| Parliament No: | 2 |
| Session No: | 2 |
| Volume No: | 31 |
| Sitting No: | 9 |
| Sitting Date: | 07-03-1972 |
|
Column: 459
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
SECOND PARLIAMENT
Tuesday, 7th March, 1972
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Dr Yeoh Ghim Seng, B.B.M., J.P. (Joo Chiat).
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang).
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development and Leader of the House.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh).
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (MacPherson), Minister for Health.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong).
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister of Defence.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah).
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division).
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Column: 460
Mr Hon Sui Sen, D.U.B.C. (Havelock), Minister for Finance.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Minister of State for Education.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah).
Mr Lim Kim San, D.U.T. (Cairnhill), Minister for Education.
Mr Low Guan Onn (River Valley).
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford).
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Inche Mohd. Ghazali Bin Ismail (Aljunied), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Labour.
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon).
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Defence.
Inche Rahmat Bin Kenap Al-Haj (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam). Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Potong Pasir).
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs.
Column: 461
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee).
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang).
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Minister of State for Labour and Government Whip.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan (Whampoa).
Mr Tang See Chim (Chua Chu Kang), Minister of State for Finance.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology.
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Minister of State of Defence.
Column: 462
Prof. Wong Lin Ken, B.B.M. (Alexandra), Minister for Home Affairs.
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampong Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Mr Yeo Choo Kok (Delta).
Mr Yeo Toon Chia (Kampong Kapor).
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications.
ABSENT:
Dr Chiang Hai Ding (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Inche Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampong Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Column: 461
PERMISSION TO MEMBERS TO BE ABSENT
Under the provisions of clause 2 (d) of Article
30 of the Constitution of Singapore, the following
Members have been granted permission to be or to
remain absent from sittings of Parliament (or any
committee of Parliament to which they have been
appointed) for the periods stated: -
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health - from 6th to 22nd December, 1971.
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs from 13th to 17th December, 1971.
Mr Tang See Chim (Chua Chu Kang), Minister of State for Finance - from 20th December, 1971, to 3rd January, 1972.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office - from 1st January to 30th June, 1972.
Dr Chiang Hai Ding (Ulu Pandan), from 1st January to 30th June, 1972.
Column: 462
Inche Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampong Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture - from 4th to 11th January, 1972, and from 29th February to 14th March, 1972.
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampong Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office - from 16th January to 29th February, 1972.
Mr Lim Kim San (Cairnhill), Minister for Education - from 24th to 28th January, 1972.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah) - from 5th to 12th February, 1972.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu) - from 22nd to 26th February, 1972.
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang) - from 10th to 22nd March, 1972.
| | YEOH GHIM SENG |
| | Speaker, |
| | Parliament of Singapore |
Column: 463
ASSENTS TO BILLS PASSED
The following Bills were assented to
by the President of the Republic of Singapore on the dates stated:-
3rd December, 1971
(i) Customs (Amendment) Bill;
(ii) Employment (Amendment) Bill; and
(iii) Redundancy Payments Fund (Amendment) Bill.
9th December, 1971
(i) Pensions (Amendment) Bill; and
(ii) Parliamentary Pensions (Amendment) Bill.
16th December, 1971
(i) Parliamentary Membership Bill; and
(ii) Parliamentary Elections (Amendment) Bill.
Column: 464
18th December, 1971
Common Gaming Houses(Amendment) Bill.
21st December, 1971
(i) Singapore Polytechnic(Amendment) Bill;
(ii) National Statistical Commission of Singapore Bill;
(iii) Chit Funds Bill; an
(iv) Clean Air Bill.
21st January, 1972
(i) Dentists Registration(Amendment) Bill;
(ii) Medical Registration(Amendment) Bill.
| | YEOH GHIM SENG |
| | Speaker, |
| | Parliament of Singapore |
Column: 463
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEE
(Annoucement by Mr Speaker)
Mr Speaker: In accordance with Standing Order No. 97, I have to
inform Hounourable Members that, on 16th December, 1971,
the Speaker nominated Mr Ng Kah Ting to take the place
of Mr Hon Sui Sen on the Public Accounts Committee.
Column: 463
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
STUDENTS COMPLETING FULL-TIME NATIONAL SERVICE
(Particulars)
1. Mr P. Govindaswamy asked the Minister of Defence how many
students have completed full-time national service since
the implemnetaion of national service; how many of them have been
offered jobs or higher education; and how many of them are still jobless.
Column: 464
The Minister of Defence (Dr Goh Keng Swee): Sir, there are
2,449 national servicemen with School Certificate, Higher School
Certificate, Diploma or Degree qualifications who have completed
national service. Of these, 1,144 left the Singapore Armed Forces
before teh Direction of Employmnet Scheme was introduced. The rest(1,305)
had been registered with the Direction of employment Department as at 31st
December, 1971. Of these, 1,007 are known to have obtained employment
because their employment cards have been returned to the Department by
employers. The others, some 298, presumably were still looking for
jobs as on 31st December, 1971. It could be that most of these had
only just been released.
Column: 464
WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION
ACT
(Amending legislation for enhanced compensation)
2. Inche Abdul Aziz Karim asked the Minster for Labour
if he will introduce legislation to amend the Workmen's
Compensation Act (Chapter 130)
Column: 465
(i) to ensure that a workman who suffers
permanently disabling injury is compensated for
loss of earnings, medical costs, rehabilitation,
pain, suffering, shock, loss of standing in the
community, humiliation, mortification and all other
forms of tangible and intangible ill-effects; and
(ii) to entitle a permanently disabled workman to
monetary compensation exceeding several-fold the
rates and sums laid down under the existing law.
The Minister of State for Labour (Mr Sia Kah Hui) (for the Minister for Labour): (i) Mr Speaker, Sir,
the Workmen's Compensation Act provides that the
workman who suffers as a result of an accident
arising out of and in the course of his employment
shall be entitled to compensation. The compensation
is related to the loss of earning capacity and is
intended to be a substitute income contributed by
the employer. In addition, the employer is required
to bear medical costs arising out of a workman's
hospitalisation and treatment, including artificial
and surgical appliances.
According to the Act, the injured worker is
entitled to compensation, regardless of whether or
not he is responsible for the accident. Members
will no doubt agree that this is a practical and
realistic approach to the question of compensation.
However, the worker has the option of proceeding to
claim damages in the Civil Courts if he feels that
the liability for the accident can be attributed to
the employer or a third party.
The Member for Kallang will no doubt agree that
whatever the quantum of compensation, it can never
fully compensate the worker who sustains an injury
resulting in permanent disablement. Moreover,
compensation on the lines suggested by the Member
will present numerous difficulties in practice,
such as quantifying the compensation payable for
such intangible ill-effects like pain, shock,
mortification, humiliation and loss of standing in
the
Column: 466
community. However, may I assure the Member that
practical suggestions from him would always be
given due consideration by the Ministry.
(ii) Members will recall that the Workmen's
Compensation (Amendment) Act, 1971, passed by
Parliament on the 19th October, 1971, had increased
considerably, in fact, threefold in most cases the
quantum of workmen's compensation payable to
workmen and their dependants. Under the amended
provisions, a workman above the age of 18 years
would be entitled to a sum of $28,800, or a lump
sum equivalent to 60 months' earnings, whichever is
the less, for injuries resulting in total permanent
incapacity. The Act also specifies separate rates
of compensation payable to workmen below the age of
18 years and those below the age of 16 years. In
addition to the compensation for total permanent
incapacity, the Act provides that the workman would
also receive an additional one-quarter of the
computed sum where he is unable to perform the
essential actions of life without the constant
attention of another person.
In view of the very recent amendments providing
for increased quantum of compensation, the time is
not opportune for further amendments to the
Workmen's Compensation Act.
Instead of hankering over the quantum of
compensation, may I suggest that it would be more
fruitful for all concerned to concentrate their
time and energy in getting the trade unions and the
workers to play a more active and constructive role
in the prevention of accidents. This could be done
through education of the workers and by exerting
greater pressures upon the employers to provide for
a safer and healthier working environment. As many
accidents were due to the irresponsibility of the
employers as well as the negligence on the part of
the workers and their stubbornness and resistance
to using protective apparels and other safety
devices, I would like to count on the support of
the Member
Column: 467
for Kallang when Government prosecutes such
recalcitrant employers and workers for
infringements of the provisions of the Factories
Act and the regulations made thereunder.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang): Mr Speaker,
Sir, we have much to educate the employers too.
What I want to know is: will the Government be
prepared to undertake a claim for damages for and
on behalf of an injured workman if, on the face of
it, there is evidence to show that his employer had
partly or wholly contributed to the cause of the
industrial accident which resulted in his
sustaining an injury?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: Sir, as I said in my answer
earlier, workmen's compensation does not take into
consideration who is at fault. However, if the
injured worker feels that he is not responsible,
but that there is a third party involved, or that
the employer is responsible, then he can take the
case up to the Civil Court.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Mr Speaker, will the
Government spare an injured workman all the ordeal
and legal expenses incurred in securing a claim for
damages?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: Sir, as provided for, claims can
be made under the Workmen's Compensation Act. But
if the injured workman wants to take other courses
which are open to him, then I am afraid he will
have to follow the procedure as laid down in the
Courts of Law.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Sir, if I may ask a last
supplementary question. The principles that I have
laid down are found to be practicable in certain
countries. Will the Government accept my
proposition in the final analysis?
Mr Sia Kah Hui: Sir, as I have said earlier, I
assure the Member that any practical suggestions
that he has to make are welcome and will be given
due consideration, and will he please put them up
in writing.
Column: 468
SINGAPORE INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
(Construction of second runway)
3. Mr Ng Kah Ting asked the Minister for
Communications whether his Ministry has come to a
final decision on the construction of a second
runway for the Singapore Airport; where will it be
constructed; and when construction is expected to
commence.
The Minister for Communications (Mr Yong Nyuk Lin): Mr Speaker, Sir, on the basis of the present
rate of growth of air traffic in Singapore, my
Ministry anticipates that a second runway would be
needed around 1977 or 1978. The utilisation rate of
the present runway capacity at Paya Lebar is around
40 per cent and is increasing rapidly.
Last year, 41,241 commercial aircraft, two
million passengers, 25.5 million kilograms of
freight and 2.8 million kilograms of mail, passed
through the Paya Lebar Airport. This represents an
increase of approximately 20 per cent, 20 per cent,
21 per cent and a drop of 10 per cent respectively
over the 1970 performance.
As the second runway is needed around 1977-78,
construction will have to commence around 1974.
Therefore, the Department of Civil Aviation is
proceeding with work to build the second runway at
the Singapore International Airport at Paya Lebar.
Column: 468
RENEWAL OF CLASS IV DRIVING LICENCES
(Imposition of limit in unladen weight)
4. Inche Abdul Aziz Karim asked the Minister for
Communications (a) if he knows to the best of his
knowledge that persons who had been granted class 4
licences under the Motor Vehicles (Driving
Licences) Rules, 1948, which qualified them to
drive heavy motor cars with no maximum limit in
unladen weight, have on renewal of their licences
been granted a similar class licence under the
Motor Vehicles (Driving Licences) Rules, 1969,
which
Column: 469
automatically disqualified and debarred them from
driving vehicles exceeding 7 tons in unladen
weight; (b) if he is aware that it is common
occurrence that holders of class 4 heavy motor car
licences are still driving vehicles exceeding 7
tons in unladen weight with the full knowledge, but
with no valid authority; of the Registrar of
Vehicles; and (c) in view of the fact that such
persons might be committing road traffic offences
and might face serious consequences, if he will
take urgent steps to restore to such persons, who
held class 4 heavy motor car licences granted under
the Motor Vehicles (Driving Licences) Rules, 1948,
their status and qualification in all fairness to
them and in the interest of the general public in
the other respect.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Mr Speaker, Sir, when the
Registry of Vehicles driving licence records were
being computerised on 1st February, 1969, the 1948
Motor Vehicles (Driving Licences) Rules were
replaced by the 1969 Rules. In order to streamline
the driving licence records and to facilitate
issuance of driving licences, the classification
for motor vehicles was at the same time reduced
from nine to five classes.
It is true that persons issued with Class IV
licences under the old rules were allowed to drive
heavy motor-cars with no maximum limit in the
unladen weight, whereas persons issued with Class
IV licences under the new rules are not licensed to
drive heavy motorcars above seven tons, for which a
Class V licence is required. This, however, does
not mean that under the Motor Vehicles (Driving
Licences) Rules, 1969, those who had acquired Class
IV driving licences before 1st February, 1969 are
being automatically disqualified and debarred from
driving heavy motor-cars above seven tons. The
validity of licences issued under the 1948 Rules is
not affected, as the 1969 Rules were not introduced
with retrospective effect. In addition, there is a
saving clause under Rule 17 (3) of the Motor
Vehicles (Driving Licences)
Column: 470
Rules, 1969, which provides that the new rules do
not alter the classes of motor vehicles which a
holder of a licence has been licensed to drive
before the date when the new rules come into
operation. Those issued with Class 1V licences
before 1st February, 1969 are, therefore, legally
entitled to drive heavy motor-cars above seven
tons. The question of restoring to these people
their status and qualifications to drive vehicles
above seven tons, therefore, does not arise.
In reducing the classes of vehicles from nine to
five, an unfortunate anomaly was created when those
persons issued with Class IV licences prior to 1st
February, 1969 renewed the old licences for new
ones, as the new driving licences contained a pre-printed description of all the five classes of
vehicles as defined under the new rules. In this
description, Class IV vehicles are defined as heavy
motor-cars above 2j tons up to seven tons, although
these people are legally entitled to drive heavy
motor-cars above seven tons as they had X been
granted licences prior to 1st February, 1969.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I wish to express my gratitude
and thanks to the Member for Kallang for being so
alert and drawing the attention of my Department to
this anomaly. The necessary amending Rules re-classifying the classes of motor vehicles under the 1969 Rules to make driving licences issued under
the 1948 and 1969 Motor Vehicles (Driving Licences)
Rules equitable, have been published in the
Government Gazette on 25th February, 1972. Action
will also be taken by the Registrar of Vehicles to
change the pre-printed description of the five
classes of vehicles as contained in the new driving
licences.
Column: 470
PORT OF SINGAPORE AUTHORITY
(Bonus payments to monthly-rated employees)
5. Mr P. Govindaswamy asked the Minister for
Communications whether the operational profits of
the Port of
Column: 471
Singapore Authority in 1970 would enable the
Authority to pay a bonus for productivity to its
monthly-rated employees; and whether the Authority
is considering paying such bonus, just as it had
paid a bonus to such employees in the past, and if
the bonus will be paid as soon as possible.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Mr Speaker, Sir, since the
Member for Anson has used the term "operational
profits" of the Port of Singapore Authority for the
year 1970, may I state that the term `profits'
would appear to be a misnomer and the word
`surplus' would perhaps be more appropriate for the
situation. We generally talk of `profits' of a
commercial organisation, which will be distributed
amongst shareholders or the staff. But in regard to
surpluses, if any, of a statutory organisation like
the P.S.A., these will be reinvested for further
development.
As an example, may I refer the Member for Anson
to Supplements 1/72 and 2/72 of the Government
Gazette dated 28th January, 1972, where it will be
noted that whereas the Revenue for P.S.A, for 1972
is estimated at $144 million with a net surplus of
$51 million, the estimated Capital Expenditure for
the same period will be no less than $63 million.
Coming now to bonus, the Minister of State for
Finance has previously made clear the Government's
stand with regard to payment of bonuses to its
employees. As a statutory board, the P.S.A, must
conform generally to Government's policy on matters
relating to remuneration, terms and conditions of
service. This means that bonuses for P.S.A.
employees cannot be considered, but any betterment
in the remuneration and terms and conditions of
service of Government employees might, as far as is
applicable, be extended to P.S.A, employees.
Column: 472
ADMISSIONS TO PRIMARY 1
CLASSES IN 1972
6. Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi asked the
Minister for Education how many children were
admitted to Primary I classes in 1972 in each of
the four language streams.
The Minister of State for Education (Dr Lee Chiaw Meng) (for the Minister for Education): Mr Speaker,
Sir, the number of children who were registered for
admission to Primary I classes in 1972 in each of
the four language streams is as follows:
Malay 553
Chinese 14,348
Tamil 41
English 37,342
------
Total 52,284
======
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan)(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, from this
total figure, how many children were admitted to
Primary I classes this year, and what is the
percentage of children who have been admitted to
schools of their choice?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Sir, I believe all these
children have been admitted to Primary I classes,
and about 95 per cent of them have been admitted to
the schools of their choice.
Column: 472
1971 PRIMARY SCHOOL LEAVING EXAMINATION
(Particulars of failures)
7. Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi asked the
Minister for Education how many children who failed
the Primary School Leaving Examination in 1971 (i)
were allowed to repeat in Primary VI classes in
1972; and (ii) were asked to leave school, giving
breakdown figures for each of the four language
streams.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (for the Minister for Education): Mr Speaker, Sir, of the 75,000 pupils
who sat for the 1971
Column: 473
Primary School Leaving Examination, 29,000 or 39
per cent were unsuccessful but allowed to repeat
Primary VI classes in 1972. The breakdown figures,
according to language streams, are as follows:
English 20,264
Chinese 6,577
Malay 2,263
Tamil 102
------
Total 29,206
======
With respect to the second part of the question,
the number of unsuccessful pupils who had to leave
school is as follows:
English 4,306
Chinese 1,221
Malay 394
Tamil 52
-----
Total 5,973
=====
These pupils had to leave school because they were
over-aged for the Primary VI classes. However,
they were invited to join the Vocational
Preparatory Classes which were specially organised
for them by the Adult Education Board.
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff(In Malay): Sir, can the Minister of State for Education tell
the House in which centres are these Vocational
Preparatory Classes conducted?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, there are at
present four such centres. They are at Parry
Avenue, Kim Keat, Mountbatten Road, and
Queenstown.
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, will the Minister of State
consider setting up a similar centre in the
eastern sector to cater for pupils in Kampong
Kembangan and the surrounding areas?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, at present,
pupils from the eastern sector are being catered
for by the centre at Mountbatten. However, if
there is sufficient response and when facilities
are available, we may consider setting up a centre
in the Kampong Kembangan area.
Column: 474
MALAY PRE-UNIVERSITY 1
CLASSES IN 1972
(Particulars)
8. Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi
asked the Minister for Education the number of
Malay Pre-University I classes in 1972 and the
schools in which they are conducted.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (for the Minister for Education): Mr Speaker, Sir, the number of Pre-University I classes for Malay-medium students in
1972 and the schools in which these classes are
conducted are as follows:
School No, of Total Enrolment
classes
Sang Nila Utama 3 131 students
National 1 39 students
Junior College
- ---
Total 4 170 students
= ===
Another class will be started in Sang Nila Utama
if there are enough late applicants with the
requisite qualifications.
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, can the Minister of State tell
the House the number of students admitted into the
Pre-University classes (Malay stream) for 1970,
1971 and 1972?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, there were
70 students in 1970 and 100 in 1971, increasing to
170 for this year, 1972.
Inche Rahmat Bin Kenap Al-Haj (Geylang Serai)(In Malay): Sir, can the Minister
of State explain this position? In past years, the
Malay stream students who obtained an aggregate of
20 and above were admitted to the PreXUniversity
classes, and that this privilege is not extended
to them this year.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, the
criterion for entry into the PreXUniversity
classes remains essentially the same.
Column: 475
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir,
will the Minister of State consider the possibility
of teaching Mathematics and Economics in English in
the Malay Pre-University classes?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Mr Speaker, Sir, we have
always been encouraging the teaching of such
subjects in English. In fact, when a survey was
conducted recently among the Secondary IV students
in a certain Malay secondary school, the majority
of the students indicated their preference for
these subjects to be taught in English. However,
the proposal of the Member will be taken into
consideration when we plan for next year's intake.
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff(In Malay): Sir, in
addition to the classes at the Sang Nila Utama and
the National Junior College, will the Minister of
State consider opening up another Malay Pre-University class in Tun Sen Lanang?
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng: Whenever sufficient staff and
facilities are available, we will consider the
Member's proposal. As the intention of the
Government is to concentrate all the Pre-University
classes in the Junior Colleges, therefore, there is
no purpose in diverting them in various centres at
the moment.
Column: 475
TIONG BAHRU CONSTITUENCY
(Building of new schools)
9. Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon asked the Minister for
Education whether sites have been reserved for
schools in the Tiong Bahru Constituency; and
whether it is planned to build new schools in that
Constituency in the near future and what type of
schools.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (for the Minister for Education): Mr Speaker, Sir, a site at the junction
of Jalan Membina and Gagak Selari Barat has been
reserved for a primary school in the Tiong Bahru
Constituency. Owing to great shifts in the
population caused by the Housing and Development
Board building programme, certain areas like Toa
Payoh, MacPherson /Aljunied, and Tanjong
Pagar/Queenstown, which
Column: 476
includes the Tiong Bahru Constituency, are now
suffering from acute shortages of school places. To
rectify the uneven distribution of schools, the
Ministry of Education has initiated studies on
schools required in the next 10 years so that
suitable sites can be reserved in centres of
population, and funds will be provided by the
Ministry of Finance. The school building programme
will give priority to the areas where the demand
for school places is most urgent.
Column: 476
HOUSING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD
(Policy on applications for flats by non-citizen permanent residents)
10. Inche Abdul Aziz Karim asked the Minister for
Law and National Development if the Housing and
Development Board will adopt a new policy to allow
non-citizens, who are permanently resident in
Singapore, to apply for flats after the untimely
death of their citizen-spouses, in view of the fact
that their children, if born in Singapore, should
enjoy the same rights and privileges as any
citizen.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division) (Mr Ho Cheng Choon) (for the Minister for Law and National Development): Mr Speaker, Sir, if
a non-citizen is the surviving spouse of a
Singapore citizen and is a permanent resident of
Singapore, his or her application for a Housing
Board flat will be favourably considered.
Column: 476
HOUSING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD
(Retention of proportion of new 3-room flats for rental)
11. Mr J. F. Conceicao asked the Minister for Law and National Development if the Housing and Development Board will continue to retain a
proportion of new 3-room flats for rental and not
put all such units for sale under the Home
Ownership Scheme.
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (for the Minister for Law and National Development): Mr Speaker, Sir, the Housing
and
Column: 477
Development Board will continue to let out for
rental at least 20 per cent of the new 3-room
flats.
Column: 477
COASTAL FISHING OPERATIONS
(Interference by deep-sea trawlers and measures to safeguard)
12. Mr Hwang Soo Jin asked the Minister for Law
and National Development the number of deep-sea
trawlers arrested and prosecuted in court for
operating in shallow waters and interfering with
the operations of coastal fishermen between 1st
January, 1971 and the latest convenient date, and
if he will direct the Primary Production Department
to step up raids in conjunction with the Marine
Police against such trawlers in the Sungei Seletar
area in order to safeguard the interests of coastal
fishermen.
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (for the Minister for Law and National Development): Mr Speaker, Sir, altogether
eight trawlers were arrested for operating in
shallow waters between 1st January, 1971 and 7th
February, 1972. In two cases the offences were
compounded. In another two cases the offenders were
prosecuted and convicted in court and fined. The
remaining four cases are pending a hearing in
court. The Primary Production Department, together
with the Marine Police, have already stepped up
raids against illegal trawlers, and such raids also
covered the Sungei Seletar area.
Column: 477
BRITISH FORCES' HOSPITALS
HANDED OVER ON WITHDRAWAL
(Adequacy of staff)
13. Mr P. Govindaswamy asked the Minister for
Health whether there are adequate staff to run the
hospitals which have been handed over by the
British Forces on their withdrawal from Singapore;
and, if not, if his Ministry is taking steps to
recruit more staff for those hospitals.
The Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, two hospitals were taken over from
the British Forces and they are:
Column: 478
(a) The Sembawang Hospital (formerly known as the
Naval Base Hospital) has a total of 62 available
beds for in-patient care. All beds have been
commissioned for use, and report 50 per cent
occupancy, at the present moment. For this
hospital, staff have been approved under Head A/C
Code 1202 of the Estimates of Revenue and
Expenditure for 1971-72. The full complement is
presently not deployed into the hospital as
renovations to various departments have not been
completed, and the hospital is not running at full
strength as yet.
(b) As for the Alexandra Hospital (formerly the
British Military Hospital) which was handed over in
early September, it admitted its first patient on
the 15th September, 1971. More than 50 per cent of
the staff of all grades, as approved under the
Estimates, are already working within the hospital.
Employment against vacant posts is being programmed
to meet the needs of the hospital as it continues
to expand its activities. There is at the present
moment available, medical beds, surgical beds
paediatric beds and obstetrical and gynaecological
wards. In addition, there is a radiological
service, pathological service, anaesthetic service
and a day-operated Casualty Unit. A little over 200
beds have been commissioned for use with an average
daily bed occupancy of 50 to 60 per cent. Further
beds will be commissioned as renovation programmes
are completed.
Thus, on the basis of the present activity of
these two hospitals there is an adequate number of
staff to run them.
Column: 478
MALABAR STREET, HYLAM STREET, MALAY STREET AND
PURVIS STREET
(Removal of refuse and cleaning of drains)
14. Mr Ho See Beng asked the Minister for Health
if he is aware that the removal of refuse and the
cleaning of drains by cleansing workers of his
Ministry in Malabar Street, Hylam Street, Malay
Street and Purvis Street in
Column: 479
the Bras Basah Constituency have been rather
irregular, and if he will cause instructions to be
given to the Cleansing Department for the regular
removal of refuse and cleaning of drains in those
streets
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, except for an
occasional vehicle breakdown which is inevitable,
regular direct collection of refuse has been
provided to Malabar Street, portion of Bugis Street
between Victoria Street and Malabar Street, Malay
Street and Purvis Street every morning. In the
event of a vehicle breakdown, the refuse is usually
cleared in the afternoon or, at the latest, the
next morning.
For Hylam Street and the portion of Bugis Street
between Malabar Street and North Bridge Road,
refuse is collected by handcart as these streets
are impassable to the refuse collection wagon,
owing to the location of the overhead pedestrian
bridge, hawkers and lock-up stalls near the
junction of Bugis Street and North Bridge Road.
Cleaning of drains in this area is also being
carried out regularly. However, the streets in this
area are lined on both sides by street hawkers with
heavy congestion at Bugis and Malabar Streets,
making the cleaning of drains infinitely more
difficult. This is because the hawkers cause
obstruction to these drains by placing planks over
them to serve as additional preparation area. They
are also in the habit of discharging their washings
directly into these drains. As a result, besides
being swept, the drains have also to be flushed.
However, the flushing of drains has been restricted
to about twice a week to conserve water.
It would be a great help in keeping the drains
clean if the Member for Bras Basah would advise the
hawkers to cooperate by refraining from dumping
left-over food and sullage waste from their
washings into the drains.
Column: 480
HOLLOWAY LANE AND ROCHORE ROAD
(Offences for obstruction by loading and unloading of goods)
15. Mr Ho See Beng asked the Minister for Home
Affairs why the parking of vehicles for the loading
and unloading of goods in Holloway Lane and Rochore
Road is not allowed and drivers who so park their
vehicles are served with notices of offence for
obstruction, when there has been no promulgation of
such prohibition.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs (Mr L. P. Rodrigo) (for the Minister for Home Affairs): Mr Speaker, Sir, parking at any
time along the first approximately 30 metres of
Holloway Lane from its junction with Victoria
Street is prohibited by a single white line. One
side of the rest of the lane is for paid parking
and the other side is prohibited to parking at any
time by traffic signs. These restrictions have been
imposed because Holloway Lane is only 20 feet wide
and carries continuous traffic. There are, however,
no restrictions to the parking of vehicles for
loading and unloading of goods in Rochore Road. The
prohibition to parking in Holloway Lane is
stipulated by a white line and traffic signs which
are promulgated in Rule 43 of the Road Traffic
Rules, 1950, and the Traffic Signs (Size, Colour
and Type) Rules, 1970, respectively.
Vehicles may still park in the "No Parking" area
for the purpose of loading and unloading of goods
provided no obstruction is caused to traffic flow.
Drivers must, therefore, ascertain that they are
not causing any obstruction to traffic flow before
stopping their vehicles for loading and unloading
purposes. The problem is that some lorries park
side by side for loading or unloading, whilst
others are parked in "No Parking" areas for
purposes other than the loading or unloading of
goods.
Column: 481
MALAYSIAN WOMEN MARRIED TO SINGAPORE CITIZENS
(Waiving of visa requirements)
16. Mr Ho See Beng asked the Minister for Home
Affairs why Malaysian women, who have been married
to Singapore citizens as far back as 1965, cannot
be allowed to reside permanently in Singapore but
are required by the Immigration Department to
obtain visas which have to be renewed fortnightly
at the Woodlands Immigration Depot; and if he will
consider taking steps to waive such visa
requirements and obviate the inconvenience caused
to such women.
The Minister for Home Affairs (Prof. Wong Lin Ken): Mr Speaker, Sir, Malaysian women married to
Singapore citizens before the 1st of July, 1967,
when immigration controls were introduced at the
Singapore end of the Causeway and who have been
staying here since then, are allowed to remain in
the Republic permanently. However, if they have
left Singapore temporarily without obtaining re-entry permits, either before or within one month of
their departure, they would have lost their
permanent residence status. In such cases, they are
required to apply for permanent residence or entry
permits, and each case will be considered on its
own merits. If an application is rejected,
consideration is always given for the grant of a
Social Visit Pass which can be extended, on
application, from time to time.
It is therefore not true that women in this
category are required to renew their passes
fortnightly at the Immigration Woodlands
Checkpoint. Women who do so are probably those who
have not applied for an Entry Permit or a Social
Visit Pass.
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
am not asking a supplementary question. But I would
just like to mention a case to the Minister as
proof.
Mr Speaker: Mr Ho, this is Question Time. Perhaps
it is better for you to write to the Minister about
the case.
Column: 482
Mr Ho See Beng: Yes, Sir.
Column: 482
BILLS INTRODUCED
3.04 p.m.
SCIENCE COUNCIL OF SINGAPORE (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Science Council of Singapore Act (Chapter 318 of the Revised Editions)",
presented by the Minister for Science and technology (Dr Toh Chin Chye); read the First time,
to be read a Second time on the next available
sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 482
SINGAPORE ARMED FORCES BILL
"to provide for the raising, maintenance-and
discipline of the Singapore Armed Forces and for
matters connected therewith and for the repeal of
certain enactments relating to existing forces",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by the Minister of Defence (Dr Goh Keng Swee); read
the First time, to be read a Second time on the
next available sitting of Parliament, and to be
printed.
Column: 482
NATIONAL PRODUCTIVITY BOARD BILL
"to establish the National Productivity Board and
for purposes connected therewith",
presented by the Minister for Labour (Mr Ong Pang Boon); read the First time, to be read a Second
time on the next available sitting of Parliament,
and to be printed.
Column: 482
TELECOMMUNICATION AUTHORITY OF SINGAPORE BILL
"to provide for the establishment of a
corporation to be known as the Telecommunication
Authority of Singapore and for the exclusive
exercise, performance, administration and
regulation by the corporation of functions relating
to the provision of overseas and domestic
telecommunication services; for the transfer to and
the vesting in the corporation of the functions,
assets and liabilities of the Telecommunications
Department; for the transfer to the corporation of
the staff of the Telecommunications Department; to
repeal the Telecommunications Act (Chapter 86 of
the 1970 Revised Edition) and for matters connected
therewith",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by the Minister for Communications (Mr Yong Nyuk Lin);
read the First time, to be read a Second time on
the next available sitting of Parliament, and to be
printed.
Column: 483
NGEE ANN KONGSI (INCORPORATION) (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Ngee Ann Kongsi (Incorporation)
Ordinance (Chapter 307 of the 1955 Revised
Edition)",
presented by the Minister of State for Education (Dr Lee Chiaw Meng); read the First time, to be
read a Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 483
NGEE ANN TECHNICAL COLLEGE (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Ngee Ann Technical College Act (Chapter 179 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by Dr Lee Chiaw Meng; read the First
time, to be read a Second time on the next
available sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 483
LEGAL PROFESSION (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Legal Profession Act (Chapter 217 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by the Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker); read the First time,
to be read a Second time on the next available
sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 483
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Criminal Procedure Code (Chapter 113 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by Mr Barker; read the First time, to be
read a Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 483
CONTROLLED PREMISES (SPECIAL PROVISIONS) (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Controlled Premises (Special Provisions) Act (Chapter 267 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by Mr Barker; read the First time, to be
read a Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 483
PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Parliamentary Elections Act (Chapter 50 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by Mr Barker; read the First time, to be
read a Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 484
VOLUNTARY STERILIZATION (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Voluntary Sterilization Act (Chapter 170 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by the Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin); read the First time, to be read a Second
time on the next available sitting of Parliament,
and to be printed.
Column: 484
SENTOSA DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION BILL
"to establish the Sentosa Development Corporation
and for purposes connected therewith",
presented by the Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen); read the
First time, to be read a Second time on the next
available sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 484
TIMBER EXPORT INDUSTRY BOARD (INCORPORATION) (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Timber Export Industry Board (Incorporation) Act (Chapter 203 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by Mr Hon Sui Sen; read the First time,
to be read a Second time on the next available
sitting of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 484
SUPPLY BILL
"to provide for the issue from the Consolidated
Fund of the sums necessary to meet the estimated
expenditure for the public services of Singapore
for the financial year 1st April, 1972, to 31st
March, 1973",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by Mr Hon Sui Sen; read the
First time, to be read a Second time on Tuesday,
28th March, 1972, and to be printed.
Column: 484
DEVELOPMENT LOAN BILL
"to authorise a sum of two thousand million
dollars to be raised by way of loan for the
purposes of the Development Fund",
recommendation of President signified;
presented by Mr Hon Sui Sen; read the First time, to be read a
Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 484
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT BOARD (AMENDMENT) BILL
3.14 p.m.
First Reading
Certificate of Urgency signed by the President in
respect of the Bill, laid upon the Table by the
Minister for Finance.
Column: 485
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to introduce a Bill intituled
"An Act to amend the Economic Development Board Act
(Chapter 189 of the Revised Edition)".
Bill read the First time.
Printed copies of the Bill distributed to
Members.
Second Reading
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Mr Speaker, Sir, beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Mr Speaker, Sir, the financial year of the
Economic Development Board -under the law is the
calendar year. In 1969, however, when the
Government changed its financial year from the
calendar year to 1st April - 31st March, the Board
did likewise because it is wholly dependent on
Government funds for its operation, and adopting a
similar accounting system was both practical and
convenient for purposes of control. It is necessary
now to make provision through clause 3 of the Eco.
nomic Development Board (Amendment) Bill, 1972, to
enable the Board to adopt as its financial year a
period of 12 months ending on the 31st day `of
March in each year and to prepare its accounts
accordingly. There is a transitional provision for
the Board's financial year in 1969 to be 15 months
commencing on the 1st day of January, 1969, and
ending on the 31st day of March, 1970. Following
the change in the financial year, the submission of
the Board's Annual Report will have to he-amended
accordingly, and this is being provided for in
clause 4 of the Bill.
The opportunity is also being taken to
incorporate a provision in clause 2. -for the
appointment of the Chairman of the Economic
Development Board to be either full-time or part-time, since at -present there is provision only for
a full-time officer. This will provide for greater
flexibility in appointment.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
Column: 486
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Hon Sui Sen].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 486
COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL SECURITY CORPORATION BILL
"to establish the Commercial and Industrial
Security Corporation and for purposes connected
therewith, and to amend the Police Force Act (Chapter 78 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by the Minister for Home Affairs (Prof. Wong Lin Ken); read the First time, to be read a
Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 486
DEPARTMENTAL TITLES
3.21 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That this Parliament, pursuant to section 3 of
the Departmental Titles (Alteration) Act (Chapter
53), resolves that the Schedule to the said Act be
amended with effect from 1st February, 1972, by the
addition under the headings of "Old Title or Name
of Office" and "New Title or Name of Office"
respectively of the following:
" Chief Building Assistant Director
Surveyor. (Building Control),
Public Works Department.".
Sir, the Building Control Division was set up
from the 1St February, 1972, within the Public
Works Department to take over the functions of the
Chief Building Surveyor's Department. With the
abolition of the Chief Building Surveyor's
Department, the post of Chief Building Surveyor was
redesignated Assistant Director (Building Control),
Public Works Department, as head of the new
division.
Consequent upon this departmental change, it is
necessary to substitute the corresponding new title
or name of "Assistant Director (Building Control),
Public Works Department", for the old title or name
of "Chief Building Surveyor", wherever the old
title or name appears in any law or document as
provided in section 2 of the Departmental Titles
(Alteration) Act (Chapter 53). The Act also
provides in section 3
Column: 487
that additions and amendments to the Schedule to
the Act may be effected by a resolution at any
time.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Parliament, pursuant to section 3 of
the Departmental Titles (Alteration) Act (Chapter 53), resolves
that the Schedule to the said Act be amended with effect from 1st February, 1972,
by the addition under the headings of "Old Title or Name of Office"
and "New Title and Name of Office" respectively of the following:-
" Chief Building Assistant Director
Surveyor. (Building Control),
Public Works Department.".
Column: 487
RECLAMATION (SUNGEI KRANJI)
3.25 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move the motion*
standing in my name on the Order
Paper.
* The motion reads as follows:
That this Parliament, in accordance with section 4 of the Foreshores Act(Chapter 270), approves -
(a) the construction of a dam across the mouth of Sungei Kranji as shown coulured dark brown on the plan
marked 'LAND OFFICE RECLAMATION PLAN NO. 1/72' which is deposited in hte Land Office, Singapore;
(b) the dredging of part of Sungei Kranji bed for the construction of a spillway channel as shown coloured
blue on hte same plan; and
(c) the filling up of the sites shown coloured green and mared 'Zone A' and 'Zone B'
on the same plan with the dredged materials.
Sir, for the implementation of the
Kranji/Pandan Water Scheme, which will mobilise
nearly all the water resources in the western part
of Singapore, the Public Utilities Board proposes
to construct a dam across the mouth of Sungei
Kranji to form an impounding reservoir with a
storage capacity of 3,300 million gallons. Details
of the scheme are shown on the plan marked
`LAND OFFICE RECLAMATION PLAN NO. 1/72', a copy of
which is displayed in the Library of this House
for the information of Members. The Pandan
Reservoir and the Jurong Reservoir which form part
of the Scheme will provide storage capacity for
another 1,100 million and 100 million gallons
respectively.
Column: 488
The dam will be about 3,200 feet long with a
width of approximately 70 feet at its top to
provide for a future arterial road linking the
Kranji Industrial Estate with Lim Chu Kang Road.
It will rise to a maximum height of about 61 feet
from the river bed and its crest level will have
an elevation of 13 feet above mean sea level.
Included in the dam project is a concrete spillway
channel of 175 feet width for the discharge of
floods occurring upstream of the dam. This
spillway channel will be controlled by the
provision of three electrically operated gates.
The materials required for the construction of
the dam will be obtained from the quarries along
Mandai Road and Bukit Timah Road. Extensive
dredging of part of Sungei Kranji bed and its left
bank near its mouth is, however, necessary for the
construction of the spillway channel. The dredged
materials will be used to fill up the mangrove
swamps in the vicinity.
The whole project, which will be partly financed
by the Asian Development Bank, is expected to be
completed within three years at an estimated cost
of $74.5 million excluding costs of land
acquisition, resettlement and antipollution
measures.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Parliament, in accordance with section 4 of the Foreshores Act(Chapter 270), approves -
(a) the construction of a dam across the mouth of Sungei Kranji as shown coulured dark brown on the plan
marked 'LAND OFFICE RECLAMATION PLAN NO. 1/72' which is deposited in hte Land Office, Singapore;
(b) the dredging of part of Sungei Kranji bed for the construction of a spillway channel as shown coloured
blue on hte same plan; and
Column: 489
(c)the filling up of the sites shown coloured
green and marked `Zone A' and `Zone B' on
the same plan with the dredged materials.
Column: 489
TREASURY BILLS
3.28 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That this Parliament, in accordance with section
2 of the Local Treasury Bills Act (Chapter 72)
resolves that the Minister for Finance be
authorised to borrow by the issue of Treasury
Bills in Singapore a sum not exceeding Singapore
three thousand million dollars.
Sir, on the 10th July, 1968, Parliament
resolved, in accordance with section 2 of the
Local Treasury Bills Act (Chapter 72), that the
Minister be authorised to borrow by the issue of
Treasury Bills in the Republic a sum not
exceeding $1,000 million in amount.
The demand for Treasury Bills has been
increasing rapidly over the last few months, and
the present limit of $1,000 million is likely
soon to be insufficient. There is apparently a
large quantity of surplus funds which arc
available for investment for short periods. It is
also essential that in our efforts to make
Singapore more of an international financial
centre, banks, as well as other financial
institutions, including Government statutory
bodies, should be provided with a secure short-term investment outlet for such funds. The
authority of Parliament is, therefore, requested
to enable the Government to issue Treasury Bills
up to an amount not exceeding $3,000 million
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Parliament, in accordance with section
2 of the Local Treasury Bills Act (Chapter 72),
resolves that the Minister for Finance be
authorised to borrow by the issue of Treasury
Bills in Singapore a sum not exceeding Singapore
three thousand million dollars.
Column: 490
SUBSCRIPTION TO ASIAN DEVELOPMENT BANK
3.30 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That this Parliament, in accordance with section
4 of the Asian Development Bank Act (Chapter 59),
resolves that the Minister for Finance be
authorised to increase, on behalf of the
Government, the total subscription of Singapore
to the authorised capital stock of the Asian
Development Bank to a sum not exceeding twelve
million five hundred thousand United States
dollars.
Sir, the Board of Governors of the Asian
Development Bank has adopted a resolution to
increase the capital stock of the Bank by 150 per
cent.
Singapore's subscription to the Bank is at
present 500 shares, equivalent to US$5 million.
Under the proposed increase, Singapore's
subscription will be increased by a maximum of
750 shares, equivalent to US$7.5 million.
Singapore is a large borrower of the Bank and
has obtained US$73.68 million in loans from the
Bank to-date. The Republic, therefore, has
benefited from its membership in the Asian
Development Bank and, it is envisaged, will
continue to borrow from the Asian Development
Bank to finance its future economic development
plans.
Parliament is requested to authorise the
Government to increase the total subscription of
Singapore to the authorised capital stock of the
Asian Development Bank to a sum not exceeding US$12,500,000.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Parliament, in accordance with section
4 of the Asian Development Bank Act (Chapter 59),
resolves that the Minister for Finance be
authorised to increase, on behalf of the
Government, the total subscription of Singapore
to the authorised capital stock of the Asian
Development Bank to a sum not exceeding twelve
million five hundred thousand United States
dollars.
Column: 491
CIVIL LIST
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Sir, I
beg to move,
That this Parliament pursuant to section 7 of the
Civil List and Pension Act (Chapter
52) resolves that the Schedule to the said Act be
varied by deleting the figures "$10,000",
"$390,000" and "$84,000" appearing in the second
column thereof and substituting therefor the
figures "$15,000", `S508,620" and "$108,680"
respectively.
The amount of provision approved under the Civil
List is insufficient to meet the increasing
expenses of the President resulting from the take-over of Command House, increasing expenses of the
Household on public utility services, telephone
rentals, printing, stores and maintenance of Istana
Domain, and the additional expenditure in hosting
of functions.
It is, therefore, necessary to augment the
provision for "Entertainment Expenses" from $10,000
to $15,000; the provision for "Salaries of Personal
Staff" from $390,000 to $508,620; and the provision
for "Expenses of Household" from X84,000 to
$108,680.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Parliament pursuant to section 7 of the
Civil List and Pension Act (Chapter 52) resolves
that the Schedule to the said Act be varied by
deleting the figures "$10,,000", "$390,000" and
"$84,000" appearing in the second column thereof
and substituting therefor the figures "$15,000",
"S508,620" and "$108,680" respectively.
Column: 491
ANNUAL BUDGET STATEMENT
3.35 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That Parliament approves the financial policy of
the Government for the financial year 1st April,
1972 to 31st March, 1973.
Last year, when I presented the Budget for the
financial year 1971-72, 1 tried to assess the
probability that the high growth rate of 15 per
cent for the Singapore economy as measured
Column: 492
by the Gross Domestic Product (or G.D.P.) in the
preceding years could be sustained in 1972. I was
fairly confident that the general policies we had
adopted, including our emphasis on the major growth
sectors including export-oriented manufacturing
industries, were basically correct for rapid
economic growth but warned against possible adverse
factors which might upset our carefully laid plans.
Preliminary figures show that, in the event, with
a 14 per cent G.D.P, increase, we did not quite
attain the 15 per cent growth target, although the
outcome of the last year's working must be
considered highly satisfactory. With the momentum
generated during the preceding year, the economy
initially moved forward rapidly but was
subsequently slowed down by the instability caused
by the international monetary crises which occurred
in the latter part of 1971.
Survey of International Economic Events
That year will probably go down in the annals of
economic and financial history as a turning point
for the world monetary system. For the first time
since it established its complete dominance after
the Second World War, the strength of the U.S.
Dollar was called seriously into question. At
first, it was suggested that the U.S, should favour
a policy of "benign neglect" of the dollar's
weakness. This casual attitude soon disappeared. In
May, the first indications of potential trouble
came with the free floating upwards of the German
Mark, and the revaluation of the Swiss Franc and
the Austrian Schilling. This was followed by a
period of intense speculation in the Mark, the Yen,
and finally against the U.S. Dollar, which resulted
in a rapid deterioration of the dollar's position.
Finally, the international monetary system devised
at Bretton-Woods, of internationally agreed par
values and strictly maintained exchange margins of
not more than 2 per cent, collapsed with the "Nixon
shock" in August, announcing
Column: 493
suspension of the convertibility of the dollar and
the imposition of a 10 per cent surcharge on all
U.S, imports. The draconian measures adopted to
shore up the dollar's crumbling defences and to
exact trade concessions from her trading partners
(including restraints in textile exports under
"voluntary" agreements) had widespread
repercussions on world economies. Many countries
were obliged to float their currencies or to
restrict dealings in their currency exchanges, and
the resultant uncertainties on prices had a
depressive effect upon world trade. There was even
talk of retaliatory restrictions being imposed
against U.S, goods. By the end of the year, wiser
counsels prevailed and the crisis began to recede
with an agreement for the devaluation of the dollar
against gold and realignment of all other major
currencies on new parities or central rates either
in terms of the U.S, dollar or gold. To ensure
further stability, the limits within which currency
rates were allowed to fluctuate were widened from 1
per cent to 2¼ per cent on either side of parity.
This wider band should, theoretically, give greater
flexibility to governments intending to defend
their central rates against speculation. The
financial world has therefore been given respite
from impending disaster, but the basic problems
underlying the monetary crisis remain to be
resolved. The year 1972 may yet see a recrudescence
of the old symptoms and a recurrence of the
disease.
In the general realignment of currencies when the
dollar was devalued in terms of gold by 8.57 per
cent, Singapore followed the British Pound in
maintaining its gold parity. In other words, the
Pound Sterling was revalued upwards against the
American Dollar by 8.57 per cent, and the Singapore
Dollar maintained its parity with Sterling and was
also revalued upwards by 8.57 per cent against the
U.S. Dollar. However, in relation to all of
Singapore's world trading partners the effective
net revaluation for the Singapore Dollar has been
Column: 494
calculated to be only 0.53 per cent. Our trade with
Malaysia will be completely unaffected as parity
between the Singapore and Malaysian dollars has
been maintained, but one consequence of Singapore's
decision not to follow the-American Dollar
downwards may be some small increase in the overall
cost of imports. However, this increase could be
reduced if trade and capital transactions are
changed in direction to take advantage of the
altered currency rates. Thus, unless prices also
change, imports from Japan and Germany which are
now relatively more expensive as suppliers, may be
reduced while imports from the United States,
cheaper because of devaluations, should be
increased.
The monetary uncertainty had a deleterious effect
on trade last year. In a preliminary assessment of
international trade in 1971, the General Agreement
on Tariffs and Trade (G.A.T.T.) Secretariat
indicated that there was a marked slowdown in the
rate of growth of world trade in 1971. The volume
of trade grew by a mere 5 per cent - well below the
average annual growth of the sixties. In dollar
values, the increase in trade was close to the
average of 9.3 per -cent for the last decade.
However, the value figures are inflated by the
parity changes during the year and even so, the
rise remains well below that recorded in 1969 and
1970.
The British Government's decade-long quest to
join the European Economic Community (E.E.C.) on
acceptable terms has finally succeeded. The British
Parliament endorsed by a sizable majority in
October 1971 the principle of Britain's entry into
the E.E.C. In spite of the narrow majority recently
on the Second Reading of the legislation to effect
such entry, we must expect that Britain will be in
the European Common Market in January 1973.
Britain's move to identify herself more with the
European community of nations will have major
effects on her relationship with other Commonwealth
countries and on the role and status of the Pound
Column: 495
Sterling as an international currency and the
monetary reserve assets of other Sterling Area
countries. Singapore will now, therefore, like
other members of the Commonwealth and of the
Sterling Area, have to consider her position in
relation to these two matters.
First, in regard to the change in its trading
relationship with Commonwealth countries under the
present system of Commonwealth preferences, the
British entry into an outward-looking E.E.C, should
not have too serious effects on Singapore's trading
position. The main dislocation is likely to arise
from the application of the common external tariffs
of the E.E.C, which the United Kingdom will have to
implement in stages on imports from non-E.E.C.
countries. The ultimate situation will be the
eventual elimination of preferential tariffs
enjoyed by Commonwealth members in their trade with
Britain in the past. While our entrepot trade may
be affected in volume and our earnings reduced on
the export of entrepot trade commodities to the
E.E.C., it is mainly our domestic exports into
Britain which will be affected by the difference
between the Commonwealth preference rates and the
E.E.C, common external tariff. Less than one-third
of Singapore's present exports to Britain are of
domestic origin, but this is likely to increase
considerably in the future. Singapore would benefit
from freer entry into an enlarged E.E.C, market for
its goods. It is therefore our intention, by
establishing an official representation to the
E.E.C, in Brussels, to investigate the
possibilities of negotiating an associate member
status or a trade agreement with the E.E.C, which
will facilitate such entry. This could be done
bilaterally and also, as has been suggested, in a
common approach with other ASEAN (Association of
Southeast Asian Nations) countries, on the 1ineX of
the South American Andean Common Market talks with
the E.E.C.
Secondly, there is the question of Singapore's
Sterling reserves. After
Column: 496
Britain's entry into the E.E.C., she is.; committed
to Sterling playing a diminishing role as an
international reserve currency, and consequently, I
assume, to the running down of the Sterling area
reserves and its replacement by some other
international currency in general trading use, or
by funding in some form of created reserve asset,
such as the I.M.F. Special Drawing Rights (or
S.D.Rs). The latter is the more likely in view of
the British Chancellor of the Exchequer's Speech at
the I.M.F./ I.B.R.D. (International Monetary Fund /
International Bank for Reconstruction-and
Development) meeting in Washing-, ton last year
favouring S.D.Rs or some, new form of it as the
num‚raire in the new international monetary system.
In that event, since we do not regard S.D.Rs, as at
present constituted to be a satisfactory substitute
for the Pound Sterling,, we may have to consider
how we can, safeguard the value of our external.
reserves.
By an agreement signed between the-British arid
Singapore Governments, not less than 36 per cent of
Singapore's, external reserves are at present
required, to be held in Sterling. In consideration
of this obligation, 90 per cent of such. Sterling
reserves are guaranteed by Britain against a
devaluation of the British Pound by more than 1 per
cent from its old parity of US$2.40 to 1. The
currency realignment after the recent international
monetary crisis resulted in. Sterling having a
parity or central rate-of US$2.6057 to the Pound
and a wider margin of 2¼ per cent on either side of
parity, which clearly renders the Sterling
Guarantee Agreement inapplicable without major
amendment. To meet the new situation, therefore, I
propose to initiate discussions with the British
Government for the cancellation or amendment of the
Sterling Guarantee Agreement in order that some
further diversification of our external assets may,
if necessary, be considered.
Column: 497
Singapore's Economy in 1971
I would now like to discuss in some -detail the
performance of our economy. I am again
distributing, for the convenience of Members, a
number of statistical tables (See Appendix, cols. 553-88), upon which I shall partly base my remarks.
Appendix to Annual Budget Statement(Cols. 553-588)
I have previously mentioned the figure of 14 per
cent in connection with our preliminary figures for
G.D.P, growth in 1971. The more commonly used
indicator of overall growth, the Gross National
Product (G.N.P.) has also been calculated this
year. Preliminary estimates of G.N.P, at current
prices for the year show that it rose by $860.8
million to reach the level of $7,000.8 million. In
percentage terms, this represented an increase of
some 14.0 per cent which, though somewhat lower
than the 17.2 per cent recorded for 1970,
nevertheless compared favourably with the average
growth rate of around 14.1 per cent per annum for
the period 1966-70. Estimates of G.N.P, at constant
prices are not yet available at this moment.
However, since the general price levels except for
certain lines of consumer goods have been observed
to show mild increases, it can be expected that the
real growth in G.N.P., discounting price increases,
would not deviate significantly from the current
price estimation. Growth was, therefore, in the
main non-inflationary.
With the population growth of nearly 2 per cent
in 1971, the per capita G.N.P, at current market
prices advanced by about 12.1 per cent from $2,960
in 1970 to $3,317 in 1971. At these levels the per
capita G.N.P, is the second highest in Asia after
Japan.
Another interesting indicator is that for Gross
Domestic Expenditure (G.D.E.) representing resource
use. Preliminary estimates of G.D.E, also
registered a comparable high rate of increase. The
expenditure on all goods and services for 1971
amounted to $6,759.3 million, which is about $1,000
million, or 17.4 per cent higher compared to the
1970 estimates. As for G.N.P., the G.D.E, growth
rate was
Column: 498
slightly below the level experienced in 1970 of
around 21.0 per cent.
The increase was contributed by both components,
namely, consumption and gross domestic capital
formation. Capital formation rose substantially by
$383.6 million, or 27.9 per cent, to reach a high
level of $1,759.3 million, which consumption rose
more moderately hut still at a sizable rate of 14.1
per cent to reach $5,000 million. The rise in
capital formation, though somewhat less than that
achieved in 1970 of $421 million, or 44.2 per cent,
was still substantial, and it can be said with
confidence that Singapore's political stability and
its potential for profitable economic development
continue to be recognised by investors both local
and abroad. Economic Development Board estimates of
commitments for additional foreign investment in
new industries or for expansion of existing ones
indicate that this will total $930 million, not
much less than the $1,000 million for 1970.
Gross Domestic Capital Formation, which registered
a growth rate of 27.0 per cent per annum for the
period 1967- 69, rose sharply to a peak level of
44.2 per cent in 1970 over 1969. Although the
growth for 1971 of 27.9 per cent was noticeably
below the rate experienced in 1970, nevertheless it
measures up to the trend of growth for the earlier
period 1967-69. The lower growth rate of new
investments in 1971 can be explained partly by the
slowing down of construction activity, due
primarily to the shortage of capacity - labour and
material resources - in the industry generated by
the boom in building activity during the past two
to three years. This lack of capacity has also led
to the control of urban renewal development.
Further, a relatively smaller growth rate in
expenditure on machinery and equipment was also
registered compared to 1970, and this has also
contributed to the smaller growth rate in the Gross
Domestic Capital Formation during the year. This
was due to the establishment in 1970 of a number of
large industries where expensive plant and
machinery have been set up.
Column: 499
The substantial expansion in Gross Domestic
Capital Formation in 1971 reflected the increased
pace of development efforts in both the public and
private sectors. Private sector investments
increased by 29.3 per cent to $1,304.3 million and
public sector by 23.9 per cent to $455 million. As
in previous years, the private sector's share of
capital expenditure was maintained at a high level,
accounting for about 74 per cent in 1970 and 1971,
as against 26 per cent for the public sector. The
increase for the private sector was mainly in
respect of expenditure on transport equipment and
construction of non-residential buildings,
primarily of offices, shopping complexes and
factories, whereas for the public sector, it was
mainly in respect of machinery and equipment and
public housing.
Expenditure on transport equipment by the private
sector increased very substantially from $108.2
million to $271.5 million, giving an increase of
150.0 per cent, and this comprised largely of
purchases of ships and air--craft by Neptune Orient
Lines and Malaysia-Singapore Airlines.
In the case of consumption, public sector
expenditure rose much more sharply by 35.1 per cent
than did private consumption expenditure (10.2 per
cent). The increase in Government consumption
expenditure, which has been expanding rapidly since
1969, far exceeded the rate achieved in 1970 of
25.5 per cent, whereas for private consumption
expenditure it was below the 1970 level of 13.5 per
cent.
The net result of these changes is that the share
composition of private consumption expenditure fell
from 64.3 per cent in 1970 to 60.4 per cent in
1971, whilst that of Government consumption
expenditure and Gross Domestic Capital Formation
rose from 11.8 per cent and 23.9 per cent to 13.6
per cent and 26.0 per cent respectively. It is
significant that the share of consumption
expenditure (both private and public) to total
-expenditure fell from 93.4 per cent in 1960 to
74.0 per cent in 1971, whereas
Column: 500
for Gross Domestic Capital Formation it rose
markedly from 6.6 per cent to 26.0 per cent, an
increase of nearly four times.
The largest increase in private consumption
expenditure in 1971 was registered in expenditure
on clothing, furniture and durables, housing and
transport, which was in line with the trend
experienced during the past few years. The outcome
of this is that the share of expenditure on basic
necessities, primarily food, has fallen from 32.3
per cent in 1960 to 25.4 per cent in 1971, whilst
the shares for other items have risen accordingly.
This is a reflection of the rising economic well-being of the population. With respect to public
sector consumption, the sharp increase of 35.1 per
cent in 1971 as well as for the previous two years
of over 20 per cent was largely for the defence
build-up.
Gross Domestic Product by Industrial Origin
Before we turn to review the Republic's
performance in the various sectors of the economy
in 1971, it is perhaps in order to mention that the
rapid growth, particularly during the past five
years, has been accompanied by some degree of
structural transformation of the economy. The
manufacturing and construction sectors registered
rapid growth particularly during the last five-year
period whereas the trade and other services sectors
had a relatively lower rate of growth. The net
result was that the share composition of the
manufacturing and construction sectors jointly rose
sharply from 11.2 per cent in 1960 to 25.5 per cent
in 1970 and 28.5 per cent in 1971. On the other
hand, the ratio of the trade and other services
sectors to the G.D.P, has slipped from 70.7 per
cent in 1960 to only 58.6 per cent in 1970 and 55.5
per cent in 1971.
I should now like to review the development of the
major sectors, primarily manufacturing,
construction, trade, Government services and
utilities, and other services sectors, of the
economy and their impact on the overall growth of
the Republic.
Column: 501
(i) Manufacturing Sector
In 1971, manufacturing industries generated an
income contribution of $1,490.9 million to G.D.P.,
an increase of 30.3 per cent compared to 27.5 per
cent in 1970. This was nearly eight times as much
as in 1960, while G.D.P, grew by three times over
this period. This rapid development has raised the
share composition of the manufacturing sector to
total G.D.P, from 9.2 per cent in 1960 to 23.0 per
cent in 1971.
Our manufacturing industries are becoming
increasingly characterised by orientation towards
exports and by the higher quality of their
products. Overall, some 40 per cent of our
domestic manufactures is exported. Among pioneer
companies, exports account for some two-thirds of
their output. Last year, more than one-third of
our domestic exports went to developed countries,
as compared with less than one-fifth five years
ago.
The fastest growth was recorded by the petroleum
refining, manufacture of electrical machinery and
apparatus, and ship building and repairing
industries where increases in value added
averaging around 40.0 per cent were recorded. In
addition to these industries, other sub-sectors
also registered favourable growth during 1971 as
compared to 1970.
One of the major obstacles in industrial growth
experienced in 1971 was the acute shortage of
skilled labour for specific industries. Up to
1971, increases in output were matched by
increases in employment. The average labour
productivity in manufacturing appears to have
risen very little and rapid industrial expansion
has been wholly dependent on a growing labour
input. However, this is not likely to continue
since the rapid restructuring of the economy and
the raising of the technological level of the
labour force through retraining and the
acquisition of new skills are now being actively
promoted, as I shall describe later.
Column: 502
The growth of the industry will also-have to
depend on higher productivity and Government's
policy is aimed at achieving this target.
Data from the Census of Industrial Production
showed that the largest industrial sector in the
economy is petroleum refining which accounted for
about 33.4-per cent of total output for the
manufacturing sector in 1971. By the end of 1970,
total refining capacity in Singapore amounted to
368,000 barrels daily. In 1971 the capacity was
increased by a, further 250,000 barrels per day.
However, although petroleum refining is a, major
activity in terms of output, in terms of value
added the contribution of this industry to total
value added of manufacturing is only 20.2 per
cent.
Associated with the oil industry and. Singapore's
position as the fourth largest port in the world
is ship building and ship repairing, which is
included under transport equipment industry. The
transport equipment industry ranked a close second
with 15.4 per cent of total value added, and this
in turn was followed by the electrical machinery
industry, which contributed 14.2 per cent of total
value added. Of the more traditional industries,
food, beverage and tobacco industries jointly
accounted for another 9.4 per cent of the total.
value added.
(ii) Construction
The contribution by the construction industry,
which has been growing rapidly since 1967, rose by
about 16.6 per cent, to $352.5 million in 1971.
Although the growth rate was much lower compared
to the previous year of 47.1 per cent, it was
nevertheless among the highest rates-registered by
the other sectors and was-well above the 14.0 per
cent for the-overall G.D.P. As a result, its share
in G.D.P, was maintained at about the same level
as in the previous years of around S per cent or
eight times over 1960. The lower growth rate for
1971 compared to 1970 can be largely attributed to
the shortage of capacity faced by the industry
both in terms of labour and contracting skills and
materials which have been developing for some
Column: 503
time now. The building boom over the last two to
three years has been caused by a combined demand
from the massive public housing programme; the
boom in hotel and office construction stimulated
by the urban renewal programme; as well as
construction associated with the burgeoning
industrial expansion. This has exerted excessive
pressure on all resources associated with the
construction industry, including labour. Suppliers
of construction materials were also hard put to
meet demands and temporary shortages on a number
of occasions in 1971. The situation was aggravated
by speculators moving in to corner the market, and
Government had to step in on a number of occasions
to authorize controlled imports of restricted
building materials to meet the shortage.
The deceleration of the growth in this sector
during 1971 was primarily in respect of non-residential buildings in the private sector due
largely to the curtailment of sales of sites for
urban renewal projects. Construction of non-residential buildings comprising mainly shopping
and office complexes undertaken by the private
sector registered a relatively small increase of
21.9 per cent compared to 121.6 per cent in 1970.
On the other hand, construction of residential
buildings forged ahead with a higher growth rate
of 32.6 per cent compared to 28.4 per cent in
1970. The increase has been primarily in respect
of public housing and, to a lesser extent, private
housing.
(iii) Trade
The growth rate for the entrepot and domestic
trade sector, which formed nearly one-third of the
G.D.P., reflected a slight declining trend during
the past decade, except for 1968 and 1969 when the
accelerated growth reflected the resumption of
trade with Indonesia. In line with this trend, the
contribution of this sector increased by only 9.6
per cent or $166.7 million in 1971, representing a
slower rate of growth compared to 12.6 per cent in
1970. This lag could be attributed to, among
others, the pursuit of a direct trade policy by
neighbouring countries, the general
Column: 504
decline in produce prices primarily of rubber, the
de-escalation of the war in Vietnam and, last but
not least, the-uncertain trading conditions which
prevailed during the recent international monetary
crisis.
Of the total increase in the trade sector,
entrepot trade accounted for 3.6 per cent and
domestic trade for 6.0 per cent. The entrepot
trade component, which showed a declining trend in
growth over the past decade, virtually maintained
the same low rate of growth of 3.0 per cent. The
domestic trade sector increased by 13.8 per cent
which, though higher than the entrepot trade was
below the level recorded in 1970 of 20.2 per cent.
The increase in domestic trade sector was however
close to the overall rate for the G.D.P. As a
result, the ratio of the entrepot trade to total
G.D.P, declined further from 12.0 per cent in 1970
to 10.9 per cent in 1971, whereas for domestic
trade the same ratio of around 18 per cent as in
the previous year was maintained.
It is interesting to note that within the trade
sector there has also been a shift in emphasis
with domestic trade gaining in importance as
compared to entrepot trade. Entrepot trade, which
in the earlier sixties formed 18.6 per cent of the
trade sector, dropped to only 10.9 per cent in
1971, while domestic trade gained in importance,
particularly from 1968. In value terms, entrepot
trade amounted to $703.6 million in 1971 against
$1,206.0 million for domestic trade, and this is
in sharp contrast to 1960 where entrepot trade
amounted to $381.1 million and domestic trade to
$269.0 million, The declining trend of entrepot
trade may be largely attributed, as mentioned
earlier, to an increasing participation of direct
foreign trade by neighbouring countries and the
low level, of produce prices. On the other hand,
the rapid growth in the domestic trade sub-sector
has been propelled by the rising purchasing power
of the population and increased earnings from the
distribution of domestic export which has shown a
substantial growth during the past few years.
Continued expansion
Column: 505
of this sub-sector can be expected in the next few
years in line with the general economic growth. On
balance it is envisaged that the declining
importance of the entrepot trade in the years ahead
will be offset by the growth of the domestic trade
sector and the trade sector as a whole can be
expected at the minimum to maintain the trend of
growth rate recorded for the period 1970 and 1971
of around 11.1 per cent per annum.
The total external trade reached a record level
of about $14,026.3 million in 1971, an increase of
$1,736.7 million or 14.1 per cent as against 11.9
per cent in 1970. Exports rose by 12.9 per cent to
$5,371.3 million in 1971, while imports advanced at
a faster rate of 14.9 per cent to $8,655.0 million,
compared with the respective rates of 0.3 per cent
and 20.7 per cent for the previous year. The most
substantial increase was observed in imports of
capital goods and materials to meet the increased
pace of development in the industrial sector.
In the case of exports, the increase came
primarily from domestic exports which rose by 29.6
per cent to the level -of $2,368.2 million as new
markets are found for the products manufactured by
local industries. The rising trend in domestic
exports is expected to continue as increasing
promotional efforts are being made to establish new
markets overseas. Re-exports or entrepot exports,
however, stagnated at the 1970 level of around
$3,003.1 million which may be attributed to the
general slump in prices of primary commodities,
primarily of rubber and the increased participation
in direct trade by our neighbours. To the extent
that our neighbours continue to pursue their direct
trade policies and world prices of primary produce
remain at low levels, it can be expected that re-exports will decline in the years ahead and
accordingly the contribution of the entrepot trade
sector to the G.D.P, would also decline.
Column: 506
The recorded trade deficit in 1971 amounted to
some $3,283.7 million compared to $2,778.0 million
in 1970. The ever-widening trade deficit as
recorded, particularly in recent years, has been
aggravated by higher costs of imported goods.
Unlike other industrial countries such as Japan and
Germany, which have accumulated large trade
surpluses, Singapore has run a persistent trade
deficit and this has been largely financed by
earnings from "invisibles" and large capital
inflows which have gone into meeting the costs of
substantial imports of machinery and equipment.
Whilst there may be concern at the consequences
of our growing trade deficit in the balance of
payments, I have explained in the Budget Speech
last year that there is basically no need for
alarm. Our preliminary estimates of balance of
payments indicate that the balance of payments
surplus would amount to $844.6 million, which far
exceeds the surplus for 1970 by $383.3 million. In
the coming year or two, however, it is felt that
unless large capital inflows continue and increase,
the balance of payments position may be strained as
the Republic would be faced with the total
reduction of British military expenditure in
Singapore which would undoubtedly have a big impact
on Singapore's external financial position. Also,
payments for machinery and equipment and materials
for industrial development as well as for the
public sector infrastructure development are
expected to increase in the next two to three
years. Thus, the pressure on the balance of
payments may, in certain circumstances, be expected
to continue till such time when new industries are
fully operational and have established export
markets for their products and when the anticipated
larger earnings from tourism and other
"invisibles", such as ship-repairing, materialise.
Thus, it is of utmost priority that efforts should
be made to increase our domestic exports and
invisible earnings and Government's policy is aimed
at fostering this.
Column: 507
(iv) Government Services and Public Utilities
The contribution by Government services in 1971
to the G.D.P, increased by 15.9 per cent, which
follows the trend of growth for the past decade
where an annual average growth rate of about 14 per
cent was registered. The contribution of this
sector to G.D.P, in 1971 was $452 million. At this
level, Government services accounted for about 7
per cent of the G.D.P. It is interesting to note
that the share composition of this sector to the
G.D.P, has been maintained at a steady 7 per cent
throughout the entire period. The main increases
are in respect of expenditure on defence, education
and health.
As in the case of Government services, public
utilities showed a steady growth i-ate of 13.7 per
cent for the year under review and its share to
G.D.P, has been maintained at around 2 per cent
since 1966. The contribution of this sector to
G.D.P, stood at $157.3 million in 1971.
(v) Other Services
(a) Tourism
As I told you in the last Budget Speech, it is
our intention to develop the tourist industry to
increase the flow of foreign exchange earnings and
strengthen the balance of payments position.
However, care has to be exercised to ensure that
the investment is in those facilities and amenities
which do not tax the already short supply of labour
resources. To this end, the massive hotel building
programme of the last few years has had to be
slowed down to provide for a more balanced
development and the reallocation of building
construction and other capacity to development
projects of higher priority.
The encouraging signs of success in our efforts
in promoting tourism is evidenced by the growing
number of visitors who come to Singapore each year.
In 1971, 632,000 tourists visited the Republic, as
against 522,000 in 1970 and 409,000 in 1969.
Although the growth rate for 1971 of 21.0 per cent
is lower than the 27.6 per cent for 1970,
Column: 508
which was partly due to the post-Expo `70 influx of
tourists, the growth rate of tourist arrivals is a
fairly respectable rate by international standards.
Earnings from tourism continued to grow and
reached $323 million in 1971 compared to $275.6
million in 1970, or an increase of some 17.2 per
cent. This was ten times higher than 1960, thereby
raising the share composition from 1.5 per cent in
1960 to 5.0 per cent in 1971. The average stay of
visitors also rose slightly from about 3.3 days in
1967 to about 3.9 days in 1970 and 1971.
However, despite our past efforts to promote
tourism there remains much to be done. A more
intensive programme is required to attract tourists
to Singapore especially from those countries whose
nationals are now providing the major share of
world tourists. By these, I mean Japan, Australia,
the United States, and the richer European
countries. The occupancy rate for hotels has fallen
from 73.5 per cent in 1969 to 70.7 per cent in 1970
and 65.4 per cent in 1971. One of the objectives of
tourist promotion will, therefore, be to get the
occupancy rate back to something like the level of
the late sixties, and the hotel industry and the
Tourist Promotion Board will each have to play its
part to achieve this end. On the infrastructure
side and the provision of amenities and facilities
the proposed Development Budget for the financial
year 1972-73 makes provisions for the development
of a large number of projects which should go some
way to encouraging tourists to increase their
length of stay in Singapore.
Thus, with greater promotional efforts, I expect
that the tourist industry will increase its
earnings in the current and ensuing years.
(b) Foreign Military Expenditure
Preliminary estimates for foreign military
expenditure in 1971 covering both British military
expenditure and expenditure by A.N.Z.U.K.
(Australia-New Zealand-United Kingdom) Forces
indicate that there is practically no change in the
level of expenditure from that
Column: 509
registered in 1970. The expenditure remained at
around $420 million. The phased reduction in
British military expenditure, which was only
completed by the later part of 1971, was
counterbalanced by a corresponding increase in
A.N.Z.U.K. Forces expenditure during the year. The
full impact of the withdrawal has not therefore
been felt in 1971. When the expenditure for this
sub-sector is reduced to less than $100 million in
1972, it is hoped that any dampening effect on the
economy particularly on domestic demand and
employment can be counteracted. Since the major
growth sectors of the economy, namely,
manufacturing, construction, tourism, banking and
port activity, are expected to forge ahead with
sustained efforts at expansion, the delayed effects
of the complete British military withdrawal in the
current year can be fully mitigated and the economy
should
-continue to grow, though perhaps at a lower level
than in the past year.
(c) Banking and Insurance
I should now like to conclude this sectoral
analysis with a reference to that sector of the
economy - banking and insurance - which embraces
the financial operations of the economy. The
contribution of banking and insurance to the
G.D.P., which has consistently shown a rising
trend, further expanded by 15.0 per cent to $112.6
million in 1971. The share in G.D.P, has been
maintained at around 1.7 per cent throughout the
past decade.
Banking continued to grow in 1971 along the lines
of Government policy which is to encourage Swiss
type banking procedures as part of the overall
programme of developing Singapore into a financial
centre for Southeast Asia. By the end of 1971, the
number of banks totalled 42 with 192 branch
offices. Total deposits rose from $3,194.9 million
in 1970 to $3,745.8 million, giving a growth rate
of 17.2 per cent. Of total deposits, fixed deposits
comprised 57.9 per cent, indicating that banks have
funds to lend on a long-term basis. During the same
period, bank loans and advances
Column: 510
increased from $2,167.7 million to $2,615 million,
an overall growth rate of 20.6 per cent. Banks have
gradually moved into industrial financing though a
large proportion of total loans and advances is
still made to trade and commerce. The latest data
available shows that by December 1971, out of a
total of $2,615 million in loans and advances, 31.3
per cent was made to the commercial sector, while
31.4 per cent was made to the manufacturing sector.
Another indicator of the growth of banking is
reflected by the increasing share of demand
deposits to the total money supply. On average,
about 55 per cent of the total money supply, which
is a significant ratio by international standards,
was raised out of demand deposits. The fact that it
forms slightly more than half of the total money
supply shows that banking facilities are being
increasingly made use of by the public.
The Asian Dollar Market continued to attract
foreign funds. There are now 19 banks authorised to
deal in Asian Dollars as compared to 16 at the end
of 1970. Total liabilities of the Asian Currency
Units by the end of 1971 aggregated to nearly US$1
billion as compared to US$400 million at the end of
the previous year - an increase of l« times.
Interest rates on Asian Dollar deposits have fallen
in sympathy with world interest rates and are now
earning depositors 6.5 per cent for one-year
deposits, 5 per cent to 6 per cent for three to six
months and 4.75 per cent for one month. To
stimulate its further expansion, the Government
will encourage the development of an Asian Dollar
Bond Market. Two bond issues have so far been made,
one floated by the Private Investment Company for
Asia (P.I.C.A.) for $10 million and the other by
the Development Bank of Singapore (D.B.S.) for a
similar sum. The first loan was underwritten by
Singapore banks and constitutes an important
development for Singapore. The D.B.S, loan was
oversubscribed, two-thirds of it being
Column: 511
allotted to principal institutions in Singapore,
Hong Kong and Japan. It is intended to encourage
further borrowings in the Asian Dollar Market by
reputable financial institutions of good standing
in Singapore, the ASEAN region and even other
countries in Asia.
Future Prospects
Now future prospects: what is the ,outlook for
1972 and beyond?
We have seen from our survey of the international
economic setting and our analysis of the main
economic indicators and their growth rates that the
performance of the Singapore economy was affected
last year and will depend again this year partly
upon the turn of international events. It is,
therefore, of some concern that in spite of what
was thought at the time to be a valid settlement of
international monetary problems, we should still
have continuing uncertainty, with weakness in the
U.S. Dollar and volatility in exchange markets in
all the major financial centres. The ability of
world trade to expand will be reduced if the
domestic problems of high unemployment at the same
time as inflation persist in many major economies;
or if the dollar reflow is delayed and the balance
of payments problem continues in the United States;
or if the uncertainty and exchange restrictions
arising from the currency crises and the
possibility so soon after the realignment of
December of yet another revaluation continues to
affect even the strong economy of Japan; or if its
slower growth rate, which only it could call a
"recession", results in reduced imports of
petroleum products from the Middle East (and
Singapore as a refining centre) and of raw
materials such as iron ore and other minerals from
Australia. The success of the domestic policies of
all these countries and, in particular, of the
United States, in solving their problems and -
stimulating growth would give a powerful uplift to
other economies. It is to be hoped therefore that,
notwithstanding gloomier predictions since then,
the forecast by most U.S, economists during the
beginning -of the year of a 5.5 to 6 per cent real
Column: 512
growth to about $1,150 billion or twice as much as
last year, with a price rise of some 3.1 -3.4 per
cent only as measured by the G.N.P, deflator, and a
reduction of unemployment to under 5.5 per cent,
can be realised. Certainly the presently buoyant
market in U.S. Stock Exchanges and the resumption
of consumer spending are favourable signs of
recovery in the U.S, economy. It is to be hoped
also that the optimistic estimate of the
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and
Development (O.E.C.D.), which includes most
developed countries including Japan, will be
correct for a 5 per cent growth rate for 1972 as
against 3 per cent for 1971.
The international trade picture is, however,
obscure. The G.A.T.T, prediction of world trade for
1972 contented itself on 15th February, 1972, with
the statement that:
`It is difficult to forecast developments in 1972
in terms of value with any confidence. It seems
likely, however, that the rise in export prices
expressed in U.S, dollars will be greater in 1972
than in 1971.'
In volume terms, however, it was prepared to
forecast a 5 per cent increase at best against the
8.5 per cent increase in 1970, and the 5 per cent
increase in 1971.
In the face of the general uncertainty and of the
more restricted trade and economic growth rates in
other countries, sustained growth for Singapore in
1972 may, as during the last year, lie largely with
our manufacturing sector and its ability to export
its products. Our hope is that our vulnerability to
these adverse influences has been avoided, to some
extent, by our selection and promotion, in
accordance with our optimum investment policy, of
multi-national manufacturing companies having a
scope for progressive growth in technological
content in their manufactures, and, consequently, a
greater capacity for development of modern skills
at all levels. Unlike simple manufacturing or
assembly-type industry depending upon low cost
labour, these industries are less likely to be
displaced by sudden competition in their export
markets from new manufacturers from
Column: 513
other countries. In any case, by their nature,
multi-national companies have diversified and
established markets overseas and can operate also,
when necessary, largely independently of foreign
exchange requirements and variable currency rates,
or are even able to take advantage of them.
Perhaps partly for the reasons mentioned above,
our leading growth sector, manufacturing, managed
to grow by 30 per cent in 1971, a faster rate than
in 1970, in spite of the rather more adverse
international trading conditions in 1971, which
according to the Survey of Business Opinions
covering a sample of industrial establishments,
curbed the growth of some manufacturers during the
fourth quarter. In short, we shall do well to
press on with the promotion and establishments of
more, progressively higher, technology and export-oriented industries.
However, the achievement of higher levels of
sophistication in industry is correlated to a
diligent and disciplined striving for higher
productivity. This requires not only management
efficiency as well as labour productivity, but
also an equitable sharing of the fruits of greater
efficiency and upgraded skills in an orderly
manner. Among other matters, the determination of
equitable shares will now be the concern of the
National Wages Council which has been set up with
tripartite representation from labour, employers
and the Government. The Council's role will
include assisting in the formulation of general
guidelines on wages policy, recommending necessary
adjustments in wage structure, with a view to
developing a coherent wage system consistent with
long-term economic and social development, and
advising on desirable incentive systems for the
promotion of operational efficiency and
productivity in various enterprises.
The promotion of higher technology and the work
of the Council both fall within Singapore's long-term objective or strategy for the promotion of
modernisation in all sectors of our economy
Column: 514
and its transformation into an increasingly
outward-looking cross-roads of international
economic activities. Such a long-term objective
would be assisted by a plan for long-term
development. I have accordingly asked my Ministry
to formulate such a plan for the l970s. In order
that targets for the plan should be set which are
sufficiently ambitious and yet perfectly capable
of realisation, the plan would project a sustained
rapid economic growth of 15 per cent per annum
with a doubling of the per capita income by 1975,
on a population growth checked by sensible small
families. With full employment, a goal that seemed
unattainable in the 1960s, labour will become an
increasingly scarce resource, and the development
plan will also seek to maximise the income derived
by the use of labour through the expensive
development of high skills and productivity.
The development plan will be supported by a
programme for public sector action, which will not
be to a rigid framework but will be flexible
enough to accommodate contingencies and unforeseen
circumstances. Five basic elements or components
to the plan have been identified for special
attention and for implementation in the public
sector programme. These are manpower, science and
technology, infrastructure, taxation and
promotion.
With regard to manpower, the intention will be
to build up a large pool of professional and
technical personnel through upgrading of local
talents and skills, and selective immigration. Our
industrial training policies will be geared
towards producing the necessary skills, while our
immigration policies will be more liberal in
selected categories of skilled workers. We shall
presently be setting up an Industrial Training
Board to co-ordinate and rationalise all
industrial training. Industrial training would be
both institution based and industry-based. The
institution-based industrial training will seek to
improve technical teaching in primary and
secondary schools, vocational and technical
institutions as well as to provide technical
teacher-training. The industry-based
Column: 515
training programme will include
apprenticeship schemes, off-the job industrial
training, overseas training schemes and joint
industry / Government training. The Technical
Education Department will be finalising
arrangements for the apprenticeship schemes to be
implemented in co-operation with the longer
established firms in Singapore.
With regard to overseas training schemes, some
are sponsored by international companies with
operations in Singapore. 412 trainees have already
completed their training and returned to
Singapore. Today, there are 316 such trainees,
mostly in Germany and Japan. It is expected that,
in the course of this year, the companies will
send a further 400 abroad. Apart from these, which
are sponsored by the manufacturers, we have also
emplaced 53 trainees in precision engineering and
other metal trades in apprentice programmes in
Europe, while the Economic Development Board has
received firm offers for a further 206 to be sent
this year. For training at home, under the joint
industry/Government training programmes, the first
centre will be located at the Jurong Vocational
Institute and is expected to have its first intake
of 50 trainees in a few months' time, with the
intake increasing to 100 a year from the third
year. Arrangements with three other international
companies for similar joint industry/Government
training centres are also expected to be concluded
within the next three months.
Mr Speaker: Mr Hon, may I interrupt you at this
stage? Something is wrong with the loudspeaker
system, and Members just cannot get on to what you
are saying. Perhaps this would be an appropriate
stage to allow the loudspeaker system to be looked
into.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Yes.
Mr Speaker: Order. I propose to suspend this
sitting and to take the Chair again at a quarter
past five.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
4.42 p.m. until 5.15 p.m.
Column: 516
Sitting resumed at 5.15 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
ANNUAL BUDGET STATEMENT
Resumption of Motion.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Mr Speaker, Sir, just before the
tea break, I was saying that arrangements with
three other international companies for similar
joint industry/Government training centres-are
also expected to be concluded within the next
three months. These centres, will be located
either within the premises, of other vocational
institutes or adjacent to the plants themselves.
The total annual intake of these three centres
will initially be 268 trainees. Under the-scheme,
the Government will contribute 50 per cent of
training costs provided the organisation assisted,
trains twice-its requirements and releases 50 per
cent, of the trainees to Government for upgrading
skills. In this way, we hope to produce sufficient
numbers of well-trained persons. As for
immigration, our procedures are undergoing
streamlining to ensure that persons who can
contribute to the economy are not turned, away.
As regards science and technology,, the aim is to
promote practical research and development both at
the universities-and by international and multi-national companies. The Universities of Singapore
and Nanyang as well as the Polytechnic-and Ngee
Ann Technical College will, under our strategy
have a major part to play in research and
development. We will further develop the Singapore
Institute of Standards and Industrial Research. We
are now considering the setting up of a Centre for
Applied Research under the auspices of the
Ministry of Science and Technology whereby the
best of our scholars from the institutions of
higher learning and private industry can be drawn
upon to, provide research and consultancy
services, both within and outside Singapore.
Through selective use of taxation, we hope, too,
to encourage international companies to conduct
their research and development here.
Column: 517
As to infrastructure, much has already been
accomplished in the last few years. Under our
development plan, further improvement and expansion
of infrastructure for efficient distribution of
goods and services from Singapore is vital. The
transport and communications sector in our economy
will have to be strengthened. We have already taken
steps in this direction. Capital expenditure for
port development will amount to $153 million in
1972 and this will be spent on development of
containerizations at the East Lagoon, warehousing
at Pasir Panjang and the Ocean Terminal at Tanjong
Pagar. With regard to air communications, Mercury
Singapore Airlines will be taking over, on payment,
substantial assets and facilities from Malaysia-Singapore Airlines and will continue to expand and
maintain their services. We are also looking into
improvements and developments of the airports and
related services. As regards transportation on
land, a feasibility study on a Mass Rapid Transport
System will be undertaken shortly with the United
Nations Development Programme and World Bank
assistance. It is hoped that the study will provide
the guidelines in solving the increasing congestion
on our roads. In the
electronics and telecommunications sector, an
autonomous statutory corporation will be set up
this year to take over the functions of the
Telecommunications Department, A 10-year programme
has been formulated to meet the Republic's
telecommunications requirements, particularly for
telex machines and telex services. Further -
development in the telephone services is also
envisaged.
Under the development plan, emphasis will be
placed on developing tourist infrastructure with
the aim of developing Singapore into an "entrepot"
centre for tourism, and as a centre for regional -
and international conventions. The development of
Sentosa will be the major undertaking under this
heading. Over the coming 10 years, 31 Government
projects and eight projects by
Column: 518
the private sector are planned for the island. A
corporation to be known as the Sentosa Development
Corporation will be established shortly to
undertake the entire development and to turn
Sentosa into a resort of quality in a tropical
setting. As for the promotion of conventions, the
Tourist Promotion Board has set up a special
conventions unit specifically for this purpose.
Our plan to develop as a centre for brain
services will require the examination and
modification of present taxation laws. This will
help the overall development of Singapore as a
financial and monetary centre. A committee of
taxation experts has already been convened to look
into the possibility of using tax measures to
attract cram service industries and industries with
very high-level technology and to promote the
growth of a regional money market.
The present promotion programme of the Economic
Development Board is geared to attracting high-level technology industries. This will be
indemnified. Besides this, we are promoting a!
types of brain services in Singapore -engineering
and consultancy, marketing, physical planning and
development, international sales and servicing,
education, medicine and especially, banking and
financing services. Under the programme, Singapore
wilt develop into an international banking and
financial centre. Hence, measures are being
introduced to stimulate our banking sector and the
capital and money markets. To bring international
participation in our financial centre, we have
approved a number of licence for foreign banks to
operate in Singapore and will be liberalising our
exchange controls further.
These elements comprise our development plan for
the l970s. In broad terms the goal is to transform
Singapore within ten years, at an economic
development growth rate of 15 per cent per annum,
into a regional centre for brain services and brain
service industries. Success will depend upon the
quality of our people, their capacity to
Column: 519
improve themselves through education, training and
experience. This is an expensive process which can
only be carried out if population growth is kept
down to almost Zero Population Growth. Then we can
the better afford to attract expertise and
technology from outside.
Budget Estimates 1972-73
Let me now turn to the main business of the
Budget proposals for the financial year 1972-73.
The detailed estimates are contained in two
documents*(*Papers Cmd. 3 and 4 of 1972.) - the "Estimates of Revenue and
Expenditure" and the "Development Estimates". As
in past years, a Treasury Memorandum+(+Paper Misc. 1 of 1972.)
on each of the Estimates with detailed
explanatory notes on the various
Heads of Expenditure has also been
circulated to Members. It is unnecessary therefore
for me to do more than make general observations
on those areas of expenditure which involve
changes in policy and comment on broad policy
measures for greater efficiency and effectiveness
in government administration.
The changing needs of the economy in the 1970s
will require the Government to reappraise, from
time to time, the policies and priorities for
allocation of funds as well as manpower resources
to the various sectors. Further, there is a need
also to review our administrative machinery
including the present system of Government
budgeting and financial control. The emphasis in
the present system has hitherto been on the
balancing of the budget and the diversion of more
of our resources towards economic development and,
latterly, also towards defence. This system has
served us well in the 1960s during the initial
phases of our economic development. In the l970s,
however, with rising labour costs in a situation
of full employment, the budget should be used also
to effect mechanisation and introduce other labour-saving methods, and generally to modernise and
improve Government
Column: 520
administration. Set up originally to provide
minimal services at least cost, many of the
departments are not equipped for developmental
activities or for active interventionist policies
and are unable to cope with the increasing new
demands for their services. During the current
financial year, therefore, a number of
organisational and structural changes have been
introduced in several Ministries.
In addition, the following statutory authorities
have been or are in the process of being set up by
legislation -the National Sports Promotion Board,
the National Stadium Corporation, the National
Statistical Commission, the Post Office Savings
Bank Board, the Telecommunication Authority of
Singapore and the Commercial and Industrial
Security Corporation.
Various measures have also been introduced for
the general improvement of the terms and
conditions of service in the Civil Service. A
systematic reappraisal has been made of the terms
and conditions of service of various services,
notably the Technical Services, the Education
Service and the Police Service.
There has also been a general reorganisation of
the Administrative Service under which, in future,
all recruits will be appointed as Cadet Trainees
for a period of two years during which time they
will be given specific postings covering different
spheres of Government administration and
operations. A scheme for the training of Medical
Officers in the various medical specialities has
also been introduced. Provisions for overseas
scholarships, training and study awards have also
been substantially increased in the new financial
year.
All these measures are designed to bring about
not only an improvement in the quality of Civil
Service personnel, but also to ensure a permanent
Service with a lower turnover of experienced
staff.
Column: 521
However, in an expanding economy and with a
manufacturing sector, particularly, growing in
size and complexity, managerial talent is in short
supply. Handsome inducements are often offered to
attract the best. Consequently, what appear to be
fresher and greener pastures often tempt some men
of experience and promise from the Civil Service
to the private sector. Whilst some mobility must
be expected, the public service is already
suffering from an acute shortage of experienced
administrators and professional cadres, and the
continuing loss of trained men must be checked.
The Government is aware that one difficulty in
retaining them is due to the widening gap in pay
between the private and public sector for men of
comparable grades. Our public service is widely
recognised, and rightly so, as second to none in
this part of the world. If our economic growth has
been sustained in recent years at an unprecedented
high level, if our economy today is buoyant and
full employment is a reality, a major part of
these achievements can be attributed to our
efficient public service. If we do not wish to see
a collapse of this service, an improvement in
terms and conditions of employment must be made.
At the very least, therefore, we must do what we
can to prevent the gap in pay from widening. The
payment of a non-pensionable annual allowance
which the Prime Minister has already announced two
days ago is the first step towards this end.
In addition to this allowance, it is intended
that the process of rationalisation and
restructuring of the salary scales of the Civil
Service will continue. Some of the disparity in
wages between daily-rated skilled workers in the
private sector and in Government has been under
examination for some time by a Review Committee on
Daily-Rated Employment. We shall effect necessary
adjustments in wages, taking into account the -
annual allowances - already -announced. The Public
Service Commission will, moreover, continue to
conduct
Column: 522
regular and frequent promotion exercises in order
to ensure that the brightest and most promising
officers will receive accelerated promotion.
Now, the day-to-day operations of Government.
The Government intends to gradually introduce more
modern and efficient systems and methods of
operation. Greater emphasis will be placed on
mechanisation. Budgetary support has been given
for the increased use of office machines and other
mechanical aids in the day-to-day operations.
Increases in personnel have been kept to the
minimum. Consideration has also been given to the
computerisation of operations of Government
Departments. A Management Services Unit has been
formed in the Treasury which will systematically
study Government Ministries and Departments and
will suggest improvements in organisation and
methods. It will do this in co-ordination with the
Electronic Data Processing Unit in the Ministry of
Finance which has been reorganised and
reconstituted as the Computer Services Department
to cope with the increasing demands for
computerisation from all Ministries. Where
necessary, existing computer facilities will be
further augmented.
The present overall system of budgeting is also
being reviewed. Some of the more useful and
desirable features of what is known as the
Planning, Programming Budgeting System may be
introduced. The P.P.B.S, provides a more
systematic means of assessing requirements and
evaluating performance in terms of effectiveness
and costs. A feasibility study has been made. The
service of a U.N. Technical Assistance Expert is
being sought to work out a programme of
implementation in stages.
Ordinary Estimates of Expenditure
The overall Budget provision for Recurrent
Expenditure for 1972-73 is $1,448.69 million which
is $141.88 million or 10 per cent more than the
provision for 1971-72. In comparison with the
estimated revised expenditure for 1971-72, the
provision is only 6.1 per cent higher.
Column: 523
Of the total provision, 38.9 per cent is for
Defence and Internal Security, 26.6 per cent for
Social Services, 15.1 per cent for Statutory
Expenditure and 7.8 per cent for Economic
Services. The allocation for Defence has increased
by 16.5 per cent compared to the provision for
1971-72 while that for Social Services has
increased by 12 per cent. The total allocation for
Economic Services does not show any significant
change. The somewhat lower figure of $113.14
million as compared to $131.42 million for 1971-72
for Economic Services is due to the deletion of
the provision of $19.4 million for the
Telecommunications Department which is to become a
statutory authority early in the new financial
year.
The main Heads of Expenditure which have been
allotted sizable increases in funds are: Defence
($72.8 million), Education ($18.7 million), Health
($16.2 million), Home Affairs ($7.1 million) and
National Development ($3.3 million). There has
been an increase of $12.9 million for Statutory
Expenditure and the Contribution to the
Development Fund has also been increased by $20
million.
At this stage, I would like to mention some of
the significant changes in the allocation to the
major Ministries resulting from increases in the
level of activity.
Ministry of Labour
A proper assessment of our man-power needs and
resources and the formulation of an effective plan
for the optimum utilisation of available labour
will need to be made by the Labour Ministry. A
general revision of its scope and functions is now
in progress. For the coming year, additional
provisions have been entered for the setting up of
regional offices in Alexandra, Toa Payoh, St.
Michael's Estate and Jurong Industrial Estate. The
Factory Inspectorate will also be expanded and its
staff augmented for more effective supervision of
the factories and establishments to ensure
compliance with industrial safety regulations. The
Industrial Health Unit at present shown
Column: 524
under the Ministry of Health would also be
transferred in the new financial year to the
Ministry of Labour.
A study has been made by the newly appointed
Labour Adviser to the Ministry of the scope and
functions of the Labour Exchange and his
recommendations that the Labour Exchange should be
expanded to play a more effective role in the
deployment and utilisation of labour force as well
as in the provision of labour market information
and vocational guidance have been accepted in
principle and will be implemented during the
course of the coming year.
Ministry of Communications
The main Departments under the Ministry of
Communications where significant changes have been
made are the Postal Department, the Registry of
Vehicles and the Telecommunications Department. A
general review of the overall working of the
Postal Department has been undertaken with the
assistance of the National Productivity Centre and
a series of studies on the reorganisation and
modernisation of the Postal Services has been
completed. The recommendations of the initial
reports for the mechanisation of the delivery
services, and the use of mechanised means for the
handling of mail and parcels as well as the
resiting of the mail handling sections have been
partly implemented in 1971-72 and will be
completed in 1972-73.
In the Registry of Vehicles, the work of
computerisation of drivers' licences has been
completed and plans for the computerisation of
motor vehicles' records have been finalised and
will be implemented in the new financial year.
Although the cost of computerisation and
conversion of records is estimated at $206,650,
this will result in some saving of manpower and
the provision of a more efficient service to the
public.
The Telecommunications Department has been
reorganised and will be converted into a statutory
authority on 1st April, 1972.
Column: 525
Ministry of National Development
The main changes in the allocation for the
Ministry of National Development have been the
result of the expansion in the functions of the
Primary Production Department and the increase in
area of responsibility of the Public Works
Department. The Primary Production Department has
embarked on a scheme for farm licensing and
control of farm structures as part of its overall
programme for more intensive agricultural
development and as a means of farm sanitation and
pollution control in the rural areas.
The Public Works Department has now taken over
the responsibility for the maintenance of the
Jurong Industrial Water Treatment Works and the
three aerodromes at Changi, Seletar and Tengah. As
a result of the takeover of the areas previously
occupied by the British Armed Forces, there has
been a substantial increase in the work of upkeep
and maintenance of grounds and buildings and in
maintenance costs. The Sewerage Branch has
commissioned three new sewerage pumping stations
and has expanded the treatment works at Serangoon.
The Parks and Trees Branch will also be expanding
its area of activity with the opening up of new
parks and wooded areas.
Ministry of Education
The provision for the Ministry of Education has
increased from $191.03 million for 1971-72 to
$209.7 million for the coming year. The main
changes of significance are the restructuring of
the Education Service, the continued expansion of
the technical stream of education and the proposed
separation of the functions of vocational and
industrial training from that of the general
stream of school education.
In order to provide an efficient and co-ordinated
programme of training of technical personnel for
the industries, it is proposed to set up ,in the
new financial year the Industrial Training
Column: 526
Board, with the responsibility for all matters
relating to industrial training and the
administration of industrial training institutions
including the vocational institutes and the
industrial training centres. Greater emphasis will
be placed on the upgrading of skills through
apprenticeship schemes and joint industrial
training programmes particularly for skills
relating to precision industries.
Ministry of Health
Under the Ministry of Health, a total provision
of $114.4 million has been made as compared to
$98.2 million in 1971-72. Of the increase of $16.2
million, $7.6 million has been allotted to the
Hospitals Division and $3.6 million to the Public
Health Division.
The major increases in the Hospitals Division are
associated with the implementation of the first
phase of fostering medical specialities, the
general improvement of Medical Services and a
gradual expansion in the services provided by the
Alexandra Hospital and the Sembawang Hospital
which were recently taken over from the British
Services. The training of Medical Officers in the
various specialities has also been stepped up and
an annual complement of about 50 doctors will
undergo a two-year training in selected
specialities.
Under the Public Health Division, the general
emphasis is on the provisions of improved
environmental health services and the extension of
the coverage of such services to all parts of the
Republic including areas formerly occupied by the
British Services. The Public Health Engineering
Branch will also undergo some fundamental
reorganisation and the scope of its work will be
extended to cover additional areas of
environmental control. The Public Cleansing
Service has been provided with additional funds so
as to extend its coverage to the former British
Armed Forces areas.
Column: 527
Home Affairs
The Ministry of Home Affairs is now responsible
for the additional Departments of the Singapore
Citizenship Registry, the National Registration
Office and the Registry of Births and Deaths which
were formerly under the Ministry of Labour. The
Prisons Department will also be transferred to the
Ministry of Home Affairs in the new year. Further,
a reorganisation of the Police Force, after the Lee
Soo Ann Report, has been undertaken. This will
improve the quality of the rank and file of the
Police Force. There will also be a substantial
increase in the use of modern methods and
techniques for combating crime and an increasing
use of vehicles, radio and electronic equipment for
the routine patrol system.
The Vigilante Corps has also been expanded to
provide for the establishment of a Civil Defence
Organisation and the Auxiliary Fire Fighting
Service and to undertake the training of National
Servicemen in these disciplines.
Defence
Under the Ministry of Defence, the increase in the
block provision for Armed Forces is based on the
need to continue the build-up of the Services,
particularity that of the Air Force and the Navy.
A general review is being undertaken of the
administration of the Ministry. The aim is to
provide a permanent corps of Administrative and
Executive Officers to replace the military
personnel now engaged in administrative duties and
who could be better used in military functions.
Development Estimates
I now come to the Development Expenditure for 1972-73. A total amount of $750.77 million is provided
as compared to $635.96 million and $442.59 million
provided for 1971-72 and 1970-71 respectively.
The major portion of the provision for 1972-73
goes to the economic sector amounting to $342.23
million or 45.6 per cent of the total provision.
Out of this,
Column: 528
35.4 per cent or $121.13 million is for direct
expenditure by the various Ministries on
development projects. The remainder is for
extending loans to the statutory bodies and
companies wholly or partly owned by the Government.
For the financial year 1972-73, the provision for
direct expenditure on development projects in the
economic sector is distributed as follows:-
$ milllion
Tourist Infrastructure Development 10.26
Transport and Communications 44.32
Land Development 64.90
Primary Production 1.90
------
$ 121.13
======
Work at Sentosa on the Golf Course,. Swimming
Lagoon and Gun Museum are now well underway. The
next financial year will see the development of the
Coral and Shell Museum, the Open Air Theatre, the
Cable Car Landing Plaza and other amenities. An
amount of $10.26 million is provided to finance the
development of Sentosa.
In transport and communications, a major
development project is the expansion of the
Singapore Airport. Since its inception in 1955, the
Singapore Airport has seen tremendous increases
both in number of passengers and volume of freight.
To cater for the rapidly increasing number of
passengers and volume of freight the Airport has to
handle, a development plan has been formulated. The
immediate phase involves the extension and
renovation of the existing passenger terminal
building. It has now been completed. In the
intermediate phase, a new passenger terminal, a
freight terminal, a Boeing hangar, the extension of
the runway, new parking aprons and various
navigational and landing aids will be provided.
This phase is scheduled to be completed by 1976. It
will require a sum of $105 million. An Asian
Development Bank Loan of $60 million has already
been obtained.
Column: 529
The increasing volume of vehicular traffic is a
never-ending problem, not -only of traffic flow,
but also of availability of parking space
particularly in the city. This necessitates
improvements to existing roads and construction of
new roads and car parks. Thus, a substantial
provision is made for the vote on Transport and
Communications for 1972-73.
Land development constitutes a sizable part of
direct expenditure by Government Ministries in the
economic-sector. With limited land resources, it
is imperative that we should put them to utmost
use. Part of the provision for land development is
for the acquisition of land required in connection
with various public development projects. Our
major reclamation scheme, the East Coast Foreshore
Reclamation Scheme, is now in its third phase of
development. We seek to build what we have not
been endowed with by Nature.
Loans to statutory boards falling under the
economic sector amount to $221.10 million for 1972-73. These comprise mainly loans to the Jurong Town
Corporation, the Public Utilities Board, the
Singapore Telephone Board and to industrial and
commercial enterprises wholly or partly owned by
the Government. The provision in respect of this
-for 1971-72 was $248.55 million. Loans for
industrial and commercial enterprises, however,
show a reduction amounting to $96.10 million for
1972-73 as compared to $198.55 million for 1971-72. This is attributable to the fact that as more
of these enterprises become well established, they
are better able to draw upon their own resources
and require less external finance for their
development programmes.
A total sum of $263.33 million is provided for
the social sector as compared with $161.74 million
provided for 1971-72. Of this provision of $263.33
million for 1972-73, $77.33 million is for direct
expenditure on development projects and $186.00
million is for loans to statutory boards
Column: 530
in the social sector, including $180.00 million
for the Housing and Development Board.
The distribution of $77.33 million for direct
expenditure by Government Ministries is as follows:-
$ million
Education 23.95
Health 12.71
Sewerage 20.05
Community & Welfare Services 20.62
--------
$ 77.33
========
Though the provision for Education has dropped
slightly from $27.14 million for 1971-72 to $23.95
million for 1972-73, emphasis continues to be
placed on expanding the level of technical and
vocational education in order to meet the
increasing demand for skilled, technical and
professional manpower. The past few years have
seen the restructuring of secondary education
towards technical and vocational education. This
emphasis will be extended to education at the
tertiary level. Thus a great portion of this
year's provision is for development of the new
University of Singapore campus at Kent Ridge in
Pasir Panjang, development of the new campus for
the Polytechnic, and expansion at the Nanyang
University and the Ngee Ann Technical College.
The provision for Health projects has increased
by more than two-fold from $5.57 million in 1971-72 to $12.71 million for 1972-73. The relatively
low level of expenditure for Health development
projects in the past few years has reflected the
emphasis on industrialisation and defence. The
1972-73 provision will cater for more
sophisticated health services as well as improved
environmental health services. The Government has
decided to provide highly-skilled medical
specialists with the necessary facilities to make
Singapore into a medical specialities centre in
this part of the world. The first phase
Column: 531
of this programme is the implementation of the
interim development of four medical specialised
units, Nephrology, Neurosurgery, Cardio-Thoracic
Surgery, and Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery.
Work on them will be completed in two years.
Funds are also provided under Public Health for a
pilot project for mechanisation of street cleansing
operations and for additional vehicles required to
provide efficient refuse collection services. A
considerable sum is also being provided to develop
hawker -centres and markets to resite the
unhygienic stalls and markets now proliferating in
various places in the city.
The development of sewerage facilities in 1972-73
accounts for $20.05 million. Modern sanitation and
better-sewerage facilities are necessary for better
environmental health to check pollution and
increase our water resources. The system will be
extended throughout Singapore as soon as possible.
Government has, under the Garden `City Campaign
for the past two years, developed a great number of
open spaces into beautiful parks and spots. Trees
and shrubs have been planted .along the main
thoroughfares. Government is continuing its efforts
in its Garden City Campaign for which a sum of
$6.30 million is earmarked for 1972-73. This
includes the park developments at Mount Faber,
Central Park and East Coast Park.
The provision for urban and rural-services has
increased to $3.25 million this year, as compared
with $2.48 million for 1971-72. More funds are
required in 1972-73 so as to provide kampong roads,
street lighting, drainage and extension of public
utilities supply in the rural areas. An interesting
project of immense educational value is the
construction of the proposed Science Centre at
Jurong. This Centre
Column: 532
will be opened throughout the year and should
stimulate and educate our students in the science
and technical streams.
The greater portion of the loans to the statutory
boards in the social sector goes to the Housing and
Development Board. The Board has embarked on its
Five-Year Building Programme with the target of
building 100,000 units of flats during the plan
period. For 1972-73, a total of 20,000 housing
units is expected to be built. To achieve this
target, an amount of $180 million has been set
aside as a loan to the Board in 1972-73.
The provision for defence and public
administration amounts to $145.21 million, of which
$11.23 million is for public administration. We
must defend what we have built.
The main share of the provision for public
administration goes to the development of the
Subordinate Courts New Building at Havelock Road,
and improvements to other Government buildings.
Estimates of Revenue
I come now to the Estimates of Revenue. Without
additional taxation, or changes in present rates,
the estimated revenue for the financial year
1972-73 is $1,449.1 million. This represents an
overall increase of $142.1 million or 10.9 per cent
over the estimated revenue of $1,307.2 million for
1971-72.
The estimated revenue yield from direct taxes is
$537.7 million which is an increase of $106.7
million or 22.5 per cent over the estimated revenue
for 197 1-72. The main items in this category are
income tax and property tax. The yield from income
tax is expected to increase by about $70.0 million
and from property tax by $31.7 million. This
represents an increase of about 25 per cent over
the estimated revenue for 1971-72, and is largely
the result of the satisfactory growth rate of the
economy by about 14 per cent in 1971.
Column: 533
Revenue earnings from indirect taxes and other
taxes on outlay are expected to bring in an
additional yield of $26.0 million. The main items
included under this category are customs and excise
duties and revenues from motor vehicles'
registration and licensing fees. Revenue from
customs duties is expected to yield an additional
amount of $18 million or an increase of 6.4 per
cent over the estimated figure for 1971-72. The
growth in earnings from this group of items is
dependent on the overall growth in consumption of
petroleum, liquor and cigarettes, and reflects
largely normal growth rates. Protective import
duties which accounted for part of the increases in
previous years have declined in importance due to
the revision of duties and the removal of tariffs
on many items.
The other main sources of revenue include sales
of goods and services by Government Departments,
sales of land and land premium, income from
property and from investments, and earnings from
currency surplus. This group of items is expected
to bring in some incises in revenue in the new
financial year. The changes in yields from these
intern, however, vary significantly from item to
item and are dependent on actual plans of
operations rather than on normal growth patterns.
The main chances affecting the yield from "Other
Sources" are due to variations in the group of
items covered. The main items that have been
excluded from this category are receipts from
Telecommunications Services and Japanese Special
Aid, both of which accounted for the substantial
amount of $54 million in revenue last year. The
decline in revenue due to this has been partly
compensated by an increase in revenue from interest
on investments and currency surplus which will
jointly yield an additional revenue of about $33.1
million in 1972-73.
Tax Changes
Finally, we have to consider the question of what
additional taxation should be imposed.
Column: 534
In the past, our tax policy has been very simply
the stimulation of rapid economic growth to lay a
wider tax base which would provide increased
revenue sufficiently to meet new requirements for
Government expenditures. This has been almost
completely successful. Since independence, we have
had need, in our direct taxation, only in 1966 to
increase the maximum rate of personal tax from 50
per cent to 55 per cent for incomes above $100,000.
In indirect taxation, only four minor taxes were
introduced and three existing ones were revised,
these being duties on tobacco, beer, stout and
samsu.
For the next financial year also, I propose to
continue this policy. No new taxes are, therefore,
being introduced. There will, however, be a number
of changes which will assist Government's economic
and social policies. They will be tax reliefs
relating to the following:-
(1) stamp duty on certain negotiable
certificates of deposits transacted through
financial institutions:
(2) income tax allowance for earned income for
low income salary earners;
(3) income tax on the imputed income of owner-occupied houses, other than toe largest homes;
(4) income tax deduction of expenditure on
maintenance of gardens;
(5) estate duty on small estates;
(6) income tax depreciation allowance on
expenditure by industries on antipollution
devices.
Details of the tax reliefs are as follows: -
(1) Abolition of Stamp Duty on Negotiable Certificates of Deposits and Bills of Exchange
It is the Government's intention, as-part of the
plan for assisting the development of Singapore
into a regional financial centre, to promote a
short-term money market. This is at present non-existent because the stamp duty on Bills of
Exchange and Negotiable Certificates of Deposit is
inordinately high. In the leading international
financial centres, either there is no stamp duty,
or the rates are nominal. I propose therefore to
remove the stamp duty on Bills of Exchange,
Negotiable Certificates
Column: 535
of Deposit and allied forms of promissory
notes which are transacted from or through banks.
The expected reduction in revenue from such removal
is estimated at $2.5 million per year, but it is
hoped that it will be offset by returns in
increased economic activities and in earnings of
the financial institutions.
(2) Earned income Relief up to $1,000 under the Income Tax Act
At present, in addition to personal allowances,
the Income Tax Act allow a taxpayer a deduction for
earned income which is defined as including income
from salaries, partnerships and other sources
except income from capital such as rents, dividends
and interest. This relief is, however, limited to
20 per cent of the earned income, and subject also
to a maximum deduction of $1,000. For the small
taxpayer earning less than $5,000 per annum,
however, the maximum deduction is determined only
by the first limit of 20 per cent of the earned
income. I propose to remove this 20 per cent limit
so that the deduction will be of full earned income
subject only to the maximum deduction of $1,000.
This will benefit about 33,000 taxpayers. The
proposal will be effective from this year of
assessment.
(3) Increase in the exemption from $6,000 to $12,000 in the Net Annual Value of owner-occupied residence for Income Tax purposes
The rapid progress of the economy has resulted in
an escalation in prices of landed property,
particularly in the last two to three years, which,
in turn, has brought about a general increase in
rentals of houses. Following these increases in
rentals, the revaluation of the annual values of
properties has been undertaken by the Property Tax
Department, but has been the cause of much
complaint by owner-occupiers, some of whom have
claimed that it may soon become too expensive to
live in their own houses! The reason is that
although no additional Property Tax is payable by
owner-occupiers, some of them have become liable to
income tax
Column: 536
on the imputed income taken as the net annual value
of the house in excess of $6,000. (The net annual
value of the house is derived by deducting property
tax, maintenance cost and interest charged on
mortgage loans from the annual value of the house.)
As it is the policy of the Government to
encourage greater home-ownership in the Republic,
it is proposed that the existing exemption of net
annual value be increased from $6,000 o $12,000 for
the purposes of income tax. Such exemption will
give avoidance from payment of additional income
tax to the large majority of owners who live in
their own houses. Even the small minority who own
and live in very large residences will enjoy a
reduction in income tax which they can well afford
to pay.
(4) Increase in the remission of income tax on cost of maintaining of garden
In 1970, the Government decided to remit income
tax on expenditure up to $100 incurred by taxpayers
for maintaining well kept gardens as part of the
national campaign to make Singapore a clean and
green city. This remission is confined to
individuals; companies can already treat
expenditure incurred on gardens like any other
expense.
The Government spends considerable sums of money
in planting trees, flowers and bushes along roads
and in public places. The public has responded to
the campaign and Government's example by improving
their gardens through planting flowers, bushes,
hedges and creepers. As the garden city campaign
must be further encouraged I propose, for the
purpose of giving a remission of income tax, to
increase the maximum from $100 to $300 per annum
for the expenditure on gardens. Whilst the
conditions of eligibility for remission would
remain the same, I am prepared to consider easing
the procedure for making such claims.
(5) Remission from Estate Duty on Estates between $10,000 and $25,000
Column: 537
For the first $10,000, there is now no duty on
the estate of a deceased person. As duty is payable
on the market value of the assets, the appreciation
in recent years has made even terrace houses and
Housing and Development Board flats often worth
more than $10,000 and, therefore, liable to estate
duty. I propose to restore the position by
remitting the estate duty between $10,000 and
$25,000. This will ensure that poor beneficiaries
inheriting small estates do not suffer by having
to sell or mortgage their modest dwellings and
possessions on the death of the bread-winner. Based
on 1970 statistics, this remission would have
benefited about 293 families out of 732 who paid
estate duty. There will be no change for persons
inheriting an estate worth more than $25,000
because it remains Government policy to narrow the
income gap between the poor -and the wealthy.
(6) Accelerated Depreciation for industrial Anti-Pollution Devices
In promoting industrial growth, the Government
has to keep in mind also the wider interest of the
community. Though we want more industries and the
job opportunities they bring, we do not want the
pollution which is sometimes a by-product.
Legislation for
-control of various kinds of pollution has been
enacted and the Government is now intensifying
enforcement of its provisions.
Though the onus lies with the owners of
industries to control pollution, the Government is
prepared to assist them by allowing accelerated
depreciation over three years on capital investment
in approved anti-pollution devices. With the
introduction of this incentive, industrialists
should also accelerate their plans to install
pollution control equipment.
The above measures are expected to cost the
Government a total loss of revenue of approximately
$3.5 million, but would bring compensatory benefits
to Singapore.
Column: 538
Mr Speaker, Sir, may I, in concluding this
"painless budget" Statement, pay a tribute to those
who made it possible the workers of all ranks and
occupations who so spiritedly and undauntedly met
the challenges of the years since independence and
by their constancy and adaptability to new
circumstances, changed the difficulties and
uncertainties caused by the loss of neighbouring
markets upon separation from Malaysia and the loss
of employment and foreign exchange upon the British
military rundown into economic opportunities,
opportunities which have now produced our present
healthy financial situation. I am sure that in
taking some of the fruits of our economic success
for present consumption, they will all want to -do
so with an eye for future consumption and with an
appreciation of the need of investment for long-term returns.
Sir, I beg to move.
Mr Speaker: The Question is, "That Parliament
approves the financial policy of the Government for
the financial year 1st April, 1972 to 31st March,
1973." In accordance with paragraph (1) of Standing
Order No. 84, the debate now stands adjourned.
Mr Hon, debate to be resumed on what day?
Mr Hon Sui Sen: On 16th March, 1972.
Mr Speaker: So be it.
Column: 538
ADOPTION OF CHILDREN (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.17 p.m.
The Minister for Social Affairs (Inche Othman Bin Wok): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
The purpose of this Bill is to introduce a number
of amendments to the Adoption of Children Act,
1970.
Column: 539
The existing provisions under section 3 of the Act
are considered to be too restrictive in that they
do not allow the making of an adoption order in
certain cases where there are exceptional
circumstances meriting a legal adoption.
The amendments to the first and second provisos to
subsection (1) of section 3 of the principal Act
and the addition of a third proviso is to enable an
applicant under 25 years of age or less than 21
years older than the infant (or both) to adopt an
infant who is within the prohibited degrees of
consanguinity and in other exceptional
circumstances. Under the existing law, a parent
under 25 years of age cannot adopt his or her own
child, particularly where the infant concerned is
an illegitimate issue, and the parent subsequently
marries and desires to adopt the child jointly with
his or her spouse. The same restriction also
applies to the adoption of an orphan by an uncle or
an aunt who is less than 25 years of age. The
proposed amendment to remove the above restriction
will not only apply to cases involving illegitimate
children but will also apply to cases involving
legitimate children, for example, a young widow
under the age of 25 years remarries and desires her
child by the deceased husband to be recognised not
only as her own but also as that of her present
spouse, through the process of legal adoption. In
all these instances, it is felt that a waiting
period may cause humiliation and embarrassment to
the parties concerned, particularly where the
infant is an illegitimate issue.
The proposed new proviso to subsection (I) of
section 3 will enable the Court to allow a person,
who is not within the prohibited degrees of
consanguinity and less than 21 years older than the
infant, to adopt such an infant if exceptional
circumstances merit such an adoption, particularly
in cases where the infant is a female, and the
person debarred from adopting the infant in a joint
petition is the female petitioner.
Column: 540
The proposed amendment to subsection (3) of
section 3 spells out in detail the various grounds
for the dispensation of the natural parents'
consent in the interest and welfare of the child to
be adopted. The existing provision does not
elaborate sufficiently the circumstances where the
Court may dispense with the consent of the natural
parents. The present provision has sometimes given
rise to difficulties in interpretation, and because
of the generality of this proviso, the Courts have
on occasions been reluctant to dispense with the
consent even when the circumstances warranted it.
Moreover, there is at present no provision for
dispensation of consent when a parent has
persistently ill-treated the infant, or has failed
to exercise normal parental duties, or has placed
the infant in the care of the Social Welfare
Department and has shown little or no interest in
the welfare of the infant except perhaps a rare
visit once in a long while. Dispensation of consent
under such circumstances is considered justifiable -
and in the interest of such children, who-would
otherwise be deprived of a chance to be adopted by
suitable families who can offer them good homes.
Many children presently under the care of social
welfare homes and other voluntary institutions
could have been adopted and brought up in a happier
and more secure home atmosphere, if not for the non-availability or wilful withholding of parental
consent.
The citizenship status of the adopted infant is
not spelt out in the Act. Because of this, many
people are under the impression that legal adoption
automatically awards citizenship of the adoptive
parents to the adopted infant. Amendment to section
6 of the principal Act seeks to clarify the
position that adoption does not affect the
nationality or citizenship of the adopted infant.
This amendment will bring the Act in line with the
local citizenship law under which even a natural
child of a Singapore citizen parent, born outside
the Republic, does not automatically assume-the
citizenship of his parents.
Column: 541
The present practice of issuing an extract from
the Register of Adopted Children for all adopted
infants is unsatisfactory and has caused much
embarrassment and unhappiness to both the adoptive
parents and the adopted children. Many adoptive
parents have found it most difficult to explain to
the adopted child why his "birth certificate" is
different from his other siblings. The adopted
child himself has also suffered countless ridicules
from his fellow school-mates on account of his
being known as an adopted child, having no natural
parents. Mr Speaker, Sir, if you will recollect,
this has been the -common subject of complaints of
many adopted parents, made in writing to both the
Government and the local press. Since section 6 of
the Adoption of Children Act has accorded the
status of a natural child to the adopted child, it
seems, therefore, a logical step to amend the
present legislation to provide for registration of
adoption and the issue of an ordinary birth
certificate to the adopted child, thus enabling his
complete integration into the adoptive family.
Clause S of the Bill repeals section 11 of the
principal Act and re-enacts a new section which
deals fully with the whole process of registration
of legal adoption to enable all adopted children to
have a birth certificate which is similar in all
respects to that of a child who has not been
adopted. It also ensures that all adoption records
maintained by the Registrar of Births and Deaths
are treated as confidential matters, and access to
them is only possible under a court order. Unless
reference is made to these records, it will not be
possible to know from the new form of birth
certificate whether or not its holder is an adopted
child. The amendment also provides for
retrospective issue of such certificates to adopted
children upon application made by the adoptive
parents when the legislation becomes operative.
Column: 542
This new section 11 relating to the issue of a new
birth certificate is modelled on similar
legislation which was first introduced in New
Zealand in 1915. It is confirmed that, besides New
Zealand, the following countries also have similar
provisions in regard to registration of adoption
and the issue of a new birth certificate to adopted
children: Canada, France, Switzerland, Argentina,
Bolivia, Denmark, U.S.S.R., and U.S.A.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Inche Othman Bin Wok].
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
6.27 p.m.
Clause 1 -
The Chairman: The citation year"1971" appearing
in page 1, line 4, is to be altered to "1972". This will be done.
Clause 1 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clauses 2 to 4 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clause 5 -
Inche Othman Bin Wok: Sir, I beg to move,
In page 4, after line 25, to insert -
"(j) in the case of adoption by a single adopter,
whether the adoptive parent wishes that the words
"adoptive father" or "adoptive mother" as the
case may require, appear on the face of any
certified copy of the entry of birth of the child
issued after the birth has been registered under
this section:".
Sir, the reasons for this amendment are as
follows:
(1) It is desirable to have a special
provision to protect a single adopter from any
possible embarrassment which may be caused by the
issue of a birth certificate to the adopted child
showing only one parent's name when the new form of
birth certificate comes into use. Otherwise, a
child adopted by a single adopter (particularly a
female person) may appear to be illegitimate.
Column: 543
(2) Originally it was intended to give, on the
request of the single adopter, a letter showing
some essential details of the adoption. However,
on further consideration, it was felt that it
would be more expedient to make a special
provision in the Bill.
Amendment agreed to.
The Chairman: There are consequential amendments
to be made,
To re-letter existing paragraphs 0) and (k) as
(k) and (I) respectively.
This will be done.
Clause 5, as amended, ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clause 6 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 7 -
Inche Othman Bin Wok: Sir, I beg to move,
In page 7, at the end, to add -
"In the case of adoption by a single adopter,
whether adopter wishes his or her name to appear
as adoptive father or adoptive mother on the
child's new birth certificate ".
Sir, my reasons for this amendment are the same
as those explained to you when I moved the
amendment to clause 5.
Amendment agreed to.
Clause 7, as amended, ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Bill reported with amendments; read a Third time
and passed.
Column: 543
TOURIST PROMOTION BOARD (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.33 p.m.
The Minister of State for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
The Singapore Tourist Promotion Board which was
set up in 1964 is now well on its way to being
firmly established as the major organisation for
promoting Singapore internationally as a tourist
centre. To finance its opera-lions, the Board
collects a three per cent
Column: 544
cess on hotel charges and on the sale of food and
drinks in the Republic's higher class tourist
establishments. The annual income of the Board is
about $5 million, of which $3 million has been set
aside for overseas promotion during the current
fiscal year. This is some $1.7 million more than
the sum budgeted for promotional work for the last
fiscal year, and it is aimed not only at
intensifying the international advertising and
promotion programme but also at setting up new
overseas representations, one in Frankfurt and one
in New York possibly, to supplement the efforts of
existing ones in Tokyo, Sydney and San Francisco.
Whilst the Board is successfully promoting
Singapore as a tourist centre internationally,
there is a great need to co-ordinate the efforts
of the various promotional agencies in Singapore,
so that Singapore can be promoted as a tourist
centre in the most effective manner possible by
both Government and the private sector.
Furthermore, there is a pressing need to develop
within Singapore those touristy facilities which
would result in tourists extending their stay in
the Republic by an additional day or two with
consequential benefits to hotel occupancy rates.
To bring together in one co-ordinated effort the
promotional efforts of the various private
organisations engaged in the tourist business with
those of Government, the Tourist Promotion Board
Act is being amended to enable any person, who is
carrying on the business of a tourist enterprise,
to become an Associate Member of the Board's
organisation. Two Associate Members will he
appointed to the Tourist Promotion Board to advise
on policy matters as well as on operations. Whilst
Associate membership will give certain advantages,
as all Associate Members will stand to gain by way
of publicity and business, it will alto entail the
responsibility of the member for maintaining high
standards at
Column: 545
all times in the conduct of his business and
adherence to any regulations made by the Board
governing touristy operations. In anticipation of
the coming into effect of this scheme of Associate
membership to the Tourist Promotion Board, the
Singapore Tourist Association has dissolved itself
so that its members, comprising various tourist
establishments from the private sector, can join
the organisation of the Singapore Tourist
Promotion Board.
In keeping with the objective of making the stay
of a tourist here a comfortable and a satisfying
one, the Tourist Promotion Board Act is also being
amended to regulate and control tourist and travel
business in Singapore. These amendments prohibit a
person from describing his business or activities
as a tourist or travel agency, without the prior
approval of the Tourist Promotion Board. The
amendments also restrict a person from using the
words "tourist" or "travel" except with the prior
permission of the Board. The purpose of this is to
prevent those persons operating social escort
agencies from describing their activities as
tourist services. Further, to keep the travel
business in Singapore in a healthy state, travel
agencies will in future be licensed. AU these
measures are designed to protect the tourist from
exploitation and to ensure that during his stay in
Singapore he will only be exposed to bona fide
travel agencies or tour operators.
Another amendment to the Tourist Promotion Board
Act enables the Board to acquire shares in any
company or to invest in any business which will
promote the tourist trade in Singapore. Such
direct financial participation by the Board will
accelerate the development of the necessary
touristy facilities in Singapore which are
necessary to support the overseas promotional
programme. This will not only encourage more
tourists to come to Singapore but also to prolong
their stay here.
Column: 546
Other amendments, as proposed, seek to prevent
the indiscriminate use of the Board's official
symbol, the Merlion, and to protect funds credited
to any superannuation scheme or provident fund
established by the Board for its employees from
being utilised for the payment of an employee's
debts should he be made a bankrupt.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang):Mr Speaker,
Sir, is the Minister of State for Finance aware
that some social escorts are also called "girl
guides", and that the service they provide is
called "girl guide service"? Furthermore, will
this law prohibit the use of the term "girl
guides"?
Mr Speaker: Are they called girl' guides?
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Yes. Some social escorts
in Singapore call themselves girl guides.
Mr Tang See Chim: Sir, I think this matter is
well out of my province. Perhaps the Member could
address it to the Girl Guides Association.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim: Sir, if the Minister of
State for Finance had been reading the
advertisement columns in the newspapers, he would
have come across that term.
Mr Tang See Chim: Sir, the Board's jurisdiction
is confined to tourist promotion and, of course,
within that sphere it will do its best to see that
tourists who come to Singapore have an enjoyable
holiday and that their stay here is as comfortable
as possible. If it comes to our notice that
certain organisations are, in fact, using the term
"girl guides" or whatever -description to hoodwink
the tourists, then, of course, my Ministry will
see to it that they do not do so.
Column: 547
Mr Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I would just like to -draw the attention of the
Minister of State for Finance to the provisions of
the new sections 15D and l9C. Sir, you will notice
that the penalty imposed on any business, which
describes itself as a tourist service without the
permission of the Board, carries a higher penalty
than a business which makes use of the symbol of
the Board. However, I believe that the latter
offence is more serious. And in this respect, the
penalty is only a fine, and there is no additional
provision of a term of imprisonment as provided
for under the new section l5D. May I -seek
clarification from the Minister of State for
Finance?
Mr Tang See Chim: Sir, the provisions of the
Bill have been carefully considered, and it is
thought that a fine would be a sufficient penalty
for the contravention of the provision on the use
of the Board's symbol of the Merlion, and no
imprisonment is necessary. However, if we find
that such penalty is inadequate, an amendment can
always be made to the law.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and
committed to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
6.43 p.m.
Clause 1 -
The Chairman: The citation year "1971", appearing
in page 1, line 4, is to be altered to "1972".
This will be done.
Clause 1 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clauses 2 to 5 inclusive ordered to stand part
of the Bill.
Clause 6 -
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker. Sir, I beg to
move,
In page 7, line 16, to leave out "reasonably"
and insert "unreasonably".
Column: 548
Sir, this is just to correct a grammatical
error.
Amendment agreed to.
Clause 6, as amended, ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clauses 7 to 9 inclusive ordered to stand part
of the Bill.
Bill reported with an amendment; read a Third
time and passed.
Column: 548
TOURIST PROMOTION (CESS COLLECTION) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.45 p.m.
The Minister of State for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
The Singapore Tourist Promotion Board commenced
collection of cess horn hotels in January 1964,
and from tourist public houses and food
establishments in March 1970, following the
necessary amendments to the Tourist Promotion
Board Act. The collection of cess is currently
being undertaken by the Department of Customs and
Excise on behalf of the Board, in accordance with
the Regulations established under the Act. With
the passing of time, it has been found necessary
to introduce various amendments to the Act to
prevent tax evasion and unauthorised collection of
cess, as well as to enable the process of cess
collection to be undertaken more effectively.
To this end, it is proposed to incorporate
within a single Bill all legislation pertaining to
the imposition and collection of cess which will
also repeal the existing provisions on cess in the
Tourist Promotion Board Act.
There will be no change in the rate of cess
levied. This will remain at 3 per cent. However,
instead of imposing the cess only on the sale of
food and drinks in tourist establishments, as
provided in the Tourist Promotion Board Act, this
Bill seeks to widen the scope of the cess so as to
cover sales and charges levied or collected by all
tourist food establishments and by
Column: 549
tourist public houses. This is thought to be fair
and reasonable because many of these
establishments benefit from tourists visiting
Singapore but are not contributing to the upkeep
of the Singapore Tourist Promotion Board and its
promotional efforts. This amendment would bring in
additional income to the Tourist Promotion Board
to supplement its promotional efforts, and it is
also expected to facilitate the present
administration of the tax itself.
There are also provisions in the Bill to enable
tourist establishments required to pay cess to
recover from their customers the cess payable.
Customers are, however, protected under the Bill
from payment of cess to unauthorised
establishments. Other new provisions in the Bill
enable the Tourist Promotion Board to recover cess
due to it on the basis of an estimate made by the
Board, and to sue for cess outstanding by way of a
specially endorsed writ of summons. Where legal
proceedings are instituted by the Board, it is
entitled to all costs allowed by law against the
person liable. Cess owing to the Board shall rank
first in priority to all other debts in any
bankruptcy proceedings or in the distribution of
the property of a person dying insolvent. Also,
persons who attempt to evade cess are liable on
conviction to heavy fines and/or imprisonment. The
Bill also provides for the prosecution of any
offence under the Act to be conducted by officers
of the Board or the Government with the sanction
of the Public Prosecutor. These new provisions in
the Bill are considered necessary to enable the
Board to collect cess more effectively.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee.
Column: 550
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
6.50 p.m.
Clause 1 -
The Chairman: The citation year "1971", appearing
in page 1, line 4, is to be altered to "1972".
This will be done.
Clause 1 ordered to stand part of the
Clauses 2 to 28 inclusive ordered to stand part
of the Bill.
First and Second Schedules ordered to stand part
of the Bill.
Bill reported without amendment; read a Third
time and passed.
Column: 550
ACCOUNTANTS (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.51 p.m.
The Minister of State for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
The Singapore Society of Accountants Ordinance,
1963, now called the Accountants Act (Chapter 212
of the 1970 Revised Edition of the Laws) was
enacted to register accountants and to regulate
the practice of accountancy in Singapore. This
legislation, which was passed nine years ago, gave
recognition to locally-trained accountants and
accorded them professional standing in line with
the other professions.
Section 8 of the Accountants Act provides that
the Society of Accountants may, with the approval
of the Minister for Finance, make rules for the
administration of the Act. This is cumbersome and
unsatisfactory as, in effect, it means that all
such rules have to be considered and deliberated
on by the general body of the Society at a general
meeting. In most other professional Acts as, for
example, the Legal Profession Act, the authority
for the making of such rules lies with the Board
of Legal Education. It is therefore proposed to
amend section 8 of the Act
Column: 551
to provide for the Council of the Society to be
vested with this function. This amendment will
bring it in line with a similar provision in the
Legal Profession Act.
Section 9 of the Act provides for the University
of Singapore to be represented on the Council, but
there is no similar provision for Nanyang
University. Both the Universities award
Accountancy degrees which are recognised by the
Singapore Society of Accountants. It is therefore
logical that Nanyang University should also be
represented on the Council. Accordingly, it is
proposed to amend section 9 of the Act to provide
for representation by the Nanyang University on
the Council of the Singapore Society of
Accountants.
Section 12 of the Act, which gave specific
powers to the first Council of he Singapore
Society of Accountants hen the Act became
operational in1963, is now obsolete and
opportunity therefore taken to repeal this
section.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
Column: 552
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
6.54 p.m.
Cause 1 -
The Chairman: The citation year 1971", appearing
in page 1, line 4, is to be altered to "1972".
This will be done.
Clause 1 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clauses 2 to 5 inclusive ordered to stand part
of the Bill.
Bill reported without amendment; read a Third
time and passed.
ADJOURNMENT
Resolved,
"That Parliament do now adjourn to Thursday,
16th March, 1972."- [Mr E. W. Barker].
Adjourned accordingly at
Five minutes to Seven o'clock p.m,
to Thursday, 16th March, 1972.
Column: 553
Appendix to Annual Budget Statement(Col. 497)(Cols 553-588)