| Parliament No: | 3 |
| Session No: | 2 |
| Volume No: | 34 |
| Sitting No: | 14 |
| Sitting Date: | 27-03-1975 |
|
Column: 1055
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
THIRD PARLIAMENT
Thursday, 27th March, 1975
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Dr Yeoh Ghim Seng, B.B.M., J.P. (Joo Chiat)).
Encik Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang).
Mr Ahmad Mattar (Leng Kee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Dr Ang Kok Peng, B.B.M. (Crawford), Minister of State for Health.
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr Ivan Baptist (Potong Pasir).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and National Development and Leader of the House.
Mr Chai Chong Yii (Bukit Batok), Minister of State for Communications.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh).
Dr Chiang Hai Ding (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Chin Harn Tong (Aljunied).
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for the Environment.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (Mac Pherson), Minister for Health and Home Affairs.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong).
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah).
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development.
Column: 1056
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Hon Sui Sen (Havelock), Minister for Finance.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu) .
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Mr Lai Tha Chai (Henderson).
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Minister for Education .
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Mr Lee Yiok Seng (Bukit Panjang).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs.
Mr Lim Kim San, D.U.T. (Cairnhill), Minister for the Environment.
Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampung Kembangan).
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Ong Teng Cheong (Kim Keat).
Encik Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Defence.
Encik Rahmat Bin Kenap Al-Haj (Geylang Serai).
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens).
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee).
Mr P. Selvadurai (Kuo Chuan).
Column: 1057
Haji Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampung Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Minister of State for Labour and Government Whip.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Dr Tan Eng Liang, B.B.M. (River Valley).
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan (Whampoa).
Mr Tang See Chim (Chua Chu Kang), Deputy Speaker.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Prof. Wong Lin Ken, B.B.M. (Alexandra).
Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampung Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister for Communications.
Column: 1058
ABSENT:
Encik A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Defence.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Dr Ong Leong Boon (Kim Seng).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Labour.
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampung Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Science and Technology.
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines), Minister of State for the Environment.
Mr Yeo Choo Kok (Delta).
Column: 1057
PERMISSION TO MEMBERS TO BE ABSENT
Under the provisions of clause 2 (d) of Article
30 of the Constitution of Singapore, I have
granted permission to the following Members to be
or to remain absent from sittings of Parliament
(or any Committee of Parliament to which they
have been appointed) for the periods stated:-
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs - from 29th to 31st March, 1975.
Column: 1058
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Labour - from 31st March to 14th April, 1975.
Mr J. F. Conceicao (Katong) - from 31st March to 22nd April, 1975.
Encik Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs - from 3rd to 6th April, 1975.
| | YEOH GHIM SENG |
| | Speaker, |
| | Parliament of Singapore |
Column: 1057
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
INSPECTIONS ON REGISTERED FACTORIES
(Particulars)
1. Mr Ivan Baptist asked the Minister for Labour
(a) how many inspections were made on registered
factories by (i) the Factory Inspectorate; and
(ii) the Industrial Health Unit, in 1974; and (b)
of those inspections (i) how many
Column: 1058
arose from complaints received from workers,
unions and others; and (iii) how many were
unannounced or surprise inspections.
The Minister of State for Labour (Mr Sia Kah Hui) (for the Minister for Labour): Mr Speaker, Sir, in 1974 the Factory Inspectorate
of the Ministry made 5,915 inspections on
registered factories. If the figure were to
include those made to factory premises prior to
their registration, then the figure is 6,189. Of
these, 411 visits were made
Column: 1059
as a result of complaints received by the Factory
Inspectorate from workers, persons living close to
factories and members of the public. The majority
of the complaints were about noise and air
pollution from factories.
As it is not the practice for Factory Inspectors
to make appointments with factory occupiers before
they inspect their factories, most of the
inspection visits made last year were unannounced
or surprise visits. The Factory Inspectorate,
however, does not keep separate statistics on
unannounced or surprise inspections.
Where the Industrial Health Unit is concerned, it
made 1,000 inspections in 1974. Of these, 160
inspections were made in connection with
complaints. A total of 55 complaints were received
in 1974; 20 (or 36%) were from workers and unions
and 35 (or 64%) were from neighbouring residents
and anonymous callers.
Of the 1,000 inspections made last year, about
80% were made without prior notice given to
factory occupiers. However, the remaining 20% were
announced visits as arrangements had to be made
with the management for a suitably qualified
person to be present to clarify details of
processes operating in the factory.
Column: 1059
FOOD REGULATIONS, 1974
(Particulars of inspections)
2. Mr Ivan Baptist asked the Minister for the
Environment (a) how many inspections have been
made by his Ministry under the Food Regulations.
1974 since the Regulations were brought into
operation; and (b) how many infringements have
been detected and what action has been taken
against the offenders.
The Minister for the Environment (Mr Lim Kim San): Sir, the Food Regulations, 1974, were brought into
operation on 1st May, 1974. These Regulations were
made under the Sale of Food Act, which came into
operation in May, 1973. The Food Regulations,
1974, govern the standards of the food sold in
Column: 1060
Singapore, while the inspections and prosecutions
against offenders are mainly done under the Sale
of Food Act.
Inspections of food sold, kept or intended for
sale are carried out daily by the staff of the
Ministry of the Environment. The total number of
inspections made under the Sale of Food Act and
the Food Regulations, 1974, from May 1973 to
February 1975 is 28,219. The details of the
inspections made are as follows:-
No. of
Type Visits
(a) Inspection of public markets 2,474
(b) Inspection of private markets 1,973
(c) Inspection of provision shops,
supermarkets and other premises 21,866
(d) Inspection of ice-cream factories 1,020
(e) Examination of food as requested
by importers and traders 664
(f) Destruction of usound food 70
(g) Investigation of complaints
related to food 63
(h) Investigation of food
poisoning incidents 89
-------
Total 28,219
=======
Summons action has been taken against offenders
for infringing the Sale of Food Act, 1973, and
the Regulations made thereunder. From May 1973
to February 1975 there were 356 convictions.
The breakdown figures of the offences are as
follows:-
No. of
Nature of Offence Convictions
Food - labelling 51
Food containing prohibited
preservatives 62
Food containing excessive
preservatives 55
Food containing artificial sweetening
agents without licence 88
Food - adulterated 19
Food containing prohibited
colour 36
Food - not of the quality, nature
or substance demaned by purchaser 15
Food - unfit for unman consumption 11
Food containing metals 5
Importaion of Filled Milk 1
Food containing mineral oil 10
Food containing excessive arsenic 3
Total 356
Column: 1061
REARRANGEMENT OF ORDER OF BUSINESS
2.38 p.m.
Resolved,
"That the Second Reading of the Parliamentary
Pensions (Amendment) Bill be taken after a few
other items on the Order Paper have been dealt
with." - [Mr E. W. Barker].
Column: 1061
LOCAL GOVERNMENT INTEGRATION (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
This Bill seeks to amend the provisions of the
Local Government Integration Act (Chapter 210 of
the Revised Edition) which deals with the
construction, widening and repair of public and
private streets and back-lanes. In view of the
massive urban renewal programme that is being
carried out to the city and the Government's
desire to further implement the Garden City
concept, it has been found necessary to make
certain amendments to the Local Government
Integration Act to empower the Director of Public
Works to achieve this objective more readily.
I will now draw Members' attention to the more
significant clauses of the Bill.
Clause 3 seeks to add a new section 16A to the
Act to facilitate the vesting in the Government of
lands which have been set aside as road reserves
pursuant to development proposals approved by the
competent authority under the Planning Act. All
these road reserves will eventually be made up
into new or enlarged public streets. It is
customary for the owners of lands to agree to
surrender part of their lands for road reserves to
the Government without charge in consideration of
the approval given for their development
Column: 1062
plans. The new section 16A will facilitate the
vesting in the Government of such lands which have
been set aside as road reserves.
Clause 5 seeks to amend section 18 of the Act to
empower the Government to require a developer or
owner of a property constructing a new street to
make provision for the planting of trees along the
new street. Section 18 of the Act is also amended
to require any person erecting any building or
planting of any hedge within any land set aside as
a road reserve to seek the prior approval of the
Director of Public Works.
Clause 7 seeks to amend section 28 of the Act,
which empowers the Director of Public Works to
acquire premises for the widening of streets, to
provide that no compensation shall be payable for
the acquisition of any premises for the purposes
of street-making when the premises are within the
street reserves set aside pursuant to any
development proposal approved by the competent
authority. Since the owner of the premises has
agreed to surrender the land free of charge to the
Government, the Government should not pay for the
building standing on the premises.
Clause 9 seeks to amend section 58 of the Act to
enable the Director of Public Works to construct
back-lanes and to recover the cost thereof from
the owners of properties fronting these back-lanes. Under the existing provision the cost of
constructing back-lanes is borne by the
Government.
Clause 10 seeks to amend section 102 of the Act
to empower the competent authority to impose
interest charges at a rate not exceeding 6% per
annum for late payments levied under the Act.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr E. W. Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1063
APPORTIONMENT OF RENTS (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.45 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill
be now read a Second time."
Sir, quit rents are payable to the Government in
respect of lands held under State leases as well
as Statutory Land Grants which are grants in
perpetuity issued under the State Lands Act. In
the case of land held under a State lease, the
owner may make an application under the
Apportionment of Rents Act for apportionment of
the rent payable in respect of the land, where
there has been a subdivision. The Act does not,
however, make it mandatory for the owner to make
an application for apportionment and often no such
application is made. In such a case, the Collector
of Land Revenue can only apportion the rent when
the subdivision of the land subsequently comes to
his knowledge. This procedure has been found to be
unsatisfactory and entails delay in apportionment
of the rent. Moreover, land held under a Statutory
Land Grant does not at present fall within the
ambit of the Apportionment of Rents Act. An
apportionment of the rent payable in respect of
such land is done administratively.
The Bill now before this House will make it
mandatory for the owner of land held either on a
State lease or a Statutory Land Grant to inform
the Collector of Land Revenue of any approved
subdivision of his land by the Competent Authority
under the Planning Act, so that the apportionment
of the rent may be appropriately made without
delay. Under the Bill a penalty not exceeding $500
will be imposed for non-compliance with this
requirement.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Mr Ong Teng Cheong (Kim Keat): Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like to request the
Minister to explain to this House why it is
necessary to make it obligatory
Column: 1064
for a landowner to inform the Collector of Land
Revenue of any approved subdivision. Why not make
it obligatory for the relevant authority to inform
the Collector of Land Revenue of the subdivision
when approving the application? I can understand
the situation where if a landowner subdivides his
land without Government approval, then it is fair
that he must inform the Government.
I find it rather difficult to perceive in this
particular situation where the Government approves
an application for land subdivision and then
requires the landowner to inform the Government
that his application has been approved by the
Government. I would have thought that this is a
simple inter-departmental communication - one arm
of the Government telling the other arm what is
happening. Why rely on the people to do the
transmission work and then penalise them on
default?
Mr Barker: Sir, sometimes, as the Member has pointed out in
the Budget debate, one Government department does
not inform the other department. It usually does,
but sometimes one does not catch up with the
other. Therefore, the object of the Bill is to put
the burden on the applicant, whose application for
subdivision has been approved, to in-form the
relevant department so that the Collector may
apportion the rent. The penalty provided is really
not excessive for non-compliance.
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol): Sir, first of all, may I say that I fully support
this amendment Bill. I would like to seek
clarification from the Minister. 1 note that in
the Explanatory Statement to the Bill a penalty
not exceeding $500 will be imposed for non-compliance with this new requirement. I think this
penalty is far too small a sum to impose. I
believe that during the property boom land prices
soared up to incredible levels. As a result, quite
a number of landowners put up subdivisions of land
for eventual sale. If that is the case, then the
penalty on them must be heavy enough to deter them
from taking the law into their own hands. I hope
the Minister would care to clarify this point.
Column: 1065
Mr Barker: Sir, there is nothing to clarify. This is a new
amendment and, in the light of what the Member for
Kim Keat has stated, I would prefer to leave the
maximum penalty at $500 rather than to impose a
punishment which might be too punitive.
Mr Ong Teng Cheong: Mr Speaker, Sir, the Minister said that the
purpose of the Bill is to enable the Collector of
Land Revenue to apportion the rent. I am of the
view that it is rather premature to inform the
Collector within one month from the date of
obtaining approval of subdivision from the
relevant authority, as the land would still be
under the same ownership at that stage. Therefore,
the question of apportionment of rent does not
arise.
Besides, the owner of the land may decide not to
proceed further with the subdivision. He may
decide not to obtain separate titles for the
subdivided plot through the Registrar of Land
Titles and Deeds. The apportionment of rent will
only be effected when separate titles for the
approved subdivided plots are issued. Would the
Minister not agree then that it would be more
appropriate for the Collector of Land Revenue to
be informed at that stage in order to enable him
to apportion the rent?
Mr Barker: No, Sir. The lessee or grantee is asked, after he
has obtained written permission from the competent
authority to subdivide his land, to inform or make
a notification to the Collector in writing within
one month from the date of approval. If he changes
his mind, he can always inform the Collector
again. But the important date is when the
subdivision has taken place. Conveyance might be
done later. 1 think one month should be ample time
for the purposes of this Bill. In any event should
the Member be proved right, and if there are
teething troubles with this Bill, we will extend
this period.
Mr Ong Teng Cheong: Sir, I would like to thank the Minister for his
explanation. If the Bill must be passed
Column: 1066
today as it stands, and I believe it is going to
be passed, may I make an appeal on behalf of the
ordinary citizen? We know that ordinary citizens
are not conversant with the numerous legislations
that exist and are usually unaware of the hidden
rules and regulations which are introduced from
time to time as amendments are made to this or
that Act. May I request the Minister, therefore,
to assure the House that he will instruct the
relevant authority, when approving any subdivision
of land, to advise the landowner of his obligation
to inform the Collector of Land Revenue of such
approval within one month from the date of
granting of the written permission.
Mr Barker: Yes, Sir, we will do that.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr E.W. Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1066
HIRE-PURCHASE (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.57 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
The principal amendments that are proposed in the
Bill appear in clauses 2 and 8 and are designed to
confer some measure of protection upon finance
companies which are owners of motor vehicles
subject to hire purchase agreements and which
suffer loss due to acts or omissions on the part
of the hirers of such motor vehicles. These
amendments, if passed, will in no way detract from
the paramount policy of the principal Act, which
is to safeguard the interests of hirers under hire
purchase agreements, as part of the larger field
of consumer protection. They will, however, ensure
that hirers will be less likely
Column: 1067
to abuse their rights under the agreements to the
disadvantage of the lawful owners of these motor
vehicles.
Clause 2 which amends section 26 of the Act makes
it mandatory for a hirer to inform the owner of
the vehicle (the finance company) in the event
that he changes his registered insurer during the
period of the hire-purchase agreement. In the
past, the new registered insurer, not being aware
of the interest in the motor vehicle of the
finance company, have, in some instances, where
there has been a claim on a total loss basis by
the insured hirer, made payments on a total loss
basis direct to the hirer. Although the owners
have a right at common law to sue the hirer in
respect of their interest in the motor vehicle,
this has not been shown to be a satisfactory
remedy, for hirers have been known to disappear
with the insurance monies received from the
insurers. This amendment, accordingly, places a
legal obligation upon the hirer, who by virtue of
section 26 (1) of the Act alone must choose his
registered insurer, to advise the owner if he
decides to change his insurer. The owner will then
inform the insurer of his interest in the motor
vehicle under the Hire-Purchase agreement.
Clause 3 amends section 33 (c) of the Act in such
a way as to provide greater flexibility in
adjusting interest rates payable on overdue
instalments. With the recent rise in interest
rates in money markets the existing provision in
this section fixing a ceiling of 9% per annum
which finance companies may charge is unrealistic,
having regard to the cost of these companies of
borrowing money. It is, therefore, proposed that a
maximum rate of 12% per annum should be fixed in
section 33 (c) but at the same time to confer upon
the Minister power to determine such lower rate
from time to time as he may think fit. This lower
rate, it is envisaged, should correspond
approximately to prevailing commercial rates.
Though interest rates now appear to be
Column: 1068
on a downtrend, they are likely to remain well
above historical rates.
The other major amendment appears in clause 8
which amends the Fourth Schedule. The effect of
this amendment will be to reduce the number of
notices to repossess (under section 15 (1) ) that
are sent out by finance companies to hirers who
tend to be continually in default in their payment
of instalments. Such hirers often find themselves
in further arrears of instalments which have
fallen due after the date of the notice. The
existing Notice, therefore, fails to reflect the
true position of the amount of arrears that are
due up to the time that the finance company takes
action to repossess. The amendment, accordingly is
designed to deal with this matter by providing
that the hirer, in order to avoid repossession,
must pay all arrears of instalments that have
fallen due since the date of the Notice.
Finally, the amendments proposed in clauses 4, 5,
6 and 7 seek to increase the penalties provided
for in sections 35, 36, 37 and 38 respectively of
the Act. These penalties, with the passing of
time, have become a little unrealistic.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr E. W. Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1068
HOUSING AND DEVELOPMENT (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.04 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
Sir, there have been complaints from the public
that there are owners of Housing and Development
Board flats who acquire and then let out other
immovable properties while they are
Column: 1069
still staying in HDB flats. In order to ensure
that the Board's flats are in the hands of those
people who deserve them and to avoid longer
frustration by those on the Board's waiting list
(at the moment there is a waiting list of about
100,000 applications), this Bill will introduce
the following measures:-
(a) to make provision for the Board to
compulsorily acquire any HDB flat sold subject to
the provisions of Part IV of the Act in certain
circumstances which I will refer to shortly;
(b) to prohibit any person from applying for an
HDB flat if he, his spouse or an authorised
occupier either - (i) owns or has an interest in
any other immovable property; or (ii) has, at any
time within 30 months prior to the date of his
making an application to the Board for an HDB
flat, owned or had an interest in any other
immovable property;
(c) to make it an offence for any person to give
false information in his form of application for
an HDB flat and to make such an offence punishable
with a fine not exceeding $5,000 or to
imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months
or both such fine and imprisonment; and
(d) to make unauthorised subletting of an HDB
flat an offence punishable with a similar penalty.
The Board will compulsorily acquire any flat sold
subject to the provisions of Part IV of the Act in
any of the circumstances set out in the new
section 48A to which I will now refer:-
(a) if the owner thereof and his spouse, if any,
has, in the opinion of the Board, ceased to occupy
the HDB flat; or
(b) if the owner thereof, his spouse or any
authorised occupier has acquired any title to or
an estate or interest in any other immovable
property; or
(c) if the owner thereof has, in the opinion of
the Board, used the HDB flat, otherwise than for
the purpose permitted by the lease; or
Column: 1070
(d) if the owner thereof has permitted any person
other than an authorised occupier to reside or
stay in the HDB flat; or
(e) if the owner thereof has failed to perform or
observe any condition contained in the lease to be
performed or observed on the part of the owner
after a notice in writing has been sent by the
Board drawing his attention to the non-performance
or non-observance of the condition in the lease
and the Board is of the opinion that he is likely
to continue to do the same if he should continue
to own the HDB flat; or
(f) if the owner thereof has made a misleading or
false statement in his application to the Board
for the purchase of the HDB flat; or
(g) if the owner thereof has made a mis-representation of a material fact, whether
innocently or otherwise, in his application to the
Board for the purchase of the HDB flat; or
(h) if the owner thereof assigns, underlets or
parts with the possession of the HDB flat or any
part thereof without obtaining the prior written
consent of the Board as required by the lease; or
(i) if, in the opinion of the Board, the HDB flat
is not being occupied by such minimum number of
persons as the Board may require; or
(j) if the owner thereof has ceased to be a
citizen of Singapore; or
(k) if the rent or any payments or any part
thereof due to the Board reserved under the lease
or mortgage remains unpaid for three calendar
months after they are due and payable and the
Board has sent a notice of demand in writing to
the owner thereof. Any person who is dissatisfied
with a decision of the Board to acquire a HDB flat
under section 48A of the Act may appeal to the
Minister whose decision thereon will be final.
Mr Speaker, Sir, apart from these major
amendments to the Housing and Development Act, the
Bill also seeks
Column: 1071
to make other amendments which I will now refer to
briefly.
Clause 3 of the Bill seeks to amend section 4 of
the Act to permit the legal officers of the Board
to execute certain documents for and on behalf of
the Board.
Clause 4 seeks to add a new section 27A to the
Act to empower the Board to appoint committees to
carry out its duties under the Act and to delegate
its powers to such committees.
Clause 5 seeks to amend section 41 of the Act to
empower the Board to forfeit any monies paid to
the Board by an applicant who has made an
application to purchase an HDB flat from the Board
in contravention of the provisions of section 41
of the Act.
Clause 6 seeks to amend section 42 of the Act to
enable the officers of the Board to attest
assurances pertaining to flats sold by the Board.
Clause 8 seeks to repeal and re-enact with
amendments section 45 of the Act to deal with the
acquisition by the Board of a flat of a deceased
owner in the case where no representation has been
taken out under a will or intestacy of a deceased
owner of the flat within twelve months from the
death of the owner.
Clause 9 seeks to amend section 48 of the Act to
enable the Board to repossess a flat speedily when
it exercises its right of forfeiture under a
lease.
Clause 12 seeks to repeal and reenact sections 55
to 58 of the Act to prescribe the financial
procedures to be observed by the Board and to make
provision for the keeping and audit of the
accounts of the Board.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Mr Ng Kah Ting: Mr Speaker, Sir, whilst I fully support this
Bill, I would like to seek clarification from the
Minister with regard to clause 10, which is to
insert a new section 48A (1), paragraph (i), and I
quote:
Column: 1072
`(i) if, in the opinion of the Board, the flat,
house or other living accommodation is not being
occupied by such minimum number of persons as the
Board may require; or'
Sir, it may well be that a flat owner in the
service of a company may be transferred out for an
overseas assignment. It is also possible that his
family will have to go along with him, and the
flat will be left vacant. If this is the case,
will the Minister consider, in view of the nature
of work to which the flat owner is committed,
allowing the owner to continue to own the flat in
his name? I have come across a case which comes
under this particular provision as laid down in
this proposed new section 48A (1) (i) in clause 10
of the Bill.
3.15 p.m.
Mr Ong Teng Cheong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, our Government has all along been
advocating the policy of home ownership for the
people in order to look after their welfare. The
people can thus own their own homes and have a
sense of security in life. This amendment Bill
therefore has come as a surprise.
Certain provisions in the Bill are rather vague
and will cause concern and confusion among the
people. I am referring particularly to the
provisions of clauses 5 and 8 of the Bill which, I
think, ought to be clarified. Clause 5 provides
that no person shall be entitled to purchase an
HDB flat if he, his spouse or any authorised
occupier, is the owner of any other immovable
property. What will be the position of a person
who owns a shophouse or a nonresidential property
in the name of a company or on behalf of a
company, or who jointly owns such property with a
company? Will he be entitled to apply to purchase
a Housing Board flat? According to the Public
Relations Officer of the HDB, after the Bill has
been passed the Housing Board will announce
details specifying the circumstances under which
persons are entitled to purchase flats and those
who are not entitled to purchase flats. May I ask
why should the details of these new
Column: 1073
provisions be explained to the people after the
Bill has been passed? Is this not tantamount to
effecting the law before any prior information has
been given? The people who suffer will be those
who live in the HDB flats. They will be at the
mercy of the Housing Board after due passage of
the Bill. Therefore, I hope the Minister will be
able to clarify these two vague provisions as to
which category of persons possessing which types
of property are or are not entitled to buy HDB.
flats, so as to enable us to understand the
intentions of this Bill and its measures in
detail.
Sir, another provision in the Bill provides that,
under certain circumstances, the Housing Board can
repossess a flat upon the death of the owner,
whether or not the owner has left a will. Again
the Housing Board officials also said that after
the Bill has been passed and become law, the Board
will notify the people concerned of the
circumstances under which the flat could be bought
back by the Board upon the death of the flat
owner.
Sir, I hope the Minister would consider the fact
that flat owners are not wealthy property owners.
Most of them are not conversant with the law and
being in the low-income group they are not able to
take on any additional burden that is imposed on
them. The Government should have sympathy for the
hardship of the people and simplify all the
necessary procedures. The Government should follow
the example of the Central Provident Fund Board
system of authorising a nominee successor to
administrate the estate, which system is for the
convenience of the people and also to reduce their
burden. I hope the Minister can enlighten us with
a clarification as well as a direction on these
matters.
3.20 p.m.
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan (Whampoa): Mr Speaker, Sir, I am in general support of the
amendment Bill. However,
Column: 1074
I feel that clause 5, which prohibits persons who
have sold property within 30 months prior to date
of application, has the unfortunate effect of
penalising widows and orphans who may be forced by
circumstances to sell their homes. Such widows and
orphans will then be forced to wait six or seven
years before getting a flat. I hope the Minister:
will amend this particular clause of the Bill.
Mr Barker: Sir, as I pointed out earlier, the whole purpose
of this Bill is to ensure that the Board's flats
remain in the hands of people who deserve them and
to avoid frustration by those on the Board's
waiting list. At the moment, there are 75,000
applicants wanting to buy flats and about 25,000
wanting to rent them. The object of this Bill is
not to make things worse for widows and orphans or
for the poor people living in HDB flats.
I have spelt out earlier in my speech details of
the circumstances under which people who have
bought flats will lose them. In my view, the
provisions set out under clauses 5 and 8 are quite
clear. One deals with the position where the
owner, his spouse or any authorised occupier is
the owner of any other flat, house, building or
land or has an estate or interest therein; or has,
at any time within 30 months immediately prior to
the date of making an application to the Board to
purchase a flat, sold any flat, house, building or
land.
The Member for Whampoa takes objection to the 30-month condition. It has been the experience of the
Board that this period is reasonable enough for
people to dispose of their properties, which may
be substantial properties, and with the proceeds
buy a five-room flat.
The Member for Punggol is worried about people
who have to leave the country after buying a flat.
They do not have to give up the flat. All they
have to do in such cases is to inform the Board.
Column: 1075
As for the other clause which deals with the
position where the owner of an HDB flat dies,
either testate or intestate and his executors or
administrators do nothing about it for years, the
purpose is to give them one year which should be
enough time to take out either Letters of
Administration or Probate of the Will so that the
legal formalities in respect of the flat can be
put right. Otherwise if they do nothing, the Board
cannot do anything. Hence this clause.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr E. W. Barker],
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
3.25 p.m.
Clauses 1 to 5 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clause 6 -
Amendment made:
In page 6, line 11, at end, to add-
"(2) This
section shall apply to any instrument lodged
before, on or after the date of the
commencement of the Housing and Development (Amendment) Act, 1975.".-[Mr E. W. Barker].
The Chairman: There is a consequential amendment
to be made.
In page 5, line 38, after "42.", to insert "-(1)".
This will be done.
Clause 6, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 7 -
Amendment made:
In page 6, to leave out lines 13 and 14 and
insert -
`deleting subsection (2) thereof and
substituting therefore the following:-
"(2) Where any assignment, mortgage, transfer,
charge or lease of any
Column: 1076
such flat, house or other building which is
executed by or on behalf of the owner thereof
without the prior written consent of the Board
is registered under the provisions of the
Registration of Deeds Act or the Land Titles
Act, the Board may by an instrument lodged with
the Registrar of Deeds or the Registrar of
Titles, as the case may be, declare such
assignment, mortgage, transfer, charge or lease
to be void and the Registrar of Deeds or the
Registrar of Titles shall register the
instrument without being concerned to inquire
into its regularity or validity, and upon
registration thereof shall cancel the
registration of any such assignment, mortgage,
transfer, charge or lease.'.-[Mr E. W. Barker].
The Chairman: There is a consequential amendment to be made.
In page 6, line 15, to leave out the open inverted commas.
This will be done.
Clause 7, as amended, ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clauses 8 and 9 ordered to stand part of the
Bill.
Clause 10 -
Mr Barker: Sir, I beg to move,
In page 10, line 19, to leave out "or his spouse"
and insert ", his spouse or any authorised
occupier".
This amendment will enable the Board to
compulsorily acquire any flat, house or other
living accommodation sold subject to the
provisions of this Part, if an authorised occupier
has at any time whether before or after the date
of commencement of the Housing and Development
(Amendment) Act, 1975, acquired whether by
operation of law or otherwise any title to or an
estate or interest in any other flat, house,
building or land.
Amendment agreed to.
Clause 10, as amended, ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clauses 11 to 15 inclusive ordered to stand part
of the Bill.
Bill reported with amendments; read a Third time
and passed.
Column: 1077
PARLIAMENTARY PENSIONS (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.30 p.m.
The Prime Minister: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
For officers in the public service, the Pensions
Act sets out conditions under which pensions are
withheld either wholly or partially. Section 5
lists offences for negligence, irregularity or
misconduct. A disciplinary committee of inquiry
will determine the degree of culpability.
In section 14 pensions are withheld completely
for any term of imprisonment for any crime or
offence.
It has taken the Government some time to decide
how to modify these provisions to apply them to
Parliamentary Pensions under the different
circumstances for Members of Parliament, Political
Secretaries, Parliamentary Secretaries, Ministers
of State and Ministers. The Government decided
that to withhold part of an MP's or Minister's
pension for any negligence, irregularity or
misconduct was not practical. It would have to
follow the findings of a disciplinary committee of
fellow-Ministers and MPs. Nor was it appropriate
since the careers and responsibilities of MPs and
Ministers were different from those of public
officers. Nor does imprisonment for any crime or
offence unconnected with parliamentary or
ministerial duties appear valid ground for the
withholding of pension.
But there can be no question that if any
Minister, Minister of State, Parliamentary
Secretary, Political Secretary or MP has been
convicted under the Prevention of Corruption Act,
or of any crime involving corruption under any
other written law, even if he has only been fined
and not imprisoned, then this warrants the
withholding of the pension. The President, after
consideration of the
Column: 1078
record of the proceedings of the Court, will
decide whether the whole or a part of any pension
should be withheld.
Every Honourable Member knows that nothing is
more likely to lower standards of integrity in the
conduct of government than to have a member of the
political leadership setting a bad example. All
those who hold office must abide by strict
standards of public and private conduct. It is not
possible to enforce high standards of integrity in
the civil service if the political leadership
tolerates any corrupt behaviour amongst its own
ranks. An MP or a Minister must take the
consequences of any corrupt act. Losing his
pension is one of the least of the sanctions.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Prime Minister].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1078
PARKS AND TREES BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.38 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
Members are aware of the Government's efforts to make Singapore a garden
city and to provide recreational facilities for
the urban population. For these purposes the
Ministry of Law and National Development set up
the Parks and Recreation Division in the Public
Works Department. The powers which are vested in
the Commissioner for parks and Recreation are at
the moment found in several pieces of legislation,
namely, the Trees and Plants (Preservation and
Improvement of Amenities) Act, 1970, (Act 59 of
1970), the Botanic Gardens
Column: 1079
Act (Chapter 300) and Part V of the Local
Government Integration Act (Chapter 210).
Since it has been found necessary to amend the
existing legislation to vest in the Commissioner
new powers to enable him to carry out his work,
the opportunity has been taken to revise all the
various legislation pertaining to parks and trees.
This Bill, therefore, seeks to amend and
consolidate the law which is found in the various
Acts which I have referred to.
The main changes which will be made to the
existing legislation are as follows:-
(a) A restriction will be imposed on the felling
or cutting of any tree on any vacant land with a
girth exceeding one metre (3 ft. 4 ins.) measured
half a metre (1 ft. 8 ins.) from the ground. Under
the existing provision of section 4 of the Trees
and Plants (Preservation and Improvement of the
Amenities) Act, 1970, this restriction applies to
trees with a girth exceeding five feet, measured
two feet from the ground. Vacant land is defined
in clause 2 of the Bill to refer to land which has
not been developed for residential or industrial
purposes. This change has been proposed after a
study was made by my Ministry's officers of the
sizes of the different types of trees found in
Singapore at their various stages of growth.
(b) Clause 5 of the Bill introduces a presumption
that where a tree is felled on any vacant land it
shall be presumed that it has been felled by the
owner or occupier of the land. This provision is
necessary in order not to frustrate the work of
the Commissioner.
(c) In clause 7 the Commissioner is given the
power to serve a notice on the occupier of any
vacant land or land on which a new street is to be
constructed to require the occupier to plant
trees. Further, the Commissioner is empowered
under clause 11 to require housing developers to
make a deposit to ensure that trees are planted
and open spaces made up in accordance with the
approved plans and specifications.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Column: 1080
3.40 p.m.
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I support the
Bill, the purpose of which is to promote the
planting and protection of trees and flowers in
order to make Singapore a garden city. Over the
past few years the Government has observed one day
in the year as the national "Tree Planting Day" to
encourage people to plant more trees and shrubs in
order to beautify our environment in the concept
of a Garden City.
Sir, the people in my constituency have been
supporting this campaign every year. On "Tree
Planting Day" hundreds of people of different
races would turn up voluntarily to take part in
tree planting. Thus they have not only shown
enthusiasm in their support of the annual Tree
Planting Day, but they have also in their daily
life been actively promoting this concept by
planting trees and shrubs on empty plots around
their shophouses or houses to beautify and uplift
the environment.
Sir, the Parks and Recreation Division under the
Ministry of National Development has contributed a
lot towards achieving the objective of beautifying
our environment. For instance, the stretch of land
along the east coast from Tanjong Rhu to Bedok is
being developed into a public seaside park. This
is being developed into a first class public
resort of international standard even for
tourists.
But as regards tree planting at other places
there are certain shortcomings. For instance,
along Bras Basah Road and Robinson Road the PWD
has planted trees along that side of the road
which originally was a pedestrian walk. I think
this is not quite right because the roads are
already quite narrow and in view of the traffic
congestion along these roads, the demand for road
space is very urgent. So it would be proper for
the PWD to widen the roads instead of planting
trees along the sides, which worsens the traffic
congestion. Planting trees at random without
proper or advance planning is a sheer waste of
Column: 1081
public money because tree planting costs a lot of
money. One tree can cost several hundred dollars
if a contractor were to do it. This is a waste of
public funds and is not justified. So I would urge
the Minister to give careful consideration in
advance before planting any more trees.
Another matter relates to a strange complaint
which I have received. This is the case of a
private landowner who wanted to develop his land,
but there stood in the way a big tree several
decades old. The developer applied for permission
to cut it down. The authorities concerned said
that the tree could not be cut down because it is
under the protection of the law. The landowner
feels that there is no reason for the authorities
to deny him permission to fell the tree which
stands in his own private land. I therefore hope
that the Minister will look into this complaint
too.
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens): Mr Speaker, Sir, with reference to clause 5 of
the Bill, I just want to make a brief observation
on a matter therein and perhaps seek a
clarification from the Minister. In clause 5 there
is an exception made for the felling or cutting of
trees, i.e, the prevention of imminent danger. I
take it that "imminent danger" in the Bill
contemplates imminent danger to human life. Would
the Minister clarify as to whether the term
"imminent danger" also contemplates imminent
danger to property and animals, like pigs and
pets, etc.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs (Mr Lim Guan Hoo)(In Mandarin): Sir, I wonder if the Member for Sembawang would
care to clarify this point. In the earlier part of
his speech he supported the planting of trees, but
in winding up he seemed to favour the cutting down
of trees. He seemed to contradict himself.
Therefore, may I ask him this: does he or does he
not want to plant trees? Would he clarify this
point?
Column: 1082
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, I feel that the Parliamentary Secretary is
wasting his breath with a lot of trash.
Mr Lim Guan Hoo(In Mandarin): Sir, I think the last remark of the Member for
Sembawang, namely "trash", is not proper. If he
thinks it is proper, can he explain?
Mr Barker: Sir, perhaps the Member for Sembawang still
thinks that we are debating in Committee of
Supply. He should have taken the opportunity
during the last few days in Committee of Supply to
grumble about trees planted in the wrong places or
narrowing down roads. But he has made one relevant
observation, and that is, about one big tree on a
piece of vacant land which is about to be
developed. The position is this. Where a housing
developer applies to build on vacant land which
may have beautiful trees there in existence for
more than 50 or even 100 years, we send officers
to the vacant land to mark out where the trees
are, and the developer is still allowed to build
provided he preserves some trees. We are not here
to protect all the trees nor to stifle building
development. We would allow developers to build
provided sufficient trees are preserved.
I could not follow the Member for Serangoon
Gardens who wanted clarification, unless it
appears in clause 10 which states:
`Where the Commissioner is satisfied that any
tree or plant, whether growing or not, is in an
inflammable state or is likely to be dangerous to
life or property or to cause an obstruction . . .
the Commissioner may by notice in writing require
the occupier of the land on which it is growing or
lying to remove it within a time specified in the
notice.'
We do not propose to prevent all trees being
felled or cut down. `There must be a few trees
which are about to fall down either because of
root trouble or some other disease to the trunk.
Where a tree is likely to fall anti is a danger to
life and/or property, permission can be sought for
it to be cut.
Column: 1083
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, I would like the Minister to clarify certain
points. The Minister said that if there is a tree
on a piece of private land which is to be
developed the authority concerned would first send
somebody to see where the tree is.
For instance, if the land is 10,000 sq. ft. and
the building area of 5,000 sq. ft. is to be sited
in the centre of the land according to the plan,
then the tree which stands in the centre has to be
cut down before development can take place. There
may also be a need to comply with other
regulations such as the provision of car parks,
pedestrian walk, an open space in the property, or
other requirements, all of which necessitate the
cutting down of that tree. Under these
circumstances, although the tree is protected by
the law, can the Minister enlighten the House
whether it should be cut down.
Mr Barker: Yes, permission will be given to cut down such a
tree.
Mr Ong Teng Cheong: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am in full support of the Bill
which is tabled for Second Reading. However, I
would like to point out some of the practical
problems which may arise.
As spelt out in clauses 11 to 14, the
Commissioner of Parks and Recreation is empowered
to take a deposit from the developer to ensure
that he plants trees and lays out the open spaces
in accordance with the plans and specifications
approved by the competent authority. More often
than not, Sir, the developer has no intention of
retaining ownership long after a project has been
completed. He sells the property to various
buyers, and sometimes there are differences of
opinion as to what types of trees should be
planted. Surely, the buyer should have a say in
the type of trees to be planted in front of his
house or the type of hedges to be planted around
his fencing and compound. I wonder if the Minister
would agree that some flexibility should be
allowed in instances like this.
Column: 1084
Mr Barker: Yes, Sir, we have looked into this matter. Clause
11, for instance, was brought in for a specific
reason. Previously some developers, after
obtaining subdivision of the land and planning and
building approval from the competent authority,
would just sell the houses and leave the roads in
a very bad state. As the Member has pointed out,
developers want to sell. So they sell all the lots
and then disappear; leaving the roads not even
properly constructed nor the road lights
installed. This is the sort of situation we want
to prevent. Hence, this provision that on
application for building approval one of the
conditions imposed is that the developer plants
certain trees. We cannot allow them to sell the
land after development and then disappear.
But as far as the type of trees which the
developer or his purchaser may prefer, the
Commissioner is really not rigid. They can choose
the type of trees and we can make recommendations.
All we want to ensure is that the person who gets
the approval does something to plant in accordance
with the plans which he has obtained. Hence the
deposit.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr E. W. Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1084
TRUSTEES (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.57 p.m.
The Minister for Law and National Development (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
Sir, this is a very short Bill and I will keep my
speech short. The Bill seeks to amend the Trustees
Act (Chapter 40) by increasing the borrowing power
of an "approved company" from two-thirds to three-quarters of its mortgaged assets.
Column: 1085
Sections 3 and 4 of the Act lay down the
prerequisites that must be complied with by a
company before it can obtain the status of an
"approved company" within the meaning of the Act.
An "approved company" is defined in the Act as one
that is incorporated in Singapore and which has a
place of business in Singapore, having as its sole
or primary object the promotion of home ownership
by advancing purchase monies, repayable by
instalments over a specified period of time. Such
an "approved company" would then be permitted to
seek loans from trustees in accordance with
section 4 (1) (e) of the Trustees Act. Section 4
(2) of the Act, however, lays down the conditions
under which trust funds may be invested with an
"approved company". One of the conditions is that
the total borrowing power of the "approved
company" must not exceed two-thirds of its
mortgaged assets.
Representations have been received for an
increase of an borrowing power of an "approved
company" from two-thirds to four-fifths of the
company's mortgaged assets as the present limit is
considered too restrictive. Consideration has been
given to these representations. It is, however,
felt that the limit imposed by the Act should be
raised from two-thirds to three-quarters instead
of four-fifths of the mortgaged assets. This
requires an amendment to the relevant section of
the Trustees Act; hence the Bill before this
House.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr E. W. Barker].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1085
MEDICINES BILL
Order Second Reading read.
4.00 p.m.
The Minister of State for Health (Dr Ang Kok Peng): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
Column: 1086
It is perhaps a sad commentary on present-day
living that there is such a large consumption of
medicines. And because of this tremendous appetite
for drugs, a vast pharmaceutical industry exists
today. In Singapore the total value of trade in
pharmaceutical products in 1973 was $170 million.
For the four years 1969-1973, imports increased by
over 80% while exports increased by 400%.
In earlier times, medicines were of simpler
chemical substances or derivatives of herbs. They
were consumed in the form of powders prepared by
pounding or in the form of liquid obtained by
brewing the medicinal preparations. The
advancement of science has made it possible for us
to extract the active ingredients from these
medicinal preparations, synthesising them and even
modifying their structures to make them more
potent and specific. In these forms they are then
made available to the public in elegant pills,
capsules, injectionables and suppositories.
Even preparations used as home remedies in the
traditional systems of treating ailments have
changed beyond recognition. No longer do they
conic only as dried parts of plants or animals;
they are now sold in powder form or liquid
extracts and some of them have been found to be
mixed with dangerous substances making them no
longer harmless remedies but potent poisons.
The existing bewildering array of medicines of
high potency and diverse effects has created
certain problems of control. Whilst on the one
hand the public needs to be protected and assured
that the medicines that are available are safe and
useful; on the other hand, those who are in the
pharmaceutical industry should not be unduly
discouraged from introducing new and more useful
medicines.
The existing controls are no longer adequate in
dealing with a pharmaceutical trade that has grown
tremendously and a situation where complex
chemicals with far-reaching effects on the human
Column: 1087
being now form the bulk of medicines available in
Singapore.
The proposed Medicines Act is an omnibus act
designed to bring together controls which were
formerly exercised under various separate Acts.
Most of the provisions of the Poisons Act will now
be incorporated into the Medicines Act. Only a
residual portion on the control of industrial
poison will remain. The Medicines Act will
supersede the Sale of Drugs Act and the Medicines
(Advertisement and Sale) Act, both of which will
be repealed. As the control of opium and other
similar narcotic drugs is subject to international
conventions because of international illegal
trafficking, special controls will continue to be
exercised under the Misuse of Drugs Act.
The primary purpose of the Medicines Act is to
protect the persons who use drugs, that is the
customers who, by and large, have no knowledge of
factors influencing the safety and usefulness of a
medicine. The Act is to ensure that the medicine
which a consumer obtains is safe and useful and of
a quality he should expect. Since he is generally
not knowledgeable in this matter, the influence
brought to bear on him through advertisements must
be fair. The drug he obtains, be it from a doctor
who prescribes it or bought over the counter from
a medicine shop, should comply with certain
quality and safety standards. Conversely, neither
should he have access to drugs for which he has no
need of; nor should he consume drugs which he has
no knowledge of their potency or safety.
Under the Act, all medicinal products will come
under strict scrutiny. Medicinal products prepared
from herbs, animals or insects which have been
used in traditional systems of treating ailments
and which were largely not controlled previously
will now be subject to similar scrutiny under the
law. This is essential. These products are more
often than not supplied as pills and potions where
the original herb or animal part
Column: 1088
is no longer recognisable. It has been discovered
that unscrupulous manufacturers and charlatans
have resorted to adding highly active chemical
substances to lend potency to their medicine.
Arsenic discovered in several brands of
preparations used widely in the treatment of
asthma is an example. Potent hydrocortisones have
been found in others and so too have mercury and
lead. We can no longer ignore the large numbers
and brands of medicinals which are freely
available in the market, nor can we rightly assume
that they are harmless. More often than not they
are mixed with poisons and arc compounded by
persons with no knowledge of basic pharmacy or
pharmacology and distributed by persons whose sole
interest is profit. Even cosmetics which may
contain harmful or deleterious substances can also
be brought under the purview of the Act.
The simplest method of achieving the objective of
protecting the public in regard to medicines is to
impose a ban on advertisements of medicines anti
couple this with a complete control over the
dealing in medicines by only allowing sales by
prescription and restricting the import or
manufacture of medicines to a few types of brands.
In fact such controls are practised in some
countries. Such a measure would reduce
considerably the expenditure on drugs and drug
control. It would eliminate malpractices and
unscrupulous dealings in drugs. However, we cannot
adopt this simplistic attitude as we are an
important centre of communications and trade.
Nevertheless, we must exercise certain controls
and restrictions while permitting legitimate
pharmaceutical trade without compromising on the
efficacy and quality of medicines available in
Singapore. This Act attempts to do just that.
The Act accordingly provides close control at all
levels of the pharmaceutical trade - from the
import and manufacture of drugs to the sale of
drugs and even to the dispensing of drugs by
practitioners and pharmacists. Strict regulations
will be aimed at ensuring public
Column: 1089
safety. This is paramount. Further, in view of the
general ignorance about medicine there are
controls over advertisements and other techniques
for promoting drug sales since doctors and
patients are normally not in a position to verify
the claims of manufacturers.
The Act lays down in considerable detail the
authority and the principles of control while the
procedures for implementation will be set out in
the regulations.
The basic instrument to effect the objectives
will be the product licence. Any persons wishing
to import or manufacture any medicinal products
will have to satisfy the licensing authority who
is the Director of Medical Services that the
product complies with certain quality standards.
Medicinal products will be classified under two
categories, (a) non-general sales list medicines
and (b) general sales list medicines. Only
qualified persons, i.e, doctors, dentists,
pharmacists and veterinary surgeons, may deal with
non-general sales list products. Medicines on the
general sales list which are relatively harmless
will be subject to less stringent control and may
be sold as it is now being sold in our medicine
shops, over the counter and without a
prescription.
Medicinal products will now be screened by the
Ministry before they appear on the local market.
Where necessary, the screening will be done by
advisory committees. The evidence that is to be
provided by applicants for a product licence will
include details of pharmaceutical, bio-chemical
and chemical formulation, conditions and locality
of manufacture, details of qualified person
supervising its manufacture, and results of trials
carried out, and whether it complies with the laws
of the country of manufacture if this is not
manufactured locally. It shall be an offence to
misrepresent any of these facts and the licensing
authority is authorised to refuse to grant or
revoke a licence and vary any or all of the
conditions upon
Column: 1090
which the product licence has been granted.
Penalties are provided for those who breach the
law.
Manufacturers of medicinal products will be
required to apply for licences. The issuance for
such a licence will be conditional on, amongst
other requirements, suitability of personnel,
equipment and premises, as well as adequacy of
storage facilities.
Only qualified persons should be employed by
manufacturers to supervise production at each
stage and deal in medicinal products. No person
may manufacture a product if that product is not
so licensed.
Wholesale dealers will also be subject to
licensing. The issuance of such a licence will be
tied to amongst other requirements suitability of
premises as well as the employment of qualified
personnel. Their premises will have to be adequate
with suitable storage and distributing space and
equipment. Persons supervising the dealing of
medicinal products at wholesale dealer's premises
arc to be suitably qualified if dealers wish to
deal in the sale and supply of non-general sales
list products.
It shall be mandatory for all licence holders to
maintain adequate records for their transactions
as well as ensure that such records are well and
safely kept for inspection at reasonable times by
the Ministry officials. Adequate records are
required also to facilitate easy recall of drugs.
The Bill also protects the purchaser from
fraudulent representation on the safety, efficacy
and quality of medicinal products. Medicinal
products shall have to comply with the standards
of relevant monographs if they are claimed to be
sold or supplied in accordance with such
specification.
The Act has provisions for it to be brought into
effect in parts. Thus one of the first parts to be
implemented will be the notice categorising
medicines on a general sales list and a non-general sales list. The next would be the
regulations on registration of all medicines and
medicinal products. The regulations would
Column: 1091
be for provisional licensing of medicinal products
so that medicinal products on the market can
continue to be available.
In the advanced countries, research
establishments undertake research into drugs,
including clinical testing of their toxicity,
effectiveness and side-effect. While our
facilities and expertise in this field are not
adequate for such comprehensive investigations of
drugs, we are able for the time being to
concentrate on testing the toxicity of drugs for
which we can enlist the assistance of the Ministry
of Science and Technology. We will also rely on
the independent reports published regularly by the
World Health Organisation and internationally
renowned research centres for making rational
judgments on the safety and efficacy of particular
drugs and their use in Singapore.
To administer the law will require a large
expansion of the section of the Poisons
Inspectorate of the Ministry of Health. This
section will be responsible for the keeping of the
registers, issue of licences and inspections.
There are provisions in the law for the Minister
to appoint committees. Perhaps the one which would
be of more immediate interest would be a Committee
to deal with appeals against decisions taken
administratively on licensing. Other expert
committees such as a committee on safety may be
introduced in due course.
Because of the complexity of the Act and its far-reaching controls which will affect the fabric of
medical practice and the pharmaceutical trade, it
is recommended that the Bill be committed to a
Select Committee.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
4.15 p.m.
Dr Tan Eng Liang (River Valley): Mr Speaker, Sir, arising from an oral question
which I asked the Minister of State for Health
sometime last year, I am glad to note that he has
kept his promise by referring the Bill to a Select
Committee.
However, I would like to give some general
observations why this Medicines
Column: 1092
Bill should be sent to a Select Committee. The
Minister of State has correctly brought out the
point which I intended to raise, and that is, it
appears extremely restrictive that an appeal is
decided by the Minister alone. I think he has
indicated just now that it would be better that an
appeal committee consisting of knowledgeable
representatives from the relevant authorities be
appointed to assess all appeals and makes its
recommendations to the Minister for a final
decision.
In Part II, clause 10 (3) the definition of
"product licence" is not clear for it does not
positively say whether it is the brand or trade
name or whether it is the chemical or generic
name. Therefore, the question of issuing third
party licence on patented products becomes
relevant. It is reasonable to accept that products
with patent protection still in force, third
parties should not be allowed to apply for the
licence. However, product licence holders can
assign the right to a third party.
A few medicinal authorities in the United States
have questioned the adequacy of the United States
Pharmacopoeia (USP) standards. As with the British
Pharmacopoeia (BP) or the European Pharmacopoeia
(EP) bio-availability standards are generally not
available. Hence in clause 12 (1), the safety
efficacy and quality of medicinal products should
be thoroughly reexamined.
Clause 18 (a), (b) and (c) allows the Minister to
make regulations for clinical trials and for
medicinal tests. It is recognised that we have
limited clinical and testing facilities. It is
therefore unlikely that we are in a position to
conduct tests on tetratogenic effects or
congenital deformities. In view of this, the
licensing authority should be flexible in
assessing submitted literature for medicinal
products. An example of this test in case is the
experience relating to the introduction of
thalidomide in Germany resulting in thousands of
babies being deformed. It is therefore essential
to
Column: 1093
establish whether local manufacturing facilities
provide certain safeguards on the consumers in
case of such an unfortunate event for if they
should seek monetary compensation, how do the
manufacturers intend to meet these requirements? I
think this is one area which is worth looking
into.
Again in Part III, clauses 34 and 35, and Part
IV, clauses 37 (3) and 41(1), these provisions
appear to discriminate against practising
pharmacists or pharmacies. It appears reasonable
that these similar provisions should also be
extended to all those handling and dispensing
medicinal products.
Part V, clause 47 (1), this provision is not
practical as most imported medicinal products are
already produced by multi-national pharmaceutical
corporations for the international market.
Therefore, it may be difficult for the Minister to
make regulations stipulating distinctive colours,
shapes and markings of medicinal products.
The whole of Part VI of the Bill deals with the
promotion of sales of medicinal products and
medical advertisements. This has extremely wide
implications and requires closer study.
Representations by interested and knowledgeable
parties will be made to the Select Committee.
The good intention of any Bill or Act will be
thwarted and cannot achieve its required effects
if the implementation process is not as effective
and sensibly carried out. Hence proper
consideration should be given to the formulation
of various regulations by the licensing authority
for the practical implementation of the Medicines
Act, 1975, when it is finally passed.
Dr Ang Kok Peng: Mr Speaker, Sir, I wish to thank the Member for
River Valley for his views which will be conveyed
to the Select Committee for consideration.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Resolved,
Column: 1094
"That the Medicines Bill be committed to a Select
Committee consisting of Mr Speaker as Chairman and
the following Members:
Dr Ang Kok Peng
Mr Ivan Baptist
Mr Chan Chee Seng
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon
Mr P. Govindaswamy
Haji Sha'ari Bin Tadin
Dr Tan Eng Liang."-[Dr Ang Kok Peng].
Mr Speaker: Order. I propose to suspend the Sitting and will
take the Chair again at 4.55 p.m.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
4.22 p.m. until 4.55 p.m.
Column: 1094
Sitting resumed at 4.55 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
SINGAPORE FAMILY PLANNING AND POPULATION BOARD (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
The Minister of State for Health (Dr Ang Kok Peng): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
The proposed amendment is to allow the Singapore
Family Planning and Population Board to adopt
certain financial procedures so that the Board's
financial accountability can be placed on a firm
footing. These amendments are now required of any
statutory board set up by the Government.
In keeping with this move, the amendment will
require the Board to keep proper accounts and
records of monetary transactions, ensure that
payments made are credited and properly authorised
and proper control is maintained over its assets;
in short, the Board is to take steps to ensure
that money given to it is well and properly spent.
It also allows the Board's accounts to be audited
by the Auditor-General. However, where it has been
decided that the Board's accounts are to be
audited by any other qualified auditor, it shall
be done with his concurrence. The duties of the
auditor are clearly spelt out. He
Column: 1095
shall have to certify that financial statements
reflect fairly the financial transactions and
state of the Board as well as report on such
matters which he considers should be reported upon
at any time.
A penalty is also imposed on persons who wilfully
obstruct the auditor from performing his duty such
as preventing access to any records which he may
wish to see or withholding of information relevant
to his work. The auditor is also entitled to make
copies or extracts of documents.
Further, apart from submitting his annual report
the Auditor is empowered to inform the Minister on
any relevant matter that comes to his notice at
any time.
Where the Auditor-General is not the auditor,
copies of the audited financial statements are to
be forwarded to him at the same time as and when
the auditor submits accounts to the Board.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Dr Ang Kok Peng].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1095
NURSES AND MIDWIVES BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.00 p.m.
The Minister of State for Health (Dr Ang Kok Peng): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
The Bill will bring about an amalgamation of the
nursing and midwifery professions by having one
controlling body to regulate their activities.
These two professions are now quite separate.
Each is governed by its own regulatory body: the
nurses by the Nursing Board and the midwives by
the
Column: 1096
Midwives Board. Both Boards were established under
authority of separate laws.
The first legislation on nurses known as the
Nurses Registration Ordinance came into effect in
February, 1949, and a Nursing Board was
established to maintain a register of nurses and
to regulate on the training and conduct of nurses.
The legislation for midwives was introduced very
much earlier. The Midwives Ordinance was brought
into effect in July, 1917. Amendments were passed
subsequently in 1923 and 1924, and in 1959 new
regulations were incorporated. Under this
Ordinance, a Midwives Board was established with
the function of maintaining a register and
regulating the training and conduct of midwives.
Times have changed. Midwifery has now become a
subject of study in the training of nurses. It is
also taken as a course in the post-basic nursing
training. Furthermore, fewer people arc choosing
midwifery training solely. The sophistication of
our population, increasing urbanisation and the
extensive and comprehensive medical services have
reduced the demand for domiciliary midwifery. More
than 80% of all deliveries in Singapore are now
undertaken in our Government medical institutions.
The rest are delivered mainly in maternity homes.
Only a few are delivered by private midwives at
home.
Consequently midwifery should logically be
regarded as another branch of nursing, the
separate law on midwifery be abolished, and the
activities in regard to nursing and midwifery be
put under the jurisdiction of a single board The
Singapore Nursing Board. This Board will supersede
the Nursing and the Midwives Boards. The
consolidation of the two professions and services
will also lead to administrative convenience.
This, however, does not mean that midwives will
play a role secondary to that of the nurses,
neither does it suggest that midwifery is to be
governed by a nursing body. On the contrary, the
composition of the Board allows for both
Column: 1097
midwives and nurses to be represented. In addition
to the traditional role of midwives which was
confined in the main to the delivering of babies
and giving advice to mothers on the care of
children, the midwives nowadays also have an
important role to play in family planning by
giving counsel to parents on the need for planning
a small family.
The Singapore Nursing Board will be responsible
for ensuring that nurses and midwives who are to
be emplaced on the register or roll have been
adequately trained in accordance with the courses
and examinations conducted by the Board. The Board
shall also have powers to determine what
qualifications are necessary for anyone seeking to
be emplaced on its register or roll. In short, it
will oversee, maintain and improve the standards
of practice and conduct of nurses and midwives.
The Board is empowered also to impose punitive
measures on those who choose to bring the
professions to disrepute. Accordingly the Board is
empowered to remove the names of such persons from
the register or roll or impose as it sees fit
lesser penalties such as cautioning, censuring or
suspending persons for adverse practice. The Board
is also empowered where it deems fit to restore
names of persons to the register or roll.
Aggrieved persons are allowed to appeal to the
High Court.
A registrar of the Board is to be appointed and
he shall be responsible for the preparation and
maintenance of the register and roll and act as
secretary to the Board.
The Act also prevents unqualified persons from
taking the titles of nurse or midwife so that the
public will not be misled. An offence under this
section carries a fine not exceeding $1,000.
The Bill seeks to repeal the Nurses Registration
Act and the Midwives Act. However, those whose
names are already on the register or roll of
nurses and midwives prior to the passing of this
Bill will be deemed to have been registered or
enrolled.
Column: 1098
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Dr Ang Kok Peng].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1098
INCOME TAX (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.10 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
This Income Tax (Amendment) Bill is necessary,
first, to give legislative authority for a number
of income tax concessions; second, to further
strengthen the law against income tax offenders;
and third, to streamline procedures and improve
existing legislation.
A number of tax concessions were announced by me
previously in Parliament. These included income
tax relief for supporting parents and grandparents
and child relief for supporting handicapped
children over 16 years. Clause 8 of the Bill
provides for these concessions which need no
further elaboration.
Another announced concession was that with effect
from the year of assessment 1975, annuity payments
will be taxed only on that portion deemed to be
income, the balance being considered capital and
not taxable. Clause 3 (b) will provide for this
using a simple rule adopted by actuaries in some
countries to determine the income portion of an
annuity payment. I will not trouble Honourable
Members with details on how this rule works except
to say that the method of apportionment is
reasonable and is favoured because of its
simplicity in calculation both for the Inland
Revenue Department and the annuitant.
Column: 1099
Clause 3 (b) will also provide for the method of
taxing gains from Negotiable Certificates of
Deposits (NCDs) which I hope will soon make its
appearance in the Singapore money market. An
announcement on this will be made very shortly.
Because of the current uncertainty in the
financial world, the introduction of NCDs in
Singapore has been delayed but I am confident
that eventually NCDs will be an instrument
commonly traded in the Singapore money market.
Because of our desire to consolidate the
development of Singapore as a maritime centre, it
has been our policy to give fiscal incentives to
encourage shipowners to register their ships in
Singapore. I announced previously that the
balancing charge which may arise on the sale of a
Singapore ship will not be subject to tax and
that there will be income tax exemption for crews
working on board Singapore registered ships.
Clauses 3 (a) and 4 (a) provide for these
concessions. In addition, I am proposing a new
concession under clause 5. Hitherto, although
income from a Singapore ship is exempt from tax,
depreciation allowances on the ship are still
required to be charged against the exempt income.
The effect is to reduce the amount of tax exempt
dividends that could be declared by shipping
companies. I propose to lift this requirement and
allow Singapore ships the option to claim or not
to claim depreciation allowances. However, should
a ship leave the Singapore registry and become
liable to Singapore income tax, any unclaimed
depreciation allowances accumulated during the
period of its Singapore registration will not be
allowed. At the same time, it is also proposed
that tax exempt shipping income be separated from
other taxable income or losses of the same
company. In the past, shipping losses may be used
to offset against non-shipping taxable income
which is undesirable.
Clause 7 is also concerned with depreciation
allowances and provides for accelerated
depreciation over three
Column: 1100
years on capital investment in antipollution
devices. This concession is in keeping with
Government's policy to promote a cleaner and
healthier atmosphere in industrial estates and in
the community as a whole.
The export of our manufactured goods is the
basis of our industrial strategy. I am pleased to
see the number of trade missions organised
recently to visit potential markets to push
exports of Singapore-made goods. To assist these
efforts in export promotion, I announced that
double deduction will be allowed for expenses
incurred in approved overseas trade fairs,
exhibitions or trade missions organised to
promote the exports of Singapore-manufactured
goods. This concession, however, will not apply
to enterprises which are already enjoying export
or other incentives under the Economic Expansion
Incentives Act. Clause 6 of the Bill provides for
the double deduction concession which will have
retrospective effect from 1st April, 1973.
I now come to the amendments in the Bill
designed to tighten the law against income tax
offenders. Income tax is the mainstay of our
revenue structure accounting for more than one-third of total revenue. Compliance by taxpayers
is therefore of paramount importance and
Government must see to it that every person who
is liable pays his fair share.
The design of a penalty system for tax evasion
which without excessive harshness would yet be
punitive enough to deter would-be offenders is no
easy task. Some guidance is provided by
experience in the day-to-day administration of
the law. And such experience has shown that
certain modifications in the law dealing with
offenders should be made.
Clause 13 of the Bill provides for modification
of the penalty for failure to make an income tax
return or furnish particulars. There have been
too many cases where a fourth, fifth or sixth
conviction has not had the desired effect of
getting the taxpayer to submit his
Column: 1101
returns or accounts. The present penalty of a
maximum fine of $1,000 appears ineffective. It is
now proposed that if the conviction is a second or
subsequent conviction relating to the same year of
assessment, the taxpayer shall be made to suffer a
further penalty of $50 a day for every day that
the offence is continued after conviction.
It is also proposed to remove the requirement of
a possible minimum of six months' imprisonment in
addition to a fine for taxpayers who are convicted
for omitting or making false returns without
reasonable excuse or through fraud. A minimum six
months' imprisonment seems too harsh in this case
and invariably this has led to offenders being let
off with only a fine. Clauses 14 and 15 of the
Bill will allow for the length of imprisonment to
he decided by the Court. However, for cases of
fraudulent evasion for more than three years, a
minimum six months' sentence will remain.
At present, only the High Court may impose the
full penalty in respect of offences under the
Income Tax Act. As a good number of income tax
cases are dealt with in the District or
Magistrate's Court, clause 16 will empower the
District or Magistrate's Court to impose the full
penalty as well.
Clause 10 will require a married woman to sign
and furnish a return in respect of income
assessable in her husband's name, if deemed
necessary by the Comptroller. This will make it
possible for the Comptroller to take action
against the wife where she derives unearned income
which is assessable only in her husband's name and
which has not been declared to the Comptroller.
Hitherto, it was not possible to prosecute the
husband since he may genuinely be unaware of the
wife's undeclared income. At the time it is not
possible to prosecute the wife since she is not
assessable on this income. The amendment will plug
this loophole.
In the past, provisions in the Income Tax Act
regarding the general secrecy
Column: 1102
of income tax matters prevented the Comptroller
from making a complaint to any Professional Body
even if he is aware of blatant unprofessional
practices. This is an obstruction to the course of
justice. Clause 2 will take out this fetter on the
Comptroller to allow him to make a complaint to
the appropriate Professional Body of professional
misconduct against a person in his professional
dealings with the Comptroller.
Finally, I come to those amendments which are
intended to streamline procedures and improve
existing legislation.
Clause 18 will restrict the double child relief
given to taxpayers whose children are studying
abroad. It has been found that a number of parents
want their children to be "expatriates" at an
early age by sending them to expensive school
abroad. In the past, double relief could be
claimed for these children but there seems no
reason why Government should continue to doubly
subsidize such unnecessary expenditure. Clause 18
therefore provides that double relief will only he
allowed where the course of study abroad pursued
by the child is either not available in Singapore
or the child is unable to gain admission to an
institution of higher learning in Singapore.
Income of public entertainers is exempted from
tax if their visits are supported from public
funds of foreign governments. Sometimes, the
financial support from foreign governments is
purely nominal. Clause 4 (b) proposes to make it
clear that exemption will apply only if the visits
of public entertainers are substantially supported
from public funds of foreign governments.
To simplify procedures, clause 17 proposes to
vest the Minister with powers to amend the First,
Third and Fourth Schedules to the Income Tax Act.
The First Schedule deals with income tax exemption
for statutory boards and other institutions. The
Third Schedule concerns tax on income held by the
Custodian of Enemy Property.
Column: 1103
The Fourth Schedule lists the Government loan
stocks where interest earned therefore will be
subject to half the tax. As the Minister is
already empowered to reduce tax or give exemption
in the main Act, it would simplify procedures to
vest in him the powers to amend these three
Schedules as well. It is intended that the
remaining two Schedules in the Act, the Second and
the Fifth Schedules, which deal with the rates of
income tax and amount of child reliefs
respectively should continue to be amended only by
Parliament as these two Schedules would affect a
great number of people.
The remaining amendments are either consequential
in nature or are meant to tidy up procedural
matters.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
5.18 p.m.
Mr P. Selvadurai (Kuo Chuan): Mr Speaker, Sir, I merely would like to say a few
words on clause 2 of this Bill, which provision
may have quite unforeseen consequences in its
implementation. One could foresee a situation in
which a professional man may have committed
professional misconduct, justifying the
Comptroller laying a complaint before the
appropriate professional body authorised to take
disciplinary action but whose client may be
entirely innocent. In such a situation any
complaint laid by the Comptroller would result in
the confidential tax problem of the client being
discussed by other professional men who sit in the
appropriate disciplinary committee and who may
well represent other clients with conflicting
vested interests in the same matter. Such a
situation would nullify the protection afforded to
a taxpayer by the secrecy provision of the Income
Tax Act.
Whilst I agree that clause 2 is desirable for
preventing a particular form of professional
abuse, the machinery for its implementation, as it
now stands, is wholly inappropriate in the context
of a taxpayer's rights. This particular problem
should be looked into in greater
Column: 1104
depth, in fact, Sir, on second thought, I really
wonder what prevents the Comptroller from laying
such a complaint before the appropriate
disciplinary body in a given case regardless of
the provision of the proposed clause 2.
Apart from these comments, Sir, I support the
Bill.
Mr Rodrigo: Mr Speaker, Sir, I just wish to make observations
on some of the clauses in this Bill. On clause 3
(a) of the Bill, I am sure the shipping community
will welcome this proviso which no doubt will give
a fillip to shipping activity in Singapore. This
proviso excludes from tax the balancing charge
arising on the sale of a Singapore ship. Up to
now, because of the absence of such a provision,
the Comptroller has sought to tax this charge.
This measure has to some extent defeated the
purpose of section 13 (A) of the Act, that is, to
exempt from tax the income derived from the
employment or charter of a Singapore registered
ship.
The other clause that I wish to dwell on is
clause 4 (a) of the Bill. I feel that this new
amendment will no doubt further assist Singapore
shipping but something should he said in respect
of the drafting of this clause. In clause 4 (a)
paragraph (w) the use of the term "substantially"
can give rise to problems of construction
especially in the absence of a definition of the
term in this Bill or in the Income Tax Act. I am
led to wonder why the draftsmen have not chosen to
employ a phraseology giving a definite number of
days in a year instead, as in clause 4 (b) where
the words "sixty days in the year" are used.
Lastly, on clause 5 (a), (b) and (c) of the Bill,
this is another favourable development. This
amendment no longer makes it mandatory for capital
allowances to be deducted from the income of a
shipping enterprise. At present, this is necessary
in determining the exempt profits, the resultant
of which is that in many cases, as the Minister
quite rightly said, the huge allowances cancel the
profits leaving little or nothing for dividend
distribution.
Column: 1105
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Sir, I am in some difficulty in replying to these
criticisms because they are matters of technical
detail. On the first proposal about revealing
information on taxpayers' matters I thought that
we had taken care of the problem which was
presented and that this had been carefully
drafted. I do not know in what way this provision
can be improved. If the Member for Kuo Chuan has
any special change in the drafting, perhaps this
could be moved in the Committee stage.
I thought that this provision was satisfactory. I
assume that professional bodies often get
information which they must keep confidential even
in their proceedings before the professional body.
The names of the particular taxpayer could be
suppressed. Names could be omitted or replaced by
alphabetical symbols and the details of the
taxpayer need not be given. The nature of the
misconduct probably relates only to a particular
act which may not concern the whole of the
taxpayer's financial affairs. I would be prepared
to listen to any desirable amendment in Committee.
With regard to the comments by the Member for
Serangoon Gardens on balancing charges, I think he
welcomes clause 3. But he thought that under
clause 4 (a) (w) the word "substantially" should
be defined. I will give consideration to some
administrative definition of the word
"substantially", but I do not know whether in fact
a line can be drawn as we have drawn for clause 4
(b) (new subsection (4) ) where 60 days were
given. This is a well recognised limitation for
that particular purpose -employment exercised in
Singapore by short-term visiting employees. I
doubt whether there can be a very much closer
definition than the word "substantially". The
point is that in some cases the seaman is from
Singapore and he goes on a ship. The ship probably
operates elsewhere but the seaman comes for an
indeterminate period, I suppose on leave or for
other purposes, back in Singapore.
Administratively, it is possible to come to some
satisfactory arrangement but I
Column: 1106
do not know whether we can do much better in the
legal definition in stating the total number of
days.
The Member made another comment on clause 5 (a)
which I was not clear about. This is in respect of
allowances which leave nothing for income
distribution. I thought that was a desirable
amendment.
Mr Rodrigo: Sir, I did mention that was a desirable
amendment. I only referred to clause 4 (b).
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Sir, since that is a desirable amendment, I do
not have any particular comment then.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Hon Sui Semi].
Bill considered in Committee.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
5.31 p.m.
Clause I ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 2 -
Question proposed, "That clause 2 stand part of
the Bill."
Mr Selvadurai: Mr Speaker, Sir, I was wondering whether we can
really delete the whole of clause 2 for the time
being and come back to it when Parliament sits at
a future date if at all necessary, because if the
information which the Comptroller would like to
lay before the Disciplinary Committee does not
involve a confidential type of matter then, of
course, the secrecy provisions of the Act will not
apply at all. He could just as well lay the
complaint before the Committee. So I do not see
how clause 2 is really going to make any
difference to the present situation.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Sir, it is a question of interpretation. The
Comptroller has been very scrupulous in believing
that he cannot even lay a complaint. But this
clause will enable him to lay a complaint in a way
which will not reveal very much of the taxpayer's
financial affairs.
Column: 1107
We want to be sure that we can, in fact, lay a
complaint. We thought that at the moment this was
debarred because of the secrecy provisions.
Mr Selvadurai: This would really imply that the nature of
complaints that the Comptroller may lay before the
Disciplinary Committee will involve confidential
tax matters. That is why he had a doubt in his own
mind as to whether he could do it or not. This is
where the problem is because once it goes before
other professional men then, of course, a conflict
between respective clients becomes relevant.
The Chairman: Perhaps, Mr Hon, we can postpone the Committee
stage and reconsider the Bill later.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Sir, I think this is a matter of principle. I
believe that if the Member takes the view that
making a complaint means that we must reveal
information, then it means that we cannot make a
complaint of misconduct. My point is that the
complaint can be laid, the name of the taxpayer
suppressed, and the details of his tax affairs
need not be revealed except to the extent of that
particular piece of misconduct. At the moment the
interpretation of the Comptroller is that he
cannot even lay a complaint because of the
prohibition in the Act which provides that there
should be nothing which would indicate that a
taxpayer's affairs have been dealt with in such a
complaint. I think we want to relax it to the
extent that a complaint can be laid but we would,
as we have done previously, be quite scrupulous in
trying to omit details which would give
information to other people about the affairs of
the taxpayer.
I do not know whether we can resolve it by just
postponing consideration in Committee. It is not a
matter of drafting. It is a matter of whether, in
fact, the principle must be preserved - that
nothing should be revealed at all so that we
cannot even lay a complaint.
Mr Selvadurai: That is so, Mr Speaker, Sir, but if the client
concerned is completely innocent then, of course,
Column: 1108
it is going to be very hard on him just because
his professional adviser has mis-conducted
himself. The whole question relates to the nature
of the evidence that is going to be placed before
the professional body.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: On this matter, may I give the assurance that we
will take the greatest pains to prevent any
revelation of tax matters relating to taxpayers.
But we will in fact only do it to the extent that
complaints can be laid against certain
professional men in the discharge of their duties.
Mr Selvadurai: Thank you very much, Mr Speaker, Sir. We will
accept that for the time being, and perhaps we
will take it up in a different context if the
problems were to arise on a scale to warrant it.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Sir, I would be prepared to accept suggestions
for administering this particular section which
would satisfy both the professional bodies and my
Ministry as to the ability to make
representations.
Question put, and agreed to.
Clause 2 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clauses 3 to 5 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
Clause 6 -
The Chairman: In page 5, in lines 33 and 34, the word
"subsistance" appearing therein will be corrected
to read "subsistence", that is, with an "e"
instead of an "a". This will be done.
Clause 6 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clauses 7 to 18 inclusive ordered to stand part
of the Bill.
Bill reported without amendment; read a Third
time and passed.
Column: 1108
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT BOARD (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.38 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill
be now read a Second time."
Column: 1109
This Bill seeks to amend the Economic Development
Board Act so as to provide for:-
(a) the appointment of two Deputy Chairmen
instead of one Deputy Chairman at present;
(b) the appointment of a member of the Board to
act on behalf of the Chairman outside Singapore in
relation to any matters or class of matters;
(c) the appointment of not less than four and not
more than ten members of the Board (apart from the
Chairman and the Director) instead of six as at
present; and
(d) the manner in which the fixing of the common
seal of the Board is to be authenticated.
The Bill also makes clear that the Annual Report
of the Board will be based on its operations of
the preceding financial year.
These organisational changes are necessary to
enable the Economic Development Board to step up
its industrial promotion efforts at home and
abroad.
Since its establishment in 1961, the Economic
Development Board has been able to attract
considerable foreign investments into industry in
Singapore. Foreign investments and fixed assets in
the manufacturing sector rose from $10 million in
1964 to $2,930 million by the end of 1974, an
average annual increase of 40%.
High oil prices, inflation and massive
unemployment, even in industrialised countries,
have slowed down our ability to attract foreign
investments in industry into Singapore. Industrial
investment commitments in 1974 amounted to $829
million, less than the figure of $957 million the
year before. Though the prospects of foreign
investments into Singapore are currently less
encouraging, the international division of labour
will go on inexorably. Industries in Japan, Europe
and North America, which find that they can no
longer compete if they continue manufacturing in
their own countries, will seek to locate their
operations
Column: 1110
overseas in countries where the factors of
production are more in their favour.
Singapore, located in the midst of a rapidly
growing region of great mineral and agricultural
potential, is one of perhaps no more than a dozen
countries in the world in which multi-national and
even smaller-sized companies will consider it in
their interest to position themselves to face the
future, changed irreversibly by the oil producers
of OPEC.
The oil producers' successful change of the terms
of trade so much in their favour and so swiftly
marks an economic watershed. It presents Singapore
with immediate as well as long-term opportunities.
The more urgent search for oil has greatly
benefited Singapore's marine and offshore-oil-rigs
construction and logistics industries. In recent
months, the Economic Development Board's
investment centre in Houston, which is noted for
the number of US oil industry companies located
there, has been most active. In the long-term, the
higher price of oil will raise the cost of sea or
air transportation substantially. Energy and
mineral intensive industries would have to be
located nearer the sources of raw materials or
nearer the markets for their products. Singapore,
with its well-developed human and physical
infrastructure in the midst of a resource rich and
populous region, is well placed to compete for
such industries.
The relatively higher price of energy should help
also to improve the competitive position of our
established industries. The textiles and garments,
electrical and electronic, and woodworking
industries have played and will continue to play a
significant role in Singapore's industrialisation.
Value added by these three groups of industries
rose from 21% in 1970 to 31% in 1974 of total
value added by the manufacturing sector. They have
been able to do this because, these industries
have been continually improving their design and
quality through heavier investment in machinery
and technical training. Value added per worker in
the textile and garment industries more than
trebled from $1,960 in 1965 to $6,900 last year.
Similarly, value
Column: 1111
added per worker in the woodworking industry,
which progressed from simple sawmilling to wood-moulding, almost doubled from $4,170 in 1965 to
$7,100 last year. Value added per worker in the
electronics industry rose from $7,000 in 1965 to
$18,000 last year as the industry advanced from
component assembling to instrumentation and
testing.
I have quoted these value added figures at some
length because of a tendency to dismiss the so-called cheap textile and electronics industries.
These industries far from declining should, in
fact, grow even stronger. In future, all
manufacturing industries spurred on by the higher
price of oil would have to compete on the basis of
organisation and equipment rather than simple
unskilled labour. A relatively earlier start and
nearness to energy sources would enable Singapore
to compete on equal, if not better, terms with
countries further away from Southeast Asia.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Hon Sui Sen].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1111
CONSUMER PROTECTION (TRADE DESCRIPTIONS AND SAFETY REQUIREMENTS) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.47 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
It is already an offence to apply a false trade
description to goods under the Merchandise Marks
Act. However, this Act, which was first enacted in
1917, has many shortcomings and is out-of-date for
our present day needs. It is considered therefore
that the Merchandise Marks Act should be replaced
by new and more comprehensive legislation. The
provisions of the Consumer
Column: 1112
Protection Bill have been drafted in consultation
with the Consumers' Association of Singapore
(CASE) and are on lines similar to the Trade
Description Acts of Malaysia and the United
Kingdom.
The more extensive provisions in the Bill
prohibiting false and misleading description of
goods will not only protect the interests of
consumers, but also those of honest traders. The
coverage of the Bill is not limited to
descriptions appearing on products, but extends
also to false information given in the course of
enquiries or advertisements or oral statements.
The Bill also provides for the disclosure of
additional particulars of goods where such
information is lacking and of importance to
consumers. It is not intended, however, that the
disclosure provisions will require the publication
of trade secrets or formulae. Indeed, the Bill
makes it an offence for any person to disclose to
any other person such information if he has
obtained them in pursuance of the Act.
Further, the Bill provides that advertisements
are to be regulated so as to prevent misleading
statements in relation to the goods being
advertised. The consumer is entitled to expect
that the goods purchased fit the description given
in the advertisements.
The Bill also relates to the safe composition,
design and construction of goods for the
protection of consumers. On safety and health
grounds, it is required that certain goods be of
stipulated minimum standards. This is not a new
requirement as we already have minimum standards
set for certain goods, for example, crash helmets,
industrial helmets, hair-sprays and the like. It
is only after careful examination of the need for
minimum standards for consumers' safety that they
will be required.
The Bill includes provisions for the Minister to
make regulations for the purposes I have
mentioned, i.e., to require informative marking
and to impose safety requirements and also to
allow exemptions of goods from the
Column: 1113
operations of such regulations. It is the
intention that in such regulations, exemptions
will be given for goods for export or re-export
in any particular case, or in respect of the
particular categories of goods. Members are
therefore assured that it is not the intention of
the Government to restrict regional or
international trade.
In the enforcement of the law, the ability to
take prompt action will gain favourable consumer
reaction and will also act as a deterrent to the
commission of offences. The Controller of
Consumer Protection is therefore vested with the
authority to compound offences for a sum not
exceeding $2,000. Such an enabling provision will
make administration of the Act less costly as
well as help to impress on the traders the need
to adhere to the law.
Column: 1114
Members may also like to know that under the
Act, the Court convicting a person for an offence
may, at the same time, award damages to the
injured party up to $1,000 without prejudice to
the right of the party to take civil action to
claim damages beyond this amount.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and
committed to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Hon Sui Sen].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
ADJOURNMENT
Resolved,
"That Parliament do now adjourn to a date to be
fixed."-[Mr E. W. Barker].
Adjourned accordingly at Five Minutes to
Six o'clock p.m. to a date to be fixed.