| Parliament No: | 3 |
| Session No: | 1 |
| Volume No: | 33 |
| Sitting No: | 11 |
| Sitting Date: | 27-03-1974 |
|
Column: 905
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
THIRD PARLIAMENT
Wednesday, 27th March, 1974
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Dr Yeoh Ghim Seng, B.B.M., J.P. (Joo Chiat)).
Encik Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang).
Encik A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Ahmad Mattar (Leng Kee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Dr Ang Kok Peng, B.B.M. (Crawford), Minister of State for Communications.
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr Ivan Baptist (Potong Pasir).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development and Leader of the House.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Chin Harn Tong (Aljunied).
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for the Environment.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (Mac Pherson), Minister for Health and Home Affairs.
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah).
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development.
Column: 906
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Hon Sui Sen (Havelock), Minister for Finance.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Mr Lai Tha Chai (Henderson).
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Minister for Education.
Mr Lee Yiok Seng (Bukit Panjang).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs.
Mr Lim Kim San, D.U.T. (Cairnhill), Minister for the Environment.
Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampung Kembangan).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Dr Ong Leong Boon (Kim Seng).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Labour.
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Ong Teng Cheong (Kim Keat).
Encik Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Phey Yew Kok (Boon Teck).
Encik Rahmat Bin Kenap A1-Haj (Geylang Serai). Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens).
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee).
Mr P. Selvadurai (Kuo Chuan).
Haji Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampung Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Column: 907
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Minister of State for Labour and Government Whip.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Dr Tan Eng Liang, B.B.M. (River Valley).
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan (Whampoa).
Mr Tang See Chim (Chua Chu Kang), Deputy Speaker.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology.
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Minister of State for the Environment.
Prof. Wong Lin Ken, B.B.M. (Alexandra).
Mr Yeo Choo Kok (Delta).
Mr Yeo Toon Chia (Kampung Kapur).
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications.
Column: 908
ABSENT:
Mr Chai Chong Yii (Bukit Batok), Minister of State for Education.
Dr Chiang Hai Ding (Ulu Pandan).
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong).
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Defence.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Defence.
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampung Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampung Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Column: 907
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
TELECOMMUNICATION AUTHORITY OF SINGAPORE BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
The Minister of State for Communications (Dr Ang Kok Peng): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Before I elaborate on the provisions of this
Bill, may I give a brief summary of the
background? Prior to April, 1972, the
Telecommunications Department was a Government
department providing external telecommunication
services while the Singapore Telephone Board was a
Statutory organisation providing domestic
telephone services. With very high rates of growth
and fast changing technology in communications, it
was clear that radical changes in the organisation
and management were required to cope with the
developments and challenges in the years ahead. An
expert from the International Telecommunications
Union was therefore invited to advise the Ministry
on the reorganisation
Column: 908
of the telecommunication services and his
recommendation was that the Telecommunications
Department should be converted into a statutory
organisation. This recommendation was accepted and
implemented on 1st April, 1972, with the
Telecommunications Department becoming a statutory
body known as the Telecommunication Authority of
Singapore (TAS).
This Bill seeks to provide for the second stage
of reorganisation, namely, the merger of the
Singapore Telephone Board with the
Telecommunication Authority of Singapore into a
single organisation to be known as the
Telecommunication Authority of Singapore (new
TAS), i.e, both domestic and external
telecommunications are to work as one and not as
two separate entities.
I will now summarise the main features of this
Bill. The Bill essentially re-enacts the
provisions of the Singapore Telephone Board Act
and the Telecommunication Authority of Singapore
Act, 1972, both of which will be repealed. The new
TAS shall consist of a Chairman, a General Manager
and
Column: 909
not less than five and not more than seven other
members all of whom shall be appointed by the
Minister.
The new TAS shall have the exclusive privilege of
operating telecommunication services in the
Republic and, in addition to the functions of the
existing TAS, the new TAS will also perform the
functions of the STB. There are pro, visions for
the appointment of staff and the appointment of a
General Manager. The General Manager is to be
appointed by the TAS with the approval of the
Minister and will be chief executive of the
organisation. The persons presently employed by
the STB or TAS shall be transferred to the service
of the new TAS on the same terms.
The new TAS will be empowered to raise funds by
the issue of stocks or loans from banks and to
levy charges, rates and fees. The new TAS will
acquire the existing assets and liabilities of the
STB and TAS.
The new TAS has power to acquire land and to
enter upon land for the purpose of its
installations, and compensation is payable for the
exercise of such powers. The accounts of the new
TAS shall he audited by the Auditor-General or by
an auditor appointed by the Minister in
consultation with the Auditor-General. The audited
accounts as well as the annual report shall be
presented to Parliament.
The new TAS will be commanding substantial
manpower of over 5,000 staff and financial
resources exceeding $150 million in annual gross
revenue. With such resources and an integrated
organisation, we can expect more vigorous
development, increase in efficiency and higher
quality of telecommunication services. To ensure
that our Republic will continue to be a leading
communication centre, the new TAS will continually
keep abreast of latest technological innovations
and developments. Hon. Members may wish to note
that a five-year development programme costing
more than $560 million has already been prepared
for implementation by the new TAS.
Before I conclude, Mr Speaker, Sir, I wish to add
that all necessary steps
Column: 910
have been taken to ensure that the merger will
proceed as smoothly as possible, and an extensive
internal reorganisation has already been put into
effect.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
2.38 p.m.
Mr Ong Teng Cheong (Kim Keat): Mr Speaker, Sir,
there are instances where occupants of offices and
commercial buildings which are ready for
occupation have to wait for months for the
provision of telephone services. Clause 6 of the
Bill says that it shall be the function and duty
of the Authority to provide, operate and maintain
a good and sufficient telecommunication service,
and also to promote the economic development of
the telecommunication service in accordance with
public demand. I also note that clause 6 (1) (f)
provides for the further advancement of
telecommunication technology and the development
of telecommunication in Singapore in co-operation
with the broadcasting and television authority and
tertiary technical institutions. I would like to
see closer co-ordination and also streamlining of
the administrative structure of the Authority to
ensure that this long wait for telephone services
is avoided. As we know, in the past the reasons
usually given to applicants for the long wait are
either there are no spare lines available or there
is a shortage of equipment. Because of this,
commercial premises without telephone services
are, therefore, in many cases left unoccupied for
months because they are unsuitable for business
operations although they are certified fit for
occupation in every respect. I am sure the
Minister will agree that this state of affairs is
obviously undesirable because it means a waste of
usable facilities and also a restriction of
commercial activities. I would, therefore, like to
see this part of the administrative structure
streamlined in the new Authority.
Dr Ang Kok Peng: Sir, I would like to assure the
hon. Member for Kim Keat that all efforts will be
exerted towards closer co-ordination between the
various
Column: 911
parties concerned to ensure speedy installation of
the necessary telephone services. But I would like
the Member to note that the increase in the number
of telephones installed has been averaging at
about 14 per cent per annum. This is a very high
rate of growth compared with the world average of
about 8 per cent. So it is sometimes difficult to
meet immediate demands and some delay is
unavoidable.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - (Dr Ang Kok Peng].
Bill considered in Committee: reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 911
ENVIRONMENTAL PUBLIC HEALTH (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.45 p.m.
The Minister of State for the Environment (Mr Wee Toon Boon): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That
the Bill be now read a Second time."
The Ministry of the Environment is now
responsible for administering the Environmental
Public Health Act (Cap. 155). Prior to the setting
up of this Ministry, the Act was administered by
the Ministry of Health, and the Commissioner of
Public Health was responsible for its
administration subject to the supervision of the
Public Health Authority established under section
3 of the Act. The Public Health Authority
comprises the Director of Medical Services and the
Deputy Director of Medical Services of the Public
Health Division, Ministry of Health. Both these
offices are no longer directly concerned with the
administration of the Act. It is, therefore,
necessary to delete all references to "the
Authority" in the Act and for the Commissioner of
Public Health to be responsible for the
administration of the Act subject to the
directions of the Minister for the Environment.
Column: 912
The opportunity is also taken to make other
amendments to the Act which have become necessary.
Our policy is to resite street hawkers into
premises including eating establishments. The
powers of the Commissioner should be extended to
the control of hawkers within these
establishments, i.e, hawkers and stalls in coffee
shops including those in HDB estates will he
licensed directly. Provision is also made for
ticketing of unlicensed stallholders and seizure
of stalls, appliances and goods belonging to
unlicensed stall-holders in the eating
establishments.
The present definition of "premises" in the Act
requires amendment to enable prosecution of
unlicensed hawkers of any goods, including food
and drinks, who operate in public places like
parks and car parks.
To provide for more effective control of food
handlers in food establishments and at food
stalls, the Act requires amendment to permit
ticketing of offenders.
Inadequate capacity, inept operation, poor
maintenance and consequent breakdown of air-conditioning plants in places frequented by the
public such as hotels, cinemas, offices, shopping
complexes and restaurants pose a public health
problem. The Commissioner of Public Health should,
therefore, be empowered to require owners,
occupiers or licensees of such buildings to take
necessary measures to ensure that the air-conditioning system is functioning properly.
The definition of "public health auxiliary"
requires amendment consequential to the
redesignation of the post of Public Health
Assistants which is now titled Assistant Public
Health Inspectors.
It is also proposed to delete repetitions of the
definition of "public health officer" in several
sections of the Act and to insert a single
definition in section 2 of the Act which will
apply throughout the Act.
Column: 913
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Wee Toon Boon].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 913
NEWSPAPER AND PRINTING PRESSES BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.51 p.m.
The Minister for Culture (Mr Jek Yeun Thong): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
The Printing Presses Act was originally enacted
in 1920. Various amendments, as were found
necessary have, since then, been made to the Act,
the last one being in 1970. Experience has,
however, shown that the provisions of the Act are
still inadequate, particularly in relation to the
sections concerning the publication of newspapers.
Although a permit is still required for the
printing or publication of a newspaper, recent
events have shown that it is possible for foreign
elements to gain control of our newspapers, and
use them for their own ends against our national
interest. There is, therefore, need to further
amend and update this Act to meet present-day
requirements. Under the provisions of the existing
Act, as it stands today, foreign interests could
obtain control of any newspaper printed and
published in Singapore. This is obviously an
unhealthy situation.
In May, 1971, for example, the "Eastern Sun", an
English language newspaper closed down
voluntarily, following exposure by the Government
of its having received subventions amounting to
nearly HK$8 million from a Communist intelligence
agency in Hong-kong. The "Singapore Herald",
another English language newspaper, which was also
financed with funds from foreign sources,
conducted a campaign to mis-
Column: 914
lead the people of Singapore especially the
English-educated. The Government had, therefore,
in 1971, to withdraw its publication permit.
We would be failing in our duty and
responsibility to the people of Singapore, if we
do not protect our citizens from the manipulations
of subversive or hostile elements, operating
through our newspapers. Although newspapers are
commercial organisations, they have a special
responsibility to the society they cater for. They
have a duty to always bear in mind their social
and political obligations because, as a medium of
communication, their influence can be crucial.
Singapore, therefore, cannot allow foreign control
of any of its newspapers, that is to say, those
overseas who may seek to manipulate or influence
public opinion through this media. We cannot
afford to have "black operations" mounted against
us.
The intention of the Bill before us is,
therefore, to make a substantial change of the
Printing Presses Act to ensure that newspapers are
not used as instruments of subversion. Precaution
must be taken to prevent the newspaper from being
used to poison the minds of its readers by
reporting news in a biased way or to reproduce
propaganda material "lifted" or cut out from
newspapers controlled by foreign countries.
But, while it is necessary to ensure that control
of our newspapers remain in the hands of our
citizens, the Government also does not wish to
upset the commercial operations of newspaper
companies, or intervene in the market forces
determining the value of their shares. We
certainly do not want to get involved in the day-to-day running of newspapers. Management will be
free to operate the newspapers as commercial
enterprises, provided they ensure that there is no
manipulation by foreign elements and that no
attempt is made by them, or through their proxies,
to glorify undesirable viewpoints and
philosophies.
Mr Speaker, Sir, it is against this backdrop that
I have introduced the Newspaper and Printing
Presses Bill.
Column: 915
The Bill seeks to re-enact, with additions or
amendments, certain provisions of the Printing
Presses Act (Chapter 258). I do not propose to
take the House through the entire Bill, clause by
clause, as many of the provisions are re-enactments of the existing Act. I would like,
however, to touch on some of the salient points of
the Bill.
Permits will still be required for the printing
and publication of newspapers, but all newspaper
companies will have to go public, unless there is
some special difficulty, perhaps on account of
size in going public. In such cases, the Minister
will be empowered to grant special exemptions.
All newspapers will have to be locally managed;
the members of the Board of Management will have
to be Singapore citizens.
In a newspaper company, there will be two
classes of shares, namely, management shares and
ordinary shares. There is, no restriction to the
ownership of ordinary shares; however, the issue
and transfer of management shares must have the
approval of the Minister, and such approval will
only be given to citizens of Singapore, or to such
corporations which have been granted approval by
the Minister. This arrangement is necessary, since
the total voting rights of the management shares
is greater than that of the ordinary shares.
All foreign investments injected into the
newspaper must have the approval of the Minister;
this is to ensure that the Government is not kept
in the dark as regards the real ownership of
capital of newspapers. In this way, we will be
able to ensure that the management of the
newspapers will always be in the hands of our
citizens, and the policies also determined by our
citizens.
It will be appreciated that ample notice has been
given to the newspapers of the Government's
intention to make major Singapore newspapers to go
public - in fact, that indication was given as
early as January last year. However, in order to
ensure that there will be adequate opportunity for
all interested
Column: 916
parties to air their views and make such
representation as they might deem necessary, the
Government has decided to send this Bill to a
Select Committee.
As I mentioned earlier, it is not the intention
of Government to interfere unduly in the affairs
of the Press. The sole purpose is to safeguard our
national interest and the well-being of our
citizens.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
3.00 p.m.
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I support the main provisions of the
Bill to make it law that all Singapore citizens
can have a right to fashion the policy of the
newspaper. This is in line with the argument that
if one's survival depends on keeping the boat on
an even keel as it charts its way through
unpredictable seas, then it is in the interest of
that person not to provoke any kind of a
disequilibrium of the boat.
In the Singapore context, Sir, a responsible
newspaper is a critical factor in the well-being
of the nation. The newspaper provides information
upon which members of our society conduct intense
communication among themselves, between themselves
and the Government, form impressions, construct
convictions and make decisions. It is imperative,
therefore, as far as is reasonably possible and
democratically feasible, that news and information
offered by the newspaper are responsible news
resulting from the responsible policies of the
management comprising responsible citizens of
Singapore, whose stakes are in this country and in
this country only. In a world of super powers,
super nationalisms and monolithic commercial
organisations, Sir, which contend for power and
profit, Singapore is a consideration in their
strategy of operations, and in my view the sooner
we rise up to this fact, the sooner will we begin
to ensure our own national security.
I also support, Sir, the committal of this Bill
to Select Committee.
Column: 917
Mr Yeo Choo Kok (Delta)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, the whole intention of this Bill may
be summed up in one sentence, that is, in future
newspapers in Singapore will only be run by
Singapore citizens with the permission of the
Minister in charge. As the Bill stands, the whole
spirit of the Bill lies in Part III, which gives
the Minister very extensive powers, particularly
in clause 9.
The appointment of directors on the board must be
approved by the Minister. But the Bill does not
provide how any citizen of Singapore can be
approved by the Minister to be a holder of
management shares. It does not say how an
application is to be made, whether it should be on
a specified form or whether it is to be by letter.
On the question of funds, of course, we can
prevent a local newspaper from obtaining foreign
sources of finance. But we cannot control the
content of the newspapers, and therefore we may
not prevent incidents similar to what had happened
before, and certain undesirable events may happen
again. We have seen incidents in Sri Lanka which
were mainly due to newspaper influences. Now,
there are embassies and consulates in our midst,
and they can pay substantial amounts on
advertisements to publicise through the newspapers
any article of a political content, such as how
great a certain political machinery or thought is,
what it has produced, and what a great personage
the ruler is, etc. This is very dangerous. Once we
have diplomatic relations with more countries,
more embassies and consulates will be set up in
Singapore, and every one of them can by paying
advertisement charges publicise in our local
newspapers as to how great are their great
political leaders, how good are their political
systems, and so on. Under such circumstances, with
a multi-racial setup as ours, would it be good for
Singapore? They can carry across their messages
through such advertisements and publicity in our
newspapers. Even underground agencies or
undesirable elements can also make use of the
newspapers to convey their message if they want
to.
Column: 918
Just now the Minister has said in his speech that
the intention of the Bill is to ensure that
newspapers in Singapore will in future be under
the control of Singapore citizens, but it also
does not wish to upset the commercial operations
of newspaper companies. But a commercial
establishment does not usually care very much
about politics, social conscience or any other
thing except profits. So a newspaper can publicise
articles to suit some people with ulterior motive.
I would now refer to clause 11 of Part III. This
applies only to any newspaper published at
intervals not exceeding one week. In other words,
if a newspaper is published less than once a week,
say, every eight days, once a month or longer,
such a newspaper can be exempted from the
provisions of this Part. If that is the case, then
the purpose of this Bill may be defeated. So I
hope this aspect of the Bill will be well
considered by the Select Committee.
About the management shares being in the hands of
our citizens, as I have pointed out, certain
publicity can still go through the newspaper, and
they may not effectively exercise their control
through the means as provided. Now there is the
suggestion of establishing a Press Council, and
the Minister for Foreign Affairs has spoken about
it. Perhaps this Press Council can provide some
guidance for the newspapers. However, with all
these provisions, anybody, including a journalist
or a citizen, if he wants to, can still exercise
subversive influence through the newspaper. So I
hope the Select Committee can look into this.
Dr Ong Leong Boon (Kim Seng): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
rise to support, in principle, the introduction of
this Bill. I think it is unquestionable that the
spirit and intention of the Bill is good.
However, I would just like to add my own comments
on what I feel are the important points. There are
provisions in this Bill for reference to be made
to the Minister, and giving the Minister certain
powers to decide. This is, I am sure, a good
point. But what I would caution as a possible
reaction is that
Column: 919
a decision of the Minister might be interpreted as
partial or biased at times. I do not wish to
question the Minister on this point, but I am just
suggesting that the number of references or
provisions allowing reference to the Minister may
by itself create a problem and misinterpretation.
I think it is important for us to realise that in
Singapore today we have a great desire and a need
for a constructive and responsible press. This is
one laudable objective. The second is that we have
to ensure and provide for adequate measures to
prevent subversive activities or subversion in
Singapore through the mass media. To meet this
end, this Bill is appropriate.
I would like to point out that there is a
possible side effect of this Bill. But it is my
hope that the measures contained in the Bill will
not lead to a curbing of genuine public expression
to the extent of stifling a healthy debate on
issues of national and international interest
through the mass media. I think this point has to
be taken very seriously and I am sure that the
Hon. Minister has this point in mind when he
decided to commit this Bill to a public hearing. I
give him my whole-hearted support.
With these comments and reservation, I wish to
express once again my support for the Newspaper
and Printing Presses Bill.
Mr Lai Tha Chai (Henderson)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I fully support this Bill. In my
view, this Bill is one way to deal with the entry
of "devils" and "demons" from foreign countries,
as our cultural ballast is too weak at the moment.
We can still see newspapers glorifying the fads
and fetishes of the West, emphasising
individualism. While some girls wear mini-skirts
to show off their thighs without any sense of
shame, others wear the maxis which are long enough
to drag along the road, without realising that
their skirts will be dirtied. All these fads and
fetishes and fashions have been played up and
glorified through the medium of the newspapers. On
the other
Column: 920
hand, we can also see the relics of conservatism
and feudalistic colours from the East. I do not
know why the newspapers should always publish full-page advertisements in glorification of the dead
in the oriental tradition. I do not know the
actual meaning behind all this. If this state of
affairs is allowed to continue, it will perpetuate
the contradictions, anomalies and even
anachronisms in Singapore. All these anachronisms
and contradictions can be made use of and
exploited by ambitious elements from foreign
sources, as pointed out by the Minister when he
said that there was an attempt at exploitation of
newspapers through black operations. But for the
timely decision taken to deal with such a
situation, I am afraid the stability of Singapore,
and even this House, would have changed.
Sir, in a country like Singapore, which is
subject to foreign influences, we must build up
our own culture through a selection of good
foreign cultural influences. Of course, this is
easier said than done. It is, therefore, necessary
to institute measures such as those provided in
this Bill, introduced by the Minister. In other
words, this Bill seeks to transfer the control of
the newspapers from some private hands into the
hands of Singapore citizens. By these means we
would be able to resist the interference by some
ambitious foreign elements. Furthermore, I should
also point out that when a private newspaper
enterprise is controlled by a small group of
people, the journalists are already known to
suffer badly. Newspaper business is a profitable
one. The leading Chinese newspapers make millions
of dollars' profit per annum, but the journalists
in such newspaper establishments, i.e, those who
have to crack their heads and rack their brains,
have not been properly remunerated. They have also
not been allowed to have a share in the profits of
the business. As the Member for Delta has pointed
out, we should be able to improve the conditions
of service of the journalists in Singapore through
the establishment of a Press Council or any such
body. Only then will journalists in Singapore be
able to do a better job in the service and
interest of our nation,
Column: 921
and also to enrich our cultural heritage.
Therefore, in view of this, I fully support this
Bill.
I would also like to take this opportunity to
propose to the Government that apart from the
negative approach to control by getting rid of
undesirable influences, we should also adopt the
positive approach for support of our cultural
development. For example, the Ministry of Culture
is now publishing the Mirror and also a radio and
television magazine. However, I do not think this
is adequate. Therefore, apart from the annual
reports, which are inadequate, other Government
Ministries and statutory bodies should also
publish magazines containing materials of cultural
value, including biographies. I would like to
quote one example. Today I read a short article
which reminds me of a certain reputable person,
the late Mr Lee Kong Chian. He was a man of
praiseworthy ambition and exemplary conduct. He is
an example of a national asset. Although I cannot
hope to do what he had done, I can at least look
up to the ideals of his achievements. Therefore,
we must try to record his words and deeds in some
kind of publication so that Singapore citizens can
learn from him. This is what I mean by the
adoption of a positive approach as distinct from
the negative approach to control.
I would suggest that we must also adopt the
positive approach by giving support to the
encouragement of a constructive cultural
development in our nation building. In this way we
will be able to strengthen and consolidate our
cultural front in the task of nation building.
Then it will not be so easy for our people to be
influenced by foreigners.
Finally, Sir, I would reiterate my support for
this Bill and its committal to the Select
Committee for further consideration.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs (Mr Lim Guan Hoo)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, the Minister for Culture has just
introduced the Second Reading of the Newspaper and
Printing Presses Bill, and I fully support him
from the bottom of my heart. Sir, the introduction
of this
Column: 922
Bill is the very natural reflection of certain
aspects of life in Singapore. Some people may
associate this Bill with some kind of interference
or control of the freedom of the press. Mr
Speaker, Sir, in a country like Singapore which
practises democracy, the freedom of the press is,
of course, a matter of tradition. But if the
people are to assume that the freedom of the press
is something separate from the national interest,
then it is not a healthy belief. No matter how
sincere the directors or managers of newspapers
may be and although they are without any political
blots, it does not mean that their newspapers will
be free from outside influence or unblemished as
the directors and management personnel themselves.
We have experienced attempts at black operations
in the past. Black operations have come to be
associated with the publication of news. We can,
therefore, learn a lesson from this experience.
And that is, in any country, newspapers of any
type -whether it is a political, cultural,
financial or movie newspaper - can be controlled,
influenced or infiltrated by undesirable elements
because the newspaper is a good means of
disseminating propaganda. Once a newspaper is
published, it is read by thousands and thousands
of people in the home, in the office, or even in
the toilet. It is because of the inherent and
formidable influence of the newspaper that there
is always the temptation for ambitious foreign
elements to come in.
Mr Speaker, Sir, in our midst we have a lot of
journalists, who are now Ministers. I can mention
the Minister for Foreign Affairs, the Minister for
Culture, the Parliamentary Secretary, and even
some Backbenchers. For example, the Member for
Henderson is the editor of the Petir (Chinese
edition) and another Member is also the editor of
the Jurong Newspaper. I myself was the former
editor of the Petir (Chinese edition). So in our
midst we have a number of journalists, and this
instance is enough to indicate the close
connection between politics and journalism. In the
light of these facts and realities, there are some
people who even dream dreams of freedom of the
press. They
Column: 923
are obsessed with the freedom of the press.
However, these facts are enough to serve as an eye-opener to such dreamers.
The Bill in this House seeks to ensure that the
control of newspapers will always remain in the
hands of our citizens and not in the hands of
foreigners. This is, in fact, the very spirit of
this Bill, as indicated by the Member for Delta.
Whether this Bill is adequate to ensure what we
want to achieve is something we have to think
about. For example, under the Bill, shares of
newspaper companies are to be classified into two
categories, management shares and ordinary shares.
Management shares can only be transferred to
citizens approved by the Minister.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the People's Action Party has
gone through many years of political struggle.
Through all our experiences in the struggle we
have come to a situation where we have two types
of membership in the PAP, the cadre membership and
the ordinary membership. With these two classes of
membership, we are able to ensure that control of
a very influential political party like ours does
not fall into the wrong hands. And if the
management of newspapers can use a similar
provision in the Bill wisely and with an
enlightened view, they will be able to promote the
interest of the country. Then only will the Bill
be able to achieve what it seeks.
I would also like to point out some of my
misgivings. I am afraid that some newspaper men
may misunderstand and think that the introduction
of this Bill is just to control the press. This is
not the case. As a matter of fact, bona fide
newspaper men can, with the provisions of this
Bill, do their job more efficiently and without
fear. This Bill seeks to exercise some kind of
check to ensure that the right people are in
control of management shares and to prevent
undesirable elements from owning management shares
and thus gain control of the newspapers. In this
way, bona fide newspaper men will be able
Column: 924
to carry out their duties with peace of mind. When
the Bill is passed, I hope such newspaper men will
carry out their duties more positively and
efficiently, particularly those who are thinking
of publishing academic magazines or newspapers.
Notwithstanding what I have said, Sir, we still
have some newspapers of good standing. Newspapers
which do good deeds will receive good rewards.
However, there are newspapers which publish
undesirable news items, articles or reports in
order to attract a wider readership. I hope that
after the final passage of this Bill, such a
newspaper will be able to develop from a mosquito
newspaper into a medium-sized newspaper and from a
medium-sized newspaper into a large newspaper. The
small or mosquito newspapers actually depend on
crime reports or even sex stories to boost their
sales. Such mosquito newspapers seem to paint a
chaotic state of the world because the more
chaotic the world is the more news they can
publish, and the more sensationalism they can whip
up the greater the boost to their sales. It is my
hope that after the passage of this Bill, these
newspapers will develop along a healthier
direction in the interest of the people. With this
hope I reiterate my full support for this Bill.
3.30 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour (Mr Fong Sip Chee)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I hope the air of light-heartedness
will not diminish the gravity of this Bill. Two
years ago, when I was still in the Ministry of
Culture, I dwelt on this same topic in this House
- perhaps, the newspapers at that time did not
give a fair description of my views then. But this
is a trivial matter.
Several Members have expressed their views on the
influence of newspapers on culture, the very
freedom of the press itself and foreign influence
making inroads into Singapore. They also rightly
commented on certain activities of the newspapers
that were irrelevant as far as our people were
concerned.
Column: 925
But I feel that our main consideration for the
passage of this Bill is based on national interest
and security. We have to explain to the people the
measures we now take lest they may feel that the
introduction of this Bill is merely to exercise
control over the English, Chinese and other
newspapers. It must be made clear and the people
must realise that what we are doing is in the
interest of our country. What is important is that
if a newspaper is in the hands of foreigners - as
we all know the newspaper is a very effective
public medium - and acts against the interest of
our country, we must be vigilant against this
manoeuvre and must necessarily nip it in the bud.
Certain foreigners had publicised their own
thoughts and ideas through our newspapers.
Articles were written on what was labelled as "one-party monopoly" and on the question of
parliamentary democracy in Singapore, lamenting
the fact that there was no opposition in
Parliament. What they advocated was the simplistic
view that since there was no opposition in
Parliament, there was no democracy. All these
talks were nonsensical utterances. They viewed
Singapore with a foreign standpoint and through
tinted glasses. The result, of course, was that
events were distorted and consequently confused
the views of the people. These foreign journalists
judged local events according to their own
philosophies, standards and their own mental
makeup. What may be acceptable to them, perhaps,
would be a situation obtained in line with their
own liking. What they failed to understand, and we
are very conscious, is that our way of life,
philosophy and attitude towards life are quite
different from their own and since they do not see
any similarity between Singapore and their
country, they simply equate the situation as the
non-existence of democracy and that ours is a "one-party monopoly" - or other evil things like that.
Of course, not all foreign journalists are
ignorant of the facts of life in Singapore, some
were even appreciative of the situation here but
there were others, awareness of the facts not-
Column: 926
withstanding, deliberately behaved in a manner as
dictated by their "behind-the curtain masters". It
is not my intention to place all foreign
journalists in this category but even they would
accept that there were a few black sheep among
them. It is understandable that foreign
journalists have to make a living by selling their
articles and news reports.
There were articles specially written to
criticize the method of governmental
administration, implying high-handedness on the
part of the Government in exerting pressure on
certain newspapers and the journalistic circles.
All these were calculated to create a confusion of
mind and subvert the country's peace and order. It
must be emphasized that when the chips are down,
it was Singapore that would be responsible to
ensure peace and order in our society. None of
those who branded Singapore with all sorts of
mischievous names could state in black and white
that they, and they alone, could guarantee that
peace and order in Singapore would not break down.
What happened in the event of a chaotic situation
that they helped bring about? Far from being able
to assist, they would just make quick exit from
the country and then retire into their bedroom to
write articles on the situation and continue to
earn their fees. Is that the kind of contribution
they could make to Singapore?
Even in Australia there was a time when members
of the public were stirred when they learnt that a
foreign newspaper tycoon was attempting to take
over a certain local newspaper there.
As I said earlier, there are those who view us in
a different light and through their tinted
glasses. Whatever we do, they react with
scepticism. They seem to have strange imaginations
about everything that we are trying to do for the
good of our people. What we desire is a situation
where the wishes and thinking of the people can be
expressed truly through the newspapers, in short,
the press should reflect the aspirations of
Singaporeans and not foreigners. There were some
newspapers who
Column: 927
supported the views of other countries against
their own viewpoints. This, perhaps, was intended
to net in a wider readership. The question of the
Straits of Malacca was a good example in point.
This showed that we do have parasites even among
our own journalists who are prepared to repeat
what others say and echo them without considering
the effects or consequences as a result of their
toeing the policies of other countries.
A journalist is just like anybody else. Everyone
has his own character and personality. Likewise, a
journalist should have his own professional
integrity, personality and character. It is a pity
that there are people who are only interested in
fees and circulation and therefore seek to publish
news or views that will cause public
sensationalism. I had the opportunity to discuss
this matter with one of them who remarked that
"Whilst in business, let's talk business." I
bluntly told him that if what he really wanted was
mere business, then he should find it more
profitable to launch into some other kind of
enterprises and certainly not the newspapers
because a newspaper should not be only a money-making proposition. I further added that there are
many other ways to make money other than
irresponsible writing in the newspapers. In fact,
writing is a very hard way to make a living and if
money is what one is after, then certainly the
newspaper is the wrong place.
The Member for Henderson commented on certain
reports which my colleague, the Parliamentary
Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs, did
not seem to agree to. I will give just one example
to illustrate what effects the choice of news
reports can make in the community. There was
quoted in a certain newspaper a robbery case in a
foreign country. A clipping of that newspaper was
sent to Singapore for publication. At the risk of
being accused of creating an uproar in this House,
let me briefly describe the contents of this news
report as I think it is a very serious matter. The
report said that a
Column: 928
gang of robbers entered into a house and on
failing to find anything valuable, they became
furious and castrated a child whom they found in
the house. This news item of atrocious brutality
was a sensational news item in that country and
every full stop and comma of this news report was
reproduced in one of our local newspapers. What
was it they hoped to achieve by quoting this
article? Was it meant to reflect the comparative
security of Singapore or was it meant to introduce
or give ideas to our local criminals? Therefore,
there must be certain principles which the editors
must adopt in the choice and publication of news
items.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the main objective of this Bill
is to ensure that newspapers should reflect the
views and aspirations of our citizens. It cannot
be denied that the newspaper is also an
educational medium for the public and it has also
a duty to educate and enlighten the community.
Through its circulation, it can positively help in
our efforts in nation building and in the
maintenance of law and order. In short, the
newspaper must work in the interest of the country
and the people rather than for the sheer profit to
fill the pockets of a small group of individuals.
Sir, I support this Bill.
3.42 p.m.
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
rise to support this Bill in toto. Although what I
wanted to say has already been said, there is just
one point I wish to mention. I feel that there is
one clause in the Bill which is a little too
preponderant. In Part III, clause 9 (2) says:
`No newspaper company shall refuse to issue
management shares to any person who has been
granted the written approval of the Minister to
purchase such shares.'
I feel that this is a little too drastic, and I
hope to present certain views on this point when
this Bill is sent to Select Committee.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu): Mr Speaker, Sir, I
promise to be very brief. Clause 10 prohibits the
receipt of
Column: 929
funds from a foreign source. The intention is
quite clear. But on reading it, I am a little
concerned that the clause, if implemented in its
present form, may also be used as a means of
subversion against us. For example, if someone
dislikes a particular pressman, it can be so
easily arranged for a certain sum of money to be
deposited into a bank account in that individual's
name. Having done so, an anonymous report can then
be made to the Minister and, if the consequent
investigations are not objective and thorough
enough, miscarriage of justice could arise. I am
not a lawyer. I do not know what the legal
implications are, but I am just wondering whether
there are adequate safeguards for our pressmen. I
hope this point will be looked into by the Select
Committee.
3.44 p.m.
Mr P. Selvadurai (Kuo Chuan): Mr Speaker, Sir,
this is an important Bill, one that is bound to
provoke controversy both within and outside
Singapore. It brings to the fore once again the
peculiar problems faced by small strategically
located developing States that are endeavouring to
transform their socio-economic structures without
compromising their independence internationally on
the basis of democratic institutions. Sad to say,
the Bill also demonstrates the fragile base on
which educated opinion in Singapore moves. It is a
pity too that despite the phenomenal strides that
we have made in education over the last 20 years,
no newspaper has emerged in Singapore as a
national institution serving the national
interest.
It was still possible only a few years ago for a
combination of foreign interests to mount the
Singapore Herald to confuse and divide educated
opinion on issues that were vital to the social
peace and security of Singapore. There were no in-built checks and balances to contain the
operation. The State had to step in.
Popular political thinking defines democratic
politics in terms of a few fundamental freedoms,
of which freedom
Column: 930
of the press is one. But, unlike the other
fundamental freedoms, the freedom of the press has
become over the last hundred years or so the
handmaiden of vast economic interests. In the
context of Singapore these interests have always
been international in character. In the final
analysis the press in South-east Asian states has
to-date been controlled by foreign rather than
national interests. It is this situation that we
have to meet in the course of our political
development.
Having said this, Sir, one wonders if the Bill
has not gone too far than was necessary in
regulating the problem. The provision that
management shares could only be held by Singapore
citizens with the approval of the Minister appears
to be too drastic, on the face of it. It would be
preferable to leave the management shares in the
hands of Singapore citizens regardless of
Ministerial approval but with the negative
stipulation that no management shares shall be
refused to persons who have been approved by the
Minister. The provisions of clause 10 are more
than sufficient and adequate to deal with the
problems posed by foreign financial control of
national press. The experiment is an interesting
one. Time only will tell if the aims and
objectives of the Bill are achieved and also
whether in the process we have stifled free, frank
and fearless discussion of issues that vitally
concern the nation.
3.50 p.m.
Mr Speaker: Mr Govindaswamy?
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson): Sir, in fact, I do
not want to speak on this Bill, but since Mr
Speaker has called me I might as well say
something.
Mr Speaker, Sir, I fully support the Bill. But we
must not be too strict in our control of the
newspapers, for if we do they cannot be published.
That is very bad. The newspaper must be given some
freedom, otherwise people will say that it is
controlled by the Government. Therefore, the
Minister must consider giving some freedom to the
newspaper. However, I fully support
Column: 931
the Bill. Since this Bill is going to the Select
Committee, most probably we will get public
opinion.
Mr Jek Yeun Thong: Sir, first of all, I must
thank Members for their enthusiastic support for
this Bill. Many of them have been very articulate
and, in fact, they have made longer speeches than
I expected. I must take this opportunity to assure
Members of the House and also members of the
public that it is not the intention of the
Government to go into the newspaper business. Our
intention is to see that newspapers are properly
managed and that they cannot be taken over by
undesirable elements which may then direct their
policies against the interests of our nation. That
is the sole purpose of this Bill.
The Member for Kim Seng and the Member for Kuo
Chuan have to a certain extent mentioned the fear
that the Bill might be delegating undue powers to
the Minister or the Government for control of the
press. Those fears exist in the minds of many
people. I think it should be sufficient to allay
the fears of these people when I say that it is
not the intention of the Government to take over
the newspapers but to see that a free press is
allowed to be conducted in Singapore. It is
certainly not our intention to curb the genuine
expression of public opinion. In fact, it is to
our interest that those opinions should be allowed
to be expressed. Let the flowers bloom. In a
situation like ours it is quite important that the
man-in-the-street should be given the opportunity
to express his opinion, whether it is about buses,
the Ministry of Culture's TV programmes or other
matters. He should be given the opportunity to
express his opinion publicly and there is no other
medium better than the press. We would like to see
this sort of freedom existing in Singapore.
However, many very important
Column: 932
views have been expressed by Members, and I
am sure that these views will be taken care of
when the Bill is considered by the Select
Committee.
There are some minor points which I should touch
on briefly. The Member for Delta has queried:
since the management shares are so important that
their voting rights are greater than those of the
ordinary shares, what type of citizens will be
allowed to own these management shares? We have
not come to that stage yet; let us cross the
bridge when we come to it. I am sure the Minister
for Home Affairs will be able to advise me as to
which type of citizens will be allowed to own
those shares.
We have, in fact, considered a Press Council for
a very long time, but we found that it is not
practicable under our present conditions. First of
all, who is to be the Chairman? Who gives the
order? Who lays down policies? These are all very
complicated matters, and I think it would be
better that the press be allowed to manage
themselves. Therefore, we have introduced these
management shares to ensure that only the right
people are allowed to exercise the powers of
management of newspapers. The Members for Bukit
Merah and Henderson and the Parliamentary
Secretary to the Minister for Labour have also
offered very good advice to the newspaper
directors as to how they should run the newspapers
and what sort of articles should be put in to
attract more readers, and so on. I hope the
newspapers concerned will take note of their
advice and make improvements to the contents of
their newspapers. Apart from those comments, Sir,
I have nothing more to add.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Resolved,
"That the Newspaper and Printing Presses Bill be
committed to a Select Committee consisting of Mr
Speaker as Chairman and seven Members to be
nominated by the Committee of Selection." - [Mr Jek Yeun Thong].
Column: 933
MUTUAL BENEFIT ORGANISATIONS (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.55 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs (Mr Chan Chee Seng): Mr Speaker,
Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a
Second time."
The purpose of this Bill is to introduce several
amendments to the Mutual Benefit Organisations Act
(Chapter 254 of the Revised Edition) which are
found necessary in the light of experience gained
in administering the Act.
The proposed amendments seek to strengthen the
hands of the Registrar in administering the Mutual
Benefit Organisations Act which provides for the
registration and control of all mutual benefit
organisations in the Republic. At present, there
are 427 such organisations with a total membership
of 191,367. Many of the long established
organisations have accumulated large surplus funds
over the years. As the majority of the members of
mutual benefit organisations are from the lower-income group and often illiterate, there must be
adequate legislation to ensure that these mutual
benefit organisations are properly managed and
their activities consistent with the objectives of
their organisations for the welfare and benefit of
the subscribers. It is, therefore, necessary that
the interests of the members be safeguarded by
appropriate law against exploitation by
unscrupulous persons.
Experience over the years has shown that the
existing provisions in the Mutual Benefit
Organisations Act relating to registration and
cancellation of mutual benefit organisations are
inadequate and restrictive. There is no provision
at present empowering the Registrar to refuse
registration of newly formed organisations if he
has reason to believe that such organisations have
been formed for the personal gain of the
organisers. Nor has the Registrar the power to
prevent mutual benefit
Column: 934
organisations from being managed by persons of
dubious character or used for any purpose contrary
to the public interest. To remedy this, sections 5
and 6 of the Act will be repealed and two new
sections re-enacted to provide the Registrar with
wider powers in considering an application for the
registration of a mutual benefit organisation.
Under the existing section 7, a person aggrieved
by the refusal of the Registrar to register an
organisation may appeal at any time to the
Minister. It is desirable to stipulate a fixed
period in which an appeal may be made. Section 7
of the Act is, therefore, being amended so that an
appeal against the decision of a Registrar must be
made within one month from the date of
notification of such a decision.
In addition, a new section 1lA is being
introduced for the purpose of prohibiting any
person who has been convicted of an offence
involving dishonesty or moral turpitude, or who
has been sentenced to imprisonment for a term of
not less than one year or to a fine of not less
than $2,000 and who has not received a free
pardon, from acting as an officer of a mutual
benefit Organisation.
Subsection (1) of section 27 will be deleted and
a new subsection re-enacted to give the Registrar
wider powers to cancel the registration of any
mutual benefit organisation.
Finally, the Bill also seeks to introduce a new
subsection under section 45 to enable the Minister
to exempt any organisation, person or class of
persons, from any or all of the provisions of the
Act. The purpose of this new subsection is to
allow some flexibility in administering the Act
under special circumstances.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Chan Chee Sengl.
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 935
PARKING PLACES BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
4.02 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
The Urban Redevelopment Authority Act (No. 65 of
1973), which was passed by this House in November
last year and assented to by the President in
January this year, will be put into operation on
the 1st of April this year. Under the provisions
of the Act, the Car Parks Division of my Ministry
will be integrated with the Urban Redevelopment
Authority. However, matters presently administered
by the Car Parks Division will continue to be
governed by the Parking Places Act (Cap. 19, 1970
Edition). The Bill now before the House seeks to
repeal and re-enact, with amendments, the Parking
Places Act, 1970.
I will draw Members' attention to only some of
the more significant features, namely, clause 3
which empowers the Minister to provide suitable
parking places for vehicles. Clause 4 prohibits
persons from maintaining or operating any private
parking places unless he is a holder of a valid
licence, and empowers the Minister to prescribe
the manner in which a licensed private parking
place is to be maintained or operated. Clause 6
provides for the appointment of a Superintendent
of Car Parks. Clause 8 empowers the Minister to
make rules to regulate the use of public and
private parking places. Clause 16 provides for the
payment of all charges collected and all fines
imposed into the funds of the Urban Redevelopment
Authority.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr E. W. Barker].
Bill considered in Committee.
Column: 936
Clause 1 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 2 -
Mr Barker: Sir, I beg to move,
In page 2, line 3, after "Government", to insert
"or the Authority".
This is a drafting error which needs correction.
Amendment agreed to.
Clause 2, as amended, ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clause 3 to 17 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Bill reported with an amendment; read a Third
time and passed.
Column: 936
MARTIAL ARTS INSTRUCTION BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
4.08 p.m.
The Minister for Health and Home Affairs (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Hitherto, the Government has adopted a laissez-faire policy towards martial arts organisations in
Singapore. This is because these organisations
like the Chinese pugilistic organisations, the
bersilat and judo clubs, etc., have been in
existence for many years and have become part of
the cultural life of our population. Hence any
exponent of these arts is free to practise or to
impart his skill to whoever wants to learn the
art. The Government considers that the discipline
and the training provided in acquiring the skill
will develop a "healthy mind and healthy body" and
thus help to build a rugged society in our
Republic. These organisations were, therefore,
allowed to function without impediment.
In recent years there has been a proliferation of
martial arts organisations in Singapore. At the
end of 1973, there were 128 martial arts
organisations registered in Singapore compared to
only 32 in 1963. It is difficult to estimate the
Column: 937
number of trainees learning martial arts, although
this has been placed between 13,000 to 18,000. New
arts like karate and taekwondo have emerged in
Singapore, and variations of these arts like
akido, kendo, jiu-jitsu, as well as the different
Chinese pugilistic arts have been developed. The
rapid growth of these organisations and the
increasing number of trainees learning different
martial arts can be traced to their popularisation
by Chinese films especially from Hongkong and
Taiwan in the late 60's which glorify the use of
martial arts. These films which emphasise violence
and bloodshed were one of the contributory factors
resulting in an increase in the crime rate and a
rise in violence in the commission of crimes. It
is noted that between 1967 and 1969 when these
films were widely shown in the Republic, the
number of new pugilistic organisations which
applied to the Government for registration
increased at the rate of 11 to 15 each year
compared to very few in the 50's and in the early
60's. Although the Government has imposed strict
censorship on these films last year, the number of
martial arts organisations applying to the
Government for registration has not abated. Up to
March this year, there were 133 registered martial
arts organisations with 11 new applications under
consideration.
The increasing interest amongst our population in
martial art training has made many of these
organisations become commercial concerns. Some
pseudo martial arts organisations have also sprung
up to exploit the market. Since there is little or
no control over these organisations, any
instructor who professes sufficient knowledge of
any martial art can organise a class and apply for
registration to the Registrar of Societies or the
Registrar of Business Names by payment of a small
fee. Both the Registrars have no means of checking
whether such an instructor is qualified to teach
this skill or to whom he should impart his
knowledge. Similarly, instructors will readily
accept any trainee as a student with scant concern
about his background, his purpose in
Column: 938
acquiring the art and whether he would benefit
from it, so long as he is prepared to meet the fee
required for receiving such training. There is,
therefore, little control as to who is qualified
to teach or who can learn the art.
Because of the laxity in admission and the
general availability of these martial arts
organisations to the public, many of these
organisations have been penetrated by secret
society members and the criminal elements who
learn martial art to further their own ends. These
secret society members use the art in gang clashes
to glorify the triad which they belong and also to
cow innocent victims from whom they extort money.
In a recent study on some 115 pugilistic
organisations in Singapore, it was found that 33
of these have been penetrated by secret society
elements and 10 of them have elements with adverse
security records.
Although it is not the intention of Government to
deter anyone who requires martial art training to
build up a healthy body and for self-defence, it
is recognised that organisations which teach
martial art, be it a Chinese pugilistic art, or
karate or taekwondo or judo or bersilat, in
effect, equip their members with a potential
weapon which, if abused, can have serious
consequences for their victims and serious
implications for the maintenance of law and order.
As such, in the interest of society, Government
has found it necessary to institute proper
controls to regulate the activities of such
organisations and to ensure that those whom they
teach are not likely to abuse the art that they
have acquired. In other words, the knowledge and
skill of martial arts in the hands of disciplined
and law-abiding persons can be of benefit to both
the exponent and society. But if such knowledge
and skill were allowed to fall into the wrong
hands it can be very dangerous and detrimental to
society. Hence, the Martial Arts Instruction Bill
before the House.
Martial arts, as defined in the Bill, include
karate, taekwondo, judo, akido, kendo, bersilat,
kung-fu, jiu-jitsu, or a
Column: 939
combination thereof. However, in view of the fact
that new forms of martial arts or variations of
existing forms of martial arts are introduced into
Singapore from time to time, this definition of
"martial art" cannot be comprehensive. However,
the Minister is empowered by clause 2 (2) to
declare any other art of pugilism, fighting,
boxing or self-defence to be a martial art for
purposes of the Act.
The administration of the Act will be in the
hands of a Controller of Martial Arts. Assistant
Controllers will also be able to exercise all the
powers conferred on the Controller, subject to
such limitations as he may impose (clause 3).
Clause 5 of the Bill requires all martial art
associations to be registered. The Controller
shall refuse registration in the circumstances
stipulated in clause 4 (3) and may refuse
registration in certain other circumstances
stipulated in clause 4 (4). An unregistered
martial art association, which is organised in
Singapore and whose officers, employees or members
provide instruction in any form of martial art in
Singapore, will be deemed to be unlawful. It will
be an offence for a person to pursue certain
activities in connection with unlawful martial art
associations (clauses 5, 15, 16, 17 and 18).
Clause 11 empowers the Controller to order any
registered martial art association to furnish him
with such information as he may require concerning
the provision of instruction in any form of
martial art at a place of instruction provided by
the association or with any document, account or
book of the association relating thereto.
Clause 19 seeks to disallow any person from
holding office in a registered martial art
association if he has been declared, in writing,
by the Controller to be unfit to act as an officer
of a martial art association. The Controller may
make such declaration upon any of the grounds
stipulated in clause 19. Any person who acts in
contravention
Column: 940
of this clause will be liable, on conviction, to a
maximum fine of $500 or to a maximum term of
imprisonment of six months or to both such fine
and imprisonment.
Whenever it appears to the Minister that any
officer, employee or member of a registered
martial art association provides instruction in
any form of martial art at a place of instruction
provided by the association in an unlawful manner
or for unlawful purposes or for purposes
prejudicial to public peace, welfare or good order
in Singapore, the Minister may order the
cancellation of the registration of the
association. A similar power is conferred upon the
Minister where the association has contravened any
provision of the Act or any regulations made
thereunder.
No person except an instructor who is in
possession of an instructor's certificate issued
under the Act may instruct any person in any form
of martial art (clause 21). The Controller will be
responsible for granting instructor's
certificates. Clause 25 (3) stipulates the grounds
on which the Controller may refuse to grant an
instructor's certificate. Clause 26 empowers the
Controller to revoke, cancel or suspend an
instructor's certificate for any of the reasons
stipulated in that clause.
No person may receive instruction in any form of
martial art from an instructor unless he is
registered as a trainee under the Act (clause 22).
The Controller will be responsible for the
registration of trainees. Clause 22 stipulates the
grounds on which the Controller may refuse to
register any person as a trainee. Clause 24
empowers the Controller to revoke, cancel or
suspend the registration of a trainee for any of
the reasons stipulated in that clause.
Clause 31 provides the Controller and Police
officers with the powers of entry, search and
arrest, in circumstances where there is reason to
believe that an offence has been committed under
the Act.
Clause 34 empowers the Minister to exempt any
organisation, person or
Column: 941
class of persons from any or all of the provisions
of the Act. The Minister may also make regulations
generally for carrying out the purposes and
provisions of the Act (clause 39).
There are transitional provisions in the Bill to
cater for those martial art associations which are
in existence and for those instructors and
trainees who are providing or receiving
instruction in any form of martial art, as the
case may be before the commencement of the Act
(clauses 40 and 41).
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
4.20 p.m.
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee): Mr Speaker, Sir,
I rise to support the Martial Arts Instruction
Bill. I would like to inquire from the Minister
for Health and Home Affairs whether he would
consider encouraging members of the Police force
to undergo training in all the various forms of
martial arts because in Singapore at the present
time a lot of bad hats have some experience in
various forms of martial art. Members of the Armed
Forces too have a duty to enforce law and order.
Therefore, it would be advantageous and necessary,
if it is possible, for all members of the Armed
Forces to be trained in the martial arts. If there
are sufficient instructors, members of the
Vigilante Corps should also be encouraged to
undergo this kind of training.
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I rise in support of this Bill. In
recent years the various forms of martial arts,
such as the Chinese pugilistic art, Western
boxing, wrestling, taekwondo, judo and many others
have been found to be very popular with the
younger generation. More and more people are
learning some form of martial art. The Bill
introduced by the Minister, therefore, seeks to
exercise certain control over the instruction and
training of the various forms of martial art, so
as to ensure their proper guidance and
development.
Column: 942
The Chinese pugilistic arts have a very long
history, whereas the development of martial arts
in Singapore has been very active only in recent
years. I remember a few years ago after a Chinese
martial art organisation was formed, much
assistance was given to its various members. Its
members have contributed to many items of activity
for our National Day celebrations and other
festivals. I refer to the Singapore Federation of
Pugilistic Association. Their contributions
include the lion dance, the dragon dance and other
performances for our various celebrations,
particularly on National Day.
The Bill requires instructors and members of any
martial art organisation to be registered and
perhaps screened so that there can be proper
control over them. This is very good indeed
because those people who learn the martial arts
comprise all kinds of people, including dubious
elements. So if by legislation we can ensure that
the members of these organisations are all
disciplined and law-abiding people, then it is a
law that will indeed do good for Singapore.
I have several suggestions to make to the
Minister. The Bill provides for the appointment of
a Controller of Martial Arts who will have to
exercise administrative control over martial arts.
However, I would like to know whether he will be
someone well versed in the martial arts. I suppose
he is expected to be conversant with all forms of
martial arts. If not, he should at least be
conversant with certain forms of martial arts, so
that he will be capable of exercising judgment
when reviewing applications. Secondly, with regard
to the registration of private martial art
organisations, or institutes as they call them, I
understand some of these organisations are
recruiting trainees in kung-fu or some kind of
pugilistic art. I would like to ask whether these
martial art institutes have to be registered under
the Bill before they can carry out their enrolment
exercise.
Column: 943
4.28 p.m.
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru)(In Mandarin): Mr
Speaker, Sir, following the call by the Government
to all citizens to be strong and healthy, many
martial art organisations have sprung up, and more
and more people are joining these institutes to
take up martial arts. But these people have
different motives. Some learn it as a form of
exercise to improve their health; while others
have ulterior motives. So the introduction of this
Bill is very timely and also very useful.
However, there are several points which I would
like the Minister to clarify. First, the
definition of martial arts. For instance, the so-called kung-fu, as I understand it, is a Chinese
form of pugilistic art. However, its connotation
is very wide. There should be a more clear-cut
definition of kung-fu. Another instance is tai-chi. It should be made clear whether or not tai-chi, or shadow boxing, is to be classified under
this definition. There are many old folks
performing the tai-chi in the parks and other
places. They even include old crones, grandmothers
and grandfathers, and they go to the Botanic
Gardens as well. Therefore, there should be a
proper definition of martial arts so that the
Director of Botanic Gardens will not mistake the
exercises of these old people for something
unlawful. Secondly, with regard to instructors
which the Member for Sembawang has also touched
upon, they have to apply to the Controller for an
instructor's certificate. Before the Controller of
Martial Arts issues such certificates, he has to
be satisfied with the applicant's character and
morals. But, in addition to this, the Controller
should also make sure that the applicant is well
qualified in the particular martial art in which
he wishes to instruct.
The third point is about registration of
trainees. The Minister has given a detailed
explanation on this point. The idea is to exercise
some control over these people so that they may
not utilise their skill for criminal purposes.
Therefore, the registration of trainees is very
important. I remember that in
Column: 944
the past, when one wished to be enrolled for the
boxing or weight-lifting classes run by the
community centres, one's name would be sent for
screening. But such practice has ceased now. I
think it is necessary to revive such practice.
Another aspect is that if a community centre
wants to provide instruction in certain forms of
martial art, the centre concerned must first take
its environment into consideration whether or not
such form of martial art is worthwhile to be
introduced to the people around. For illustration
purposes, I would like to quote one example of the
community centres in my constituency. Martial art
classes, such as karate, etc, are conducted in the
Tiong Bahru Community Centre, and many people have
been taking part in these classes. A number of
people who live around the Kim Tian Community
Centre have also requested for such classes to be
conducted there. But I opposed the suggestion
because we frequently read in the newspapers about
gang fights among secret society members around
that area. So I feel that martial art classes
should not be allowed in certain areas.
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like
to thank the hon. Members who have spoken in
strong support of the Bill. There is nothing more
for me to add except to answer a few queries which
Members have brought up. The first is from the
Member for Bukit Ho Swee. He asked whether some
form of martial art training is being given to
Police officers. In fact, in the training of
Police officers, they are given training on what
is called unarmed combat. With regard to the VCs,
particularly those who are now engaged in the
community security force policing, they are also
being taught or given training in unarmed combat
as well.
With regard to the queries brought up by the
Member for Sembawang, who I understand is an
honorary adviser to a pugilistic association, he
asked whether the Controller of Martial Arts will
be a person well versed in martial arts.
Column: 945
May I say that he would have knowledge of martial
arts but he need not necessarily be an exponent of
martial arts.
The Member also asked whether all martial arts
associations must be registered. If they come
within the definition of "martial arts" as has
been defined in the Bill, they will have to be
registered.
The point brought up by the Member for Tiong
Bahru is with regard to the definition of martial
arts. I have in my speech given the definition as
provided by the Bill. "Martial art" is defined to
include taekwondo, judo, akido, kendo, bersilat,
kung-fu, jiu-jitsu or a combination or variation
thereof. However, as I have also stated, the
definition cannot be exhaustive because it has a
very wide meaning, and therefore the Minister has
been given powers to declare any other art of
pugilism, fighting, boxing or self-defence to be a
martial art for the purposes of the Act. The
purpose of the Act is to control the people who
have acquired the skill so that they would not use
it for their own ends, in other words, for
criminal purposes. That is the wide basis on which
the definition is made.
The Member brought up the specific example of tai-chi, or shadow boxing. I do not know very much
about tai-chi. From what I can gather, tai-chi is
actually a form of exercise and not necessarily a
form of self-defence where one can cause injury to
another person. If it is brought to my notice that
it can cause injury, then I will exercise my
powers under the Bill and classify it as a martial
art. If it is just a form of exercise and cannot
cause injury, then I will not consider it as a
form of martial art. The word "martial" means
"pertaining to warfare". So it must be an
aggressive art, although used in self-defence. But
I think an exponent of martial arts will be able
to advise me whether tai-chi should or should not
be considered a martial art. I do not want to
decide on the matter right now.
Column: 946
With regard to the point brought up by the Member
for Tiong Bahru about what sort of instructors
will be issued with certificates, of course,
firstly, they will be screened and if they have a
criminal record, then they will not be issued with
instructors' certificates. Secondly, on the
question of what sort of skill they should have,
unless we have a board of examiners, we are unable
to judge the skill of an instructor. But so long
as an applicant has genuine skills and is not a
pseudo, he may be certified as an instructor.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Chua Sian Chin].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Mr Speaker: Order. I suspend the Sitting now and
shall take the Chair again at 5.10 p.m.
Sitting accordingly suspended
at 4.42 p.m. until 5.10 p.m.
Column: 946
Sitting resumed at 5.10 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
NATIONAL REGISTRATION (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
The Minister for Health and Home Affairs (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
The re-registration exercise for persons born
between 6th May, 1949, and 5th May, 1955, and who
obtained their identity cards before attaining the
age of 17 years ended on 29th September, 1973.
However, in spite of the wide publicity given to
this exercise and the provision of facilities for
re-registration in practically all the community
centres, about 19,000 persons Out of the 252,000
persons required to register under Regulation 15
of the National Registration
Column: 947
Regulations, 1966, have not re-registered. These
persons are liable on conviction to imprisonment
for a term up to five years or to a fine up to
$1,000 or to both imprisonment and a fine.
In order to reduce further the number of persons
who have not registered, the Government has
decided to extend the closing date of the re-registration exercise to the end of this month.
However, it is envisaged that there will still be
some who will still not re-register by this new
dead-line. This number may be further increased
with future re-registration exercises. It would be
impractical to bring every case to court. Besides
the presence of large numbers of offenders will
increase congestion in our courts.
It is, therefore, proposed that the National
Registration Act be amended to provide for the
composition of offences prescribed under the
National Registration Regulations, 1966.
Consequent upon this amendment, the National
Registration Regulations, 1966, will empower the
Commissioner of National Registration to compound
offences relating to late re-registration of
persons who have attained the age of 17 years, by
a fine not exceeding $100.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Chua Sian Chin].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 947
PROPERTY TAX (SURCHARGE) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.15 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time,"
Column: 948
The Bill proposes to impose with effect from 1st
January, 1974, a surcharge of 10 per cent on the
annual values of real estate, other than
industrial and commercial properties, not owned by
citizens of Singapore or permanent residents. The
Bill has arisen from Government's concern with the
speculation on residential properties and vacant
land and the consequent escalation in their
prices. The steep rise in prices is attributable
to, among other factors, purchases by non-residents. Those of our local citizens and
permanent residents who do not qualify for Housing
Board flats, therefore, find their hope of
purchasing their own homes from private housing
estates frustrated by prices beyond their means to
pay.
It is the objective of the Government to realise
a scheme for widespread home ownership amongst its
citizens and permanent residents. To ensure the
success of such a scheme, Government announced in
September last year that only Singapore citizens
would be eligible to purchase residential
properties and vacant land with effect from
September, 1973. Permanent residents, non-citizens
and others may be allowed to purchase residential
properties or vacant lands only with the approval
of the Government. The imposition of a property
tax surcharge, equal to 10 per cent of the annual
values of properties and land, was also announced
as a further measure aimed at curbing excessive
speculation in real estate and stabilising prices
of residential properties and vacant land. Both
these measures are designed to assist the many
young executives, professionals, etc, among its
citizens ineligible for Housing Board units to
purchase their own homes.
The present Bill is, therefore, to give effect to
the second of these measures in Government's
stated policy.
Clause 4 enables rules to be published in the
Gazette to exempt certain classes of persons or
categories from payment of the surcharge.
Exemption of the
Column: 949
surcharge will be granted to the following
categories of properties:
(a) Properties owned by a Singapore citizen
or a permanent resident of Singapore including
all owner-occupied HDB fiats and temporary
structures;
(b) Properties owned by a company registered in
Singapore and carrying on business in Singapore;
(c) Properties owned by an association, club,
society or an approved body registered in
Singapore; and
(d) Industrial and commercial built-up
properties irrespective of ownership.
Clause 5 vests in the President the power to vary
the rate of surcharge.
Clause 6 provides for the situation where a
residential property is jointly owned by either a
Singapore citizen or a permanent resident and a
non-citizen. In such cases, the Comptroller is
given discretionary power to remit wholly or in
part the property tax surcharge payable, if he is
satisfied that the property is occupied by the
joint owners and that payment of the surcharge
will result in hardship.
Clauses 8, 9 and 11 make provisions for the
Comptroller of Property Tax to seek information
and prescribe forms or returns for effective
enforcement and collection of the surcharge.
Clause 10 provides that if an offence is
committed to evade the surcharge, any person on
conviction is liable to a fine not exceeding
$1,000. When fraud is involved, the penalty will
be five times the surcharge not including a
further fine of $5,000 or a term of imprisonment
not exceeding six months or both fine and
imprisonment.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Dr Ong Leong Boon: Mr Speaker, Sir, I rise to
support this Bill in its spirit. I think it is a
laudable Bill in that the intentions as expressed
in September last year were to have a stabilising
effect upon the rising cost of land and
Column: 950
private property. What I would like to know from
the Minister, however, is: what has been the
actual effect of this Bill on the state of things
today, whether the announcement in September last
year has produced any decline or stabilising
effect on the prices of land and private property
in this country?
The Minister has quite rightly pointed out the
plight of the middle income wage earners. As it is
today, I think even with a knowledge of the
present inflationary trend, private property and
land are well beyond the reach of the middle
income wage earner. To my mind, the proposition
that the Government has made and the measures it
has taken to build more flats and also the
intention to build condominium type of terrace
houses for this middle income group is something
worth pursuing. What I feel is that the Government
should step up the construction of these flats and
houses. This will probably contribute more towards
the welfare of the middle income wage earner than
the Bill as such, although in principle and in
spirit, it has laudable objectives.
May I ask the Hon. Minister if he could explain
to this House whether this Bill has or will have
any real effect upon the state of property and
land values today?
5.20 p.m.
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi): Sir, I share the
sentiments expressed by the Member for Kim Seng.
The Minister has said just now that the intention
of this Bill is to help the young executives who
do not qualify for Housing and Development Board
fiats. I wonder whether these young executives are
in a position to purchase flats built by private
developers. Sir, I saw an advertisement only about
a week ago on the sale of flats in the Cairnhill
Plaza. The price of each flat ranges from $200,000
to $300,500. If someone takes a housing loan
amounting to 80 per cent of the price of the flat,
payable in 15 years, he would have to pay a
monthly instalment of over $1,000. I wonder
whether a young executive or a young professional
person, like a doctor, who earns
Column: 951
about $1,200 a month can afford to buy that sort
of a house.
Sir, my suggestion is this: with the increasing
cost of building materials, cement and other
things, perhaps the Government could allow
development of certain places at a higher density
than the present. This will help to lower the
prices of land, and at the same time since more
flats could be built this will naturally reduce
the price of houses. I think this is much better
than depending only on the Housing and Development
Board flats. Even the HDB project in Ulu Pandan
has to be stopped for the time being because of
price increases in building materials. I wonder if
this project is going to materialise and whether
these young executives will be able to purchase
those flats.
5.23 p.m.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Sir, on the questions which have
been raised, it is possible to give answers on a
very general basis. My Ministry of Finance has
monitored the prices of houses since we announced
the Government policy on this matter. We notice,
first of all, a tendency for prices to remain
relatively stable. In the few cases that we have
monitored in different housing estates, we have
noticed a fall in prices of 10-20 per cent. In
other cases, of course, we have seen that there
was a sort of stabilisation in the price. In
certain cases, however, some flats have even gone
up in price, hut this may be due perhaps to
furniture and furnishings, air-conditioning, and
so on, which we do not know very much about. The
data I have are not sufficiently detailed for an
analysis to be made, but I am quite sure that
there has been some effect upon the announcement
of Government's policy since last September.
The Member for Kim Seng was quite right in saying
that we should also build more flats in
condominium type units for the middle income
group. We certainly are going to do this. I
believe my colleague here has announced that even
the Housing and Development
Column: 952
Board is going to build some flats for people who
do not qualify now as they are above the $1,500
per month household income.
While I agree that we should build these units, I
think we must tackle the problem from as many
fronts as possible, and the Bill which I am taking
through all its stages here today will help to
reduce or stabilise prices of the kind of housing
which the middle income groups may be able to
purchase.
I agree with the Member for Changi that when it
comes to flats costing $200,000 and over, or
detached houses of the same value, it is very
unlikely that an executive drawing $1,500 a month
will be able to afford the instalments, which he
will be required to pay for the flat. But there
are other types of housing, like the terrace
houses, semi-detached houses and flats which are
not in the $200,000 class. I think there are flats
costing around $100,000 or even less.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Even then they have to pay an
instalment of about $900 per month.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: That depends also on the interest
rate which is charged, and I think many employers
and certainly the Government and the statutory
boards have given housing loans at lower interest
rates.
Dr Ong Leong Boon: On a point of clarification,
Sir,I am sure the Hon. Minister is aware that the
credit squeeze has resulted in very high interest
rates and difficulty in getting loans. Even if we
work on the basis of a $100,000 flat, payable in
10 years at 10 per cent interest per annum, we
have got to pay $200,000 in 10 years, which means
$20,000 per year or about $2,000 a month. Can a
wage earner earning $1,500 to $2,000 afford this
kind of housing? If my figures are correct, then
it is not possible for him to purchase such a
flat. I think there is a strong case for the
Government to step up its building programme for
the middle income wage earners. Priority, of
course, must be given to those in the civil
service.
Column: 953
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Sir, I have already said that I
fully agree there is a need for more housing to be
constructed, whether by the Housing Board,
statutory boards, JTC, or by firms. I am sure the
executive housing in Jurong is within the means of
the junior executives in Jurong. If any of our
Members of Parliament wish to buy the kind of
executive flats that are being put up in Jurong, I
think we can easily build quite a lot more in
addition to what my colleague has been building.
With regard to the credit squeeze, I think that
is generally applicable to purchases of luxury-type apartments and housing, and it is not
intended for the kind of loans which companies
make to their employees. If, in fact, the credit
squeeze is being operated in a way which has
prevented this, I am sure my Ministry and the
Monetary Authority of Singapore will be prepared
to consider a relaxation of this kind of credit
control to the benefit of the middle income group.
Mr Sim Boon Woo: Hear, hear!
Mr Barker: Sir, I had no intention of joining in
this debate. I am sure my colleague can look after
himself very well. But there was a point raised by
the Member for Changi that if population densities
were higher, plot ratios increase and on a given
plot of, say, one acre, if a building goes higher,
then the total cost will be cheaper. I agree with
that. In fact, it has been the practice of my
Ministry to relax and increase plot ratios,
especially in the heart of the City. That is why
we see the high buildings that are being erected,
some of which have been completed. But obviously
there is a limit beyond which we cannot go, and
the density aspect, of course, is just one part of
the cost. Costs have gone up because building
materials have gone up, and I have spelt out the
details earlier on.
I thought I should clarify to the Member on this
point which has not been answered by my colleague.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah): Sir, neither
did I intend to take part in
Column: 954
this debate. But I think the density ratio plays
an important part. I have some experience in this.
Perhaps there has been some relaxation within the
City area. But in the periphery, the Building
Control Division, or the approving authority, is
still very strict on allowing a relaxation of
density in certain areas. This applies not only to
developments of private developers but also to
statutory boards wanting to build houses for their
employees. In the Minister's constituency,
Tanglin, certainly nobody can put up houses more
than 4-storeys high. Sir, I know of a statutory
board which planned to build blocks of houses 8-storeys high. There was a tremendous response from
the employees. But planning approval was not
given, and modifications had to be made, after
which the cost of each unit went up by about 25-30
per cent, making it beyond the means of the junior
executive to purchase. Perhaps what the Member for
Changi said has more value than it really appears.
I think the Building Control Division and the
Planning Office could also assist junior
executives to purchase flats and bring down the
cost by relaxing the density ratio.
Mr Barker: Sir, I think that point deserves a
reply. Firstly, I think the hon. Member does not
know exactly the boundaries of my constituency
when he said that housing development is confined
to 4-storey flats. To give him an example, he will
find that flats opposite the Botanic Gardens have
gone far, far beyond the 4-storey height which he
has referred to. And that is not the only place in
Tanglin. Tanglin stretches from Lido Theatre to
the MacRitchie Reservoir.
Regarding densities, we have been allowing
developers to build higher and higher. But if a
developer had bought a piece of land knowing that
the plot ratio is 3:1, and then having bought it
expect to get a plot ratio of 10:1, it means he is
going to make a lot of money, and the prices of
land will still go much higher. But there have
been many cases where the ratios have been
relaxed, especially in town where the
Column: 955
plot ratio is now 10:1. It used to be 3:1
before. That is why there are buildings going up
to 50 storeys. There is one developer who wanted
to go up to 100. Every developer in Singapore
wants to go higher and higher. He builds 36, I go
37. Someone else goes 50. They all want to go the
highest. So there must be some planning control.
I do not know the particular statutory board that
the Member has referred to, but statutory boards
are given special attention by my Ministry.
Obviously we cannot favour statutory boards and
give them high plot ratios when perhaps next door
we have confined a private developer to a certain
plot ratio. But I agree with Members that the
price of land bears an important part to the total
price. Hence Government's measures to try and
bring down the price of land, and this Bill helps
to further stabilise the price of land. We have
succeeded to some extent, as my colleague has
pointed out, in bringing down the prices of land
by about 20 per cent in some cases. We hope it
will stay that way, and does not rocket to the
skies again.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Hon Sui Sen].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 955
COMPANIES (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.40 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
The reasons for introducing this Bill are the
same as those I mentioned in introducing the
amending Acts of 1971 and 1973, namely, to give
effect to recommendations by the U.K. Jenkins
Column: 956
Committee Report on Company Law Reform,
particularly insofar as these recommendations
affect the principle of greater disclosure of
information by companies as a safeguard against
malpractices and the powers and duties of
directors.
Disclosure of information is an essential part of
the working of a free and fair economic system,
subject to certain limitations to allow for
competitive situations. Under existing
legislation, substantial powers already exist to
require disclosure by directors in their accounts
or in relation to contracts in which they have an
interest, or in any dealings they may have in
their company shares (including insider dealings)
and so on.
This Bill extends the disclosure principle by
requiring that the interests of members of a
director's family in contracts with the company
shall be treated as an interest of a director and
will need to be disclosed to fellow directors
(clause 14), and by requiring a director who
acquires or disposes of shares in his company
which are listed on a Stock Exchange to notify a
Stock Exchange which may publish the information
(clause 17), and by providing that there should be
clear and specific disclosure in general meeting
of any alteration in directors' emoluments (clause
18).
On a previous occasion in this House, I have made
the point that there is nothing inherently wrong
in the practice of holding shares through nominees
and there are many circumstances in which the
practice is both normal and convenient on
commercial and personal grounds. However, there
are circumstances in which concealment of a
beneficial interest in a shareholding can be
undesirable. I refer particularly to the situation
known as "warehousing", in which a number of
parties act in undisclosed concert in such a way
as not to bring their interest within the existing
provisions dealing with substantial shareholders.
These provisions require that those with an
interest in the equity of a company of 10 per cent
or more have to disclose their interest. Persons
can
Column: 957
evade the provisions by acting in concert and
acquiring shareholdings amounting to, for example,
9.5 per cent. This enables such persons to acquire
by stealth a dominant position in a company,
particularly in a take-over situation. Government
considers that the risk of abuse of the nominee
system in this regard will be minimised if the
notification percentage is reduced from 10 per
cent to 5 per cent, and if the notification, in
which changes or cessation of a substantial
shareholding are to be given to the company, is
reduced from 14 days to seven days (clause 9). A
further provision is inserted which will enable a
company to know if a warehouse situation is
developing or if it is a target for a take-over
bid. This provision confers the right upon a
company to ascertain the real identity of the
owners of its shares (clause 12).
Other major amendments proposed in the Bill are
concerned with the powers and duties of directors.
Clause 15 lays down in a new section 132B that the
matter in which directors of a company are
entitled to have regard are the interest of its
employees as well as its members. This provision
serves to emphasise the duty that a company has to
its employees and may be compared with clause 4
which includes amongst the powers of a company to
make provision for the benefit of employees and
former employees upon the cessation of the
business of a company or any subsidiary.
This clause introduces two new provisions which
are important. In section 132D it is provided that
approval of a company in general meeting is
required before directors of a company issue
shares. The unfettered discretion of directors to
issue shares (once authorised) has sometimes
worked to the detriment of shareholders, for
example, by diluting shareholders' capital in
certain circumstances. The imposition of the
proposed form of control will apply to the issue
of shares for cash or for other consideration. Its
effect will be to give more control to
shareholders without interfering unduly with the
directors' business of managing the company.
Column: 958
The provisions in section l32C is a restatement
of the law as at present appears in section 35 (3)
of the Act. Power is given to the court on the
application of a member of the company to prevent
directors from carrying into effect proposals for
disposing of the whole or substantially the whole
of the company's undertaking or property; but if
directors contravene this requirement that such a
disposal should be approved by the company in
general meeting the transaction will not affect a
purchaser for consideration who acquires the
property without actual notice of the
contravention.
Clause 16 introduces a new section 133A which
prohibits in subsection (1) thereof a company from
making a loan to another company or to provide any
security for a loan to another company if
directors have an interest in the shares of the
other company equal to one-fifth or more of the
nominal value of its equity share capital; and
also prohibits loans to persons who are members of
the family of any of its directors. There are,
however, certain specific exclusions in subsection
(3) of this section which should be noted. The
interest of a member of a director's family is
treated as an interest of the director for the
purposes of subsection (1). The purpose of this
amendment is to close a loophole which at present
exists under section 133 of the Act which
prohibits a company from making loans to its
directors. This section can be circumvented by
making loans to a company in which a director of
the lending company has effective control.
The remaining major amendment to which I would
wish to comment upon appears in clause 19 which
amends section 179 dealing with take-overs. The
purpose of this amendment is to clarify the status
of the Singapore Code on Take-overs and Mergers.
The Code is not a statutory code but it is
intended that it should have statutory backing and
should have a locus standi in relation to the
Government. For this reason it is expressly
recognised by statute as is the Securities
Industry Council which administers it. Although
the Code is
Column: 959
modelled on the City Code on Take-overs and
Mergers, that Code has not been recognised in any
legislation in the United Kingdom - it is regarded
purely as a measure for voluntary self-regulation.
The Government takes the view that for the Code to
be really effective something more than this is
needed although we still adhere to our conviction
that, in the highly technical field of take-overs
and mergers, a non-statutory code is a better way
of dealing with this subject than by Act of
Parliament. The new subsection makes it clear that
breach of the Code is not a criminal offence. The
Code may be revised from time to time and the
public will be advised of such revision by
notification in the Gazette. The Securities
Industry Council may from time to time issue
rulings on the interpretation of the Code and lay
down rules of practice. It is not intended that
these rulings should be challenged in the courts
or that the Code will be subject to judicial
interpretation for the Code is concerned with
standards of conduct to be followed in take-overs
and mergers. Members will also note that in clause
15 a provision is inserted in relation to the
rulings of the Securities Industry Council and
lays down that directors in the exercise of their
powers are entitled to have regard to these
rulings.
The Explanatory Statement refers to the remaining
amendments proposed in the Bill and I need not
elaborate upon them.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Hon Sui Sen].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 960
SECURITIES INDUSTRY (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.52 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr
Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
Although this Bill would appear to introduce a
large number of amendments to the Act, the bulk of
them are merely consequential amendments that
arise as a result of three major amendments that
are proposed. These amendments appear in clause 2
(dealing with dealer's licences), in clause 19
(repealing Part VIII of the Act which provides for
investment of stockbroker's funds) and in clause
23 which makes new provision for the Stock
Exchange fidelity fund.
I shall deal with these three topics in numerical
order. At the time the Act was drafted persons
could carry on the business of dealing in
securities as a sole trader, as partner in a
member firm or as director of a member company.
This is no longer the position. Under the new
Stock Exchange rules only persons who are
directors of a member company can now be admitted
as members of the Stock Exchange. The intention of
clause 2 is, therefore, to reflect the position as
it exists on the Stock Exchange by providing that
a dealer's licence shall be granted only to a
corporation. The great merit in this conceptual
change is that corporations that deal in
securities will be subject not only to the Act
itself but also to the detailed provisions of the
Companies Act (Cap. 185). This will undoubtedly
operate to the advantage of the investing public
because of the greater measure of control that can
be exercised through the Companies Act. Under the
existing provisions stockbrokers are required to
take out an individual dealer's licence but under
the new proposals they will be required to be
licensed as dealers' representatives, that is to
say, as representatives of the corporation that
employs them or with which they have an
arrangement as directors. The position of
remisiers will
Column: 961
remain unchanged in this regard for they also will
be required to take out licences as dealers'
representatives.
The amendment to section 14 will have the
additional advantage of streamlining the licensing
provisions and make the administration of the
licensing provisions and the regulations so much
the easier. Accordingly, all references in the Act
to dealers who are partners in a firm or sole
dealers have been deleted, and the Act has been
further amended in various respects to give effect
to the new concept.
Part VIII of the Act which deals with investment
of stockbroker's funds is repealed though this
will not affect the obligation of a dealer to
maintain a trust account under other provisions of
the Act. Experience has shown that the existing
Part VIII presents serious practical difficulties
to the Stock Exchange if it is to be implemented
effectively. As required by the existing section
54, the member company must deposit with a stock
exchange an amount that is not less than the
prescribed part of the lowest balance in the
company's trust account during the relevant period
(i.e. 12 months). This formula is difficult to
implement since it is not possible for the Stock
Exchange to know the lowest balance unless a
member company submits daily bank statements or
cash books - this would place an unnecessary
burden upon member companies and lead to all kinds
of practical difficulties. Furthermore, the
requirement in this Part that the Stock Exchange
has to place its deposits from member companies in
interest bearing accounts with banks creates
further problems since money so deposited with the
Stock Exchange are repayable upon demand. There
is, in any event, no need, having regard to the
new provision inserted in this Part of the Act
dealing with fidelity funds, for interest derived
from investment of deposits received by the
Exchange to be credited to a fidelity fund.
With regard to the fidelity fund provisions
themselves, some significant changes are proposed.
At the present time the Fidelity Fund of the Stock
Column: 962
Exchange of Singapore stands at over $2 million
though section 68 of the Act envisages an amount
of $1 million. This large amount of fund money is
derived mainly from the transfer from the fidelity
fund that was held jointly by the Singapore and
Malaysian Stock Exchange and not from
contributions to the fund by individual
stockbrokers. Having regard to the present state
of fidelity fund as well as the proposals for
increasing the fund by annual transfers from the
Stock Exchange General Fund, Government considers
that the requirement in section 67 that
stockbrokers should make an annual contribution of
$1,000 - which is, in any event, a comparatively
small amount bearing in mind the total membership
of the Exchange - to the fund, is not necessary as
regards the existing Stock Exchange and inadequate
if another stock exchange is created; for annual
contributions are not likely to be sufficient to
meet any liabilities that might arise due to the
failure of even one member company. It is
essential that a substantial amount of money
should already be in a fidelity fund on its
establishment. Under the new sections 67 and 68 a
fidelity fund will consist of an amount that is
not less than $2 million or such other sum as the
Minister may by order determine. This fidelity
fund will be increased annually by payments into
it of a sum that is equal to 10 per cent or more
of the net income of a stock exchange. If a
fidelity fund falls below $2 million or such other
sum as the Minister may determine, the Committee
of a stock exchange shall take such steps to make
up the deficiency as are provided for in section
68.
If at any time a fidelity fund is not sufficient
to meet liabilities, the Committee may impose a
levy of such amount as it thinks fit on a member
company but this levy must not exceed $100,000 in
the aggregate (clause 24).
The only other amendments that call for special
mention appear in clause 33 which amends section
95 of the Act and in clause 3 which amends section
7. The amendment to section 95 empowers the
Registrar to compound the less serious offences
which are punishable only by
Column: 963
a fine whether under the Act or under the
Regulations. This provision is a standard one and
is to be found in many of our Acts.
The amendment proposed in clause 3 is designed to
facilitate the administration of the Act in
relation to the Minister's approval of amendments
proposed to Stock Exchange Rules. The existing
provision in section 7 has proved to be
inappropriate and inconvenient for it does not
allow sufficient time for the Minister to consider
the matter, particularly where as in most
instances the Securities Industry Council is asked
to make its recommendations to the Minister on the
proposed amendments. The time element referred to
in the existing provision has accordingly been
deleted.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill. - [Mr Hon Sui Sen].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 963
JETTY AT KRANJI INDUSTRIAL ESTATE
6.04 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development (Mr Ho Cheng Choon): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move the motion* standing in the name of the Minister for Law and National Development, as it appears on the Order Paper.
* The motion reads as follows:
`That this Parliament, in accordance with section 4 of the Foreshores Act (Chapter 270),
approves the construction by Government of a jetty within the foreshore at Kranji
Industrial Estate as shown coloured red on the plan marked "LAND OFFICE PLAN NO. 2/74",
which is deposited in the Land Office, Singapore.'
Column: 964
Sir, hon. Members will recall that in June, 1965,
this House approved the reclamation of about 213
acres of the swamp land in Kranji for development
by the Jurong Town Corporation as an industrial
estate for sawmilling. On completion of the
reclamation, the reclaimed land was proclaimed as
State land on 13th August, 1971, and subsequently
alienated to the Jurong Town Corporation for 99
years to enable the Corporation, in turn, to sub-lease the land to the various sawmilling operators
on 30-year leases.
The land shown edged in red on the plan marked as
"LAND OFFICE PLAN NO. 2/74", a copy of which is
displayed in the Library of this House for the
information of Members, is one of the lots sub-leased by the Corporation to Kwang Maw Sawmill
Limited. The Corporation has now applied for
approval to construct a jetty measuring about 430
feet by 25 feet terminating in a platform about 50
feet by 50 feet as shown coloured red on the plan,
to be used in conjunction with the sawmilling and
woodworking operations of Kwang Maw Sawmill
Limited.
On approval of the construction of this jetty
being given by this House, the Land Office will
issue a foreshore lease to the Corporation
pursuant to section 9 of the Foreshores Act
(Chapter 270).
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Parliament, in accordance with section
4 of the Foreshores Act (Chapter 270), approves
the construction by Government of a jetty within
the foreshore at Kranji industrial Estate as shown
coloured red on the plan marked "LAND OFFICE PLAN
NO. 2/74", which is deposited in the Land Office,
Singapore.
Column: 965
RECLAMATION AT LABRADOR/TANJONG BERLAYER
6.06 p.m.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development (Mr Ho Cheng Choon): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move the motion* standing in the name of the Minister for Law and National Development, as it appears on the Order Paper.
* The motion reads as follows:
`That this Parliament, in accordance with section 4 of the Foreshores Act (Chapter 270), approves the reclamation by Government of that portion of the foreshore at
Labrador/Tanjong Berlayer containing an area of approximately 11.80 acres as shown
coloured yellow on the plan marked "LAND OFFICE RECLAMATION PLAN NO. 1/74", which is
deposited in the Land Office, Singapore.'
Sir, the Port of Singapore Authority proposes to
reclaim about 11.80 acres of the foreshore at
Labrador/Tanjong Berlayer as shown coloured yellow
on the plan marked as "LAND OFFICE RECLAMATION
PLAN NO. 1/74", a copy of which is displayed in
the Library of this House for the information of
hon. Members, for parkland development. The
reclaimed area will be integrated with the
adjoining land shown edged in green on the plan
proposed for development by Government as the
Labrador Public Park scheme to create an
attractive promenade with sea frontage for the
public with a portion thereof, about 5.5 acres
(shown coloured yellow and edged in blue on the
plan), to be used for port purposes on integration
with the adjoining area shown edged in red on the
plan.
The cost of the reclamation is estimated at
$2,152,000 and will be borne by the Port of
Singapore Authority which will carry out the
reclamation as agent of the Government. Fill for
the reclamation will be obtained
Column: 966
from the former Alexandra Brickworks' land at
Pasir Panjang/Alexandra Road, where some 400,000
cubic yards of earth are readily available.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Parliament, in accordance with section
4 of the Foreshores Act (Chapter 270), approves
the reclamation by Government of that portion of
the foreshore at Labrador/Tanjong Berlayer
containing an area of approximately 11.80 acres as
shown coloured yellow on the plan marked "LAND
OFFICE RECLAMATION PLAN NO. 1/74", which is
deposited in the Land Office, Singapore.
ADJOURNMENT
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, we have been
active for more than a week. May I take this
opportunity of thanking Backbenchers for all their
contributions and on behalf of each and every
Member of the House, may I thank you, Sir, for
listening to us for more than a week so patiently?
Sir, I beg to move, "That Parliament do now
adjourn to a date to be fixed."
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
"That Parliament do now adjourn to a date to be
fixed."
Adjourned accordingly at Nine minutes past Six
o'clock p.m, to a date to be fixed.