| Parliament No: | 2 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 28 |
| Sitting No: | 10 |
| Sitting Date: | 23-12-1968 |
|
Column: 781
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
FIRST SESSION OF THE SECOND PARLIAMENT
PART II OF FIRST SESSION |
VOLUME 28 |
Monday, 23rd December, 1968
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Mr P. Coomaraswamy).
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang).
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development and Leader of the House.
Inche Buang Bin Omar Junid (Whampoa), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta).
Mr Eric Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh).
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (MacPherson), Minister for Health.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong).
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister for Finance.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah).
Column: 782
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division).
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu).
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (Kampong Kapor).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah).
Mr Lim Kim San (Cairnhill), Minister for Defence.
Mr Lim Soo Peng (Havelock).
Mr Low Guan Onn (River Valley).
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford).
Inche Mohd. Ghazali Bin Ismail (Aljunied).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon).
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Communications.
Inche Rahmat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour.
Column: 783
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Potong Pasir), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (Law Division).
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens).
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee).
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang).
Inche Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampong Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour and Government Whip.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance.
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology.
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampong Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Column: 784
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng (Joo Chiat), Deputy Speaker.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications.
ABSENT:
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Inche Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Education.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Wee Toon. Boon (Sepoy Lines), Minister of State for Defence.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken (Alexandra).
Column: 783
PERMISSION TO MEMBER TO BE ABSENT
Under the provisions of clause 2 (d) of Article 30
of the Constitution of Singapore, I have granted
permission to the following Member to be or to remain
absent from sittings of Parliament (or any committee
of Parliament to which he has been appointed) for the
period stated:-
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten) - from 24th to 31st December, 1968.
| | (P. COOMARASWAMY) |
| | Speaker, |
| | Parliament of Singapore |
Column: 784
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
CONSIDERATION OF MORE THAN ONE ITEM OF
SUPPLY BUSINESS
Resolved, "That, notwithstanding the Standing
Orders, the second and third readings of the Supply
Bill for 1969, the Supplementary Supply (No. 2) Bill.
1968, and the Supplementary Supply (No. 3) Bill,
1968, be taken today." - [Dr Goh Keng Swee].
Column: 784
SUPPLY BILL
Order for Second and Third Readings read.
2.32 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim) (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker,
Column: 785
Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a
Second time."
The Main Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure for
the financial year 1st January, 1969, to 31st March,
1970, have been considered and approved by the House
as Cmd. Paper 27 of 1968. Under section 85 of the
Constitution of Singapore, heads of expenditure other
than statutory expenditure to be met from the
Consolidated Fund have to be included in a Bill to be
known as the Supply Bill. The purpose of such a Bill
is to provide for the issue from the Consolidated
Fund of the sums necessary to meet the expenditure
and the appropriation of these sums for the purposes
specified therein.
The Supply Bill before Members is to give
legislative approval for the issue of funds from the
Consolidated Fund to meet the sums of expenditure for
the financial year 1st January, 1969, to 31st March,
1970. In the Schedule to the Bill are shown the
various heads of expenditure and the sums that may be
incurred in respect of each head. These have been
approved by the House in the Estimates of Expenditure
for the financial year 1st January, 1969, to 31st
March, 1970, and appear in pages 53 and 54 of Cmd.
Paper 27 of 1968.
Once the Supply Bill is approved, the Minister for
Finance will be empowered to issue warrants
authorising expenditure up to the amount under each
head as shown in the Bill to be paid out from the
Consolidated Fund.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Third Reading
Mr Speaker: Mr Tang, will you please move the
Third Reading?
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Third time."
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 786
SUPPLEMENTARY SUPPLY
(NO. 2) BILL
Order for Second and Third Readings read.
2.36 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim) (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
The purpose of this Bill is to provide statutory
authority in accordance with clause 2 of Article 87
of the Constitution of Singapore for additional
provisions for expenditure in excess of the pro
visions for expenditure authorised by the Supply Act,
1967. These additional sums have been scheduled as
Supplementary Estimates which have been considered
and approved by the House as Cmd. Paper No. 16 of
1968.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Third Reading
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Third time."
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 786
SUPPLEMENTARY SUPPLY
(NO. 3) BILL
Order for Second and Third Readings read.
2.38 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim) (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
The purpose of this Bill is to provide statutory
authority in accordance with clause 2 of Article 85
and clause 2 of Article 87 of the Constitution of
Singapore for additional provisions for
Column: 787
expenditure in excess of the provisions for
expenditure authorised by the Supply Act, 1967. These
additional sums have been scheduled as Supplementary
Estimates which have been considered and approved by
the House as Cmd. Paper No. 25 of 1968.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Third Reading
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Third time."
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 787
NATIONAL MUSEUM
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.40 p.m.
The Minister for Science and Technology (Dr Toh Chin Chye): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That
the Bill be now read a Second time."
The purpose of this Bill is to legislate for the
formation of a Museum Board. Members of this board
will be drawn from the public. The purpose of this
board is to advise the Director of the Museum on the
setting up of exhibits in the museum and generally to
make the museum attractive so that visitors to the
museum will find it a pleasure to do so. Members of
this board will be drawn not only from those
connected with education but also generally from
people who find that using the museum is instructive
and educational.
Question proposed.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten): May I point out a
typographical error? The first word "Act" appearing
in the first line of page I should have been "An".
The word "An" is misprinted as "Act",
Column: 788
Mr Speaker: Yes.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Dr Toh Chin Chye].
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
2.43 p.m.
Clauses 1 to 3 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
The Chairman: The clerical error as pointed out by
Mr Ng Yeow Chong will be corrected.
Bill reported without amendment; read a Third time
and passed.
Column: 788
STAMP (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.44 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim) (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a
Second time."
Members will recollect that in the Budget Speech the
Minister for Finance mentioned that the rates of
stamp duty for a number of items, most of which have
not been revised since the 1930s, would be revised to
bring them in line with the present value of money
and to suit present day conditions. From the revenue
angle, the most important item of stamp duty is on
conveyances on property, accounting for 40 per cent
of the stamp revenue during 1966. The existing rate
is $2 for every $100 or part thereof. It is proposed
to base the duty on a sliding scale. Where the value
of the property is up to $30,000, there will be no
change in the existing rate and, as such, purchasers
of Housing and Development Board flats or other low-cost houses will not have to pay higher stamp fees.
Where the value of the property is above $30,000,
and not more
Column: 789
than $50,000, there will be an increase of 50 cents
for every $100 or part thereof on the value of the
property exceeding $30,000. In respect of property
exceeding $50,000, there will be an increase of $1
for every $100 or part thereof on the value of
property exceeding $50,000. It is quite reasonable
that purchasers of property of higher value pay more.
At present the rate of duty on the transfer of
shares and stocks is 15 cents for every $100 or part
thereof where the name of the transferee is filled
prior to the execution of the transfer, in other
cases, the rate is 20 cents for every $100 or part
thereof. It is proposed to increase the stamp duty to
20 cents and 30 cents respectively.
The present fee of 10 cents per share certificate
will be increased to $1 for every $1,000 or part
thereof of the par value in respect of new share
certificates. This revised rate will also apply to
certificates issued in respect of bonus and rights
issues. The higher fee is justified because, in
subsequent transactions, very often shares change
hands without registration, resulting in a loss of
revenue. At the same time, the existing flat rate of
50 cents on a contract note will be replaced by an ad
valorem duty. A duty of $1 for every $1,000 of the
value of the shares and stocks will be payable.
The stamp duty on cheques will be raised from 10
cents to 15 cents and on receipts from six cents to
10 cents.
Apart from these, there are small increases in the
rate of stamp duties on mortgages, leases, insurance,
appraisements, etc.
There is, however, no increase in the duties on 15
items. These consist of the following five items for
which there has been no increase in the rates since
1935.
(i) bonds on superannuation annuity - the rate is
25 cents for every $100;
(ii) bonds of any other kind whatsoever - the rate
is $5;
(iii) apprenticeship deed - the rate is $1;
Column: 790
(iv) policy of sea insurance, where the premium
does not exceed $1 - the rate is five cents; and
(v) life insurance policy for every $1,000 insured
- the rate is 10 cents per $1,000 or part
thereof.
The first two items affect people in the lower
income group and item (iii) affects students who wish
to learn a trade. In the case of item (iv) , if a
higher duty is charged, it may divert business to
other countries as the policy of sea insurance could
be taken elsewhere. In the case of life insurance
policy, the rate is not increased because there is an
automatic increase in the amount of stamp duty
payable with the larger value of life policies being
taken now.
The ten items for which the rates have not been
increased since 1952 are as follows:
(i) affidavits and statutory declarations - $2;
(ii) bonds on letters of administration where the
estate does not exceed $10,000 - $2;
(iii) power or letter of attorney for appointing a
proxy or where the value of a property is
below $1,000 - $1;
(iv) any instrument certified or endorsed by a
public notary - $2;
(v) reconveyancing of mortgaged properties and
securities:
(a) where the amount of monies secured does
not exceed $1,000 - $1;
(b) where the amount of monies secured is
between $1,000 and $10,000 - $3;
In any other case, the rate is $10;
(vi) declaration of any trust or instrument
chargeable with duty on a settlement - $10;
(vii) appointment of a trustee - $10;
Column: 791
(viii) duplicate of any instrument chargeable with
duty - $2;
(ix) protest of bill or note made by a public notary
attesting the dishonour of a bill of exchange
or promissory note - $1; and
(x) revocation of any trust of any property other
than a will - $10.
The specific rates of duties affect generally people
in the lower income group. Affidavits and statutory
declarations are required by people for purposes of
identity cards, birth certificates and for admission
of children to schools, etc. In the case of bonds on
letters of administration, the specific duty is only
applicable for release of estates of less than
$10,000. This will affect families with small means.
Power or letter of attorney appointing a proxy to
vote at a meeting is a very small item of revenue.
In the case of the other items, the present rates
are reasonable, considering that the parties affected
would have to pay duties on the other instruments
connected with the transactions.
Members will note that where the items affect people
in the lower income group, the duties will remain
unaltered and, at such, the revision of stamp duties
will only affect people who can afford the small
increases in the rates.
Clause 2 of the Bill seeks to amend section 36 (1)
of the Stamp Ordinance by increasing the flat fee for
adjudication from $1 to $25 to cover the cost of
services performed by the Commissioner of Stamps. In
addition, it is proposed to introduce a fee where the
value of the property has to be certified by .1
Government valuer. This fee will be based on the
difference between the amount declared by the
applicant and the amount certified by the Government
valuer as follows:
(a) a fee of one per cent will be charged on the
first difference of $10,000;
Column: 792
(b) a fee of half per cent will be charged on the
next difference of $90,000.
Where the difference is in excess of $100,000, the
rate of duty will be one-quarter per cent. This
measure is necessary to circumvent and discourage
under-valuation by applicants.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 792
STATUTORY BOARDS (TAXABLE SERVICES) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.55 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim) (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
Sir, before I deal with the Bill which covers two of
the four new taxes announced by the Minister for
Finance in his Budget Speech, I would like to say
that the response of the public to the additional tax
measures is heartening. These tax measures have been
described as mild and fair because the new taxation
has been kept to the minimum and the additional
burden is spread thinly over a large number of
persons who are able to pay without being over
burdened.
Some Members have expressed fears that the levy on
Public Utilities Board bills will cause hardship to
the poor households. In fact, the levy is based on
the ability to pay and the burden on the lower income
group is minimal. This has been achieved by avoiding
any additional tax on cheaper cooking fuels and by
exempting households whose
Column: 793
P.U.B. bills do not exceed $10 a month.
There is a rough relationship between
the amount of the P.U.B. bill and the
economic status of the household. The
very poor are not on the P.U.B. billing
list or have bills between $1 and $5.
Such households use only little electricity
for lighting and consume little water.
The next group with P.U.B. bills
between $6 and $10 consumes more electricity
and water. There are some
58,000 households, or roughly 25 per
cent, whose monthly P.U.B. bills are
less than $10. These people do not have
to pay tax on their bills. As the income
rises, households purchase refrigerators,
radios, television sets and install fans,
water-heaters and air-conditioners. The
average monthly cost of power for each
of these appliances is as follows:
Average
Article cost of power
per month
Fan $3 to $4
Refrigerator $3 to $4
Television $3 to $4
Water-heater $5 to $6
Air-conditioner
(one horse-power unit) $27 to $30
It is also possible to isolate the really
poor households y the type of cooking
fuel used, suhc as kerosene, charcoal
and wood. Sir, may I rfer to teh
Singapore Sample Household Survey,
1966, which was conducted by the
Ministry of National Development and
the Economic Research Centre,
University of Singapore? It is entitled
Singapore Sample Household Survey, 1966, No 1,
and printed by the Government Printer in
September 1967. The table I refer to,
Sir, is H.54 at page 234 of the Report.
According to this survey, of the total 331,952
households; kerosene was used by 104,399 households; charcoal was used by 32,675 households; and wood was used by 58,231 households;
collectively accounting for 59 per cent of
the households. There are about 73,000
P.U.B. consumers whose monthly bills
range from $10 to $20. They will be
liable to pay a levy of five per cent.
Nearly half of these households will
Column: 794
have to pay between 50 cents and 70
cents per month and the other half will
have to pay between 75 cents and $1
more per month. The small levy will not
cause any hardship as these households
are in the better financial position, or
otherwise they would not be in a
position to have fans, radios and
refrigerators.
The next category of households,
numbering 32,000, have P.U.B. bills of
between $21 and $30. They will be required
to pay a levy of 10 per cent.
These households will have to pay
between $2 an $3 a month. Such households will normally have fans, television sets and refrigerators and the extra $2 to $3 a month is not likely to
involve any sacrifice on their part.
There are about 50,000 households
with P.U.B. bills above $30. These
households are the more affluent and
they have refrigerators, television sets,
water-heaters and even air-conditioners.
These households also have two or three
water closets. I am sure that these
people can afford to pay a levy varying
from $3 to $12 per month. Members
will agree that the tax which rises from
a few cents to a few dollars in line with
the economic status of the households
is not unreasonable.
The levy on Singapore Telephone
Board - for short, I shall just say
S.T.B. - bills will only affect people
with means, as the less well-to-do are
unlikely to have a telephone. There are
45,104 residential lines and 35,552
business lines for our population of two
million people. This is the first time for
more than a decade that telephone subscribers
will have to pay an additional
amount, as the telephone charges have
not been revised since 1958. Resisdential
subscribers who do not make trunk calls
frequently will, on the average, pay about
$3.50 per line per month. I am sure the
amount of tax is far from being
exorbitant and can be borne easily.
Although new administrative machinery
is not requried for the collection
of taxes on P.U.B. and S.T.B. bills, it is
Column: 795
necessary to provide by enactment of this Bill, legal
authority for the imposition and collection of these
taxes. The definition of "services" and "taxable
services" in clause 2 of the Bill includes letting of
apparatus or appliances.
Clause 3 of the Bill empowers the Minister to
specify by publishing an order in the Gazette the
statutory boards and the services which will become
taxable as well as the rates of tax to be charged.
Clause 4 gives the power to the statutory board for
the collection and recovery of this tax in such
manner as approved by the Minister.
Clause 5 stipulates that the tax collected under
this Bill shall be paid into the Consolidated Fund.
Clause 6 gives the power to the Minister to exempt
any person from the payment of this tax. Under this
provision, the Minister for Finance intends to exempt
subscribers of the P.U.B, whose bills are below $10
per month and industrial consumers of electricity
using more than 400,000 units of electricity a month.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 795
CUSTOMS (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.05 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim) (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
Column: 796
The Bill before Parliament seeks to amend the
Customs Ordinance, 1960 (No. 44 of 1960) to
streamline customs procedures with a view to
improving the efficiency of the Customs Department
and reducing inconvenience to traders.
I shall now deal with the important, amendments.
Section 14 of the Ordinance is amended by the
addition of a new section - section 14A - to allow
for goods manufactured, assembled or produced in
Singapore which are not subject to excise duties and
which have been exported to be re-imported without
payment of import duty. The importers will, however,
have to satisfy the Comptroller of Customs that such
goods have not undergone any processing or
manipulation outside Singapore. At present, such
exemptions are given on an ad hoc basis by the
Minister. This causes some delay in clearance of
goods and unnecessary correspondence.
Under the existing Ordinance, drawback of duty is
allowed on goods, subject to import duty, but not on
goods, subject to excise duty. Clause 18 of the Bill
extends drawback facilities to locally-manufactured
products which may be subject to excise duty.
At the moment, the power to levy or vary the special
tax on diesel-engined vehicles lies with Parliament.
Clause 6 is intended to transfer the power to the
Minister. This will enable any changes to be made
speedily by a Ministerial order.
Clause 9 of the Bill simplifies the procedure for
the duty-free importation of bona fide trade
samples.
Clause 11 of the Bill dispenses with the need for
customs permits for dutiable imports except
intoxicating liquors or tobacco where the duty is
less than $100. This will expedite clearance of
passengers.
The other amendments are to raise the minimum amount
from $10 to $100 for drawback claims and to reduce
the period during which claims can be made from 12
months to six months, to give discretionary power to
the Comptroller,
Column: 797
to waive collection of duty of less than $5, and to
increase the maximum composition fee from $600 to
$1,000 which is the level prevailing in Malaysia.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.- [Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third Time and passed.
Column: 797
CINEMATOGRAPH FILM HIRE
DUTY (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.13 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim) (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
The Bill now before Parliament proposes two
amendments to the Cinematograph Film Hire Duty Act,
1966. An amendment to section 10 to limit the amount
of gross receipts which may be deducted by a film
renter for the purposes of film hire duty assessment,
and the other is an amendment to section 16 to enable
senior officers of Customs to compound offences under
the Act where the amount involved does not exceed
$100.
Film hire duty is assessed at 60 per cent of the
gross receipts of a renter derived from the renting
of films. For the purpose of duty assessment, a film
renter is allowed to deduct from the gross receipts,
proceeds derived from the sale or hire of advertising
materials or accessories used in connection with the
distribution or hire of films. There have been
instances of renters deducting unreasonably large
amounts in this respect, thus reducing the amount
assessable for duty. As a remedy to such abuse, the
amendment to section 10
Column: 798
of the Act limits such deductible amounts to 10 per
cent of the gross receipts or $50, whichever is the
lesser.
At present, senior officers of Customs are empowered
to conduct court prosecutions on behalf of the
Comptroller of Customs and Excise for offences under
the Act. Experience has shown that it is desirable to
provide powers for such officers to compound offences
involving sums of less than $100 to avoid taking
cases to the court. This is effected by the proposed
amendment to section 16 of the Act.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 798
DIPLOMATIC AND CONSULAR
OFFICERS (OATHS AND FEES) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.18 p.m.
The Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour (Mr S. Rajaratnam): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg
to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Singapore's international trading character, coupled
with the fact that many of our citizens often travel
to different parts of the world, makes it necessary
that officers of our Diplomatic Corps should be
enabled to administer oaths or affirmations, take
affidavits and do notarial acts which notary publics
in Singapore are normally empowered to undertake, and
for these to be valid in law.
From the copies of the Bill which have been
provided, Members will have seen that the primary
purpose of this Bill, as set out in clause 3, is to
Column: 799
empower diplomatic and consular officers of Singapore
missions abroad, as well as those consular agents who
may be acting for Singapore in countries where we are
unrepresented, to perform these functions and levy
appropriate fees for such services.
Members will appreciate that the process of
consolidating the friendly relations we have
established with foreign countries will take time,
money and personnel. Much as we would wish to do so,
it will not be feasible to establish missions in
every friendly country. As of today, we have
diplomatic missions in 11 countries. In alphabetical
order, our missions are located in Bangkok, Cairo,
Canberra, Jakarta, Kuala Lumpur, London, New Delhi,
Phnom Penh, Tokyo, Washington and Wellington. Besides
these, we also have a Commissioner in Hong Kong and a
permanent mission to the United Nations. With our
citizens travelling and doing business with more
countries than those in which we are represented,
Singapore has to depend upon friendly governments
with missions in those countries where we are
unrepresented for the performance of the functions
envisaged in the Bill as and when the need arises.
As of today, Members will be interested to know, and
note with appreciation the fact, that we have
hitherto been assisted in this respect by the
Governments of Malaysia, the United Kingdom and
Thailand in different parts of the world where we
have no missions of our own. Provision is, therefore,
made in the Bill for such situations where these
friendly governments can perform the functions
envisaged in the Bill on our behalf and for these to
be valid in law.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Rajaratnam].
Column: 800
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 800
SEAMEN'S REGISTRY BOARD
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.24 p.m.
The Minister for Communications (Mr Yong Nyuk Lin):
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
There has been, in recent years, an increasing
demand for Singapore seamen as a result of which the
reserve pooi of seamen registered in the Seamen's
Registry Board has fallen below the accepted minimum
of 20 per cent. As at 31st October, 1968, the total
number of seamen on the register was 8,264, and a
reserve pool at 20 per cent would be 1,653, but the
actual availability was only 1,258 or 15 per cent of
the total number of registered seamen in Singapore.
The demand has arisen, firstly because of the
cessation of confrontation by Indonesia with
consequent new job opportunities, and the preference
for Singapore seamen in relation to other Asian
seamen, and, secondly, because of our Government's
promotional activities for more jobs at sea. Our
training ship "Singapore", which was started in 1964,
has so far creditably produced over 1,600 trained
seamen. This training ship scheme, however, is not
capable of significantly increasing the output of
trainees to meet the urgent demands at hand.
Consequently, a crash programme to increase the
supply of seamen has been drawn up by our Seamen's
Registry Board.
Briefly, the new scheme will supplement what our
training ship is able to produce, by allowing
shipowners to take on a flexible number of Singapore
citizens to acquire the skills of seamanship through
on-the-job training on board ship. Such men will be
expected to do the jobs in the category in which they
are employed under the guidance of experienced hands,
and they will he required to serve for a period of
six
Column: 801
months before being discharged. Those who
satisfactorily complete the six months' period will
be given provisional registration as ordinary ratings
for a further period of six months. Those who
satisfactorily complete both their on-the-job
training period and their period of provisional
service, that is, after one year's service made up of
two periods of six months each, will be registered as
regular seamen and they will then be free to select
employment on home-trade, local-trade or foreign-trade ships.
Shipowners who participate in the new scheme are
free to select and sign-on Singapore citizens whom
they consider suitable for on-the-job training on
their ships, without having to go through the
Seamen's Registry Board. As an encouragement and
incentive, owners of foreign-going ships are entitled
to seek reimbursement from the Seamen's Registry
Board at the rate of $35 per month per person in
respect of trainees who have successfully completed
their six months' on-the-job training, on board their
ships. I am pleased to state here that the Singapore
shipping community have responded favourably to this
scheme and have indicated their willingness to
participate as and when the new scheme is introduced.
It will, therefore, be necessary to amend the
Seamen's Registry Board Ordinance, 1957, so that the
men selected for the on-the-job training by
shipowners will not be required to go through the
process of selection by the Board, as stipulated in
the present Ordinance. The Seamen's Registry Board
(Amendment) Bill seeks to achieve this by excluding
probationer deck-hands, probationer engine-room hands
and probationer catering hands signed on ship's
articles under the scheme from the definition of
"seamen" in section 2 of the Ordinance. This
amendment will allow shipowners to take on untrained
men for training on their ships.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
Column: 802
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. --[Mr Yong Nyuk Lin].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 802
MERCHANT SHIPPING
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.33 p.m.
The Minister for Communications (Mr Yong Nyuk Lin):
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
Before I proceed to discuss the contents of this
Bill, allow me to elaborate a little on the
background of the subject. Prior to the formation of
Malaysia, Singapore was a Port of British Registry.
With Malaysia, Singapore became a Port of Malaysian
Registry. Soon after the separation in 1965, we
decided to establish our own Registry of Ships, and
the Merchant Shipping (Amendment) Act of 1966 was
accordingly promulgated. Under this piece of
legislation, ownership of Singapore ships was
confined to Singapore citizens and companies
incorporated in Singapore and having their principal
place of business in Singapore. Indeed, Singapore
citizens and companies were compelled under the law
to register their ships as Singapore ships. While, on
the one hand, an obligation was imposed upon
Singapore citizens and companies to register their
ships with us, on the other hand, no corresponding
incentives were offered. It was not surprising,
therefore, to find that after one year of the
establishment of our Registry, as at 31st October,
1967, there were only 298 ships on the Register
totalling some 123,000 gross tons. Of the 298 ships,
244 or 82 per cent were tugs, barges, dumb lighters
and other small harbour craft.
Consequently, a review was made and we decided that
we should remove the restriction on ownership of
Singapore ships and offer attractive incentives so
Column: 803
that, by making it worth while, ship-owners would be
induced to fly the Singapore flag. Members may
recollect that the then Deputy Prime Minister, now
the Minister for Science and Technology, stated in
Parliament during the course of the Budget debate in
December last year that legislation would be
introduced this year to encourage more ships to fly
the Singapore flag.
The Bill before this House seeks to amend the
Merchant Shipping Ordinance to enable Singapore to be
a party to the International Convention for the
Safety of Life at Sea, 1960, and to establish an open
Registry of Ships. At present, Singapore is a party
to the 1948 Safety Convention. This Convention
prescribes certain requirements relating to the
construction and survey of ships, provision of life-saving appliances and radio equipment, safety of
navigation, carriage of grain and of dangerous goods.
Signatory governments are obliged to apply these
prescribed standards to their ships. The 1960
Convention is in scope and content essentially a
revision and extension of the 1948 Convention which
it replaces. Being a major port and having a vital
interest in the development of merchant shipping, it
is necessary for Singapore to accept the 1960
Convention. The first part of this Bill, therefore,
contains provisions whkh will enable Singapore to
give effect to the provisions of the 1960 Convention.
This is achieved by deleting Part III of the existing
Ordinance which deals with passenger ships only and
whith contains outdated provisions, and substituting
therefor a new Part III. Under this new Part III,
ships are required to hold Safety Convention
certificates, and provision is made for the issue of
the appropriate certificates for both passenger ships
as well as cargo ships. Power is given to the
Minister to make the necessary regulations to
implement the provisions of the 1960 Convention.
The second part of this Bill seeks to amend the existing
Ordinance to
Column: 804
provide for an open Registry of Ships in Singapore.
This is achieved by deleting the existing Part XIV
and substituting a new Part XIV. The ownership of
Singapore ships is not restricted to Singapore
citizens or companies incorporated in Singapore.
Under section 504, any person or company,
irrespective of nationality and place of
incorporation, is eligible to register ships under
the Singapore flag. Where previously ownership was
confined to Singapore citizens and companies, this
clause now provides an opportunity for foreign
shipowners to place their ships under the Singapore
Register.
However, it would not be sufficient merely to open
the Register to foreign shipowners and companies.
Incentives have to be provided for to make it worth
while for shipowners to fly the Singapore flag, and
I, therefore, draw Members' attention to section 512
which provides for very low fees for the registration
of ships. An initial registration fee of $2.50 per
net ton, and an annual tonnage tax of 20 cents per
net ton only shall be payable for every Singapore
ship. It is provided that this fee and annual tonnage
tax shall not be increased for a period of 20 years
from the date of initial registration of the ship.
Shipowners will note that these rates are very much
lower than those charged by other flags.
In addition to this incentive of low fees, we will
provide another extremely attractive financial
incentive, which is that no Singapore income tax is
payable on profits derived from ships registered in
Singapore. Financially, therefore, a shipowner need
only pay very low fees, the rate of which is
guaranteed for 20 years, and profits derived from
Singapore ships are exempt from Singapore income tax.
I should like to assure shipowners that although
income tax exemption provisions are not specifically
stated in this Bill, appropriate amendments to our
Income Tax laws are expected to be introduced in
Parliament in the near future.
In addition to these financial incentives, we will
also be providing other advantages of an
administrative
Column: 805
and technical nature. Shipowners who wish to transfer
their ships to the Singapore flag will not be
required to have them re-surveyed if the ships
possess valid certificates. As a matter of fact,
this policy of not requiring ships to be re-surveyed
has been in force since early last year and will be
continued. Further, provision is made in section 509
(4) to accept foreign tonnage certificates. This
means that a ship holding a foreign tonnage
certificate need not be re-measured for tonnage when
transferring to the Singapore flag. Again, this
practice has already been in force and will continue
to be so. The acceptance of valid certificates and
foreign tonnage certificates will obviate the
necessity to have the ship drydocked and re-measured,
and consequently will save the shipowner considerable
expense.
As an added facility, international classification
societies will be appointed to survey Singapore ships
and issue certificates on behalf of the Singapore
Government. At present, four classification societies
have been appointed, namely, the American Bureau of
Shipping, the French Bureau Veritas, the British
Lloyds Register of Shipping, and the Norwegian Norske
Veritas. Two other international classification
societies are also being considered for appointment
and, when appointed, shipowners will have six
classification societies for the purpose of survey
and issue of certificates. In addition to these,
there is, of course, our own Government Survey
Division whose services are available to shipowners.
So altogether there will be seven survey authorities
fully empowered to survey Singapore 'ships and issue
certificates on behalf of Government and, with the
six classification societies giving international
coverage, shipowners will be assured of maximum
survey facilities wherever their ships may be. Power
to appoint classification societies is given in
section 160.
On top of all this, our registration procedures will
be kept simple so that the whole process can be
expeditiously completed. We will do everything
Column: 806
possible to facilitate the transfer and registration
of ships to the Singapore Registry.
Members may want to know what we hope to gain out of
this exercise. With income tax exemption and very low
fees, we could not hope to gain much by way of
revenue although the acquisition of a large tonnage
would bring in some useful revenue. We hope, by
encouraging foreign shipowners to register their
ships under our flag, to create more employment
opportunities for our citizens. Under section 527,
Singapore ships engaged in home and local trade
voyages shall be obliged to carry such percentage of
Singapore seamen as may be prescribed from time to
time. This may seem onerous at first sight, but it is
really not so, because these home and local trade
ships are already carrying Singapore seamen. To
encourage more foreign-going ships to take on
Singapore seamen, we would refund 50 per cent of the
annual tonnage tax if the foreign-going ship carries
at least 25 per cent Singapore seamen. This is
provided for in section 527 (2). In this way, owners
of foreign-going ships can reduce costs simply by
engaging Singapore seamen.
With regard to officers, the existing Ordinance
requires Singapore ships to be manned by officers
holding Singapore certificates of competency or
Commonwealth certificated officers. Since we are
very short of local deck officers, we will be
prepared to grant liberal exemptions so that
Singapore ships may be manned by officers holding
valid foreign certificates. As a matter of fact, this
policy of granting exemptions was implemented about a
year ago, and during the period January 1967 to
November 1968, 53 exemptions were granted to allow
foreign certificated deck officers to sail on
Singapore ships.
Finally, Mr Speaker, Sir, the Bill provides the
Minister with powers to make such regulations as are
necessary or expedient. There is no need for me to
go into the details of the various' regulations that
we will promulgate in the near future, but I should
like to deal with an important set of regulations.
Column: 807
relating to the construction, survey and equipment of
ships. This set of regulations, which will be known
as the Safety Convention Regulations, will give
effect to the International Convention for the Safety
of Life at Sea, which I mentioned earlier. I would
like to say that we expect all Singapore ships to
come up to international standards. We will not allow
sub-standards in matters of construction, surveys and
equipment. But, on the other hand, we will not insist
on excessive standards. All that we ask of the
shipowner is to maintain his ship in accordance with
international standards as prescribed under the 1960
Safety Convention. Consequently, our Safety
Regulations will be derived substantially from the
regulations annexed to the 1960 Convention. The
Safety Regulations are already in draft form and can
be expected to come into force in the not too distant
future.
In conclusion, Sir, I would like to say that since
the mention of new legislation in Parliament in
December last year, we have had many inquiries from
ship-owners all over the world on the new Registry.
Members may wish to know that as at 30th November,
1968, there were 349 ships exceeding 242,000 gross
tons on our Register. Although it is gratifying to
note that the registered tonnage has almost doubled
since October last year, the figure is still not
commensurate with our status as a major shipping
centre. I am confident that with the passing of this
Bill and with all the incentives enumerated, more
shipowners will fly our Singapore flag.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
3.51 p.m.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng (Joo Chiat): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
know that there are many advantages in having ships
registered in Singapore. But what worries me is what
will happen in case of accidents, say leakage of oil
from a tanker registered in Singapore? Is the
Government of Singapore responsible for such
incidents?
Column: 808
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Sir, I think this is a question
which is exercising the minds of legal experts the
world over. So I would hesitate to try to be one up
on them. It is not wise to anticipate too many
obstacles and problems so that you do nothing. First,
I think we should get more ships registered with us
and then think of the consequences, if any, later.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.- [Mr Yong Nyuk Lin].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 808
LEGITIMACY (AMENDMENT)
BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.55 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That
the Bill be now read a Second time."
The Bill which is now before the House seeks to
amend the law relating to legitimacy of one's
children. Although it is a general principle of
English law that children born out of wedlock may,
nevertheless, become legitimate children of their
parents if and when their parents subsequently marry
after the birth of such children, this has not been
the case in Singapore in regard to all members of our
several communities.
This anomaly in the law has resulted from the fact
that our society seeks to accord the respect due to
such personal laws of the various sects and religions
that form part of our multi-racial population. And so
it is that those members of our society that belong
to the Muslim faith are governed by their own
personal laws in respect of such matters as marital
laws, family laws and laws of succession. Those of
the Muslim
Column: 809
faith, therefore, are governed by those precepts of
the Muslim law as would be applicable to the
respective schools of Muslim law to which they
belong.
However, the general precepts of Muslim law were
consolidated in the very comprehensive Administration
of Muslim Law Act which was passed in 1966. That Act
specifically provides that members of our society who
belong to the Muslim faith are obliged to register
their marriages at the Shariah Court. Unfortunately,
although it is so provided in that Act that such
registration of marriages must take place, it was not
provided in regard to children that were born of
legal marriages, should they be born out of wedlock,
that they would receive the consequential benefits of
having their status altered and becoming legitimate
children of their parents. In other words, Sir, the
principle of legitimatio per subsequens matrimonium
was not afforded to them. This obvious omission
should, in fact, have been taken care of in the Act
of 1966 itself. It is therefore to provide for this
hiatus in the law, i.e., legitimation of children
born of such marriages, that the present Legitimacy
(Amendment) Bill is being introduced.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
3.59 p.m.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng: Mr Speaker, Sir, with the
exception of those people of the Muslim faith, what
will happen to our citizens born out of wedlock and
whose parents do not subsequently get married? Are
they going to be labelled for the rest of their lives
as bastards? Or will they be ordinary citizens of
ours and not have the stigma of bastards?
Mr Barker: Sir, if the parents refuse to marry,
then, of course, the children will he illegitimate.
The Legitimacy (Amendment) Bill covers only cases
where parents marry after a child or children are
born. So until the date of the marriage, the children
are illegitimate. But when they marry, that act
Column: 810
of marrying makes the children legitimate. But unless
the parents are married, I am afraid the children
will still be illegitimate.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng: Mr Speaker, Sir, the point I am
getting at is, what will happen to our citizens whose
parents were never married? Will they carry on for
the rest of their lives as illegitimate citizens of
this country in the eyes of the law, and what happens
when they hold passports, and so on?
Mr Speaker: Perhaps they are not illegitimate
citizens of the country but are illegitimate children
of their parents.
Mr Barker: Sir, legitimacy has nothing to do with
citizenship. Whether the children are born out of
wedlock or whether or not their parents are married
does not affect their citizenship. But if the
children are illegitimate and if the father or mother
dies intestate, they do not share in the distribution
of the estate unless, of course, there is a will. But
illegitimate children can still be citizens - if that
is what has been worrying the Member for Joo Chiat.
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I think what is in the mind of the Member for
Joo Chiat is the status of the child who is born
illegitimate and whose parents subsequently do not
marry, and whose status as citizens has not been
disclosed, because the issue becomes a citizen of the
state only if at the time of his birth his parents
are citizens of the state.
Mr Speaker: I believe there is a provision in the
Constitution which says "one of whose parents is a
Singapore citizen". So if one parent is a citizen it
is immaterial if they are not married at the time of
the child's birth.
Mr Rodrigo: Sir, if the status is not disclosed at
the time of the birth of the child, then the issue
cannot be said to be a citizen of the state. I think
that is what is in the mind of the Member for Joo
Chiat.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng rose -
Column: 811
Mr Speaker: Mr Yeoh, I take it that you are
seeking a further point of clarification and not
making another speech?
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng: Sir, another point which I have
in mind is this. Can illegitimate children who
subsequently grow up become Ministers of State or
Ministers?
Mr Barker: Do you have anybody in mind?
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I wish to ask the Minister one
question. When an illegitimate child grows up and
marries, will he still be illegitimate?
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang): Mr Speaker, Sir,
on the question of children who are born out of
wedlock, I do not think there is any difficulty in so
far as citizenship is concerned, because the child
will follow the citizenship of the mother. There is
no need for the child to have a parent or father who
is a citizen of Singapore for the purpose of becoming
a citizen of Singapore.
Mr Speaker: The debate on the Second Reading cannot
be used as an excuse for seeking legal advice from
the Minister.
Mr Barker: Sir, first, if I may deal with the
Member for Sembawang who asked whether the subsequent
marriage of the child, when he is of age, will make
him legitimate. It can never make him legitimate. If
he marries, his children will be legitimate.
With regard to the queries by the Member for Joo
Chiat and the Member for Serangoon Gardens, I think
they have been answered by the Member for Bukit
Panjang. But there are difficulties when children are
born out of wedlock, because sometimes the father is
disclosed in the birth certificate or a notification
of birth. Sometimes, of course, the father's name is
not disclosed. But if the children are illegitimate,
then the father, whoever he may be, has no right
whatsoever over the child. It is
Column: 812
the mother who has the sole right to the child.
Therefore, the citizenship of the child will follow
that of the mother.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 812
PUBLIC UTILITIES (AMENDMENT)
BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
4.10 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That
the Bill be now read a Second time."
Sir, the Public Utilities (Amendment) Bill proposes
a number of amendments which, it is considered, in
the light of experience gained in the administration
of the Public Utilities Ordinance since it was
brought into force in 1963, will make administration
more effective.
The Bill makes provision for the transfer of powers
vested in the Yang di-Pertuan Negara (now the
President) under the Ordinance to the Minister. The
amendments provided for this, under clauses 2 and 3
of the Bill, will bring the Ordinance in line with
the Port of Singapore Authority Ordinance, 1963, the
Housing and Development Ordinance, 1959, and the
Telephone Board Ordinance (Cap. 107), wherein the
appointments to the Board thereunder are made by the
Minister.
With the expansion of the Public Utilities Board's
functions and activities and the tremendous increase
in the work which members of the Board have to
undertake, it has become necessary to expand the
membership of the Board. It is, therefore, proposed,
under clause 2 of the Bill, to increase the member
ship of the Board from nine to 12. Consequent on this
increase, the quorum
Column: 813
at meetings of the Board will also be increased from
five to seven, which is in clause 4 of the Bill.
Provision is made under clause 5 of the Bill for the
Public Utilities Board to collect fees for services
rendered by the Government or any of its departments
or any statutory body. The amendment will also
empower the Board to grant or guarantee loans to its
employees to enable them to purchase houses for their
use or for any other purposes specifically approved
by the Board as being likely to increase the
efficiency of the employees.
The new subsection (1) introduced by clause 6 of the
Bill gives the Board power to appoint committees from
among its members. The new subsection (2) under this
clause will enable the Board to delegate to its
committees certain of its powers, functions and
duties. At present the Board is empowered under
section 22 (1) of the Ordinance to delegate such
powers, functions and duties only to its employees.
The enlargement of the membership of the Board, and
the power to appoint committees to which certain
powers, functions and duties can be delegated will
not only relieve the Board of some of its onerous
duties but will also enable the Board to conduct its
affairs more expeditiously.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
4.13 p.m.
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
think it is obvious that there is a necessity for
enlarging the composition of the Board. From the
reports of the Board, the electricity generation has
doubled from the time the Board took over, and the
consumption of water and gas has increased by more
than 50 per cent. However, I do not consider that by
increasing the membership of the Board it will be
able to cope with such expansion. The United Kingdom
Central Electricity Generation Board, for example,
has
Column: 814
more full-time members than the Public Utilities
Board has. If we can align the composition of the
Public Utilities Board with that of the United
Kingdom Central Electricity Generation Board, it is
likely that the efficiency of the Board can be
further improved.
Sir, I note that with the resignation of the
previous Deputy Chairman of the Board, the loss of
whose services we have greatly felt, there are, at
present, no technical personnel sitting on the Board
whose functions are mainly concerned with the
installation and supply of public utilities such as
power, water and gas. Can the Minister give an
assurance that at least some technical personnel will
be appointed on the Board so that they may be able to
give competent advice? Sir, I am not doubting the
ability of the present members of the Board. But I am
sure that with technical men sitting on the Board,
they will be of great assistance.
Sir, I have gone through the reports of the Public
Utilities Board since its inception in 1963, and 1
have found that it has gone to great lengths to
publicise the activities and achievements of the
Board. If I am not mistaken, sometime in 1964 or
1965, the Board appointed some American consultants
to look into the administration and organisation of
the Board. But since 1963, and up to the latest
report which we have, that is 1966, no mention has
been made about this whatsoever.
Mr Speaker: Mr Low, I find it difficult to see how
the line of argument you are now pursuing arises out
of the Bill.
Mr Low Yong Nguan: Sir, I just want to show why an
expansion of the membership of the Board is necessary
Mr Speaker: Please proceed, Mr Low
Mr Low Yong Nguan: Under the provisions of the new
clause in the amendment Bill, there should be a
standing committee comprising Board members to look
into the question of administration or organisation,
because
Column: 815
there is an apparent drop in the efficiency of the
staff of the Board. I will quote one example. Not
long ago, a member of the public paid a deposit for
the supply of gas. But after repeat, ed inquiries,
nothing happened. It was only when I rang up that the
whole matter was solved in two days and the gas
supply was turned on. This shows that there is a drop
in the general efficiency of the Board. I think the
setting up of a standing committee to look into the
organisation and daily functions of the Board is
urgent. That is why I have said that there may be a
necessity for more full-time members to sit on the
Board.
Sir, I also feel that a standing committee should be
set up to look into the de-salinisation of water with
the co-operation of the Ministry of Science and
Technology.
Mr Speaker: Order. Mr Low, I am afraid I have to
rule that you are in breach of the Standing Orders as
the subjects you have raised are not relevant to the
provisions of the Bill. If you have any comments on
the increase in the size of the Board, or the
additional powers of the Board, or the power to
appoint sub-committees under clause 6, please address
your remarks to those points.
Mr Low Yong Nguan: Mr Speaker, Sir, I wish to
stress the necessity for standing committees because
of the increase in the Board membership. In any case,
I accept your ruling. I have concluded my speech.
Mr Barker: Sir, the Bill seeks to increase the
membership of the Board from nine to 12. The Member
for Crawford wants to go further. I do not know
whether he is right, but I would appeal to him to let
this go for some time, and if we find that 12 are not
sufficient, we will come back here and get more
members on the Board. But a dozen is quite a big
number and any Board beyond that number might become
too big and unwieldy.
Column: 816
The Member is correct when he says that with the
retirement of the previous Deputy Chairman of the
Board, there are hardly any others left with engineer
ing experience. But new members of the Board will be
appointed soon and I assure the Member that at least
one will be an engineer who will be of great
assistance in the Board. Of course, I must remind the
Member that there are engineers in the Public
Utilities Board and, if not in the Board, at least in
the Electricity Department or the Water Department or
the Gas Department.
As for standing committees, there are standing
committees but they have no blessing of the law
behind them. Hence this Bill, one of the clauses of
which empowers the Board to delegate its powers and
duties to smaller subcommittees.
As for some of the other points raised by the
Member, I will not reply to him since you, Mr
Speaker, Sir, have ruled him out of order. But I can
make one suggestion. Perhaps on some other occasion
if he will file questions in Parliament on previous
commissions and what the Public Utilities Board is
doing about de-salinisation, I will do my best to
answer him.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 816
COPYRIGHT (GRAMOPHONE
RECORDS AND GOVERNMENT BROADCASTING) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
4.24 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That
the Bill be now read a Second time."
Column: 817
The law enforced in Singapore relating to copyright
is the Copyright Act, 1911, of the United Kingdom, as
modified by the Copyright Ordinance (Chapter 176).
The Copyright Act, 1911, was repealed by the
Copyright Act, 1956, of the United Kingdom. However,
the repeal did not apply to Singapore and the 1956
Act was never extended to Singapore.
Sir, it is not the intention of this Bill to make
comprehensive changes to the present law as was done
by the 1956 Act of the United Kingdom. The Bill, as
Members will note, is quite limited in scope and
deals with two immediate problems - to prevent the
piracy of gramophone records and to exempt the
Government from infringement of copyright in respect
of radio and television broadcasting.
As regards the first problem, there has been over
the past year or so a large increase in the
importation and sale of pirated records of musical
works with subsisting copyright. Many of such pirated
records are of sound recordings made in Singapore and
the royalties which are due to local artistes and
composers and the employment of local musicians are
somewhat in jeopardy.
[Mr Deputy Speaker in the Chair]
4.27 p.m.
The newly established industries -there are three of
them - for the manufacture of phonograph records in
Singapore are also seriously threatened. For these
reasons, penalties for the infringement of copyright
in gramophone records are urgently required. Thus
clause 3 of the Bill provides that any person who
makes, reproduces, imports for sale, exposes or
offers for sale or has in his possession for sale any
pirated copies of any gramophone record, shall be
guilty of an offence and shall be liable on
conviction to a fine not exceeding $1,000, and in the
case of a second or a subsequent conviction to
imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year or a
fine not exceeding $2,000 or to both such
Column: 818
imprisonment or fine. However, it shall be a defence
if such person proves that he had no reason to
suspect that he was dealing with pirated copies of
gramophone records, that he had given all information
in his power to the police or the prosecutor, and
that he had acted innocently in the matter. A police
officer is also empowered to arrest without warrant
any person who sells or exposes for sale any pirated
copies of any gramophone record in a public place.
Any person who has in his possession five or more
pirated copies of any gramophone record shall be
deemed to be in possession of such copies for sale.
Provision is made under clause 4 of the Bill to
empower a Magistrate to grant a search warrant
authorising any police officer to enter the premises
named therein to search for and seize any copies of
any gramophone record which appear to be pirated
copies. All copies of a gramophone record so seized
shall be brought before a court and, if they are
proved to be pirated copies, shall be delivered to
the owner of the copyright of such record or dealt
with as the court thinks fit.
To facilitate the prosecution of such offences,
clause 5 of the Bill provides that an affidavit made
before a notary public by or on behalf of the owner
of the copyright in any gramophone record may be
admitted in evidence and shall be prima facie
evidence of the matters stated therein.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
4.31 p.m.
As regards the second problem, the Broadcasting
Department of the Ministry of Culture is paying to
account a fixed sum each year to the Performing
Rights Society, London, for the performing right in
sound recordings broadcast over Radio and Television
Singapura. Claims for royalties have also been
received by the Broadcasting Department from the
International Federation of Phonographic Industry and
the Mechanical Copyright Protection Society. It is
estimated that if all
Column: 819
these claims have to be met, the Broadcasting
Department will have to pay quite a substantial sum
each year in respect of its use of sound recordings
made abroad. In addition, expenditure will also have
to be incurred by the Broadcasting Department to keep
a record or records of the number of times each sound
recording is broadcast for the purpose of determining
the royalties payable to these organisations. As
Radio and Television Singapura provide an essential
service, it is in the interest of the public that the
cost of this service be kept as low as possible.
Hence the Bill provides that the copyright in a
musical work or gramophone record is not infringed by
the Government when it causes the musical work or
gramophone record to be heard in public by means of a
radio or television broadcast. Clause 6 of the Bill
further provides that the copyright in a musical work
is not infringed by the Government when it makes a
record, tape or other device in respect of that work
solely for the purpose of being used in radio or
television broadcast.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I am raising my query not to seek a legal
opinion from the Minister but to seek clarification
in respect of clause 6 (2) of the Bill. The Bill
contains provisions which empower Radio and
Television Singapura to make records or tape from
gramophone records and telecast and broadcast the
taped records. Am I right in assuming that one can
make a record or tape the broadcast which has already
been taped by Radio and Television Singapura without
infringing the provisions of the Bill? If my
interpretation is correct, will the Bill not open
itself to abuse by pirates?
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng: May I know if it is the usual
custom for other countries to have a clause similar
to clause 6 of the Bill?
Column: 820
Mr P. Selvadurai: Mr Speaker, Sir, while I would
welcome this Bill, clause 6 is a bit difficult
because it tends to expropriate property rights. In
order to justify this clause, I would like to know
how much Government proposes to save by validating
its action in recording these materials.
Mr Barker: If I may deal with the Member for Telok
Blangah first. If anyone tapes from Radio and
Television Singapura and uses it outside, it will be
piracy. If the Member for Telok Blangah has a tape
recorder at home, tapes and records from T.V.
Singapura and uses it in public, he will be liable to
the penalties provided for under this Act.
The Member for Joo Chiat wants to know whether
there is similar legislation to that provided in
clause 6 elsewhere. The answer is - if there is, I am
not aware of such legislation.
The Member for Bukit Panjang talks of expropriation
and he wants to know what is the amount involved. I
am afraid I cannot give him the details. I am not the
Minister for Culture. Unfortunately, he is not here.
But I am sure he will be happy to provide the Member
with figures. But I would like to assure the Member
that we have no intention of making this Bill
retrospective. What is past is past. This Bill
provides for the future.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Barker].
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
4.41 p.m.
Clauses 1 to 5 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clause 6 -
Question proposed, "That clause 6 stand part of the
Bill."
Column: 821
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture (Mr Fong Sip Chee): Sir, I crave your
indulgence in taking this opportunity to answer the
query raised by the Member for Bukit Panjang. The
Broadcasting Department has been paying royalty fees
to some international bodies. In fact, they are
United Kingdom based organisations. One is the
Performing Rights Society, London. We pay the Society
a fixed sum of about $25,000 a year. The other is the
International Federation of Phonographic Industry, to
which a sum of $15,000 is paid. In the past, a
directive came from the then Governor that we would
have to pay royalties, and we did pay. There was no
reason given why we should pay. But in the colonial
days the directive came from the Governor, and it was
complied with.
The Performing Rights Society, London, claims to
represent international authors and composers in
respect of royalties to be paid. This body and the
International Federation of Phonographic Industry
have claimed in recent years an increase in the sum
payable to them on the grounds that we have extended
the hours of radio broadcasts and that recently we
have introduced television. We have considered this
problem. Let me put it this way. Broadcasting in
Singapore is a Government institution. The motivation
is, therefore, not profit. Whatever entertainment and
information we provide through this medium is a kind
of education for our people. It is unlike other
commercial stations in the world, if it were, I would
have supported the payment of royalties. Although
Radio and Television Singapura is partially
commercialised, as I said earlier, the entertainment
and other programmes provided through this medium are
not profit motivated. As such, we feel that it is
imperative that we should keep the cost of
broadcasting as low as possible for the benefit of
the public.
Mr Barker: May I have your indulgence, Sir? Members
may be interested to know, whilst we are on clause 6,
that though Singapore has attended many international
conferences
Column: 822
on protection of copyrights, designs and patents, we
are not a signatory to any international convention
on copyrights. We have not signed because it is the
developed countries that have the know-how and
knowledge of these matters. They have in the past
refused or have been rather reluctant to help
developing countries increase their knowledge of this
subject. This Act provides for protection of
copyrights and, in fact, it is welcomed by
international bodies like the Performing Rights
Society of London, it provides them considerable
protection from piracy. The amounts paid by
Government, as mentioned by the Parliamentary
Secretary to the Minister for Culture, are small when
compared to the extent of protection afforded to
copyright owners. I think I had better state here
openly that we have received representations from
these societies. They welcome the Bill, but they have
asked us to reconsider the provisions of clause 6. We
have considered their representations and decided to
proceed with clause 6.
Mr Selvadurai: May I crave your indulgence, Mr
Speaker, Sir? The consequence of what the Minister
said just now is that we should not sign the
International Convention on Copyrights and Patents.
If we do, then, of course, we might have to amend
clause 6, which might otherwise become illegal.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng: Mr Speaker, Sir, if we have
clause 6, I am afraid one day the result will be such
that even the poorest type of films or musical shows
of any kind will not be obtainable for Radio and T.V.
Singapura.
Mr Fong Sip Chee: Sir, I am not quite clear about
what the Member for Joo Chiat has said. Perhaps he
might care to repeat it.
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng: Sir, I am thinking in terms of
musical films of any kind for T.V.
Mr Fong Sip Chee: That is quite simple, Sir. When
we hire the films, we pay for the hiring of the films
and we are not liable. It is the film distributors
Column: 823
who will be liable. I am sure they have already made
arrangements with the international body concerned.
Mr Barker: Sir, I would like to assure the Member
for Bukit Panjang that we are not a member of inter
national conventions and we have no intention of
becoming a signatory to these conventions. The
reason, I repeat, is that these conventions are for
the benefit of the developed countries who refuse to
share their knowledge with us. It is for this reason
that a Bill of this nature was not passed before. I
have mentioned that three industries have been set up
in Jurong producing musical records and it is for the
protection of these industries that this Bill is
introduced.
Column: 824
The Member for Joo Chiat is a little worried about
not getting films. I think the answer is quite
simple. Unless we pay for our films, the film
distributors will not let us have them.
Question put, and agreed to.
Clause 6 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Bill reported without amendment; read a Third time
and passed.
ADJOURNMENT
Resolved, "That Parliament do now adjourn to a date
to be fixed." -[Mr Barker].
Adjourned accordingly at
Eleven minutes to Five o'clock p.m. to
a date to be fixed.