| Parliament No: | 2 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 30 |
| Sitting No: | 15 |
| Sitting Date: | 23-03-1971 |
|
Column: 1047
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
FIRST SESSION OF THE SECOND PARLIAMENT
PART IV OF FIRST SESSION |
VOLUME 30 |
Tuesday, 23rd March, 1971
The House met at 2.30 pin.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Dr Yeoh Ghim Seng, B.B.M., J.P. (Joo Chiat)).
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang).
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development and Leader of the House.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh).
Dr Chiang Hai Ding (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (MacPherson), Minister for Health.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong).
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah).
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division).
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Hon Sui Sen, D.U.B.C. (Havelock), Minister for Finance.
Mr Hwang Soo Tin (Jalan Kayu).
Column: 1048
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Minister of State for Education.
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah).
Mr Lim Kim San, D.U.T. (Cairnhill), Minister for Education.
Mr Low Guan Onn (River Valley).
Inche Mohd. Ghazali Bin Ismail (Aljunied), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon).
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Communications.
Tuan Haji Rahmat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Labour.
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Potong Pasir).
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs.
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee).
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang).
Inche Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampong Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Minister of State for Labour and Government Whip.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan (Whampoa).
Column: 1049
Mr Tang See Chim (Choa Chua Kang), Minister of State for Finance.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Minister of State of Defence.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken, B.B.M. (Alexandra), Minister for Home Affairs.
Mr Yeo Choo Kok (Delta).
Mr Yeo Toon Chia (Kampong Kapor).
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications.
ABSENT:
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister of Defence.
Column: 1050
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford).
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister.
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology.
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampong Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Column: 1049
PERMISSION TO MEMBERS TO BE ABSENT
Under the provisions of clause 2 (d) of Article
30 of the Constitution of Singapore, I have
granted permission to the following Members to be
or to remain absent from sittings of Parliament
(or any Committee of Parliament to which they have been appointed) for the periods stated:
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister on 23rd March, 1971.
Column: 1050
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu) - from 30th March to 1st April, 1971.
| | YEOH GHIM SENG |
| | Speaker, |
| | Parliament of Singapore |
Column: 1049
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
COMMITTEE OF SUPPLY
(Announcement by Mr Speaker)
Mr Speaker: In accordance with the provisions of
paragraph (5) of Standing Order 88 and paragraph
(7) of Standing Order 87, I have for the
Development Estimates of Singapore for the
financial year 1st April, 1971, to 31st March,
1972, fixed the times on the allotted days, namely,
the 25th and 26th of
Column: 1050
March, 1971, at which consideration of the heads of
expenditure in respect of which amendments stand on
the Order Paper Supplement shall, if not previously
disposed of, be concluded. These times have been
notified to hon. Members and will appear in the
Official Report*.
(*Appendix, cols. 1153-4.)
Appendix to Speaker's Announcement (Cols. 1049-50) (Cols 1153-1154)
Mr Speaker: I believe the first Question* has been postponed to tomorrow.
(* This Question appears as Question No. 2 in Cols. 1158-61)
The Minister of State for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim) (for the Minister for Finance): Yes.
Column: 1051
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
PRICE INCREASES OF DAILY
FOODSTUFFS
(Committee of inquiry)
2. Mr Yeo Toon Chia asked the Minister for
Finance if he will consider setting up a committee
to inquire into the reasons for the increases in
the prices of daily foodstuffs in recent months in
order to ensure that the public are not cheated by
market stall-holders and shopkeepers.
Mr Tang See Chim (for the Minister for Finance): Mr Speaker, Sir, it is not proposed to set up a
committee to inquire into the reasons for price
increases in recent months. As I already explained
in some detail on Friday, in Singapore where a
substantial proportion of daily foodstuffs are
imported, prices are subject to fluctuations in
supply. For some items the price increases in
December/January are seasonal, due to the festive
season.
Where the main fluctuations in prices are due to
such factors as mentioned above, a committee on
prices cannot exert any influence on prices. This
point was discussed by the then Minister for
Finance [Dr Goh Keng Swee] in December 1968 when
the same question was raised.
What is possibly more useful is the formation of a
Consumers' Association to keep watch on price
movements and to ensure that prices of essential
foodstuffs are not manipulated by unscrupulous
stallholders and shopkeepers and any such
malpractices are detected and publicised. It is
understood that there is a move for such an
association -- the Consumers' Association of
Singapore - to be registered. The Government,
Column: 1052
on its part, will give every assistance to
the Consumers' Association and will do everything
possible to curb unwarranted price increases.
There have been some remarks in Parliament
regarding the reliability of official prices used
in the compilation of the Consumer Price Index. A
full list of the average retail prices of essential
foodstuffs is published in the Monthly Digest of
Statistics regularly and the study of fluctuation
in the prices will clearly indicate that official
prices do properly reflect price fluctuations
experienced by the public.
Column: 1052
TRAFFIC POLICE SUMMONS NOTICES
(Delay in issue)
3. Mr Low Guan Onn asked the Minister for Home
Affairs (a) if he will give the reason for the
delay of over one year in the issue by the Traffic
Police of a summons notice in respect of a 13-month
old traffic offence; and (b) what is the backlog of
such cases, and if he will take steps to remedy
the, situation.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs (Mr L. P. Rodrigo) (for the Minister for Home Affairs): Mr Speaker, Sir, normally, if
the personal particulars of the offending driver
are available on the spot and if the offence is
compoundable, an offer of composition will be sent
to him within two weeks of the offence. If the
offer is not accepted by the driver after a period,
action by way of summons will be instituted against
him.
However, there are many cases of traffic
violations where the particulars of the offenders
are not obtainable on the spot by the Traffic
Police. In these cases, some time is spent in
obtaining the particulars of the owner of the
vehicle from the Registrar of Vehicles, and
thereafter, the particulars of the driver at the
time of the alleged offence from the owner. Often
reminders have to be sent to the vehicle owners.
Column: 1053
When the particulars of the driver are finally
obtained, it will take some time before an offer of
composition is sent to him. If the offer is not
accepted, the case will be further delayed in that
some more time will have to be spent in obtaining a
summons from the court.
There are also difficulties in effecting the
service of summons. In many cases, accused drivers
change addresses without notifying the National
Registration Office and the Registrar of Vehicles
of these changes, although required by the law to
do so. Hence an accused driver may receive his
summons for an offence committed one year ago.
At the moment, there is a backlog of approximately
21,500 traffic cases, all more than a year old,
waiting for the issue of summonses.
However, a ticketing system will soon be
implemented to deal with traffic offenders more
effectively and expeditiously. Under the new
system, a ticket will be issued to the offending
driver on the spot stipulating the amount of fine
which he has to pay at the Report Section, Traffic
Police, within two weeks from the date of the
offence. The necessary amendments to the Traffic
Ordinance have been made and, as soon as the
mechanics of the ticketing system as well as the
rules governing it have been finalised, it will be
put into operation.
In the meantime, measures are being taken to
process the backlog of traffic cases more rapidly
without at the same time causing a drag on the pile
of current cases.
Mr Low Guan Onn (River Valley): Sir, will the
Traffic Police give them a target date to finish
all the 21,000 cases.
Mr Rodrigo: Sir, that is hardly possible. All
that my Ministry can say is that specific measures
are being taken by additional manpower to try to
reduce this backlog as rapidly as possible.
Column: 1054
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah): Sir, may I know
what is the maximum amount for a compoundable
traffic offence?
Mr Rodrigo: Sir, the maximum amount for
compoundable cases is $50 at the moment.
Mr Ho See Beng: Does this amount of $50 apply to
all types of offences, or does it apply only to a
particular type of compoundable traffic offence?
Mr Rodrigo: Sir, this sum of $50 is the maximum
amount for an offer of composition. The amount set
on a particular offence will depend on the type of
offence.
Column: 1054
ESTIMATES OF EXPENDITURE FOR FINANCIAL YEAR
1ST APRIL, 1971, TO 31ST MARCH, 1972
Order read for resumed consideration in Committee
of Supply [4th Allotted Day].
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
2.39 p.m.
Head 1101 -
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1101 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1001*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Cheong Yuen Chee.)
Sir, I am moving this amendment in order to seek
some clarification of the policy of the Ministry,
it is with some temerity that I do so, as I am
fully aware that the housing programme of the
Housing and Development Board has been accorded
world-wide acclaim. The Housing Board's
achievements dominate the low profile of
Singapore's skyline with the presence of more than
a hundred thousand housing units, many of them in
blocks of high-rise flats which the Board has put
up since its inception. The magnitude of the
Board's achievements
Column: 1055
can be further gauged by the fact that nearly
30 per cent of our population are housed in the
Board's flats. We are given to understand that the
Board is constantly making plans to catch up with
the past accumulated demand, and coping with future
anticipated demand for public housing.
Sir, all these heart-warming data, plus the proud
claim that the Board is building one unit per every
half-hour, undoubtedly make for a very effective
advertisement of Singapore's image abroad. However,
to the many thousands of citizens who are
unfortunate enough to be still on the waiting list
of the Board, they may wonder whether the housing
shortage is ever likely to be solved. It is not
uncommon to hear that an applicant has to wait for
as long as even one and a half years before he can
be housed. The only persons who are lucky enough to
move into the Board's flats without having to wait
their turn are those unfortunate, or rather
fortunate enough, to be evicted as a result of the
Government's development programme. In other words,
the popular impression seems to be that we build
houses only in sufficient numbers to meet the
requirements of the urban renewal scheme. Added
force is given to such impression by the fact that
the disposal to private developers of well located
plots of land vacated under the urban renewal
scheme has proved very profitable to the
Government. We in this House know that such an
impression, though invariably popular, is erroneous
and misconceived. A blunt denial, no matter how
authoritative, is not sufficient to counteract it.
A more concrete answer is required of the Board,
otherwise the purpose of the urban renewal scheme
will continue to be misconstrued. I understand and
appreciate the great strain being placed on the
Housing and Development Board as a result of the
spiralling increase in the prices of privately-built houses and the rents of privately-owned
houses. In addition, the decision to permit
purchase of the Board's flats by making use of the
Central Provident Fund contribution and the raising
of the maximum income limit
Column: 1056
on eligibility have helped to swell up the Board's
waiting list. Thus, if we continue at the present
rate of building just sufficient housing units to
take care of persons rendered homeless under the
urban renewal scheme, the waiting list for public
housing is likely to become longer rather than
shorter.
2.45 p.m.
What is worse is my fear that our building
programme may not even be able to keep up with the
urban renewal programme. Unless the Board is able
to step up its building programme, I do not think
there can be any satisfactory solution to the
problem of mounting pressure in the demand for
public housing as long as private housing remains
exorbitantly priced.
Another matter on which I require clarification is
the Ministry's urban renewal programme. I am sure
Members of this House are aware of the Telok
Blangah New Town project. This is to cover a vast
area of about 932 acres. That it is a tremendous
project cannot be denied, and in a project of such
dimensions, many problems and vexations are to be
expected. It is also to be expected that a great
deal of planning has to be thought out and many
preparatory measures in the form of land
acquisition and eviction of residents and
arrangement for their alternative accommodation
have to be carried out before the first pile of the
project can be sunk into the ground. My complaint
is directed not to the fact that such a project
will cause hardships for some of my constituents,
but to the fact that unnecessary hardship has been
caused. What is alarming is that the nature of such
hardship seems to indicate insufficient planning of
the project. The project was divided into several
phases of development. Thus, the process of land
acquisition and eviction of residents had been
effected in accordance with the order of
development of the various sections comprising the
project. Suddenly it was decided that the order of
development must shift from one section, where
eviction had already begun, to another section
which was originally to
Column: 1057
be the last phase of development. As a result,
there is considerable confusion and suffering among
the residents of the whole area, whether they
remain in or move out of the area. Chief tenants of
houses refuse to repair houses and the requests by
subtenants for Housing and Development Board
accommodation are denied as they are not deemed to
be evicted tenants as a result of the shift in
priorities. On the other hand, other residents who
are not supposed to move out until much later are
suddenly required to move at short notice. All
these unnecessary hardships could have been avoided
if the order of development had been properly
planned without having to make changes half-way
through the project.
Sir, people residing in an area prefer to remain
in it for various reasons. Some of them because of
their business associations, employment, children's
education, and others merely because of the social
contacts they have made.
The Chairman: You have one more minute, Mr
Govindasamy.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, in the case of the Telok
Blangah project, may I say that no such
consideration was given in planning it. Unnecessary
hardships could have been easily avoided if the
planning had been thorough and if the original plan
had not been changed, as I have mentioned earlier,
half-way through the project.
Mr Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh): Mr Speaker,
Sir, it is a well-known fact that the achievements
of the Housing and Development Board in public
housing have earned praise, both locally and
internationally. However, there are some matters
concerning public housing that require the
attention of the Minister. There are various
problems facing flat-owners and tenants in Toa
Payoh that give rise to irritations and
misunderstanding. One of this is the Housing
Board's attitude in prohibiting flat-owners from
making improvements to their own flats no matter
how minor they are. As a flat-owner surely one can
Column: 1058
be permitted to make improvements to enhance one's
own property provided such improvements do not
alter or damage the structure of the building. Flat-owners always have difficulties with the Housing
Board over the fitting of louvered windows, metal
grills, gate canopies and even colour schemes for
such fittings. As a matter of fact, the Board is
now taking legal action against several flat-owners
for installing louvered windows in preference to
the casement type installed by the Housing Board.
No one in his right senses would take the trouble
to make alterations to existing fittings or install
new fittings which obviously cost money if they do
not serve a useful purpose. If a flat-owner feels
that the fittings installed by the Housing Board
are not up to his expectations, he should be
allowed to change them. We should encourage flat-owners and tenants to keep the environment
attractive instead of discouraging them.
The other problem concerns defects like cracked
floors, cracked ceilings, and choked and leaking
pipes. Here the dispute is who should be
responsible for repairing such defects. The Board
maintains that if the occupier has been in
residence in a flat for more than six months, it is
not responsible for such repairs. I believe there
is one such building regulation which favours the
Board. It is absurd for the Board, on the one hand,
to disclaim responsibility for repairs to these
defects and, on the other hand, to discourage
owners from improving their flats. The defects
mentioned usually appear after the six-month period
of residence. Representations were made to me by
the flat-owners and complaints were brought to the
notice of the Board, but so far no satisfactory
solution has been found. Most of these defects are
due to the negligence on the part of the Board's
contractors. Debris is conveniently dumped into
drainage pipes and toilets, thereby choking the
whole system and affecting several floors in some
instances. The Board should exercise more stringent
supervision of the contractors
Column: 1059
and impose penalties if they are found to be
negligent, like barring them from further contracts
for a period of time.
Here again, Sir, I would like to mention the
irresponsible attitude of some contract workers in
defacing and dirtying partially completed buildings
in Toa Payoh. It is not uncommon to find human
excreta in some of these buildings when visitors go
up there to have a look at them.
As regards hawkers, the present policy of the
Housing Board in allocating stalls to bona fide
hawkers only has caused hardships to some
residents, particularly those staying in one-room
flats. With more one-room flats coming up in Toa
Payoh, more people will be taking up petty hawking
as a means of supplementing their income. There are
residents who because of tragic circumstances, have
to take to hawking to earn a decent living. There
are others who are unemployable for various
reasons. It is better to allocate stalls to such
people than to let them subsist on public
assistance. Because of a shortage of stalls and
unsuitable location, there is an increase in the
number of unauthorised hawkers in Toa Payoh. The
location of the market near Block 18 has also given
rise to numerous complaints from residents. Due to
the close proximity of this market and the hawker
stalls, residents have complained of flies and
noise nuisance coming from the stalls day and
night. The noise starts from 5 am, in the morning
when stallholders arrive in the market to prepare
for the day's work. At night, the cooked food
hawkers also join in. The noise from the
conversation of stallholders in the early hours of
the morning and the banging of frying pans at night
disturbs the peace of the residents. As a result,
many of them have indicated that they wish to sell
their flats and go elsewhere. I would suggest that
future sites for markets and hawker centres should
be so located that they are further away from the
residential area.
With regard to car parks, much has been said in
the local press about inadequate car parking
facilities in Toa
Column: 1060
Payoh. I must say that, overall, there are adequate
parking areas in Toa Payoh, but the location of
such parking areas leaves much to be desired. Here,
the planners have failed to make a proper
assessment of the situation. Large and spacious car
parks are located near to the one-room and two-room
flats, for example, near Blocks 45, 44, 28, 30 and
99. Car parks near the sold properties are much
smaller. Common sense will tell us where the demand
for parking space is. Block 99 is mainly used by
unauthorised hawkers. To solve the problem, I would
suggest that the Board restrict the parking of
buses, commercial vehicles and taxis to the larger
car parks which are less used and to review the
demarcation of the smaller ones to ensure optimum
usage of the space available.
On the question of play areas, in reply to a
question raised in the previous sitting, the
Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and
National Development (National Development
Division) stated that play areas are now provided
by the Board on the ground floor of flats. This is
indeed welcome news, particularly to the lower-income group. However, may I point out to the House
that the play areas mentioned are located in the
west sector of Toa Payoh. There are none in the
east sector where there are more people of the
lower-income group. There are 20 blocks of one-room
flats in the east sector compared to seven only in
the west. In order to meet the recreational needs
of residents in the east sector, may I suggest that
the Board consider resiting some of the ground
floor residents in the one-room flats so that these
flats could be converted into play areas?
One question that always irritates tenants is the
applications for transfers. Most applications for
transfers are from smaller to larger units or from
larger to smaller units. There is a tendency for
the Board to treat all applications alike,
irrespective of whether it is a deserving case or
not. The usual reply is that all vacant flats are
reserved for resettlement cases and applicants are
requested to wait for their turn, which
Column: 1061
can be for months or years. I see the need for the
Board to reserve vacant flats for resettlement
cases. But allowing a transfer does not fill such
vacant flats. It merely creates another vacancy
elsewhere. For instance, there is a case of a
family whose two children were murdered. Their
application for a transfer to another flat or an
early allocation of a sale flat met with the same
negative response.
As regards the lifts, it appears that the policy
of the Board, in accepting the lowest tenders for
lifts, has resulted in poor quality lifts being
installed in the Board's flats. Frequent
breakdowns, inadequate ventilation, rusty
interiors, inferior fittings like indicator knobs
where the signs are obliterated after a short time
of usage, are fairly common. When you enter a lift
in a Housing Board flat, you have a feeling of
insecurity. Whether the lift will move up or get
stuck halfway is a matter of interest. It is never
a smooth journey when you travel in a Housing Board
lift. Sometimes the lift vibrates or emits a
grumbling noise which sends shivers down your
spine. I hope, Sir, the Minister will look into
these problems and try to rectify them wherever
possible.
3.00 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, do I have
just 10 minutes?
The Chairman: That is right.
Mr Barker: It is rather difficult in 10 minutes
to deal with two dissatisfied Members of Parliament
who have raised so many points. Perhaps I can deal
with them in turn.
The Member for Telok Blangah seeks clarification
of the Housing and Development Board policy and
questions the long wait of one and a half to two
years before one gets a Housing and Development
Board flat, either as a tenant or as a purchaser.
It is admitted that the waiting period for
allocation of flats is at least one and a
Column: 1062
half to two years, sometimes even longer. It was
different in the 1960s when the demand for housing,
either from resettlement or other cases, was about
equal to the number of Housing and Development
Board flats built. The position today is entirely
different and I put this down to the extensive
concessions granted by the Government early last
year, especially the availability of the Central
Provident Fund monies. Previously one had to wait
until one reached 55 years before drawing that
money. Now everybody is rushing to use his Central
Provident Fund money, and hence the desire to
purchase Housing and Development Board flats.
Last year alone the Board received 12,324
applications for rent and 20,598 applications from
purchasers desiring to buy flats, making an
unprecedented total of 32,922 applications in one
single year. At the start of 1970 there was already
a backlog. And we had to deal with another 33,000
applications. Last year the Board built a little
less 1han 14,000 units. It cannot build 28,000
units within one year. That is not all. It is
difficult enough building 14,000 units, but there
are plans to increase this to about 20,000 units
annually by 1975. This year the Board hopes to
build about 17,000 units. Even if it succeeds in
this plan and builds 17,000 units, it is a far cry
from the 32,922 applicants who registered for flats
last year. The position is not hopeless. We have
broken the back of the housing problem in
Singapore, but the Member for Telok Blangah used a
different word, "solve". By "solve" it means that
we must be able to provide a flat to anyone who
wants a flat. The position today is that the demand
far exceeds the supply.
The Member also grumbled about the hardships that
his constituents are undergoing as a result of this
planning for the new town in Telok Blangah. He says
that it is a gigantic problem, so on his own
admission it is not easy.
Mr N. Govindasamy: There is no planning!
Column: 1063
Mr Barker: The plans are there, otherwise you
would never have a new town, but I think there is a
little confusion here. There are plans. The work is
going according to phases, but certain areas were
cleared to make way immediately for urgent
projects. For instance, two areas within the town
were cleared for the development of the P.U.B.
substation and the Singapore Telephone Board
Exchange. Hence eviction. Yet another place was
cleared for the cutting of a hill as well as an
access road to this hill in order to provide for
the Pasir Panjang Reclamation Scheme. These
clearance projects were undertaken and they might
have given the Member the impression that there
have been no plans. I can assure him that there are
plans. They are well laid-out plans, but any plan
to be implemented must be a flexible one. You
cannot say, "I am moving in here on this day and
there on that day." Circumstances change and if
there is hardship we regret it. In order to avoid
more hardship, I would suggest that the Member call
at the Ministry of National Development and look at
some of the plans, which I assure him we have in
the Ministry. I do not know how much time I have
for the Member for Toa Payoh.
The Chairman: You have three minutes more, Mr
Barker.
Mr Barker: Three minutes. Perhaps I should assure
the Member for Toa Payoh that I will look into his
complaints. I do not think all his complaints are
true. There is such a demand for Housing and
Development Board flats and yet the Member says
that the lifts are no good, the walls are cracking,
there is dirt all over the place, the market is too
close to the flats, the car parks are in the wrong
place, and the playgrounds are in the wrong place.
If all these are true, I do not know why everyone
wants to go to Toa Payoh. I do not know why we had
32,000 applications by last year. Something must be
wrong! In one breath the Member says that some of
his poorer constituents who occupy one-room flats
would like to supplement their income by being
Column: 1064
hawkers. In the next breath he says the hawkers
make too much noise at night or in the market in
the day. But there are difficulties. Everyone wants
to be a hawker nowadays.
The Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin): We are short of labour!
Mr Barker: Yes, we are short of labour. The
building industry is short of labour. Hawking is
one way of supplementing their income. It is hard
work, of course, but there is plenty of money in
it.
Perhaps I should deal with the business of minor
changes of awnings. In multi-storey housing, strict
discipline must be maintained for the common good
of the residents. You can have your minor repairs
provided they are within the building, but if you
put an awning on to the common corridor or to some
other common area, then the neighbours grumble. If
you want to put a gate or a grill, put it in your
own house, but do not trespass on to the common
area because if you do your neighbours grumble.
The Chairman: Mr Barker, your time is up.
Mr Barker: That is all, Sir.
Mr N. Govindasamy: I am glad the Minister agrees
that the applicants will have to wait one and a
half and sometimes even two years to get a Housing
and Development Board flat. This is the point I
made, but there are also one or two other points.
Mr Barker: They have to do with planning?
Mr N. Govindasamy: Yes, planning, but I would
like to come to urban renewal. I admit this is a
gigantic project. I admit there are bound to be
problems in a project of such vast dimensions, but
I have, as the Minister knows, gone to the Housing
and Development Board and looked at these plans. My
objection is to the chopping and changing of a
decided pattern of a plan, in the sense that one
area was laid down for the first phase of development
Column: 1065
and you moved out the people from there, and
then half-way through, perhaps for some good
reason, it was decided to move the phase to another
location where the people would be evicted. So you
have the situation where half of the people were
evicted in the first location, and the other half
still remain behind, thereby creating unnecessary
problems. If there had been planning, if this
change in phase development had not taken place,
there would not have been these problems.
Sir, I also admit that the backlog in the Housing
and Development Board is bound to increase as a
result of using C.P.F. funds for purchase of
houses. The high-cost houses developed by the
private developers will again further --
Mr Barker: Is that the fault of the Housing and
Development Board?
Mr N. Govindasamy: No, but we have got to cope
up with the requirements which we are not able to
do. Perhaps there may be other causes too. May I
suggest one or two other causes which may have
resulted in this big backlog? One could be that at
present there is no means of preventing members of
one family from making separate applications and
using one another in substitution of their
respective applications for one flat. In one family
of six people, two or three can make separate
applications. The enforcement of the income ceiling
for eligibility for the Board's flats militates
against fixed wage-earners, people who earn monthly
incomes in the form of salaries. It benefits
business people who are likely to claim very small
incomes and the Board is not in a position to check
and provide flats only to those whose wages do not
exceed the requirement. Similarly through the
absence of a cross-check between the Board and the
Property Tax Department, property owners, people
who own houses, may be also allotted flats. Not all
attap dwellers are really impoverished. Hawkers may
be people who earn very much more
Column: 1066
than what they claim to earn. There is no check to
prevent them from applying for these flats.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi): Be careful of what you
say.
3.15 p.m.
Mr Cheong Yuen Chee: Point of clarification,
Sir. The Minister has said that the fittings which
I have mentioned are regarded as an encroachment on
a common area. I beg to differ; they are not. They
are actually installed within their own premises.
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan (Whampoa): Mr Speaker,
Sir, can I raise -
The Chairman: Can the Member wait until the
Minister has answered?
Mr Barker: Sir, can the Member for Whampoa give
me the courtesy of dealing with these two points
first before I hear him?
The Member for Telok Blangah grumbles about
separate applications being made, or not being
made, I am not sure.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Certainly "being made".
Mr Barker: We catch up with the loopholes that
exist in the system. Cross-checks are now being
made with the Property Tax Division. If anyone who
already owns property is caught making an
application for a Housing Board flat, he will not
only lose his flat, but he is liable to be
prosecuted.
As for the income of hawkers, why does the Member
not ask the Minister for Finance how he checks on
them? I do not think he has any means of checking
on them. If the Member has any suggestions how we
can check the income of these hawkers, we will be
happy to consider and to implement them. These are
the problems - there are loopholes.
I can tell of another loophole. There are grouses
that when you buy a Housing Board flat, it really
does not belong to you. You cannot do this, and you
cannot do that, as the Member for
Column: 1067
Toa Payoh has said. Fair enough. We have introduced
a rule which says, "If you want to sell a fiat, go
ahead and sell it, provided you sell it to someone
who qualifies to buy that flat and he is already on
the register." This has led to abuse. Mr X gets a
flat today and sells it tomorrow at a handsome
profit of $5,000. These are loopholes which we will
plug. So the Housing Board is now considering
imposing a limitation on the resale of Housing
Board flats, and anyone who sells a flat will not
be allowed to apply for another flat for the next
five years.
As for the planning of Telok Blangah, my
instructions are that, except for the specific
projects which I have mentioned, there should be no
chopping and changing about. I think the Member for
Telok Blangah will agree with me when I say that no
one likes to shift on his own. And when he is
evicted, he wants to come back. The usual excuses
are that they have got used to the district, the
school is nearby, and the market is nearby. They do
not tell you that their wives' mahjong friends are
close by, too! No one likes to move, but unless we
move them there will be no urban renewal. Do you
want progress, or do you want stagnation? If you
want progress, you have to evict them. So you
compensate them, but they are not satisfied. You
provide them with Housing Board flats, they are
also not satisfied. They want a flat of their
particular choice. They want the fifth floor, and
they want a corner flat. And everybody wants that
flat. We cannot satisfy everybody.
Dr Augustine Tan: Mr Speaker, Sir, may I raise
two points concerning the economics of our hawker
centres? I think the Minister for Health might be
interested in this too.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: I will give you a hearing!
Dr Augustine Tan: Sir, it seems to me that for
want of space the Housing Board is able to think
only in terms of large hawker centres sited in
rather remote places. This means that there is
little business turnover for the large numbers of
hawkers congregated at the
Column: 1068
newly-built hawker centres. Why cannot the Board
think in terms of small hawker centres which
although they can accommodate fewer hawkers, are
sited at places more likely to attract business?
The appropriate choices for these places can easily
be known by observing where the unlicensed hawkers
site themselves, usually at corners of buildings,
as one can see them.
The second point that I want to raise concerns the
rentals charged for the hawker centres. It seems to
me that the rentals are too exorbitant for some of
these hawkers. It seems to me too that at some of
these hawker centres, the charges are so high that
the hawkers pass them on to the consumer in the
form of higher prices for cooked food, resulting in
a rise in the cost of living for the lower income
group. I hope both Ministers will take due note of
this.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: What about the Minister for
Finance?
Dr Augustine Tan: Furthermore, I think we ought
to exercise leniency in regard to unlicensed
hawkers. I know they are a nuisance, and I know
their stalls do not look nice. They congregate in
places where they might obstruct pedestrians, if
not traffic, and so on. But until such time as we
are able to educate or re-educate these people to
turn to occupations that we want them to go into,
that is, the factories, building construction, and
so on, we have to let them earn their living. It is
better they do unlicensed hawking than turn to
crime or some other illicit business. Thank you,
Sir.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Are you speaking as an
economist?
Mr Ho See Beng: Economist and socialist.
Mr Barker: Sir, I think that is a good
suggestion. In fact, the construction of smaller
hawker centres at strategic sites is being
considered by the Housing Board, because a hawker
goes out of business if he is in some lonely
outpost.
Column: 1069
As to the rentals charged, it can be looked at
both ways. Some hawkers are making money hand and
foot, but others are not. But we have to have one
standard rate, otherwise they grumble.
As for unlicensed hawkers, the Government is
sympathetic. The Government's policy is not to get
rid of hawkers in Singapore. But licensed hawkers
complain about unlicensed hawkers. For instance,
you build a market for foodstalls. You license the
hawkers therein. And as some of them were
unlicensed before, you give them a licence. But
other hawkers come in, and sell across the road. So
the licensed hawkers say, "What are you doing about
that? We will go out of business." An example is
the little row of stalls we built opposite the
entrance to the Botanic Gardens. Previously all, or
most of them, were unlicensed hawkers selling under
insanitary conditions. We put up a permanent
hawkers centre and rented out the stalls quite
cheaply. They were given water and electricity, and
they are doing good business. But now unlicensed
hawkers come along. And you must have read in the
papers about the police chasing an unlicensed
hawker and, in running across the road, knocking
down somebody's child. Well, this happens.
Another example is the hawkers at the junction of
Farrer Road, Dunearn Road and Bukit Timah Road, in
Tanglin Constituency; and yet another one in
Newton, in Cairnhill Constituency. These hawkers
were all unauthorised or trespassing on someone
else's land. They were not paying any rent, and
were selling food in rather insanitary
surroundings. We levelled the land, cemented the
place, put up little stalls, and they are now
paying rent at about $40 a month for a stall. If
you sell cooked food, for which you pay a rent of
about $1.50 a day, you are well in. On the other
hand, if you merely sell sweets, for which you have
to pay a rent of $1.50 a day, you might not make
it. If you sell ice-water --
Column: 1070
Mr Chua Sian Chin: You boom.
Mr Barker: - you are in. These are the
differences, and it is difficult to play one
against the other. But I can assure the Member that
Government's policy is not to get rid of every
hawker in Singapore. We have come to accept hawkers
as part of the life of Singapore. In the past when
hawkers were moved into shops in the Housing Board
premises, they had to pay a high rent. As a result,
the price of their food went up. Customers
subsequently stopped coming, and then they went
bankrupt. But they cater for a need. The Government
realises this, and we will continue to build more
and more hawker centres, so that they can hawk at
very cheap rates, otherwise they go out of
business. I am speaking generally, not only in
respect of those built in Housing Board estates but
those at Farrer Road, Newton Road, and the one at
Orchard Road in front of the Cold Storage, which is
the most popular in Singapore. They are doing a
roaring business. There is another centre opposite
the Singapore Polytechnic, which recently started
business - a car park by day, and a hawkers centre
by night. So once again may I assure the Member
that we are not against hawkers. We have come to
accept them as part of the life in Singapore. But
we have to ensure that they sell food under
sanitary conditions, so that when hon. Members eat
at such places they will not get a stomachache or
diarrhoea the next day.
Dr Augustine Tan: Sir, may I make a further
point on the question of hawkers' rentals? I do
realise that at certain hawker centres the hawkers
are so rich that they can afford to go round the
world. But at the same time, there are other places
where the hawkers are so poor that the rentals
which they have got to pay are really exorbitant.
What I would like to suggest is to apply the simple
law of economics - supply and demand - to each and
every hawker centre.
Sir, with regard to unlicensed hawkers, we have to
ask ourselves this question: why are there so many
unlicensed hawkers?
Column: 1071
This is a situation which reflects upon the
success or failure of our educational policy, our
health measures, and our ability to educate the
public on these matters. Sir, at one time I agreed
with the Housing Board and the Hawkers Department
in the Ministry of Health to control unlicensed
hawkers in my constituency. But there came a time
when several of them approached me, saying they
were widows with seven or eight children each to
take care of, and with tears in their eyes showed
me summonses of $15 each. Sir, I cannot take any
such action now nor can I support such action.
Mr Barker: Sir, if I am not mistaken, the
summonses do not come from the Ministry of National
Development. The Member for Whampoa is sympathetic
towards these people. So am I! The law has to be
imposed, otherwise there will be chaos. He can
philosophise, but I have to deal with realities.
But if he can point his finger at a particular
hawkers centre where the rents are too high, and is
able to make a case out for the lowering of such
rents -
Mr Chua Sian Chin: He can easily get a job.
Mr Barker: - we will consider lowering the rents,
provided, of course, it will not have repercussions
in other centres making the same demand. However,
if the business is not so good, I think common
sense should tell them that they should change
their business.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Get a job.
Mr Barker: Jobs are easy to find, but I do not
know what the Minister for Health has got to offer
them.
The Chairman: Mr Chua, I believe you want to say
something?
3.30 p.m.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Member
for Whampoa has raised a matter under a subhead
which is not within my time to answer. Otherwise I
would like to answer him more fully. But with the
permission of the
Column: 1072
Minister for Law and National Development I just
want to say this. If, as the Member for Whampoa has
stated, summonses should not be issued to
unlicensed hawkers, then he would be asking the
Government to be discriminatory as far as
imposition of the law is concerned. My colleague
has said that unless that is done, there will be
chaos. What is the meaning of the rule of law then?
He has quoted an example of how some unlicensed or
licensed hawkers are not able to make ends meet. I
agree that the situation could be given sympathetic
consideration five years ago when there was a large
unemployment situation, but it should not be so at
the moment. They do not have to hawk as a matter of
necessity, because there are always jobs ready for
them. If the hawker is a widow, and I am sure the
Ministry of Labour will support me, there is a
shortage of domestic servants, and she can become
one. I know that it is not easy to get a domestic
servant nowadays. Why hawk then?
Dr Augustine Tan: Sir, we are a free and open
society and people can choose any kind of job they
want. And so does the Minister for Health!
Mr Chua Sian Chin: We are concerned with the
law.
Dr Augustine Tan: I understand the law, Sir,I
am not advocating that the people should be allowed
to violate the law. I am advocating compassion in
the application of the law. It seems to me that
when a person is earning $100 a month and he is
fined $15 per offence, that is 15 per cent of his
income. If a person from the middle income or upper
income group were to face a fine of 15 per cent of
their income, they would raise hell not just in
this House but in the newspapers too.
Mr Barker: The fines are imposed by the
magistrate in court. The magistrate hears the facts
from the prosecutor and imposes what he considers a
suitable fine. To discuss here whether a fine of
$15 for someone earning $100 is good or bad seems
somewhat irrelevant. Of course, I would agree that
if I were
Column: 1073
drawing $100 a month I could not afford to pay a
fine of $15, especially if it is quite frequent.
But we are talking in general terms. I think our
magistrates have enough common sense to listen to
the facts and impose what they think is a proper
and reasonable fine.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Low Guan Onn: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1101 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1061.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I fully support the policy of the Government in carrying out its urban renewal scheme to make our city greener, cleaner and more beautiful to attract more tourists and to create a more modern metropolis in South-east Asia. However, I would like to comment on the implementation of
this policy which involves the acquisition of lands
belonging to the private sector. In the process of
acquisition of private lands belonging to
individuals, much criticism, acrimonious complaints
and dissatisfaction have been expressed by the
public over the arbitrary prices paid for such
lands which have no relationship to the market
price which can be obtained for their lands.
Private landowners welcome and are very happy and
willing if lands are requisitioned to build roads
and other public projects for national use.
However, the lands acquired by the Ministry of
National Development for the private sector have
been re-tendered for sale at prices five to ten
times more than the original price paid for, and it
is in such cases that genuine grievances have been
expressed. The owners feel that they have not been
fairly compensated and that they are being
exploited in order to make the rich people richer,
especially when land has been sold with all the
built-in incentives provided by the Government. Can
the Minister for Law and National Development
explain to this House by what criteria lands
Column: 1074
which are to be acquired for development are
evaluated and the price arrived at? Is the
valuation undertaken by a Government or an
independent valuer? Although there is legal
machinery by which dissatisfied landowners can
appeal to the Appeals Board, more often than not
the aggrieved party is not prepared to go to court
to get a judgment because they know that it is a
foregone conclusion and, at the same time, the
legal expenses involved are too costly. Can the
Minister give more sympathetic consideration to
landowners, especially small landowners, who own
small plots of land, so that in future acquisition
of land a more equitable price is paid for land to
be developed by the private sector?
May I also suggest that landowners be given a
period of grace for half a year to one year to
develop the land themselves if they intend to do so
before acquisition?
Mr Speaker, Sir, urban renewal schemes will be undertaken in many other areas. I am very concerned with those areas bounded by Kallang Road, Lavender Street, and Jellicoe Road where small- and medium-sized engineering works are situated. Many of these engineering workshops have been in existence for two or three generations. The business has been
passed down from grandfather to father, and from
father to son. The skills also have been passed on
from the elders to the children. They have been
acquired through the hard school of experience and
through trial and error.
Mr Speaker, Sir, will the Minister give the House an assurance that when these areas which I have mentioned are acquired for urban renewal, he will provide a suitable area with clean and cheap factory buildings for these engineering works so that they can survive? A reasonable rental can be
charged for these new workshops. At their present
sites they pay low rentals and their overheads are
low. These engineering works are the mainstay in
providing the supporting manpower skill and high
productivity, especially as
Column: 1075
sub-contractors to the big engineering, ship-repairing and shipbuilding firms. Without them the
big firms will find great difficulty in competing
with other countries in fabricated metal work and
other engineering services. I hope the Minister
will bear in mind that these firms are firmly
rooted and every effort should be made by the
Government to enable them to continue their trade.
They will then be able to upgrade their skills and
acquire new know-how it will be a big loss to our
Republic without them because they make a real
contribution to our economic growth.
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, first may I thank
the Member for River Valley for giving me an
opportunity to explode a myth? This myth is the
general misconception that Government acquires land
cheaply and sells it at high prices. It is admitted
that in the past year or so the Government has
acquired quite a bit of land. Most of this
acquisition has been made for purposes of defence.
Our soldiers need training grounds, and, therefore,
large tracts of land have been acquired. However,
it is not true that we acquire land and pay the
owner whatever we like. The Land Acquisition Act
itself provides that land can be acquired for
public purposes but at the market rates. The
Government Valuer values the land, but that is not
the end of the matter. The owner of the land
acquired has his own valuer and, if he is
dissatisfied, there are provisions by which he can
ask for a hearing before the Appeals Board where
the two valuers can set out their cases. They can
give their reasons why the land should be $10 a
square foot or $20 a square foot. A High Court
judge sits on the Appeals Board and he decides the
case accordingly.
But to go back to the question of Government
acquiring land cheaply and selling it dearly. One
reason for this misconception perhaps is that no
one likes his land to be acquired by Government. It
does not matter whether it is acquired cheaply or
dearly, he does not like it. However, we have to
acquire land for public purposes. Perhaps people
have this false impression because they
Column: 1076
are not aware of the following factors. The land
which is bought by Government is usually
encumbered. It costs a lot of money and it takes a
lot of time to clear the land of these
encumbrances. It is only the Government that can
evict the squatter occupiers. If the land is
subject to rent control, it is very difficult and
virtually impossible for the landowner to evict his
tenant. In some cases, the tenant demands hundreds
of thousands of dollars. Therefore, one of the
factors is encumbered land which has to be
unencumbered. The Government's offer to the private
sector in respect of urban renewal sites includes
many concessions. First, there is the easy
repayment of the purchase price: 20 per cent down
payment with the balance repayable over ten years
without interest. This works out roughly at a
saving of approximately 35 per cent of the land
premium. Second, there is reduced property tax
which is one-third the normal rate. The normal rate
is 36 per cent. The property tax for the urban
renewal sites is 12 per cent payable over 20 years.
Therefore, many people buy them. There are a lot of
purchasers willing to buy them. The owner pays only
12 per cent property tax for the next 20 years. The
Housing Board flat-owners pay 23 per cent property
tax now, after long communication and conferences
with the Ministry of Finance. Previously,
Queenstown flat-owners paid 23 per cent and
Aljunied flat-owners paid 36 per cent. Now there is
a flat rate. In any case, even Housing Board flat-owners pay more than the 12 per cent property tax
in respect of the urban renewal sites. There are
also other reasons. The land acquired is usually
fragmented with small and narrow frontages which
cannot be developed. These little pieces of land
are collected by the Government and put together
into one big complex and then sold.
3.45 p.m.
Again, when Government sells land, it sells at
"net", if I can use the phrase. `You do not have to
set aside part of your property for drains, canals
or
Column: 1077
roads. Everything is laid on. All you do is build
on that land. The planning work has been done. In
fact, the land offered is almost immediately ready
for construction. And last but not least, the
simulated plans provided by the Urban Renewal
Department give the developer expert advice on the
optimum use of the land. I have not given you all
the factors. But these are the major factors why
the three urban renewal sales that we have had have
been successful and why the public is prepared to
pay more and more for these sites.
As for the assurance asked for by the Member in
respect of resettlement of the small industries at
Lavender Street, Geylang Road and Jellicoe Road, he
need not worry now. No clearance programme has been
initiated for urban renewal purposes as it is the
intention of Government to ensure that there is
suitable alternative accommodation available before
full-scale relocation takes place. But the widening
of Lavender Street by the Public Works Department
will affect a few cases in this locality, and this
cannot be helped as the road widening is urgently
needed. There will be about seven cases affected
-four carpenters, two repairers of engines and one
business of detergent packing. We will look for
suitable alternative accommodation for them.
Mr Low Guan Onn: Sir, I thank the Minister for
his reply and I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $462,710 for Head 1101 ordered to stand
part of the Estimates.
Column: 1077
Head 1107 -
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1107 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1005*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Ho Kah Leong)
Column: 1078
Sir, every Singaporean knows that our Government
has been able to lead us on to the bright and
glorious path of national development. As a result
of the prosperity of our country, certain problems
of communication were created. Two years ago, Upper
Paya Lebar Road was widened in order to facilitate
the laying of sewer pipes. Some attap houses in
Lorong Tai Seng were demolished and the sewers were
laid.
Paya Lebar Airport will have to accommodate the
Boeing 747s and, as a result of the need to expand
the airport, some houses in Paya Lebar will have to
be demolished. There is no doubt that these
development projects have affected the people in my
constituency who have to make sacrifices. We have
to be very careful in dealing with the problem of
resettling people who are affected by these
projects. We should not carry out plans rigidly and
without any flexibility, thus driving them to the
brink of despair and hopelessness.
Sir, I would like to point out clearly that, as a
result of such development projects as road-widening and sewerage works, many houses and shops
have been demolished. Many of my constituents have
expressed their distress and great disappointment
when they see their houses brought to the ground.
However, after lengthy persuasion on the part of
the local leaders and myself, the great majority of
them have come round to the point of view that the
national interests must come first. The question
now is how to resettle properly those who are
affected by these development projects. Because of
improper handling by the officials of the Housing
and Development Board, many problems which were
originally capable of solution have become more and
more complicated and have caused great
inconvenience to many of our people.
Sir, when a person who has been affected by
resettlement applies for Housing Board
accommodation or shop premises, he has to fill in
an application form to indicate his choice of
premises. These people have accordingly indicated
Column: 1079
their preference for the location, the lot numbers
and the addresses. However, what they have been
allocated in the end turns out to be completely
different. Their original choice has been given to
other people. This situation has made me doubt the
statement that these people are, in fact, given
preferential treatment.
Sir, compulsory reallocation of shop premises
cannot work because much depends on the customers.
For example, if a coffee shop has been given an
isolated corner to carry on the business --- I
have received complaints from coffee-shop owners on
this score it has only itself to serve and no other
customers, and it will have to wait for the day to
fold up its business.
On the problem of allocation of premises to those
affected by resettlement, we must find them a
better solution and give them a better choice. Only
in this way can we say that we are fair and
impartial. Many people have been delayed or
disappointed by the method and the way in which
allocations have been made. However, the Public
Works Department, especially the Roads Section,
does not seem to be aware that these people have
not been allocated their new premises and have
issued summonses to them asking them to appear in
court. I have emphasised this point before. These
people have already agreed to move away but they
have not been allocated any premises yet.
Therefore, they are still there. This anomaly quite
common and people who are affected by resettlement
have complained to me very often about this.
Sir, the right hand of the Government does not
seem to know what the left hand does. Because of
this, we seem to have lost the spirit and the
quality of the P.A.P. when we first came to power.
I complained to the department concerned about
this. The reply was that those who were affected by
resettlement were in the wrong. Or else I would get
a perfunctory reply full of high-sounding language
and beating about the bush. On behalf of my
constituents. I would like the Minister to instruct
his departmental heads that they should not be
overbearing. Otherwise he will become
Column: 1080
embarrassed if a complaint is again raised in this
House.
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like to raise one or two
points in this respect. In my constituency, more
than half the area is designated for industrial or
military use. In these areas, people have become
very hard pressed. First, the period given for
development is not fixed. Some of them say this
area is to be developed in two years, but after
five years, nothing seems to have been done. During
this period, the farmers will have received notice
to cease further cultivation of their land and
their huts, however decrepit, cannot be repaired.
Most of them do not have water and electricity
supplies and they are not going to have any. If the
drains are blocked and the roads damaged, no
repairs are carried out. Only until the Citizens'
Consultative Committee have repeatedly brought up
their complaints that the roads are in poor
condition that any action has been taken and only
very minor repairs have been carried out. Needless
to say, these minor repairs do not help to solve
the problem.
4.00 pm.
Sir,I have noticed that the policy of allowing no
major repairs but permitting only minor repairs
seems to have been changed. Three roads in my
constituency are in a horrible and shocking
condition. They are Lorong Kemabal, Joo Koon Road
and Jalan Tuas. The people have recently submitted
their applications for urgent repairs to be made to
these three roads. I do not know why permission has
not been given. I wish to point out to the Minister
that the first two roads are used daily by
thousands of people in my constituency. The third
one is the only road that leads to an army camp.
Many of the parents whose children are doing
national service in the camp have to make use of
this road to go to the camp. I fail to understand
why even minor repairs to these roads are not
approved. This has given rise to a great deal of
discontent and unhappiness. I would like to ask the
Minister whether
Column: 1081
it is true that minor repairs cannot be carried out
in areas designated for industrial or military
development, and what is the reason for this.
Mr E. W. Barker: The Members for Paya Lebar and Jurong
are again singing their annual tune, playing the
same organ-grinder.
For the information of the Member for Paya Lebar,
I do not understand Mandarin, but according to the
interpretation I received, he mentioned "despair"
and "hopelessness". I also heard the word
"inconvenience". I think that is the proper word. I
travel to Paya Lebar quite frequently, but I do not
see any "despair" or "hopelessness" on the faces of
the constituents in Paya Lebar. "Inconvenience"
yes, because they are living next to a busy airport
which is being extended. If they choose to live
near an airport, they have got to put up with some
degree of noise.
As for road widening, we have been attempting to
complete that job for the last few years, but we
have not managed to do so in spite of the fact that
I have sought assistance from the Member -his
constituents are pretty tough - they will not move,
so the road widening is still
Mr Tay Boon Too(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
a point of clarification. In my speech, I said the
local leaders and myself have tried our very best
to convince and persuade the people in our
constituency to look after the national interest,
but my point is that the Housing and Development
Board has not allocated any place for them to go
to. The Minister says that the road has not been
widened because the people will not move. It is not
that the people do not want to move, but because
the Housing and Development Board has not allocated
any place to them. Are you asking them to go on to
the road?
Mr Barker: Sir, to come to the point, the
position in Paya Lebar is this. A total of 335
families were affected by road widening. A total of
272 families found their own accommodation or
Column: 1082
accepted the accommodation offered by the Housing
and Development Board. There are still remaining 63
families. They were offered accommodation in
several Housing a n d Development Board estates,
but they declined to accept it. They have requested
accommodation as follows: 24 families want flats in
MacPherson Estate or the Kallang Basin; 36 families
want shops, and all want to go to the Kallang
Basin, two motor vehicle workshop owners request
locations which are not even available, and one
light industrial factory wants another allocation
which is also not available. Priority for
allocation of accommodation in the Kallang Basin is
given to those families affected by the Sims Avenue
Extension and the Pan-island Expressway cutting
across Paya Lebar Road We have not got enough
flats. So the request of these 24 families asking
for flats in the Kallang Basin and 36 more asking
for shops in the Kallang Basin cannot be met. We
have not got them.
As for the summonses, we cannot proceed with the
building of the road unless they move out. Yes,
they have agreed to move out, but they want the
moon, but we have not got the moon, so we have to
prosecute them.
If I may now turn to the Member for Jurong. He
grumbles about military and industrial extensions
in Jurong. The Member is fortunate. His
constituents can easily find jobs in Jurong.
Mr Ho Kah Leong rose -
Mr Barker: Sir, I will give the Member for
Jurong an opportunity to seek clarification or ask
me further questions, but I have not dealt with him
in just one sentence. The Member grumbles about
repairs, that only minor repairs are being carried
out. To cut it short, proposals to effect minor
repairs to Joo Koon Road and Lorong Kemabal,
costing $2,000, and to Jalan Tuas, costing $1,400
were deferred. They were considered by the Urban
and Rural Services Committee but were deferred due
to lack of funds and also because Jurong
Constituency had spent all the funds
Column: 1083
allocated to it. In fact, it had overspent. So
there are no more funds to provide for further
kampong road repairs and pavings. Other Members in
this House will be interested to know that for the
last financial year a sum of $61,284.65 was
approved for repairing and paving kampong roads
within Jurong Constituency. This is the highest sum
given to any constituency in Singapore.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Sir, why not Changi?
Mr Barker: This is not all. This is just for
kampong roads and pavings. On the whole, a total
sum of $219,124.65 was approved for carrying out
various projects and services within Jurong. This
again is the highest sum given to any constituency.
If I can mention it, Choa Chu Kang has the second
highest sum - $208,000. I am not saying that we
should not spend money in Jurong or Choa Chu Kang.
It is only right that we should, because both
Jurong and Choa Chu Kang are in the rural areas.
The rural areas are relatively undeveloped compared
to the urban areas, like Hong Lim, or the semi-urban areas, like Tanglin. [Laughter] Do not laugh,
because Tanglin is partly rural. We have ten
kampongs or more, but all I am trying to say is
this. I am surprised. We have spent so much money
in the Member's constituency, which proves again
that he is hardworking but do not come here and
grumble about lack of repairs.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Sir, a few points
of clarification. The first point is that the
Minister said we sing the same tune every year. Why
is it that we have repeatedly to bring up our
points? It is because the departments concerned
have not really seriously considered what we have
proposed and therefore we cannot help but harp on
the same tune.
The second point I wish to clarify is that I am
not against my constituency being developed for
industrial and military use.
The third point, as the Minister himself agreed,
is that Jurong is a
Column: 1084
relatively undeveloped constituency and, therefore,
we need more funds for road repairs and other
facilities and so on But in drawing up plans for
minor repairs, the three roads which I have
mentioned require urgent minor repairs because they
are in a shocking condition. As the Minister has
said, it is only a few thousand dollars. I hope he
will approve the expenditure of this sum.
Mr Tay Boon Too(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
before I withdraw my amendment, I would like to
clarify a few points. On the matter of summonses,
those people who are affected by resettlement have
not been allocated accommodation, so summonses
should not be issued to them. The Minister has said
that the Kallang Basin has no vacancies. I would
like to ask, why then is it that the project in
Paya Lebar is to be started first? Is it because
the "Member for Sims Avenue," is working under the
Minister? Is it because of that that the people in
Sims Avenue are given preferential treatment? Is it
because, as I have said, the "Member for Sims
Avenue" is working under the Minister?
An hon. Member: It is the Member for Geylang East!
Mr Barker: I did not catch what the Member asked.
Could the Member please repeat what he said about
my relationship with the "Member for Sims Avenue"?
4.15 p.m.
Mr Tay Boon Too(In Mandarin): Sir, what I am
trying to say is that Upper Paya Lebar should not
be developed without first giving priority to the
resettlement of the people affected in the case of
the shops in the Kallang Basin which were allotted
to those affected by the Sims Avenue Scheme, I
think it was because Sims Avenue is in the
constituency of the Member for Geylang East, who is
in the Ministry of National Development.
Mr Barker: Sir, let me deal with the Member's
last allegation first. That is not true. I had no
dealings with the Member for Geylang East in this
case
Column: 1085
as he was not concerned with the Sims Avenue
extension. I think the Member for Paya Lebar has
done him a wrong. Those people who were affected by
the Sims Avenue extension were the constituents in
Geylang Serai, Kampong Ubi, and, to some extent,
Kampong Kembangan. We decided to give them priority
because we considered the extension of Sims Avenue
and the Paya Lebar Expressway as matters which must
be completed quickly. So between one part, which is
in Paya Lebar and the other part, which is in Sims
Avenue, we had to decide whom we wanted to move
first. We decided against the constituents in Paya
Lebar. That is all.
As for the Member for Jurong, we have already
spent so much money on his constituency. But I can
assure him that after this budget session, if we
have any savings, we will spend more money to
repair the roads which he has complained about.
Mr Tay Boon Too(In Mandarin): Sir, in view of
the detailed answer given, although I am not
completely satisfied, I beg leave to withdraw my
amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Sir, I beg to
move.
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1107 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1101.
Sir, I have already done my duty by repeatedly
raising in this House the problem of the serious
decline in agriculture in Singapore. On numerous
occasions, too, I have repeatedly suggested certain
proposals for the improvement and reformation of
our agriculture. The speaker may be persuasive, but
so far, unfortunately the listener is rather
indifferent. I hope I will not find it necessary to
repeat again what I have said in this House in
future.
The Primary Production Department was established
over 11 years ago. But has it seriously considered
the crux of the problem relating to the farmers?
Has it seriously considered how it should
Column: 1086
help the farmers? Sir, before the department
started to exercise farm licensing, it claimed that
it was not in a position to assess the true
position of the farmers. Therefore, on the 16th
October, 1968, to be exact, the department carried
out farm licensing. All the data on the farmers
were gathered, but in spite of their establishment
strength of 1,218 members, the Primary Production
Department has not been able to disclose any plans
for agricultural development in Singapore. If at
all any help is given, it is only for the big-time
farmers. Little assistance is given to the small-time farmers. When I last visited my constituency,
I formed the impression that the small-time farmers
are still on the brink of poverty. They lead a very
simple life and they use very old methods of
farming and livestock rearing. They work throughout
the day and only manage to live from hand to mouth.
They make up the majority of our farming
population, and therefore the problem of improving
their standard of living is a very serious matter,
deserving the attention of the Primary Production
Department.
Mr Speaker, Sir, although our country is unable to implement the scheme of "land to the tillers," our farmers should at least have some form of security in respect of their land. At the present moment, farmers are occupying land under Temporary Occupation Licences, a system inherited from the
days of colonial administration. The T.O.L.s are
granted to the farmers on a temporary basis, and
they can be withdrawn at any time. Sir, if they are
withdrawn, the farmers will be left without any
land to till. Since a total area of 581 square
kilometres (permit me to use the metric here) for
the various zones, like the industrial zone, the
Golden mile zone, the motor repair zone, and the
high-class residential zone, has been drawn up in
the Master Plan, how is it that there is no
agricultural zone? Can we not give our farmers some
kind of lease that is more tenable so that they can
be assured of land to till without having to worry
about the withdrawal of the T. 0. L.s?
Column: 1087
Sir, for several years the Primary Production
Department has been carrying out a feasibility
study of our offshore islands for agricultural
purposes; in particular, Pulau Ubin and Pulau
Tekong, with a total area of about 28 square
kilometres. But why has it been so quiet about it?
Does it not have any plans?
The main problem confronting the farmers is
finance. The farmers' crops are subject to price
fluctuations, and they require financial assistance
for any development or expansion. I have,
therefore, suggested to the Minister for Finance to
establish a Farmers' Bank to grant loan facilities
to our farmers in times of need. Since the Ministry
of Finance has not indicated whether or not it is
prepared to accept this proposal, perhaps we may
consider converting the Primary Production
Department into a statutory board so as to avoid
all the unnecessary administrative restrictions
imposed on it as a Government department, in this
way the Primary Production Department, as a
statutory board, will be able to have, in addition
to its existing functions, a Finance Division to
deal specially with financial matters to assist the
farmers. The banks and other financial institutions
in Singapore are prepared to grant loans only for
commercial and industrial purposes. They are not
prepared to grant loans for agricultural purposes,
particularly to the small-time farmers. So they
have no choice but to resort to money-lenders or to
rely on tontines to raise funds. Sometimes they
even have to borrow from the grocers or the animal-feed dealers. And if any epidemic breaks out among
their livestock, or their harvest is poor, or if
there is any price reduction in agricultural
produce, they will be heavily in debt. But when
times are good, their profits have to be used to
purchase agricultural implements, seeds and
fertilisers. So they have no savings at all and
there is no capital accumulation. So whatever
techniques you can create or devise for the
farmers, they are not able to take advantage of the
technical assistance offered because of lack of
finance, if the Primary
Column: 1088
Production Department still stagnates in its
function to provide technical assistance to
farmers, it is of no help at all. In fact, even in
the dissemination of technical assistance among the
farmers, the department has not been very
effective.
I will therefore say that financial assistance is
of greater importance to the farmers than anything
else, and I urge the Government to convert the
Primary Production Department into a statutory
board, so that it will be in a better position,
through the proposed Finance Division, to help our
farmers financially. With adequate finances, they
will be able to take advantage of whatever new
developments, techniques, or technical aid is
offered to them. At the same time, I would also
like to suggest that the Finance Division of the
Primary Production Department (as a statutory
board) set up some sort of a crop insurance
scheme, so that when the farmers are faced with
problems such as a decline in prices of
agricultural produce, they will not have to lose
very much. This problem is particularly evident at
the present moment as their prices are manipulated
by the middlemen, The prices in the market are
quite good, but because of the manipulation of the
middlemen, all that the farmers get for their crops
is very little. So the Government should assist
them in this respect.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I hope the Minister will give serious consideration to my proposals. Farmers make up about nine per cent of our population, that is there are about 175,000 of them, and so they deserve our assistance.
Mr Teong Eng Siong rose -
The Chairman: May I remind Members that the
guillotine time for this Head is Five o'clock. Mr
Teong.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, I am in
full sympathy with the Member for Jurong who has
spoken of the problems of the farmers. The farming
industry in Singapore forms quite an important
sector of our economy. At a time when our
agricultural produce brings in an income of about
Column: 1089
$200 million, their contribution to our economy
cannot be overlooked or underestimated.
Sir, what assistance has the Government given to
our farmers? Speaking dispassionately, over the
past few years the Government has done quite a
great deal for them through the Primary Production
Department. The department teaches them how to
improve their farming techniques, how to vaccinate
their livestock, and other such things. At the same
time, the department has also been conducting
experiments, and the results of these experiments
are made available to the farmers so that they will
know how to breed their livestock. As a result of
all these improvements, our agricultural produce
has increased. But this does not mean that we have
done enough for the farmers, or that we have done
all that is needed to be done to help them. On the
contrary, Sir, the Minister for Finance has pointed
out in his budget statement a few days ago that our
agricultural industry is now faced with many great
problems. He has also said that over the past few
years there has been an apparent decline in
agriculture, if that is the case, I must appeal to
the Ministry concerned to take early steps to try
to solve the problem.
4.30 p.m.
Mr Speaker, Sir, in my view, there are two problems facing agriculture. First, there is the shortage of land. As we know, consequent on the acquisition of land for industrial purposes, urban renewal and housing development, arable land is diminishing in area. In order to ensure the
development and viability of our agriculture, I
feel that the existing agricultural areas should be
preserved for agricultural purposes. There should
be no more acquisition of such land for other kinds
of development. In order to solve the acute problem
of land shortage, the then Minister for Finance
last year during the budget debate proposed flatted
farming as a method for rearing poultry. However, I
Column: 1090
do not know whether the Primary Production
Department has made any study of this proposal. If
so, what progress has been made on flatted poultry
farming?
Mr Speaker, Sir, the land allotted to farmers now is barely sufficient for agricultural purposes. One acre of land allotted to a farmer is too small a size for the development of agriculture. Therefore, the farmers affected by land acquisition should be allotted a bigger area of land so that they can
carry on with their farming, whether poultry or
vegetable farming, and in this way they can
contribute to our national income. The Primary
Production Department has been allotted huge sums
of money to carry out experiments and research
projects. This is, of course, a good policy in
principle, because it indirectly helps our farmers.
However, the question is whether the results of the
research and experiments will benefit every farmer
and, if it does, to what extent?
I would also like to raise the question of the
erection of chicken sheds. If a farmer puts up a
chicken shed of a size in excess of the dimensions
originally approved, no mercy will be shown to him.
The shed will be immediately demolished, I hope
that in future some sympathy will be shown to such
cases. The authorities should not be too rigid
about the measurements.
The next question I wish to ask is this. In view
of the shortage of land, is there any plan to
develop agriculture in our off-shore islands, and
is there any plan for deep-sea fishing?
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, first, may I deal
with the question of flatted farming'? It was a
suggestion by the then Minister for Finance.
However, he is not in charge of farmers. I am in
charge of them. But he is in charge of money. If
you want to borrow money or if you want your
farmers to be financed, do not ask me. Ask the
Minister for Finance. The Member should get this
clear. The Minister for Finance is concerned with
finance, and I am concerned with flatted factories.
Column: 1091
The Member for Sembawang has referred to the
income of $200 million from farmers. Yet he says
they are poor. I do not follow him.
Dr Augustine Tan rose -
Mr Barker: The Member wishes to enter into this
debate?
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan: Mr Speaker, Sir, the fact
that $200 million has been earned by the farmers
does not necessarily prove that they are either
rich or poor. It depends on the number of farmers
among whom the $200 million is to be divided.
Mr Barker: That is accepted. But surely in
Singapore there is not such a big number of farmers
that this $200 million does not go a long way?
Dr Augustine Tan: I do not think we have the
figures to prove or disprove the point. The
Minister is trying to make out a case that the
farmers are not poor on the basis of $200 million.
That is not fair.
Mr Barker: I am not saying that at all. If the Member has been in this House for several years, he will hear Members saying the same thing every year - that the farmers are poor! When the price of eggs goes down. I am supposed to explain why it is down, and what am I doing about putting the price of eggs
up. When the price of eggs goes up, some other
Members of Parliament will ask me what I am doing
about getting it down. Anyway, Sir, over the years,
the Primary Production Department has developed a
network of ten extension centres in the more
important farming areas staffed by qualified
officers. These officers visit the farms regularly
and give on-the-spot advice to the farmers, whether
they are big-time farmers or small-time farmers.
They also organise training programmes and talks in
the respective farming areas for farmers to obtain
the most up-to-date information on farming
techniques and the results of experiments and
research. Information is also disseminated widely
through the Department's news bulletins, pamphlets,
rural
Column: 1092
film shows and rural news broadcasts. More
specifically, the Pig and Poultry Training and
Research Institute in Sembawang organises, within
the station, talks and demonstrations on various
aspects of pig and poultry rearing based on the
results of research.
The Agricultural Division organises regular
courses in mushroom cultivation for the public. On
a more formal basis, the Farm School at Sembawang
offers training courses in which advanced and
proven techniques of farming developed from the
Department's research programme are passed on to
our young farmers.
I am afraid that land is in short supply in
Singapore and it is really not possible to allocate
more land to farmers. Land is needed for other
projects. Hence, the price of land in Singapore is
going up.
As for chicken sheds being demolished, these are
minor matters. If they are not built to
specifications, naturally they are demolished. The
answer is, build according to the specifications, I
do not know whether I have dealt with all the
matters, but if Members want to raise something
which I have not answered, please do so.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker.
Sir, the Minister has not listened to me carefully.
I would like to raise again two questions which he
has not answered. First, has he any plans for the
development of agriculture on our off-shore
islands? Second has he any plans for deep-sea
fishing?
Mr Barker: There are plans for agriculture on the
off-shore islands, but they are mostly concerned
with the growing of orchids. However, they have not
started yet. In fact, quite a bit of land in Pulau
Tekong was recently acquired so that our army can
train there. It meant the resettlement of some
farmers there. Therefore, development on the
offshore islands has not started. I think industry
will begin first instead of agriculture.
Column: 1093
As for deep-sea fishing, most of our fishermen are
in-shore fishermen and they are reluctant to go far
out. We have a training school in Changi to train
them. A few of them have been trained. But,
unfortunately, it is a hard life and very few would
like to go far out to sea because it means being
away from the family. But we are trying to do our
best to encourage more and more fishermen to go
into deep-sea fishing.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
the Minister has not replied to the various
questions which I have raised just now. However,
because of the time factor I would not like to
raise the same points again. But I hope that when
the Hansard is out he will pay serious attention
to my questions by reading them carefully.
The question of fisheries was raised just now and
I would like to express my own opinion on it. Sir,
152 years ago Singapore was a small fishing
village. It has now developed into a great
metropolis in South-east Asia. We should be proud
of the progress our country has made, but we should
feel sad because Singapore is not self-sufficient
in its supply of fish. According to the statistics
in the 1969 Year Book, the quantity of locally-produced fish was 12,714 tons, whereas in the same
period the quantity of imported fish was 41,951
tons. In other words, three-quarters of our fish
consumed is dependent on foreign import. Thus every
year there is a loss of millions of dollars in
foreign exchange. We can see from the same year
book that the number of fishermen registered in
1962 was 4,366, whereas in 1969 there were only
1,348 fishermen registered left. We can see from
this that our fishing industry is declining. With
the increase of our population, the demand for fish
consumed will, of course, increase, whereas the
catch of fish is decreasing. Based on the
calculation of 60 pounds of fish consumed per
person per year, by 1985 when our population will
have reached three million, the consumption will be
Column: 1094
80,000 tons, whereas by the year 2,000 when our
population will be four million, the consumption
will reach 107,000 tons. From this we can see that
while our population is increasing every year our
fishing industry is dwindling. The more dependent
we are on imported fish, the less bargaining power
we have over increasing prices. So now is the time
for us to save our fishing industry and I hope that
the Government will make a two-pronged approach to
remedy the situation. The Government should
seriously develop the deep-sea fishing industry and
provide actual and positive assistance to our
fishermen who are in dire difficulties.
4.45 p.m.
Sir, our island is surrounded by seas all round.
In the seas, there are inexhaustible resources.
Particularly in the Indian Ocean and the South
China Sea there are rich fish belts waiting to be
exploited. In the Indian Ocean, there are lots of
tuna fish which is a great potential for our fish
processing industry. The Government has not
encouraged deep-sea fisheries in any way. On the
contrary, by the end of 1969, the Government has
withdrawn the pioneer status of the deep-sea
fishing industry. It has spent a lot of money, in
conjunction with the United Nations Food and
Agriculture Organisation, to set up a Fishing
Training School in Changi and also, under the aegis
of the South-east Asia Fisheries Development
Centre, to set up a South-East Asia Fisheries
Research Centre to train our youth in deep-sea
fishing. But then, although the Government has
spent a lot of money, the trained youths cannot get
any jobs because there are not enough deep-sea
fishing boats. Is this all that the Government can
do? In the end, all this is a waste of money. The
Government should consider and encourage
investments in deep-sea fishing and try to think
out schemes to encourage its development. From the
point of view of old-time merchants, an investment
in deep-sea fishing is an uncertain investment. So
the Government should provide more encouragement
Column: 1095
to this industry and take the lead. It should
also establish joint ventures with local or foreign
capitalists in this industry.
Our traditional fishing methods, such as kelong
fishing, are out-dated and backward. Our coastal
fishing areas are limited in fish supplies. So our
fishermen have to venture out into the open seas to
fish. But now and then we read in the newspapers
about fishermen being robbed by pirates or detained
in foreign countries. This happens when they meet
with a storm or an engine failure and have to take
refuge in neighbouring islands belonging to other
countries. Sometimes they meet with pirates and
they incur more losses than just imprisonment,
fines and confiscation of their ship by foreign
governments. But some of them, after having been
robbed by pirates, did not report to our police,
knowing very well that even if they did, they could
not get any assistance from the Government because
it could not do anything. Due to all these
hazardous incidents the off-shore fishermen are
faced with problems. Furthermore, the Government
has not allotted them sites for resettlement. So
all this has resulted in the dwindling number of
fishermen in our country. Sir, now is the time for
the Government to save our fishermen and give
positive assistance to them.
The Minister for Culture (Mr Jek Yeun Thong) rose -
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): I hope the
Minister will be patient. He will have an
opportunity to speak after I have spoken.
At least, the Government should consider the
following points:
(1) We have all along maintained good relationship
with our neighbouring countries. We should have
some sort of fishing agreement with our
neighbouring countries so as to allow our fishermen
to fish in their territorial waters. At least, they
should be given safe passage home and not be
detained.
Column: 1096
(2) We should send out more sea patrol boats or
organise a kind of emergency sea relief fleet
in order to protect our fishermen.
(3) As regards fishermen being robbed by pirates,
the Government should give them financial
assistance to ensure that they could continue
with their old trade so that they may not be
forced to change their vocation.
(4) The Government may perhaps set up a sort of
air reconnaissance service to spot the
location of fish from the air by scientific
means. This would be better than the
fishermen themselves spotting for fish in the
vast expanses of the seas. Furthermore, with
our own planes flying overhead, it would
provide additional protection to the
fishermen.
(5) The Government should allot certain areas
near the sea coast for fishing villages so
that fishermen who are evicted can be
resettled there. If they are forced to live
in Housing Board flats, they would have to
change their vocation.
I hope the Minister can seriously consider my
suggestions.
Dr Augustine Tan: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Members
for Sembawang and Jurong have raised two very
serious questions: one, regarding the use of
agricultural land, and the other, the promotion of
fisheries. Just because the demand for agricultural
products and the demand for fish are both likely to
increase dramatically in the years ahead does not
necessarily mean that it will be economic for us to
produce more in respect of agricultural products
and more fish ourselves; in other words, to be more
self-sufficient. Much of modern economic life
depends upon specialisation, a division of labour.
Sir, you can imagine the kind of life each one of
us would lead if we were to build our own houses,
make our own clothes and so on. We would be back in
the cave age. In similar fashion, a country has
Column: 1097
got to specialise too. If we can use our labour and
our resources more profitably in manufacturing and
so on, I say by all means give up fishing and
agriculture. Of course, there is a short-term
problem as well, to the extent that the farmers and
the fishermen get penalised. I would join them in
their plea for some kind of Government assistance
accordingly. But let us not lose sight of the long-term perspective for both these industries.
The Chairman: Mr Jek, I believe you wanted to
say something?
Mr Jek Yeun Thong: Sir, the Member for Jurong
just now was rattling off his speech so fast that
the interpreter was unable to catch up with it.
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, like the Member for
Jurong. I myself was very disappointed when the
pioneer status for deep-sea fishing was struck off
the list of pioneer status industries. The Primary
Production Department has done its best to
encourage deep-sea fishing. There is the Fishing
Training Centre at Changi, a joint Singapore-U.N.D.P. (United Nations Development Programme)
project established in 1969 conducting two types of
one-year courses: firstly, a deck course to train
navigators and fishing technicians; and, secondly,
an engineering course to train fishing vessel
engineers. Prior to running these courses, the
Fishing Training Centre conducted several short-term intensive courses of two to three months'
duration for fishermen in late 1969 and early 1970
in seamanship, navigation, engine repair and
operation of fishing gear. A total of 51 out of 75
fishermen satisfactorily completed these courses.
The centre also conducted a one-week course in
January 1970 for 32 captains of fishing trawlers
based at Upper Serangoon Road. So the Primary
Production Department is not sleeping on this
matter. But as I said, our fishermen prefer to do
in-shore fishing and I am ashamed to say that we
import three-quarters of the fish we consume in
Singapore.
Column: 1098
Dr Augustine Tan: Sir, why should we be ashamed?
It is simple economics.
Mr Barker: Sir, perhaps the Member misunderstood
me. We are an island surrounded by water.
Dr Augustine Tan: So we should all be fishermen!
The Chairman: Dr Tan, can you sit down when the
Minister is speaking?
Mr Barker: I am not here to battle with the
Member for Whampoa on economics. We are an island
surrounded by water and we only catch one-quarter
of the fish we eat.
Dr Augustine Tan: We buy it.
Mr Barker: That is what you say.
Dr Augustine Tan: Mr Speaker, Sir, this is a
very serious economic question indeed and I must
have some time to reply to this.
The Chairman: Dr Tan, you have all the time
until 5 o'clock. You can carry on.
Dr Augustine Tan: Sir, if we appeal to intuitive
arguments of the sort that because we are an
island, therefore we must catch all the fish that
we eat instead of importing three-quarters of it,
it just does not make economic sense. If our
fishermen can do better, can earn more in
factories, in manufacturing and so on, let them do
it. If they can build ships, let them do it. But if
our neighbouring countries can get the fish cheaper
than we can, let them do it and we import it and
use our resources better. Why does not somebody
stand up and ask, "Why cannot we plant rice, plant
more vegetables? Why build Housing Board flats?"
Because this does not make economic sense. Just
because we are surrounded by water, we just cannot
appeal to arguments of that sort.
Mr Barker: The Member for Whampoa has put it very
nicely. But we can always import fish from our
neighbours provided fish comes in. We can always
import water from our neighbours provided the water
always comes in. When there is a blockade, what
happens?
Column: 1099
Dr Augustine Tan: Fish and water are two
different things altogether.
Mr Barker: Fish and rice, too, are two different
things. You grow rice on land.
Dr Augustine Tan: We cannot live without water.
We can live without fish and we can always buy fish
from other places. If they catch the fish, they
have to sell it. But they do not have to sell us
the water.
Mr Barker: I do not think we can take this
argument any further. The Member for Whampoa has
his point, and I have mine. We are surrounded by
water and I say that we should catch more fish. I
never said that we must catch all the fish that we
eat. But we must catch more fish. I never said stop
manufacturing, stop building Housing Board flats.
That came from the Member for Whampoa.
Dr Augustine Tan: That is not fair. I never said
that.
Mr Barker: That is what the Member was
suggesting.
Dr Augustine Tan: If we take it to its logical
conclusion.
Mr Barker: That is the Member's conclusion.
Dr Augustine Tan: Sir, this is getting to be a
terribly fishy business!
Mr Barker: On the Member's interruptions!
The Chairman: I do not mind, I have got up to 5
o'clock. You can carry on. Mr Ho.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Sir,I wanted to
know why the pioneer status for the deep-sea
fishing industry was struck off the list of pioneer
industries. The Minister has not answered this
point.
Mr Barker: Sir, I sympathise with the Member for
Jurong. I am just as sorry as the Member that it
was removed. But I had nothing to do with it. I was
for it. It was the Ministry of Finance which is in
charge of industries and pioneer status. They
removed it. I
Column: 1100
had nothing to do with it. I was against its
removal, like the Member. I suggest that at the
appropriate time, the Member should ask the
Minister for Finance. Why ask me? I am on the
Member's side.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Sir, in future,
when I have the opportunity I would like to ask the
Minister for Finance about this matter. Since the
Minister for Law and National Development has
assured us that he is on my side, I beg leave to
withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Sim Boon Woo -
(3) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1107 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1103.
The Chairman: Mr Sim, you have exactly one minute
on amendment (3) .
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Mr Speaker, Sir, since the
Members for Sembawang and Jurong have spoken on the
subhead "Director of Primary Production", I am not
moving my amendment.
5.00 p.m.
The Chairman: It is "guillotine" time.
The time allotted for Head 1107 having expired,
the following amendments were not proceeded with:
Mr Ho Kah Leong:
(4) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1107 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1321.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong:
(5) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1107 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 3005.
The sum of $15,015,510 for Head 1107 ordered to
stand part of the Estimates.
The Chairman: I propose to take the suspension
now.
Thereupon Mr Speaker left the Chair of the
Committee and took the Chair of the House.
Column: 1101
Mr Speaker: I suspend the sitting now and shall
take the Chair again at 5.30 p.m.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
5.00 p.m. until 5.30 p.m.
Column: 1101
Sitting resumed at 5.30 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
Debate in Committee of Supply resumed.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
Head 1108 -
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Potong Pasir): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1108 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1321*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr J. F. Conceicao)
Mr Speaker, Sir, I see that the Drainage and Flood Alleviation Schemes in the coming year will cost about $4.5 million. I do not see the Potong Pasir Constituency included in any of these schemes, nor does the Toa Payoh scheme --
The Chairman: Mr Ramaswamy, are you talking about
the Development Estimates or the Expenditure
Estimates?
Mr Ramaswamy: Sir, I am talking about subhead
1321 -- Roads, Bridges and Drainage.
The Chairman: On the Expenditure Estimates?
Mr Ramaswamy: Yes, on the Expenditure Estimates.
The Chairman: Yes, carry on, Mr Ramaswamy.
Mr Ramaswamy: Subhead 1321 -Roads, Bridges and
Drainage. I wish to ask the Minister whether the
Toa Payoh scheme includes the improvement of the
drainage of Sungei Kallang and the alleviation of
floods in that area. In the Potong Pasir area,
whenever there are two inches of rainfall, Kampong
Potong Pasir near Braddell Road is flooded up to
one or two feet. During
Column: 1102
the 1969 flood, all the kampongs were under four or
five feet of water. The floods were 12 to 15 feet
high. The Government is taking flood alleviation
measures in Bukit Timah and other areas. I just
want to find out from the Minister whether he has
any schemes for the alleviation of floods in the
Potong Pasir area.
The Chairman: Perhaps it will be more appropriate,
Mr Ramaswamy, if you ask this question the day
after tomorrow when the Development Estimates come
up. What I am trying to tell you, Mr Ramaswamy, is
that you are talking on this subject in the
Development Estimates today when we are on the
Expenditure Estimates.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong): Mr Speaker, Sir,
if you wish, you may rule me out of order also.
The Chairman: I may have to, if you speak on the
Development Estimates, Mr Conceicao.
Mr Conceicao: I just wanted to bring up this
brief point to the Minister for National
Development, whether he does not think that perhaps
the quality of our road surfaces could be improved.
I do not know what specifications the road builders
adhere to, and how they compare with standards in
other countries - am I in order, Sir?
The Chairman: Yes, if you will dwell on the
Estimates of Expenditure, Mr Conceicao.
Mr Conceicao: This subhead is in respect of the
"Mechanical Engineer" who, I thought, was supposed
to be in charge of roads, bridges and drainage. If
you think I am out of order, I will withdraw my
amendment.
The Chairman: I think you can wait till the debate
on the Development Estimates comes up.
Mr Conceicao: As you please, Sir.
The following amendments stood on the Order Paper
Supplement -
Column: 1103
Mr J. F. Conceicao:
(2) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1108
be reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1341.
Mr Cheong Yuen Chee:
(3) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1108
be reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1581.
The Chairman: Amendment No. (2) , Mr Conceicao.
Mr Conceicao: I am not moving, Sir.
Mr Cheong Yuen Chee: Sir, I am also not moving
my amendment.
The sum of $12,604,810 for Head 1108 ordered to
stand part of the Estimates.
Column: 1103
Head 1109 -
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Ng Yeow Chong -
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1109 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 2013.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten): Sir, I am not
moving.
The sum of $22,506,500 for Head 1109 ordered to
stand part of the Estimates.
Column: 1103
Head 1110 -
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1110 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1001*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Sim Boon Woo)
Under this subhead I would like to refer to the
deterioration in the efficiency of the Building
Survey Division. I have received many complaints
from people in my constituency that there has been
an excessive delay in their applications to repair
their houses. Let me quote an example. In my
constituency, a certain person applied for
permission to repair his attap hut. This hut is in
an advanced state of dilapidation, and if repairs
are not carried out immediately, it will not be
safe to live in that hut. His application was
submitted a long time, but he has so far received
no reply. This goes to show
Column: 1104
that the efficiency of the Building Survey Division
has deteriorated very badly. I hope the Minister
will order investigations to be carried out and
instruct the division to raise their efficiency. I
hope he will ask them to speed up the processing of
applications to repair houses.
Next, I would like to talk about the cumbersome
procedure in dealing with applications. As far as I
know, it is as follows. In the first place the
applicant must go to the Ministry of National
Development and inform the building inspector (Di-Niu) that he would like to repair his house. The
building inspector will give him a form and ask him
to go back and fill it. After filling it, it will
have to be returned to the Ministry of National
Development. A month later the person will receive
a letter asking him to submit his property tax
receipts, land rent receipts and two maps. These
two maps are to be purchased from the Ministry of
National Development. To purchase these two maps
the person has to fill in another form. What gives
these applicants a considerable headache is that
they must supply the mukim and the lot number for
the area in which the house is situated. Most of
these people in the rural area are not familiar
with these mukims and lot numbers. They have to
consult the Di-Niu (building inspectors), and, more
often than not, they cannot help. So the applicants
are advised to refer to the landlord. After filling
in the form --
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture (Mr Fong Sip Chee): Sir, point of
clarification. The Member referred to the housing
inspector in the Chinese colloquial term Di-Niu,
which means land cow. This term is generally
accepted outside the House, Sir, but as a gesture
of respect to the civil servant, I think the Member
should use the actual term of inspector, housing
inspector or survey inspector, but not land cow!
The Chairman: How do you use it in Chinese, Mr
Fong?
Column: 1105
Mr Fong Sip Chee: Ji Char Yuan, Sir
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker.
Sir, I think the Parliamentary Secretary is saying
an unnecessary thing. It is up to the Speaker to
tell me what to do. Is the Parliamentary Secretary
the Speaker?
Mr Fong Sip Chee: Mr Speaker, Sir, I would have
expected the Member, after several years in this
House to understand the proceedings of the House.
It is not my intention to take over the
responsibilities of the Speaker. I think it is the
duty of every Member to draw the attention of the
Speaker to any irregularities in the House, whether
in respect of speeches or the conduct of hon.
Members.
The Chairman: I think Mr Teong Eng Siong is
conducting himself quite well, except that he has
used a colloquial term in Chinese which I shall
excuse him for the time being.
Mr Fong Sip Chee: Mr Speaker, Sir, but the
Member insists on using the term "land cow". I
should like to see how this will go down in
Hansard!
The Chairman: Mr Teong, will you stop using the
term "land cow" and use "inspector" instead?
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I regret the Parliamentary Secretary
interrupted me for no reason at all. Let me
continue. After filling in the form the applicants
have to purchase the maps. They have to wait for
another week before they receive them. Together
with the property tax receipts and the receipts for
the land rents, they have to submit the two maps.
After another two or three weeks, another letter
will be sent by the Ministry of National
Development asking for details of the renovation,
whether it is going to be a complete renovation or,
reconstruction, or merely involve the changing of
the roof or walls. The applicants have to draw two
sketches giving the specifications of the length
and breadth of the existing house. Of
Column: 1106
course, they have no choice but to abide by the
procedure. A few days later, the housing inspector
or building inspector -- I hope the Parliamentary
Secretary is satisfied with this term now - will
arrive and check whether the house is according to
the specifications. This is stage one of the
application procedure. The applicants will have to
wait patiently. After a month or so, they go and
ask the building inspector what progress has been
made. The reply is, "Hey, how can you expect us to
work so quickly? We are very busy. Come back in two
weeks' time." Two weeks later, the answer will be,
"The application has been submitted to the Planning
Department." The same old story - "Come back in two
or three weeks' time." After the two or three weeks
are up, the applicants again make inquiries. The
answer now is, "Come back next week." At least this
is good news. One week later, they go back and ask.
The reply this time is, "Ah! The Ministry of
National Development has approved your application.
However, the plans have been submitted to the
Ministry of Health, and we can proceed only after
the Ministry of Health has given its approval." But
that will take another two or three weeks. However,
at long last they are granted a temporary licence
to carry out repairs or renovations.
5.45 p.m.
All these delays here and there cause the
applicants to go to and from more than ten times
altogether. This is not the way to do things. I
hope the Minister will consider simplifying the
application procedure and assigning one or two
officers to assist the applicant to fill in
application forms for permission to carry out house
repairs, and what is more important, to ensure that
there are facilities to enable them to complete all
the necessary procedure in one visit. This will
save them a lot of precious time, which they can
usefully spend on working in the farms. Sir, if the
Building Survey Division is willing to help the
rural people, it should be a very easy matter now
because all the depart-.
Column: 1107
ments of the Ministry of National Development are
housed in the same building. So it should not be
too difficult to co-ordinate the procedure of
applications and to instruct the departments
concerned to liaise with one another.
The third point I would like to raise refers to
illegal structures which are more than three years
old. In the past certain people in the rural areas
constructed houses in violation of the building
laws. This was because they did not quite
understand these laws. So in respect of these
dwellings which are more than three years old, I
hope the department concerned will consider the
position sympathetically, otherwise summonses will
be issued to them every six months, and the fines
will increase with each summons. This will impose a
very heavy financial burden on them. I hope the
Minister will consider the plight of these rural
people and help them solve their problems.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Sir, I would like to associate
myself with the Member for Sembawang in airing the
grievances of the rural people in this House. But I
do not agree with him and I cannot associate myself
with him in the matter of unauthorised houses for
which he is asking for consideration.
My question is very short and simple. What is the
policy of the Chief Building Surveyor in granting
permission to applicants who wish to repair their
houses in the rural areas? In this respect, can the
Chief Building Surveyor think of a more simple way
to help these people get their houses repaired,
such as cutting out red tape, as mentioned by the
Member for Sembawang just now, which requires the
applicant to go down town to the Chief Building
Surveyor's office, then to the Planning Department,
and then to the Health Ministry, and so on? I wish
such a complicated procedure can be made simpler so
that it will also help those Members of Parliament
in the rural constituencies, including the Minister
of State for Finance.
Column: 1108
Mr E. W. Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, I think the Member
for Sembawang has somewhat exaggerated the position
as regards the delay and the procedure. My
understanding is that normally an application for
repair of temporary houses is approved within two
weeks from the time the application is made to the
Chief Building Surveyor's Department. The procedure
for submitting such applications is already quite
simple. There seems to be no need to further
simplify it. The procedure may be generally listed
as follows. The applicant first goes to the Chief
Building Surveyor's Department and the building
inspector will help him fill in the application
form. He is then immediately advised to purchase
two copies of the site plans from the Development
Control Division of the Planning Department. Next,
the plans together with the ground rent or
assessment receipt to prove ownership of the house,
are then handed to the building inspector. After
this, the building inspector will then visit the
site, take measurements of the building and its
location, and draw up the necessary plans for
approval. Those are the three steps of the
procedure.
As for the mukim number and the lot number, my
sympathy goes to those people who do not understand
what this is all about. But I think the Member for
Sembawang will appreciate that no building plan can
be passed unless the site is located. To do this,
we must know the mukim number and the lot number.
But as far as is possible, the building inspector
will assist the applicant in this respect.
I think the confusion about the procedure really
lies with what is meant by "repairs". The Member
for Sembawang spoke about repairing a house which
was in a dilapidated condition, If a house is in a
dilapidated condition, seldom will the owner want
to repair it. What he does is to demolish the
building and put up a new one. This is where the,
trouble starts. A simple application for repairs
can be approved provided it is merely repairs. But
more often than not, you will find the occupier
applying
Column: 1109
to the department for repairs to his house when his
intention is to demolish it and put up a new one.
And when the building inspector subsequently makes
a check, he finds that the rooms have been
enlarged, the house has gone a little higher; and
then there is trouble. I think this is the basis of
the confusion that exists, because if a house is to
be reconstructed, the signature of the land owner
is required as he owns the land. You cannot build a
house on his land without his permission. He will
not give the occupier permission to build a new
house nor will he sign the plan, but the occupier
comes to the Chief Building Surveyor with an
application for repairs. So there is trouble all
round.
But if the houses are reconstructed on the same
site with the same floor area as the original, the
owner's consent is done away with. But in many
cases the reconstruction is first carried out, and
then the applicants go to the department to
regularise the position. It is only in cases of
reconstruction of concrete semi-detached or terrace
houses that applicants are advised to engage an
architect to prepare the building and site plans.
The Member for Sembawang also mentioned
continuous court actions. It all starts with the
builder being prosecuted for putting up an
unauthorised building. The magistrate convicts him
and fines him, and also makes an order that he
should demolish that house. It is called a
mandatory order. But, of course, he does not
demolish the house. He will not comply with the
terms of the mandatory order. Because of that, he
is brought to court again and again. And, of
course, as long as he does not comply with the
order to demolish, subsequent convictions lead to
bigger fines. If we are to drop the matter after,
say, three years, then the position will become
hopeless. He defies the law, he ignores the
mandatory order, and after three years, when
everybody keeps quiet, he has got away with it. So
I think the Member for Changi is right on that
Column: 1110
score. But there have been cases where, after
several convictions and on sympathetic grounds, the
department has not taken any further action. But to
do that in all cases would lead to many more
unauthorised houses being put up, thereby getting
the cloak of authority within three or four years.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I would like the Minister to clarify two
points. First, he has mentioned just now that the
building inspectors will help the applicants to
fill in the forms. As far as I know, they have not
assisted the people from the rural areas to do
that. These forms are in English, and because these
people do not know English, they do not know how to
fill in the forms. If the building inspectors had
assisted them, I think this problem would have been
solved. But since the Minister says that they do
help, I hope that they will from now on actually
assist them in filling up the forms.
In regard to repairs and renovations of old
houses, these houses are in many respects in a
dilapidated condition. All that the occupier wants
to do is to replace some of the old parts of the
building with new ones. They are not reconstructing
the whole building. They want to renovate the
building on the existing site. If the Minister says
that this work does not require the approval of the
landlord, I say that this is not so. In fact, the
building inspectors often make it difficult for the
applicants. Sometimes they kick them about like a
ball from here to there. I think the Minister is
not aware of this fact. I hope he will pay
attention to this matter. This is a great
inconvenience to the people in the rural areas.
6.00 p.m.
As a representative of the people in the rural
areas, we have often encountered problems of this
nature. I have the opportunity to understand these
problems more clearly. I am speaking very slowly
now. I hope the Minister can understand me.
Column: 1111
The other point is this. Some houses which are
more, than three years old do not have any building
plans. At the time when the builders first
constructed their houses, they were not aware of
the building laws. As a result, they violated them.
The Minister has said that one must look at these
cases sympathetically, and that after one or two
fines have been imposed, these offenders should not
be fined any further. However, some of them have
been fined more than three times. They still
receive a fine thereafter. I hope the Minister will
pay attention to this matter. He has already said
in this House that he will consider these cases
sympathetically. I hope he will instruct his
Ministry to do so.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Mr Speaker, Sir, I seek some
clarification from the Minister. If a person wishes
to repair a house by replacing the main pillars and
changing the roof and, at the same time, replacing
half of the planks, will it be considered a new
house or a repaired house? The sides and the height
of the house remain the same.
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, if the repairs
mentioned by the Member are carried out to the
letter, it will not be considered by the department
as reconstruction but under the phrase "repairs",
provided, of course, the rooms are not extended. If
you re-build your house, shall we say, on the same
site with exactly the same area; that is, you
completely demolish the house, and you put
something new there but with exactly the same area
as before, the department considers the work as
repairs. But if you increase the size of the house
by three square inches or three square feet and
when the building inspectors measure it and find
that the house is bigger, they will say it is a new
house.
The Member for Sembawang seems to be at issue with
me as to what happens in the Chief Building
Surveyor's Department. My understanding is that the
building inspectors are there to help members of
the public. The Member's understanding is that they
do not help them. However, since the beginning of'
this year, my Parliamentary
Column: 1112
Secretary has been put in charge of the Chief
Building Surveyor's Department and he can keep an
eye on what is happening in the department from day
to day. If the Member has any difficulties on this
score, I would suggest that the Member contact him.
As for the court convictions, I do not think I
need repeat what I have said. There have been
convictions of even more than half a dozen times.
But if there are sympathetic grounds on which we
can drop the whole matter, we will do it. And this
has been done in several cases. If the Member has
any particular case in mind, he can draw my
Ministry's attention to it and we will give it
every consideration.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I think the Minister is sincere in his reply
to my question. However, there is another point on
which I wish to seek clarification. This concerns
the difficulties in the application procedure. The
Minister says that I have exaggerated the case. I
do not think I have exaggerated in the slightest
degree, because what I know has been gathered from
complaints by many people who have, in fact, gone
through this cumbersome procedure. What I have said
is based on facts, and nothing else. Since the
Minister has given serious consideration to my
question and has assured the House that his
Parliamentary Secretary will now be responsible for
the Chief Building Surveyor's Department and that
every problem can he referred to him, I beg leave
to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $819,150 for Head 1110 ordered to stand
part of the Estimates.
Column: 1112
Head 1202 -
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1202 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1001.
Mr Speaker, Sir, there are some junior doctors who resign
from Government service after serving a couple of
Column: 1113
years. As a result, there are no immediate
replacements for the vacant posts. It appears that
the student doctors who are in the housemanship
programme have to consult the senior doctors every
now and then. In the end they are a burden to the
senior doctors.
As a result of this pressure and if the senior
doctors resign from the service, what will happen
to the Hospitals Division? I, therefore, call upon
the Minister to rectify the situation in the
medical services, or else the standard in the
hospitals will deteriorate.
I understand that some doctors work from 82 to 119
hours a week. If this is true, how can they manage
to continue in Government service?
I believe that it is not financial considerations
alone which have resulted in the resignation of
doctors. It is, in fact, because of their poor
conditions of service.
On the other hand, if too many specialist doctors
resign from Government service, I fear that the
many costly instruments and apparatus owned by the
Government will not be properly handled by
inexperienced doctors. If that is the case, these
costly instruments may turn out to be a waste.
I presume some of the departments have
insufficient staff when resignations or retirements
occur, especially in the E.C.G. Department.
Mr Speaker, Sir, student nurses should be given proper training in good manners, politeness and etiquette, because I have seen some of them not performing their duties according to the above standards.
I also understand that it is compulsory for
student nurses to stay in the hostel during their
training periods. As a result, expenses are
incurred by them for lodging, laundry, food, etc.,
even though they may stay near to the hostel. I
would, therefore, suggest that staying in the
hostel should not be made compulsory, because it
will affect the take-home pay of the nurses.
Column: 1114
There is another matter which I wish to raise but
which probably does not come under this subhead.
Anyway, I will mention it, although I do not know
whether or not the Minister will reply to it. Sir,
with reference to the Institute of Health at Outram
Road, it appears that the conditions in the
vicinity of the institute are more like those of a
market than a hospital. I wonder whether some
changes can be made to the institute so that this
hospital for children will have a brighter
appearance.
Sir, I also wish to know whether the Minister will
consider introducing a health service system, as is
being adopted in the United Kingdom.
Mr Speaker, Sir, a professor from New Zealand a few days ago mentioned the shortage of doctors in Singapore. This confirms what I have told the Minister, that there is a shortage of doctors in the Singapore General Hospital.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I agree with
the Member for Anson that we are short of doctors.
In fact, when I made my speech last year, I did say
so.
Taking his first point, when talking about the
resignation of specialists, he has asked what will
happen after that? Following the resignation of a
specialist, the next most senior officer is
immediately appointed to act in the post. This
period is necessary to enable this officer to carry
out the duties of the specialist and to enable the
Ministry to assess his suitability for promotion.
Promotion exercises are held about twice a year, as
the Public Service Commission is not in a position
to hold them more frequently. Furthermore, time
must be allowed for officers who were considered
not suitable in the earlier promotion exercises to
prove their worth.
The Member for Anson has also mentioned some
doctors who have been made to work from 82 to 119
hours. Though I agree that some of them have been
asked to work long hours, I think 119 hours is a
bit of an exaggeration. If we divide 119 by seven,
we get 17 hours. I do not think that it is possible
Column: 1115
for any doctor to work 119 hours a week. Therefore,
this is quite obviously a prima facie case of
exaggeration. However, may I say that a survey of
the working hours of doctors was carried out in
August 1969. It showed that they were on duty from
42 hours to a maximum of 86 hours a week. The
matter was looked into and in August 1970, on my
instruction, a circular was issued to all heads of
departments to the effect that whenever the
exigencies of the service permitted, medical
officers on night duty in a clinical unit should be
given half a day off the next day. The position up
to the beginning of this month showed that this was
being implemented in 16 out of the 23 clinical
units of the hospital services.
6.15 p.m.
Sir, may I just say something about the number of
medical officers who are now working in the
hospitals? In August 1970, the number of medical
officers in service was 248 and on 15th March,
1971, the figure was 261. There has been an
increase of 13 medical officers. In view of the
improvement in the staffing position, instructions
have been issued that with effect from 15th of
March this year, all medical officers who are
required to perform night duty will be given a half-day off the following day. This would result in the
reduction of the total number of hours of duty by
doctors by about four hours per week if an officer
does one night duty per week, and by about eight
hours per week if an officer does night duty twice
per week.
As regards the nurses, I agree again with the
Member for Anson that the student nurses - I do not
know why the Member has picked on student nurses -
should be properly trained and should be courteous,
in fact, they are properly trained. I can say that
the majority of them are courteous to the public.
Not only student nurses but, in fact, all grades of
the nursing staff are taught to be courteous at all
times with the patients, with the public, their
colleagues and their seniors, and this has been
emphasised throughout their training
Column: 1116
period as well as in circulars and so on. The
Member for Anson will agree with me that in any
organisation there are bound to be some black
sheep. I believe he will also agree with me that
there are black sheep among postmen. That being the
case, we have devised a method whereby all members
of the staff of the hospitals have been asked to
wear a name tag and, if there are any complaints,
to let us have them. Has the Member for Anson any
complaints about the student nurses?
Mr P. Govindaswamy indicated none.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: The Member has none.
Therefore, may I say that the general statement
made about discourtesy and so on is not very
helpful to my Ministry.
The Member also made a comment that the Institute
of Health is like a market. I do not know how he
views it to be like a market. I agree with him that
the building is quite old. We always welcome new
buildings, but so long as we have none, we have to
make the most of what buildings we have.
Finally, the Member mentioned the United Kingdom
national health service. In other words, he wants
us to bring private practitioners also within the
health service. May I say that at the moment the
Ministry of Health has about 27 outpatient
dispensaries, and they are providing a service
particularly to the low-income group, and I can say
that the service is adequate. Therefore, at the
moment we are not considering utilising the doctors
in private practice and introducing a U.K. type of
national health service.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, I quite
agree with what the Minister for Health has said.
But a professor from New Zealand has mentioned that
even in New Zealand doctors in private practice are
brought into the national health service for a
certain period. Anyway, I do not want to prolong
the matter.
As regards student nurses, the Minister has asked
me whether I have complaints to make. These nurses
are student
Column: 1117
nurses. They are not trained nurses. If they are
trained nurses and if there are complaints, we can
send them to the Ministry of Health. Student nurses
are still students. Therefore, I would ask the
Minister to advise the heads of departments to urge
the student nurses to be courteous.
Sir, I have received another complaint about the
nurses of Kandang Kerbau Hospital. It seems that
they are rude to the patients. The Minister says
that circulars are issued to the hospitals from his
Ministry, and I ask the Minister to issue another
circular to all the hospitals calling on the nurses
to be courteous with the patients.
Sir, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr J. F. Conceicao: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1202 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1161.
Sir, I merely wish to inquire whether there are
trained staff under the charge of the Senior Sister
Tutor who can undertake the training of nurses in
industrial health. With our expanding
industrialisation, the question of industrial
health has to be scrutinised more and more. It is
possible that we may at some future date want to
provide the services of industrial nurses in the
factories in Jurong, and for that purpose I ask
this question.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, at the
moment, the Ministry of Health does not have a
formal course in our School of Nursing for the
training of industrial health nurses. The reason is
that this subject is a very new one and the
training of nurses in industrial health has to be
undertaken overseas. In the initial period,
however, the Ministry will be sending one staff
nurse some time this year to be trained in
industrial health nursing at the Royal College of
Nursing in London. Others will follow later. Once a
core of nurses specially trained in this subject
has been
Column: 1118
built up, the Ministry may consider planning a
special course of training in our School of
Nursing. Assistance could, of course, be obtained
from the World Health Organisation or other
international agencies to formulate a programme
when so required.
Perhaps the Member for Katong may be thinking of
training nurses working in the industries in the
private sector. If that is what he is thinking of,
may I say that at the moment the Singapore Trained
Nurses Association, in conjunction with the Society
of Occupational Medicine, is currently running an
introductory course in industrial health nursing
for such nurses and others who are interested.
Perhaps in the future if there is sufficient demand
from industries to employ trained industrial health
nurses, the professional bodies concerned, and
perhaps the Extramural Studies Department of the
University of Singapore, may join in to continue to
provide such courses.
Mr Conceicao: Sir, I do not think any voluntary
organisation or educational body can do the job as
well as the relevant officers in the Minister's own
relevant unit. I thank the Minister for his answer
and I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu): Mr Speaker, Sir.
I beg to move.
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1202 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1733.
Sir, as our society becomes more urbanised and
more industrialised and as the pace of life
quickens, it seems inevitable to me that more and
more people will crack up mentally. As a result,
they are unable to adjust themselves and to come to
terms with the tremendously increased pressure and
changed circumstances of a modern society. This
seems to be the sad story behind the statistics
supplied by the Minister for Health to the Member
for Katong yesterday. It will be seen that the
total number of people who sought psychiatric help
has gone up from 28,431 in 1968 to 39,847 in 1970.
These
Column: 1119
are patients who attended the outpatient clinics.
The increase is definitely quite frightening. I am
rather surprised to see that in Woodbridge Hospital
itself, there is only one psychiatrist. I cannot
see how one psychiatrist can cope with the total
number of some 3,000 inmates at any one time.
Perhaps the Minister would like to clarify this
point.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I agree
with the Member for Jalan Kayu that one
psychiatrist cannot cope with so many cases.
Therefore, there must be something incorrect about
it. It is not correct to say that there is only one
psychiatrist who is working in Woodbridge Hospital.
In fact, we have three consultant psychiatrists.
They are the person who is noted down in the
Estimates as Psychiatrist (Grade G), referred to by
the Member for Jalan Kayu, and the Medical
Superintendent and Deputy Medical Superintendent of
Woodbridge Hospital who are also consultant
psychiatrists and are doing the duties of
consultant psychiatrists. In addition to these
three, we have three senior registrars in
Woodbridge Hospital all of whom are in possession
of the Diploma in Psychological Medicine and are,
in fact, specialists in psychiatry, although they
have not been appointed clinical consultants.
I agree that even this number of psychiatrists
will not be sufficient in the next few years. At
the moment, we have one officer in the United
Kingdom undergoing training, and a further three
medical officers will also be leaving this year to
undertake courses in psychiatry in the United
Kingdom.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin: Sir, before I withdraw my
amendment I would just like to draw the attention
of the House to the fact that about 50 per cent of
the number shown against Woodbridge Hospital are
apparently readmissions. This does seem to suggest
that perhaps the treatment given at the hospital is
not really good. I have heard complaints that
patients are sent home too soon. In fact, I know of
one particular case
Column: 1120
my constituent - who was beaten up twice by his son
who was apparently let out too soon from the
hospital.
Another point which I would like to mention is
that I use Yio Chu Kang Road quite often and some
nights on my way home, I was surprised to see some
patients apparently doing a striptease by the
roadside. They are not only a hazard to themselves,
but also a danger to people driving along that
stretch of the road. This is one matter which I
feel might be due to the lack of supervision and
possibly could be due to the shortage of staff at
the Woodbridge Hospital.
6.30 p.m.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir,
unfortunately, the Member for Jalan Kayu has not
understood the modern psychiatric approach of
treatment of patients. In fact, it is the policy of
psychiatric hospitals to have an open-door policy
wherein patients are allowed a more open and free
environment under supervision. This more natural
environment helps the patients in the process of
recovery. In many hospitals patients are encouraged
to run their own wards and given the freedom to
move in and out. It is not true that the inmates of
the hospital are let loose, as was put forward by
the Member for Jalan Kayu.
As regards readmissions, of course, it is best
that if a patient has recovered a certain degree of
sanity, he has a chance to return to his home. The
idea behind it is that in their natural home
surroundings they should get better faster.
Unfortunately, there may be cases of relapse and so
on. May I just say that if a patient is known to be
unpredictably violent or shows a possibility of
violence, he will be put in a more secure ward. I
do not think the Member for Jalan Kayu should be
very worried when he passes along Yio Chu Kang Road
at night.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin: In view of the fact that the
Minister seems to be aware of the problems
involved, I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Column: 1121
The sum of $52,753,270 for Head 1202 ordered to
stand part of the Estimates.
Column: 1121
Head 1203 -
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr Conceicao -
(1) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1203 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1071.
The Chairman: Mr Conceicao is not here.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1203 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1601*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr Conceicao.)
The cleaning of the Republic is not done daily,
and there are places where rubbish and garbage are
accumulated. Therefore, it has resulted in the
breeding of mosquitoes and flies. Will the Minister
take action to see that the rubbish and garbage are
cleared daily? We complained many times to the
Public Health Division but they replied that they
were short of men, short of lorries and all sorts
of things. The Minister must take action to clear
the rubbish and garbage daily.
Tuan Haji Rahmat Bin Kenap (Geylang Serai)(In Malay): Sir, I wish to draw attention to the recent
outbreak of typhoid in Kampong Ubi and Geylang
Serai. It appears that the Health Ministry shirked
its responsibilities by putting the blame on a man
who had failed to practise personal hygiene, and
who had acted as a carrier of the disease, as was
reported in the newspapers recently. I consider
that such an accusation brings disrepute to the
Health Ministry itself for trying to cover up its
faults regarding public cleanliness in this area.
The efforts of the Public Cleansing Department in
the Kampong Ubi and Geylang Serai constituencies
were very inefficient. Refuse was allowed to
accumulate and became stinking, while drains were
blocked. The residents of these two areas had
played a useful role during the
Column: 1122
Keep Singapore Clean campaigns in 1969 and 1970,
with the result that they are now imbued with the
spirit of cleanliness and it has become a household
chore to clean the environment of their homes.
However, it is a matter for regret that the Health
Ministry cannot share this responsibility in regard
to cleanliness.
I wonder whether the Minister is aware that the
construction of a new road from Sims Avenue, which
is in the Geylang Serai and Kampong Ubi
constituencies up to Jalan Eunos, has resulted in
several drains being blocked. If the Minister is
aware of the consequences after a flood, what steps
and measures can be taken by the Public Cleansing
Department to overcome this hardship? I am sure the
typhoid carrier contracted the disease by accident
of circumstances, but up to date no conclusive
evidence has been obtained. What ought to be done
by the Public Cleansing Department is to send the
cleansing workers to take over the responsibility
of maintaining a state of cleanliness in these two
areas and, at the same time, clear the drains which
have been choked in consequence of the road project
now in progress. This should be done daily and not
once or twice a year, which has hitherto been the
practice of the Public Cleansing Department in
respect of these constituencies.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, may I refer
first to the rather blatant statement by the Member
for Geylang Serai who attributed all the blame of
the typhoid outbreak to the Health Ministry. I
believe he must have followed the correspondence in
the Berita Harian where my officer put the facts
quite clearly. We are not trying to shirk any blame
whatsoever, but we put the facts clearly, and
wherever the blame falls, it falls rightly. From
what the doctors told me - it was not told to me
just for the sake of trying to exculpate themselves
from blame, but as a result of bacteriological
tests which
Column: 1123
had been carried out and from the evidence gathered
- it was quite conclusive that the major factor in
the outbreak was a break-down of personal hygiene,
and not the unsanitary conditions of the drains and
so on. This outbreak was the result of transmission
of the disease through food. In other words, it was
transmitted by carriers. In fact, this has been
borne out by the fact that one carrier, who
happened to be a hawker selling ice-drinks, was
responsible for the people who had bought drinks
from him going down with typhoid, and they, in
turn, infected their families and friends. These
victims had informed the Ministry officials that
they had bought drinks from this man. It is quite
clear that this outbreak of typhoid was the result
of poor personal hygiene.
Perhaps I may explain what I mean by personal
hygiene. It means that you must wash your hands
when you handle prepared food and before you eat
it. Not only that, you must cover any exposed food
or drinks from flies around.
It is not true to say that the Health Ministry has
been shirking its duties. It has been carrying out
its duty of removing the refuse in that area. But
may I say that if there is refuse in the drains it
is also the fault of the residents of the area
because, as the Member for Geylang Serai will know,
in our Keep Singapore Clean campaigns, the message
was that refuse should be thrown into dustbins and
not into drains. If there is refuse in the drains,
whose fault is it? Of course, it is the duty of the
Ministry's workers to collect the refuse from the
drains, but whose fault was it that, from the very
beginning, refuse was thrown into the drains?
Perhaps the Member for Geylang Serai may answer
that simple question. Also, we have been informed
that the residents did allow the children to
defecate into the drains. Again, there was evidence
that many of the lavatories - this is the bucket
system of lavatory which we find is unsatisfactory
- was not in a good state. Does the Member for
Geylang Serai say that the Health Ministry must
repair these lavatories for the residents there?
Column: 1124
Then he mentioned the construction of the Sims
Avenue Expressway which he blamed as the cause of
flooding. I am afraid he has raised this matter
under a different subhead. It should be under a
different Ministry. There again, may I say that
this is an area which is below the high-tide level.
I think my Ministry officials have stated quite
clearly that the only way to solve this problem of
flooding is to raise the whole area, because, as we
know, water flows from a high level to a low level.
It cannot flow from a low level to a high level. So
if the land is below high-tide level, how do you
expect it to flow? Is it the responsibility of the
Health Ministry to see that water flows upward?
The Member has said that the people in his
constituency have co-operated with the Government
in its Keep Singapore Clean campaign. I am very
glad they have done so. And he says that because
they have done so, they are now clean. We are not
saying that the residents are dirty or have poor
personal habits. It needs only one, two or three
hawkers who practise poor personal hygiene to cause
an outbreak of typhoid, even though the majority
practise a high standard of personal hygiene. That
is why the Ministry has never grown tired of
reminding the people of Singapore that, for the
sake of their own health, a high standard of
personal hygiene should be maintained. My officials
have told me that even though the surrounding areas
are insanitary, if a high standard of personal
hygiene is maintained by everybody, this sort of
outbreak via carriers cannot occur. I believe that
our Chairman, who is a medical man, will be able to
understand it even better. But that does not mean
that the Health Ministry is neglecting its duty to
clear the rubbish. We do clear it. In fact, a
correspondent in one of the newspapers says that
the place is much cleaner now. Of course, an
argument can be raised that we only cleaned it up
after the outbreak. But if the Cleansing Department
has not done its duty, did the Member complain to
the Ministry of Health before? I did not receive
any complaint from him.
Column: 1125
I turn now to the Member for Anson. He says that
the removal of refuse in the Republic is being done
irregularly. May I say that, as far as removal of
refuse is concerned, it is being regularly removed
daily. May I also add that Singapore is about one
of the very few countries in the world which remove
garbage daily, including Sundays and public
holidays. The position is quite different from that
in more advanced countries like New York, London or
even Tokyo where refuse is removed once or twice a
week.
6.45 p.m.
The Chairman: One minute to go, Mr Chua.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Yes, Sir. But I agree that
there may he cases of non-removal on particular
days, and the reasons are a shortage of labour and
drivers, and a break-down of vehicles.
Actually at the moment we are suffering from a
shortage of garbage truck drivers and labourers. In
fact, there is a need for 963 cleansing labourers
and 48 garbage truck drivers, and it is impossible
for us to --
Mr P. Govindaswamy: You give more pay and more
people will come forward.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Well, my colleague, the
Minister for Finance, is here, and the Member for
Anson can raise that matter with him if he has the
time.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Sir, in view of the
explanation given by the Minister, I beg leave to
withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to
move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1203 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1721.
Sir, we are trying to keep the city clean and our
campaign has met with some success. But
unfortunately we still find that there are certain
areas
Column: 1126
where mosquitoes are breeding. In spite of the
cleaning of the city, these mosquitoes are still
active. I wonder how the Anti-Mosquito Unit works.
Can the Minister see to it that the Anti-Mosquito
Unit checks the breeding spots of mosquitoes more
thoroughly, so that these places will not be
infested with mosquitoes? I understand there are
some new spray machines available in Singapore, and
perhaps these can be used to kill the mosquitoes
wherever they are found breeding.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Sir, first of all, may I
thank the Member for saying that Singapore is much
cleaner now. May I also say that the problem of
mosquitoes will be there so long as there are
people who breed mosquitoes in their own homes.
There are different types of mosquitoes. One of
them is the Aedes mosquito which causes dengue and
haemorrhagic fevers. This species breeds in water-bearing receptacles and other artificial containers
in the homes, which are often carelessly thrown
into the garden or into the open. Since launching
our Keep Singapore Clean and Mosquito Free Campaign
in 1969, we have had some good results in the sense
that the number of haemorrhagic fever cases has
gone down. In 1968 the number of these cases was
1,000 and in 1969 there were only 200 cases.
About the spraying of drains to prevent the
breeding of mosquitoes, that is being done. But may
I say this: Singapore is a tropical country, and
the climate is such that you may spray the drains
in the morning, but if it rains in the afternoon
all the insecticide is really going down the drain
into the canal. So as far as mosquito breeding in
drains is concerned, it is an engineering problem,
as there must be proper levels of drainage, in
other words, water must flow from higher levels to
lower levels.
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan: Sir, may I ask the Minister
whether we are still using D.D.T. for mosquito
control? If so, is he aware that in countries like
the
Column: 1127
United States of America, they have noted that
inordinate amounts of D.D.T. can cause all kinds of
health complications?
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Sir, there is a Vector
Control Unit in my Ministry headed by a specialist
officer. They have experimented with a certain type
of oil which is slightly different from D.D.T. We
are using this new type of oil. I cannot give the
Member for Whampoa more details about this, but if
he likes he can file a question so that I can
answer him. We are trying to go away from D.D.T. to
another type of oil, not only because D.D.T. is not
good for health, but because it also makes the
larvae more resistant. They become more rugged and,
therefore, more difficult to kill.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Sir, I beg leave to
withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
Conceicao -
(4) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1203 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1741.
The Chairman: Amendment (4) , Mr Conceicao. He is
not here. Amendment (5) , Mr Ramaswamy.
Mr S. Ramaswamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1203 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1831*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the names of Messrs. P. Govindaswamy and Yeo Choo Kok.)
Sir, under this subhead, Hawkers' Superintendent,
I wish to bring to the notice of this House the
nuisance and the difficulty caused by the hawkers
in my constituency. There are about 100 hawkers
doing business along Tai Thong Crescent, by the
side of MacPherson Market. In the mornings these
hawkers obstruct the flow of traffic, and it is
impossible for vehicles to pass through Tai Thong
Crescent. This problem has been brought to the
notice of the Hawkers Department a few years ago,
with the request that they resite the hawkers or
allot them pitches near the market,
Column: 1128
in the backlanes and sidelanes and along one side
of Tai Thong Crescent. In this way they need not
lose their livelihood, and the traffic also need
not be obstructed. From time to time the Potong
Pasir Citizens' Consultative Committee and I myself
have written to the Hawkers Department, and once to
the Parliamentary Secretary about this problem, but
without any result.
Can the Ministry take steps to allot proper
spaces or pitches to these hawkers, and to settle
this matter soon without causing any hardship to
them? From time to time the reason given for not
taking action to solve the problem is that the
Hawkers Department has priorities and that this
case does not deserve first consideration.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Sir, I brought up the hawker
problem in the last budget debate, and I have to
bring it up again today. In the cleared areas when
the hawkers slightly obstruct the road, the Hawkers
Department takes legal action against them. But
you find that no legal action is taken against
hawkers in many areas which are still uncleared,
and these hawkers make more profits and do not pay
licence fees. I am not speaking against the
officials concerned for not taking action against
the hawkers. All I am asking is that, until such
time as the whole of the republic is considered a
cleared area, the hawkers in the cleared areas
should be treated more leniently as they are
legitimate hawkers, and they possess licences to do
business.
Mr Yeo Choo Kok (Delta): Mr Speaker, Sir, I am
not speaking.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Sir, the hawker problem is
quite a difficult one. We heard the Member for
Potong Pasir saying that the hawkers are
obstructing traffic, and therefore action must be
taken. And then we heard from the Member for Anson
that, although they may obstruct traffic slightly,
we should not take action. So I am between the
devil and --
Column: 1129
Mr Ramaswamy: Point of clarification, Sir.
The Chairman: If the Minister gives way.
Mr Chua Sian Chin resumed his seat.
Mr Ramaswamy: Sir, I did not ask the Minister to
take action to clear them. I asked him to allow the
hawkers to do business without obstructing the
traffic.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Sir, I can understand the
point of the Member for Potong Pasir. In order not
to take action per se, but to resite them, you must
have a piece of land or site. And he also complains
of the delay. The delay is because it is not easy
to get another site where you can resite the
hawkers.
Mr Ramaswamy: I have suggested other sites.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Are they suitable? May I say
this then to put the mind of the Member for Potong
Pasir at rest: something is being done about this
problem. Although, as he has rightly said, we have
priorities, he can be sure that the Hawkers
Department will effect the resiting of the hawkers
at Tai Thong Crescent in June 1971. It is the
intention of the Department to resite them into a
newly paved back-lane and sidelanes around the
MacPherson Market.
Coming to the Member for Anson, he suggested
something which quite astounded me. He said that no
action or very little action should be taken
against hawkers in a cleared constituency. My
rational mind says that if you clear a constituency
of hawkers and resite them properly, you must not
allow other unlicensed hawkers to take the place of
those who have been resited.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Point of order, Sir.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: May I just say this?
Column: 1130
Mr P. Govindaswamy: No, I did not mention
unlicensed hawkers. I spoke about licensed hawkers.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: I agree. If licensed hawkers
have been properly resited in a certain place, but
you allow one of them to go back to the old place,
the others will say, "If you allow him to go back
to the old place, why cannot you allow the rest?"
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Sir, I only said that these
licensed hawkers obstruct the road a little bit. My
point is: these hawkers have limited space, and if
they move their pitches a little bit, then action
is taken against them.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: If you allow him a little
bit, you can allow him a little bit more, say, two
inches, three feet, or one mile.
Mr Ramaswamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am very glad
that the Minister has promised to resite these
hawkers in June - after two years. I beg leave to
withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $34,052,490 for Head 1203 ordered to
stand part of the Estimates.
Column: 1130
7.00 p.m.
Head 1301 -
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1301 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1001*.
(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr N. Govindasamy)
Mr Speaker, Sir, in our budget for the next financial year there is no increase in taxation or the imposition of new taxation. This is a very judicious financial policy, because it will not impose any additional burden on our people. This shows that our Government is looking after the
livelihood of our people.
Column: 1131
However, we should not overlook the fact that
there has been a general rise in the prices of
various goods recently. This has greatly affected
the livelihood of the people in the middle and
lower income groups. In order to get the facts to
substantiate my argument, I have personally made
inquiries into the increase in prices of daily
necessities. Let me quote the prices of the items obtaining in the past and compare them with those
obtaining in January 1971. We all know there are
several items of daily necessities. Although the
price of rice has not gone up, the price of bread
has recently been increased. Bread can be a
substitute for rice.
First of all, let me mention the price of oil.
Formerly, cooking oil cost $3.80 a tin. Now it is
$4.20 a tin. Salt now costs 15 cents more. Bean
sauce now costs 90 cents per bottle. Formerly it
was 80 cents per bottle. One tin of condensed milk
cost 40 cents before. Now it is 45 cents per tin. A
five-katty tin of biscuits formerly cost $3.00. Now
it costs $3.30 per tin. Lean meat cost $2.50 per
katty before. Now it is $3.30 per katty. There are
also other imported goods, for example, frozen
beef, which formerly cost $2.60 per katty. Now it
costs $4.40 per katty. This is quite a considerable
rise.
I am just enumerating these few items to enable
the Minister and his Parliamentary Secretary to
understand the situation better. Perhaps the
Ministry of Finance has not been very careful in
compiling the data. It may well be that it has
gathered the data from hearsay and, as a result, it
is not well informed. The increases in prices have
a great influence on our people, especially those
in the lower income group. Take, for instance, an
employee working in a small office earning a
monthly salary of $200 and with many mouths to
feed. His livelihood will be made very difficult as
a result of these increases in prices. Out of the
$200, he will have to spend $40 on house rent, and
in addition he will have to spend money on
education, food and other items of daily
necessities. How is he going to make ends meet?
Column: 1132
What is the reason for the increase in prices in
recent months? We should find out the real reason
so that we can deal with this problem. I hope the
Minister will not take a cannot-careless attitude.
On the contrary, he should take positive steps to
remedy the situation by curbing the increase in
prices. I agree with the Minister of State for
Finance when he suggested that we should form a
Consumers' Association. A Consumers' Association,
comprising people of the middle and lower classes,
can see to it that the merchants and traders will
not overcharge the prices of goods. In this way,
the consumers can bargain with the traders and
maintain the prices of goods at a reasonable level.
I appreciate the suggestion and I hope the Ministry
of Finance will take steps to assist in the
formation of a Consumers' Association. For
instance, the Ministry of Finance can be of great
assistance in the field of administration.
I also wish to suggest to the Minister that he
should set up a Price Control Committee. Although
he may say that he is not prepared to do so, I
would like him to reconsider my suggestion, because
I think a Price Control Committee is very
essential. This committee can be charged with the
duty of not only collecting data on prices, but
also determining whether or not certain increases
in prices are justified. The committee can also
deal with merchants who increase their prices
unreasonably. In fact, the price of daily
necessities does not depend on supply and demand
only. Sometimes it is due to personal manipulation
and other extraneous circumstances. For instance, a
few weeks ago when Parliament was about to sit to
debate the present budget, certain irresponsible
merchants spread rumours among the people that
certain goods would be taxed and that certain
tinned foodstuffs would also be taxed. Even
Ovaltine and rice would be further taxed. All these
rumours caused fluctuations in the market prices,
especially the prices of daily necessities. Some
irresponsible merchants made use of this
opportunity to increase the prices
Column: 1133
of certain goods. If we can set up a Price Control
Committee to control the prices of daily
necessities and to supervise the market, the prices
of daily necessities will be more stable. Our
people will be able to live a more stable life and
they will not be subject to the fluctuations in
market prices. I hope the Minister will consider my
suggestion.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, after going
through the Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure of
Singapore for the current financial year, I find
that I am more confused about the actual staffing
position in the various Ministries and departments.
Let me illustrate my point by referring to the
Ministry of Labour, for example, where the
incumbents of various positions, from that of
Permanent Secretary to those of executive officers,
are not substantive holders of the posts. They are
merely acting in the posts. What is most puzzling
to me is that some of them are acting in posts two
grades above their substantive grades. If these
acting appointments were made for a short period of
time, it would have been more understandable. But
the strange fact is that these acting appointments
are often of several months' duration and, without
exaggeration, they may be said to be made for life.
Such a situation is obviously very unhealthy.
The same can be said of practically all the other
departments in the Singapore civil service. Even in
the Ministry of Finance, I believe there are more
"actors" than substantive holders of the posts.
The civil service has many types of employees,
namely, open-vote employees, temporary employees,
acting employees, officiating employees, and
supernumerary employees. Open-vote employees are
also known to be temporary. However, some of these
open-vote employees have been in service for more
than 30 years and they are still known by the
nomenclature. Temporary and officiating employees
are either acting for some other
Column: 1134
incumbents, who themselves are acting or
officiating for others or are officiating in their
own right, but in both cases for long periods. In
addition, we have supernumerary posts filled by
people who have no business to be there at all.
When can we expect the Ministry of Finance to
streamline the civil service so that all
appointments are filled by permanent employees who
are more likely to give better service, since one
of the main grouses and frustrations of our civil
servants is that, although they may be good enough
"actors" for many years, they are not able to
qualify for the substantive appointments in which
they have acted. If they are not suitable for
substantive appointments, it is not fair to ask
them to act for long periods. Perhaps we should try
to induce more suitably qualified persons to apply
for civil service appointments. The salary scales
for senior civil servants are not competitively
attractive and their working conditions leave much
to be desired.
I spoke about this aspect during the debate on the
Government's financial policy statement, and I was
not properly answered. A committee was set up on an
ad hoc basis to revise the salary structure of the
open-vote daily-rated employees. Another committee
was set up to look into the salaries of the Police
Force. And yet a third committee was set up to look
into the salaries of senior civil servants.
Yesterday we were told by the Minister for Social
Affairs that the salaries of the Fire Brigade staff
and their terms and conditions of service will also
be looked into after they have settled with the
Police Force. The Ministry of Education is again
looking into the salary structure of the teachers.
Are we going to continue to look into the salary
structures and working conditions department by
department? I believe it is high time that the
Ministry of Finance gave sufficient thought to the
whole structure of the civil service and drew up a
comprehensive programme for streamlining the civil
service in respect of the salary structure and
working conditions if we are to have an efficient
civil service. A solution that is framed
Column: 1135
in a haphazard manner and in isolation from other
considerations is worse than no solution at all.
Sir, I have mentioned all this quickly because
perhaps the Minister has only ten minutes to reply
and I sincerely hope he will delve into this
problem and not into the business of the high cost
of living, because, however important it may be, it
has been raised before.
7.15 p.m.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein): Mr Speaker, Sir,
you will recall that on the 16th of this month I
asked the Minister for Education about the progress
of the current negotiations between the Teachers'
Unions and his Ministry and the response of the
Ministry to the teachers' proposal. The reply of
the Minister for Education was that, as far as his
Ministry was concerned, they had already submitted
their proposals to the Ministry of Finance some
time in December last year. This is late March. I
would like to ask the Minister for Finance when we
can expect an answer from his Ministry and whether
he will personally look into the matter. He must
excuse me if I have got not much confidence in the
civil servants of his Ministry for two reasons. One
reason is that, as the Member for Telok Blangah has
pointed out, they are in acting capacities and are
not confident or competent enough to make a very
serious study and make sound judgments on some of
the proposals that have been put forward by the
Ministry of Education. The other reason is that I
myself have personally lost confidence in the
manner in which the Treasury handles civil
servants' problems with regard to conditions of
service.
Sir, to illustrate my point, I quote the example
of one teacher's problem on the question of
anomaly. On 1st May, 1958, a new salary scale was
introduced for teachers who joined the service
after this date. This scale is inferior to the old
scale. The stipulation of the Treasury and the
Education Ministry was that those who joined the
service after that
Column: 1136
date would be placed on the new scale and those who
were in the service before that date would get the
old scale. And today we have teachers who joined
the education service before 1st May, 1958, and who
were put on the new scale. This problem was raised
with the Education Ministry years ago by the
Teachers' Unions and we received a reply saying
that the matter had been referred to the Treasury,
but up to now there has been no reply from the Trea
sury. This is one example to illustrate my point
about the very inefficient manner in which the
Treasury is handling some of the civil servants'
problems with regard to terms and conditions of
service.
Just to round off my request, I would seek the
Minister for Finance's personal attention to the
teachers' proposals so that the matter can be
expedited. He will appreciate that on the 1st of
September, 1970, the then Minister for Education,
Mr Ong Pang Boon, made an announcement inviting
the Teachers' Unions to negotiate with the Ministry
of Education. The first official meeting was on
10th October, 1970. All that the teachers are
asking for is some response to the proposals that
were put forward at the meeting. Surely this is not
too much to expect from the Ministry of Finance
when the Ministry of Education has already
submitted its recommendations on the teachers'
proposals.
Mr Ho Kah Leong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I have the same feeling as the Member for Moulmein
has in regard to the officials of the Ministry of
Finance. They are slow as snails in their working
efficiency. I hope the Minister himself will
supervise them and ask them to expedite the
question of teachers' salaries.
I would like to take this opportunity to ask the
Minister one question. When we were discussing the
question of fisheries, the Minister for Law and
National Development said that the question of
pioneer status came under the Ministry of Finance
and not under his Ministry. I want to know why the
pioneer status for the deep-sea fishing industry
Column: 1137
was withdrawn. The Minister for Law and, National
Development has asked me to refer this matter to
the Minister for Finance. So I am taking this
opportunity to do so. I notice that in the Finance
Minister's budget speech, he mentioned that he
would encourage deep-sea fishing. If he intends to
encourage it, why was the pioneer status for the
deep-sea fishing industry withdrawn?
The Chairman: Mr Hon, you have 10 minutes to
reply to all the points.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr
Speaker, Sir, because of the shortage of time, I am
afraid I will not be able to answer all the
questions. I will take the suggestion of the Member
for Telok Blangah that I should not concentrate too
much on the rise in the cost of living. This is not
because I do not consider it important. In fact,
this is one of the many problems that we shall have
to consider during this year. Perhaps I should say
to the Member for Sembawang that I do not live on
fresh air and sunshine, and that I also consume
some of the commodities that he has mentioned, like
rice, bread, oil, salt and so on. My wife tells me
that there has been some increase in prices of
goods that she buys.
Mr J. F. Conceicao: Good show!
Mr Hon Sui Sen: As far as the increases in some
other cases are concerned, they may not be
justifiable. We have not agreed to these increases.
For example, in the case of bread, the impression
that has been given that we have accepted the
increase in the price of bread is not correct. We
have asked why there has been this increase, and we
have found that even if there is an increase in raw
materials, it does not justify an increase of five
cents. There may be an increase in the price of
flour which might justify a one-cent increase. We
are looking into all these matters and we shall try
to do what we can.
Column: 1138
At the same time, I do not think we can accept
the idea of price control, because the experience
of people who lived with price control just after
the war should make it clear that this is
detrimental to the supply that is coming on to the
market at reasonable prices. But we will give such
help as we can in the collection of statistics,
although there is some doubt about the figures that
we produce. I think our inspectors in the market
are just as able to find out about prices. The
Trade Division and the Singapore Institute of
Standards and Industrial Research will look into
the quality and nature of the materials that go
into the finished products.
I will now come to the matter of the civil
service. I am in some sympathy with the Member for
Telok Blangah when he says he is confused by the
many appointments - acting, officiating, temporary,
supernumerary, etc. These, of course, are not there
because we like to confuse Members or ourselves.
But they are just the result of a very rapid
increase in the number of civil servants. In fact,
50 per cent of the administrative officers have
less than three years' service. They are
probationers. In the circumstances, it is not
possible for the posts to be filled by officers who
have the requisite experience and qualifications.
In 1959, our civil service had 1,255 Division One
posts. Today there are 3,907 Division One posts, an
increase of more than three times, and we are not
able to keep up with the expansion of the services.
Therefore, we have had to resort to acting
appointments. Where these appointments are more
than two grades higher, then the persons who fill
them are said to be officiating.
The supernumerary appointments are, of course,
necessary. Under various circumstances, officers
going on very long leave or going on leave prior to
retirement, or officers who are understudying other
officers before taking over the duties, and
officers in excess of requirements naturally will
have to be shown in the estimates, especially when
they go off on national service. These various
designations are there because there is
Column: 1139
a need to show them as such, rather than as
permanent officers. Of course, we would like to
have a civil service filled with officers of the
right quality and calibre in substantive
appointments, and we are trying our best to do what
we can to train our civil servants so that they can
be fully qualified for their duties.
In regard to the salary scales and conditions of
service and their determination, this is one of the
important matters we have to look into in order to
get a full complement of substantive holders of the
posts, and we will give consideration to the
various salary scales. Consideration of these
scales is being done. In fact, it has been
mentioned that we are looking into the scales of
daily-rated workers, the Police Force, the Fire
Brigade and so on. So some action is being taken,
perhaps not as fast as the Members would like us to
take, but we are looking into these salary scales.
In view of the shortage of staff which I have
mentioned, and the fact that we do not always have
people in the grades doing the work of looking into
the salary scales, I think our civil service,
instead of being criticised, ought to be given some
praise for the work that they are doing and for the
very large amount of overtime which they are doing.
In regard to the Ministry of Education and the
teachers' proposals, this is not something which
has been set aside. I hope that after consideration
of the budget has been gone through, we shall get
in touch with the Ministry of Education and come to
some arrangement on the new salary scales which
have been under examination.
7.30 p.m.
The Member for Jurong asked why fisheries are not
pioneer industries. The reason for this is fairly
simple. The fishing industry is really a very old
industry, if not the oldest industry in the world.
It certainly is not a modern industry, and
therefore we did not think that it was appropriate
that it should come under pioneer status. We wish
to encourage fisheries. In fact, we make large
amounts of finance available to
Column: 1140
anyone who wishes to engage in deep-sea fishing.
The loans which have been approved by the
Development Bank for some of the industries have
been to the extent of 80 per cent of the cost of
the assets.
The Chairman: Your time is up, Mr Hon.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, I was not criticising the
civil service but the Ministry of Finance. Officers
have been asked to act for umpteen years and they
are doing a good job. This is quite clear. I am not
criticising the officers who are acting. If they
are found to be suitable to act for a number of
years, they should be found suitable to hold the
job substantively. As far as I am concerned,
officiating means somebody officiating a marriage.
There must be a tremendous shortage of suitable
persons in the civil service if officers are asked
to officiate two steps above their substantive
appointments. This shortage, as I mentioned earlier
when we debated the Minister's financial policy
statement, is due to the fact that we are not
getting the appropriate persons into the civil
service, as we are not offering competitive
salaries and attractive terms and conditions of
service. Therefore, my point is that there is
justification for a salary revision, which the
Government accepts, and as a result ad hoc salary
revision committees have been set up for daily-rated and senior civil servants, the Police Force,
the Fire Brigade and the teachers. I think the
Minister accepts that the cause for revision is
there. My point is, why not do it once and for all
for the whole civil service instead of department
by department and division by division?
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan: Mr Speaker, Sir, in virtually
every country civil service salaries lag behind
commercial and industrial salaries, even more so in
a situation of very rapid development as we find
ourselves in. The danger that we are confronted
with here in Singapore today is that the top
calibre personnel in the civil service may be drawn
away towards the commercial and industrial sectors,
leading to shortages of the kind
Column: 1141
which are very serious indeed, namely, top-level
personnel. In such a situation, there are two
things which can be done. One is a quick revision
of salary, but this cannot be done to a
considerable extent, especially in the present
context of our general wage restraint policy for
industry and the commercial sector as well. The
other possibility, taken in conjunction with some
revision of salary, is rapid promotion of people.
We have to get away from the kind of mentality
which says that, because I took 20 years to become
a Permanent Secretary, therefore anybody who
becomes a Permanent Secretary must take 20 years to
get up there. Why cannot a person do it in five
years or seven years if he has the ability and is
prepared to work hard? Let us change this kind of
mentality. Promote people rapidly. If they have the
ability, put them up there. If you put them in an
acting capacity for three months or six months and
they have shown themselves to be capable, confirm
them in their positions. I have argued on at least
two occasions for the upgrading of the quality of
the civil service, especially in respect of the
upper level and the professional staff. Our economy
is getting more sophisticated, and in order to
understand it, to comprehend it and to service it
adequately, we need to have technical and
professional people to monitor and service industry
and commerce. In order to do this, we have to be
prepared to pay the price for people with these
qualifications.
At present we pay Master's Degree holders two
increments above the ordinary point of entry, and
four increments in respect of Ph.D.s. It seems to
me that it is just ridiculous to give two
increments for a Master's degree and four for a
Ph.D, degree, because, first of all, there are
considerable earnings which a person has to give up
when he pursues a Master's degree, which normally
takes at least one year, if not two; and a Ph.D.
degree takes at least two years, if not four,
depending on which country he goes to. In addition,
there is
Column: 1142
considerable effort behind the acquisition of a
higher degree. It also presupposes a certain high
enough level of qualifications in respect of the
basic degree. All things taken together, Sir, the
indication is that we need substantially more than
two increments for the Master's degree and
substantially more than four increments for the Ph.
D. degree, and also rapid promotion for both.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Sir, nobody cares very much
for the civil servants because they cannot run away
from a department after having served there for 20
to 25 years. The professional officers can all run
away because they can get higher salaries outside,
but the poor junior officers, with whatever
salaries they receive, will have to remain there.
Now legally qualified officers also come into
Government service and therefore long-service
people have difficulty in getting promotion. The
Minister for Finance must consider revising the
salaries of the civil servants because they are the
backbone of the Government. If they work hard, the
Government will also get a better name. Because the
poor civil servants cannot vent their grouses, we
tend to leave them out. Perhaps the Minister will
consider the matter.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): I asked a
question just now, but the Minister appears not to
have clearly understood it. It is about the
establishment of a consumers' association. I
requested the Ministry of Finance to take steps to
assist in the formation of a consumers'
association, and the Minister of State for Finance
himself mentioned this possibility. I think this is
definitely a very good thing to do. We would like
to set up a consumers' association to stabilise the
prices of our goods. I did ask the Ministry of
Finance to assist in its formation and
administration.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: As the Minister of State for
Finance has already said that he will be prepared
to give assistance to the consumers' association, I
think I need say nothing more on this. We will give
assistance.
Column: 1143
I would like to answer the comments of the Member
for Telok Blangah in which he blamed the Ministry
of Finance, but not the civil service, for the
present condition of the civil service and their
terms and conditions of service. As far as the
acting appointments are concerned, and their being
done away with, this is not within our
dispensation. The substantive filling of posts,
especially the superscale posts, is a matter for
the Public Service Commission. Unless it considers
that the civil servant can fill the post
substantively, the only course of action we can
take is to fill it on an acting basis or an
officiating basis or a temporary basis.
With regard to quick solutions to the civil
servants' salaries, of course, it is very easy to
suggest that we should do this in a very rapid way.
I suppose the most rapid way is to give everyone a
10 per cent increase. On this basis, we can then
really get rid of the committees inquiring into the
salary scales of daily-rated workers, the senior
civil servants and the staff of the Fire Brigade!
Perhaps we should take some of the blame for not
dealing with these matters as rapidly as possible,
but I suppose the test of any Minister for Finance,
or any of his officials, is whether or not they are
accused of giving in too easily to requests for
salary increases!
The Member for Whampoa suggested that it would be
necessary to give salary increases for a Master's
degree and a Ph. D. degree beyond the two to four
increments that have already been conceded. On this
point, we must consider not whether the paper
qualifications are a Master's, a Ph. D's or an
Honours degree, but whether the applicant or the
present holder can fill the job, and on this there
is no other test than actual performance of the
job. For quality in the civil service, it would be
very desirable that we should be able to pay civil
servants a remuneration commensurate with their
value, but the difficulty in dealing with, say,
4,000 senior civil servants - that was the figure
of Division One officers which I gave is that we
cannot compete with the commercial
Column: 1144
firms which want only one or two officers and can
therefore pay 10 per cent above whatever may be
offered in the civil service. Even if we increase
the senior civil servants' salaries by 20 per cent,
the commercial firms can always up this by another
20 per cent.
An hon. Member: Give them rapid promotion!
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Well, that is being done. Perhaps
there has been some complaint that we do not
consider the seniority principle too sacrosanct,
and we have sometimes promoted fairly young
officers to Permanent Secretary grade, if not
substantively, at least to act in the Permanent
Secretary's post even though they have not had 20
years of service. If there are officers with five
to seven years' service and with outstanding
ability, and if they can perform the job of the
Permanent Secretary, I, as Minister for Finance,
will have absolutely no objection to their being
rapidly promoted. I think I have answered most of
the questions.
Dr Augustine Tan: Sir, I am afraid the Minister
has missed the point regarding the two increments
for the Master's degree and four for the Ph.D.
degree. I was not at any time implying that holding
a Master's degree or a Ph. D. degree alone is
sufficient to indicate quality. All I was saying
was that you must take into account the
marketability of such degree holders. If you do not
pay them a sufficient number of increments, you are
not likely to be able to attract better quality
degree holders into the civil service. You end up
with a mediocre one, from Timbuctoo or some other
unknown university.
7.45 p.m.
Sir, may I also vent my frustration, which I am
sure my fellow Backbenchers also share, that
Ministers seem to be in the habit of passing the
ball from one to the other - from Health to
Finance, now from Finance to the Public Service
Commission. Sir, may we know the ultimate
repository of power that we may have recourse to to
get some of these things done?
Column: 1145
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Perhaps I can answer the last
one, i.e., passing the buck or the ball. As far as
the Public Service Commission is concerned, it is
the ultimate authority. I do not think there is any
question of its passing the buck any further.
An hon. Member: The buck stops there!
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Yes, the buck stops there. I do
not think there is any question about it. This was
the decision of Members of Parliament here when the
Public Service Commission Ordinance was passed. I
still think that however much we like to be able to
promote the officers, the neutrality of the Public
Service Commission is something which we still
accept and would like to see continue.
On Master's and Ph. D. degrees, it has been
considered that two and four increments
respectively would be sufficient, because it is a
matter of opinion whether or not we are getting
enough Ph.D.s. But we have quite a number. Those
whom we send overseas on study courses, when they
come back, are usually bound to the Government for
three or five, or even eight years in some cases.
Our problem really is not to recruit them into the
service but rather, after they have been recruited
into the service, to retain them in the face of the
blandishments of commerce and industry. I say that
is very difficult because the private sector can
always pay a little bit more than whatever we may
want to pay them. The final test really is whether
the man likes the administrative work in the civil
service or whether he wants to go outside and try
his luck in commerce and industry. Perhaps there
are very big rewards obtainable there, but at the
same time there is the great risk that his paper
qualifications may not, after all, make him a good
industrialist.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong: Sir, on the question of
passing the buck with regard to promotion
exercises, I accept the explanation of the Minister
for Finance that the buck has got to be passed to
Column: 1146
the Public Service Commission, because it is the
ultimate authority in determining the promotion of
officers. But there are other civil service matters
which the Public Service Commission is not
concerned with, and the buck actually ends at the
Ministry of Finance. Therefore, the Ministry of
Finance is responsible for, shall I say, messing
things up.
To illustrate my point, I will just quote an
example of what happened in the Education service.
Not everybody knows that there is a shortage of
teachers, but everybody knows that there is a
shortage of graduate teachers. Sometime between
advertisements for teachers, graduates applied for
posts in the Education Ministry, and the reply was
that there was no vacancy because certain civil
service procedures had to be observed to determine
the vacancies. I think it will take me a long time
to explain how they work. In fact, I myself do not
quite understand how they work. They have a one-track mind. This is just to illustrate the
ridiculous situation that exists. You know very
well that there is a shortage of graduate teachers,
and yet you get a reply saying that there is no
vacancy. And they quote so many rules and
stipulations to prove that there is no shortage of
teachers. This proves the point that when the
responsibility is clearly with some department,
they mess things up.
I now come back to the other point which I
mentioned earlier but which was not answered, and
that is the stipulation laid down by the Education
Ministry (of course, with the approval of the
Finance Ministry) that teachers who joined on or
after 1st May, 1958 would receive a salary scale
lower than that given to those who joined before
that date. The old salary scale is much better.
There are teachers who joined the service before
1st May, 1958, and so according to the stipulation,
they should get the old scale, but instead they
were given the new scale. And when representations
were made to the Education Ministry, they said the
Finance Ministry was responsible. The Finance
Ministry in turn said the
Column: 1147
Education Ministry was responsible. This went on
for years. What happens then to the teachers? This
is only one example to show how helpless the civil
servants are. When they want to seek redress for their grievances in matters
relating to service conditions, I do not
think the Ministry of Finance can pass the buck to anybody else,
because the buck ends there. I think this manner of handling problems
relating to service conditions and other matters has
reach such a very unhealthy level
that a log of dissatisfaction and
unhappiness is caused, apart from the poor salary scales of the civil service.
I think it is because of this situation that civil servants are just not satisfied
with the answers they get for their
grievances. They get lost. They are
helpless. They do not know where to
go to. This passing of the buck from
one Ministry to the Finance Ministry
conveniently ignores the civil servants'
problems. So unless the Finance Ministry takes the
buck and handles the
problems more intelligently - rather than with a one-track mind -
I think such problems will never be solved. But
if there is a more efficient and more intelligent manner of handling
civil service problems, many of the grievances will be removed, and there will be greater
contentment in the civil service.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Sir, first of all, I do not know
why the Ministry of Finance should be blamed even for
graduate teacher vacancies not being
filled. Quite obviously there are vacancies,
and the Minister for Education, I
believe, has made it quite clear that he cannot get
enough teachers. And if the
Member for Moulmein has got any
graduate teachers knocking at the door,
I guarantee that they will be let in.
There will be no passing of the buck in
this case.
As to the stipulation laid down by
the Ministry of Education, I am afraid
I do not know much about the circumstances
Column: 1148
in which the old and the new salary scales
were formulated. But if it will give him any satisfaction, I will look into
this and see whether it is the Ministry of Finance that is
responsible for this.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, will Minister consider
setting up a Personnel Department to look after the interests
of the civil servants, as this will prevent the passing of the
buck? This is important, because I have noticed
from the civil service structure in the Ministry of Finance
that there is only one Executive Officer (I think he is
acting as Higher Executive Officer) looking after the interests
of about 13,000 daily-rated employees. The civil servants do
not know where to take their problems to. If they take them to the Ministry
concerned, they are asked to refer to the Ministry of Finance, and they do
not know whom they should approach there. I think it is about time the
Government prevented further frustrations of the
civil servants and set up a Personnel Department in the Ministry of Finance
to look into the problems
of the numerous civil servants that we have. Will
the Minister consider the possibility of setting up such a department?
Mr Hon Sui Sen: I think the Member for Telok Blangah is not really aware
of the organisation of the civil service. Surely
we have a Personnel Department; in fact, it
is the Establishment Branch of the Ministry of
Finance, and the Permanent Secretary is in
charge. He has a number of Deputy Secretaries in
charge of service conditions. There is a
Career and Development Officer whom we recently
appointed to take charge of the training of civil
servants. The question which has been asked
about the Higher Executive Officer in
charge of the Training Centre - I do not know
whether this is the same matter - but anyway I can
categorically assure the Member that the Personnel
Department and personnel matters are not being
handled at Executive Officer or Higher
Executive Officer level.
Column: 1149
Dr Augustine Tan: Mr Speaker, Sir, may I ask
the Minister for Finance when was the last time
that rules and regulations governing the terms and
conditions of the entire civil service were revised
or overhauled? It seems to me that some of these
rules must be out-dated. Although they were meant
to prevent abuses and so on, they do, in actual
fact, considerably tie the hands of the brighter
people, people with more entrepreneurial energies.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong: Sir, on the question of the
Personnel Department, it is true that there are
persons or bodies in this department handling
personnel matters and so on. But I think it is not
so much a question of bodies handling these
problems, but the approach adopted by the -
The Chairman: Mr Sia, what do you mean by
"bodies"? Do you mean human beings?
Mr Sia Khoon Seong: Persons, yes. The Minister
replied to my colleague, the Member for Telok
Blangah, that there is such a department with the
Permanent Secretary in charge, and Deputy
Secretaries and so on. It is accepted. But I think
it is the manner of handling these personnel
problems. And as has been pointed out by my
colleague, the Member for Whampoa, some of the
rules and regulations are obsolete. I think there
should be some adoption of modern management
techniques, personnel relationship. I suggest that
we follow some of the private firms where they have
much less employees, and they adopt very modern,
close personnel relations, human relations,
absolutely important, not bureaucratic, impersonal.
I was told that in the civil service they are just
digits -
Mr Conceicao: Bodies!
Mr Sia Khoon Seong: Bodies. I think it is a
matter of revamping the whole set-up and adopting a
new approach in keeping with the progress of
Singapore.
Column: 1150
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, this is an important
issue. Fortunately for me, Sir, I have dealt with
the Ministry of Finance on grievances of civil
servants, daily-rated employees, the lot. The
Minister is right - they have an Establishment
Branch where a Deputy Secretary, who is in charge
of so many other matters, is also in charge of
personnel problems. When I said that there is only
an Executive Officer, acting as Higher Executive
Officer, who handles the problems of 13,000 daily-rated employees, I meant it, Sir. That is a fact.
They do not have a Personnel Department in the
Ministry of Finance as such. The Estimates do not
provide for it. But there are persons in the
Establishment Branch who, when grievances are taken
up, deal with them. As the Member for Moulmein has
pointed out, what we want is a department that
looks after nothing else but this, and a department
which has sufficient people to handle the day-to-day problems that arise in such a large civil
service as ours, perhaps even to match the
personnel departments in the private sector. In the
long run, Sir, this will be a worthwhile investment
on the part of the Government in that it will have
a less frustrated civil service. Although it may
not be possible to remove all the frustrations,
perhaps we could have a less frustrated civil
service.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong: The human touch!
Mr Hon Sui Sen: First of all. I think the
question of when the rules and regulations of the
civil service were revised -
8.00 p.m.
The Chairman: Order. Moment of interruption.
Thereupon Mr Speaker left the Chair of the
Committee and took the Chair of the House.
Column: 1151
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to report that the Committee of
Supply has made further progress on the
Estimates of Expenditure for the financial year 1st April,
1971, to 31st March, 1972, and ask leave to sit again tomorrow.
Mr Speaker: So be it.
Column: 1152
ADJOURNMENT
Resolved,
"That Parliament do now adjourn." - [Mr Hon Sui Sen]
Adjourned accordingly at
One minute past Eight o'clock p.m.
Column: 1152
Appendix to Speaker's Announcement (Cols. 1049-50) (Cols 1153-1154)