| Parliament No: | 2 |
| Session No: | 2 |
| Volume No: | 31 |
| Sitting No: | 15 |
| Sitting Date: | 23-03-1972 |
|
Column: 1055
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
SECOND PARLIAMENT
Thursday, 23rd March, 1972
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Dr Yeoh Ghim Seng, B.B.M., J.P. (Joo Chiat)).
Inche A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang). Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development and Speaker of the House.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh). Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Health.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (MacPherson), Minister for Health.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong). Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah). Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Law and National Development (National Development Division).
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong). Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Column: 1056
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Minister of State for Education.
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah).
Mr Lim Kim San, D.U.T. (Cairnhill), Minister for Education.
Mr Low Guan Onn (River Valley).
Mr Low Yong Nguan (Crawford).
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan).
Inche Mohd. Ghazali Bin Ismail (Aljunied), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Labour.
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon).
Inche Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Defence.
Inche Rahmat Bin Kenap Al-Haj (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampong Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr S. Ramaswamy (Potong Pasir).
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs.
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee). Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang).
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Minister of State for Labour and Government Whip.
Column: 1057
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan (Whampoa).
Mr Tang See Chim (Chua Chu Kang), Minister of State for Finance.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology.
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Minister of State of Defence.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken, B.B.M. (Alexandra), Minister for Home Affairs.
Mr Yeo Choo Kok (Delta).
Mr Yeo Toon Chia (Kampong Kapor).
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications.
Column: 1058
ABSENT:
Dr Chiang Hai Ding (Ulu Pandan).
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Minister of Defence.
Mr Hon Sui Sen, D.U.B.C. (Havelock), Minister for Finance.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Inche Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampong Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampong Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Column: 1057
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
POLICE JUNIOR OFFICERS
(New structure and salary scales)
(Statement by the Minister for Home Affairs)
Prof. Wong Lin Ken: Mr Speaker, Sir, during the
Parliamentary session in October, 1971, the
Minister for Finance informed the House that the
Lee Soo Ann Committee's recommendations on the
structure and salary scales for the Junior
Officers and Constables of the Regular Police
Force had been accepted in principle by
Government and would be implemented in the new
fiscal year on 1st April, 1972. He stated that as
soon as the principles of conversion were
resolved, the new salary scales would be
implemented. The House was also informed that
pending implementation of the new salary scales
on the 1st of April this year, Government had
decided that the Junior Officers and Constables
should be given with effect from the 1st of
November, 1971, an interim allowance of 10 per
cent of salary and of all allowances drawn,
except Public Utilities Board and Housing
Allowances.
Column: 1058
I am pleased to announce that Government has
accepted in principle most of the other
recommendations of the Lee Soo Ann Committee
Report. Officials of my Ministry and the Finance
Ministry have been working closely together and a
formula of conversion has now been worked out and
approved by Government. The new total emoluments
will be computed on the following basis:
Salary as at 1-4-72
+
Allowances to be abolished
+
Interim allowance of 10 per cent
(made up of 10 per cent of salary
and of all allowances drawn, except
P.U.B, and Housing Allowances)
Convert to the nearest higher point
in the new scale
+
Increment credits(if any)
+
Allowances to be retained (if any).
The conversion will come into effect on 1st
April, 1972, and, as from that date, payment of
the 10 per cent interim allowance will cease. The
conversion to
Column: 1059
the new salary scales, including the allowances
to be retained, will cost the Government an
additional $3.2 million per annum.
About 5,220 Junior Officers and Constables in the
Regular Police Force, excluding members of the
Gurkha Contingent and the Guard and Escort Unit,
will be affected by the conversion. Those holding
the rank of Corporal and below will be emplaced
on the new salary scale for Constables. Staff
Sergeants and Sergeants will be emplaced on the
new scale for Sergeants. Sub-Inspectors will be
absorbed as Assistant Inspectors, who will also
be known as Station Inspectors. All serving
officers will convert to the new salary scales as
follows:
(a) those with the School Certificate or
equivalent qualifications will convert to the
appropriate new scale in accordance with the
conversion formula and progress up the scale in
the normal way;
(b) those with Secondary Il/Ill or equivalent
qualifications will convert to the appropriate
new scale in accordance with the conversion
formula. They will not proceed beyond $425 in the
new scale for Constable; $505 in the new scale
for Sergeant and $690 in the new scale for
Assistant Inspector (Station Inspector), as the
case may be, until such time as they obtain the
School Certificate or pass an examination to be
conducted by the Ministry of Home Affairs and the
Public Service Commission and accepted as an
equivalent to the School Certificate, when they
will be allowed to cross the bar at these points;
(c) those without Secondary II but with
specialist qualifications, e.g, bandsmen,
helmsmen and engine drivers (about 170 of them)
will convert in the same way as for category (b)
above;
(d) those without Secondary II or specialist
qualifications (about 800 in number) will convert
to the appropriate
Column: 1060
new scale in accordance with the conversion
formula and be dealt with as follows.
Government has accepted the recommendation that
serving officers without Secondary II or
equivalent qualifications should be converted to
the new salary scales and stagnate at their
respective points of conversion. Of the 800 men
who do not have the Secondary II or specialist
qualifications, 340 would be eligible for
retirement in the normal course of events before
1st July, 1974. These 340 men will convert to the
new salary scales and remain at their respective
conversion points until they retire.
The remaining 460 men will convert to the new
salary scales and be retired on enhanced terms
specifically provided in Section 9 (1) of the
Pensions Act as recommended by the Lee Soo Ann
Committee Report. Retirement under this provision
gives an enhanced pension factor of One over five
hundred (1/500) of an officer's annual
pensionable emoluments for each complete month of
pensionable service, as compared to a pension
factor of one over six hundred (1/600) for an
officer who retires in normal circumstances on
account of age or for medical reasons. It is the
intention of Government that the retirement of
these 460 men will be so phased out that actual
retirement will commence on 1st April, 1973, and
be completed by 30th June, 1974. Those who are
physically fit will be offered employment with
the Guard and Escort Unit, which will by then
have been reorganised into a statutory board and
run on commercial lines, if they take up
employment with this statutory board, they will
be eligible, in addition to their pensions, for
the full salary paid by the board. Efforts will
also be made to assist those in Police quarters
to find alternative accommodation.
Column: 1061
ESTIMATES OF EXPENDITURE
FOR FINANCIAL YEAR 1ST APRIL,
1972, TO 31ST MARCH, 1973
Order read for resumed consideration in
Committee of Supply [5th Allotted Day].
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
2.37 p.m.
Head 1401 -
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg
to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1101.
Sir, may I request the Minister for Home Affairs
to inform the House as to how many political
parties there are on the Register of Societies
today, and whether they are alive and functioning?
If they are not, will the Minister consider
introducing amending legislation to the Societies
Act to remove all these dead-wood organisations
from the Register, thereby protecting the people
from the dupery of so-called political parties
which resuscitate when general elections approach
and promise the people nirvana-plus? Sir, if this
mischievous practice of political parties of
merely securing their registration is allowed to
continue unchecked, our City State will in no time
hold such an assortment of rackets that our people
may turn politically frigid, and astute visitors
to our country leave in bemused bewilderment at
the spectacle we offer. Sir, in the name of
rational freedom, I call upon the Minister to
avoid turning our beautiful Republic into a museum
of political parties.
The Minister for Home Affairs (Prof. Wong Lin Ken): Mr Speaker, Sir, as on the 17th of March
this year, there are 15 political parties
registered on the Register of Societies. They are:
(1) Singapore Chinese Party, formerly Malayan
Chinese Association, Singapore Branch, registered
on the 26th September, 1950;
(2) Persatuan Melayu Singapura, formerly
Persatuan Melayu Semenanjong, i.e., the Peninsula
Malays Union, registered on the 2nd February,
1952;
Column: 1062
(3) Partai Rakyat, Singapore State Division,
registered on the 3rd December, 1956;
(4) Angkatan Islam, formerly Pan Malayan Islamic
Party, Singapore, registered on the 6th August,
1958;
(5) Workers' Party, registered on the 30th
January, 1961;
(6) People's Action Party, registered on the 18th
February, 1961;
(7) Pertubohan Kebangsaan Melayu, Singapura,
formerly Pertubohan Kebangsaan Melayu Bersatu,
Singapura, i.e., the United Malays National
Organisation, Singapore, registered on 20th of
February, 1961;
(8) United People's Party, registered on the 14th
July, 1961;
(9) Barisan Sosialis, registered on the 15th
August, 1961;
(10) Parti Kesatuan Ra'ayat, i.e., the United
Democratic Party, registered on the 18th June,
1962;
(11) Singapore Indian Congress, formerly the
Malaysian Indian Congress, Singapore, registered
on the 7th August,. 1962;
(12) Alliance Party Singapura, registered on the
17th February, 1966;
(13) United National Front, registered on the 6th
March, 1970;
(14) National Party of Singapore, registered on
the 26th February, 1971;
(15) People's Front, registered on the 21st May,
1971.
Of these 15 parties, the following parties
have not complied with the Societies Act requiring
their constitution to be amended to provide for
membership to be confined to Singapore citizens.
These parties are:
(1) Partai Rakyat, Singapore State Division;
(2) Angkatan Islam;
(3) Workers' Party; and
(4) Barisan Sosialis.
It is also relevant to note that of the 15 listed
parties, Parti Kesatuan Ra'ayat, i.e., the United
Democratic Party, has ceased to function, while
the
Column: 1063
United People's Party and the Singapore Indian
Congress are apparently inactive.
Under section 6 of the Societies Act, the
Registrar of Societies has powers to declare
societies as deemed to cease to exist should they
be unable to furnish him with proof of their
existence. The Registrar of Societies has not
taken action against dormant political parties and
those which have not complied with the Societies
Act. In view of the fact that the Registrar of
Societies has sufficient powers to remove dead-wood political organisations, there is no need to
amend the Societies Act to provide him with such
power. In any case, there are politicians outside
this Parliament who do not share the same down-to-earth views about dormant political parties as the
Member for Changi. They believe in flogging a dead
horse to life oblivious of past records of
undistinguished performance.
2.45 p.m.
As for Singapore becoming a museum of political
parties, I am afraid this is part of history. As
to the possibility of confusing the people of
Singapore because of the large number of political
parties, I submit, our electorate is an
intelligent electorate.
Hon. Members: Hear! hear!
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Sir, the Minister has said that
the Registrar of Societies has got the full power
of deregistering any political parties if they are
defunct or inactive. I do not know why no such
action has been taken. Can the Minister explain to
the House?
Prof. Wong Lin Ken: The reason is very simple.
We do hope that there will be some other people
who would like to revive dormant political parties
and save them the bother of registration.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: In view of the explanation, I
beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Column: 1064
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1151*.(* The same amendment also stood in the, names of Messrs Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi, J. F. Conceicao and P. Govindaswamy.)
In moving this amendment, Sir, I wish to speak on
the Police Force. You will recall that during the
debate on last year's Budget, I pointed out that
some constables and Police officers were rude to
members of the public. At that time the then
Minister expressed concern over this issue and
promised to take appropriate action to rectify the
position. I am glad to note that since then
members of the Police Force have shown a new style
of behaviour in carrying out their services. The
Police have been very active in some campaigns to
bring about a better public understanding of the
Police Force. For example, during Police Week they
have put up road safety exhibitions in the
community centres to bring about a better
relationship and an improvement in co-operation
between the people and the Police, and to make the
people understand that the policeman is a friend
of the people. These are some achievements which
are praiseworthy. Undoubtedly a rapport between
the Police and the people is meaningful in
Singapore, because this, will promote the co-operation between the people and the Police,
thereby enabling the Police Force to be more
effective in crime prevention and detection.
However, in the interests of the public, I wish to
bring up two points.
Firstly, the Police Week should be held annually
in order to continue to improve the relationship
between the people and the Police. It is only when
there is co-operation between them that we can
hope to achieve greater stability and better
social order in our country so that our people
will be able to live in peace.
Secondly, in recruiting Police officers we must
recruit more citizens. Sir, the Minister has said
in a Statement earlier
Column: 1065
on that there has been a considerable improvement
in the remuneration of Police officers. Therefore,
I should think that this new salary structure is
enough attraction to Singapore youths to join the
Police Force. If this should fail to attract our
own youths, then we have to make a further review
and to study the causes. I would also like to ask
the Minister concerned how many non-citizens have
been recruited into the Police Force.
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampong Kembangan) (in Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, the
Government has launched several campaigns, such as
the Industrial Safety Campaign, Pedestrian Safety
Campaign and Road Safety Campaign. To ensure the
safety of members of the public on the roads and
to prevent them from accidents which are, of
course, avoidable, several road safety measures
have been provided and a lot of money spent on
them. For example, overhead bridges have been
constructed and zebra crossing lines painted on
the roads. All these are for the safety of
pedestrians. But such campaigns and measures will
be meaningless if all kinds of road users, either
pedestrians, motorists or motor cyclists, still
meet with accidents.
One contribution to road accidents is that
children are allowed to fly their kites anywhere
they like. Sometimes these kite flyers can be seen
by the roadsides, running across roads, and in
many other places which are dangerous. This is a
hazard to motorists and, apart from accidents that
can happen to them, the kite flyers themselves can
be knocked down by cars. The time has come for
the Commissioner of Police to take firm measures
against these kite flyers.
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson): Sir, how many
policemen have resigned from the Force? Quite a
number, I think; enough to create a staffing
problem that can be described as critical. May I
ask the Minister concerned why has this problem
been allowed to deteriorate to such a state? Is it
because of
Column: 1066
lack of esprit de corps in the Force? Or is it
because of the bullying attitudes of the superior
officers who, in the execution of their duty, may
tend to be highhanded, or is it because of the
poor pay structure? The Minister has announced a
new pay structure for the Police Force, and it is
most probable that Police officers will welcome it
very much. Therefore, I hope they will work harder
in future.
Sometime ago we heard of a few Police officers
who were sacked and then reinstated all because of
a few missing Playboy magazines, which are banned
in Singapore. Why was it that no action was taken
against the person who was in possession of those
bad magazines? Can it be said that the action
against these four poor Police officers could have
a demoralising effect in the Police Force, and
thereby causing some to resign?
It is encouraging to note that the Police Force
is going to be modernised and reorganised but
those responsible for the reorganisation should
take the humane values into consideration. I hope
that in the computerisation of the Police Force
the policemen will not exist as mere digits in the
minds of those responsible for the reorganisation.
The chances of promotion in the Republic's Police
Force should not only be given to people holding
requisite qualifications, but equal chances should
also be given to those with long service and with
good records.
May I also ask why at present the traffic is in a
chaotic state? What is the number of traffic
policemen at present in the Force, and how many of
them are on traffic duty at any one time? Why is
it a common sight in Singapore's roads to find
traffic policemen on duty in pairs, in threes or
in fours? It is time that more traffic policemen
were on foot duty at junctions of busy roads,
particularly in narrow lanes where most of the
traffic offences are committed.
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong) (in Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, please permit me to ask the Minister
a question. This is in relation to the security
Column: 1067
of the Central Fish Market in Jurong. The Central
Fish Market in Jurong is the only venue for the
auction of fresh fish. Every day thousands of
people do their fish business in this market.
Because of the great number of people entering and
leaving the market, it is inevitable that some bad
hats mingle themselves with the crowd. As a result
there have been cases of fighting, Xamb1ing and
theft in the market.
I have received complaints from the fish
merchants in the market to the effect that over
the past few months the security of the market has
deteriorated. There has been an increasing number
of thefts in the market. Fish packed in crates are
simply stolen. For every crate of fish stolen the
fishmonger loses about $100 to $200. If it is a
crate of prawns, then the loss will be about
$1,000. Those fish merchants who were affected
have reported the cases to the Police, but were
told that they could not do anything. I am told
that usually the theft occurs before auction
begins. This is the time when the businessmen are
so busily occupied with the preparations for the
auction that the thieves move in. I would like to
ask the Minister whether he can send some
policemen there between the hours of 10.00 p.m.
and 2.00 a.m, to maintain order and security in
the fish market.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken: Sir, first let me say how
much I appreciate the statement from the Member
for Sembawang that the Police Force has improved
in its courtesy to the public. I am very pleased
to hear that. The Member has also raised the
question that we should, in fact, make the Police
Week an annual affair. The Ministry has this in
mind, and will certainly give the proposal every
serious consideration. I am also very pleased to
note that the series of 12 Police Week shows,
which began last year and will continue in the
present year, have produced the desired effect of
establishing a better relationship between the
Police and the public. The House can rest assured
that the Police Force will be instructed that good
Police relationship is not just a matter of Police
Column: 1068
shows. This should be a continuing daily
experience between the Police and the public.
3.00p.m.
The Member for Sembawang also raised the question
of the recruitment of non-citizens. I think what
he has in mind is the recruitment of Malaysians
into the Police Force. The reason for this is
simply that under the previous salary scales,
before the present revision recommended by the Lee
Soo Ann Report, it was found impossible to recruit
Singapore citizens into the Police Force. I do
share his hope that with the improvement in salary
scales and also the conditions of work, we will
have more Singaporeans applying to join the Police
Force in our next recruitment exercise.
I believe the Member has also asked for the
figures of Malaysians recruited. I am unable to
give him the exact figure, but if he wishes he can
ask an Oral Question later. If he will be
satisfied with a rough figure, it is in the region
of 600. I would like to add that the recruitment
of foreigners is only an interim measure, and we
hope that in the future we do not have to recruit
people from outside Singapore to fill up the
Police Force.
The Member for Kampong Kembangan raised the
question of public safety, particularly with
regard to kite-flying. Under section 14 (e) of the
Minor Offences Act (Chapter 102), it is an offence
for any person to fly a kite which obstructs or
interferes with the traffic in any public road or
with the use of telephones wires. The flying of
kites is a seasonal past-time indulged in by young
and old throughout the Republic. I believe it is a
common feature in the Geylang Serai area. However,
to-date there has been no occasion for the Police
to take action against these persons because they
have not obstructed or interfered with the
traffic, and there has been no complaint of
telephone wires having been damaged. The danger
arising from this past-time is caused by children
running after kites that have
Column: 1069
been cut loose. I can assure the Member that the
Police will do all it can to prevent any hazard
arising out of flying of kites, and I do hope that
the Member will also urge people who wish to fly
kites to be more careful.
Sir, there are also a few questions raised by the
Member for Anson. I believe he wanted to know how
many policemen have resigned, and I can give him
the figures. The number of resignations of junior
officers was 122 for 1969, 246 for 1970, and 235
for 1971. From the beginning of this year to the
15th March, 1972, there were only 12 resignations.
For senior officers, the number of resignations
was 12 for 1969, 19 for 1970, and 24 for 1971.
From the beginning of this year till the 20th
March, 1972, there were only nine resignations. I
think the House is fully aware of the reasons for
the resignations, namely, the salary scales and
the conditions of work. All this has been removed
by the recommendations of the Lee Soo Ann Report,
which the Government has accepted in principle.
It is hoped that with the improvements in salary
scales and conditions of work, there will be less
resignations in future.
I believe the Member for Anson is also concerned
with the state of traffic in Singapore. If I heard
him correctly, he described it as chaotic.
Although traffic on our roads appears to be
apparently chaotic, it is, in fact, not so. There
are two vivid patterns in the flow of traffic -
into the city in the morning peak, and out of the
city in the evening peak. During these periods,
the flow of traffic is congested, and I have no
doubt that this congestion must have given rise to
the impression that the flow of traffic is
chaotic. With more vehicles on the roads during
peak hours, the journeys to and from work create
great demands on road space and certain delays are
inevitably experienced. This is a common
occurrence not only in Singapore, but in all big
cities in the world. The Government is trying to
overcome some of the problems of traffic
congestion by making improvements to the network
of roads and to traffic management
Column: 1070
and enforcement schemes. It is also relevant for
me to point out that normally we do not deploy
three or four traffic policemen on traffic duty in
one spot, except in places where we have recently
introduced the box junction system. I quite agree
that we do need more traffic policemen, but I hope
that as all the vacancies in the rank and file are
filled, the position will be improved.
The Member for Jurong raised the question of
security in the Central Fish Market in Jurong. As
this matter has just been pointed out to me, I
will certainly look into it to see that the
situation is improved.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, the
Minister has not replied to my question regarding
the Playboy magazines.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken: If the Member is referring
to the particular case of Playboy magazines, which
I think he has in mind, that case has been
investigated into and dealt with according to the
instructions of the Attorney-General's Chambers. I
believe the office concerned has already
reinstated the officers.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I thank the Minister for his answers, and I
beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1251.
Sir, every family has a law and every nation has
a statute of laws. A nation enacts laws in order
to maintain order in its society. However, if the
enforcement of the law is ineffective, or worse,
if the law is abused, there will be disharmony
among members of the family and they will lose
confidence in the enforcers of the law. If this
goes on, the law will be flouted and in the end it
will be very difficult to maintain law and order
in the society. If I may use a colloquial phrase
it is like an entanglement of the strands of jute.
Column: 1071
Human beings are like social animals. They live
together but because of civilisation they have
advanced both socially and materially. Therefore,
with the rising desire and expectation for
progress they have differed in their mental make-up. This, together with the different levels of
education that they receive, we find that there
are the capable and the incapable, the stupid and
the intelligent. Therefore, even in a very simple
society, there is bound to be a certain number of
people who are evil-doers. Among them there are
those who have breached the law once or twice,
while there are others who are incorrigible
criminals. They break the law in order to achieve
their ulterior motives. They try to create trouble
and cause chaos. The Government, in order to
safeguard the interests of the people, has to set
up police stations, and send policemen and other
officers in plain-clothes for patrol duties to
prevent these evil-doers from breaking the law and
to help the people to cope with emergencies.
However, some members of the public in my
constituency have complained to me that people
have been wrongly arrested and beaten up by plain-clothes officers. I have carried out
investigations into such complaints and have found
them to be true. Hence, I would like to say
something about this matter.
Mr Speaker, Sir, it is said that whenever the
Police arrest a suspect, he will first be beaten
up to be taught a lesson. Sometimes he has to make
a statement under duress. If this kind of approach
is used against proven gangsters, I would be the
last to object. On the contrary, I feel that more
severe punishment should be meted out against such
bad elements to stop them from doing bad things.
However, the indiscriminate beating-up of suspects
can sometimes involve innocent persons. I
therefore feel that whenever the Police arrest
certain suspects, they should first be
interrogated and investigations made. The Police
should check their identity to find out whether or
not they have any previous criminal records. If
they have no records, then investigations should
be carried out at the scene of the crime.
Column: 1072
And if the suspects are found innocent, they
should be released. If they are found guilty, they
should be duly dealt with. Those who are guilty
will not resist arrest, and will submit to
punishment. In this way, the innocent will be
spared corporal punishment. It is important to see
that there is justice in the enforcement of the
law. Then the country as a whole will be peaceful.
Mr Speaker, Sir, plain-clothes Police officers
are charged with the responsibility of
safeguarding the peace of the country. They should
not only be given privilege to be armed with
revolvers but also the privilege to use them in
self-defence. However, the use of firearms should
only be resorted to when they are in very great
danger. In a normal situation the Police should
not use firearms.
3.15 p.m.
There should be justice in the enforcement of law
and order. This will promote a close rapport
between the Police and the people. We should
educate the people to be more friendly towards the
Police Force. To accomplish this, I feel that all
suspects should be thoroughly interrogated before
any action is taken against them. If this is not
done, there will be a miscarriage of justice and
there will be hostility towards the Police. If
suspects are taken to the Police station, and
there are sufficient grounds to find them guilty,
they should be charged accordingly. I hope the
Minister will take note of what I have said so
that a close rapport can be established between
the Police and the public.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken: Mr Speaker, Sir, let me
first say that I share the views of the Member for
Paya Lebar that law and order should be maintained
and that justice should not only be done but is
seen to be done. The main thrust of his debate is
that some plain-clothes officers have beaten up
suspects and that he himself has conducted an
investigation into the matter. I appreciate the
Member's good intention. However, I would like to
say that if there are any complaints, there
Column: 1073
is a proper procedure to deal with them. He
himself has conducted an investigation, but the
results of his investigation cannot be the basis
for disciplinary action. If he were to lodge a
complaint, and if it is found that what he says is
true, then disciplinary action will be taken
against the officers concerned. Police officers
are not above the law. There are specific
provisions in the Penal Code which make it an
offence for persons, including Police officers, to
use force of any kind to extract confession or
information which may lead to the detection of a
crime. Any person so aggrieved by such action can
lodge complaints against the officers concerned,
and every complaint will be thoroughly
investigated. If the investigation reveals that a
particular officer is at fault, disciplinary
proceedings will be taken against him. Any
instance of misconduct on the part of any Police
officer will not be condoned and will always be
viewed very seriously. Police brutality will not
be tolerated even if, after investigation, the
suspect is found to have committed the offence. In
fact, if a person is found to have committed an
offence, the chances are that he will be charged
in court. If the Member for Paya Lebar has lodged
a specific complaint, I am sure the Police will
certainly look into the matter.
Mr Tay Boon Too(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
am very satisfied with the Minister's answer. I
beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendments stood on the Order
Paper Supplement -
Mr J. F. Conceicao:
(4) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401
be reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1339.
Mr P. Govindaswamy:
(5) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401
be reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1551.
The Chairman: Mr Conceicao is not here. Amendment
(5), Mr P. Govindaswamy.
Column: 1074
Mr P. Govindaswamy: I am not moving, Sir.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1601.
Sir, this subhead concerns the Vigilante Corps
which has a glorious record ever since its
inception in 1964. The Vigilante Corps was
actively discussed during the Committee of Supply
last year. I do not propose, therefore, to go over
the same ground which has been covered by Members
last year. I merely wish to seek clarification
from the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister
for Home Affairs: who is really in charge of the
Vigilante Corps, and whether there are any plans
to re-activate the Volunteer Vigilante Corps or,
for short, the V.V.C.? At present there are only a
very few volunteers remaining in service and the
V.V.C, is, therefore, very inactive. Nowadays we
seldom see them patrolling the streets or helping
at community centre functions or participating in
community activities in the various
constituencies.
Mr Speaker, Sir, sometime ago, Members of
Parliament were asked to submit their views on the
reorganisation of the V.V.C, in their respective
constituencies. I wonder what conclusions have
been made as a result of these suggestions by
Members. Are there any plans to revive the V.V.C.
and to make it play a more effective role in the
interest of the community? In my view, in order to
achieve this the V.V.C, members should not be
confined to guard duties only but should also be
encouraged to participate in the various
activities organised by the Citizens' Consultative
Committees or by the management committees of the
community centres in the various constituencies.
Moreover, the Citizens' Consultative Committees or
the management committees of the community centres
should have a measure of control over the V.V.C.
members in their community centres. At present the
community leaders have first to seek permission
before they can obtain the
Column: 1075
services of the V.V.C. This formality should be
dispensed with wherever possible, otherwise it will
be a hindrance to any plan to promote an effective
role of the V.V.C, in community activities.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs (Mr L. P. Rodrigo): Mr Speaker, Sir,
may 1 thank the Member for Mountbatten for the
praise he has accorded to the Vigilante Corps, it
is true that the headquarters of the Vigilante
Corps has circulated a questionnaire to Members of
Parliament for the purpose of accumulating
information and data to see how the performance of
the Volunteer Vigilante Corps can be improved.
However, not all the questionnaires circulated to
Members of Parliament have been returned and, as a
result, the headquarters is still having some
difficulty in working out plans to improve the
organisation as well as the performance of the
Volunteer Vigilante Corps. This provides me with an
opportunity to prevail upon Members of Parliament
to kindly let me have this data sheet to enable the
headquarters of the Vigilante Corps to plan out
this reorganisation. The specific suggestions made
by the Member are, in fact, the subject of various
considerations in the questionnaire, all with a
view to undertaking this proposed reorganisation.
And let us hope that with the reorganisation the
services of the Volunteer Vigilante Corps may be
utilised without having first to obtain the
approval of the headquarters of the Vigilante
Corps.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am quite
satisfied with the answer given. I beg leave to
withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff(In Malay): Mr Speaker.
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1651*.(* The same amendment also stood in the name of Mr P. Govindaswamy.)
Sir, I wish to congratulate the Minister for Home
Affairs in setting up the Central Narcotics Bureau.
It has a corps
Column: 1076
of efficient officers who recently have done much
to expose the drug-pushers, and to confiscate
quantities of MX pills, heroin and ganja, all in a
short space of time after its setting up. The
officers have been very efficient in their efforts
to abolish drug trafficking.
However, I regret to say that the people who were
prosecuted for trafficking or peddling in MX pills
and ganja have been given only light prison
sentences. In the Straits Times dated 4th March, it
was reported that two persons were convicted and
fined $150 each for possession of ganja. In the
Straits Times of 22nd March, a labourer was fined
$25 for possession of ganja. Mr Speaker, Sir, the
penalties given to these persons are very light in
comparison with the penalties for other offences.
They should be given the maximum penalty. If a
person is convicted for causing damage to other
people's property under the Vandalism Act, the
sentence can include the rotan. Why cannot the
punishment by the rotan be extended to persons
trafficking in MX pills and other drugs? I feel
that the Minister for Home Affairs should amend the
laws so that these people will be given a heavier
punishment, such as a longer term of imprisonment,
including caning.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, the newly
formed Central Narcotics Bureau has been very
successful in smashing the drug peddling rings in
the notorious areas. However, the Bureau should
expand its staff by recruiting some young men. At
present the Bureau consists of older men who rely
on tips more than anything else. The younger men
can penetrate into these drug rings and thereby
expose them, and perhaps they may catch the "big
fish" behind this menace.
3.30 p.m.
Furthermore, what action has been taken by the
Bureau to prevent University boys from becoming
addicts? I understand that some of our University
boys are taking pills to keep up with the
Column: 1077
"in-crowd". It is time that some of the vermin was
eliminated before it spreads like a plague in the
University.
Sir, sometimes when one takes ganja, it activates
the mind. Because of this, the University students
take ganja in order to concentrate on their
studies. But this has a bad effect on the human
body, and will finally ruin the body. There is no
doubt that this is bad and dangerous for their
future. Therefore, the Government must take action
on this serious matter.
Sir, I also understand that hippism is associated
with drug-taking and if long hair is characteristic
of hippism, then it is time that we acted on our
youngsters who sport long hair. Even junior doctors
have long hair! We must check this trend because it
affects the society. We must destroy the poisoning
effects of the demoralised Western society being
accepted here by our local youths as being a
fashionable thing. These youngsters who keep long
hair must be pulled up and charged. Parents too
should do their part in discouraging their children
from keeping long hair. It is very important for
the Minister to take action on this matter. He must
not prolong the matter. Otherwise our youths and
also the citizens of Singapore will be spoilt in
the future. It is very bad for the State.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken: Mr Speaker, Sir, very rarely
do law enforcement agencies get praises from the
public. And I am quite sure that what the Members
for Kampong Kembangan and Anson have stated about
the efficiency of the officers of the Central
Narcotics Bureau will reach the ears of the
officers concerned and spur them on to better
performances.
As regards the sentences passed on the traffickers
of ganja as administered by the law courts, my
Ministry is aware of the situation. In fact, my
Ministry and the Ministry of Health are at the very
advanced stage of making new laws to deal with
traffickers in dangerous
Column: 1078
drugs, including ganja. It is too early for me to
reveal the details now, as it would not be quite
proper. But I can assure the Member that the new
laws will provide for enhanced punishment and,
possibly, even flogging. I must say that the matter
is in the discussion stage and nothing has been
finalised.
The Member for Anson has raised the question of
effective penetration of drug syndicates. This is
being done. It is not in the nature of things to
reveal how we are going about it because this would
jeopardise all our operations. However, I can
assure the Member that we are interested in all
drug syndicates, big or small.
As regards long hair and hippism, 1 think the
public is aware that the Singapore Government does
not encourage the sporting of long hair and
certainly not hippism. We are doing what we can
against the problem of long hair. The Member is
aware that there is no law against long hair. What
we can do is to provide various kinds of sanctions
against the sporting of long hair in Singapore.
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff(In Malay): Sir, with the
assurance given by the Minister, I beg leave to
withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr
J. F. Conceicao -
(8) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1658.
The Chairman: Amendment (8) has been withdrawn.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1701*.
(*The same amendment also stood in the names of Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi and Messrs Sim Boon Woo and P. Govindaswamy.)
Sir, this amendment refers to the Singapore
Citizenship Registry. The work of the Registry has
increased quite a lot. We all know that the
question of citizenship has, over the last few
years, been debated enthusiastically by many
Column: 1079
Members in the House on behalf of the people in
the various constituencies. At that time, the
Minister for Home Affairs was a Backbencher and he
was speaking On behalf of the people in his
constituency. He asked the Minister for Labour to
consider more sympathetically the situation faced
by the people in his constituency. Allow me to
quote the Member for Alexandra, who is now the
Minister for Home Affairs, when he spoke in this
House. This is in Hansard, Vol. 29, No. 12, col.
802, dated 20th March, 1970:
`Mr Speaker, Sir, may I say how much I share the
views of the Member for Toa Payoh on the question
of eligibility of citizenship and the way by which
citizenship is granted to applicants? Speaking on
the basis of my own experience in my own
constituency, I feel that, perhaps, there should
be some relaxation and more compassionate ways in
which applications for citizenship are
considered.'
Sir, the reason for quoting the Minister for Home
Affairs' statement is to show that he was
sympathetic towards the people without citizenship
when he was a Backbencher. Now that he is the
Minister for Home Affairs, I hope that he will
consider the question of citizenship more
sympathetically.
Sir, the main reason why we impose a strict
policy on citizenship is to reduce the economic
burden of our country. Of course, I support this
argument. But over the last year or so, there has
been a great improvement in our economy and I
think we can well afford to relax our policy on
the granting of citizenship. We have, in fact,
issued more than 60,000 work permits to non-citizens. Therefore, for those who have waited
many years for their citizenship - some of them
have their families, wives and children in
Singapore and they have long regarded Singapore as
their permanent residence or home - I think we
should be more liberal and grant citizenship to
them.
Sir, following the rapid economic expansion
experienced by our economy, the wage level of our
workers has been increased. A semi-skilled worker
can obtain an average income of around $200 to
$300 per month. For a shopkeeper, the total income
for a month is more than $400. Sir, these people
Column: 1080
can well afford to support their families. For
those people who are economically independent, I
think we should consider granting citizenship to
them.
Sir, another category of applicants may not
require our support economically. Some of these
applicants are rather old but they have a good and
sound economic foundation. Some of them are well
supported by their own children, and they have no
problem at all in getting a livelihood. But why
are they applying for citizenship? 1 have spoken
to some of them in the past as I wanted to
understand them better and to find out their
reason for applying for citizenship. According to
them, they are applying for citizenship because of
the question of honour. They say that they have
been living in Singapore for many years, several
decades, in fact. They have been law-abiding
citizens and in the past they did not apply for
citizenship earlier because they did not pay much
attention to the question of citizenship. Another
reason is that they now understand that Singapore
is better than many other countries. They feel
that they are in love with our country. They say
that living in Singapore allows them to have a
peaceful life and, therefore, they are eagerly
awaiting their citizenship. Of course, I
sympathise with them for the various reasons they
have given.
Another category of applicants wants to go
overseas and with citizenship, it is more
convenient to apply for a passport. Of course, we
have issued Certificates of Identity to non-citizens but they feel that this is rather
inconvenient. I also hope the Minister will give
sympathetic consideration to this category of
applicants.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, citizenship
is not a right but only a privilege. I fully agree
with the statement. But can the Minister say why
there are so many stateless persons in Singapore?
They are "floating" characters, and are neither
citizens of any country nor are they likely to be
granted Singapore citizenship. Because of their
status, they cannot apply for flats and cannot
even go across the Causeway to visit relatives or
friends. Surely they
Column: 1081
deserve a more humane approach by the Government.
Why not issue them with Certificates of Identity
so that at least they can go across the Causeway?
Furthermore, there are many people who have
applied for citizenship and although they are kept
waiting, they are not told what their chances are
of obtaining citizenship. To assist them can we
not give them a specific date when they will be
informed whether their application is approved or
rejected? They will at least be saved the misery
of the long wait and instead can make alternative
arrangements.
3.45 p.m.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken: Mr Speaker, Sir, firstly, I
would like to thank the Member for Sembawang for
quoting a statement I made when I was a
Backbencher in this House. I have not forgotten
that statement. Indeed, I thank him for mentioning
it because I can now say publicly that what I said
then was, in fact, a less than responsible
criticism of the Minister of Labour, who was then
in charge of the very difficult portfolio of
citizenship. I was then moved more by my heart
than by careful consideration of the problems of
citizenship in this country. Sir, I am very much
sobered by the responsibility of office and know
that what I do in the Citizenship Office will
affect the future generations of Singapore. I have
considered the pros and cons of current policy and
have come to the conclusion that the policy on
citizenship built up over a period of years is in
the best interest of Singapore - for your children
and my children, and their children's children.
However, having said this, I would say that by and
large we have been very generous and liberal in
our citizenship policy. I have made a calculation
of our citizenship figures, and I can say that 28
per cent of our citizens are, in fact, registered
citizens, a figure which is high by any standards
in the world.
Sir, to put the whole problem in its proper
perspective, let me give a comparison. I will take
the year 1968 as the basis for comparison because
this is the
Column: 1082
only year for which I could collect the necessary
statistical data. In Australia, in 1968, one
person was granted citizenship for every 70 square
miles of land. In Canada in the same year, the
figure was one for every 64 square miles. In
Malaysia, it was one for every three square miles.
In New Zealand, it was one for every four square
miles. But in Singapore, we granted citizenship to
16 persons for every square mile. I need hardly
remind Members that we have only 224 square miles
of land at high tide, with one or two more square
miles at low tide. In contrast, Australia has more
than 2.9 million square miles of land, Canada 3.9
million square miles, Malaysia 130,000 square
miles, New Zealand about 104,000 square miles. I
am not unmindful of the hardships imposed on the
people, but I am equally aware of the fact that
the responsibility of this Government is towards
the people who are born in Singapore and who have
no other possibilities of acquiring citizenship in
other countries. I think all of us here in this
Parliament are kind-hearted and gentle people. I
have not come across any other country except
Singapore which shows so much concern for making
things easier for the people to acquire
citizenship of her country. In fact, records over
the past few years have shown that every
government is making it more and more difficult
for the people to acquire citizenship of that
country. Perhaps this quality distinguishes us
from other people. Despite comments that we are
becoming ugly Singaporeans, I suspect that deep
inside us we have very soft hearts. But there is
also a limit beyond which we cannot go, without
jeopardising our collective welfare. It is for
this reason that although we are very sympathetic
in the granting of citizenship, we are also very
careful in our consideration.
The Member for Anson has asked why do we not fix
a time limit and tell the applicants what their
chances are. The reason why we do not do so is
because we hope that, as time goes on, they will
be given citizenship. If they do not get it the
first time, there is always a second chance, and
then a
Column: 1083
third. We do not want to discourage them. It has
been suggested that we are in relatively good
times, and therefore why should we not be generous.
True, our economy has picked up far beyond
expectations in the last two or three years. But I
would like to remind Members of the House that this
is the first time, within the memory of a living
generation after the Second World War, that we have
anything like the situation of full employment. We
hope this situation will exist for a long time to
come, in which case the whole question of
citizenship can be reconsidered. Until we can be
assured that the good times will last, the present
policy will continue. I should hate to think that,
because of what this Government does and what this
House wants, in the years to come our children and
their children's children would have to go around
the world begging for citizenship.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I thank the Minister concerned for expressing
his wish that he is going to consider the cases for
citizenship more sympathetically. I beg leave to
withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The following amendment stood in the name of Mr P. Govindaswamy -
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1751.
Mr P. Govindaswamy: I am not moving, Sir.
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1801.
Sir, in moving this amendment, I wish to ask the
Minister concerned if he will consider allowing
parents of children born at the Kandang Kerbau
Maternity Hospital to apply for their children's
birth certificates at the Registry of Births,
Empress Place. As far as I know, the office of the
Registry of Births in Empress Place will only
accept applications for registration of birth of
babies who are born in their
Column: 1084
homes or in private hospitals. As for those born in
the K.K. Hospital, the parents will have to do so
at the K.K. Hospital. Because of this, those
parents who work in the City area find it
inconvenient to go to the K.K. Hospital. This means
that they might have to take one day's leave to go
to the K.K. Hospital for this purpose.
Administratively, if it is not too difficult, I
hope the Minister concerned will allow them to do
the registration at Empress Place.
Mr Ng Yeow Chong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I would also like to make a request to the Minister
concerned. My request is for exemption of search
fee required for the inspection of particulars of
birth from the Register of Births. Normally a fee
of S2 is payable for this purpose in cases where
the applicants do not have the red-printed
duplicate copy of the registration of birth, it is
only when a search has been successful that they
have to pay a further sum of 52 for a Certificate
of Extract from the Register of Births which we
normally call tile birth certificate. So a total of
54 will have to be paid for the purpose of
searching for a birth certificate. This is a burden
to the poor people.
The next point I wish to make is that the time of
the search should be shortened as far as possible
so as to facilitate matters for people who require
the information.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken: Mr Speaker. Sir, if I
understood the Member for Tiong Bahru correctly, he
wants to centralise the issue of birth certificates
at Empress Place. With that clarification, I will
proceed.
Sir, the present practice is for births which
occur in Government hospitals to be registered at
the hospitals. Of the total of 45,934 births in
Singapore in 1970, 36,129 or about 79 per cent were
born in hospitals. This system has proved to be
very convenient for parents, and it also ensures
completeness of registration. Births occurring in
the rural areas are now registered at the 14
Maternal and Child Health Clinics, which have been
gazetted as
Column: 1085
registration centres. This not only facilitates
registration, but enables the Maternal and Child
Health Clinic to undertake post-natal care and
supervision of the mother and child. Of the total
births in 1970, only 6,439, or about 14 per cent,
were registered at Empress Place. It is evident
from the figures just cited that it is far more
convenient to allow registration at the different
centres than to centralise it at Empress Place.
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I thank the Minister for his reply. But what I
mean is not centralisation at Empress Place. What
1 requested was for Government to grant
registration facilities at Empress place to those
parents whose babies were born at the K.K.
Hospital. I know the Government has done a lot in
improving the registration of births. This is a
clear example of providing better service to the
people by the Government. But I feel it would be
better if registration service can be provided at
Empress Place to those who want to register the
birth of their babies who are born in the K.K.
Hospital. The reason is that it is usual for
mothers to be discharged after a stay of one or
two days in the K.K. Hospital. The law allows
registration of births within 42 days from the
date of birth. The husband will have to take all
the trouble to go back to the hospital to register
the birth if he happens to be working in the City.
It is inconvenient for him. So. I hope that
registration of births at the Empress Place office
for the category of persons just mentioned can be
allowed.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken: I understand the point made
by the Member for Tiong Bahru. I will look into
the matter and see whether administratively it is
feasible. As regards the point raised by the
Member for Mountbatten, I agree with him that it
takes a long time before a search can be
completed. This is because of the large number of
people who apply for the searches. As to cost, I
am afraid very little can be done because
Column: 1086
it is quite a costly thing to run the Registry and
considering the time taken to produce results, I
think $4 is a very reasonable rate.
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon(In Mandarin): Sir, in view of
the satisfactory answer given by the Minister, I
beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
4.00 p.m.
The following amendments standing in the name of
Mr J. F. Conceicao were not moved -
(12) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401
be reduced by $10 in respect of item (2) of
subhead 2101.
(13) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401
be reduced by $10 in respect of item (6) of
subhead 2101.
(14) That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401
be reduced by $10 in respect of item (7) of
subhead 2101.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1401 be
reduced by $10 in respect of item (11) of subhead
2120.
Just a matter of information, Sir While I applaud
the Minister for any efforts that aim at bringing
about greater safety and courtesy on the roads,
may I specifically ask what will the greatly
enhanced sum for this item be spent on? Can we
have further details, Sir?
Mr Rodrigo: Sir, increase in the provision of
this item from $4,500 to $27,000 for the next
financial year is due to the following factors.
First, the replacement of old signs made obsolete
as a result of the introduction of the Traffic
Signs (Size, Colour, and Type) Rules, 1970.
Secondly, additional signs are required for
functions such as the Grand Prix, National Day
Parade, exhibitions, etc. Further, may I say that
the emphasis is on Safety First and Signs and
Pedestals.
Mr Conceicao: Sir, I was first under the
impression that perhaps this increased vote has
indicated a greater interest in educating the
public towards greater consciousness in road
safety. However, since my impression does not
Column: 1087
seem to be correct here, may I just express the
hope that such efforts may be intensified in the
future until greater success is reached in making
our roads much safer, and with conditions
reflective of greater courtesy. With that hope,
Sir, I beg leave to withdraw.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $60,589,890 for Head 1401 ordered to
stand part of the Estimates.
Column: 1087
Head 1402 -
Inche Rahmat Bin Kenap Al-Haj (Geylang Serai)(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That the sum to be allocated for Head 1402 be
reduced by $10 in respect of subhead 1001*.
(*The same amendment also stood in , the names of Messrs Sim Boon Woo and Govindaswamy)
The Immigration Department is an important
department and it must play its role in a proper
manner because it reflects the attitude of the
Government of that country. A few months ago the
action of Singapore Immigration officials of
cutting the hair of long-haired foreigners who
wanted to enter Singapore at the Woodlands
checkpoint was unsuitable and improper. Every
tourist who comes to Singapore wants to visit the
country and to see for himself what the situation
is like in our country. But suddenly he finds that
his hair has been trimmed to look like soldiers! I
hope this matter will be reconsidered by the
Immigration Department.
Another matter which I would like to raise with
the Minister is the complaints received from
members of the public against the Immigration
Department. The Immigration Department does not
entertain letters from members of the public. This
is a very conceited attitude on the part of the
Immigration officials. This is very regrettable
because the work of immigration bears some
relationship with the public. Therefore, this
department should entertain letters from members of
the public, whether or not the matters raised are
relevant. As officials of the Government, they
must,
Column: 1088
in their line of duty, reply to all letters
received, and must not throw these letters into the
waste paper basket.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Sir, I do not quite agree with
the Member for Geylang Serai that the Immigration
Department does not reply to letters sent to them.
I think the Department has a high standard of
efficiency as regards work.
I would like to know how soon will the Immigration
Office, presently situated at Empress Place, move
to its new office, which I am given to understand,
is to be located at Phoenix Park. Members of the
House are no doubt aware of the working conditions
of the staff of the Immigration Department. The
congestion in the public waiting lounge in the
Immigration office is most unbearable and chaotic.
The situation now is quite similar to that of a
fish market. This certainly presents a bad picture
to the tourists and foreigners, particularly those
prospective foreign investors and tourists who have
occasion to complete certain formalities in the
Immigration Office. However, in spite of this
pathetic situation brought about by insufficiency
of staff and compact office space, Immigration
staff has maintained a high standard of efficiency,
for which I commend. While I am concerned with the
image that we present to the foreigners, who would
certainly count such a visit to our Immigration
Office as quite an experience, I am even more
concerned for our own citizens who have to wait for
several hours in seemingly unending queues in such
an environment. I hope the Minister will make an
immediate adjustment, bearing in mind my
observation, when this office moves to its new
premises.
The Chairman: Mr P. Govindaswamy is not here.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken: Sir, two views were expressed
of the Immigration Department and its public
relations. The Member for Geylang Serai indicated a
certain laxity, while the Member for
Column: 1089
Changi has praised the efficiency of the staff
working under very difficult conditions.
I am not quite sure what the Member for Geylang
Serai is specifically referring to. All officers
in our Ministry, including those in the
Immigration Office, have instructions to reply to
grievance letters against them appearing in the
press. They are also instructed to acknowledge
letters written directly to them. If there is any
specific instance of what the Member has alleged,
I will look into the matter if he will direct the
letter to me.
As regards the question of overcrowding at
Empress Place office, I think not only myself but
all my officers, including those in the
Immigration Office, have agreed that the
Immigration Office at Empress Place is too
congested for the purposes. Action has already
been taken to look for an alternative site, and
the Ministry hopes that the new site will be large
enough to meet the needs of the Office as well as
the public.
Inche Rahmat Bin Kenap(In Malay): Sir, there were
instances when officials of the Immigration Office
did not reply to letters. Those people who were
affected did refer their cases to me, and I have
letters in my hand to show that their letters have
not been replied.
I hope the Minister will also reply to my
question regarding the cutting of long hair at the
Woodlands checkpoint.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken: First, with regard to
unanswered letters, I would ask the Member to pass
them over to me. With regard to long hair, I think
the Member is concerned with our policy that the
cutting of long hair will affect the number of
tourists coming in to Singapore. I do not have the
actual figures, but I can say that it does not, in
fact, affect the number of people coming in to
Singapore. The Government will continue with the
policy of discouraging people with long hair from
entering Singapore. There has been sufficient
publicity on this. In fact, the
Column: 1090
Ministry was quite happy at the publicity because
it had the effect of putting across the message to
other countries.
Inche Rahmat Bin Kenap(In Malay): I beg leave to
withdraw my amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
The sum of $2,663,690 for Head 1402 ordered to
stand part of the Estimates.
The Chairman: The remaining heads of expenditure
in respect of which no amendment stands on the
Order Paper Supplement are Heads 0103, 0105, 0106,
0107, 0109, 0302, 0702, 1004, 1102, 1103, 1105,
1106, 1109, 1302, 1305, 1307, 1308 and 1309.
Question, "That the sums stated for those heads
of expenditure which appear in the last column of
the Abstract of Estimated Expenditure on pages 49
and 50 of Paper Cmd. 3 of 1972 stand part of the
Estimates of Expenditure for the financial year
1st April, 1972, to 31st March, 1973," put, and
agreed to.
Question, "That the sum of $1,230,465,920 shall
be supplied to the Government under the heads of
expenditure for the public services shown in the
Estimates of Expenditure for the financial year
1st April, 1972, to 31st March, 1973, contained in
Paper Cmd. 3 of 1972," put, and agreed to.
Resolution to be reported.
Thereupon Mr Speaker left the Chair of the
Committee and took the Chair of the House.
The Minister of State for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to report that the
Committee of Supply has come to a certain
resolution.
Resolution reported -
"That the sum of $1,230,465,920 shall be supplied
to the Government under the heads of expenditure
for the public services shown in the Estimates of
Expenditure for the financial year 1st April,
1972, to 31st March, 1973, contained in Paper Cmd. 3 of 1972."
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That Parliament doth agree with the Committee on
the said resolution."
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolution accordingly agreed to.
Column: 1091
SCIENCE COUNCIL OF SINGAPORE
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
4.15 p.m.
The Minister for Science and Technology (Dr Toh Chin Chye): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That
the Bill be now read a Second time."
This Bill seeks to bring the financial year of
the Science Council in line with that of the
Government, which is, 1st April to 31st March. The
amendment proposed in clause 2 (b) of the Bill is
consequential, and it requires that a report from
the Science Council is submitted before the end of
June.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Dr Toh Chin Chye]
Bill considered in Committee: reported without
amendment: read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1091
SINGAPORE ARMED FORCES BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
4.18 p.m.
The Minister of State of Defence (Mr Wee Toon Boon): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
For many years now, the disciplinary provisions
under the law have been found increasingly
anomalous, unsatisfactory and unworkable,. The
disciplinary laws had diverse origins being
scattered, as it were, in a number of enactments
including the Singapore Army Act, the British Army
Act, Queen's Regulations, and the People's Defence
Force Act, a situation which made administration
cumbersome, tedious and frustrating. What was even
more unsatisfactory was the fact that the
provisions in these enactments were, mainly,
relevant to an army based on regular professional
soldiers or a volunteer part-time army. They are,
apart from being partly irrelevant to
Column: 1092
a large national service army such as ours,
inadequate and inappropriate in the context of a
unified force consisting of army, maritime and air
commands which severally and collectively
constitute the Singapore Armed Forces. For
instance, to a professional soldier in a standing
army to be discharged with ignominy from the army
would be a grave form of punishment. But this
would not deter some of the less responsible
national servicemen who would, on the contrary, be
quite happy to be discharged regardless of
ignominy. For to them ignominy would be the way of
escape from their military obligations to the
nation. A major difficulty experienced has been in
regard to the punishment of Senior Non-Commissioned Officers and Officers who, under
present conditions, can only be tried summarily by
an Officer of the rank of Brigadier. There is no
such officer in the Singapore Armed Forces today,
so that Senor NCOs and Officers either had to be
court-martialled or else let off scot-free. I
shall elaborate this further when I discuss the
salient features of the Bill.
First and foremost, the Bill envisages a concept
appropriate in the context of a unified force
comprising the army, maritime and air commands
which are brought under the centralised control of
an Armed Forces Council, which is the overall
authority under clauses 7 and 197 of the Bill, for
all matters connected with the Armed Forces,
except for the authority vested in the President
for the formal establishment of the Singapore
Armed Forces, vide clause 6.
The major portion of the Bill deals with all the
various matters covering and connected with
disciplinary measures including the mechanics of
the administration thereof. Additional or revised
military offences are introduced and some of the
present military offences are extended, the prime
purpose being to consolidate, streamline and
telescope within one single enactment the usual
military offences that are ordinarily found in
military law enactments.
Column: 1093
A major change brought about by the Bill is in
respect of summary trials. There is now introduced
a system of trial by disciplinary officers to
replace the system of trial by Company Commanders,
commanding officers and appropriate superior
authority under the Singapore Army Act, 1965,
where the only person who can be the appropriate
superior authority is a Brigadier. Under the new
system introduced in the Bill, there will be three
types of disciplinary officers, namely, junior
disciplinary officers, senior disciplinary
officers, and superior commanders, and it further
allows the appointment of any person commanding a
command, a formation or any other person as a
superior commander.
Under the Singapore Army Act. Company Commanders
can only deal with offences committed by Other
Ranks of the rank of corporal and below, whilst
Commanding Officers are allowed to deal only with
temporary warrant officers and those below that
rank. Officers with the rank of Second Lieutenant
to Captain and substantive warrant officers are
dealt with by the appropriate superior authority,
whilst officers above the rank of Captain cannot
be dealt with summarily but only by a court-martial. This Bill, on the other hand, allows
junior and senior disciplinary officers, that is,
Company and Battalion Commanders respectively, to
deal with Other Ranks of the rank of temporary
warrant officers and below; and superior
commanders, that is, Brigade Commanders, to deal
with substantive warrant officers and above up to
the rank of Major. Persons of the rank of
Lieutenant-Colonel and above who could not
previously be dealt with summarily can now be so
dealt with by the Armed Forces Council.
Further, the powers of punishment of disciplinary
officers have been increased, the main aim being
to dispose of more cases expeditiously at unit
level. Under the Bill, a junior disciplinary
officer can award up to 10 days' detention to
Column: 1094
privates and recruits, a form of punishment which
he could not award under the Singapore Army Act,
under which the most severe punishment which a
Company Commander could award to NCOs of the rank
of Corporal and below was a reprimand, and to
soldiers the minor punishment or restriction of
privileges up to a maximum of seven days. The most
severe punishment that a Commanding Officer could
award previously was 28 days' detention and that
too only to privates and recruits, and the most
severe punishment that he could award to a
substantive NCO was nothing more than a severe
reprimand. This Bill does away with all these
restrictions and allows senior disciplinary
officers to award detentions of 40 days even to
NCOs. The Bill also allows the superior commander
to award detention to warrant officers, which he
could not do under the Singapore Army Act, the
most severe punishment under which being just a
forfeiture of seniority of rank.
There are very good reasons for increasing the
power of punishment of disciplinary officers. From
what I have said above, hon. Members will see that
extremely light punishments were meted out to
NCOs, both regulars and national servicemen. This
tended to give the impression that they were
immune from serious punishments unless the case
went up for a court-martial. There were some cases
of indiscipline during the last few weeks before
the national servicemen NCOs were due for release.
These acts of indiscipline certainly warrant
disciplinary action of a higher level than a
reprimand at the unit level. Under this Bill,
senior disciplinary officers will be able to award
detention to NCOs, and superior commanders can
award detention to warrant officers, measures
which will certainly dispel any impression amongst
the less responsible that they can get away
lightly for their misdemeanours. Further,
punishment for an offence which did not warrant a
court-martial was inadequate. For instance, a
soldier who absents himself without leave for 35
days could, as the
Column: 1095
law now stands, only be detained for a maximum of
28 days by his Commanding Officer. Clearly, this
must be rectified and the Bill, therefore, now
allows Commanding Officers to give up to 40 days'
detention. A further reason is that the increase
in punishment will allow cases to be dealt with
more expeditiously. An example will illustrate
this. Let us take a national serviceman NCO who is
due to be released from national service in three
days' time. He commits an offence which deserves
something more than the punishment of a reprimand.
Under the present law, detention of NCOs can only
be awarded by a court-martial. The NCO in this
case will have to be held back from release until
a court-martial is held and he has served his
punishment. Under the Bill, however, since
detention can be given to NCOs by the Commanding
Officers, such cases can be quickly dealt with by
the Commanding Officer himself. Further, the
increase in punishment will also allow more cases
to be disposed of at unit level. It must not,
however, be assumed that the offender has no
safeguard. If in any case he feels that he is
being wrongly punished and the punishment that the
disciplinary officer is going to award is
something more than a reprimand, he can elect to
be tried by a subordinate military court.
To ensure that errors by disciplinary officers in
dealing with cases are corrected and that any
abuse of powers is checked, the Armed Forces
Council has been given the power of review to
enable it to quash the findings and sentences 0
disciplinary officers and to substitute new
findings and sentences. For the information of
hon. Members, I must point out that there is no
such system of review under the Singapore Army
Act. However, the power of review under section
115 of the British Army Act has been made use of.
It is of interest to note, however, that the Armed
Forces Council in reviewing a case can only award
a lesser form of punishment. It cannot enhance the
punishment already awarded. An enhanced
Column: 1096
punishment can only be awarded by a
Military Court of Appeal.
I shall now discuss the system of military
courts, including the Military Court of Appeal,
introduced by this Bill. Under the present set-up
there are three types of courts-martial, namely,
general courts-martial, district courts-martial
and field-general courts-martial. Officers can
only be tried by general courts-martial and field-general courts-martial while other personnel can
be tried by all three types of courts-martial.
Further, whilst general courts-martial and field-general courts-martial can award death or any
lesser punishment, the most severe punishment that
district courts-martial can award, however, is two
years' imprisonment. There is, as hon. Members
will appreciate, no reason to have three types of
courts-martial when two can serve the purpose just
as well. We can do away with district courts-martial and have, instead, one court, that is, the
general courts-martial to deal with all personnel
irrespective of rank. This Bill, therefore,
simplifies the military court system. The
subordinate military courts shall consist of two
types of courts-martial, namely, general courts-martial and the field-general courts-martial, both
of which can deal with all servicemen irrespective
of rank. However, a field-general courts-martial
will only be convened when a unit of the Singapore
Armed Forces to which the offender belongs is on
active service. Each of these courts shall consist
of not less than three officers.
The Bill establishes for the first time a
Military Court of Appeal. No such court exists now
and the only remedy that the aggrieved party has
in such circumstances is to petition to the
confirming authority against the findings and
sentence. The Military Court of Appeal established
by this Bill is, therefore, an important
innovation; it can hear and determine appeals
against decisions made by the subordinate military
courts. There is, however, no appeal from the
Military Court of Appeal whose powers are
analogous to those of the Court of Criminal
Appeal. The President of the Court shall either
Column: 1097
be a Judge of the High Court or a person qualified
to be such. There are four other members, two of
whom are to be legally qualified persons of at
least five years' standing. The other two members
will be officers of the Singapore Armed Forces of
or above the rank of Captain.
The punishment which subordinate military courts
can impose range from death to minor punishment.
For non-military offences, a subordinate military
court can impose the same punishment as a civil
court. A new punishment, however, deserves
mention. Subordinate military courts can, for
certain offences, require a reservist to serve for
a further period of service not exceeding 12
months. Provision is also made for the suspension
of sentences and for the grant of a pardon by the
President for an offender.
Another salient feature of the Bill is the
enlargement of the powers of search and
investigation. Hitherto, under the Singapore Army
Act, investigations have been done by officers
appointed by the Commanding Officer and military
policemen had powers to investigate only with the
permission of the Commanding Officer. This Bill,
however, removes the restrictions placed on the
powers of investigation and search. There will be
two categories of investigating officers:
investigating officers authorised by a senior
disciplinary officer or a superior commander to
investigate specific offences and Military
Policemen who may investigate all offences. This
is necessary in a rapidly expanding force, many of
whose units are commanded by young and
inexperienced officers. Other important aspects of
the Bill are the powers to set up Boards of
Inquiry where there is a matter relating to the
Singapore Armed Forces which would be desirable to
investigate into; the emergency powers in clauses
191 and 192 which can be brought into operation
only if the President so declares for securing the
public safety or the defence of the Republic;
reduction in rank for inefficiency
Column: 1098
of a member of the Singapore Armed Forces;
and, last but not least, channels by which
servicemen who are wronged in any matter may lodge
complaints to seek a redress.
The amendments to the Enlistment Act effected
through the Singapore Armed Forces Bill would
enable an employer to recover from Government any
amount that he has paid as makeup pay to a
reservist or a person who is mobilised, by
deductions from pay-roll tax, if the reservist is
self-employed, he can claim make-up pay from
monies to be provided by Parliament. However, if a
reservist is convicted of a specified offence
involving a breach of discipline and the court is
satisfied on the evidence that the reservist has
shown himself to be not responsive to discipline,
the court may punish him under clause 114 (14) of
the Bill by requiring him to serve a further
period of service not exceeding 12 months. The
reservist, if working under a contract of employ-merit, would be entitled to receive make-up pay
from his employer during the further period of
service, but the employer cannot deduct this from
payroll tax. An employer would not be obliged to
reinstate such a reservist in his civilian
employment. Indeed an employer can, if he so
wishes, dismiss such reservist from his employment
at any time prior to the completion of such
additional reserve service.
Hon. Members may look askance at these measures
now introduced by the Bill as they are undoubtedly
a departure from what may be considered to be
accepted norms. But good and potent reasons exist
to introduce these measures if our Army is not to
degenerate into a rabble of indiscipline soldiers.
There have been a number of incidents which do not
credit the Singapore Armed Forces and which, if
not curbed or deterred, can bring the Singapore
Armed Forces into disrepute. One of a number of
incidents that have taken place will convince hon.
Members of the absolute necessity to adopt the
strong measures proposed in the Bill. A number of
reservist service officers were called up to
attend a conversion
Column: 1099
course sometime in November last year. From the
very start, these officers continuously carried
out their training in an unwilling manner. Towards
the end of the exercise, however, the reservists
took it upon themselves to walk off from the
exercise, without the permission of the
instructors. They also hailed two lorries to
transport them back to the Singapore Armed Forces
Training Institute leaving their tools and
equipment behind in the training area. Because of
this, these officers had their training extended
for one week, and this had a salutary effect as
they showed that they were capable of carrying out
their tasks as required of them. This particular
incident is one which would call for the most
severe form of punishment possible. Clearly,
therefore, more stringent laws are necessary to
deal with such situations. However exalted a
soldier may consider his civilian occupation and
standing, he is not outside the scope of military
discipline once he is in uniform. The strong
measures introduced in the Bill will deal
appropriately with those predisposed to insolence,
indifference and indiscipline which must not and
cannot be tolerated. Discipline and order are
sacrosanct in any army, and an army devoid of
these qualities will not be able to serve the
nation well and truly.
Before I conclude, I must point out that through
this Bill an amendment is also made to the Finance
Act to provide for a new definition of "payroll".
Hon. Members will see from what I have said so
far that in concept and design the Bill is nothing
more than an attempt to make good glaring
deficiencies in the existing law and to encompass
within the framework of one enactment the subject
of military discipline in all its manifestations.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
Question proposed.
4.37 p.m.
Mr P. Selvadurai (Bukit Panjang): Mr Speaker,
Sir, everybody knows that the Singapore Army Act
and the People's Defence Force Act passed soon
after independence in 1965 were temporary
Column: 1100
measures designed to meet an emergency
situation. It was inevitable that a comprehensive
code relating to a legal organisation,
administration and discipline of the Armed Forces
would see the light of day sooner or later. We
should pay tribute to the Ministry of Defence for
having completed the work of reorganisation of the
Armed Forces and the drafting of its basic law
within the shortest time of the Ministry's
existence, particularly in the context of a
society which did not have sound or organised
martial traditions.
Sir, I am concerned with Part IV of the Bill.
While Part IV of the Bill lays clown an attractive
procedure for the summary trial of offences by
disciplinary officers, clause 65 of the Bill
typifies the basic human problem that we face in
Singapore, whether in civilian or military life
and the problem of trained human beings fighting
shy of making unpleasant decisions. It would be
interesting to see if the Armed Forces would set
new standards which would not fail to be humane
for their civilian counterparts to emulate.
Sir, the performance of the judicial function is
not an easy one. It calls for qualities of total
human breeding and responsibility which few humans
are blessed with at the best of times. We are now
calling for these very qualities from the men of
the Armed Forces, and we must hope that the
traditions that they do establish would help to
mould the Armed Forces into a civilised force
worthy of the fair name of Singapore. We have the
beginnings of military jurisprudence, and it is
essential that we build up expertise in this field
from among the ranks of the officers of the Armed
Forces within the shortest possible time.
4.40 p.m.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol): Mr. Speaker, Sir, I
rise to give my support to this Bill. I am glad to
note that one of the objects of this Bill is to
establish a unified force called the Singapore
Armed Forces consisting of military, maritime and
air commands. This Bill is definitely an
improvement of the
Column: 1101
Singapore Army Act, 1965, and the People's Defence
Force Act, which my colleague, the Member for
Bukit Panjang, has just pointed out that these
Acts were temporary measures designed to meet an
emergency situation. I Xho1e-heartedly agree with
what the Member has just mentioned. I also note
that this Bill will provide for the establishment,
administration, maintenance and discipline of the
Singapore Armed Forces. In other words, all the
three sectors of the Singapore Armed Forces, i.e.
the military, the maritime and air commands, will
now come directly under this Bill.
Sir, whilst I do not wish to go into the Bill in
detail, I would like to touch on some of the
points raised by the Minister of State of Defence
pertaining to discipline. I am quite surprised to
note that the various breaches of discipline
committed by the rank and file could only be dealt
with by certain categories of officers at certain
levels under the two previous Acts. But now, with
the establishment of the Singapore Armed Forces
Council, it is noted that radical changes have
been made and introduced in this Bill which will
empower officers like company commanders,
battalion commanders, brigade commanders to deal
with acts of indiscipline committed by the rank
and file of the Singapore Armed Forces. I cannot
disagree with the Minister of State of Defence
when he enumerated the various types of offences
for which nothing much could be done in the case
of senior officers, and that for certain offences
there is the need for a Brigadier to mete out
punishment. But since the Singapore Armed Forces
do not have the rank of Brigadier at the moment
except Colonels and below, I think this Singapore
Armed Forces Bill would streamline the entire
Force and will empower the various commanders at
various unit levels to look into and mete out
punishment that is proper to the severity of a
breach of discipline.
Just now the Minister of State mentioned an
instance when some of our N.C.O. national
servicemen simply
Column: 1102
walked out during an exercise without any
permission. Sir, this is one of the many examples
which the Minister of State has brought to light
in this House. I am even more surprised to learn
why these culprits who have breached military
discipline could not be more severely dealt with.
I hope that with the establishment of this Council
much improvement can be seen in the running of the
Singapore Armed Forces.
4.46 p.m.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu): Sir, I am pleased
to see that clause 196 provides for the mode of
complaint by servicemen. It seems to me that the
average national serviceman is not aware that this
is one area where he can sound out his grievances.
More often than not he feels that he has been
wronged but does not know how to go about it to
complain to his superior officers. This clause
sets down the procedure how to go about it. I hope
that, in the implementation of this Bill, the
particular provision under clause 196 is brought
to the attention of all national service recruits,
and that preferably each recruit is given some
guidance and explanation in the particular
language in which he is conversant with.
Mr Wee Toon Boon: Sir, with regard to the
observations made by the Member for Jalan Kayu,
procedures have, in fact, been laid down for any
national serviceman to raise any grievances
through the proper channels. All national
servicemen have been acquainted with these
procedures, and I believe that many of them are
fully aware of them. However, special classes have
been conducted for this purpose and, of course, if
need be, arrangements can be made to publicise
these procedures. However, the Member's suggestion
will be looked into, and proper measures will be
taken to implement them.
With regard to the comments made by the Members
for Bukit Panjang and Punggol who have expressed
their support of the Bill, may I say that it is
Column: 1103
due to the deficiencies in the present law that it
has become necessary to introduce this Bill in
order that adequate punishment can be meted out to
those who are disinclined to discipline.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and
committee to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Wee Toon Boon].
Bill considered in Committee: reported without
amendment: read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1103
NGEE ANN KONGSI (INCORPORATION)
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
4.55 p.m.
The Minister of State for Education (Dr Lee Chiaw Meng): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That
the Bill be now read a Second time."
The Ngee Ann Kongsi was incorporated by the Ngee
Ann Kongsi (Incorporation) Ordinance of 1933 to
administer its incomes and properties for various
worthy public purposes, including the support of
education.
The Kongsi established the Ngee Ann College (now
Ngee Ann Technical College) in 1963 and initially
housed it in the Kongsi's premises at the Teochew
Building in Tank Road. In i 967 a new campus for
the College was built from public donations on the
Kongsi's land in Clementi Road.
In 1968, with massive financial support from the
Government, the College was reorganised into a
technical college offering diploma courses in
engineering and commerce. This reorganisational
change was incorporated in the Ngee Ann Technical
College Act. Section 17 of that Act provides that
the income and property of the College shall
include such contributions as the Kongsi shall
make.
The land in Clementi Road on which the campus now
stands and the building thereon were given to the
College
Column: 1104
by the Kongsi through a conveyance on 26th March,
1971, in accordance with section 20 of the Ngee
Ann Kongsi (Incorporation) Ordinance.
The Kongsi currently donates 50 per cent of its
net income or $100,000, whichever is the more, to
the College for its running expenses. This
contribution is made in accordance with a
resolution passed by the Committee of Management
of the Kongsi at a meeting held on 5th May, 1967.
To cover the remaining major part of its annual
increasing budget, the College has also been
receiving grants from the Government since the
Act came into force.
Since the reorganisation in 1968, the Kongsi has
contributed $400,000 to the College, as against
financial assistance from the Government totalling
over $2.5 million. With the proposed development
plan, the administrative expenditure of the
College is expected to rise very substantially
from its present level of $2 million per annum.
The Committee of Management of Ngee Ann Kongsi at
a recent meeting adopted another resolution that
the quantum of its contribution to the Ngee Ann
Technical College be increased from 50 per cent to
75 per cent of its income. The Committee of
Management also decided that these resolutions,
that is, to donate 75 per cent of its income to
the College, should be embodied in its Ordinance.
In this respect, Sir, the term "income" assumes
the normal commercial interpretation which is the
total receipts less the normal direct operational
costs.
This move follows from the fact that the Kongsi
proposes to develop its land along Orchard Road
which, when materialised, holds promise of very
substantial future income.
The property along Orchard Road was originally a
burial ground, but was allowed to be converted for
residential and commercial uses by the former
Government.
I would like to congratulate the Ngee Ann Kongsi
for this decision which is in full accord with the
spirit of the Prime Minister's remarks made
recently over
Column: 1105
the use of burial grounds in general, to the
effect that it is not proper that private and
sectional groups should benefit from the gains in
value or productivity of land resulting from the
public developments taking place around it, but
rather that the society, as a whole, should
benefit.
I would, therefore, like to compliment tile Ngee
Ann Kongsi for this bold and progressive approach
to educational support by the direct application
of property and business income. The decision of
the Kongsi to commit 75 per cent of its income for
the Ngee Ann Technical College represents the most
concrete and enduring way in which any association
can apply its revenues for the support of
education. I would like to take this opportunity
to urge other similar organisations and groups to
emulate this example and to take the positive step
of pledging permanent endowment to other
educational institutions in Singapore, such as the
Nanyang University.
The Bill now before the House seeks to embody in
the Ngee Ann Kongsi (Incorporation) Ordinance, the
resolutions passed by the Committee of Management
of the Ngee Ann Kongsi with respect to its
financial contribution to the Ngee Ann Technical
College established by the Kongsi itself in 1963.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and
committed to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Dr Lee Chiaw Meng].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1105
NGEE ANN TECHNICAL COLLEGE
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.02 p.m.
The Minister of State for Education (Dr Lee Chiaw Meng): Mr Speaker, Sir, 1 beg to move, "That
the Bill be now read a Second time."
Column: 1106
At present section 17 of the Ngee Ann Technical
College Act provides that the income and property
of the College shall include, inter alia, such
immovable property as the Ngee Ann Kongsi may,
subject to the provisions of section 20 of the
Ngee Ann Kongsi (Incorporation) Ordinance,
alienate or donate to the College.
However, under section 20 of the said Ordinance,
before the Ngee Ann Kongsi can alienate any of its
immovable property, it must first go to a General
Meeting to pass a resolution to seek leave from
the High Court and subsequently apply for such
leave. Under these requirements, the alienation of
land and other immovable property by the Kongsi to
the College becomes, each time a long and
cumbersome process. Indeed, in the past, there
have been occasions when the development of the
College has been hampered by the need to comply
with these time-consuming requirements. Further,
while in 1933 when the Ngee Ann Kongsi
(Incorporation) Ordinance was enacted, there was
perhaps justification for these elaborate
safeguarding provisions, this is no longer the
case in respect of the Ngee Ann Technical College.
The Ngee Ann Technical College Act now already
provides for the Kongsi to make contributions to
the College's income and property, and an
amendment to the Ngee Ann Kongsi (Incorporation)
Ordinance itself makes it statutory that 75 per
cent of the Kongsi's income be set aside for the
College.
The Kongsi has already donated 40 acres of its
property at Clementi Road to the College, but it
is envisaged that if the $11 million development
of the College is to proceed as planned, it will
involve re-alignment of boundaries and possibly
will require a greater land area than the 40 acres
already endowed to the College.
Sir, development of this educational institution
should not be hampered by the provisions of
section 20 of the Ngee Ann Kongsi (Incorporation)
Ordinance, especially since the College was
founded by the Kongsi itself. The proposed
amendment to section 17 of the Ngee
Column: 1107
Ann Technical College Act seeks to remove the need
for compliance with the conditions under section
20 of the Ngee Ann Kongsi (Incorporation)
Ordinance in so far as the alienation or donation
of immovable property by the Kongsi to the Ngee
Ann Technical College is concerned.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Dr Lee Chiaw Meng).
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Mr Speaker: I propose to suspend the sitting now
and take the Chair again at 5.35 p.m.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
5.05 p.m, until 5.35 p.m.
Column: 1107
Sitting resumed at 5.35 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
LEGAL PROFESSION (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Second time".
Sir, the Bill that is now before the House seeks
to amend the Legal Profession Act in respect of
two matters: firstly, in regard to the necessity
of legal officers obtaining practising
certificates to practise as solicitors, and
secondly, in regard to the nationality of those in
charge of the conduct and discipline of practising
members of the Bar.
In respect of the first amendment contained in
clause 2 of the Bill, the general provisions of
the Act on this matter require, in the first
instance, the obtaining of a practising
certificate, before a qualified advocate and
solicitor, who has been admitted to practise by
the Court, is in fact able to carry on practice as
an advocate and solicitor. There are,
Column: 1108
at the present moment, certain exemptions to the
general requirement. These are contained in
subsection (2) of section 30; for example,
solicitors employed by certain Statutory Boards,
like the Housing and Development Board, the Public
Utilities Board, the Economic Development Board,
the Jurong Town Corporation and the Port of
Singapore Authority, may now practise in certain
matters as may be specified in a certificate
issued by the Attorney-General. Upon the
certification of the Attorney-General, the
Registrar of the Supreme Court will issue to such
a solicitor a certificate in lieu of a practising
certificate. The solicitor concerned would then be
able to practise in such branches of the law and
only in his capacity as an employee of the various
Statutory Boards in which he is employed.
Unfortunately, this exemption clause has been
found to be defective in the sense that it would
not apply to a member of the Legal Service, who
may not even defend any member of the Legal
Service, or Civil Service, who is or may be sued
in his private capacity for acts done in the
course of his official duties. It is in order to
remove this restriction that the present amendment
has been devised. Legal officers who, in the
course of their duties, meet with difficulties by
way of having suits brought against them, will be
able to, where they so desire, have the services
of a State Counsel. I must add, however, that this
amendment will not preclude private practitioners
from acting on behalf of those officers, nor will
it restrict the choice of solicitors by those who
may be faced with legal action in such
circumstances.
The second amendment, that is, in clause 3 of
the Amendment Bill, will have the result of
confining the eligibility of membership in the
Council of the Bar, which is the body responsible
for the maintenance of standards of etiquette and
of conduct of members of the legal profession,
solely to those who are of Singapore nationality.
It has been felt that so important a body, as the
legal profession, should be managed, in such
important matters as disciplinary control, by
those of that
Column: 1109
profession who are our own citizens so that they
may reflect, it is hoped, the needs, aspirations
and standards of behaviour of not only the
profession but also of the society in which they
live and practise. It is felt that nationals with
their roots in the country would be more in a
position to set standards which would be
acceptable to all in the country.
I understand, however, that in so far as the
present members of the Council are concerned, they
are all Singapore citizens so that in effect the
Bill will only affect the future membership of the
Council.
The last amendment in clause 4 has been asked for
by the Council itself in reducing the number of
members necessary to form a quorum from seven to
five. The Council of the Law Society feels that it
would be quite impracticable to insist on seven
out of ten members in the Council to be present in
order to form a quorum. Recent amendments have had
the effect of reducing the overall size of the
Council, and it is for this reason that a
reduction in the number necessary for a quorum has
been requested.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and
committed to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr E. W. Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1109
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.42 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Second time".
The purpose of this Bill is to reform the
existing procedure of committing criminal cases
for trial in line with the
Column: 1110
United Kingdom Criminal Justice Act, 1967. The
Bill in its draft stage was referred to the
Council of the Law Society of Singapore which
submitted its recommendations thereon. The Council
accepted the principle of admitting written
statements at preliminary inquiries, observing
that this would (and I quote) "undoubtedly lighten
the burden of Magistrates' Courts in committal
proceedings without in any way prejudicing the
interests either of the prosecution or of the
defence". The Council also suggested a number of
modifications to the Bill which were carefully
considered and which have, in the main, been
accepted.
While Members would have read a detailed account
of the contents of the Bill in the Explanatory
Statement, it would be helpful, I think, if I were
to touch on the principal aspects of the new
procedure that this legislation will introduce
into our subordinate courts. 1 should first
explain that preliminary inquiries in Singapore,
as in England, were originally considered to be an
extra safeguard for the accused. This procedure is
interposed between the arrest of a suspect and his
eventual trial before the High Court and has, as
its main object, the examination of the evidence
of the prosecution and its sufficiency in making
out a prima facie case against the accused for
trial before the High Court. Of necessity,
therefore, it was confined solely to such cases as
were cognisable only in the High Court. The
current practice in Singapore has, however, made
it extremely doubtful as to the usefulness of this
aspect or stage of criminal proceedings. The
primary purpose of these proceedings, namely, to
allow lawyers to examine the adequacy of the case
alleged against an accused by cross-examining
witnesses for the prosecution, does not appear to
have been utilised to the full. In many cases
there is not even a submission made to the
examining Magistrate at the close of the
proceedings, the case for the defence being
reserved until such time as the trial begins in
the High Court. Indeed, this practice has resulted
in committal proceedings or preliminary
Column: 1111
inquiries sometimes working against the interests
of an accused person. Newspapers that report these
proceedings often dwell only on the case for the
prosecution, while nothing is recorded of the case
for the defence. This could result in an accused
being prejudiced at his trial.
The Bill provides for the existing procedure with
regard to preliminary inquiries to be abandoned in
favour of committals to the High Court without the
necessity of examining witnesses for the
prosecution on oath at a court hearing before an
examining Magistrate. This will no longer be
required of the examining Magistrate for, under the
proposed procedure, he may commit an accused person
to the High Court for trial if he is satisfied that
all the evidence for the prosecution or the defence
consists of written statements which disclose
sufficient evidence to put the accused upon his
trial. While, however, the Bill is an adaptation of
the United Kingdom Criminal Justice Act, 1967, much
of the English procedure being incorporated in the
Bill, it is not exactly on all fours with the
current English practice in that whereas in England
"paper committals", as they are known, are
optional, here they are to be compulsory. This is
because much of the purpose behind the Bill would
be lost if the English procedure were adhered to
rigidly since it is more than likely that in almost
all cases here counsel for the defence will elect
to proceed under the old system of examining
witnesses for the prosecution one by one, orally
upon oath before the committing Magistrate, which
would defeat the very object of the new
legislation. Another significant difference is that
under the English procedure, the Magistrate has the
power to commit an accused for trial without
considering the written statements of witnesses,
while under our proposed procedure the Magistrate
is bound to consider the contents of the written
statements of witnesses to decide whether there is
sufficient evidence to commit an accused for trial.
This may be regarded as an important safeguard
Column: 1112
particularly where an accused is not represented by
counsel at the preliminary inquiry.
Furthermore, the new system proposed in the Bill
has the merit of saving the time of the court and
of the parties as well as of avoiding inconvenience
and expense to witnesses. On the other hand, as in
England, a considerably enhanced workload will have
to be borne by the Attorney-General's Chambers,
since as a result of the amending Act statements
will need to be examined carefully to ascertain
whether they sufficiently disclose evidence
admissible in court to prove the guilt of the
accused. The clarification of doubtful points which
must be effected before the hearing will also take
up time. I take the view, which is shared by the
Attorney-General, that the additional work which
the new legislation will involve for his Chambers
would be well worthwhile since it would be in the
interests of the more efficient administration of
justice and of the hundreds of witnesses who have
to give evidence in our subordinate courts each
year.
I must hasten to assure Members that the new
procedure, as embodied in the Bill, accomplishes
the same purpose as the existing procedure which is
sought to be replaced. The principal difference is
that in the existing procedure an oral statement of
a witness is taken down by the court in the form of
a deposition, that is, a statement on oath or
affirmation, arid witnesses are liable to be cross-examined on that statement, while under the new
procedure a copy of the written statement made by a
witness and signed by him and certified by him that
it is true to the best of his knowledge and belief
will be given to the defence or the prosecution, as
the case may be, before it is tendered in evidence.
After all the written statements and all other
evidence in support of the prosecution have been
received in evidence, the examining Magistrate will
then generally follow the existing procedure of
either committing
Column: 1113
the accused for trial, discharging him or
dealing with the case summarily.
The Bill also contains two provisions modelled on
the English Act. The first relates to restrictions
on the publication of reports of preliminary
inquiries in newspapers, radio and television with
a view to safeguarding the interests of the
accused. Certain particulars such as the name,
address and occupation of the accused, the offence
and decision of the court are permitted to be
contained in reports. The second provision is to
the effect that the accused shall not, without the
court's permission, adduce evidence in support of
an alibi unless he gives notice of particulars of
the alibi. This is to ensure that no last-minute
defence of alibi is sprung upon the prosecution.
Two fresh technical provisions relating to
evidence contained in the Bill are set out in
clause 4 and are explained at the end of the
Explanatory Statement.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like to conclude by
making two points. First, the new procedure as
contained in the Bill achieves the same object as
the present parallel provisions of the Criminal
Procedure Code in that the accused will be made
aware of the case that he has to meet; and,
secondly, there have been no serious criticisms in
the United Kingdom as to the operation of the
Criminal Justice Act, 1967, on which our Bill is
largely based. Indeed, the general consensus is
one of approval.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and
committed to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. -[Mr Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1114
CONTROLLED PREMISES (SPECIAL PROVISIONS)
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.57 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Second time."
The amendments proposed in this Bill are
concerned principally with the compensatory
provisions of the Controlled Premises (Special
Provisions) Act. Section 7 (3) of the Act provides
that the total amount of compensation to be
awarded in a case where a tenant has sublet his
premises must not exceed the amount of
compensation that could be awarded in a case where
a tenant has not so sublet his premises. In the
working of this legislation since the Act came
into force, the Tenants Compensation Board has
found that this section is unduly restrictive in
enabling the Board to award fair and reasonable
compensation to tenants. The original philosophy
behind this provision was that landlords should
not be penalised by having to pay out more
compensation where tenants had sublet parts of the
controlled premises; for, after all, landlords had
over the years derived no financial benefit
themselves from the subletting. But the experience
of the Board has shown that this approach has
failed adequately to take into account the reality
of existing economic and social conditions in
Singapore.
In order, therefore, for the Tenants
Compensation Board to strike a fairer balance as
between landlords and tenants in the award of
compensation, it is proposed that section 7 (3)
should be deleted from the Act. While the effect
of the deletion will be that landlords may be
liable under the law to pay out more compensation
than might otherwise be the case, it will ensure
that dispossessed tenants will receive sufficient
compensation to enable them to set up new homes or
businesses elsewhere.
Column: 1115
The Tenants Compensation Board has also proposed
an amendment to give the Board power to award
compensation to any person (other than a tenant or
subtenant) using or occupying any part of the
controlled premises. Such occupiers have no
protection or standing under the Control of Rent
Act, upon which the Controlled Premises (Special
Provisions) Act hinges. The adoption of this
proposal, therefore, entails widening the scope of
the parent Act in a way that was not envisaged
when the Act was drafted. Although the concept
does not lend itself to ready acceptability within
the narrow confines of property law, the Board is
convinced that social and economic considerations
justify the adoption of this novel concept. The
proposal has principally in contemplation
occupiers who are stall-holders selling goods or
refreshments to the public under an arrangement
with the chief tenant. So long as it is enacted
that any compensation that is payable to these
occupiers comes out of the amount that is payable
to the person who has derived benefit from the
occupation, that is to say the chief tenant in
most cases, the amendment can be justified on the
wider social and economic grounds and will not,
within these limits, do too much violence to the
settled principles of property law. The amendment
giving effect to this proposal would appear as a
new section 9A in the Act.
The other amendments in the Bill are of a
consequential or formal nature and do not call for
special comment.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
6.00 p.m.
The Minister for Labour (Mr Ong Pang Boon): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I rise to support the Amendment Bill
moved by my colleague, the Minister for Law and
National Development.
Sir, we all agree that a large part of the
Central City areas is in need of renewal, as many
of the properties were built in the last century
and are now in a dilapidated condition. Some are
even unsafe for occupation, quite apart
Column: 1116
from health considerations. Thus, when the
Controlled Premises (Special Provisions) Act was
introduced in 1969 to remove the protection
accorded to tenants of controlled premises under
the Control of Rent Ordinance so as to enable
redevelopment to take place, there was general
support from the public. In fact, all agreed that
redevelopment of the Central City areas would not
only bring greater economic opportunities and
employment to the people of Singapore in general,
but would also change Singapore into a modern City
befitting its status as a regional and
international centre of communication, trade and
commerce.
However, in the process, there is bound to be
some dislocation and suffering to some of the
affected tenants and subtenants, especially those
who depend on the Telok Ayer Basin and the
waterfront for their livelihood. It is only fair
and just that they should be compensated to make
their removal and resettlement in a new and more
distant environment more bearable. It would be
grossly unjust if prosperity in one sector of our
society should be built on the misery of another
sector, albeit a smaller one. Indeed, this was
taken into consideration in the Act, wherein
provisions were made for the establishment of a
Tenants Compensation Board to ensure that fair and
reasonable compensation shall be paid by the
landlord or developer to tenants or subtenants
affected by urban renewal in the designated area.
The landlord is offered generous concession for
undertaking urban renewal project in the form of
lower property tax - 12 per cent as against 36 per
cent. A landlord who can commit millions of
dollars in a redevelopment project can in all
cases offer a fair amount of compensation to
affected tenants and subtenants, otherwise he
should not be in the business in the first
instance.
However, in the short period since the Act was
in force, it has been found that landlords were
far from willing to offer fair and reasonable
compensation to tenants and subtenants. They often
exploited the ignorance of the illiterate
residential tenants and subtenants. In
Column: 1117
one case I was informed, as I was then in America,
that a landlord even resorted to the tactics of
demolishing parts of a building in order to force
tenants in another part to accept unreasonable
terms of compensation and move out for their own
safety. In another instance, despite the strong
recommendation made by the Tenants Compensation
Board for enhanced ex gratia payments, the
landlord, a leading local bank, was unsympathetic
to the claims of a number of occupiers in
controlled premises. The landlord was prepared to
pay only a derisory sum of ex gratia to them. It
was only through the intervention of elected
representatives that the bank eventually agreed to
increase ex gratia payments to the occupiers. In
fact, it was as a result of this case that the
present amendments to section 9 were introduced.
Indeed, if landlords or developers, particularly
those with millions of dollars of assets, were to
take the lead and show a little sympathy for the
plight of the poor, the present amendments would
not have been necessary.
It is to the credit of the Tenants Compensation
Board that, in the course of its deliberations, it
has adopted a liberal attitude and has been
responsive to the changing circumstances in our
economy and the Government's more liberal policy of
compensation in respect of its own resettlement
cases. As the House is aware, since the coming into
force of the Controlled Premises (Special
Provisions) Act in 1969, the rent of private
residential properties has gone up several-folds
and well beyond the reach of tenants and subtenants
in controlled premises in the Golden Shoe area. As
a result, the demand for public housing has shot up
to an all time high so much so that, despite the
record annual output of 16,000 units per annum by
the Housing and Development Board, the demand
cannot be met promptly. Today, an applicant has to
wait an average of about three years before he can
obtain a fiat, either on rent or
Column: 1118
purchase. This is a factor which the Tenants
Compensation Board will have to take into
consideration in deciding the quantum of
compensation as the Housing and Development Board
has become the only source of supply of cheap
housing within the reach of the poor living in the
Golden Shoe area. My personal view is that a
reasonable minimum amount of compensation for a
residential tenant or subtenant as of today, shall
be in the region of $5,000 or 18 years' rent,
whichever is the greater amount, not taking into
consideration other relevant factors such as
removal costs, location and siting of controlled
premises, hardship, etc. 1 have no doubt that the
Tenants Compensation Board appreciates the position
and will know how to exercise discretion in this
matter.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I support the Amendment Bill.
Mr Barker: Mr Speaker, Sir, I thank my colleague,
the Minister for Labour, for his support. At the
Second Reading of the Controlled Premises (Special
Provisions) Bill, I did inform Members that the
formula set out in the Ordinance, for compensation
of at least six to eight years' rent was not a
magic formula,, and that we were experimenting with
this formula in an Act which has been extended only
to the Golden Shoe area in Telok Ayer. It was as a
result of the experience of the Board that these
amendments as contained in the Bill have been put
before the House today, and I hope that, as a
result, fairer compensation will be paid out to
occupants of houses in the Golden Shoe area. It may
well be that subsequent experience may even lead to
further amendments.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1119
PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.12 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That the Bill be now read a Second time."
This purely formal Bill seeks to substitute in
subsection (2) of section 10 of the Parliamentary
Elections Act (Chapter 50) the year "1971" for the
year "1967" so as to bring it in line with the
amendment made last year by the Parliamentary
Elections (Amendment) Act, 1971, and also to
delete the reference to the first registers of
electors in the said subsection, as that reference
is no longer applicable.
Clause 3 of the Bill effects a minor amendment
to Form 1, which is the Writ of Election. This
amendment would enable the Writ, which is at
present required to be signed by the President at
the top of the Form, to be signed by him at the
same time at the end thereof as well. This would
avoid the existing requirement for a separate
reference to the Secretary to the Cabinet under
section 34 of the Interpretation Act, which
provides that the exercise of a power by the
President may be signified under the hand of the
Secretary to the Cabinet. In short, the amendment
proposed at clause 3 would obviate the need for an
unnecessary procedural step.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and
committed to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1120
VOLUNTARY STERILIZATION (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.16 p.m.
The Minister for Health (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
In 1969, when I moved the Second Reading of the
Voluntary Sterilization Bill in this House, I say,
inter alia, that the Bill together with the
Abortion Bill and the Singapore Family Planning
and Population Act of 1965 would be a "charter to
liberate women from unwanted pregnancies". I have
also stated that during the operations of the Act
a critical assessment would be made of its
effectiveness.
Both the Abortion Act and the Voluntary
Sterilization Act have been in operation in the
last two years. Experience gained has shown that
the Abortion Act has been operating smoothly and
fulfilling its purpose. Since its coming into
operation till the end of December 1971, about
5,300 abortions have been carried out. The vast
majority of the abortions were done on women with
unwanted pregnancies who have a large number of
children and belong to the low income group. The
Abortion Act can be said to have more than
fulfilled the objectives for which the Act had
been passed. The same, however, cannot be said of
the Voluntary Sterilization Act. During the same
period, only 1,639 sterilizations were carried
out. This is a pity since sterilization is the
best method of family planning for those who
completed the number of children they want.
From the figures I gave a moment ago, it can be
said that the number of abortions performed was
more than three times the number of sterilizations
over the same period. This is because the demand
for sterilization has been hampered by a number of
restrictions in the Voluntary Sterilization Act.
Some of these restrictions are connected with the
procedure in applying for
Column: 1121
sterilizations; others with the conditions that
have to be satisfied before sterilization can be
approved under the Act. It is, therefore,
considered desirable to amend the Act suitably so
that it will serve its purpose well, namely, to
make sterilization, as a method of family
planning, easily available to as many men and
women who come within its ambit. Hence, the
present Bill before the House.
Under the Voluntary Sterilization Act, every
applicant has to appear before the Eugenics Board
for an interview. This is a mandatory provision of
the law as it stands, and the Board has no
discretion in the matter. The purpose of the
interview is to explain to the applicant the
meaning and consequences of sterilization. The
reason underlying this provision is that every
applicant should be clearly aware of the steps
being taken so that he or she will not enter into
it unknowingly, or under false ideas nor
frivolously - to be regretted when it is too late
at a later date.
Sometimes good intentions have a way of
achieving unexpected results. But one of them
might have been foreseen. This is that many of the
applicants find it an embarrassment to present
themselves before the Board for the interview.
Many have refused to attend the interviews after
they had made their applications. How many more
have not made applications for sterilization
because of this requirement will never be known.
Because of this one reason, this important method
of contraception for family planning is not as
popular as it should be.
There are other reasons too, which make the
rigid requirement for the interview undesirable,
one of which is that hardship is caused to those
applicants in the lower income group (the large
majority of applicants are in this group) who live
away from the City, particularly in the rural
areas, in that they have to take time off from
work, perhaps losing a day's wages and spend money
on transport to attend the Board's interview at
the Kandang
Column: 1122
Kerbau Hospital. As a result of this compulsory
interview, the Board has, to meet regularly to
deal with all applicants. In view of the large
number of applicants received - about 150 a month
- the Board at present meets weekly. It is,
therefore, considered desirable that the question
whether an applicant is to be interviewed by the
Board or otherwise be left to the Board's
discretion and provision to this effect has
accordingly been made in the Amendment Bill. In
other words, the Board will decide on the basis of
the information contained in the application
whether a person should be called for interview or
not.
Every applicant whose application for
sterilization has been approved and who is not
required by the Board to appear for an interview
will be notified by post. As a safeguard and to
enable the applicant to have a full medical
explanation, he or she will be provided with a
leaflet, in the appropriate language, explaining
the meaning and consequences of sterilization so
that he or she will be fully aware of the step
intended to be taken. This leaflet has, been
prepared in four languages and has been in use
since December 1970. In this connection, I would
like to mention that the staff of the various
hospitals and maternity and child health clinics,
where most applicants go t& get application forms,
will continue to give an explanation of the
meaning and, consequences of sterilization to the
applicants as they have been doing hitherto.
Under the Act, at least 30 days are required to
elapse between the date of the application and the
date sterilization is to be carried out. This is
intended as a safeguard in case the applicant
changes his mind, when it would have acted against
the basic purpose of the law. The need for such a
long waiting period has been criticised. Many are.
unable to understand the need for the delay.
Indeed, many applicants have indicated a desire to
be sterilized immediately after the Board's
interview. It is known that some women became
pregnant during the waiting period. An
Column: 1123
amendment to shorten the waiting period from 30
days to 7 days has, therefore, been made. The
safeguard is retained, only the period between
the approval and when the sterilization operation
can be carried out has been shortened. There can
be no undue haste in taking this important
decision, yet it should not be unduly long.
At present one of the conditions that every
applicant must satisfy before the Board will
authorise treatment for sterilization is that he
or she must have at least three children. In
other words, the present position is that parents
who have decided that their family is complete
with two children cannot benefit from
sterilization and would have to adhere to other
contraceptive methods for the rest of their
lives. It is an undesirable hardship on the
marriage partners. It is inconvenient and can be
expensive, and further, other contraceptive
methods are not 100 per cent effective and there
is the ever-present fear of an unwanted
pregnancy. After looking into this matter very
carefully, it is considered that there is
justification in liberalising the law in this
regard. Accordingly, the present requirement of
three children has been reduced to two and the
Bill gives effect to this.
Further, it is also provided that where there
are exceptional circumstances, the Board may
approve sterilization in the case of an applicant
with one living child. The "exceptional
circumstances" may be on medical, therapeutic or
environmental grounds. The last mentioned ground
includes the financial and social circumstances
of the applicant. Any application under this head
will naturally be scrutinized by the Board with
the utmost care, and approval would be given only
if the Board is satisfied, having regard to all
the circumstances, that there is real
justification. Each case will depend on its own
merits.
The present law allows the Board to approve
sterilization in the case of a person under 21
years of age if he is suffering from hereditary
illness that is recurrent, mental illness or
epilepsy, and if his parent or guardian consents
to it.
Column: 1124
This precludes unmarried persons over 21 years of
age and married persons of any age from applying
for sterilization if they are suffering from
these illnesses. The Bill seeks to remedy this.
deficiency.
At present, the Eugenics Board has no powers to
appoint committees for any general or specific
purpose or to authorise them to do any specific
act or carry out any specific function. Such
powers have been provided for the Termination of
Pregnancy Authorization Board under the Abortion
Act. It is considered that there is a need for
similar powers for the Eugenics Board. Clause 2
of the Bill gives effect to this.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I have dealt with the main
amendments proposed in the Bill and have
explained why they are necessary. I would,
however, like to assure the House that the
existing safeguards enshrined in the principal
Act remain, and these are -
(a) that the authority of the Eugenics Board
will continue to be required to authorise
sterilization;
(b) that sterilization will not be carried out
against a person's, will, in each case, the
consent of the person concerned being
necessary;
(c) that sterilization will be carried out only
in Government hospitals or in approved
institutions;
(d) that sterilization will be effected only
after a period of seven days has elapsed
following the Board's approval of the
application, giving sufficient time for a
change of mind;
(e) that no medical personnel will be obliged to
carry out sterilization if it is against
his, conscience.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and
committed to a Committee of the whole House.
Column: 1125
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Chua Sian Chin].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1125
SENTOSA DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.31 p.m.
The Minister of State for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
The Annual Budget Statement mentioned our
intention to further develop the tourist industry
to increase the flow of foreign exchange earnings
and to strengthen the balance of payments
position. It was indicated that though there are
encouraging signs of success in our efforts in
promoting tourism, we still need an intensive
programme to .attract more tourists to Singapore.
The programme would include the laying of a
tourist infra-structure by the provision of
additional amenities and facilities and the
development of projects which would help to
encourage a greater flow of tourists and to
increase the length of their stay in Singapore.
The Government decided as early as 1969 to
develop Sentosa as a tourist resort. An
internationally known firm was asked subsequently
to study the feasibility of so developing Sentosa.
This study, which was completed in September 1970,
confirmed that the proposal was a viable one and
that it would play an important role in
substantially increasing the rate of growth of
tourists coming to Singapore. The study envisaged
that the development of Sentosa into a tourist
resort would require Government investment to the
extent of $68 million spread over a period of nine
years until the whole project is completed. The
private sector too is expected to play an
important role by investing about $56 million.
These sums will have to be spent on the
development of infra-structure and the creation of
facilities for tourist
Column: 1126
attraction. The proposals include a vacation
complex comparable to the best in the world,
centralised shopping facilities, recreational
amenities such as a golf course, an open-air
theatre, a gun museum, a maritime museum, a marine
complex consisting of a corallarium, a pirates
cove, and an aquarium, together with first-class
hotels and restaurants. In the creation of these
facilities, the greatest care will be taken to
ensure that there will be no conflict between
tourist facilities on Sentosa and tourist
facilities on the mainland. I should mention
perhaps that, in fact, a few of the essential
projects such as the golf course, the cable car
and beach facilities are already in various stages
of implementation. It is anticipated that by March
1973, there should be adequate attractions on
Sentosa to make a visit to the island worthwhile.
It will be appreciated from the above remarks
that the development of Sentosa is a major
undertaking. This requires the establishment of a
permanent organisation which will be responsible
not only for the implementation of the numerous
projects but also for the efficient administration
of the island after the expected completion of all
projects by 1979. It is, therefore, proposed in
the Bill now before the House that there should be
established a Sentosa Development Corporation with
responsibilities for the control and
administration of Sentosa, and for the development
of services and amenities for tourists and the
public. This will reduce the burden shouldered
hitherto by various Government Departments such
as the Jurong Town Corporation and the Urban
Renewal Department which, despite their stretched
resources, have hitherto been responsible for the
implementation of the initial projects on Sentosa.
The Sentosa Development Corporation will be
placed under the guidance of the Economic
Development Division of the Ministry of Finance,
under whose purview is the development of our
tourist industry. The Corporation will be run by a
Chairman, a Deputy Chairman and such number of
other
Column: 1127
members as the Minister may from time to time
determine, provided that there will not be less
than eight or more than 15 members. For the day-to-day administration of the Corporation, a General
Manager will be appointed.
Apart from the development and administration of
Sentosa, provision has also been made to enable
the Corporation to develop other areas in
Singapore as touristy centres to complement the
work performed by the Tourist Promotion Board
which, due to lack of physical resources, may not
be able to undertake such development.
With regard to financing, the Corporation may,
with Ministerial approval, borrow funds for its
operation. Further, provision has also been made
for loans and grants to be made to the Corporation
from the Government for capital and recurrent
expenditure. As for its surplus funds, the
Corporation is empowered to invest these in
trustee securities. The Corporation's accounts
will be audited by auditors appointed with
Ministerial approval. An annual report of the
Corporation, together with its annual audited
accounts, shall be submitted to the Minister and
presented to Parliament.
The Bill has general provisions to exempt the
Corporation from stamp duty and income tax and
also provisions to appoint committees and, with
Ministerial approval, to establish superannuation
schemes for its employees. Clause 25 of the Bill
empowers the Minister to make such regulations for
carrying out the provisions of the Act.
When the Corporation is established, all
immovable and movable properties in Sentosa will
be transferred to it on such terms and conditions
as the Minister may determine. Prior to this date,
the Minister is empowered to make such contracts
and agreements on behalf of the Corporation for
the development of Sentosa and such contracts or
agreements shall be deemed to have been made by
the Corporation when it is established.
Column: 1128
The immediate task of the Sentosa Development
Corporation will be to, take over the
implementation of numerous projects which have
already been launched and are in various stages of
implementation. It will also have to evaluate,
reassess and implement the many other projects
proposed for Sentosa. In the long run, it is
anticipated that the Sentosa Development
Corporation would, at the least, be self-supporting.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
6.39 p.m.
Clauses 1 to 5 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clause 6 -
The Chairman: Mr Tang, there is a clerical error
here. The word "or" appearing in page 3, line 31,
should read "in".
Mr Tang See Chim: Yes, Sir. Mr Speaker, Sir, may
I have your consent and the general assent of
Members present to move an amendment to correct
this small clerical error?
The Chairman: I give my consent. Does the
Minister of State have the general assent of hon.
Members?
Hon. Members indicated assent.
Mr Tang See Chim: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
In page 3, line 31, to leave out "or" and insert
"in".
Sir, this is just to correct a clerical error.
Amendment agreed to.
Clause 6, as amended, ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clauses 7 to 26 inclusive ordered to stand part
of the Bill.
Bill reported with an amendment; read a Third
time and passed.
Column: 1129
TIMBER EXPORT INDUSTRY BOARD (INCORPORATION)
(AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.42 p.m.
The Minister of State for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time".
The Timber Export Industry Board was established
under the Timber Export Industry Board
(Incorporation) Act passed by Parliament in 1966.
This is a joint Singapore-Malaysian Board and is an
example of the close cooperation between our two
countries. Since its establishment, the Board has
been doing a good job in regulating and improving
the timber export industry.
The principal source of the Board's funds comes
from the collection of cess on the export of
timber. Section 20 of the 1966 Act provides for the
establishment of the Timber Export Industry Fund
into which all monies collected by the Board are to
be paid. There is, however, no provision in the Act
for the investment of the surplus funds. At
present, the Timber Export Industry Board has
accumulated some $960,000 of surplus funds which
are held in fixed deposit accounts because of the
lack of power of the Board to invest these surplus
funds in other forms of securities.
An amendment to the 1966 Act is, therefore,
necessary to enable the Board to invest its surplus
funds. And this Amendment Bill seeks to do just
that. A new section, section 20A, is to be added to
the 1966 Act to empower the Board to invest its
surplus funds in investments or securities
authorised for the investment of trust funds. The
Minister may also direct the Board to invest in any
of these authorised investments and securities as
he may think fit.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Tang See Chim].
Column: 1130
Bill considered in Committee: reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1130
DEVELOPMENT LOAN BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.45 p.m.
The Minister of State for Finance (Mr Tang See Chim): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time".
The Development Loan Act, 1967 (Chapter 66),
authorises a sum of $1,000 million to be raised by
way of loan for the purposes of the Development
Fund. To-date, a total of $963 million has been
raised under the provisions of the Act, leaving a
balance of $37 million of the prescribed maximum.
Members are no doubt aware that besides external
sources such as the World Bank, the Asian
Development Bank and the international money
markets, Singapore will have to continue to
mobilise resources from the domestic sector to
finance its development programme. For this
purpose, it is envisaged that the loans raised for
the Development Fund will amount to about $2,000
million over the next five years. The Bill, which
is now before the House, is necessary since the
previous legislation, which I mentioned earlier,
cannot be suitably amended to increase the amount
of loan that can be raised.
The Bill follows closely the provisions of the
Development Loan Act, l967 (Chapter 66), with one
difference. This is that the maximum amount of loan
which can be raised under the Bill is $2,000
million, as compared to $1,000 million authorised
by the 1967 Act. A new feature is that the proposed
Development Loan Act will be administered by the
Monetary Authority of Singapore instead of the
Treasury.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Tang See Chim].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1131
NATIONAL PRODUCTIVITY BOARD BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.51 p.m.
The Minister for Labour (Mr Ong Pang Boon): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
The importance of raising productivity in
Singapore stems from basic economic realities. We
are a small country in terms of our population and
the natural resources we possess. Indeed, our only
natural resources are our resourceful working
population, our geographical location and a fine
harbour. While other countries have abundant
mineral deposits to exploit, we have none. While
other countries have vast, fertile tracts of land
to till, we have none. We can build a healthy
economy and enjoy a high standard of living only
upon the productivity and discipline of our
working population, including both the managing
and the managed in both the public and private
sectors.
Unlike other populous countries, we do not even
have a large, guaranteed, domestic market for our
locally-made products. Given our limited domestic
market of 2.1 million persons, in order to attain
our targeted Gross Domestic Product growth rate of
15 per cent annually over the next five years, we
simply must export more and more. To secure
markets for our exports, we must be able to
compete internationally in terms of the price and
quality of our products. And to do so our
businessmen, industrialists and workers must be
efficient and productive. The importance, indeed,
the necessity of raising productivity in Singapore
can never be overemphasised.
Moreover, increases in productivity make
possible wage increases without upsetting the
economic apple-cart. Many of our workers in the
past have worked conscientiously, diligently and
with the welfare of the nation at heart. Not only
do they deserve our thanks, in this decade they
should enjoy higher wages. However, higher wages
without accompanying
Column: 1132
productivity increases can impede economic
growth. Fundamentally, the businessman is more
interested in his labour cost per unit of output
rather than wages as such. If the productivity of
his employees rises, he can raise their wages
without simultaneously increasing his unit labour
cost. Through higher productivity then, the
aspirations of our workers for higher wages can be
met without inflation, without damaging the
competitiveness of our products in international
markets, and without reducing the attractiveness
of our investment climate. I repeat --the
necessity to raise productivity in Singapore
cannot be over-emphasised.
The National Productivity Centre was established
in May 1967, within the Economic Development Board
as a result of a joint declaration signed by the
National Trades Union Congress, the Singapore
Employers' Federation and the Singapore
Manufacturers' Association. In July last year, the
National Productivity Centre was transferred from
the Economic Development Board to my Ministry. It
had always been envisaged that after the National
Productivity Centre had acquired sufficient
experience and expertise, its status would be
raised to that of a statutory board. Having been
in existence for almost five years now, and
bearing in mind the importance of raising
productivity, it is opportune to transform it into
a statutory board now.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I do not wish to go into the
details of the Bill as regards the aims, powers
and functions of the National Productivity Board
as these are clearly indicated in the Explanatory
Statement to the Bill. I shall only point out some
of the salient features of the Bill.
Clause 4 of the Bill provides for the
appointment of a 14-member board consisting of the
chairman, three directors each to represent the
Government, employers, trade unions, academic and
professional bodies associated with productivity,
and an Executive Director. This equal and broad
representation will help the Board to better serve
the
Column: 1133
felt needs of different groups in our society and
to better elicit their support in the task of
raising productivity.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the fundamental task of the
National Productivity Board is to raise the level
of productivity in Singapore. Its specific
objectives are set out in clause 6 of the Bill,
the more important of which are:
(i) to promote productivity consciousness
amongst management personnel, trade union leaders
and workers;
(ii) to provide training facilities for
management and trade unions personnel in all
productivity techniques, including general
management, personnel management, supervisory
development, management accounting and industrial
engineering;
(iii) to foster and promote good industrial
relations by training and by promoting the
formation of joint consultative councils;
(iv) to render management consultancy services
in the same fields in which training activities
are undertaken with a view to assisting industrial
enterprises to achieve a general raising of
productivity; and
(v) to assist industrial establishments in
formulating and rationalising wage policies and
wage systems.
In order that the objectives of the Board will
be achieved, it is also empowered in clause 7 to
publish works and disseminate information
concerning productivity techniques, to award
certificates of efficiency to persons attending
courses organised by the Board and to establish,
under clause 6, a scheme of subscribing membership
to the Board.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
7.00 p.m.
Inche Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I wish to express my views on the National
Productivity Board Bill which are purely those of
a common man. Sir, I therefore beg the indulgence
of the economists and other
Column: 1134
intellectuals to bear with the viewpoints of the
common man, which I now express. The common man
believes that if he works, and works hard enough,
he is entitled to a fair wage and a bonus out of
the fruits of his labour. The average man's basic
philosophy towards work and the purpose of
production as an extrapolation of work is to
satisfy his own welfare and those whom he
considers are part of society. I hope the National
Productivity Board, when it proceeds in furthering
its objective, will endeavour to simplify the
meaning of productivity in terms of job security
and satisfaction and a better standard of life.
The average worker could hardly feel secure and
happy if it were otherwise.
Mr Speaker, Sir, for the time being I would like
to express my views on the subject in simple,
rounded terms. I hope over the years I could have
the opportunity of elaborating my viewpoints.
I could not but agree that this is a vitally
opportune time to introduce the concept of
productivity in the process of production and in
the process of distribution of wealth in a just
and logical mode and manner. Therefore, I support
the establishment of the National Productivity
Board whose main purpose is to promote
productivity in all enterprises industrial or
otherwise for the general well-being and
economic progress of Singapore.
It is already accepted as a fact of life that
Singapore does depend on foreign investments,
foreign raw materials for its industries and
foreign markets for our manufactured goods.
Practically all that we have is abundance of human
resources, and there is no option but to improve
productivity through better use of labour through
time and space. In doing so, I hope the National
Productivity Board will ensure the adoption of the
following working principles:
1. Productivity exercises should not cause job
insecurity.
Column: 1135
2. Productivity exercises should proceed through
bargaining at grass-roots level.
3. Productivity exercises should not endanger
the health and safety of workers.
4. The employer must pay for the cost of
retraining the employee when there is redundancy.
If these conditions cannot be fulfilled, then
all productivity drives and plans will be looked
with suspicion, cause resentment, frustration,
discord and conflict.
One other pertinent point I wish to make is that
the National Productivity Board should not take
upon itself the ultimate of knowing the absolute
truth and solutions to all problems and to proceed
by setting guide lines and recommendations without
due consultation with both individual employers
and workers and their organisations. No amount of
firm orders or benign decrees, even lawfully given
after this Bill is passed, will create good
industrial relations and human happiness in the
long run. Democracy must be practised at grass-roots level in the best principles of industrial
democracy.
If you will recall, Sir, I said in Parliament on
11th July, 1968, when the House debated the
Employment Bill in 1968 [Hansard, Volume 27, No.
10 cols. 535-61]:
`The question of increasing productivity in any
firm or undertaking and the payment of
productivity rewards can also be worked out
between the particular employer, employees'
representatives and the National Productivity
Council. There must be the machinery for working
out productivity plans, examining the results and
for negotiating the payment of incentive awards to
make any productivity drive achieve its
objectives. The question of increasing
productivity is an urgent matter and should be of
serious concern to employers, Government, workers
and their organisations in the interest of
economic progress. In this respect, if workers are
asked to give their wholehearted support to higher
productivity programmes and campaigns, they must
be allowed to participate actively and
constructively in formulating and implementing
them. When there is success there must be concrete
and reasonable returns or rewards.'
It was my thinking then as it is now that it is
illogical and beyond comprehension that payment of
bonus to workers, a vital incentive to higher
productivity, is negotiable only within a certain
restricted limit.
I see there is provision to foster and promote
good industrial relations through the formation of
joint consultative councils as one of the
objectives of the National Productivity Board. I
do hope that it will be within the province of
such joint consultative councils not only to
discuss and to implement agreed work procedures,
but also to look into the question of the payment
of productivity bonuses, provided, however, they
represent the will of the workers.
Mr Speaker, Sir, at this point I would like to
say that the idea of forming joint productivity
councils in enterprises, which would serve as
consultative bodies guiding and promoting
productivity, is not new. In 1965, the Singapore
Employers' Federation, the Singapore
Manufacturers' Association and the National Trades
Union Congress at the behest of the Government
jointly endorsed the Charter for Industrial
Productivity Code of Practice. Unfortunately, this
Charter, which was solemnly contracted, was not
religiously practised in spirit and in real terms.
This Charter is nothing but a dead letter. I hope
the National Productivity Board will pick up the
fallen threads, but not tread the same path.
Sir, I also observe that among its objectives,
the National Productivity Board shall assist
industrial establishments and trade unions in
formulating and rationalising wage policies and
wage systems; shall assist the Government from
time to time in shaping a national wage policy;
and shall undertake manpower and wage studies. On
the other hand, the Minister for Labour has on 8th
February, 1972, constituted the National Wages
Council with somewhat similar terms of reference,
as follows:
(i) To assist in the formulation of general guide-lines on wage policy;
Column: 1137
(ii) To recommend necessary adjustment in wage
structure, with a view to developing a coherent
wage system consistent with long-term economic and
social development;
(iii) To advise on desirable incentive systems
for the promotion of operational efficiency and
productivity in various enterprises.
Can the Minister for Labour clarify if the Wages
Council is to operate as a body separate from the
National Productivity Board or as an adjunct to the
Board? Or will the Wages Council be subsidiary to
the National Productivity Board? Or will it be
unscrambled?
Sir, I hope the Minister For Labour will consider
the last point because if he has too many dons
around him, sometimes they become boisterous. They
do not write a one-and-a-half page memorandum to
the Cabinet. I tend to think that the Minister
himself might be confused, and we all will suffer
in the end.
Mr Ong Pang Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, I share the
sympathy of the Member for Kallang in respect of
his apprehension and fear that the increased
productivity may lead to loss of job security for
workers, may endanger the safety of workers while
at work, and so forth. It is, in fact, to meet this
kind of reservation that there will be
representations from the trade unions on the
National Productivity Board itself. I am quite sure
the trade union representatives on the Board will
be competent enough to safeguard the interests of
the workers.
Sir, regarding the question of bonus payments, as
I have said earlier during the Budget debate, the
whole question of bonus payment and the amount of
bonus negotiable is being referred to the National
Wages Council for deliberation. The Government has
made known its views to the National Wages Council
regarding this matter, and we are waiting for its
recommendations. I think the Member for Kallang is
well aware that the recommendations of the Wages
Column: 1138
Council will only be ready around the end of April
or early May. So I ask him to be a little bit more
patient.
There can really be no conflict arising between
the National Wages Council and the National
Productivity Board, because the Board is, in fact,
servicing the National Wages Council. The National
Wages Council is purely an advisory body which will
submit reports and recommendations periodically to
the Government on wages and guide-lines for
implementation by the Government and the `various
employer organisations. In servicing the National
Wages Council, I am quite sure the National
Productivity Board will be able to assist in the
various ways of formulating such guide-lines.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Ong Pang Boon].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1138
COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL SECURITY CORPORATION
BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
7.16 p.m.
The Minister for Home Affairs (Prof. Wong Lin Ken): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the
Bill be now read a Second time."
This Bill seeks to establish the Commercial and
Industrial Security Corporation to take over on a
commercial basis the functions of the Guard and
Escort Unit constituted under the Police Force Act
in providing for guards and escorts as a security
service to the commercial and industrial sector.
The Guard and Escort Unit was formed in 1959 from
the ranks of the old Special Constabulary and at
the outset consisted of the Commandant, 11
Inspectors and 800 Special Constables.
Column: 1139
The Union performs a wide range of duties
including:
(1) guard for important personages;
(2) escorts for payroll and the delivery of
cash;
(3) static property and building guards; and
(4) ship guards.
The Unit was constituted primarily for the
purpose of providing guards and escorts to
Government Departments, thereby leaving the
regular policemen to deal with matters pertaining
to the preservation of public peace and order. In
addition, the Unit also contributes towards crime
prevention by offering its services to the private
sector on payment.
Apart from the Guard and Escort Unit providing a
security service to the commercial and industrial
sectors, there are also a number of other private
firms in the security business. Despite
competition from these firms, the Guard and Escort
Unit netted about $2.1 million and $2 million in
revenue for the years 1970 and 1971 respectively.
This amount was earned by deploying only one-third
of the manpower, as the other two-thirds were
deployed for unpaid duties and administrative
work. It is, therefore, evident that the services
of this Unit are heavily in demand and it is
envisaged that the trend would continue well into
the future. With this in view, the National
Productivity Centre was requested in October 1970,
to study the feasibility of expanding the Guard
and Escort Unit on a commercial basis. The finding
of the National Productivity Centre is that it is
a viable project.
Many of the payroll and cash-in-transit
robberies occurred because of no security guards.
On 4th September, 1971, five employees of the
Singapore Woollen Knitwear (Private) Limited in
Jurong, including two female payroll clerks, were
robbed of a sum of about $45,000 at Quality Road
while on their way back to the factory from the
bank. The firm probably felt that since five
persons were accompanying the payroll it was not
necessary to have security guards to
Column: 1140
escort the cash-in-transit. On 1st August, 1970,
the Manager of Diamond Theatre at North Bridge
Road was robbed of the previous day's collection
amounting, to about $10,000 by two youths armed
with daggers, when he was on his way to bank in
the cash. He also had no security escort. I could
cite some more examples, but I think the point is
made.
This Bill provides for the establishment of the
Commercial and Industrial Security Corporation,
which will consist of not less than four and not
more than nine members to be appointed by the
Minister.
The functions of the Corporation are:-
(a) to provide guard and escort for the protection
of persons and property;
(b) to provide such other security services as the
Corporation may determine; and
(c) to co-operate as far as practical and
necessary with the Singapore Police Force in the
performance of its functions under this Act.
The Corporation is empowered to appoint such
officers and employees as it considers necessary
for the purpose of carrying out its functions,
including the appointment of a General Manager.
As it is considered desirable that the services
of the Corporation should be available to
Government in times of emergency, personnel of the
Corporation will continue to carry arms. Clause 12
of the Bill enables the Corporation, with the
approval of the Commissioner of Police, to provide
its officers and employees with arms, warrant
cards and powers and immunities as a Police
Officer. Like Police Officers, they will not be
allowed to be members of a trade union.
Clause 14 empowers the Commissioner of Police,
with the approval of the Minister, to mobilise for
active service all or any officers or employees of
the Corporation to perform either general
Column: 1141
or special Police duties. An officer or employee
of the Corporation who is so mobilised is liable
to perform such service as the Commissioner of
Police or his authorised representative directs,
and during the period of mobilisation shall have
the same powers and duties and the same
protection and immunities as a Police Officer.
The transfer of employees from the present Guard
and Escort Unit to the Corporation as well as the
transfer of rights, liabilities and obligations
of the Unit to the Corporation are catered for in
clause 15. Those who will be transferred to the
Corporation will go over on terms and conditions
no less favourable than those they enjoyed
immediately prior to their transfer.
The Corporation is empowered under clause 16 to
establish a scheme or schemes for the payment of
pensions, gratuities, provident fund or other
superannuation benefits to its officers and
employees.
Financial provisions relating to the Corporation
(for example, powers to
Column: 1142
borrow and invest) are dealt with in clauses 18
to 21.
Clause 23 empowers the Minister to make rules.
Part IX of the Police Force Act relating to the
Guard and Escort Unit is repealed.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and
committed to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Prof. Wong Lin Ken].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
ADJOURNMENT
Resolved,
"That Parliament do now adjourn." -[Prof. Wong Lin Ken].
Adjourned accordingly at
Twenty-seven minutes past Seven o'clock p.m.