.
liability on the part of the bank, the moral
responsibility here, however, is very grave.'
You went on to say, Mr Speaker, Sir:
`I think we accept that. But Mr Tang's
point of view is that, if a finance company that
is a wholly-owned subsidiary of a bank, fails, it
will be poor consolation to the depositors who
have lost money even if that, finance company has
had the bank's moral.
backing.'.
And that is exactly the position with regard to a
finance company which is wholly owned by a bank. I
think it was very well put, Mr Speaker, Sir,
when you said that it was cold comfort to the
depositors.
Banks are strictly controlled because they also
make use of the public's & money for re-lending and
in the process make a profit. In the same way, the
finance companies do that on a smaller scale. If
banks are controlled, why should not finance
companies also accept some control?
Mr Speaker, Sir, I think most of the
complaints of my colleagues about this. Bill centre on clauses 19, 20 and 21. These are
restrictions on the type of business that a
finance company can enter into. I think these
complaints arise from a misunderstanding of the
functions of a finance company. If a company
professes its business to be that of lending money
to the public, and borrowing and using the money
for relending, why should it be allowed carry on
all sorts of trade, especially import and export,
which, unless you
Column: 1071
are in that line, is a very risky sort of
business? Again, why should a finance company be
allowed to hold more than 25 per cent of its
equity capital in the shares of any of the under
takings listed under clause 20 of the Bill? Clause
21 does not prevent a finance company from holding
immovable property as long as such property is
held as security and not as assets.
I think another complaint is that finance
companies are required to keep a certain liquidity
ratio. Again, I see no reason why this should not
be done. If banks have to hold a minimum liquidity
ratio, I see no reason why finance companies
should be an exception.
There are one or two minor complaints that I can
voice. One of these complaints, which I made in
the Budget debate, is the need to introduce legis
lation to control hire purchase, which is the
other side of the finance company's business. The
other minor complaint is the unhappy drafting of
some of the clauses of the Bill, especially clause
17. But as far as the main aim of the Bill in
controlling finance companies for the proper
protection of the small investor is concerned, I
am in hearty agreement with the Government, and I
support the Bill unreservedly.
6.19 p.m.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, the Member for Choa Chu
Kang was quoting from the proceedings of the
Select Committee on the current Companies Bill in
which the topic discussed was finance companies
which are subsidiary companies of banks, and it
was regretted that banks had only a moral
obligation and not a legal obligation to support
the finance company, so that the finance company
could use a bank's name and in that way attract
deposits. Here, Sir, in today's Straits Times
there is an advertisement, presumably inserted by
one of the big local banks, which disclaims all
connection with a finance company with a similar
name. May I read you excerpts from this
advertisement which appears on page 20 of today's
Straits Times?
Column: 1072
`THE OVERSEAS UNION BANK LTD, and the OVERSEAS
UNION GROUP offer to their customers a
comprehensive range of
services ... etc.
OVERSEAS UNION BANK LIMITED
and its wholly-owned subsidiaries:
OVERSEAS UNION BANK NOMINEES LTD.
OVERSEAS UNION INSURANCE LTD.
OVERSEAS UNION ENTERPRISE LTD.
OVERSEAS UNION GARDEN LTD.
To save confusion, may we point out that THE
OVERSEAS UNION BANK LTD, and the OVERSEAS UNION
GROUP have no
connections whatsoever with the OVERSEAS UNION
FINANCE LTD. of Singapore.'
Sir, when things have reached such a pass, that
finance companies resort to this kind of dubious
practice, I think it is absurd to suggest that we
refer this Bill to Select Committee in order to
allow more scope for rather dubious characters to
engage in this kind of dubious practice. So I am
afraid I cannot agree with the proposal from Mem
bers to refer this Bill to Select Committee, as
there is urgent need to see that control is
instituted forthwith over finance companies. In so
saying, may I repeat again that I do not regard
all finance companies as of a doubtful character?
I have stated in my speech on the Second Reading
that they do perform a useful role in society and
that we should try to allow them to fulfil this
useful role. The Member for Have-lock and the
Member for Choa Chu Kang have so clearly and so
forcefully put the case for control of finance com
panies that there is very little for me to say,
without repeating what they have already said.
But I do wish to refer to the points made by the
Member for Havelock. He said that we should not
try to control how people should lend their own
funds. That is not the case. We are trying to
control the means by which people lend other
people's funds. It is all right if you speculate
and make money; or if you speculate and go
bankrupt. No one is going to stop you one way or
the other. But we must make sure that you do not
endanger other people's money, and that when you
borrow money from the
Column: 1073
public, you invest it wisely and securely, and
that abuses of various kinds whereby directors of
companies can make use of other people's money to
get rich, must stop. This is the cardinal
principle underlying this Bill.
Critics of the Bill have said that it will bear
very harshly on finance companies and many of them
may close down. On the one hand, they say that
these companies are essential to the economy and
that they are being well run. In fact, the Member
for Ulu Pandan claims that in many cases their
liquid position is even better than that of the
banks. If that is so, what have they got to fear
from this control?
Many Members have stressed the need to safeguard
the interests of small borrowers who are traders
or small industrialists and have to go to finance
companies for finance. I can give an assurance
that we will do everything to safeguard the
interest of small borrowers from finance
companies, be they small traders, fishermen, or
small industrialists. What we want to prevent is
the wrong or inappropriate investment of other
people's money either in non-liquid or in
speculative ventures.
The Member for Tampines says that the
Commissioner for Finance Companies is a powerful
man. Of course, he is a powerful man. He needs the
power to control finance companies. How are you
going to ensure that adequate control is exercised
over these people if the Commissioner does not
have these powers? But what the Member for
Tampines has not said is that these powers are
unnecessary. He says that civil servants cannot
tell finance companies how to make a profit. I
agree with him. But we can tell finance companies
how their assets can be secured so that when their
depositors want their money back, it can be
forthcoming.
The Member for Tampines also asks:
do other countries have similar powers in their
legislation? The answer is: in other countries
finance companies are not allowed to be
established. You have
Column: 1074
to establish a properly-run bank, which is subject
to all the controls which a central bank
exercises over people who take in deposits and
lend out deposits. It is only here, due to a
lacuna in the law, that these finance companies
have been allowed to be established. We cannot get
them under the Moneylenders' Ordinance. We cannot
get them under the Banking Ordinance. Therefore,
it is necessary to introduce new legislation to
control them.
The Member for Jalan Kayu has not made any new
points. I think he has repeated the points made by
previous speakers, and I think the Member for
Havelock and the Member for Choa Chu Kang have
adequately answered all his points.
There is one point raised - that there is fear
that there will be unemployment as a result of
Government control of finance companies. Why
should there be unemployment? Unless, of course,
some of these finance companies are found to be
unsound, then they have to close down. If that is
the case, it is better that they close down early
so that fewer depositors lose their money than
that more people are stung.
The Member for Mountbatten, I think, has made
some valid points. He says that we must ensure
that the small businessmen who go to finance com
panies for credit are not endangered. I have
already given this assurance. Then he mentions
housing investments and says that many finance
companies invest in housing projects, and that
this practice is disallowed in the Bill. Precisely
so - you cannot take other people's money and
invest it in long-term projects, money which the
lender is entitled to have back, it is difFerent
if you use your own money. If a group wants to
invest in housing so that there can be better and
more houses, the proper way is to use its own
money to float a company and invite public sub
scriptions for shares and use the capital to build
the houses. You cannot use short-term deposits in
building houses.
Column: 1075
Unsecured loans have been limited to $1,000, and many Members, both critics
and supporters, think that this may be too
small. I am prepared to look into it. But at
present you cannot say to what
extent the finance companies are, in fact,
helping the small traders or small manufacturers.
We just know nothing about the way these finance
companies operate. My Ministry tried to get some
information and asked for returns. These com
panies refused to give any returns, so we just do
not know what they are doing, and how they are
investing their assets. Once this Bill becomes
law, it is my intention to call upon all these
companies to furnish me with the fullest details
of how they have been investing their money. If
it so turns out that a small trader or small
manufacturer will suffer considerably by the
limitation of unsecured loans -
The Minister of Defence (Mr Lim Kim San): None.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: - then I am prepared to
reconsider the matter. But my colleague and
predecessor, the Minister of Defence, under whose
skilful hands this Bill was produced, says none.
He is also an experienced banker. All the same, we
will give the benefit of the doubt to the Back-benchers who claim that small traders will be
affected and, if that is the position, we will
have a second look at this particular clause. In
the meantime, this Bill must go through and
controls must be imposed.
Mr Rajoo rose -
Mr Speaker: Mr Rajoo, you have already spoken.
Mr Rajoo: I think the Minister has not answered
my point, and that is, to include the "chit fund"
companies under this Bill. As he has explained
just now, these companies come under the category ---
Mr Speaker: Order. You are making a second
speech, Mr Rajoo. You can perhaps raise the
matter in Committee.
Question put, and agreed to.
Column: 1076
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Dr Goh Keng Swee].
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
6.34 p.m.
Clauses 1 to 16 inclusive ordered to
stand part of the Bill.
Clause 17 ---
Question proposed, "That clause 17 stand part of the Bill."
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I agree with
the aims of clause 17 in controlling the dealings
of finance companies. My only complaint is that
the clause is not happily drafted, it is rather
vague. Clause 17 (1) reads:
`No finance company shall ---
(a) accept any deposit which is repayable on
demand by cheque, draft or order;'.
I do not quite know what this means, if it is the
intention of the paragraph that deposit accounts
in finance companies should not be drawn on by the
depositor by the use of cheque, draft or order, it
should be expressly stated.
With regard to paragraph (c) . Sir, the granting
of unsecured advances to
'(i) a firm ...
(ii) any other person or body of persons
whether incorporated or not.',
I am of the opinion that legally it is
comprehensive enough to say that no finance
companies shall grant unsecured loans to any
person or body of persons whether incorporated or
not, it embraces everybody - persons, companies,
firms or what have you. It is unnecessary to have
the first paragraph which expressly defines a firm
in which a director of a finance company is
interested, etc. These are my complaints about the
drafting. They have nothing to do with the aim or
the intention of this clause to control finance
companies
.
Column: 1077
Dr Goh Keng Swee: The intention of
clause 17 (1) (a) is as stated by the Member for
Choa Chu Kang. I do not know how it can be redraf
ted in a happier way. I would have thought that,
as it stands, this is to describe a bank account
which is operated by payment on demand by cheque.
If the hon. Member can propose a happier form of
words, I am sure the House will be willing to
consider it. I thought that there was some
ambiguity about paragraph (a). It looks a bit odd,
I confess. But on deeper reflection, I think the
meaning becomes clear. My colleague, the Minister
for Law, might want to comment on this. It is not
really within my professional province.
As regards clause 17 (1) (c), what the Member
said is quite true. But I think the intention of
the law officers who drafted it is to draw
attention to the fact that the director, agent or
manager of a finance company is not exempted from
these restrictions. I think the intention is to
make it clear beyond all doubt. I do not know
whether my colleague, the Minister for Law, can
perhaps elaborate on this.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): The object of clause 17 (1) (a) is
to prevent finance companies from acting like
banks. Hence, anyone who deposits money with a
finance company cannot get it back, as it were, on
demand by writing out a cheque, as one does with a
bank account. You deposit money in a bank which
issues you with a cheque book, and by writing out
a demand note by cheque, draft or order, you can
immediately draw on that account. This is the
object of clause 17 (1) (a) . I myself cannot see
how it can be drafted in a better way. It does not
prevent finance companies from returning money by
cheque, draft or order. One deposits money not for
immediate return but for return after three
months, six months or a year, when it can be done
by cheque, draft or order. What clause 17 (1) (a)
seeks to prevent is a deposit followed by an
immediate demand for payment by the depositor.
Column: 1078
As far as clause 17 (1) (c) is concerned, I
need not add more to what the Minister for Finance
has said. It is aimed at everybody. But the
drafters felt it would be safer specifically to mention partner, manager or agent or any
individual or firm of which any of its directors
is a guarantor. This is to prevent ambiguity, and
it is to make sure that these people do not get
away with it that they are specifically mentioned.
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Minister for Finance has asked whether I
can propose a happier set of wording.
Unfortunately, I have not given notice of an
amendment to this paragraph (a). But with your
consent and with the general assent of the House,
I can do so.
The Chairman: Mr Tang, before I give consent,
may I offer a little comment? The words "cheque,
draft or order" to my mind clearly refer to the
means by which the "demand" is made,, and not to
the means by which repayment is made. If you agree
with that, interpretation, you may not wish, at
this-stage, to seek to introduce an amendment. In
any event, I take it the Minister will want to
consult professional opinion in the Attorney
General's Chambers before he expresses any views
or accepts, any amendment from you at this stage.
Mr Tang See Chim: As you please,
Mr Speaker, Sir.
Question put, and agreed to.
Clause 17 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clauses 18 to 27 inclusive ordered to
stand part of the Bill.
Clause 28 -
The Chairman: Mr Rajoo, sub-clause
(2) will give you an opportunity to say what you
wanted to say a few minutes, ago on "chit fund"
companies.
Question proposed, "That clause 28, stand part of
the Bill."
Mr Rajoo: Mr Speaker, Sir, thosecompanies which
have "chit" funds need not come under the Banking
Ordinance
Column: 1079
or under the Moneylenders Ordinance. Therefore,
these companies are registered as limited
companies and the directors are not doing business
in the
best interest of the public. I understand that
when some of these limited companies were
registered, certain banks gave a guarantee to
them. When cheques were issued by these companies
to their depositors, the same banks returned the
cheques dishonoured because of insufficient funds.
So I would suggest to the Minister that in the
public interest these "chit fund" companies should
also be brought under this Finance Companies Bill.
6.45 p.m.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, the Companies Act, which
has just been passed by Parliament, provides under
section 38 certain obligations in respect of com
panies which invite the public to deposit money
and there are certain obligations laid down under
this Act to ensure that some control is exercised
over them. I am not sure whether the companies
referred to by the Member for Farrer Park would
not come under the provisions of this Bill,
because finance business is defined as borrowing
money from the public, and this is exactly what
these tontine companies do. They lend money to the
public. I would have thought that it could be that
these `companies would fall under the provisions
of this Bill. This is really a rather legal
technical point and perhaps the Minister for Law
and National Development may come to the rescue
again.
The Chairman: Mr Rajoo, is there anything you
wish to say further?
Mr Rajoo: I have not got anything
further to say. But as the Minister for Finance
has requested the Minister for Law and National
Development to look into the matter, I hope he
will do so.
Mr Barker: Sir, these tontine companies, which
the Member for Farrer Park is rather worried
about, will be
Column: 1080
caught by section 38 (1) of the Companies Act
which was read for the Third time a few hours ago.
Section 38 (1) provides that:
'An invitation to the public to deposit money
with or lend money to a corporation or proposed
corporation shall not be issued circulated or
distributed by the corporation or by any other
person unless -'
paragraphs (a), (b) and (c) are complied with.
Section 38 (9) provides for heavy penalties -
'conviction to imprisonment for a term not
exceeding two years or to a fine not exceeding
five thousand dollars.'
I doubt very much whether these tontine operators
will be caught by the Finance Companies Act which
strictly covers finance companies which borrow
money and then lend it out. A tontine operator
does not strictly borrow or lend. What he does is
to invite people to subscribe to a certain fund
and then it is more of a debt. I say $20, you say
$21, someone else says $22, and the highest bidder
gets the money for the month, after which he has
to return a fixed sum. It is a group of people
getting together, putting in a certain sum a
month, and every month someone takes it away. All
the operator does is to get his little commission.
So, strictly speaking, he is not borrowing and
then lending out. They are all perhaps borrowing
and lending to one another. I doubt whether they
would be caught by the Act. I may be wrong but, in
the final analysis, it is for the courts to
decide, and if we are wrong here, we can always
amend our laws.
Mr Lee Teck Him(In Mandarin): Sir, I would like to say a few words on tontine
organisations. These organisations originated out
of some moral responsibility for friendly mutual
aid. For instance, if I am short of $2,000 for
business, I gather a few friends together and form
a tontine organisation. The purpose is to help
myself to run
Column: 1081
my business. But nowadays people are different.
They make use of this sort of organisation to
swallow up other people's deposits. Once the
leader has collected the money, he runs away. So
there should be a law to control tontine
organisations. Originally, the purpose of tontine
organisations was very good. It was for mutual
assistance. But now it is different. Nowadays the
morals of the people are quite different from what
they were in ancient times. So in law, we should
have some measures to prevent people from a breach
of faith by running away with the money deposited
by their friends.
Mr. P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang): Sir, now that we are talking about tontines, I
agree with what the Hon. Minister for Law and
National Development has stated just now, that
this Act does not catch tontine operators. In
fact, I think there is a dubious line of common
law authority which says that tontines are illegal
as they are against public policy. In any event, I
think there is a case that at some future session
of Parliament, measures should be introduced in
Parliament to control tontine operators and
regulate this kind of business, because tontines
also satisfy certain social and economic needs in
Singapore. I think a study is being made by the
Faculty of Law of the University of Singapore and
perhaps we will have the time to go into it.
Mr Rajoo: Sir, I am a bit disturbed by the
Minister for Law and National Development's reply
that he cannot do anything about this "chit" fund.
In fact, I am not asking him to look into illegal
tontine organisations, but these are companies
which are registered under the Companies Ordinance
or some other law, and they seem to operate in a
way which is not in the interest of the public.
The public subscribe to these "chit" funds. Say
the tontine is for $20 a month. They subscribe to
the tontine. They put their savings into these com
panies. Finally, after paying for 10 or 12
Column: 1082
months, these people are informed by the operator
that he is not going to pay back their deposits.
This is something which the Government should look
into, in order to safeguard the interest of such
people. If there is no law at present to control
tontine organisations, then the Minister should
introduce legislation or amend the law to control
them.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, I always thought that
tontine operators were small-time people,
domestic servants and such types. This is the
first time I hear that they have formed a limited
company. If, in fact, they have formed a limited
company, then they will fall under section 38 of
the Companies Ordinance provided, of course, the
Member for Bukit Panjang is not correct in saying
that these activities are illegal in law. Assuming
that they are legal and they are registered, then
they will come under section 38. Subsection (7) of
section 38 gives the Minister authority by
notification in the Gazette to specify terms and
conditions subject to which subsection (6) of this
section shall have effect. In other words, the
activities and terms upon which these transactions
are conducted can be regulated by the Minister; in
this case, the Minister for Law. So the Member for
Farrer Park need not despair. Of course, all this
is on the assumption that these activities are
legal. If they are illegal, then such companies
cannot be registered.
Question put, and agreed to.
Clause 28 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clauses 29 to 45 inclusive ordered to stand part
of the Bill.
The Chairman: After that interesting
debate, I must refer to a very mundane matter. A
spelling correction is to be made in the Long
title. In the word "licence", the letter "c" where
it occurs, for the second time should be an "s".
This error will be corrected.
Bill reported without amendment; read a Third
time and passed.
Column: 1083
LAND TITLES (STRATA) BILL
(As reported from Select Committee)
Order for Third Reading read.
7.00 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Third time."
Members of the House will recall that the Land
Titles (Strata) Bill was referred to the Select
Committee on the 27th June this year. Written
representations were received from the Estates
Manager. Housing and Development Board, the Land
and Housing Development Association of Singapore,
and the Real Estate Valuers Association
(Singapore). In addition, the Select Committee
also heard oral evidence from the Real Estate
Valuers Association. A number of useful
suggestions which were made have been accepted.
The amendments made by the Select Committee are
set out on pages C4, C5 and C6 of the Committee's
Report tabled in this Parliament on 7th December
this year as Paper Parl. 12 of 1967. I will not
burden the House with details of these amendments,
many of which are drafting amendments which merely
refine the Bill. One particular clause, however,
in the original Bill `dealing with the collection
of pioperty tax in respect of flats has been
deleted, as it appears that such a provision, if
necessary or advisable, should properly be in the
Property Tax Ordinance.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the Bill as now tabled before
the House incorporates the recommendations of the
Select Committee.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Mr Speaker: There is a clerical error in the
marginal note of clause 32 which reads "Surrender
of unregistered land to Singapore.....". It should
read "Surrender of unregistered land to the President....." as provided in the clause itself.
That correction will be made.
Mr Barker: I am much obliged, Sir.
Column: 1084
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1084
REGISTRATION OF IMPORTS AND EXPORTS RULES, 1967
7.03 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That Parliament, pursuant to subsection t3) of
section 5 of the Registration of Imports and
Exports Ordinance (Cap. 261), resolves that the
Registration of Imports and Exports Rules, 1967,
published as Notification S 244 in the Gazette
Subsidiary Legislation Supplement No. 76 of 14th
December, 1967, as contained in Paper S.L. 60 of
1967, he approved.
Sir, the Registration of Imports and Exports
Rules, 1967, embody the Imports and Exports Rules
of 1935 together with a new provision for the
documentation of trade between Singapore and West
Malaysia. Until now, imports and exports to and
from West Malaysia do not require Singapore per
mits or Singapore documentation. The proposed
documentation is to enable us to compile our own
statistics of trade with West Malaysia. Such trade
statistics are now compiled and supplied by the
Statistics Department at Kuala Lurnpur.
Documentation of our trade with West Malaysia is
also made necessary by the export incentive scheme
which is to be effective next year.
Under the amended Rules, importers and exporters
will be required to submit documents to cover
goods imported from or exported to West Malaysia.
In the case of imports by road or rail, the
document required will be submitted to the Customs
and will merely be an additional copy of the
export permit which the exporter in West Malaysia
submits to Malaysian Customs. For exports to West
Malaysia by road or rail, the document required
will be a copy of the Malaysian Customs import
permit. In case of imports or exports by sea or
air, the trader will submit one copy of the
Singapore Inward Declaration or Outward
Declaration to the shipping or airline agent. The
shipping or airline agent
Column: 1085
concerned will then forward the declarations to
the Import and Export Office. All declarations
will not have to be approved by the Import and
Export Office. No fees are payable on these
declarations. In this way, very little delay and
no inconvenience will be caused to the traders.
We have already consulted the various Chambers
of Commerce, shipping associations and the Airline
Operators Committee, and they have agreed to the
procedures proposed.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Column: 1086
Resolved,
That Parliament, pursuant to subsection (3)
of section 5 of the Registration of Imports
and Exports Ordinance (Cap. 261), resolves that
the Registration of Imports and Exports Rules,
1967, published as Notification S 244
in the Gazette Subsidiary Legislation Supplement
No. 76 of 14th December, 1967, as contained in
Paper S.L. 60 of 1967, be approved.
ADJOURNMENT TO A DATE TO
BE FIXED
Resolved, "That Parliament do now adjourn to a
date to be fixed." - [Mr Barker].
Adjourned accordingly at
Six minutes past Seven o'clock p.m. to
a date to be fixed.