| Parliament No: | 3 |
| Session No: | 2 |
| Volume No: | 34 |
| Sitting No: | 16 |
| Sitting Date: | 19-08-1975 |
|
Column: 1179
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
SINGAPORE
OFFICIAL REPORT
THIRD PARLIAMENT
Tuesday, 19th August, 1975
The House met at 2.30 p.m.
PRESENT:
Mr SPEAKER (Dr Yeoh Ghim Seng, B.B.M., J.P. (Joo Chiat)).
Encik Abdul Aziz Karim (Kallang).
Mr Ahmad Mattar (Leng Kee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education.
Dr Ang Kok Peng, B.B.M. (Crawford).
Mr Ang Nam Piau (Thomson).
Mr Ivan Baptist (Potong Pasir).
Mr E. W. Barker (Tanglin), Minister for Law and the Environment and Leader of the House.
Mr Chai Chong Yii (Bukit Batok), Minister of State for Education.
Mr Chan Chee Seng (Jalan Besar), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Cheong Yuen Chee (Toa Payoh).
Dr Chiang Hai Ding (Ulu Pandan).
Mr Chin Harn Tong (Aljunied).
Mr Ch'ng Jit Koon (Tiong Bahru).
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for the Environment.
Mr Chua Sian Chin (Mac Pherson), Minister for Home Affairs.
Mr Fong Sip Chee (Stamford), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Labour.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah).
Column: 1180
Mr P. Govindaswamy (Anson).
Mr Ho Cheng Choon (Geylang East), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development.
Mr Ho Kah Leong (Jurong).
Mr Ho See Beng (Bras Basah).
Mr Hon Sui Sen (Havelock), Minister for Finance.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu).
Mr Jek Yeun Thong (Queenstown), Minister for Culture.
Mr Lai Tha Chai (Henderson).
Dr Lee Chiaw Meng (Farrer Park), Minister for Science and Technology.
Mr Lee Khoon Choy (Hong Lim), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Lee Yiok Seng (Bukit Panjang).
Mr Lim Guan Hoo (Bukit Merah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Home Affairs.
Mr Lim Kim San, D.U.T. (Cairnhill), Minister for National Development and Communications.
Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampung Kembangan).
Mr Ng Kah Ting (Punggol).
Mr Ng Yeow Chong (Mountbatten).
Mr Ong Pang Boon (Telok Ayer), Minister for Labour.
Mr Ong Soo Chuan (Nee Soon), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Mr Ong Teng Cheong (Kim Keat), Minister of State for Communications.
Column: 1181
Encik Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs.
Mr Phua Bah Lee (Tampines), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Defence.
Encik Rahmat Bin Kenap Al-Haj (Geylang Serai).
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens).
Mr Seah Mui Kok (Bukit Ho Swee).
Mr P. Selvadurai (Kuo Chuan).
Mr Sia Kah Hui (Upper Serangoon), Minister of State for Labour and Government Whip.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein).
Mr Sim Boon Woo (Changi).
Dr Tan Eng Liang, B.B.M. (River Valley), Minister of State for National Development.
Dr Augustine H. H. Tan (Whampoa).
Mr Tang See Chim (Chua Chu Kang), Deputy Speaker.
Mr Tay Boon Too (Paya Lebar).
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang).
Dr Toh Chin Chye (Rochore), Minister for Health.
Column: 1182
Prof. Wong Lin Ken, B.B.M. (Alexandra).
Mr Yeo Choo Kok (Delta).
Mr Yeo loon Chia (Kampung Kapur).
Mr Yong Nyuk Lin (Geylang West), Minister.
ABSENT:
Encik A. Rahim Ishak (Siglap), Minister of State for Foreign Affairs.
Dr Goh Keng Swee (Kreta Ayer), Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Defence.
Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Tanjong Pagar), Prime Minister.
Dr Ong Leong Boon (Kim Seng).
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampung Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Haji Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampung Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture.
Mr Wee Toon Boon (Sepoy Lines).
Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampung Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office.
Column: 1181
PERMISSION TO MEMBERS TO BE ABSENT
Under the provisions of clause 2 (d) of Article 30 of
the Constitution of Singapore, I have granted
permission to the following Members to be or to
remain absent from sittings of Parliament (or any
Committee of Parliament to which they have been
appointed) for the periods stated:-
Haji Sha'ari Bin Tadin (Kampung Chai Chee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Culture - from 15th to 22nd August, 1975.
Haji Ya'acob Bin Mohamed (Kampung Ubi), Minister of State, Prime Minister's Office - on 19th August, 1975.
Column: 1182
Mr Wee loon Boon (Sepoy Lines) - on 19th August, 1975.
Mr Tang See Chim (Chua Chu Kang), Deputy Speaker, - from 19th to 24th August, 1975.
Mr Ahmad Mattar (Leng. Kee), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Education - from 19th to 24th August, 1975.
Mr P. Selvadurai (Kuo Chuan) - from 19th to 24th August, 1975.
Mr S. Rajaratnam (Kampung Glam), Minister for Foreign Affairs - from 21st August to 16th October, 1975.
Column: 1183
Encik Othman Bin Wok (Pasir Panjang), Minister for Social Affairs - from 23rd August to 6th September, 1975.
Mr Hon Sui Sen (Havelock), Minister for Finance - from 23rd August to 12th September, 1975.
Mr Chai Chong Yii (Bukit Batok), Minister of State for Education - from 1st to 21st September, 1975.
Column: 1184
Mr Chor Yeok Eng (Bukit Timah), Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for the Environment - from 1st to 26th September, 1975.
Mr Sia Khoon Seong (Moulmein) - from 2nd to 15th September, 1975.
| | YEOH GHIM SENG |
| | Speaker, |
| | Parliament of Singapore |
Column: 1184
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
BILLS INTRODUCED
EMPLOYMENT (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Employment Act (Chapter 122 of the
Revised Edition)",
presented by the Minister of State for Labour (Mr Sia Kah Hui); read the First time, to be read a Second
time on the next available sitting of Parliament, and
to be printed.
Column: 1183
COMPANIES (AMENDMENT) BILL
First Reading
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to introduce a Bill intituled
"An Act to amend the Companies Act (Chapter 185 of the
Revised Edition)".
Bill read the First time.
Second Reading
Mr Speaker: Second Reading, what day?
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Now, Sir.
Certificate of Urgency signed by the President in
respect of the Bill, laid upon the Table by the
Minister.
Typed copies of the Bill distributed to Members.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
Column: 1184
Section 196 of the Companies Act deals with the
appointment of inspectors to investigate the affairs
of a Declared Company. The Bill now before the House
seeks to amend this section so as to enable an
inspector to inform the Minister of any matters coming
to his knowledge as a result of the investigation
tending to show that an offence has been committed.
The Minister may then take such steps as he deems fit.
Under the law as it now stands, an inspector may only
disclose such information to the Minister when he
makes his report. The law in Singapore is in exactly
the same state as it was in England prior to 1967.
When a revised Companies Act was introduced in the
United Kingdom in 1967, the corresponding section of
the English Act was amended so that now an inspector
may, without the necessity of making an interim
report, inform the Department of Trade (which is the
appointing authority for inspectors in the UK) of
matters disclosing the probability that an offence has
been committed.
It is with a view to achieving the same result in our
laws that the proposed amendment to section 196 of our
Companies Act is now before the House. When this Bill
becomes law, an inspector may, at any time in the
course of his investigation, without the necessity of
making an interim report, make disclosures of such
matters. Honourable Members will appreciate the
importance
Column: 1185
of this Bill which would enable prompt and speedy
action to be taken whenever an inspector whose duty it
is to investigate the affairs of a company obtains
incriminating evidence in the course of his duties.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
2.37 p.m.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin (Jalan Kayu): Mr Speaker, Sir, I am just wondering whether the Hon.
Minister would care to inform the House of the reason
for the urgency in taking the Bill through all its
three stages today.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Sir, while I did not mention it, I think the reason
is perfectly clear. There is now an investigation and
I would like to be given information on matters which
the inspector may be able to give, because in the
course of his investigation he may have come across
matters which might suggest that an offence has been
committed. This Bill would then enable him to make
such disclosure to the Minister without having to make
an interim report.
The need of this particular piece of legislation was
discovered when in looking through Our Act, in
comparison with the English Act, we found that the
deficiency in our Act prevented information to be
given except by way of an interim report. This we
thought was not necessary and, therefore, I felt that
this particular Bill should be introduced and taken
through all its stages in this House.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill-[Mr. Hon Sui Sen].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without amendment;
read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1186
NGEE ANN TECHNICAL COLLEGE (AMENDMENT) BILL
"to amend the Ngee Ann Technical College Act (Chapter
179 of the Revised Edition)",
presented by the Minister for Science and Technology (Dr Lee Chiaw Meng); read the First time, to be read a
Second time on the next available sitting of
Parliament, and to be printed.
Column: 1186
PORT OF SINGAPORE AUTHORITY (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.40 p.m.
The Minister of State for Communications (Mr Ong Teng Cheong): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
There are four main amendments proposed in this Bill.
Clause 2 of the Bill seeks to add a new Part VA to
the Act to make special provisions governing the sale
of flats, houses or buildings sold by the PSA under
its housing scheme. Any property sold by the PSA will
be subject to restrictive conditions prohibiting the
dealings in such property without the permission of
the PSA and to special rules governing the
transmission of the property on the death of the
owners. For example, no property sold by the PSA shall
be sold, leased, mortgaged, transferred or charged
without the written consent of the PSA. This will
safeguard the PSA's interest and ensure that the
living accommodation is not transferred to undesirable
persons or disposed of to make quick profits. The
Authority will also be empowered to compulsorily
acquire the property if the owner or his spouse has
not complied with certain provisions laid down in this
Part. These proposed provisions are broadly similar to
those of the Housing and Development Act. The PSA's
legal officers will be empowered to certify and
register documents relating to the sale of PSA
properties on behalf of the employees.
Column: 1187
Clause 3 seeks to repeal and reenact sections 45 to
49 of the principal Act which relates to the keeping
of accounts, the appointment, powers and duties of the
auditor, the preparation of financial statements, the
submission of the financial statements, audit reports
and annual reports to the Minister and the
presentation of these reports and statements to
Parliament. This proposed amendment is in compliance
with the Auditor-General's request to standardise the
procedures of auditing for all quasi-government and
statutory bodies. The PSA has already been following
these procedures and the amendment is only to reflect
the actual position.
Clause 4 seeks to amend section 52 of the Act. Under
the existing section 52, goods dues shall be paid by
the owner or occupier of private wharves or premises.
The PSA has experienced difficulty in some cases in
collecting goods dues from operators of private
wharves or premises. The amendment will empower the
PSA to collect goods dues either from the owner or
occupier of private wharves or premises or from the
owners or agents of the vehicles or vessels carrying
such goods into or out of the wharves or premises.
Clause 5 amends the existing section 100 which,
though it provides for penalties for offences in
connection with the safety of vessels, does not
include cases of overloaded or improperly manned
vessels. The proposed amendment will include a
provision to make it an offence to use or permit to be
used a vessel which is unsafe or overloaded or not
properly manned.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Ong Teng Cheong].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1188
PLANNING (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.45 p.m.
The Minister for National Development and Communications (Mr Lim Kim San): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
While my Ministry has been fairly successful in
taking enforcement action against the erection of
unauthorised structures and is able to contain such
illegal activities, however, there has been an
appreciable increase in unauthorised change of use of
premises, both within and outside the city area. Many
trades and small industries, offices, stores, and
workshops have moved into premises which are not to be
used for such purposes. This is especially so in the
residential areas. Sir, such unauthorised uses
invariably affect the amenity and the environmental
quality of the area and create nuisance and
disturbance to the neighbourhood.
On the other hand, change of use of buildings or land
is permitted where the proposed activities can be
logically and naturally integrated into the prevailing
activities of the area. In such cases, the change of
use usually results in more intensive usage of the
premises and land.
Mr Speaker, Sir, the Bill seeks to amend the Planning
Act so as to give specific powers to permit the change
of use of buildings and land where conditions allow,
to grant such permit for a specific period of time,
and to impose a development charge which will be set
out in subsidiary legislations. It is also intended to
intensify enforcement action against all unauthorised
changes of use
Column: 1189
in order to bring such illegal activities under
effective control.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and com
mitted to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Lim Kim San].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1189
PARKING PLACES (SURCHARGE) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
The Minister of State for National Development (Dr Tan Eng Liang): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
As part of the scheme to restrain non-essential
usage of private cars in the Central Business
District, it is necessary to increase parking
charges in public and private car parks. This Bill
seeks to impose a surcharge on parking places in
designated areas.
The Minister is empowered to designate areas or
places by order in the Gazette and to impose a
surcharge on parking places in the designated
areas (clause 3). Different rates may be imposed
in different designated areas, and the rates may
be based on the number of parking lots or on other
basis. The surcharge collected shall be paid into
the Consolidated Fund (clause 6).
The Bill does not apply to parking places used
exclusively in connection with any private
dwelling houses (clause 8). The usual penalties,
exemption and rule-making powers are provided for
in the Bill.
Members may wish to know that the area to be
designated will be the present Restricted Zone.
For the purpose of the surcharge, a Core Area
within the Restricted Zone will also be
designated.
Column: 1190
This Core Area roughly covers the heart of the
Central Business District and will be more
accurately described in the Order to be made when
the Bill is passed by Parliament and brought into
force. I can also inform Members of the House that
the rates of surcharge will be $20 per parking lot
per month in the Core Area and $10 per parking lot
per month in the rest of the Restricted Zone as
recommended by the Road Transport Action
Committee. The surcharge will apply to all car
parks in the designated area including Urban
Redevelopment Authority car parks. Designated
areas and the rates of surcharge may be varied
from time to time to achieve the desired traffic
restraint objectives and policies.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed
to a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Dr Tan Eng Liang].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1190
ADMINISTRATION OF MUSLIM LAW (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
2.55 p.m.
The Minister for Social Affairs (Encik Othman Bin Wok): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
The Administration of Muslim Law (Amendment)
Bill, 1975, was introduced in Parliament on 29th
July, 1975.
The Majlis Ugama Islam Singapura, under the
Administration of the Muslim Law Act (Cap. 42) has
certain responsibilities. One of these is the
administration of all mosques in Singapore.
Progress in Singapore involves change. The
numerous development schemes such as public
housing, road
Column: 1191
development, etc, require the best possible use of
land. Wherever possible, alternative sites for
religious buildings are provided within the
framework of a rational utilisation of scarce
land. This applies to all religions in Singapore.
The process of urban renewal has resulted in the
moving of population from one area to another and
the concentration of people in satellite towns. In
recognition of the religious needs of the Muslims
who have been resettled, the Government has
provided the Majlis Ugama Islam Singapura sites
for mosques at the satellite towns of Jurong, Toa
Payoh and Queenstown. Mosque sites at Woodlands
and Chai Chee are also made available to the
Majlis. At Chua Chu Kang, a new mosque has already
been built by the Government at the site of the
new cemetery. At Geylang Serai, two mosques had to
be demolished as a result of a new road project,
but both were re-built nearby at Government's
expense. The re-built mosques at Jalan Rebong and
Lorong Ungku Aman are bigger and are provided with
better modern facilities. Moreover, the Government
has already publicly announced in November 1973
that its policy in the process of urban renewal
and development is to reserve adequate sites for a
temple, a mosque, and a church in each of the new
towns or concentrations of population into which
people are moving. Depending on the size of the
community in each of these housing estates,
adequate space will be reserved for each religion
in every new town.
The Muslims in Singapore have experienced
difficulties in raising funds for the mosque
building programmes. To-date, not a single mosque
has been erected at the sites in satellite towns
provided by the Government, despite the efforts
made by Muslim groups in various parts of
Singapore to raise funds for the construction of
mosques. The difficulty and the slow pace in fund-raising are compounded by the escalation
Column: 1192
in building costs. A number of appeals for
assistance have been made to the Majlis Ugama
Islam Singapura and this has led the Majlis to
approach the Government to help solve the problem.
The Bill now before the House seeks to amend the
Administration of Muslim Law Act to provide for
the establishment of a Mosque Building Fund to be
used for building one mosque in each new town. In
the course of the next three to eight years, four
new mosques, each varying between $500,000 to
$800,000 in costs, will be built in Toa Payoh,
Queenstown, Jurong and Woodlands. Two other
mosques will also be built, one in Chai Chee,
another in Telok Blangah or Pasir Panjang.
The Mosque Building Fund will be administered by
the Majlis Ugama Islam Singapura (MUIS) and
contributions to the Fund will be voluntary. The
MUIS will appoint their own agents to collect
contributions from Muslims who are employers or
are self-employed, since these people do not have
CPF accounts. For this purpose, Ketua Amils and
Amils will also be appointed during each fasting
month. The Central Provident Fund Board will be
the collecting agent for the contributions payable
in respect of Muslim employees.
Members of the House will observe that the Bill
makes it compulsory for every employer of a Muslim
employee to pay monthly contributions to the Mosque
Building Fund of an amount set out in the Schedule
to the Act on behalf of his employee. He is
empowered to recover such contributions from the
wages of his Muslim employees.
Realising that there may be Muslims who are
financially unable to afford to contribute, the
scheme has been designed as a voluntary scheme.
Since contribution to the Mosque Building Fund is
voluntary, a Muslim employee who does not wish his
employer to contribute to the Mosque Building Fund
on his behalf can exercise an option not to contribute
Column: 1193
under the Act. A Muslim employee who does not
wish to contribute could, therefore, file an
application for a Certificate of Option with the
Majlis Ugama Islam which is responsible for issuing
Certificates of Option which are valid for a period
not exceeding 12 months. Whilst the Certificate is in
force, his employer need not pay contributions on his
behalf. However, on the expiry of the period for which
the option is in force, the employer shall be liable
to pay the contributions unless the employee again
exercises an option to absolve him from this liability
for a further period of time not exceeding 12 months.
Just as there may be Muslims who are financially
unable to contribute, there may be those who wish to
contribute more than the minimum amount. For this
purpose, the Bill also makes provision for
contributions in excess of the minimum amount of 50
cents per month to the Mosque Building Fund. An
employee who wishes to contribute more than 50 cents
per month can notify his employer by submitting a
Notification Form stating the desired amount for a
period of six months. Self-employed Muslims can notify
the MUIS in like manner.
The MUIS is also empowered to receive contributions
for the Mosque Building Fund from non-Muslim persons.
Non-Muslim well-wishers are, therefore, welcomed to
contribute to the Mosque Building Fund.
The Bill also provides for the Majlis to make rules
with the approval of the Minister for Social Affairs
for the purpose of collecting contributions direct
from those who do not have CPF accounts, either
because they are employers or self-employed, and also
for the purpose of carrying out the provisions of the
Act relating to the Mosque Building Fund.
Column: 1194
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
3.03 p.m.
Haji Mohd. Ariff Bin Suradi (Kampung Kembangan)(In Malay): Mr Speaker, Sir, following the Prime Minister's
announcement concerning the provision of sites for
mosques in new satellite towns, statements were made
concerning the voluntary deductions of 50 cents per
month from Muslim employees through the CPF. Muslims
in Singapore have now become more than ever convinced
of the Government's policy. Prior to these
announcements, complaints and grievances could be
heard from many Muslims in Singapore, and their target
was the Muslim Religious Council of Singapore.
Although the Muslims in Singapore accepted, in
principle, the demolition of old mosques on those
sites which are affected by urban development,
nevertheless their feeling of suspicion could be
discerned because those mosques affected by
development have already been demolished whilst the
building of new ones has yet to commence. With the
spiralling costs of building materials consequent upon
inflation, it is even more difficult to build the
mosques which are being planned because of the
shortage of funds. It would seem that these mosques
will never be built so long as building costs do not
return to normal levels as in 1972 and 1973.
With this Bill, however, Mr Speaker, Sir, the Muslims
now feel that the Government is really sincere in
wanting to assist and cooperate with them towards the
progress of Muslims in Singapore, so that they can be
put, on the same level as the other communities, not
by providing a subsidy but by practical means, like
giving them facilities to collect and raise funds from
the Muslims themselves. The Muslims in Singapore also
realise that although they are left far
Column: 1195
behind in all fields of endeavour, they do not want to
depend solely on assistance from the Government. They
do not want to be a social burden to the Government
and to the other communities in Singapore.
I have been informed that, since the commencement of
the deductions in May, 1975, the net amount received
by the Muslim Religious Council of Singapore through
the CPF was $51,000 and in the subsequent month it was
$53,000. From the total number of Muslims in Singapore
only 40 do not wish to have their pay deducted for the
purpose. This means that the number of such people is
negligible. I believe that this Bill will produce the
desired benefits for the Muslims in Singapore.
Mr Speaker, Sir, may I say something on the new
section 75B in clause 3 regarding the provision for
the payment of any costs of administering this Fund? I
believe this Fund will be maintained through
computerised collections by the CPF. I also believe
that the cost of administering this Fund and the
salaries of those who administer this Fund will be
paid out of the contributions. May I suggest to the
Minister in charge that similarly contributions to
this Fund be used to pay the Imams and the caretakers
of the mosques built out of this Fund.
With regard to the new section 7SF, which empowers
the Majlis to make rules, I would ask the Minister to
give careful attention to this power. I would like to
draw the attention of the Minister to the power given
to the Majlis Ugama Is/am to award scholarships met by
the collection of tithes. From my experience I have
discovered that some Muslims in Singapore who have
gone abroad to further their studies and are no longer
Singapore citizens still continue to receive these
scholarships. Furthermore students who are studying
abroad and who have since married foreigners in their
places of study are still receiving these
scholarships. I think this is most
Column: 1196
inappropriate. Again, recipients of these scholarships
have been known to drive in Opel 1700s to attend
classes whilst applicants for such scholarships who
are genuinely in need of financial assistance, as they
are fatherless and depend solely on their brothers who
themselves have their own responsibilities, are
deprived of these scholarships. I hope the Minister in
charge will give serious attention to this matter
concerning the power to make rules to pay out money
from contributions by Muslims towards the Mosque
Building Fund.
Encik Othman Bin Wok: Mr Speaker, Sir, I would just like to point out to
the Member for Kampung Kembangan that this Fund is
established for the purpose of building mosques in the
new towns only, and not as he has stated just now,
i.e, whenever a mosque is pulled down a new mosque
will be built on the site. The Fund is not meant for
that purpose. It is specifically set up to build
mosques in the new towns which I have named in my
Second Reading speech.
On his point about utilising monies in the Mosque
Building Fund under the new section 75B, in clause 3
of the Bill, I wish to reiterate that the Fund is
established for a specific purpose only, that is, it
shall be used for:
`(a)the purpose of building any mosque in Singapore;
and
(b)the payment of any costs, charges and expenses of
maintaining and administering the Mosque Building Fund.'
I am afraid the monies cannot be used
for any other purpose than what is stated in the Bill.
On his third point about the powers given to the
MUIS, I can assure him, Sir, that I will keep an eye
on whatever the MUIS is doing.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Encik Othman Bin Wok].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1197
LAND TITLES (STRATA) (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.17 p.m.
The Minister for Law and the Environment (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
Sir, although the Bill appears to introduce a large
number of amendments to the Act, the bulk of them are
merely consequential amendments, and I shall deal with
only the main ones.
The Land Titles (Strata) Act, enacted in 1968,
enables purchasers of flats for which strata titles
have been issued to manage and maintain the building
containing the flats and its related common property
such as common corridors, staircases, garden and
lifts. However, in recent years there have been
attempts made by the developer of a subdivided
building to control the management of the building
after the issue of the certificates of strata title by
issuing leases of the flats to the purchasers with
terms entrenched in the leases in favour of the
developer. To ensure that these purchasers, who have
been granted a leasehold interest of a term of not
less than 21 years, should have a say in the
management and maintenance of the common property
pertaining to the subdivided building, it is necessary
to amend the Act to allow such purchasers to exercise
fully the rights of management conferred upon Strata
title owners as if the leases were not created. The
Bill before this House seeks, inter alia, to do this.
The Bill provides for the issue of strata titles for
condominium developments. Perhaps I should explain
briefly what a condominium development is. A housing
estate which is classified as a condominium
development will have the usual bungalows, semi-detached houses, terrace houses and, perhaps flats.
The estate looks no different from the
Column: 1198
usual housing estate. However, in a condominium
development, the developer will be required to provide
recreational facilities for all the residents in the
estate. As soon as the strata title plan of the estate
has been registered with the Registrar of Titles the
owners of the housing or flat units in the estate will
constitute the management corporation of the estate.
The management corporation will then be responsible
for the maintenance of all the recreational facilities
and the common property.
The interest which an owner of a housing unit in such
an estate acquires is contained in a strata title. He
owns what is within the confines of his bungalow, semi-detached house, terrace house or flat as the case may
be. The land on which all the housing units are built
is vested in all the owners as part of their common
property in accordance with the shares allotted to
them as shown in the strata title plan.
In such an estate, owners of bungalows, semi-detached
houses and terrace houses may also own private
gardens. The land comprising the garden also forms
part of the common property but an "accessory" strata
lot will be created for the garden so privately owned
and such "accessory" lot can only be transferred
together with the strata lot comprising the dwelling
unit.
The Bill also provides for the issue of strata titles
for a condominium development as and when part of it
is completed. In a very large housing project, it is
desirable to allow the developers to convey the legal
title of completed housing units even though the whole
housing project has not been completed. This will
enable a developer to divest himself of his title in a
completed housing unit while the construction of the
remaining part is still in progress and a purchaser to
obtain a good title to his individual housing unit
much earlier.
Under the Bill some significant changes have been
proposed for the pur-
Column: 1199
pose of enlarging the powers, duties and obligations
of a management corporation established under Part IV
of the Act in respect of subdivided buildings and
condominium developments. These changes are necessary
because every owner of a strata lot in a subdivided
building or a condominium development participates in
community living. It has been found necessary to amend
the law in this respect to ensure that every owner
plays his part in maintaining a subdivided building or
the condominium development.
Sir, the Bill will affect the rights and interests of
a large section of our public. It is therefore
proposed to refer it to a Select Committee so that all
interested parties can air their views and make such
representations as they may deem necessary.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
3.23 p.m.
Mr Teong Eng Siong (Sembawang)(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like the Minister to clarify
a few points. The Bill provides that condominium land
is common property. In other words, it is land
commonly owned by the owners of the houses. However,
if the buildings in this condominium estate have to be
rebuilt, will this condominium land still belong to
the owners of the housing units? In other words, if
there is rebuilding on this site and if the owner of a
flat on this condominium property is unable to carry
out the rebuilding of his flat, what will happen to
him?
Mr Barker: Sir, can the Member repeat his question, because I did
not quite catch him?
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, the Minister has said that the land which is
developed by condominium housing belongs to the owners
of the houses or flats on this property. My
Column: 1200
question is: if a block of flats has to be pulled down
and rebuilt, what happens if certain owners of the
flats are unable to rebuild, although they still have
their share of the land? What is the position of such
flat owners?
Mr Barker: The answer is simple. All that the flat owner owns is
a part of the land. If the flat owner owns, let us
say, Flat A on the 16th floor, then if the flat is
demolished all he owns is a little portion of the land
in the proportion in Which he owned it before.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, if the land area measures 10,000 sq.ft. and there
are 20 housing units on it, then if this piece of land
is subdivided into 20 parts, it will be wasted. If
certain owners do not want to rebuild their flats on
this piece of land and if you subdivide this land into
20 lots, it will be a waste.
Mr Barker: Yes, I agree with the Member that it will be a waste.
But what is his point? The owner of a strata title
owns his particular flat. All these flats are on a
piece of land. If there are 20 flats of equal area, he
owns one-twentieth of that land. Obviously you cannot
divide 10,000 sq.ft. by 20, as there will be not much
left to build. Hence the condominium idea.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Resolved,
"That the Land Titles (Strata) (Amendment) Bill be
committed to a Select Committee consisting of Mr
Speaker as Chairman and seven Members to be nominated
by the Committee of Selection."- [Mr E. W. Barker].
Column: 1200
RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.28 p.m.
The Minister for Law and the Environment (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
Column: 1201
On 10th September, 1973, a Government press statement
made it known that as from the day following the
announcement only citizens of Singapore would be
permitted to purchase residential property without any
restriction. This decision was arrived at after
considerable thought. For many months before that, the
cost of real estate had been sharply on the increase
and had almost doubled over the previous year.
Government was concerned about the rise and decided
that it should confine its efforts at keeping down the
cost of residential property, leaving the market value
of commercial and industrial properties to find their
levels by the interaction of factors governing supply
and demand.
Land is a precious commodity in Singapore. Of
Singapore's total area of about 596 sq, km, or 230 sq.
miles, about 65% is State land or is held by statutory
boards. Only 34% or 20,540 hectares or 78 sq, miles,
is still in private ownership. We, therefore, need not
only to husband land more carefully but also to ensure
that, in so far as residential properties are
concerned, citizens of Singapore are able to purchase
their own houses. While those eligible for Housing and
Development Board flats are catered for, and the well-off can afford the more choice residential property,
it is for the middle income groups who find housing of
reasonable standards beyond their means - our
teachers, administrators, lawyers, engineers,
executives, civil servants, etc., those serving in the
Police and Armed Forces and others - for whom every
endeavour should be made to enable them to enjoy home
ownership.
Since 11th September, 1973, administrative control in
respect of residential properties has been exercised
by the Registrar of Titles and the Residential
Property Advisory Committee under my supervision. This
has
Column: 1202
given us an opportunity of observing the effect of
control and of working out necessary procedures and
rulings so that the sum total of all this experience
has gone into the drafting of the Bill, which, in
consequence, has been revised and amended several
times. Government has felt that it should not rush
headlong into a legislative measure of this nature and
that account should be taken of the effect of the
restriction on the property market. Thus, 16 months
after the restriction was imposed, it was found that
the curbs on non-citizens could be relaxed to some
extent. Consequently, on 9th January, 1975, a second
Government press statement was issued stating that as
from the following day Government would remove
restrictions on the purchase by non-citizens of flats
or apartments in buildings of not less than six
storeys, including the ground floor, and that such
flats or apartments could be bought and sold by non-citizens in the same way as commercial and industrial
properties. Non-citizens wishing to purchase other
types of residential property would have to continue
to seek approval in accordance with already
established procedures. Sub-clause (3) of clause 2 of
the Bill expressly states this particular exemption.
At the time of the second press statement in January
the Residential Property Advisory Committee had
considered and approved 220 applications from non-citizens to purchase residential properties. Sub-clause (4) of clause 30 provides that all approvals
granted from the 11th day of September, 1973, to the
11th day of September, 1975, shall be deemed to have
been made under the Act.
The Bill has been drafted in general conformity with
the guidelines laid down by the first press statement
but departs from it in certain particulars where this
has since been considered necessary. It is the
intention of the Government to refer the Bill to a
Select Committee so that all
Column: 1203
interested bodies and members of the public will have
an opportunity to present their views which will be
carefully assessed.
The Explanatory Statement to the Bill sets out in
some detail the nature of the provisions of the Bill,
and I do not therefore propose to discuss them in
detail. However, I would like to touch on some of the
more salient points.
The Bill expressly prohibits the transfer to, or
purchase or acquisition by, "foreign persons" of
"residential property". These as well as a number of
other expressions are defined in the Bill. It is also
provided that no estate or interest many residential
property belonging to a deceased person who dies on or
after 11th September, 1973, shall pass to a
beneficiary who is a foreign person. In the case of
such residential property which would otherwise have
passed to a foreign person, the legal personal
representatives of the deceased person are required to
sell such property to a citizen of Singapore or an
"approved purchaser" within five years of the death of
such deceased person and pay the proceeds, less
expenses, to the foreign person so beneficially
entitled. It has been found necessary to include such
a provision as its omission would constitute a
loophole or a method of circumventing the proposed
legislation.
Clauses 4 and 5 of the Bill require "foreign
companies" to dispose of all the residential
properties owned by them at the date of the coming
into operation of the Act, i.e. 11th September, 1973
(or within such period as may be allowed by the
Minister) by transferring these residential properties
to citizens of Singapore or approved purchasers, un
less such foreign companies are permitted to retain
them by virtue of clause 16 or are exempted under
clause .22. Where such foreign companies do not
dispose of such properties within that period, the
Minister may direct the Controller of Residential
Property to attach
Column: 1204
and sell such properties at any time after three
months of the date of such notice. As soon as
practicable thereafter, the Controller is required to
sell the same to a citizen of Singapore or an approved
purchaser and pay the proceeds of the sale, less any
costs, to the foreign company concerned.
I would like to dwell for a moment on clauses 4 and 5
which are important aspects of the Bill. They achieve
the object of the policy as stated in the press
statement of 10th September, 1973, though the means
employed are, for good reasons, different. It is
considered that the provisions in the Bill obliging a
foreign company to dispose of Its residential property
provide a more workable, less cumbersome and much less
restrictive legislative framework than an approach
which involves the disposal of shares held by foreign
shareholders as envisaged in the first press
statement. The Bill provides that where a foreign
company holds residential property, it must dispose of
such residential property within a period of time.
However, the Minister, after considering the
recommendations of the Residential Property Advisory
Committee, would have discretionary power to allow the
foreign company to retain its residential property as
provided in clause 16 (4) (a).
In the very early drafts of the Bill, an attempt was
made to implement the modus operandi outlined in the
press statement by adopting the device therein
suggested which involved requiring foreign companies
to dispose of shares held by foreign shareholders and
by making it mandatory for foreign companies to alter
their memorandum or articles of association so as to
prohibit non-citizens from becoming directors and also
to limit shareholdings to Singapore citizens or local
companies. But this approach, apart from leading to
certain unintended results would create a rather
untidy situation whereby the Controller of Residential
Property would be
Column: 1205
obliged to dispose of many millions of shares on the
Stock Exchange. This approach was finally abandoned
for a number of reasons. For one thing, banks which
have many millions of shares held by foreign persons,
and which might wish to retain their residential
property would be faced with having to dispose of
their foreign shareholdings. Further, the procedure
suggested could lead to large numbers of shares being
disposed of on the stock market, which could well
result in the artificial depression of share prices in
leading counters and in the Stock Exchange generally.
That procedure would also cause the unnecessary
disposal of foreign shares by foreign investors who
acquired the shares because of the intrinsic
investment potential of the foreign company. It would
seem to be harsh and unfair to oblige foreign
investors to dispose of their shareholdings merely
because the foreign company in which they invested
happened to hold residential properties in Singapore.
Such properties would constitute only a small
percentage of the total assets of the foreign company.
There were also a number of other reasons for
abandoning the original approach which I do not now
propose to discuss, but what finally persuaded us to
adopt the approach in clauses 4 and 5 of the Bill as
now drafted were the advantages of this method which
are threefold, namely:-
First, the forced sale is in respect of residential
properties only (which is, in fact, the Government
objective); foreign shareholdings in these companies
would not, therefore, be affected once the
residential properties are sold as required by these
clauses; further, under clause 16, the Minister would
have a discretion, where the circumstances so
warrant, to permit foreign companies with foreign
shareholders to acquire, purchase or retain any
specific residential properties;
Column: 1206
Secondly, administratively it would be much easier
for the Controller of Residential Property to deal
with property transfers rather than share transfers
which it would be best for a civil servant not to
handle; and
Thirdly, it is generally likely to cause less
dislocation and upheaval in the foreign companies
concerned and in the stock market.
It should be noted that foreign companies only, but
not foreign natural persons or societies, are required
to dispose of residential properties vested in them as
at 11th September, 1973. Such natural persons and
societies will be required to obtain approval for the
purchase of properties after that date. Foreign
persons who are permanent residents or who are of
economic benefit to Singapore or who have professional
qualifications or experience advantageous to Singapore
may be granted approval to purchase residential
property for their own occupation as dwelling houses.
Similarly, foreign companies which are of economic
benefit to Singapore and intend to purchase or retain
residential property for occupation by their key
personnel, may also be granted such approval.
Turning now to clause 14, we find that it follows the
intent of the first press statement in providing that
residential properties may not be purchased or
acquired by a citizen or an approved purchaser as a
nominee of a foreign person, but departs from the
press statement in not providing in the Bill that the
nominee citizen is to be charged income tax on the
value of the property. Apart from anything else, such
a "taxing" provision could be rendered ineffective or
easily circumvented by the Singapore citizen disposing
of the residential property in question and pocketing
the proceeds and there would be no means whereby the
Government could recover such proceeds. A better
approach, it is thought, is to provide that any
citizen,
Column: 1207
approved purchaser or foreign person who contravenes
this provision should be liable to the general penalty
set out in clause 25.
It will thus be seen that Government's initial
thoughts on the method of implementation have not been
carried through where more appropriate methods have
subsequently emerged. Further amendments may also be
necessary in the light of fresh information laid
before the Select Committee. Representations thereto
on every aspect of the Bill would be welcome as we are
anxious that the legislation which is finally enacted
should be workable and beneficial to the Republic as a
whole. It is possible, for instance, that
representations may be received on the effect on the
property market of the implementation of clauses 4 and
5. Could all the relatively expensive residential
properties appearing on the market within this period
as a result of this provision be beyond the reach of
most Singapore citizens, particularly in this present
recessional state which is so vastly different from
the economic situation obtaining in 1973? Could our
economists and financial and property experts advise
whether there is or is not a danger of foreign
companies being unable to sell choice residential
properties they are legally required to sell to
Singapore citizens within the required period? Should
we therefore exercise caution and keep in abeyance or
suspense clauses 4 and 5 and related, clauses and not
bring them into operation until a later date? The
commencement clause, that is clause 1, would then need
to be amended and some tidying up done at the Select
Committee stage to render that clause accurate.
Perhaps these are unnecessary fears but changed
economic conditions do warrant some caution and a
careful appraisal of these and other provisions in the
Bill.
The position of diplomatic and consular missions and
religious groups in
Column: 1208
Singapore (as stated at clause 20) is that they will
not be required to follow the formal procedure for
obtaining approval as required under clause 16 but
will nonetheless have to "seek the permission in
writing of the Minister" before purchasing residential
property.
Clause 21 sets out the position of housing developers
who, before purchasing an estate or interest in any
residential property, will be required to obtain from
the Controller of Housing a "qualifying certificate".
The Minister's power to exempt, which is contained in
clause 22, would be exercised in circumstances which
warrant exempting any person, body or property who or
which would otherwise come within the ambit of this
legislation.
The savings provision at clause 23 makes it clear
that the Act is not applicable in certain specific
instances. For example, foreign persons are not
prevented from entering into a tenancy agreement for
the occupation of residential property so long as the
agreement does not exceed a term of seven years at any
one time. Further, a permanent resident married to a
citizen is not precluded from purchasing a flat or
house sold under Part IV of the Housing and
Development Act (Chapter 271) if the Board has
consented to such purchase.
The general penalty provided in the Bill for any
contravention or failure to comply with any of the
provisions of the Bill for which no penalty is
expressly provided is, on conviction, a fine not
exceeding $5,000 or imprisonment for a term not
exceeding three years or to both such fine and
imprisonment.
Before I conclude I would, once more, like to
emphasize that the Bill is to be referred to a Select
Committee, that adequate time will be given for the
Bill to be studied, and further that all represen-
Column: 1209
tations made to the Select Committee will be given
very careful consideration.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Resolved,
"That the Residential Property Bill be committed to a
Select Committee consisting of Mr Speaker as Chairman
and seven Members to be nominated by the Committee of
Selection."-[Mr E. W. Barker].
Column: 1209
CRIMINAL JUSTICE (TEMPORARY PROVISIONS) (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
3.50 p.m.
The Minister for Home Affairs (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
Sir, in the combat of crime it is essential to have
not only an effective police force to detect and
arrest criminals but also an adequate system of
punishment and rehabilitation of the criminals when
convicted. Those who are convicted of serious crimes
such as armed robbery, criminal intimidation and
rioting should be sentenced to corrective training for
periods of three to seven years. Such corrective
training is provided for in section 3(1) of the
Criminal Justice (Temporary Provisions) Act, but it
applies only to persons who are not less than 18 years
of age.
A disturbing trend has now emerged in that more and
more young persons between the ages of 16 and 18 years
are committing serious crimes. However, this trend is
not peculiar to Singapore. It is a trend which' is
prevalent the world over.
In 1970, the number of criminals within this age
group who were sent to
Column: 1210
penal institutions totalled 186. This number
increased during the following four years, that is,
1971-74. In 1974, the figure had reached 377. However,
in the first six months of this, year, the number has
already reached 377. Expressed as a percentage of the
total number of criminals sent to penal institutions,
those who were within the age group of 16-18 years in
1970 accounted for 6.5%. In the first six months of
this year the corresponding figure has already reached
9.1%.
The Prisons Reorganisation Committee recommended that
the minimum age for corrective training be lowered
from 18 years to 16 years to enable the District and
High Courts to sentence younger criminals to
corrective training. This recommendation has been
accepted by Government and clause 2 of the Bill is
intended to give effect to this recommendation.
Clause 3 seeks to make certain minor consequential
amendments to the First Schedule to the Act.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Chua Sian Chin].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment, read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1210
SINGAPORE CORPORATION OF REHABILITATIVE ENTERPRISES BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
The Minister for Home Affairs (Mr Chua Sian Chin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
The Prisons Reorganisation Committee which was set up
to examine the reorganisation of the Prisons Department
Column: 1211
had recommended that work should be the primary
medium for the rehabilitation of prisoners. Work helps
to develop discipline. It also equips the prisoner
with skill in a particular trade or vocation so that,
when he is discharged upon serving his sentence, he
could be gainfully employed and be a useful digit in
society. This would help the prisoner to readjust
himself on his return to society. Work in prisons
would also enable every employable inmate to be a
productive unit instead of letting him waste away his
time.
To date, the Prison Industries has been responsible
for organising work programmes for prisoners. It was
started in 1965 as a separate section within the
Prisons Department. It provides facilities for various
trades including woodworking, metalworking, printing,
bookbinding, tailoring, footwear and leather craft,
canework, timber processing and cement work. But it is
only able to cater for a work force Of 1,900 prisoners
out of an average of 4,000 prisoners. Even the work
force of 1,900 prisoners are not optimally utilised.
The Prison Industries as presently constituted is
handicapped by a number of major problems, which
include problems of staff, operational difficulties
and inadequate work facilities. As on 31st July, 1975,
there are 18 vacancies out of an authorised
establishment of 74 posts for instructors. It can
barely cope with its present work programme and much
less carry out a programme of expansion.
To run the prison industries in an efficient manner
there must be sufficient flexibility in the
recruitment and promotion of key marketing and
production staff, purchase of raw materials,
contracting of work and so on. There will also be a
need to expand or install new facilities and these
should be done promptly. Such flexibility .is not
available to the Prison Industries Section of the
Prisons Department because it has to comply with
administrative and finan-
Column: 1212
cial regulations like all other Government
departments. Without the flexibility, private
industries competing with the Prison Industries
Section will have a decided advantage. On a number of
occasions the Prison Industries Section was unable to
meet orders because it was unable to maintain adequate
stocks of raw materials. There has also been a high
turnover and poor recruitment of skilled instructors
owing to the more attractive salaries offered by other
industries in the private sector.
It is therefore necessary to put the organisation of
the productive work in prisons on a new footing. The
Prisons Reorganisation Committee examined the idea of
forming a private company to run the prison industries
but considered it unlikely that such an arrangement
would achieve the desired results. Also there would be
other problems, such as the heavy capital outlay, high
turnover and the special nature of prison labour and
the need for physical security.
The Committee therefore recommended that a statutory
board be formed to run the prison industries. A
statutory board has more flexibility than a Government
department and it is not precluded from Government
help in the form of a subsidy or a grant. It was
therefore decided that a statutory board should be
established to run the prison industries. The
statutory board will be called the Singapore
Corporation of Rehabilitative Enterprises, in brief
SCORE. I shall hereafter refer to it as "the
Corporation".
The Prisons Reorganisation Committee also found that
the existing prisoner-earning scheme is inadequate and
does not provide sufficient incentive for hard work.
At present, even the most highly skilled and
productive worker in prison earns not more than $40
per month. Moreover, these wages do not allow the
prisoners to contribute towards the upkeep of their
dependants outside.
Column: 1213
Together with the establishment of the Corporation,
the Government has decided that the prisoner-earning
scheme will be revised to take into consideration the
prisoners' skill. They will be placed on salary scales
which would be comparable to those in the other
industries. The revised earning scheme, which will be
considered further by the Corporation once it is
established, will range from $2.40 per day for an
unskilled prisoner to $6.80 per day for a skilled
artisan, depending on the product which he is making.
Thereafter, prisoners will have to contribute towards
their upkeep of board and lodging in prison. Prisoners
will, however, be permitted to use a portion of their
wages for canteen purchases. The remaining earnings
would be credited to a compulsory savings account
which would be opened for each prisoner at the Post
Office Savings Bank. The prisoner's dependants would
be permitted to draw upon his savings while the
prisoner is serving his sentence.
I would like now to mention the salient points in the
Bill. The Bill is modelled on the Industrial Training
Board Act. It provides for the setting up of the
Singapore Corporation of Rehabilitative Enterprises.
The functions of the Corporation will be:
(a) to manage and maintain the industrial or
vocational training institutions transferred to the
Corporation and such other institutions as the
Corporation may establish for the employment, or
industrial or vocational training of prisoners;
(b) to provide or secure the provision of such
employment or facilities for such training and to
organise programmes therefore;
(c) to provide technical training in skilled trades
for suitable prisoners;
(d) to promote the vocational skills of prisoners;
Column: 1214
(e) to require any prisoner to work pursuant to
section 50 of the Prisons Act; and
(f) to advise the Government on all matters relating
to the provision of industrial or vocational training
and technical training in trades for prisoners.
The Corporation shall be governed by a Board whose
members will be appointed by the Minister. The Board
comprises:
(a) a Chairman;
(b) a Deputy Chairman who shall be the Permanent
Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs or his
representative;
(c) a representative each from the Ministry of
Finance, the Ministry of Labour and the Industrial
Training Board; and
(d) not less than two but not more than ten other
members.
It is intended that a successful entrepreneur will be
appointed as the Chairman and that there will be
sufficient representation of the private sector on the
Board. It can be seen from clause 16 of the Bill that
the Board will have adequate powers and flexibility to
perform the functions entrusted to it.
Industrial or vocational training institutions, for
the purpose of training prisoners, which were
established by or vested and held by the Government,
will be transferred to the Corporation as provided in
clause 10. Government employees in these industrial or
vocational training institutions, and other Government
employees which the Minister may determine, will also
be transferred to the Corporation. These employees
will be given the option of remaining in the service
of the Government. Their rights to pension, gratuity
or other allowances payable by the. Government will
also be preserved
The Corporation will have a Chief Executive Officer
who will be responsible
Column: 1215
to the Corporation for its proper administration and
management. The Minister may also appoint other
employees on terms and conditions determined by the
Corporation.
Clause 20 stipulates that the Corporation may, with
the approval of the Minister, make regulations for the
establishment of pension and provident fund schemes
for its employees.
Clause 22 confers personal immunity upon members and
officers of the Corporation for any action taken by
them for the purpose of carrying out the provisions
under the Act.
Part VI of the Bi1l contains provisions dealing with
the Corporation's financial year, the financial
procedure to be adopted by the Corporation, the audit,
preparation and publication of annual statements of
accounts and reports. Under clause 27, the Minister
may make grants, approved by Parliament, to the
Corporation to enable it to carry out its functions.
Part VII of the Bill contains miscellaneous
provisions dealing with such matters as the common
seal of the Corporation, the execution of documents,
and the power to make regulations relating to the
appointment, promotion, dismissal and disciplinary
control of employees.
With the passing of this Bill a major step forward
would have been taken towards reforming our penal
system.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
4.06 p.m.
Mr Yeo Choo Kok (Delta): Mr Speaker, Sir, in his speech the Minister has said
that a statutory body is more flexible than a
Government department as far as SCORE, as he calls it,
is concerned. Can the Minister tell the House in what
way a statutory body is more flexible than a
Government department?
Column: 1216
Mr Chua Sian Chin: Mr Speaker, Sir, much time would be taken if I were to
enumerate the `many ways in which the Corporation as a
statutory body has greater flexibility. But perhaps I
may point out a few examples. For instance, in respect
of salary scales for its employees, the Board can work
out its own salary scales which need not be approved
by the Establishment Division of the Ministry of
Finance. It can carry out business dealings or
organise the sale of the products of the Prison
industry without having to follow Government
procedures, and so on and so forth.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Chua Sian Chin].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Mr Speaker: Order. I propose to suspend the Sitting now and will
take the Chair again at 4.45 p.m.
Sitting accordingly suspended at
4.13 p.m. until 4.45 p.m.
Column: 1216
Sitting resumed at 4.45 p.m.
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
REARRANGEMENT OF ORDER OF BUSINESS
Resolved.
"That items 10 and 11 on the Order Paper be taken
after item 15."-[Mr E. W. Barker].
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
The Minister for Law and the Environment (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
The Prisons Reorganisation Committee in its Report
submitted to the
Column: 1217
Government last year observed that sentences of
corrective training on young offenders who show signs
of embarking on a lifetime of crime and sentences of
preventive detention on habitual criminals are rarely
passed by our courts. The Committee recommended
therefore that judicial officers in dealing with
offenders should be compelled to consider passing a
sentence of either corrective training or preventive
detention. The Committee further recommended that the
courts should also be empowered to impose caning in
addition to sentences of corrective training or
preventive detention.
The Committee noted that, under the existing section
12 of the Criminal Procedure Code, a sentence of
corrective training could range from two to four years
but under section 3(1) of the Criminal Justice
(Temporary Provisions) Act, the permissible range of a
sentence of corrective training is three to seven
years. The Committee recommended that the range of a
sentence of corrective training under the Criminal
Procedure Code should also be three to seven years.
The Committee also recommended that the Criminal
Procedure Code be amended so as to -
(a) enhance the jurisdiction of the District Courts
by empowering District Judges to pass sentences of up
to five years for first offenders and up to ten years
for habitual offenders; and
(b) empower the Magistrates' Courts to pass sentences
of up to two years on first offenders.
Clauses 2 and 3 of this Bill seek to amend the
Criminal Procedure Code to give effect to these
recommendations.
Experience has shown that determined criminals are
not sufficiently deterred by merely enhancing the
punishments for various offences. A greater deterrent
would be to increase the chances of their
Column: 1218
conviction when they are apprehended and, with this in
mind, it has been decided through this Amendment Bill
to adopt certain of the recommendations of the
Criminal Law Revision Committee of the United Kingdom
whose report was presented to the U.K. Parliament in
June 1972.
The Bill proposes to restrict greatly the so-called
"right of silence" enjoyed by suspects when
interrogated by the police or by anyone charged with
the duty of investigating offences. By the "right of
silence" in this connection I mean the rule that if
the suspect, when interrogated, omits to mention some
fact which would exculpate him but keeps this back
till the trial, the court may not infer that his
evidence on this issue at the trial is untrue. Under
the proposals contained in clauses 5 and 6 of the
Bill, it will be permissible to draw this inference if
the circumstances justify it. The accused will still
have the "right of silence" in the sense that it is no
offence to refuse to answer questions or tell his
story when interrogated; but if he chooses to remain
silent, he will risk `having an adverse inference
drawn against him at his trial and the failure may, on
the basis of such inference, be treated as capable of
amounting to corroboration of any evidence given
against him. The Criminal Law Revision Committee in
its report remarked.
`In our opinion it is wrong that it should not be
permissible for the jury or magistrates' court to draw
whatever inferences are reasonable from the failure of
the accused, when interrogated, to mention a defence
which `he puts forward at his trial. To forbid it seems to us to be contrary to common
sense and, without helping the innocent, to give an
unnecessary advantage to the guilty. Hardened
criminals often take advantage of the present rule to
refuse to answer any questions at all, and this may
greatly hamper the police and even bring their
investigations to a halt. Therefore the abolition of
the restriction would help justice.'
It is as much in the public interest that a guilty
person should be convicted as it is that an innocent
person should be acquitted.
Column: 1219
If the proposal to allow adverse inferences to be
drawn from the accused's silence is accepted, it
follows that the requirements of the so-called Judges'
Rules contained in Schedule E to the Criminal
Procedure Code to caution a suspect that he is not
obliged to say anything must be abolished or replaced
by different kinds of warnings or intimations. The
Bill therefore proposes that after the accused has
been charged with an offence he should be served with
a notice in writing advising him that adverse
inferences may be drawn from his failure to mention a
fact on which he is going to rely at his trial.
The United Kingdom Government has not taken any steps
to introduce legislation based on the recommendations
of their Criminal Law Revision Committee but their
report has been debated in the House of Lords, and the
Council of the Law Society and the General Council of
the Bar of England and Wales have submitted memoranda
on it. The recommendation to restrict the right of
silence and to abolish the Judges' Rules attracted the
most severe criticism. Some of the comments contained
in the memoranda of the Law Society and the Bar
Council have been found to be not relevant in the
Singapore context. In this context I must point out
that we have no jury in Singapore and we have to
assume that our magistrates and judges can empathise.
it is relevant to note here that whereas a very high
proportion of the criminal cases heard in the
magistrates' courts in England and Wales are tried by
lay justices, all the magistrates in Singapore are
today legally trained.
Another criticism is that there is little to protect
the vast majority of alleged offenders who are to be
required in a situation of stress to formulate
defences to as yet an unspecified charge, or risk
having adverse inferences drawn against them at a
later, and perhaps more critical stage. But clause S
of the Bill requires the accused to be served with a
Column: 1220
notice in writing setting out the charge to which he
has to answer. He does not have to formulate defences
in relation to anything else he may have done. This
provision does not appear in the draft Bill prepared
by the Criminal Law Revision Committee. Another
criticism is to the effect that it is quite wrong that
the accused's silence when interrogated or charged
should be capable of being regarded as corroborative
of other evidence implicating the accused. However,
under the present law the suspect who tells a lie may
be regarded as providing cogent evidence against
himself capable of amounting to corroboration. An
extension of this rule to cover the accused's silence
when confronted with a specified charge should not
therefore cause undue alarm. Whether his silence does
or does not amount to corroboration must depend on all
the circumstances of the particular case and this is
precisely what the Bill states. However, serious
consideration has been given to these criticisms, and
the proposals of the Criminal Law Revision Committee
have been modified to suit the system of criminal
justice operating in Singapore and to provide further
safeguards. For instance, clause 5 of the Bill seeks
to amend section 121 of the Criminal Procedure Code in
such a way that even though an accused person is
advised to disclose his defence, if the making of any
statement by an accused person appears to the court to
be caused by an inducement, threat or promise
proceeding from a person in authority, the court may
in its discretion refuse to admit such statement or
allow it to be used in cross-examination or for the
purpose of impeaching his credit. And clause l6 of the
Bill does not seek to adopt the recommendation of the
Criminal Law Revision Committee that the accused's
failure to give evidence on oath or affirmation at his
trial should be capable of providing corroboration in
law of any evidence given against him.
Another long standing practice which the Bill seeks
to abolish is the accused's
Column: 1221
right to make an unsworn statement from the dock in
his own defence instead of giving evidence on oath or
affirmation. Although the legal status of an unsworn
statement is that of a kind of inferior evidence
because it is not given on oath or affirmation, an
accused who has something to hide and does not wish to
be subject to cross-examination would invariably take
advantage of his right to make an unsworn statement
from the dock. However, if an accused who has a
criminal record wishes to make imputations against the
character of the witnesses for the prosecution, it may
be to his advantage to make an unsworn statement
instead of giving evidence on oath; for in the latter
case, but not the former, he will be liable to have
his criminal record brought out by the prosecution. In
England, the right to make an unsworn statement
derived from the time when the accused was not allowed
legal representation (except in the case of
misdemeanours), but for some years before the Criminal
Evidence Act, 1898, the accused was allowed to make an
unsworn statement about The facts whether or , not he
was legally represented. It might have been expected
that, when the 1898 Act allowed him to give evidence
on oath, it would have abolished the right to make an
unsworn statement as no longer serving any useful
purpose. Instead the Act expressly preserved the right
in keeping with the policy of the Act that pressure
should not be put on the accused to take advantage of
the new right to give evidence on oath. The learned
members of the Criminal Law Revision Committee
observed:
`We think that the time has come to reverse this
policy.... We are strongly of the opinion that the
right to make an unsworn statement about the facts
instead of giving evidence on oath or affirmation
should be abolished. Whatever justification there may
have been for preserving the right in 1898: we think
that nowadays the accused, if he gives evidence,
should do so in the same way as other witnesses and be
subject to cross-examination.'
Column: 1222
We have not only followed the English practice by
giving the accused the right to make an unsworn
statement. We have gone even further than that by
allowing him to tender or read out from the dock a
written statement prepared by his lawyer. It does not
appear to be in the interest of justice that the
accused should have the advantages I have just
mentioned, for what they may be worth. Clauses 10, 14
and 16 of the Bill therefore seek to change the
procedure in trials before the Subordinate Courts and
the High Court, abolishing the right of an accused to
make an unsworn statement about the facts instead of
giving evidence on oath or affirmation. If the accused
refuses to give evidence on oath or affirmation the
court may draw inferences as appear proper from the
refusal, if without good cause. However, the accused
shall not be compelled to give evidence on his own
behalf.
Clause 11 proposes to require the accused to give
notice to the Court or to the Public Prosecutor of
particulars of any alibi, if such is his defence. If
he does not give such notice, he shall not without the
leave of the court adduce evidence in support of the
alibi at his trial. In 1972 the Criminal Procedure
Code was amended so as to require an accused to give
notice of his alibi at a preliminary inquiry, but no
such requirement was imposed in respect of a summary
trial in the Magistrates' and District Courts.
Clause 23 of the Bill seeks to make radical changes
to the rule against hear say evidence. This rule is
summarised in the third edition of Professor Cross's
"Evidence" on page 387 as follows:
`Express or implied assertions of persons other than
the witness who is testifying, and assertions in
documents produced to the court when no witness is
testifying, are inadmissible as evidence of the truth
of that which was `asserted.'.
The rule, however, is subject to a large number of
exceptions, the best known of which are informal
admissions and confessions, dying declarations,
statements
Column: 1223
in public documents and some statements admissible as
being part of the res gestae. But there are many other
exceptions, some by common law and some by statute.
Professor Cross has pointed out that the admission of
certain kinds of evidence "can only be explained on
the footing that there are many more exceptions to the
hearsay rule than is commonly supposed".
The present law has caused a great deal of trouble
owing to the difficulty of deciding whether a
statement is hearsay, and, if so, whether it is
admissible under any of the exceptions to the rule.
The difficulty is further compounded by the
differences between the English law of evidence and
our law which is based on the Indian Evidence Act.
The scheme that the Bill proposes has the following
purposes:-
(1) to admit all hearsay evidence likely to be
valuable to the greatest extent possible without undue
complication or delay to the proceedings;
(2) to ensure that evidence should continue to be
given for the most part orally by allowing hearsay
evidence only if the maker of the statement cannot be
called or it is desirable to supplement his oral
evidence; and
(3) to include necessary safeguards against the
danger of manufactured hearsay evidence.
The proposals in this Bill relating to hearsay
evidence adopt many of the recommendations contained
in the Criminal Law Revision Committee's Eleventh
Report. Certain modifications have been made to these
proposals after considering the views expressed by the
General Council of the Bar of England and Wales and
the Council of the Law Society of England in their
memoranda.
The opportunity has been taken to amend other
sections of the Code to correct existing mistakes and
anomalies as well as to expedite the administration of
Column: 1224
justice as when an accused wishes to plead guilty in
the High Court.
It is proposed to refer the Bill to Select Committee
where all representations will be given careful
consideration.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
5.05 p.m.
Mr N. Govindasamy (Telok Blangah): Mr Speaker, Sir, today no less than four Bills are
being debated, which are intended to make substantial
amendments to our judicial system. We have just had
the Criminal Justice (Temporary Provisions)
(Amendment) Bill passed. Now we are debating the
Criminal Procedure Code (Amendment) Bill, and later we
shall be going through the Evidence (Amendment) Bill
and the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions)
(Amendment) Bill.
With the sudden introduction of amendments to so many
of our Criminal Law Acts, one begins to wonder if all
these pieces of legislation were defective. No
evidence has been advanced so far to substantiate the
need for radical changes which the passing of these
Bills will have on our judicial practice.
Since there are so many hon. Members in this House
with legal training, I would leave to them the
intricacies of the debate in respect of legal matters.
However, I would like to touch on two clauses of the
Bill, namely, clauses 5 and 6 which, even as a layman,
I feel I can comment on.
Clause 5 deletes the legal requirement to give a
caution to a person under arrest before he is
interrogated by the police. Instead, he is to be
served with a notice advising him that adverse
inferences may be drawn from his failure to mention a
fact on which he is going to rely at his trial. This,
to me, means a person arrested, even before he is
charged, has to spill the beans. If he does not
mention a fact that is later brought out in his trial,
then adverse inferences would be
Column: 1225
drawn. During the course of a lengthy trial, all sorts
of minor as well as major facts are brought out in
court. If any one of the facts that is brought out in
court has not been mentioned by the accused during the
arrest and interrogation by the police, then, it is
going to adversely affect the accused. This, I feel,
is a fundamental deviation from the existing law.
Under clause 6, the accused cannot even remain
silent. While being interrogated, the silence of the
accused is to be taken as amounting to corroboration
of any evidence against him. When he is being
interrogated by a police officer who could even be
just a police constable, the accused must be in a
position to make up his mind immediately what line of
defence he is going to take during the trial and must
inform the interrogator the facts he is going to rely
on for his defence. He has to make a decision even
before he has an opportunity to consult legal counsel.
There is no question of legal advice that he may have
to seek in order to put up his defence.
I am sure there are many other points in this Bill
that need further and more important comments which
hon. Members from the legal profession in the House
would no doubt make.
To me, these two clauses are sufficiently important
as fundamental changes from the present procedures. To
me, it means that if the police cannot secure evidence
through detective work, they can get evidence by just
arresting an accused and interrogating him. What he
says or what he does not say is to be used as evidence
against him. Are we trying to promulgate laws to cover
up for police deficiency? Are our laws to be
promulgated to rectify the ineffectiveness of police
investigations? Is Parliament asked to do police work?
I am glad that this Bill is being committed to a
Select Committee.
Column: 1226
Mr L. P. Rodrigo (Serangoon Gardens): Mr Speaker, Sir, notwithstanding the report of the
Criminal Law Revision Committee, I take the view that
this Bill will have the effect of changing or removing
altogether time-tested legal concepts and practices in
criminal law. What is more, it will construct new
instruments of prosecution for the prosecuting power
of the State.
The provisions in the Bill are not selective
provisions, selective in the sense that they relate to
certain offences. They are blanket provisions. The
meaning and implications of the changes described in
the Bill are extensive and are not obvious. How they
relate to criminal practice and the conduct of the
court in its function of administering justice is
highly important. The possibilities of clause 6 of the
Bill, for example, where the accused's silence can
corroborate the evidence against his own silent person
are not easily discernible. The Member for Telok
Blangah has also made reference to this clause with
some expertise.
Clause 16 abolishes the right of an accused to make
an unsworn statement and he runs the risk of having an
adverse inference made against him if he refuses to
give evidence, on oath without good cause. Whatever is
contemplated by "good cause" is left extremely
indefinite good cause for the court, good cause for
the prosecutor or good cause for the accused person
himself.
The changes in the Bill are indeed far-reaching and I
am therefore glad that this Bill and the Evidence
(Amendment) Bill are being committed to a Select
Committee where they will be examined in greater
detail. But at this stage. Sir, I wish to express the
hope that all these changes which will facilitate
prosecution of the criminal by apparently constricting
the defence of the accused will not have the result of
blunting the effectiveness of criminal investigation
which ends with the apprehension of the criminal in
the very first place.
Column: 1227
Mr Barker: Sir, may I thank both Members for their criticisms and
interest in this Bill which, as the Member for
Serangoon Gardens says, makes radical and far-reaching
changes. It is for this reason that the Bill is being
sent to a Select Committee where, as I said, we would
welcome representations which will be given very
careful consideration.
At this stage I do not think I should take on both
Members except that perhaps I should welcome them to
the Select Committee.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Resolved,
"That the Criminal Procedure Code (Amendment) Bill be
committed to a Select Committee consisting of Mr
Speaker as Chairman and seven Members to be nominated
by the Committee of Selection."-[Mr E. W. Barker].
Column: 1227
ECONOMIC EXPANSION INCENTIVES (RELIEF FROM INCOME TAX) (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.15 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
Since the early days of Singapore's drive towards
industrialisation, one of the more effective
instruments of investment promotion has been exemption
from income tax granted under the Economic Expansion
Incentives (Relief from Income Tax) Act. Under the
Act, companies implementing new and desirable projects
could be granted pioneer status which exempts them
from income tax for a period of five years. By the end
of April, 1975, there were a total of 411 pioneer
enterprises, investing some $3,100 million and
manufacturing a wide range of products in Singapore.
Column: 1228
However, as we strive towards higher levels of skills
and technology in our industrialisation effort, we
have found that the existing tax relief period of five
years is too short to provide an effective tax
incentive for the more sophisticated types of
industries which we are now trying to attract to
Singapore. These new industries such as machine tools,
diesel engines, precision instruments, aircraft
components, specialised electrical equipment and
industrial machinery involve much heavier capital
investments in plant and machinery and require more
sophisticated manufacturing skills which are only
acquired after long periods of training. Such
industries have long gestation periods and take much
longer time to become profitable, some breaking even
only in the fourth or fifth year of production. A five-year tax relief period would therefore not benefit
them to any extent and a longer period of pioneer
status is now necessary to encourage such new
industries to establish in Singapore.
Thus, section 6 of the Act is being amended to extend
the tax relief period of a pioneer enterprise from the
present fixed period of five years to a maximum of ten
years. The longer period of tax relief will enable
desirable industries with long gestation periods to
effectively enjoy pioneer tax incentives and thus
provide a more effective promotional tool for the
further upgrading of manufacturing skills and
technology in Singapore. The maximum ten years' tax
relief will only be granted to the most deserving
cases involving large capital investments and
sophisticated technology and manufacturing skills. The
longer period of pioneer status will only apply to
pioneer certificates awarded after the date these
amendments come into force.
Furthermore, to encourage the establishment of small
but highly specialised supporting industries, section
5 of the Act is also being amended to dispense with
the requirement that a company
Column: 1229
must incur a fixed capital expenditure of not less
than $1 million before it is eligible for pioneer
status. With the establishment of a widening range of
large scale manufacturing plants in Singapore, there
is an increasing need for specialised supporting
industries to supply parts and components to the
larger manufacturing plants. Such supporting
industries often involve sophisticated technology and
skills but owing to their smaller size their fixed
capital investment may not reach $1 million. Removal
of this minimum investment requirement will enable
pioneer tax incentive to be used to promote the
establishment of such desirable supporting industries
which are now playing an increasingly important role
in the further integration and development of our
industries.
Consequential amendments are also being made to
sections 10 and 25 of the Act.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I fully support this Bill which seeks
to provide greater and better tax relief incentives to
certain types of industries which help to promote our
industrialisation programme.
In view of the world economic recession and the fact
that its effects are still being felt, and that the
Government is trying its best to revive our economic
activity, the Economic Development Board has more
important tasks to perform. Foreign investments in
Singapore have decreased this year, amounting to only
one-third of that of last year. This shows that our
economic position has been affected. The Economic
Development Board, therefore, has the immediate .and
urgent task of attracting more foreign investment into
Singapore so as to promote our economy and
industrialisation programme, thus creating
Column: 1230
more jobs for our people. In this respect, I would
like to raise certain Un-favourable comments on the
Economic Development Board for the information of the
Minister.
I have received certain complaints from foreign
investors who wish to invest in Singapore. One
complaint is that an applicant normally has to wait
for half a year to one year before he receives any
reply. This delay in replying will discourage foreign'
investors from investing in our local industries.
Another complaint is that the staff in the relevant
department have not been giving good advice or
direction to foreign investors. Perhaps it is due to
the lack of commercial knowledge on the part of the
public servants concerned. If that is the case, we
should train them properly so that they can better
handle inquiries from foreign investors. This is a
very important aspect of our effort at economic
development.
Sir, I support this Bill.
Mr Yeo Choo Kok: Mr Speaker, Sir, in order to safeguard our industrial
sector the Bill before the House is a timely one.
However, in order to attract fresh investment, the
Government should continue to give every assistance
arid encouragement to existing manufacturers, whether
or not the nature of their particular operations has
stepped out of line with our long range objectives on
account of shift in emphasis. For example, the current
emphasis is on higher technological and less labour-intensive type of operations. However, we should not,
because of this, leave those less sophisticated and
labour-intensive type of operations uncared for, or
even let them feel that they are unwanted. While costs
and other market factors will most probably force some
such operations to close down ultimately, we should in
the meantime continue to give them every assistance
and support wherever possible so that their exit will
be made less painful.
Column: 1231
In saying so, I am not being sentimental. I am only
concerned with the impression that has been created - that our attitude appears to be one of wooing the new,
deserting the old, in our endeavours to attract more
investments in our industrial sector.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Mr Speaker, Sir, I am grateful for the advice which
both Members of the House have given in regard to
investments in Singapore. We realise the necessity for
more investments not only from people outside
Singapore but also from people who are already
manufacturing here.
I am, of course, a bit taken aback by the suggestion
of the Member for Sembawang that the Economic
Development Board is falling down on its job because
the applications have been left undecided for half a
year to one year. I would have thought that the
general period of time taken for a decision is more
like half a month to one month. If the Member for
Sembawang has any information of such applications, I
for one would certainly be very glad to hear of these
cases because with the emphasis that we are now
placing upon industrial investment and with more
intensified promotion efforts by our offices I would
be very surprised that there are any applications
which have been left undecided for one year or so.
As for the other criticism that some of the staff
have not been giving good advice, again I would be
very interested in knowing the kind of advice which is
considered unsatisfactory, and I can assure, the
Member for Sembawang that if his criticism is
justified it will certainly be corrected by not only
the Economic Development Board itself but also by, I
think, an admonition from the Ministry of Finance. I
do not, however, anticipate that there can be very
many of these cases. The EDB is generally regarded
even by foreign investors as being very efficient, and
I am surprised to hear
Column: 1232
about this. It may be that this criticism emanates
from existing manufacturers.
The Member for Delta suggested that we are neglecting
the existing manufacturers. I can assure him that
there is no intention of doing so and if they have any
interest in investing more money or if they need
advice in any way, whether financial or technical, the
EDB and the Ministry of Finance (Development Division)
will be most happy to provide any assistance they can.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, let me give an example for the
information and reference of the Minister.
Mr Speaker: Mr Teong, I think it is best you give your example
to the Minister in writing.
Mr Teong Eng Siong(In Mandarin): Sir, I think it is better to say a few words here. It
is about the guidance given by the staff of the
Economic Development Board on the proposal to set up a
textile industry here. If such an enquiry is made to
the staff of the EDB, they would say that there are
too many textile factories here. The investor would
then say, "Please give me the kind of guidance as to
what type of industry would be welcome here." The
reply would be: "You can make your own assessment as
to whether or not there is an international market,
and then we will approve your plan." As a matter of
fact the staff of the EDB should give guidance as to
what types of industry would be more favourably
received here, together with certain useful hints. If
the applicant has taken several months to draw up a
proposed plan and it is not accepted in the end, he
will be wasting his time in addition to incurring
great inconvenience.
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Mr Speaker, Sir, the very short answer is that we are
prepared to give the advice, but perhaps what has been
misunderstood is that we cannot make the decision for
the investors. They have to decide whether any
particular industry
Column: 1233
which they want to set up is likely to succeed.
Where it is obvious that there is really not enough
market, say, for textile goods, at this particular
period of time, the EDB is right in advising them that
perhaps textile manufacturing is not an industry to go
into now.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Hon Sui Sen].
Bill considered in Committee; reported without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1233
RUBBER ESTATES ASSESSMENT (REPEAL) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.32 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
This Bill proposes to repeal the Rubber Estates
Assessment Act (Chapter 145) and the Rubber Estates
(Surcharge on Assessment) Act (Chapter 146) and to tax
all rubber estates under the Property Tax Act (Chapter
144) and the Property Tax (Surcharge) Act, 1974, with
effect from 1st January, 1976.
The assessment of rubber estates is a relic of the
past. In the present circumstances, it would not be
appropriate to perpetuate the practice of charging
rubber estate assessment according to yield,
particularly when this is less than what is payable as
property tax. Moreover, all other land in Singapore is
subject to property tax.
The proposed measure would achieve equitable tax
treatment on all land. There would be no adverse
effect on the economy as the production of natural
rubber in Singapore is on the decline and is rather
insignificant.
Column: 1234
Clause 4 enables the Chief Assessor to amend, as soon
as possible, the Valuation List to include rubber
estates.
Clause 5 provides that any outstanding liability or
any legal proceedings in respect of such liability
shall not be affected by the repeal of these
enactments.
Clause 6 is a transitional provision. Owners of
rubber estates are allowed to continue paying taxes
levied under the repealed enactments. Such payment of
assessment shall be deemed as property tax. When the
Valuation List is authenticated, the Comptroller of
Property Tax shall make the necessary adjustment of
property tax payable on the rubber estates with effect
from 1st January, 1976. This may result in owners
having to pay more taxes or to claim refund of excess
taxes paid, as the case may be.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Hon Sui Sen].
Bill considered in Committee; reported, without
amendment; read a Third time and passed.
Column: 1234
TRAVEL AGENTS BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.37 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time."
Last year, no less than 1,230,000 visitors came to
Singapore compared with 580,000 visitors in 1970.
Earnings from tourism increased from $280 million in
1970 to $758 million in 1974, contributing
respectively 4.8% and 5.9% of Gross Domestic Product
in these two years.
Currently, the Tourist Promotion Board is empowered
by the Tourist
Column: 1235
Promotion Board Act (Cap. 205) to license only
travel agents engaged in inbound travel. But
instances of malpractices by agents handling out-bound travel have been reported. It is, therefore,
proposed to license these travel agents as well.
The Travel Agents Bill, 1975, will empower the
Singapore Tourist Promotion Board to regulate the
activities of all travel agents in Singapore,
whether handling in-bound or out-bound tours. All
tourist enterprises will have to be licensed. In
considering the grant of a licence, the Board will
take into account the character and reputation of
the applicant. Any applicant previously convicted
of any offence involving fraud or moral turpitude
will be denied a licence. The Board will also
impose any condition as is reasonable, and to vary
or to revoke any licence so granted. However, any
person who is aggrieved by a decision of the Board
may, within a month, appeal to the Minister whose
decision will be final.
A Compensation Fund will be created to mitigate
the difficulties of travellers cheated, or left
stranded, by their travel agents. It will be made
up of levies to be imposed on tourist enterprises
as a condition of licensing. The Board has
proposed that the levy be made up of two tiers,
comprising a first-tier primary cash levy of
$5,000 and a second-tier of acceptable instruments
or guarantees for a value of $20,000. In the event
of default, the second-tier guarantee will be
invoked first so as not to drain the cash reserves
proper of the Fund.
The Board is satisfied that the Compensation Fund
Scheme will be welcomed by the tourist industry as
one effective way of relieving problems caused by
malpractices of unscrupulous travel agents. Major
travel agencies, which assisted in the formulation
of the Scheme, do not consider the proposed $5,000
cash payment and $20,000 securities as unduly
onerous.
Column: 1236
A Compensation Fund Committee, with powers to
make payments, will be appointed by the Minister.
The assets of the Fund, though the property of the
Board, will be kept separate from all other
property, and will be held in trust. The Board
may, after consultation with the Committee, invest
funds not immediately required.
Any licensee who fraudulently converts to his own
use, fares or other monies paid by travellers
shall be liable, on conviction, `to imprisonment
for a term not exceeding three years.
This Bill, therefore, provides some safeguards
against malpractices by travel agents. However,
those who travel would be well advised to always
exercise their judgment in purchasing services
from travel agents, even if they are licensed.
Disbursements from the Compensation Fund will not
compensate in full measure for losses of money
and, more important, time.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Mr Speaker, Sir, I understand the purpose of this
Bill.
While appreciating the rationale behind the
introduction of the Bill, I am a little perturbed
as to the consequences that this Bill will have on
Singaporeans who wish to travel as well as those
who are in the travel agency business.
I have no doubt, as a result of the Bill, that
the cost of travel is going to increase. Although
the intention of the Bill is to see that there are
no fly-by-night travel agencies and that the
travelling public is protected, the cost of travel
is bound to go up. This protection that we hope to
offer will no doubt ensure that travel agencies
are properly organised and managed. The control we
try to ad-minister will stifle the free enterprise
economy that we have in Singapore. The additional
expense that is to be borne by the travel agencies
will certainly be passed on to the customers.
Column: 1237
As I understand the Bill, there will be two financial
commitments on the part of the travel agencies. One is
the licensing fee and the other is the payment to the
Compensation Fund. How much the licensing fee is going
to be and how much the travel agencies have to pay
towards the Compensation Fund will be left to the
Board to decide, although the Minister mentioned just
now about the primary cash levy of $5,000 and the
other payment to be in the form of a bank guarantee,
if I understood him correctly. The payment to the
Compensation Fund could consist of, according to
clause 32(f) an initial contribution as well as annual
contributions. If these contributions are to be a
deterrent to the setting up of mosquito travel
agencies, then they should be substantial. If the
payments are not substantial, then they would not be a
deterrent to anybody to set up a travel agency. This
would, as I have said earlier, increase the cost of
running a travel agency and the additional cost will
be passed on to the travellers.
If the purpose of the Compensation Fund is to
safeguard the welfare of Singaporeans travelling
abroad, if they are stranded and lose financially as a
result of the shady business of the travel agency, and
not to increase the funds of the Tourist Promotion
Board, then I would suggest that the licensed travel
agencies be required to provide a bank guarantee of a
sum to be decided by the Tourist Promotion Board and
not pay such sums into the Compensation Fund. The bank
guarantee should be a sufficient deterrent and it
would not be an excuse for travel agencies to increase
their fares.
I contend, Sir, that it is a good thing to encourage
Singapore citizens to travel abroad, especially to
other countries in Asia. When the greatest critic of
Singapore comes back after a trip
Column: 1238
abroad, he appreciates Singapore more than ever
before. Let me quote the example of a politician who
was the greatest critic of the Singapore Government
and its way of life. When he came back after having
been away for a short while from Singapore in 1972, he
said that "there is no place like Singapore".
Therefore, these restrictions imposed on travel
agencies will result in an increased cost of running a
travel agency which no doubt will be passed on to the
travelling public and will reduce the number of
Singaporeans going abroad.
I contend that the same safeguards for Singapore
travellers can be obtained by other forms of
registration of travel agencies, prosecuting them when
they fall foul of the law or when they cheat their
clients by not fulfilling their contractual
obligations. Sir, there are reputable, well-run travel
agencies as well as not-so reputable ones. But the
enforcement of this Act will penalise the good travel
agencies as well as the bad agencies.
Let me now turn to clauses 20, 21, 22 and 23 which
deal with the power to search premises, power to
arrest, power to investigate, and powers of the Board.
Under the provisions of these clauses, any police
constable has a right to search all persons found in a
travel agency, seize all documents, detain persons,
arrest any person without a warrant, take possession
of all articles, etc, if the police constable suspects
that the travel agency has committed an offence under
this Act. This, I am afraid, with due respect to our
Police Force, gives a police constable unlimited
authority.
Does this Bill also cover those airlines that are not
registered as travel agencies but offer package tours,
which include travel, transportation, sightseeing,
hotel accommodation, etc.?
I am glad that this Bill is being cornmitted to a
Select Committee, and I am sure that the travel
agencies will, make the necessary representations.
Column: 1239
Mr Hon Sui Sen: Sir, I do not propose to make a lengthy reply since
the Bill is going to Select Committee, but some of the
comments by the Member for Telok Blangah can be
considered now.
We are all agreed that there is a necessity for some
kind of regulation. We are also agreed that this
should be maintained at the lowest possible cost to
the traveller. At the same time, we are all agreed
that there should be a maximum fund to compensate a
traveller in case of any malpractice by travel agents.
Some of these objectives are in conflict with each
other because obviously we cannot have the lowest
possible cost to the traveller if we insist upon a
very high compensation fund.
I need only comment on one suggestion that there
should be a bank guarantee instead of cash. That is
already taken care of in my speech, i.e, the second-tier of acceptable instruments or guarantees for a
value of $20,000 could possibly take into account the
bank guarantee instead of cash. The two tiers consist
of a first-tier of a cash levy of $5,000 and a second-tier of acceptable instruments or guarantees which
would be to the value of $20,000. Of course, these
sums can be varied and I have no doubt that in Select
Committee full consideration can be given to any
representation.
On the other comment which the Member has made about
the powers of the police constable to arrest and to
seize documents and so on, I have no doubt again that
these can be considered in Select Committee.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Resolved,
"That the Travel Agents Bill be committed to a
Select Committee consisting of Mr Speaker as Chairman
and seven Members to be nominated by the Committee of
Selection."-[Mr Hon Sui Sen].
Column: 1240
TOURIST PROMOTION BOARD (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.51 p.m.
The Minister for Finance (Mr Hon Sui Sen): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
Though the existing Tourist Promotion Board Act (Cap.
205) empowers the Tourist Promotion Board, with my
approval, to regulate standards which tourist
enterprises are expected to maintain, these powers do
not extend to tourist enterprises providing services
to out-bound travellers. It is proposed, therefore, to
amend section 2 of the Act, so that the conduct of
tourist enterprises engaged in providing services to
both inbound and out-bound travellers can be
regulated. This is a consequential amendment of the
Travel Agents Bill which I have earlier moved its
Second Reading.
In line with international practice of identifying a
national tourist organisation through the name of its
country, the name of the Board will be changed from
"Tourist Promotion Board" to "Singapore Tourist
Promotion Board". This not only facilitates
international communication but also gives official
authority for the already widely recognised
abbreviation "STPB".
Section 16 of the Act is also to be amended so that
the Board, like other statutory bodies, will observe
more closely the financial procedures laid down by the
Auditor-General.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time and committed to
a Committee of the whole House.
The House immediately resolved itself into a
Committee on the Bill.-[Mr Hon Sui Sen].
Column: 1241
[Mr Speaker in the Chair]
Clauses 1 to 3 inclusive ordered to stand part of
the Bill.
The Chairman: I would like to draw the attention of hon.
Members to errors in the numbering of clauses of
the Bill. Clauses 3 to 8 inclusive, appearing in
page 2 of the Bill, should be renumbered as
clauses 4 to 9 respectively.
Clauses 4 to 9 inclusive, as renumbered, ordered
to stand part of the Bill.
Bill reported without amendment; read a Third
time and passed.
Column: 1241
EVIDENCE (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
5.56 p.m.
The Minister for Law and the Environment (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be
now read a Second time."
The Evidence Act needs to be amended to bring it
into line with the changes proposed for the
Criminal Procedure Code. The Bill also seeks to
clarify certain sections of the Act relating to
the accused's character and his right to claim the
privilege against self-incrimination and against
incriminating his spouse.
Clause 3 of the Bill provides for the
admissibility of statements produced by computers.
It seems desirable to include this provision in
the Bill because the increasing use of computers
by the Post Office, statutory bodies, banks and
business firms to store certain kinds of
information will make it more difficult to prove
certain matters, such as cheque frauds, unless it
is made possible for this to be done from
computers. Admissibility is subject to strict
conditions, necessary to ensure that the
information is reliable, as to the regular supply
of information to the computer and to its proper
working. Subsection (4) of section 34A in clause 3
of the Bill allows
Column: 1242
evidence by certificate in order to identify a
document produced by the computer and to give
particulars of its working, but subsection (5) of
section 34A enables the court for special reason
to require oral evidence to be given of these
matters.
Section 34B in clause 3 contains various
supplementary provisions relating to proof of
documents, to the drawing of inferences, for the
purpose of deciding admissibility, from the
circumstances in which a statement was made and
from the form and contents of a document, and to
the weight to be attached to a statement
admissible under section 34A. Subsection (3) of
section 34B provides that in estimating the
weight, if any, to be attached to a statement
produced by a computer, regard shall be had to all
the circumstances and, in particular, to its
contemporaneity or otherwise and to the question
whether any person who was in a position to do so
had any reason to conceal or misrepresent the
facts.
In 1960, section 54 of our Evidence Ordinance was
amended to take away the accused's immunity from
cross-examination about his other misconduct if
the accused has personally or by his advocate and
solicitor asked questions of the witnesses for the
prosecution with a view to establishing his own
good character, or has given evidence of his good
character, or the nature and conduct of the
defence is such as to involve imputations on the
character of the prosecution witness, or the
accused has given evidence against any other
person charged with the same offence. Modern
criminals, however, have developed a practice of
giving the impression that they are respectable
persons while avoiding taking any course which
clearly enables the court to hold that the accused
has personally or by his advocate and solicitor
asked questions of witnesses for the prosecution
with a view to establishing his own good
character, or has given evidence of his good
Column: 1243
character within the meaning of subsection (2) of
section 54 of the Evidence Act. Moreover, section 54
of the Act does not make it clear that the prosecution
can adduce evidence to prove that the accused is not
of good character and at what stage of the proceedings
it may do so. Clause 4 of the Bill, therefore,
proposes to clarify the situation and to deal with
cases in which it is hinted indirectly, that the
accused is a respectable person. The clause makes it
clear that a co-accused, as well as the prosecution,
may cross-examine the accused to rebut his claim to be
of good disposition or reputation and may adduce
evidence for this purpose. However, clause 6 proposes
to restrict the right of the prosecution or of a co-accused to cross-examine the, accused about misconduct
other than that involved in the offence charged on the
ground that he has made imputations against the
witnesses against him. The court shall not permit a
question tending to reveal that the accused has
committed or has been charged with or convicted or
acquitted of any offence or that he is a person of bad
disposition or reputation unless it is the opinion of
the court that the question is relevant to the
accused's credibility as a witness. However, this
restriction does not apply to a question tending to
prove that the accused has committed the offence
charged or to a question which will enable a co-accused to reveal a fact which would prove that he is
not guilty of any offence with which he is jointly
charged with the accused.
Clause 7 restricts in two ways the right of the
accused, if he gives evidence, to claim the privilege
against self-incrimination or against incriminating
his spouse. The proposal is that the accused should
have no privilege against self-incrimination in the
case of a question about the offence charged or about
any other offence which is admissible as standing
directly or indirectly to show that he committed the
offence charged but should have the privilege in
respect
Column: 1244
of other offences which are relevant to his
credibility as a witness. But no privilege should be
allowed if the accused has claimed to be of good
disposition or reputation. On the same principle, the
accused should be allowed no privilege against
incriminating his wife except in relation to an
offence going to his credibility as a witness.
Clauses 5, 8 and 10 of the Bill seek to abrogate the
common law rule, making it obligatory for a judge to
give a warning of the danger of convicting on the
uncorroborated evidence of an accomplice. Since
corroboration is not required as a matter of law, it
follows that the conviction will not be quashed merely
because of absence of corroboration; but if the judge
does not warn himself the conviction will be quashed,
even if there is corroboration, unless the appeal can
be dismissed on the ground that "no miscarriage of
justice has actually occurred". Since evidence in
corroboration must be "independent testimony which
affects the accused by connecting or tending to
connect him with the crime", it follows that a witness
cannot corroborate himself. A witness whose evidence
requires corroboration, or in whose case corroboration
has to be looked for under the common law rules,
cannot be corroborated by a similar witness. Thus an
unsworn child cannot corroborate another and one
accomplice cannot corroborate another.
Members may well ask, who is an accomplice? There is
no legal definition of the word. But on any view,
persons are accomplices who are participes criminis in
respect of the actual crime charged, whether as
principals or accessories before or after the fact or
persons committing, procuring or aiding and abetting.
This is the natural and primary meaning of the term
"accomplice." But persons falling strictly outside the
ambit of this category have been held to be
accomplices; e.g, receivers have been held to be
accomplices of the thieves from whom they received the
goods although
Column: 1245
the receiver was not necessarily a party to the
substantive crime of theft.
The common law rules have the great disadvantage' of
being sometimes difficult to apply owing to technical
distinctions, for example as to what kinds of evidence
may he corroboration and as to whether a person is an
accomplice. These difficulties have caused many
mistaken rulings at trials and consequent quashings of
convictions. One disadvantage in particular is that a
conviction may have to be quashed if the judge holds
that a piece of evidence is capable of being
corroboration but the appellate court holds that it is
not capable of being so. Convictions have been quashed
even in cases where there was ample evidence to
convict the accused because the appellate court
considered that the judge might have found that the
evidence was corroborated when in fact it was not, and
so have thought that the danger referred to did not
exist.
The reasons for exercising caution in accepting the
evidence of accomplices are obvious:-
Firstly, the accomplice being a criminal, his evidence is
impugned;
Secondly, an accomplice has a strong motive to remove
suspicion from himself by fixing it on another;
Thirdly, if he has a spite against the accused, then,
knowing all the circumstances of the crime, he will
have little difficulty in making convincing false
charges against him, although the accused is innocent.
But as long ago as 1836 when it was only a rule of
practice that a special direction should be given as
to the evidence of accomplices, Henry Joy, Lord Chief
Baron of the Court of Exchequer in Ireland, published
a book, On the Evidence of Accomplices, in the course
of which he wrote:
Column: 1246
`How the practice which at present prevails, could
ever have grown into a general regulation, must be
matter of surprise to every person who considers its
nature. Why the case of an accomplice should require a
particular rule for itself: why it should not, like
that of every other witness of whose credit there is
an impeachment, he left to the unfettered discretion
of the judge, to deal with it as the circumstances of
each particular case nay require, it seems difficult
to explain. Why a fixed unvarying rule should be
applied to a subject which admits of such endless
variety as the credit of witnesses, seems hardly
reconcilable to the principles of reason. (But, that a
judge should come prepared to reject altogether the
testimony of a competent witness as unworthy of
credit, before he had even seen that witness; before
he had observed his look, his manner, his demeanour;
before he had an opportunity of considering the
consistency and probability of his story; before he
had known the nature of the crime of which he was to
accuse himself, or the temptation which led to it, or
the contrition with which it was followed;) that a
judge, I say, should come prepared beforehand to
advise the jury to reject without consideration such
evidence, even though judge and jury should be
perfectly convinced of its truth, seems to he a
violation of the principles of common sense, the
dictates of morality, and the sanctity of a juror's
oath.'
The view that the present requirement is wrong is
also in accordance with the views of the learned
members of the Criminal Law Revision Committee of the
United Kingdom whose Eleventh Report on Evidence
(General) was presented to the United Kingdom
Parliament in June 1972. It is felt `that it should be
a matter for the judge's discretion whether or not to
convict on the uncorroborated evidence of an
accomplice and as long as the judge recognises who are
the accused's accomplices in the case before him and
treats their evidence with caution there should be no
danger of a miscarriage of justice. There appears also
to be no real need for retaining the rule that certain
witnesses are incapable of corroborating other
witnesses.
Clause 9 proposes that a previous statement made by a
witness should be admissible not only to support or
impugn his credibility as a witness but as evidence of
the fact stated in it. The present law has caused
difficulty when evidence is given that a witness made
a previous statement inconsistent with his
Column: 1247
evidence given in court. Evidence that the witness did
so is admissible but it is admissible not in order to
prove the truth of what was said in the previous
statement but only in order to neutralise, the effect
of the evidence given in court by the maker of the
statement. Many regard this as too subtle a
distinction. Similarly, where a document used by a
witness to refresh his memory is proved, it is
proposed that the statement in that document shall be
admissible as evidence of the facts stated in it. The
law at present requires the witness who has refreshed
his memory to produce and show to the adverse party
the document used by him to refresh his memory and he
may be cross-examined on the contents of such document
but the document shall not be admissible as evidence
of the facts stated therein. The above proposals,
however, are subject to certain safeguards for it is
provided in subsection (5) of section 145 in clause 9
that in estimating the weight, if any, to be attached
to a statement admissible under this clause, regard
shall be had to all the circumstances and, in
particular, to its contemporaneity or otherwise and to
the question whether any person who was in a position
to do so had any reason to conceal or misrepresent the
facts. Subsection (6) proposes that a statement
admissible by virtue of this clause shall not be
capable of corroborating the evidence given by the
maker of the statement.
Sir, like the Criminal Procedure Code (Amendment)
Bill, it is the intention to refer this Bill to Select
Committee where representations will be welcome and
will be given careful consideration.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
6.18 p.m.
Mr P. Selvadurai (Kuo Chuan): Mr Speaker, Sir, these four Bills that we have before
us in this House today relate to the administration of
criminal justice
Column: 1248
in our courts. Whilst the provisions of the Criminal Justice (Temporary Provisions) (Amendment) Bill do not affect the substance and character of criminal trials, the provisions of the
Criminal Procedure Code (Amendment) Bill, the Evidence
(Amendment) Bill and the Criminal Law (Temporary
Provisions) (Amendment) Bill do. They make substantial
alterations, among other changes, to the law as it
stands now relating to caution statements made to the
police by an accused person before he is interrogated
by the police, corroboration of the testimony of an
accomplice, confession, and they also introduce
further refinements to the rule against hearsay.
One's first instinctive reaction to the proposed
changes is one of suspicion born of the fact that this
is an instance of an already powerful executive branch
of the State seeking to increase its powers in its
dealings with the citizens. But a closer reading of
the provisions of these Bills would show that apart
from removing some of the fetters, presumptions and
inferences that hamper the prosecution in proving its
case against an accused person, they also in the
process augmented the judicial power and
responsibility in ascertaining the truth or otherwise
of evidence sought to be proved in court. This
tendency to grant greater judicial flexibility to the
judge is to be welcomed.
The law relating to caution statements made by the
accused to the police and to the need for
corroboration of the evidence of an accomplice has so
got into such a morass of technicalities that a
caution required to be administered by a police
officer to an accused person before he was
interrogated had become a piece of catechism and it
failed wholly to achieve the purpose that it was meant
to achieve. The voluntariness of the accused's
statement was not enhanced and the prevention of
police brutality during interrogation of witnesses was
not thereby automatically guaranteed.
Column: 1249
We all know, Mr Speaker, Sir, that no crime would be
solved and no criminal brought to book on the basis of
purely voluntary statements made by accused persons or
witnesses to the police over cups of tea. It is a hard
fact of life that due to the power of terror and
reprisal wielded by the secret societies in Singapore
no witness to a violent crime would voluntarily come
forward to give evidence against a miscreant. It is
small wonder that in approximately 70% of the murder
trials, convictions were obtained on the basis of
caution statements that were promptly disavowed in
court amidst allegations of police brutality. This
must mean that despite such allegations our judges
were satisfied that the offences against the accused
had been proved probably true beyond reasonable doubt.
In human affairs even when the subject of inquiry was
susceptible of legal proof, certainty is usually
unattainable. The substitute is probability and the
tribunal of fact had to decide which case was probably
true and in a criminal trial probably true beyond
reasonable doubt. I must also point out that the laws
relating to hearsay, corroboration and the reception
of caution statements were originally fashioned and
laid down by the great judges of the common law in the
context of jury trials when juries had at all times to
be guided by judges on how to decide fairly without
caprice or prejudice. Now that we do not have juries a
greater latitude should be left for the free exercise
of judicial reasoning and discretion and, insofar as
this Bill achieves this; this House should welcome it,
particularly so where over the years we have enacted
laws that have in some measure taken away the business
of judging questions dealing with rights of our
citizens from the judiciary and placed them in the
hands of the executive. This is a derogation from the
judicial power under our Constitu-
Column: 1250
tion and may well be ultra vires and void. This,
however, is a different question and I shall have
occasion to expand on it in this House at the
appropriate time.
Mr Speaker, Sir, if all of us do our work properly
under these Bills, it is conceivable that the
provisions we seek to introduce today may work out to
be more humane to an accused person than it otherwise
is today.
Sir, I support this Bill.
Mr N. Govindasamy: Sir, I suppose the hon. Member for Kuo Chuan, who is
well-versed in law, is right in his pronouncement that
under these Bills things may work out better than it
is today. However, may I just have my own reservation
on at least one clause in this Bill.
Sir, it is the judicial practice now that at a trial
it is obligatory for the court to warn itself about
convicting an accused on the uncorroborated testimony
of an accomplice. In this Bill, if clause 8 is
accepted, then it is obligatory for the court to
accept the uncorroborated testimony of an accomplice.
An accomplice, to save his own skin, will give all
sorts of evidence in order to convict others.
Acceptance of this uncorroborated evidence is a move
that leaves much to be desired.
Sir, having lost faith in the investigative
capabilities of the police force, we now have to rely
on the evidence of only collaborators and accomplices.
If I may say so, the Bill wants to take a short-cut to
justice. There is no such thing as a short-cut to
justice. The way to justice is always a long and
burdensome one. Does this mean "Prosecution made
Easy"?
Mr Barker: Sir, I do not propose to deal with the arguments here
but to leave them to the Select Committee. But I would
like to correct a misapprehension held by the Member
for Telok Blangah who says that it is obligatory for
the
Column: 1251
court to accept the uncorroborated testimony of an
accomplice, and he quotes clause 8. Clause 8 says
nothing of that kind. It says:
`An accomplice shall be a competent witness against
an accused person; and any rule of law or practice
whereby at a trial it is obligatory for the court to
warn itself about convicting the accused on the
uncorroborated testimony of an accomplice is hereby
abrogated.'
What is abrogated is the requirement of a warning. It
does not make it obligatory for the court to accept
the uncorroborated evidence of an accomplice. It can,
but it is not obligatory.
Sir, I would like to thank both Members for their
contribution and hope to see them in Select Committee.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Resolved,
"That the Evidence (Amendment) Bill be committed to
a Select Committee consisting of Mr Speaker as
Chairman and seven Members to be nominated by the
Committee of Selection."-[Mr E. W. Barker].
Column: 1251
CRIMINAL LAW (TEMPORARY PROVISIONS) (AMENDMENT) BILL
Order for Second Reading read.
6.25 p.m.
The Minister for Law and the Environment (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now
read a Second time."
Sir, section 14(1) of the Criminal Law (Temporary
Provisions) Act (Chapter 112) empowers a police
officer not below the rank of a sergeant, without
warrant, to enter and search any premises, vehicle or
individual if he suspects that any evidence of the
commission of an offence is likely to be found on such
premises, vehicle or individual, and may seize any
evidence so found. It is proposed to amend the proviso
to the section to
Column: 1252
enable a police officer below the rank of sergeant to
exercise similar powers if he has good reasons to
believe that, by reason of the delay which may be
caused by referring the case to his superior officer,
any such evidence is likely to be removed.
The Bill also seeks to amend section 22 of the Act to
bring it in line with a proposal to amend the Criminal
Procedure Code (Chapter 113), which has just also been
read the Second time, by deleting the legal
requirement to give caution to a person under arrest
before he is interrogated by the police.
Like the other two Bills which had their Second
Reading today, Sir, it is also proposed to refer this
Bill to a Select Committee.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question proposed.
Mr Hwang Soo Jin: Sir, in the light of an increasing crime rate, the
intention of this Bill before the House is obviously a
good one and will make the job of the police much
easier in bringing criminals to book. By delegating
the power of search, without warrant, to police
officers below the rank of sergeant as provided under
clause 2, it is to my mind important for the
Government to ensure that there will be no abuse of
such power and that all junior officers do understand
that the power delegated to them will be exercised
only with very good reasons and under fully
justifiable circumstances.
Sir, in implementing the law it will perhaps be
desirable for proper guidelines to be laid down and
their practical implications fully explained to all
junior officers so that in the course of carrying out
their duties they would not, by their rash action,
antagonise members of the public unnecessarily and so
lose the confidence and support of the public, which
is so vital in our efforts to combat crime.
Column: 1253
Mr Barker: Sir, I would like to thank the Member for Jalan Kayu
for his valuable contribution. Unfortunately, the
Minister in charge of the Police is not present here,
but I will convey his remarks and the reservation
which he expressed, to the Hon. Minister.
Question put, and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Resolved,
"That the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions)
(Amendment) Bill be committed to a Select Committee
consisting of Mr Speaker as Chairman and seven Members
to be nominated by
the Committee of Selection."-[Mr E. W. Barker].
Column: 1253
RECLAMATION AT PULAU DAMAR LAUT
6.32 p.m.
The Minister for Law and the Environment (Mr E. W. Barker): Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move the motion* standing in my name as it appears on the Order Paper.
*The motion reads as follows:
`That this Parliament, in accordance with section
4 of the Foreshores Act (Chapter 270), approves the
reclamation by Government of approximately 10.93
hectares of the foreshore and seabed at Pulau Damar
Laut, Jurong, as shown coloured green on the plan
marked "LAND OFFICE RECLAMATION PLAN NO. 10/75"
which is deposited in the Land Office, Singapore.'
Sir, Pulau Damar Laut, about 15.7 hectares in area
and shown coloured yellow on the plan marked as "LAND
OFFICE RECLAMATION PLAN NO 10/75", a copy of which is
displayed in the Library of this House for the infor
mation of hon. Members, was alienated to the Jurong
Town Corporation in 1962 for the extension of the
Jurong Industrial Estate. The Corporation now proposes
to reclaim about 10.93 hectares of the foreshore and
seabed at this island as shown coloured green on the
plan for the future extension of the Jurong Port.
The reclamation, which is the first stage of the
development of the island,
Column: 1254
will be undertaken by the Corporation as agents of the
Government. It is expected to take about 1 1/2 years to
complete at a cost of about $2.5 million. Fill for
this reclamation will be obtained by levelling the
existing hills on the island. The second stage of the
development is still under study by the Corporation.
Under the second stage, it is envisaged that further
reclamation may be necessary and wharves may be
constructed at the periphery of the reclamation.
On completion of the reclamation, the reclaimed land
will be proclaimed as State land and will be alienated
to the Corporation on terms and conditions to be
agreed with the Commissioner of Lands.
Sir, I beg to move.
Question put, and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this Parliament, in accordance with section 4 of
the Foreshores Act (Chapter 270), approves the
reclamation by Government of approximately 10.93
hectares of the foreshore and seabed at Pulau Damar
Laut, Jurong, as shown coloured green on the plan
marked "LAND OFFICE RECLAMATION PLAN NO. 10/75" which
is deposited in the Land Office, Singapore.
ADJOURNMENT
Resolved,
"That Parliament do now adjourn to a date to be
fixed."-[Mr E. W. Barker].
Adjourned accordingly at Twenty-six minutes to
Seven o'clock p.m. to a date to be fixed.