| Parliament No: | 3 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 33 |
| Sitting No: | 1 |
| Sitting Date: | 04-03-1974 |
|
Column: 1
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
THIRD PARLIAMENT
Monday, 4th March, 1974
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Dr Yeoh Ghim Seng, B.B.M., J.P. (Joo Chiat)).
Encik Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang).
Encik A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Ahmad Mattar (Leng Kee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Dr Ang Kok Peng, B.B.M. (Crawford), Minister of State for Communications.
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr Ivan Baptist (Potong Pasir).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development and Leader of the House.
Mr Chai Chong Yii (Bukit Batok), Minister of State for Education.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh).
Dr Chiang Hai Ding (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Chin Harn Tong (Aljunied).
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for the Environment.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (Mac Pherson), Minister for Health and Home Affairs.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong).
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour.
Column: 2
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Defence.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah).
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development.
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Hon Sui Sen (Havelock), Minister for Finance.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Mr Lai Tha Chai (Henderson).
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Minister for Education.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Mr Lee Yiok Seng (Bukit Panjang).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs.
Mr Lim Kim San, D.U.T. (Cairnhill), Minister for the Environment.
Tuan Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampung Kembangan).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Dr Ong Leong Boon (Kim Seng).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Labour.
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Ong Teng Cheong (Kim Keat).
Encik Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Column: 3
Mr Phey Yew Kok (Boon Teck).
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Defence.
Encik Rahmat Bin Kenap Al-Haj (Geylang Serai).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampung Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens).
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee).
Mr P. Selvadurai (Kuo Chuan).
Tuan Haji Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampung Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Minister of State for Labour and Government Whip.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Dr Tan Eng Liang, B.B.M. (River Valley).
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan (Whampoa).
Mr Tang See Chim (Chua Chu Kang), Deputy Speaker.
Column: 4
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology.
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Minister of State for the Environment.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken, B.B.M. (Alexandra).
Mr Yeo Choo Kok (Delta).
Mr Yeo Toon Chia (Kampung Kapur).
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications.
ABSENT:
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampung Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Column: 3
PERMISSION TO MEMBERS TO BE ABSENT
Under the provisions of clause 2 (d) of Article
30 of the Constitution of Singapore, I have
granted permission to the following Members to be
or to remain absent from sittings of Parliament
(or any Committee of Parliament to which they have
been appointed) for the periods stated:
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens) - from 22nd to 30th December, 1973.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs - from 1st January to 30th June, 1974.
Encik A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs - from 8th to 18th January, and from 21st January to 9th February, 1974.
Column: 4
Mr P. Selvadurai (Kuo Chuan) - from 14th January to 28th February, 1974.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister - from 15th to 17th January, 1974.
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampung Glam), Minister for Foreign - Affairs - from 15th to 17th January and from 20th January to 9th February, 1974.
Mr Ahmad Mattar (Leng Kee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education - from 15th to 17th January, 1974.
Encik Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs - from 25th January to 10th February, 1974.
Column: 5
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Minister for Education - from 27th to 31st January, 1974.
Mr Lee Yiok Seng (Bukit Panjang) - from 27th January to 3rd February, 1974.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol) - from 28th January to 5th February, on 4th March and from 11th to 27th March, 1974.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi) - from 1st to 10th February, 1974.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein) -from 17th February to 3rd March, 1974.
Column: 6
Mr Phey Yew Kok (Boon Teck) - from 17th February to 3rd March, 1974.
Tuan Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampung Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office - from 4th to 24th March, 1974.
Tuan Haji Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampung Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture - from 6th to 13th March, 1974.
| | YEOH GHIM SENG, |
| | Speaker |
| | Parliament of Singapore |
Column: 5
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
MASS TRANSIT SYSTEM
(Operational date)
1. Mr Ong Teng Cheong asked the Minister for
Communications whether any positive decision has
been made on the proposed Mass Transit System, in
view of the rapidly deteriorating traffic
situation and the current pace of physical and
economic development; and whether a Mass Transit
System is likely to be operational before 1980.
The Minister for Communications (Mr Yong Nyuk Lin): Mr Speaker, Sir, the Mass Transit Study
(MTS) project commenced in July 1972. The project
is undertaken with the assistance from the United
Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and with the
World Bank as its Executing Agency.
The aim of the MTS, which is in two phases, is to
assist the Government in the formulation of a
transportation programme that would efficiently
serve present and future needs and complement
overall plans for long-range development of the
Republic. Phase I of the Study will provide
recommendations for development of mass transit
services based on comprehensive evaluation and
analysis of available transportation alternatives.
Phase II will be a detailed
Column: 6
feasibility study of the recommended system.
Phase I of the Study was recently completed and
the Consultants are expected to submit their Final
Report around the end of this month. On receipt of
the Final Report, the recommendations of the
Consultants would be reviewed and submitted to
Government for decision. When a decision is made
on the system selected for detailed study, Phase
II will commence. The details of Phase II cannot
be finalised pending a decision on Phase I. For
these reasons, it is not possible to say at this
stage whether a mass transit system is likely to
be operational before 1980.
It is relevant for me, Sir, to point out that the
objective of the MTS is to provide long-term
solutions. For the short-term, as Members are
aware, vigorous steps have been and are being
taken to improve the public transport system and
the traffic situation. These measures include
reserved bus lanes some of which are already in
operation, as well as measures to restrain the
growth of the private car population. Plans are
also being studied for the location of over a
dozen parking places around the periphery of the
congested Central Business District to accommodate
between 25 to 30 per cent of private
Column: 7
cars entering the Central Business District at
peak hours and arrange for special buses to carry
such commuters into the Central Business District.
This plan is based on the park-and-ride schemes
operational in several large cities where cars
which do not use these peripheral car parks have
to pay a fee to enter the restricted zone. This
plan when finalised will be published. After
public discussion the plans may be improved upon
before implementation.
Column: 7
BREAKDOWNS OF PUBLIC BUSES
(Request for effective action)
2. Mr Teong Eng Siong asked the Minister for
Communications whether he is aware of the many
breakdowns of public buses daily, and if he will
consider taking effective steps in the matter such
as requesting the Singapore Bus Services Limited
to promptly tow away buses which have broken down
on the roads so that traffic flow will not be
hindered for long and to engage more mechanics and
operate a two-shift system, or engage private
motor workshops, to expedite repairs of the buses
so that they may be put back into service quickly.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Mr Speaker, Sir, not only are
we aware of the daily occurrence of public buses
breaking down on the roads, but have viewed it
with concern. Since Singapore Bus Services Ltd.
(SBS) took over operation of the public bus
service from the three former companies - Amalgamated Bus Co. (ABC), Associated Bus Service
(ABS) and United Bus Co. (UBC) - on 1st November
last year, it has been required to submit daily
returns to the Ministry of Communications and the
Bus Services Reorganisation Committee (BSRC) on
the bus operations. Included in these returns are
the number of breakdowns occurring daily. The
returns show an average of 35 breakdowns daily
over the four months from November 1973 to
February 1974. The breakdown figures were counter-checked with daily reports from the Police for the months
Column: 8
of November and December only. This represents 2.5
per cent of the daily average operational fleet of
1,400. It should be noted the buses operate for
about 18 hours a day, often under congested
traffic conditions and severely overloaded. This
would strain even the best of equipment.
We are as concerned as the hon. Member for
Sembawang that buses breaking down by the roads
should be quickly removed and not allowed to
obstruct traffic. Through efforts of the BSRC. SBS
entered into an agreement with a private motor
repairer to tow away and repair its buses which
breakdown by the roadside in the city area. At the
request of the BSRC, SBS also undertook to obtain
other private motor repairers to assist in the
repair of its buses which break down, including
those breaking down by the roadside.
Advertisements inviting such private motor
repairers to undertake this work were published by
SBS in the Press on 14th, 19th, and 20th February.
It is expected that SBS would finalise the
arrangements with those companies which respond,
shortly. SBS is also finalising arrangements for
installation of mobile VHF communication equipment
in its repair vehicles with the control centre at
its main workshop. This, when installed, would
speed up the repair of roadside breakdowns.
In addition, under the Road Traffic (Removal of
Vehicles) Rules, the Police are empowered to
remove broken down vehicles on the roads which
cause obstruction and to charge the owners for
removal and storage fees. The present removal
charge for a bus is $60 and the storage charge is
$20 per day. The Registry of Vehicles and Traffic
Police are reviewing this with a view to
increasing the rates as a deterrent to roadside
breakdowns and incentive to better maintenance.
The Traffic Police are also arranging with
suitable private contractors for towing away of
buses broken down by the roadside which are too
large to be towed away by their present
contractor.
Column: 9
The key, Sir, to reducing the number of buses
breaking down by the roadside is, however, to
maintain the buses properly. SBS inherited most of
its present bus fleet from the three former bus
companies, and many of these buses, I am sorry to
say, were very poorly maintained. More than 400
were out of repair and laid up when SBS began
operations on 1st November last year. Through the
efforts of the BSRC, an agreement was entered into
by SBS with a private motor repairer to repair
these 400 buses at an estimated cost of $1.2
million and to put them back on the road as soon
as possible over the six months from November 1973
to April 1974. Unfortunately, owing to the poor
state of maintenance, many of these buses are
irreparable without replacement of major
components. Up to 28th February last month, only
43 of the buses have been repaired and put back
into operation. However, SBS now has, on order,
227 replacement engines, gearboxes and axles
costing an estimated $2 million. It is also
undertaking some of the repairs itself and is
arranging with additional private repairers to
assist in the work.
To ensure higher standards of maintenance of the
buses in future, SBS is leasing a 17.6-acre site
at Braddell Road for 15 years from the Housing and
Development Board to put up a proper central depot
and workshop. Plans for the workshop are now being
drawn up by the architects commissioned by SBS
with the assistance of consultants from certain
major motor suppliers and repairers. SBS has also
employed a qualified mechanical engineer to
supervise its workshops operations. Arrangements
have, in addition, been made for SBS to recruit
more motor mechanics and to undertake a proper
scheme for motor mechanic trainees in conjunction
with the Registry of Vehicles, the Industrial
Training Board and the Singapore Industrial Labour
Organisation.
Column: 10
All public buses are required to be inspected and
certified fit by the Mechanical Inspection Unit of
the Registry of Vehicles once every six months.
These inspections have been intensified and
proposals are being studied by the BSRC to ensure
that buses appearing for inspection in future have
properly documented and certified service record
cards. Under the proposals, these cards would show
the repair jobs and servicing carried out on the
buses in the six months preceding each inspection.
Buses which do not meet the standards of
maintenance specified by the Registry of Vehicles
would not be passed for use on the roads and the
bus company would be penalised for operating buses
which are not up to the standard of maintenance
required. False certification of the service
record cards would also be subject to penalty.
The hon. Member for Sembawang may be assured that
every effort is being directed towards ensuring
proper maintenance of our public buses with a view
to avoiding roadside breakdowns and providing a
maximum operational fleet.
Dr Ong Leong Boon (Kim Seng): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
fully sympathise with the Minister on the state of
the bus service in Singapore. From the points
which he has raised, I would like to ask him a few
supplementary questions. Firstly, it would seem to
me that the introduction of bus lanes on certain
roads has created new problems. The right of way
for smaller vehicles is one such problem. It is
all right if we are in a mini-car alongside a big
bus. Actually out of fear for our own safety, we
give way to the bus. What happens if an army truck
happens to be parked at the red light next to the
bus? Who has the right of way to turn left?
The introduction of bus lanes also leads to a
slowing down of traffic. All buses following
behind a bus that stops at a bus stop will
naturally have to stop. This will mean that the
entire chain of buses have to stop, whether or not
there are passengers getting off from the second,
third or fourth bus. I am sure
Column: 11
these problems have been thought over carefully by
the Ministry, and the Minister will have good
answers to them.
The second question concerns the efforts made by
the Ministry of Communications to encourage more
and more people to use public transport. I notice
that there are no schedules of routes at bus stops
to help commuters. I think it would be a good idea
if the Ministry could ask SBS to publicise at all
bus stops a schedule of all the buses that come
that way, giving the routes and Service number of
every bus. I am sure this can be done and should
be done with haste.
Thirdly, I notice that the SBS has recently
introduced some 40 to 50 jumbo buses. This jumbo
bus can carry 90 passengers. I am told that at
certain junctions cars following closely behind
this jumbo bus have got to reverse in order to
allow this jumbo bus to turn into a small lane. I
am sure the Ministry can also ask the SBS to
reschedule bus routes so that these jumbo buses
will not cause any inconvenience to other
commuters on the road.
Fourthly, the question of conductors, I am sure
that the provision of just one conductor for a
jumbo bus is going to create more problems for the
commuters and also for the bus conductors. I am
inclined to believe that unhealthy incidents
between commuters and conductors may increasingly
occur if we do not provide one more conductor to
each jumbo bus. Let us say that we should have two
conductors instead of one conductor in each jumbo
bus. Can I have the answers?
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Sir, I shall endeavour to
answer the rather long-winded question with its
many provisos. Firstly, on the question of the
reserved bus lanes and the problems arising
therefrom. Problems will always arise when we
start on something new. There will be teething
problems. Even the bus drivers and bus conductors
realise for the first time now that they have
Column: 12
the right of way when they are in the bus lanes.
The answer to the question of right of way is very
simple. When there is a reserved bus lane, the
right of way is the privilege of the buses. Anyone
getting into this lane will be booked, and he will
have to exercise greater care. If a driver of a
vehicle, be it an army truck, wishes to turn left,
then if there is a bus lane on his left, he should
first have to give the right of way to the bus. He
should be more patient before turning left because
he has to see that the passage is clear before
making his turn. Otherwise he will get a ticket
for the offence.
With regard to the question about the change of
buses and so on and whether adequate steps have
been taken to review the situation, I can assure
the hon. Member, as well as members of the public,
that this matter is constantly under review. If it
is found that certain adjustments have to be made
to improve the flow of traffic, we will do so. May
I also assure the hon. Member that it is not just
the Ministry of Communications and a few officials
in the Registry of Vehicles who are involved in
the drawing of lines on the road. We have a
technical team of road engineers and planners from
the Ministry of National Development. They are the
ones who really plan the whole scheme and, of
course, it did receive our criticism as well as
that of the Traffic Police in the Ministry of Home
Affairs. The whole scheme of reserved bus lanes
was not just the work of one Ministry. I would say
that at least three Ministries were involved.
The second question is about encouraging more
commuters by providing certain facilities which
the hon. Member considers should be the
responsibility of the bus company. There is no
doubt that the bus company should do much more
than just print some bus guides. In fact, the
company will have to make up for lost time by
having more officers appointed so that they can
communicate with the public,
Column: 13
and the business of the BSRC is to ensure that the
needs of commuters are looked after.
The other point raised by the Member is that at
each of the main terminals there should be
sufficient boards to indicate routes of the buses
that leave the terminus, and so on. This takes a
little bit of time to eventuate. I can assure him,
however, that every effort will be made to get the
SBS to provide a public bus service that is up to
standard. But we have our difficulties, and the
first is the objective to get 400 buses, which are
now off the road, to be back on the road. Once the
public get the buses to travel in, then we can
think of other improvements to the service.
As to his last suggestion about having two
conductors to one bus, may I say that it is our
hope that ultimately there will be no conductors
in the bus. But that is a long way yet. This is
something which we would like to see -that
ultimately each bus will be operated by only a
driver and the commuters need only to drop their
shillings for a ride, depending on distance, and
there would not be any conductors at all. But I do
not wish to agitate my good Friend, who is in
charge of the Singapore Industrial Labour
Organisation, by causing a ripple amongst his
midst. That is quite a distant dream.
Encik Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang): Mr Speaker,
Sir, as hon. Members know, about 400 to 500
physically broken-down buses have been sent to the
grave. What I would like to know and very firmly
ask is whether the bus service is going to improve
in three months' time, or never at all? Or is the
Hon. Minister for Communications still thinking of
doctoring the SBS and "transplanting" engines and
whatnots, rather than performing the last rites of
the SBS and the funeral service?
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Sir, I am sorry to hear that
the hon. Member thinks that I am doctoring the
SBS. Having seen the collapse of one bus company
(the Singapore Traction Company) in December 1971,
it is my last wish that the SBS will collapse. I
think it is only
Column: 14
fair that we should give the bus company some time
to get on its feet, because it is only four months
since the company started operations as a single
organisation.
As I have stated, there are a number of
deficiencies, including 400 buses not put on the
road. To be fair, I must say that SBS has entered
into a contract with a motor repairer to repair
the 400 buses in six months' time, that is, by
April 1974. We should therefore not judge it
before then. If it is necessary for "surgical
operations" to be done, perhaps I would be in a
position to do it then, but not now.
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah): Sir, there has been
Some talk that public transport may be
nationalised. I would like to have the views of
the Minister on this talk about the
nationalisation of the transport service.
Mr Speaker: Mr Minister, is it relevant to the
main question?
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: Sir, this supplementary
question looks like an extension of the many
supplementary questions that have been raised. I
believe it has been stated in this House sometime
ago that the present Government has no intention
to nationalise the public transport. If a Member
puts in an Oral Question and then withdraws it, I
am not in a position to answer it. And since he
has not raised it, I would say that the position
remains the same - there is no intention to
nationalise public transport at this stage.
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I would like to ask the Minister
whether he is aware that the buses are emitting a
lot of smoke, and whether the Singapore Bus
Services Company is being penalised for running
such smoky buses. Every day we see buses emitting
black smoke. What measures are being taken by the
Government to remedy this situation?
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin: The question is very simple,
Sir,It is a matter of either having a bus to
carry passengers although the bus appears to have
smoky
Column: 15
exhausts, or to look after the smoky exhausts and
thereby have less buses on the road. The answer is
simple: let the buses run and look after the
passengers first.
Column: 15
LIFTS
(Proper maintenance of)
3. Mr Teong Eng Siong asked the Minister for Law
and National Development (a) whether there are
statistics of the lifts installed in Housing and
Development Board estates, private housing estates
and in Government and private buildings; (b)
whether these lifts had been checked and approved
by the Government department concerned before they
were installed and again, after installation,
before they were put into operation; (c) whether
steps have been taken to set up a body to make
compulsory periodic inspections of all lifts after
installations; and (d) for public safety and the
cleanliness of lifts, if he will consider
introducing legislation to require lifts to be
operated by lift attendants only.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, as at the 31st
of January this year, there were 1,350 lifts in
Housing Board estates and another 117 in
Government buildings. There are no statistics
available for private buildings at the moment. But
with the introduction of the Buildings and Common
Property (Maintenance and Management) Rules
sometime this year, statistics of lifts in such
buildings will become available. The lifts in
Housing Board flats are installed in accordance
with the Board's specifications and under the
supervision of the Board's electrical engineers.
The lifts are tested for a period of two weeks
before use. They are cleaned regularly and
serviced and oiled fortnightly. The Board also
maintains a 24-hour Lift Emergency Unit to deal
with breakdowns.
Lifts in Government buildings are checked and
approved before and after installations by the
electrical branch of
Column: 16
the Public Works Department which is also
responsible for their maintenance. Regular
cleaning is carried out by the user department.
Lifts in private buildings were previously
subject to the 1931 Lift by-laws which required
owners of buildings to engage and authorise lift
contractors to carry out regular maintenance and
to ensure safe operation. As this piece of
legislation is not adequate to cope with the high-rise developments, the Building Control Division
has been given the responsibility for the control
and installation of lifts and escalators by the
Building Control Act of this year. The Division
proposes to introduce regulations that will
require lifts to be installed and maintained by a
professional engineer in accordance with the code
of practice for installation, operation, and
maintenance of lifts. The code is being finalised
in conjunction with the Singapore Institute of
Standards and Industrial Research.
Sir, apart from the Building Control Act which I
have mentioned, action has also been taken to
ensure the proper maintenance of lifts in private
buildings under the Buildings and Common Property
(Maintenance and Management) Rules which I have
mentioned. The Commissioner of Buildings will be
responsible to ensure that owners keep their lifts
in clean and proper working condition at all times
and have them serviced monthly and inspected
annually at least. It is not practicable to make
it compulsory for all lifts to be operated by lift
attendants, as too large a number of attendants
will be needed and it will be difficult to recruit
or retain such persons. The Housing and
Development Board would then require about 3,375
lift attendants to man the 1,350 lifts now in
operation. The presence of a lift attendant may
ensure that the lift is clean, but not necessarily
safe. The Robinson fire is an example.
Legislation is being drafted to ensure that stand-by generators are installed in all public lifts so
that they can be brought down to a safe floor in
the event of fire or a power failure. There
Column: 17
will also be provision for all public lifts to be
provided with a communication system, whereby if
the hon. Member for Sembawang is trapped in a
lift, he can always call for help from outside.
Column: 17
CIVIL SERVANTS SPORTING LONG HAIR
(Action against)
4. Mr Teong Eng Siong asked the Minister for
Health and Home Affairs if he is aware that,
though action has been initiated against
Government servants having long hair, there are
certain Government employees still sporting long
hair, and what action he intends to take against
such persons.
The Minister for Health and Home Affairs (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, since May last
year, all Government departments and statutory
boards have each appointed a senior officer as
Enforcement Officer to ensure that the
Government's anti-long hair policy is
conscientiously implemented. The Enforcement
Officer checks (a) on the staff and ensures that
appropriate disciplinary action is taken against
those who sport long and unkempt hair; and (b) to
ensure that the policy that males with long hair
will be attended to last is enforced. He also
submits monthly reports to the Ministry of Home
Affairs, giving details of the number of male
officers sporting long hair and the action taken
against them.
The Ministry of Finance has also issued circulars
warning male Government servants that the sporting
of long hair constitutes a disciplinary offence
and may result in their dismissal. Up to December
of last year, more than 4,000 male officers in
Government departments and statutory boards have
been called up and warned for sporting long hair.
Among them were three Division I officers, 25
Division II officers, and the rest were Division
III and IV officers and daily-rated employees. All
those who were warned did not sport long hair
again, except for seven Division IV officers, five
of whom were dismissed and the other two resigned.
Column: 18
In general, the Government's anti-long hair
policy is having its intended effect. There has
been a marked improvement in the hair styles of
civil servants since the anti-long hair policy was
introduced. However, there may be isolated cases
of Government employees sporting long hair which
may have escaped the attention of the Enforcement
Officer. Government departments and statutory
boards have been reminded to exercise continued
vigilance over all their employees and to take
action against them. The Member for Sembawang may
rest assured that any male civil servant found
sporting long hair will be appropriately dealt
with.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I raised this question three months ago but I
had no opportunity to raise any supplementary
questions at all in this House. Now that three
months have passed, I was hoping that the
authorities concerned would pay more attention to
this matter. But recently I notice that certain
Government servants, particularly those in
Division IV, are still sporting long hair. Even
Police Inspectors are now sporting long hair. Can
the Minister pay more attention to this matter?
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Sir, although the question
was put in three months ago, as the Member for
Sembawang has said, the figures given in my answer
are up to-date. As far as those sporting long hair
are concerned, as I have said, appropriate action
had been and is being taken. But in the event that
they have escaped the notice of the Enforcement
Officer, then if the Member himself has seen any
offenders, he can make a report.
Column: 18
ANTI-INFLATIONARY AGENCY
(Setting up of)
5. Mr Hwang Soo Jin asked the Minister for
Finance if he will consider setting up a special
anti-inflation agency with suitable consumers'
representation and armed with statutory powers to
investigate into public complaints of
unjustifiable price increases and other
manipulative practices and to take punitive action
against offenders.
Column: 19
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr
Speaker, Sir, a special Anti-Inflationary Agency,
as proposed by the hon. Member for Jalan Kayu,
will not be necessary at this juncture. My
Ministry already possesses the machinery to co-ordinate the formulation as well as implementation
of various anti-inflationary measures. An Anti-Inflationary Committee has been formed within the
Ministry to look after all aspects of anti-inflation policies. Legislation, such as the Price
Control Act and the Control of Essential Supplies
Act already enacted, give the Government statutory
powers to take drastic punitive action against
manipulation by traders. Private consumers
associations such as CASE can liaise with my
Ministry on various anti-inflationary measures
which are being implemented.
While the Government has to play the main role in
combating inflation, success hinges crucially on
the co-operation of all concerned, including
employers and employees, manufacturers, traders
and consumers. I believe that there is no better
way to counter the present rise in prices than by
curbing our demand especially on luxury goods; by
abstaining from panic buying and hoarding, as well
as being more selective in our shopping habits,
and in specially bad cases of profiteering or
manipulation, by a boycott of the goods or the
sellers concerned.
Column: 19
3.06 p.m.
BILLS INTRODUCED
ENVIRONMENTAL PUBLIC HEALTH (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Environmental Public Health Act
(Chapter 155 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by the Minister of State for the Environment (Mr Wee Toon Boon); read the First
time, to be read a Second time on Thursday, 14th
March, 1974, and to be printed.
Column: 20
MUTUAL BENEFIT ORGANISATIONS (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Mutual Benefit Organisations Act
(Chapter 254 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by the Minister for Social Affairs (Encik Othman Bin Wok); read the First time, to be
read a Second time on the next available sitting
of Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 20
MARTIAL ARTS INSTRUCTION BILL
"to provide for the registration and control of
martial art associations and instructors and
trainees in martial arts and for matters connected
therewith",
recommendation of President signified; presented by the Minister for Health and Home Affairs (Mr Chua Sian Chin); read the First time, to be read a
Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 20
NATIONAL REGISTRATION (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the National Registration Act (Chapter
45 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by Mr Chua Sian Chin; read the First
time, to be read a Second time on the next
available sitting of Parliament, and to be
printed.
Column: 20
PROPERTY TAX (SURCHARGE) BILL
"to provide for the levy of a surcharge on
property tax levied under the Property Tax Act
(Chapter 144 of the Revised Edition)",
recommendation of President signified; presented by the Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen); read
the First time, to be read a Second time on the
next available sitting of Parliament, and to be
printed.
Column: 20
SUPPLY BILL
"to provide for the issue from the Consolidated
Fund of the sums necessary to meet the estimated
expenditure for the public services of Singapore
for the financial year 1st April, 1974 to 31st
March, 1975",
Column: 21
recommendation of President signified; presented by Mr Hon Sui Sen; read the First time, to be read
a Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 21
SUPPLEMENTARY SUPPLY BILL
"for making Supplementary Provision for the
public services for the financial year 1st April,
1973 to 31st March, 1974",
recommendation of President signified; presented by Mr Hon Sui Sen; read the First time, to be read
a Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 21
REPORT OF THE COMMISSION ON PARLIAMENT STAFF
3.11 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move
the motion* standing in my name as it appears
on the Order Paper.
* The motion reads as follows:
That this Parliament, noting the Report of the
Commission on Parliament Staff as contained in
Paper Misc. 1 of 1974, accepts the recommendations
of the Commission as contained in paragraph 16
thereof and resolves in accordance with such
recommendations.
Honourable Members may be aware from the Report,
which was presented to this House as Paper Misc. 1
of 1974, that a Commission consisting of you, Mr
Speaker, the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of
Defence, the Minister for Finance, the Chairman of
the Public Service Commission, and myself, was
appointed to study the terms of service of the
staff of this House.
The Commission has met and has made certain
recommendations as contained in the Report. To
attract and to continue to attract good officers
to the Parliamentary service, and also in the
interest of the present staff of this House, the
Commission has considered it necessary to revise
the terms of service of the senior posts such as
will appropriately equate them, in terms of salary
and status, to the rest of the civil service.
The Commission recommended that the three senior
posts of the Parliamentary service be restructured
as recommended
Column: 22
in paragraph 13 of the Report. It is the
view of the Commission that, with the
restructuring of the two existing promotional
posts of Clerk Assistant and Second Clerk
Assistant, there will be a wider basis in that
serving officers in the Administrative or the
Legal Service may be attracted to the
Parliamentary service either on secondment or even
on substantive appointment.
The Commission did not, however, recommend any
change with regard to the post of Clerk, (Grade E)
as it is satisfied that the salary attached to the
post is sufficiently attractive.
Sir, I beg to move,
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Parliament, noting the Report
of the Commission on Parliament Staff as
contained in Paper Misc. 1 of 1974, accepts the recommendations of the Commission as
contained in paragraph 16 thereof and resolves in accordance with such recommendations.
Column: 22
CIVIL LIST
3.15 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
That this Parliament, pursuant to section 7 of
the Civil List and Pension Act (Chapter 52),
resolves that the Schedule to the said Act be
varied by deleting the figures "$52,000",
"$594,010", "$135,270" and "$91,000" appearing in
the second column thereof and substituting
therefor the figures $56,320", "$667,020"
"$145,060" and "$14,050" respectively.
Sir, the provision approved under Classes I and
II of the Civil List is insufficient to meet
increasing expenses, such as the 9 per cent wage
supplement and the higher rate of Central
Provident Fund contributions. The increase under
Class III is mainly for improvements to the Istana
grounds. A smaller provision is required under
Class IV. The provision is for the purchase of
lawn
Column: 23
mowers and other equipment for the maintenance of
the grounds as well as two colour TV sets for the
use of guests. It is, therefore, necessary to
augment the provision for the Privy Purse from
$52,000 to $56,320; the provision for Salaries of
Personal Staff' from $594,010 to $667,020; and the
provision for Expenses of Household from $135,270
to $145,060. The provision for Special Services is
to be reduced from $91,000 to $14,050.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Parliament, pursuant to section 7 of
the Civil List and Pension Act (Chapter 52),
resolves that the Schedule to the said Act be
varied by deleting the figures "$52,000",
"$594,010", "$135,270" and "$91,000" appearing in
the second column thereof and substituting
therefor the' figures "$56,320", "$667,020",
"$145,060" and "$14,050" respectively.
Column: 23
ANNUAL BUDGET STATEMENT
3.17 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move,
"That Parliament approves the financial policy of
the Government for the financial year, 1st April,
1974 to 31st March, 1975."
Sir, following the practice I started last year,
I have asked and you have agreed that my Economic
Survey of Singapore in 1973 be distributed in
advance to Honourable Members for their detailed
study. I crave your indulgence and theirs once
again to have my remarks extended in the
Parliamentary record by the inclusion of this
Survey as the first part of my Budget Statement. I
have also asked for the distribution to hon.
Members of the first 30 pages of my Budget
Statement, as I propose with your permission to
also skip some of the paragraphs in the hope that
they will also be extended in the report in
Hansard.
Column: 24
Economic Survey of Singapore in 1973
Preliminary estimates show that Singapore's Gross
National Product (GNP) at current prices grew in
1973 by $1,832.7 million to $9,892.9 million, at
an annual growth rate of 22.7 per cent. Allowing
for the large price increases during the year,
real GNP probably grew by only 11 per cent, which
is not altogether surprising considering the many
uncertainties in the international scene,
particularly those caused by the "oil crisis".
I propose therefore, as in previous years, to
survey external developments of direct bearing on
Singapore's welfare before analysing the State of
the Domestic Economy in 1973.
Survey of international Economic Events
International economic developments in the past
two years have shown by their effects on the world
economy the strong interdependence of all
countries, but more especially of those which
depend substantially upon international trade,
capital flows and tourist spending for the
generation of domestic output and employment.
Singapore, by virtue of its size and geographic
location, cannot help but be influenced by
external economic conditions.
"Oil Crisis"
In terms of frequency and intensity, the economic
crises of 1973 surpassed those of the previous
year. Of greatest impact was the "oil crisis"
which threatened the very fabric of Japan's
prosperity. The "economic miracle" of its rapid,
sustained development post-war was worked on the
increasingly larger importation of cheap petroleum
energy resources for its industries, mainly from
the Middle East. Although less dependent on oil
supplies for its economies, other major industrial
countries including the United Kingdom, West
Germany and France, and to a lesser extent, the
United States, were not spared. The warning signs
of impending petroleum shortages had appeared some
time before but the "oil
Column: 25
crisis" was actually triggered off by an
announcement by the Arab oil-producing countries
in October 1973 that oil would be embargoed
against certain countries and that production
would be reduced by 5 per cent every month with
effect from the end of September. In November, the
cutback was proposed to be raised to 25 per cent,
but was subsequently relaxed by 10 per cent in
December. The real problem remained, however, in
the phenomenal increases in oil prices. Since
October, the posted prices of crude oil (on which
taxes and royalties to the oil-producing countries
are calculated) had been escalating, threatening
oil-consuming countries with catastrophic balance
of payments problems. The unilateral increase of
70 per cent in posted prices by the Gulf States in
October 1973 was followed by further increases in
December 1973, bringing the posted prices to
US$11.60 per barrel, a four-fold increase compared
to the pre-October prices.
The production cutback, oil embargo and the high
oil prices accentuated the underlying recessionary
pressures on major industrialised countries
already existing before the oil crisis and it was
feared that the economic growth of the major
industrialised countries would be severely
affected.
Economic Slow-down in the Industrial Countries
The boom conditions which prevailed in the major
industrial countries in the latter half of 1972
continued into 1973; the average growth in real
GNP for these countries was estimated to have
increased by 6.5 per cent as compared with 5.5 per
cent the previous year. The rate of growth in the
two halves of 1973, however, differed
considerably. Real output in the first half of the
year accelerated as expansionary policies adopted
earlier began to take effect. In the second half,
there was a tapering off, with real growth
estimated at 4.5 per cent against 7.2 per cent in
the first half. Several factors contributed to the
slower growth rate. To counter inflation, several
countries had adopted restrictive measures
Column: 26
which subsequently curbed growth as
aggregate demand moderated. Physical constraints,
including high rates of capacity utilization and
tightness in labour markets, set limits to
continuing expansion. The growth momentum was
further checked when the oil crisis developed
towards the end of the year.
Worldwide inflation
1973 was also characterised by high prices
throughout the world. An excessive demand for
primary commodities reflecting the upsurge in
economic activities propelled prices upwards,
while a shortfall in agricultural output and
subsequent steep increases in food prices
reinforced the inflationary momentum. Despite the
later anti-inflationary policies adopted by the
major industrial countries, prices continued to
spiral. The GNP deflator (a commonly used
indicator of the inflation rate) rose in the
United States by 7.1 per cent in 1973 (against 3.3
per cent in 1972), Japan 10.5 per cent (4.8 per
cent), West Germany 6.2 per cent (6.1 per cent)
and the industrial countries as a whole 6.9 per
cent (4.7 per cent). Consumer prices rose at even
higher rates, being 8.4 per cent for the United
States (compared to 3.5 per cent in 1972), Japan
19.9 per cent (4.8 per cent) and West Germany 8.3
per cent (5.8 per cent). The developing countries
were not spared, as the rapid price increases were
transmitted to them via imports. In 1973, consumer
prices rose in Hong Kong by something of the order
of 24 per cent against 6.1 per cent in 1972 and
9.5 per cent against 4.9 per cent in Taiwan.
Singapore's own rise in consumer prices over the
two years of 22.9 per cent and 2.1 per cent did
not therefore appear excessive, having regard to
the fact of our being non-food producers.
International Trade
Parallel with the upswing in economic activity in
1973, international trade registered marked
increases. In terms of volume, world trade was
estimated to have risen by 13.6 per cent compared
to 8.6 per cent for 1972. In terms of
Column: 27
value in US Dollars, the growth of international
trade was even more remarkable with an increase of
over 37 per cent or more than twice the rate of
the previous year. The increase reflects the
depreciation of the US Dollar for the larger part
of the year as well as the high rate of inflation.
However, this rapid expansion in world trade was
accompanied by growing shortages of certain
commodities and policies restricting exports.
What could be the most significant event in 1973
relating to international trade set a hopefully
opposite trend away from restrictive policies. At
the Multilateral Trade Negotiations (MTN)
Ministerial Meeting in Tokyo, in September 1973,
countries including non-GATT members agreed to
enter into multilateral trade negotiations aimed
at the expansion and liberalization of world trade
with consideration also to increasing the exports
of developing countries to developed countries.
However, as progress in the MTN would be dependent
on so many factors, including an early solution to
the problems of the disordered international
monetary system, it was expected that negotiations
would be extended over a couple of years. Any
assessment of the outcome of the MTN would
therefore he premature at this stage.
Among other developments of note in 1973 was the
entry of Britain into the European Common Market,
when she began to align her customs tariffs to
those of the EEC, and to phase out her
Commonwealth preferences. Singapore's exports to
the United Kingdom were affected, though not
severely. As against this, we were able, together
with our ASEAN neighbours, to secure the EEC's in-principle agreement for improvements to its
Generalised System of Preferences for our exports,
especially in regarding as within the percentage
requirements of its rules of origin of products,
the proportion contributed by cumulative
manufacture in countries of the ASEAN region
instead of by manufature
Column: 28
within Singapore alone. The EEC also
agreed to recognise Singapore's special position
as a Market for primary commodities produced in
the region.
International Monetary Situation
In my Budget Statement last year, I made
reference to 1972 as a year of high monetary
instability and to the unsettling effects of
currency developments in early 1973. The
subsequent part of 1973 witnessed no significant
improvement in the situation. In fact, the oil
crisis during its period of buildup and subsequent
development added further elements of uncertainty
and instability to the monetary situation.
Following the devaluation of the US Dollar in
February for the second time in 14 months and the
floating of major currencies of the world, the US
Dollar continued to weaken for some months after
its devaluation and only strengthened towards the
closing months of the year. These developments had
their repercussions on Singapore, for the earlier
weakness of the US Dollar led to a large
speculative capital inflow, with inflationary
effects caused by domestic over-liquidity. The
need to curb this inflow, coupled with concern
over imported inflation, led to the decision to
float the Singapore Dollar on June 21, 1973.
Several other countries revalued their currencies
in 1973 citing the curtailment of inflation as the
main reason. These countries included the
Netherlands, Norway, Australia and New Zealand.
The US Dollar staged a dramatic recovery towards
the end of 1973 as her balance of trade improved
and as her own large domestic energy sources gave
rise to a general expectation that the US would be
relatively less badly hit by the oil crisis than
other industrial countries.
The depreciation of the Japanese yen in late 1973
resulted from a deteriorating balance of payments
as well as the threat of economic dislocation
arising from the Arab countries' oil cutbacks. In
the United Kingdom, the Pound continued to weaken
in the face of
Column: 29
industrial unrest, and intensified inflationary
pressures. The French franc and the Italian lira
also showed weakness stemming mainly from
industrial unrest and certain political factors.
These violent changes in major currency exchange
rates point to the need for an early and
satisfactory reform of the international monetary
system. However, only minor progress was made by
the IMF and its Committee of Twenty during 1973.
The first outline of reform was presented to the
Board of Governors of the Fund at the IMF Annual
Meeting at Nairobi in September 1973. Discussion
of the changes recommended was taken up by
technical groups. Developments since the IMF
Annual Meeting have changed somewhat the outlook
for reform. First, the termination of the 1968 two-tier gold agreement followed by the termination of
the IMF Agreement on South African gold sales to
finance payments deficits indicate some
recognition of the desire to de-sterilize gold
reserves for use by central banks and the urgency
of agreeing on the future role of gold vis-a-vis
reserve currencies. Secondly, the effect of the
energy crisis would probably be to delay the
deadline for Agreement of Reform originally set
for July 31, 1974 by up to 1«-2 years. Moreover,
balance of payments difficulties caused by the
energy crisis have changed the positions on reform
which various countries have taken. Some of them
will no doubt re-examine the effect on their
individual interests of the reform proposals.
Nevertheless, the current economic uncertainties
indicate the desirability of reaching an interim
solution which could be further developed and
modified over a period of time until a complete
restructuring of the international monetary system
is achieved. There is some consensus that in such
a system, the existing flexibility for adjustments
in exchange rates would be useful in cushioning
any sudden shocks caused by extreme balance of
payments difficulties arising from the massive
increase in the petroleum import bill of oil-consuming countries.
Column: 30
State of the Economy
I now turn to the domestic economy. We shall look
first at Singapore's performance as measured by
its Gross Domestic Product.
In 1973, according to preliminary figures, our
Gross Domestic Product at current prices grew at
the record rate of 22.0 per cent. But inflation,
which had over the years been at very moderate
rates in Singapore, even when it was rampant
elsewhere, finally caught up with us. The very
rapid rate of GDP growth is attributable partly to
the large price increases in 1973. Discounting
these increases, the growth of GDP at 1972 prices
is estimated at only around 11 per cent, which is
lower than the average growth of 12.5 per cent for
the past four years. In analysing the main
components of Singapore's growth which I now
propose to do, it is necessary, if one is not to
be lulled by the apparently expansive boom
conditions of 1973 into a state of euphoria, that
one should remember to mentally deflate all the
figures which are given at current prices to
arrive at the more sober real growth rates.
Gross Domestic Product by Industrial Origin
The manufacturing sector continued to be the
leading growth sector in our economy. Its
contribution to the Gross Domestic Product
increased to 26.2 per cent in 1973 from 24.6 per
cent in 1972. The growth in construction slowed
down in 1973, resulting in a slight decline of its
share in total GDP from 7.6 per cent in 1972 to
6.7 per cent in 1973. This relatively poorer
performance of the construction sector was,
however, compensated by the performance of the
wholesale and retail trade sector which grew at
25.8 per cent compared to 6.1 per cent the
previous year.
Manufacturing Sector
The manufacturing industries contributed a total
of $2,378.8 million to GDP in 1973, an increase of
$545.6 million or 29.8 per cent (compared with
Column: 31
28.2 per cent in 1972 and 25.0 per cent in 1971).
This increase in the value added by the
manufacturing sector accounted for about one-third
of the total increase of $1,637.9 million in GDP.
As a result of its rapid growth, the manufacturing
share of GDP has increased from 16.7 per cent in
1967 to 26.2 per cent in 1973, and with its direct
effect in generating trade in the imports of raw
materials and exports of manufactures, and its
indirect effect on the services sector, maintained
its position as the most dynamic sector of our
economy.
Our manufacturing industries continued to show
increasing orientation towards exports and higher
quality products. Overall, some 45 per cent of our
domestic manufactures were exported. In 1973,
developed countries continued to be our main
export market absorbing about half of our domestic
exports, as compared to less than one-fifth in
1967.
While increases in output and value added were
registered in all the major industry groups, some
industries have continued to be the mainstays of
the manufacturing sector. Petroleum refining is
still the largest individual industry in the value
of its products, its contribution to total output
of the manufacturing sector accounting for 25.6
per cent. Its rate of growth in output was 9.9 per
cent in 1973, compared to 8.2 per cent in 1972.
However, the contribution of petroleum refining to
the total value added to the product by the
manufacturing process in Singapore has declined
from 15.7 per cent in 1972 to 13.4 per cent in
1973. The electrical machinery industry
contribution is larger than that of petroleum
refining, its value added accounting for 23.1 per
cent of total value added. Petroleum refining has
in this respect also been overtaken by the
transport equipment industry (including
shipbuilding and ship-repairing). The manufacture
of textiles and garments and the more traditional
food, beverages and tobacco industries are other
large sectors taking 9.8 per cent and 8.9 per cent
respectively.
Column: 32
1973 has therefore been a good year for
Singapore's manufacturing sector, in spite of the
uncertainties prevailing in the international
monetary situation as well as the "oil crisis"
which developed towards the end of the year. Our
strategy of promoting high technology and export-oriented industries has also begun to show
encouraging results as an examination of the
foreign investments committed in 1973 will show.
Total investment commitments in manufacturing
rose from $336 million in 1972 to $819 million
last year, an increase of 144 per cent. 01 these
commitments, the foreign investment component rose
from $255 million to $602 million, an increase of
136 per cent. Most of the investment commitments
were for higher technology industries, in
particular petroleum and petrochemical products,
chemical products, metal products/mechanical
engineering and professional, scientific, and
precision equipment. These industries together
accounted for 86.7 per cent of the total
investments committed in 1973.
Construction
The construction industry in 1973 faced shortages
as well as high prices of labour and building
materials, and managed to grow by only 9.1 per
cent as compared with 39.1 per cent in 1972. Its
percentage share of GDP accordingly dropped from
7.6 per cent in 1972 to 6.7 per cent in 1973.
Private non-residential construction as a whole
showed a decline of $26.5 million in 1973 or a
negative growth of 6.7 per cent primarily due to
the completion of work on new oil refineries.
However, other types of nonresidential buildings
such as shopping and office complexes registered
increased growth. In the public sector, the growth
was mainly attributable to the construction of
public housing which grew by $86.2 million or 34.8
per cent. Some contribution to growth in
construction was also provided by the relatively
high increase of 21.2 per cent in private
residential construction.
Column: 33
Wholesale and Retail Trade
The contribution from Wholesale and Retail Trade
activities which had been slowing down for the
past five years picked up in 1973, increasing at
the record rate of 25.8 per cent which is more
than four times the rate achieved in 1972 and
about 1« times the average rate of growth for the
period 1967-73. As a result, the share of this
sector in GDP grew from 26.3 per cent in 1972 to
27.1 per cent in 1973. The main cause for the high
rate of increase in 1973 was the world commodity
boom, and in particular the high produce prices
especially those of rubber and other raw
materials.
This is shown by the fact that of the total
increase of $505.8 million in contribution to GDP
by this sector, entrepot trade accounted for
$259.5 million, while domestic trade accounted for
the remaining $246.3 million. The value added for
the entrepot trade sector registered a growth of
38.4 per cent in 1973 (as compared to a negative
growth of 0.8 per cent in 1972) while domestic
trade grew by 19.2 per cent (as compared to 10.1
per cent in 1972). As a result of its large growth
in prices, not in volume, the relative share of
the entrepot trade in the total GDP which had been
registering a declining trend since 1969 showed an
increase from 9.1 per cent in 1972 to 10.3 per
cent in 1973, while that of the domestic trade
sector in the total GDP showed a marginal decline
from 17.2 per cent to 16.8 per cent.
External Trade
The value of total external trade in 1973 soared
to new heights with increased prices registering a
record increase of 36.9 per cent over 1972 which
more than trebled the 11.8 per cent accomplished
the previous year despite the world currency
problems and energy crisis. Of the total value of
$21,476 million of external trade, $12,562 million
was imports and $8,914 million exports. For the
second year running, the rate of increase of
exports exceeded that for
Column: 34
imports, the former reaching a spectacular 45.0
per cent and the latter 31.7 per cent. Both,
however, showed higher rates of growth as compared
to 14.5 per cent and 10.1 per cent over 1972,
respectively.
The vigorous expansion of external trade in 1973
was due to the larger volume of trade with our
trading partners, the significant price increases
in most primary commodities such as rubber, palm
oil and timber, as well as the general worldwide
inflation. High prices of primary commodities also
accounted for the very high growth of re-exports
in 1973 of 35.3 per cent far exceeding the
corresponding rate of 1.7 per cent achieved the
previous year. It is heartening to note that even
after eliminating the effects of price increases,
total exports still registered an increase of 14.1
per cent which is as high as that attained in
1972, while re-exports grew at 6.0 per cent
(thrice the rate of 1.7 per cent achieved in
1972). On the other hand, the growth in imports
after discounting for price increases was slightly
lower at some 6.2 per cent compared to 10.1 per
cent in the previous year. The high growth in
exports was made possible mainly by the rapid
expansion in our domestic exports, the bulk of
which comprises local manufactures. At current
prices, domestic exports reached $4,791 million in
1973, representing an increase of 54.5 per cent.
Malaysia remained Singapore's leading trading
partner, accounting for 17 per cent of our total
trade based on estimates of January-November 1973
figures. The currency split, the severance of the
rubber market, the separation of the joint stock
exchange as well as the establishment of
independent timber boards in Singapore and
Malaysia emphasised further the separateness of
the two economies. These have had only a minimal
effect upon Singapore's trade performance. Our
trade with Malaysia remained buoyant. Our next
three largest trading partners in order of
importance continued to be the United States,
Japan and the United Kingdom.
Column: 35
Government Services and Public Utilities
In 1973, Government services contributed $559.7
million to GDP, an increase of 18.2 per cent over
that in 1972. This rate of growth was almost
treble the previous year's rate of 6.7 per cent
and was also higher than the average annual growth
rate of 13.3 per cent for the 6-year period in
1967-73. However, the share of Government services
in the total GDP was 6.2 per cent for 1973, which
was slightly lower than that of 6.3 per cent for
1972. The main increases were in respect of
services provided for internal security and
defence, education and health.
The public utilities sector maintained a steady
growth rate of 13.8 per cent which is slightly
higher than the 13.1 per cent achieved in 1972.
Its share of GDP, however, declined marginally
from 2.3 per cent to 2.2 per cent.
Ownership of Dwellings
The value added by ownership of dwellings to GDP
increased by about 19.9 per cent from $343.2
million in 1972 to $411.4 million in 1973. The
relatively high growth rate was, however, lower
than the 24.5 per cent achieved in 1972, leading
therefore to a slight decline in its share of GDP
from 4.6 per cent to 4.5 per cent.
Other Services
The contribution of this sector to GDP increased
by $315.6 million or 16.6 per cent to reach
$2,221.9 million in 1973. The performance of this
sector was attributable mainly to the growth of
the banking and insurance, and tourism services in
the private sector, as well as Government-controlled enterprises, such as the Port of
Singapore Authority and the Singapore Airlines.
Reflecting the Government's effort to promote
Singapore as a major financial centre of Asia, the
contribution of the banking and insurance sector
to GDP increased by $35.3 million or 23.8 per cent
in 1973. Because of its relevance to the
Government's monetary policies and the effects of
such policies on our
Column: 36
Balance of Payments, I propose to deal with the
growth of our financial institutions at some
length later in this Statement.
The tourism sector registered a substantial
increase in its value added of 27.9 per cent (as
compared to 26.1 per cent registered in 1972),
increasing its share of GDP from 5.5 per cent in
1972 to 5.8 per cent in 1973. This high growth
rate is the result of the rapid growth of tourist
arrivals. The number of visitors to Singapore by
air and sea passed the million mark in 1973. A
total of 1,134,000 visitors (including 149,800
Malaysian visitors from West Malaysia) arrived in
Singapore by air and sea, representing an increase
of 28.9 per cent over the corresponding total for
1972. By country of residence, Australia
maintained the leading position among major
overseas tourists-generating markets for the third
year running, with 173,900 visitors giving an
increase of 25.0 per cent over 1972. However, the
fastest growing market was Japan which generated
113,400 visitors or an increase of 59.1 per cent
over the preceding year.
Foreign military expenditure showed an increase
of 11.4 percent, from $141.1 million in 1972 to
$157.2 million in 1973. However, as a component of
total GDP, its share declined from 1.9 per cent in
1972 to 1.7 per cent in 1973.
Gross Domestic Expenditure
Let us now examine the other indicator of
economic health, the Gross Domestic Expenditure.
In 1973, estimated Gross Domestic Expenditure at
current prices, consisting of consumption and
capital formation, showed an increase of $1,655.3
million, or 21.2 per cent over that in 1972, to
reach a total of $9,450.6 million. The higher rate
of increase compared to that experienced in 1972
of about 15.5 per cent is to a large extent
because of price increases especially in
consumption goods. The high growth rate of GDE was
reflected mainly in the relatively higher growth
of consumption of goods and services of 25.4 per
cent as compared to that of fixed capital
formation of 11.6 per cent.
Column: 37
Consumption
Both private and public consumption grew
considerably in 1973, the former by 25.7 per cent
from $4,545.1 million in 1972 to $5,714.3 million
in 1973, and the latter by 23.7 per cent from
$905.2 million to $1,119.8 million. Inflation
especially in imported food prices was responsible
for a large part of this growth. The corresponding
growth rates in 1972 were 11.2 per cent and 14.5
per cent, respectively, which had already begun to
reflect price increases although at much lower
levels than 1973.
While every major component of private
consumption showed large increases in 1973, three
components, food, clothing and transport and
communications registered the fastest growth with
rates of more than twice or three times those of
1972. Expenditure on food, accounting for 15.8 per
cent of total GDE, grew by $366.3 million or 32.5
per cent to $1,491.9 million, reflecting the
substantial rise in prices of food, especially
rice. Clothing expenditure increased by $208.2
million or 31.6 per cent to $867.6 million.
Expenditure on transport and communications
increased by $179.5 million or 28.9 per cent to
$801.5 million. Another component of consumption
expenditure that more than doubled the growth rate
in 1972 was expenditure on beverages and tobacco
which grew by 19.7 per cent to $442.3 million in
1973.
Gross Fixed Capital Formation
Building, other construction and works comprised
46.1 per cent of the total fixed capital formation
in 1973. Capital formation in machinery and
equipment, largely directed towards expanding the
manufacturing sector, accounted for another 35.4
per cent while expenditure on transport equipment
accounted for the remaining 18.5 per cent. Of the
three components of capital formation, expenditure
on transport equipment registered the highest rate
of increase of 61.8 per cent as compared to only
3.9 per cent in 1972. A large part of the increase
was due to the purchase of aircraft. Expenditure
on buildings,
Column: 38
other construction and works grew by 9.2 per cent,
which was disappointingly low compared with an
increase of 39.9 per cent in 1972. So was the
expenditure on machinery and equipment, which, in
fact, declined by 1.6 per cent as compared to an
increase of 19.1 per cent in 1972. The dismal
performance of these two categories of expenditure
was due partly to the fact that the balance of the
construction work for the oil refineries was
completed in early 1973, and partly perhaps to the
fall in investment commitments in 1972 arising
from currency uncertainties.
The overall slower growth of Gross Fixed Capital
Formation was experienced by both the public and
private sectors, which grew by only 15.6 per cent
(as compared to 54.8 per cent in 1972) and 9.8 per
cent (16.0 per cent), respectively.
It is disquieting that the growth in 1973 should
have been stimulated mainly by large increases in
consumption expenditure while gross capital
formation showed relatively low growth. Moreover,
even the low growth achieved in gross fixed
capital formation was contributed largely by
expenditure on transport equipment and only
marginally by machinery and equipment. The latter,
in fact, registered a decline. Growth in 1973 was
regrettably generated substantially by increased
consumption spending, which was manifested in
higher imports, while investments declined from
31.5 per cent in 1972 to 28.8 per cent of GDP in
1973.
Inflation and Prices
Though I mentioned it briefly in the early part
of this Statement, it is necessary to expand on
the problem of inflation. This is in the main of
external origin. The consumer price index rose by
an average of 22.9 per cent in 1973, compared to
2.1 per cent in 1972. Food prices rose even faster
at 35.5 per cent, compared to 2.7 per cent in
1972. Even this did not reflect the increase in
price of rice, the staple food of the majority in
Singapore. Assisted by a ban on exports from
Thailand, the retail price of
Column: 39
Thai rice rose spectacularly from 35 cents in
December 1972 to $1.07 cents per kati in December
1973, or an increase of more than three times.
This was the sharpest increase in prices since
1960 when the consumer price index was first
introduced. Most of this inflation was caused by
external forces, outside our control. Estimates
based on the unit value index for imports revealed
that import prices rose by 12.5 per cent in 1973
while food import prices rose by as much as 19.1
per cent. Actual import price increases have, of
course, been higher than these indices showed, as
the estimates have a downwards bias. As a very
open economy which imports most of its food and
raw material requirements from other countries,
Singapore is inevitably affected by any rise in
their prices. Inflation measured by consumer
prices in the advanced countries has been running
at rates of between 8.0 per cent to 20 per cent. A
good indicator of the worldwide inflationary
pressures can be found in the World Commodity
Price Index compiled by the Economist. This shows
that the price of food commodities rose by 56.5
percentage points during 1973, a percentage
increase of 35 per cent over the same period one
year ago. The corresponding figures for fibres
were 109.1 percentage points and 56 per cent, and
for all items 73.3 percentage points and 51 per
cent, respectively.
However, domestic forces worked to accentuate the
"imported inflation". While increases in prices of
finished goods could be expected from the
increased cost of imports or of production
(including higher materials import cost), the
inflationary situation gave rise to greater
opportunities for profiteering, and traders,
including producers, often marked up prices higher
than required by the increase in costs. On the
other hand, consumers often over-reacted to the
inflationary situation by panic buying and
hoarding of certain commodities, creating or
aggravating a tight supply situation, and causing
the much higher prices they feared.
Column: 40
The Government took whatever measures were
practical to tackle the inflation problem locally.
Apart from monetary and fiscal policies, which
will be discussed below, the Government thought it
desirable to diversify the sources of our most
essential food supplies as well as of the raw
materials for our industries. It decided to revive
the scheme for a rice stockpile which would
eliminate any fear of shortages by ensuring
availability of supplies for six months and would
result in more stable prices for consumers. Also,
the Sugar Industry of Singapore, in which
Government has an interest, by prudent forward
purchasing, had assured the availability and price
stability of its sugar supplies. Some panic buying
of sugar occurred on one or two occasions during
the year, but confidence was quickly restored by
plentiful supplies being quickly made available by
the Company at the same unchanged price of 45
cents per kati, which it undertook to maintain.
Moves to stamp out or reduce profiteering which
was undoubtedly the cause of these and other panic
situations have, so far, proved difficult.
However, credit must be given to the Community
Centres which helped to sell rice and publicise
its availability at reasonable prices, to the NTUC
for the good start it made in helping to ensure
lower prices for consumers through its
establishment of Welcome Supermarkets, and to the
Armed Forces which also opened its first SAFE
Supermarket. These actions served notice upon our
wholesalers and retailers that their greedy and
anti-social actions will lead to consumer support
going permanently to public and quasi-public
enterprise and corporations and affect adversely
their system of private enterprise, which if not
abused during periods of shortages, is the most
efficient as it allows for free competition.
Employment and Wages
I shall now touch briefly on the employment
position in 1973. It is estimated that more than
50,000 new jobs were created in 1973, the bulk of
which was found in manufacturing (24,400), trade
Column: 41
(11,700), transport and communications (4,200) and
other services (7,300). Such a massive new job
creation was, however, not in accord with our
strategy of raising the productivity of labour.
This increased by only 3.6 per cent in 1973, less
than half that achieved during 1970-72 which was
7.7 per cent, a result which runs counter to our
objective of enhancing efficiency through the
upgrading of industries and orderly but
significantly large enough wage increases. Home
market supply activities (wholesale, retail and
other services activities) in which labour
productivity was far below the national average,
continued to absorb large numbers of workers which
should, for the greater part, have gone into
manufacturing.
The National Wages Council increase for the
lowest paid workers in 1973 was 9 per cent with no
setoff of wage benefits given under normal yearly
increments in wage schemes. But even this,
equivalent to an increase of about 15 per cent
monthly wages, was in due course offset by the
rapid rise in the cost of living which, according
to the present imperfect cost of living index,
averaged 22.9 per cent last year. Real wages for
workers therefore declined. Furthermore, as prices
increased, on the very rough figures available, it
is thought that business profit margins for the
manufacturing sector as a whole expanded
considerably over the previous year. Therefore,
despite having to pay the NWC agreed increased
wages in 1973, employers apparently did not feel
sufficiently induced to economise on scarce
labour.
Domestic Monetary Situation
We must now examine our domestic monetary
situation. Singapore continued to grow vigorously
as a financial centre in 1973 despite anti-inflationary policies restraining credit expansion
and the influx of US dollars. As Singapore
expanded its international financial links and
developed increasing sophistication in its
domestic monetary institutions and instruments,
the monetary and other sectors became more
interdependent. It is therefore of interest to
review the
Column: 42
major developments in the domestic monetary sector
in the past year.
Financial Institutions
1973 witnessed a growing sophistication in the
development of our money and capital markets, with
the establishment of 11 new banks and one merger,
bringing the total number of banks as at the end
of December to 54. One local bank (the first local
bank to be formed since the establishment of the
Development Bank of Singapore in 1968) commenced
operation in February 1974. Total bank assets in
1973 grew by 31 per cent which, although lower
than the 35 per cent achieved in 1972, was
attained in spite of monetary measures to curb
credit expansion. Total deposits increased by 23
per cent, slightly lower than in 1972. Total
assets of finance companies rose at a higher
annual growth rate of 33 per cent compared with 23
per cent in 1972. Deposits also grew at a higher
annual rate of 25 per cent compared with 24 per
cent the previous year while total loans and
advances grew at the even higher rate of 45 per
cent as against 28 per cent for 1972. Hire
purchase finance and housing loans again absorbed
the major portion of finance companies' credit
operations.
In its fifth year, the Asian Dollar Market
continued to expand rapidly, stimulated partly by
the Government's tax concessions and exchange
control liberalisation measures. The market's
resources swelled to over $15.5 billion (over
US$6.3 billion) by the end of 1973, showing a
growth rate of almost 85 per cent during the year.
Although in percentage terms this is lower than
the growth rates of previous years, in absolute
terms, the increase is still the largest annual
increase so far and the Asian Dollar Market
continued to generate international confidence and
interest in Singapore as a financial centre. There
were significant developments also in the Asian
Dollar bond market with the floating in early
November 1973 of the United Overseas Bank US$30
million convertible Asian Dollar bearer bonds, and
in early December 1973 of the
Column: 43
US$10 million Asian Dollar bonds by the Orient
Leasing Company of Japan. Further, Asian Currency
Units (ACUs) have been participating in an
increased number of consortia loans in 1973. As at
the end of 1973, 17 merchant banks, actively
involved in the underwriting business and in the
Asian Dollar Market, supplemented and complimented
the services provided by banks. The three discount
houses grew significantly with total assets
expanding more than seven times, from $49 million
as at the end of November 1972 to $369 million as
at the end of December 1973.
The year 1973 saw two events affecting the Stock
Exchange in Singapore, namely, the establishment
of the Securities Industry Council in January
1973, and the break-up of the joint Stock Exchange
of Malaysia and Singapore in May 1973 along with
the termination of the Currency Interchangeability
Agreement with Malaysia and the new exchange
control measures imposed by Malaysia. However,
practically all the counters which were listed in
the previous joint Stock Exchange were listed in
the Stock Exchange of Singapore throughout the
rest of the year. The rate of new listings of
Singapore incorporated companies was also stepped
up. The new Stock Exchange therefore went off to a
good start in June 1973 and the current depressed
state of the Stock Market must be regarded as
contemporary with similar conditions in major
stock markets round the world.
Monetary Policies
In the light of the uncertainties of the
international currency markets and the
inflationary pressures within the economy, our
monetary policies were designed to stabilise the
economy without adverse effects on our growth as a
financial centre. Anti-inflationary monetary
measures implemented in 1973 included the
imposition of a 5 per cent (subsequently raised to
9 per cent) Special Deposit on the net foreign
liabilities of banks, the raising of the minimum
reserve ratios for banks and
Column: 44
finance companies and the increase of bank
interest rates for deposits and loans by « per
cent in April and subsequently by another 1 per
cent in December. Banks were also requested by the
Monetary Authority of Singapore in early 1973 to
exercise caution in extending loans for
speculation in the then feverishly bullish stock
market.
These measures were intended to counter unstable
developments in the international monetary
situation which were contributing increasingly to
imported inflation in Singapore. Despite the
devaluation of the US Dollar for the second time
in February 1973, the US Dollar continued to
remain under speculative pressure in international
currency markets. The situation developed into one
of widespread floating exchange rates in March. As
the major EEC currencies and the Japanese yen
floated upwards against the US Dollar to which the
Singapore dollar was then pegged, an artificially
low external value resulted for the Singapore
dollar, which thereby attracted a large
speculative inflow of foreign funds into
Singapore, swelling the already excessive
liquidity in the economy. It was therefore decided
in June 1973 to allow the Singapore dollar to
float upwards to stem any further inflow of
unwanted funds. The Singapore Dollar went up to
11.8 per cent over par exchange rate with the US
Dollar in July 1973. At present it is ranging
between 2-3 per cent above par.
At the same time as an anti-inflationary monetary
policy was adopted, the need to promote a healthy
growth of the monetary sector was recognised.
Measures to stimulate the growth of financial
institutions included the reduction of corporate
tax on income earned on offshore loans from 40 per
cent to 10 per cent, exemption from tax on
interest received from Asian Dollar bonds issued
in Singapore and the waiver of stamp duty on Asian
Dollar bond certificates and promissory notes
Column: 45
issued by or in favour of or negotiated through
merchant banks. Exchange controls were liberalised
in July 1973 and Singapore residents were given
permission to invest up to specified limits in the
Asian Dollar Market. The Monetary Authority
continued to provide the discount houses with
lender of last resort facilities with occasional
intervention in the money market in order to
smoothen out unhealthy fluctuations. Priority was
also given for the establishment of a training
programme to upgrade the skills of bank officers.
Balance of Payments
In spite of uncertainties in international trade
and of monetary instability, our balance of
payments for 1973 continued to be favourable,
although the overall surplus of $333.6 million for
1973 was lower than the $582.6 million surplus for
1972. One reason which slowed down the further
accumulation of official foreign reserves during
1973 was that in June 1973, the Singapore dollar
was floated upwards to relieve the pressure caused
by an abnormal influx of US dollars due to
international investors seeking a safer currency
than the then weak US Dollar. Under the regime of
a floating exchange rate, there was less
speculative incentive to convert into Singapore
dollars.
The persistent trade deficit, which increased in
1973 by $301 million to $3,471 million, was
financed largely, as in the past, by earnings from
the services sector as well as by capital inflows.
Recorded net earnings from services increased by
$102 million to $901 million, largely on account
of higher net receipts from investment income,
travel and other transportation.
In the capital account, net long-term capital
imports fell by $117.6 million to $622.5 million.
Government official long-term borrowing also
declined as there were in 1973 no substantial new
loans of the nature of the DM bond or Asian Dollar
loan of 1972. Private long-term capital, however,
increased by $24.9 million to $577.1 million.
Column: 46
Official Reserves
The year ended with Singapore's total official
assets standing at $5,707.5 million, an increase
of $776.6 million from the $4,930.9 million held
at the end of 1972. The healthy state of
Singapore's reserves will stand us in good stead
to weather any storms which the oil crisis, the
worldwide inflation, or the international monetary
and balance of payments uncertainties may bring in
1974.
[The Minister for Finance continued --]
It would be useful for me here to recapitulate
the main points of this Economic Survey and to
state what I consider to be its main conclusions.
The Economic Survey has shown that despite
adverse circumstances, Singapore performed
reasonably well in 1973 to achieve the high growth
in Gross Domestic Product (GDP) at current prices
of 22.0 per cent. We have not yet constructed an
accurate GDP deflator. An estimate of real growth
is around 11 per cent. Our leading growth sector,
manufacturing, continued to maintain its buoyancy,
growing at 29.8 per cent. External trade
registered a record increase of 36.9 per cent with
exports growing at a very high rate of 45.0 per
cent, exceeding the growth rate for imports of
31.7 per cent. The contribution to GDP of the
wholesale and retail trade sector (consisting of
entrepot and domestic trade) grew at 25.8 per cent
which was more than four times the growth achieved
in 1972. The value added by entrepot trade
increased at a record rate of 38.4 per cent while
that of domestic trade grew by 19.2 per cent.
Other Sectors registering high growth included
government services (which grew at 18.2 per cent),
public utilities (13.8 per cent), ownership of
dwellings (19.9 per cent), banking and insurance
(23.8 per cent), and tourism (27.9 per cent). The
contribution of foreign military expenditure to
GDP rose by 11.4 per cent. However, the
construction sector showed a poorer performance,
growing at only 9.1 per cent. The surplus in our
balance of payments was maintained although at a
Column: 47
reduced sum of $333.6 million, and our official
reserves ended the year with a healthy $5,707.5
million.
Though the economy expanded creditably in 1973,
there were major weaknesses or adverse factors in
our economic position. First, despite a full-employment situation, economic growth last year
was contributed largely by a quantitative increase
in the labour force rather than by increased
productivity. More than 50,000 new jobs were
created, representing an increase of 7.7 per cent
of the employed labour force. The value-added per
worker rose by only 3.6 per cent, less than half
that achieved over the period 1970-1972. This runs
counter to the results we expected from our policy
measures for an increasingly labour scarce
economy.
Secondly, the high growth of Gross Domestic
Expenditure was achieved largely through a rapid
growth of consumption of 25.4 per cent, while
gross fixed capital formation rose by only 11.6
per cent. Economic expansion was therefore
sustained mainly by rising consumption rather than
by increased savings channelled into productive
investments.
Thirdly, while there was high economic growth,
there were also strong inflationary conditions.
Consumer prices rose by an average of 22.9 per
cent over the previous year, largely the result of
importing worldwide inflation. As inflation for
many countries was at equally high or even higher
rates, our export competitiveness was fortunately
not jeopardized. However, the rising cost of
living severely affected the real income or
purchasing power of the earnings of our workers,
particularly those in the lower income groups.
Fourthly, there appeared to be no solution in
sight to the problems of a disordered
international monetary system, and the sharp
changes in rates and general uncertainties of the
major currencies.
And finally, 1973 saw the beginnings of the
energy crisis and the problems
Column: 48
which a reduction in oil supplies and higher oil
prices would bring upon all economic and social
activities as well as upon the international
balance of payments position of different nations.
Turning our attention from the economic scene in
1973 to that of the current year, what can we see
regarding our prospects for economic growth in
1974? And what are the broad economic policies
that are required to overcome the problems that we
are likely to face in the coming months?
In my earlier budgets, it was possible for me to
describe external factors such as international
inflationary conditions, monetary instability,
economic stagnation or recession as looming over
the horizon or posing a threat. But they never
posed as immediate threats to the continued
expansion of our domestic economy. We are no
longer in that, it seems to us now, happy
position. These recent external events have become
factors unfavourable to our domestic economy. The
problems carried over from 1973 which are
presented by the oil crisis, and by inter-related
worldwide inflation, monetary instability and
currency rate uncertainties, restrictions on
international trade and economic stagnation or
recession, will directly affect our internal
conditions either for growth or stagnation. Some
examination of the impact of these external
factors on our economy would therefore be useful
before we examine the purely domestic factors.
External Factors: The Oil Crisis
The world entered 1974 in a somewhat better state
in regard to oil supplies than it had dared to
hope during the earlier months of the oil crisis.
As a result of the decision in late December to
restore production cut-backs from 25 per cent to
15 per cent of the September 1973 level, the
threat of oil starvation in 1974 becomes somewhat
less likely. However, until a final settlement is
reached in the Middle East negotiations for peace,
it would be premature to assume that oil embargoes
Column: 49
and production cut-backs could not be extended and
reimposed or made even more severe than in the
past.
The problem of higher oil prices, in any case,
remains. The average price of crude oil is now
well over US$8 a barrel, a four-fold increase in
price over the pre-October 1973 rate. It may rise
even higher depending on the price which oil
producers may have to pay to the OPEC states for
what is known to the industry as "buy back" oil,
oil which producing countries are free to sell to
third parties if they choose. Some very high
prices indeed have been paid in a few auctions of
such oil, which could eventually influence oil
producers' and therefore oil consumers' prices.
High oil prices impose very large burdens on the
balance of payments of consumer nations. These
burdens on developing nations with limited foreign
reserves and rapidly dwindling foreign aid may
prove unmanageable. They also add to the already
severe inflationary pressures affecting most of
the economies of the world since the second half
of last year. Of course, they bring to the oil
producing countries greatly increased oil revenues
which they are unable to absorb by expenditure on
even massive development projects at home. The
resulting revenue surpluses accordingly accumulate
as very large holdings of external reserves,
estimated to grow at over $50 billion or more a
year. Reserves of such magnitude, unless
sterilized in long term asset holdings, are likely
to cause monetary instability and violent currency
rate fluctuations by its movements in large
capital flows and reflows, from currency to
currency seeking the most profitable or safest
investments.
These disturbances could have disastrous
international consequences. Much depends upon how
the large oil importing and exporting countries
react to the oil shortages and increased prices.
Already, there have been sharp movements in the
exchange rates of major currencies. The date for
the reform of the international monetary system
will be set back indefinitely as
Column: 50
the major developed countries turn from their
contemplation of its seemingly academic
complexities to grapple with their own urgent
monetary problems. An economic slowdown is
expected in the major industrial countries,
accentuating the trend which was developing even
before the oil crisis. According to the OECD
estimates, made in December, 1973, the forecast of
growth has been scaled down in the United States
to only 2 per cent in 1974 (from 6 per cent in
1973), in Japan to 8 per cent (from 11 per cent),
and in West Germany to 3 per cent (from 6 per
cent). If, in addition, the large oil importing
countries pursue beggar-thy-neighbour policies by
resorting to competitive devaluations to promote
exports and setting up trade barriers to curb
imports and reduce their balance of payments
deficits, then the world will head for a very
severe economic depression.
Fortunately, there are welcome signs of a
general, if not unanimous, recognition by both oil
consuming and producing nations that the problems
of energy shortages and pricing should be solved
by consultation together, and not by the attempts
of individual countries or groups of countries
acting alone without regard to their effects on
other countries. There is awareness also of the
need to avoid a disruption of the world trade and
monetary system. There even is growing acceptance
of a moral obligation by the oil producing
countries to channel part of their oil surpluses
through the IMF, the World Bank or other multi-national banks to the developing countries, in
particular, to assist them in their balance of
payments and development financing difficulties.
There is hope therefore of an accommodation and
adjustment between oil consuming and oil producing
nations, and of a new equilibrium between the
prices of oil and of other goods and services,
which will remove or reduce the present resort to
bartering with the oil producing nations and
restore the trade and payments functions once
again to the world economic system.
Such an equilibrium must, in any case, eventually
be reached even without
Column: 51
deliberate agreement. In the long term, the
price of oil must take into account the
possibilities and the cost of working previously
uneconomic oil deposits, of winning oil from shale
or tar sands, and of discovering large new oil
sources through the intense exploration which has
been stimulated in other areas. And it would also
certainly have regard to the ready availability
and cost of alternative proven sources of energy,
such as nuclear power.
Singapore's Economic Situation
Until such an equilibrium is reached, whether
sooner or later, each country must cope, as best
it can and without beggaring its neighbour, with
the problems as they affect its individual
economy. How will Singapore manage?
One effect of the oil crisis will be on our
balance of payments. Unless we can reduce our
present domestic consumption of oil of around 2
million tons annually, Singapore will have to
spend more than $290 million this year on oil
imports for purely domestic consumption equivalent
to 6 per cent of the value of Singapore's domestic
exports last year. If there is no serious downturn
in international trade, however, we may expect to
recover some of the increased cost of oil by
higher export earnings on those of our
manufactures, including petroleum products, which
use higher cost oil among their inputs. We need
not fear being undersold as our competitors will
also have to pass on such higher costs to their
customers. It is possible also that with the OPEC
countries' large oil revenues seeking
international investments, capital inflows into a
financial centre such as Singapore can be more
than sustained. However, if, by a combination of
adverse circumstances, we should end the year with
an overall adverse balance of payments for the
first time in many years, we shall, in any case,
have more than adequate reserves to tide us over
the period until stability returns into the
international economic system.
Another effect will be on the already serious
inflation in Singapore. The oil
Column: 52
industry has estimated that an increase of US$1 in
the price of crude oil would raise the cost of
living or the rate of inflation by 1 per cent in
industrialised countries. Though the impact would
be less for a country like Singapore, there is
unlikely to be any relief for us from the burden
of imported inflation this year or from the direct
effects of the higher price of oil on our own
manufactures. Inflation will, unfortunately, work
its relentless way into our economy through higher
prices in partially oil based products such as
chemical fertilisers for food; steel, cement and
other building materials; paper, synthetic
textiles, plastics and many other essential
commodities we have to import, and through the
escalating costs of transportation, public
utilities and other services. In spite of better
weather and better harvests, there appears also no
sign as yet of any substantial drop in the prices
of food grains or other agricultural commodities.
Perhaps exporters are holding back sales to keep
up high prices and importers are buying more than
their immediate needs to store against a poor
harvest.
There is very little one can do about such high
import prices except to ensure that these are not
aggravated by manipulation and profiteering. The
Government will take measures to minimise the
effects of inflation. Tariffs will be continually
reviewed for the purpose of removing or reducing
them, where possible, to curb inflation. More
consumer cooperatives and Welcome-type
supermarkets will be helped to set themselves up
in the main population centres. But, I strongly
urge that our people should restrain demand,
refraining from hoarding and purchasing in advance
of their normal requirements. People should become
more selective in their shopping for essential
commodities. Cutting down expenditures on
unnecessary purchases and increasing their savings
and channelling them into productive investments,
our people can help themselves to fight inflation.
At the same time, traders caught manipulating
supplies to raise prices, retailers giving short
weight of rice or bread will
Column: 53
find their business cut off by withdrawal of
supplies or licences to import or export.
However, price controls are not suitable as a
means of curbing inflation in a very open economy
like Singapore's. Even large countries, like the
USA which is less dependent upon imports and which
has adopted the system of price controls, have had
only modest and temporary success in curbing
inflation. When controls continue beyond realistic
limits, goods disappear. So when controls are
lifted, another bout of large price increases
immediately occurs. My view is that it is better
for Singapore to let market forces operate. But
checks will be mounted to ensure that wholesalers
will deal fairly with the public, and themselves
help the Government to check the manipulation of a
minority, for which they, as a class, get the
blame.
The problem of inflation is a complex one with
implications on growth. If the wrong set of
solutions is implemented, economic growth will
suffer, generating unemployment which is a more
serious problem than that of an inflation. As long
as the economy is able through larger export
earnings to bear the increase in import prices due
to inflation, we shall be able to maintain our
economic growth. There may be need, however, to
correct the adverse effects of inflation on the
real wages of workers and this will no doubt be
considered in due course in the National Wages
Council's recommendations on wage increases this
year.
Fiscal and Monetary Policies
In a situation of rising prices, the Government
is faced with a difficult policy choice. There is
an inherent conflict between the need for
increased expenditure to sustain expansion of the
economy and the equal need to alleviate
inflationary pressures by curbing public
expenditure. And in deciding policy we have to
take note of the economic recession widely
forecasted in America and the industrial centres
in the latter part of the year.
Column: 54
A policy of cutting down public expenditure
indiscriminately would sacrifice growth, and not
help reduce, to any significant extent, price
increases. The best policy in these circumstances
is to dampen increases in recurrent expenditure,
but at the same time, to allow in full all
development expenditure required for the expansion
of productive capacity essential to economic
growth. The budgets of Government, and of the
statutory boards, will therefore be scrutinised
both for their growth potential as well as their
inflationary impact. The measures we take should
have the beneficial effect of increasing public
savings and investment.
Monetary policy will likewise balance the
objective of achieving sustained economic growth
and the need to dampen inflationary pressures. The
existing anti-inflationary monetary policy will
not be relaxed, but consideration will be given to
the need for minimising as far as possible any
financial constraints to economic growth. To
reinforce this objective, a package of monetary
measures will be implemented by the Monetary
Authority of Singapore.
First, the Authority is consulting with the
Association of Banks to raise interest rates on
deposits to encourage higher savings. At the same
time banks' prime lending rate will be raised
slightly to check wasteful spending as well as to
align it with comparable interest rates to reflect
the real cost of funds.
Secondly, the Special Deposit ratio which was
modified from 9 per cent to 5 per cent in December
1973 will be reduced to zero per cent. This
Special Deposit requirement was imposed to check
the large influx of foreign funds in early 1973
and has served its purpose. The funds released
will be available for financing productive
activities within a system of selective credit
control administered by the Authority.
Thirdly, the Authority would also be ready to
consider some reduction in the reserves ratios of
banks and finance companies provided the resources
are used to finance investment and productive
activities in priority sectors in the
Column: 55
economy. Banks and finance companies will have to
submit monthly data on their loan operations
relating to changes and usage of credit by
purposes. This information will be closely
monitored by the Authority within a framework of
ceilings and guidelines for credit to various
sectors. Where credit is being channelled into
productive activities the Authority will be more
flexible. But credit for inflationary spending and
speculation will be reduced.
With all these efforts, we may still find
inflation too obstinate a disease to respond to
local treatment. We need not be overcome with
gloom if these unsettling economic circumstances
persist. Nor should we be dismayed if in the
latter part of this year, as a consequence of
inflation and the inability of the major nations
to keep up demand at inflated prices, a recession
of serious proportions sets in. This is not the
first nor will it be the last time that we have to
meet the challenge of adverse conditions.
Singapore overcame successfully even more severe
disruptions like separation from Malaysia in 1965
and the rundown of British Bases in 1968. Our
survival depends, as then, upon a robust approach
to life, that the world does not owe us a living.
Nothing is for free. Hence, the virtues of thrift
and hard work and our resilience and capacity to
adapt to changing circumstances saw us through.
The question is whether we have not already been
softened by the increasing affluence now so
clearly and even delightfully evident in the
colourful dress and appearance of our bright young
things. This change in life style is shown in our
sombre statistics indicating a propensity to save
less and consume more. With annual economic growth
no longer to be expected as of right, we shall
have to rely on the qualities of hard work, thrift
and grit to see us through a difficult time ahead.
In 1974, we are in better shape than we were in
1965 or 1968 to deal with a severe economic
crisis. First, there is now full, or perhaps
overfull, employment to cushion the shock of any
Column: 56
business recession and retrenchment. If our
economy does not grow quite as fast as in the past
or even if it stagnates for some time, we need not
fear, as we did in the past, the spectre of
widespread unemployment.
Secondly, our economy is now more diversified
than it was in the Sixties. Being more broadly
based on manufacturing, trade, construction,
transportation, tourism and a growing financial
sector, the economy should be better able to
withstand a recession in any one sector or market.
Specific anti-recession measures could be put in
hand, if necessary. For example, the enormous
backlog of Housing Board building could take up
any slack of building activity as well as provide
job opportunities for those thrown out of work.
Other public sector projects can also be used for
the same purposes. Short of a disastrous world
slump, which economic forecasts consider unlikely,
Singapore should be able to earn a modest, if not
comfortable, livelihood.
We must, however, improve our ability to cope
with the present circumstances. What specific
remedies can we devise in each sector?
Manufacturing Sector
As the leading growth sector of our economy,
manufacturing will continue to receive the
Government's full encouragement and support either
for new industries or for expansion of existing
ones.
The choice of industries must finally lie with
the investors or entrepreneurs. But the Singapore
Government and its agency, the Economic
Development Board, will always give help on
preferred new industries or assist in the
upgrading of existing ones which take into account
Singapore's existing and future factor endowments.
We shall press forward with our policy of
promoting skill-intensive, high technology
industries. This policy is showing results. The
progress in upgrading industries can be gauged
from the expected labour productivity (measured by
value added per
Column: 57
worker) of the new industries. It has been
estimated that the average value added per worker
of the major new projects under implementation and
in the pipeline will show a 120 per cent increase
over that of similar industry groups in 1973. We
do well therefore to concentrate our efforts on
the industrial promotion of these higher value
added industries and to offer them appropriate
incentives. Moreover, our strategy of enhancing
the value added by our manufacturing operations is
entirely appropriate in the current situation of
rising freight, fuel and raw material costs.
High technology industries require a large supply
of skilled workers. While the Government will
continue for the time being to be liberal in its
immigration policy towards skilled workers, an
adequate solution can be provided only by creating
our own ample supply of trained workers. We will
accordingly continue to make substantial sums
available for massive technical and industrial
training, and the Government has earmarked $12.3
million for such training in FY 1974 compared to
$9.7 million in FY 1973. With the successful
implementation of our industrial training policy,
our dependence on immigration of foreign workers
for growth can then be scaled down to an
acceptably modest level.
The Economic Development Board now has under its
administration various training programmes for
workers. In industrial training, we have the joint
training programme, overseas training programme,
industrial development scholarship scheme and
apprenticeship training scheme. There is also the
new industrial training subsidy scheme for
sophisticated industries which I announced in
October 1973. The response to this training
subsidy scheme has been very good. So far, 42
companies have expressed interest and 12 have put
up concrete proposals for training. Moreover, last
year, 53 trainees were sent overseas under the
overseas training programme and 177 machinists
underwent training under the joint training
programme. All the training
Column: 58
programmes I have mentioned are regularly reviewed
so that our targets of building up and providing a
large reservoir of skilled workers can be met in
the most efficient way.
With our industrialisation gathering momentum, I
expect that in 1974 our strategies in upgrading
industries and providing adequate incentives and
training subsidies for manufacturers will be
sufficient to cushion any decline in performance
by the manufacturing sector caused by the economic
slowdown in the industrial countries. Our
manufacturing industries should be able to meet
the challenges posed by the energy crisis, without
too serious a dislocation of their operations. The
high oil prices should be reflected in terms of
higher prices for our industrial goods. In an
inflation-prone world, when other countries with a
higher base in manufacturing costs are expected to
inflate by 7-12 per cent in 1974 (depending on the
countries concerned), our competitive edge in
overseas markets will be maintained, as buyers
will still find Singapore goods relatively
competitive even at the new prices.
Employment, Productivity and Wages
In a situation of full employment, labour
productivity through the modernisation and
upgrading of industries can be promoted by
appropriate wage policies, formulated to induce
employers to be more efficient in their usage of
scarce labour. A desirable secondary product of
such policies is to help workers, particularly
those in the lower income brackets, to recover by
wage increases the loss in their real incomes due
to inflation. But these wage increases would still
have to be related to productivity increases to
avoid generating further inflationary pressures.
To upgrade industries and raise productivity,
wages must be made sufficiently high to attract
labour from low productivity sectors which are
less able to afford such wages into the high
productivity sectors. There need not be any undue
concern that somewhat higher increases in wages in
1974 for Singapore workers will affect our
competitiveness
Column: 59
in overseas markets. According to the
International Labour Organisation (ILO) Year Book
of Statistics 1972, manufacturing wages in Korea
since 1967 have gone up by 37.8 per cent and in
Hong Kong by 14 per cent. These countries are our
major competitors. On the other hand, according to
our own Census of Industrial Production, Singapore
experienced increases in wages in manufacturing by
much less over the same period. Moreover, when
compared to the developed countries to which a
major portion of our exports are destined, that is
the United States of America, the United Kingdom,
Japan and West Germany, workers in Singapore
obtained much lower wages, compared to workers of
the United States of America who draw six times as
much, of the United Kingdom 3.6 times, of Japan
3.1 times and of West Germany 3.7 times. Higher
wage increases for Singapore in 1974 will narrow
this differential only very slightly, given the
wage cost spirals in these countries.
Of greater concern would be the risk of
unemployment considered in the economy as a whole,
which we must weigh against the beneficial effects
of a higher wage rise. Although employers are
expected to pass on at least a part of their wage
increases in prices to their customers, there is
still the possibility of an undesirably high
degree of unemployment. In our labour scarce
economy, however, a slackening only of the present
overfull employment situation could be beneficial.
Trade Sector
Despite the international monetary uncertainties
and the oil crisis, Singapore's external trade
grew at a record rate in 1973. In 1974, however,
the deflationary policies already adopted by the
major industrial countries to curb inflation
coupled with the adverse effects of the oil crisis
and the consequent uncertainties of the
international situation are expected to slow down
the economic growth of these countries in 1974.
World trade is therefore unlikely
Column: 60
to show the boom conditions it exhibited in 1973,
and the economic slowdown of our trading partners
will equally affect our trade with them. On the
brighter side, however, our neighbouring countries
in the South-East Asian region especially ASEAN
countries are relatively unhurt by the oil crisis
and will continue to enjoy high prices for their
primary exports. Their buoyant economies should be
a plus in our relations with them.
In the Middle East, it is not unlikely that
negotiations for a settlement of the Arab/Israeli
conflict can progress sufficiently for the Suez
Canal soon to reopen. In that event, international
trade would most likely recover a lot of its
buoyancy. On balance, therefore, it would appear
that there will be some slowdown in world trade
but this should not be so serious as to generate a
world depression, and we can remain hopeful of
surmounting without undue hardship the adverse
effects of such a slowdown in world trade.
Services Sector
Singapore must continue to improve its
capabilities as a brain services centre. Our
increasingly sophisticated financial, banking,
insurance, transport and communications
institutions should take on a regional, and even a
global role. Among special developments relevant
to the Services Sector in 1974 will be the
situation caused by the oil crisis which has
intensified the search for oil. Singapore, with
its capacity for building oil drilling rigs and
production platforms and its offshore supply
bases, should be well placed to service any
increase in offshore prospecting activities in the
South-East Asian or even in the Pacific Basin
area. With higher prices for oil and other primary
commodities, the economies of ASEAN are likely to
remain buoyant. This buoyancy will stimulate
demand on services, especially in economic
engineering supply and construction services.
Conclusion
1974 therefore poses a number of new challenges
for Singapore. High oil prices will exert pressure
on the Balance
Column: 61
of Payments of Singapore as it will do on those of
other oil importing countries. Inflation and the
uncertainties in the international monetary system
will continue to plague world economies with the
result that Singapore, like all the major
industrial countries, is likely to experience some
deceleration in the pace of its economic growth.
To meet these new difficulties, concerted efforts
by employers and workers, producers, traders and
consumers must match the Government's own efforts
to achieve continued economic growth, with
inflation kept down as low as possible. If we all
pull together, in the first half of this year at
least, we may still be able to achieve a real
growth rate of some 10 per cent per annum.
Employers and employees alike must move
vigorously also towards productivity increases.
Wastage must be reduced both in the home and in
our factories to counter the growing shortages in
industrial raw materials and consumer goods.
Consumers, both industrial and domestic, should
economise on their consumption of fuel and
electricity, so as to make more available for
industries. We should cut down unnecessary
consumption especially on luxury goods. Thus we
should correct the unhealthy situation of last
year when consumption expenditure registered very
high increases and surpassed the growth of fixed
capital formation.
The Budget
I would like to turn now to the Estimates. But
first, I should like to explain some of the more
important presentational changes which have been
made in this year's Estimates. Last year the
provisions in the Main Estimates which were
entered for "Contributions" to various statutory
boards and non-profit making organisations not
directly responsible to the Minister for Finance
were deleted from the Ministry of Finance Head of
Expenditure and shown, it was thought more
appropriately, under the Ministries having
responsibility for the functional policy and
performance of these bodies. This year, for
similar reasons, the provisions
Column: 62
entered for "Loans" to these bodies which were
still shown last year under the Ministry of
Finance Head have also been devolved to the
respective Ministries. However, the terms and
conditions of the loans will continue to be set as
before by the Ministry of Finance, which was the
reason for retaining the provisions previously
under the Ministry of Finance Head. With these
changes, the share of total Budget Expenditure
properly allocable to the Ministry of Finance
would also now be more correctly shown.
In previous years' Estimates, for comparison with
the new Budget requests, the provisions in the
current Budget were reproduced exactly as
Parliament had approved them. Our experience is,
however, that there are invariably organisational
changes during the year such as the establishment
of new units, the merging of units, the transfer
of functions from one unit to another, the
conversion of units into statutory boards, etc.
The figures for the current financial year as
approved by Parliament, therefore, no longer
reflect the existing organisational structure, and
to that extent, comparisons between the figures
for the new financial year and those for the
current financial year shown exactly as approved
by Parliament will clearly not be valid. From FY
74, therefore, I propose to show more correctly
the current financial year's figures so that they
can be directly and therefore more conveniently
compared with the new financial year's figures. In
this way, for example, we have some means of
assessing the changes in the proposed provisions
for FY 74 requested under the two new Heads of
Expenditure, namely, "Primary Production" and
"Police".
I mentioned in my last Budget Address that my
officials were exploring the possibility of a re-structuring of subheads in the Main Estimates. A
set of proposals was subsequently developed and
presented to the Estimates Committee of this
Parliament, and, I am pleased to say, agreed in
toto. These proposals have given this year's
Estimates a new
Column: 63
look and I hope, Members will also find it a more
useful and helpful budget document.
Briefly, all subheads are now coded and grouped
into two major categories, namely, Expenditure on
Manpower (EOM) and Other Operating Expenditure
(OOE). In the EOM category only political and
superscale posts are shown in detail. Other posts
are shown by Division of service so that the user
of the Estimates readily gets a picture of
manpower cost and manpower mix rather than feels
lost in a myriad of details. Those who need the
details may, however, find them in a separate
Establishment List which has been tabled as a
Command Paper.
The codification of subheads will facilitate
studies of like Government expenditure. For
example, present circumstances call for
surveillance over the consumption of water and
electricity by all departments and all the figures
of expenditure by individual departments on public
utilities can now be aggregated easily because
they come under the same code. If the increase in
such expenditure is too rapid it is possible to
trace more easily than before, those departments
which are principally responsible for causing the
increase. Similarly, studies can be carried out in
respect of inputs such as maintenance of vehicles
and vessels, rations and diets, printing,
transportation, etc. Within limits, two or more
departments or sub-divisions of a department doing
similar work should have similar patterns and
scales of expenditure in relation to those inputs.
Whilst such an input-oriented view on expenditure
is necessary to detect waste or inefficiency in
organisational units, it is equally useful to see
how funds are allocated to the major functions of
government such as defence, justice, health,
transport and communications, etc. Such a function-oriented approach transcends departmental
delineation and is possible again because of the
codification of the subheads. The coverage of a
particular function can be specified with
reference to the sub-head
Column: 64
codes which generally will not change from
one year to another. In fact the various Divisions
and departments which have to prepare past
expenditure figures, study budget allocations or
estimate future expenditures have agreed to a
common functional classification of expenditure
and this has been made possible largely as a
result of the codification of subheads. A fuller
presentation of expenditure is now possible as
this year's Memorandum on the Main and Development
Estimates for FY 74 shows.
Thus, the new format of the Estimates has already
brought benefits. My officials will continue to
search for improvements to the Estimates format so
that more information may be made available for
management purposes.
Budget Cornerstones
The Government budget for FY 74 is designed to
restrain operating expenditure and channel more
funds into desirable development projects. Revenue
is expected to reach $2,035.4 million in FY 74
owing to the satisfactory growth rate of the
economy in 1973. Total provision for expenditure
in FY 74 under the Main Estimates is $2,299.5
million of which $480 million is a transfer to the
Development Fund. Such a large transfer is
required because the total provision for
expenditure under the Development Estimates in FY
74 is $1,561.6 million or 32.6 per cent more than
that in FY 73.
Faced as we are with inflation, all Ministries
and departments are expected, indeed required, to
scrutinise their operating expenditure patterns to
cut out waste or unnecessary operations. Direct
operating expenditure excluding the Armed Forces
is allowed to increase by slightly more than 19
per cent only. Allowing for the general increase
in prices and the additional manpower costs such
as wage supplements and other allowances, there is
hardly any growth in real terms and in the context
of ever increasing workloads, this means that
Ministries and departments have to exercise great
care over their expenditure in the next financial
year.
Column: 65
As regards manpower, the search for manpower
saving methods of work continues. Grass-cutting in
school compounds will be progressively undertaken
by grass-cutting contractors and the number of
school servants accordingly reduced. Security
alarms will be installed in schools so that school
watchmen can be phased out eventually. More
mechanised road sweepers will be introduced and
existing staff will be redeployed for the
cleansing of new housing estates and roads. Over
and above the mechanisation effort, a stringent
control was imposed on the creation of additional
posts so as not to add fuel to the inflationary
fire. As a result of these measures, the net
increase in the permanent establishment for FY 74
including those created by Establishment Warrants
is kept down to 1,762 posts or 2.9 per cent of the
establishment level in FY 73.
This, of course, does not mean that expenditure
on manpower will also be held down to a 2.9 per
cent growth. In fact, as I have stated in this
House, the Government and statutory boards will
adopt National Wages Council's recommendations and
will require to make provision for payments in
accordance with such recommendations. At the same
time, I should mention here that as the NWC wage
increases are already fairly substantial and as
shown by their interim $25 wage supplement,
already would have regard to the rising cost of
living, ad hoc revisions of salary for particular
services except where necessary to remove obvious
anomalies, will not generally be entertained.
Whilst some restraint is imposed on operating
expenditure, there will be no let-up on
implementing desirable development programmes and
projects. I mentioned earlier that the total
outlay under the Development Estimates for FY 74
has increased by 32.6 per cent. Of the total
provision, about 28 per cent is allocated for
direct expenditure by Ministries and departments
as well as the Armed Forces. The remainder is
earmarked for loans to statutory boards and
commercial and industrial enterprises.
Column: 66
Expenditure
The Treasury Memorandum on the Estimates explains
in some detail the expenditure provisions under
each Head of Expenditure and there is no need for
me to repeat what is already stated therein. I
would like to highlight, however, some of the
major areas of Government endeavour and the
allocation of funds to these areas, viz. Housing,
Education and Industrial Training, Health and
Environment, and Road Transport.
Housing
Low-cost housing continues to be the key area of
building development. In fact, some other major
projects have had to be rejected or postponed in
order to ensure that there is sufficient building
capacity and supplies for the implementation of
the low-cost housing programme. For FY 74 the
provision of loan funds and subsidies to the
Housing and Development Board is some 48 per cent
higher than that for FY 73. The share of total net
provision allocated to Housing has increased from
12 per cent to 15 per cent.
One of the basic infrastructure facilities
directly related to housing is, of course,
sewerage. Provisions are made for low-cost housing
estates such as Bedok New Town and Telok Blangah
New Town, the East Coast Reclamation Area and the
North and South Precincts under the Urban Renewal
Programme.
More schools will be built in new satellite towns
and major housing estates. It is expected that 12
schools will be completed and provision of funds
for the building of another 20 schools to be
commenced in FY 74.
Education and Industrial Training
Whilst the construction of schools goes on, the
Ministry of Education is pressing ahead with its
programmes to increase the second language
exposure time in primary schools and to implement
curricular changes in secondary schools. After
taking into consideration the changes in enrolment
in primary and secondary schools, a net increase
of 233 posts is provided for FY 74.
Column: 67
With the greater emphasis on quality, there will
be a corresponding increase in the cost of
education. This will be reflected not only in the
salary of teachers, but also in the higher cost of
equipment, chemicals and materials for laboratory
work and workshop practice. It will therefore be
necessary to increase the education fees from time
to time, to remind our people of the enormous
State subsidies in education, and parents of their
responsibility in paying towards the cost of
bringing up and educating every additional member
in his family.
As an earnest of our interest in technical and
industrial training, grants to the Industrial
Training Board, Singapore Polytechnic and Ngee Ann
Technical College have increased by $4 million or
19.4 per cent. Even more significant is the
increase by $2.6 million or 270 per cent in the
provision for the overseas industrial training
scheme, the industrial development scholarship
scheme and subsidies for local industrial
training. It is hoped that industry will, on its
part, take an increasingly active participation in
industrial training through apprenticeship and
other programmes. `The production of enough
personnel with the necessary industrial training
skills must, in the long run, be a joint effort
between industry and Government.
Health and Environment
Recent energy and materials shortages have
reminded us once again of our lack of natural
resources and therefore the importance of
upgrading what we do have - our human resources
and our environment. The allocations for Health
and Environment add up to almost 20 per cent of
total net provision in the Estimates. Improvement
of medical facilities for the people will proceed
on a broad front by the further development of
medical specialities, the opening of new hospitals
and the expansion of existing hospitals. Of these,
the largest single project is still the re-
Column: 68
development of the Outram Road General Hospital.
All require investment in buildings, equipment and
manpower, that is, the training of nurses and the
upgrading of skills of doctors. Unfortunately,
these are too often taken for granted. It is
necessary that hospital charges be increased from
time to time to help symbolically towards the
increasing cost of medicine and drugs, disposables
and rations and diets.
However, increasing expenditure on health
facilities will not lead to better standards of
care if the population growth is unchecked, and
pollution of the environment goes unabated. If the
number of patients increases hand in hand with
total expenditure on health facilities, no
improvement can be expected. For FY 74, the grant
to the Singapore Family Planning and Population
Board is increased by two-thirds and more Maternal
and Child Health Clinics will be opened in low-cost housing estates. In the area of pollution
control, I have mentioned the sewerage projects
which will be undertaken in FY 74. The development
of proper markets and hawkers centres will
continue and the Refuse Incineration project will
be implemented a stage further.
Road Transport
Finally, I should say a few words on the
provisions for the improvement of road
transportation, a subject which has recently
attracted much attention both from the public and
the Government. Provisions for the construction,
widening and realignment of roads and bridges
total $28.1 million. Another $5 million is set
aside for special projects recommended by a high
level Road Transport Action Committee. This total
allocation of $33.1 million is 8.4 per cent of the
provision for direct expenditure by Government
departments on development projects and reflects
the high priority which Government gives to the
solving of problems in road transport.
Column: 69
Revenue
We must now consider the question of financing
the proposed expenditure. It is expected that
external loans, domestic loans, loan repayments
and interest and dividends will together yield
$1,057.5 million. This together with the expected
Government revenue of $2,323 million at existing
tax rates will just about meet the net total
provision for expenditure.
The revenue estimate of $2,323 million for FY 74
represents a 14.1 per cent increase over the
latest estimate of revenue to be collected in FY
73. This rate of increase in revenue is not
unreasonable despite the gloomier international
scene this year. One reason is that the largest
single source is income tax and this is dependent
on the previous year's earnings rather than those
of the present financial year. Another reason i5
that inflation tends to increase revenue through
indirect taxes which are based on prices.
For FY 74, income tax is expected to reach $700
million or 20.7 per cent more than the revised
estimate for FY 73. It also represents around 30
per cent of total revenue for FY 74.
Property tax is the next largest single source of
revenue. For FY 74, this source is expected to
yield $230 million or 12.2 per cent more than the
revised estimate for the current financial year.
Other main increases in revenue in FY 74 are
expected to come from land sales, additional
registration fees on motor cars, road taxes,
customs duties on liquors, petroleum products and
tobacco as well as regulatory charges. These
together account for 52 per cent of the increase
over the revised estimate of revenue for FY 73.
Taxation Policy and Changes
And now we come to the question of new tax
measures.
Hon. Members will be glad to learn that there
will be no new taxes.
I propose instead to give a number of tax
concessions. The reliefs, which
Column: 70
I shall describe in detail, will cost some $8.8
million, which can be broken down
as follows :-
Million
(1) Raising of exemption and remission
limit under Estate Duty $7.0
(2) Increase in Relief for Parents and
Grandparents $0.6
(3) Exemption of the Balancing Charge
on Singapore registered ships
from tax $1.0
(4) Tax only on the Interest Portion
of Annuity Instalments $0.2
----
Total $8.8
====
(1) Higher Exemption and Remission Limits of Estate Duty
Under the present tax rates, estates are exempted
from duty on the first $10,000 of its value. In
addition, since March 1972, any estate duty
payable has been remitted for estates which do not
exceed $25,000 in value. The intention of this
remission was to ensure that families buying the
low-cost Housing and Development Board housing
units under Government's scheme for encouraging a
property-owning democracy would be in no danger of
losing their homes because of inability to pay the
estate duty. It was not intended to benefit the
majority of the tax-payers owning estates above
this value which would, however, still enjoy the
exemption on the first $10,000 which was
introduced in 1955.
Representations have, however, been made about
the inadequacy of the present exemption and
remission limits by the public through the press,
and also by hon. Members in this House. Property
owners hope the Government will extend exemption
or remission to the terrace or semi-detached house
or even the owner-occupied family detached house.
Since prices of land and houses have increased
substantially in the past few years, it is argued
that wage earners may find it difficult to bear
the full burden of estate duty.
While I have considerable sympathy for these
suggestions, I have rejected the demand for
complete exemption from
Column: 71
estate duty in respect of one owner-occupied
family house. Such an exemption would benefit the
wealthy more than others and result in
discrimination against other forms of assets like
shares, deposits and life insurance policies.
However, recognising the need to ensure against
undue hardship and possible disruption of families
as a result of burdensome estate duty payments on
the death of a breadwinner, I now propose to raise
the exemption and remission limits of estate duty.
The intention is to give relief from estate duty
by a combination of exemption and remission. The
exemption will be for the first $50,000 of the
value of the estate which represents an increase
of $40,000 over the existing exemption limit of
$10,000. The remissions will be one declining by
steps of 10 per cent of the duty payable. Thus 90
per cent will be remitted of the estate duty
payable for the next $20,000 in value of the
estate, and 80 per cent, 70 per cent, 60 per cent,
etc, of the duty for every succeeding $20,000 in
value of the estate up to $230,000. This would
mean that if an estate is worth up to $50,000
only, no duty will be payable. If the estate is
worth $150,000, the duty payable is $3,337 and if
the estate is worth $230,000, the duty payable is
$14,037. Estates which are worth more than
$230,000 will be subject to full duty on the
amount exceeding $230,000.
The revised exemption and remission limits will
apply to estates passing on or after 1st April,
1974. The proposal will give full relief to people
in the lower income group living in all, even the
largest, HDB flats, who form about 40 per cent of
the population. The people in the middle income
group living in owner-occupied terrace, semi-detached and even detached houses will have the
burden of estate duty considerably reduced. Those
who wish to reduce or avoid estate duty further
can transfer the property as a gift during the
lifetime of the owner or create joint
Column: 72
tenancies or tenancies in common or mortgage or
charge the property, thus reducing the value of
the estate.
(2) Revision of Tax Relief for Dependent Parents and Grandparents from $300 to $750
Last year when I announced the relief to
taxpayers for supporting parents or grandparents,
many hon. Members felt that the tax deduction at
$300 per dependant was inadequate. I have given
this matter further consideration and I am happy
to inform hon. Members that the relief will now be
increased from $300 to $750 per dependant. There
will be no change in the other conditions
announced last year. The increase in the relief
will also take effect from the year of assessment
1975, that is, based on 1974 income.
(3) Balancing Charge on Sale of a Singapore Registered Ship
Profits from the operation of Singapore
registered ships are exempted from income tax as
an incentive for ship-owners to register their
ships in Singapore. However, when a Singapore
registered ship is sold and the sale price is
higher than the written down or depreciated value,
a balancing charge arises which under ordinary tax
liability, is subject to income tax. If this
liability is not removed, it could discourage
local shipowners from upgrading their fleets
through disposal of older vessels and possibly
also act as a disincentive to foreign shipowners
from setting up shipping companies in Singapore to
operate Singapore registered ships.
To encourage the registration of ships in
Singapore, we have already provided for income tax
exemption for profits, low registration fees and
annual tonnage fee, rebate of half the tonnage fee
if 25 per cent of the crew are Singapore citizens,
a simplified registration and mortgage system and
income tax exemption for crews working on
Singapore registered ships. After giving such
incentives, it was not specifically intended that
there should remain a liability to tax of the
balancing charge on the sale of a Singapore
registered ship. I therefore propose, by the
removal of
Column: 73
this liability, to add still another incentive for
the registration of ships in Singapore from the
assessment year 1974.
(4) Income Tax on Annuity Instalments
The aim to develop Singapore as an important
insurance centre is in line with our efforts to
develop Singapore as the "brains" service centre
of South-east Asia. Hon. Members will remember
that I have in previous Budgets announced fiscal
incentives to foster the growth of the finance and
insurance industries.
As a further step to assist the insurance
industry, I propose to revise the basis of the
income tax on annuities. Annuities, at present,
form a very small part of the insurance business
here because, among other factors, tax is imposed
on the whole of an annuity instalment received.
An annuity purchased by payment of an insurance
premium or premiums provides for the payment of
periodic sums of money to the purchaser.
Essentially, the payment represented by an annuity
instalment consists of two elements: one is
repayment of part of the capital, and the other is
the payment of interest on the outstanding
capital. At present, both elements comprising the
whole of an annuity instalment received are
subject to income tax. This is an anomalous
situation because only the interest portion should
properly be considered as income and taxed,
leaving the capital element free of tax.
With effect from the assessment year 1975,
therefore, I propose to change the basis of tax to
charge only the interest element of annuity
instalments. This measure will not only assist the
insurance industry but also popularise a different
and attractive form of insurance cover.
The above remarks conclude the account of tax
concessions I propose.
Since there still appears to be some lack of
understanding of Government's taxation policy,
particularly with reference to recent tax
measures, let me take the opportunity here to
state it once again. For the growth of revenue
Column: 74
to meet rising Government expenditure, it is our
policy to rely mainly upon a rapid expansion of
the economy and upon an efficient machinery for
enforcement and collection of the taxes which such
an economy can afford to pay. While major and
painful new taxes or increases in tax rates for
the purpose purely of raising additional revenue
will generally be avoided, it may be necessary in
order to implement our social or economic policies
that from time to time, we impose new tax
disincentives, or give incentives.
The last really new taxes were introduced at the 1968 December Budget and were prompted by the need
to raise revenue for building up our own defence
forces consequent upon the withdrawal of the UK
armed forces from the Republic. Since then,
revisions mainly have been made to taxes on
private motor vehicles, cigarettes and tobacco
products, liquors and petroleum. These revisions
raised additional revenue but were made quite as
much to alleviate traffic congestion and
pollution; to bolster Government's anti-smoking
campaign; and to discourage consumption of luxury
and non-essential items. If such higher taxes and
duties encourage the people to forgo or reduce the
consumption of these items, the whole community
will benefit through the better flow of traffic,
reduced pollution, better health and a smaller
national expenditure on imported luxury items. Tax
revisions have not affected food items or daily
necessities. On the contrary, during the financial
year 1973, Government lifted import duties on 149
items of a wide range of foodstuffs, household
appliances and construction materials, resulting
in a potential loss of revenue of $21.4 million
per annum. And, of course, the tax concessions now
announced and costing some $8.8 million per annum
give some recognition to changed economic
conditions.
I should like to make it clear, however, that it
is not part of Government policy to subsidise or
to continue to subsidise activities which are not
viable in the long run, and it will be
Government's intention to recover, so far as
Column: 75
is consistent with Government's policies for
social justice, all costs for the provision of
Government services.
It is useful to re-state the principles which
determine the philosophy on which our way of life
is based. Since 1965, one principle which has
enabled us to survive and to thrive is not to
encourage passengers. Nothing is more likely to
ensure our bankruptcy and disintegration than
feather-bedding and subsidies in pursuit of
equality, not of opportunities, but of rewards.
Over and over again, in developing countries,
political parties have won office by putting
attractive proposals of subsidised food, free
education and health services to a semi-educated
electorate, unable and later unwilling to face the
hard facts of economic life. Inevitably these
countries have ended in economic chaos and
bankruptcy. If any political party succeeds in
selling this `something for nothing' philosophy,
it will be particularly bad for Singapore. For we
make our living through organised servicing and
production, not with the help of the sun and rain
to produce food and agricultural commodities. So
when the financial rot sets in and the firm
framework which rewards effort and enterprise
gives way, there are no soft rice fields to
cushion the hard fall. And the fall will be most
painful for the poor and the unskilled.
When the price of imported oil goes up, it is no
less than madness to subsidise PUB charges, as
some letters to the press have urged, particularly
when we want people to cut down on consumption of
electricity and oil. On the contrary, in the case
of petrol, a tax was added in order to further cut
down non-essential travelling by motor cars.
However, to meet steep price increases in
foodstuffs, and the effects of increased oil
prices, the Government has accepted the National
Wages Council's recommendation to give a $25
interim allowance. There is a likelihood of a
further increase in July.
Column: 76
Meanwhile, the cost of running buses has gone up
- half because of wages, half due to higher cost
of diesel oil, spare parts and tyres. So the
Government has had to allow the bus companies to
put up bus fares. There have been suggestions that
the Government nationalise the bus companies and
subsidise the commuter. But what happens when the
Government nationalises a company which has not
yet got institutionalised management, and
corruption on a scale rampant in the former
Singapore Traction Company inevitably results? Let
us first get management and services improved
through tighter supervision from the Ministry of
Communications.
Hospital ward charges for `C' class patients have
gone up by a token $1 per day, since January 1974,
when the actual cost per patient per day went up
$8 from $37 in 1972 to $45 in 1973, the result of
increase of wages of all hospital staff and the
cost of equipment and medicines.
The underlying rationale is, whoever makes use of
these services must pay a token share towards its
cost, to check abuse in the unnecessary use of
these services. This has happened in even
developed countries like Britain. There, a Labour
government in 1968 was forced to introduce
prescription charges. Human nature being what it
is, the charge, however small compared to the
actual cost, helps to cut down wastage.
With miscellaneous school fees, a cognate
principle applies. Every parent must bear a token
sum, to remind him that the bigger his family, the
higher the burdens on his family and on the State.
We must employ every means to impress on our
people the need for family planning, or abortion,
or serialisation. That there is a small surplus in
miscellaneous fees for the cost of ECA, means that
more activities can be catered for, and principals
and senior teachers can be more imaginative in
planning activities such as educational tours
during holidays. The hefty increased cost of
education, at about $324 per annum for a primary
school student,
Column: 77
and $582 per annum for a secondary school student,
is carried by the Government. This, as with all
subsidies, comes from taxes paid for by the
people.
The largest single tax revenue is from income
tax, paid for on a graduated scale, those earning
more paying more, to subsidise those earning less.
It is nearly 30 per cent of total revenue.
The principle of the more you can earn, the more
you must pay for the poor, when carried too far
has led, in many countries like Britain, to
professionals migrating to North America,
Australia and New Zealand. They see no reason why
they should work to pay for the indolent and
irresponsible. We are in a poorer position than
the British, for we are short of top level
personnel. If our trained administrators, managers
and professionals leave, those left behind, nearly
all of whom cannot emigrate, will become
unemployed and suffer grave privation.
Every society has its quota of idealists, and of
hypocrites, especially amongst the intelligentsia.
The idealists believe in equal rewards. But many
are hypocrites, pretending to feel sorry for the
poor. They are the people who, whilst lamenting
the extra dollar on miscellaneous school fees,
quietly send their children abroad to expensive
schools in Australia, Britain and elsewhere.
For those of us who intend to stay, let us take a
hard look at our circumstances. To protect our
long-term interests, everyone, even our poor, must
face up to our responsibilities to each other, and
to the country. To spread the belief in heavier
and heavier subsidies to cushion the adverse
effects of world economic forces on our lives,
means encouraging and making more people
Column: 78
into passengers. People who can help push the
economy by striving to earn and pay a part of
their essential needs will just sit back, waiting
to be carried for free. This is the road to ruin.
The Government's duty is to ensure the wellbeing
of all, including the poor. We best do this by
ensuring that people get better and better paid as
they improve their training and attain higher
skills. The basic formula for Singapore's
continued success, without raw materials, is hard
work. There is no magic strategy for economic
growth which can feed us without work. This budget
reflects a realistic appraisal of our position in
a world where only those who make the effort will
make the grade.
Sir, I beg to move.
Mr Speaker: The Question is, "That Parliament
approves the financial policy of the Government
for the financial year 1st April, 1974 to 31st
March, 1975." In accordance with paragraph (1) of
Standing Order No. 84, the debate now stands
adjourned.
Mr Hon, debate to be resumed on what day?
Mr Hon Sui Sen: On 15th March, 1974.
Mr Speaker: So be it.
ADJOURNMENT
Resolved,
"The Parliament do now adjourn to Thursday,14th
March,1974."[Mr E. Barker].
Adjourned accordingly at Eight minutes past minutes
past Four o'clock p.m to Thursday, 14th March,1974.
Column: 81
Appendix to Annual Budget Statement(Cols 81-124)