| Parliament No: | 2 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 29 |
| Sitting No: | 5 |
| Sitting Date: | 23-12-1969 |
|
Column: 233
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
FIRST SESSION OF THE SECOND PARLIAMENT
PART III OF FIRST SESSION |
VOLUME 29 |
Tuesday, 23rd December, 1969
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Mr P. Coomaraswamy).
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang).
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development and Leader of the House.
Inche Buang Bin Omar Junid (Whampoa), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar). Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta).
Mr Eric Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh).
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (MacPherson), Minister for Health.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong).
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister for Finance.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah).
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division).
Column: 234
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu).
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (Kampong Kapor).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah).
Mr Lim Kim San (Cairnhill), Minister for Defence.
Mr Low Guan Onn (River Valley).
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford).
Inche Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Inche Mohd. Ghazali Bin Ismail (Aljunied).
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Education.
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon).
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Communications.
Inche Rahmat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam). Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour.
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Potong Pasir), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (Law Division).
Column: 235
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee).
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang).
Inche Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampong Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour and Government Whip.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Acting Minister for Culture.
Column: 236
Prof. Wong Lin Ken (Alexandra).
Dr Yeoh Ghim Seng (Joo Chiat), Deputy Speaker.
ABSENT:
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Mr Lim Soo Peng (Havelock).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology.
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampong Ubi), Minister of State Prime Minister's Office.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications.
Column: 235
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
FACTORIES SET UP UNDER
INDUSTRIALISATION POLICY
(Particulars)
1. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for Finance
(a) how many factories have been set up under the
Industrialisation Policy up to the latest convenient
date; (b) how much foreign capital is invested; (c)
how much local capital is invested; (d) how many
workers are employed in those factories; (e) how
many of those factories are operating
satisfactorily; and (f) how many of those factories
have closed down or ceased operation and how many
workers became unemployed as a consequence.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim) (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, according to the annual
Column: 236
Census of Industrial Production which covers
establishments employing ten or more workers, there
were 1,555 manufacturing establishments at the end
of 1968, employing 72,200 workers. In 1959, there
were 531 establishments employing 25,600 workers. In
other words, factories and industrial workers nearly
trebled since 1959. This covers the Member's queries
(a) and (d) as appeared in the Order Paper.
As at June 1969, foreign paid-up capital amounted
to $637 million. Of this, $264 million or 42 per
cent came, from local sources, while $373 million
or, 58 per cent came from abroad.
The actual capital investment in fixed assets
exceeds the above and is estimated, at some $780
million. This is much higher than the paid-up
capital, but is made possible because most of the
companies are able to get credit facilities
Column: 237
from various sources, and, besides, in most cases,
land in industrial estates is leased from the
Government, while buildings are either leased or
mortgaged. Such credit availability has enabled
sound enterprises to commence with lower capital
requirements.
The above statistics on capital investments are
based on a quarterly survey conducted by the
Economic Development Board. The survey covers all
pioneer firms in Jurong and non-pioneer firms in the
nine major industrial estates and is not comparable
with the Census of Industrial Production. The above
covers the Member's queries (b) and (c).
With a few exceptions, Singapore factories are
active and operating satisfactorily. Of the pioneer
firms, nine have ceased operation. Their closure
affected roughly 300 workers. These workers were
mostly absorbed by other establishments. This last
bit covers the Member's queries (e) and (f) as
appeared in the Order Paper.
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, is the Parliamentary Secretary
aware that some factories in Jurong have a shortage
of workers, especially technicians and artisans? If
such a situation exists, can the Parliamentary
Secretary inform the House what measures the
Government intends to take to deal with it?
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, while this question should
properly be directed to the Minister for Labour, I
suppose I can just say a few words. There is
evidence recently that there is some shortage of
skilled labour. The Government is taking all
necessary steps to remedy this situation.
Column: 237
UNIFORMED CIVIL SERVANTS
(Change of uniforms)
2. Mr P. Govindaswamy asked the Minister for
Finance whether it is intended to change the
uniforms of the other uniformed civil servants
besides Police and Customs officers.
Mr Tang See Chim (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, uniforms
Column: 238
are issued to civil servants who are required to
wear uniforms for easy recognition or identification
by the public to prevent undue wear and tear to
their own personal clothing, or for reasons of
prestige and ceremony.
In the case of the Police and Customs, uniforms
are provided mainly for purposes of easy recognition
and identification. As they belong to law-enforcing
forces, their uniforms should have the appearance of
smartness and dignity to command better respect, it
is with this object in mind that their uniforms
were changed.
Where a similar need exists, the uniforms of a
particular group of officers will be changed, but
uniforms will not be changed just for the sake of a
change.
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson): Mr Speaker, Sir, may I know which particular
group of officers' uniforms will be changed?
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, as far as I know, no other group
exists which needs a change of uniforms. But if the
Member can make out a case for a change, his
suggestion will be considered and, if found
necessary, the uniform will be changed. But as I
said, the uniform will not be changed just for the
sake of a change.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah): Now that a change of uniform for the police has
been enforced, will the Minister also change the
uniforms of police cadets in schools who are still
using the same old uniforms?
Mr Tang See Chim: There is no plan just now to change the uniforms of
school police cadets.
Column: 238
TAX RELIEFS ON PREMIUMS FOR GROUP MEDICAL
INSURANCE SCHEMES
3. Inche Abdul Aziz Karim asked the Minister for
Finance if he will consider granting tax reliefs on
premiums for group medical insurance schemes which
have been introduced by collective
Column: 239
agreements, in the same manner as reliefs are
allowed on premiums for life insurance policies and
contributions to provident funds.
Mr Tang See Chim (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, premiums for group medical
insurance under most collective agreements are
payable by employers. As such, they are trade or
business expenses and have always been deductible
from income for tax purposes.
There are a few schemes under collective
agreements in which employees may voluntarily
participate and make small payments to cover
themselves and their families for hospitalisation
and surgical benefits. Under the law, medical
expenses of the community at large are not
deductible for income tax purposes and there is no
valid reason to give special relief for
contributions by employees to group medical
insurance schemes.
Such contributions are similar to payments for
personal accident policies, for which no income tax
relief is given, and are not in the same category as
provident funds or life insurance policies which
are, in fact, savings schemes, although the latter
provide for capital sums being payable on death.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang): Does the Parliamentary Secretary not recognise the
fact that if group medical insurance schemes become
popular, it will be a great boon to the Government
in the sense that members of medical insurance
schemes who become hospitalised will generally get
themselves warded in Class I and Class II wards
instead of the virtually free Class III wards?
Mr Tang See Chim: Medical insurance schemes are for the benefit of
the persons taking out these schemes. As a general
rule, there is no income tax relief for accident
schemes and, as I have just said, they are not in
the same category as life insurance schemes which
are, in fact, savings schemes.
Column: 240
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Will the Parliamentary Secretary consider changing
the Income Tax Ordinance so that tax relief can be
granted on premiums paid for medical insurance
schemes?
Mr Tang See Chim: My Ministry has found no valid reason for making
any change to the existing Income Tax Ordinance so
as to give relief to such contributions.
Column: 240
FACTORIES ORDINANCE
(Inclusion of I.L.O, safety regulations)
4. Inche Abdul Aziz Karim asked the Minister for
Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour if he will
consider widening the scope of the provisions in the
Factories Ordinance by including the safety
regulations recommended by the International Labour
Organisation.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour (Mr Sia Kah Hui) (for the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour): Mr Speaker, Sir, the scope of the existing
Factories Ordinance is sufficiently comprehensive
for safeguarding the health and safety of persons
employed in factories. Relevant International Labour
Organisation safety regulations have already been
used by the Factory Inspectorate to guide the
factory occupiers in safety and health practices in
such industries as the iron and steel industry, the
chemical industry, textile mills and industrial
gases manufacturing plants. Further, there is
provision in the Ordinance for the Minister to make
special regulations to uphold higher standards of
safety and health of workers in industry where the
risk of bodily injury is abnormal.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu): It appears to me that there are no adequate safety
regulations in respect of building sites. With the
tendency now for buildings to go higher up, I think
it is high time to look into this particular aspect
of safety regulations. Will the Parliamentary
Secretary please tell the House whether he will look
into this matter?
Column: 241
Mr Sia Kah Hui: Mr Speaker, Sir, in the construction of
factories, all aspects of safety are being looked
into by the various Ministries concerned.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Mr Speaker, Sir, does the Parliamentary Secretary
not recognise that rapid industrialisation has given
rise to a lot of harm and safety problems, making it
imperative to strengthen the provisions of the
Factories Ordinance?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: Sir, as I have indicated just now, the present
Ordinance is adequate to meet the present
requirements. I think the House was told yesterday
by the Minister for Health that the Industrial
Health Unit was going to play a major part on the
whole question of industrial safety.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Does the Parliamentary Secretary not agree that
the appropriate authorities in his Ministry - the
Factory Inspectorate - refer to the I.L.O.
recommendations for guidance?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: It is difficult to hear the Member.
Mr Speaker: The Member's question was whether the
Parliamentary Secretary appreciated that the factory
inspectors, in fact, refer to the I.L.O.
recommendations for guidance.
Mr Sia Kah Hui: The I.L.O. recommendations are being implemented.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: If the I.L.O. recommendations are referred to for
guidance, does the Parliamentary Secretary not agree
that suitable I.L.O. recommendations be made part of
the Factories Ordinance?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: It is not just a simple matter of putting the
recommendations into our present legislation. This
sort of thing will take time. As far as the present
Ordinance is concerned, we feel that it is quite
adequate to meet our present needs. However, I am
sure that when the time comes, steps will be taken
to deal with such matters. I think the next question
of the Member on the Order Paper will deal with
that.
Column: 242
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah): Mr Speaker, Sir, arising out of this question, may
we know how old is the Factories Ordinance?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: I am afraid I have no idea of how old it is,
Mr Ho See Beng: If that is the case, the word "adequate" is not
very appropriate.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Sir, does the Parliamentary Secretary not agree
that the Factory Inspectorate believe that the
Factories Ordinance is inadequate?. He can refer to
the 1968 Annual Report of the Ministry of Labour
under the appropriate section.
Mr Sia Kah Hui: Mr Speaker, Sir,I think the Member is
anticipating the answers to his next question,
because he is now dealing with the next question.
Column: 242
FACTORY INSPECTORATE
(Increase and upgrading of staff)
5. Inche Abdul Aziz Karim asked the Minister for
Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour if he will
consider (i) strengthening the Factory inspectorate
by increasing the numbers of Senior Inspectors and
Inspectors of Factories; (ii) upgrading the posts of
Chief Inspector, Senior Inspector and Inspector of
Factories and (iii) re-organising the Factory
Inspectorate to increase its enforcement capability.
Mr Sia Kah Hui (for the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour): Mr Speaker, Sir, the Factory Inspectorate has
already been strengthened by the creation of two
posts of Inspector of Factories, one in 1968 and
another in 1969. In 1967, the Factory Inspectorate
had only four posts of Inspector of Factories in
addition to the Chief Inspector of Factories and the
Senior Inspector of Factories. The established posts
of Inspector of Factories have now been increased to
six in the I 969-70 Estimates. Although all the
posts of Inspector of Factories have been filled,
two of the officers have been taken into national
service. To make up
Column: 243
for the loss of service of these two Inspectors of
Factories, provision has been made in the 1969-70
Estimates for a supernumerary Inspector of Factories
to be recruited. Attempts are now being made to fill
this post on a temporary basis until the return of
the two Inspectors of Factories from national
service, one in April and the other in September
1970.
The salary scale of Factory Inspectors, including
the Chief Inspector of Factories and Senior
Inspector of Factories who are all qualified
engineers, was revised in July this year to bring it
into line with that of engineers employed in other
departments of Government, such as the Public Works
Department. Since the staff in the department is
limited in number, consisting in all of 18 persons,
Government has not seen fit to upgrade the post of
Chief Inspector of Factories and Senior Inspector of
Factories. If, however, the department is
reorganised, consideration will be given to upgrade
these two posts.
Recognising the importance of industrial safety in
the context of rapid industrialisation, Government
has obtained the services of two International
Executive Service Corps experts to make a study of
industrial safety and health in industrial
establishments. They have completed their reports
and their recommendations are being studied by the
Government with a view to their implementation.
The reorganisation of the Factory Inspectorate to
increase its effectiveness is one of the
recommendations made by the experts. However,
industrial safety and health is not just a problem
of enforcement. Both management and workers at
factory level must themselves ensure that the laws
enacted for the health and safety of workers are
strictly observed.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Mr Speaker, Sir, does the Parliamentary Secretary
not agree that a staff complement of one Chief
Inspector of Factories, one Senior Inspector of
Factories and five Inspectors of Factories
Column: 244
is far from adequate to ensure that the minimum
standards of safety, health and welfare of persons
engaged in factories are observed? When the position
in 1968 is compared to that in 1959 when
industrialisation was first mooted, there was one
Chief Inspector of Factories, an Industrial Training
Officer --
Mr Speaker: Order. Inche Abdul Aziz, what you are saying
sounds more like a speech than a supplementary
question. What is the question?
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Mr Speaker, Sir, does the Parliamentary Secretary
not agree that the position in
1968 is far from favourable or satisfactory as
compared to the position in 1959?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: Mr Speaker, Sir, I think every department would
like to increase its staff, but there is always a
limit. I am sure as time goes on and when the need
is such as to enable us to convince the Minister for
Finance, I am sure more posts could be created.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Does the Parliamentary Secretary not agree that
with rapid industrialisation and increase in the
number of factories and diversity of the kinds of
factories, a total of seven Inspectors of Factories
is far from adequate and satisfactory to cope with
the cases in hand?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: Mr Speaker, Sir, I have already indicated that we
have increased the number of posts in the Factory
Inspectorate and that is as far as we can go just
now.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Mr Speaker, Sir, can the present number of
Inspectors of Factories deal efficiently and
expeditiously with all the cases in hand?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: I do not know whether the Member can indicate an
instance where the Inspectors of Factories were not
available to deal with any case in hand. As far as I
know, there has been no complaint of any negligence
or unsatisfactory performance of their duties. But,
as I said, if we can make
Column: 245
out a strong case that there is really a need for an
increase in the number of Inspectors of Factories, I
am sure the Minister for Finance will give it
sympathetic consideration.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, can the Parliamentary Secretary
say whether he agrees that this is a question of
priority? If there are frequent occurrences of
accidents in factories, I think we should consider
it as a priority question.
Mr Sia Kah Hui: Sir, I fully agree with what the Member for
Sembawang has said.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein): Mr Speaker, Sir, the Parliamentary Secretary to
the Minister for Labour has said that he will
prepare a strong case to the Minister for Finance if
there is such a need. I want to know whether his
Ministry at this juncture think that there is such a
need and whether, in fact, his Ministry is taking
steps to prepare such a case for the consideration
of the Minister for Finance for the provision of
extra personnel for this particular department.
Mr Sia Kah Hui: Sir, I have already indicated in my answer that
the number of posts has already been increased in
the 1969-70 Estimates. I think that is as far as we
can go at this stage.
An hon. Member: Is there a need?
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Mr Speaker, Sir, what assurance can the
Parliamentary Secretary give to the House that
persons of the highest calibre arid qualifications
are engaged as Inspectors of Factories?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: Sir, that is the common practice when recruiting
Government officers.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Sir, what are the qualifications of Inspectors of
Factories?
Mr Speaker: Order. I do not think that is a supplementary question
that properly arises out of the original question.
In any event, the information
Column: 246
asked is easily available in publications of the
Public Service Commission.
Column: 246
NEW POLICE UNIFORM
(Additional expenditure)
6. Mr P. Govindaswamy asked the Minister for
Defence whether and what additional expenditure has
been incurred by the issue of the new uniform to
Police personnel.
The Minister for Defence (Mr Lim Kim San): Mr Speaker, Sir, no additional expenditure was
incurred for the issue of the newly-designed
uniforms to police personnel as these uniforms were
issued in lieu of the old type uniforms. And, in any
case, these uniforms were due for replacement.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like to know what
happened to the old uniforms?
Mr Lim Kim San: The old uniforms were worn out.
Column: 246
ROAD LINKING PUNGGOL ROAD
WITH TAMPINES ROAD
(Construction)
7. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for Law
and National Development whether there are any plans
to, construct a road linking Punggol Road with
Tampines Road; and where the link road will be
constructed.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division) (Mr Ho Cheng Choon) (for the Minister for Law and National Development): Mr Speaker, Sir, the Public Works Department has
looked into several possibilities of constructing a
link road to join Punggol Road with Tampines Road.
Any link road to be constructed would run through
swampy land. Further, a bridge must be built across
Sungei Serangoon. In view of the high cost involved,
there is no immediate economic justification for
such a project.
Column: 247
ELECTRIFICATION OF BUKIT
PANJANG CONSTITUENCY
8. Mr P. Selvadurai asked the Minister for Law and
National Development if he will ascertain from the
Public Utilities Board how long it will be before
the Board completes the electrification of the Bukit
Panjang Constituency.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, the Public Utilities Board
expects to complete the electrification scheme of
Bukit Panjang Constituency by the end of 1972.
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang): Mr Speaker, Sir, can the Minister give the House
some particulars of the schemes that have been
implemented and also the schemes that are under
planning at the moment?
Mr Barker: Since 1963 up to date, about 24 schemes to provide
electricity supplies to about 674 authorised houses
have been completed at a cost of about $457,000.
There are, at present, 11 schemes which have been
approved for implementation to cater for another 427
authorised houses. These will be carried out in
stages and are expected to be completed before mid-1971 at a cost of about $317,000. Survey and
planning of the schemes to provide electricity
supplies for the resettlement of 86 shop-houses at
the l4½ milestone Woodlands Road are under
consideration by the Board. In addition, seven other
schemes are now under active survey and planning in
Bukit Panjang.
Column: 247
MOSQUITO MENACE
(Setting up of inter-departmental Committee)
9. Mr P. Selvadurai asked the Minister for Health
if he will take steps to constitute an inter-departmental committee that will receive from the
public complaints relating to the mosquito menace
and take effective action thereon without the need
to pass the responsibility from one Ministry to
another.
Column: 248
The Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, an Operations Room was set up in
the Ministry of Health on 1st October, 1968, for the
purpose of receiving all complaints relating to
public health, including those on the mosquito
menace, and dealing with them expeditiously. Every
complaint received is investigated, if
substantiated, remedial measures are promptly taken.
Where the matter complained of is the responsibility
of another Ministry, Government department or
statutory board, or where the problem can only be
solved by such other Ministry, Government department
or statutory board, the complaint is immediately
referred to them for necessary action to be taken.
Quite often joint action is taken to deal
satisfactorily with the complaint.
Since the existing arrangement I have described
has worked satisfactorily, I do not think it is
necessary to constitute a special inter-departmental
committee just to deal with mosquito complaints.
Column: 248
INCREASE OF WATER CHARGES
(Statement by the Minister for Finance)
3.00 p.m.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Mr Speaker, Sir, complementary with the
construction of low-cost houses by the Housing and
Development Board has been the expansion of modern
sanitation facilities throughout the Republic. In
1960, 36 per cent of the population was served by
modern sanitation. The percentage now is 55 per
cent. Some $69 million have been spent over the last
nine years in extending sewerage facilities not only
to new industrial and housing estates but also to
outlying areas which hitherto had not been provided
with such facilities.
It is the Government's intention to make modern
sanitation available to every home within economic
reach. We will spend approximately $60 million for
the period 1968-73. To help finance the scheme, the
World Bank has agreed to a loan of $18 million to
meet the foreign exchange component of the sewerage
projects, the first time the World Bank
Column: 249
has given a loan for sewerage development anywhere
in the world.
Up to now, the capital and operational costs of
the Sewerage Department have not been covered by the
revenue collected. To be quite candid, no one knew
what returns we got on expenditure as the sums had
never been worked out. In the course of negotiations
with the World Bank for the loan, the Bank made it
clear that approval of the loan was conditional on
the sewage fees being revised. Further, fees were to
be linked to the volume of water consumed and the
revenue by 1972 was to be adequate to cover
operating expenses plus interest on capital
amortisation. It is a cardinal principle with the
World Bank that investments must pay their way.
In compliance with the conditions set out by the
World Bank, it is necessary to raise the charges for
water. The increases will be as follows:
(i) Domestic users of water will pay an additional
20 cents per thousand gallons of metered water in
addition to a fee of $2 per fitting per month;
(ii) In the case of non-domestic premises, the
charge will be 50 cents per thousand gallons of
metered water;
(iii) In the case of industries utilising water in
their end-products, meters will be fixed to assess
the amount of water used for industrial purposes and
not discharged into sewers.
These fees will be collected by the Public
Utilities Board on behalf of the Government. The
additional payments from domestic premises will vary
between 20 cents and $1 per month for more than 55
per cent of the population, while another 30 per
cent will pay between $1 and $2 per month.
Commercial and industrial premises will also bear a
share of the costs, varying from $2.50 to $15 per
month in the case of coffee-shops, and $15 to $75
per month for the smaller industrial premises.
In order that the increases in utility charges
will not be reflected in poorer households, the
current exemption from the P.U.B. sales tax on
consumers whose bills are below $10 a month will be
extended to those whose bills are below
Column: 250
$12 a month. The five per cent tax payable on bills
between $11 and $20 will now be applicable to bills
between $12 and $25 a month and the ten per cent
rate of tax will in future apply only to bills over
$25. In spite of the increases, the return of
investments in sewerage is expected to be no more
than two per cent on capital invested.
Legislation to give effect to these increased
charges will be introduced at this sitting of
Parliament, and when the Bill is passed early next
year the increases will take effect.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol): Mr Speaker, Sir, I think this is a Christmas
present for the thousands of consumers. I have two
questions, Sir. First, what is the number of
consumers who are making use of the sewage schemes?
Secondly, the Minister for Finance mentioned that
the revenue returns would be only two per cent. In
other words, it is only $1.2 million. Will there be
further increases later on when the Minister will
probably come here with another Ministerial
statement?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, the Member has not been listening with the
attention that the statement deserves. As I said in
my closing remarks, these increases will take effect
next year and therefore he and his friends can spend
their Christmas without undue concern that the water
bills are going up.
As regards the two per cent return, I do not know
how the Member arrived at the figure of a yield of
$1.2 million. When I said a two per cent return on
capital, I meant a two per cent return on the
capital that had been spent in all sewerage works in
the past. The Member will agree that this is a very
low return on capital investment. For instance, if
you were to invest money in business, you would
expect a return of at least 20 per cent; but this
being a public utility, Government had to settle for
a very low rate of return indeed. Of course, I agree
with the Member that this is most unfortunate, but
let us reflect on the good fortune in the past when
these people were getting subsidised services. In
the past, as I have said, there was no
Column: 251
accounting on this score, and what happened was that
the general tax revenue had gone into meeting the
losses sustained by running the sewerage system.
With these new charges, the Sewerage Department
should at least no longer be in the red.
Whether there would be further increases or not,
no one can say. It all depends on a number of things
which it is not possible to predict now. For
instance, if wages and costs go up, then naturally
the charges will also have to go up.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, the figure of $1.2 million was
arrived at as a result of the $60 million loan,
apart from the other capital investment involved.
Just now the Finance Minister mentioned that the
Sewerage Department had been running at a loss. I
would be grateful if he could inform the House of
the amount of losses up to date.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Mr Speaker, Sir, as I said in my statement, no
one knew what the losses were because no one did the
sums. But the Member for Punggol will recollect that
the Sewerage Department was at one time a department
of the former City Council. When the City Council
hived off into different departments with the main
utilities department forming the Public Utilities
Board, the treasurer then knew what the position was
and passed on the Sewerage Department to the
Government. He was under no illusion that this was a
losing proposition. So Government had to carry this
baby, and this was carried, as I said, out of the
general tax revenue until we applied for the World
Bank loan. The World Bank did the calculations and
said that this loss has now got to be made good.
Mr Ho See Beng: Sir, is it correct to say that it is a loss
because it is a service to the public and not a
trade?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Yes, it is a loss in the sense that those receiving
the services did not pay for the cost. It is like
people riding on the Singapore
Column: 252
Traction Company's buses and the company is losing
money - in the same way that the Sewerage Department
is losing money.
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (Kampong Kapor): Mr Speaker, Sir, may I ask the Finance Minister
this: if the Sewerage Department is losing money,
would it not be more equitable to raise the sewage
fee rather than the rate of water consumed, because
the people who do not now enjoy the use of the
sewage system will be asked to pay for something
which they are not receiving?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: That is one way of charging people, in proportion
to the user of the facilities. It is quite a
technical subject and this matter has been gone into
in great detail by officials of my Ministry and the
Public Works Department. The calculations were
checked by a mission sent by the World Bank, and
they came to the conclusion that a combination of
fees per fitting plus the consumption of water is
the best and most equitable method of charging for
this service.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Finance Minister mentioned
that a loan of $60 million will be coming from the
World Bank to enable us to extend our sewage
facilities in the next five years. Can he inform the
House whether the entire Republic will have such
facilities, bearing in mind, of course, the increase
in water rates?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: The sum of $60 million is the total expenditure
from 1968 to 1973. The World Bank will finance only
a part of this expenditure, that is, the foreign
exchange component, the money used on imported
material, and this comes to only a proportion of
this amount.
Whether the whole population will receive this
facility by 1973 I doubt it.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, will the Finance Minister not
agree that to charge the increase in water rates to
those who lack such sewage facilities is unfair?
Column: 253
Mr Speaker: Order. Are you repeating Mr Lim Cheng Lock's
question in different terms?
Mr Ng Kah Ting: It is somewhat different from the question asked
by the Member for Kampong Kapor. The Member's
question was about the increase of sewage fee. My
question is: will the increase not be unfair to those
consumers who make use of water only?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: I do not follow the Member's question.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: The Minister has already informed the House that
water rates will be increased after the New Year.
Whether it be a Christmas present or a New Year
present makes no difference. My question is this:
will he not consider it unfair to those consumers
who lack the sewage facilities and yet have to pay
more for the water consumed?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Mr Speaker, Sir, I suppose in a sense it is
unfair. But, on the other hand, let us not forget
that these are homes in rather remote areas, and
possibly if we were to apply the principle of
charging every one the cost of the services, it may
well be that houses in such remote areas would have
to pay more for their water anyway because it is
more costly to lay the mains to these areas. In
these matters, of course, one tries to apply a rough
and ready rule whereby everybody makes his
contribution to the services.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, if it is a case of rates which the Finance
Minister mentioned just now in respect of no tax on
consumers whose bills are now below $10 a month,
will he then increase them to, say, $15 and $30
instead of coming to a happy compromise at $12 and
$25?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Yes, this is exactly what has happened. The
exemption rates have been raised so that this
additional charge will not bring in new consumers to
pay the sales tax. In fact, there will be a
reduction in the tax on Public Utilities Board
bills. So the limits
Column: 254
which have been proposed are more than generous.
Mr Ho See Beng: Sir, in view of the Minister's statement that
there is a possibility that the cost of water will
be increased, has Government explored the
possibility of installing machinery to desalt sea
water?
Mr Speaker: Desalination is far from sewerage. Mr Ho, I do
not see how your question can arise out of the
Ministerial statement.
Mr Ho See Beng: Sir, I think the Minister did say that there is a
possibility that the cost of water would have to be
increased. So if we could introduce desalination,
water might be cheap.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, I only mentioned the
possibility of further increases in charges because
I was asked to commit myself to the position that
there would never be any increases in charges. Of
course, I cannot give any undertaking of that kind.
I have also linked the possibility of increases in
water charges with the possibility of increases in
wages. So if the Member applies himself diligently
in the trade union field to the task of maintaining
wage stability, then he will ensure that there will
be less chances of increases in water charges.
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: Sir, for several years I have been a member of the
Public Accounts Committee which drew attention to
the appalling state of affairs in the financial
administration of the Sewerage Department. Can we
have the assurance of the Finance Minister and also
of the Minister for National Development that they
will seriously look into the financial
administration of the Sewerage Department and will
take corrective measures on the financial side of
the department?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Yes, Sir.
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford): Mr Speaker, Sir, before the whole project of
sewerage development is undertaken, has the Ministry
ever explored
Column: 255
the possibility of allowing it to be handled by
private enterprise? It might be more economical.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, that novel proposition has never entered my
head.
Column: 255
BILLS INTRODUCED
3.20 p.m
BILLS OF EXCHANGE
(AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Bills of Exchange Ordinance, 1949,
of the Federation of Malaya (No. 75 of 1949)",
presented for the Minister for Finance by his Parliamentary Secretary (Mr Tang See Chim); read
the First time, to be read a Second time on the next
available sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 255
CONTROL OF MANUFACTURE
(AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Control of Manufacture Ordinance,
1959 (No. 14 of 1959)".
recommendation of President signified (Mr Barker);
presented for the Minister for Finance by Mr Tang See Chim; read the First time, to be read a Second
time on the next available sitting of Parliament,
and to be printed.
Column: 255
PENSIONS (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Pensions Ordinance, 1956 (No. 22 of
1956)",
recommendation of President signified (Mr Barker);
presented for the Minister for Finance by Mr Tang See Chim; read the First time, to be read a Second
time on the next available sitting of Parliament,
and to be printed.
Column: 255
TOURIST PROMOTION BOARD
(AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Tourist Promotion Board Ordinance,
1963 (No. 35 of 1963)",
Column: 256
recommendation of President signified (Mr Barker);
presented for the Minister for Finance by Mr Tang See Chim; read the First time, to be read a Second
time on the next available sitting of Parliament,
and to be printed.
Column: 256
LOCAL GOVERNMENT INTEGRATION (AMENDMENT) BILL
First Reading
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to introduce a Bill
intituled "An Act to amend the Local Government
Integration Ordinance, 1963 (No. 18 of 1963)".
This is the Bill referred to by the Minister for
Finance in his Ministerial statement just now.
Bill read the First time.
Second Reading
Mr Speaker: Second Reading, what day?
Mr Barker: The next available sitting of Parliament, Sir.
Column: 256
CUSTOMS (DUMPING AND SUBSIDIES) (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.24 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
This is a very short amendment Bill, the aim of
which is to simplify the procedures for invoking the
law against dumping of imported goods in Singapore.
The Customs (Dumping and Subsidies) Ordinance,
1962, which first came into force on 16th April,
1962, provides the legislative framework against
the dumping of imported goods in Singapore and for
safeguarding locally-made goods
Column: 257
from unfair competition posed by imported goods
which have been subsidised by their countries of
origin.
Under the Ordinance, the powers to invoke the law
and impose duties rest with the President of the
Republic. These powers have so far been invoked only
once, and it was found that the procedures for
invoking these powers were rather cumbersome. This
amendment Bill, therefore, seeks to adopt a less
cumbersome procedure, by transferring the powers
from the President to the Minister, to enable the
Minister to impose duties by publishing an order in
the Gazette and presenting it to Parliament. This
procedure is in line with other revenue legislation
and is aimed at facilitating the imposition of
duties and preventing any delays. Speedy action in
cases of this nature is necessary to protect the
interests of our local industries and of our honest
trading partners, and to penalise those who are
engaged in unfair competition by dumping imported
goods in Singapore or who have the benefits of
subsidies from foreign countries.
The transfer of powers from the President to the
Minister is to be effected by clause 4 of the Bill.
Clause 2 provides for such powers to be exercised by
the Minister by publishing an order in the Gazette
and presenting it to Parliament.
Clause 3 seeks to amend section 14 of the
principal Ordinance to make it mandatory for all
regulations made under the Ordinance to be published
in the Gazette and presented to Parliament as soon
as possible after publication.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 258
JUDGES' REMUNERATION
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.30 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
The Salaries Commission recommended that the
salaries of Puisne Judges should be considered in
relation to the salaries of the civil service in
Singapore and that the former relationship between
the salaries of the Judges and the Permanent
Secretaries should be restored.
The Commission also suggested that if the
recommendation regarding the salaries of Puisne
Judges is accepted, then the emoluments of, inter
alia, the Chief Justice should also be reviewed.
With the introduction of Superscale 'B' (all-in
salary of $2,700 a month) and Superscale 'A' (all-in
$3,000 a month) for Permanent Secretaries on a
personal-to-holder basis, it was decided that a
comparable revision of the salaries of the Chief
Justice and Puisne Judges be effected.
Accordingly, the salary of the Chief Justice has
been revised from $2,570 a month (basic) to $3,500 a
month (consolidated) and for the Puisne Judges from
$2,100 a month (basic) to $2,700 a month
(consolidated). This revision was effected
retrospectively from 1st January, 1969,
administratively.
To give legal effect to this revision, it is
necessary for the Judges' Remuneration Act, 1963, of
Malaysia to be amended. This Bill seeks to do just
that.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
Column: 259
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.- [Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 259
FINANCE COMPANIES
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.35 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
The Finance Companies Act, 1967, was passed by
Parliament on 21st December, 1967, and was brought
into operation on 10th January, 1968. The purpose of
the Act is to safeguard the interests of the public
who deposit funds with finance companies. Since the
coming into operation of the Act, companies
transacting financing business have been licensed
and their operations subject to the supervision and
control of the Commissioner for Finance Companies.
Members will recollect that during the Second
Reading of the Finance Companies Bill in Parliament
in December 1967, the Minister for Finance explained
that it was necessary to pass the Bill without
reference to Select Committee, so that proper
control could be established immediately to check
the future proliferation of finance companies.
However, the Minister for Finance also indicated
that every consideration would be given to
representations from finance companies and, if
necessary, amending legislation could later be
proposed.
Since the coming into operation of the Act, the
Finance Ministry has received representations from
the Association of Finance Companies, the Finance
House Association of Singapore
Column: 260
and the Singapore Chinese Chamber of Commerce
on certain provisions of the Act. After
consideration of the views expressed and in the
light of the experiences gained in the last two
years or so in regulating and controlling the
operations of the finance companies, it was felt
that a comprehensive review of the Act need be
carried out.
An Advisory Committee was then formed for this
purpose. This Committee was chaired by the
Commissioner for Finance Companies and included
representatives from the two finance associations
and the Chinese Chamber of Commerce as well as
consultants from the International Monetary Fund. It
considered various memoranda and proposals submitted
to it and held discussions and consultations with
the Solicitor-General, the Registrar of Companies
and other Government departments concerned with the
working of the Act.
As a result of its deliberations, it recommended
certain amendments to the Act which are incorporated
in the amendment Bill now before the House.
The Bill seeks to amend the Finance Companies Act,
1967, by introducing a number of unrelated
amendments designed, in the main, to alleviate or
relax the strictness of certain provisions in their
application to the business activities of finance
companies. In the task of protecting depositors'
funds, it must be conceded that the profitability of
finance companies should not be unduly crippled by
the too restrictive provisions. The more important
amendments are as follows.
Clause 2 amends section 2 of the Act on the
definition of "financing business". This amendment
extends the definition of "financing business" to
include hire-purchase companies which accept
deposits from the public. As now defined in the Act,
"financing business" means, in summary, the carrying
on of the dual function of borrowing money from, and
lending money to, the public, but as hire-purchase
financing by legal definition is
Column: 261
not lending of money, these hire-purchase companies
have so far not been brought within the ambit of the
Act. Since it is the aim of the Act to protect
depositors' funds, those companies which engage in
hire-purchase financing, but do not accept deposits
from the public, will still not be subject to the
provisions of the Act.
[Mr Deputy Speaker in the Chair]
3.40 p.m.
Clause 4 adds a new section - section 3A - to the
principal Act. This new section restricts the use of
the term "finance company" or any of its derivatives
indicating that a company transacts financing
business. Henceforth, the use of the words "finance
company" will be confined to only finance companies
licensed under this Act in the same manner as the
word "bank" is restricted to companies doing banking
business. This is to avoid confusion and provide the
means to the members of the public to distinguish a
company which is licensed to carry on financing
business from the great number of companies which
are not so licensed, but whose business is akin to
that of "financing business".
Clause 7 repeals section 12 of the principal Act
and substitutes therefor a new section. The existing
law provides that every finance company shall
maintain a reserve fund and, before any dividend is
declared, it shall annually transfer a certain
percentage of net profits to reserve to strengthen
the company. This restriction on payment of dividend
to shareholders will now be relaxed, so that
adequate profits may be left over for distribution
to the shareholders to encourage equity
participation in finance companies. On the other
hand, it is felt that smaller finance companies
should be encouraged to grow faster by building up
their reserves at the higher rates.
The amendment, therefore, provides for different
amounts to be transferred to reserve fund according
to the paid-up capital of the finance companies.
For
Column: 262
this purpose, licensed finance companies are divided
into two categories:
(a) companies whose paid-up capital and reserves
are $2 million and above each - these are required
to transfer to reserve fund at the lower rates;
(b) companies whose paid-up capital and reserves
are less than $2 million each - these are required
to transfer to reserve fund at higher rates.
Clause 10 amends section 17 and relaxes the
restriction on unsecured loans by raising the limit
for each unsecured loan from $1,000 at present to
$5,000 so as to enable the finance company to have a
certain amount of "clean" lending to those who are
considered credit-worthy, but the aggregate of all
unsecured loans should not exceed 10 per cent of the
finance company's paid-up capital and reserves.
A new provision has been added imposing a ceiling
on secured loans to any single borrower to not
exceeding 60 per cent of the paid-up capital and
reserves of the finance company, but, with the
approval of the Commissioner, this limit of 60 per
cent may be raised to 100 per cent of the paid-up
capital and reserves. The introduction of this limit
is to spread the risk of lending of the finance
company, so that "all the eggs would not be put in
one basket", so to speak, which may endanger the
interests of depositors.
A finance company is prohibited from investing
more than 25 per cent of its paid-up capital and
reserves in any other undertakings. Clause 12 raises
this limit to 50 per cent, provided the approval of
the Commissioner is obtained. This serves to improve
the capacity of finance companies as institutional
investors or, alternatively, it will enable finance
companies to participate in equities aimed at
economic development.
The present law provides that no finance company
is permitted to acquire any immovable property
except for the purpose of conducting financing
business. While it is recognised that channelling
too large a proportion of depositors' funds to
acquire immovable
Column: 263
properties may be of adverse interest to the
depositors, nonetheless the finance companies should
not be totally prevented from direct investment in
immovable properties which offer an assured and
growing income and become increasingly popular.
Clause 13, therefore, removes this restriction and
allows a finance company to acquire immovable
properties up to 25 per cent of its paid-up capital
and reserves, and such other additional property as
may be approved by the Commissioner.
Apart from the foregoing, the scope of the Act has
been narrowed so that it will not apply to licensed
pawnbrokers whose business is already subject to the
control of the Pawnbrokers Ordinance. Conversely,
licensed finance companies will be specifically
exempted from the operation of the Moneylenders
Ordinance.
Provisions are also incorporated to empower the
Commissioner to compound offences and make
regulations to control advertisements by finance
companies. Other amendments are concerned with the
inspection and investigation of finance companies or
are mainly intended to improve the administration of
the Act.
It is not unlikely that some finance companies
will still express dissatisfaction over some of the
provisions of the law in spite of the fact that they
will have been relaxed. But certain minimum
standards and norms must be observed. It is believed
that this amendment Bill strikes the happy medium
between the interests of shareholders in maximising
profits and the protection of the depositors' funds.
It is hoped that this Bill will further achieve the
purpose for which the Act is intended, i.e., the
protection of the depositors as well as the orderly
expansion of finance companies.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
Column: 264
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.- [Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment: read a Third time and passed.
Column: 264
RUBBER ASSOCIATION OF
SINGAPORE (INCORPORATION) (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.50 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Deputy Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
Subsection (2) of section 3 of the Rubber
Association of Singapore (Incorporation) Act, 1967,
provides for a common seal of the Association.
Subsection (4) of section 3 of that Act provides for
the use of this seal, in that the seal can be
affixed only pursuant to a resolution by the
Committee and in the presence of, and witnessed by,
the Chairman or Deputy Chairman or any member of the
Management Committee and by the Secretary.
At present, the Rubber Association of Singapore
issues Certificates of Origin to rubber exporters to
facilitate shipments of rubber to European and
American countries. Though there is no statutory
requirement that a Certificate of Origin must be
sealed to be valid, it is an accepted commercial
practice to seal such certificates. All Certificates
of Origin issued by the Trade Division of the
Ministry of Finance, for example, are sealed by the
Government seal. In the case of Certificates of
Origin issued by the Rubber Association of
Singapore, certain European countries like Spain,
Portugal, Italy and Greece have refused to accept
these Certificates of Origin unless they are sealed,
and such refusal would affect our export of rubber
to those countries.
The present procedure for the endorsement of the
common seal on Certificates of Origin issued by the
Column: 265
Association is extremely cumbersome. Quite apart
from the requirement of a resolution, it is also not
convenient for all endorsements to be carried out in
the presence of a member of the Committee, whether
he be the Chairman or Deputy Chairman or an
ordinary Committee member. This is because members
of the Association and the Association's Secretary
do not share the same premises. As such, the
endorsement of the seal has to be done at a
Committee member's office in the presence of both
the member and the Secretary, and the Committee
member's office may be far away from the
Secretariat. Rubber exporters have complained that
such procedures have caused unnecessary delay in the
endorsement of urgently required Certificates,
resulting in delay in the shipment of rubber.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
3.54 p.m.
This Bill, therefore, seeks to simplify the
procedure for the affixing of the Association's
common seal on Certificates of Origin. It seeks to
do away with the requirement of a resolution and
allows the seal to be affixed in the presence of the
Secretary and any other person so authorised by the
Committee. This simplified procedure applies to
Certificates of Origin only and does not apply to
any other document.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 265
INCOME TAX (AMENDMENT)
BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.56 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Speaker,
Column: 266
Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
This Bill makes a number of important amendments
to the Income Tax Ordinance. The amendments range
from exemption from income tax on interest accruing
to non-residents and on shipping profits, to
simplifying the commencement and cessation
provisions of the Act.
For the benefit of Members, I shall go through the
Bill clause by clause.
Clause 1 provides for the Act to come into
operation from 1st January, 1970.
Clause 2 is to permit the Comptroller to give
information to the Manager of the Central Provident
Fund Board, where such information is required by
the latter for the performance of his duties. Under
the existing provisions, this is not permissible.
Clause 3 provides for complete exemption from
income tax on interest from deposits in approved
banks derived in Singapore by non-residents. Members
will recall that in 1967, the rate of tax was
reduced from 40 per cent to 10 per cent on interest
earned by non-resident depositors in approved banks.
The amendment also provides for exemption from tax,
of interest derived on or after 1st January, 1968,
by all persons, resident or non-resident, from
deposits in the Post Office Savings Bank. These
exemptions are designed to make banks in Singapore
even more attractive as depositories for surplus
funds from outside Singapore and also to encourage
people to cultivate the saving habit with the Post
Office Savings Bank.
As the law now stands, any income remitted from
outside Singapore to a Singapore resident is subject
to tax in Singapore. Provision is also being made
for the Minister to exempt from tax income remitted
from abroad and received by a person resident in
Singapore where relief is not provided under double
taxation agreements. This will allow flexibility, so
that in cases where the Minister considers it
desirable, income received in Singapore from
Column: 267
specified overseas investments may be exempted from
tax.
When the Merchant Shipping (Amendment) Act, 1968,
was before the House last year, it was announced
that exemption from income tax would be granted to
Singapore-registered ships. Clause 4 is in
accordance with that statement and the amendment
seeks to exempt from tax income derived from 1st
January, 1969, from the operation of Singapore-registered ships. This exemption will apply whether
a ship belongs to a Singapore owner or an owner
resident outside Singapore and is designed to
encourage the registration of ships under The
Singapore flag, thereby creating employment
opportunities for our citizens. The response from
maritime circles has already been encouraging.
Clause 5 provides for the repeal of the provisions
allowing double deductions for market development
expenditure. As the Economic Incentives Act is
comprehensive, covering a wide range of incentives,
double deductions for market development are no
longer necessary.
Clause 6 alters the existing commencement and
cessation provisions which have often perplexed a
number of taxpayers in the first one or two years of
assessment. Under the existing provisions, while for
the first year of the three-year commencement
period, the income for tax purposes is the amount of
income in that calendar year, in the second tax
year, the income is computed by reference to the
income for one year from the date of commencement,
resulting in the income for the first twelve months
being used as the basis for assessing tax liability
in the first two years. The taxpayer, however, gets
the benefit of the cessation provision by which in
the year during which he ceases receiving income,
his tax is not based on the full earnings during the
preceding year, but on his actual earnings in the
year of cessation. In addition, the income from one
of
Column: 268
the two preceding years is relieved from tax.
However, this is not generally appreciated and there
is a general misconception that when a person
commences employment he is taxed twice.
Under the proposed amendment, the income assessed
for any year of assessment shall always be that
earned in the preceding year, e.g., a person
commencing employment in 1970 will only be liable
for tax in 1971 based on his 1970 income. This will
allow for a straightforward computation of tax
liability and, at the same time, curb manipulations
resulting in loss of revenue by artificial
commencements and cessations.
All in all, the proposed amendment, by which in
each year a person is liable for tax based on his
actual income in the preceding year, is simpler and
more easily understood.
Transitional provisions have been made, so that
those who have been liable to tax under the
commencement provisions will still have the benefit
of the old cessation provisions. All taxpayers who
commence their trade, business or employment after
1st January, 1969, will be assessed under the new
preceding-year basis. Those who have already paid
tax in 1969 and who commenced employment or trade in
1969 will be subject to tax in 1970 but the tax paid
in 1969 will be credited against their 1970 tax
liability.
Clause 7 is a consequential amendment arising from
the repeal of the old commencement and cessation
provisions.
Clause 8 is aimed at restricting the carry-forward
of losses to such cases where the beneficial
shareholders to whom the carry-forward of losses is
to be allowed are substantially the same as those in
the company which incurred the losses. This is to
prevent abuses resulting from the purchase by
unrelated persons of companies which have
substantial losses in order to derive tax benefits.
Clause 9 repeals the existing law which provides
for tax at the rate of 10 per cent on interest
received by non-residents from deposits in approved
Column: 269
banks, as the new provisions in clause 3 allow
complete exemption.
Clause 10 deals with the manner in which interest
from tax-free bonds and stocks is dealt with for tax
purposes, where the recipients are banks and
financial institutions. Since such organisations
receive the interest as trading receipts and are
allowed to deduct, as expenses, the cost incurred in
the garnering of funds, etc., the credit allowed is
one-half of the tax on the income from interest
which is brought to charge for tax purposes.
Clauses 11 and 13 are provisions which require the
remaining partners in a partnership to keep the
Comptroller informed where any partner is leaving
the partnership or leaving the country. The
remaining partners are made liable for the tax
payable by any person who ceases to be a partner
where moneys have been paid to an outgoing partner
without the written permission of the Comptroller.
This is to tighten up on possible avenues for tax
evasion.
Clause 12 allows the Comptroller to raise advance
assessments where a person's source of income ceases
or when he is about to leave the country. This is a
procedural amendment which is necessary to prevent
tax losses, taking into account the repeal of the
old cessation provisions and the introduction of the
strict preceding-year basis of assessment.
Clause 14 is to permit the Comptroller to withhold
the refund of any tax collected until the matter has
been finally determined in the Courts of law with
provision for interest to be paid on the amount so
withheld. This would safeguard revenue and prevent
taxpayers from being able to obtain refund of tax
which the Comptroller may not be able to recover
when the case is finally decided in favour of the
Government.
Clause 15 lists the stocks and bonds which are tax-free at the date of publication of the Bill.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Column: 270
4.05 p.m.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin: Mr Speaker, Sir, it, is interesting to note the
number of items on today's Order Paper which are of
direct relevance to the commercial sector. All of
these items, particularly the important Bill
currently before us, when implemented, will have the
effect of helping to rationalise and liberalise
certain vital aspects of our commercial activities.
It illustrates to my mind very clearly that in
emphasising the importance of industrialisation, the
Government has not overlooked the need to assist
constantly in raising the standard of our
traditional commercial activities in order to keep
pace with changes and to maintain our position as a
leading international business centre.
The Bill before us is an excellent example of what
the Government can do to provide the private sector
with wider scope of operation. I have in mind
clauses 3 and 4.
Clause 3 concerns the banking industry and I hope
that with the official encouragement now provided,
our banks will proceed to attract more money from
abroad to be deposited in Singapore and, perhaps in
time, we shall rival Switzerland in this particular
area of international banking service. In this
regard, we have two very salient points, namely, our
strong currency system and political stability.
Clause 4 concerns the shipping industry and is
part and parcel of the incentives promised by the
Minister for Communications to encourage a greater
number of merchant ships to fly our flag. Since the
official announcement of the Government's intention
to introduce such facilities, I understand that
considerable interest has been aroused the world
over and there have been many inquiries from abroad.
I feel sure that with the passing into law of this
particular amendment to the Income Tax Ordinance,
and a host of other advantages which are already in
existence, such as the strategic position of our
port, the highly developed port facilities, and
facilities for ship-repairing and maintenance, we
shall soon see an influx of applications for the
registration of
Column: 271
sea-going vessels in Singapore, resulting in
expanded employment opportunities for our young
people who may be interested in seafaring as a
career.
Sir, the Minister for Finance has time and again
demonstrated that, be it in the industrial sector or
the commercial sector, he is always prepared and
willing, within reason, to offer incentives in the
form of tax concessions to encourage development or
expansion which will be of ultimate benefit to the
country. But the success or failure of such
incentives to achieve the desired effect depends
largely upon the initiative, ingenuity and
determination that can be exercised by those
concerned in the private sector.
Sir, I support the Bill.
4.10 p.m.
Mr Ho See Beng: Mr Speaker, Sir, I rise to support the amendments
proposed in the Income Tax (Amendment) Bill. I am
only surprised that this amendment Bill was not
introduced earlier. To take one example, the
commencement and cessation provisions of the Income
Tax Ordinance, which are as confusing as modern
abstract paintings, have led to confusion amongst
laymen.
A wage-earner cannot understand why if he commences
employment in December in any year he has to pay
income tax for two years in January of the next
year. He has hardly worked for more than a month and
has only been paid one month's wages, yet he is
liable to pay income tax for the first year on the
month of December, and for the second year of
assessment, from December of the first year to
November of the next year. I therefore welcome this
amendment Bill and note with even greater
satisfaction that those of us who have already been
hit, like myself, by double taxation when we
commenced employment will be given a reduction in
income tax when we cease employment.
Sir, I understand that many big business companies
have taken advantage of
Column: 272
the commencement and cessation provisions to avoid
paying income tax. This has been going on for
several years and the Government has, as a result,
lost several million dollars. May I inquire whether
action can be taken to recoup these losses?
4.12 p.m.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like to congratulate the
Parliamentary Secretary on introducing this Bill
which is a fair and progressive measure. It clearly
shows that we have a very healthy economic policy.
Before the amendments were introduced, the Income
Tax Ordinance was rather confusing but now it is
more reasonable. Income tax will now be based on the
income derived in the preceding year, and the tax to
be paid next year will be based on the income
derived this year. I believe that all taxpayers will
be satisfied with this arrangement.
Sir, where does this fair and equitable taxation
policy come from? We know that our Government
practises democratic socialism. We often need to
emphasise that it is our noble aim to build a more
fair and more equitable society. In order to achieve
this aim, we must lay down a fair and reasonable
taxation policy. We must specify that the rich will
bear a greater part of the tax burden and the poor
will be exempted from income tax. It is only through
this progressive policy that we can realise an
egalitarian society.
We know that a healthy and progressive taxation
policy will promote the development of our economy
and improve the prosperity of the country. For
example, the Bill provides that ships registered in
our country as well as deposits which are put in our
banks by foreigners will be exempted from income
tax. I think this will encourage more foreign
capital to be invested in our country. Once we have
got hold of these investments they will be used to
finance the various activities of our commerce and
industry. This will also encourage
Column: 273
more ships to be registered in our country. In this
way, our economy will improve and more employment
opportunities will be created. Therefore, we must
maintain a progressive economic policy.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the amendment Bill mainly looks
after the interests of the rich and big enterprises.
Naturally I support this Bill because it is
beneficial to our economy. But I would like to take
this opportunity to remind the Minister that he must
also look after the interests of the working class.
For example, we should reduce the property tax rates
on Housing Board flats in order to reduce their
burden. All in all, this amendment Bill is a
progressive and equitable measure. I support it.
4.15 p.m.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, this Bill makes several important
and desirable amendments to our Income Tax
Ordinance. Like the Member for Bras Basah, I am also
surprised that these amendments were not thought of
very much earlier.
For example, tax exemption is to be given in
respect of interest derived in Singapore by a non-resident individual. This will encourage him to
leave his money here instead of taking it out of
Singapore for investment abroad. I am also glad to
know that such exemption is to be back-dated to 20th
August, 1968.
I am also glad to see that the Minister will be
given the power to exempt from tax any income
received in Singapore from sources outside
Singapore. But there is a proviso which specifies
that this outside source must come from a country
with which there is no arrangement for the avoidance
of double taxation. I would be interested to know
how many and which are the countries that Singapore
has made arrangements with for the avoidance of
double taxation.
I understand we have such an arrangement with
Australia. Mr Speaker, Sir, we are getting closer
and closer to Australia in many fields, such as
trade and investment. Any Singaporean who has
considerable assets in Australia will
Column: 274
not bring back to Singapore the income derived from
these assets, because if he does so he has to pay
income tax in Singapore. Hence, he leaves his
assets, whatever they may be, in Australia. What
then is the benefit to Singapore? We should be much
happier if this particular amendment could be
further amended by the deletion of the proviso that
limits the Minister's powers of exemption only to
countries with which Singapore does not have double
taxation agreements.
4.20 p.m.
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I wish to thank those Members who
spoke in support of this Bill. They have all spoken
very well of our economic policies, and I think
Singapore justly deserves to be the financial centre
of this part of the world. The provisions in this
amendment Bill are, in fact, making this possible.
I think two Members complained that certain
provisions, like the provisions for commencement and
cessation, were not introduced earlier. My reply is
that it is better late than never. Anyway, the
present provisions for commencement and cessation
are straightforward and would not lead to
misunderstanding by taxpayers that they are taxed
twice in the year of commencement.
I think the Member for Bras Basah wants an
assurance from me that the present taxpayers who
commenced business or employment before the coming
into force of the Act would get the benefit of the
old cessation provision. Mr Speaker, Sir, I can
give this categorical assurance. In fact, it is
provided in the Bill that those who commenced
business or employment before the coming into force
of this Act would get the benefit when their
business or employment ceases.
The Member for Telok Blangah is labouring under
some misapprehension. The proviso in clause 3
clearly states that the Minister will have the
discretion to exempt from tax income from countries
with which we have no double taxation agreement. But
where there is a double taxation agreement,
provision
Column: 275
is made normally for the exemption of tax on income
when it is remitted back to Singapore, because
income is normally taxed at the place where it is
earned. The whole idea of double taxation agreements
is that they will not be taxed twice. For example,
if profits are earned in Australia, the Australian
Government will have the primary right to tax the
profits. Normally, without double taxation
agreements, when the profits are remitted back to
Singapore, the Singapore Government will also
exercise the right to tax such profits. However,
under a double taxation agreement with, say,
Australia, it is normally provided that once the
profits are taxed in Australia, they are not taxed
again when they are remitted back to Singapore. The
proviso in clause 3, however, gives the Minister the
discretion to exempt profits from tax where such
profits derived from countries with which Singapore
has no double taxation agreement are remitted back
to Singapore. That is the position.
With regard to the remark made by the Member for
Sembawang that the provisions of this Bill are only
for the rich. I say that it is not true. If he will
remember that an ordinary wage-earner, who has a
wife and two children and earning less than $500 a
month is not subject to tax, he will not make such a
complaint; he will realise that the P.A.P.
Government is a socialist one and does not tax
workers with a small income.
The Member also touched on the question of
property tax. I am very happy to announce in this
House that the Government has decided to reduce
property tax for all owner-occupiers of Housing
Board flats to the uniform rate of 23 per cent of
the annual value. This again is another
manifestation of the Government's policy to
encourage people to own their own homes and to
create a stable and prosperous society.
Question put, and agreed to.
Column: 276
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.- [Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Mr Speaker: Order. I will suspend the sitting of the House and
take the Chair again at 5 o'clock.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
4.30 p.m. until 5.00 p.m.
Column: 276
Sitting resumed at 5.00 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
ADJOURNMENT MOTION
(Business Motion)
Resolved,
"That at this day's sitting, Parliament do adjourn
at 6.00 p.m."-[Mr Barker].
Column: 276
CONSTITUTION
(AMENDMENT) BILL
(As reported from Select Committee)
Order for Third Reading read.
5.02 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, when this Bill was introduced in
the House, I explained that it would amend the
Constitution in two respects. First, it would set
out a new Part relating solely to the Judiciary.
Second, it would set up the Presidential Council
whose creation was recommended by the Constitutional
Commission on minority rights.
Six written representations were received by the
Select Committee and accepted as being relevant.
These are annexed to the Committee's Report as
Column: 277
Appendix II. Members will note that these
representations were made only in respect of the
second part of the Bill, namely, the Presidential
Council. Oral evidence was heard by the Committee in
respect of one representation.
No major amendments have been recommended by the
Select Committee. In respect of the first part,
Article 52D has been redrafted because it was
thought that the requirement that one must be a
citizen before he can be appointed a Judge of the
High Court may exclude otherwise suitable
candidates. The other change is the insertion of
clause (10) to Article 52F wherein it is provided
that the President may, in his discretion, grant
leave to the Chief Justice and the other Judges of
the High Court.
The second part of the Bill sets out more radical
provisions and only one minor amendment thereto has
been recommended -- a purely drafting amendment to
Article 81M (5).
Members will recall that the Constitutional
Commission on minority rights had recommended the
creation of the Presidential Council and that
Government had accepted this recommendation. The
main function of this Council would be to offer such
assistance by way of counsel and advice upon
legislation, including subsidiary legislation, that
might have provisions which conflict with
fundamental rights and liberties of minority
interests in the State. It is hoped, as well, that
the Council would provide the Government or
Parliament with such advice as may be sought from
it, on any matter relating to the safeguarding of
rights or liberties belonging to certain sections of
our community, whether they relate to racial,
religious or other matters. While recognising its
usefulness, the Government has also provided such
measures in the Bill as to ensure the legislative
supremacy of Parliament. We have endowed the Council
with the authority and status to make its views
known and felt on all those matters I have just
referred to. So it is, Sir, that the Council can, in
regard to what it considers to be
Column: 278
differentiating measures, cause a reconsideration of
such provisions in any proposed law or indeed any
existing law.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Third time."
Question proposed.
Mr P. Selvadurai: Mr Speaker, Sir, it is important that the
Presidential Council to be set up does its work with
honour and responsibility and not become a centre of
reaction. It is to be hoped that its contribution
would always be directed towards the consolidation
and not the disruption and weakening of the State. I
cannot help feeling, however, that some of the
curious features in this amendment Bill would add a
few more legal conundrums to the as yet unresolved
problem posed by Articles 52 and 90 of the
Constitution.
It is also questionable if the two-thirds majority
in Parliament needed to overcome a report by the
Council that a proposed piece of legislation is a
differentiating measure or otherwise inconsistent
with the fundamental liberties of the subject could
not be negatived and overcome by the device of
introducing a constitutional amendment in Parliament
requiring only a bare majority under Article 90,
Rule 1. Further, subsidiary legislation
characterised by the Council as a differentiating
measure or otherwise inconsistent with the
fundamental liberties of the subject could also
remain in the statute book as enforceable law for
six months before appropriate measures of revocation
are taken. I hope, however, that it is not too much
to expect that more careful and elegant drafting
would be a feature of the new Constitution that we
are to have in due course.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I support the Bill.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I support the Constitution
(Amendment) Bill. I wish to touch upon the second
part of the Bill, namely, the Presidential Council
and matters related thereto. When the Bill was read
a Second time in Parliament, I remember I made a
statement supporting the setting up of the
Presidential
Column: 279
Council. In my opinion, I regard it as the second
most progressive measure ever taken by Parliament in
the history of our parliamentary democracy. The
Select Committee took into consideration various
matters, including procedural, relating to the
Presidential Council. The Government is to be
praised for exercising care in the introduction of
this Bill and its passage through all its stages.
For instance, there is a provision stipulating that
members of the Council should be people above 35
years of age. This will enable people who are mature
and knowledgeable to be appointed as members. The
Bill also provides that people of unsound mind shall
be disqualified for appointment as members of the
Council. These provisions are very appropriate.
The Select Committee also gave careful
consideration to the various details in the Bill.
The Presidential Council's main function is to see
that there is no discriminatory measure in all our
legislation against the minority groups. In this
way, various opinions and views can be advanced so
that the Government can take a judicious stand in
its policies for the people's benefit. In this
respect, the Government has set up community centres
and citizens' consultative committees throughout the
Republic to look after the interest of the people of
Singapore, and also to assess their views and
opinions so as to help the Government in the
implementation of its policies. We all know that in
dictatorial countries, the authorities do not like
freedom of expression for the people. They would
like to shut them up. But this is not a judicious
policy. There is a Chinese saying that it is more
difficult to shut up the people than to stop the
flow of a river. This is something that cannot be
controlled. We must develop the spirit of
parliamentary democracy. In this respect, the
setting up of the Presidential Council will afford
an opportunity for people who have distinguished
themselves in public service or attained eminence in
their respective walks of life to contribute
Column: 280
their part in nation-building for the benefit
of the people.
As regards the appointment of members of the
Council, I would like to make some suggestions.
First, the Council should be composed of
representatives of various races in various walks of
life. Second, the members of the Council should come
from the four streams of education. They should not
come from only one stream of education. As we are
implementing the policy of multi-lingualism, the
Council should conduct its proceedings in the four
official languages.
Finally, can the Minister say when this
Presidential Council will be set up? Two or three
years have elapsed since the setting up of the
Constitutional Commission. As ours is an efficient
government, every kind of work should be efficiently
carried out. The people of Singapore would like to
know when the Presidential Council can be set up.
Sir, I support this Bill.
5.20 p.m.
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, after hearing the speech of the
Member for Sembawang, I feel that certain parts of
his speech are worth listening to. For instance, the
Constitution (Amendment) Bill represents a symbolic
step in Parliament. But he has not said why it is
so. If we look up the political history of
Singapore, we can see that there is a great
difference in the present Constitution of Singapore
compared to the Singapore (Constitution) Order in
Council, 1958. From there we can see where we have
progressed.
This Bill has been introduced in the House
together with the Criminal Procedure Code
(Amendment) Bill. The Constitution (Amendment) Bill
is on constitutional matters and the Criminal
Procedure Code (Amendment) Bill is on judicial
matters. With their passage, we can see that we have
progressed constitutionally as well as in criminal
procedural law.
Column: 281
When we debated the Criminal Procedure Code
(Amendment) Bill yesterday, we heard that there was
a person who held a public rally at Fullerton Square
against the Criminal Procedure Code (Amendment)
Bill.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I think the Member for Bukit
Merah has deviated in his speech on the Constitution
(Amendment) Bill. He is referring to the rally held
at Fullerton Square which has no relationship at all
with the Constitution (Amendment) Bill.
Mr Speaker: The Member for Sembawang must appreciate that I am
listening to the Member for Bukit Merah in the
spirit of the season. Mr Lim.
Mr Lim Guan Hoo(In Mandarin): Perhaps the Member for Sembawang is too impatient.
I was about to refer to the Bill now before the
House. Just now I was talking about a certain person
who held a public rally at Fullerton Square against
the Criminal Procedure Code (Amendment) Bill. But we
have not seen anybody holding a public rally against
the Constitution (Amendment) Bill. Perhaps there is
an explanation in that not many people are
interested in the setting up of the Presidential
Council. There is another view that this is a
democratic process which is easily understood by all
people and that there need not be any hue and cry
against it. Furthermore, the Bill would be able to
present a kind of democratic spirit. This is an
honour that Parliament has achieved. However,
without the setting up of the Presidential Council,
it does not mean that our Constitution is not
democratic or up to date. The point is that with the
introduction of the Bill, our Constitution can cope
with more comprehensive matters and in wider scope
touching on the interest of minority groups.
Since Singapore is multi-racial, it is very
necessary to look after the interests and needs of
the minority groups. Article 89 (1) of the
Constitution of Singapore is a provision relating to
the
Column: 282
rights of the minorities. Even before we achieved
our present stage of progress in our Constitution,
the Government had already taken care of the welfare
and interest of the minorities. With this amendment
Bill, we can improve the provisions of the
Constitution so as to look after their interests
better. The Presidential Council can assess opinions
and views from various quarters and put their heads
together to consider any legislation which might be
a discriminating measure. This is in keeping with
our democratic practice. This will cut down any
possibility of dictatorial measures in legislation.
In this context, I must say that the Bill and its
provisions are very appropriate at this time.
Sir, I support this Bill.
5.28 p.m.
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, if I may first deal with the
Member for Sembawang. He wants to know when the
Presidential Council will be set up. The answer is
next year. How early next year I do not know. It
takes a lot of administrative work to get such a
Council on to its feet. But perhaps the Member
himself is anxious to get on the Council.
The Member for Bukit Panjang questioned whether
the provision in Article 81K (6) (c) of the Bill is
not inconsistent with or illogical when compared
with the present Article 90 of our Constitution
relating to constitutional amendments. He also
referred to Article 52 which says:
'Any law enacted by the Legislature after the
coming into operation of this Constitution which is
inconsistent with this Constitution shall, to the
extent of the inconsistency, be void.'
Article 90 (1) provides that:
'The provisions of this Constitution may be
amended by a law enacted by the Legislature.'
Sir, as the law now stands, the Constitution may
be amended by a simple majority, as laid down in
Article 90. But Article 81K clause (6) (c) of the
Bill requires a two-thirds majority in order to
overcome any adverse opinion
Column: 283
of the Council to the effect that a provision in the
proposed law is a differentiating measure
inconsistent with the fundamental liberties of the
subjects. Members will agree that it is only but
right that we should have this provision in order
that Parliament may not, without such a majority,
abrogate these fundamental liberties if, in the
opinion of the Council, a Bill would have such ill
effects. Any suggestion that the requirement in
Article 81K clause (6) (c) might be overcome by a
withdrawal and re-submission of such a proposed
measure as the Constitution (Amendment) Bill would
be quite incorrect. Such a Constitution (Amendment)
Bill would again have to obtain the clearance of the
Presidential Council so that any such Bill which in
the opinion of the Council adversely affects
fundamental rights or liberties may not be passed by
Parliament without a two-thirds majority. There is
really nothing inconsistent with the constitutional
amendment provisions. The effects of the particular
clause would be to ensure further the protection of
these fundamental rights or liberties.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, I would like to ask the Minister some
questions and would also like him to clarify certain
points.
Mr Speaker: The Minister has spoken in reply.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): There were some questions which were not replied
to. Can I ask him to clarify?
Mr Speaker: Yes.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, I would like to ask the Minister about the two
questions I mentioned just now. The first question
relates to the appointment of members of the
Presidential Council. Can the Minister assure the
House that the members of the Council will include
people from various races and all walks of life, and
also from all the streams of education?
Mr Barker: Sir, if the Member for Sembawang had taken the
trouble to
Column: 284
read the Report of the Select Committee, he would
not have to ask me these questions. These matters
were raised in representations to the Select
Committee and the Committee's Report is before the
House.
I do not appoint members of the Presidential
Council, but certainly the Member's views will be
taken into account. It is a great pity, after having
heard him today, that we did not appoint him to the
Select Committee.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi): The Member for Sembawang cannot read English! You
have to excuse him.
Mr Speaker: Order.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Third time and passed.
Column: 284
ABORTION BILL
(As reported from Select Committee)
Order for Third Reading read.
5.35 p.m.
The Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Third time."
The Select Committee considered 33 written
submissions on the Abortion Bill and heard oral
evidence from the representors of five different
organisations which had submitted memoranda. The
Committee decided to incorporate certain amendments
based on some of the points brought up in the
memoranda as well as in oral evidence.
However, no change in the basic purposes of the
Bill was deemed necessary. The basic aim of the Bill
is to reform and liberalise the abortion law so that
women with unwanted pregnancies may, on social and
humanitarian grounds as well as on medical and
eugenic considerations, have their pregnancies
terminated safely and cheaply in approved
institutions and by approved doctors.
As was expected, there were written submissions
which argue on the principles of the Bill. Of
course, the stand
Column: 285
taken depended upon whether the individual person or
the organisation which made the representation was
for or against the principle of treatment by way of
a deliberate act to terminate pregnancy. Some took
their stand in accordance with their particular
religious persuasion, although they of course did
not want openly to admit it. There were also other
submissions which proposed amendments to specific
provisions of the Bill. Often the representations
took the form of the first part being devoted to
arguments on principle and, in the latter part, to
propose specific amendments to the Bill. It is
interesting to note that there were also memoranda
which, in the first instance, argued against the
principle of the liberalisation of the law of
abortion, but later went on to propose amendments to
specific provisions of the Bill, presumably to
improve it.
Most of the issues raised in the submissions
pertaining to the principles of the Bill were indeed
familiar ground as these had already been covered by
arguments for and against the Bill which had been
raised before the Bill was presented to Parliament
and which were exhaustively debated in Parliament at
the Second Reading of the Bill. I can say that, all
in all, with a few exceptions, most of the
representations were agreed that there was a need to
reform and liberalise our law of abortion, although
there was disagreement on specific provisions of the
Bill and their wording and how far we should go in
liberalising it.
As a result of the representations, the Select
Committee decided upon certain amendments to the
Bill. But I wish to emphasise here that these
amendments to the Bill will in no way alter the aims
and objectives of the Bill or deviate from the basic
considerations which had made the Government
introduce the Bill. Neither would they in any way
weaken the Bill as had been suggested in one
quarter. The amendments which are submitted for
acceptance would, in fact, improve the Bill and
considerably strengthen some of its provisions. For
this, I would like to take
Column: 286
the opportunity here to express my thanks to those
who had come forward to make representations to the
Select Committee.
I do not propose to comment on every one of the
amendments which the Select Committee decided to
recommend acceptance by the House. These have been
described in detail in the Report of the Select
Committee. I propose instead to consider them under
main subject headings. They are as follows:
(1) Membership of the Termination of Pregnancy Authorisation Board
The total number of members of the Board remains
at 11. The amended changes relate to changes in the
composition of the five appointed members. Of the
five members to be appointed by the Minister, three
instead of the original two shall be females. It is
further specified in the amendments that two of
these three women are to be "professionally
qualified social workers". The original text stated
it rather ambiguously as persons with "experience in
social welfare work".
The reasons for these amendments will be
immediately apparent to Members. It was pointed out
both in written representations and in oral evidence
that abortions involve primarily the female person
and, therefore, female representation should be
larger. Hence the amendment to increase the
appointed number of female members to at least
three. The number can, of course, be larger if the
Minister wishes to appoint more women on the Board
if he considers this of advantage.
The appointment to the Board of two
"professionally qualified social workers" instead of
persons with "experience in social welfare work" was
made on the suggestion of various organisations.
such as the Catholic Social Guild, the Inter-Religious Organisation and the professional social
workers. Professionally qualified persons are
identifiable. They are persons who possess a
qualification in social work, i.e., the Diploma in
Social Studies. This would not be the case if the
original term "experience in
Column: 287
social welfare work" is used, as this could include
a range of persons from charitable organisations,
voluntary workers and those whose experience may be
limited and not relevant to the issues.
The other amendments relating to the membership of
the Board are minor administrative amendments. Thus,
for clarification, the filling of a casual vacancy
on the Board should be by a person who has
equivalent qualifications to the member whom he
replaces. Also, the composition of the Board, but
not the number, may be varied by the Minister. In
the original text the Minister would be able to vary
the composition as well as the number of members of
the Board. This appeared objectionable to the
Catholic Social Guild.
(2) Conditions under which abortions may be authorised
Several significant amendments to the conditions
under which abortions may be authorised have been
accepted as a result of the suggestions by various
representations made orally and in written
submissions.
The first amendment makes a qualification to the
medical reasons under which an abortion may be
authorised. In the original text, an abortion could
be performed where there was risk to the life of the
pregnant woman or injury to her physical and mental
health. The amendment clarifies that these risks
should be "serious" risks. The addition of the
adjective to qualify the risk to life or the threat
to a woman's physical and mental well-being injects
a relative term into the considerations and probably
will restrict the conditions under which abortions
can be carried out for medical reasons. If the
amendment is accepted, medical practitioners will
probably find their area of manoeuvre restricted
even more than under the present law which allows an
abortion to be performed where there is a threat to
the life and health of the pregnant woman, without
qualification. The amendment is made on the
suggestion of various representations, that is,
Column: 288
the Singapore Medical Association, the Catholic
Social Guild, the Catholic Medical Guild and the
Regional Council of Churches.
Since, however, this amendment was largely
proposed by the medical profession which have
probably weighed the disadvantages, the amendment is
submitted for acceptance. But I would like to
reiterate here that this amendment will in no way
weaken this part of the Bill. In fact, it will serve
to clarify the position of this provision.
The second amendment (made to clause 5 (2) (d))
adds another condition under which an abortion may
be approved by the Board. This is when pregnancy has
been due to carnal connection.
The Women's Charter makes unlawful carnal
connection with any girl under 16 years of age. The
exception is when the girl is married. Since the
clause provides that pregnancy consequent on rape or
incest is ground for abortion, it is equally good
grounds for adding this other sexual assault on the
girl to be included under this clause.
A further amendment relating to the conditions
under which abortions can be performed relates to
abortions in cases of emergencies. This is provided
under clause 5 (5). Under this clause, it was
provided that an abortion could be performed when it
is immediately necessary to save the life of the
pregnant mother or to prevent grave permanent injury
to the physical or mental health of the pregnant
woman. The amendment seeks to restrict the
practitioner's discretion to a condition where it is
immediately necessary to perform the operation to
save the life of the pregnant woman. In other words,
the condition where there may be reason to perform
the operation to prevent grave permanent injury to
physical or mental health is excluded under this
clause.
The amendment was made on the suggestion of the
Singapore Medical Association in the course of
discussions with its representatives in Select
Committee. The view expressed was that if there was
a grave threat of permanent
Column: 289
physical or mental injury of the pregnant woman,
this should be done under a different clause (i.e.
clause 5 (3)) where a second medical opinion is
required and that the operation is carried out in a
Government hospital or in an approved hospital.
The fourth significant amendment relates to the
citizenship status of the woman applying for
abortion. The relevant clause is clause 5 (8). The
original text would have covered abortions under the
approved conditions to residents of Singapore only.
Although a woman who is "resident in Singapore"
would normally include Singapore citizens, it could
happen that such a citizen might not have been
resident in Singapore during the four months prior
to the application of the abortion and would, by
interpretation of this clause, become ineligible for
consideration for an abortion. Obviously this is not
the intention of the Bill. The intention of this
clause is to exclude non-residents and non-citizens
from taking advantage of the liberalisation of our
laws. It should not operate, however, against our
women citizens. The amendment seeks to clarify and
forestall the remote, though possible,
interpretation of the clause against our citizens.
It specifies that an abortion may be authorised if
the pregnant woman is a resident in Singapore in the
four months prior to the application, or is a
citizen or wife of a citizen of Singapore.
The other amendments under this heading are
administrative and consequential to the three major
amendments which I have just described. For example,
it is provided that a report of an abortion
performed for medical reasons by a medical
practitioner where the prior authority of the Board
has not been obtained will have to be made within 14
days. It was considered that the original text
providing for the report to be made "as soon as
possible" was ambiguous.
(3) Processing of applications for abortions
Several amendments are proposed relating to the
clauses which pertain
Column: 290
to the work of the Board in processing the
applications for abortions. This may briefly be
described as follows:
(a) Referrals for specialist opinion
In clause 7, the Board may make reference, as
circumstances arise, to specialists for an opinion
on an application before it makes a decision on
it. In the original text, in clause 7 (4) (d),
this was limited to a reference to an obstetrician
and gynaecologist. It was rightly pointed out that
this was an unnecessary restriction. There may be
other conditions outside the competence of an
obstetrician and gynaecologist which may require
another medical specialist opinion, say, that of a
physician or a psychiatrist. With this amendment,
the Board would have the discretion to refer such
matters to the appropriate specialist.
(b) Consent for the operation of termination of pregnancy
For obvious reasons, the Board has to be
satisfied that the application for abortion is of
genuine intent and a consent to undergo the
operation is an indication of this intent. A valid
consent for such an operation is described in
clause 8. This clause states that a valid consent
may be given by a woman who is over 18 years of
age. By the proposed amendment, this has been
extended to a married woman even though she is
under 18 years of age.
It is only where the pregnant woman is unmarried
and under 18 years of age that the consent of her
parents or that of a guardian is required.
(c) Participation in the decisions of the Board
As a safeguard to the impartiality of the Board,
an amendment is provided in clause 9 to disallow a
member of the Board or any committee appointed by
the Board involved in any way with the application
or in the operation to terminate a pregnancy, to
be party to the authorisation for treatment to
terminate the
Column: 291
pregnancy. This amendment has been inserted on the
suggestion of the Inter-Religious Organisation,
whose representors to the Select Committee appeared
rather concerned and wished to exclude the
possibility of a conspiracy between medical
practitioners to procure an abortion.
(4) Conscientious objection
The original text of clause 10, which is called
the "conscience clause", provides that a person who
has a conscientious objection may refuse to
participate in any treatment to terminate pregnancy.
Sub-clause (2) of clause 10, however, states that in
any legal proceedings the burden of proof of
conscientious objection shall rest on the person
claiming to rely on it. This unfortunately has
caused some misapprehension, as can be seen from the
representation of the Singapore Medical Association
as well as several others. Therefore, in order to
clear the ambiguity, an amendment has been proposed
which will provide specifically the manner in which
a person who may be involved in the operation of
termination of pregnancy can indicate his
conscientious objection to participate in the
operation. This is done by the person testifying on
oath or affirmation that he has a conscientious
objection to participating in the operation of
abortion.
There are, of course, many other amendments which
had been suggested by the various representations
but which the Select Committee had decided to
reject. One of the amendments proposed but was
rejected was from the Singapore Medical Association
which sought to add in a phrase that an additional
child "is likely to impose additional and grievous
hardship on the woman or her family" to the
environmental clause, i.e., clause 5 (2) (b). As I
have stated before, this proposal to add in this
additional phrase, though it may appear to make the
clause slightly restrictive, adds nothing materially
to the criterion already contained in it, nor does
it in any way alter its essential
Column: 292
meaning, that is, to allow abortions on socio-economic grounds. Moreover, it has been rightly
pointed out that it may unnecessarily impose a
restriction on the judgment of the Board which
already has a difficult job to perform. This
suggested amendment was accordingly rejected. The
reasons for the rejection of the other suggested
amendments become quite apparent, Mr Speaker, Sir,
if you are to read through the proceedings of the
Select Committee as published in its Report, and I,
therefore, do not propose to go through them.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the passage of this Bill
together with its companion Bill, the Voluntary
Sterilization Bill, is certainly an event of major
importance to the people of our Republic. This Bill
has been rightly described outside this House as a
Human Rights Bill. When adopted by this House, it
will forever liberate our women from the present
tyranny of unwanted pregnancies. It will free the
family from the burden of having to feed and care
for the child which, on account of family and
financial hardships, it is just unable to do. As for
the community, it will be spared the tragedy of
having unwanted children from whom most of the
delinquents, the criminals and the anti-social
elements are derived. This is the social evil from
which our community will be freed. On the other
hand, it will help to ensure that children born in
Singapore will be wanted children, being children
who will be properly cared for and have
opportunities for education and the full development
of their faculties so that they can grow up to lead
meaningful lives and contribute to our society.
The Bill also respects the religious and ethical
beliefs of our people in that it does not compel any
woman to have an abortion if she does not want it on
account of her religious and ethical beliefs or for
any other reasons. But it makes it possible for
those whose religious and ethical beliefs do not
forbid them from having an abortion to request for
treatment by way of a deliberate act of termination
Column: 293
of pregnancy under certain conditions as specified
in the Bill. This indeed does vindicate the
freedom and rights of the individual and his
conscience which is so important in our
multiracial and multi-religious society.
The passing of this Bill indeed marks a historic
milestone in the development and progress of our
Republic. This Abortion Bill, which will allow
abortions on purely socio-economic grounds under
its environmental clause, can indeed be considered
one of the most progressive pieces of social
legislation ever to be adopted in the non-Communist world.
This Bill, when it becomes law, will be in force
for four years and may be extended for a period of
not more than one year, after which it will have
to come up for review before Parliament. No doubt
time and experience gathered from its
administration will tell us how effective the
great change proposed in this Bill will fulfil its
purposes. Of
Column: 294
course, we shall watch very carefully the effects
of the implementation of this law on our social
and medical habits, and if it is deemed necessary
in the light of experience gathered, it can be
brought up for review before this House even much
earlier. However, I have every confidence that,
barring initial practical difficulties in
implementation, this Bill, on which a great deal
of thought and consideration had been given, would
more than fulfil the purposes for which it has
been drawn up.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Resolved.
"That Parliament do now adjourn to the 29th
December, 1969."-[Mr Barker].
Adjourned accordingly at
Six o'clock p.m. to
Monday, 29th December, 1969.