| Parliament No: | 2 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 29 |
| Sitting No: | 3 |
| Sitting Date: | 15-10-1969 |
|
Column: 79
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
FIRST SESSION OF THE SECOND PARLIAMENT
PART III OF FIRST SESSION |
VOLUME 29 |
Wednesday, 15th October, 1969
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Mr P. Coomaraswamy).
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang).
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development and Acting Minister for Foreign Affairs and Leader of the House.
Inche Buang Bin Omar Junid (Whampoa), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta).
Mr Eric Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh).
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (MacPherson), Minister for Health.
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister for Finance.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah).
Column: 80
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East),Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (Kampong Kapor).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah).
Mr Lim Kim San (Cairnhill), Minister for Defence.
Mr Lim Soo Peng (Havelock).
Mr Low Guan Onn (River Valley).
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford).
Inche Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Inche Mohd. Ghazali Bin Ismail (Aljunied).
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Education.
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon).
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Communications.
Inche Rahmat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai).
Column: 81
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Potong Pasir), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (Law Division).
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee).
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang).
Inche Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampong Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour and Government Whip.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Acting Minister for Culture and Acting Minister for Labour.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken (Alexandra).
Mr Yeoh Ghim Seng (Joo Chiat), Deputy Speaker.
Column: 82
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications.
ABSENT:
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong).
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour.
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology.
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampong Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Column: 81
PERMISSION TO MEMBERS TO BE ABSENT
Under the provisions of clause 2 (d) of Article
30 of the Constitution of Singapore, the following
Members have been granted permission to be or to
remain absent from sittings of Parliament (or any committee of Parliament to which they have been appointed) for the periods stated:-
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah) from 30th June to 14th July, 1969.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs from 14th to 20th July, and from 25th September to 4th October, 1969.
Column: 82
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture from 15th July to 31st December, 1969.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi) - from 17th to 21st July, and from 19th August to 6th September, 1969.
Mr Lim Soo Peng (Havelock) from 23rd to 27th July, 1969.
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampong Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office - from 25th to 28th August, 1st to 6th September, and from 18th September to 31st December, 1969.
Column: 83
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Communications - from 1st to 14th September, 1969.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications - from 1st to 30th September, 1969.
Mr P. Coomaraswamy (Mr Speaker) from 3rd to 30th September, 1969.
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs - from 6th to 20th September, 1969.
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Potong Pasir), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (Law Division) - from 11th September to 2nd October, 1969.
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture from 16th September to 15th October, 1969.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education from 21st September to 1st November. 1969.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister for Finance - from 24th September to 8th October, 1969.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong) - from 25th September to 23rd October, 1969.
Column: 84
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu) - from 25th September to 25th October, 1969.
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour - from 26th September to 2nd November, 1969.
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Foreign Affairs - from 1st October to 4th December, 1969.
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong) from 11th to 25th October, 1969.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office - from 13th October to 31st December, 1969.
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson) from 22nd October to 9th November, 1969.
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon) from 29th October to 15th November, 1969.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang)- from 29th October to 17th November, 1969.
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology on 15th October, 1969.
| | (P. COOMARASWAMY) |
| | Speaker, |
| | Parliament of Singapore |
Column: 83
ASSENTS TO BILLS PASSED
I have been informed by the President that, on
the days stated, he assented to the following
Bills:-
14th June, 1969
(i) Currency (Amendment) Bill; and
(ii) Parliamentary Pensions Bill.
16th June, 1969
(i) Economic Development Board (Amendment) Bill;
Column: 84
(ii) Port of Singapore Authority (Amendment) Bill; and
(iii) National Service (Amendment) Bill.
17th June, 1969
(i) Drugs (Prevention of Misuse) Bill.
| | (P. COOMARASWAMY) |
| | Speaker, |
| | Parliament of Singapore |
Column: 85
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
INCOME TAX RELIEFS
FOR AGED PARENTS
1. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for
Finance if he will consider introducing
amending legislation to allow income tax
reliefs to tax-payers who are maintaining their
aged parents.
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Mr Speaker, Sir, in Asian societies, the
support of aged parents is an acknowledged
responsibility of all decent citizens. Indeed,
Confucius has elevated this into a basic
ethical principle, and Chinese classical
literature is replete with examples of
outstanding acts of filial piety. In these
circumstances, it would be unworthy of us to
introduce mercenary considerations such as
relief from income tax.
Sir, if this approach does not appeal to the
hon. Member, may I add a less traditionalist
argument? An International Monetary Fund
mission has recently examined our tax system
and has stated that our tax reliefs are
overgenerous and could with advantage be
reduced.
Column: 85
PROPERTY TAX
(Notices for payment)
2. Mr Tay Boon Too asked the Minister for Finance (a) whether notices for payment of
property tax on attap or wooden houses are sent
annually to the house-owners so as to avoid
their having to pay accumulated arrears for as
many as five years' tax in one payment; and (b)
whether he is aware that some such house-owners
who had been ordered to demolish their houses
have had to pay five years' arrears of property
tax.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim) (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, notices for payment of
property tax in respect of known attap or
wooden houses are sent out half-yearly,
although, in law, property owners are required
to pay property tax in respect of their
property without demand.
Column: 86
Sir, it is known that there had been, cases
of landlords who, with a view to evading
property tax, had let out their property and
collected rents without informing the tax
department and without paying property tax.
When these cases were discovered, these
landlords were made to pay the property tax
due, notwithstanding the fact that the property
in question was under an order for demolition.
Column: 86
HOUSING LOANS TO CIVIL
SERVANTS
(Particulars)
3. Mr N. Govindasamy asked the Minister for
Finance (a) how many applications have been
received from, civil servants for loans to
purchase houses built by private developers
from 1st January, 1964, up to the latest
convenient date, and the total amount of the
loans applied for; (b) how many of the
applications have been approved, and what is
the total amount of the loans granted; (c) what
are the reasons or grounds for rejecting an
application; and (d) whether he will consider
relaxing the rules governing applications for
housing loans by granting loans to civil
servants who are already living in their own
houses and who wish to exchange their existing
houses for bigger ones.
Mr Tang See Chim (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, the answer is as follows:
(a) Up to 30th September, 1969, 992
applications for loans amounting to $22,721,460
were received.
(b) A total of 771 applications for loans
amounting to $16,775,770 were approved.
Ninety-two applications for loans
amounting to $2,013,400 were withdrawn.
Thirty-five applications for loans
amounting to $810,180 are under consideration.
Column: 87
(c) Applications are rejected where the applicant
is ineligible under the Government Officers'
Housing Loan Scheme, e.g. where the applicant
already owns a house, and has previously been
granted a loan to purchase a house.
(d) Each case is considered on its merits. As a
general rule, because the interest rates are
low and the Scheme is intended to assist
those who do not own houses, the exchanging
of houses for bigger ones is not allowed,
unless there are exceptional circumstances.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah): Sir, it is not a question of exchanging a house.
What would be the answer in the case of an officer
who having had a housing loan now sells the house
with the intention of buying another?
Mr Tang See Chim: As I said, Mr Speaker, Sir, the interest rates
for housing loans are very low. Also, these loans
are primarily meant to help Government officers who
do not own houses. If they already had housing
loans, normally their applications would not be
approved unless there were special circumstances.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, can the Parliamentary Secretary enlighten.
me on what the "special circumstances" are before
an officer is entitled to a second loan?
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, each application will be
considered on its merits. Unless the applicant
lists his special circumstances, I will not be able
to tell the Member whether or not the application
will be approved. But if he has any particular
application in mind, perhaps he will send it to the
appropriate authority who will no doubt consider
it.
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford): Sir, can the Parliamentary Secretary inform the
House of any example of
Column: 88
"special circumstances" that has been applied in
such a case?
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, all cases will be considered on
their merits. Unless the Member can give a
particular case, I cannot really answer his
question. To do so would, in fact, just be an
academic exercise.
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson): Sir, is there any discrimination between lowly-paid and highly-paid Government officers in the
consideration of housing loans?
Mr Tang See Chim: I do not think so, Sir.
Column: 88
FREE PRIMARY EDUCATION FOR CHILDREN OF NON-CITIZEN
PERMANENT RESIDENTS
4. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for
Education whether free primary education will be
given to children born in the Republic of parents
who are non-citizens but are permanent residents.
The Minister for Education (Mr Ong Pang Boon): Mr Speaker, Sir, children born in the Republic
prior to 16th September, 1963, are eligible for
free primary education. Children born in the
Republic on or after 16th September, 1963, are
eligible (in accordance with the Constitution of
the Republic in respect of citizenship) for free
primary education only if at least one of the
parents is a Singapore citizen. However, those born
in the Republic on or after 16th September, 1963,
of non-citizen parents, at least one of whom has
been permanently residing in the Republic prior to
1st January, 1966, will be required to pay the old
rate of school fees, which is only $2.50 per month.
Column: 88
UNIVERSITY NIGHT COURSES FOR WORKING CLASS
5. Mr Lee Teck Him asked the Minister for
Education if he will examine the feasibility of the
running of university courses at night to afford
young working-class people the opportunity to do a
university course.
Column: 89
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, our university education has
expanded at a considerable speed recently, and with
the reorganisation that is taking place, it would
be desirable for our universities to consolidate
their existing commitments and to expand further
only in those areas which are to serve the more
urgent needs of the Republic.
Though university resources are at present
limited in terms of finance and staff, the
University Extra-mural Studies Department has been
organising courses for the last six years to fulfil
the needs of persons who are already in employment.
The Adult Education Board also runs further
education classes to afford young working-class
people the opportunity of further education.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Ulu Pandan)(In Mandarin): Sir, does the Government intend to
organise night courses at the universities to cater
for the young working-class people?
Mr Ong Pang Boon(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I have just given two reasons why
it is not feasible to run night courses at the
universities.
Column: 89
DISCIPLINARY ACTION AGAINST OFFICIALS AND TEAMS FOR
BAD
CONDUCT IN TOURNAMENTS
6. Mr Tay Boon Too asked the Minister for
Education what action has been taken to deal with
(i) players and officials who beat up referees at
tournaments sponsored by the Schools' Sports
Council at both school and district levels; and
(ii) school teams which displayed bad conduct at
national tournaments; and what measures have been
taken to prevent similar occurrences.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, as far as
this Ministry is aware, there was only one incident
in the Basketball National Championship Tournament
sponsored by the Combined Schools' Sports Council
this year. The referee's decision during a keenly-contested match between two schools was not well
received by some spectators. In the melee that
ensued when the
Column: 90
spectators invaded the court, a coach was alleged
to have assaulted the referee. The coach denied
this allegation of assault, but nevertheless
apologised to the referee concerned.
The Basketball Convenors Committee has
recommended to the Singapore Combined Secondary
Schools' Sports Council that in future tournaments:
(a) Officials and players must adhere strictly to
the decision of the referee. A team will be
disqualified for the whole tournament if any
violence breaks out as a result of the non-acceptance of the referee's decision.
(b) Principals must place great emphasis on good
sportsmanship and discipline among their
teachers, pupils and players throughout the
tournament.
These recommendations were conveyed to all school
principals.
My Ministry takes a very serious view of any
misconduct by teachers and pupils during sports
competitions. In future, such misbehaviour will be
dealt with severely and any teacher or pupil found
guilty may be dismissed from service or expelled
from school.
Column: 90
SCHOOL TRAFFIC WARDENS
(Delays in payment)
7. Mr Tay Boon Too asked the Minister for
Education whether he is aware that there are delays
in payments to school traffic wardens, and if he
will look into the matter.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, school traffic wardens are paid
twice monthly and the majority of the claims for
payment are sent to the Ministry by post on the 1st
and 16th of each month. Payment is made to
principals by cheques sent by post. Delays in
payment largely arise from late submission of
claims or mistakes in claims which have to be
returned to the schools for rectification. There
were some delays earlier
Column: 91
in the year as a result of the transfer of
responsibility to this Ministry from the Police,
when new arrangements had to be made for submission
and processing of claim forms. However, now that
the system has been in operation for some months,
delays are minimal. For instance, this month, as of
the 10th, there were only 15 late submissions in
respect of 151 claims for the second half of
September 1969.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar)(In Mandarin): Sir, can the Minister ask his Ministry to prepare
the salaries for school traffic wardens a month in
advance?
Mr Ong Pang Boon: I certainly will consider that suggestion from
the Member.
Column: 91
PAYA LEBAR INTERNATIONAL
AIRPORT
(Luggage storage facilities and luggage clearance)
8. Mr Ng Yeow Chong asked the Minister for
Communications (a) if consideration will be given
to providing luggage storage facilities for transit
passengers at the Paya Lebar International Airport;
and (b) if he will look into ways and means to
speed up the clearance of luggage at the arrival
channels.
The Minister for Communications (Mr Yong Nyuk Lin): Mr Speaker, Sir, air passengers who remain
inside the Transit Lounge of our Paya Lebar Airport
do not require luggage storage facilities as their
baggage would be transferred directly from one
aircraft to another by the airlines concerned.
However, for those transit passengers who go
through the arrival formalities, there are two
rooms in the Arrival Block to keep their baggage.
If they do not wish to leave their baggage in these
rooms, they will have to make separate arrangements
with the airline offices concerned at the Airport.
The baggage of arriving passengers is, at
present, being handled by three different
organisations. Our Department
Column: 92
of Civil Aviation handles the baggage of seven
airlines, K.L.M. handles two (including its own)
and Malaysia-Singapore Airlines 14. As this
arrangement is unsatisfactory, a study is afoot for
the early formation of a separate company to handle
the baggage of all arriving and departing
passengers at Paya Lebar Airport.
Our Department of Civil Aviation is also planning
to install at least two more conveyor belts in the
Arrival Block (making a total of four) in order to
speed up the conveyance of baggage to the Customs
examination area after they have been taken off the
aircraft. The work will be carried out as soon as
plans for certain modifications to the existing
terminal building have been finalised. When
completed, it will be possible for passengers to
claim their own baggage from the conveyor belts,
thus speeding up the movement of baggage at the
arrival channels.
Column: 92
DRIVING LICENCES
9. Mr Ng Yeow Chong asked the Minister for
Communications if he will consider the issuing of a
more durable driving licence and including the date
of first issue in it.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Our new driving licence is made of good quality
paper (rag paper) which, if carefully handled,
should easily last up to its renewal date, be it
one year or three years' time, as the case may be.
It has been suggested, however, that our driving
licences could perhaps be plasticized, as in the
case of our identity cards. I have given
instructions for such a feasibility study to be
made. One problem immediately presents itself.
Should we decide to issue plastic-type driving
licences, it will be necessary to do so at a
central place whereas, at present, for the
convenience of the public, we have already
decentralised the renewal of driving licences
whereby a person can renew his driving licence on
the spot at any of 15 specified post offices.
Another practical difficulty is that sometimes
particulars in the driving
Column: 93
licence have to be altered; for example,
disqualification of the driver from driving a
certain class of vehicle. With the plastic driving
licence, it would be difficult to effect such an
amendment on it.
As regards the question of the inclusion of the
date of first issue in the driving licence, there
are certain practical difficulties which must be
pointed out. The present driving licence is a
composite one authorising its holder, if he has
passed the relevant test, to drive a number of
classes of vehicles such as motorcycle, motorcar,
heavy motorcar, motor tractor, etc. The dates of
authorisation for the driver to drive the various
classes of vehicles are likely to be different and
it is not possible to record these dates on the
driving licence without having to produce an
oversized driving licence.
Should a person desire to know the date of
original issue for personal reasons or for the
purpose of providing prospective employers with
references as to his driving experience, this
information, if so required, may be obtained from
the Registrar of Vehicles Department on payment of
a nominal search fee of $2.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten): Rag paper, as its name implies, is not a good
paper. However, is the Minister aware that even up
till today some police constables do not recognise
this new licence? Has the police force been
informed of the change?
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: We are responsible for issuing the driving
licences. Perhaps my colleague, the Minister for
Defence, will follow up on what the Member for
Mountbatten has said about the police force?
The Minister for Defence (Mr Lim Kim San): Mr Speaker, Sir, I am unaware that members of
the police force do not recognise the new licence.
Can the hon. Member mention any specific case?
Column: 94
TAXI DRIVERS AND TAXI
LICENCES
10. Mr N. Govindasamy asked the Minister for
Communications if he will consider (a) taking steps
to enforce more strictly and effectively the
regulation that no taxi-driver can refuse a fare on
the ground that the passenger's intended journey is
too short; and (b) issuing more taxi licences in
order to provide more employment opportunities and
also to discourage taxi-drivers from refusing a
passenger because of the shortness of the intended
journey.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Mr Speaker, Sir, up to 1959, an Enforcement
Section (comprising 51 inspectors) in the Registrar
of Vehicles Department was responsible for carrying
out enforcement duties in respect of recalcitrant
taxi-drivers, etc. However, because of frequent
allegations of corruption and high handedness
against this Enforcement Section, it was dissolved
in that year - ten years ago. Since then, the
enforcement functions in respect of public service
vehicles have been placed in the hands of the
Traffic Police.
At present, taxi-drivers who refuse fares on the
ground that the passenger's intended journey is too
short are suspended from driving for a specified
period, ranging from one week to one month, and the
Transport Advisory Board is currently looking into
this problem with a view to finding more effective
ways of dealing with such offenders.
I am waiting for the recommendations of the
Transport Advisory Board on the subject whether or
not it is desirable to issue more taxi licences,
and Government's decision will be made known at the
appropriate time.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, I believe the Enforcement
Section was closed down in 1959 as a result of
allegations against it. Is there a move by the
Ministry to employ vehicle inspectors to see that
taxi-drivers do not refuse a passenger's fare if he
wants to go only a short distance?
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: I have already indicated in my answer that the
Column: 95
Transport Advisory Board is looking into this problem.
Whether or not it will recommend the reintroduction
of this Enforcement Section should be left entirely
to the Board.
Column: 95
SINGAPORE BADMINTON TEAM
(Improvement of standard)
11. Mr Ng Yeow Chong asked the Minister for
Social Affairs what measures will be taken to
improve the standard of the national Badminton
Team.
The Minister of Social Affairs (Inche Othman Bin Wok): Mr Speaker, Sir, the role of the Sports Division
of the Ministry of Social Affairs is to render
whatever assistance that is needed by national
sports bodies in promoting their particular sport.
This includes assistance in obtaining coaches of
repute, both locally and abroad, provision of
supplementary funds and finding suitable venues for
training.
In February 1968, Mr Wong Peng Soon was employed
by the Sports Division of my Ministry to train the
most promising badminton players with a view to
entering for the Thomas Cup Championship in 1969
and 1972.
Although there was a request for an open trial to
decide the final composition of the Thomas Cup
Team, it was decided that since Mr Wong had been
appointed full time specifically to train the most
promising players for the Zone Finals in the Thomas
Cup in 1969, and that he had been coaching the
Thomas Cup Squad or the national Badminton Team for
well over a year, the final composition of the team
would best be left in his hands.
I have no doubt that the experience gained from
Singapore's participation in the last Thomas Cup
matches in New Zealand will be put to good use.
Column: 95
PUBLIC UTILITIES BOARD
(Complaints of low water pressure)
12. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for Law
and National Development if he will ascertain from
the
Column: 96
Public Utilities Board (a) whether the Board has
received any complaints by residents in Jalan
Perisai, St. Joseph's Lane and Holy Innocents Lane
of low water pressure in these areas; (b) whether
any action has been taken to ascertain the causes;
and (c) whether any remedial actions have been
taken.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, not even one complaint of low
water pressure in Jalan Perisai or St. Joseph's
Lane or Holy Innocents Lane has been received by
the Public Utilities Board other than the
representation made by the hon. Member on behalf of
the residents in these areas. It has been
ascertained that the water pressure in Jalan
Perisai was and still is satisfactory. But the
water pressure in St. Joseph's Lane and Holy
Innocents Lane was low due to inadequate sub-mains
and consumers' service pipes. Remedial action has
been taken by the Public Utilities Board by
extending the existing two and a quarter inch sub-main at St. Joseph's Lane by about 500 feet at a
cost of $1,000, and by laying a new six-inch main
about 1,625 feet long at a cost of $19,000 in Holy
Innocents Lane. The water pressure in these areas
is now satisfactory.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol): Mr Speaker, Sir, I am surprised that the
Minister's reply indicated that no complaint came
from the residents in the three areas mentioned.
Would he be interested to ascertain from the Board
that such written complaints by the residents of
Holy Innocents Lane were submitted to the relevant
authorities, through me, as far back as last year?
Mr Speaker: Mr Ng, perhaps you did not hear the first part
of the Minister's reply. Would the Minister like to
repeat it?
Mr Barker: Perhaps there is some misunderstanding here. I
did say that complaints were received from the hon.
Member made, of course, on behalf of the residents
in the district. He represents them. Apparently he
is doing good
Column: 97
work! He has complained and the complaints have
not been attended to. But my understanding of the
matter is that no complaints were made direct by
the residents to the Public Utilities Board. I do
not think we need split hairs on this point.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, it is true that the complaints were made
through me. However, can the Minister enlighten the
House whether there have been any complaints of low
water pressure in areas other than the three
mentioned by me?
Mr Speaker: Are you in a position to answer that question
now, Mr Barker?
Mr Barker: I am afraid I do not know of other complaints,
Sir. The Public Utilities Board supplies water
throughout the island, and not only to the outpost
of Punggol. But if there are other low water
pressure areas in Punggol, I hope the Member will
bring them to the attention of the Public Utilities
Board or to me. There are always low water pressure
areas in Singapore due either to repairs of pipes
or maintenance service of our filtration plants at
Woodlands and Bukit Timah. But it is the practice
of the Public Utilities Board to give notice of any
repairs that are about to be undertaken.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Is the Minister aware that these complaints were
not attended to immediately? Also, can he say when
the complaints in the areas mentioned were
submitted to the relevant authorities and when
action was taken'?
Mr Barker: Sir, I am afraid I cannot now supply the Member
with details. But the point here is that the
complaints had been attended to, and if the Member
had wanted the work to be done more expeditiously,
he could have taken the matter up direct with me.
Column: 97
PROPERTY ACQUISITION
(Payment of compensation)
13. Mr Lee Teck Him asked the Minister for Law
and National Development whether he will consider
the
Column: 98
payment of reasonable compensation when acquiring
lands and houses.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division) (Mr Ho Cheng Choon) (for the Minister for Law and National Development)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, under the Land Acquisition
Act, 1966, Government pays reasonable
compensation to owners of lands and houses when
their property is acquired.
The principles for the determination of
compensation are provided in section 33 of the Act.
The Member may recall that the provisions of the
Act were considered by a Select Committee. The
Committee also considered representations from
various quarters before the Bill was passed. Owners
of lands and houses to be acquired are given
reasonable and just compensation in accordance with
the Act. Furthermore, under this Act, the owners
concerned have the right to appeal if they are not
satisfied with the compensation given to them.
Moreover, under this Act, if a person has a
temporary house or fruit trees in somebody else's
land, he too would get compensation under the
rehousing scheme.
Mr Lee Teck Him(In Mandarin): Sir, the Parliamentary Secretary in his explanation
mentioned the Land Acquisition Act, 1966. Of
course, I dare not oppose that law. But the
Government should give reasonable compensation. It
acquires lands at a very low price but sells them
at a high price. There is no provision in the Act
prohibiting such practice of the Government. The
Government does not take into consideration the
present market price of lands. There is a great
difference in the present market price of land as
compared to that in 1961.
Mr Speaker: Order. Mr Lee, what is your supplementary
question, please?
Mr Lee Teck Him(In Mandarin): Sir, I wanted to say that the law on acquisition of
lands should have provisions to the effect that the
Government must not pay compensation at a low
Column: 99
rate when the market price of the land is high. The
rate should be dependent upon the prevailing market
price of the land.
Mr Speaker: Mr Lee, you can question the Minister or the
Parliamentary Secretary on the administration of
the Land Acquisition Act. But I do not think you
can question them on the provisions in the Act. The
Parliamentary Secretary's answer was that
compensation is based on the provisions in the Act.
Is your supplementary question directed to bring
about a change in the law or its administration?
Mr Lee Teck Him(In Mandarin): Sir, what I meant was that the Government should
compensate the landowners according to the
prevailing market price of lands.
Mr Ho Cheng Choon(In Mandarin): Sir, in my answer to the Member for Ulu Pandan, I
mentioned that payment of compensation is based on
section 33 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1966. If
the Member has read section 33 (a), he will see
that it is clearly stated that in acquisition, the
market value is one of the factors to be taken into
consideration in determining compensation. So how
can he say that the Government disregards the
market price?
Mr Lee Teck Him(In Mandarin): Sir, I would like to give an example. In the North
Bridge Road vicinity, I was told that compensation
is paid at the rate of $8 per square foot. But the
present market price is $112 per square foot. How
can there be such a big difference? Perhaps the
assessor was wrong in determining the compensation
rate. I would also like to add that further
consideration should be given to improve the Land
Acquisition Act.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, will the compensation given when Government
acquires land be extended to tenants as well as sub-tenants of houses which are affected as a result of
acquisition by Government?
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: Sir, compensation for acquisition is paid only to
owners of lands and houses.
Column: 100
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, will the Ministry look into the possibility
of extending compensation to tenants and sub-tenants as well, because they suffer just as much
as, if not more than, the owners of the houses?
Mr Ng Yeow Chong rose -
Mr Speaker: Order. Mr Ng, Mr Govindasamy's second
supplementary question has yet to be answered, if
it is intended to be answered.
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: When Government acquires a piece of land, only
the landowner is compensated. But when the
Government evicts the tenants on a piece of land,
we have a compensation scheme to deal with the
tenants and sub-tenants.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: Sir, will the Land Office accept the valuation
report by a licensed valuer or a recognised valuer
if the owner presents such a report to support his
claim?
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: Yes, we can consider the report submitted by a
licensed valuer.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, the question is: will the Land Office accept
or just consider the report'?
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: The Land Office will consider whether to accept
it or not.
Column: 100
GOVERNMENT HOSPITALS AND OUTPATIENT CLINICS
(Charges)
14. Mr N. Govindasamy asked the Minister for
Health (a) what is the rate of charges payable by a
person who makes use of the services and facilities
provided by Government hospitals and outpatient
clinics; and (b) whether he will consider waiving
the charges payable by a person on the second or
subsequent visit to a hospital or outpatient clinic
for the change or removal of dressing which does
not entail any consultation with the doctor.
The Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, the rates
Column: 101
of charges for medical services provided in
Government hospitals and outpatient clinics would
be too long and complicated to detail. They are
recorded in a printed pamphlet entitled The Scheme
of Charges for Government Hospital Services
(including Outpatient Services) 1969. This pamphlet
may be purchased by any member of the public at $1
a copy, either from the Government Printer or from
the Publications Bureau at Fullerton Building. A
copy will be made available to the Member for his
information if he so desires.
Very briefly and without going into detail, the
Scheme of Charges prescribes the charges for the
various services, and, in certain cases, sets out
the categories of persons eligible for exemption
from charges for in-patient hospital services and
for out-patient services.
The hospital in-patient charges are of two
categories, namely, ward charges and service
charges.
(i) These charges vary according to the type of
patients (medical, surgical or psychiatric) and the
class of ward into which he seeks admission. For
medical and surgical patients, the daily ward
charge is as follows: -
Class A - $45 per day
Class B - $20 per day
Class C - A token charge of $1 per day.
The charges for psychiatric patients are different,
being $20 and $10 per day for A and B classes
respectively.
(ii) Service charges may be taken as charges for
treatments, investigations and other services which
are charged according to the type of service given.
These services would be too long to describe here.
The service charge for delivery in the maternity
hospital, e.g., is $200 for A Class and $100 for B
Class.
(iii) Charges for outpatients are made on the
basis of each attendance and vary according to the
outpatient services provided. At the travelling
dispensaries, the charge is 20 cents per
attendance; at the outpatient dispensaries, it is 80
Column: 102
cents per attendance on week days and $1.50 per
attendance on Sundays and public holidays. At the
specialists clinics in the hospitals, the rate is
$1.50 per attendance.
The attendance charge in each case is an all-in
charge.
Replying to the second part of the question, I
would say that the outpatient attendance charge,
whether at specialist medical clinics, outpatient
dispensaries or travelling dispensaries, is merely
a nominal one. It does not come any way near the
total cost of the services provided. It is only a
consolidated charge for the various services
provided, which include the professional attention
of doctors, nurses, laboratory technicians and
others, the provision of medicines and the carrying
out of investigations. Thus, it will not be
possible to agree to a waiver of these nominal
charges merely because the patient may not have
seen the doctor when attending the dispensary to
have his dressing changed. There are still costs
for the services provided by the nurse and other
incidental expenses which could be accounted for in
the nominal charge levied.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Does the Minister consider the charges of 80
cents and $1.50 for the second and third visits
respectively merely to remove a dressing justified?
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, may I repeat what I have just
said. I said that the charge of 80 cents is, in
fact, an attendance charge. Secondly, it is a
nominal charge and it is, in fact, not possible to
work out the cost of each attendance. As I have
said earlier, this is a consolidated charge and we
have to make a flat rate charge.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, will the Minister at least consider the
waiving of these charges for cases which are in
receipt of public assistance from the Social
Welfare Department?
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, the charges are normally waived
in cases where the persons are receiving social
welfare assistance, if an application is made.
Column: 103
RADIO AND TELEVISION
ADVERTISING RATES
(Payment by non-profit making institutions)
The following Question stood in the name of Mr
J. F. Conceicao -
15. To ask the Minister for Culture why non-profit making institutions have now to pay for
advertisements on Radio and TV at full commercial
rates.
Mr Speaker: Mr Conceicao.
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang): Question No. 15.
The Acting Minister for Culture (Mr Wee Toon Boon): Mr Speaker, Sir, by non-profit making
institutions, I presume the Member for Katong is
referring to Government departments, statutory
boards, cultural organisations and charitable
bodies.
The Treasury has ruled that with effect from 1st
August, 1969, all Government departments and
statutory boards have to pay for advertising over
radio and TV at rates currently applicable to all
advertisers. Consequently, the Broadcasting
Division decided that an anomalous situation will
arise if cultural organisations and charitable
bodies were not charged advertising fees.
The rationale behind Treasury's ruling is that
from the cost effectiveness point of view, it is
essential that departments and statutory boards be
able to show the results of its efforts in the true
light of costs. This rationale is equally
applicable to cultural organisations and statutory
bodies.
Government departments now pay for their
advertising by journal adjustments. Statutory
boards pay by cheque or cash along commercial
lines.
It is possible that certain cultural
organisations and charitable bodies may not be
financially capable of paying for radio and TV
advertisements. Administratively, a procedure has
to be evolved whereby such bodies with worthy
objectives may apply to the Treasury for a
Column: 104
grant for such advertising. In such cases, the
merits of each effort can be scrutinised and
evaluated.
Column: 104
RADIO AND TELEVISION
AUDIENCE RATING SURVEY BY RTS
The following Question stood in the name of Mr
J. F. Conceicao -
16. To ask the Minister for Culture whether RTS
will conduct a Television and Radio audience rating
survey for various programmes.
Mr Speaker: Mr Conceicao.
Mr P. Selvadurai: Question No. 16.
Mr Wee Toon Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, the answer to the Member for
Katong is "Yes". Indeed, Radio and T.V. Singapore
is extremely keen to have such a survey. It is only
on the basis of reliable findings from such a
survey that programme planning and commercial
policy can be founded.
In this year's Estimates, a sum of $30,000 has
been provided for such a survey. RTS, in planning
for such a survey, has liaised closely with the
Economic Research Centre of the University of
Singapore and the Statistics Department of the
Government. A paper has been prepared setting out
proposals on the methods to be used in such a
survey. This paper has been submitted to the
Commission of Inquiry on Statistical Activities,
and it is hoped that the findings of this
Commission will support Broadcasting Division's
appeal for adequate funds for such a survey.
Mr Selvadurai: Question No. 17.
Mr Speaker: The Minister can, if he likes, answer Questions
Nos. 17 and 18 together.
Column: 104
RTS ENTERPRISES (PRIVATE)
LIMITED
17. Mr P. Selvadurai asked the Minister for
Culture if he will state whether RTS Enterprises
(Private) Limited is a limited company wholly owned
by Government and whether
Column: 105
this company also functions and does business as a
travel agency.
18. Mr J. F. Conceicao asked the Minister for
Culture if RTS has become a Travel Agency, and why.
Mr Wee Toon Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, in his
question the Member for Katong is presumably
referring to RTS Enterprises (Private) Ltd., a
wholly-owned subsidiary of RTS. RTS itself has not become a travel agency. RTS Enterprises (Private) Ltd. has a travel department
which serves as a travel agency to Government and
statutory bodies.
The Member for Katong will appreciate that
Government and statutory bodies have to incur a
substantial amount for travel for their officers on
duty overseas. If the passages for such travel were
purchased by Government directly, the full price of
the passage has to be paid. As all airlines give a
commission to travel agents, the establishment of a
travel department within RTS Enterprises (Private)
Ltd, has enabled the Company to earn the commission
payable to travel agents.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, will the Minister for Culture
enlighten the House on the difference in functions
between RTS Enterprises (Private) Ltd, and RTS?
Mr Wee Toon Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, RTS, that is
the Broadcasting Division, normally performs the
duties of the Broadcasting Department. RTS
Enterprises (Private) Ltd., which is a corporate
body but one fully owned by Government, enters into
the production of records, promotion of shows and
also acts as a travel agency for the Government.
Mr Selvadurai: Mr Speaker, Sir, can the Minister for Culture
give us the figures of the amount of savings
effected by performing this function for Government
and Government agencies?
Mr Wee Toon Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, I cannot give the exact amount,
Column: 106
but in the case of the travel agency, since it
began business in November
1968, it has earned up to 30th June, 1969, a
commission of $15,612 from
airlines.
Column: 106
BILLS INTRODUCED
3.25 p.m.
CUSTOMS (DUMPING AND SUBSIDIES) (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Customs (Dumping and Subsidies)
Ordinance, 1962 (No. 3 of 1962)",
presented for the Minister for Finance by his Parliamentary Secretary (Mr Tang See Chim); read the First time,
to be read a Second time on the next available sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 106
INTERNATIONAL MONETARY
FUND BILL
"to enable effect to be given to certain
amendments of the Articles of Agreement of the
International Monetary Fund, and for purposes
connected therewith",
recommendation of President signified (Mr Barker);
presented for the Minister for Finance by Mr Tang See Chim; read the First time, to be read
a Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 106
JUDGES' REMUNERATION
(AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Judges' Remuneration Act, 1963, of
Malaysia (No. 36 of 1963)",
presented for the Minister for Finance by Mr Tang See Chim; read the
First time, to be read a Second time on the next
available sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 106
FINANCE COMPANIES
(AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Finance Companies Act, 1967 (No. 43 of 1967)",
presented for the Minister for Finance by Mr Tang See Chim; read the First time, to be
read a Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 107
RUBBER ASSOCIATION OF
SINGAPORE (INCORPORATION)
(AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Rubber Association of Singapore
(Incorporation) Act, 1967 (No. 26 of 1967)",
presented for the Minister for Finance by Mr Tang See Chim; read the First time, to be read a Second
time on the next available sitting of Parliament,
and to be printed.
3.30 p.m.
Committee of supply.
Later ---
3.50 p.m.
Column: 107
INCOME TAX (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Income Tax Ordinance
(Chapter 166 of the Revised Edition)",
recommendation of President signified (Mr Barker);
presented for the Minister for Finance by Mr Tang See Chim; read the first time,
to be read a Second time on the next available
sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 107
LIGHT DUES BILL
"to establish a corporation to be known as the
Singapore Light Dues Board and to repeal and re-enact with amendments the Light Dues Ordinance,
1957 (No. 6 of 1957)",
presented by the Minister for Communications (Mr Yong Nyuk Lin); read the
First time, to be read a Second time on the next
available sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 107
CRIMINAL LAW (TEMPORARY PROVISIONS) (AMENDMENT) BILL
First Reading
The Minister for Defence (Mr Lim Kim San): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to introduce a Bill
intituled "An Act to amend the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions) Ordinance. 1955 (No. 26 of 1955)."
Bill read the First time
Column: 108
Second Reading
Mr Speaker: Second Reading, what day?
Mr Lim Kim San: Now, Sir. Mr Speaker, Sir, I lay upon the Table
a Certificate of Urgency signed by the President in
respect of the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions)
(Amendment) Bill.
Certificate of Urgency handed in.
Mr Speaker: The Certificate is in order. Are typed copies of
the Bill available for distribution to Members?
Mr Lim Kim San: Yes, Sir.
Typed copies of the Bill distributed to hon. Members.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move. "That the Bill
be now read a Second time."
Sir, this Bill seeks to amend the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions)
Ordinance, 1955, which will lapse on the 20th
October, 1969, by extending its life for a period
of another five years with effect from 1st October,
1969. As hon. Members may be aware, this Ordinance
provides primarily for the maintenance of public
safety, peace and good order, prevention of strikes
and lock-outs in essential services, and detention
and supervision of persons associated with
activities of a criminal nature.
Since its introduction, this Ordinance has been
of considerable value in curbing secret society
activities and the number of secret society
incidents has shown a downward trend as follows: -
Number of secret
Year society incidents
1959 416
1960 241
1961 211
1962 209
1963 144
1964 72
1965 70
1966 73
1967 74
1968 74
Mr Speaker, Sir, Members will appreciate that it
is necessary to rehabilitate
Column: 109
and re-educate secret society gangsters while they
are under detention in order that when they return
to society on their release, we hope they would
become law-abiding and useful citizens.
Rehabilitation takes time and varies with the
individual. Some may respond quickly to the
rehabilitation programme, while others need a
longer period.
Hon. Members are most probably aware that only the hard-core secret society members are put under
detention orders. The others are placed under
police supervision orders for a period of two
years. This enables the less dangerous members of
secret societies to earn their livelihood and, at
the same time, enables the police to keep track of
their movements outside their working hours in
order to curb their anti-social activities.
It may also interest Members to know that since
the implementation of the Ordinance on 15th August,
1958, up to and including April 1969, 13,241
persons have been arrested under the provisions of
section 55. Out of these, 762 persons are now
detained under section 47 (a) and 642 persons are
ordered to be placed under police supervision.
Although the current situation with regard to
secret societies in the Republic is under control,
there is still a need for constant vigil to be
kept. It is therefore essential that the
suppression of secret societies in the Republic
should go on relentlessly, especially in view of
the possible involvement in racial disturbances.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Lim Kim San].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 110
MONEYLENDERS (AMENDMENT)
BILL
"to amend the Moneylenders Ordinance, 1959 (No. 58 of 1959)",
presented for the Minister for Social Affairs by his Parliamentary Secretary (Mr Chan Chee Seng);
read the First time, to be read a Second time on
the next available sitting of Parliament, and to be
printed.
Column: 110
STATUTE LAW REVISION BILL
"to provide for omissions, amendments and
additions considered desirable by the Law
Revision Commissioners in their preparation of a
revised edition of Acts pursuant to the
Revised Edition of the Laws Act, 1966 (No. 16 of 1966)",
presented by the Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker); read the First
time, to be read a Second time on the next
available sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 110
HOUSING AND DEVELOPMENT (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Housing and Development Ordinance,
1959 (No. 11 of 1959)",
presented by Mr E. W. Barker; read the First time, to be
read a Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 110
EXTRADITION (AMENDMENT)
BILL
"to amend the Extradition Act, 1968 (No. 14 of 1968)",
presented by Mr E. W. Barker; read the First time, to be
read a Second time on the
next available sitting of Parliament, and to be
printed.
Column: 110
PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERS BILL
"to establish a Professional Engineers Board, make
provision for the registration of professional
engineers and for purposes connected therewith",
presented by Mr E. W. Barker; read the First time, to be
read a Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 111
FIRST SUPPLEMENTARY DEVELOPMENT ESTIMATES OF
EXPENDITURE FOR FY 1969/1970
3.30 p.m.
Order read for consideration in Committee of
Supply [Allotted Day].
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
The Chairman: We are on the First Supplementary Development
Estimates of Expenditure for the financial year 1st
January, 1969, to 31st March, 1970, contained in
Paper Cmd. 24 of 1969. The summary is on the last
page of the Paper. There are two heads of
expenditure and amendments in respect of both heads
stand on the Order Paper Supplement.
Head 71 -
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 71 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 302.
Sir, it is interesting to note from Paper Cmd. 24
of 1969 that,
'In conjunction with the celebrations in
commemoration of the 150th Anniversary of the
Founding of Singapore, stereophonic broadcasts have
been commenced in the Republic this year.'
It would, therefore, mean to me, Sir, that there
would have been no stereophonic broadcasts if
Singapore had not celebrated its 150th anniversary.
In fact, stereophonic music has been here for quite
some time. I think it must have struck the
ingenuity of someone in the Broadcasting Department
that it was a novel idea to introduce such a
service. It means buying a radio set or a
transistor radio set with an FM stereophonic band
in order to receive such broadcasts. Sir, I stress
on the FM stereophonic band because I remember the
FM station has already been in existence for quite
some time. If a listener wishes to receive
stereophonic broadcasts, he must buy a set that has
Column: 112
this band, otherwise he will continue to receive
music without stereophonic effects. Therefore, my
conclusion is obvious.
However, I shall be grateful to the Minister for
Culture if he will inform the House whether any
careful consideration was given in all respects
before introducing such a service, and whether a
survey has been made to establish the number of
listeners tuning in to such a service.
Furthermore, Sir, I would ask the Minister if a
$10 token provision in the Development Estimates
means the provision of a further sum of $50,000. If
savings in the current Development Estimates can
warrant increased expenditure, I would like to see
more urgent items of expenditure, like the
construction of abattoirs in the rural areas,
treated with the same priority.
I would also like to seek elucidation from the
Minister regarding the actual source of savings
amounting to $14,990. Did it come from the
Development Estimates pertaining to his Ministry or
otherwise?
Sir, I beg to move.
The Acting Minister for Culture (Mr Wee Toon Boon): Mr Speaker, Sir, since 1967 Radio Singapore has
been operating four radio channels on frequency
modulation, commonly known as FM. These channels
were an addition to the four existing amplitude
modulation, commonly called AM medium wave channel.
The four channels were radiated without the device
called the encoder to enable a receiving set with a
decoder to receive such broadcasts in stereophonic
sound. It was felt that the time had come for such
FM broadcasts to be improved to the level where
stereophonic sounds can be radiated.
With regard to the point raised by the Member for
Punggol in connection with the source of savings,
the token provision of $10 in the Development
Estimates for this year was made for the purchase
of stereophonic equipment. A sum of $14,990 was
found from
Column: 113
savings from subhead 201, Improvements to
Television and Broadcasting Services. The House is
now asked for a supplementary provision of $50,000
to make a total of $65,000 needed.
With regard to the other point, since
stereophonic broadcasts started only in July this
year, it is too soon to conduct a survey. An
overall survey of listeners and their preferences
is being planned and, when carried out,
stereophonic broadcasts will certainly be included.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, in view of the Minister's
reply, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $50,000 for Head 71 ordered to stand
part of the First Supplementary Development
Estimates of Expenditure for the financial year 1st
January, 1969, to 31st March, 1970.
Head 102 -
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 102 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 205.
Sir, the explanatory note to this subhead clearly
stresses the need for more vehicles to meet the
increasing demands of the public cleansing
services. I would have thought that with assiduous
planning, the need of more vehicles for the public
cleansing services would have received high
priority when the "Keep Singapore Clean" campaign
was mounted last year. In other words, there should
have been forward planning to enable the Ministry
of Health to meet immediate requirements.
Hence I would be grateful if the Minister for
Health could enlighten the House on the date when
such vehicles were ordered, and also how many
workers are manning them. I would have imagined
that these vehicles would have already been
purchased and are now on the road serving their
purpose.
Also I would like to suggest to the Minister to
look into the possibility of introducing a
cleansing service either
Column: 114
at night or in the early hours of the morning, as
there is less traffic during, those hours.
Will the Minister also look into the possibility
of increasing the frequency of clearing away
rubbish and trade refuse from our bin centers? To
illustrate, Sir, I notice that at two bin centers
in my constituency, namely, at Punggol Road 8¾ m.s. and Upper Serangoon Road 6½ m.s., the bins
are cleared in the morning, but by evening they are
full to the brim.
Sir, I beg to move.
The Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, the first point that the Member
for Punggol made is the need for more public health
vehicles, and that this must be given high
priority. I cannot agree with him, more. That is
the very reason why we are here today debating
these supplementary estimates.
The refuse load at present handled by the public
cleansing services is, approximately 1,200 tons per
day. This is quite a marked increase compared with
800 tons per day formerly handled, by the Public
Health Division. I am glad to say that this
increase in refuse removal does indicate the
success of the "Keep Singapore Clean" campaign
which was launched last year and is, continuing
throughout this year as well. Although this result
was welcomed, it was quite unexpected because in
Government planning you do not normally expect a
sudden jump from 800 tons, to 1,200 tons per day.
You need additional equipment. As a result, there
was, an urgent need for more refuse removal
vehicles. The Member for Punggol also asked when
these vehicles were ordered. They were ordered
immediately after the Treasury approved their
purchase.
The other point which he made was, the request
for greater frequency in the removal of refuse in
Singapore. I do not know what he means by that. At
the moment, we have daily removals, in other words,
once every day. As a matter of fact, since the
enforcement of the Employment Act, we have been
able
Column: 115
to introduce refuse removal on Sundays and public
holidays as well, resulting in an increase in the
number of removals per week. I do not know if the
Member is advocating that we should increase the
number of removals from once to twice or three
times a day. To put him in proper perspective, may
I bring to his attention the fact that in many big
cities in Europe and America they remove their
refuse only three times a week, or even once a
week. Even in the big city of New York, they remove
their refuse only three times a week.
An hon. Member: Once a month!
Mr Chua Sian Chin: May I assure the Member for Punggol that with the
present provision, if it is approved by the House,
the number of refuse vehicles will be quite
adequate to meet the needs of the Public Cleansing
Department.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I was only suggesting to the
Minister to look into the possibility of a night or
early morning removal service. I was not advocating
that it be made more frequently. However, in view
of the answers given by the Minister, I beg leave
to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
3.45 p.m.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 102 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 901.
In spite of the amount of $44,000 revoted for, a
further sum of $37,460 is required for the
construction of Taman Jurong Market I, and also
another sum of $197,540 is required for the
completion of Taman Jurong Market II.
Sir, I am a bit confused here. Perhaps the
Minister for Health can clear my confusion. Why are
two markets being built in Taman Jurong?
Approximately how many residents are there who will
benefit from the construction of these two markets?
Where are their
Column: 116
exact locations? Is it really necessary to put up
two markets in one area? How much revenue can be
collected from them each year? Has the Government
any plans to build one or more markets in other
constituencies?
An hon. Member: In Punggol!
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Not Punggol. It has one market which is adequate
for Punggol's purposes.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, may I say that in the original
planning for the provision of markets in the Jurong
area, especially in the proposed town centre, it
was considered that the provision of two small
markets instead of one would render better and more
effective service for the expected population.
There is not only the need to tie them in with the
phases of development in Jurong Town, but there is
also the need to allocate markets within convenient
distance for the residents of this new township
which will be more extensive in area when it is
fully developed. That indirectly answers the Member
for Punggol's point when he asked whether there was
any need for two markets. As the Member knows,
Jurong is going to be a big satellite town. I do
not think that even these two markets will be
sufficient when Jurong is eventually fully
developed. But at the moment we consider that the
two markets are sufficient.
Perhaps a few figures pertaining to the number of
stalls and the number of stalls occupied will give
him an idea whether the two markets are going to be
fully used. In Taman Jurong Market I, the total
number of stalls is 122; the number of stalls
licensed and taken up, up to date, is 95 and the
number of stalls vacant is 27. In the market itself
there are a number of open pitches. These number
112. The number of pitches licensed and taken up,
up to date, is about 103 and the number vacant is
nine. This does indicate that the market is in
reasonable use at the moment. But, of course, we
cannot expect it to be fully occupied because
Column: 117
this will depend on the occupation of the area by
residents.
In Taman Jurong Market II, the total number of
stalls is about 122, and up to date the number of
stalls licensed and taken up is 108. The number of
vacant stalls is only 14. The total number of open
pitches is 65, and the number taken up is 56. The
number vacant is nine.
With regard to his general question about whether
the Government has any project to construct any
more new markets in the future, this is a point of
considerable interest to the Ministry of Health. In
fact, the Ministry has always advocated that in the
long-term plan, all hawkers should conduct their
business from within premises. In a count made in
December last year, there were 24,845 static
hawkers in Singapore, of whom 15,135 were engaged
in the sale of market produce. Only 7,711 hawkers
of all types were accommodated within premises,
such as markets and hawker centres. The remaining
17,000 hawkers were scattered all over the island,
particularly in the urban areas - in streets, foot-ways and back-lanes. The resiting of hawkers into
markets and other premises is a project of mammoth
proportions, requiring careful planning and follow-through action by the planning and building
authorities of the State. The location of
appropriate markets and hawker centres must be
considered in the light of the overall development
planning for the island, and is not a matter within
the sole capacity of the Ministry of Health.
Substantial capital cost will also be required. The
Ministry of Health proposes to take the matter up
with the appropriate agencies and is presently
compiling the necessary data.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am happy with the Minister's
reply. I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $1,077,000 for Head 102 ordered to
stand part of the First Supplementary Development
Estimates of
Column: 118
Expenditure for the financial year 1st January,
1969, to 31st March, 1970.
Question, "That the sum of $1,127,000 shall be
supplied to the Government under the heads of
expenditure for the public services shown in the
First Supplementary Development Estimates of
Expenditure for the financial year 1st January,
1969, to 31st March, 1970, contained in Paper Cmd.
24 of 1969", put, and agreed to.
Resolution to be reported.
Thereupon Mr Speaker left the Chair of the
Committee and took the Chair of the House.
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to report that the
Committee of Supply have come to a certain
resolution.
Resolution reported -
That the sum of $1,127,000
shall be supplied to the Government under the heads
of expenditure for the public services shown in the
First Supplementary Development Estimates of
Expenditure for the financial year 1st January,
1969, to 31st March, 1970, contained in Paper Cmd.
24 of 1969.
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That Parliament
doth agree with the Committee on the said
resolution."
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolution accordingly agreed to.
4.10 p.m.
Mr Speaker: Order. I propose to take the
suspension now. I will take the Chair again at 4.30
p.m.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
4.10 p.m, until 4.30 p.m.
Column: 118
Sitting resumed at 4.30 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
STAMP (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim) (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time.".
Column: 119
At the outset, I wish to relieve the anxiety of
Members by saying that this Bill does not intend to
increase the rates of stamp duty on the heels of
the last revision in January this year. It deals
with some amendments to the provisions of the
existing Ordinance.
Under the existing law, any change - however
minor - to the rate of stamp duty can only be done
by amending the Stamp Ordinance in Parliament. The
experience of the last revision of stamp duties in
December 1968 has proved this process to be
cumbersome and unsatisfactory. Hon. Members will
remember that the revision of the rates of stamp
duty was announced by the Minister for Finance
during his Budget Statement, but the revision could
not be effected until January 1969, because of the
need to amend the Stamp Ordinance. In the meantime,
there was a rush to the Stamp Office as people
tried to jump the gun by getting their documents
stamped before the increased rates were effected.
This resulted not only in a loss of revenue, but,
also a congestion at the Stamp Office, which
prompted an hon. Member to ask a question in
Parliament.
In view of this experience, it is now proposed to
add a new section to the Ordinance to enable the
Minister to impose new duties or to revise the
rates of existing ones by an Order to be published
in the Gazette. This amendment will bring the
Ordinance in line
with the other revenue Ordinances, such as the
Customs Ordinance.
Hon. Members will remember that in my answer to
the question on the congestion at the Stamp Office,
I said that the Government was looking into the
question of allowing more documents to be stamped
by franking machines so as to relieve the pressure
at the counter of the Stamp Office. I am happy to
say that the Government has now decided to allow
insurance policies and contract notes to be stamped
by postal franking machines. Clause 2 of the Bill
seeks to effect this. At the same time, power will
be given to the Minister to extend
Column: 120
the number of instruments on which duty may be paid
by franking machines.
As the fee for a Certificate to Practise for an
advocate and solicitor has been specifically
provided in the Legal Profession Act, this duty
will be removed from the Stamp Ordinance. This is
stated in clause 14 (b) of the Bill.
The Bill also seeks to clarify the position of
stamp duty in relation to receipts, letters of
guarantee, payment of stamp duties on shares, by
removing the ambiguities. The other minor
amendments include deletion of rates from the main
body of the Ordinance, renumbering of various
articles, and consequential changes to the
Schedules of the Ordinance.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr
Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 120
NATIONAL SPORTS PROMOTION
BOARD BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
4.38 p.m.
The Minister for Social Affairs (Inche Othman Bin Wok): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill
be now read a Second time."
The main purpose of the Bill as found in the
Explanatory Statement is to incorporate the
National Sports Promotion Board.
The Government has considered that the time has
come for sports to be organised and co-ordinated in
a more efficient way than hitherto if it is to
fulfil its primary role of not only creating a
physically rugged population
Column: 121
but also promoting national consciousness and
identity in our multi-racial nation.
Over the past ten years since the present
Government came to power, recognising the
importance of sports and games as a unifying factor
of our nation made up of diverse races of immigrant
stock, Government has actively encouraged sports
and games as part of the activities of the network
of community centres spread throughout the island
and of the extra-mural activities of the half-million school-going population. Other steps taken
to promote sports and games have been the
introduction since 1964 of the annual Pesta Sukan
when sporting teams from neighbouring countries are
invited to participate in the games around National
Day Week; the assistance given to the participation
of the Singapore contingent in international sports
events such as the SEAP Games, the Commonwealth
Games, the Asian Games and the Olympic Games; and
in March this year the launching of the National
Fitness Exercise so as to spread sports
consciousness and physical well-being to a greater
section of our population.
In the active encouragement of sports and games,
Government has not overlooked the need for
increased facilities to be set up where sports and
games can be carried out. Besides the
Extracurricular Activity Centre built by the
Ministry of Education and the numerous school halls
and fields to cater for sports and games amongst
the school children, Government, realising that
since a large percentage of our urban population
are residing in Housing and Development Board
flats, has found that it would be logical for
sports fields, swimming pools and other facilities
to be sited in the housing estates themselves.
Plans have therefore been made by the Housing and
Development Board to construct sports stadiums and
swimming pools in its large housing estates of
Queenstown and Toa Payoh Housing Estate as well as
its other large housing estates. But the main
centre of facilities for sports and
Column: 122
games which Government will be providing for our
population is the National Sports Complex at
Kallang which, besides the main open stadium to be
completed in early 1972, will also have a covered
stadium for indoor games and swimming pools and
tennis courts to cater for all the major games in
international meets.
In spite of the active support for sports and
games by Government and the setting up of the
Sports Division of the Ministry of Social Affair in
1966 to provide assistance for voluntary sports
organisations by way of getting foreign expert
coaches and fund-raising, it has been found that
the activities carried out by the voluntary sports
bodies had been greatly handicapped by the lack of
adequate finance and proper executive
functionaries. It has also been found that the co-ordinating bodies of the voluntary sports
organisations, such as the Singapore Olympic Sports
Council, the Singapore Sports Council and the
Sports Division of the Ministry of Social Affairs,
have ill-defined functions which overlap in many
ways and therefore have not provided the direction
and impetus for the planned growth of sports in
Singapore.
In order that the voluntary sports bodies and
other organisations concerned with sports could
better achieve the aims for which sports and games
are to be promoted in the Republic, Government has
seen fit that a statutory body whose primary
function would be the promotion of sports should be
set up. In order that this statutory body should be
an effective one, it is intended that membership of
the Board would consist of persons who have been
generally accepted in the sporting world for their
proven interest and knowledge of sports, and also
of representatives of the Ministry of Education,
the People's Association, and the Armed Forces,
since all these institutions are actively involved
in sports promotion in their respective
organisations, and therefore can make significant
contributions to meet the objectives of the Board.
The number of members on the Board is provided in
clause 4 of the Bill.
Column: 123
The functions of the Board are spelt out in
clause 5 of the Bill. They are:
(a) to encourage, develop and promote sports for
competitive and recreational purposes;
(b) to co-ordinate the activities of voluntary
sports organisations;
(c) to organise, in consultation with national
sports organisations, including the National
Olympic Committee, international
competitions and games;
(d) to foster research and study in sports,
physical education and the training of
instructors;
(e) to manage and maintain facilities and sports
stadiums.
Provision is also made in clause 5 of the Bill
for the Board to receive donations and
contributions, to raise funds and to make grants
and contributions to any person or sports
organisation on such conditions as are stipulated
by the Board. The Board is also empowered to
prescribe minimum standards for participating in
international sports competitions and games, and
other terms and requirements for the purpose of
receiving aid from the Board, and to promote
schemes for the improvement of sports and
recreational facilities.
In order that the Board should have sufficient
funds for its activities, clause 6 of the Bill
provides for the setting up of a National Sports
Promotion Fund, which will consist of grants or
loans made by Government, donations or
contributions by the public, and monies accruing to
the Board.
To prevent monies donated, contributed or
accruing to the Board from being used for other
purposes, clause 7 of the Bill requires that monies
of the Board shall be applied solely for making
payments in connection with the performance of the
Board's functions.
Provision is also made in clause 11 of the Bill
for the Board to employ staff and for it to set up
pension schemes, gratuities or provident fund
schemes for its employees.
Column: 124
To encourage public donations and contributions
to the Board, provision is made in clause 16 for
the National Sports Promotion Board to be an
institution of a public character so that gifts to
the Board shall be exempted from income tax.
It is hoped that by setting up the National
Sports Promotion Board, there will be an
organisation in the Republic made up of persons
actively concerned with the promotion of sports and
games in the various institutions and of
individuals who are knowledgeable and have proven
their interest in sports. It is also hoped that
with the setting up of the Board, the overlapping
functions of the various co-ordinating bodies in
sports as found at present in Singapore will be
resolved. This will be done by the modification of
the objects of the Singapore Olympic Sports Council
to be renamed as the Singapore Olympic Committee
and concerned only with the participation of
Singapore at international games, such as the SEAP
Games, the Commonwealth Games, the Asian Games and
the Olympic Games, and the abolition of the
Singapore Sports Council, an ad hoc Government
Sports Council set up by the Ministry of Social
Affairs, and also the absorption of the functions
of the Sports Division by the Board.
May I conclude by saying that whilst sports must
have the active recognition and encouragement of
the Government, it should not be directly
controlled and run by the Government and be just
another portfolio of a Government Ministry or
Department. The interest in sports, participation
in it and support for it must come from the people
and the private sector to a large extent. It is
with this in view that the proposed National Sports
Promotion Board, in motivation, organisation,
objective and activity, is structured to perform.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
4.49 p.m.
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, I fully
Column: 125
support this Bill. Undoubtedly it has very grand
objectives. When it is implemented, I believe it
will have a very decisive effect on the promotion
of sports in our country and on the raising of our
standard in sports.
Sir, the purpose of this Bill, as the Minister
has already described, is to set up the National
Sports Promotion Board. Its tasks can be said to be
quite comprehensive, with such functions as to
encourage, develop and promote sports on a national
basis for both competitive and recreational
purposes; to co-ordinate the activities of
voluntary sports organisations; to organise, in
consultation with national sports organisations,
including the National Olympic Committee, national
and international competitions and games; and to
foster research and study in sports and physical
education and to provide for the training of
instructors.
[Mr DEPUTY SPEAKER in the Chair]
4.51 p.m.
All these functions will ensure that this Board
plays an important part in the promotion of sports
in our country. Because of the various important
tasks entrusted to the Board, it will have very
great responsibilities, such as co-ordinating the
various sports organisations and raising the
standard of the various sports and popularising
them. In carrying out these responsibilities, there
are questions to look into and matters to be taken
care of. In working to achieve the objectives
envisaged in the Bill, the National Sports
Promotion Board will, I am confident, do its best
to live up to its expectations.
Sir, I believe you will agree with me that in
promoting sports, there are three main objectives
which should be well recognised. They are:
(1) To train our people to have healthy and
strong bodies so that our country will be able to
shoulder the heavy task of nation building.
Column: 126
(2) Through the various sports tournaments and
competitions, the people will be able to enjoy some
recreational activity.
(3) To raise the competitive standard of the
various kinds of sports, our national teams should
be sent abroad to take part in regional as well as
international tournaments in order to gain honour
as well as publicity for our country. So these are
very grand objectives and high ideals in the
promotion of sports.
Let us now examine the progress of sports over
the past few years. Undoubtedly through the efforts
of the Ministry of Social Affairs and with the help
of various sports circles, we have had great
achievements in many fields of sports, such as
basketball, badminton, football, table tennis,
swimming, and weightlifting. They are now
flourishing. Now and then we see many youngsters
training or taking part in tournaments either in
school grounds or in community centres. These
activities were never seen before.
Although we are a small country, our standard of
sports is not far below that of other countries. We
can be said to be comparable to them. This has been
proved in the results we achieved at the last Asian
Games and the SEAP Games. But we should also
recognise that in certain kinds of sports we have
not done as well as before. For instance, our
basketball team brought back a "big zero" in the
last international competition. Our badminton
standard has dropped even further. A few years ago
we claimed to be the champions of the world in
badminton, but just about a month ago we
unexpectedly lost to an unknown national team from
New Zealand. Is this not a pity? How did this come
about? We must examine the reasons for this
dropping of standard and take remedial measures.
In order to promote sports, particularly to raise
the standard of our national teams, I would like to
make four suggestions for the Minister's
consideration.
Column: 127
(1) To engage international coaches of repute.
(2) All national team members should be given
certain safeguards in respect of their employment,
so that they can have peace of mind while taking
part in sports.
(3) Once a year there should be a definite
programme for centralised group training. This will
help the team members to attain all-round
improvement, in addition to improvement in their
physique, their spirit and their standards. And
while they are taking part in group training, they
should continue to draw their salaries if they are
employed.
(4) We should inculcate into them the spirit of
patriotism in order to win honour for our country.
The implementation of all these measures needs a
lot of money. But the Minister has pointed out that
there is provision for the setting up of the
National Sports Promotion Fund to receive donations
from various sources, such as commercial
organisations and individuals, to meet expenses.
These donations will be tax free. I believe this is
a good measure, and with the setting up of this
Fund, we will be able to have more funds to carry
out our sports activities. Here I would like to
appeal to sports enthusiasts, particularly those
who are rich, to donate generously to help promote
sport.
Sir, I support this Bill.
4.59 p.m.
Mr Tay Boon Too(In Mandarin): Mr Deputy Speaker, Sir, I take part in sports
activities, and therefore I am concerned with all
matters connected with sports. I fully support this
Bill. In order to meet our future economic
challenge, our people will undoubtedly have to have
strong physiques and better endurance. A strong and
healthy physique can only be acquired through
sports. At the same time, through sports, we will
also acquire a strong national consciousness and
also we can, indirectly, fulfil the aim of
achieving racial harmony.
Column: 128
As the Minister has said, the introduction of
this Bill is to provide for the planning and
promotion of national sports activities and to do
away with whatever duplication there has been in
this field. The result is that all sports
activities will be planned, co-ordinated and
controlled by a centralised body consisting of
representatives of the Singapore National Olympic
Committee, the Sports Division of the Ministry of
Social Affairs, the Ministry of Education, the
Armed Forces, the police and the People's
Association. In this way, it is hoped to promote
sports activities and raise the standard of sports
in this country. These are lofty and praiseworthy
aims.
Mr Deputy Speaker, in order to raise the
standard of our sports and to achieve greater
prestige for our country, the following points
should not be overlooked. During the past two or
three years, the various sports organisations as
well as the Singapore Sports Council have done
their very best to obtain the services of expert
coaches for the more popular sports activities in
Singapore. These organisations have also tried
their very best to look out for talent and
potential sportsmen so that under a proper system
of training they will be nurtured and developed
into State players. These are praiseworthy efforts.
However, some doubts have been expressed in this
regard. They have given rise to the question
whether we are able to obtain the sympathy and
support of other countries in supplying the first-class coaches that we require. If the answer to
this question is in the negative, the next question
will arise. Are we prepared to accept second- and
third-class coaches to train fourth- and fifth-class players? Perhaps the Minister will give some
consideration to a more economical approach to this
problem and plan an extensive programme to train
our players and thus obtain the instruction by
cheaper means. One of the ways is to get a
plentiful supply of films showing how first-class
coaches train sportsmen in order to reach international standards. By showing these films to our
trainees, we will be able
Column: 129
indirectly to train our own people, short of
getting expert coaches from abroad. Our trainees
will be able to learn from watching these films;
how they should train and what are the points they
should bear in mind when they are in training.
The second point I wish to raise is the extension
of the age limit for sports training. At the
present moment, most of the sports activities are
confined to our school-going population. In order
to raise our sports standard, we must not only
popularise sports activities among students, but
also extend them outside the schools. This work
must be done by the various sports organisations in
conjunction with the commercial and industrial
sectors. These sectors should also be encouraged to
make a contribution to sports. In other words, Mr
Deputy Speaker, it is our hope that they will at
least shoulder some responsibility by taking in
sportsmen who have graduated from schools and other
institutions of higher learning. They should also
allow such people to continue with their sports
activities when they are working. In this way,
their skill and standard will be maintained. There
are people who have to give up sports activities
because of their employment. We have lost a large
reservoir of talent because of the hard economic
facts of life. When sportsmen leave school and
happen to be employed in a very small company which
is not prepared to allow them to take time off for
training, or does not provide any facility or
encouragement for them to carry on their sports
activities, the loss of such talent to sport will
be complete. In order to earn their living, these
sportsmen will have to accept the hard economic
facts of life at the expense of their sports
activities and the talent that they have developed.
Thirdly, I wish to stress that the present
training facilities for sportsmen are more or
less of a spontaneous and voluntary nature. We
must have a centralised body, such as a sports
college, to shoulder the responsibility of
Column: 130
training our sportsmen. In this way, we will have
better hopes of our sportsmen achieving higher
standards. Furthermore, the establishment of a
sports college will provide employment
opportunities for those who are active in sports.
In other words, those who are good in sports
activities will be able to find employment in the
sports college and they, in turn, will have the
responsibility of training other sportsmen.
Fourthly, as the Member for Sembawang has just
said, State players should receive the attention of
the State. Perhaps the Minister's answer to this
question will be that, as the State is faced with
its economic problems, it does not have the
capacity or the ability to look after our sportsmen
in terms of finance. But it is my view that since
our Armed Forces and our Police Force have the
means and the ability to maintain brass bands,
which consist of more people and cost much more
money than, for example, a normal basketball team,
how is it that we find ourselves unable to maintain
a team of State players? Of course, it is not my
proposal to ask the State to feed the players. My
proposal is that the Government should do all it
can to absorb these sportsmen into the various
Government departments so that while in employment
they will also have the time to continue with .
their sports activities. Thus, in both ways they
serve the country.
Finally, if the Minister will bear all these
points in mind, he will surely find some solution
to the problems raised. It is my belief that just
as we have been able to raise our standard of
health and hygiene, we should be able to raise our
standard of sports. In view of the compactness of
our island Republic, I sincerely believe that we
will be able to achieve our aims. Let me reiterate
my full support of this Bill.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: I have just a brief comment to make on this Bill
which is now before the House for its Second
Reading. The Minister has mentioned that he will co-opt people from various organisations, such as the
Column: 131
army, the police, the Ministry of Education and the
People's Association, to serve on the National
Sports Promotion Board. It appears to me that
colleges and universities have been omitted. Mr
Deputy Speaker, Sir, you are well aware that in
advanced countries college and university students
play a very prominent part in sports activities. In
fact, most of the outstanding sportsmen have come
from colleges and universities. In this respect, I
would urge the Minister for Social Affairs not to
overlook appointing representatives from our
colleges and universities. This will at least
enable our college and university students to
participate actively in the promotion of sports.
Sir, you will agree with me that our younger
generation must not only be intelligent but they
must also be rugged and robust. It is, therefore,
important that our college and university students
must excel in all forms of sports and, in time to
come, they will become outstanding sportsmen and be
able to make a name for the Republic of Singapore
in the world of sports. I support this Bill.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang): Mr Deputy Speaker, Sir, I support this Bill.
However, I hope and I wish that the National Sports
Promotion Board will never finance sports and
recreation clubs, associations or bodies which are
organised exclusively on a racial basis; nor should
the players, members and officials of such
organisations be allowed to represent the Republic
at the expense of the Board; nor should the
officials of such organisations ever he appointed
to the Board by the Minister. I hope he can give
this assurance.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
5.l5 p.m.
Inche Othman Bin Wok: Mr Speaker, Sir, I have nothing much to say
except to thank Members for their support of the
Bill, particularly the Member for Sembawang who has
been repeating some of the points I have made in my
speech. I will consider all the points that he has
raised when the Bill is considered by the Select
Committee.
Column: 132
On the first point raised by the Member for Paya
Lebar, whether there is any possibility of our
getting first-class coaches from abroad to train
our sportsmen and, if it is not possible, whether
it would be possible for us to have some training
films from abroad, I think this is not a difficult
matter. We can look into that.
On the question of sports training to be extended
not only to the school-going population but also to
persons outside our schools, if I am not mistaken,
the Pioneer Industries Union have a sports
division. Many of our industries in Jurong as well
as business houses all over Singapore have got
their own sports teams
On the question of State players being maintained
by the State, I would like to inform the Member
that there are quite a number of unemployed
sportsmen and sportswomen who have been absorbed
into some Government departments as well as
business houses through the help of the Sports
Division of the Ministry of Social Affairs.
The Member for Mountbatten has raised the point
that members of the proposed Board do not include
representatives from the colleges and universities
in Singapore. He says that most of our sportsmen
come from the universities and colleges. But, in
fact, I am very sad to say that although this is
true in other countries, it is not so in Singapore.
Very few sportsmen and sportswomen come from the
universities. Nevertheless, I will consider his
proposal.
On the point raised by the Member for Kallang, he
has my assurance that whatever help is given by the
National Sports Promotion Board will not be on a
racial basis.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Resolved,
"That the Bill be committed to a Select Committee
consisting of the Speaker as Chairman and the
following Members:
Inche A. Rahim Bin Ishak, Minister of State for Foreign Affairs,
Column: 133
Mr Chan Chee Seng, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs,
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education,
Inche Othman Bin Wok, Minister for Social Affairs,
Mr Phua Bah Lee, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Communications,
Mr L. P. Rodrigo, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Foreign Affairs,
Mr P. Selvadurai, Member for Bukit Panjang, and
Mr Sim Boon Woo, Member for Changi."-[Inche Othman Wok].
Column: 133
RECOVERY OF POSSESSION
OF CONTROLLED PREMISES
(SPECIAL PROVISIONS) BILL
[changed to CONTROLLED PREMISES (SPECIAL PROVISIONS) BILL]
(As reported from Select Committee)
Order for Third Reading read.
5.25 p.m.
Mr Speaker: Before I call upon the Minister, I draw attention
to an oversight in the Bill as amended by the
Select Committee. This error has to be corrected.
It is in clause 6, which appears in page 7 of the
Report of Select Committee. In line 21, "three"
should, in fact, read "four". This is a change that
makes no material difference and it will be done.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): I am much obliged. Sir, I beg to
move, "That the Bill be now read a Third time."
Members of the House will recall that this Bill
was referred to Select Committee on the 22nd of
May, 1968.
The Bill, which is novel in concept and
potentially far-reaching in its social and economic
impact, has aroused a considerable amount of
interest and it has been a subject of much well-informed comment. This interest is evident from the
number of representations that were made to Select
Committee. In all, thirteen written representations
were received and the Committee heard oral evidence
from ten of
Column: 134
the representors. Representations came not only
from landlords, tenants and developers but also
from interested professional and business
associations, such as the Singapore Advocates and
Solicitors Society, the Singapore Real Estate
Valuers Association, the Singapore Planning and
Urban Research Group and the Chinese Chamber of
Commerce. Apart from the representations of the
Singapore Advocates and Solicitors Society, which
confined itself to the technical legal aspects of
the Bill, almost all the representations were
concerned either with the scope of the legislation
or with the compensation formula that is proposed
in the Bill. There was much difference of opinion
in the representations on both these aspects of the
Bill. Despite this, or maybe because of it, almost
all the representations had something of value to
contribute and gave the Select Committee much food
for thought. In the result, as Members may observe
from the Report, many of the suggestions and
proposals in the representations have been adopted
and are written into the Bill, and undoubtedly have
improved it
.
Although the Bill as tabled does not provide the
perfect solution to some of the problems raised,
and although it may in regard to the compensation
formula lack the sort of legal precision to which
legislators would aspire, I would suggest it does
provide a satisfactory framework in which the
policy of the Bill may be carried out and under
which the interests of landlords and tenants
affected by the Bill will be adequately protected.
The Committee's Report was presented on the 13th
of June, 1969, as Paper Parl. 3 of 1969. Mr
Speaker, Sir, the Bill as now tabled before the
House incorporates the recommendations of the
Select Committee. Members will observe from the
Report that fairly detailed statements are given
therein explaining the reasons for accepting all
the major amendments. I need not burden the House
by repeating them. It may, however, be of interest
to Members if I refer to a basic provision in
Column: 135
the Bill upon which representations were made to
the Select Committee and which the Committee were
unable to accept.
I refer to clause 3 dealing with the application
of the Bill. Certain representations, particularly
those from developers, proposed that the whole of
Singapore should be designated as a development
area or, alternatively, that any landlord may make
an application for the area in which his controlled
premises are situated to be declared a development
area. It is not difficult to see that the effect of
accepting either of these proposals would be that
the Tenants' Compensation Board would be flooded
with applications for possession of premises and
the whole of the provisions of the Control of Rent
Ordinance would be nullified, for all controlled
premises in Singapore would potentially be liable
to decontrol. This was not the purpose of
Government in introducing this legislation. On the
contrary, if Government had decided that it was
time to nullify the effect of the Control of Rent
Ordinance, it would not have adopted this backdoor
method of doing so. It was precisely because
Government considered that the time was not as yet
opportune for an outright repeal of this Ordinance
that it was considered that, in the general context
of Government's policy to promote development in
the private sector, the approach in this Bill of a
limited and phased form of de-control with payment
of compensation to dispossessed tenants was
adopted. If and when the time comes for the repeal
of this Ordinance, it would by no means follow that
compensation would be paid to tenants who would be
obliged to leave their premises because they could
not pay the resulting increases in rent. The reason
being that if Government decided to repeal that
Ordinance, it would be because the economic and
housing situation as it affected protected tenants
would be such as to persuade Government that no
further control over rents was necessary. In other
words, this category of persons would then be able
to pay an economic rent or obtain suitable
alternative accommodation.
Column: 136
By and large, the Control of Rent Ordinance
confers protection upon the poorer sections of the
community, and although Government is fully aware
of the price that has to be paid for this
protection in terms of unsightly buildings and slum
tenements and the discrimination against one
section of the community at the expense of another,
which is inherent in the present system, Government
considers that we have not yet reached the stage
when this protection can be thrown overboard. The
repeal of this Ordinance would have the effect of
rendering homeless thousands of persons in
Singapore and, though much has been done to provide
low-cost housing for these poorer sections of the
community, we are not as yet in a position to
rehouse all the persons that would be affected.
However, everyone is aware of Government's policy
to encourage home ownership, and there is no doubt
that the time will come when this Ordinance may be
safely repealed - at first in part and then as a
whole. I can assure the House that Government is,
in fact, giving very serious and careful
consideration to the question of decontrol;-perhaps commercial or business premises could be
decontrolled in about five to seven years' time and
residential premises in 10 to 12 years' time, but
there will be complications where premises are used
for mixed purposes unless a just solution is found
or some equitable formula arrived at. For the
moment, it is Government's intention to advance
slowly and in an orderly manner in this respect.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 136
CATTLE (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.33 p.m.
The Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill
be now read a Second time."
Column: 137
Hon. Members of this House will recall that in
November 1964, this House passed the Cattle Bill
which subsequently became the Cattle Ordinance,
1964 (No. 15 of 1964). The Cattle Ordinance has
since proven to be an extremely effective legal
instrument in attaining our objective of raising
our environmental standards.
Today, cows and buffaloes roaming unchecked on
our arterial roads, traffic circuses and rampaging
private property are conspicuous by their absence.
All cattle sheds are now licensed and are
situated in well-defined and demarcated "non-restricted" areas. These measures have in turn
solved all the outstanding problems caused by stray
cattle in respect of health and traffic control.
The cattle nuisance has, once and for all, been
dealt with by the Ministry of Health armed with an
effective piece of legislation.
However, with the rapid and intensive
urbanisation and physical development that are
taking place around us today in Singapore, other
sub-standard environmental health conditions in
certain slum and squatter areas have now been
brought into focus. The unfavourable environmental
health conditions in such areas are intensified by
the rearing of domestic animals, the most
outstanding of which is the rearing of pigs, or
what are legally termed "swine". These animals are
often to be found being reared in pockets of slum
areas in insanitary pig-sties and these pigs are
allowed to stray and roam at will. These animals
defecate all over the place and create appalling
insanitary conditions in the areas and their
surroundings.
To make matters worse, such places are usually
situated just adjacent to newly-developed housing
estates, both public as well as private, and even
in the immediate vicinity of the precinct of our
Paya Lebar International Airport. The roaming about
of these animals from their insanitary pig-sties
into the more developed and hygienic environment of
the neighbouring areas has
Column: 138
in the past brought numerous cries of protest and
complaints from the public. It is now time for us
to introduce more effective legislation in order
that the rearing of these pigs is controlled so
that the nuisances caused by them are eliminated,
just as it was in the case of the cattle nuisance.
The present law governing the rearing of pigs,
which is in the form of by-laws, was made under the
repealed Municipal Ordinance, as is the case of
most of our old laws. The concepts embodied in this
law are now outdated and have been overtaken by
events around us.
I therefore propose to deal with this outstanding
environmental health problem of insanitary
piggeries and the roaming of pigs in a similar
fashion as in the case of cattle. This, in short,
is the purpose of this Cattle (Amendment) Bill.
The Bill is not aimed at any specific group of
people, nor is it intended to cause hardship to any
one. Let me make it clear that it is certainly not
the purpose of the Bill to prohibit the rearing of
pigs. Indeed, it seeks to ensure that farmers breed
pigs in well-defined areas and in as sanitary a
manner as it is possible to do and without creating
environmental health hazards, as well as being a
nuisance to the public.
Specifically, the Bill seeks to extend the
existing definition of "cattle" in the Cattle
Ordinance by including swine as well. This will
enable the authorities to apprehend the stray pigs
that are a public nuisance and turn them over to
the slaughter-house to be turned into meat for
distribution among our charitable homes in
Singapore.
In order to institute effective enforcement
action when necessary, a new section 5A is enacted
to empower the Commissioner of Public Health to
delegate his powers to any public officer and, with
the approval of the Minister, to any officer of any
statutory board to deal with the problem.
Certain consequential changes are also made in
the definition of "officers" so as to bring the
Cattle Ordinance in line with the Environmental
Public
Column: 139
Health Act, 1968 (No. 32 of 1968). There are also
amendments of a purely formal nature such as "the
Legislative Assembly" to "Parliament" and "the
State" to "Singapore" and so on.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move. Question put,
and agreed to. Bill accordingly read a Second
time and committed to a Committee of the whole
House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Chua Sian Chin].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 139
5.43 p.m.
ADJOURNMENT TO A DATE
TO BE FIXED
(Motion)
Resolved,
"That at its rising this day Parliament do stand
adjourned to a date to be fixed."-[Mr Barker].
ADJOURNMENT MOTION
Mr E. W. Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That Parliament do now adjourn.
Question proposed.
Column: 139
SUPPLY OF ARTIFICIAL LIMBS
TO INJURED WORKMEN
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein): Mr Speaker, Sir, I rise to speak on the matter of
artificial aids for persons who are unfortunate
enough to suffer the loss of any portion of their
limbs through accident or otherwise, and who are
not fortunate enough to be able to purchase such
aids which are necessary for them to earn their
livelihood.
Any accident resulting in the injury to and
eventual loss of a limb is a tragedy for any
person. The tragedy, however, is greater where the
person concerned belongs to the under-privileged
class of manual workers whose very limbs are the
means of supporting
Column: 140
themselves and their families. I may safely say
that it is not only a tragedy but also a calamity
for a worker to have an accident to his limbs,
because of his low level of wages and because of
his invariably having little or no savings at all.
Added to the physical agony and pain of his
injuries, he has to suffer a great deal of mental
agony and anxiety regarding his own future and the
future of his wife, children, aged parents perhaps,
and other dependants. His worries and fears about
the future are very real and substantial,
particularly if he is the sole bread-winner. Apart
from the productive use of his God-given limbs, he
has no other means or savings to depend upon for
his livelihood. The plight of such an unfortunate
victim deserves not only compassion and sympathy
but also whatever help that can be given to enable
him to face the future with a certain amount of
hope and confidence
.
Mr Speaker, Sir, in bringing up this matter of
artificial aids for persons with amputated limbs, I
am prompted by the need to rationalise the basis
for determining the type of artificial aids to be
supplied and the amount of charges to be levied, if
the aids are so supplied. As an illustration, I
refer to the case of a Public Works Department
labourer who was admitted to hospital in February
this year for diabetic gangrene of the left foot,
resulting in his left leg being amputated below the
knee. The hospital decided to fit him with a pylon
or a wooden peg, and not with an artificial limb.
The reason for this decision seemed to be on the
following ground: as a Government employee, he
would be fitted with a wooden peg free of charge,
but if he wanted to have an artificial limb fitted,
he would have to pay the full cost of the
artificial limb.
In terms of money, it means that he would have to
find $250 to pay for the cost of such an artificial
limb, which is made locally. Knowing the financial
position of this P.W.D. labourer, I need not
elaborate on his difficulty in finding this sum of
money.
Hon. Members in this House may want to know what
is the difference
Column: 141
between an artificial limb and a wooden peg. An
artificial limb has certain advantages over a
wooden peg, namely, a patient fitted with an
artificial limb will look in appearance very much
like a normal person with natural limbs, and after
some time he will be able to move about quite
easily. But a patient fitted with a wooden peg is
likely to feel dejected perpetually because of its
unnatural appearance and will, in addition, find
greater difficulty in moving about. An artificial
limb is certainly far more superior to a wooden peg
in terms of function and appearance.
A patient by reason of his being poor is not
likely to be given a chance to be fitted with an
artificial limb, simply because there is in
existence at present a puzzling hospital
regulation. The paradox of the whole situation is
that if his condition requires him to have a wheel-chair, he is entitled, as a Government employee, to
be supplied with one free of charge. I am sure hon.
Members will agree with me that it is extremely
paradoxical that, as a Government servant, while he
is entitled to a free wooden peg which costs about
$100, and a wheel-chair which has to be imported
from the United Kingdom at a cost of $300, he is
not entitled to an artificial limb which is made
locally and which costs $250.
The reason for such a paradox is that there is a
hospital regulation which classifies artificial
limbs under the heading "Prosthesis", and wooden
pegs and wheel-chairs under the heading
"Appliances". According to this regulation or
stipulation, items such as artificial limbs under
the heading "Prosthesis" can only be supplied to a
third-class patient if he pays the full cost of
such items, irrespective of whether or not he is a
Government employee. But such items as wooden pegs
or wheel-chairs under the heading "Appliances" can
be supplied to a third-class patient free of charge
if he is a Government employee, and at a
concessionary rate of 20 per cent of the actual
cost if he is not a Government employee.
Column: 142
It is very difficult to follow the logic behind
such a stipulation. To a layman particularly,
artificial limbs, wooden pegs, or wheel-chairs,
prosthesis or appliances all mean one thing, i.e.,
artificial aids for a patient who has had his limbs
amputated. To split hairs by classifying one item
under the heading "Prosthesis" and other items
under the heading "Appliances" might be convenient
for the purpose of administration, but certainly in
this instance it is not to the advantage and
interest of a third-class patient who has had his
limbs amputated. This absurd stipulation deprives a
poor patient of a chance to be fitted with an
artificial limb which, as I said earlier, is far
more superior to any other artificial aids in terms
of function and appearance, simply because he
cannot find the money to pay the full cost of an
artificial limb that the hospital wants to charge
him.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I hope you will allow me at this
juncture to mention in passing that, with regard
to this P.W.D. labourer whose case I have just
mentioned, the National Trades Union Congress
decided to pay for the cost of an artificial limb
to enable him to be fitted with one instead of
with a wooden peg. The decision of the N.T.U.C. is
only a symbolic gesture to ring out the cry of
distress of this labourer and all those who happen
to suffer the same misfortune. However, this must
not be taken to mean that the N.T.U.C. has now
been turned into a philanthropic organisation. It
just does not have the financial resources to dole
out assistance to all those who need help and
charity -
The Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin): What about the hospitals?
Mr Sia Khoon Seong: - especially at a time when it needs all its own
resources to strengthen the Singapore trade union
movement. The responsibility of giving all possible
care and assistance to the unfortunate must rest
largely upon the State that has all the national
resources at its command, and not on an
organisation like the N.T.U.C.
I am sure hon. Members in this House will agree
with me that requiring
Column: 143
third-class patients, who are no more than humble
and poor workers, to pay the full cost of
artificial limbs, if they wish to have these fitted
in place of their natural limbs that have been
amputated, is both harsh and unnecessary. Fate has
been cruel enough to them and, in addition to their
agony and the pain of injury, they have grave
worries and nightmares about their own future and
the future of their loved ones and dependants.
Their plight and distress are often shared and felt
by well-meaning people who have shown and expressed
their compassion and sympathy by making generous
donations to assist them to meet the future with a
certain amount of courage and confidence. Dedicated
doctors and nurses have also done their bit by
providing them with the best medical treatment and
attention possible. Let there be no hospital rule
or regulation that is harsher than is necessary.
Laws and rules are made to serve mankind, not to
enslave them.
I ask the Minister for Health to give his urgent
attention and sympathetic consideration to my
proposal to rationalise the various hospital
stipulations governing the supply of artificial
aids to orthopaedic patients, and to take steps to
supply artificial limbs on the same basis as wooden
pegs and wheelchairs are supplied to patients in
third-class wards, whose limbs have to be amputated
as a result of an accident or events beyond their
control.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I sympathise with the Member for
Moulmein when he makes a request for the supply of
artificial limbs. This is a matter of aftercare,
because if a worker meets with an accident and has
to have one arm or leg amputated, he will have to
fit himself with an artificial limb in order to
carry on his daily activities so as to look after
the livelihood of his family. This brings me to the
subject of better methods of safety in industrial
firms.
There have been serious cases recently of
industrial accidents. According to the statistics
of the Ministry of
Column: 144
Labour for 1968, there was a total of 8,147 cases,
of which 109 were fatal. A total of 195 persons
have become permanently disabled, and 1,343 persons
have been disabled to the extent that they are
unable to work further. From these statistics you
can see the seriousness of the situation.
Singapore is peaceful. We have no wars. However,
every year, unfortunately, we find that more than
100 people lose their lives and limbs. This is
really a very serious matter and is a problem to
ponder on. So a more practical attitude is not just
to discuss the supply of artificial limbs but to
adopt better effective measures. I think the
Ministry of Labour should engage more inspectors to
go to the factories and other places of work to
make routine or surprise inspections to see whether
the facilities there are safe and without hazards.
Mr Speaker: Order. Mr Teong, the
debate is on the question of the supply of
artificial limbs to injured workmen. The Minister
for Health will be in no position to answer
questions such as increasing the strength of the
inspectorate, which should properly be directed to
the Minister for Labour. Can you please confine
your remarks to the supply of artificial limbs to
injured workmen?
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I understand your ruling, and I
will cut short my speech. As I have said just now,
I feel that artificial aids are very necessary for
these unfortunate people. But if the cost is to be
borne by the workers themselves, it might be
impossible for them to get artificial limbs because
they draw a very low pay. According to
calculations, an artificial limb costs about
$2,000. If the worker happens to be working in a
Government department, I feel that the authorities
concerned should look into the matter and try to do
all they can to enable him to maintain his
livelihood and the livelihood of his family. This
is what we,
Column: 145
as a Government that looks after the welfare of the
people, should do to help him discharge his
responsibility.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I quite understand the
unfortunate plight of the victims who have lost
their limbs. I personally do feel compassion and
sympathy for them. But I would like to clarify
certain points which have been brought up by the
Member for Moulmein. He seemed to convey to the
House the impression that artificial limbs are not
supplied free to the unfortunate victims by the
hospital authorities because the hospital
administrators are splitting hairs and want to
distinguish between a peg-leg and an artificial
limb. He said they are slaves to rules and
regulations. That is not the case. First of all,
rules and regulations must be there and they must
be applied. Obviously rules and regulations have
been drawn up because there is a - and I underline it -
rationale on which they have been drawn up. Perhaps
if I may just explain, it will clarify matters.
What is the difference between an artificial limb
and a peg-leg or a pylon? As far as these aids are
concerned, they are an artificial substitute for a
lost limb. According to the experts, as far as peg-legs and pylons are concerned, they are the minimum
substitute for a lost limb, whereas an artificial
limb is something much more sophisticated and
elaborate. Of course, the sophistication and the
elaboration of artificial limbs can vary from type
to type. Some artificial limbs can be
electronically operated. But as far as the hospital
rules and regulations are concerned, they are based
on the policy that a peg-leg is the minimum
substitute for a lost limb, and that is what the
hospitals are providing at a subsidised price.
Artificial limbs are something more than a minimum
substitute. Of course, in any case, we must draw a
line somewhere. If you say that a patient is
entitled to a free artificial limb, then he may
demand an artificial limb which is electronically
operated.
Column: 146
There is another matter which I wish to point out
to the Member for Moulmein - if he has not been
aware of it, although he is a trade unionist. Under
section 15 (3) of the Workmen's Compensation
Ordinance, workmen who are injured are entitled to
artificial limbs, but the price must be paid for by
the employers. Why should the Government be held
responsible for supplying a free artificial limb
when, under the Workmen's Compensation Ordinance,
it is the employers who should be liable to supply
it? After all, they are the people who make a
profit, whereas the Government does not make a
profit. Of course, if the Government is the
employer, it is a different matter.
Another point which hinges on policy is this. The
Member for Moulmein said that in the case of the
P.W.D. labourer, the N.T.U.C. had contributed some
funds and, as a result, the labourer is now in a
position to have the artificial limb. He also added
that the N.T.U.C., although it helped in this
instance, was not indicating that it was going to
turn itself into a philanthropic organisation. On
the same basis, I would say that a hospital is not
a philanthropic organisation.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong: It is a State organisation.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: A State organisation is different from a
philanthropic organisation. Is the Member for
Moulmein suggesting that a hospital should be
turned into a philanthropic organisation? Perhaps
if I may bring up certain points, it may clarify
the matter. According to the regulations, at the
moment, a peg-leg or a pylon, which will cost about
$100, will be supplied to a "C" class patient (who
pays $1 per day) at 20 per cent of the cost of the
peg-leg; that is, he will have to pay $20. In other
words, it is subsidised; whereas if an "A" or "B"
class patient wants a pylon or a peg-leg, he pays
the full price of $100. However, I wish to point
out that even the $100 is an economic cost. In
other words, no profit is being made by Government.
The
Column: 147
$100 is the cost of the production of the peg-leg
or the pylon.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong: Mr Speaker, Sir, I think the Minister for
Health has missed some of my points in his reply.
I am not quarrelling over the fact that there
should be rules and regulations.
Mr Speaker: Mr Sia, you are not entitled to make a second
speech. But if you will briefly enumerate your
points without introducing any new argument, I
will permit you to carry on.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong: I just want to tell the Minister that I am not
talking about rules and regulations, or that they
should not be there. What I am talking about is
the rationale of the case. The rationale here
seems to be a bit cock-eyed simply because, on the
one hand, the Government allows a wheel-chair
costing $300 to be given free and, on the other
hand, it does not allow an artificial limb which
costs $250 to be given free. That is the rationale
that I am questioning, Mr Speaker, Sir.
With regard to the Workmen's Compensation
Ordinance which was referred to by the Minister, I
just want to point out that I am not referring to
the cases under that Ordinance. I am referring to
those labourers who, outside their work, happen to
be knocked down by a car
Column: 148
and are not covered by the Workmen's Compensation
Ordinance. These are the two points I wish to
mention.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, the way the Member for Moulmein has explained his case, of course, the
rationale of it looks cock-eyed. But I think
that is not the rationale on which the rules and
regulations have been drawn up. I have made it
quite clear just now that the rationale behind
the rules and regulations is that, as far as the
hospitals are concerned, they will give an
artificial aid which will be the minimum
substitute for a lost limb. According to my
experts, the minimum substitute for a lost limb
is a peg-leg. But if a person wants something
more superior and sophisticated like an
artificial limb, then he will have to pay for
it.
May I just reply to the Member's other point? He
has mentioned car accidents and so on. If a person
involved in a car accident was not negligent, he
can easily claim compensation.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That Parliament do now adjourn.
Adjourned accordingly at
Ten minutes past Six o'clock p.m. to
a date to be fixed.
Column: 149
WRITTEN ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
Wednesday, 15th October, 1969
GOVERNMENT ENTERPRISES
(Capital investment)
1. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for Finance
(a) how many Government enterprises and
corporations have been established, up to the
latest convenient date; (b) how much capital is
invested; (c) how many other enterprises are there
in the Republic in which the Government has equity
participation, and how much capital is invested; and
(d) whether he is satisfied with the progress made
by such enterprises.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: (a) Eight wholly-owned
Government enterprises have been established. They
are -
1. Chartered Industries of Singapore Ltd.
2. Keppel Shipyard (Pte.) Ltd.
3. Neptune Orient Lines Ltd.
4. Sembawang Shipyard Ltd.
5. Singapore Electronic & Engineering Ltd.
6. Singapore Pools (Pte.) Ltd.
7. Singmanex Ltd.
8. R.T.S. Enterprises (Pte.) Ltd.
(b) The total equity investment in these
enterprises amounts to $70 million.
(c) In addition, Government has equity holdings
in joint ventures with 21 industrial, banking and
communication companies. The total value of equity
participation at cost in these 21 enterprises
amounts to $122.4 million. This figure is
substantially larger than the one I used in a
recent speech because it includes, in addition to
manufacturing enterprises, the Government's share
in the Development Bank of Singapore as well as
Malaysia-Singapore Airlines Ltd.
(d) I am satisfied with progress made by these
enterprises.
Column: 150
GOVERNMENT ENTERPRISES
(Control)
2. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for Finance
(a) whether the Government has direct or any
control over enterprises such as Radio and
Television Singapore Enterprises (Pte.) Limited,
Chartered Industries of Singapore Limited, Intraco
and other similar enterprises wholly owned by the
Government; and (b) how many civil servants are
administering those enterprises, and how are they
paid and from what sources.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: (a) Since Government is the
sole owner of these enterprises, it has full
control over them. The Government, however, does
not exercise control in detail in the day-to-day
affairs of these enterprises. Such matters are
left to the management of the enterprise.
Government's control is exercised over policy
through the Board of Directors. These are appointed
by the Government and, in the main, they consist of
civil servants.
(b) Civil servants, i.e. employees in the
Government Service, are not responsible for the
administration of these enterprises, as they are
not members of the management team, unless
specifically seconded to these enterprises. Such
secondment occurs rarely, and, when they do, they
are on usual terms governing conditions of
secondment.
Column: 150
SINGLE BUS-FARE SYSTEM
3. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for
Communications whether he will introduce a single
fare system for all passengers travelling whatever
distance by bus along a bus route in the Republic.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: The introduction of a single fare system for all
passengers travelling whatever distance by bus
along a bus route in the Republic as proposed
Column: 151
by the Member for Punggol is an attractive
proposition if there is only one bus company
responsible for Singapore's public transport
service.
But, as there are, at present, as many as 11 bus
companies operating in the Republic and with
different scales of fares in operation, e.g.
Singapore Traction Co. charges 10 cents for the
first mile and thereafter 5 cents for every
subsequent mile, up to a maximum of 25 cents;
whereas the other 10 bus companies charge 5 cents
for the first mile and thereafter 5 cents for every
subsequent mile, without a maximum, it will be
quite an accounting problem to resolve before
contemplating any such proposal in Singapore.
However. I may add that the Transport Advisory
Board is attempting a study of the possibility of
introducing a uniform system of bus fares, in the
first instance.
Column: 151
SINGAPORE ARMED FORCES (Accidents)
4. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for Defence
(a) in how many accidents, fatal or otherwise, were
members of the Singapore Armed Forces involved, up
to the latest convenient date; and (b) how much
compensation has been paid for loss of lives or
limbs as a consequence of those accidents.
Mr Lim Kim San: (a) The total number of traffic
offences of every description involving drivers of
Singapore military vehicles and members of the
public during the period 1st January to 30th
September, 1969 was 369.
(b) Of the 369 cases, fatal injuries were
sustained in three instances, there were 29 cases
in which persons were seriously hurt and the rest
were all minor accidents. Of the three fatal
accident cases, two of the cases are pending and in
the third case the S.A.F. driver was found to be
not at fault.
Accident claims made against the Ministry of the
Interior and Defence are forwarded to the
Solicitor-General's Office for necessary action
in keeping
Column: 152
with procedure relating to claims against
Government vehicles.
Column: 152
NATIONAL SERVICEMEN
(Employment)
5. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for Defence
(a) when the first batch of National Servicemen was
discharged after having served their two-year full-time military service; (b) how many have been
offered employment and where; and (c) how many are
still unemployed.
Mr Lim Kim San: (a) The first batch of National
Servicemen who have served two years of full-time
service were released into the Reserve between mid
August and the end of September
1969.
(b) For reasons of security the actual number of
Servicemen going on to the Reserve cannot be
divulged but of the batch that was so released 90
per cent of the Servicemen have been placed in the
following sectors of employment, namely - the civil
service, statutory boards, the hotel industry,
factories, ship building, construction and the
building trade, printing, transportation, commerce
and security guards.
(c) Of the 10 per cent who have not been placed
in employment a number of them are awaiting the
results of interviews with various prospective
employers or are waiting to appear for more
interviews.
Column: 152
SINGAPORE ARMED FORCES
(Scheme of service)
6. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for Defence (a) whether there is any
scheme of service for the Singapore Armed Forces;
(b) when was such a scheme introduced; (c) whether
the members of the Forces are satisfied with the
scheme; and (d) whether he will table the scheme in
Parliament.
Mr Lim Kim San: (a) and (b) When the Ministry of
the Interior and Defence was established in August
1965, there was only the existing Malaysian Armed
Column: 153
Forces schemes of service to rely upon. The
Treasury and the Director of Audit accepted the
arrangement and since at that juncture an
appreciable number of members of the S.A.F. were
Singaporeans who had been employed in the Forces
during the Malaysian period it was merely a
question of their continuing with their existing
schemes of service.
However, with the introduction of National
Service and the rapid expansion of the S.A.F. the
Malaysian Armed Forces schemes of service have had
to be progressively reviewed and examined to meet
the requirements of our own Armed Forces.
Consideration has had to be given also to the
schemes of service obtaining in the civil service,
the effect that National Service has on the
staffing composition of the S.A.F. and the special
requirements of the S.A.F. Therefore, a new salary
scheme, a new leave scheme, routes of promotion, to
mention a few, have had to be introduced and these
have all been laid down in either MID Orders,
Circulars, Army Board Instructions or subsidiary
legislation made by the Army Board in accordance
with the provisions of the Singapore Army Act,
1965.
(c) There are various categories of officers and
personnel in the MID, namely - regular
commissioned officers and servicemen, short
service commissioned officers, mobilised
officers and mobilised servicemen, officers
seconded from other Government Ministries and Departments; and National Service officers and
servicemen.
In so far as officers in the S.A.F. are
concerned, they are generally satisfied with their
terms and conditions of service. With regard to
Other Ranks, a new pay code is being introduced
presently and though there are problems because of
the limitations of finance, it is hoped that the
majority concerned will benefit. There is close co-ordination between the Ministry and Units in the
field on service conditions and within the funds
available conditions are improved where it is
feasible to do so.
Column: 154
(d) I do not propose tabling the schemes of
service as there is no legal requirement for them
to be tabled. However, honourable Members who may
be interested in the various aspects of the schemes
such as Pay codes, Leave Regulations, Promotions,
etc, could be supplied with the necessary
information on application to me.
Column: 154
CLEANSING WORKERS
(Complaints)
7. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for Health
(a) how many complaints have been received by his
Ministry in respect of cleansing workers not
performing their duties satisfactorily from 1st
January, 1968, up to the latest convenient date;
and (b) what action has, been taken against those
workers.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: From 1st January, 1968 to
31st August, 1969 there were only six complaints
received in respect of cleansing workers not
performing their duties satisfactorily, and this
involved 12 cleansing workers. Disciplinary
action was taken against these cleansing workers
and the punishments imposed were as follows :-
Details of Punishment Imposed Number
(a) Verbal Warning 1
(b) Written Warning 4
(c) Suspension 1
(d) Fine ( 1/2 day's to 3 days' wages) 6
It is to be noted, however, that an Operations
Room was set up at the Ministry of Health in
October last year to receive and expeditiously deal
with the complaints from members of the public in
respect of health nuisances. The public were also
urged to lodge their complaints to this Operations
Room.
From 1st October 1968 to 31st August, 1969, a
total of 2,467 complaints of health nuisances were
thus received. Each and every complaint was
investigated and 556 of them were not
substantiated. Of the remaining 1,911 complaints,
investigations disclosed that
Column: 155
60 complaints had resulted from neglect or
unsatisfactory performance of duty on the part of
98 cleansing workers. Disciplinary action was
therefore taken against them and the punishments
imposed were as follows : -
Details of Punishment Imposed Number
(a) Verbal Warning 15
(b) Written Warning 8
(c) Suspension 4
(d) Fine (1½ day's to 3 days' wages) 69
(e) Dismissal 2
Column: 155
CLEANSING WORKERS
(Recruits)
8. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for Health
(a) how many daily-rated cleansing workers have
been recruited since the "Keep Singapore Clean"
campaign which began last year; (b) whether there
is any need to recruit more workers; and (c)
whether he is satisfied with their performances.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Since the commencement of the
"Keep Singapore Clean" campaign on 1st October,
1968, to 31st August, 1969, an additional 200
daily-rated cleansing workers were recruited into
the service to provide for a full seven days'
cleansing service per week. The actual strength of
the cleansing workers as on 1st September, 1969,
was 4,033. There are 919 vacancies due to
resignations, dismissals, etc., and action is
being taken to fill them. It is considered that
the full complement of 4,952 workers will be
sufficient at the
Column: 156
present time to maintain a reasonable standard of
cleansing services. In 1970-71 it is estimated
that an increase of about 930 labourers' posts
will be required based on additional built-up
areas, new housing estates and streets which will
have to be taken over for service by the Public
Cleansing Branch. In particular, there is a need
to provide a better service in the Jurong
Industrial Estate where at the moment only the
Town Centre is serviced.
The performances of the cleansing workers have
improved considerably since the reorganisation of
the cleansing services in August 1968. This is
evidenced by the increase of the average daily
tonnage of refuse collected from 800 tons to 1,200
tons. They are better
disciplined as a result of better supervision by
supervisory staff who were put through a course of
instruction on leadership and man-management
techniques organised in co-operation with the
Police Academy. Further improvement in the
performance of workers can be expected following
the introduction of a scheme of monetary awards to
be given to those who are hard working and who
contribute towards greater efficiency and
productivity in the services.
Studies of the norms
for labourers were also undertaken by the Public
Cleansing Branch and many of the labourers' beats
are being lengthened. This is possible due to
better disposal of litter and refuse into
receptacles by the public. An increase in
productivity and savings in manpower will result
from this exercise of lengthening the beats.