| Parliament No: | 2 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 29 |
| Sitting No: | 16 |
| Sitting Date: | 26-03-1970 |
|
Column: 1145
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
FIRST SESSION OF THE SECOND PARLIAMENT
PART III OF FIRST SESSION |
VOLUME 29 |
Thursday, 26th March, 1970
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Dr Yeoh Ghim Seng) (Joo Chiat).
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang).
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development and Leader of the House.
Inche Buang Bin Omar Junid (Whampoa), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Madam Chan Choy Siong (Delta).
Mr Eric Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh).
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (MacPherson), Minister for Health.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong).
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister for Finance.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah).
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Column: 1146
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division).
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu).
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Mr Lee Teck Him (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (Kampong Kapor).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah).
Mr Lim Kim San (Cairnhill), Minister for Defence.
Mr Lim Soo Peng (Havelock).
Mr Low Guan Onn (River Valley).
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford).
Inche Mohd. Ghazali Bin Ismail (Aljunied).
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Education.
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon).
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Communications.
Inche Rahmat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour.
Column: 1147
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Potong Pasir), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (Law Division).
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee).
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang).
Inche Sh'ari Bin Tadin (Kampong Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour and Government Whip.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chu Kang), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance.
Column: 1148
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Acting Minister for Culture.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken (Alexandra).
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications.
ABSENT:
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Inche Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology.
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampong Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Column: 1147
PERMISSION TO MEMBER TO BE ABSENT
Under the provisions of clause 2 (d) of Article 30
of the Constitution of Singapore, I have granted
permission to Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar),
Prime Minister, to be absent from the
Column: 1148
sitting of Parliament today, the 26th March, 1970.
| | (YEOH GHIM SENG) |
| | Speaker, |
| | Parliament of Singapore. |
Column: 1147
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
ROAD ACCIDENTS
(Removal of blood stains)
1. Mr Ng Yeow Chong asked the Minister for
Defence whether the Police will liaise with the
Public Cleansing Branch of the Ministry of Health
for the removal of any blood stains on the roads
immediately after injured persons or dead bodies
are removed from the scene of an accident.
The Minister for Defence (Mr Lim Kim San): Mr Speaker, Sir, arrangements have been made for the
Public Cleansing Corps of the Ministry of Health
to remove blood stains on the road between 6 a.m.
and 6 p.m. after
Column: 1148
the injured persons or dead bodies have been taken
away from the scene of accidents. In the event of
blood stains left on the road between 6 p.m. and 6
a.m., the Police will cover up these stains with
sawdust which will be swept as soon as possible.
The Public Cleansing Corps will be contacted at 6
a.m. the following morning for a more thorough
cleansing of the stains.
Column: 1148
TRAFFIC LAWS
(Stricter enforcement to curb accidents)
2. Mr Ng Yeow Chong asked the Minister for
Defence whether he will adopt stricter enforcement
of traffic laws in view of the alarming increase
of fatal accidents recently.
Column: 1149
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am glad to
say that statistics show that there was a decrease
in the number of fatal accident cases in 1969 as
compared with the previous year. In 1969, a total
of 302 persons were killed on the road, whereas in
1968, the number of road accident victims killed
was 312. The traffic police are already stepping up
action against motorists who show no consideration
for other road users on the roads, and the traffic
laws are being enforced as strictly as possible.
The scale of composition fines that can be
imposed for traffic offences which are compoundable
has been reviewed, and the Ministry of
Communications has been urged to introduce
legislation in order to raise the maximum
composition fine from $20 to $50 so that the
habitual offender will not get off as lightly as
the first offender. The majority of road accidents
in 1969 involved pedestrians who crossed the road
heedless of road traffic. The question of
prohibiting jaywalking is now being considered by
the Ministry of Communications.
Column: 1149
NATIONAL SAFETY FIRST
COUNCIL
(Launching of pedestrian safety campaign)
3. Mr Ng Yeow Chong asked the Minister for
Defence whether he intends to request the Safety
First Council to conduct an all-out campaign
involving civil organisations to drive home the
importance of road safety.
Mr Lim Kim San: Mr Speaker, Sir, the National
Safety First Council holds campaigns periodically
to stress the importance of road safety to the
public. As a matter of fact, Sir, the Council will
be launching a pedestrian safety campaign from the
30th March to the 14th April this year.
Column: 1150
BILL INTRODUCED
SUBORDINATE COURTS BILL
"to amend and consolidate the law relating to the
constitution, jurisdiction and powers of the
subordinate courts and the administration of
justice therein",
presented by the Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker); read the First
time, to be read a Second time on the next
available sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 1151
DEVELOPMENT ESTIMATES
FOR FINANCIAL YEAR
1ST APRIL, 1970, TO 31ST MARCH, 1971
Order read for consideration in Committee of
Supply [Allotted Day].
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
2.36 p.m.
The Chairman: Development Estimates of
Expenditure for the financial year 1st April, 1970,
to 31st March, 1971, contained in Paper Cmd. 5 of
1970. Before I go further, I must remind Members
that the debate on these Development Estimates will
proceed purely on the basis of development and
principles concerning development. Members will
therefore confine their remarks to the development
aspects of the items they propose to discuss, and I
intend to be strict on this.
I might add that the amount of time requested by
Members for the discussion of their various
amendments exceeded the time available by almost
four times, and it was necessary, therefore, to
curtail Members' requirements by about three-quarters. I hope Members will have this in mind
when they speak on their amendments and will be as
brief as possible in their speeches in order that
all, or, failing that, as many as possible, of the
amendments standing on the Order Paper Supplement
can be taken.
For the convenience of Members, I intend taking
the total for each head of expenditure as it
appears in the last
Column: 1151
column of Summary of Estimated Expenditure on
pages 5 and 6 of the Paper.
I shall deal first with the heads of expenditure
in respect of which amendments stand on the Order
Paper Supplement.
Head 10 -
Mr Lim Cheng Lock (Kampong Kapor): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 10 be
reduced by $10 in respect of item 001 of subhead
101.
Mr Speaker, Sir, it is acknowledged that over
the past ten years, Singapore has made
considerable progress politically, socially,
industrially and economically. New laws have been
introduced and passed and existing laws have been
revised and brought up to date. But I must say
that reasonable and suitable accommodation for
the administration of justice does not keep pace
with other fields of progress that we have made.
I refer to the Criminal District and Magistrates'
Courts at South Bridge Road. It is stated in the
Memorandum on the Development Estimates (Misc. 2
of 1970) that the building is very old and
dilapidated. In fact, the conditions are
considered unsafe and also overcrowded.
Sir, although the total expenditure for the
construction of a new building is estimated to
cost $6.4 million, only a sum of $750,000 is to
be voted for this year and that is also subject
to Treasury's sanction. According to the
Estimates (Cmd. 4 of 1970), the revenue derived
from these courts during the past year amounted
to about $3 million for fines in the subordinate
courts, and about $2 million in the traffic
courts, making a total revenue of about $5
million. I am sure, Sir, that the Minister for
Law will agree that even the offenders should
expect reasonable accommodation when they appear
in these courts. Furthermore, the judges,
magistrates and the staff who work in these
courts should be
Column: 1152
provided with more reasonable and suitable
accommodation.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, the need
for a new building to house our subordinate
courts, i.e., the Criminal District and
Magistrates' Courts, the Traffic Courts and the
Civil District Courts, have been felt since 1963.
However, for one reason or another, it was not
possible to implement the proposal until now,
when opportunity has been taken, with the
proposed redevelopment of the areas adjoining and
surrounding the existing Criminal District and
Magistrates' Courts in South Bridge Road under
the urban renewal scheme, to provide a site
approximately 92,000 square feet in area for this
new building opposite the present Ministry of
Labour within the area bounded by Park Road,
Pearl's Hill Road, Havelock Road and New Market
Road. The new building will be a 14-storey one
designed to cope with the needs of the next 50
years. It will have a floor area of about 200,000
square feet, of which a little more than half
will be air-conditioned. Besides 25 court rooms,
there will be chambers, ante-chambers, witness
rooms and a big general office.
The building, which is estimated to cost $6½ million - and this excludes furniture and
equipment is expected to be completed within a
period of three years. It is hoped to be able to
commence construction work in July this year. The
provision of $750,000 now provided under Head 10,
subhead 101, item 001, is required to meet the
cost of initial work for the foundation, piling
and likewise. In fact, the sum has received the
approval of Treasury.
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: Sir, in view of the
explanation. I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $750,010 for Head 10 ordered to stand
part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1153
2.45 p.m.
Head 11 -
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 11 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 101.
It is noted that a sum of $300,000 has been
provided in the two items under the above subhead
for improvements to the National Museum (Works and
Buildings - $200,000) (Furniture and Equipment - $100,000), and I wish to take this opportunity to
praise and thank the Minister concerned for his
keen interest shown in this respect. My suggestion
made last year that the names of the various
categories of exhibits in the National Museum be
written in four languages has been accepted and
implemented. This is confirmed by my visit to the
museum recently.
Now, I wish to ask the Minister the following
four questions:
(i) What improvements will be made to the National Museum?
(ii) What type of equipment will be purchased for the museum, and what is the estimated cost?
(iii) What was the sum incurred in the purchase of curios last year?
(iv) During the past year, how many persons visited the museum and what was the
percentage of visitors who were students?
Mr Speaker, Sir, may know whether the National
Museum arranged for students to visit museum,
because I think this increase their cultural
knowledge?
The Minister for Education (Mr Ong Pang Boon): Mr Speaker, Sir, following the Government's
decision in 1968 to convert the museum into a
natural history museum, it was decided that the
reorganisation be held in abeyance pending the
recommendations and costing by a U.N.E.S.C.O.
expert for whose services the Ministry of Science
and
Column: 1154
Technology had requested. The expert, Mr James
Gardner, a designer, arrived in late January 1970
for a short stay of ten days. He advised that the
present taxonomic arrangement was out of date and
that, instead, the approach should be one that
would lend itself to lively presentation.
He recommended that a far greater sum of money
than the amount provided for is required for the
reorganisation. He recommended to the Museum Board
and the Minister for Science and Technology that a
pilot project be implemented. The pilot project,
which will set the trend for future reorganisation
of the museum, will depict the ecology of a
tropical rain forest. It will cover about 5,000
square feet and will cost about $300,000. Action
has been taken with Mr Gardner, now in London, for
the preparation of a new brief with detailed
costing for submission to the Ministry of Finance.
As for equipment, we are now awaiting detailed
costing of the items from Mr Gardner. The items
will include modern show-cases with internal light
fittings for all the exhibits pertaining to the
rain forest. The exhibits will comprise insects,
large and small mammals and birds, as well as
fabricated interiors of the various habitats these
animals occupy.
Last year, 304,000 persons, the majority of whom
are students, visited the museum as against 342,000
in 1968. However, for the first two months in 1970,
a record number of 221,000 persons visited it.
Arrangements are being made for school children to
visit it on conducted tours. I think at the moment
there are two teachers attached to the National
Museum.
Mr Teong Eng Siong: Mr Speaker, Sir, I thank the
Minister for his answer. I beg leave to withdraw my
amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
Column: 1155
That the sum to be allocated for Head 11 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 201*.
(*The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ng Kah Ting.)
Sir, our young people today are more inclined to
the study of science than art. This is borne out by
the fact that there is an increasing enrolment for
the science stream at the pre-university level. It
is from this pre-university level that the students
branch out to specialise in chemistry, physics,
engineering, medicine, etc, when they enter the
universities or other institutions of higher
learning.
Sir, in the process of industrialisation, there
is a great need for more and more science graduates
and other professionals to man the essential posts
in all fields. It is, therefore, important for our
young people in schools as well as the general
public to have a good understanding of what science
can do for mankind in general, and how it can help
our society in particular to achieve success in our
industrialisation programme. In this respect, the
Government has not lost sight of the need to build
a Popular Science Centre for this purpose. It has
already been explained in the Memorandum on the
Development Estimates (Misc. 2 of 1970) that the
building of this Popular Science Centre is to give
the people of Singapore a better understanding of
the role of science and technology in the
Republic's industrialisation programme.
Sir, in the Minister's reply to the Member for
Telok Blangah earlier on, when the House discussed
the Ordinary Estimates, he told us what he proposed
to do and what he wished to achieve with this
Popular Science Centre. Can he again elaborate on
this subject for the benefit of the Members in this
House?
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, I think the
Popular Science Centre project has been quite
adequately
Column: 1156
explained by my colleague. I do not think there is
any need for me to add to his explanation.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: Before I withdraw my
amendment, I would like to ask the Minister when
this Popular Science Centre will be set up.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, at the
moment we are looking for a suitable site for this
centre. When it is available, further publicity
will be given to this project. The Member for
Mountbatten will then be duly informed.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: Is it in the Mountbatten
Constituency? On that note, I beg leave to withdraw
my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $1,800,030 for Head 11 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1156
Head 21 -
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 21 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 001+.
(+ The same amendment also stood in the names of Mr Ho Kah Leong and Mr Lim Soo Peng.)
Mr Speaker, Sir, I understand that $50 million
has been provided to expand Jurong Town. I think
this expenditure is important and can benefit our
country. However, I wish to ask three questions.
First, for what purpose is this large sum of money
intended? Secondly how many acres of land have been
used for building factories in Jurong Town?
Thirdly, how many applications for factories have
been deferred?
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I would like to thank the Member for
Sembawang for being very concerned about the
affairs in Jurong.
Column: 1157
The reason why I move this amendment is that I
would like to seek information on two points.
First, can the Minister tell us whether the
provision of this $50 million also includes
provision for the setting up of a community centre?
We all know that in the last few years the
development in Jurong has been very rapid and there
are now more than 20,000 residents there.
3.00 p.m.
At present there is a community centre housed in
flat premises. It does not meet the needs of the
residents there because it is quite far away from
the main residential area. I would like to ask the
Minister whether a community centre located in a
central point in Jurong Town will be built.
The other question is whether this $50 million
provision includes the building of a secondary
school in Jurong Town. I ask this question because
at present there is only one primary school there
and it is overcrowded. Therefore, many secondary
school students living in Jurong Town have to go to
schools at distant places. Can the Minister tell us
whether the Jurong Town Corporation intends to
build a secondary school in Jurong Town?
Mr Lim Soo Peng (Havelock): Sir, in providing
facilities and amenities, the Jurong Town
Corporation appears to have forgotten a very
important need - there is no fire station in this
industrial area. A fire station is the back-bone of
our industrial system. The nearest fire station is
miles away, and at present even without a traffic
jam a fire engine takes 15 to 20 minutes to reach a
factory in the Jurong industrial estate. If it is
not the responsibility of the Jurong Town
Corporation to provide a fire station, will it not
at least make available a piece of land for a fire
station, and get the proper authorities to put it
up? After all, the Jurong Town Corporation has to
protect its own interests as well.
Column: 1158
The Minister for Finance (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Sir, this loan of $50 million will pay for a wide
range of development projects which the Jurong Town
Corporation intends to carry out in this fiscal
year. It includes land development, both in Jurong
estate as well as in other areas of Singapore. It
is also proposed to extend the deep-water wharves,
and the total cost of this wharf extension will be
$10 million. Standard factory buildings, as well as
flatted factory buildings, are expected to come to
nearly $13 million. A total of $8.8 million will go
towards the construction of workers' houses in
Jurong, and $1.5 million in housing for other
industrial estates. Then, of course, a substantial
amount will be spent on social amenities, such as
the park, the aviary, a sports complex, and a
public jetty to facilitate transportation between
Jurong and some of the southern islands which have
been developed for industrial purposes. These,
broadly, are the main purposes for which the loan
money will be used.
The Member for Sembawang asks for details of the
acreage of land opened for industrial use, as well
as the number of outstanding applications. The land
in Jurong available for industrial use now stands
in the region of 4,000 acres. The number of
outstanding applications varies from time to time.
I cannot give the exact figure off-hand, but I
think it is probably between 40 and 60 applications
which need to have their land requirements
fulfilled.
The Member for Jurong wants to know whether this
$50 million loan will include expenditure on a
community centre. There is an item here with the
heading, "Mosque, community centre, etc." at
Kampong Java Teban, and a sum of $20,000 has been
set aside for this.
As regards a secondary school for Jurong, no
secondary schools will be built there. Most of the
workers there are not married, and those who are
married have very young children. In fact, even the
primary school in Jurong has not been filled up. So
it will be
Column: 1159
many years before we need secondary schools in the
estate itself. But there are secondary schools
quite close by, for instance, the Jurong Integrated
Secondary School at 12¼ m.s. Jurong Road, the
Yusof Ishak Integrated Secondary School in West
Coast Road, and the Toh Tuck lntegrated Secondary
School in Toh Tuck Road. These three secondary
schools are well under capacity, and they may serve
the population of Jurong for some time.
As regards a fire station, no fire station will
be built in the Jurong industrial estate. There is
a fire station in Queenstown, and there is another
fire station in Bukit Timah. So the necessity of
having one in Jurong is not all that urgent. In
fact, when the fireworks factory in Jurong blew up
about a year ago, the fire brigade got there in a
very short time - five minutes, I believe; in any
case very much less than 15 minutes. In fact, in
the Development Estimates in one of the previous
years, a sum of $1.5 million was provided for a
fire brigade. My officials had a look at it and
wondered whether there was any justification for
spending this large sum of money for a fire
brigade. Most of the money spent on this fire
brigade would be to provide quarters for the
firemen. This is one of the extraordinary features
about Government development projects - the money is
not spent on items that one would conclude from
reading the title of the project. For instance, $5
million is to be spent on, say, building a prison.
You will find that $4 million will be spent not on
housing the convicts, but on housing the prison
staff. It is the same with this vote. I hope we can
develop a system where the firemen will go to the
fire brigade station according to a duty roster,
but go home after that. I do not understand why we
have to provide accommodation on the site of the
fire brigade station. Certainly in other countries
they do not have this. So if the Member for
Havelock wants to have a fire station there, but
without firemen's quarters,
Column: 1160
then I think my Ministry will be more willing to
consider this proposition than otherwise.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Sir, I have a
point to clarify. The Minister for Finance just now
mentioned the building of a community centre and
also that provision is ear-marked for the building
of a mosque at Kampong Java Teban. I would like to
point out that the place is not in Jurong Town. I
would like to know whether he intends to build a
community centre in the centre of Jurong Town.
As regards the Minister's reply that there is no
need for a fire station in Jurong Town, I wish to
say that I had an argument with the Minister for
Social Affairs on this question. The Finance
Minister says that it takes a fire engine only five
minutes to reach the site of the fire. The Minister
for Social Affairs did say that the firemen would
take about one minute to be ready to leave the fire
station. If that be the case, I think it is
incredible that the journey from Bukit Timah to
Jurong could be made within four minutes. In view
of this, I feel that perhaps the Minister for
Finance will reconsider the need for a fire station
in Jurong.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Not for $1.5 million. If the
residents in Jurong are prepared to have fire
services on a more modest scale, where you park one
or two engines with the crew on a rotating basis,
then perhaps I might think it over. This sort of
arrangement will be more reasonable and will be
sufficient to deal with small outbreaks of fires in
the factories. I do not think we need a large fire
station such as we have in Queenstown or elsewhere.
As regards the community centre, I do not make
the decision. I think it will be fairer if I do not
decide such matters. It is best that the Member
take it up with the Jurong Town Corporation. I
believe the N.T.U.C. is represented on the Board of
the Jurong Town Corporation, and maybe the N.T.U.C.
representative will listen sympathetically to what
the Member has to say.
Column: 1161
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir,
in view of the Minister's satisfactory reply, I beg
leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The Chairman: Amendment (2)* has been cancelled. Amendment (3)+, Mr Ng Yeow Chong.
* Amendment (2), standing in the name of Mr Teong Eng Siong, reads as follows:
That the sum to be allocated for Head 21 be reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 002.
+ The same amendment also stood in the names of Messrs, Teong Eng Siong, Ho Kah Leong and Lim Cheng Lock.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 21 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 003+.
(+ The same amendment also stood in the names of Messrs. Teong Eng Siong, Ho Kah Leong and Lim Cheng Lock.)
Sir, when the Committee of Supply discussed the
Second Supplementary Development Estimates of
Expenditure for the Financial Year 1st January,
1969, to 31st March, 1970, I did raise the subject
of building warehouses for the relocation of
warehouses which are in acute shortage as a result
of urban renewal schemes. The Minister for Finance
then replied that warehouses were not the
responsibility of the Jurong Town Corporation. I
hope he will not say again that warehouses are not
the responsibility of the Housing and Development
Board.
Sir, in this respect, I would like to refer to
Hansard, Vol. 26, col. 158, dated 7.9.67. The
Minister for Law and National Development, in his
written answer to my question, said, and I quote:
'I would like to assure the Honourable Member
that my Ministry has indeed been looking into
various possibilities of providing more warehouse
facilities both in the suburbs and near industrial
areas to enable commercial houses and distributors
of merchandise to relocate warehouse affected by
urban renewal.'
In the same Hansard, col. 159, the Minister
continued:
'More investigations and feasibility studies are
being undertaken by the Urban Renewal Department.
Eventually, land may have to be reclaimed from the
sea along Pasir Panjang to provide a warehouse zone
that will be generally acceptable.'
Column: 1162
More than two years have passed, and the shortage
of warehouse facilities has not been solved. In
fact, it has now become more acute, as more and
more areas are being decontrolled for
redevelopment. May I, therefore, ask the Minister
concerned what plans have been made to solve this
shortage of warehouses in the near future, and what
is the progress of sea reclamation along Pasir
Panjang for the warehouse zone?
3.15 p.m.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, in moving this amendment, I wish to raise
three questions. Firstly, I have received
complaints from some tenants of the Housing and
Development Board flats that some of the staff of
the Housing and Development Board are discourteous
in that when the tenants (probably they are
hawkers) pay their rents, they use silver coins
- either ten cents or twenty cents coins - and these
coins are not accepted.
The Chairman: Mr Teong, are you dealing with the
right subhead or not?
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): It is subhead
003 "Loan to Housing and Development Board".
The Chairman: Yes, and please concentrate on
subhead 003 "Loan to Housing and Development
Board".
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, if I do not raise this matter about silver
coins not being accepted by the H.D.B. staff now,
then I will not have the opportunity to do so,
because in the Development Estimates there is no
such item.
As regards the H.D.B. officers refusing to accept
silver coins from these tenants, I think there is
no reason why they should not. Since silver coins
are issued by the Government, why should they not
be accepted by the H.D.B. staff? The only reason is
that these officers are either discourteous or
lazy.
Column: 1163
Secondly, the complaint is on cleanliness in
H.D.B. flats. As far as I know, the Government
receives $10 from each unit of flats as maintenance
for its cleanliness. Very often I discover that the
sweepers do not do their sweeping every day. I
would ask the Minister concerned to see that the
sweepers do their work conscientiously.
Thirdly, I wish to know where the flats will be
built with this loan.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I have two suggestions for the Minister concerned.
Firstly, can flower troughs be made for the tenants
of Housing and Development Board flats to put
flowers along the public corridors in order to
beautify the surroundings? At present they do not
have a place to put their potted plants except
along the public corridors. However, this will be
interfered with by the officers of the Housing and
Development Board. In order to solve this problem,
I hope that the Minister concerned will take
positive measures to enable tenants of H.D.B. flats
to grow potted plants along the public corridors.
The second suggestion is this: Will a swill chute
be provided by the H.D.B, for the tenants to throw
away their swill? At present, they pour their
swill into empty tins or cans and leave them in the
common corridor, thereby raising a stinking smell.
As a result, inspectors from the Housing and
Development Board will interfere with them, saying
that this method of disposing of their swill is not
clean and healthy. In order to solve this problem,
I would ask the Minister concerned whether he can
consider erecting a chute or special container so
that the tenants will be able to pour their swill
down it. It will be more hygienic and will not
raise a stinking smell this way. At the moment, the
Housing and Development Board is charging the
collectors of swill 10 cents per unit for the
collection of swill. Some farmers who rear pigs
will come and collect it. If there are no
containers
Column: 1164
for the swill, the farmers will not be able to
collect it.
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: Mr Speaker Sir, under subhead
003, a sum of $100 million will be provided to the
Housing and Development Board. I believe this sum
will be provided at an interest rate of 7¾ per
cent. The Housing and Development Board, in
assisting persons who wish to own Housing and
Development Board homes, gives loans to persons
purchasing H.D.B. flats at an interest rate of 6¼ per cent. I wonder whether the Minister for
Finance is aware of this subsidy that the people in
Singapore who purchase H.D.B. homes are receiving.
I am quite sure many persons in Singapore who
purchase these homes do not realise the subsidy
they are receiving from the Housing and Development
Board.
I also wish to find out from either the Minister
for Finance or the Minister for Law and National
Development whether, in addition to this subsidy of
$15 per $1,000 loan, the houses are sold at cost or
at a profit?
Mr E. W. Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, if I may first deal
with the queries of the Member for Mountbatten. Up
to the 31st December of last year, 174 stores and
warehouses had been cleared or demolished to make
way for urban renewal. It has not been possible to
provide alternative accommodation as the Housing
and Development Board has not up to date built any
store or warehouse for resettlement purposes.
However, most of those evicted have found their own
accommodation.
The Member will be interested to know that the
State and City Planning Office has conducted a
survey of stores and warehouses to gather data for
the proposal to develop a warehouse complex at
Pasir Panjang. The Port of Singapore Authority is
also making investigations into the possibility of
constructing warehouses within their property. If
implemented, store and warehouse clearance cases
can be offered alternative accommodation at the
proposed complex. The Member
Column: 1165
also asked how far work has progressed. The answer
is that the survey has just been completed and work
has not started.
If I may deal with the Member for Sembawang and
the Member for Jurong. Somehow the questions they
asked me now should have been directed at me
yesterday. Anyhow, I will deal with them.
The Member for Sembawang complains of discourtesy
- silver coins not being received. Silver coins are
valid tender and they should be received. If the
Member knows of any particular case, he should
give the particulars so that the matter can be
investigated. As for cleanliness, it is agreed that
the standard of cleanliness could be further
improved. The Board is now exploring the
possibility of establishing block and floor
representatives to improve the management and to
bring about a higher standard of cleanliness in the
Housing and Development Board estates.
The Member for Jurong made remarks about
providing a swill chute in flats to get rid of the
swill. The problem of collecting swill led to some
difficulties some time ago, but the matter has been
satisfactorily resolved by the appointment of
registered farmers as swill collectors. I
understand that the collection of swill is done by
means of proper containers and under controlled
conditions.
As for planting flowers, substantial numbers of
flower troughs have been provided in Housing and
Development Board estates for landscaping and
beautifying. The tenants are also encouraged to
keep potted plants to make their flats more
pleasant, so long as the potte4 plants do not fall
down to the flat below.
I believe the Member for Sembawang wanted to
know where we are going to build more flats. The
answer is in several places in Singapore - Queenstown, Toa Payoh, Telok Blangah and even on
both sides of Farrer Road.
Column: 1166
Mr Teong Eng Siong: The Naval Base?
Mr Barker: No, I am afraid it will take some time
before we reach the Naval Base.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am sure
the Minister is fully aware that a lot of
businessmen store their goods in their own private
houses in the residential areas and even in flats
or apartments. Will the various authorities like
the Chief Building Surveyor's Department, the
Ministry of Health, the Fire Brigade and the
Planning Department be lenient with them in view of
the shortage?
Mr Barker: I am afraid I cannot speak for the
Fire Brigade. If there is a fire hazard, the Fire
Brigade will ask them to move out. There have been
cases of residential premises being used as
warehouses. Depending on the type of goods stored,
the vicinity and the particular circumstances
temporary approval has been granted in many cases.
3.30 p.m.
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, can the Member for
Kampong Kapor quickly recapitulate his questions?
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: Sir, very briefly, what I
wanted to find out from the Minister is whether he
is aware that the sum of $100 million is being
provided to the Housing and Development Board at an
interest rate of 7¾ per cent, whereas the Board
is giving loans to purchasers of flats at an
interest rate of 6¼ per cent, which means that
the Government is subsidising $15 per $1,000. In
addition to this subsidy, can the Minister say
whether the flats are sold by the Board at cost or
at a profit?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Actually, the Government loan
to the Housing and Development Board takes two
separate forms: one is a 60-year loan at 7¾ per
cent, and the other is a 10-year loan at 6 per
cent, which is to finance houses put up for sale
under the home ownership scheme. The Board itself
Column: 1167
lends money to purchasers at 6¼ per cent for 15
years. This has been extended to 20 years.
Government, of course, has been subsidising this
scheme all along. It is in the general interest
that we should provide housing on the best possible
terms.
As regards the sale of flats, the Housing Board
is not a profit-making body and it sells at cost,
taking into account administrative and other
overheads. Indeed, because the Housing Board has
been able to buy land in the past at very low
rates, my guess is that if you value these
properties at current land values, the purchasers
would be getting very good value for their money.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: Sir, I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 21 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
004*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ng Kah Ting)
Sir, I have some questions on the National
Stadium Corporation for the Minister. What is the
object in setting up this Corporation? How will the
provision of $7.8 million be utilised? What is the
National Stadium Corporation's relation to the
National Sports Promotion Board which has yet to be
established? Will the Kallang Park Sports Complex
be managed by the corporation? Will the Corporation
also manage other sports stadiums elsewhere in the
Republic, such as the Jalan Besar and Farrer Park
Stadiums? Finally, will the Corporation run and
manage small gymnasiums in various parts of the
city for the benefit of our workers?
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
seek somewhat different information from my
colleague, the Member for Mountbatten. I remember
that the National Stadium Complex was supposed to
get its financial support
Column: 1168
from profits derived from the setting up of
Singapore Pools (Pte.) Limited. In this respect, I
shall be grateful if the Minister for Finance will
disclose to this House how much has been collected
by Singapore Pools (Pte.) Ltd, in respect of the
two lotteries they run - Toto and the Singapore
Sweep. How much of the collections have been
ploughed back into the National Stadium? As the
Member for Mountbatten has mentioned, I believe the
Corporation has not been set up. In fact, the Bill
is still with the Select Committee. How much will
it cost us when the National Stadium Complex is
completed? Can the Minister assure this House that
it will not be another white elephant?
Dr Goh Keng Swee: Sir, I hope I can remember all
the questions that have been raised. First, what is
this National Stadium Corporation? This has yet to
be set up and the Corporation will look after the
National Stadium. Whether it will look after other
stadiums and whether it will establish gymnasiums I
will not venture to predict. But the Corporation is
quite different from the National Sports Promotion
Board which is to promote sports. The Corporation
will manage the National Stadium and one hopes that
it will prevent the stadium from becoming a white
elephant. It might well become a white elephant, as
the Member for Punggol has said, but one hopes that
that would not be the case.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I hope so!
Dr Goh Keng Swee: How much has been paid for
this project from Singapore Pools? A sum of $4.2
million was contributed from Toto operations and
$1.8 million came from the profits of the Singapore
Sweep. This gives a total of $6 million. The
stadium will eventually cost $18 million and the
first stage of the project will be completed by the
middle of 1972. Whether Singapore Pools will make
profits fast enough to pay the contractors, I would
not know.
Column: 1169
3.38 p.m.
The Chairman: Time is up, Dr Goh.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: Sir, I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The time allotted for Head 21 having expired, the
following amendments were not proceeded with:
Mr Ng Yeow Chong:
Mr Lim Cheng Lock:
Mr Hwang Soo Jin:
Mr Ng Kah Ting:
(5) That the sum to be allocated for Head 21 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
101.
Mr Ng Kah Ting:
(6) That the sum to be allocated for Head 21 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 201.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong:
Mr Lim Cheng Lock:
Mr Hwang Soo Jin:
Mr Ng Kah Ting:
(7) That the sum to be allocated for Head 21 be reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 301.
The sum of $232,749,810 for Head 21 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates
Column: 1169
Head 22 -
The following amendments stood in the name of Mr
Ng Kah Ting-
(1) That the sum to be allocated for Head 22 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
201.
(2) That the sum to be allocated for Head 22 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
404.
The Chairman: Mr Ng Kah Ting.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, I am not moving the two
amendments.
The sum of $1,233,800 for Head 22 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1169
Head 31 -
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: Mr Speaker. Sir, I beg to
move,
Column: 1170
That the sum to be allocated for Head 31 be
reduced by $10 in respect of item 001 of subhead
101.
Sir, the provision of over $1.7 million is for
the construction of a luxury hotel adjacent to the
Hotel and Catering Training Centre. In view of the
overbuilding of private hotels, I wish to ask the
Minister for Labour whether it is prudent for the
Government to go into the hotel business on a
commercial basis in competition with the other
hotels.
The Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour (Mr S. Rajaratnam): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
presume that what the Member for Kampong Kapor
wants to find out from me is whether it is prudent
for the Government to go into the hotel business.
Sir, anything that the Government does is always
prudent. In this particular case, this is a hotel-cum-training centre. If we have to provide some
10,600 persons who will be required to service our
fast-expanding hotel industry by 1972, then it is
necessary that there should be some systematic
training of staff. And this hotel - it is to be
called Hotel Premier - is mainly for training
people. We are not going into competition with the
private hotels. I mentioned this project to some of
the hoteliers and they were quite grateful that the
Government is undertaking the task of providing a
school and a hotel where potential hotel staff will
get in-service training while they are on the job.
At present, they are trained and have to learn
their business in established hotels which
sometimes do not add very much to the prestige or
the efficiency of the hotels. Therefore, there is
no question of Government going into the hotel
business. After all, there are only 30 bedrooms in
this hotel. In fact, far from offering competition
to the private hotels, this hotel will enhance the
efficiency and possibly the profits of private
hotels.
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: Sir, I beg leave to
withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Column: 1171
The following amendment stood in the names of Mr
Ng Yeow Chong and Mr Ng Kah Ting -
(2) That the sum to be allocated for Head 31 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 101.
The Chairman: Mr Ng Yeow Chong, amendment (2).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: I am not moving, Sir.
The Chairman: Mr Ng Kah Ting.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not moving, Sir.
The sum of $2,192,000 for Head 31 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1171
Head 41 -
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Tay Boon Too -
(1) That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
101.
The Chairman: Amendment (1), Mr Tay.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar): I am not moving,
Sir.
The Chairman: Amendment (2), Mr Ho Kah Leong.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 he
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
203*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon.)
Sir, as a graduate of Nanyang University, I am
glad to see that more and more financial assistance
is being given to the University. Under this item.
the Government intends to spend about $700,000 on
the sports complex, and this is heartening news.
3.45 p.m.
With regard to the building of this complex, I
recall that it began when I was still in the
University. At that time,
Column: 1172
only the land was levelled. The complex is about to
be completed. I hope the students will make use of
its training facilities and build up their bodies.
I would now like to ask a few questions on the
development of Nanyang University. We read from the
press that a College for Post-Graduate Studies was
set up on the 20th of this month.
The Chairman: We are on the sports complex and
not on the development of Nanyang University. Will
the Member please confine himself to the sports
complex?
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): I crave your
indulgence and I hope you will allow me to ask
certain questions on the development of Nanyang
University. I think it is quite proper for me to
talk on the development of Nanyang University since
we are discussing the Development Estimates.
The Chairman: The $700,000 provision in the
Development Estimates is for a sports complex and
not for Nanyang University.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
apart from the sports complex, may I range over
other topics regarding the development of Nanyang
University?
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Member
should have spoken on the item "Grants to higher
education" as appeared in the Ordinary Estimates.
The Chairman: I agree with the Minister. The
Member for Jurong should have done that. Mr Ch'ng
Jit Koon.
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I am having the same problem as my colleague,
the Member for Jurong.
The Chairman: I am afraid you have submitted the
wrong amendment. You should confine yourself to the
sports complex.
Column: 1173
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon: In that case, Sir, I am not
moving.
The Chairman: Does the Minister wish to reply on
the sports complex?
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, there is
nothing for me to reply. I think the Member for
Jurong was praising the Government's decision to
allocate a sum of $700,000 for the construction of
a sports complex.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
since the Government has been giving a lot of
assistance to Nanyang University, I would like to
know whether it intends to help in its development.
I hope the Minister will let the House know what
other schemes the Government has in mind to develop
Nanyang University.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: I am not sure whether the
Member has finished asking what he wants to ask.
The Chairman: All these questions should have
been asked during the debate on the Ordinary
Estimates which we have been discussing for the
last five days. The Member has moved an amendment
to a subhead which concerns the sports complex, and
yet he wants to ask about the development of
Nanyang University. My ruling is that he is out of
order. Will he withdraw his amendment?
Mr Ho Kah Leong: I withdraw my
amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ng Kah Ting -
(3) That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
205.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not moving,
Sir.
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 301.
This subhead concerns new primary schools. That
the Government has not
Column: 1174
made proper plans for building new schools can be
seen from the fact that in Tiong Bahru places for
children in the primary schools are not sufficient.
As a result, many pupils are being sent to distant
schools. This is causing a lot of inconvenience to
the pupils as well as the parents. We know that the
Government is providing $100 million to the Housing
and Development Board to build high-rise flats in
the Tiong Bahru, Delta and Alexandra areas. After
the Housing Board has built the flats, there will
be more people staying in these areas. There will
then be a serious problem of finding school
accommodation for the children. I wonder whether
the Government has any plans to build more schools
in these areas.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, it is not
true that the Government has not properly planned
its school building programme to cater for the new
housing estates that are springing up all over
Singapore. It is a case of financial stringency
rather than poor planning. In fact, in many of the
new Housing Board estates, school sites have been
reserved but we have not been able to build schools
because of financial reasons. There are enough
school places in Singapore to cater for all
children of school-going age. The problem is that
there have been such a lot of population movements
from the centre of the city to the new Housing
Board estates that the schools in the centre of the
city have vacancies, whereas in the Housing Board
estates there are children of school-going age but
no schools. I am afraid this problem will persist
for quite a long time to come unless funds are
available. As I said just now, in view of the
financial stringency which my Ministry is required
to exercise, new primary schools will only be built
in areas where there is very extensive resettlement
or the building of new flats by the Housing and
Development Board or where replacement schools have
to be provided because of urban renewal.
Members of the House are no doubt aware of the
very small provision
Column: 1175
allocated for the development of new primary
schools in this year's estimates. The provision is
sufficient for the construction of only one primary
school, which is now being built in MacPherson
Housing Estate where an acute shortage of primary
school places is being experienced largely because
of intensive building by the Housing and
Development Board in this area during the last
couple of years. With no funds being made available
to us, and as there has been no substantial
building of new Housing and Development Board flats
in the Tiong Bahru area, there are no immediate
plans for the building of primary schools in that
constituency.
However, Mr Speaker, Sir, a 10-storey primary
school with an enrolment capacity of 2,800 is now
being built in Chin Swee Road in Havelock
Constituency to replace two very old schools, Sepoy
Lines Malay School and Pearl's Hill School. They
will soon have to be demolished to give way to
urban renewal.
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon(In Mandarin): I beg leave to
withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ho Kah Leong
(5) That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
502.
Mr Ho Kah Leong: I am not moving amendment (5),
Sir.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
601.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the title under this subhead is
"Land Acquisition for Technical Education". There
is a provision of $500,000 and, of course, as usual
it is subject to Treasury sanction. I notice also
that there is a revote of $311,800. I would like to
seek clarification on the
Column: 1176
location of the land which will be required for
technical education purposes.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education (Dr Lee Chiaw Meng): Mr Speaker, Sir,
this sum is provided to pay for the land which
belongs to the Housing and Development Board. It
has been taken over by the Ministry of Education
for the development of the Vocational Institute at
Bukit Merah.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I have been told - rightly or
wrongly - by the Parliamentary Secretary just now
that this provision is for the Vocational Training
institute. Would he care to elaborate further on
the term "Vocational Training Institute"?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, actually I
used the term "Vocational Institute" and not
"Vocational Training Institute". With the
introduction of the modular system of training at
the beginning of this year, all the various types
of training institutes have become unified into one
type. In fact, all of them will henceforth be
referred to as vocational institutes where
instruction in a vocation will be given to the
trainees.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, in that case,
what is the difference between a vocational
institute and a technical institute? In other
words, what is the difference in the level of
instruction between the two types of institute?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Sir, the vocational institute
will teach more "how" and the technical institute
will teach more "why". They differ in the skill and
theoretical content of a particular trade. The
technical institute will train craft technicians at
a level which is slightly below that of a technical
college and the vocational institute is for the
training of craftsmen.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, I am satisfied with the
Parliamentary Secretary's reply. I beg leave to
withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Column: 1177
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 701.
Sir, with your permission, may I, in my
discussion, range over amendments (8)* and (9)+ which stand in my name?
The amendments read as follows:
*(8) That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 be reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 702.
+(9) That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 be reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 703.
The Chairman: Yes.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, this concerns
the conversion of schools. Under these subheads
one can see the following titles: subhead 701,
"Construction of Centralised Workshops for
Academic Schools"; subhead 702, "Modification of
Multi-Purpose Schools Workshops"; subhead 703,
"Conversion of Academic/Vocational Schools into
Bilateral Schools"; and subhead 704, "Modification
of Technical School Workshops". I have been trying
to find out more about these titles from the
Memorandum on the Development Estimates of
Singapore for the financial year 1st April, 1970,
to 31st March, 1971 (Misc. 2 of 1970), but I have
not been able to get any clear picture of the type
of conversion or construction. I hope the
Parliamentary Secretary will elaborate further and
inform this House of the exact nature of the work
to be undertaken this year and next year.
4.00 p.m.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am not
surprised that explanatory notes on this
conversion are not found in the Development
Estimates, because they are all contained in a
booklet which was tabled in Parliament last year.
In this booklet, entitled One Year of Technical
Education, we did lay down the proposed
reorganisation whereby all boys and 50 per cent of
the girls in Secondary I and II are required to go
for three hours' training per week in metal work
together with either woodwork or basic
electricity. As such, we
Column: 1178
have to provide sufficient workshops to cater for
this new subject that has been introduced for the
first time in the secondary school curriculum. As
most of the academic schools do not have a work.
shop, and as this subject requires only three
hours per week of training, we find it is better
to locate all the facilities in one central place
to be known as a centralised workshop to cater for
a cluster of schools in that area. There are some
14 administrative units of centralised workshop,
each of which will consist of four metal, two
woodwork and two electricity workshops, and will
cater for some 3,200 students.
The same set-up goes for the Multi-Purpose
school which was first established in 1964. This,
school provides, in addition to a classroom and
science laboratory, facilities for art and craft
work, domestic science teaching and technical
education. This will enable all students to be
educated according to their interest, ability, and
aptitude.
With the introduction of this new workshop
training in Secondary I and II curricula, it was
decided that the technical workshop at these Multi-Purpose schools should be converted into a
centralised workshop to cater for Secondary I and
II academic school students living in that area.
In the case of academic/vocational schools, the
conversion is of a slightly different nature.
Since 1969 we have abolished all vocational
schools and integrated them with the neighbouring
academic schools into a bilateral school, which is
a school consisting actually of two streams, one
technical and the other academic. This will allow
both streams of education to come under the same
administrative head. And the vote asked for is to
provide additional facilities to enable the
student to go right up to Technical III and IV
levels in the technical stream.
Column: 1179
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, in that case, I beg leave
to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1001.
This subhead concerns the Singapore Technical
Institute, and Parliament is asked to vote for a
provision of $300,000. I would like to know the
location of this Institute, and what courses of
study leading to what level it provides. I would
also like to know the student enrolment, and
whether the Minister or his Parliamentary Secretary
can indicate the number of students who have passed
out from this Institute.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, the
Singapore Technical Institute will provide courses
at craft-technician level, which I have explained
earlier: there will be courses in mechanical
engineering practice, applied electronics,
furniture production, electrical craft technician,
refrigeration, air conditioning, and engineering
drawing. All these courses leading to the award of
a Craft Technician Diploma which, as I have
explained earlier, is slightly lower than that of a
Technical College. Polytechnic and the Ngee Ann
Technical College, in the sense that the courses
that these Colleges conduct have a slightly higher
theory content than those of the Singapore
Technical Institute.
The Singapore Technical Institute at the present
moment is functioning temporarily in the Singapore
Vocational Institute at Balestier Road. Proposals
for its future development have been finalised, and
it has been decided to house the Singapore
Technical Institute permanently at a site provided
near the MacPherson Housing Estate, which was
formerly earmarked for the MacPherson Vocational
Institute. Within this same complex, it will also
house the Technical Department of the Teachers'
Training College.
As the Singapore Technical Institute was only
established at the beginning
Column: 1180
of 1969, it has not produced any graduates yet. The
present enrolment is 240, and when the Institute is
fully operational on completion of the new
building, it will have a maximum enrolment of 1,000
full-time and 1,000 part-time students.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, in that case, when will the
Institute be completed?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker,
Sir, the building for the Institute will be
completed by April next year.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ng Kah Ting -
(11) That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
1101.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, I am not moving amendment
(11).
The Chairman: Amendment (12) then, Mr Ng.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
That the sum to be allocated for Head 41 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1202.
Sir, I believe this is a contribution to the
Polytechnic. For last year there was only a token
contribution of $10, but for this year a sum of
slightly more than $1.5 million is asked for Works
and Buildings and Furniture and Equipment. Will the
Minister kindly indicate to this House what sort of
Works and Buildings will entail such a high cost?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Sir, to meet the increasing
demand for technicians as a result of our
industrialisation programme, there is a need to
expand the School of Industrial Technology at the
Polytechnic. As we are all aware, the Polytechnic
is at present sited at Prince Edward Road, and it
has no room for expansion. The only alternative is
to put up additional buildings to cope temporarily
with the increasing intake of students.
Consequently the Polytechnic obtained permission to
use the
Column: 1181
land opposite its present site for the purpose of
putting up additional temporary structures for a
workshop, draughting room, offices, and lecture
rooms.
The Polytechnic has agreed that emphasis in the
teaching should be aimed at practical application
rather than theoretical principles. This has
resulted in the introduction of a new course known
as the General Certificate of Industrial
Technology. The intake for this particular course
has increased substantially for the coming year.
This has necessitated the provision of additional
workshop and laboratory facilities, and additional
equipment will be required for the new course. It
is estimated that about $1.5 million will be
required for works and buildings, and another $1
million approximately will be required for
furniture and equipment. In addition, a sum of
about $76,000 is needed to compensate the Ministry
of Interior and Defence for vacating the land
opposite the Polytechnic.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, the
Parliamentary Secretary has mentioned just now that
the works and buildings will be of a temporary
nature to cope with the increasing demand for
places in the Polytechnic. I believe that the
additional buildings for the Polytechnic on its
present site will not be sufficient and there is
contemplation to re-site the Polytechnic.
Therefore, this being the case, can the
Parliamentary Secretary say whether or not the
Polytechnic, together with the Singapore Technical
Institute which will be completed by 1971, could
provide sufficient places, in spite of the present
crash programme of building additional works and
buildings? Under these circumstances, Sir, I would
be grateful if the Parliamentary Secretary could
also indicate where the new Polytechnic will be
sited.
Mr Lim Kim San: In Punggol.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Certainly, Sir, not in Punggol.
I would rather prefer Punggol to be a peaceful
area, without
Column: 1182
all the banging going on in the machinery
workshops. Anyway, my question is this: with the re-siting of the Polytechnic, the emphasis on
technical education will inevitably be greater. So
should we not start off on this new site rather
than spend more than $1 .5 million on these works
and buildings as a temporary measure?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, I fully
agree with the Member for Punggol. Unfortunately we
cannot yet locate an ideal site for the Singapore
Polytechnic. Of this $1½ million, not all will be
lost when the Polytechnic moves to the new site - if we ever locate one - because the present
facilities are of a movable nature.
Incidentally, there is a vocational institute in
Punggol Constituency.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, I beg to correct the last
sentence. The vocational secondary school in
Punggol does not exist any more. It is now known as
the Punggol Industrial Training Centre.
Sir, the Parliamentary Secretary has not given me
a satisfactory reply with regard to the re-siting
of the Polytechnic. He says that he has not been
able to locate an ideal site for the Polytechnic.
But can he assure this House that vigorous steps
will be taken to ensure that the construction of
the Polytechnic will not be too far into the
future?
Mr E. W. Barker: If I may reply, Mr Speaker, Sir?
The Chairman: Yes.
Mr Barker: Sir, if plans for moving the
University of Singapore to Kent Ridge are
implemented, then the Polytechnic may move to the
present site of the University. When the University
moves, we must find a use for the present building
and grounds. In my view, the present University
site would be the best site for the Polytechnic.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, I wish to thank the
Minister for Law and National Development for his
intervention and very good suggestion. And I
Column: 1183
hope the Minister for Education will take this into
serious consideration. Under the circumstances,
Sir, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
4.15 p.m.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the total sum to be allocated for Head 41
be reduced by $100*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ng Kah Ting.).
Mr Speaker, Sir, the provision for this Head
exceeds $22 million. Some of this money will be
used to build technical schools and buy equipment
and machinery. Such a big provision is necessary
because we are now in the midst of expanding our
technical education so as to train more and more
technical personnel. I would like to ask the
Minister a few questions.
Firstly, I have received complaints that the
machinery in certain vocational institutes breaks
down very often. This machinery is all very new but
it breaks down after a short time and is left
unattended to for a long period. This is a very
grave defect. The Minister should see to it that
his Ministry rectify the defect of not repairing
machinery immediately it breaks down. I think it is
not only a waste of public money, but it is also
obstructing the studies of the students.
Secondly, the teaching aids and other equipment
in the vocational schools are always missing. It
seems that the administration of these schools is
not very satisfactory. Teachers are not able to
take care of this expensive equipment. This is
another example of waste of public money.
Thirdly, as we have so many technical and
vocational institutes, we must also have a
sufficient number of teachers. The teachers in
these institutes have to teach their subjects
through the medium of English, as many of the terms
are in English. Therefore, these teachers must have
a high standard of English so that
Column: 1184
they are able to communicate to the students what
they teach. I do not know whether the Technical
Education Department has any plans to improve the
standard of English of these teachers so that they
will not be faced with difficulties when they give
instruction to their students.
Fourthly, inspectors from the Technical Education
Department seldom visit these technical institutes.
Therefore, if the teachers are faced with
difficulties, they are not able to get proper help
and guidance from them.
Lastly, does the Minister intend to build a
vocational or technical institute at Sembawang?
This is because there is a naval base and a
shipyard there. As the Government intends to build
factories there, the building of a vocational or
technical institute will facilitate the training of
skilled workers to man these factories.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I would like to ask the
Minister several questions regarding Nanyang
University.
From press reports, we know that a College for
Post-Graduate Studies was set up on the 20th of
this month. It is a milestone in the development of
Nanyang University. We welcome the setting up of
the college because it will help to train more
professional people to serve our country. This
college requires a big sum of money to carry out
its activities. For example, it must at least have
a good building. However, in the Development
Estimates of 1970-71, I have not been able to find
a provision for this College for Post-Graduate
Studies. I would like to know what steps the
Government intends to take towards the expansion of
this College for Post-Graduate Studies.
In his financial statement, the Minister for
Finance says the Government intends to recruit
overseas scholars and professional people to work
here. Of course, the material incentives here are
not comparable to those abroad. However,
Column: 1185
if these scholars want to come and serve here, they
do so with a sense of dedication. We should
therefore provide them with suitable living
accommodation.
Ever since the setting up of Nanyang University,
many of the quarters for the teaching staff have
not been renovated. For example, the dormitories
have not been renovated. I think it is time they
should be renovated. With the setting up of the
College for Post-Graduate Studies, this renovation
should be undertaken now. I hope the Minister will
ask for more money from his colleague, the Minister
for Finance. From the financial policy of the
Minister for Finance, we know that, because of the
rapid industrialisation programme, we need not only
technicians but also managerial and high executive
personnel to man our industries. There is a great
shortage of such talents. Many of our graduates who
have gone abroad for higher studies have not come
back. We should adopt the policy of using local
talents to teach in Nanyang University. What plans
does the University have to encourage its own
graduates who have gone abroad for higher studies
to come back and take over the key positions in
Nanyang University?
A year ago the Minister, in answering my
question, stated that Nanyang University asked for
$20,000 to improve its ventilation facilities. I do
not know whether such a provision has been made to
improve the ventilation facilities at Nanyang
University.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, in reply to
the query by the Member for Sembawang regarding the
damage to the machinery at the vocational
institutes, I would like to say that the technical
education programme has expanded so rapidly that we
find it a bit difficult to maintain the machinery
which happens to break down almost at the same
time. Formerly, the minor maintenance of machinery
was done by our own craft teachers and workshop
instructors, and major faults were repaired by the
P.W.D. Owing to the sudden increase in machinery in
our technical institutions and its intensive
Column: 1186
usage, the P.W.D. has not been able to cope with the
requests for repair immediately. As a result, the
Ministry has set up a maintenance unit to relieve
some of the burden on the P.W.D.
As for the Member's query regarding the language
of instruction, I am quite sure he is fully aware
that even in secondary schools, Mathematics and
Science are being taught in English. Therefore, it
is reasonable that technical subjects should be
taught in English. As I said just now, when
answering a query from the Member for Punggol, in
the technical institutions the instruction is more
in the acquisition of skills and therefore the
language of instruction is not a crucial point.
The Member for Sembawang also raised a query
about inspectors from the Technical Education
Department not visiting the technical institutions
as often as the other academic schools. I think
this will be much to the relief of the Member for
Paya Lebar, who is rather worried about - the
frequent visits of these inspectors to the schools
in his constituency!
Our Technical education is managed in a different
way. The Principal of the Singapore Technical
Institute, who is a professional officer, has an
almost autonomous say in the running of the
Institute. The Education Ministry is presently
running a management course for all principals of
vocational institutes.
If the demand for skilled workers arises in
Sembawang, we will look into the establishment of a
vocational institute there.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, my Ministry
has supported the setting up of a College for Post-Graduate Studies because it will provide proper
research facilities for the staff. Only a small
establishment will be required because research
will be done by the academic staff from other
departments who will be attached to the college as
Senior Fellows or Fellows. The number of post-graduate students is expected to be small, and
admission will be very selective. A sum of
$46,000 has been
Column: 1187
included in the $3.5 million Government
contribution to Nanyang University for this
purpose. This will cover the honoraria for the Dean
of the college, for the four heads of the
institute, and remuneration for technical and
general staff.
As far as capital development of the College of
Post-Graduate Studies is concerned, it will be
carried out in two phases, and a sum of $1.2
million is required. So far, Nanyang University has
raised $300,000 for the first phase. Meanwhile the
University has asked Government for a dollar-for-dollar grant.
It has always been the accepted policy of Nanyang
University, since reorganisation began over five
and a half years ago, to build up a corps of local
academic staff so that the University can be fully
developed to fulfil its role as a national
university. What Nanyang University will become in
the years ahead depends largely on the calibre of
the academic staff. This policy has not been
changed. I am sure that the administrators of
Nanyang University are implementing this policy
with understanding and vigour.
In last year's Estimates, Government provided
$3.89 million to Nanyang University. This grant
included a sum of $220,000 for repairs and
renovation to student hostels and staff quarters,
including replacement of furniture. Another sum of
$220,000 for a similar purpose is included in the
Government contribution of $3.5 million this year.
With the installation of ten additional exhaust-fans and numerous wall-fans early last year, the
ventilation of the auditorium has improved and it
is tolerable under normal conditions. The
University authorities are now considering
improving the ventilation of the stage. The Hokkien
Huay Kuan contributed $100,000 in 1968 for the
improvement of the auditorium.
The Chairman: You have one more minute left, Mr
Ong.
Column: 1188
Mr Ong Pang Boon: The expenses for improvement
of the auditorium are not paid out of the annual
budget of the University.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, since there is no time left, I would like to
withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn,
The sum of $22,134,310 for Head 41 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1188
4.30 p.m.
Head 51 -
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 51 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 302*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ng Kah Ting.)
Sir, the provision of $3 million is for the
redevelopment of the passenger terminal building,
and I think this project is very necessary for the
development of tourism, because the number of
tourists coming to Singapore is increasing year by
year. I have several questions to ask. Firstly,
when will this project be completed? Secondly, what
are the facilities that will be provided in this
building? Thirdly, how many passengers can the
building accommodate? Fourthly, what are the
improved services that will be provided for the
tourists?
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I fully agree
with the proposal to redevelop the passenger
terminal building. I believe that the number of
passengers entering and leaving Singapore is
increasing. Hence there is a need to redevelop the
building which, I understand, will be completed in
late 1971. In this respect. I would suggest to the
Minister for Communications that in redeveloping
the passenger terminal building, consideration
should be given to the improvement of the transit
lounges. In other words, we should provide better
facilities for passengers in transit.
Column: 1189
Furthermore, can the Minister say whether there
is an intention to develop the terminal building in
the same way as in some other countries where the
planes are parked just next to the terminal
building and the passengers can simply walk down
the gangways right into the terminal building? For
example, like the terminal buildings in New York
and Schipol in Amsterdam. This would more or less
relieve the passengers from having to come down
from the plane, get into buses or coaches and be
transported to the terminal building.
In other words, we want a modern passenger
terminal building.
The Minister for Communications (Mr Yong Nyuk Lin): Mr Speaker, Sir, as explained in the
Memorandum on the Development Estimates of
Singapore (Misc. 2 of 1970) which was tabled by the
Minister for Finance on the 5th of March, 1970, at
page 4, Head 51 -Civil Aviation - the second
paragraph says:
'The major project will be the redevelopment of
the Passenger Terminal Building, for which $3.0
million is provided. This project is scheduled for
completion by late 1971.'
That is in reply to the first question posed by the
Member for Sembawang.
As regards the facilities which will be provided
when the extension to the present passenger
terminal building is completed, we hope to have
approximately double the present floor space, and
the biggest increase will be in the arrival area
which will comprise two floors. There is provision
for two jumbo-jets - the 747s - to nose into the
building so that passengers will just walk out of
the plane on to the landing. In addition, of
course, there will be other facilities like
conveyor belts for baggages to be conveyed to the
customs hail on the ground floor. I think all this
while there have been a good number of complaints
about the delay in baggage handling and we are
making an effort to modernise the handling of
baggages with the extension to our passenger
terminal building. In all, there will be five new
conveyor belts installed with the possibility
Column: 1190
of another two being added on at a later
stage.
Coming to the arrivals wing, there will be a roof-top waving deck for people to say "bye bye" to
those taking leave or on their arrival which will
be an improvement over the present waving gallery.
This will be a roof-top waving deck and I think
they will be able to enjoy a panoramic view of our
airport, and also have light refreshments and meals
as we intend to have a partial open-air restaurant
at this place.
We are hoping that this improved passenger
terminal building will be able to handle three
million passengers per annum, which is three times
the present number of one million per annum.
All in all, when this project is completed, we
shall have a very much improved international
airport.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, since the
Minister has fully answered my questions, I beg
leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 51 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 911*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Hwang Soo Jin)
Sir, in moving this amendment, I wish to seek
information from the Minister for Communications as
to whether he proposes to introduce a television
information system at the passenger terminal
building in addition to the public address
system.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Sir, we shall try to introduce
this system subject to Treasury's approval.
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: Sir, in view of the
assurance, I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $6,678,110 for Head 51 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
The Chairman: I propose to take the suspension
now.
Column: 1191
Thereupon Mr Speaker left the Chair of the
Committee and took the Chair of the House.
Mr Speaker: I suspend the sitting now and shall
take the Chair again at 5.10 p.m.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
4.40 p.m. until 5.10 p.m.
Column: 1191
Sitting resumed at 5.10 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
Debate in Committee of Supply resumed.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
Head 52 -
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Lim Soo Peng -
That the total sum to be allocated
for Head 52 be reduced by $100.
The Chairman: Mr Lim.
Mr Lim Soo Peng: I am not moving,
The sum of $522,400 for Head 52 ordered to stand
part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1191
Head 53 -
The Chairman: Amendment (1). Mr Ng Yeow Chong is
not here. Mr Teong Eng Siong.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 53 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 404.
Sir, the provision of $10 million is for the
setting up of a Satellite Earth Station, which is
an important project because we are now entering
the space age. And there is a need to set up a
Satellite Earth Station in Singapore so as to keep
Singapore in touch with other countries. In this
connection, I would like to raise four questions.
First, why are we so slow in establishing this
station? Second, when will it be completed? Third,
when
Column: 1192
it is completed, what benefits will it provide for
Singapore? And, fourth, who is building it?
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Mr Speaker, Sir, in answer to
the Member's first question why we appear to be so
slow in establishing this Satellite Earth Station,
I would like to assure him that the sum involved is
$10 million and one does not try to spend $10
million rather quickly, at least not in Singapore.
As there are lots of technical details involved in
the building of a highly technical project like
this, it is better to hasten slowly.
As regards the date when we expect to have this
station completed, I would like to say that public
tenders for the building of this station closed in
November last year and it has taken the last three
months to evaluate them. The official evaluation is
now complete and the file is now in my office. As
and when the Senior Tenders Board has made its
award, we hope to have the station completed within
a year. That means it will be by April 1971.
5.15 p.m.
Regarding the Member's third question as to the
benefits that will accrue from building this
station, I would like to say that although at
present Singapore has a very efficient
telecommunications system, we are beginning to find
that our facilities are not quite able to cope with
the demands required of them. Therefore, it is
necessary to have this modern earth satellite
station. We believe that it will bring us a lot of
benefits in that the most modern method of
telecommunication will be made available to the
commercial world as well as to members of the
public. We expect the returns will be of a sizable
amount. We estimate that during the first year of
operation we might make as much as $70,000 net
profit. In the second year it would be $970,000,
which is almost a million dollars, and the third
year over $2 million. The benefits, from the point
of view of financial gain will be considerable.
Column: 1193
The Member's last question is, who will build
this earth satellite station? That will be
determined by the Senior Tenders Board. When the
award is made, we will know which company has been
successful in the tender. It is a bit early for me
now to disclose the name of the successful
tenderer.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, since the Minister has explained that this
will be a profitable project, I beg leave to
withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ng Kah Ting -
(2) That the sum to be allocated for Head 53 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 502.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not moving, Sir.
The sum of $15,178,560 for Head 53 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1193
Head 55 -
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ng Kah Ting
That the total sum to be allocated for Head 55 be
reduced by $100.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not moving, Sir.
The sum of $194,600 for Head 55 ordered to stand
part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1193
Head 61 -
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 61 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 101.
The provision for this subhead is about $51
million. This is for the expansion of our Armed
Forces and Police. We are now strengthening our
defence establishment in order to ensure our
independence and security. This is very important.
Can the Minister tell the House how this vote is to
be spent?
Column: 1194
The Acting Minister for Culture (Mr Wee Toon Boon): Mr Speaker, Sir, in reply to the Member, I
can briefly give an explanation of the proposed
expenditure for this vote.
(a) The construction of new camps, renovations
and alterations to existing army camps, and British
bases that will be made available to the Ministry
of Interior and Defence, the cost of land
acquisition and compensation to squatters.
(b) The construction and renovation of police
projects and land acquisition for station sites.
(c) Purchase of weapons for the Singapore Armed
Forces and the Police.
(d) Purchase of ammunition and demolition
materials for unit holding.
(e) Purchase of heavy plant, engineering equipment
and bridging equipment for the Singapore Armed
Forces.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $51,033,100 for Head 61 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1194
Head 62 -
The following amendments stood in the name of Mr
Ng Kah Ting
(1) That the sum to be allocated for Head 62 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
101.
(2) That the sum to be allocated for Head 62 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
302.
(3) That the total sum to be allocated for Head 62
be reduced by $100.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am not
moving all my three amendments.
The sum of $330,500 for Head 62 ordered to stand
part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1195
Head 71 -
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 71 be reduced
by $10 in respect of subhead 301*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ng Kah Ting.)
Sir, this vote involves a sum of $1,250,000 for
"Works and Buildings" and "Furniture and Equipment"
for the "New Radio Studios and Office Buildings".
Can the Minister answer the following questions:
(1) When will the construction of the buildings be
completed? (2) What kind of facilities will be
provided in these buildings? (3)Will there be any
improvement in the broadcasting services after the
completion of these buildings?
Mr Wee Toon Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Member
for Sembawang wants to know when the construction
of the buildings will be completed. It is planned
that the project will take two years to complete.
He has also asked what facilities will be
provided. Provision is made for the construction of
new radio studios and office buildings. The
facilities that will be provided are those
connected with radio studios. Therefore, they are
factors involving special accoustic treatment
required for broadcasting studios; that is, there
will be sound-proof doors, accoustic treatment of
walls and ceilings, cables, ducts and air-conditioning requirements and also broadcasting
studio equipment of professional standard. Then
there will be an auditorium, five continuity
studios for the four language-channel service and a
F.M. stereophonic service, three "talk studios" and
four general purpose and music studios for the
production of local programmes and also for the
Master Control Room. The last project that will be
required is the transfer of telephone lines and
cables which are used to send programmes from
Broadcasting House studios to the transmitting
Column: 1196
station in Jurong and the purchase of a diesel
stand-power generating plant.
The Member's last question is whether these new
projects will increase efficiency. Mr Speaker,
Sir, of course, the additional facilities will
provide a bigger-sized auditorium which will seat
350 people for audience-participation shows and
there is an increase in size for music studios.
There will be technical improvements and the
introduction of new systems designed to facilitate
production work. Planning for the project will also
take note of future development; that is to say,
there will be one additional continuity studio for
news service and one additional music and general
purpose studio. The increase of operational
efficiency and improvement of technical standards
will no doubt assist the programme staff in
producing better programmes.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, the Minister has explained the projects and
also promised to improve the programmes. I beg
leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendments stood in the name of Mr
Ng Kah Ting -
(2) That the sum to be allocated for Head 71 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
302.
(3) That the total sum to be allocated for Head 71
be reduced by $100.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not moving my two
amendments, Sir.
The sum of $1,595,840 for Head 71 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1196
Head 81 -
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 81 be reduced
by $10 in respect of subhead 101.
Column: 1197
Sir, this subhead concerns the Junior Approved
School. I believe I have another amendment* on Head 141 -
U.K. Financial Assistance Schemes. This refers to the same topic I am going to discuss
now. I will not be moving my amendment to Head
141.
* The amendment reads as follows:
That the sum to be allocated for Head 141 be reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 401.
Sir, I would like to seek further clarification
on the type of Junior Approved School that is to
be constructed and which is expected to be
completed either this year or next year. This work
will be undertaken with financial assistance
amounting to $175,000 from the United Kingdom.
Perhaps the Minister for Social Affairs will
elaborate on what this Junior Approved School is.
I find that what it says on page 7 of the
Memorandum on the Development Estimates of
Singapore is not very clear to me.
The Minister for Social Affairs (Inche Othman Bin Wok): Mr Speaker, Sir, this Junior Approved
School will be sited at Clementi Road, next to
Ngee Ann College. It will comprise two units of
building. The first unit is the Junior Approved
School which will replace the existing Welfare
School for Boys at Keppel Road. It is the one that
we have at the moment. It will consist of a two-storey building with dormitory accommodation and
toilet facilities on the first floor for 80 boys
using double-decker beds. The offices, stores,
workroom, kitchen and dinning room facilities will
be on the ground floor. We are not giving any
facilities for staff quarters, but there will be a
night duty room for the watchman there.
5.30 p.m.
The second unit will be a remand home which will
replace the present very inadequate remand
facilities in the Gimson School for Boys. This
remand home will be built adjacent to the approved
school and will consist of a single-storey
building with accommodation
Column: 1198
for 32 boys in two dormitories separated by a
multi-purpose hall. If necessary, the
accommodation could be increased to 64 by again
using double-decker beds. There will also be four
individual cells for difficult cases, and a small
office with quarters attached for one residential
staff.
Why is it necessary to build this school? The
reason is that there is a need to provide separate
training facilities for young offenders below 14
years of age and also older ones between the ages
of 14 and 19. Each of these two groups requires a
different type of training, and the Department's
efforts to rehabilitate delinquents would be
seriously jeopardised if relatively young
offenders were to be accommodated and trained in
the same setting as the older hard-core offenders.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, just one more question.
Will the Minister consider accepting into this
Junior Approved School, when it is completed, not
only delinquents referred to the juvenile courts,
but also those children whose parents have no
control over them?
Inche Othman Bin Wok: Those admitted to this school
are delinquents taken off the courts. For the
other categories of boys, there are other homes
which can accommodate them.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, in view of the answers
given by the Minister, I beg leave to withdraw my
amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Ho Kah Leong: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 81 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 103.
Sir, it is noted that a sum of $80,000 is
provided for the building of a creche at Taman
Jurong, i.e., Jurong Town. In moving this
amendment, Sir, I merely want to seek information
from the Minister as to how and when this creche
will be constructed.
Column: 1199
Inche Othman Bin Wok: Sir, this sum of $80,000 as
stated in the Development Estimates is a provision
to be released by Government on a dollar-for-dollar
basis towards the cost of the proposed Taman Jurong
Creche. A tentative site measuring about 210 feet
by 146 feet at Taman Jurong has been earmarked for
this project. The site is ideal, as working mothers
may walk to the creche, leave their children there
to be taken care of, catch a bus and go to work.
And on their way back, they can stop there, fetch
their children and go home.
As to when the creche can be completed, I have
not seen the money yet and, therefore, I am not
able to say. But as soon as we get the money, we
will start building.
Mr Ho Kah Leong: Sir, I thank the Minister for
his explanation, and I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $204,000 for Head 81 ordered to stand
part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1199
Head 83 -
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Teong Eng Siong
That the sum to be allocated for Head 83 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
102.
Mr Teong Eng Siong: I am not moving, Sir.
The sum of $98,000 for Head 83 ordered to stand
part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1199
Head 90 -
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 90 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
201.
Sir, it is noted that the vote for this subhead
amounts to $540,000. This is a new vote, and I
would like to ask the Minister why there is a need
for it and for what purpose it will be used.
Moreover, in what way will the use of this vote by
the Survey Department benefit our country?
Column: 1200
Mr E. W. Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, national mapping is
a Government responsibility and compatible with our
independent status. It is essential that we have at
our disposal facilities for such mapping work.
Hitherto, Singapore maps were produced by the
Surveyor-General, the Director of National Mapping,
Malaysia, and, to a lesser extent, by the Assistant
Director of Surveys of the United Kingdom Services,
as we did not have these facilities. This
arrangement was expedient so long as the Singapore
Survey Department was pan-Malaysian and came under
the Surveyor-General, Malaya, and as a Federal
department when Singapore was a constituent state
of Malaysia.
On separation from Malaysia, the responsibility
for the production of all Singapore maps fell on
the Chief Surveyor, Singapore. However, since our
Survey Department did not have the necessary
facilities, both in respect of equipment and
personnel, all Singapore maps have been printed by
the Malaysian Directorate of Mapping on a
commercial basis. This arrangement is clearly
unsatisfactory.
The current demand for mapping from numerous
departments and statutory bodies, such as the
Planning Department, the Public Works Department,
the Ministry of Health, the Land Office, the
Housing and Development Board, the Economic
Development Board, the Jurong Town Corporation, the
Public Utilities Board, the Bases Economic
Conversion Department, and the Ministry of Interior
and Defence, has come about as a result of the
accelerated rate of planning and development in
various fields. Maps are a prerequisite for all
planning and development projects and for effective
and efficient administration. The setting up of the
Mapping Unit in the Survey Department is,
therefore, a vital necessity.
The sum of $540,000 represents the full capital
cost of the purchase of comprehensive equipment
needed to operate an independent Mapping Unit.
Column: 1201
The various items, if the Member is interested,
are:
$
Printing machine 135,000
Camera 84,000
Automatic proofing press 102,000
Guillotine 20,000
Kern stereoplotter 45,000
Wild plotter 45,000
Negotiations are in hand to obtain some of the
equipment at the Dover Road Mapping Unit of the
British Services when their facilities are
transferred to the Singapore Government at the end
of this year. If the Member is interested, the
establishment of the Mapping Unit will require a
staff of 57 under the Chief Surveyor.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, I thank the Minister for his detailed
explanation, and I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $753,100 for Head 90 ordered to stand
part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1201
Head 91 -
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ho Kah Leong
(1) That the sum to be allocated for Head 91 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 101.
The Chairman: Mr Ho Kah Leong.
Mr Ho Kah Leong: I am not moving, Sir.
The following amendment stood on the Order Paper
Supplement:
Mr Ng Yeow Chong:
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon:
Mr Lim Cheng Lock:
Mr Ng Kah Ting:
(2) That the sum to be allocated for Head 91 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 201.
The Chairman: Mr Ng Yeow Chong.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: I am not
moving, Sir.
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon: I am not moving, Sir.
Column: 1202
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 91 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 201.
In moving this amendment, Sir, I am trying to
seek information from the Minister as to the
intention of the Land Office to purchase Chip Bee
Gardens, Married Quarters Estate. What does
Government propose to do with this estate in the
future?
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not speaking, Sir.
Mr E. W. Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, Chip Bee Gardens is
an estate along North Buona Vista Road and Holland
Road, near Holland Village. It comprises terrace
houses and shophouses with flats above. In 1963 the
United Kingdom Services Authorities obtained
permission from the Singapore Government to
negotiate with the developers for a lease of a
portion of this property when built, with the
option to purchase it if the owners declined to
lease.
The estate was developed by the owners, the
United Development and Finance Co. Ltd., under the
terms of agreement between the company and the
Services Lands Board, as a housing estate for
Service families. However, before formal conveyance
and transfer of this property to the Services Lands
Board was completed, the pull-out was announced.
The Service authorities then considered reverting
to a hiring agreement which would have left the
property in the legal ownership of the United
Development and Finance Co. Ltd.
Following discussions, the Singapore Government
decided to enter into financial arrangements with
the Service authorities, so that the transaction
could be completed and the estate transferred to
the Singapore Government. Provision has
accordingly been made for acquisition of this
property at a cost of $6,770,000. The total cost to
the British Exchequer, if the transaction had been
completed, would have been about $l5½ million.
Under the present arrangements,
Column: 1203
for a payment of $6,770,000 the transaction would
be completed and the property would vest in the
Singapore Government.
Service families would be allowed to continue in
occupation of the premises till the end of 1971 at
the latest. If the Member wants to know what use
could be made of these premises, there are a number
of possible uses. The estate is ideally situated
and can house many visiting foreign experts
advising Government and statutory boards and other
agencies of Government. These foreign experts are
at present housed either in hotels or in quarters
provided by Government and statutory boards, and
they are housed in quarters which are large
colonial type bungalows in areas which can be more
intensively developed or better utilised. If we can
find no use for Chip Bee Estate, we can let it out
quite easily.
5.45 p.m.
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: In view of the
explanation, I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $11,770,000 for Head 91 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1203
Head 92 -
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 92 be
reduced by $10 in respect of item 001 of subhead
201.
Mr Speaker, Sir, a token vote of $10 has been
entered in this item for the development of an
underground car park at the Padang. In view of the
importance of this piece of land which is being
used from time to time for national purposes, I
wish to seek information from the Minister as to
how he proposes to develop the Padang into an
underground car park.
Mr E. W. Barker: Sir, only $10 has been provided and
it is a token vote. Studies are being made and
further studies will have to be made with regard to
the
Column: 1204
proposed car park. The object, if it is feasible,
is to construct a car park under the Padang. Cars
will go in from both sides of the road so that you
can carry on with your National Day parade,
football games, hockey, cricket and tennis on the
Padang. The Padang has become a part of Singapore.
It has been a part of Singapore for so long that I
think our planners would be mad if we did anything
else with it; but I have been told that they can
build a car park underneath the Padang without
affecting the grass and we will have to wait and
see whether or not their plans are feasible. Hence
the token vote.
Mr Lim Cheng Lock: In view of the explanation, I
beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ng Kah Ting -
(2) That the sum to be allocated for Head 92 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 202.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, I am not moving.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 92 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 301.
This sum of money is to be used for the East
Coast foreshore reclamation scheme. This scheme is
a very farsighted one, because Singapore is short
of land. That is why we have to extend our land by
reclaiming from the sea. I would like to pose a few
questions to the Minister.
Firstly, in respect of the present East Coast
foreshore reclamation scheme, how many acres of
land have been reclaimed?
Secondly, how long will it take before we can use
this reclaimed land?
Thirdly, what plans does the Government have and
what buildings will be built on this reclaimed
land?
Mr Barker: Sir, the earthworks for the
reclamation of about 1,000 acres of land from Bedok
to the Singapore
Column: 1205
Swimming Club under Phase One of the East Coast
reclamation scheme was completed in January this
year. However, work on the drainage system has yet
to be done.
Under Phase Two, about another 125 acres will be
reclaimed from the Singapore Swimming Club to the
end of Tanjong Rhu. About 30 of the 125 acres have
so far been reclaimed. It is hoped to complete the
second phase of the reclamation by the end of the
year.
The reclaimed land is earmarked for housing,
tourist projects, commercial shopping centres,
light industries and parks for recreational
purposes. It will have a five-mile long beach and a
marineland complex which is being planned by the
Primary Production Department.
As to how long before the land can be used, we
will have to wait. This really depends on what
particular use the land will be put to. As for the
marineland complex, if we are ready we can go ahead
tomorrow. If buildings are to be put on, we will
have to wait a little time for the earth to settle.
And if piling is needed, piling will have to be
done.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I thank the Minister for his detailed
explanation and I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 92 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
302.
This is also a provision for the reclamation of
land from the Singapore Swimming Club to the end of
Tanjong Rhu. I would like to ask the Minister two
questions.
Firstly, how many acres of land will be reclaimed
under this reclamation scheme?
Secondly, are there any plans to build a road
stretching from Tanjong Rhu to Clifford Pier? If
there are, when will the plans be implemented?
Column: 1206
Mr Barker: Under this scheme, 125 acres of land
from the Singapore Swimming Club to the end of
Tanjong Rhu will be reclaimed. So far, about 30
acres of land have been reclaimed. The first
project that will be completed along the whole East
Coast reclamation is a road from Bedok right up to
the end of Tanjong Rhu. If we are to cross from
Tanjong Rhu into town, we will either have to build
a bridge which will be too long, or reclaim some
more land, and that will be a possible third phase
and it will take a very long time.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): I beg leave to
withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ch'ng Jit Koon -
(5) That the sum to be allocated for Head 92 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
401.
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon: Sir, I am not moving.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 92 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 403.
The provision for subhead 403 is a big one. It
amounts to $11 million. I would like to know what
the Government intends to do with this big sum of
money. What purposes will this money be used for?
Why should there be such a big vote? What are the
uses when the plans are completed? Has the
Government any plans to build houses or residential
estates or other types of buildings on this land?
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, with the successful
completion of two urban redevelopment pilot schemes
- Precinct North One and Precinct South One - the
additional section of the urban area which has been
divided into a number of precincts, collectively
termed as "Other Precincts", will now be
implemented. Some of these areas have already been
acquired for redevelopment, and even private
developers and landowners will be encouraged to
redevelop in accordance with guide plans prepared
by the Urban Renewal Department.
Column: 1207
Any urban renewal scheme needs a lot of money.
If the Government acquires land, it has to pay
for it. Land in the city is expensive. After
having paid money for the land to the owners,
Government has also to compensate the occupiers - tenants, sub-tenants, licensees, and sometimes
trespassers. All this takes a lot of time and, in
the final result, a lot of money.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): From the
Minister's explanation, does it mean that our
urban renewal scheme will be unprofitable?
Mr Barker: We are not going into urban renewal
for profit, but neither can we afford to lose on
it. The object of urban renewal is to renew the
town, otherwise we will have old houses and
dilapidated buildings - and eyesores.
6.00 p.m.
Some of our houses were built 50 or 60 years ago
for those times. They are falling apart now. I
have not come here to speak about control of
rent. But one major factor which has prevented
development in this city is the fact that we have
the Control of Rent Ordinance, and because of
this, landlords cannot obtain possession of their
property from tenants. Hence the experimental
scheme under the Control of Rent (Special
Provisions) Act. We have demarcated about 80
acres in the centre of the city for
redevelopment. Without that amending Act, no
development can take place. And it would be for
the Government to evict everybody and sell the
property. We do not lose money. In fact, we make
money. But the money we make is used to provide
better housing for the poorer sections of the
population.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, I am
satisfied with the Minister's explanation and I
beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Column: 1208
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 92 be
reduced by $10 In respect of subhead 406*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ng Kah Ting.)
Sir, what I wish to raise under this amendment
is purely a question of technicality. According
to my view, this subhead, which involves a sum of
$1.8 million, should be more appropriately placed
under Head 1207 - National Development Division - in the Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure and
not in the Development Estimates. If this is
done, the details of the various posts of
officers in charge of administration of urban
renewal schemes and the various items of Other
Charges Annually Recurrent can be shown in the
Estimates and subject to scrutiny by this House.
May I ask the Minister for Law and National
Development to give his comments to this House?
The Chairman: Mr Ng Kah Ting.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not speaking, Sir.
Mr Barker: Sir, the Member has made a good
point. There is no special reason for this. But
the urban renewal programme was started as a
development project. We are discussing the
Development Estimates and, therefore, all items
of expenditure, including Personal Emoluments,
Other Charges Annually Recurrent, together with
other items of development expenditure such as
Land Acquisition and Resettlement, were lumped
together for budgetary convenience. That is all.
But the Member has made a point that it should be
elsewhere.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: Sir, I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendments stood in the names of
Mr Ho Kah Leong and Mr Ng Kah Ting respectively -
(8) That the sum to be allocated for Head 92 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
501.
(9) That the total sum to be allocated for Head
92 be reduced by $100.
Column: 1209
The Chairman: Mr Ho, amendment (8).
Mr Ho Kah Leong: I am not moving, Sir.
The Chairman: Mr Ng, amendment (9).
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not moving, Sir.
The sum of $47,145,650 for Head 92 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1209
Head 93 -
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 93 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 102.
Sir, this provision of $25,500 is for the
Poultry Broiler Research Unit. Firstly, I wish to
know what kind of research work this Unit will
carry out. Secondly, will it be useful for the
development of agriculture in our country?
Thirdly, will the farmers benefit from the
research? And, fourthly, how many employees are
there in this unit?
Mr E. W. Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, like the Member
for Jurong, the Member for Sembawang has always
asked the Primary Production Department to help
farmers more and more. This is one way in which
the Department is positively helping farmers.
Sir, a pilot project of broiler production has
been carried out in the Sembawang Research Station
in Sembawang in the last two years.
Mr Teong Eng Siong: No, it is in Nee Soon.
Mr Barker: I am sorry. Broiler production is
processed to rear large numbers of poultry for
poultry meat. Poultry reared under this intensive
production system reaches marketing weight in nine
to ten weeks instead of the usual three to four
months. In other words, the chickens grow faster.
This pilot project
Column: 1210
has been successful and the information and
techniques gained have been disseminated to the
farmers. Nowadays, many farmers have already
started, to produce broilers and the Poultry
Section in the Sembawang Research Station is
continuing its investigations to improve the
techniques and to solve any problems that may
arise. The unit is not very big and it consists of
a dozen or so employees.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, does this unit provide free services to the
farmers?
Mr Barker: The unit does not charge the
farmers. It teaches them the methods and the
techniques.
Mr Teong Eng Siong: Free of charge?
Mr Barker: No fees are charged. But if a
farmer, after having learnt the techniques, wants
his chickens to grow faster, then he must spend
money.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, since
this is a project to help farmers, it deserves
praise. Therefore, I beg leave to withdraw my
amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 93 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
104*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ng Kah Ting.)
Sir, I stand to be corrected, but I seem to
remember that during the debate on the Development
Estimates in December 1968, the Minister told the
House that when the pig section of the Central
Abattoir in Jurong was ready, he would give
consideration to building a few rural abattoirs.
But I have been looking through the Development
Estimates and subhead 105, which is in respect of
rural abattoirs, has been taken off. Can the
Minister tell the House whether it has now been
decided not to go ahead with the building of rural
abattoirs? And, if so, why is this so?
Column: 1211
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I share the
same sentiments as expressed by my colleague, the
Member for Jalan Kayu. In fact, a couple of years
ago, I brought up this question of rural abattoirs.
There was then a token provision of $10 in respect
of several rural abattoirs in the Development
Estimates. I feel that there is a need for the construction of such abattoirs in centrally located
rural areas to help pork sellers get their supply
of meat and arrive at the markets in the rural
areas as quickly as possible. Sir, I have brought
up this point because I have received complaints
that the Central Abattoir is too far from areas
like Jalan Kayu, Punggol or Upper Serangoon.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi): Changi!
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Yes, Sir, Changi and also
Tampines. We have a sizable population in these
areas. Under such circumstances, will the Minister
for Law and National Development sympathetically
consider the building of rural abattoirs? And, if
not, whether he will look into the prospects of
awarding tenders for the construction of rural
abattoirs with a view to getting private
organisations to run them?
Mr Barker: Sir, the Member for Punggol
practically took the words out of my mouth!
Government's thinking on the need for rural
abattoirs has not changed. But Government's
thinking on who should run these abattoirs has
changed. In view of our experience at the Jurong
Abattoir, we are thinking of letting private
enterprise run even the Jurong Abattoir - in other
words, a statutory board or a public company and we
are inviting the private sector to come in. We do
not want just the civil servants to run the
abattoir if it is converted into a public company.
As far as rural abattoirs are concerned, no
provision is made this year for the simple reason
that Government, by itself, does not intend to
build abattoirs in the rural areas. That does not
mean to say that we have abandoned the idea of
building abattoirs in the rural areas. But as the
Member for Punggol
Column: 1212
has put it, we think that the abattoir could be run
better if it was built by private enterprise.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin: Sir, I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
6.15 p.m.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 93 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
202.
Sir, I would like to have some information on the
intensive farm improvement scheme. May I know how
far the scheme has progressed and whether the
farmers are taking part in it?
Mr Barker: The intensive farm improvement scheme
has been implemented in the last two years in the
Sembawang Research Station with the object of
developing intensive farming techniques and finding
solutions to some problems related to this form of
farming, in particular pest and disease control.
The construction of laboratory facilities has been
completed, technical personnel have been recruited,
and the project is just getting off the ground with
the assistance of horticulturists from New Zealand
under the Colombo Plan.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): The Minister
seems to have forgotten another question which I
have raised. May I know whether there are any
farmers taking part in this scheme?
Mr Barker: No, not yet.
Mr Ho Kah Leong: I beg leave to withdraw my
amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 93 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
203.
Sir, I am moving this amendment in order to
obtain some information from the Minister. Can he
inform the House what is this provision for? I see
that
Column: 1213
there is a vote of $50,000 now as against a token
vote of $10 for last year.
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Government
proposes to carry out a pilot scheme on factory
farming, that is to say, to rear animals in
confined spaces and, if possible, in multi-storey
livestock houses. The objective of the scheme is
to intensify the use of land and increase
production per unit area in view of the shortage
of agricultural land in Singapore. Under the
scheme, it is proposed to rear poultry, pigs and
goats in multi-storey livestock houses and to
assess the technical as well as the economic
feasibilities of such a project.
The factory farming pilot scheme is, therefore,
at present only in its initial stages. It is a
plan awaiting the approval of the Government.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin: I beg to withdraw my
amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 93 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
206*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the names of Mr Hwang Soo Jin and Mr Ng Kah Ting.)
Can the Minister inform us how the Agricultural
Statistics Unit is carrying on its work? In what
way are the statistics on the farmers collected by
this unit used to assist the farmers?
Mr Hwang Soo Jin: Mr Speaker, Sir, may I know
what has accounted for the delay in carrying out
the agricultural survey?
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I just wish
to ask one question. I notice that under this
subhead, a "Farm Licensing, Agricultural Survey
and Agricultural Statistics Unit" will be set up.
Can the Minister disclose to this House how many
licences have been issued up to the latest
convenient date? I welcome the proposal to set up
this unit and I hope it will assist the farmers
Column: 1214
in every possible manner, because I feel that the
agricultural produce supplied by the farmers in
Singapore has contributed in no small measure to
our economy.
Mr Barker : Mr Speaker, Sir, the data collected
under farm licensing will be used to ascertain the
existing state of agriculture in Singapore and to
assess future potential and development, thus
enabling the Government to plan for agricultural
policy on the basis of the kind and amount of
services needed by the farming community. Unless
we know how many and what type of farmers there
are, we will not be able to know what sort or what
amount of help they would need.
It may be possible that, with adequate
information available, even farmers may be advised
to plan their production targets in relation not
only to domestic needs but also to the export
market demand for agricultural produce. This was
only recently the subject of a question from the
Member to me in this House.
As for the agricultural survey, there has been
no delay. At the moment, we are ready to go on but
we are awaiting approval from the Ministry of
Finance. In all, 20,357 farm licences were issued
for the year 1969. A report on farm licensing,
giving various details based on information
provided by the farmers, has been prepared and, if
any Members are interested, I can easily send them
a copy of the report.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I thank the Minister for his explanation and
beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 93 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
207.
Column: 1215
Mr Speaker, Sir, last year the Minister very kindly
explained to us what hydroponics involved. I
should appreciate it if the Minister would inform
us to what extent progress has been made in
experimenting with hydroponics. When can the
knowledge and experience gained by such experiments
be passed on to the private sector for commercial
exploitation?
Mr Barker : Mr Speaker, Sir, as the Member has
pointed out, the hydroponics scheme is new to
Singapore. But the Member can see from the amount
of money which has been provided that more is
needed. Facilities for carrying out the projects
are being organised, equipment is being purchased,
and more staff is being recruited. Hence the bigger
vote.
I am not very optimistic that we can help the
farmers very soon, but it is estimated that within
two years, after results of certain findings are
made available for dissemination to the farming
community, and if the Department is satisfied that
the information released would enable the farmers
to operate hydroponics on a profitable commercial
basis, then hydroponics will have come to stay with
us. I am afraid that at the moment it is still very
much in the experimental stage.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin: I beg leave to withdraw my
amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 93 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 301.
Sir, I just wish to seek further information on
the question of providing the necessary fishing
training facilities by the Fishing Training Centre.
How many courses have been conducted and how many
trainees have passed out to date? Has the Fishing
Training Centre encountered any difficulties in
recruiting the necessary trainees?
Column: 1216
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, two training
courses have so far been completed at the Fishing
Training Centre at Changi. The first course was
from August to October 1969, and the second course
was from December last year to February this
year. A third course will be started in April this
year, that is to say, next month.
There has been no difficulty in recruiting
students. There were 60 places for the two courses
- in other words, 30 places for each course. More
than 400 youths applied for training. To date, 42
trainees have completed the course successfully,
and 75 per cent of them have already found jobs on
fishing vessels. The rest are likely to be taken up
for employment by fishing companies in the near
future.
Reports received show that the fishing companies
are satisfied with the work of the trainees.
6.30 p.m.
In addition to these three-month courses to
which I have referred, the Fishing Training Centre
conducted a one-week course in January for captains
of small trawling vessels to give them some up-to-date knowledge of navigation and chart reading, as
well as modern fishing methods and use of fishing
gear. Forty-five persons applied for the course,
but only 38 were taken. Thirty-five completed the
course and are now back on their jobs.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Minister
has mentioned just now that there were 400
applicants for 60 places. In view of the large
number of applicants for such a training course, I
would enquire of the Minister if he would consider
taking in as many applicants as possible for such
courses, because at the moment we have quite a
large number of fishing trawlers.
Some time ago the Minister for Finance made a
remark in this House that our youths could not
withstand the training at sea. Therefore, in view
of the, large, number of applications for these
courses, would the Minister not.
Column: 1217
consider opening the door wider so that more
youths could come forward to play their part? And
what future prospects do these trainees have in
this respect?
Sir, I also feel that more publicity should be
given to this matter as I strongly support the
setting up of such training facilities.
Mr Barker: Sir, we would be happy to take more
on if we could take more on. But the facilities are
limited - one training vessel - and hence only 30
have been taken per course. The course is for three
months only. But if that is the way we carry on,
all the 400 who applied will have to wait a few
years before they get in. I do not know the exact
details, but I will look into the suggestion of the
Member to see whether more courses can be conducted
or more trainees will be allowed to attend per
course.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, I must thank the Minister for
his kind consideration, and I do beg leave to
withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr Ng
Kah Ting -
(8) That the total sum to be allocated for Head
93 be reduced by $100.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not moving, Sir.
The sum of $2,457,020 for Head 93 ordered to stand
part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1217
Head 94 -
The following amendments stood on the Order Paper
Supplement:
Mr Ng Yeow Chong:
(1) That the sum to be allocated for Head 94 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 201.
Mr Ng Kah Ting :
(2) That the sum to be allocated for Head 94 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 211.
(3) That the total sum to be allocated for
Head 94 be reduced by $100.
Column: 1218
The Chairman: Mr Ng Yeow Chong, amendment No. (1).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: I am not moving, Sir.
The Chairman: Mr Ng Kah Ting, amendment No. (2).
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not moving both amendments
Nos. (2) and (3), Sir.
The sum of $1,703,300 for Head 94 ordered to stand
part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1218
Head 95 -
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 95 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 201.
Sir, this item concerns the Pan-Island Expressway,
and I have only one question to ask. Will the
Minister consider developing a coastal road round
the island?
Mr E. W. Barker: Mr Speaker. Sir, the whole transport
system in Singapore is at present being studied by
a team of United Nations consultants and our local
counterparts at the State and City Planning
Department. There is no plan for a coastal road
right round the island. All I can offer the Member
is a plan for a new coastal road linking the east
coast to the city. This is the only positive
proposal under active consideration.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 95 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 206.
Sir, one item of this vote is for Sembawang Road
Improvement (10 m.s. to 13 m.s.). I think this
stretch of Sembawang Road includes a road in the
Nee Soon area. Since this road improvement project
involves two constituencies, I think the Member
for Nee Soon, who is now here, would also like to
express his views on this project.
Column: 1219
Sir, I have several questions to ask and I would
like the Minister to pay special attention to what
I am going to say. This project for extension of
roads has affected 40-odd shops and private houses.
May I ask, when will this project start? The second
question is: how does the Government propose to
deal with the shops and dwelling houses affected by
this project? The third question is: what
compensation is the Government prepared to pay
them, and in what form?
Mr Barker: Sir, the Member can rest assured that I
pay particular attention to his remarks. I always
do!
The Sembawang Road to City System is divided into
two sections: (1) a proposed improvement of the
road from 10 m.s to 13 m.s. The project costs
about $560,000. (2) The proposed improvement and
widening of Upper Thomson Road - from Braddell
Circus to the 6½ m.s. Upper Thomson Road. The
project costs $800,000.
In view of the increasing industrial expansion in
Sembawang, proposals are under consideration to
make Sembawang Road into a major dual carriageway
to serve the future development in that area. A
census is now being taken of the number of families
that will be affected, and a preliminary estimate
is that about 476 families may be affected, of whom
about 100 are shopkeepers. How do we resettle them
and where will we resettle them? How? With the help
of the Member for Sembawang. Where? We are building
a housing estate complex along Thomson Road where
we hope to rehouse persons occupying houses along
the road, whether residents or shopkeepers. At the
moment, the housing complex is not ready. Perhaps
in two years' time, when the complex is ready, we
may be able to house all, if not most, of the
Member's evicted constituents in this housing
complex. When the time comes, I will need the help
of the Member for Sembawang.
Column: 1220
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, of course,
if the Minister's request is reasonable, I will
lend my full support. But I would like to raise two
further questions. The Minister seems to have
omitted answering my question: when will this
project start? The Minister has also mentioned the
housing complex at Thomson Road, and I think the
Member for Thomson will be interested in this. My
second question is: when will the resettlement of
the affected residents and shopkeepers take place?
Will it be before or after the completion of this
housing complex at Thomson Road?
Mr Barker: I am sorry for not answering all the
Member's questions. He asked so many questions that
I am afraid I forgot to answer some of them.
The Member can rest assured that most of the
occupants will not have to move until we have
alternative accommodation for them.
The complex I referred to is a complex which is
to be built on a piece of land near the Home of the
Little Sisters of the Poor. Work has begun and most
of the complex should be ready by the end of this
year; but this is an estimate.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, I am
satisfied with the answers given, but I hope that
the staff concerned with this project will also pay
attention to the answers given by the Minister. I
beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ng Kah Ting -
(3) That the sum to be allocated for Head 95 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 302.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not moving, Sir.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ch'ng Jit Koon -
(4) That the sum to be allocated for Head 95 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
306.
Column: 1221
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon: I am not moving, Sir.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 95 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 310.
In moving this amendment, Sir, I am referring to
item 007 - not James Bond, of course - which
concerns Bus Bays, Shelters, Vehicle Parks and
Roadside Kerbs. This item has a provision of
$300,000. I would be grateful to the Minister if
he could inform this House whether any bus
shelters will be put up along Punggol Road this
year. I have made representations on this before,
and was told no funds were available and that I
was to be patient.
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, the programme for 1970-71 for the construction of bus shelters is now
under study. The need for more bus shelters in
Punggol will be investigated in consultation with
the Registrar of Vehicles, the Omnibus Services
Licensing Authority, and the P.W.D. At the moment,
I cannot promise the Member more bus shelters. All
I can say is that any application from Punggol
will be given every consideration.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: In view of the Minister's reply,
I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
6.45 p.m.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ng Kah Ting
That the total sum to be allocated for Head 95 be
reduced by $100.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, I am not moving.
The sum of $13,272,300 for Head 95 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1222
Head 96 -
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the total sum to be allocated for Head 96 be
reduced by $ 100*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ng Kah Ting.)
Mr Speaker, Sir, $2.3 million of the nearly $4.2
million provision under this head will be required
for the Bukit Timah Flood Alleviation, Phase I,
project. Under this head, it is very much
regretted that no provision whatsoever has been
made for Changi Constituency. As the Minister is
aware, Changi is a flood-affected area, especially
the Koh Sek Lim area. I think there is unfairness
in the allocation of funds under this head.
I know that many rich people live in the Bukit
Timah and Ulu Pandan areas. I also know that a
number of Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries
live in these areas too. We are a socialist
government and surely, whilst looking after the
rich people, we should also look after the poor
country folk and the farmers.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I share the
sentiments expressed by the Member for Changi. At
the same time, I wonder whether the Minister is
aware that the drainage and flood alleviation
system in certain areas in Punggol needs to be
attended to.
Sir, I bring up a somewhat new subject under this
topic "Drainage and Flood Alleviation". Whilst the
Government is taking steps to introduce schemes to
alleviate floods, etc., the private developer also
presents this problem. I have noticed two projects
in my constituency, at about the 6¾ milestone
opposite Upper Serangoon Road. They have their own
drainage systems in the private housing estates.
Very often the drains are constructed in such a
way that, instead of the outlets facing the main
road, they face inwards, towards low land.
Consequently, all waste and water just simply run
on to somebody else's land, and, worse still, the
residences in the neighbouring lands are affected.
I hope the Minister will look
Column: 1223
into this problem of drainage and see what steps
the private developers have to take to ensure that
the water in the estate does not drain into someone
else's land, This will prevent houses in the lower
area from being subject to flood hazards.
Mr E. W. Barker: Firstly, may I correct a
misapprehension which the Member for Changi appears
to be under when he refers to the Bukit Timah
scheme on which we are spending a total of
$2,330,700 for the first phase, the misapprehension
being that the richer people live in Bukit Timah
and under that heading he includes a few Ministers
who are not rich. But there are many kampongs in
Bukit Timah, and when the Bukit Timah canal floods,
the rich people are all right because they have two
houses - one in Tanglin and the other in Changi - and they move to Changi. But it is the poor people
who are affected and it is these people that we
have to rescue. Hence, this big canal scheme
diverting waters of the upper Bukit Timah Canal to
Ulu Pandan. As I have said before in this House,
work is in progress and it is anticipated that this
scheme will be completed by the end of this year.
It will not eliminate flooding in Bukit Timah, but
it will alleviate flooding along Bukit Timah. There
is no provision for Changi, and unless my experts
are wrong, there is no need to provide for Changi.
Changi had a bad flood on the 10th December, 1969,
but that was because a bund built as part of a
drainage system to hold water broke and, as a
result, the water flowed down a valley causing
floods.
As for Punggol, no provision has also been made
because flooding in Punggol is really very minor.
There is nothing serious - occasional minor floods
in certain lands at the 8th m.s., Punggol Road,
owing to the very low-lying nature of the land. You
have the Serangoon River and the swamps around it.
Occasionally flooding in such low-lying areas is, I
am afraid unavoidable.
Column: 1224
As to complaints against private developers, any
private developer who constructs or builds a
housing estate must have his plans approved by the
Chief Building Surveyor. Many Members have
complained of delays in the plans. One reason why
it takes a little time is that the plans have to go
to various departments - the Ministry of Health, the
Fire Brigade and, in the context of what the Member
for Punggol seeks, the Drainage Department of the
Public Works Department. So any, developer must
have had his plans approved, including plans for
his drainage. So if water flows into someone else's
land, the appropriate remedy is a complaint to the
Drainage Department of the P.W.D. Alternatively, an
action at law in our courts.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Point of clarification, Sir. The
drainage problem in one of the two places where
these new housing estates are coming up was
attended to by the Drainage Department of the
Public Works Department quite some time ago. The
point I am trying to drive home is whether the
Drainage Department of the Public Works Department
studies the drainage problem pertaining to a
proposed housing project. Will they not consider
this aspect that drains in the housing estate
should not divert into someone else's land? When
complaints come up, the private developers just
keep the matter in abeyance. Meanwhile, they go on
building houses, and who suffers? It is the
residents. In other words, it is the Drainage
Department of the P.W.D. that has to make sure that
the developers do not allow the drainage outlet to
go into someone else's lands which are low-lying.
Mr Barker: If the Member is speaking of the
development of the Hai Sing estate, as the Member
himself has put it, the matter has been settled.
If I have to repeat myself, water flows downhill
and not uphill. Sometimes with the permission of
adjoining landowners, drains are built But where
a housing estate is built and, as a result of the
bad drainage system, the water
Column: 1225
flows into and floods someone else's land, he has a
good cause of action in law. If he cannot obtain
sufficient satisfaction from the drainage engineer
of the Public Works Department or from the
developer, my advice to him would be to bring an
action in court for damages, for trespass and
nuisance.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I was not very expressive in
explaining to the Minister, but my question was
whether this drainage outlet should be allowed to
divert into someone else's land by the Drainage
Department of the P.W.D. My point was that this
should not be allowed, and therefore the drainage
outlet should be diverted outwards, even though
there are low-lying areas. Certainly you should
have a system whereby you allow a drop of so many
inches per length of, say, a hundred feet outward
onto the main road. Further, we have a scheme along
Tampines Canal. That area of Punggol which I am
discussing is rather low-lying, and all drainage
outlets that are directed to that area will
definitely flood it.
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am afraid I
cannot help the Member further, unless I visit the
place with him. But there are big drains, monsoon
drains, into which water from houses flow. There
are plenty of these drains in Tanglin. I do not
know the details of the cause of the complaint, and
I think it would be pointless carrying on this
debate here. The only thing for me to do would be
to visit the place with the Member and see whether
he or the Public Works Department or the developer
is right.
7.00 p.m.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like
to know whether the Minister agrees that the poor
people in Bukit Timah should be looked after. I
also hope that the villagers in Changi are also
looked after. Therefore. I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Column: 1226
The sum of $4,184,670 for Head 96 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1226
Head 97 -
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 97 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
104.
Sir, there is a provision of $1 million for the
Serangoon sewerage scheme. What I am going to bring
up is nothing new, because it is stated in the
Memorandum on the Development Estimates that the
project will have a capacity to serve 77,000
persons. I shall be grateful if the Minister will
enlighten this House on which particular area in
Serangoon will benefit by this project?
Mr E. W. Barker: Sir, the area approved for provision
of sewerage facilities in the Serangoon sewerage
scheme is approximately 1,300 acres bounded by
Upper Serangoon Road, Yio Chu Kang Road, Braddell
Road, Sungei Kallang and Serangoon Gardens Estate,
which means that Punggol is out. There is no
immediate plan to serve the Punggol area because of
its low density of population. But I have said
before in this House that the object of the
Government in the long-term is to provide sewerage
facilities throughout the island as far as is
possible. The day will come when we will reach
Punggol.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, the Minister has taken the
question out of my mouth. He mentions an area of
1,300 acres bounded by certain roads. In fact, I
notice that there are many septic tanks in a few
places within the area mentioned by the Minister.
In other words, there is already provision of
modern sanitation. With the extension of sewerage
facilities to Serangoon, can it not be extended to Upper Serangoon? The Minister says that Punggol
will have sewerage facilities later on. But the
area mentioned by the Minister is a congested area
and quite a number of housing estates are coming
up there
Column: 1227
There are septic tanks in this area. Are we doing
away with septic tanks and having the houses
connected direct to main sewers?
Mr Barker: No, we are not getting rid of septic
tanks. Obviously, the Member for Punggol cannot
take "No" for an answer. But I cannot say "Yes" if
the P.W.D. is not as yet ready to move into
Punggol.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, I can always take "No" for
an answer and can assure the Minister that the
answers given by him are satisfactory. I beg leave
to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $12,061,480 for Head 97 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1227
Head 98 -
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 98 be
reduced by $10 in respect of item 001 of subhead
101.
Sir, since 1966, about 82 miles of agricultural
and kampong roads have been constructed. I note
that only $400,000 is allocated for the financial
year 1970-71. Members who represent the rural
constituencies will agree with me that this amount
is inadequate, especially when kampong and
agricultural roads which were built two or three
years ago are now in a very deplorable condition.
Sir, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister
for National Development (National Development
Division), who is the Chairman of the Urban and
Rural Services Committee, has gone round Pulau
Tekong Besar with me, and he agrees that the roads
there are in a deplorable state. Sir, $400,000
will not be enough to build even one-quarter of
the roads. Therefore, I hope the Minister will
consider asking the Ministry of Finance to
allocate more
Column: 1228
money for the construction, improvement and
maintenance of agricultural roads in the rural
constituencies.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division) (Mr Ho Cheng Choon): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I quite agree that the amount of $400,000 provided
for the financial year 1970-71 for the construction, improvement and maintenance of agricultural
and kampong roads is not enough. But from past
experience, the Urban and Rural Services Committee
has decided that when a kampong road is to be
repaired and it costs a lot of money to do it,
then it should be done in two or three stages.
This has been the practice in the past few years.
In the financial year 1970-71, if the amount
provided for the construction, improvement and
maintenance of kampong roads is not enough, there
are many items under this subhead which are
transferable. For instance, if the provision for
extension of electricity supply has not been
spent, we can transfer this amount and use it for
the repair of kampong roads.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Sir, I hope my suggestion will
be seriously looked into. And in view of the
Parliamentary Secretary's explanation, I beg leave
to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 98 be
reduced by $10 in respect of item 011 of subhead
101*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ho Kah Leong.)
Sir, with the removal of public stand-pipes in
the rural constituencies, I hope that the Ministry
concerned can give immediate approval for the
laying of water mains so that the people living
there can have their own supply of water. When a
project for the laying of water mains costs over
$30,000, it is the usual practice of the Urban and
Rural Services Committee to defer it.
Column: 1229
And their excuse is that there are not many houses
in that particular area to justify the laying of
water mains.
Sir, I wish to state one case in Kampong Darat
Nanas in Jalan Bena in my constituency. My
Citizens' Consultative Committee and I made a
request five years ago for the extension of water
supply to this place. But to date, the request has
still been deferred. We agree that public stand-pipes should be removed and the people should know
that water means life. But if we are to remove
something from the people, we have to substitute
another thing in place thereof. Therefore, it is a
matter of how we should implement the policy. I
hope the Ministry concerned can give consideration
to my suggestion.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I fully support what the Member for Changi has
said, because a supply of water is very essential
to the people in the rural areas. The Member has
said that if there are few dwelling houses in a
remote rural area, then the Urban and Rural
Services Committee does not consider it worth while
to lay water mains in that area. In the Development
Estimates, there is a provision of $1 million for
the extension of water supply. I hope the
Parliamentary Secretary will consider extending the
supply of water to remote rural areas.
7.15 p.m.
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: Mr Speaker, Sir, in reply to
the Member for Changi, I wish to say that it is
true that two requests for the laying of water
mains have been made and that the matter has been
deferred for quite some time. However, I can assure
him that we have been provided with more money for
the supply of water mains this year. His request
will therefore be given due consideration.
Sir, I explained yesterday the procedure
regarding the removal of stand-pipes. Perhaps I can
explain further how the position stands at the
moment. On 31st December, 1966, there were 2,471
stand-pipes. By 31st December,
Column: 1230
1969, there were only 1,088 stand-pipes left.
Therefore, within a period of three years we have
removed 1,383 stand-pipes. From this figure, Sir,
it can clearly be seen that we have spent quite a
lot of money on the laying of water mains in order
that the rural people can connect water mains to
individual households. Since we have been provided
with more money for the supply of water mains in
this year's estimates, more and more of them will
be laid, especially in the rural areas.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Mr Speaker. Sir, I just do not
understand the Parliamentary Secretary when he said
just now that by cutting down the number of public
stand-pipes, a greater amount of money has been
spent. What is the logic behind this statement? Can
he clarify?
Mr Ho Cheng Choon : To give an example, Sir, I
have a list of requests for the laying of water
mains in the rural and urban, or suburban areas
which have not been approved by the Urban and Rural
Services Committee. For instance, there was a stand-pipe at Jalan Darat Nanas in Changi. After its
removal, we have to lay a water main there at a
cost of $12,000. This is a bigger main than the one
available to supply water to the individual
households in that area. The water main for
ordinary stand-pipes is only two inches in
diameter. We have to change it to four or six
inches in diameter water mains in order to supply
more water to the individual households.
The Chairman: Do you understand now, Mr Sim?
Mr Sim Boon Woo: I still do not understand the
way it is answered. I stand to be corrected, Sir,
but is it correct to say that by cutting down the
number of public stand-pipes and putting bigger
water mains in, a lot of money is spent?
An hon. Member: I think you have got it right!
Column: 1231
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Sir, this is not the point
which I raised. When you take something from the
people, you must substitute another thing in its
place.
The Chairman: That is what the Parliamentary
Secretary has said, Mr Sim. He says that more
water mains have been laid so that more houses
will now get water.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am not
very happy with the answer. I am not
withdrawing.
Question on the amendment put, and negatived.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 98 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 101*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ng Kah Ting.)
Mr Speaker, Sir, there is a provision of $2.3
million against the title "Urban and Rural
Services". I would like to ask a few questions.
It seems that there is a reduction in the
provision for the rural areas. If we compare the
provision made for Sembawang Constituency a few
years ago and the sum allotted now, we see that
there is a reduction of about 80 per cent in the
provision. I believe this is true for all the
rural areas, for example, Changi, Nee Soon and
Thomson Constituencies. We must provide an
adequate amount of money for facilities in the
rural areas. Amenities of many kinds are
provided in the city area and we should not
spend too much money there. I would like the
Parliamentary Secretary to make more provision
for the rural areas.
Under item 011 there is a provision of $1
million for the extension of water supply. Many
stand-pipes have been removed by the Government.
However, before they were removed, water mains
should have been laid so that the installation
of waterpipes to the individual households would
be facilitated.
Column: 1232
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: Mr Speaker, Sir, on a
point of order. I have already replied to the
question on water mains.
The Chairman: Have you finished, Mr Teong?
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Not yet,
Sir, I have another question. Although the
Parliamentary Secretary may have answered the
question raised by other Members, I am concerned
with Sembawang Constituency. It is a different
proposition. There is a road called Jalan Pasar
Sembawang. About 100 families live along this
road. The people here used to have stand-pipes,
but these have now been removed. We have made
representations to the U.R.S.C. but approval has
not been given for their replacement. The
residents have complained to me about it. I
would like the Parliamentary Secretary to pay
special attention to their request and that it
will be approved by the U.R.S.C.
Mr Ng Kah Ting : I am not speaking, Sir.
Mr Ho Cheng Choon : Mr Speaker, Sir, the
Member for Sembawang has said that the provision
allocated to the rural constituencies has been
reduced. In the past, before the number of
constituencies was increased, there were only
the following constituencies: Bukit Panjang,
Bukit Timah, Changi, Choa Chu Kang, Jalan Kayu,
Jurong, Nee Soon, Punggol, Sembawang and
Tampines. But after changes in the
constituencies were made, Kampong Chai Chee also
joined their ranks. The allocation for the
constituencies is made on this basis: 10 per
cent for 32 urban constituencies, 35 per cent
for 15 suburban constituencies and 55 per cent
for 11 rural constituencies.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: It is not enough.
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: If the Member concerned
says that it is not enough, the right thing to
do is to complain to the Ministry of Finance.
Column: 1233
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Come on, do not pass the buck!
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: Sir, on this basis of
allocation, only 10 per cent is for 32
constituencies. It is true that quite a large sum
of money was not spent during past years. However,
beginning from this financial year, we are trying
to divert this money into beautifying the urban
areas and also the rural areas if applications are
submitted for this purpose.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: We are not interested!
Mr Ho Cheng Choon: Regarding the laying of water
mains in Sembawang Constituency, as mentioned by
the Member just now, the matter may still be in the
hands of the Public Utilities Board. I have not
received the application yet.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, I am not
quite satisfied with the answer given by the
Parliamentary Secretary. I would like to give an
example and I wish him to explain the position.
Three years ago the vote for Sembawang Constituency
was about $100,000. Last year the vote was only
$18,000. This is a reduction of 80 per cent. I
would like the Parliamentary Secretary to make a
calculation himself and see how much reduction in
the provision has been made.
The Chairman: The Member will notice that the 12
months' provision for 1970-71 adds up to more than
the 15 months' provision for 1969-70. On that
issue, will the Member withdraw his amendment?
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): I am not
prepared to withdraw my amendment.
Question on the amendment put, and negatived.
The sum of $2,300,000 for Head 98 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1233
Head 101 -
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
Column: 1234
That the sum to be allocated for Head 101 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 101.
Sir, I am glad to note that the Institute of
Medical Specialities has passed through Phase I and
that the Centre is now in operation. But then
Parliament is being asked to provide for Phase II
of the project which costs slightly more than
$200,000.
7.30 p.m.
Sir, I would be grateful if the Minister for
Health could elaborate on the type of specialized
units that we are going to set up in Phase II of
the Institute of Medical Specialities. Sir, I am
told that some specialists are fighting over the
question of priority of specialization. If this is
true, can the Minister say whether his Ministry has
encountered any difficulties in setting up this
Institute?
The Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Sir, as the Member for Punggol has said, Phase I of
the Institute of Medical Specialities has been
completed, and it was officially opened by me on
23rd February, 1970. That is the Radiotherapy
Isotope Centre consisting of two cobalt units.
The Member has asked me about Phase II of the
Institute of Medical Specialities. May I say that
Phase II consists of the main building which will
house other specialities. Building plans have been
drawn up and estimates, of course, made. Planning
approval, however, is still awaited, and this is
not expected to be given until the concept and cost
of the Institute is reviewed.
The Member might have heard that I have appointed
a Ministerial Committee on Medical Specialization,
which will be making its recommendations on the
priorities of the specialities to be established.
Before this Committee makes its recommendations, I
would not like to say in this House what the
specialities are that will be established, as it
will only prejudice the work of this Committee on
Medical Specialities.
Column: 1235
The Member also did say that he had heard that
there are difficulties because the specialists are
fighting among themselves over the question of
which speciality should be developed first. I would
like to put it this way. It is only natural that
every specialist would like his speciality to be
developed first. That is one of the reasons why I
have appointed this Committee on Medical
Specialization. It will make recommendations to me
on the order of priority of the specialities to be
developed in Singapore.
Perhaps, Sir, it will interest the Member for
Punggol if I say something about this Committee on
Medical Specialization. May I refer him to its
terms of reference? Its first term of reference is
to investigate the extent of development of medical
specialization in the hospitals and, after
consideration of such development, to recommend a
programme of development or the creation of a few
specialities, listing them in order of priority for
selection. The basis of selection is as follows:
(a) that the specialities should meet the needs
of Singapore;
(b) that they can be developed to achieve
eminence, so that Singapore will be recognised
regionally and internationally as a centre of
treatment, training and research.
The Committee's second term of reference is to
estimate the cost of development or creation of
some specialities and the personnel required.
First, let me explain that the development of
medical specialization in Singapore is a costly
business. Funds will not only be needed for the
training and employment of the necessary staff, but
also for the acquiring of more up-to-date
equipment. The maintenance of this modern and
sophisticated equipment is just as costly. It is
therefore obvious, Mr Speaker, Sir, that it is
beyond the resources of a small country like
Singapore to develop the entire
Column: 1236
range of specialities. The Committee has therefore
been asked, in its terms of reference which I have
mentioned just now, to select a few specialities,
listing them in order of priority for all-out
development. As its terms of reference specify, the
Committee in making the selection must bear in mind
two factors: (1) that development of such a
speciality will meet the needs of Singapore; (2)
taking into consideration our existing and
projected resources both of staff and finance, and
whether or not the development of the specialities
recommended can reasonably achieve a level of
eminence so that Singapore can be recognised
regionally and internationally as a centre of
treatment, training and research. In other words,
with such development, Singapore will be recognised
as one of the world's centres of excellence in
medicine.
I must say here, Sir, that the task of the
Committee is certainly not an easy one. It has to
make a difficult choice in listing the priorities
from among the competing claims for support for
future development among the many specialities. It
will have to exercise impartial and objective
judgment in making its choice, bearing in mind the
terms of reference.
The Member has perhaps seen the membership of the
Committee. But what I would like to say is that the
members of the Committee have been very carefully
selected, so that those who are on the Committee
will not have a vested interest in development of
any particular speciality. Moreover, the membership
also brings with it a wide range of expertise of
various backgrounds, talents and interests. Besides
medical men, they also include businessmen,
administrators and economists.
Lastly, may I say that this Committee has so far
made good progress, having received numerous
memoranda from our heads of units and members of
the medical profession. Sir, here I would like to
refer to the Budget statement made by the Minister
for Finance on
Column: 1237
9th March, 1970, and I quote from Hansard, Vol. 29,
col. 496, first paragraph, last sentence:
'A committee is investigating and identifying
those areas of medical specialisation in which
Singapore could achieve pre-eminence by providing
available medical expertise with the latest in
equipment and facilities.'
This statement of the Minister for Finance, Sir, is
indeed most encouraging. For the doctors and
specialists in my Ministry, this statement clearly
indicates that funds will be forthcoming from the
Treasury, when the recommendations of the Committee
are adopted.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Sir, this is indeed a very
encouraging reply, and I must admit that I have no
knowledge of what the composition of the Committee
is like. In any case, I must say I am very happy
with the detailed reply given by the Minister, and
I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 101 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 605.
Sir, this subhead concerns "Refuse Treatment and
Disposal Plants", and there is a token provision of
$10 as against nil for last year. I wish to bring
to the notice of the Minister for Health that the
Tampines dumping ground is a very unsatisfactory
place. No doubt it has been the refuse dumping
ground for several years. I wonder what steps the
Minister will take, with only a token provision of
$10, in regard to refuse treatment and disposal
plants. I assume his Ministry is exploring the
possibility of buying some disposal plants, so that
the disposal of trade refuse and other rubbish can
be done in a much more hygienic way than the
present measures taken at the Tampines dumping
ground.
I bring this matter up because I have received
many complaints from my constituents that all
manner of rubbish is being dumped there. This
causes a stench in certain areas in Punggol, and
during the recent drought there were
Column: 1238
some outbreaks of fire. In this respect, Sir, I
would be grateful if the Minister could indicate to
this House what his plans are for the treatment of
refuse and disposal plants.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Sir, I fully sympathise with
the Member for Punggol because the biggest dumping
ground in Singapore is situated in his
constituency. Sir, in the nature of human activity,
there is always garbage to be disposed. That cannot
be helped, and therefore a method must be evolved
by the community to dispose of its garbage. To
quote one good example of the presence of garbage
whenever there is human activity. Last year man
first landed on the moon and, as you know, when the
astronauts left the moon they also left some
garbage behind.
I agree with the Member that the site of the
refuse dumping ground at Tampines is
unsatisfactory, especially because of its nuisance
potential. The method of refuse disposal at that
site by dumping refuse directly into the swamp not
only causes water pollution but also a smell
nuisance due to the decomposition of the refuse.
Hence the complaints from his constituents. Flies
and other vermin breed in the refuse and
insecticides have to be used to control such
breeding. From the big mass of rotting refuse,
various gases of decomposition evolve, including
methane gas which is highly inflammable when mixed
with air. As a result of such mixture of methane
gas and air you get instantaneous combustion and
fires consequently break out. That, I think, is the
reason for the fires in the dumping ground, as
complained by the Member for Punggol.
There are newer methods of refuse disposal, and
my Ministry at the moment is considering the
following ways of handling the 1,200 tons per day
of refuse currently produced in Singapore. First,
to acquire an incinerator to dispose of 900 tons of
refuse per day, and ancillary equipment to utilise
the waste heat to produce high
Column: 1239
pressure steam for generating electricity, thus
providing some economic return from the burning of
refuse.
7.45 p.m.
The second method is to build two refuse
compaction plants to handle the remaining 300 tons
of refuse per day by compressing the refuse into
high-density bales measuring about one cubic yard
each, which could be used for reclaiming swamp
land. The ground thus reclaimed can be developed
for use by light-weight structures. In order that
there will be an alternative refuse disposal method
available should any of the aforementioned plants
break down, we have also to provide a disposal area
for the ash and clinker from the incinerator, and
an adequately equipped refuse dumping ground
properly operated on the sanitary land-fill method
will also have to be maintained. This will,
however, be a very small one. I do not know where
it will be - perhaps Punggol or somewhere else. As
I have said, it will be a small one and it will be
more hygienically operated. I hope that will
satisfy the Member for Punggol.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am indeed satisfied with the
Minister's reply and I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 101 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead
703.
Sir, in moving this amendment, I wish to seek
clarification on the development of and improvement
to markets and hawkers' sites. Will the Minister
for Health indicate the sites where such
development of and improvement to markets will take
place?
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, yesterday I asked the Minister two questions
on the vote for hawkers, but the Minister did not
reply to one of my questions because of the lack of
time. Therefore, I feel that
Column: 1240
since the question I raised yesterday has some
relationship to this vote, i.e., "Development of
and Improvement to Markets and Hawkers' Sites" --
The Chairman: If questions during the last few
days were not answered because of "guillotine"
time, and Members want them answered today, the
debate on this vote will never end.
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, what I want to ask is quite relevant to the
item here.
The Chairman: We have another few more minutes.
If you like, you can carry on but the Minister will
not be able to reply.
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, what I want to say is that the Hawkers
Department and the Housing and Development Board
have been discussing the question of taking over of
hawkers' sites. I hope they have come to some
agreement on the matter.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, it is not
that I did not want to reply to the Member for
Tiong Bahru yesterday, but I was "guillotined". May
I say that the Member has brought up a quite
relevant question. The matter is under
consideration between my Ministry and the Housing
and Development Board. We are quite willing to hand
over the markets in the Housing and Development
Board estates to the Housing and Development Board,
but there are certain snags. For example, the
Ministry of Finance will want the markets to be
sold to the Housing and Development Board. Of
course, it simply means transferring money from one
pocket to another, but certain arrangements will
have to be made between the Government and the
Housing and Development Board before the control of
these markets can be taken over by the Board.
The Member for Punggol wants to know about the
plans for resiting, and development of and
improvement to hawkers' sites, for which a sum of
$150,000 has been provided under this subhead 703.
Of this sum, $50,000 is
Column: 1241
a revote in respect of projects planned but not
implemented last year, owing to funds being made
available late.
First, the resiting of hawkers. Part of the
revote will be used for resiting of hawkers planned
last year in respect of the following areas:
(a) Cluny Road;
(b) Yew Tee Village, that is the side-lanes;
(c) Clemenceau Village-Bukit Timah Road;
(d) Onraet Road; and
(e) Jalan Mat Jambol, off Pasir Panjang Road.
In addition to this, a sum from this year's vote
will be used for the resiting of hawkers in 12
constituencies. These constituencies will be chosen
on the basis of the urgency with which the hawkers
there need to be resited, i.e., how much
obstruction they are causing, and under what
sanitary conditions they are currently operating,
etc.
Concerning the development of hawkers' sites, I
wish to say that new hawkers' sites will be
developed, if necessary. As I have mentioned
earlier, if land is available in the 12
constituencies, the funds allocated for the
resiting of hawkers will be used for that purpose.
As regards the improvement of hawkers' sites, the
funds remaining in the revote will be used for the
improvement of:
(a) Geylang Serai Market; that is, (1) covering
of pitches; and (2) improvement to lighting;
(b) Seng Poh Market; that is, improvement of bin
compartments; and
(c) Taman Jurong Market; that is, washing
platforms.
The funds provided in this year's vote will also
be utilised to:
(a) cover pitches at
(1) Bukit Ho Swee - four.
(2) Queenstown - three.
(3) Queenstown - four.
Column: 1242
(b) carry out improvements to markets as follows:
(1) Upper Serangoon Market. Provision of
stalls for pork and fish licences and
chain link fence and gates.
(2) Jalan Eunos Market. Paving of open areas
for licensed pitches.
(3) Cambridge Road Market. Repairing poultry
slaughtering yards and bin compartments.
(4) Jalan Kayu Market. Repairs to office and
stalls.
(5) Bukit Panjang Market. Repairs to office and
poultry slaughtering yards.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the summary of development
costs under this subhead for 1970-71 is estimated
to be:
(a) Revote 50.000
(b) Resiting of hawkers 120,000
(c) Covering of pitches 42,350
(d) Improvement to markets 36,150
--------
Total: $248,500
========
As the Member for Punggol will have noted, the
funds allocated for this subhead will be $98,500
short of what was requested. Several of the
improvements that I have earlier enumerated may
have to be shelved.
7.54 p.m.
The Chairman: It is "guillotine" time now, Mr
Chua.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The time allotted for Head 101 having expired,
the following amendment, standing in the name of Mr Ng Kah Ting, was not proceeded with:
(4) That the total sum to be allocated for Head
101 be reduced by $100.
Column: 1243
The sum of $3,834,830 for Head 101 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
Column: 1243
Head 141 -
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ng Kah Ting -
That the sum to be allocated for Head 141 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 401.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: I am not moving, Sir.
The sum of $230,200 for Head 141 ordered to
stand part of the Development Estimates.
The Chairman: The remaining heads of expenditure
in respect of which no amendment stands on the
Order Paper Supplement are Heads 54, 72, 73, and
82. I propose to take those heads of expenditure
en bloc.
Question, "That the sums stated for those heads
of expenditure which appear in the last column of
the Summary of Estimated Expenditure on pages 5
and 6 of Paper Cmd. 5 of 1970 stand part of the
Development Estimates for the financial year 1st
April, 1970, to 31st March, 1971," put, and agreed
to.
Question, "That the sum of $438,556,420 shall be
supplied to the Government under the heads of
expenditure for the public services shown in
Column: 1244
the Development Estimates for the financial year
1st April, 1970, to 31st March, 1971, contained in
Paper Cmd. 5 of 1970," put, and agreed to.
Resolution to be reported.
Thereupon Mr Speaker left the Chair of the
Committee and took the Chair of the House.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
report that the Committee of Supply has come to a
certain resolution.
Resolution reported -
That the sum of $438,556,420 shall be supplied
to the Government under the heads of expenditure
for the public services shown in the Development
Estimates for the financial year 1st April,
1970, to 31st March, 1971, contained in Paper
Cmd. 5 of 1970.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Sir, I beg to move, "That
Parliament doth agree with the Committee on the
said resolution."
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolution accordingly agreed to.
Column: 1244
ADJOURNMENT
Resolved,
"That Parliament do now adjourn." -[Mr Chua Sian Chin].
Adjourned accordingly at
Two minutes to Eight o'clock p.m. to
Monday, 30th March, 1970.