| Parliament No: | 2 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 27 |
| Sitting No: | 14 |
| Sitting Date: | 01-08-1968 |
|
Column: 741
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
FIRST SESSION OF THE SECOND PARLIAMENT
PART I OF FIRST SESSION |
VOLUME 27 |
Thursday, 1st August, 1968
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Mr P. Coomaraswamy).
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang).
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development and Leader of the House.
Inche Buang Bin Omar Junid (Whampoa), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta).
Mr Eric Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh).
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (MacPherson), Minister for Health.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong).
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister for Finance.
Column: 742
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah).
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division).
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (Kampong Kapor).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah).
Mr Lim Kim San (Cairnhill), Minister for Defence.
Mr Lim Soo Peng (Havelock).
Mr Low Guan Onn (River Valley).
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford).
Inche Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Inche Mohd. Ghazali Bin Ismail (Aljunied).
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Education.
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon).
Column: 743
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Communications.
Inche Rahmat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour.
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Potong Pasir), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (Law Division).
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens).
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee).
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang).
Inche Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampong Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour and Government Whip.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Column: 744
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Minister of State for Defence.
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampong Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng (Joo Chiat), Deputy Speaker.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications.
ABSENT:
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken (Alexandra).
Column: 743
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
EDUCATIONAL ADVISORY
COUNCIL
(Advice on educational policy and development)
1. Mr L. P. Rodrigo asked the Minister for
Education if the Educational Advisory Council has
hitherto been an efficient source of advice on
matters of educational policy and development.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education (Dr Lee Chiaw Meng) (for the Minister for Education): Mr Speaker, Sir, although the
individual members of the Educational Advisory
Council have rendered invaluable
Column: 744
service, the Council, as a whole, has not been an
efficient source of advice on educational matters,
mainly because of its unwieldy composition. The
Council has a membership of no less than 21,
including six members of the Education Finance
Board, a body which has become defunct as a result
of the changes in the financial procedure of the
Government.
In order that educational planning may keep pace
with our unprecedented expansion of school
enrolment in the past, and with the rapid changes
which are now taking place in the educational
system, it has been found more expedient to seek
advice on educational matters from small committees
of specialists on an ad hoc basis. Consequently,
the Educational Advisory Council has been largely
inactive since May 1962.
Column: 745
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens): Mr Speaker, Sir, as I understand the Educational Advisory Council, it is a body set up by the
Education Ordinance, 1957, and the provisions
setting up this body also make it mandatory for the
Educational Advisory Council to sit a number of
times a year. In the circumstances, how is it
possible for the Parliamentary Secretary to say
that this body is defunct?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, as I
explained earlier, seeking advice from a large
committee is inefficient. We find it more efficient
to seek advice from small committees or from
individual members. As this method has been so
effective, we find that it has not been necessary
to convene the Educational Advisory Council since
1962.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol): Mr Speaker, Sir,
since the Educational Advisory Council is
inefficient and too large, would the Government
consider abolishing it?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: There have, in fact, been a
couple of advisory committees on educational
policy. Since the Educational Advisory Council is
so ineffective, I would say it will die a natural
death.
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, can the Parliamentary Secretary
tell us who are the members of the smaller ad hoc
committees?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng(In Mandarin): The smaller ad
hoc committees are established under various
circumstances. For instance, if my Ministry require
advice on technical education, we set up a small
committee under the Ministry of Education to
provide such advice.
Mr Rodrigo: Mr Speaker, Sir, from what the
Parliamentary Secretary has said, do I understand
that he will advise his Ministry to seek certain
amendments to the Education Ordinance of 1957 so
that a more effective body can be set up?
Column: 746
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: The question of amending the
Education Ordinance of 1957 is, in fact, under
consideration.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong): Mr Speaker, Sir,
as I see it, it is the taxpayers and the public
that are paying for the cost of education. As such,
I think there should be some representation from
the general public regarding educational policies.
With the Educational Advisory Council becoming
defunct, it seems to me that only professional
people are involved in the direction of policies.
Perhaps it might be a good idea to retain the
Educational Advisory Council but with certain
modifications to see that its functions ---
Mr Speaker: Mr Conceicao, you should ask a
supplementary question. You are now making a speech
and what you are saying would be appropriate to any
Bill that may be introduced to amend the relevant
provisions of the Education Ordinance.
Column: 746
EDUCATIONAL TELEVISION
(Evaluation of effectiveness)
2. Mr L. P. Rodrigo asked the Minister for
Education (a) whether measures have been taken to
assess the effectiveness of educational television
as it is currently programmed to schools as a
medium of instruction; and (b) whether there are
plans to expand the department of educational
television in the immediate future.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (for the Minister for Education): Mr Speaker, Sir, (a) a continuous
system of evaluating the effectiveness of E.T.V.
programmes has been in operation ever since the
Singapore Educational Television Service was
launched by the Ministry of Education in January
1967. All secondary schools in the Republic are
required to send in weekly returns containing
information on the reception of programmes telecast
in the previous week. This information is processed
and analysed by machine and the findings are used
for effecting further improvement in future
programmes.
Column: 747
In addition, courses on evaluation and
utilisation of E.T.V. programmes are conducted
periodically for all E.T.V. officers and teachers
using the programmes.
(b) Plans for the expansion of the E.T.V. Service
were submitted to the Economic Planning Unit of the
Ministry of Finance as early as April 1967. In July
the E.P.U. conducted an independent survey of the
effectiveness of E.T.V. and reported that expansion
should not be embarked upon until the service has
consolidated itself. Subsequently, the E.P.U.
relented on this decision and recommended
expansion. More recently, an internationally known
expert on E.T.V. was provided by the Ford
Foundation at the request of the Government to make
recommendations concerning the E.T.V. Service. This
expert has submitted a favourable report
recommending expansion. Whether the service is to
be expanded now is purely a question of financial
consideration.
Mr Rodrigo: Mr Speaker, Sir, do I understand
that the intended expansion of television is going
to displace radio broadcasting to schools? Also,
what is the future of radio broadcasting to
schools?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, the
expansion of E.T.V. in relation to radio broadcasts
to schools is still under consideration. The
running up of the E.T.V. Service and the running
down of radio broadcasts to schools has still to be
worked out.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, what measure
of success has been achieved as a result of the
introduction of E.T.V. programmes in secondary
schools?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, my original
answer to the hon. Member for Serangoon Gardens
answers this supplementary question. E.T.V. has
been successful and that is why we are planning
expansion.
Column: 748
UPPER THOMSON ROAD
(Effect of widening on residents and shop-keepers)
3. Mr Ang Nam Piau asked the Minister for Law
and National Development (a) when work will
commence to widen Upper Thomson Road between 4¾ m.s. and 6½ m.s.; and (b) what measures he proposes
to take to safeguard the interests of the residents
and shop-keepers who will be directly affected by
the project.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, work on the
widening of Upper Thomson Road between 4¾ m.s. and
6½ ms, has been carried out up to the maximum
possible width. Further widening can only be
carried out when the existing shops and houses
which line both sides of the road are demolished.
The Housing and Development Board plans to
construct two shopping centres with residential
flats to re-site the occupants of the shops and
houses along this stretch of road. One centre will
be built at the 4¾ m.s. Thomson Road, near the Home
of the Little Sisters of the Poor, and the other
near the junction of Thomson Road and the Island
Club Road. In order to build these two centres, a
few structures will have to be demolished and their
occupants resettled.
The occupants of the other structures along both
sides of this stretch of road will only be
resettled when the building of the two centres is
completed, after which Upper Thomson Road will be
widened into a dual carriage way.
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson): Can the Minister tell
the House how many residents and shop-keepers will
be directly affected by this project?
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, a survey carried
out has shown that there are 124 shop-houses and
211 residential homes along this stretch of road. I
cannot say exactly how many persons will be
affected.
Column: 749
2.41 p.m.
REPORT OF CIVIL SERVICE
SALARIES COMMISSION OF
SINGAPORE, 1967
(Statement by the Minister for Finance)
Mr Speaker: Order. Further to the statement by
the Minister for Finance yesterday, I will now take
questions for answers.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I wish to seek some clarification in respect
of employees who opt to be on the existing salary
scales and draw variable allowance personal to
themselves. Will the Government give an assurance
that such variable allowance will not be altered in
any manner whatsoever to the prejudice of the
employee who has so opted for as long as he remains
in Government service?
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee):
Sir, I cannot give any assurance that the salary
scales will never be changed to the detriment of
the officers for all time. But I can give the
assurance that they will remain substantially in
their present form unless there is another major
exercise in salary revision downwards. In other
words, if there is no general revision of civil
service salary scales downwards, those who opt to
remain on salary scales personal to themselves with
the retention of the variable allowances will
continue to receive them.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I wish to raise two questions. Firstly, in his
Ministerial statement yesterday, the Finance
Minister said that the Government propose to
introduce two Superscale posts, 'A' and 'B' into
the civil service. In the case of Superscale 'B',
the salary would be $2,700 a month, and Super-scale
'A' $3,000 a month. This salary is more than a
Minister's salary, which is only $2,500 a month.
Generally speaking, the responsibilities of a
Minister are greater than those of a Permanent
Secretary. If that is the case,
Column: 750
I wish to ask the Minister for Finance, if the pay
of Ministers' pay will be correspondingly
increased.
I warmly welcome Government's acceptance of the
recommendations of the Salaries Commission in
respect of Division IV employees. In the Primary
Production Division there are about 90 employees. I
wish to ask the Minister if these employees are
covered by the Report. If they are not, I would ask
him whether he would consider extending the
implemented recommendations to cover these
employees.
Mr Speaker: Dr Goh Keng Swee, may I suggest
that you answer Mr Teong Eng Siong's first
question first, so that if there are any questions
from other Members on the same matter you can take
them in sequence before going to his second
question on employees in the Primary Production
Department.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, Ministers' salaries will
not be revised in this exercise.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, I have a series of
questions to ask.
Mr Speaker: Do your questions arise out of Mr
Teong's first question?
Mr N. Govindasamy: No, Sir, they arise out of my
first question.
Mr Speaker: In that case, I will let the
Minister answer Mr Teong's second question and I
will come back to you. Dr Goh.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: The Commission did not deal
with the salaries of people who administer
injections to chickens, whatever they are called.
The posts of these people are temporary. I think
they carry a salary of $100 a month and are
probably held part-time by farmers. It would not be
true to say that there is a general upward revision
of Division IV salary scales. What has happened is
that the number of salary scales has been reduced,
with the result that some people benefit by having
a longer salary scale so that they will continue to
enjoy more increments. It does not mean that they
get an immediate increase in pay.
Column: 751
Since the temporary inoculators are not on any
salary scale but receive a fixed salary, they do
not enjoy the benefit of a better salary scheme. I
hope I have made myself clear. There is no way of
bringing them in because the Commission did not
recommend a general increase.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Will the promotion prospects
of an employee who opts to remain in the present
salary scale be prejudiced merely because he has so
opted?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: His promotion prospects will
not be prejudiced.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Ulu Pandan)(In Mandarin): Sir,
the Minister for Finance yesterday dealt with the
recommendations of the Salaries Commission in
respect of the increase in salaries of Division I
and Superscale posts. In my view, these Superscale
officers already have enough to live well and
Government should more properly look after the
interest of the lower-income groups. In the case of
the latter, there should be some increase in
salary. This is only right and proper because we in
Singapore practise parliamentary democracy. We must
respect these people who are not so well off. Those
officers who are getting $2,000 or $3,000 a month
already have enough. Many people sleep by the
roadside and many do not have enough to eat.
How can these top civil servants ask for more
pay? We Members of Parliament get only $500 a month
each and we have to contribute to the party funds.
How can we live on this small pay? Of course, I too
want to ask for a pay rise and hope that the
Minister will be sympathetic.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, Members of Parliament do
not get salaries or pay. They get an allowance
which is meant to help them out by way of transport
expenses and for work in the constituencies. Again,
there is no question of increase of salaries to
Members of Parliament.
Column: 752
As regards the suggestion that Super-scale
officers are overpaid, I completely disagree with
the Member for Ulu Pandan. Let me give him an
example of how pay in the top level of the civil
service compares with pay in commercial firms. A
managing director of a reasonably prosperous
company in Singapore may get a total pay of $10,000
per month or more, which is four times what the
Permanent Secretary of a Ministry is getting. The
work of the Permanent Secretaries is more onerous
and more responsible. To say that they are overpaid
when they get only one-quarter of the pay of people
of equivalent ability in the private sector is, I
think, completely misleading.
The increases which we are recommending for the
top posts in the civil service, in my view, are in
themselves inadequate to do justice to the
situation. But we expect that people will make a
career in the civil service not entirely for the
purpose of making money and becoming rich.
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah): Mr Speaker, Sir,
firstly, I want to make it clear that I do not
grudge Government's proposal to increase the
salaries of Superscale officers. My point is that
at this juncture when the Government is asking the
private sector to make a big sacrifice, is it wise
for the Government to increase the salaries of
those who are well provided?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: If we want to attract and
retain talent in the civil service, this is what we
must do. It is, therefore, a very wise move, in my
view.
Mr Ho See Beng: Sir, I agree that we need
talent. But I think these talented people should
also be considerate. When the country is in
difficulties, they should make sacrifices. Just
because they are talented, they should not get
everything.
An hon. Member: Hear, hear!
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee): Sir, does the
Government propose to accept the recommendation of
the Commission in paragraph 588* of its Report on
the restoration of commuted
* Paragraph 588 reads as follows:
'We recommend the Treasury's proposal for consideration'
Column: 753
pension to a pensioner who outlives the period in
respect of which his pension was commuted, i.e.,
12½ years?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: The answer is "yes".
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, since Government accepts a
good proportion of the recommendations of the
Salaries Commission, it means that more expenditure
will have to be incurred each year. Therefore, I
shall be grateful if the Minister for Finance can
enlighten the House on how much the additional
recurrent expenditure will be for each year.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: If we had accepted all the
recommendations of the Salaries Commission, the
additional cost to Government would be of the order
of $6.8 million a year. We have not accepted the
recommendation in respect of a general increase in
Division I salary scales and in Superscale. This
recommendation would cost $1.8 million. Therefore,
we are left with an increase of $5 million a year.
Then we have decided to allow married women,
bachelors and married women without children to
convert to the new salary scales without
restrictions arising out of their marital status.
This costs another $¼ million. So the total
additional sum is $5¼ million a year.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, does it mean that the
taxpayers will have to dig deeper into their
pockets if Government pays $5¬ million more each
year?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, since we do not print our
notes as some countries do, I am afraid that is the
case.
Column: 754
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten): Sir, the Hon. Minister for Finance has mentioned just now that
one company pays its director $10,000 a month as
director's fees. Can the Minister enlighten the
House as to which company pays $10,000 a month as
director's fees?
My second question is: are civil servants who are
serving on the boards of public companies entitled
to director's fees?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: I was not referring to
directors or members of the board of directors. I
was referring to the chief executive of companies
and they are usually known as "managing directors".
For a managing director of a big firm in Singapore
to get a pay of $10,000 a month is by no means
unusual.
Civil servants who are members of the boards of
directors of companies in which either the
Government or the Economic Development Board has a
share of equity, do receive director's fees. They
do retain these fees if they are paid out because
of the contribution that they make to the firm. I
may say that these director's fees are in most
cases very small. In some cases, the firms, being
new ones, do not pay any director's fees.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, does the
Government's acceptance of the recommendation of
the Salaries Commission for a unified salary scale
for non-graduate trained teachers imply that the
Government also accepts the Commission's
recommendation in paragraph 202* of its Report for
a lower commencing salary for technical teachers
* Paragraph 202 reads as follows:
'We recommend the following points of entry on the basic
Timescale for Trained Teachers, Non-Graduates :-
(i) Technical $295
(ii) School Certificate $315
(iii) Higher School Certificate, Craft,
Domestic Science and Physical Education $385
(iv) Technician Diploma - we recommend that posts of Teachers, Non-Graduates.
(Technician Diploma) should be included in the Review which we
recommend for all Technical Grades in the Civil Service mentioned in
paragraph 323. Meanwhile, present incumbents of the posts should be
emplaced on Scale 18A in Division III $580x20-660/725x20-805/830x30-980.'
Column: 755
as compared with academic teachers? If that is the
case, does the Government not consider the
acceptance of such a recommendation incompatible
with its avowed policy of promoting technical and
vocational education rather than purely academic
education?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: I think this point was raised
in a letter to the newspapers this morning. This
looks to me to be an oversight on the part of the
Salaries Commission. For reasons set out by the
Member for Telok Blangah, technical teachers will
convert on no less favourable terms than other
grades of teachers.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, yesterday the Minister
mentioned promotion exercises. I would like to know
how frequently promotion exercises will be held so
as to enable Division I officers to be promoted
e.g, to Superscale C, B or A posts.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: It is the Public Service
Commission which decides on the frequency of
promotion exercises. Government can only propose to
them that more frequent promotion exercises be
carried out, but the decision rests with the Public
Service Commission, it varies from Ministry to
Ministry and from service to service. So far as the
services under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of
Finance are concerned, it is mainly the
Administrative Service. The last promotion exercise
was held some 18 months ago and I think we should
have one pretty soon. If possible, one would like
to see annual exercises carried out. But the
trouble may be the lack of suitable candidates.
So, subject to these reservations, I would say
that we should carry out more frequent promotion
exercises starting from now. I am afraid I cannot
be more definite than that.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I think I have
come across a number
Column: 756
of cases where senior civil servants have been
acting for quite a long time. I am inclined to
agree with the Minister that promotion exercises
should be more frequent. I hope the time factor
will be taken into consideration, that is, instead
of a lapse of 18 months, let us have promotion
exercises on a yearly basis so that we will not
have senior officers acting for two or three years.
If they are found to be unsuitable for promotion,
another officer ought to be found to act with a
view to finding the right man for the right place.
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford): Mr Speaker, Sir,
may I know from the Minister whether the Government
is prepared to accept the suggestion of the
Commission as contained in paragraph 227* of the
Report regarding medical benefits to aided school
teachers?
* Paragraph 227 reads as follows:
'We suggest that consideration should be given to the possibility
of extending to Government-Aided Teaching Personnel the Medical Benefits applicable
to Government School Teachers.'
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Yes, Sir, the Government
accepts this recommendation.
Mr L. P. Rodrigo: Mr Speaker, Sir, will the
Minister say whether the Government accepts the
Commission's recommendation that all trained
teachers, graduates and honours graduates, be
emplaced on the Division I salary scale?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: The Government accepts this
recommendation.
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
have two questions. Firstly, regarding the mode of
salary conversion, I would like to ask the Minister
whether he is aware of the following: One officer,
"A", who is married and another officer, "B", who
is not married are now on the same basic salary. As
officer "A" is married he draws a higher variable
allowance and therefore his total emoluments are
greater than those of officer "B". According to the
Commission's mode of conversion, officer "A" will
move to a higher step in the new salary scale.
Column: 757
Should officer "B" get married after the
implementation of the recommendations of the
Salaries Commission Report, he will still be on a
lower step vis-a-vis officer "A". How does the
Minister intend to correct this?
Secondly, may I know the reason why the date of
implementation of the recommendations of the Report
of the Salaries Commission is 1st January, 1969?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: I thought I made it clear in
my speech yesterday that we do not accept the
Commission's recommendation in respect of
conversion, having a difference of conversion
between the married and unmarried officers. They
will all convert on the same basis, that is, the
bachelor officer will convert in the same way as
the married officer. In effect, he will get an
increase in total pay on this exercise costing the
taxpayers a quarter of a million dollars a year.
Why is the date of implementation 1st January,
1969? If we regard our decisions as final and
refuse to hear representations, we can probably
implement it from 1st October, 1968. But we want to
hear the views of unions, associations and other
people and, therefore, we have to give them time to
make their representations. It will probably be
sometime in October when we can make up our minds.
Therefore, it is necessary to allow another two or
three months to pass and 1st January, 1969, seems
to be a very convenient date.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, in view of
the Government's proposal to create two new
Superscale posts, that is 'A' and 'B', does it mean
that in future, we will have a Permanent Secretary
who will be placed in any one 'of these three
Superscale grades, i.e., Superscale 'A', 'B' and
'C'? If it is the intention of the Government to
create different grades of Permanent .Secretaries,
does the Government propose to determine the grade
of each Permanent Secretaryship on the basis
Column: 758
of the importance of the Ministry to which the
Permanent Secretary is attached, or on the basis of
the personal merits of the holder of such a post?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Permanent Secretaries will be
promoted on the basis of individual merits and not
by reason of their holding of posts. Of course, I
accept that this is a departure from the normal
civil service practice. But, in effect, it will
probably not make all that difference because
obviously we have got to post the ablest of them in
the most important positions.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, in our debate
on the 1968 Estimates I noticed that we have
various categories of Ambassadors and High
Commissioners. Would all these come under one and
the same category?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: I think the Salaries
Commission makes no recommendation in this respect.
I do not think I am called upon to make any comment
on this subject.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, according to
the Estimates, the Ambassadors and High
Commissioners are placed under certain grades like
'E' and so forth. I think they do come into this?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: If they are paid on Grade 'E',
then they will remain to be paid on Grade 'E'.
Mr Rodrigo: Mr Speaker, Sir, at the moment
Domestic Science teachers trained abroad and
Physical Education Inspectors trained abroad are
placed on various assorted scales. However, the
Commission has made some recommendations on this.
Will the Government accept the Commission's
recommendation that these two categories of
teachers be entered into the basic Timescale as
recommended at the point of $385?
Mr Speaker: Mr Rodrigo, can you identify the
paragraphs to which you refer?
Column: 759
Mr Rodrigo: The Salaries Commission Report - *paragraphs 214 and 216.
* The paragraphs read as follows:
'214. It was also represented to us that there
is a great disparity in the salary scales at
present paid to Domestic Science Teachers who
received their training Overseas. Some are
placed on the Honours Degree salary scale while
others are placed on the Pass Degree salary
scale. A number are on the Old Certificate
Trained salary scale while others are on the New
Certificate Trained salary scale. In paragraph
200 we have recommended a basic timescale of
$295x20-335 / 385x20-505 /560x25 /660/ 750x35-925 (Scale 5 in Division II) for Trained
Teachers, Non-Graduates and in paragraph 202 we
have recommended that Domestic Science Teachers
should enter the basic timescale at $385 per
month.'
'216. A similar situation exists with regard
to Assistant Specialist Inspectors (Physical
Education) who received their training overseas.
Some are placed on the Pass Degree salary scale
while others are placed on the Old Certificate
Trained salary scale. In paragraph 202 we have
recommended that Teachers specialising in
Physical Education should enter the basic time-scale for Trained Teachers, Non-Graduates at
$385 per month.'
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Subject to any views from the
Ministry of Education on this recommendation, my
Ministry proposes to accept this recommendation.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, in view of
the comment contained in paragraph 198+ of the
Commission's Report, will the Government consider
setting up another commission to inquire into the
basic reorganisation of the structure of the
Ministry of Education?
+ Paragraph 198 reads as follows:
'A basic reorganisation of the structure of
the Education Service as proposed by the
Ministry of Education's Scheme would not be
within our Terms of Reference, and although we
make no specific recommendations with regard to
this matter, we consider that the Scheme
warrants further serious consideration.'
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, I think we had better get
through the implementation of the recommendations
of this Commission before we start on another one.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng (Joo Chiat): Mr Speaker, Sir,
the pharmacists in this country are not
particularly happy because they have not been
classed as a professional group. Perhaps the
Minister may be able to clarify this point?
Column: 760
Dr Goh Keng Swee: The responsibility of keeping
everybody happy is not really mine. If the hon.
Member can refer to the paragraph containing the
recommendation of the Commission on this grade,
perhaps I may be able to venture an opinion.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng: It is on page 48, **paragraphs
141 and 142.
** The paragraphs read as follows:
'141. The Association in their representation
proposed that Pharmacists should be' included in
the Scheme of Service for Professional Officers.
They proposed that Medical Officers, Dental
Officers and Pharmaceutical Officers should all
be emplaced on a, common Professional Timescale
but Pharmaceutical Officers should enter the
proposed Timescale at a lower point of entry.
We have given consideration to this proposal but
do not support the suggestion since we do not
feel that a case was made out for giving
Pharmaceutical Officers parity of treatment with
Medical and Dental Officers and other officers
in the profession, e.g., Legal, Engineering,
Architecture, etc.
142. We recommend that Pharmacists should
continue to be emplaced on the non-professional
salary scale.'
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, in paragraph 142 the
Commission recommends that pharmacists should
continue to be emplaced on the non-professional
salary' scale. Therefore, I am afraid that is the
recommendation which the Government will accept. It
must be assumed that the officers concerned have
made out a case as thoroughly as possible to the
Salaries Commission, and if the finding is adverse,
then that is that.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng: Mr Speaker, Sir, I was
hoping that the Minister may be able to clarify the
position of pharmacists being on the "non-professional"
Column: 761
salary scale, because in my opinion I think they
are, in fact, professional men.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: This so-called "non-professional" salary scale is really a misnomer. It
is something like the holy Roman Empire which is
neither holy nor Roman nor an Empire. There are
many professionals who are emplaced on this scale.
Column: 761
INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order read for resumption of motion, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time," [31st July, 1968].
Question again proposed.
3.13 p.m.
The Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour (Mr S. Rajaratnam): Mr Speaker, Sir, at
the moment of interruption yesterday, I explained
clause 7. I am now going to speak on clause 8 of
the Bill which amends section 34 of the Ordinance
by providing that the Industrial Arbitration Court
shall not inquire into disputes relating to the
dismissal or reinstatement of an employee unless
such an employee has been dismissed in
circumstances arising out of the contravention of
section 79 of the Ordinance. I have already
mentioned, in connection with clause 5, the
remedial action that may be taken by an employee if
he considers that he has been dismissed without
just cause or excuse. I would, however, add here
that the Minister's decision in this regard is
final and conclusive and shall not be challenged in
any court, and that the Minister may direct the
employer to reinstate the employee in his former
employment and to pay him an amount that is
equivalent to the wages that the employee would
have earned had he not been dismissed by the
employer, or to pay such amount of wages as
compensation as may be determined by him. If the
employer does not comply with the directions of the
Minister, then the employer shall be guilty of an
offence under the Ordinance and shall be subject to
the punishment prescribed.
Column: 762
Clause 13 amends section 57 of the Ordinance by
extending the circumstances whereby the powers of
the Industrial Arbitration Court can be exercised
by the President sitting alone. The inclusion of
sections 24A, 34, 37 (4) , 39, 42, and 79 is
consequential upon other amendments in this Bill
and is intended to expedite the proceedings in the
court.
Clause 14 amends section 77 of the Ordinance by
substituting a new proviso for the existing one.
This new proviso enables an employer to require, as
a condition for the appointment or promotion of a
person to a managerial or executive position, that
that person shall not continue to be an officer or
member of a particular trade union, unless the
trade union is a trade union whose constitution and
rules restrict its membership to persons in
managerial or executive positions. This amendment
is consequential upon the amendment in clause 4 of
the Bill which requires separate representation by
employees in managerial or executive positions as
distinct from other subordinate employees. The
existing provision merely states that an employer
can object to his employees being members of a
particular trade union. This by itself does not
prevent an employee in a managerial or executive
position from joining another trade union catering
for employees in these grades. I have already
explained why separate representation is necessary
in the course of my discussion in clause 4 There
is, therefore, no need for me to repeat it here.
Clause 15 of the Bill amends the Ordinance by
introducing a new section 78A which sets out the
circumstances under which a trade union officer may
obtain paid leave of absence from his employer to
attend to trade union duties. It provides that a
trade union officer shall apply in writing to his
employer for leave of absence stating the duration
of and the purposes for which such leave is
applied. It further provides that an employee shall
not be entitled to paid leave unless the purpose of
his leave is to represent members of his trade
union
Column: 763
in relation to industrial matters affecting his
employer.
Hon. Members will appreciate that there have been
considerable difficulties in this regard. For
instance, where a trade union represents employees
in more than one establishment, it is not unusual
for the officers of the union to come from one and
the same establishment. In such an event, the
employer is penalised in that he either loses the
services of his employees for the duration of their
business for reasons quite unconnected with his own
establishment, or he incurs additional costs by
having to employ additional staff to cover the
duties of his absent employees. This, it will be
appreciated, is most unsatisfactory. There must be
reason and logic in such circumstances and it is
precisely to regularise matters that this amendment
has been made.
Paragraph (b) of clause 16 of the Bill amends
section 79 of the Ordinance by the addition of a
new subsection (6) which allows the Industrial
Arbitration Court to commence proceedings in
respect of the reinstatement of an employee who is
alleged to have been dismissed in contravention of
section 79 of the Ordinance before proceedings have
been commenced in a District Court. At present,
allegations in respect of such cases are heard
before a District Court which also has the power to
order reinstatement. However, thorough and time-consuming investigations must necessarily precede
such proceedings. This has caused long delays which
are frowned upon both by the unions and the
employers.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the amendments to the
Industrial Relations Ordinance, particularly in the
context of management rights, have evoked fears
among some trade unionists. The principle of
collective bargaining is in no way impinged.
Collective bargaining is of the essence in a free
and democratic society but vital management rights
must not be eroded if we are to create the
necessary climate of stability for investors to
come
Column: 764
in. There are, however, built-in safeguards, for
safeguards there must be if abuses are to be
minimised both by employers and trade unions. Some
wise person has stated that private rights may
become public wrongs. There is, therefore, the
urgent necessity for both parties to make
responsible decisions - decisions which are
compatible with the well-being of the country. It
is, therefore, in the interest of all concerned to
ensure that rights are related to functions.
Employers have their functions just as trade
unions have, and it is imperative that their
respective rights have a, correlation with their
respective functions. The amendments embodied in
this Bill are obviously designed to correct wrongs,
balance rights and functions and equate
responsibilities so that an independent Singapore
can move through the crucial years ahead without
coming to grief. The Government will, however, keep
a very close watch on the workings of the law on
industrial relations in the light of the amendments
that are being made. If there are abuses, the
Government will not hesitate to make the necessary
adjustments. We hope, however, that employers will
exercise their rights with responsibility, and that
they will take a far-sighted view of their real
interest. It is in their long-term interest not to
abuse, as they can, this Bill, because then I think
there can be no expectation on their part that the
trade unions themselves will act with the restraint
and responsibility which they have so far shown. We
hope, therefore, that employers will exercise their
rights with responsibility and that it will not be
necessary to take corrective action.
The objectives of these two pieces of legislation
- the Employment Bill and the Central Provident
Fund (Amendment) Bill - are, as it should be very
clear by now, to help Singapore as an independent
nation not only to meet the storms ahead but also
to ensure that we ride them successfully. I hope
that co-operation will be forthcoming from the
employers in this regard and that the trade unions
will make the necessary
Column: 765
adjustments in face of the new situation. The
delineation of management functions and trade union
functions will do away with the "Heads I win, tails
you lose" attitude. Let us resolve to replace this
with "Heads we all win, tails we all lose".
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
3.25 p.m.
Mr Seah Mui Kok: Mr Speaker, Sir, I rise to
comment on the Industrial Relations (Amendment)
Bill which is now being read for the Second time.
As the Secretary-General of the National Trades
Union Congress, I am very pleased to note that the
Government has incorporated into the Bill some of
the suggestions made by the N.T.U.C. When we were
first informed by the Government of its intention
to amend the Industrial Relations Ordinance, 1960,
we were very much taken aback by the rather drastic
scope and extent of the amendments intended by the
Government. We then strongly represented to the
Government that its objectives could still be
achieved by modifying its intended amendments so as
to minimise the adverse effects on the workers.
Evidently, as it appears from the Bill, the
Government has given heed to our representations.
[Mr Deputy Speaker in the Chair]
3.26 p.m.
For instance, it was intended that the power of
the Industrial Arbitration Court to reinstate in
employment an employee who has been wrongfully
dismissed was to be confined to cases where the
employee had been allegedly dismissed for trade
union activities. We pointed out that such a
provision restricting the power of reinstatement in
employment would give rise to many malpractices or
abuses by unscrupulous employers. At present, such
employers are deterred from dismissing their
employees summarily without justification because
of the protection given to employees under the
Industrial Relations
Column: 766
Ordinance. It would have been unduly and
unnecessarily demoralising to an employee to have
been deprived of the protection given to his
employment under the Industrial Relations
Ordinance. Not every one who has been wrongfully
dismissed by his employer can claim to be a trade
union officer or a member actively engaged in trade
union work. Paragraph (d) of clause 8 of the Bill,
however, takes care of cases of dismissal arising
out of circumstances other than those in
contravention of section 79 of the Ordinance by
amending section 34 thereof to provide for such
cases of dismissal to be referred to the Minister
who may himself, or through the Commissioner of
Labour, inquire into the dismissal and who is
empowered to order the reinstatement or payment of
compensation to an employee who is found to have
been wrongfully dismissed.
I am also happy to note that clause 7 of the Bill
has given effect to the N.T.U.C, representation
that the provision cutting across collective
agreement should not be unduly wide. The original
intention of the Government was to enact that no
collective agreement should contain provisions with
regard to terms and conditions of service more
favourable to employees than those contained in
Part IV of the Employment Act, 1968. The N.T.U.C.,
however, pointed out that since the intention of
such an amendment was to stimulate and promote
industrial expansion in Singapore and that since
the existing collective agreements relate to
employees in existing firms and factories, it was
only logical and reasonable that such a drastic
amendment should be made applicable only to firms
or factories which have not yet been established.
We note here with satisfaction that an acceptable
compromise has been made by the Government in
proposing that only employees in certain specified
industries which are established on or after 1st
January, 1968, are to come within the scope of the
proposed section 24A. We also note that the
proposed section 24A provides that the proposed
restrictions on collective agreements governing the
employees within the
Column: 767
specified industries are to be valid for the first
five years of the existence of the specified
industries. Such measures, though they may appear
to be rather drastic to employees engaged in the
new industries, are necessary to stimulate new
industries and will then lead to the creation of
more job opportunities.
While we are happy that the Government has taken
into consideration our representation by
incorporating some of our suggestions into the
provisions of the Bill, as I have just mentioned,
we cannot help noticing that the Bill also contains
provisions which appear to be unnecessarily
unfavourable to workers. For instance, in clause 4
of the Bill, by which a new subsection (3) is to be
added to the existing section 16 of the Industrial
Relations Ordinance, it is provided that any trade
union representing subordinate staff may seek
recognition in respect of employees in managerial
or executive positions or serve a notice under
section 17 of the Ordinance in respect of those
employees. We are apprehensive of the position of
such trade unions at present representing employees
who may be considered to be in managerial executive
positions. These unions, whose members consist
mainly of employees in non-managerial or non-executive positions, have been given recognition in
respect of employees in managerial or executive
positions and have concluded collective agreements
on behalf of such employees. If such unions are not
to be allowed to continue to represent employees in
managerial or executive positions on the expiry of
the existing collective agreements, then these
employees would be placed in a most untenable
position. It must be emphasised here that the
Industrial Relations Ordinance gives protection to
workers only if they are members of a trade union
which has been accorded recognition by an employer.
Where an employee does not belong to any trade
union, or belongs to a trade union which has not
been accorded recognition by his employer, he has
no effective remedy or redress against
victimisation by his
Column: 768
employer under the Industrial Relations Ordinance.
The position is complicated by the fact that
there are few trade unions to cater for managerial
or executive employees. In fact, there are, as far
as I know, only two unions catering for employees
in managerial or executive positions in the private
sector. It is inconceivable that these two unions
would be in a position to cater for all the
employees in managerial or executive positions
engaged in the various industries in the private
sector in Singapore. Even if they are, there has to
be an inevitable lapse of time before a union can
be given recognition in respect of employees in
managerial or executive positions who have been
formerly represented by a trade union consisting
mainly of non-managerial or non-executive
employees.
While we appreciate the principle that employees
in supervisory positions should belong to unions
different from those of the subordinate employees,
we are rather apprehensive that, in view of such a
radical change to prevailing practices, the
Government has not made any transitional provisions
to safeguard the interests of employees who are in
a managerial position and who happen to be members
of the trade unions representing mainly employees
in non-executive positions. If such managerial or
executive employees have nothing to fear from their
employers, they would never have found it necessary
to be members of the trade unions representing
employees in non-managerial or non-executive
positions. It is a fact which should be duly noted
by the Government when implementing tile proposed
amendment to the Industrial Relations Ordinance.
The other point which I wish to comment on
concerns clause 5 of the Bill which seeks to amend
section 17 of the Ordinance. A new subsection,
which seeks to make certain managerial functions
non-negotiable between an employer and the trade
union representing his employees, has been
proposed. The managerial functions refer to the
rights of an employer in relation
Column: 769
to (a) promotion, (b) transfer, (c) employment, (d)
retrenchment, (e) dismissal and reinstatement, (f)
assignment or allocation of duties. We must point
out that it seems most dangerously lopsided to
enact that such managerial functions are
exercisable at the absolute discretion of the
employer without providing for adequate safeguards
for the workers. In the first place, such
managerial functions exist in common law and it
appears rather unnecessary and superfluous to give
statutory protection to such managerial functions.
But granted that it is necessary from the
Government's viewpoint to give statutory protection
to these managerial functions, the failure to
provide ample safeguards for the workers does not
appear to be justifiable.
To be more specific, in respect of the management
functions pertaining to promotion and recruitment,
no attempt has been made to spell out the criteria
or limits within which an employer can reasonably
exercise his rights. Thus it is open to an employer
to adhere most rigidly to the publicised conditions
for promotion or employment of persons he does not
like and to waive such conditions on any pretext in
respect of applicants favoured by him. It all boils
down to whether an employer can he relied upon to
exercise his management functions in good faith.
Although the provisions pertaining to the rights of
an employer to transfer, retrench, dismiss or order
his employees contain certain safeguards for the
employees, such safeguards are effective only if
the assumption that an employer always acts in good
faith is justified.
On this point, we in the N.T.U.C., being used to
seeing the uglier side of the employer's face, do
not share the .optimism of the Government that
employers can be depended on to behave responsibly
and decently towards their workers. We are fully
aware that industrial or commercial organisations
are profit-making organisations and that it is in
the own interest of the management, whether it be
professional management divorced from the ownership
of tile business or otherwise, to employ the
Column: 770
best talents available or to deploy staff in the
most advantageous manner. But the fact remains that
employers and managers are only human and may
occasionally behave in an irrational and perverse
manner. Our concern is that such behaviour may have
adverse repercussions for the workers and that the
Ordinance does not seek to safeguard the rights of
the workers.
The Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for
Labour in his speech yesterday referred to the
incidence of 389 work-stoppages involving a loss of
1,284,029 man-days during the period from 1960 to
1967. The impression that appears to be given is
that the trade union movement has been
irresponsible in the past and cannot be relied upon
to ensure that work-stoppages of such magnitude
would not occur again so as not to prejudice
Singapore's future industrial expansion programme.
I wish to point out that work-stoppages must
necessarily arise out of trade disputes and that it
takes two parties to make a trade dispute. It is
not fair and correct to blame the occurrence of
each and every dispute on the union involved. For
in the first place, if an employer can be trusted
to give a fair deal to his workers, it would never
have been necessary for the Government to enact
employment legislation such as the Industrial
Relations Ordinance.
I also wish to point out that the reference to
the period, 1960 to 1967, whether intentional or
otherwise, was extremely misleading, to say the
least. The fact is that the Industrial Relations
Ordinance was enacted in 1960 to meet the need for
promoting peace and stability in the field of
industrial relations in Singapore. It takes a few
years for the Industrial Relations Ordinance to be
in operation before its effect becomes evident.
This is substantiated by the published data of the
Statistics Department pertaining to work-stoppages.
For the period 1964 to 1967, the second half of the
period referred to by the Minister, there were only
94 world-stoppages involving the loss of 11,715 man-days which do not amount to even one per cent of
the total for the whole
Column: 771
period. The only conclusion I can draw from this
comparison of figures is that the Industrial
Relations Ordinance has become increasingly
effective during the last few years even without
the gift of managerial functions to employers.
Even now as we are discussing this Bill, there
are employers who are seeking to exploit the
provisions of the Bill to their best advantage,
regardless of the intention of the Government. I
have been given to understand that one commercial
organisation, which has previously applied for the
extension of a collective agreement to which the
trade union concerned has indicated its agreement,
now seeks to oppose its own application before the
Industrial Arbitration Court. The reason for its
action appears to be that the employer anticipates
certain provisions to be superfluous in a
collective agreement in view of the Government's
gift of management functions. Such being the case,
workers cannot be blamed for feeling nervous that
some employers are clearing the decks for wholesale
exploitation of workers.
While it is heartening to know that the
Government has given an assurance that it will not
hesitate to cane the naughty employers, it is our
hope that the Government will not be found wanting
in decisiveness and firmness when it comes to
dealing with recalcitrant employers. The N.T.U.C.
will not be silent if it finds that some employers
take undue advantage of the powers of managerial
functions given to them under this Bill.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
3.43 p.m.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang): Mr Speaker,
Sir, what is the true industrial relations
situation? Are the workers suppressed or are the
employers terrorised? Neither proposition describes
the real situation. But apparently the former
Minister for Labour has quite suddenly come to
think that the workers have gone out of hand and
Column: 772
must be straightened up by harsh administrative and
legal sanctions. It is also apparent that he has
not given a factual account of the real situation.
Those who are deeply involved and concerned with
industrial relations will readily say that labour
and management have matured since the turbulent
years of the 1950s.
From Labour Department sources we gather that
there are fewer and fewer strikes and lock-outs.
The number of work-stoppages for each year since
1955 are as follows: -
1955 - 275 1962 - 88
1956 - 29 1963 - 47
1957 - 27 1964 - 39
1958 - 22 1965 - 30
1959 - 40 1966 - 14
1960 - 45 1967 - 30
1961 - 116
In the first five months of 1968 there have been
only two work-stoppages.
Although there were 18 more strikes, in 1959 than
in 1958, there were fewer man-days lost in 1959
than in 1958 due to work-stoppages. In the 1950s
the work-stoppages were mainly politically
motivated, and so were those in the early l960s.
Whatever the laws might have been, they would not
have made any difference to the trend and line of
action in those years. However, since those days,
industrial relations have gradually progressed and
found their own balance, and restrictive laws will
not at all be conducive to the further development
of better industrial relations.
Industrial relations have made a marked
improvement in the last few years, and this is
eloquently stated in the Singapore Year Book 1966,
which is published by authority. In Chapter Eight,
page 189, it states:
'The marked improvement in industrial relations
noted in 1965 continued throughout the year. There
were only 14 work stoppages during the year - the
lowest since 1961, the peak year for work stoppages
when there were 116 strikes. For the first time, at
the end of the year there were no outstanding
strikes.'
Column: 773
In the same chapter, in page 200, it states:
'The two noteworthy features in the fields of
industrial relations were firstly, that there were
only 14 work stoppages - the lowest since 1961 - and, secondly, the short duration of these work
stoppages. Nine stoppages lasted from 1 to 5 days,
four from 6 to 40 days and only one lasted for more
than 40 days, which altogether involved 1,288
workers as against 3,374 in 1965 and 43,584 in
1961. The number of man days lost as a result of
the 14 work stoppages was 17,807.'
Mr Speaker, Sir, surely there have been disputes - disputes on union recognition, dismissal and
retrenchment. Some were settled by direct
negotiations, some were settled in the Labour
Department, and some were settled in the industrial
Arbitration Court. The cases brought up to the
Labour Department were settled under the very eyes
of the former Minister for Labour, and in some of
the cases, the employees' objections were upheld.
It was true also that the Industrial Arbitration
Court has ruled in favour of the trade unions in
some dismissal and retrenchment cases. These
decisions of the Labour Department and the
Industrial Arbitration Court prove the point that
employers can abuse their powers, and that
employees should be allowed to protest, to object
and to dispute the actions taken by management
which they consider are prejudicial to their own
interests. The very fact that an employer can act,
intentionally or unintentionally, against the
present or future interests of his employee, should
be convincing enough to any man with common sense
and, more, with a sense of justice, to accept the
plea that an aggrieved employee should be allowed
to have the full protection of his trade union
against the high and heavy-handed action of his
employer. If we accept the concept of a free
society, and a society of law and order, then we
must accept accordingly the democratic right of an
individual to protest, to object and to dispute an
action which he considers is against his own
interest.
I firmly believe that an aggrieved employee
should be given the right to
Column: 774
seek justice in the Court, and it would be a shame
to clip the powers of the Industrial Arbitration
Court. The Industrial Arbitration Court is a sound
industrial relations procedure, and any attempt to
circumscribe the jurisdiction and function of the
court is unacceptable. The Industrial Arbitration
Court has obtained the respect of the workers
because it operates on sound principles. In this
connection, I quote Chapter Eight, page 202 of the
Singapore Year Book, 1966:
'The principle upon which the Industrial
Arbitration Court operates is that of offering to
employers and trade unions of employees an award or
decision which will fairly and justly reflect not
only the interests of both parties to an industrial
dispute but also to the community as a whole, as
well as the economy of the Republic.'
With these words of the Labour Department in
mind, it is hard to understand the move to take
away the powers of the Industrial Arbitration Court
to hear cases on dismissal and retrenchment, and
the contingent powers to reinstate dismissed or
retrenched employees and grant suitable reliefs. It
is imperative to note that all dismissal or
retrenchment cases that came up before the
Industrial Arbitration Court were either disputes
arising out of the operation of collective
agreements or disputes jointly referred to the
court, or disputes directed to the court by the
Minister, and included in the latter category would
be cases which his Ministry had failed to mediate
successfully. In all these cases, the trade unions
have more than accepted the awards of the Court. In
fact, they have come to respect the court as a
place of wisdom and justice. Notwithstanding this
realisation, the trade unions have discreetly
settled their disputes out of court. The records of
the court show this attitude. In 1967, the Court
heard four dismissal cases, three union recognition
cases and five retrenchment cases; and in 1966 the
court heard 13 dismissal cases, five union
recognition cases and two retrenchment cases.
The Labour Department, however, still have the
monopoly of dismissal and retrenchment cases
referred by the
Column: 775
trade unions for conciliation and arbitration. Of
the 702 disputes referred to the Labour Department
in 1966 for conciliation, 34.9 per cent were
dismissal cases; and according to the same Report
(Command 7 of 1968), "Retrenchment was again a
minor cause amounting to only 6.6 per cent." Is the
former Minister for Labour suggesting that trade
unions are also terrorising him, his officials and
the court when they were defending their members in
the Labour Department and in the court? Is the
former Minister for Labour claiming that there is a
free-for-all situation with organised workers
terrorising the employers? I think it is a figment
of his imagination. If anything is true, it is that
he possesses the quality of a fiction story-teller
quite common among some reporters who rub in highly
sensational ideas to make a no-story a tall story.
I wish to point out to the Minister that the
general consensus of opinion of workers, not just
trade union members, is that clause 5 and clause 8
of the Industrial Relations (Amendment) Bill to
amend section 17 and section 34 of the Industrial
Relations Ordinance, 1960, is an open invitation to
wield the axe. However, much depends on who the
Minister is, and if the Bill is passed, I think
workers will have to cross their fingers, and wait
and see how he plays his hand in dealing with the
bully-boys amongst unenlightened employers.
This attitude, rightly or wrongly, arouses the
hopes and fears of workers, because the proposed
labour legislation is brimming with prejudice. The
fear created by the new labour legislation in the
worker is that if he is unfortunate to be sick for
too long, he will not get a vacation leave, and
probably he will leave his family destitute. The
fear created in the worker is that if he proves, in
the opinion of his employer, to be not so useful
any more, he will lose his job. The worker is told
if the new labour legislation is not introduced,
there is the
Column: 776
prospect of a grim future for him, and when the
economic situation becomes bad, unlike money and
managerial men, he is stuck fast here. It is fear,
fear, fear without limit.
I think it would be more sensible to invoke the
patriotic spirit to work hard to be more efficient
and productive, and to make the necessary
sacrifices. I think the workers must be made to
feel they are important, useful and effective
digits in society. They must be allowed to decide
the future of the country, and feel that they do
not get the worst deal, whether the circumstances
are favourable or poor. Some may be inclined to
believe that the workers in Singapore have never
had it so good, and if things are going to be bad,
they must have the worst. This is not the correct
attitude to take towards the workers. I firmly
believe that there will be greater participation by
the workers in the affairs of the undertakings if
they are to understand most clearly, to give out
the most and receive the best in return.
The common assertion that it is the employers'
right to make business decisions free from
collective bargaining is based on property rights.
Such a contention is valid as far as the right to
organise and to direct machinery, materials and
money is concerned, but never men. As far as men
are concerned, the property basis of management
carries no legal duty, and no legal compulsion to
co-operate.
An authority on industrial relations has this to
say:
'While property rights carry with them a power of
disposition of goods, they do not carry an equal
power to use those goods if the co-operation of
others is necessary to that use. Co-operation,
without which the property right is reduced to a
power of disposition, cannot be commanded. It can
be won only by consent. And there is no legal
compulsion upon the workers to cooperate. There is
no legal statement of the terms on which co-operation must take place. The definition of those
terms is left directly to those parties involved,
and there is nothing in law to stop the union from
demanding as the price of the co-operation of its
members a voice in some matter previously
independently determined by management. Since the
property rights do not mean that one has command
over others, management
Column: 777
may find it essential to share its authority as a
means of inducing co-operation, in order to
maintain the value of a going business. Over a
period of time, it becomes customary to share
authority in order to win co-operation in certain
recognised areas of business decisions - for
example, wages, hours, or perhaps the speed of
assembly lines.'
The only institution where a man can be managed
and ordered about is the military institution where
authoritarian relationship exists by consent.
However, a military-like regime can never run an
undertaking successfully for long.
I have strongly emphasised the need for greater
participation by workers in the management of
undertakings, because this is a world-wide
phenomenon. The International Labour Organisation's
Recommendation 130 lays down that workers'
representatives should participate in the framing
of personnel policy and the solution of social
questions within the undertaking. The problems that
require the workers' participation cover conditions
of work, welfare services, safety, employment and
discipline, training and a range of matters
involving the workers and having social
consequences.
I think it is clear now that the introduction of
clause 5 to prohibit collective bargaining on
procedures on promotion, transfer, employment,
termination, dismissal, re-employment and
assignment of work is a denial of the workers'
right to participate in the affairs which
immediately affect his life and that of society.
Let me be explicitly clear that trade unions have
never desired to arrogate to themselves the
functions of management in directing the affairs of
the enterprise. Labour only wants the establishment
of rules for management to follow in exercising
their functions. This must necessarily be so, for
workers will suffer if the undertaking is managed
inefficiently or may have to suffer if the
undertaking is to be run more efficiently. In the
former case, it is clear how all those involved in
the enterprise will suffer, but in the latter case,
because of the workers' own productivity, some of
them might be dispensed with. Arising from the
points I have just made, I
Column: 778
think no self-respecting worker and trade unionist
will agree to the matters listed in clause 5 being
withdrawn from the field of collective bargaining.
Mr Speaker, Sir, clause 8 of the Bill seeks to
remove from the Industrial Arbitration Court the
power to hear and decide upon claims by unions for
the reinstatement of employees and to order the
reinstatement where the court is satisfied that the
dismissal was wrongful. Perhaps we in this House
should try to trace the events that led to the
amendment that was made to the previous section 38
of the Industrial Relations Ordinance (now section
40 of the Reprints Supplement). A glance at the
original provisions contained in section 38 of the
Ordinance seems to indicate that the court had
extremely wide powers. Section 38 gave the court
the power to make an award on any matter or thing
for the purpose of settling a trade dispute or of
preventing any further trade dispute even though
the matter or the thing was not one of the specific
reliefs claimed by the parties before the Court. My
trade union colleagues, who had occasion to appear
before the Industrial Arbitration Court in cases
for reinstatement, had on every occasion been told
by the senior representative of the Singapore
Employers Federation, who had argued against the
unions, that the court did not possess the power to
reinstate. His main argument was that, in the
absence of a specific provision empowering the
court to order the reinstatement of a dismissed
worker, the court could not order any
reinstatement. Also, he had, on occasion, compared
the powers given to industrial tribunals in
Australia where the tribunals were specifically
given the power to reinstate and he had proceeded
to emphasise that without such a power the court
could not reinstate any dismissed employee.
The present provision contained in section 40 of
the Reprints Supplement of the Industrial Relations
Ordinance was a direct result of certain proposals
put forward by the National Trades Union Congress
following the adoption of a resolution urging the
Government
Column: 779
to amend certain sections of the Industrial
Relations Ordinance, particularly those contained
in section 38. This took place on the 4th of April,
1964, at the Victoria Memorial Hall, at its first
Annual Delegates Conference. The Recommendations of
the N.T.U.C. on the amendment to section 38 of the
Industrial Relations Ordinance were as follows:
'The powers of the Court are very wide as set out
in this sub-section. There ought to be a provision
here ensuring that before the Court makes any
award, especially in relation to a matter which
does not come within the specific relief originally
claimed by any party, the Court must first bear in
open Court the submissions thereon of all the
parties who are eventually to be bound by the
award.
A specific clause ought to be included here
stating that the Court has the power to order the
reinstatement of employees no matter for what
reason they have been dismissed if for any good and
sufficient reason the Court thinks it fit that such
employees should be reinstated.'
It was as a result of this proposal that the
Government decided to amend section 38 (now section
40 of the Reprints Supplement) giving the court
specific powers to reinstate an employee who is
dismissed.
I have already stated my objection to clause 5,
but my opinion on clause 8 is quite neutral because
it does not matter very much whether general
termination cases are dealt with in the Industrial
Arbitration Court or the Ministry of Labour.
However, I give my support not to withdraw the
jurisdiction of the District Court to hear cases
subject to section 79 of the Industrial Relations
Ordinance.
Mr Speaker, Sir, at this juncture I wish to make
an observation on the futility of clause 5 and
clause 8. Even if the matters listed in clause 5
are non-industrial matters, as defined in the
Industrial Relations Ordinance, there can be
disputes not arising from the terms of the
collective agreement. Such disputes are not
necessarily bound to be referred to the Minister
under clause 8. That is the defect I wish to point
out. I come now to the crucial point
Column: 780
where it may be necessary to take extra remedial
legislative measures to make it unlawful to take
industrial action over "non-industrial matters".
Sad is the day when more restrictive laws are
adopted. Let there not be such a day.
Mr Lim Soo Peng (Havelock): Mr Speaker, Sir,
the Industrial Relations (Amendment) Bill must not
be considered in isolation. It is to be taken
together with the Employment Bill and the Central
Provident Fund (Amendment) Bill as each is part and
parcel of a deal designed to achieve new norms in
industrial relations, terms and conditions of
service and to increase domestic savings which will
benefit our people.
The Government has already explained fully that,
in connection with the Employment Bill, the purpose
is to strengthen our economy and ready us to face
the economic challenges ahead. The other Members of
this House, leaders of industry, commerce and
labour have expressed their views. Academicians and
economists have studied and debated it and the
general consensus of opinion has been that the
Government is not only right but indeed has no
other choice. It has to take stringent measures
even at the risk of being unpopular.
The Industrial Relations (Amendment) Bill sets
industrial relations in its true perspective. This
Bill may appear to the superficially minded and the
superficially inclined as a move against the
interests of labour, but in reality it is not so.
What it seeks to do is to rationalise the position
to prevent in-roads into functions which properly
belong to management. These inroads, whether made
consciously or unconsciously, have led to
aberrations in industrial relations which in turn
have dampened the incentive for some employers to
continue in business, have made them hesitate to
expand business and, worst of all, discouraged
potential new investment.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the function of management is
to manage and workers must accept this fact. It is
only under
Column: 781
such conditions that we can hope to maintain the
present buoyancy in our economy and promote a
climate of stability for further expansion of our
economy so that more jobs can be made available for
our people. The Government's measures are an
attempt to establish a balance between the needs of
the workers and the requirements of entrepreneurs
in the context of our national interest. The
Central Provident Fund (Amendment) Bill, for
example, will enable our workers to own houses and
have a stake in our country. Although the employers
will have to pay more under the new rate of Central
Provident Fund contributions, I am sure none will
grudge the extra payment when the money is put to
good use.
Mr Ho See Beng: Mr Speaker, Sir, I rise not to
oppose the Industrial Relations (Amendment) Bill;
neither do I completely support it. It is obvious
that the Government has good intentions for moving
the amendments. I think the Industrial Relations
(Amendment) Bill has the same motivations as the
new Employment Bill. It would, therefore, be
superfluous for me to go into the whys and
wherefores for the introduction of this amendment
Bill. But I will not be discharging my duty as a
Member for Parliament with labour interests at
heart if I do not point out the objectionable
portions of the Bill as they appear to me. These
amendments seek to vest in the management absolute
power and a completely free hand in dealing with
the employees without any real safeguards for the
interests and welfare of the workers. Such are the
provisions of this Bill that even the most
scrupulous of employers would be stupid not to take
advantage of them to the detriment of their
employees. In the overall interest of the working
class, the dangers and threats posed to their
security by this amendment Bill must be squarely
faced in the hope that employers would also rise to
the occasion and not abuse the absolute managerial
functions handed to them in this "silver statute".
Column: 782
I wish to seek a further amendment to this Bill,
but it is obviously not possible because neither I,
nor my colleagues from the unions, have given
notice. However, I would like to bring to the
notice of the Minister the necessity of further
protective measures in the provisions of clause 5
of this Bill.
Sir, I refer to new subsection (2) (d) of section
17 of the Industrial Relations Ordinance relating
to termination of service on the grounds of
redundancy and reorganisation. I do not wish to
imply that all employers are anti-labour; neither
are they pro-labour. It therefore stands to reason
that there must be some employers who will not
hesitate to exploit the provisions quite blatantly
and, under the guise of reorganisation, create
redundancy where none exists in order to retrench
some of their employees. Here I would like to quote
an example to the Minister for Foreign Affairs and
Minister for Labour who was an editor of a
newspaper before. He knows that if a sub-editor is
made to read the proof, at the stone, there will be
redundancy in the proof-reading department. That
kind of reorganisation cannot be justified. If a
part of the proof-reading job is taken over by the
"stone" editor, the proof-readers will lose their
jobs. I do not doubt that the Minister knows all
about this. There is nothing in this Bill to
prevent such employers from engaging their
relatives or friends a few months after their
alleged reorganisation to fill the positions
previously held by the retrenched employees.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I have no intention to take
steps to negative this clause, but I do ask the
Government to qualify this clause with protective
sub-clauses so that no employer may be able
unjustly to exploit it. As the proposed amendment
now stands, an employer may effect a retrenchment
and the union may only discuss the terms of
severance pay for those retrenched employees who
have more than three years' service.
The Employment Bill, which was read a Third time
yesterday, makes
Column: 783
provision for the payment of such retrenchment
benefits should the union and the employer agree on
the benefits to be paid. The issue can obviously be
referred to arbitration. It is the criterion for
the termination of service which only is precluded
from the purview of negotiation or arbitration. In
some ways, it may be even cheaper for an employer
to retrench his serving employees and save whatever
compensation is due to them, because the amount so
paid up will be more than recouped by the
subsequent savings from employing new and cheaper
labour. Further, the employer can always retrench
employees every two years and eleven months and
thereby pay no severance benefits. Such a situation
is not as far-fetched as the Government would have
us believe. It is because of the distinct
possibility of such malpractices and abuses that I
urge the Government to provide more safeguards for
workers. The protective clauses I seek are:
'(1) Where the union feels that the retrenchment is justified, both employer and union make a joint application to the Arbitration Court to determine the issue. This should be determined by the President sitting alone. While the issue is under the Court's jurisdiction, the employer may go ahead with the implementation of the re-organisation or retrenchment. The Court's decision, when handed down, will determine whether the retrenchment was justifiable or not.'
Sir, it will neither cost the employer anything nor
will retrenchment be delayed, but such a provision
will prevent abuse.
'(2) Where retrenchment has been effected and
upheld by the court or where the union has
agreed that it was justifiable, the employer
is free to engage new staff to fill the
vacancies within six months from the
Column: 784
date of retrenchment. If the employer finds
it necessary to recruit staff, then he shall
offer the appointments to those who have
already been retrenched.'
Sir, I do not believe that any enligtened
employer will object to these protective
provisions, because he will not abuse the powers
that are, as the Minister has said, restored to
him.
Sir, in the case of dismissal, there is an avenue
for appeal under the pro-visions of the Employment
Bill when it becomes law. The dismissed employee
may appeal to the Minister through his union. If
the employer feels that the dismissal cannot be
justified and in order to obviate the risk of
ministerial intervention, he will effect the
dismissal as "retrenchment" it is only calling it
by another name - on the pretext of
"reorganisation". This can happen. As the amendment
stands today, the Minister will be in no position
to intervene and wield the much publicised "big
stick".
Sir, these are my reasons for asking the
Government to consider giving some form of
protection to workers by means of restrictive
clauses designed to prevent abuse of the provisions
by employers.
4.23 p.m.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I am of the view that the introduction of the
Industrial Relations (Amendment) Bill is mainly for
the purposes of creating a climate that is
conducive to investments in Singapore. It will also
allay the doubts and fears of foreign investors who
intend to set up business here. If a wrong
impression is created, it will be detrimental to
our policy of encouraging more foreign investors to
come here.
As a result of our pro-labour policy of
industrial peace with justice, the industrial
relationship between employer and worker has been
very good in the last few years. Many trade
disputes have been resolved by arbitration. There
has been a marked reduction in the number of
strikes and trade disputes. We must
Column: 785
try to maintain the present good relationship
between employer and worker. This Bill is quite
fair to both employer and worker because it
provides that the transfer of any employee must not
be detrimental to his existing terms and conditions
of service. It will therefore prevent unscrupulous
employers from exploiting their employees.
The Bill also provides that in the case of an
employer who abuses his rights by sacking an
employee, the latter can, within a month, appeal to
the Minister for Labour for a withdrawal of the
notice of termination of service and for
reinstatement.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the trade union leaders in the
National Trades Union Congress look after not
merely the interest of labour but also that of the
nation as a whole. In doing so, they seldom
interfere with the rights of employers. They merely
advance advisory opinions and this is not construed
as interference with the rights of employers.
I hope that the introduction of this Bill will
not affect our policy of industrial peace with
justice and that this policy will be maintained.
The present era is not the time for employers to
increase their wealth at the expense of the
workers. The employers should treat the employees
fairly and, at the same time, the employees should
work harder. It is only in this way that we can
contribute to our economic development.
I support this Bill for all these reasons.
4.29 p.m.
Mr Low Guan Onn (River Valley): Mr Speaker,
Sir, with the enactment of the new Employment Bill
into law, a new chapter in the history of labour
legislation in the Republic will have been written
with the complete overhaul of three previous Acts
which were legacies of the colonial past. It
engenders a fertile and attractive investment
climate for both local and foreign capital. But
even with these new terms and conditions of
employment as set
Column: 786
out in the new Bill, investors will still be wary
about investing in our Republic unless certain
management functions such as employment, promotion,
transfer, dismissal, retrenchment and reinstatement
are restored to the rightful party. These are the
inalienable rights of a company's management. In
other words, the Industrial Relations (Amendment)
Bill, 1968, is a natural follow-up of the
Employment Act. These two pieces of legislation are
just like Siamese twins and cannot be separated if
they are to produce the desired objectives which
the Government has in mind.
During the years before 1966 when the history of
our industrial relations was nothing to be proud
of, the unions encroached upon the management
functions of commercial and industrial companies.
For instance, it was almost impossible in those
years to get rid of a malingering and bad worker
because he could take shelter and protection under
the umbrella of his union. Very often if a single
worker was dismissed on strong and legitimate
grounds, it would result in protracted negotiations
between union and management, and if the
negotiations came to nought, it usually ended in a
strike resulting in heavy losses of revenue to the
company. Very often, if it was a foreign concern
and the losses were too heavy to bear, the concern
would just fold up and go away.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I have to remind the trade
union Members of this House that no sensible and
responsible management will try to get rid of a
trained and exemplary worker when he is a manpower
asset in the viability of the company. The profits
of the company depend on his productivity and skill
and the effort he puts into his work. How then can
an employer afford to dismiss such a worker?
Instead, management has to think of incentives to
reward his contribution to his company and to
induce him to work as long as possible for the
company, because a worker takes many years to be
trained before he is really effective in his
contribution.
Column: 787
Moreover, provisions are incorporated in the Bill
by which wrongful dismissals, as stated by the
Minister, can be referred to him, and his decisions
to redress any wrong are final. This is a more
satisfactory procedure to avoid time-consuming
dialogues between the two parties to justify each
other's actions. Therefore, these two Bills will
provide a solid foundation to woo local trading
companies, which are now hesitant, and foreign
industrialists to invest in our island state, as
investment is necessary for our economic survival.
The presence of the British military bases
provides almost 20 per cent of our national income.
This 20 per cent income comes from abroad. With the
British withdrawal by 1971, the whole of this
source of income will be reduced to zero. We will
face a cruel world which does not owe us a living.
We must make up for the loss of this income derived
from the presence of the British military bases
here. We also face competition with other
industrial countries in Asia. We must also maintain
our present standard of living which is the second
highest in Asia. To succeed in all this, we must
raise the quality of our goods and improve the
efficiency of our services to the maximum.
Workers, like any other Singapore citizen, will
no longer be in a privileged position. They will be
called upon to make sacrifices in the national
interest by increasing productivity and efficiency.
Therefore, the trade unions will now have to play a
more positive role in educating their members to
respond to these changes of circumstances which are
crucial in the years ahead for our existence as an
independent and sovereign nation.
The Industrial Relations (Amendment) Bill, 1968,
merely re-establishes the status quo between labour
and management which is long overdue in industrial
relations. With an enlightened attitude and
positive co-operation on both sides, our nation
will co down in the annals of history that we have
Column: 788
achieved the impossible by the enactment of these
two Bills. Our labour will earn the hallmark of
being the most hard-working, intelligent,
responsible, skilled and industrious in Asia. When
this objective is reached, these two Bills will
have generated the establishment of more and more
industries. This will mean more avenues of
employment for our citizens. With that, Mr
Speaker. Sir, I beg to support the Bill.
4.35 p.m.
Mr Rajaratnam: Mr Speaker, Sir, before I deal
with some of the points raised by the hon. Members
opposite, I think I should correct the
misapprehension of one of the hon. Members that I
had quoted statistics relating to strikes to blame
the workers. If he will re-read my speech, he will
see that that was not the intention. The intention
was to show that during the period in the early
1960s, something like 57 per cent of the disputes
arose out of quarrels over management rights,
retrenchment, the right to hire workers and so on.
This was the basis on which this Bill was
introduced, because obviously there is considerable
misunderstanding between workers and management
about what are management rights.
The Industrial Relations (Amendment) Bill now,
for the first time, spells out something which hon.
Members, and especially the trade union themselves,
admit are common law rights. These rights have been
there. They are accepted as such. The rights of the
management to manage have not been queried, except
by the Member for Kallang who has suggested that
workers should also participate in the management
of industries. That is something for the future.
But, at the moment, there is no dispute and no
quarrel over the essence of the Bill.
Where there is misgiving is in regard to the
abuse of these rights by certain employers. Of
course, if one assumes that all employers are
madcaps, then not only this legislation but all
other pieces of legislation go by the board. But
employment laws are normally
Column: 789
made on the basis that employers are reasonable and
we frame legislation to suit reasonable conditions.
But where it appears to us that the number of
madcap employers becomes very substantial, then, as
I made it quite clear in my speech, we will
reconsider amendments to our Industrial Relations
Act with a view to controlling unreasonable
employers. But as things are at the moment, we work
on the assumption that most employers are
reasonable, as most trade unionists are reasonable.
If that feeling prevails and if employers and trade
unionists work on the basis that both parties are
reasonable men, then I think this Bill, when passed
into law, will achieve what we really want to
achieve.
In the debate not only on this Bill but also on
the Employment Bill, there are different objectives
or immediate objectives. Naturally for the trade
unionists, they are only interested in the trade
unions and the workers. The employer is concerned
only with his own sectional interest. But, as a
Government, our interests are national. We are
interested in the welfare of Singapore as a whole - workers, employers and professional men.
One of the main objectives of the Industrial
Relations (Amendment) Bill, as with the Employment
Act, is to resolve serious and real problems of
economic expansion, new investments, increased
productivity. And the overriding test to which we
submit any legislation is, will it help to bring
about these objectives - economic expansion, new
investments, increased productivity? If it can or
if it gives a reasonable assurance that it can,
then the legislation must over-ride the sectional
interests, whether of employers or workers or any
other groups. And this, I am convinced, will help
and definitely bring about industrial expansion,
economic expansion, new investments. If we do not
achieve these objectives soon enough before 1971,
at least in the 1970s, then the arguments about the
right to hire and fire and retrenchment would
become superfluous and unreal, because
Column: 790
there would be massive unemployment. Employers
would be checking out and concerns would be closing
down right and left, in which case even the
exercise of the need for unions would become
problematical. My colleagues and I, and I am quite
sure Members opposite also, are convinced that this
Bill will, when enacted into law, bring about new
investments, industrial expansion and, in the long
run, bigger, more prosperous and stronger unions.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Mr Speaker: Mr Rajaratnam, before we get to the
Committee stage of this Bill, I propose to suspend
the sitting now. I will take the Chair again at 5.00 p.m.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
4.42 p.m. until 5.00 p.m.
Sitting resumed at 5.00 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
Bill committed to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Rajaratnam].
Bill considered in Committee: reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 790
CENTRAL PROVIDENT FUND (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.04 p.m.
The Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour (Mr Rajaratnam): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
This Bill is the third of three Bills which are
designed to meet the challenging economic problems
that loom ahead. Whilst the purpose of the
Employment Bill and the Industrial Relations
(Amendment) Bill is to have more realistic terms
and conditions of service and employer-employee
relations
Column: 791
consonant with the need to induce greater
investment, generate higher productivity and
employment, this Bill deals with another inter-related problem -- the marshalling of domestic
savings for the economic and social benefit of our
people.
Before I deal with the Bill itself, hon. Members
will no doubt like to have the air cleared in
regard to the Fund itself. At the end of 1967,
there were 456,029 members with balances totalling
$477,315,488. The number of active accounts in 1967
was, however, 299,157 and contributions received
during the year amounted to $55.8 million. An
interesting feature of the Fund is that about 60
per cent of the members earn less than $200 per
month, whilst about 31 per cent earn between $200
and $500 per month, and only about 9 per cent earn
more than $500 per month. It would also be
interesting to note that about 57 per cent of the
total membership have a balance of less than $500,
but if we were to consider the total number of
members having a balance of under $1,000 the
percentage would be about 71 per cent. The analyses
given here will help hon. Members, in the light of
what I have to say later on, to appreciate the
effect the proposed amendments to the Central
Provident Fund Ordinance will have on the wage
earning population of Singapore.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the principal purposes of the
Bill are:
(i) to increase the contributions payable to the Central Provident Fund by employers and employees;
(ii) to enable arrangements to be made for members of the Fund to use their savings in the Fund for the purchase of houses or flats for their own occupation; and
(iii) to enable the provisions of the Central Provident Fund Ordinance to be extended to cover persons who are
Column: 792
self-employed and who do not at present
contribute to the Fund.
I shall first deal with the proposal to increase
the contributions. An amendment is made to the
Schedule to the Ordinance whereby new rates of
contribution payable are prescribed. The effect of
this amendment is that the current rate of
contribution of 5 per cent each by employer and
employee is increased by 1½, per cent to make it 6½
per cent each, and the existing provision that
limits the employers' and employees' contributions
to a maximum of $25 per month from each is removed
and a new maximum of $150 per month from each is
substituted. It should be noted, however, that
employees who earn less than $200 per month, will
not, as at present, be required to contribute to
the Fund.
This means that the payment of an additional 1½
per cent by the employer will, in respect of about
60 per cent of the members of the Fund, mean
contributions only by employers towards enhancing
the savings of workers. In an indirect way it is an
addition to workers' pay. The same advantages would
also apply to employees in the higher wage groups.
However, it is not intended to apply the new rates
to the United Kingdom Government and its employees
and they will therefore contribute the present rate
of 5 per cent each. The reason for this is obvious
as hon. Members know that the British are leaving
and retrenching their employees.
The Minister is given powers to vary the schedule
of contributions. The intention behind these powers
is to increase the rate by another 1½ per cent in
the second stage. Therefore, the total savings each
month for the worker as a result of contributions
payable both by employer and employee will be 16
per cent - that is 8 per cent each by employer and
employee. In the third stage, the contributions
will be increased by a further 2 per cent to make
it 10 per cent from each side, or a total savings
of 20 per cent of salary each month. This will
considerably increase the savings of the
Column: 793
employees and build up their reserves in the Fund
which will stand them in good stead both by
enhancing savings and accumulating sufficient money
to purchase houses or flats.
A very significant departure from the existing
law are the amendments to section 25 of the
Ordinance, as embodied in clause 14. This is to
enable members of the Fund to use their savings in
the Fund for the purchase of houses or flats for
their own occupation. A reasonable question that
can be asked in this regard is the basis on which
Government has assessed the situation. I must
inform hon. Members that the Government has
assessed the purchase intentions of the people
through a feasibility survey conducted by the
Economic Research Centre in conjunction with the
Housing and Development Board. This survey has
shown that 49 per cent, or nearly half of the
householders in Housing Board flats, expressed the
intention to buy them, 10 per cent expressed
uncertainty and 41 per cent did not wish to
purchase flats. Among those who wish to buy flats,
16 per cent live in one-room flats, 30 per cent in
two-room flats and 54 per cent in three-room flats.
29 per cent of those who expressed uncertainty live
in one-room flats, 35 per cent in two-room flats
and 36 per cent in three-room flats. An interesting
feature was that 53 per cent of those who did not
wish to buy flats live in one-room flats, 27 per
cent in two-room flats and 20 per cent in three-room flats.
These figures indicate that the proportion of
households wishing to purchase flats varies
directly with the number of rooms in a flat. While
only 24 per cent of those living in one-room flats
wish to buy, 50 per cent of those living in two-room flats and 68 per cent of those living in three-
room flats have expressed a wish to buy them.
In regard to Central Provident Fund balances of
households surveyed, an interesting revelation is
that about 31 per cent have between $1,000 and
$5,000 and 13 per cent above $5,000. About 10 per
cent have between $500
Column: 794
and $1,000 and 21 per cent less than $500. There
are, however, a good number of people in these
households who do not contribute to the Central
Provident Fund but who wish to buy flats. These
people are generally self-employed. Hon. Members
will see that there is, therefore, justification in
enabling members to make use of their savings in
the Fund to purchase houses as a sizable proportion
of our people, whether in or out of the Fund, are
keen to own their own homes. This should give the
lie to those who allege that people are forced to
buy Housing Board flats. With the enhancement of
savings through increased contributions, it can
reasonably be expected that more people will have
enough funds in due course to make down payments
and pay instalments.
Central Provident Fund members who already have
sufficiently large balances in the Fund would be
allowed to use their balances to purchase flats
outright, while those who have already purchased
flats will be allowed to use their monthly
contributions to pay the instalments of their
housing loans, but they will not be allowed to use
their balances to settle outstanding balances of
any existing loans. I must inform hon. Members that
regulations will be introduced to make the
necessary arrangements for implementing the housing
scheme.
The other notable amendment is the provision to
extend coverage to self-employed persons, that is
to say, persons who derive income from any trade,
profession or vocation. Any such person, however,
need not contribute after he has attained the age
of 55 years. Provision is also made to ascertain
from the Comptroller of Income Tax the incomes of
such persons. These are contained in clauses 2 and
14 which amend sections 2 and 25 of the Ordinance.
The necessary regulations in this regard will also
be made in due course.
The other amendments to the Central Provident
Fund Ordinance are in part consequential and in
part designed to
Column: 795
improve the drafting and the administration of the
Ordinance. These amendments, however, include a
number of others which are considered necessary for
other reasons. In particular, provisions have been
made in clause 6 to require employers to contribute
to the Fund in respect of employees over the age of
55 years and to require such employees to
contribute.
Clauses 7 and 8 of the Bill introduce two new
sections designed to clarify the procedure and
conditions of withdrawal from the Fund. The rights
of members of the Fund to withdraw will be
affected: -
(a) by restricting the right of withdrawal on
the ground that a member is leaving Malaya
permanently to persons who are not citizens
of Singapore; and
(b) by discontinuing the existing provision
under which a person who has not been an
employee for more than two years to be
allowed to withdraw if he can satisfy the Board that he is not likely to be an
employee again.
The restriction in the case of persons who have
not been employed for more than two years is
necessary in view of the fact that provision has
been made for self-employed persons to contribute
to the Fund. The existing provision in the
Ordinance that allows such persons to withdraw from
the Fund is not compatible with the new requirement
that they should contribute to the Fund.
The amendment to section 14 of the Ordinance,
which is embodied in clause 9, enables, firstly, a
member's balance in the Fund to be used as security
for the purposes of purchasing a house or a flat
for his own occupation and, secondly, deletes a
transitional provision in the Ordinance that ceased
to have any effect some 10 years ago.
The purpose of clause 10 is to make new provision
to provide penalties for publication of information
by an employee of the Board to unauthorised
persons.
Column: 796
The amendment to section 21 in clause 11 of the
Bill is in connection with approved funds. There
are 26 such funds. It is probable that in many
cases the new rates of contributions payable under
the Ordinance will be of greater benefit to the
employees who are members of such funds than their
existing rights as members of approved funds. The
amendment will merely enable the Minister to
require employers who operate approved funds to
contribute to the Central Provident Fund for their
employees if the Minister so directs. Further, the
deletion of subsection (8) of section 21 of the
Ordinance will affect between two and three
thousand employees who have been exempted from the
provisions of the Ordinance by the Board. It is now
proposed to exempt by Regulations to be gazetted
employees whose country of domicile is outside
Malaya and Singapore and who are employed in
Singapore on an Employment or Professional Visit
Pass issued by the Controller of Immigration.
Clause 12 of the Bill contains a new section
dealing with the refund of amounts paid to the Fund
by error. Most of the provisions of the existing
section 24 have been continued, but provisions have
now been made for dealing with contributions paid
in error by persons who are not employees, and with
errors made in the payment of interest under
section 7A of the Ordinance. The time for claiming
refund of amounts paid in error has been reduced
from three years to one year.
Clause 13 introduces a new section 24A which is
designed to enable the Board to engage in
activities not directly related to the
administration of the Fund and to call for
information under certain circumstances. Hon.
Members will appreciate that in the context of the
present situation, when economic planning is to the
fore, compilation of vital statistical information
relating to employees and employers may be required
from time to time.
Clause 14 includes a number of amendments to
section 25 of the Ordinance, the most important of
which are
Column: 797
those in paragraph (d). The new paragraphs (e) , (f)
and (g) that are added to subsection (1) of section
25 of the Ordinance enable the Minister to make
regulations.
There are a few other amendments which are of
minor moment.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the amendments to the Central
Provident Fund Ordinance proposed in this Bill
usher in a piece of social legislation that brings
to the workers benefits which they did not enjoy
before increased savings to provide for their old
age and the opportunity to buy a house or flat of
their own. This is an exercise in social innovation
and social transformation, an attempt to create as
large a proportion of property-owning population as
possible so that they would have a deep and abiding
stake in the country and thereby revolutionise the
pattern of living of our people for the better.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
5.25 p.m.
Mr Seah Mui Kok: Mr Speaker, Sir, I rise in
support of the Central Provident Fund (Amendment)
Bill. This Bill makes a welcome change from the
Employment Bill and the Industrial Relations
(Amendment) Bill in that it contains provisions
mainly for the benefit of workers in Singapore. The
Bill seeks to increase the existing rate of
contribution to the Central Provident Fund payable
by both employer and employee from 5 per cent to 6½
per cent, 8 per cent and 10 per cent respectively
during the next three years. It appears to be the
intention of the Government that such increases in
the rate of Central Provident Fund contributions
are to be treated as wage increases. The Government
is to be congratulated on moving such an amendment
to the Central Provider Fund Ordinance as the
increased rate of contribution would, in effect,
increase the savings of workers.
In conjunction with the increased rate of
contribution, the Bill also seeks to provide that
the amount of existing deposits credited to each
employee in
Column: 798
the Central Provident Fund can be utilised for
making a down payment for the purchase of a Housing
and Development Board flat and that the subsequent
contributions to the Central Provident Fund at the
enhanced rate of contribution can be utilised for
paying the monthly hire-purchase instalments for
the purchase of such flats. As I see it, such a
provision would enable many workers to make their
dream of owning their own homes come true. This is
particularly so when the Central Provident Fund
rate of contribution is increased to 10 per cent in
three years' time.
While I appreciate that the provisions in the
Bill are for the general benefit to workers,
however, I wish to draw the attention of the
Government to the fact that whatever benefit the
Government proposes to give to the workers under
the Bill may be largely negatived by the action
that would be taken by most employers. It is the
valid fear of workers that employers may offset the
increased rate of contribution payable under this
Bill against the gratuity benefits payable by them
under a collective agreement. Members of the House
may be aware that in most collective agreements,
provision is made for the payment of gratuity
benefit to an employee on his resignation or
retirement from the service of his employer. The
amount of this gratuity benefit depends on the
length of his service. The rate usually averages
five per cent of the last drawn monthly salary for
each year of service, in addition to the Central
Provident Fund contribution payable by the
employer. As it is proposed under the Bill to
increase the Central Provident Fund contribution
ultimately to 10 per cent, and if the employer is
allowed to offset the increased rate of
contribution against whatever gratuity benefit is
payable by him to the worker under the collective
agreement it would, in effect, mean that the worker
would not obtain the benefit of any wage increase
as envisaged under this Bill. I would therefore
urge the Government to look into this problem and
ensure that the
Column: 799
employer does not offset the increased rate of
Central Provident Fund contribution against
whatever gratuity benefit is payable by him to his
workers under the collective agreement. If
employers do this, it will defeat the very purpose
of this Bill which is to enable the workers to
enjoy any increase in wages.
I wish also to comment on an important point
which seems to be ignored under the Central
Provident Fund (Amendment) Bill. I refer to the
problem of persons who are unemployed before
reaching the age of 55 years, at which age they are
only allowed to withdraw whatever sum of money is
standing to their credit in the Central Provident
Fund. Such persons, particularly those whose ages
range between 45 and 50, may find themselves
unemployable in the labour market which is being
flooded with young school-leavers. The tragedy is
compounded by the fact that such persons are
usually family men. The result is that they find
themselves in a most unenviable situation. They
have no jobs and no means to support the family.
They find that they cannot withdraw some of the
monies which are credited to their names in the
Central Provident Fund.
I would, therefore, appeal to the Government
seriously to consider allowing such persons to
withdraw some of the monies credited to them in the
Central Provident Fund. I would suggest that a
person who has been unemployed for five years and
has attained the age of 45 years should be allowed
to withdraw up to 30 per cent of the amount of
money standing to his credit in the Central
Provident Fund, and if he still remains unemployed
at the age of 50, he should be allowed to withdraw
a further 30 per cent of the money standing to his
credit. Such a measure will allow him to make use
of the money when he most urgently needs it either
for supporting his family or for commencing a small
business. This measure also allows him
Column: 800
to retain 40 per cent of the sum of money so
deposited in the Central Provident Fund for use in
his old age, by which time some members of his
family may be able to take over the task of
maintaining the family.
5.32 p.m.
Mr Lee Teck Him(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
a few moments ago, the Minister said that the
Central Provident Fund (Amendment) Bill was to be
introduced in the interest of the workers. He also
stated that there will be 1½ per cent increase in
the amount of contributions and that there will be
provision to enable members of the Central
Provident Fund to utilise money in credit with the
Fund to buy flats. In my view, this may not be
quite correct.
The most important factor is whether or not the
products of our factories are cheap and of good
quality. It is only under these circumstances that
we can compete in the international market. If the
products of our factories are not of good quality
and are expensive, how can the workers be expected
to contribute 1½ per cent more to the Central
Provident Fund? The factories will not be able to
sell their goods. They may even have to close down.
Therefore, in my view this is not a very practical
solution. Contributions to the Central Provident
Fund should be reduced so that the cost of
production to employees may be reduced and our
goods will be more competitive in the international
market. If there are more factories, there will be
more jobs created. I am afraid that if workers
spend their money and their rate of contribution to
the Central Provident Fund is increased, many
factories will not be able to keep down the cost of
production. As a result, they may have to close
down and unemployment will increase.
5.35 p.m.
Mr Rajaratnam: Mr Speaker, Sir, in view of the
fact that hon. Members
Column: 801
are relieved that at least this Bill is the silver
lining in the black cloud which has been hanging
over them for the past few weeks, I think there are
only two points to which I need reply. The first
point is about the question of offsetting the
increased contributions to the new Central
Provident Fund against gratuities payable under
collective agreements. I suggest this is one
instance where the trade unions can legitimately
pursue their job of protecting the interest of the
workers by insisting that ---
An hon. Member: It is also good for the
Government!
Mr Rajaratnam: - the employers do stick by their
agreements.
The other point is the possibility of allowing
people who are unemployed before the age of 55 to
withdraw their Central Provident Fund
contributions. As hon. Members will know, I gave
some statistics which will show that this will not
really help anyone who is unemployed to set up
business. Something like 70 per cent of the
contributors, as I have indicated, have a balance
of $1,000 each. Thirty per cent of that is about
$300. Any man who decides to set up business with
$300 is obviously going to lose that $300 which
will be there if he does not withdraw it when he is
55. So I suggest that this Bill will safeguard at
least many of the younger people. If the Bill is
passed, 20 per cent of their wages every month will
be put into a Central Provident Fund which, over a
period of 10 or 20 years, will be very substantial
enough for them to buy a house and perhaps go into
business.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Rajaratnam].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 802
HIRE-PURCHASE BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.41 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Sir, as a result of higher living standards and
the compelling desire of more and more people in
Singapore to acquire what may be called luxury
consumer goods, such as motor-cars, refrigerators
and television sets, there has been a tremendous
growth in recent years of instalment credit
transactions carried out by resort to hire-purchase
agreements.
The Bill now before this House is principally
designed to control the form and contents of hire-purchase agreements and to spell out the rights and
duties of parties to such agreements. It is also
designed to control instalments-sale financing to
achieve certain objects, namely, to curb inflation
by restricting credit facilities; to specify
classes of goods for particular purposes, or to
divert manufacturing activity and the lending of
money to more productive purposes. The legislation
provides for the exercise of this control by laying
down minimum deposits on hire-purchase agreements
or by restricting periods for which payments by
instalment buyers may be spread.
Quite apart from this, a more pressing reason
that prompts Government to introduce this proposed
legislation is the urgent need to confer protection
upon the less sophisticated members of the
community who enter into hire-purchase agreements
and often experience hardship because of the harsh
and oppressive conditions which sometimes appear in
these agreements.
The Bill takes, as it were, a middle course
between, on the one hand, the policy adopted by the
United Kingdom legislation (which limits the
application of the legislation to hire-purchase
agreements where the hire-purchase price does not
exceed £2,000 sterling
Column: 803
and applies to all classes of goods) and, on the
other hand, the Australian and New Zealand
legislation (which sets no financial limit to hire-purchase agreements and applies to all classes of
goods). The policy in our Bill is that it should
apply only to certain categories of goods which
from their nature are normally purchased under hire-purchase agreements. No financial limit is
specified.
It is with these broad principles in mind that
the present legislation has been drafted and this
Bill, like the Malaysian Hire-Purchase Act, 1967,
incorporates many of the recent concepts that have
been written into the existing hire-purchase
legislation of the United Kingdom and Australia.
The Bill has, as its foundation, three points
fundamental to consumer protection of any kind.
Part II provides adequate disclosure requirements
in a written statement. Built-in terms in favour of
the buyer as to the title to goods and their
merchantable quality with implied warranties and
conditions are found in Part III. Finally, the Bill
in Part VII prohibits contractual provisions that
are unconscionable in their purpose or operation.
The term "hire-purchase agreement" is defined in
clause 2 of the Bill. The provisions of this Bill
will cover all hire-purchase agreements relating to
such goods as may be specified in the Schedule by
the Minister. The goods to which this proposed
legislation will apply are motor vehicles, radio
sets, television sets, gramophone sets, tape
recorders and any combination thereof,
refrigerators, deep-freeze food preservers and any
combination there of, air-conditioners, washing
machines and sewing machines. The effect of this
provision is, on the one hand, to limit the
application of the legislation to certain specified
goods, and, on the other hand, to enable Government
to adapt this legislation to meet Singapore's
changing economic and social needs.
I must stress, however, that, in the preparation
of this legislation, the
Column: 804
Government has not overlooked the consideration
that protection should also be given to the unpaid
seller's interest in the hired goods; he can re-possess the goods 21 days after serving a notice
for non-payment of instalments due. Further, the
rights of third parties who may acquire possession
of goods that are the subject of a hire-purchase
agreement have also been taken into account.
It will be observed that in the definitions of
the terms "hire-purchase" and "contract of
guarantee", transactions in which the hirer is a
dealer of goods have been excluded. The reason for
this is that, being engaged in the business of
hiring, a dealer does not need the protection that
this Bill is designed to give to the ordinary
members of the public. Stocking arrangements that
are entered into between a hire-purchase company
and a dealer are accordingly outside the scope of
this Bill.
It will also be noted that jurisdiction over
transactions in respect of hire-purchase agreements
is vested in the High Court except in some matters
arising under clauses 10, 14 and 23 of the Bill. In
so providing, this Bill follows the statutory
provisions to be found in most Commonwealth
countries that have legislated on this subject. The
principal reason for this is that questions of law
arising from hire-purchase agreements are
invariably complex and are, it is considered, more
suitably dealt with by the High Court.
A novel provision, which does not appear either
in Australian or United Kingdom legislation, is
clause 14 (5) of the Bill which confers protection
upon the owner where the hirer terminates the hire-purchase agreement.
The Explanatory Statement to the Bill outlines in
a general way the various provisions of the Bill. I
would like to mention here that the Singapore
Advocates and Solicitors Society has been consulted
in the drafting of this Bill and many of its
suggestions and recommendations have been
incorporated in the Bill. In spite of this, it is
the intention of Government to refer this Bill to a
Select Committee so as to
Column: 805
provide opportunities to other interested bodies
and members of the public to present their views on
the Bill which I commend to Members as a useful
measure for coping with the social and commercial
requirements of our developing nation.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
5.50 p.m.
Mr Lim Soo Peng: Mr Speaker, Sir, for a long
time our society and economy needed and received
the boost that hire-purchase provides in financing
what consumption and consumer need. But equally for
a long time there was no referee, save a rather
unsatisfactory one originating in the United
Kingdom, and even then ill-tailored for the needs
here. More often than not, the free play of forces
between the borrower and the lender ended in the
borrower losing to the lender. This must be so, for
you cannot afford to quarrel with the man to whom
you are in debt.
With this Bill, a new referee has come into the
ring. The provisions in the Hire-Purchase Act,
1968, as intituled, seek to regulate the form and
contents of hire-purchase agreements and the rights
and duties of parties to such agreements and
matters connected therewith. Whether the provisions
contained in the Bill will make a good and
impartial referee is something only time can tell.
At this moment the provisions appear to be
absolutely necessary. They also appear to have been
carefully considered and drafted. Even forms are
being prescribed and the terms and charges laid
down.
Going through the provisions of the Bill, I feel
that the future borrower will have his rights
protected and the future lender will know precisely
where his relief lies. The Courts are being given
exact areas of jurisdiction, and I think everyone
will be happy except the borrower who borrows with
the intention to abscond, and the lender .who lends
with the intention to squeeze the purchaser. But
the regulation and
Column: 806
control of hire-purchase is a field in which there
is little experience in this country. It is true
that the Bill has the benefit of experience in
other countries. But the experience of the other
countries is not necessarily the prescription for
us. We are an emerging country. We are beginning to
produce more and more goods for our own
consumption. It is essential that while we try to
curb abuses in hire-purchase financing, we do not
kill such financing.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I support the Bill and I should
like to ask the Minister charged with implementing
it to consider representations carefully and to
introduce any amendments whenever needed.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Resolved, "That the Bill be committed to a Select
Committee consisting of Mr Speaker as Chairman and
the following Members:
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim
Mr E. W. Barker
Mr Hwang Soo Jin
Mr Lim Soo Peng
Mr Ng Kah Ting
Mr Sim Boon Woo
Mr Tang See Chim." - [Mr E. W. Barker].
Column: 806
LAND ACQUISITION (AMENDMENT) BILL
5.55 p.m.
Order for Second Reading read.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Sir, the Bill flow before the House seeks
primarily to repeal section 32 of the Land
Acquisition Act, 1966, and re-enact it on the lines
of the corresponding provision in the repealed Land
Acquisition Ordinance (Chapter 248) to provide,
inter alia, that when the claim of an appellant
exceeds by 20 per cent or more the amount awarded
by the Appeals Board, he shall not be entitled
Column: 807
to his costs, and to give discretion to the Board
to reduce his costs or require him to pay part of
the Collector's costs when his claim is considered
excessive or where he has been negligent in putting
his case before the Collector (clause 4).
It is desirable to effect this amendment, as
under the existing section 32 (1) of the Land
Acquisition Act, 1966, it is provided that the
costs of an appeal to the Board shall be in the
discretion of the Board and shall either be fixed
by the Board or, on the order of the Board, taxed
by the Registrar or Deputy Registrar of the High
Court in accordance with the scale prescribed by
the rules of the court for the time being in force.
As this leaves the question of costs completely to
the discretion of the Board, it could be
interpreted that the normal High Court practice in
awarding costs to the successful litigant is to be
followed, which, in its application to land
acquisition appeals, will result in costs going the
way of the appellant even if he succeeds in
obtaining from the Board only a very small fraction
of his claim. The proposed amendment will restore
the position to what it was before 1966, and deter
owners from making excessive claims and act as a
restraint against an owner proceeding with an
appeal regardless of the Collector's award and the
amount of his own claim, as even if he succeeds in
obtaining a slight increase, he will not be
entitled to any costs.
Clause 3 of the Bill is merely a re-enactment of
the existing provision of section 32 (3) of the
Land Acquisition Act, 1966. Although it is proposed
to repeal section 32 of the Act, this particular
provision, section 32 (3), is being retained as it
does not really deal with costs but with the power
of the Appeals Board to confirm, reduce, increase
or annul the award made by the Collector.
Opportunity is also taken, in clause 2 of the
Bill, to amend section 8 of the
Column: 808
Land Acquisition Act, 1966, to enable the Collector
to require the person interested in any land
acquisition to furnish information relating to the
basis, or mode of valuation by which the amount of
compensation claimed by such person is arrived at.
This will enable the Collector to rationalise the
basis of such claim.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. [Mr Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 808
HOLIDAYS (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.03 p.m.
Mr Speaker: Mr Chan Chee Seng. I beg the pardon
of the House. Mr Barker, the Bill stands in your
name. Mr Barker.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That
the Bill be now read a Second time."
The Holidays (Amendment) Bill seeks to reduce the
number of public holidays in Singapore to 11 per
annum. The number of holidays in Singapore has
always been set out in an Ordinance and the number
of 'public holidays has from time to time been
varied in such a manner that it would appear that
each time there is a change in the number of public
holidays in Singapore, this has been, more often
than not, towards an increase in the number of
holidays.
I think it fair to observe that until we joined
Malaysia, the number of holidays was fairly
constant. Although the Yang di-Pertuan Negara, now
the President of the Republic, is empowered by
notification in the Gazette to appoint
Column: 809
special days to be observed as public holidays,
such discretion accorded to him lay only when an
increase in the number of holidays or when a
substitution for an existing holiday was being
contemplated. When we joined Malaysia, this
Ordinance was repealed and in substitution therefor
the Malaysian legislation was introduced to
Singapore. In 1966 we re-enacted the Holidays Act
setting out the legality or otherwise in regard to
certain acts which may or may not be done on public
holidays. By then, of course, the number of public
holidays had increased to the present number of 16
per annum.
Quite apart from these holidays, there were
certain rest days provided for in the various
Ordinances and Acts dealing with workmen and
labourers. These enactments set out certain
compulsory industrial holidays which had to be
observed and for which certain benefits would be
paid to workmen who were required to work on these
days. In the recent measures introduced by
Government in order to prepare the country for the
eventual departure of the British Armed Forces and
for the economic upheavals that may follow in its
wake, we have decided that the number of industrial
holidays should be reduced to 11. At the same time,
it was also thought proper that the number of
public holidays in Singapore should correspondingly
be reduced to coincide with the total number of
industrial holidays per year. Not only then would
the workers, but also all those resident and
working in Singapore, whether in Government
departments or in the private sector, be given
every opportunity to make their contribution
towards the national effort to remain viable
economically, and progress even during the
difficult years ahead.
It would perhaps be appropriate for me, in making
this speech, to tell the House that Government
sought the views of the various religious
communities in our society on the proposed
reduction of public holidays. The Hindus, for
example, given the choice of having Deepavali or
Thaipusam as
Column: 810
a public holiday, have chosen the former. The
Muslims have, after discussions and correspondence
with the Muslim Advisory Board, retained Hari Raya
Puasa and Hari Raya Haji to enable members of our
community who are of the Muslim faith, to discharge
their obligations and attend mosque on those
specific days. The Christians have retained
Christmas and Good Friday, the two most important
dates in the Christian calendar. The Buddhists have
retained Vesak Day. Thus it will be seen that the
choice of holidays that will be retained in
Singapore have had the blessings of the Inter-Religious Organisation, an organisation represented
by all the religious persuasions in Singapore.
The result of this Bill will bring us back to the
less playful conditions which existed before we
started to add on to our holidays as we had to
please more and more religious and cultural groups
in Singapore and Malaysia. I am sure I have the
support of hon. Members. In common with all the
measures that have been introduced in this House at
this present sitting, the main object of this Bill
is to contribute more towards the national well-being.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
6.11 p.m.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, the
proposed holidays are reasonably distributed
racially and religiously and I also agree that the
number of holidays should be reduced in order that
we can increase productivity. But I would like to
propose that the Government reconsider the deletion
of Thaipusam from the list.
Thaipusam has been celebrated in Singapore since
the later part of the nineteenth century and it has
become an important religious celebration not only
for the Hindus but also for the whole population.
The kavadi procession is an attraction to everyone
in Singapore, young and old. Moreover, it is a
tourist attraction, as we all must have seen
tourists following the procession and
Column: 811
busily taking pictures. It will be a great
disappointment both to the local people and to the
tourists if the number of kavadi processions is
reduced because Thaipusam is not a public holiday
and, therefore, workers will not be able to take
part in the processions. I therefore propose that
Government, in order to encourage the tourist
trade, should reconsider the deletion of this very
popular public holiday.
Sir, whenever the Government reconsiders the
question of public holidays, I hope Deepavali
Holiday will not be abolished.
6.13 p.m.
The Minister of State for Foreign Affairs (Inche A. Rahim Ishak): Mr Speaker, Sir, I wish to
support the Bill for a somewhat different reason
from that advanced by the Minister for Law and
National Development. Of the six days allocated to
the four major religions in Singapore two go to the
Christians, two to the Muslims, one to the Hindus
and one to the Buddhists. Quite apart from this, we
have a responsibility to ourselves, in reaching our
goal of nation-building amongst a community made up
of so many races, religions, cultures and
linguistic groups, to look to the other five
holidays, examine what they should signify and how
we should celebrate them.
New Year's Day is, of course, an international
day of rejoicing. Whether it is in the West or in
the East, i.e., in Communist countries or in Japan
or China, the 1st of January is New Year's Day.
This is one occasion for rejoicing and celebration
among all races and all communal and linguistic
groups in Singapore.
But much more significant than New Year's Day is
National Day which is Just around the corner. This
is not a day merely for Muslims, Christians,
Hindus, Buddhists or the other minority religious
groups in Singapore. For that matter, it is not
just for any linguistic or cultural group. It is a
day which all Singaporeans celebrate by taking part
Column: 812
in various activities organised in the various
constituencies. Just as we used to celebrate the
3rd of June as Constitution Day, you will find that
in the last three years since we became
independent, National Day in Singapore has been
celebrated by people of various races and
religions, and by cultural and linguistic groups as
a day of national significance, as a day when we'
achieved full self-government. On 9th August we
will celebrate National Day as a day when we
brought independence and sovereignty unto
ourselves.
In my view, National Day transcends all other
religious holidays which, in effect, are sectional
celebrations, although on these days people who do
not belong to these religious denominations take
part in the festivities too. For example, Christmas
is celebrated by Christians as well as by non-Christians in Singapore. Likewise, Chinese New Year
is also celebrated by the non-Chinese; Hari Raya
Puasa by the non-Muslims. Yet there is nothing to
compare with National Day. The celebration of New
Year's Day and National Day, besides the other
three holidays upon which I do not wish to dwell,
transcends all races, religions, or cultural and
linguistic groups. It is for us, the leaders of the
country, to help promote the significance of
National Day to an even greater degree amongst the
people. National Day is a day of rejoicing which we
should celebrate with even more festivity and
greater significance and feeling. Unless and until
this can be brought home to the people, we will be
back in the old situation where Christmas, Han Raya
Puasa and the other religious festivities of the
other religious groups mean more to these religious
groups than does National Day. This, I think, would
not be a trend towards progress in nation building.
National Day in the present context of an
independent and sovereign Singapore is perhaps
comparable to the 7th of November which is
celebrated in the U.S.S.R. to mark the Great
October Revolution. This has nothing at all to do
with Islam, Christianity and all
Column: 813
the other religions which exist in the Soviet
Union. Yet in that country and in other countries
with similar national days, the celebration of
Independence Day or National Day, whichever you
call it, has meant much more to the people over the
years than just the purely religious festivals
celebrated by certain sections of the people. I
hope in the years ahead, as we slowly grow to
understand the meaning and significance of
independence, the meaning of being free to rule
ourselves, National Day will be celebrated with
greater feeling and significance by people of all
races in this country.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, we all know that Singapore is a multi-racial society and therefore in the provision of
public holidays we give equal treatment to all
racial and religious groups.
I would like to raise one point. I wonder whether
the Minister will consider the addition of one more
holiday to the Schedule to the Bill so as to enable
women folk to celebrate a common holiday. I
recollect that the proposal for a public holiday
for women was raised in 1957. At that time the
People's Action Party was not in power. It was
during the Lim Yew Hock Administration and the
colonial era that we proposed Women's Day as a
public holiday. But we have not achieved our
purpose. The introduction of the Holidays
(Amendment) Bill provides an opportunity. We should
consider the inclusion of a Women's Day in the
Schedule.
I believe you will agree, Mr Speaker, that in
the course of Singapore's history from the colonial
era through the self-government stage to today,
when we are independent, women have contributed
much towards Singapore's history. There are,
however, still many women who are trapped in the
coils of family life. While men are able to enjoy
holidays almost all the year round, women are
confined to the kitchen. Women's Day can be a day
when women will be able to enjoy their freedom and
equality with men. The inclusion of a
Column: 814
Women's Day is, therefore, proper and necessary. I
hope the Minister will consider my proposal.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I feel that the Holidays (Amendment) Bill
introduced by the Minister for Law and National
Development is just and fair to all sectional
interests or groups. The Member for Delta has
suggested the inclusion of another holiday - Women's Day - saying that women are in a less
advantageous position. They are really looking down
upon themselves. If that is agreed, we can also
suggest a Men's Day.
Madam Chan Choy Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I remember that in 1957 when the women members
of the People's Action Party raised this suggestion
for a Women's Day, the Member for Sembawang
supported it.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I feel that what the Member for Delta has
proposed is not quite proper, because today both
men and women have equal rights. Both have
contributed towards nation building. Therefore, we
must not claim special rights or privileges for
either women or men. I feel that the proposition by
the Member for Delta is not appropriate at the
present juncture. I suggest that if there is a
Women's Day, there should also be a Men's Day.
Mr Lee Teck Him(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
the Member for Delta has said that there should be
a day set aside to enable the women of Singapore to
take time off their kitchens. I support this a
hundred per cent. There are 58 Members in this
House but there is only one woman Member. What is
the reason for this great disparity in numbers?
This is because there is no Women's Day for women
and they cannot come out of their kitchen to serve
the nation. There must be a Women's Day so as to
encourage women to take part in national affairs
and so that there will be more women Members of
Parliament. I fully support the proposition by the
Member for Delta.
Column: 815
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like to
thank the five Members who rose to speak in support
of the Bill. I am sure the other Members who have
not spoken would have spoken to support the Bill
had we not been running out of time.
As you can see, it is easy to add on holidays - whether it be Thaipusam, Women's Day or Men's Day -
because that pleases everybody. But the moment you
cut down on holidays, then people get sad. It is my
unpleasant duty tonight - in fact, one of my most
unpleasant duties in Parliament today - to move the
passage of this Bill. As you can see, Mr Speaker,
Sir, you yourself called the Parliamentary
Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs,
thinking that the Holidays Bill was within the
portfolio of the Ministry of Social Affairs. I can
assure this House that the subject of holidays does
not come within the portfolio of the Ministry of
Law. Neither does it come under the Ministry of
National Development. But somehow I am here today
moving something which has got nothing to do with
any of my Ministries. But as I said just now, if
you take something away, people get sad. If they do
not get up and support the Bill, we can understand
it. The Member for Anson wants me to reconsider and
make Thaipusam a public holiday. Like the Member
himself, I myself would prefer Thaipusam to be a
holiday! Like the Member for Delta, I myself would
like a women's holiday!
An hon. Member: What about a Children's Day?
Mr Barker: But in spite of the Women's Charter,
the Member for Delta is still not satisfied. In
this respect, we in Singapore give consideration to
women every day. In fact, every day is a women's
holiday. So I really do not understand this
request. But she has support from the Member for
Ulu Pandan.
Mr Speaker, Sir, suffice it to say that like
other Members of the House, I myself would prefer
more and more holidays. But as I pointed out
earlier in
Column: 816
my opening speech, in view of the British
withdrawal - I hope perhaps with no severe
unemployment or economic problems following in its
wake - this is one of the measures we are taking to
ask our people to work harder - which means you, me
and everybody else. I ask Members to bear with me.
If our island prospers, I am sure the Government
will ask me to come :back here and on that day it
will be my pleasure to move amendments to increase
the number of holidays. But let us first show that
we can work hard and that we deserve more holidays.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 816
DESTRUCTION OF DISEASE-BEARING INSECTS BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.36 p.m.
The Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
In the Addendum to the President's Speech at the
opening of Parliament, it was stated that public
health legislation is being consolidated into a
comprehensive Environmental Health Code, capable of
maintaining the highest standards of public health
required in a modern complex urban society. This
Bill before the House is the first of such codified
new laws which will be introduced to bring about
effective control over public health. In this case,
it covers disease-bearing insect vectors,
principally mosquitoes and flies.
This Bill replaces the 50-year old Destruction of
Mosquitoes Ordinance (Cap. 139) which was mainly
for the
Column: 817
control of malaria by measures specifically aimed
against malarial mosquitoes. The control and
destruction of what are commonly known as
"nuisance" mosquitoes has become a major problem in
recent years. The laws, however, have been
inadequate to cope with the health problems created
by these "nuisance" mosquitoes, such as the Aedes
and Culex mosquitoes which are now established to
be capable of transmitting diseases. Similarly,
the laws are also found to be inadequate to deal
with health problems created by disease-bearing
insect vectors, like flies, fleas, etc.
The Aedes aegypti mosquito, which breeds in
artificial water-bearing receptacles, is the vector
responsible for the transmission of haemorrhagic
fever, dengue fever and yellow fever. There is also
the danger of bancroftian filariasis which is
transmitted by Culex fatigans, a mosquito which
breeds in polluted stagnant water in blocked
drains. The common house-fly is a carrier of food
and water-borne diseases of the gastro-intestinal
tract, namely, cholera, typhoid, food poisoning,
enteritis in children and poliomyelitis The flea is
a parasite which lives on the rat and is
responsible for rodent plague, a disease which has
shown recrudescence in some countries in Southeast
Asia.
Complaints of mosquito nuisances have remained
consistently high over the last ten years. Factors
such as the efficiency of the Health Ministry's
work force and the quality of the supervision and
discipline are important but not enough to effect a
reduction or elimination of these nuisances.
Effective action against all the creators of these
nuisances is not possible under the existing
Destruction of Mosquitoes Ordinance or the Local
Government Integration Ordinance because of its
limited provisions aimed essentially, despite its
title, at malarial control. The rapid urbanisation
and other physical development in Singapore in the
form of vast building schemes and land reclamation
have led to the indiscriminate dumping and storage
of building materials and the
Column: 818
blocking of natural drainage. As a result of these
activities, ideal conditions are created under
which disease-bearing insects can harbour and
propagate, unless the necessary precautions are
taken by those responsible for these activities.
The high incidence of haemorrhagic fever with 815
cases, including 21 deaths, in 1967 reflects a
serious health hazard which makes it vital that
there be effective urban control of mosquitoes
which can no longer be regarded merely as
nuisances.
The evolution of Singapore as the fourth largest
port in the world and the increasing air traffic at
our Paya Lebar International Airport require
adequate provision to deal with the disease-bearing
insects likely to be brought into the country from
ships and ocean-going vessels and from aircraft.
Singapore is a "yellow fever receptive area", which
means that conditions exist under which this
disease can be introduced into the country.
Effective powers to deal with aircraft and to carry
out disinsectisation when indicated are therefore
necessary.
[Mr Deputy Speaker in the Chair]
6.40 p.m.
In the light of the seriousness of the mosquito
and other insect vector problems, as well as the
recognition of the fact that much of this is man-made, new powers and methods to cope with the
situation are needed.
These insects cannot be allowed to proliferate
unchecked as they will constitute a serious danger
to public health. Effective legislation, based on
modern scientific methods of eliminating and
controlling these insect vectors, need to be
enacted to cope with this growing problem.
In framing this new piece of legislation, the
opportunity has been taken to enhance the
preventive and control measures and its enforcement
by providing for more effective action and
deterrent penalties. Powers for summary action and
for composition of the lesser offences have been
included in this Bill. The
Column: 819
emphasis is on preventing the creation of harmful
conditions rather than allowing the conditions to
occur and then taking remedial action.
The Bill also aims to recognise the changes in
the administrative structure since the integration
of local authorities by adopting the styles of
titles and form consistent with the present and
proposed administrative organisation of public
health services.
The main features of the Bill are:
(a) It retains the basic provisions in the old Ordinance that are required for the control of malaria - transmitting mosquitoes.
(b) It streamlines the administrative lines consequent on the integration of the local authorities; defines the functions and powers to be exercised at different levels - the Minister, the Director of Medical Services, the Commissioner of Public Health and/or the Medical Officer of Health and the Public Health Auxiliary.
(c) It broadens the powers to take action to
cover all disease-bearing insects and vests
new powers for summary action, medical
examination of infected persons, blood
examination and insecticide spraying.
(d) It provides powers to obtain information
necessary for epidemiological investigations
and control measures.
(e) Ships and aircraft are for the first time
brought within the scope of this Bill, as
they are now regarded as a potential source
of introduction of new vectors of diseases
from some other territories.
Distinction is made between the overall policy
direction and the routine implementation and
execution of the various provisions in the Bill.
Column: 820
Clause 3 provides that the Director of Medical
Services shall have general superintendence of all
matters relating to this Bill, subject to the
general or special directions of the Minister.
The task of administering the Bill will be
largely in the hands of the Commissioner of Public
Health and/or Medical Officers of Health (as
defined), who are to be assisted by Public Health
Auxiliaries. The Commissioner of Public Health and
such number of Deputy Commissioners and Assistant
Commissioners of Public Health shall under clause 4
be appointed by the President. The Minister may
also, by clause 3, invest any other medical
practitioner in the service of the Government with
all or any of the powers conferred on a Medical
Officer of Health.
Clause 5 provides that the Commissioner, or the
Medical Officer of Health, or a Public Health
Auxiliary may enter and examine any premises or
vessel between the hours of 6 o'clock in the
morning and 6 o'clock in the evening to ascertain
whether such premises or vessel or anything therein
is in a condition favourable to the propagation or
harbouring of disease-bearing insects and further
to carry out, if necessary, the spraying of such
premises or vessel with insecticide. The Medical
Officer of Health may, in addition, examine any
person from such premises or vessel to ascertain
whether such person is suffering from or is a
carrier of any insect-borne disease. If so, he is
empowered to treat medically such person or to
cause a post-mortem examination to be performed on
any corpse found in such premises or vessel. Mr
Deputy Speaker, Sir, this power is absolutely neces
sary since we know that it is quite a fashion among
some youths in this country to grow long hair that
may harbour the flea that may carry the plague.
Where it is expedient for inspection of premises to
be made after the prescribed hours, at least 24
hours' prior notice shall be given to the occupiers
thereof.
Clause 6 prohibits any person from taking, doing
or performing any act or thing which may or is
liable to create
Column: 821
conditions favourable to the propagation and
harbouring of disease-bearing insects. Every person
shall comply with all such reasonable directions as
may he given by the Commissioner, or Medical
Officer of Health or a Public Health Auxiliary.
Clause 7 prohibits the breeding, collecting,
distributing, importing or exporting of any disease-bearing insects without the express written
permission of the Commissioner or Medical Officer
of Health. Such permission may be granted at the
discretion of the Commissioner or Medical Officer
of Health, if he is satisfied that the application
is made for the purposes of science, education or
research and shall be subject to such conditions as
the Commissioner or Medical Officer of Health may
deem fit to impose.
Any person who undertakes or carries out any
operation likely to create conditions which may be
favourable to the propagation or harbouring of
disease-bearing insects must have his plans
approved under clause 8.
Clause 9 specifies the powers of the Commissioner
or Medical Officer of Health to direct any owner or
occupier of premises to carry out specified mea
sures with regard to the premises for the
treatment, destruction or removal of anything
therein as may bring them into a condition
unfavourable to the propagation or harbourage of
disease-bearing insects. If the circumstances so
warrant, discretionary power is given to tile
Commissioner or the Medical Officer of Health to
execute the necessary measures himself. The costs
and expenses will, of course, be charged to the
owner or occupier, as the case may be. This is an
important power that gives tile authorities a
speedy means to bring about the destruction and
removal of conditions favourable to the propagation
and harbouring of disease-bearing insects and
charge the occupiers or owners for the costs and
expenses incurred.
The clearing of undergrowth under certain
conditions without the previous
Column: 822
sanction of the Commissioner or Medical Officer of
Health is prohibited under clause 10.
Clause 11 sets out the general measures which may
be taken by the Commissioner or the Medical Officer
of Health, or the Public Health Auxiliary with the
consent of the occupier of any premises to whom due
notice has been given. The newer method of spraying
premises or vessels with residual insecticides is
provided for in clause 13.
The power to examine medically any person who is
infected or suspected of being infected with an
insect-borne disease is provided for in clause 12.
Epidemiological investigations of insect-borne
diseases will be facilitated by clause 14 which
enables the Commissioner or a Medical Officer of
Health to demand relevant information.
The procedure for enforcement and service of
orders under the Bill is dealt with in clauses 15
and 16 respectively. Any owner or occupier who is
dissatisfied with any of the measures specified in
the notice may, by clause 17, appeal to the
Minister within 14 days of the date of such order.
Clause 20 places the responsibility on the owner
or occupier of premises to look after any works
which have been executed by the Government with the
object of preventing the breeding of disease-bearing insects.
Clauses 21, 22 and 23 provide penalties for
offences under the Bill, while clause 24 provides
for police assistance where needed. These penalties
have been enhanced.
In order to deal with offenders more
expeditious1y, clause 25 gives power to the
Commissioner or any public officer authorised in
writing on that behalf by the Minister, to compound
any offence committed under clauses 6, 7, 8, 10 and
13 by accepting from a person reasonably suspected
of having committed such offence a sum of money not
exceeding $500.
Clause 26 repeats the previous provision in the
Destruction of Mosquitoes Ordinance, making the
Bill applicable
Column: 823
to all property, including that of Government.
This Bill will provide the legal foundation to
enable more effective control of disease-bearing
insects, so that we shall be able to prevent the
creation of foci of infections, the wastage of
manpower through ill health and the needless
expenditure of large amounts f public money to
correct many situations which need not have arisen
in the first place. A new outlook is called for.
The Environmental Health Services must be
considered on a broad and integrated basis with the
emphasis placed on preventive rather than on
remedial action.
Mr Deputy Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
6.56 p.m.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Deputy Speaker, Sir, as I understand it, the main purpose
of the Bill is to destroy harmful insects so as to
safeguard the health of our people and thus make
Singapore the cleanest city in Asia. I think the
introduction of this Bill has a particular
significance to the Minister for Health. Only a few
days after he took over the reins of office, there
occurred several cases of cholera in Singapore. Of
course, according to investigations made later, it
was discovered that the disease was brought into
Singapore from outside. In any case, the occurrence
of this disease indicated that, on the one hand,
the health of the public was endangered and, on the
other, it posed a challenge to our young and
energetic Minister for Health to show whether he
had the ability to deal with this matter.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
6.57 p.m.
The result showed that our young and energetic
Minister for Health had the capacity to deal with
this matter, although he is suffering from a cold
today! When the cases of cholera came
Column: 824
to light, he immediately launched a counter
offensive by implementing new health regulations. A
nation-wide health campaign was launched. With the
full co-operation of all the people of this
country, we have officially declared war on all
harmful insects. We are determined to exterminate
them entirely.
The definition of "disease-bearing insect" in
this Bill is very extensive. In addition to
mosquitoes and flies, it also includes the eggs,
larvae and pupae of such insects.
The Bill is quite meticulous and thorough. Its
aim is to eradicate all sources of harmful insects.
No doubt this is praiseworthy. But the question is
whether its aims can be achieved. This depends on
whether the department charged with the carrying
out of this work can do its work efficiently.
Another important aspect is the co-operation of
the general masses. It is only when they understand
the importance of maintaining hygienic conditions
anti comply with health regulations - that is, by not
throwing rubbish on to open spaces and into the
drains - that we can effectively maintain a high
level of public health. Towards this end, the
Ministry of Health has decided to launch a nation-wide health campaign in October. This is a very
appropriate measure.
At the present moment, the most pressing problem
is how to destroy mosquitoes and flies. As we know,
the reason for the breeding and multiplication of
mosquitoes and flies is the existence of stagnant
water and the choking of drains. There are two
factors which have brought about this situation.
First, the inefficiency of the Public Cleansing
Department. Second, the indiscriminate throwing of
litter by some people. If this is so, we must apply
allopathic treatment to hit the nail on its head.
First, we must remedy the inefficiency in the
Public Cleansing Department. It must maintain its
work of steadily and efficiently clearing the
drains. Second, we must educate our people to abide
by the health regulations and instil in them a
sense of civic
Column: 825
consciousness. And all this with a view to
impressing the tourists, because the first
impression of the tourists is the health condition
of our people.
With regard to hawkers, they must be persuaded to
clear their own rubbish after their business is
over. In this respect, we hope the hawkers'
organisations will come forward and persuade their
members to comply with the health regulations. This
will very soon make Singapore the cleanest and most
beautiful garden city in Southeast Asia in the true
sense of the word. In this way, we will have a
better reputation in the world. Sir, I support the
Bill.
7.00 p.m.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng: Mr Speaker, Sir, in rising
in support of this Bill I have two queries to make.
(1) How is the Ministry going to destroy fleas by
not destroying rats? (2) Why is it that cockroaches
are not included in the Bill?
Sir, as the Minister has rightly pointed out,
fleas, if infected, can cause plague and I can see
no way of getting rid of fleas by means of
insecticides unless rats are destroyed at the same
time. I was hoping that the Minister was going to
tell us of a "get rid of rats campaign" in
Singapore. I hope he will do that.
As regards cockroaches, they are, as everyone
knows, scavengers among the insect world and may
easily be disease-bearing insects. I understand in
certain medical quarters, cockroaches might be
considered to be carriers of viral hepatitis.
Everyone knows that viral hepatitis is quite a
fatal disease. I gather from the Ministry of Health
statistics that there were 700 cases of hepatitis
last year of which 47 were fatal. I hope the
Minister will find ways and means of telling us how
he is going to destroy cockroaches in Singapore.
7.01 p.m.
Mr Rodrigo: Sir, while I welcome the purport of
this Bill, I must express my uneasiness at what
appears to be and could be an unbridled enthusiasm
Column: 826
with which the provisions of this Bill may be
implemented by the officials of the Ministry once
it becomes law. I note that this is a Bill of 29
clauses. One-third or nine of the provisions are
penal. In the nine penal clauses which impose
various penalties for various offences, one clause
- clause 6 - does not specifically describe the
offence for which a penalty is imposed. There is
another clause which encroaches upon the universal
rule that a person's body is inviolate and should
not be medically examined unless he gives his
permission. There is also one clause which
disallows compensation for expenses incurred by a
person for damages.
I hope, therefore, that the rigour expressed in
this Bill does not herald other Bills that will be
issuing forth from the Ministry of Health, since
the Minister himself has said recently that this is
only the beginning.
7.03 p.m.
Mr Conceicao: Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like to
comment briefly in strong support of this Bill.
There seems to be too many beelzebubs, lords of
flies and insects, who, with impunity, encourage
the breeding of insects by their irresponsible
actions. I am personally acquainted with a
situation in which river dredgings have been
decanted on to a vacant piece of land with all the
consequent effects on the health of the people who
live in the vicinity - dredgings which contain
receptacles, rotten logs, broken pails and so on. I
hope, Sir, once this Bill becomes law, it will be
implemented most promptly and with great vigour. In
this, I beg to differ from the hon. Member for
Serangoon Gardens.
I agree with the Member for Sembawang who says
that the composition of this Bill is most thorough.
There is even a clause which states that if there
is any quaint person who wishes to breed, keep,
collect, distribute, sell, import or export any
disease-bearing insects, all he needs is the
permission in writing of the Commissioner or a
Medical Officer of Health.
Sir, I support this Bill.
Column: 827
7.05 p.m.
Madam Chan Choy Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I rise in support of this Bill and all the
effective measures to destroy disease-bearing
insects in order to improve the environmental
health of Singapore. We should not deal with this
matter only on paper. We should also take effective
action at the same time.
Last year, we were told of an anti-mosquito
campaign. But until today, we have not heard
anything further. There has been no vigorous action
in this direction. The result is that mosquitoes
breed everywhere in Singapore. Flies can be seen
all over the city. We can even see flies in
Parliament House. All this is because of two
factors. The first is the inefficiency of the
public cleansing workers. I have been told that
there will be a thorough reorganisation of the
Cleansing Department. I feel that the present
reorganisation has not been effective. There must
be a thorough reorganisation so that the Public
Cleansing Department will be efficient.
The second factor is the behaviour of the public.
These two factors, in my view, must be considered
together. The officers of the Public Cleansing
Department must necessarily make an overall review
of their own position. In respect of the public,
the Ministry of Health has recently taken some
action to inculcate in them the importance of
health. In this respect, I have a suggestion to
make. In launching educational campaigns, such as
the campaign to be launched in October this year,
action should be taken to rally all civic
organisations and form an anti harmful insects
organisation.
For example, last month there was a seminar
conducted by the People's Association on the role
of community centres and environmental health. The
main theme of the seminar was how to promote a
healthy environment. The participants were from
various civic organisations and they were ready to
Column: 828
co-operate with the Government to improve
environmental health and to turn Singapore into the
most beautiful and cleanest city in Southeast Asia.
Therefore, I suggest that the Ministry of Health
call a meeting of leaders of civic organisations to
discuss the question of improving the environmental
health of Singapore.
At the same time, there should be a competition
to name the cleanest streets in Singapore. These
should be given recognition and rewarded. In this
way, we can encourage our people to improve
environmental health more positively and
expeditiously. This is my humble suggestion.
7.09 p.m.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, first of
all, I wish to thank all the hon. Members who have
spoken giving ardent support for this Bill. I would
also like to make some general comments on what
they have said.
First, I would like to deal with what the Member
for Sembawang has stated. He says that the problem
of mosquitoes and flies can only be tackled by a
two-pronged attack on it. Firstly, the public
health workers must be a disciplined and efficient
force. Secondly, there must be co-operation from
members of the public. I could not agree with him
more because I myself have stated in this House
that that is the only way to solve this very big
problem in our Republic.
As regards the reorganisation of the public
health cleansing force, I wish to tell hon. Members
that this is now nearing completion. The
reorganised set-up will be in force as from 15th
August this year. Reorganisation started less than
four months ago. But I assure hon. Members that
after 15th August, there should be some results
because the reorganisation will then have been
implemented.
The other matter about which I wish to inform
hon. Members is that with
Column: 829
the passing of the Employment Bill yesterday, it is
now possible for the Ministry of Health to
implement another very important programme, i.e.,
to get its public cleansing workers to work 365
days a year, including Sundays and holidays. I
assure hon. Members that this will also have its
effect on the problem of flies and mosquitoes.
The Member for Joo Chiat has mentioned two
specific problems posed by rats and cockroaches. I
would like to correct him by saying that although I
did not specifically mention that cockroaches are
also included in the Bill, the Bill covers all
disease-bearing insects. If the Member for Joo
Chiat says that cockroaches are disease-bearing
insects, then by definition they must come within
the purview of the Bill. He is a medical man and as
he has given an expert opinion, I will accept that.
Therefore, cockroaches are included in the Bill.
As far as rats are concerned, I agree with him
that we must first catch the rats in order to get
at the fleas. It is not that the Ministry of Health
have not in mind a rat-catching campaign, but they
must first deal with the disposal of rubbish. We
will launch this anti-litter campaign in October
and I assure hon. Members that as soon as we finish
with that, we will go on to cockroaches, rats and
so on. I am sure many hon. Members here who are
young and energetic will certainly co-operate and
support us physically in our rat-catching campaign.
I also hope that the Member for Ulu Pandan, who is
past 55 years, will also support us in the rat-catching campaign.
The Member for Serangoon Gardens has said that
certain provisions in the Bill, when implemented,
might result in unbridled enthusiasm on the part of
my Ministry's officials. I will be very happy if
that is the case.
The Member for Delta, on the other hand, has
expressed some misgivings that this campaign,
although announced, might not come off at all. I
assure her and other hon. Members that it will
Column: 830
be conducted with vigour, and this time I hope we
shall succeed.
As for the suggestion by the Member for Delta
about seeking the aid of all civic organisations,
that is certainly what we have in mind in our
October campaign. We will be seeking their
participation and if they have a mass following, we
shall invite them to participate.
The Member for Delta has also another good
suggestion - that we should hold a competition to
name the cleanest streets in Singapore. But we have
an even better suggestion. We shall not only name
the ten cleanest streets but also the ten dirtiest
streets in Singapore, and woe betide hon. Members
within whose constituencies those ten dirtiest
streets might happen to be!
Finally, may I say something about the provisions
on compensation? It is stated in clause 19 of the
Bill that no compensation will be paid for any
expense incurred or damage occasioned by any act
done in pursuance of the provisions of the Bill
unless such damage has been occasioned maliciously
or without reasonable cause. In such matters as
control of mosquitoes, flies and disease-bearing
insects, such a provision is necessary. I can
assure hon. Members that, in the exercise of their
duties, my officials will be instructed to handle
with care the property of the occupiers on whose
premises they conduct an inspection, and that they
will be given strict instructions that they should
not take any action which will unnecessarily result
in damage to property.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Chua Sian Chin].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 831
DEPARTMENTAL TITLES
7.23 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs (Mr Chan Chee Seng) (for the Minister for Social Affairs): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
beg to move the motion* standing in my Minister's
name on the Order Paper.
* The motion reads as follows:
That this Parliament, pursuant to section 3 of the Departmental Titles (Alteration) Ordinance (Chapter 55), resolves that the Schedule to the said Ordinance be amended by the addition under the headings of "Old Title or Name of Office" and "New Title or Name of Office" respectively of the following: -
"Principal Probation Officer. Chief Probation and Aftercare Officer".
The Departmental Titles (Alteration) Ordinance
provides for the substitution of new titles or
names of officers where there has been a change of
departmental title. Section 3 of the Ordinance
provides that Parliament may, by resolution, add to
or amend the Schedule to the Ordinance. The change
of title from "Principal Probation Officer" to
"Chief Probation and After-care Officer" is the
result of the implementation of the recommendation
of the Prisons Inquiry Commission, 1960, wherein
the probation service of the Social Welfare
Department was reconstituted with effect from 1st
January, 1967, as the Probation and Aftercare
Department of the Ministry of Social Affairs. The
change of title in the Schedule to the Ordinance
will
Column: 832
enable the powers and duties of the Principal
Probation Officer in the Probation of Offenders
Ordinance, 1951 (No. 27 of 1951) and other
legislation to be exercised by the Chief Probation
and Aftercare Officer.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Parliament, pursuant to section 3 of
the Departmental Titles (Alteration) Ordinance
(Chapter 55), resolves that the Schedule to the
said Ordinance be amended by the addition under the
headings of "Old Title or Name of Office" and "New
Title or Name of Office" respectively of the
following: -
" Principal Chief Probation and
Probation Aftercare Officer".
Officer.
ADJOURNMENT
Resolved, "That Parliament do now adjourn to a
date to be fixed." - [Mr Chua Sian Chin].
Adjourned accordingly at
Twenty-five minutes past Seven o'clock to
a date to be fixed.